DOCSLIB.ORG

Clean Water Rule Response to Comments – Topic 17: Non-Technical Comments (Vol.2)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Clean Water Rule Response to Comments – Topic 17: Non-Technical Comments (Vol.2) Clean Water Rule Response to Comments – Topic 17: Non-Technical Comments (vol.2) Clean Water Rule Comment Compendium Topic 17 – Non-Technical Comments (Volume 2) The Response to Comments Document, together with the preamble to the final Clean Water Rule, presents the responses of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of the Army (collectively “the agencies”) to the more than one million public comments received on the proposed rule (79 FR 22188 (Apr. 21, 2014)). The agencies have addressed all significant issues raised in the public comments. As a result of changes made to the preamble and final rule prior to signature, and due to the volume of comments received, some responses in the Response to Comments Document may not reflect the language in the preamble and final rule in every respect. Where the response is in conflict with the preamble or the final rule, the language in the final preamble and rule controls and should be used for purposes of understanding the scope, requirements, and basis of the final rule. In addition, due to the large number of comments that addressed similar issues, as well as the volume of the comments received, the Response to Comments Document does not always cross-reference each response to the commenter(s) who raised the particular issue involved. The responses presented in this document are intended to augment the responses to comments that appear in the preamble to the final rule or to address comments not discussed in that preamble. Although portions of the preamble to the final rule are paraphrased in this document where useful to add clarity to responses, the preamble itself remains the definitive statement of the rationale for the revisions adopted in the final rule. In many instances, particular responses presented in the Response to Comments Document include cross references to responses on related issues that are located either in the preamble to the Clean Water Rule, the Technical Support Document, or elsewhere in the Response to Comments Document. All issues on which the agencies are taking final action in the Clean Water Rule are addressed in the Clean Water Rule rulemaking record. Accordingly, the Response to Comments Document, together with the preamble to the Clean Water Rule and the information contained in the Technical Support Document, the Science Report, and the rest of the administrative record should be considered collectively as the agencies’ response to all of the significant comments submitted on the proposed rule. The Response to Comments Document incorporates directly or by reference the significant public comments addressed in the preamble to the Clean Water Rule as well as other significant public comments that were submitted on the proposed rule. This compendium, as part of the Response to Comments Document, provides a compendium of the non-technical comments (volume 2), submitted by commenters. Comments have been copied into this document “as is” with no editing or summarizing. Footnotes in regular font are taken directly from the comments. 1 Clean Water Rule Response to Comments – Topic 17: Non-Technical Comments (vol.2) TOPIC 17. NON-TECHNICAL COMMENTS ..................................................................................... 5 17.1. PROPERTY OWNER .............................................................................................................. 5 AGENCY SUMMARY RESPONSE ...................................................................................... 5 SPECIFIC COMMENTS ..................................................................................................... 5 Koontz, S.M. (Doc. #0020)..................................................................................... 5 Latchford, A. (Doc. #0600)..................................................................................... 5 Anonymous (Doc. #0820)....................................................................................... 6 Dion, B. (Doc. #0835)............................................................................................. 7 Ealy, S. (Doc. #0910.1)........................................................................................... 7 Shaughness, J. (Doc. #0930) ................................................................................... 8 Kaun, S. (Doc. #0944) ............................................................................................ 8 Smith, C. and L. (Doc. #0974) ................................................................................ 9 Hixson, R. and D. (Doc. #1201) ........................................................................... 10 Yoder, M. (Doc. #1601)........................................................................................ 10 Ray, C. (Doc. #1745) ............................................................................................ 11 Calcote, R. (Doc. #1850) ...................................................................................... 11 Anonymous (Doc. #2127)..................................................................................... 12 Anonymous (Doc. #2129)..................................................................................... 12 Anonymous (Doc. #2138)..................................................................................... 13 Anonymous (Doc. #2572)..................................................................................... 14 Smith, R. & J. (Doc. #2667) ................................................................................. 14 Anonymous (Doc. #3071)..................................................................................... 15 Baruch, M. A. (Doc. #3221) ................................................................................. 16 Reed, K. A. (Doc. #3386) ..................................................................................... 16 Thrower, G. (Doc. #3502)..................................................................................... 17 Dux, L. & N. (Doc. #4263) ................................................................................... 18 Anonymous (Doc. #4440)..................................................................................... 18 Daly, M. (Doc. #6516) .......................................................................................... 19 Kaufman, S. (Doc. #6833) .................................................................................... 20 Anonymous (Doc. #7176)..................................................................................... 20 Anonymous (Doc. #8794)..................................................................................... 21 Anonymous (Doc. #8805)..................................................................................... 21 Tolson, E. (Doc. #10768)...................................................................................... 22 Anonymous (Doc. #10849)................................................................................... 23 Cooper, B. (Doc. #11375) ..................................................................................... 23 Porter, P.J. (Doc. #11596)..................................................................................... 24 Williams, E. H. (Doc. #14961) ............................................................................. 25 Mason, A. and NY State Ornithological Association, Inc. (Doc. #15743)........... 25 L.H. (Doc. #15750) ............................................................................................... 26 Anonymous (Doc. #16388)................................................................................... 27 Anonymous (Doc. #16422)................................................................................... 27 Potts, C. (Doc. #16807)......................................................................................... 28 Huffmaster, D. (Doc. #18633) .............................................................................. 29 Grether, S. (Doc. #18668) ..................................................................................... 30 17.2. BUSINESS OWNER .............................................................................................................. 30 AGENCIES’ SUMMARY RESPONSE ................................................................................ 30 2 Clean Water Rule Response to Comments – Topic 17: Non-Technical Comments (vol.2) SPECIFIC COMMENTS ................................................................................................... 30 Guthrie, T. (Doc. #0921.1).................................................................................... 30 James, D. (Doc. #0991)......................................................................................... 31 Anonymous (Doc. #5366)..................................................................................... 31 Schlautmann, J. (Doc. #6072.1) ............................................................................ 32 Carlson, R. (Doc. #11834) .................................................................................... 33 Klaassen, D. (Doc. #12193) .................................................................................. 33 Martin Marietta (Doc. #13593) ............................................................................. 34 Steinlage, J. (Doc. #13751) ................................................................................... 34 Poirier, D. (Doc. #18679).....................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Hanging in the Balance the Precarious Artistry of Balancing Stones P.38
    January/February 2016 US $6.95 TM POServing ProfessionalsND in the Pond TRADEand Water Feature Industry www.pondtrademag.com Hanging in the Balance The precarious artistry of balancing stones p.38 A Pond's Patina p.15 Stop the Seepage! p.32 Conceal Your Filtration Equipment p.43 SCAN HERE AND REGISTER TODAY!! FEBRUARY 24 - 26, 2016 CHARLES VANDER KOOI DAVID DUENSING President & Consultant at Star of Pool Masters on Vander Kooi & Associates Inc. Animal Planet • Twenty-four seminars taught by the • Trade show featuring 25 of the leading industry experts industry's top manufacturers • Water feature build on 02/24/2015 • Network with other successful water • Show Special: take an extra 10-20% feature professionals off orders placed at the Expo REGISTER TODAY!! ADMISSION IS FREE!! . INDUSTRY PROFESSIONALS ONLY! 866 219 3561 OR WWW.WGEXPO.COM PONDTRADE TMTM Volume 21 | Issue 1 January/February 2016 Serving Professionals in the Pond and Water Feature Industry 24 Oh Baby, Baby! LANGUAGE OF KOI You don’t often think of koi lovers as gamblers, but it can be a bit of 19 a gamble to pick out new koi for your collection — especially when 32 they’re babies! Shane Stefek of Water Garden Gems walks you through the traits to look for when assessing Tosai, or young koi. Follow his steps to buy Tosai that will grow into award-winning adults! 28 Oh, Mama Mia! The best pond projects are catered to the needs of their wild inhabitants. So when the occupant of a project-in-progress is a Serval — a large cat native to sub-Saharan Africa — no cookie- cutter design will do! Aaron Burchett showcases the extra effort required to create a manmade home fit for a wild animal.
    [Show full text]
  • Swimponds and Ponds Professionally Designed It's Easy with OASE
    Pond Construction 2012 SwimPonds and ponds professionally designed It’s easy with OASE OASE – Passionate about water. Editorial Dear SwimPond and pond construction pros, the new pond construction season is right around the corner and this year OASE is at your side as a competent partner in all things concerning pond construction, and SwimPond construction in particular. Our pond technology will also persuade you: The new AquaMax Eco Premium 12V and the new ProfiClear Premium set standards in the area of SwimPond technology. We would be pleased to support you in the planning of your projects and advise you in the implementation. But first we would like to introduce our comprehensive product range to you. Sincerely, Christoph Bültel Sales Director, Central Europe See the OASE recommendations! 2 Contents SWIMPONDS: THE CONCEPT 4 ILLUMINATION & POWER 30 OASE SwimPonds 4 LunAqua 10 system 30 SwimPond concept 5 SwimPond 20 & SwimPond 32 6 Technical data 8 POND CONSTRUCTION & DECORATION 32 SwimPond Individual & rehabilitation 10 Maintenance & care 12 Everything for professional pond construction 32 Fleece & liner 34 Pond construction accessories 36 FILTER- & WATERCOURSE PUMPS 14 AquaMax Eco Premium 12 V 14 NATURAL POOLS 38 Clear Lake System 250/500 38 FILTERS & AERATORS 16 Clear Fountain System & water treatment 40 Module filter concept – ProfiClear Premium 16 ProfiClear Classic 20 WORTH KNOWING 41 Technical data 22 Selection tables 24 Guarantee conditions 41 Impressions 42 Discussion handbook 43 CLEANING & CARE 26 Surface skimmers AquaSkim 40 26 BioSys Skimmer + 26 ProfiSkim 100 27 Skimmer 250 27 Maintenance accessories Pond care AquaActiv 28 3 Pond Construction & Decoration Construction Pond OASE SwimPonds OASE SwimPonds Holiday paradise in your own garden A private SwimPond in the garden – the dream of many garden owners.
    [Show full text]
  • Disadvantages of a Fish Pond • Increased Expense to Install a Deeper Pond and Purchase the Fish and Supplies
    1 www.pondbuilder.com © PondBuilder 2011 Table of Contents Choose Your Pond Design…….……………………………………...………… 3 Water Gardens with Waterfalls…….…………………………………………. 4 Pond Equipment Requirements.…………………………………………… 6 Adding Fish to Your Pond…………….……………………………………..… 9 Building Koi Gardens……………………………………….…………………... 11 Routine Pond Cleaning – What to Expect……………...…………….. 13 Pondless Waterfalls……..…..…………………………………………….…….… 14 How Pondless Waterfalls Work…………………………………………… 15 Retaining Wall Waterfalls….. …………………………………………….…... 16 How Retaining Wall Waterfalls Work…………………………………… 17 Getting the Right Retaining Wall Waterfall Equipment……….. 18 www.pondbuilder.com © PondBuilder 2011 2 Choose Your Pond Design Most people associate the soothing sounds of waterfalls and streams with relaxation and calm. There is nothing more peaceful than gazing out to a beautiful landscape with the sounds of nature surrounding you. You can easily bring that feeling of serenity into your own home or office by incorporating a water garden into your landscape design. Water gardens are typically small and relatively shallow, around 18-24 inches deep, and have a gravel base. The easiest way to build a pond and waterfall is to purchase a complete water garden kit. The kits are available in a variety of sizes and specifications, include a waterfall, and come with instructions and all of the equipment you need to create an exciting water feature indoors or out. You can install them yourself or hire a professional landscape company. There are 3 types of water garden kits to choose from: 1. Water Gardens with waterfalls 2. Pondless Waterfalls (A waterfall without a pond.) 3. Retaining Wall Waterfalls www.pondbuilder.com © PondBuilder 2011 3 Water Gardens with Waterfalls Small Water Gardens Small water garden kits are great starter ponds and typically 100 square feet (approx.
    [Show full text]
  • Backyard Water Garden Pond Styles
    Backyard Water Garden Pond styles Starter Pre-formed Pond Even though starter or pre-formed ponds are very popular, there are only a few benefits to this pond style. In fact, many people become so frustrated with the problems of starter ponds that they may decide all pond styles are too much work to maintain. Hard shelled pre-formed ponds only work better than flexible rubber liners when used indoors or on top of a deck. If you must dig a hole for a hard shelled liner, you must be very careful to dig it the proper size and shape. If the hole is too big, the weight of the water will cause the hard shell to sag and crack or sag and let the water out of the low side. In areas with heavy clay soil or compacted soil, the hard shell liner can pop out of the ground when rain or irrigation water fills the hole under the pond liner. In any situation that requires digging and even in some above ground situations, a flexible liner is much better. Pre-formed ponds are the old fashioned and mostly out of date way of making a water garden. Advantages 1. Low Cost. 2. Shallower pond is be safer. 3. Can be used with out digging a hole, such as indoors. Disadvantages 1. Harder to install in the ground since the hole must fit the shape of the hard shell, otherwise the pond can crack. 2. Pump in the pond is ugly and hard to hide. 3. Pump in the pond is very prone to clogging and is hard to clean.
    [Show full text]
  • Welcome to the Heart of Texas Water Garden & Pond Society 2018
    Welcome To The Heart of Texas Water Garden & Pond Society 2018 Annual Parade of Ponds June 2nd and 3rd Saturday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM ● Saturday Night 8:30 PM to 10:30 PM ● Sunday 12:00 noon to 5:00 PM ● Please check individual ponds for SPECIAL viewing times 2 Tips for Pleasurable What is the Heart of Take a Break Lunch time is a great time to Texas Water Garden Pond Touring take a break, regroup, and make adjustments to your plan. A break from intensive pond touring Plan Your Route Before you start your tour, will increase your energy level and mental get familiar with the ponds on the tour and then The HOTWGPS is a group of people alertness. make a list of those you would like to see. who share a common interest in the Bring a Map in Addition to those pro- Drink plenty of water It is hot this time care and feeding of fish, water plants, of the year; therefore, it is very important to and the tranquility and the beauty of the vided Although directions to each pond are drink plenty of water. Because you will be out- water garden. contained inside, you may need a more detailed side all day, be sure to stay hydrated. area map. A GPS unit can be quite helpful. We are a not-for-profit organization Relax and Enjoy You may not be able to with the following objectives: Wear Sun Protection It is very easy to get a visit every pond on this tour.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the September / October, 2010
    Serving Professionals in the Garden Pond Industry ™ Volume 15 Issue 5 September/October 2010 US $6.95 Request info at www.pondtrademag.com/infocard/ ‰ # 314 Request info at www.pondtrademag.com/infocard/ ‰ # 344 ™ PPOONNDD Trraa ddee Magazine Serving Professionals in the Garden Pond Industry Features 10 IKEAGE Vicki Vaughan, Flat Rock Koi An Ikeage is a ritual performed several times a year by Japanese koi breeders. It literally means, "mud pond harvest." Ikeage is a lot of work, but it is also a time of celebration. See how one US koi farm continues this tradition. There is always a great deal of excitement when the nets are pulled and everyone sees how the koi have grown and developed. 11 Product of the Year 2010 Challenge Our Product of the Year Challenge for 2010 starts now. Manufactures send in your entries and readers can make suggestions. This is a great way to showcase the exciting new products released in 2010. 10 12 Pond Leaks Part Two – Advanced Investigation Jamie Beyer, Midwest Waterscapes Leaks can be in so many places. Pond expert Jamie Beyer takes you through a series of steps on where leaks can be and how to find them in this second of a two-part series. Areas like waterfalls, outlet tubing, skimmers, streams, invasive plants and more are all discussed. Patience is key as some leaks are easy to find, some can take days. 18 Rain Water – Benefit or Hazard for Ponds Ann Telford, AllClear Water Purifiers This may not be what you think, not all rain water is safe for fish.
    [Show full text]
  • Pond Build Pack
    Pond Build I First you dig a hole. Well, OK…..there is a little more to it than that, but not that much more. The following instructions will guide you through a simple and generic construction project suitable for most backyard ponds. Your pond can be as uncomplicated or as elaborate as you choose when using a flexible Pond Liner. We suggest you read a few of the many excellent books on water gardening and visit Nelson Water Gardens for ideas. We’re more than happy to help you design your pond! Design Designing the pond is a series of steps. The first step is to dream. Thumbing through books and magazines on gardening will help you envision your ultimate water garden. Next create a portfolio of favorite garden designs and elements. You will discover as you build your portfolio that you tend to choose the same designs and elements over and over again. This will give you a base on which to build the aesthetic portion of your design. Two helpful rules of thumb in design 1. Gardens come into two very broad categories; formal and natural. If you choose formal, then the garden will fall into straight lines and geometric shapes. A natural garden is comprised of flowing lines and curves. All other elements of the garden should be consistent with a formal or natural layout. 2. Choose a design element whether it be color, form, texture or line and repeat it over and over in the your design. This repetition will give your water garden consistency and establish a theme.
    [Show full text]
  • Welcome to the Heart of Texas Water Garden and Pond Society Tour
    Welcome to the Heart of Texas Water Garden and Pond Society Tour June 10 and 11, 2017 Saturday 9 a.m. to 5 pm Saturday Evening 8:30 pm to 10:30 pm Sunday 12 Noon to 5 pm Benefiting Waco Wetlands YOU ARE INVITED! Stroll through gardens and visit ponds in the Waco area. Whether you want ideas for creating your own water garden or just need a relaxing day, this self-drive tour has something for everyone! From a small container pond, to large in-ground ponds, to a fountain choreographed to a music and a light show, you will see a full array of ideas to inspire and delight! COST: $5 cash for a wristband at Barreras Nursery, Robinson Nursery, Landscape Supply, North Waco Tropical Fish, Bonnie’s Greenhouse, Wild Birds Unlimited or any pond on the tour. Kids under 12 free! Note: Ponds are designated DAY/EVENING days and time. Check our Website for this information and directions. heartoftexaswatergardenandpondsociety.com 1. Jerry & Doris Coffee: 3257 Village Park, Waco. A corner-waterfall and rock-ledge grace this pretty new backyard pond at patio’s edge. Adjacent to the Koi pond is a 600 gallon water garden with fancy goldfish. Large brightly colored Koi, shipped in from Hawaii, are now at home in Waco. You must see the unique and complex filtration system of this 5000-gallon pond; the water is crystal clear! Saturday day only. 2. Charlie & Barbara Lucas: 928 Talbert Ranch Rd., China Spring. This 3,500 gallon upper and lower pond with three waterfalls and a stream has been built with over 80% recycled materials including the bridge, liner.
    [Show full text]
  • Comments by Author on the Draft Water-Efficient Single-Family New Home Specification
    Comments by Author on the May 2008 Draft Water-Efficient Single-Family New Home Specification September 2008 Comments by Author on the Draft Water-Efficient Single-Family New Home Specification Commenter Comment Name Alderman, I understand that a change has been proposed in the EPA Water Sense New Homes Specification 4.1.4 for Jeffrey water-efficient new single-family homes: The new proposed draft for Ornamental Water Features reads as follows: "This specification establishes that builders shall not install or facilitate the installation of ornamental water features. Ornamental water features are defined as fountains, ponds, waterfalls, man-made streams and other decorative water related constructions provided solely for aesthetic or beautification purposes. Because these water features serve no functional or practical purpose their water use is not considered efficient." As a registered civil engineer in the state of California, I have designed hundreds of water feature projects over the course of 25 years. My comments regarding the above-proposed new specification draft are as follows: The purpose of water features is not "solely for aesthetic or beautification purposes." (emphasis mine). Your premise is flawed. Aesthetics and beautification are certainly some of the major purposes for water features, as is the case with landscaping in general. Water features also provide the following benefits as well: Provision of Earth Grading/ Earthwork/ Stabilization Options -- in some cases, the installation of a water feature, such as waterfall/ retaining walls, are a superior solution for earth grading and stabilization of land; than soil surface slopes, landscaping, and other methods would provide. Noise abatement -- in many of our projects, water features provide a pleasant, and often necessary, buffer to outside traffic and other unwanted noises.
    [Show full text]
  • Bubblebead Guide
    CONTENTS Page Number BubbleBead filtration for koi ponds 3 The principle behind all biological filter systems 4 The principal behind BubbleBead filters 4 How does such a compact filter compare to large chamber filters? 6 Choosing the correct size of filter; pump and U/V 7 Strainers 9 Table showing model capacity, flow rate, pump & UV options 10 Siting the filter 11 Filter assembly 12 Plumbing in 14 Important points - air breaks; aeration; the waste outlet bore 17 Waste water 18 Starting the filter for the first time 18 Running-in your filter 20 When to backwash the BubbleBead filter 22 Table showing recommended backwash frequencies 23 Long term maintenance 24 Winter running 25 Water quality maintenance 25 Water quality troubleshooting 27 Filter troubleshooting 30 User’s Guide Appendix One – Low siting 34 Appendix Two – Automated backwash options 35 Appendix Three – Pump assisted backwashing 35 to BubbleBead Filters Appendix Four – Combining BubbleBead filters with other equipment 37 Appendix Five – High pressure situations 40 Models 1,2,4,6 &10 References and Sources 41 Guarantee 42 Typical measurements for your BubbleBead filter 43 2 BubbleBead Filtration for Koi Ponds The Principle behind all Biological Filter Systems THE REQUIREMENT FOR FILTRATION THE LIMITATIONS OF ‘NATURAL’ FILTRATION Koi, and similar ornamental fish kept in any numbers, need some form of In natural lake ecosystems, micro-organisms build up on the surfaces of rocks, filtration for their ponds. Koi soon pollute their surroundings due to their plants etc. and help to break down wastes from the limited numbers of fish greedy appetites and vigorous browsing nature, churning up the pool base.
    [Show full text]
  • Pond Basics 4
    Proven Methods for Creating and Maintaining a Pond That’s High in Pleasure and Low in Work. Pond Basics 4 New in this 4th Edition Expanded Information on • Bacteria • Aeration • Pollution Control • Floatation Gardening What's New in Pond Basic's 4 th Edition In this edition you'll find full color and new articles dealing with Flotation Gardening, including Floating Wetlands, retention pond maintenance, aeration, bacteria and controlling pond pollution. Also, we've updated the entire book to reflect the latest information available. The format of this book is simplicity itself: Pertinent points are covered in "bullet item" form supported by easy to understand illustrations. In-depth articles are See pgs. 74-76 included where a lengthier discussion is appropriate. “Flotation Gardening” This volume represents over 60 years of accumulated water gardening experience by principal staff members of Maryland Aquatic Nurseries (M-A-N) and Charleston Aquatic Nurseries (C-A-N). This collaboration, we feel, gives the book more depth than might be possible had it been written by one individual. Throughout the book you’ll find references to specific ideas and methods that incorporate some of our own products. Please understand that the essentials of successful high pleasure / low work water gardening remain the same no matter whose products you use. For more information about our products visit us at: www.aqua-link.com & www.floatingwetlands.com This edition of Pond Basic is Dedicated to . Laurence Gedye Gedye Water Gardens Melbourne, Australia 1930 - 2007 A truly gentle man, an entrepreneur extraordinaire, a life long water gardener and our good friend.
    [Show full text]
  • Water Challenge Badge Resource and Activity Guide
    Supported by YOUTH AND UNITED NATIONS GLOBAL ALLIANCE LEARNING AND ACTION SERIES Water Challenge Badge Resource and Activity Guide CBD :: FAO :: UN-WATER :: WAGGGS :: WOSM We are many. We are YUNGA! The designations employed and the presentation of material in this information product do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) concerning the legal or development status of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. The mention of specific companies or products of manufacturers, whether or not these have been patented, does not imply that these have been endorsed or recommended by FAO in preference to others of a similar nature that are not mentioned. The views expressed in this information product are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of FAO. All rights reserved. Reproduction and dissemination of material in this information product for educational and other non-commercial purposes are authorized without any prior written permission from the copyright holders provided the source is fully acknowledged. Reproduction of material in this information product for resale or other commercial purposes is prohibited without written permission of the copyright holders. Applications for such permission should be addressed to: Chief Electronic Publishing Policy and Support Branch Communications Division FAO Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, 00153 Rome, Italy or by e-mail to: [email protected] ©FAO 2013 This document has been financed by the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency, Sida.
    [Show full text]