ivist stlin di leontologi e trtigrfi volume IIT noF Q ppF RPIERQS xovemer PHIH
ri qeqexy ii yi sx ve pe xeX ex yisi
I I
I P
pihisgy wesxs D eyvy wese sxevhs D hese i y 8 qsyexxs hs
eeivedX tune PVD PHIHY eptedX eptemer PPD PHIH
uey wordsX vte wioeneEirlylioeneD qrgnoD insulr fuE plitomeryxD rttomysD tertomysD heinoglerixD rlutrF xegli nni
nD endemismD iohronologyD iogeogrphyF 9VHD il hiprtimento di ienze dell err di pirenzeD nto gli spetE
ti tssonomii @rolgusAD ffront luni spetti evolutiviD pleogeogrE
estrtF efter fortyyersfrom its disoveryDthe historyof the fii e ioronologii he permettono di identifire le fune grgnihe
field surveys nd of the reserhes on the fossiliferous deposits of qrE ome rppresentnti di un ioprovini distint on forti rtteri enE
gno is rieflyreportedF demiiF qli nni WH rppresentno un momento di pprofondimento su
he qrgno fun elongs to the eruzzoEepulin leoioE spetti evolutivi di wikroti e ltri txF el ontempoD un mpgnD in
provine @inluding lso ontrone nd lenD eruzzoAF he fossil ui sono oinvolte ompetenze multidisiplinriD port un piuÁ dettE
ssemlge omprehends ll the lsses of terrestril vertertesX epE glit omprensione dell strtigrfi delle operture sedimentrie loli
tiliD emphiiD eves nd wmmliF he funl omposition is unE e delle modlitÁ di riempimento delle fessureF le lvoro eÁ stto ripreso
lned nd presents the fetures of typil insulr endemi funF he
reentemente in osione delle ttivitÁ di rier finlizzte llo studio
ulk of the ssemlge is omposed of smll mmmls nd irdsF fsed
dei depositi quternri ui ooperno vrie universitÁ itlineD l oE
on litertureD we report the most hrteristi feturesD phylogeneti
printendenz e gli enti loliF v9ultimo deennio eÁ dedito gli studi
reltionshipsD nd evolutionryremrks on list of mmmlsD fousing
tssonomii sui gliridiD sull9vifun e sull9erpetofunF ono frequentiD
prtiulrlyon the dpttions of the most endemi txF woreoverD
infineD lvori in ui le fune endemihe del qrgno vengono itte
iohronologil sheme of the mjor funl events is proposed nd
ome esempio prtiolrmente interessnte per l ontinuitÁ dell doE
illustrtedF elthough still imperfetD the sheme is the first synopsis of
umentzione o per l9evidenz e l dinmi dei proessi evolutiviF
ll the iohronologil nd txonomil informtion on mmmls so
v fun delle erre osse omprende tutte le lssi di verteE
fr villeF iventullyD the hypotheses on the origin nd modes of
rti terrestriX ettiliD enfiiD elli e wmmiferiF v omposizione
olonistion re summrized nd shortlydisussedF
present tutti i rtteri tipii di un fun endemi insulreD nhe se le
prom this overview the qrgno fun is indeed of gret interE
fessure piuÁ ntihe ontengono tx non endemizztiF s tx endemii est for studies of evolution nd iogeogrphyF xonethelessD there re
vengono qui trtteggiti nelle loro linee essenziliD evidenzindo possiE persistent unertinties on its ge nd originD s well s on the ge of
ili relzioni on ntenti ontinentli e i prinipli trend evolutiviF infilling of the krsti fissure system of this unique fossiliferous lolityF
iene quindi proposto per l prim volt un qudro ioronoE
logioD suddiviso in fsi di popolmentoD in ui si eÁ erto di riunire
issuntoF s depositi di riempimento delle fessure rsihe nel
tutte le informzioni reltive i mmmiferi finor desritti in qrgnoF qrgno nordEoidentle @erre osseA ontengono un ri fun
uesto qudro h tuttor un rttere preliminre per le diffioltÁ endemiF pune simili sono stte ritrovte in zone limitrofe del qrE
inontrte nell9integrre informzioni tssonomihe e ronologihe d gnoD m nhe nell zon di endri @ugliAD len e ontrone
lvori ftti d diversi speilisti e per l inompletezz delle onosenze
@eruzzoAF li fune endemihe sono stte riunite nell pleoioproE
su luni tx e sulle fune di numerose fessureF vini eruzzoEepulF
snfineD viene riperors l stori delle ipotesi sull9origine delle sn questo ontriuto si present un reve stori delle rierhe
fune dell pleoioprovini eruzzoEepulD on prtiolre ttenE sul qrgnoD on prtiolre riferimento ll omposizione dell fun
zione l settore grgnioF ve ipotesi sull9etÁ e le modlitÁ di proveE e onsiderzioni ioronologihe e iogeogrfiheF s primi resoonti
nienz sono poi onfrontte e disusseF delle rierhe sull fun delle erre osse rislgono ll9inizio degli
uest pnormi mostr heD dopo qurnt9nni di rierheD nni UHD qundo wtthijs preudenthl pulioÁ un not preliminre
l fun del qrgno eÁD d un ltoD un so di studio molto interessnte sui ritrovmenti di verterti nell9re grgniD individundone il E
per gli spetti evolutivi e iogeogrfiiD mD dll9ltroD nor present rttere endemio insulreF
spetti d9inertezz he rigurdno priniplmente l9etÁ e l provenienE eguironoD d oper di diversi utoriD l desrizione delle viE
z dei tx e in seondo luogo nhe l9etÁ dei depositi fossiliferi stessiF fune e delle forme rttere endemio piuÁ mrtoX wikrotiD roE
I niversitÁ di lermoD hiprtimento di qeologi e qeodesiD i erhirfi PPD sEWHIPQD lermoD stlyF
iEmilX fmsinidunipFitD dripeUPdunipFitD gsurdidunipFit
P niversitÁ di pirenzeD hiprtimento di ienze dell errD i v ir RD sESHIPI pirenzeD stlyF iEmilX polomriFrinldidunimiFit
RPP wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
sntrodution ited with this fun rised onsiderle interest in the
sientifi ommunity@erzrello et lF PHHTAF
ed soil deposits @erre osseA fill most of the
preudenthl @IWUIA tullyntiipted most of
extensive pleokrst network in the wesozoi limeE
the results tht were to e pulished on the erre osse
stone on the xorthEestern slopes of wount qrgnoF
funF sn the following yers preudenthl desried
everl fissure fillings yielded very rih mount of
some endemisD exhiiting most peulir feturesD suh
fossil remins of verydiversified ssemlge of verteE
s heinoglerix @preudenthl IWUPA nd wikroti @preuE
rtesF hese fossils ttest to suession of funl setE
denthl IWUTAF wenwhileD he proposed the first ioE
tlement eventsD whih ourred when the re ws isoE
hronologil rrngement of the fissure fillings @preuE
lted nd inhited yendemi txF wost of the fossiE
denthl IWUTAF preudenthl9s @IWUIA influentil study
liferous deposits hve een exposed yintensive qurE triggered flurryof studiesF
rying in smll reD of out PH squre kilometresD everl monogrphs were pulished on the qrE
inluded etween the towns of eprien nd oggio gno funX fllmnn @IWUQD IWUTA desried the ird
smperile @pigF IAF imilr funD howeverD ws lso reminsD futler @IWVHA revised the genus heinoglerixD
found out of this reD iFeFD t F xzzrio @out S km illemsen @IWVQA nlyzed the otter rlutr grgE
northwrdAD wonte qrnt @PS km outhEistAD s well nensisD veinders @IWVRA the endemi ruminnt roplitoE
s in n unidentified lolityetween frlett nd enE meryxD preudenthl @IWVSA studied the rietidsD nd
dri @preudenthl IWUIAD out IHH km outhEist of hms 8 preudenthl @IWVSA desried the gint dorE
the qurryreF he erre osse funD together with mouse tertomys ltiresttusF
those reovered from ontrone nd lenEgpo di huring the VHsD reserhers of the heprtment of
piume @eruzzoD entrl stlyAD re elieved to prove irth ienes of plorene @stlyA onduted new field
the existene of the soElled eruzzoEepulin leoE surveysD nd gve new impulse to the studies on qrgE
ioprovine @fF wzz 8 ustioni PHHVAF his ontriE no nlyzing the evolution of the fun @in prtiulr
ution intends to e stteEofEtheErt report of the wikroti nd rolgusAD s well s the pleogeogrphy
knowledge on the qrgno funF of the reD ut theylso proposed new iohronoloE
gil rrngement of the fissure fillings @he qiuli et lF
IWVTD D IWVUD Y wzz IWVUD D Y wzz 8 fonte
IWVUAF prom these studies the qrgno fun ws E e rief history of the reserhes in qrgno
knowledged to elong to distint endemi ioprovine
pield surveys were first onduted in the eprieE whih ws lled the epuloEhlmti elm @he qiuli
nEoggio smperile re from IWTW to IWUR @preuE et lF IWVUAF he qiuli 8 orre @IWVRA interpreted the
denthl persF ommFA ywtthijs preudenthl @xturE evolutionrytrends oserved in wikroti nd rolgus
lisD xtionl xtuurhistorish wuseumD of veidenD s the result of ompetitive interreltionships etween
the xetherlndsAF sn his first reportD preudenthl themD while orre @IWVTA stressed the grdulisti sE
@IWUIA identified the peulir gigntism nd errnt pets of the their evolutionF lleri @IWVRA gve suE
morphologies99 of some of the txD thus knowledging stntil ontriution proposing lioene ge to the
the insulr fetures of the erre osse funF woreoverD mrine deposits lollyseling the fissure fillingsF hese
preudenthl reported the ourrene of n erlyleiE mrine sediments were previouslydted to the ortoE
stoene @glrinA fun hrterized y ellophiE nin yh9elessndro et lF @IWUWAF yther studies folE
omysD whih hs lter on een lled irro xord pun lowedD devoted espeillyto the evolution of speifi
yhe qiuli et lF @IWVUAF he find of stone tools ssoE txD nmely wikroti @fonte 8 wsini IWWPY ezzi
pigF I E votion of the sites of the
eruzzoEepulin leoE
ioprovineF
qures indite lolities
with erre osse funD
found in fissure deposits in
the forelnd dominF rinE
gles indite lolities with
remins found in eh to
mrine deposits in the hin dominF
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RPQ
et lF IWWQY rr et lF IWWWY willienErr PHHHY willien everD the predtors re firlyommon nd represented
yroodilesD snkes nd prtiulrlyyirds of preyF 8 teger PHHIAD rolgus @engelone PHHSAD the insetiE
he ltter re represented ytwo endemi speies of vores @pnfni IWWWY vn den roek ystende PHHIAD nd
egle @qrgnoetusA nd six speies of owlD mong roplitomeryx @vn der qeer IWWWD PHHSD PHHVAF
whih three rn owl inluding the verylrgeEsized wenwhileD t the eginning of the WHsD further
yto gignteF xonEendemi smll mmmls re lso field surveys were onduted jointly y the universities
found in the ssemlgeF he funl list of the mmmE of ploreneD isD nd gmerinoF he results of these
lin txD with some txonomil detils nd evolutionE surveys were summrized in ezzi et lF @IWWTA mulE
ryremrksD is reported in F IF tidisiplinryreportD whih reonstruts the evolution
of the krst systemD s well s the origin nd strtigrE
indemi txF roplitomeriide re most peuE phyof the whole outropping suessionD from the
lir endemi ruminntsF heyre represented yseverl erre osse soils up to the leistoene @glrin to
speies of different sizeD t lest two of whih very eentA depositsF he studyinludes lso detiled
smllF heyre hrterized ythe fusion of trsl strtigrphyof the mrine sedimentryover tht loE
ones @nvioEuoid nd mettrslAD whih funtionE llysels the fissuresD together with n interprettion
llylimits lterl movements of the rtiultion @veinE of the pleogeogrphi evolution of the reF
ders 8 ondr IWURAD suggesting loomotion on rgged yver the lst ten yersD interest on the qrgno
terrinsF he most remrkle fetureD howeverD is the fun ursted ginF helfino @PHHPA nd helfino et lF
ourreneD t lest in some speiesD of five rnil pE @PHHUA studied the herpetofun for the first timeD while
pendges @one on the rer end of the nsl oneD nd qohlih 8 vi @PHHVA identified new speies of irdF È
two ouples upon eh oritA oupled with longD sreE qliridsD twentyyersfter hms 8 preudenthl9s
like upper nines @pigF PAF he morphologil distne @IWVSA desription of tertomys ltiresttusD reeived
from the other ruminnt fmiliesD together with the oE the ttention of severl reserhersD iFeFD preudenthl 8
urrene of set of dignosti feturesD whih is not wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHHTAD inldi @PHHTAD wrtõÂnEuÂrez 8
found in the other ruminntsD led veinders @IWVRA to preudenthl @PHHUA nd inldi 8 wsini @PHHWAF sn
refer these endemis to new fmilyF he phylogeneti these ppers five new tertomys speies re desriedF
reltionships of these ruminnt re still detedD s well inldi 8 wsini @PHHWA lso proposed orreltion
s the ge of their ontinentl nestorF eording to etween the fissure iohronologies proposed ypreuE
wzz 8 ustioni @PHHVAD the nestor might e tred denthl @IWUTA nd he qiuli et lF @IWVUAF
k in the vte yligoene efore the divergene eE trting from IWWHD the erre osse fun is onE
tween gervideD fovide nd qirffideF yther uthors sidered n exmple of utmost interestD euse of the
@eFgF woyÁEolÁ et lF IWWWA suggested the possiilityof ontinuityof its doumenttion nd of the promising
n erlyvte wioene nestor @ wiromeryxAD while potentils it hs to provide urteD relile nd semE
veinders @IWVRA suggested the irlywioene emphiE less informtion on evolutionryproessesF st is often
moshus s suitle ndidte to the nestryof the mentioned with ontrone in ppers devoted to the
fmilyF iventullyD vn der qeer @PHHVA nd vn den xeogene pleogeogrphyof the wediterrnen @eFgFX
roek ystende et lF @PHHWA re in fvor of leomeE he qiuli et lF IWWHY woyÁEolÁ et lF IWWWY wsini et
ryide nestorF lF PHHPD D PHHVY ook et lF PHHTD PHHVY de os et lF
heinoglerix is n insetivore elonging to the PHHUY wzz 8 ustioni PHHVAF
ihinosoriineD sufmilynowdysrestrited to
outhern esiF ixtnt ihinosoriine inlude smll
to medium sized speies tht live in tropil or sutroE
he fun
pil forests in humid environmentsF he sufmilyws
he rih erre osse fun inludes ll lsses of widespred in iurope t lest from the yligoene to the
terrestril vertertesX eptiliD emphiiD eves nd irlylioeneD prtiulrlywith representtives of the
wmmliF st is highlyunlnedD howeverD nd preE trie qleriiniF heinoglerix is hrterized yshort
sents ll the fetures of n insulr popultionF he ulk nd strong legsD lrge hed with elongted muzzleD nd
of the ssemlge is omposed of endemi mirommE highlyspeilized hewing pprtus with strongD shrp
mls nd irdsD some of whih of gignti sizeF wroE inisorsD stout third nd fourth premolrsD with lunt
mmmls re poorlyrepresentedX theyinlude group uspsD dpted for rushing99 @futler IWVHAD nd shortD
of ruminnts of the endemi fmilyroplitomeriideD strong row of molrsF he rer prt of the mndile
together with severl speies of the gint insetivore shows verylow ondyleDwhih suggests tht this
heinoglerixD whih is mentioned s lrge mmml moonrt ould widelyopen nd rpidlysnp its jwsF
euse of its nomlous sizeF grnivor re represented sn qrgnoD heinoglerix is present lredyin the most
onlyythe mrine otter rlutr grgnensisF rowE nient fissures with singleD smllEsized nd shortE
RPR wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
F I E yverll txonomi omposition of the mmmlin ssemlges of the wikroti fun @fter he qiuli et lF IWWH nd wsini et lF
PHHVD updtedAF wikroti lineges re numered fter he qiuli et lF @IWVUAF
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RPS
ies with simpler dentl morphology@ F dmsiD F simE
plex nd F degiuliiAF hese groups likelyrepresent two
independent evolutionryrnhes stemming from
ommonD prolynonEendemiD nestor @wrtõ ÂnE
uÂrez 8 preudenthl PHHUY inldi 8 wsini PHHWAF
foth smll nd lrgeEsized speies usullyour
togetherD with few exeptionsX fissure insit ID where
three smll speies ourD prtillyoverlpping in sizeD
two of whih of the simplerEtoothed group @F dmsi
nd F simplexAD nd fissure pQPD where onlythe smllE
sized F degiulii oursF inldi 8 wsini @PHHWA reogE
nized the ourrene of five distint phyleti linegesX
three of the omplexEtoothed group nd two of the
simpler oneF ynlythe evolution of the F dmsiEF
degiulii linege n e followed throughout the suesE
sion of fissuresF st hnged modestlyin morphologynd
it presents redution in size tht is pprentlyopposite
to wht is imposed ythe soElled islnd rule99F he
nestryof tertomys is disussedX preudenthl 8 wrE
tõÂnEuÂrez @PHHTA suggested wessinin wyomimus nE pigF P E eonstrution of the rnium of roplitomeryx mttheiD
estorD wheres inldi @PHHTA onsidered most likely n unusul nterior view @from veinders IWVRAF
widdleEerlyvte wioene nestor of the eridyE
romysEwyomimus linegeF
rolgus is widespred iuropen wioene ohoE muzzled speies @heinoglerix freudenthliAF st underE
tonid @ veryfr reltive of extnt piksAD whih is preE went rdition whih produed t lest two linegesD
sent in qrgno tooF wzz @IWVUD D A shows tht differing in size nd in the shpe of the foreEmuzzleF
qrgno rolgus underwent signifint evolutionry enother qleriini speiesD smller thn the wioE
hnges in the dentl morphologyD oupled with ene representtives of the trieD is veryommon in the
mrked inrese in size ompred to its ontinentl erre osse fissure fillingsF elso this tinygymnure
ounterprtsF e lessEderived nd smller speies @rolE shows some endemi feturesD suh s n enlrged nd
gus prieniusA is widespred in ll fissure fillingsD stout premolr seriesF st is phylogenetilly relted to
wheres in the youngest fissures lrger nd more deE the rsorexEhizoglerix group @pnfni IWWWY wsiE
rived speies @rolgus imperilisA lso oursF eordE ni unpulishedAF he phylogeneti reltionships of heiE
ing to wzz et lF @IWWSA qrgno rolgus derived noglerix re still disussedF futler @IWVHA suggested
from rolgus oeningensis nd olonized the ioproE possile derivtion from n yligoeneEirlywioene
vine in the widdle wioeneF engelone @PHHUA holds unknown esin nestorD while vn den roek ystende
estern iuropen F oeningensisElike nestor for the @PHHIA proposed widdleEvte wioene rsorexElike
qrgno endemiD nd suggests vte wioene @erly nestorD ssuming ommon nestryfor oth the giE
wessininA oloniztionF en rtiulted skeleton tentE gnti heinoglerix nd the verysmllEsized gymnureF
tivelyreferred to rolgus fF prienius hs een reE elso the dpttion of heinoglerix is disussedF preuE
overed in erlywessinin lgoon sediments in lenE denthl @IWUPA regrded this moonrt s svengerD
gpo di piume @wzz et lF IWWSAF wheresD ording to the elorted rgumenttion of
wikroti is n uiquitous murid of the erre futler @IWVHAD it ould hve een n tive predtorD
osse fissure fillingsD nd perhps the most hrterisE possilyspeilized in hunting fishes s well s rustE
ti genus of the ssemlgeF he endemi evolution of ensF
this murid is hrterized y verymrked growth in tertomys is n endemi dormouse of the sufmE
sizeD ompnied yn inrese in hypsodontynd ilywyomimineDwith dentl morphologyomplited
omplexityof the dentl rownsF trting from the si yn inresed numer of rests on the olusl surfe
murid ptternD s rown height inreses tuerles unite of the teeth @eFgF five to fourteen rests in the upper
forming trnsversl rests in lower molrs nd in the molrsAF he genus inludes six speies whih n e
upper third molrD while the irulr stephnodont ptE rrnged in two different groupsF he first inludes
tern of the first nd seond upper molrs is entutedF lrgeE to verylrgeEsized speies with omplex to very
he most signifint feture in the dentl evolution of omplex dentl morphology@ F duniusD F lyrifer nd F
wikrotiD howeverD is the inrese of rown omplexityD ltiresttus E the ltter mye the lrgest glirid so fr
knownAD while the seond inludes mediumEsized speE resulting from the ddition of up to five new trnsversl
RPT wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
rests in the first lower nd in the third upper molrsF tht develop on the lil order of the molrsD s well
he dvned speies from n qiovnnino possess the s the rests tht tend to eme dominting on the
most highlymodified teethF rypsodontyDtrnsversl usps99D whih give the teeth rvedEin spetF epprE
Q
rests nd inresing omplexityof the w nd w re entlyD this endemi evolved long single phyleti lineE I
hrters shred lso ywirotine rodentsX for this ge @rF eetsiErF nzriiErF grgntuAF
reson preudenthl @IWUTA oined the originl nme wiE preudenthl @IWVSA reognises ertin ffinityof
rotiF nfortuntelyD the nme hd to e hnged in rttomys with grietulodon @xeorietodon in preuE
wikroti99 ypreudenthl PHHTD sine it ws preEouE denthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez PHIHAD ut the third molrs
pied y vepidopter genusF he mrosopi morphoE tht persist to e lrge in the endemi genus rules out
logil hnges in the teeth re ompnied ymodE diret nestryF eentlyD preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrE
ifitions in the pttern of enmel mirostrutureX proE ez @PHIHA proposed possile nestryfrom grietus
gressive inrese in prism inlintion uses swith @eporietus in preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez PHIHAD
from the primitive rdil pttern to protoEtngentil whih is still nother genus present in the qrgno sE
nds @fonte 8 wsini IWWPAF foth morphologil semlgeF
nd mirostruturl hnges suggest tht the dentition
xonEendemi txF he erre osse ssemlge of wikroti eome highlyspeilized for n rsive
inludes lso nonEendemi txF ith the exeption of dietF his speiliztion ould e linked to the quisiE
epodemusD theyll our onlyin the older fissuresF tion of fossoril hit @rr et lF IWWWAF ixvtingD
hryomys pulus is srelyrepresented onlyin livingD nd possilyfeedingD in urrows likelyfored
three fissures @finone ID insit I nd pISAF his these murids to grind high perentges of orse items
dormouse hd een identified s iliomys in erlier reE @eFgFD soil prtilesAF wikroti underwent severl speiE
portsY then it ws given its orret txonomi desripE tion events produing rther omplex rnhing phyE
tion ypreudenthl 8 wrtõ ÂnEuÂrez @PHHTAF hese logenyD of whih t lest five lineges re etter known
uthors inluded it in hryomys on the sis of the morE @pigF QAF rllel morphologil evolution ourred in
phologyof the lower molrsD though dmittingD howE the different linegesD lthough the mjor phylogeneti
everD tht iliomys nd hryomys re quite indistinguishE trend hrterizes the soElled resident linege99F sn
le dentllyF foth gener re known sine the widdle those tht re onsidered the most nient fissuresD wikE
wioene @hms 8 de frujin IWWSAY iliomys ws more roti shows simpler morphologyD lose to the si murE
ommon in iurope s opposed to hryomys whih ws id ptternD lthough lredywith ertin degree of
widespred in xorth efri nd xer istF hypsodonty nd lrger sizeF sn younger fissures two
xeorietodon @grietulodon in preudenthl IWVSA nonEresident speiesD whih likelyevolved in some
neighouring islndsD rehed the qrgno islnd y is known from three fissures @finone ID insit I
nd refossi IAD wheres eporietus @grietus in preuE disperslD envisging the soElled rhipelgo effet99
denthl IWVSA ours onlyin insit IF grietids of @preudenthl IWUIY he qiuli et lF IWVTAF he morphoE
logil evolution of wikroti is strikingD to point thtD the he qiuli olletion hve reentlyeen heked y
endre vorelli @work in progressAF eording to if it hd developed in nonEinsulr ontextD it would hve
preudenthl @IWVSAD oth those rietids re similr to justified the retion of thoroughlydistint suprE
generi txonD iFeFD trieF he forerunner of wikroti their ongeneris from the urolin fun of grevillente
@de fruijn et lF IWUSAD where lso iliomys is presentF is somewht unertinF preudenthl @IWUTA suggested
wegrietodon is yet nother rietidD repreE possile nestryfrom tephnomys @see lso ezzi
et lF IWWQAF preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @IWWWA sugE sented yonlyone speimen in insit ID whih
preudenthl @IWVSA nd preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez gested tht epodemus ould e onsidered suitle
nestorD tooF his opinion is sustined ypreudenthl @PHIHA onsidered due to ontmintionF wegrietoE
8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHA onsidering the ourrene of don ourred in iurope from the middle yrlenin
@wxRA to the erlyllesin @wxWAF n unpired tuerle in the nterior prt of the w of I
epodemus nd wikroti nd tht in the ltter genus ll vrtetium fF dehmi hs een retrieved in fissures
suessive dditions of rests pss through stge with pIS nd pPIE @pnfni IWWWAY its ourrene in the
veiden olletion hs not een hekedF his shrew is suh n nterior usp99F
rttomys is n endemi hmster of the erre known in iurope from irlyto widdle wioeneF
osse fissure fillingsD lking onlyin the youngerfisE he murid epodemus is the most widespred
nonEendemi txon t qrgnoF nlike the other onE sures of phses Q nd R @see elowAF st shows mrked
endemi tendenytowrd ever lrger sizesD ompE tinentl txD whih hd gone extint preoiouslyD epoE
nied y progressive omplition of the nterior prt demus eme residentD nd underwent evolutionry
of the first molrsF eording to preudenthl @IWVSAD modifitions thtD ording to he qiuli et lF
other hrteristi fetures of this genus re the flnges @IWVUD IWWHAD re quite signifint in the lst phse of
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RPU
pigF Q E heme showing the evolution of the dentl morphologynd enmel mirostruture of the first lower molr of wikroti @fter
ezzi et lF IWWQ modifiedAF
IX dentineY PX rdil enmel with xillyinlined prismsY QX rdil enmel with prisms norml to the olusl surfeY RX rdil enmel
with Exillyinlined prismsY SX primitive tngentil enmel stge eY TX primitive tngentil enmel stge fY UX tngentil enmelF
possile fissures on the sis of the evolution of oth funl settlement @fissure pQPD pigF RAF st hs never een
wikroti nd rttomysD ssuming n irreversile inE nlyzed in detilD lthough oth preudenthl @IWVSA
rese of size of the wikroti min linegeF he qiuli nd he qiuli et lF @IWVUA reognized dvned feE
et lF @IWVUAD in ontrstD seleted the rihest smplesD tures relling those of the lte urolinEerlyusinin
pinpointing suession of funl settlement pulsesD minlnd ounterprtsF wore detils on the nestryof
sed primrilyon the evolution of wikroti nd roE this mouse re reported elowF
lgusD nd seleting the most prsimonious mong the
lterntive solutions @see inldi 8 wsini PHHW for
detiled disussionAF he iohronologil sequenes fiohronology nd outline of the phses of funl setE
otined using these two methods re firlyomprE tlement
leD with minor inonsisteniesF inldi 8 wsini
feuse the deposits from the different fissures @PHHWA tried to integrte he qiuli et lF9s @IWVUA smples
re not ordered strtigrphillyD reserhers hd to seE with some of preudenthl9s @IWUTAD otining sumE
quene them iohronologillyon n evolutionryE mrysuession whih inludes lso dt on the evoluE
sisF his ws possile euse the funl omposition tion of tertomysF heylso extensivelydisussed the
nd endemi fetures of the tx from the different fisE diffiulties theyhd ome up with tryingto omine
sures vryin firlyoherent wyF the two iohronologi solutionsF yne for llD preuE
preudenthl @IWUTA nd he qiuli et lF @IWVUA denthl @IWUTA hd not onsidered the evolution of roE
followed two slightlydifferent iohronologil strteE lgusD nd he qiuli et lF @IWVUA hd not inluded tht
giesF he former tried to rrnge hronologillyll of rietidsF sn the present ontriution updted dt on
RPV wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
hse I fissures ontin
vried funl ssemlges not
esyto group in suEphsesD
espeillyeuse of the inoE
herent funl omposition of fisE
sure insit I @see preudenthl
IWUTD IWVS nd inldi 8 wsini
PHHW for disussion on this fisE
sureAF st is hrterized ythe
sttered ourrene of nonEenE
demiD ontinentl txD s well
s ynot too endemi smll
mmmlsD suh s wikroti prE
vD wikroti evolutionrylineE
ge ID rttomys eetsiD etF his
phse is lso hrterized y
primitive heinoglerixD wheres
informtion on roplitomeryx is
snt or not villeF e lrger
nd more dvned heinoglerix
ours in the lte prt of this pigF R E enttive distriution of the mmmlin ssemlge in the erre osse depositsF
phseF his phse of funl setE he hronologil order derived from he qiuli et lF @IWVUA integrted yseverl
tlement foreshdows the ourE soures of dtF hded rows indite the distriution of the txY X ourrene reported
in the litertureY oX ourrene not reported in the litertureD nd sed on unpulished rene of funl rrivls from the
dtY cX doutful ourrene reported in the litertureY @cAX doutful identifitionY no
minlnd nd possilyfunl exE
symol mens inferred ourreneY bX phyleti trnsition within n evolutionry linegeF
hnges with the neighouring
fseID finone IY sxID insit IY pID refossi IY gQeD gnttore QeY pxhD pin
islnds of the pleorhipelgoD hY xRD xzzrio RY IfD ostihi IfY qD n qiovnninoF
frod olumns represent groups of fissuresX pPIE a pPI to pPIY xREpI a xzzrio RD ut it lso douments evolutionE
finone PD ghiroÁ QD ghiroÁ UeD izzioli RD ghiroÁ IIfD ghiroÁ Se nd pIY pW a pWD wonte rytrends in the resident txF
qrnt ID ghiroÁ TD ghiroÁ IReD ghiroÁ IPD ghiroÁ IHeEfD ghiroÁ PExD ghiroÁ WD pin r
wsini et lF @PHHVA elieve tht
nd ghiroÁ PUY If a ostihi IfD qervsio ID ghiroÁ RD ghiroÁ PHeEiD ghiroÁ PR nd
ll ontinentl99 txD ut epoE
qervsio PY q a n qiovnnino nd irro IIeF wikroti lineges re numered fter
demusD eme extint euse he qiuli et lF @IWVUAF
of their inilityto dpt to the
insulr iotopeD the other fe of
the medl of the dvntge of the resident99F rietids of the he qiuli olletion re onsidered @E
he qiuli et lF9s @IWVUA hse P n e onsidered vorelliD work in progressAF
trnsitionl from the oldest fissures to the more reent pigure R is n ttempt to omine oth sequenes
ones nd it hs een rtiulted in two suEphsesF eE into single hronologil shemeD sed on the highE
sident tx underwent phyleti evolutionry hngesD est possile numer of mmmlin txF st oviously
suh s those oserved in rttomysD wikroti nd the founds minlyon wikrotiD tertomysD rttomys nd
smllEsized tertomysF he rrivl of endemis from rolgusD ut it lso inludes roplitomeryx nd heinoE
neighouring islndsD suh s tertomys ltiresttusD glerixF xot ll fissures reported in the literture n e
nnot e exludedF sn this phseD pprentlythree difE fit into the sequeneX we hve inluded onlythe est
ferent sizes of roplitomeryx @vn der qeer PHHSD PHHVA ontrolled ones whih yielded the rihest nd most
nd two speies of heinoglerix ourF relile informtionF ome fissures with roughlysimiE
hse Q is the est doumented oneF st is hrE lr ssemlges ontining tx t similr evolutionry
terized ythe ourrene of tx with derived endemi degree re grouped togetherF his is resonle simE
feturesF hree wikroti lineges re presentY the lrgest plifition when omprle ssemlges our in difE
is new inomer @wF mgnAF everl tx underwent ferent fissuresD whih is not so infrequent @see wsini
phyleti hnges in the lte prt of this phseD eFgF the 8 ezzi PHHT nd etruso et lF PHHV for disusE
smllEsized tertomys nd the resident linege of wiE sion on this prinipleAF sn order to mnge the highest
krotiF et the sme time rietids eme extint nd possile mount of iohronologil informtionD he
rolgus imperilis ppersD either ydispersl or yin qiuli et lF9s @IWVUA four phses of funl settlement
situ evolutionF he most reent prt of the phse reords hve een rtiulted in suEphsesD following wsini
et lF @PHHVAF lso the phyleti trnsition of heinoglerix minor into
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RPW
hF revirostris nd of hF intermedius into hF koenigsE phse s suitle ondition for the dispersls onto
the qrgno islndsF eentlyD following the lims of wldiX oth ses exhiit size inreseF p to four difE
vn den roek ystende et lF @PHHWA on the ontrone ferent sized roplitomeryx tx ourF
fun @see elowAD preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHA hse R is doumentedD to dteD onlyyfissure
dmitted tht the most suitle mehnism to explin pQP @he qiuli et lF IWVUAF he smll mmml ssemE
the unlned fun of the qrgno is sweepstke disE lge is poorlydiversifiedF vrgerEsized wikroti nd
persl whihD howeverD should hd ourred during the tertomys speies eme extintD wheres smllerE
fvourle lowEstnd onditions of the wessininF preuE sized onesD long with epodemus nd qlerix @rE
denthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHHTD PHIHA refused the hyE sorexAD underwent phyleti modifition nd slightly
pothesis tht qrgno ould hve een rehed ysuE inresed in sizeF rolgus still ours with two differE
essive wves of migrtionD insisting tht mmmls ent speiesF foth roplitomeryx nd heinoglerix re
my hve rehed qrgno simultneously99 @preuE presentD ut theyhve not een studied in the detilF
denthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez PHHWAD de fto ontrditing he drop in diversityof the smll mmmls hs een
the sweepstke mehnismF interpreted s signl of trophi risisD possilydue
futler @IWVHA rgued tht the unlned ompoE to the shrinking of the islnd @he qiuli et lF IWVUD
sition of the qrgno fun ould e explined y IWWHY wsini et lF PHHVAF
sweepstkesD ut he onluded tht this mehnism
ws not exlusiveD sine it would not ount for the
ourrene of emphiiD whih nnot ross expnses he origin nd ge of the fun
of slt se wterF o resolve this inonsistenyD he interE
heoriesD modelsD nd relted ssumptions on the preted the qrgno fun s eing omposed of ore
mehnisms nd proesses tht originte the islnd fuE of n impoverished reli of n older fun99 @tully
nsD re prtiulrlyrelevnt ± nd intimtelytngled ± virine proessAD to whih new funl elements were
to the question of the ge of the funsF etullyD the dded ylter invsions @ disperslist proessAF futler
deposition of the fossiliferous sedimentsD together with wsD indeedD the first who onsidered the qrgno fun
the olonistion events ythe nestors of the insulr s the result of different events sttered in time nd
tx might hve een sttered in timeF he two quesE with different modesF
tions should therefore e exmined seprtelyD even he qiuli et lF @IWVUA lso onsidered the qrgE
though theyre often disussed jointlyin the literE no fun s the result of different dispersl events stE
tureF he different opinions of the uthors on the oriE tered through timeF he events tht rought the nesE
gin of insulr tx refletD in prtD two ontrsting theE tors of rolgusD heinoglerixD roplitomeryx nd terE
oretil pprohesD virine nd disperslismF nE tomys into the insulr dominD were elieved to hve
fortuntelyD there is ertin mount of onfusion in ourred in notEetter defined moments during the
the use of these oneptsD s stressed lso ywsini et irlywioeneEerlywiddle wioeneF e seond wve
lF @PHHPD PHHVD PHHWAF of disperslsD involving the nestors of hryomysD wiE
preudenthl @IWUIA suggested tht the qrgno kroti nd eporietusD ws ssumed to hve ourred
ws populted vi dispersls from the minlnd through during the regressive phse of the lte wessininEerliest
sort of ontinentl ridgeD possily series of islnds nlenF he dispersl of epodemus is onsidered y
whih merely offered limited pssge for the fun99 the uthors s keyto define the ge of the erre osse
@filtering orridorAF he re of origin of the fun ould fissuresF sn first reonstrutionD epodemus is ssumed
hve een either the emerged epennine hinD ross to hve rehed the islnds together with the other nonE
the poggi qrenD or the flknsD through threshold endemi rodents @hryomysD etFA during the wessininE
ross the edriti eF re first elieved tht migrtions irlylioeneF en lterntive possiility@s hypothesis
ourred in the lte llesinEerlyurolinD whih he in he qiuli et lF IWVUA is sed on the morphologil
onsidered older thn the errvllin on the sis of ffinityof qrgno epodemus with epodemus domiE
inorret dting of the lrenites tht sel the erre nns from gsrnot PD nd envisges dispersl of this
osse depositsF e lte llesinEerlyurolin ge of single murine t the veryeginning of the ientinD
oloniztion ws lso supposed ywoy ÁEolÁ et lF during mrine regression doumented lollyD s well
@IWWWA sed on preudenthl @IWUID IWUTAF vter onD s elsewhere in the wediterrnen sinF
preudenthl @IWVSA ssumed the sme mode of oloniE eording to the ltter interprettionD the fossiliE
ztionD ut t different timeF re reognized generl ferous fissures together with the whole historyof the
ffinityof the qrgno fun with those of some wesE endemi fun would hve een onentrted in the
sinin lolitiesD suh s grevillente @preudenthl IWVSAD ientinF pollowing preudenthl @IWUIAD he qiuli et
lF @IWVUA pinpointed the mjor se level regressionsD il erquilloD wrmen @preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez
nd indited them s the most suitle osions for PHHTAD nd he onsidered the wessinin low seElevel
RQH wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
ing islndsA whih ourred in two time intervls when dispersion onto qrgnoD when the soElled wid
the rriers seprting the islnds from the minlnd edriti idge99 @ sumrine struturl high ross
were esier to e rossedF he older period is not lerly the edriti eA emergedF he qiuli et lF @IWVUA did
definedD euse it would spn from the lte widdle not speifyexpliitlywhether dispersls ourred vi
wioene to the vte wioeneD involving the whole E lnd ridgesD filtering rriersD or sweepstkes onenE
leoioprovine @oth the eruzzo nd epuli setorsAF trted during the lowEstnd intervlsF heywere the
he seond phse is ssumed to hve ourred in the firstD howeverD who onsidered the qrgno funs
lte wessininD involving onlythe reli qrgno reD s nd islnds within wider pleogeogrphil ontextD
suggested yhe qiuli et lF @IWVUAF weepstkes re ttempting synthesis of mrine strtigrphyD tetonisD
preferred respet to full onnetion ylnd ridgesD pleogeogrphyof lndsD nd terrestril mmml disE
sine theypermit filtered rrivls of smll mmmlsF triutionF
woreoverD in the opinion of the uthorsD full onneE he disoveryof the ontrone fossil fun @usE
tions with the minlnd re to e exluded sine they tioni et lF IWWPA hd deep impt on the disussions
would likelyhve used the extintion of the endemi on the origin of the qrgno funF ontrone is loted
fun @see the lte leistoene of iilyD s n exmpleAF in the epennine hin out IIS km of qrgno @pigF
wsini et lF @PHHPA introdued the onept of polyE IAF st yielded fun omposed of lrgeEsized verteE
phsi popultion99 to indite funl settlements deE rtes found in ostl sediments whih were dted
rived yioevents sttered in timeD whih in turn ythe uthors to the erlyortoninF he ourrene
myinvolve different mehnisms @virine or disE of roplitomeryx nd heinoglerixD lthough exhiiting
perslistAF olyphsi popultions re very ommon in more rhi feturesD testifies the strit ffinitywith the
the wediterrnen re @eFgFD lioEliestoene of iily qrgno fun @wzz 8 ustioni IWWTD PHHVAF wzz
nd rdiniAF woreoverD wsini et lF @PHHPD PHHVD et lF @IWWSA nd wzz 8 ustioni @IWWTA suggested
PHHWA remrked the diffiulties in operting lerEut tht the oloniztion of the eruzzoEepulin re
distintion etween virine nd disperslist mehnE would hve ourred during two intervlsD vte yligoE
isms when detiled reonstrution is requiredD stresE eneEirlywioene nd wessininD in onjuntion with
sing thtD for instneD temporrylnd ridge @ peuE mjor mrine regressionsF huring the first intervl the
lir se of virineA or filtering rrier @disperslistA nestor of roplitomeryx @nd heinoglerixD ording
do not hve esydistinguishle effets on the fun of to wzz 8 ustioni PHHVA would hve rehed the
the islndsF insulr dominD while in the seond intervl most of
eentlyD wzz 8 ustioni @PHHVA reonsidered the smll mmmls typil of the erre osse fun
the question of the eruzzoEepulin fioprovine in would hve rehed the qrgno re from the minE
the light of the disoveryof heinoglerix t ontroneD lnd @wzz et lF IWWSAF
nd of the veryreful onEshore nd offEshore geologiE ezzi et lF @IWWTA onsidered tht qrgno
l investigtions in the eruzzoEepulin re nd ws wht remined of ioprovine tht wsD t lest
edriti e yt et lF @PHHVD AF he irlyorE in the vte wioeneD onsiderly lrger99D of whih
tonin ge of the ontrone fun is onfirmed yE ontrone represents n older reordF fynd lrgeD they
t et lF @PHHVA who referred the fossiliferous lyer onsidered the qrgno fun s the reli of n older
to n ge slightlyyoungerthn the pirst egulr yE funl settlementD resulting from multiple dispersl
urrene of xeoglooqudrin ostensisD some IHFS eventsF ook et lF @PHHTA interpreted the qrgno re
wD even though some unertintystill persistsD s s rther stle struturl highD eing prt of the foreE
stressed ypreudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHAF lnd of the epennine orogeneD while ontrone ws
leogeogrphil interprettions ywzz 8 involved in the tetoni disruption linked to the edifiE
ustioni @PHHVA nd t et lF @PHHVA onfirmed tion of the hinF his interprettion is fullyonsistent
lso the ourrene of two mjor regressions during with the virine modelF
the vte yligoeneEirlywioene nd the wessininD wsini et lF @PHHPD PHHVA pprohed the quesE
nd permitted to identify struturl high @gentrlE tion of the origin of the qrgno ommunities distinE
edriti fridge ac wid edriti idge of he qiuli et guishing tx s stronglyendemiD intermediteGmoderE
lF IWVUA whih ws likelyfirlyemerged during the telyendemi nd nonEendemiF
mrine lowEstndsD onneting hlmti nd the he first tegoryinludes roplitomeryx nd
heinoglerixF hese two txD following previous interE eruzzoEepulin re either in the form of stripe of
prettionsD re onsidered s survivors from the older lnd or s hin of islnds99 @wzz et lF PHHWAF wzz
phse of funl settlement of the eruzzoEepulin E 8 ustioni @PHHVA dopted the model of lnd ridgesD to
leoioprovineF por intermediteGmodertelyendemi justifythe rrivls of mmmls ndD s in their previous
s well s for nonEendemi funsD wsini et lF sugE pperD theysustined two migrtion wvesX the older
gested sort of sweepstke mehnism @rfting or flotE oneD llowing the rrivl of the nestors of roplitomeE
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RQI
ryx nd heinoglerixD nd the seond one ringing smll qrgno fun nd not on its originD we should dd
some ommentsF mmmls into the qrgno reF fynd lrgeD wzz 8
he lte irlylioene ge of the se of the ustioni @PHHVA interpreted the fun of qrgno s the
mrine deposits tht lollysel the erre osse krst result of oth pure virine mehnism @the reli of
fissures @lleri IWVRY ezzi et lF IWWTY vi et lF wider nd older leoioprovineAD nd disperslist
PHIHA is n upper hronologil onstrint for the enE mehnism vi filtering ridge in the wessininF
demi funF he lower oundryD instedD is more proE engelone @PHHUA onsidered rolgus unle to
lemtiD lso euse the suession of phses of funl ross mrine rriersD nd she sustined tht this ohoE
settlement likelyinvolved sustntil time intervlF sn tonid dispersed on islnds vi lnd ridges in the wesE
this ontext the nonEendemi tx from the older fisE sininF
sures re most suitle for inferring the ge of the eE n den roek ystende @PHHIA suggested tht
ginning of the fossil reordF eording to he qiuli et lF oth qrgno irineide @the gint heinoglerix nd
@IWVUA nd preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHAD the the smll gymnureA hve rsorex nestorD whose
ourrene of epodemus would implytht the oldest immigrtion should e younger thn wxW @erly lleE
wikroti fun99 ould not e older thn the urolinD sinAF pinllyD vn den roek ystende et lF @PHHWAD riE
euse the first ourrene of epodemus in iurope is tiising wzz 8 ustioni @PHHVAD foused on the tempo
in wxIPF roweverD the ove mentioned ffinities with
nd mode of oloniztion of the eruzzoEepulin reF
lte urolinEerlyusinin ontinentl speies @preuE
heyssumed sweepstke mehnismD onsidering
denthl IWVSY he qiuli et lF IWVUA lso suggested the tht this model should e the most suitle to explin
possiilityof youngerge @wxIQEwxIRAF por tht the unlned fetures of the qrgno funD whih in
reson there is generl greement on the vte wioE their opinion is equivlent to the funs tht re omE
eneEirlylioene ge of the wikroti fun99F ynly monlyfound on the oeni islndsF he rrivls were
vn den roek ystende et lF @PHHWA hve sustined n supposed to e onentrted in definite time intervl
erlyortonin ge for oth ontrone nd qrgnoF when ll the nestors of the qrgnoEontrone funD
nfortuntelyD they did not onsider tht the oldest inluding rodents nd other smll mmmls @not found
reord of epodemus in iurope is some P w lter nd
t ontroneAD rehed the eruzzoEepulin reF hey
pprentlyignore the ppers ontining sustntil disE
dted this intervl to the erlyortoninD dopting the
ussion on the ge of the qrgno funF he ttriuE
ontrone hronologyywzz 8 ustioni @PHHVAD nd
tion t n erlyortonin ge to the qrgno fun is
stronglyliming ginst the possiilitytht the eruzE
therefore untenleD in our opinionF
zoEepulin fun mye derived from dispersls ndG
purther omments n e dded on the mode of
or virine sttered throughout time @polyphsi poE
origin of the funsF he qiuli et lF @IWVTD IWVUA nd
pultionsAF
wzz 8 ustioni @IWWTD PHHVA tried to identifythe
preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHA refuse the
most fvourle pleogeogrphi onditions for verteE
erlyortonin dting of ontrone one eds mking
rte dispersls to the insulr dominD on the sis of
verydetiled ritiism of t et lF @PHHVAF fy
geologil dtF his method hs een exhustivelydisE
nd lrgeD theyonlude tht the fossiliferous lyers
ussed yezzroli @IWWTA nd pplied to severl insulr
should e onsistentlyyoungerof IHFS w nd older
funsF iven though the forementioned uthors use
thn TFR w @py of urorotli multiloAF sn this
typil disperslist oneptsD their pprohes re t
time intervlD preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHA
the oundrywith virine iogeogrphyDs stressed
onsider the ourrene of suitle nestors of the
ywsini et lF @PHHPAF yn the other hndD vn den
eruzziEepulin funD nd onlude tht the wxIP roek ystende et lF @PHHWA dopted the typil dispersE
zone @lte ortoninEerlywessininA ould e suiE list model of sweepstkesD dpted to the islnd theory
tle intervl for the immigrtion of the fun onto the yhermitzkis 8 ondr @IWUVA s disussed yde
insulr dominF preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHAD os et lF @PHHUAF preudenthl first dopted the impE
s yet reported eforeD shre the interprettion of vn son9s @IWRHA model of lnd ridges @preudenthl IWUID
den roek ystende et lF @PHHWA of single migrtion IWUTD IWVSA utD reentlyD he lso emres sweepstkes
possilyourred ysweepstkesD even though they @preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez PHIHAF roweverD ll the
dmit tht the pleontologil dt prevent to stte uthorsD with the exeption of vn den roek ystende et
if the migrtion wve origintes from estern or western lF @PHHWAD greed thtD when virine is ruled outD
iuropeF funs disperse onlyunder veryfvourle pleogeoE
his overview evidentlyshows tht the question grphi onditionsD iFeFD when the osts of soureElnds
of the ge of the fossiliferous deposits of qrgno nd nd trgetEislnds re reltivelylose eh other @see
of the dting of the funl migrtions re still not omE lso wsini et lF PHHPAF prom this point of viewD if
oloniztion is vi lnd ridgesD filtering rriers or pletelysettledF poussingD t firstD onlyon the ge of the
RQP wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
gonlusion sweepstkesD is not prtiulrlyrelevntF ispeillyin
the se of funs like those of qrgnoD for whih the
his overview shows tht fter fortyyersof knowledge of surrounding99 pleogeogrphil setting
reserhes the qrgno fun isD on one hndD most
nd oevl funs is verysnt nd impreiseF
interesting studyse for evolution nd iogeogrphyD
he ssumption of oeni islnd yvn den
utD on the otherD it still presents onsiderle roek ystende et lF @PHHWA lso requires some ritiE
mount of unertintyD espeilly regrding ge nd
ismsF weepstkes onto oeni islnds re expeted
provenne of the txD s well s the ge of the fossiE to e sttered in timeD nd not onentrted in prtiE
liferous depositsF fynd lrgeD this ompiltion shows
ulrlyfvourle intervlsF iven if we ssume tht
tht over the lst yers interest on this nient insulr
rrivls re onentrtedD too mnytxD iFeFD some
system is rising ginF everl new pulitions nd ten gener of mmmlsD would hve dispersed on qrE
works in progress re supplying new tessere to the gno following stohsti mehnismD suh s tyE
mosi of the qrgno historyD even though the detils pil sweepstkeF preudenthl 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez @PHIHA
re fr to e exhustivelyreonstrutedF et the stte of hve n pprentlysimilr positionD ut theylook for
the rtD qrgnoD like mnyother pleontologil oE fvourle onditions in whih sweepstkes ourredD
jetsD rells n smpressionist pintingD whih is ler
nd theyssume lesser numer of inomersD onsidE
enough if seen from distneD ut lur when the ering mnyof the endemi tx s derived from less
nvs is oserved in the detilsF endemi ounterprt found in the sme erre osse
ssemlgeD eFgF wikroti originted from epodemusD
eknowledgmentsF e wnt to thnks wssimo helfino @ niE
rttomys from eporietus nd heinoglerix from the versityof ploreneD stlyAnd wtthijs preudenthl @ niversityof
qrndD pinY xturlisD the xetherlndA for ritil hek of the verysmll qlerixF sn our opinionD howeverD onsiderE
list of referenes on qrgnoD endre vorelli @ niversityof ploreneD ing how widelydifferent is endemism in qrgnoD
stlyA for the updted dt on rietidsD nd ul wzz @ niversity of
rnging from highlyendemi to nonEendemiD ontiE
ploreneD stlyA for ritil reding of the mnusriptF he work is
nentl99 speiesD it seems veryhrd to suppose single
supported ypondi d9eteneo @ex TH7A of the niversityof lermoD
migrtion wveF yer PHHV nd y sx PHHV @godeX PHHVgtrHHRAD niversity of
perrrF
ipiixgi
fllmnn F @IWUQA E possil ogel us dem xeogen der rlE ezzi vFD fenvenuti wFD foshin qFD hominii FD wsini
inseln qrgno @stlienAF ript qeologiD IUX IEUSF pFD wezzott gFD iini vFD ook vFD lleri qF 8
fllmnn F @IWUTA E possil ogel us dem xeogen der rlE orre hF @IWWTA E evision of the xeogene nd leiE
inseln qrgno @stlienAF weiter eilF ript qeoE stoene of the qrgno region @epuliD stlyAF he
logiD QVX IESWF mrine nd ontinentl suession nd the mmml
futler FwF @IWVHA E he gint erineid insetivore heinoE funl ssemlges in n re etween eprien nd
glerix preudenthl from the pper wioene of the oggio smperile @poggiAF wemF oF qeolF stFD SIX
qrgnoD stlyF ript qeologiD SUX IEUPF QVQERHPF
hms F 8 de fruijn rF @IWWSA E e lssifition of the ezzi vFD wsini pF 8 orre hF @IWWQA E ivolutionry
qliride @odentiA on the sis of dentl morpholE ptterns in the first lower molr of the endemi murid
ogyF rystryxD T@IEPA@IWWRAX QESHF wirotiF uternF snterFD IWX TQEUHF
hms F 8 preudenthl wF @IWVSA E tertomys ltiresttusD engelone gF @PHHSA E ivolutionrytrends in dentl morE
new glirid @dormieD odentiA from the insulr fuE phologyof the genus rolgus @yhotonideD vgoE
n of qrgno @rovF poggiD stlyAF ript qeologiD morphA in the wediterrnen islndsF wonF oF ristF
UUX PIEPUF xtF flersD IPX IUEPTF
h9elessndro eFD vvino eFD ihetti qF 8 rdell eF engelone gF @PHHUA E wessinin rolgus @yhotonideD vE
@IWUWA E sl xeogene del wonte qrgnoF follF oF gomorphA of stlyF qeoiosD RHX RHUERPIF
leontolF stlFD IV@IAX WEIITF erzrello wFD wrolini pFD vi qFD vi wFD etronio gFD
he fruijn rFD wein FD wontent gF 8 vn de eerd eF etrui wFD ook vF 8 rdell F @PHHTA E ividene
@IWUSA E gorreÂltion entre les gisements de rongeurs of erliest humn ourrene in iuropeX the site of
et les formtions mrines du wioeÁne terminl irro xord @outhern stlyAF xturwissenshftenD
d9ispgne meÂridionle @provines d9elinte et de WRX IHUEIIPF
wuriAF roF uoninklijke xederlF ekdF vn eE ezzroli eF @IWWTA E roess of islnd oloniztion yterE
tenshppen eries fD UV@RAX IEQPF restril orgnismsF fiogeogrphiD IU@IWWSAX QQESHF
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RQQ
preudenthl wF @PHHTA E wikroti nomen novum for wiroE he qiuli gFD wsini pF 8 orre hF @IWVTA E iffetto ripeE
ti preudenthlD IWUT @wmmliD odentiAF tF ertF lgoD un esempio nelle fune fossili del qrgnoF follF
leontolFD PT@QAX UVRF oF leontolF stlFD PR@PEQAX IWIEIWQF
preudenthl wF 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez iF @IWWWA E pmilywuriE he qiuli gFD wsini pF 8 orre hF @IWVUA E he ltest
deF snX ossner qFiF 8 reissig uF @idA E he wioE È illfrnhin funs of stlyF he irro xord pun
nhenX RHIE ene lnd mmmls of iuropeF feilD wu È @eprienD qrgnoAF leontogrphi stliD URX
RHWF SIETPF
preudenthl wF 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez iF @PHHTA E qliride @oE he qiuli gFD wsini pF 8 orre hF @IWWHA E sslnd endemism
dentiD wmmliA from the lte wioene fissure fillE in the estern wediterrnen mmmlin pleofunsX
ing finone I @qrgnoD provF poggiD stlyAF E rdition ptterns in the qrgno pleoEripelgoF
leontolF iletrFD W@PAX IEPQF etti eF xzF vineiD VSX PRUEPTPF
preudenthl wF 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez iF @PHHWA E he ge of he qiuli gFD wsini pFD orre hF 8 foddi F @IWVUA E inE
immigrtion of the qrgno nd ontrone verterte demism nd ioEhronologil reonstrutionsX the
funsF snX pnti pF 8 pllett gF @idsA E snterntionl qrgno se historyF follF oF leontolF stlFD
gonferene of erterte leoiogeogrphyD foE PS@QA@IWVTAX PTUEPUTF
logn PVEPW eptemer PHHWF estrt fookX RPERSF he qiuli gFD wsini pFD orre hF 8 lleri qF @IWVTA E
preudenthl wF 8 wrtõÂnEuÂrez iF @PHIHA E he ge of
wmml migrtion events in emerged res of the
immigrtion of the verterte funs found t qrgE
epulin pltform during the xeogeneF qiornF qeolF
no @epuliD stlyA nd ontrone @l9equilD stlyAF
serF QD RVX IRSEITPF
gFF levolD WX WSEIHHF he qiuli gFD wsini pF 8 lleri qF @IWVUA E leogeoE
qohlih FfF 8 vi wF @PHHVA E e new speies of leorE È
grphi evolution of the edriti re sine yligoene
tyx @evesX qlliformesX hsinideA from the xeoE
to leistoeneF ivF stF leontolF trtFD WQ@IAX IHWE
gene of qrgnoD stlyF yrytosD UX WSEIHVF
IPTF
veinders tF @IWVRA E roplitomeriide fmF novF @uminnE he qiuli gF 8 orre hF @IWVRA E peies interreltionships
tiD wmmliA from xeogene fissure fillings in qrE
nd evolution in the lioene endemi funs of epriE
gno @stlyA rt IF ript qeologiD UHX IESIF
en @qrgno peninsul E stlyAF qeoiosD wemF speE Â Â
veinders tF 8 ondr F @IWURA E yn funtionl fusions in
il VX QUWEQVQF
footones of ngultesF F ugetierkdD QW@PAX IHWE helfino wF @PHHPA E irpetofune itline del xeogene e del
IISF
uternrioF hh disserttion @unpulishedAF niverE
wrtõÂnEuÂrez iF 8 preudenthl wF @PHHUA E qliride @oE
sityof woden nd eggio imiliX QVP ppF
dentiD wmmliA from the lte wioene fissure fillE
helfino wFD fohme wF 8 ook vF @PHHUA E pirst iuropen È
ing insit I @qrgnoD provF poggiD stlyAF rells
evidene for trnsontinentl dispersl of groodrylus
wusF qeolF frelonD IR@PHHTAX QUESWF
@lte xeogene of outhern stlyAF oolF tF vinnen
wsini pF 8 ezzi vF @PHHTA E e preliminryquntittive
oFD IRWX PWQEQHUF
txonomi evlution of the lioene nd leistoene
hermitzkis wF 8 ondr FF @IWUVA E he importne of
smll mmml reord in the stlin eninsulF gourF
fossil wmmls in reonstruting pleogeogrphy
porshungstinstF enkenFD PSTX PHIEPIQF
with speil referene to the leistoene eegen erE
wsini pFD fonfiglio vFD ezzi vFD helfino wFD pnfni pFD
hipelgoF ennF qeolF ys relleniqFD PW@PAX VHVEVRHF Â Â
perretti wFFD uotskis eFD etruso hFD wrr gF 8
he os tFD vn den roek ystende vFF 8 vn den fergh
orre hF @PHHPA E erterte ssemlges of the genE
qFhF @PHHUA E tterns in insulr evolution of wmE
trlEestern wediterrnen islnds during the lioE
mlsX keyto islnd pleogeogrphyFsnX enem F
ene nd uternryX refleting on extintion eventsF
@idFA E fiogeogrphyD imeD nd leX histriutionsD
snX ldren FrF 8 insenyt tFeF @idsA E orld
frriersD nd sslndsF pringerX QISEQRSF
sslnds in rehistoryF fe snterntionl eriesD
pnfni pF @IWWWA E evisione degli snsettivori trdo neogeE IHWSX RQUERRRF
nii e quternri dell penisol itlinF hh dissertE wsini pFD fonfiglio vFD etruso hFD wrr eFgFD ezzi vFD
tion @unpulishedAF niversityof woden nd eggio helfino wFD pnfni pF 8 orre hF @PHHPA E he role
imiliX PVP ppF of ostl res in the xeogeneEuternrymmml
preudenthl wF @IWUIA E xeogene vertertes from the qrE islnd popultions of entrl wediterrnenF fiogeoE
gno eninsulD stlyF ript qeologiD QX IEIHF grphiD PQX ITSEIVWF
preudenthl wF @IWUPA E heinoglerix koenigswldi novF wsini pFD etruso hFD fonfiglio vF 8 wngno qF @PHHVA E
genFD novF speFD gint insetivore from the xeogene yrigintion nd extintion ptterns of mmmls in
of stlyF ript qeologiD IRX IEIWF three entrl estern wediterrnen islnds from
preudenthl wF @IWUTA E odent strtigrphyof some wioE the vte wioene to uternryF uternF snterFD
ene fissure fillings in qrgno @provF poggiD stlyAF IVPX TQEUWF
ript qeologiD PUX IEPQF wsini pFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF @PHHWA E sslndsD funs nd
preudenthl wF @IWVSA E grietide @odentiA from the pleogeogrphyF he use of insulr vertertes in pE
xeogene of qrgno @provF poggiD stlyAF ript leogeogrphi reonstrutionsF snX pnti pF 8 plletE
qeologiD UUX PWEUSF t gF @idsA E snterntionl gonferene of erterte
RQR wsini pFD inldi F wFD etruso hF 8 urdi qF
t iFD ndone F 8 wzz F @PHHVA E yligoene leoiogeogrphyD fologn PVEPW eptemer PHHWF
migrtion pth for epuli mrommmlsX the genE estrt fookX SQESTF
trlEedriti ridgeF follF oF qeolF stlFD IPU@PAX QQUE wzz F @IWVUA E rolgus @yhotonideD vgomorphD
QSSF wmmliA from xeogene fissure filling in qrgno
vi qFD fertok gFD gimpo qFD hi honto FD wrtire vFD @outhern stlyAF follF oF leontolF stlFD PS@PA
wsini pFD vi wFD ntngelo xFD ddei uggiero @IWVTAX ISWEIVSF
iF 8 unino wF @PHIHA E etonoEsedimentryevoluE wzz F @IWVUA E purther dt on the qrgno @outhern
tion of the lioene to vower leistoene suession stlyA rolgus @yhotonideD vgomorphD wmmE
of the eprienEvesinEoggio smperile qurrying liAF follF oF leontolF stlFD PS@QA@IWVTAX PHQEPIIF
distrit @western qrgnoD southern stlyAF stlin tF wzz F @IWVUA E rolgus prienius nd rolgus impeE
qeosiF @follF oF qeolF stFAD IPW@IAX IQPEISSF rilisX two new yhotonids @vgomorphD wmmliA
etruso hFD gusumno wFD homin hFD vi wF 8 wsini of the qrgno @outhern stlyAF follF oF leontolF
pF @PHHVA E n vlutzione tssonomi quntittiv stlFD PT@QAX PQQEPRQF
preliminre dell doumentzione di verterti del wzz FD helfino wFD vn den roek ystende vFFD wsini
uternrio dell iiliF etti wusF givF tF xtF pFD vi wFD inldi FwF 8 ustioni wF @PHHWA E
riesteD SQX IVWEPQPF rowD when nd where from of the eruzzoEepulin
inldi FwF @PHHTA E wyomimine @qlirideD odentiA pleofunF snX pnti pF 8 pllett gF @idsA E snterE
delle erre osse neogenihe del qrgno @stli werE ntionl gonferene of erterte leoiogeogrE
idionleAF hh disserttion @unpulishedAF niversity phyD fologn PVEPW eptemer PHHWF estrt fookX
of ploreneX SSU ppF SUETHF
inldi FwF 8 wsini pF @PHHWA E xew dt on the txonE wzz F 8 ustioni wF @IWWTA E he urolin rtiodtyls
omyof the endemi wyomimine@qlirideD odenE from ontrone @eruzziD entrl stlyAF follF oF E
tiA from the vte wioeneEirlylioene of qrgE leontolF stlFD QS@IAX WQEIHTF
no @outhern stlyA with the desription of the new wzz F 8 ustioni wF @PHHVA E roesses of islnd oloE
speies tertomys degiuliiF follF oF leontolF stlFD niztion yyligoEwioene lnd mmmls in the enE
RV@QAX IVWEPQQF trl wediterrnenX xew dt from ontrone
ook vFD qlli qF 8 orre hF @PHHTA E vnds nd endemi @eruzzoD gentrl stlyA nd qrgno @epuliD
mmmls in the vte wioene of stlyX gonstrins for outhern stlyAF leogeogrFD leolimtolFD E
pleogeogrphi outlines of yrrhenin reF leoE leoeolFD PTUX PHVEPISF
geogrFD leolimtolFD leoeolFD PQVX PTQEPTWF wzz FD ustioni wFD erut qF 8 hi grlo iF @IWWSA E e
ook vFD ezzi vFD ghesi pFD helfino wFD perretti wF 8 wessinin rolgus from gpo di piume urry@E
qlli qF @PHHVA E he stlin reord of ltest wioene lenD eruzzoD gentrl stlyAF follF oF leontolF
ontinentl vertertesF follF oF leontolF stlFD stlFD QR@IAX SSETTF
RU@PAX IWIEIWRF wzz F 8 fonte pF @IWVUA E hyleti nd eologi onE
ustioni wFD wzz FD ezzroli eFD fosgli qFD gozzini pFD sidertions on the qrgno @outhern stlyA rolgus
hi ito iFD wsseti wF 8 isno eF @IWWPA E wioene @yhotonideD vgomorphD wmmliAF follF oF
erterte remins from ontroneD xtionl rk of leontolF stlFD PT@QAX PPIEPQIF
eruzziD gentrl stlyF endionti fisii dell9edeE willienErr F @PHHHA E he evolution of wiroti preuE
mi dei vineiD serie WD QX PPUEPQUF denthlD IWUT @wmmliD odentiAD n endemi
impson qFqF @IWRHA E wmmls nd lnd ridgesF tF E genus from the xeogene of the qrgno islndD
shington edF iFD QHX IQUEITQF southern stlyF snX heinwld qF @idFA E ssolted erE
orre hF @IWVTA E hyleti grdulism in popultions evolE terte gommunities in the ropisD roeedings of
th
ving in smll isolted resX n exmple from the fossil the R snterntionl ymposiumD fonnF fonner oE
mmmls of qrgno peninsul @stlyAF follF oF E ologishe wonogrphienD RTX QVIEQVWF
leontolF stlFD PS@IAX IHIEIHSF willien F 8 teger tFtF @PHHIA E ize evolution of the lower
lleri qF @IWVRA E xew dt on lnktoni porminifer inisor of wirotiD genus of endemi murine roE
iostrtigrphyfrom the xeogene of the qrgno dents from the lte xeogene of qrgnoD southern
stlyF leoiologyD PU @PAX QUWEQWIF eninsul @poggiD outhern stlyAF ivF stF leontolF
woyÁEolÁ FD uintn tFD elover tFeF 8 uohler wF @IWWWA trtFD WH@QAX QUSERHTF È
E indemi islnd funs of the wediterrnen wioE n den roek ystende vFF @PHHIA E e revised generi
ene @RQAF snX ossner qFiF 8 reissig uF @idsA E he lssifition of the qleriini @snsetivorD wmmE È
wioene lnd mmmls of iuropeF feilD wunhenX liA with some remrks on their pleoiogeogrphy È
RQSERRPF nd phylogenyF qeoiosD QR@TAX TVIETWSF
rr FD teger tFtF 8 foherens rF @IWWWA E he skull of n den roek ystende vFFD weijer rFtFwF 8 vn der qeer
wirotiD n extint urrowing murine rodent of the eFeFiF @PHHWA E e ridge too frF gomment on roE
lte xeogene qrgno pleoislndF vethiD QPX WHE esses of islnd oloniztion yyligoEwioene lnd
IHHF mmmls in the entrl wediterrnenX new dt from
t iFD ndone F 8 wzz F @PHHVA E he wioene ontrone @eruzzoD gentrl stlynd qrgno
lndEverterte fossil site of ontrone @gentrl @epuliD outhern stlyA99 y FFeF wzz nd wF
epenninesD stlyAF follF oF qeolF stlFD IPU@IAX SIEUQF ustioni leogeogrFD leolimtolFD leoeolF
he qrgno erre osse insulr funsX n overview RQS
n der qeer eFeFiF @PHHVA E he effet of insulrityon the PTU @PHHVA PHVEPISF leogeogrFD leolimtolFD
istern wediterrnen erlyervoid roplitomeryxX leoeolFD PUWX IPVEIQHF
the studyof the forelimF uternF snterFD IVPX IRSE n der qeer eFeFiF @IWWWA E yn the strglus of the wioE
ISWF ene endemi deer roplitomeryx from the qrgno
illemsen qFpF @IWVQA E rlutr grgnensis spF novF @wuE @stlyAF snX eumer tFFpF 8 he os tF @idsA E ileE
stelideD vutrineA new otter from the wioene of phnts hve norkel3 pers in honour of FF onE
qrgnoD stlyF ript qeologiD UPX IEVF drF heinseD UX QPSEQQTF
fonte pF 8 wsini pF @IWWPA E inmel struture evolution n der qeer eFeFiF @PHHSA E he postrnil of the deer
in the first lower molr of the endemi murid of the roplitomeryx @wioElioeneY stlyAX nother exmple
genus wiroti @lioeneD qrgnoD stlyAF follF oF of dptive rdition on istern wediterrnen ssE
leontolF stlFD QI@QAX QQSEQRWF lndsF wonogrF oF ristF xtF flersD IPX QPSEQQTF