Polymorphism in the Circumsporozoite Protein of the Human Malaria Parasite Plasmodium Vivax
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology, 55 (1992) 105-114 105 © 1992 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. All rights reserved. / 0166-6851/92/$05.00 MOLBIO 01809 Polymorphism in the circumsporozoite protein of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium vivax Shoukat H. Qari a, Ira F. Goldman a, Marinete M. Povoa b, Sylvia di Santi c, Michael P. Alpers d and Altaf A. Lal a aMalaria Branch, Division of Parasitic Diseases, National Center for Infectious Diseases, Centers for Disease Control, Public Health Services, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Atlanta GA, USA, bMalaria Program, lnstituto Evandra Chagas, Belem, Brazil; CMalaria Department, Sucen, S6,'o Paulo, Brazil and dPapua New Guinea Institute of Medical Research, Goroka, Papua New Guinea (Received 8 April 1992; accepted 12 June 1992) The circumsporozoite (CS) protein that covers the surface of infectious sporozoites is a candidate antigen in malaria vaccine development. To determine the extent of B- and T-epitope polymorphism and to understand the mechanisms of antigenic variability, we have characterized the CS protein gene of Plasmodium vivax from field isolates representing geographically distant regions of Papua New Guinea (PNG) and Brazil. In the central repeat region of the CS protein, in addition to variation in the number of repeats, an array of mutations was observed which suggests that point mutations have led to the emergence of the variant CS repeat sequence ANGA(G/D)(N/D)QPG from GDRA(D/A)GQPA. Outside the repeat region of the protein, the nonsilent nucleotide substitutions of independent origin are localized in three domains of the protein that either harbor known T-cell determinants or are analogous to the Plasmodium falciparum immunodominant determinants, Th2R and Th3R. We have found that, with the exception of one CS clone sequence that was shared by one P. vivax isolate each from PNG and Brazil, the P. vivax CS protein types can be grouped into Papuan and Brazilian types. These results suggest that an in-depth study of parasite population dynamics is required before field trials for vaccine formulations based on polymorphic immunodominant determinants are conducted. Key words: Plasmodium vivax; Circumsporozoite protein; Clonal typing; Epitope polymorphism Introduction formulations have been produced [8-16]. Vaccination with specific antigens or epi- In contrast to the progress towards vaccine topes offers the possibility of inducing immu- development against P. falciparum malaria nity against causative organisms of infectious parasite, for which several stage-specific vac- diseases. However, natural polymorphism in cine antigens have been characterized, studies the target determinants of the parasite proteins of P. vivax parasite antigens have been limited, may compromise the efficacy of a subunit partly because of the lack of in vitro culture cap- vaccine. Whether a vaccine is based on a ability. Only two vaccine candidate antigens of critically important antigen present only in a P. vivax have been characterized: the circum- single stage of the parasite or on a combination sporozoite (CS) protein and the blood-stage an- of important antigens present in several tigen, PV 200 [1-7]. Immune responses against different stages, failure to deal with antigenic the CS protein have been studied, and vaccine polymorphism could result in a vaccine that is unable to protect individuals exposed to a Correspondence address: Altaf A. Lal, Malaria Branch, Mail parasite with an antigenic variation. Therefore, Stop F 12, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA 30333, whether the vaccine is targeted against single USA. Tel: (404) 488 4079, Fax: (404) 488 4427. or multistage proteins, if a portion of a 106 parasite population can escape the effects of a Isolation and characterization of the circum- vaccine because of heritable polymorphism in sporozoite protein genes. As described earlier vaccine target antigens, the natural population [5], blood collected from patients infected with could rapidly evolve 'vaccine resistance' in a P. vivax was passed through a two-layer manner analogous to the development of drug column of acid-washed glass beads and CF resistance in malaria parasites. To ensure the 11 cellulose to remove leukocytes. Parasite efficacy of subunit vaccines based on poly- genomic DNA was isolated from infected morphic determinants, antigenic polymorph- erythrocytes, and 100 ng was used in a ism of malaria parasites must be studied at the polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-mediated population level. CS protein gene amplification. Oligonucleo- Polymorphism in the CS protein of P. tides AL60 (GTCGGAATTCATGAAGAA- falciparum has been shown to be restricted to CTTCATTCTC) and AL61 (CAGCGGA- the T-cell determinants [17-19]. However, TCCTTAATTGAATAATGCTAGG) corre- polymorphism in the CS protein of P. vivax, sponding to the terminal ends of the CS which was originally observed in the repetitive protein were used as amplification primers. B-cell determinant of the protein, has also been The PCR-generated fragments were digested recently found outside the repeat region [5]. with EcoRI and BamHI, cloned in Bluescript Variant P. vivax parasites from Thailand, plasmid, and transformed into Escherichia coli. Papua New Guinea (PNG) and Brazil have The repeat sequence of the recombinant CS the repeat sequence ANGAGNQPG, which clones was identified by DNA:oligonucleotide differs from the repetitive sequence duplex hybridization analysis using oligonu- GDRADGQPA of P. vivax CS proteins of cleotide probes ALl 14 (ATCAACCAGGAG- parasites analyzed earlier [4,5]. We and others CAAATG), and ALl l6 (GGTGATAGA- have subsequently shown that P. vivax para- GCAGATGGA) complementary to a portion sites with the variant B-epitope repeat se- of the repeat sequences ANGAGNQPG and quence have a wide geographic distribution GDRAAGQPA respectively. AL54 (CCATG- [5,20]. In continuation of our earlier studies of CAGTGTAACCTGTGGA) complementary the prevalence of CS proteins with the variant to the genus conserved CS region, R II was repeat sequence ANGAGNQPG in P. vivax also used. CS gene-specific primers were used field isolates from PNG and Brazil, we to determine the nucleotide sequence of the CS investigated: (1) nonsynonymous changes in gene by the dideoxynucleotide method [21]. the repeat region of P. vivax that result in the emergence of variant repeat sequences; (2) types of CS protein-bearing P. vivax parasites Results that predominate in PNG and Brazil; and (3) polymorphism outside the repeat region, in the On PCR-mediated amplification of the P. T-cell determinants, of the P. vivax CS protein. vivax CS protein gene amplification, genomic DNA extracted from blood samples of the patients from PNG and Brazil yielded DNA Materials and Methods fragments approximately 1.2 kb in length. We sequenced the CS protein genes of a total of Origin of P. vivax parasites. Microscopically 115 CS clones representing 15 isolates from confirmed P. vivax-infected blood was collec- PNG and 24 from Brazil. The entire sequence ted directly from individuals living in a high of a total of 13 CS clones representing 8 P. malaria-endemic region of PNG (Madang) in vivax isolates from Brazil and 3 clones March 1990 and from persons in relatively low representing 2 isolates from PNG was deter- malaria-endemic regions of Brazil (Paragami- mined. The CS genes of the remaining 102 P. nos and around Sao Paulo) between 1986 and vivax clones were sequenced to reveal sequen- 1990. ces outside the repeat regions and portions of 107 the central repeat sequences. Of the 115 CS remaining 11 clones had type 2 repeat clones, we have previously described the sequences, indicating that the variants coexist complete sequence of 4 CS genes (P19/D, P4/ within a single isolate. B, B7/4, and B 19/2) and the partial sequence of Similarly, polymorphism was noted in the another 20 CS clones [5]. For the purpose of repeat and nonrepeat regions of the P. vivax presentation, we are designating the CS protein from Brazil (Fig. 1). We sequenced GDRA(D/A)GQPA and ANGA(G/D)(N/ 8 clones from the B19 isolate, seven from the D)QPG CS protein repeats as type 1 and type B37, 6 each from the B5 and B10 isolates, 5 2 repeats, respectively. from the B7, 3 each from the B11, B15, B21, B31, B34, B40, and B43, and 2 clones from the Within-isolate polymorphism of the circum- B14, B20, B26, B30, B38, and B39. Like the sporozoite proteins. To determine the pre- mixed infection observed in the P19 isolate sence of parasite polymorphs among patients from PNG, isolates B7 and B 19 had both type from PNG, we sequenced 13 clones from the 1 and type 2 repeat sequence bearing parasites. P19 isolate, 10 clones from the P4 isolate, and However, no amino acid variation was noted 2 clones from each of the isolates P6, P7, P9, among 2-7 clones sequenced from each of the P10, P18, P25, P26, P72, and P73. A distinct 11 isolates from Brazil. variability in sequences was noted among the clones of P19, P4, P6, and P10 isolates; these Evolution of the repeat region of the circum- variations ranged from a change of a single sporozoite protein. Based on the nature of the amino acid residue to insertion of a stretch of non-synonymous changes, we have grouped amino acids (Fig. 1). The isolate P19 was a the repeat domain of the CS genes of P. vivax mixture of both type 1 and_type 2 CS repeat- into four categories (Fig. 2). The repeat bearing parasites; two clones, P19/L and P19/ sequences in rows 1-3 encode the type 1 CS M, had type 1 repeat sequences, while the repeat sequences, and the sequence in the RI Repeats RII Isolate CLOnes 13 .38 52 82 294 295 298 310 311 316 341 350 355 359 364 374 388 P19 9 L G q A Type 2 G D A T N K V A E L T G L 1 • ° • • ...