Lllliiiii Liiiiiii
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
llllIIIII000010067t lIIIIIII Transcript Exhibit(s) Docket #(s): \:l30008F-999490 00\'~\4\ I . m ?35*-,1 r m 4-, Q S ; E s L: m. < 83....> 'El .ii m .-4 *if* Sp U I .,,,4° ,.*.r Exhibit # : 'bi \~a\Tir m m 2-5 12"lim....J co *T-l0r \\s'< QI? €xV\L¥>§3vs err) *M M "s\€¢\\ v Arizona Ctimoration Commission 'Ct C r( ETE:D v { r 'I . .*WE ;.._ .4. ;J :_; DOCKETED BY o ACRA Arizona Reporting Service, Inc. NCRA.. Arizona Court Reporters Association Court Reporting & Videoconferencing Center M E M B E R Guardians of the Record e-mail: [email protected] www.az-reporting.'RECEIVED Marta T. Hetzer Suite 502 Administrator/Owner \8 2200 North Central Avenue 2889 JUL lLiF9 2: Phoenix, AZ 85004-1481 a Ru a § MAIN (602) 274-9944 L 4 1_ Mia a 1 \ FAX (602) 277-4264 ,urJcéitT°Eo:lT§oC To: Docket Control Date : July 14, 2009 Re : UNS / Vail to Valencia L-00000F-09-0190-00144 Line Siring Committee Case No. 144 Volumes I through V Concluded June 2 through July 9, 2009 STATUS OF ORIGINAL EXHIBITS FILED WITH DOCKET CONTROL Applicant (UNS Exhibits) 1 Admitted 2 Not Utilized 3 Admitted 4 Not Utilized 5 Admitted 6 Not Utilized 7 Admitted 8 Not Utilized 9-12 Admitted 21- 23 Admitted 2 4 Not offered 25~26 Admitted COMMITTEE (COM Exhibits Admitted Public Comment Admitted MAGRUDER (MM Exhibits) 1-8 Admitted 9 Denied 10-12 Admitted 13 Denied 15-19 Admitted 20 Not Offered 21 Admitted ELIZABETH WEBB (EW Exhibits) 1 Admitted 2-3 Not Admitted 4-5 Admitted 7-8 Admitted 9 Not Admitted 10 Deferred 11-19 Admitted 22 Admitted ORIGINAL EXHIBITS RETURNED TO PAR TIES MAGRUDER (MM Exhibits) 14 Withdrawn ELIZABETH WEBB (EW Exhibits) 6 Withdrawn EXHIBITS NOT GIVEN TO THE COURT REPORTER APPLICANT (UNS Exhibits) 13-20 Not Utilized ELIZABETH WEBB (EW Exhibits) 20-21 Not Offered Copy to: John Foreman, Chairman Michael P. Kearns, Interim Executive Director J. Matthew Derstine, Esq. and Marc Jerden, Esq., for UNS Elizabeth Buchroeder Webb Marshall Magruder rt 9 .4 _. > 8 8 8 g. 88 95° 7-\= ~888 8a g 5345 sea §§8 pa 8:35.8 go. 3 IB 8 g g was gist 8 > i § 8 <-< 4 8.85 3 { 8 z 8.4 8 n %§ n 8 (B ELS o n £83 338;- :- 2.3 -1 Ra ~,.n D 483 258 a 8 9 8 9 998 9 a 3 a 8. ~8 $58 O 88 8 3 3 : 9 ¢*;-f a o m .3 8883 § 3§ Bo3388 g 3 8. Q.g sf- = §s<f8 'g § 9 §. £5 § 88; ~<83 3 an § §§ :E. <3 Ag' 38 13 "0 838 34 E m 3 8;< §E> 8 n .§. n 838 a 9 8 § .H 28 3. 3 3 8; 3188 a gg-'iii £8T §38 £8~ l 3 € 38 35-' 8 E358 . 4 % 8 3 438 3 E S §. 3 8 338§= 338 n 185 8 4 8 8 8 5 1,8 as' 3 53 a if 5. m 8 ? go < 8 G 1 c : §§ E B. '30 ~§ 8 §8 o Hz Q 3 8; *Gs 248 :"'§8"ro a* o : " 1 E; 3%. .D I " I 88.~2. F l 8 <1 39 88 1388 E 5 3 go 5. i 593 "Q 85 4 4 1 88 -e g 2 3 = D- f? V93 9 8;8 3 3 .a " 3383 58 548 g 5 8lJ! 38 88 83 88 8 8 8 8 , o E : : 1 8 38- go 5:93 Q 84921i4011q_ I laxsou 3 ° a 48" H00F m dz iv 98 *Q a Sui] if lg? 2 3 3 3 . n s E a > a 3885 3 8833 =b v 94 ,w,=¢ am '85 8~5% "°§§ 38 £8 . 'i~ 3.E& 4 n 88 C148/1\i:§J;_;l;-_} V80 *§ 8 3 533 .-. 38 go 3' ~ ~ 8 8 § 3 a g N N .. anI 1-» v-1 IP* - a ox N »- LA b ) 8 i v *ii ~.¢ v v ;= 85 CO 5 *-I 5 -../ 83 8 u o w E av o iI4 S E? | Gs Cb § A -u " 53 jg 8 3 agr 3 < 3. 3 3 88 8 mo 8 8 8W § g 3. zz: n. :n 8 5 1 g z =a 55. 9 F!! o4 h 3 3 8 3. g 3. :-g 8331 88 go 5. 3 E 8 o. 8 8 8r' g 8 g 2 g s. _.8~ 5 8 3 3 3 E E. g 8 n E Lie E. 8 Q- a a o. o st 3 a: VI 5 5 ' 88=1 8 g. a 5 z '5 5 :=r $- W .8. § I go 5- g 3 as :hh- I 8 8 9 :a 3 3 3,8318 6 8.3 9 ~9 s' 8 § 8. 83 1 8 a 8 n. 8 8 3 8 3 < 8 kg 3 8 3 5° o . §§ Q' 8; 89 n M 5" 8 Ag? 3 3 3 p 8i~ Le8 5: i QC 8 3 9 8 Q Q' 8 o § Q' 8 Q' 4% 8 a. 8 88. 8 8 8 m -3' § 88 a a 5. 8 8 8w 5- I! g g = cu 3 so .Q E 3 g 5. 3. g 8 8 iii 8 3 5.3 Cb 8- 3 g 5 a. 3 g g g oz. an 338498 5: 5 g 5.8 a 8% so. 8 8 8 so § § 8 g re as 3- 3 n g 8 3. 3 g 3 Q' ~~§a 9W 8. 3 Q. 9 8. 5 :- go 'u 8 8 8 go. :. w 8 8. 8. 8 833 3 8 3 an 3 g 5 § 5. O :- 8 m `389 8 s .3 ca. >< '°8 Q 8 n . Q. .3 E £9 g'c Z' 8 2 =§§§ on 8. 3 8 E 8 B 2 ax 8' - | 8 ET 3" 8 § 8"v: n 9 8 EXHIBIT E\V - 10 UNS ELECTRIC, INC. RESPONSES TO ms. WEBB'S FIRST SET OF DATA REQUESTS L-00000F-09_0190 May 21, 2009 Data Request E Webb 5. What planned role (current economic condition not withstanding) does the Vail Substation (either the l38kva or El-Iv) have in the renewable energy ~field'? Data Request E Webb 5a What organizations has TEP worked with towards renewable energy and related transmission line corridor planning in relation to renewable energy? Please list. Data Request E Webb 5b. If TEP has not worked with any organizations but has worked independently, please list this. RESPONSE: Objection: Beyond the scope of the Committee proceedings and is irrelevant to the determination of environmental compatibility and need for the Project. Without waiving the objection, UNS Electric provides the following response: The Vail Substation is a potential connection point for any renewable energy prob acts that might be built in the vicinity of the site. In addition it is connected to the regional electric grid and allows any patty interconnected at the site to access renewables that are connected to the grid. Ar The major effort within the state is the Arizona Renewable Resource and Transmission 1denz'wcation Subcommittee (ARRTIS) that is a part of the South West Area Transmission Study (SWAT) group. This group is working to respond to issues in the Commission's Biennial Transmission Assessment requesting the utilities in Arizona to identify transmission projects to promote renewable energy. b. See the response to E Webb 5a above. RESPONDENTS Ed Beck 'um :° 8 m s II8"g=as • a • • 'S 331 QQ' F! m as 8 332812 33338 mg* o Q So 3 §838412 :a 8 =§ 33mag; go. 8 E-"' gig? 8 83" vol 8 in U\ 3§== O: 5 cm 5" EI 838§3 23~ Ar P of 38 832 41 44 8 o gr z z o "3 ,gt no 833813- 8at n> m u' Q: g 83 - 3 35 5 o 3 8 -Cb ¢o>on U 8? 383 8 3 no 5.0:o 2 83:8148 no Sr. > o g 8 m D a 3823 §9§ E C) an = 3 un) 4 0 Q Ill m 8 8 'n u o 3: 38 .|ll s §§§ fl s UI -5 N E 8' 88832;r in; : D8 q N~1 32388§ 8 3: §§§'9 o _ Q o EIT -» o .9 : 88? pa 3 2 a 8 3§=§9. 8 is 8 8 §I o 'lb _ m 00113 3 3 o 1° a 3 = m an 3 3 8 o a»_ o 8 n m-e 8 3 38 8 iii §lEl n a ~l ?i» _m o m 8 3 : 8 g 3 an 29. E 28833 c 8 "- 'n 8938;5.8§'3§ 35. IH so °a 8 m 9 ' 3 1 o as -0> 3. 8 an 85. 8 n 22 'S ague;:J 8883 33133 o o s co 9. s .= 99 I :* - C b I 5 3 4 1 4 3 8 8 o N a a33§5 : :Ir C m 8 8 2 9 ; o 1•m -L s'~°°= 3 r ' bl :! m 8383? n a 33 88, Qno :cu 8:I 3 n go 9 6 §,§e§ 11 a 8 8:38 i§§§§ g, 9: 9- 3. go a g 8 8 3 3 N so 38888 WE in 4 o_ o 38388 m 3 83 9so 5 . no '-u LII 82 V'3 gig a o 3 3 o UIb 38 2 3! 3 ea "6 B o "b 8\o l\J I i I ! I I Arizona Corporation Commission Docket No.