The Everyday Geopolitics of Messianic Jews in Israel-Palestine

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Everyday Geopolitics of Messianic Jews in Israel-Palestine Title Page The everyday geopolitics of Messianic Jews in Israel-Palestine. Daniel Webb Department of Geography, Royal Holloway, University of London. Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of PhD, University of London, 2015. 1 Declaration I Daniel Webb hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. Date: Sign: 2 Abstract This thesis examines the geopolitical orientations of Messianic Jews in Jerusalem, Israel-Palestine, in order to shed light on the confluence and co-constitution of religion and geopolitics. Messianic Jews are individuals who self-identify as being ethnically Jewish, but who hold beliefs that are largely indistinguishable from Christianity. Using the prism of ‘everyday geopolitics’, I explore my informants’ encounters with, and experiences of, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the dominant geopolitical logics that underpin it. I analyse the myriad of everyday factors that were formative in the shaping of my informants’ geopolitical orientation towards the conflict, focusing chiefly on those that were mediated and embodied through religious practice and belief. The material for the research was gathered in Jerusalem over the course of sixteen months – between September 2012 and January 2014 – largely through ethnographic research methods. Accordingly, I offer a lived alternative to existing work on geopolitics and religion; work that is dominated by overly cerebral and cognitivist views of religion. By contrast, I show how the urgencies of everyday life, as well as a number of religious practices, attune Messianic Jewish geopolitical orientations in dynamic, contingent, and contradictory ways. Taken together, I conclude that the imbrication of religion and geopolitics cannot be mapped in any simple or straightforward way. 3 Contents Title Page ...................................................................................................... 1 Declaration ................................................................................................... 2 Abstract ........................................................................................................ 3 Contents ....................................................................................................... 4 List of Figures .............................................................................................. 8 List of Abbreviations .................................................................................... 9 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................... 10 Maps ............................................................................................................ 14 Chapter 1: ........................................................................ 16 Introduction ................................................................................................ 16 1.0 Introduction .................................................................................................... 16 1.1 Introducing critical geopolitics..................................................................... 18 1.2 Empirical opportunities ................................................................................ 21 1.3 Conceptual opportunities ............................................................................. 25 1.4 A word on Jerusalem and urban geopolitics .............................................. 30 1.5 A word on Messianic Jews and the ‘Messianic’ ......................................... 32 1.6 Thesis outline ................................................................................................. 34 Chapter 2: ........................................................................ 37 Religion and geopolitics: making religion relevant ................................... 37 2.0 Introduction .................................................................................................... 37 2.1 Religion and international politics: a neglected area of study? ................ 38 2.2 Critical geopolitics and religion .................................................................... 43 2.3 Religious geopolitics ...................................................................................... 46 2.4 The ‘Geopolitics of Religion’ ....................................................................... 47 2.5 ‘Evangelical Geopolitics’ and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict .................. 50 2.6 Empirical and conceptual concerns ............................................................ 53 2.7 Propositional theology and extreme eschatologies ................................... 55 2.8 Propositional theology and the neglect of practiced religion .................. 60 2.9 A ‘lived’ approach to religion ....................................................................... 63 4 2.10 Towards an ‘everyday geopolitics’ of ‘lived’ religion ............................... 66 2.11 Summary ........................................................................................................ 72 Chapter 3: ........................................................................ 75 Researching ‘religeopolitics’....................................................................... 75 3.0 Introduction .................................................................................................... 75 3.1 Methodological considerations for new fields of enquiry ........................ 76 3.2 Research timeline ........................................................................................... 80 3.3 Research methods .......................................................................................... 84 3.4 Participant observation ................................................................................. 85 3.5 Locating the field ........................................................................................... 89 3.6 Interviews ........................................................................................................ 91 3.7 Access .............................................................................................................. 98 3.8 Positionality .................................................................................................. 106 3.9 Ethics and anonymity .................................................................................. 112 3.10 Conclusion ................................................................................................... 115 Chapter 4: ....................................................................... 117 The geopolitics of Israeli indifference ...................................................... 117 4.0 Introduction .................................................................................................. 117 4.1 Jerusalem’s light-rail ..................................................................................... 121 4.2 The ‘everyday’ train...................................................................................... 126 4.3 Encountering indifference .......................................................................... 134 4.4 Israeli Jewish indifference and the Palestinian Other ............................. 139 4.5 Jewish Israeli indifference and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict .............. 143 4.6 An everyday geopolitics of indifference. .................................................. 146 4.7 Manipulating/manufacturing indifference ............................................... 151 4.8 Coda - A summer of war, an autumn of terror: what a difference a year makes ....................................................................................................................... 155 4.9 Conclusion .................................................................................................... 156 Chapter 5: ....................................................................... 159 Encountering the everyday border: religious identity and Israeli citizenship. ................................................................................................ 159 5.0 Introduction .................................................................................................. 159 5 5.1 Citizenship borders ...................................................................................... 162 5.2 The legal borders of Israeli citizenship ..................................................... 166 5.3 The formal spaces of Israeli (non)citizenship .......................................... 170 5.4 Border materialities ...................................................................................... 174 5.5 Israel’s border agents ................................................................................... 181 5.6 Receding borders and everyday life ........................................................... 186 5.7 Conclusion .................................................................................................... 189 Chapter 6: ....................................................................... 192 Precarious positionings: everyday acts of resistance and compliance in the Messianic Jewish community. .................................................................. 192 6.0 Introduction .................................................................................................. 192 6.1 Religious positionings.................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • My Aunt's Mamilla
    My father’s eldest sister has always served in My Aunt’s Mamilla my mind as a potential family encyclopedia. Helga Tawil-Souri “Potential” because I never had the opportunity to spend much time with her. She had come and visited us in Beirut once in the mid 1970s – I vaguely remember. My grandmother, with whom I spent much of my childhood, would often mention Auntie M. under a nostalgic haze, perhaps regret, that her first-born was so far away. That longing tone for her eldest led my other aunts, my father, and my uncles to joke that Auntie M. was their mother’s favorite. For years Auntie M. endured only in my imagination. Whatever tidbits I had caught about her were extraordinary, a fusion of new world mystery and old world obscurity. She lived in faraway places that sounded utterly exotic: Sao Paolo, Etobicoke, Toronto; that they always rhymed only added to their enigma. The haphazard trail I constructed of her life seemed improbable too: old enough to remember family life in Jerusalem; married and sent off to Brazil; had a daughter ten years older than me who didn’t speak Arabic. Auntie M. hovered behind a veil of unanswered questions: How old was she? Did my grandparents marry her off or did she choose to wed Uncle A.? How is one “sent” to Brazil? Could one even fly to Brazil back then? Did she flee with the family to Lebanon first? Did she really have another daughter besides the one I knew of? What happened to the other daughter? How did Auntie M.
    [Show full text]
  • Queen of Sheba: Women for Israel Tour 2018
    Jewish National Fund QUEEN OF SHEBA: WOMEN FOR ISRAEL TOUR 2018 November 8 – 14, 2018 Chair Rhonda Sheakly Professionals Sharon David, JNF Director of Affinity Groups & Market Research Analyst Talia Tzour Avner, KKL-JNF Chief Israel Emissary Tour Guide Issy Herzog Thursday, November 8 – Arrival / Jerusalem AM Welcome to Israel! Upon individual arrivals, transfer to the Orient Hotel in Jerusalem, the spiritual hub of Israel. PM *Early arrivals have the option to meet in the hotel lobby at 12:15 pm for a visit to Yad Vashem Holocaust Museum & Memorial—strategically situated on the green slopes of Har HaZikaron, translated to mean “Mount of Remembrance.” Tour this sprawling complex of various exhibits, archives, and monuments that tell the story of the Holocaust from a unique perspective by emphasizing the experiences of Jewish victims and survivors using original artifacts, testimonies, and personal possessions. Proceed to the Knesset, Israel’s House of Representatives, for a tour with a Member of Knesset. See where major decisions, which impact the daily lives of each and every Israeli citizen, are made every day.* Our journey officially commences with an opening dinner at a local restaurant with the group and a special guest speaker. Overnight Orient Hotel, Jerusalem *Additional Cost – Early arrivals are responsible for transfer on own. The optional program for early arrivals does not include lunch. Jerusalem Itinerary is subject to change. Friday, November 9 – Jerusalem AM Following breakfast at the hotel, enjoy a guided walking tour through Mahane Yehuda Market for an authentic culinary experience with a renowned chef. Become immersed in the bustling energy of Jerusalem’s shuk (Hebrew for “market”) while sampling tasty foods from various vendors selling delicious cheeses, pastries, spices, and more.
    [Show full text]
  • CONTROL of SPACE in EAST JERUSALEM Meir Margalit
    SEIZING CONTROL OF SPACE IN EAST MeirJERUSALEM Margalit edited by Sam Blatt design by Virginia Paradinas Dr. Meir Margalit May 2010 Editing: Sam Blatt Graphics: Virginia Paradinas Photos: ActiveStills.org Alberto Alcalde Virginia Paradinas Legal adviser: Allegra Pacheco DVD producer: Elan Frenkel Seizing Control of Space in East Jerusalem Introduction Scope of this research The Legality of settlements UN resolutions Taking control of the space Permanent temporariness The colonial model of relationship with the “natives” Changing the landscape Policies of segregation Historical background The demographic factor AreasSEIZING appropriated by government in East Jerusalem Properties under Israeli control in East Jerusalem Institutions that control the land Seized and targeted areas in Eat Jerusalem Settler activity inside the Old City A summary of the numbers Settler activity outside the Old City Silwan/ Ir David DemolitionCONTROL plans for the Al Bustan neighbourhood of Silwan OF Old purposes, new strategies Illegal settler construction in Silwan Four cases Case 1: The “no permit” 7 – storey building Case 2: Revoking of demolition order by Justice Lahovsky Case 3: Dealing with containers, caravans and guard posts SPACECase 4: Using arab residents to buy property for settlers IN Sheikh Jarrah The grey elements of control in Sheikh Jarrah A-Tur Ras Al-Amud Abu Dis Isolated properties in other areas of East Jerusalem EASTProjects by private developers Jabel Mukaber/ Nof Zion Manipulations to erase reality Mar Elias Wallajeh/ Givat Yael The wholesale
    [Show full text]
  • The National Jewish Post&Opinion Volume 76, Number 1 • September 23, 2009 • 5 Tishrei 5770 Two Dollars
    The National Jewish Post&Opinion Volume 76, Number 1 • September 23, 2009 • 5 Tishrei 5770 Two Dollars www.jewishpostopinion.com This photo comes from Universe’s 2010 The Jewish Historical Museum of Amsterdam calendar. More on this and other Jewish calendars on page NAT 14. Cover designed by Crystal Kurz. NAT 2 September 23, 2009 is not only possible but also beneficial to you and I, are included in that moment of one’s well-being to be able to forgive. revelation. That moment is part of our Editorial Again, L’shana Tova to each of you and Shabbat Shalom collective memory. If these verses had your families! been left out, then we could have easily As you can read in Howard Karsh’s Jennie Cohen 9-23-09 BY RABBI JON ADLAND said that the revelation on Sinai was just column on page NAT 10 of this issue, in Sept. 11, 2009, Nitzavim/Vayelech for those who had been liberated from 5769 the Jewish community suffered Forgiving yourself (Deuteronomy 29:9–31:30), 22 Elul 5769 Egypt. Instead, it included all of us. embarrassment because of a few Jewish by Rabbi Steven Z. Leder What does this mean? It means that individuals. In contrast, I would like to Guess how many pages it takes in the Where were you eight years ago this Torah is a part of every Jewish person’s focus on a Jewish man from Indianapolis prayer book until God forgives us on Kol morning? That is the question many of us life, heart, and soul.
    [Show full text]
  • Max-Planck-Institut Für Ethnologische Forschung Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology
    Max-Planck-Institut für ethnologische Forschung Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology International Workshop INTEGRATION AND CONFLICT AMONG THE AFRICAN DIASPORA IN THE ORIENT November 8th – 9th 2007 Organiser: Ababu Minda Yimene Venue: Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology, Halle/S., Germany OUTLINE The Siddi are Indians of African origin, whose ancestors arrived in India beginning in the first century A.D. as sailors, domestic servants, serviles, soldiers, free adventurers and merchants. From the 13th to the 17th century India saw a large influx of Siddis as more African personnel were needed for the armies of the rising and expanding Moslem kingdoms of India. Not seldomly did Siddis rise to prominence, attaining military and governmental leadership positions. In fact, some established their own kingdoms, whose dynasties lasted even into the British rule of India. Two cases in point are the State of Habshan in Janjira and the State of Sachin. Siddis have adopted the indigenous religions (most Siddis are Muslim), food, and customs of India, though remnants of their African heritage are retained in their music. Since the Police Action of 1949-51, the armies of India’s princely states were dissolved and power was taken over by the Indian Union Army. The soldiers, including the Siddi, were retired with pensions, a drastic change for which they were ill-prepared. Moreover, as India vigorously strived to join the ranks of industrialised nations, the urban economy was subsequently transformed and the living standard of Siddis stagnated for lack of modern education and marketable skills. The identity of the Siddis has been changing since their arrival in India and especially so since India’s independence which led to the dissolution of the princely states.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Israeli & Palestinian Youth (Continued)
    what’s new at Musalaha? Understanding Israeli & Palestinian 1. This month we say a bittersweet goodbye Youth continued to our long-serving volunteer, Jemma. We ( ) hope that she returns to Oceania with 1 22 positive experiences, new insight, and Israeli-Palestinians are part of the state of Psychologist Judy Kuriansky suggests legitimize opposed claims and foster good friends that she met through her time Israel geographically and legally, yet they several steps for changing the attitude existential insecurity. Delegitimization volunteering with us. are excluded from national expression as of each group. The first step is to stop of the other’s identity is a common theme the flag, anthem and ideology of the state, delegitimizing the enemy, which is done by in Israeli and Palestinian societies, and 2. This December is full of events for among other things, fail to represent relating to one another as human beings. Israeli-Palestinians deal with the challenge Musalaha’s women’s groups. We are having them. Israeli-Palestinian youth comprise This can be accomplished through meeting of falling between these two conflicting a conference on trauma, a worship night for nearly twenty-six percent of Israel’s child one another and developing relationships. cultures. Though there are a number of new participants, and regular meetings of population. Three central themes in their Next, working on joint projects together organizations in Israel and Palestine local groups. Please pray that these events master narrative are: discrimination can aid in working toward reconciliation as that attempt to encourage positive will produce fruit that will spread to other WINTER 2012 women in our communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Concordis Papers Viii
    CONCORDIS PAPERS VIII Christian Churches and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict February 2010 Third Edition 2 Blessed are the peacemakers … Matthew 5:9 List of Contents Page 3 Introduction Rt Hon Viscount Brentford 4 Maps 5 A Note on the Purpose of this Booklet (Revised for 3rd Edtion) 6 Chronology (expanded in 2nd Edition) 8 Current Political Background Dr Fiona McCallum 10 A Christian View of Israel Dr Calvin Smith 12 Biblical Perspectives on Israel and Palestine and how these Relate to the Church Revd Chris Rose 14 Summary of Discussion at Consultation 16 Working Together towards Peaceful Co‐existence Geoffrey Smith and Jerry Marshall 18 Musalaha and the Churches Dr Salim Munayer 20 The Need for a Bridging Narrative Dr Richard Harvey 22 Engaging with the Land and People Revd Mike Fuller 24 Core Christian Principle Common to All Ben White 26 The Contributors 27 About Concordis International Cover photo: © CC Or Hitch 3 Introduction Rt Hon Viscount Brentford oncordis International has worked—not always under that name—for over 25 C years to build sustainable and just peace in areas suffering from war, by developing relationships between key individuals on all sides of violent conflict and helping them together to find constructive ways forward. Our field of experience includes South Africa, Rwanda, Sudan, Kenya and Afghanistan. With respect to the Middle East, we have so far limited ourselves to the relatively modest ambitions that available funding has allowed. This paper is the eighth in a series which seeks to build on the strengths of the Concordis approach through spreading understanding of issues and the multilateral consensus developed in consultations, primarily connected with the conflicts in Sudan.
    [Show full text]
  • Applied Research Institute – Jerusalem
    Applied Research Institute - Jerusalem (ARIJ) P.O Box 860, Caritas Street – Bethlehem, Phone: (+972) 2 2741889, Fax: (+972) 2 2776966. [email protected] | http://www.arij.org Applied Research Institute – Jerusalem Report on the Israeli Colonization Activities in the West Bank & the Gaza Strip Volume 203, June 2015 Issue http://www.arij.org Bethlehem Israeli Occupation Authorities handed out military orders to stop the construction in 4 Palestinian houses (each one about 200 square meters) in Umm Salamuna village, south of Bethlehem city. The targeted houses are owned by: Hussen Mohammad Taqatqih, Ja’far Khalil Taqatqih, Nasem Ali Taqatqih and Salem Ahmed Taqatqih. (Al- Quds 2 June 2015) Israeli Occupation Army (IOA) stormed and searched five of Palestinian houses in Tequ village, southeast of Bethlehem city. the targeted houses are owned by: Hamza Mahmoud Jubril, Hassan Awad Jubril, Mahmoud Kaiyed Jubril, Ibrahim Issa, Mohammad Hasan Jubril. (Wafa 4 June 2015) Israeli Occupation Army (IOA) raided and searched two Palestinian houses in Husan village, west of Bethlehem city. The targeted houses are owned by Ayed Ibrahim Za’oul and his borther Ahmed. (Wafa 4 June 2015) Israeli settlers gathered at the entrance of Al Jab’a village, southwest of Bethlehem city and attacked Palestinians and their vehicles. (Al-Quds 4 June 2015) Israeli Occupation Army (IOA) invaded and toured in several areas and neighborhoods in Beit Jala town, southwest of Bethlehem city. The IOA fire teargas and stun grenades at Palestinian houses, causing dozens of suffocation cases. (Al-Quds 7 June 2015) Two Palestinians; Mu’tasem Nabel Ash-Shwiki (21 years) and Mahmoud Imad Ash-Shwiki (18 years), were injured after the Israeli Occupation Army (IOA) stationed at the DCO military checkpoint, at Applied Research Institute - Jerusalem (ARIJ) P.O Box 860, Caritas Street – Bethlehem, Phone: (+972) 2 2741889, Fax: (+972) 2 2776966.
    [Show full text]
  • Beyond Jerusalem Syndrome: Religious Mania and Miracle Cures in British Mandate Palestine1
    Beyond Jerusalem Syndrome: Religious Mania and Miracle Cures in British Mandate Palestine1 Chris Wilson In 1937, Dr. Heinz Hermann, the medical director of Ezrath Nashim (“Women’s Help”), a private Jewish mental hospital in Jerusalem, published an article on “Jerusalem fever” (Jerusalem-Fieber) in Folia clinica orientalia.2 Based in Tel Aviv and granted a publishing license in September 1937, the German- and English-language medical journal proved a short- lived affair, eclipsed by the success of the Hebrew-language medical journal Harefuah (“Medicine”) among European Jewish doctors in Palestine. But Hermann’s argument, that there was a distinct psychiatric condition linked to the uniquely holy city of Jerusalem, would go on to enjoy a long career, repackaged and popularized later in the century as “Jerusalem syndrome.”3 Grounded in his clinical experience of the numerous prophets and messiahs who could be found wandering the streets of Jerusalem in the 1930s, the idea that a particular place could be mentally dislocating chimed with some contemporary trends in the history of the psy-sciences, particularly psychoanalysis, when Hermann published his piece in 1937. No less a figure than Sigmund Freud had just penned an open letter to Romain Rolland, in which he reflected on his own moment of “derealization” on a trip to the Acropolis in 1904. At a remove of thirty years, Freud boiled down the essence of the experience to a sense of incredulity at reality. “By the evidence of my senses,” he wrote, “I am now standing on the Acropolis, but I cannot believe it.”4 Hermann the psychiatrist had good reason to be cautious about tapping into psychoanalytic thought.
    [Show full text]
  • Spring 2010 Newsletter
    Munayer Family Musings Study Tours Hello Everybody, championships which he did along with his Sam 12 Comments from Musalaha It’s been so long since I last wrote an update. brother John who also got the gold medal At last! At last! can ride in the front seat of Study Tour Participants I can’t remember what has happened in be- in his age bracket. He came in 13th and was the car. He has been waiting for this to be like tween, looking at my calendar I see Christ- fantastic as a non–trained runner. He has a his brothers. He has to sign on the forms for mas and New Years passed twice, Daniel had heavy exam load now until the end of June. his passport re- an 18th Birthday party, Salim went to the US He is thinking of going to YWAM as well the camp, we toured the country for a The quiet drive north allowed us all to newal…..oohh and back, numerous running and swimming and in his words, “but not the same as Jack.” the excitement Steve Openshaw week. Part of it was a traditional tour rest and start processing some of what competitions [nothing new there!], Musalaha Of course we say and nod wisely. He is very of getting older. St. Peter’s Church, Bolton, UK of the biblical sites, but the last few we’d heard, and we all embraced the retreat at the Dead Sea, a few exams and I am committed at the congregation and loves his days were completely unconventional.
    [Show full text]
  • The Israeli Colonization Activities in the Palestinian Territories During the 3Rd Quarter of 2015-2016
    Applied Research Institute - Jerusalem (ARIJ) & Land Research Center – Jerusalem (LRC) [email protected] | http://www.arij.org [email protected] | http://www.lrcj.org The Israeli Colonization Activities in the Palestinian Territories during the 3rd Quarter of 2015-2016, (December 2015 – February 2016) December 2015 to February 2016 The Quarterly report highlights the chronology This report is prepared as part of of events concerning the Israeli Violations in the project entitled " Addressing Israeli Actions and its Land the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Polices int the oPT" which is confiscation and razing of lands, the uprooting financially supported by the EU and destruction of fruit trees, the expansion of and SDC. However, the content settlements and erection of outposts, the of this report is the sole brutality of the Israeli Occupation Army, the responsibility of ARIJ and do not Israeli settlers violence against Palestinian necessarily reflect those of the civilians and properties, the erection of donors checkpoints, the construction of the Israeli segregation wall and the issuance of military orders for the various Israeli purposes. 1 1 Applied Research Institute - Jerusalem (ARIJ) & Land Research Center – Jerusalem (LRC) [email protected] | http://www.arij.org [email protected] | http://www.lrcj.org Map 1: The Israeli Segregation Plan in the occupied Palestinian Territory 2 Applied Research Institute - Jerusalem (ARIJ) & Land Research Center – Jerusalem (LRC) [email protected] | http://www.arij.org [email protected] | http://www.lrcj.org Bethlehem Governorate (December 2015 - February 2016) The Israeli Violations in Bethlehem Governorate during the month of December 2015 • Israeli Occupation Army (IOA) stationed near Gilo settlement opened fire at Palestinian houses and land at Beir ‘Una and Al Jadawel areas in Beit Jala town, west of Bethlehem city.
    [Show full text]
  • Stendhal's Syndrome
    Stories Stendhal’s Syndrome Before the 19th century, there were that turned into a horrendous saga of Hans Holbein in Basle (and made his travellers. There were even rich Englishmen frostbite and starvation. He visited London pregnant wife fear he was going to have one doing the Grand Tour. But then, somewhere three times, and even contributed articles to of his epileptic fits). 1 The German poet Rainer around the time of the French Revolution (or English-language journals on the cultural life Maria Rilke wrote in his first Duino Elegy : perhaps a little before it) feelings were let of Paris. Stendhal liked to pepper his French ‘beauty is nothing but the beginning of terror, loose on the world. Back in 1761, readers with anglicisms, and was one of the first which we are still just able to endure, and we had swooned when they encountered the writers to popularise the use of the word are so awed because it serenely disdains to ‘true voice of feeling’ in Jean-Jacques ‘tourist’ in French. annihilate us.’ Philosophers were getting in Rousseau’s novel La Nouvelle Héloïse ; by It was on one of his visits to Italy in 1817 on the act too. Immanuel Kant, in his Critique the end of the decade, all of Europe was that Stendhal described an experience that of Judgement , hypothesised that the being sentimental in the manner made brought the literary swoon into tourism. contemplation of aesthetically stimulating fashionable a few years later by Laurence Visiting the Basilica of Santa Croce, he found objects induces ‘a rapidly alternating Sterne in his A Sentimental Journey .
    [Show full text]