DOCSLIB.ORG

TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE of the FLAGSTAFF AREA MONUMENTS FINAL REPORT Prepared by Rebecca S. Toupal Richard W. Stoffle

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE of the FLAGSTAFF AREA MONUMENTS FINAL REPORT Prepared by Rebecca S. Toupal Richard W. Stoffle Traditional Resource Use of the Flagstaff Area Monuments Item Type Report Authors Toupal, Rebecca; Stoffle, Richard W. Publisher Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology, University of Arizona Download date 01/10/2021 12:11:25 Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10150/272100 TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE OF THE FLAGSTAFF AREA MONUMENTS FINAL REPORT Prepared by Rebecca S. Toupal Richard W. Stoffle Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology University of Arizona Tucson, AZ 86721 July 19, 2004 TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE OF THE FLAGSTAFF AREA MONUMENTS FINAL REPORT Prepared by Rebecca S. Toupal Richard W. Stoffle Shawn Kelly Jill Dumbauld with contributions by Nathan O’Meara Kathleen Van Vlack Fletcher Chmara-Huff Christopher Basaldu Prepared for The National Park Service Cooperative Agreement Number 1443CA1250-96-006 R.W. Stoffle and R.S. Toupal, Principal Investigators Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology University of Arizona Tucson, AZ 86721 July 19, 2004 TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................iv CHAPTER ONE: STUDY OVERVIEW ..................................................................................1 Project History and Purpose...........................................................................................1 Research Tasks...............................................................................................................1 Research Methods..........................................................................................................2 Organization of the Report.............................................................................................7 CHAPTER TWO: SUMMARY OF CULTURAL AFFILIATION REVIEW..........................8 Project Overview ...........................................................................................................8 Summary of Review Findings .......................................................................................9 CHAPTER THREE: SUNSET CRATER VOLCANO NATIONAL MONUMENT.............37 Lava Flow Trail............................................................................................................38 Pai ...................................................................................................................38 Southern Paiute ................................................................................................45 O’Leary Peak ...............................................................................................................48 Zuni .................................................................................................................48 Visitor Center...............................................................................................................56 Southern Paiute ...............................................................................................57 Western Apache ..............................................................................................62 Summary and Ethnographic Commentary...................................................................74 Pai Summary....................................................................................................74 Southern Paiute Summary................................................................................76 Zuni Summary .................................................................................................77 Hopi Summary.................................................................................................79 Western Apache Summary .............................................................................81 Navajo Summary .............................................................................................83 Ethnographic Commentary ..............................................................................85 CHAPTER FOUR: WALNUT CANYON NATIONAL MONUMENT................................86 Island Trail...................................................................................................................87 Pai ...................................................................................................................87 Southern Paiute ................................................................................................93 Rim Trail....................................................................................................................100 Southern Paiute .............................................................................................100 Zuni ...............................................................................................................103 Summary and Ethnographic Commentary.................................................................113 Pai Summary..................................................................................................113 Southern Paiute Summary..............................................................................115 Zuni Summary ...............................................................................................116 Hopi Summary...............................................................................................118 Navajo Summary ...........................................................................................119 Ethnographic Commentary ............................................................................120 i CHAPTER FIVE: WUPATKI NATIONAL MONUMENT.................................................121 Citadel........................................................................................................................122 Zuni................................................................................................................122 Doney Mountain ........................................................................................................128 Pai ..................................................................................................................128 Southern Paiute ..............................................................................................134 Zuni................................................................................................................141 Lomaki ......................................................................................................................151 Zuni................................................................................................................151 Summary and Ethnographic Commentary.................................................................157 Pai Summary..................................................................................................157 Southern Paiute Summary..............................................................................158 Zuni Summary ...............................................................................................160 Hopi Summary...............................................................................................164 Navajo Summary ...........................................................................................166 Ethnographic Commentary ............................................................................167 CHAPTER SIX: CULTURAL LANDSCAPES....................................................................168 The Pai Landscape .....................................................................................................168 The Pai Cultural Landscape Map...................................................................177 Ethnographic Summary .................................................................................177 The Southern Paiute Landscape.................................................................................181 The Southern Paiute Cultural Landscape Map ..............................................192 Ethnographic Summary .................................................................................193 The Hopi Landscape .................................................................................................195 The Zuni Landscape...................................................................................................195 The Zuni Cultural Landscape Map ...............................................................201 Ethnographic Summary ................................................................................202 The Navajo Landscape...............................................................................................204 The Western Apache Landscape................................................................................205 The Western Apache Cultural Landscape Map .............................................212 Ethnographic Summary .................................................................................213 Regional Landscape...................................................................................................215 CHAPTER SEVEN: SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS .....................................221 Summary of Traditional Uses and Resources............................................................221 Tribal Recommendations ..........................................................................................227 Sunset Crater Volcano National Monument..................................................227
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Grand Canyon U.S
    National Park Service Grand Canyon U.S. Department of the Interior Grand Canyon National Park Arizona Hualapai Tribe and Skywalk The Hualapai (WALL-uh-pie), the “People of the Tall Pines,” have lived in the Southwest for untold generations. Traditionally their homelands stretched from Grand Canyon to the Bill Williams River in west-central Arizona and from the Black Mountains bordering the Colorado River to the San Francisco Peaks. Pri- marily nomadic hunter-gathers, they also traded with nearby tribes. The Hualapai Reservation of just less than 1,000,000 acres (404,686 ha) was established in 1883. Today the tribe counts about 2,300 members. Peach Springs on Highway 66 is the tribal headquarters. The tribe operates a hotel, restaurant, and gift shop in Peach Springs. While limited ranching, timber harvest, and guided hunts provide some income, the tourist industry offers the best opportunity for employment of tribal members. The Skywalk at The Hualapai Tribe has chosen a site at the far The Skywalk, managed by the Hualapai Tribe and Grand Canyon West western end of Grand Canyon about 250 miles located on tribal lands, consists of a horseshoe- (400 km) by road, a five hour drive, from Grand shaped steel frame with glass floor and sides that Canyon Village to offer a variety of visitor services projects about 70 feet (21 m) from the canyon rim. including the Skywalk in a development called While the Skywalk is the most famous attraction Grand Canyon West. Food service is limited and at Grand Canyon West, tours also include other usually as part of a package tour.
    [Show full text]
  • Monument Valley Meander
    RV Traveler's Roadmap to Monument Valley Meander However you experience it, the valley is a wonder to behold, a harsh yet hauntingly beautiful landscape. View it in early morning, when shadows lift from rocky marvels. Admire it in springtime,when tiny pink and blue wildflowers sprinkle the land with jewel-like specks of color. Try to see it through the eyes of the Navajos, who still herd their sheep and weave their rugs here. 1 Highlights & Facts For The Ideal Experience Agathla Peak Trip Length: Roughly 260 miles, plus side trips Best Time To Go: Spring - autumn What To Watch Out For: When on Indian reservations abide by local customs. Ask permission before taking photos, never disturb any of the artifacts. Must See Nearby Attractions: Grand Canyon National Park (near Flagstaff, AZ) Petrified Forest National Park (near Holbrook, AZ) Zion National Park (Springdale, UT) 2 Traveler's Notes Monument Valley Navajo Tribal Park The stretch of Rte. 163 called the Trail of the Ancients in honor of the vanished Anasazis cuts across Monument Valley at the Utah border on its way to the little town of Mexican Hat. Named for a rock formation there that resembles an upside-down sombrero a whimsical footnote to the magnificence of Monument Valley—Mexican Hat is the nearest settlement to Goosenecks State Park, just ahead and to the west via Rtes. 261 and 316. The monuments in the park have descriptive names. They are based on ones imagination. These names were created by the early settlers of Monument Valley. Others names portray a certain meaning to the Navajo people.
    [Show full text]
  • Tribal Governance Innovation Spotlight
    NATIONAL CONGRESS OF AMERICAN INDIANS TRIBAL GOVERNANCE INNOVATION SPOTLIGHT Food Sovereignty SAN CARLOS APACHE TRIBE WHAT’S INSIDE Seeking to reconnect the Western Apache people to the natural world and the physical, cultural, and spiritual sustenance it provides, the San Carlos Apache Tribe has spent the past three decades exhaustively documenting the diversity, expanse, and nutritional benefits of the pre-reservation Apache diet. Through its Traditional Western Apache Diet Project and the various informational and educational resources the Project shares across the reservation and beyond, the Tribe is training and guiding tribal members to embrace their traditional foodways as an irreplaceable pathway to individual, family, and community wellness and prosperity. he San Carlos Apache Tribe is one of four federally Western Apaches’ mutually nourishing relationship with the recognized tribal nations in Arizona that descend in natural world is what made them “Innee (in Apache, ‘the T whole or part from the Western Apaches, a closely people’), who they know themselves to be.”9 related network of 20 Apache bands that had long presided over a substantial portion of the state’s eastern half before Apaches and the Natural World: Forced Separation the arrival of white settlers in the mid-19th century.2 However, the Western Apaches’ finely-tuned food system Prior to their confinement on reservations following the could not withstand the unrelenting advance of the Civil War, Western Apaches adeptly supported themselves American frontier beginning in the 1850s. In just two through their adaptive management of a versatile seasonal decades, encroachment by white settlers and attacks by the subsistence system rooted in an U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 Electronic Data Deliverable Valid Values Reference Manual
    ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGION 5 ELECTRONIC DATA DELIVERABLE VALID VALUES REFERENCE MANUAL Appendix to EPA Electronic Data Deliverable (EDD) Comprehensive Specification Manual . March, 2019 ELECTRONIC DATA DELIVERABLE VALID VALUES REFERENCE MANUAL Appendix to EPA Electronic Data Deliverable (EDD) Comprehensive Specification Manual TABLE OF CONTENTS Table A-1 Matrix .......................................................................................................................................... 5 Table A-2 Coord Geometric type .................................................................................................................. 7 Table A-3 Horizontal Collection Method ..................................................................................................... 7 Table A-4 Horizontal Accuracy Units .......................................................................................................... 8 Table A-5 Horizontal Datum ........................................................................................................................ 8 Table A-6 Elevation Collection Method ....................................................................................................... 8 Table A-7 Elevation Datum .......................................................................................................................... 9 Table A-8 Material ........................................................................................................................................ 9 Table
    [Show full text]
  • FEIS for Arizona Snowbowl Facilities Improvements
    United States Department of Agriculture Final Environmental Forest Service Impact Statement Southwestern Region for Arizona Snowbowl February 2005 Facilities Improvements Volume 2 Response to Comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement Coconino National Forest Coconino County, Arizona FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT FOR THE ARIZONA SNOWBOWL FACILITIES IMPROVEMENTS PROPOSAL VOLUME 2 RESPONSE TO COMMENTS ON THE DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT COCONINO NATIONAL FOREST COCONINO COUNTY, ARIZONA FEBRUARY 2005 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................................1 1.0 NEPA PROCESS...........................................................................................................................................3 2.0 USFS POLICY.............................................................................................................................................13 3.0 DOCUMENT STRUCTURE......................................................................................................................19 4.0 MODIFIED ALTERNATIVES..................................................................................................................21 5.0 CULTURAL RESOURCES .......................................................................................................................25 6.0 WATER RESOURCES ..............................................................................................................................40
    [Show full text]
  • 4312-52 DEPARTMENT of the INTERIOR National Park Service
    This document is scheduled to be published in the Federal Register on 10/23/2019 and available online at https://federalregister.gov/d/2019-23078, and on govinfo.gov 4312-52 DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR National Park Service [NPS-WASO-NAGPRA-NPS0029003; PPWOCRADN0-PCU00RP14.R50000] Notice of Inventory Completion: U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Wupatki National Monument, Flagstaff, AZ AGENCY: National Park Service, Interior. ACTION: Notice. SUMMARY: The U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Wupatki National Monument has completed an inventory of human remains, in consultation with the appropriate Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations, and has determined that there is no cultural affiliation between the human remains and any present-day Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations. Representatives of any Indian Tribe or Native Hawaiian organization not identified in this notice that wish to request transfer of control of these human remains should submit a written request to Wupatki National Monument. If no additional requestors come forward, transfer of control of the human remains to the Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian organizations stated in this notice may proceed. DATES: Representatives of any Indian Tribe or Native Hawaiian organization not identified in this notice that wish to request transfer of control of these human remains should submit a written request with information in support of the request to Wupatki National Monument at the address in this notice by [INSERT DATE 30 DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER]. ADDRESSES: Kayci Cook Collins, Superintendent, Wupatki National Monument, 6400 N. Highway 89, Flagstaff, AZ 86004, telephone (928) 526-1157 ext.
    [Show full text]
  • Contributions by Employer
    2/4/2019 CONTRIBUTIONS FOR HILLARY CLINTON FOR PRESIDENT HOME / CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS AND DATA / PRESIDENTIAL REPORTS / 2008 APRIL MONTHLY / REPORT FOR C00431569 / CONTRIBUTIONS BY EMPLOYER CONTRIBUTIONS BY EMPLOYER HILLARY CLINTON FOR PRESIDENT PO Box 101436 Arlington, Virginia 22210 FEC Committee ID #: C00431569 This report contains activity for a Primary Election Report type: April Monthly This Report is an Amendment Filed 05/22/2008 EMPLOYER SUM NO EMPLOYER WAS SUPPLIED 6,724,037.59 (N,P) ENERGY, INC. 800.00 (SELF) 500.00 (SELF) DOUGLASS & ASSOCI 200.00 - 175.00 1)SAN FRANCISCO PARATRAN 10.50 1-800-FLOWERS.COM 10.00 101 CASINO 187.65 115 R&P BEER 50.00 1199 NATIONAL BENEFIT FU 120.00 1199 SEIU 210.00 1199SEIU BENEFIT FUNDS 45.00 11I NETWORKS INC 500.00 11TH HOUR PRODUCTIONS, L 250.00 1291/2 JAZZ GRILLE 400.00 15 WEST REALTY ASSOCIATES 250.00 1730 CORP. 140.00 1800FLOWERS.COM 100.00 1ST FRANKLIN FINANCIAL 210.00 20 CENTURY FOX TELEVISIO 150.00 20TH CENTURY FOX 250.00 20TH CENTURY FOX FILM CO 50.00 20TH TELEVISION (FOX) 349.15 21ST CENTURY 100.00 24 SEVEN INC 500.00 24SEVEN INC 100.00 3 KIDS TICKETS INC 121.00 3 VILLAGE CENTRAL SCHOOL 250.00 3000BC 205.00 312 WEST 58TH CORP 2,000.00 321 MANAGEMENT 150.00 321 THEATRICAL MGT 100.00 http://docquery.fec.gov/pres/2008/M4/C00431569/A_EMPLOYER_C00431569.html 1/336 2/4/2019 CONTRIBUTIONS FOR HILLARY CLINTON FOR PRESIDENT 333 WEST END TENANTS COR 100.00 360 PICTURES 150.00 3B MANUFACTURING 70.00 3D INVESTMENTS 50.00 3D LEADERSHIP, LLC 50.00 3H TECHNOLOGY 100.00 3M 629.18 3M COMPANY 550.00 4-C (SOCIAL SERVICE AGEN 100.00 402EIGHT AVE CORP 2,500.00 47 PICTURES, INC.
    [Show full text]
  • Ashfall to Pact Events, and the State of the Early Atmosphere
    Newsletter of the Volcanology and Igneous Petrology Division Geological Association of Canada No. 64 April 27, 2007 From the President Canada has been doing well, the universities are produc- ing high-quality graduates in our field and the theses topics As a member of the selection committee for the Gelinas are more diverse than they were twenty years ago but still Gold Medal, I read several Ph.D. theses over a period of outstanding. several weeks. They were all excellent, cutting edge theses covering a wide variety of topics ranging from physical From the Editor volcanology through experimental petrology to petrology of mineralized granites. While reading the theses, I thought In this issue we have activity reports from Dante Canil at back to about twenty years ago when I first was on the the University of Victoria, Ryan Toole at the University of executive committee and the chair. At that time the division New Brunswick and Ben Edwards from Dickinson Col- discussed creating an award for the best thesis in volcanol- lege. There have been a few significant eruptions in the last ogy. A prominent member of the division, Leopold Gelinas few months. Nevado Del Huila in Colombia erupted on from Montreal, had recently died so we decided to name 17-18 April causing damage to houses and destroying 19 the award after him. Initially, the division had only a single bridges along the Páez and Símbola rivers. According to the award so we had to compare Ph.D. and M.Sc. theses but the New Zealand Institute of Geological & Nuclear Sciences, total number of theses submitted was significantly lower on Sunday, 19 March, rain triggered a lahar or volcanic than at present.
    [Show full text]
  • MANAGEMENT PLAN November 2003
    MANAGEMENT PLAN November 2003 for Stikine Country Protected Areas Mount Edziza Provincial Park Mount Edziza Protected Area (Proposed) Stikine River Provincial Park Spatsizi Plateau Wilderness Provincial Park Gladys Lake Ecological Reserve Ministry of Water, Land Pitman River Protected Area and Air Protection Environmental Stewardship Chukachida Protected Area Division Skeena Region Tatlatui Provincial Park Stikine Country Protected Areas M ANAGEMENT LAN P November 2003 Prepared by Skeena Region Environmental Stewardship Division Smithers BC Stikine Country Protected Areas Management Plan National Library of Canada Cataloguing in Publication Data British Columbia. Environmental Stewardship Division. Skeena Region. Stikine Country Protected Areas management plan Cover title: Management plan for Stikine Country Protected Areas. Issued by: Ministry of Water, Land and Air Protection, Environmental Stewardship Division, Skeena Region. “November 2003” “Mount Edziza Provincial Park, Mount Edziza Protected Area (Proposed), Stikine River Provincial Park, Spatsizi Plateau Wilderness Provincial Park, Gladys Lake Ecological Reserve, Pitman River Protected Area, Chukachida Protected Area, Tatlatui Provincial Park”—Cover. Also available on the Internet. Includes bibliographical references: p. ISBN 0-7726-5124-8 1. Protected areas - British Columbia – Stikine Region. 2. Provincial parks and reserves - British Columbia – Stikine Region. 3. Ecosystem management - British Columbia – Stikine Region. I. British Columbia. Ministry of Water, Land and Air Protection.
    [Show full text]
  • Traditional Resource Use of the Flagstaff Area Monuments
    TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE OF THE FLAGSTAFF AREA MONUMENTS FINAL REPORT Prepared by Rebecca S. Toupal Richard W. Stoffle Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology University of Arizona Tucson, AZ 86721 July 19, 2004 TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE OF THE FLAGSTAFF AREA MONUMENTS FINAL REPORT Prepared by Rebecca S. Toupal Richard W. Stoffle Shawn Kelly Jill Dumbauld with contributions by Nathan O’Meara Kathleen Van Vlack Fletcher Chmara-Huff Christopher Basaldu Prepared for The National Park Service Cooperative Agreement Number 1443CA1250-96-006 R.W. Stoffle and R.S. Toupal, Principal Investigators Bureau of Applied Research in Anthropology University of Arizona Tucson, AZ 86721 July 19, 2004 TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................................iv CHAPTER ONE: STUDY OVERVIEW ..................................................................................1 Project History and Purpose...........................................................................................1 Research Tasks...............................................................................................................1 Research Methods..........................................................................................................2 Organization of the Report.............................................................................................7
    [Show full text]
  • Four Corners Regional
    «¬96 ¤£191 ¤£40 «¬46 287 «¬79 UTAH ¬131 «¬9 ¤£6 40 ¤£ COLORADO«¬36 36 ¤£89 « «¬103 ¤£ ¨¦§225 ¤£ ¬264 «¬74 «¬132 « 70 177 «¬13 §¨¦ 6 «¬5 «¬ 1 Four Corners National Monument 117 ¤£ 1 Four«¬75 Corners«¬88 National«¬470 Monument «¬ 116 2 Hovenweep National Monument «¬78 «¬ 124 139 2 Canyons of the Ancients National Monument Four«¬ Corners«¬ Regional Map 9 3 Bluff Fort «¬ 3 «¬ 121Lowry¤£85 Pueblo 4 Valley of the Gods «¬31 4 Cortez 155 ¤£285 5 Goosenecks State Park 125 «¬ 5 Canyons of the Ancients Visitor Center «¬ 105 6 Goulding's Trading Post Museum «¬29 «¬91 6 Mesa«¬ Verde National Park 28 www.aztecnm.com 1-888-543-4629 7 La Plata Canyon 83 «¬86 7 The Dinosaur Museum «¬ «¬67 «¬ ¤£6 57 ¤£6 8 Durango - Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad 8 Edge of the Cedars State Park «¬ 330 ¤£50 «¬ 9 Chimney Rock National Monument 9 Natural Bridges National Monument ¤£50 )"15 «¬82 9 ¬64 «¬ 10 Pagosa Springs 10 Newspaper Rock State Park « ¤£6 ¤£6 65 133 ¤£24 11 Silverton «¬217 11 Canyonlands National Park (East«¬100 Entrance) «¬10 «¬ «¬ )"18 «¬6 «¬141 12 Ouray 12 Canyonlands«¬257 National Park (North Entrance) 13 Telluride «¬21 13 Hole in the Rock 14 Black Canyon of the Gunnison National Park 14 Arches National Park §¨¦70 15 Dinosaur Journey¤£24 (Museum of Western«¬94 Colorado) 15 Dead Horse Point State Park133 119 16«¬67 Great Sand Dunes National Park and Preserve «¬ «¬ «¬9 «¬21 16 Goblin Valley State Park ¤£89 «¬128 «¬135 17 Little Wild Horse Canyon «¬141 115 «¬313 «¬348 «¬ 18 John Wesley Powell River History Museum «¬72 )"14 Colorado Scenic Byways )"17)"16
    [Show full text]
  • Mineral Appraisal of the Kaibab National Forest, Arizona MLA 6-92
    ! a [MLA[6"g2 I Mineral Land Assessment Open File Report/1992 I I Mineral Appraisal of the Kaibab National Forest, I Arizona I I I I tional I I I i L I BUREAU OF MINES I UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR I I I I I MINERAL APPRAISAL OF THE KAIBAB NATIONAL FOREST, ARIZONA ! I by I David C. Scott I I MLA 6-92 I 1992 I I -.4 Intermountain Field Operations Center ! Denver, Colorado ! UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR I Manuel Lujan Jr., Secretary BUREAU OF MINES I T S ARY, Director I I l I I PREFACE A January, 1987 Interagency Agreement between the Bureau of Mines, U.S. Geological Survey, and U.S. Forest Service describes I the purpose, authority, and program operation for the forest-wide studies. The program is intended to assist the Forest Service in incorporating mineral resource data in forest plans as specified by I the National Forest Management Act (1976) and Title 36, Chapter 2, Part 219, Code of Federal Regulations, and to augment the Bureau's mineral resource data base so that it can analyze and make I available minerals information as required by the National Materials and Minerals Policy, Research and Development Act (1980). This report is based on available data from literature and field investigations. I l I I I I I I I I This open-file report summarizes the results of a Bureau of Mines forest-wide study. The report is preliminary and has not been edited or reviewed for conformity with ! the Bureau of Mines editorial standards.
    [Show full text]