23Rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Show Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary Π V

The 23rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Show Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary π v. Yale A Δ v. Lafayette π v. NYU B Δ v. Penn State 4-3-1 Alabama WLT L L L W W W W T CS: 14 OCS: 71 Jon Stewart PD -7 -6 -11 +2 +7 +4 +3 0 PD: -8 Δ v. Haverford π v. Yale B Δ v. Hillsdale π v. William & Mary 4-4-0 Brown WLT W W L L L L W W CS: 17 OCS: 62.5 James Corden PD +8 +19 -2 -17 -3 -2 +2 +5 PD: 10 π v. Rochester A Δ v. Tufts A π v. Yale B Δ v. Northwood A 4-1-3 BU A WLT W T W W L W T T CS: 18.5 OCS: 69.5 Dick Clark PD +7 0 +3 +10 -6 +9 0 0 PD: 23 Δ v. Fordham LC A π v. Penn State π v. Minnesota A Δ v. Rutgers A 4-4-0 Columbia WLT L W W W L W L L CS: 20 OCS: 60 Trevor Noah PD -8 +8 +6 +4 -10 +2 -6 -5 PD: -9 π v. Columbia Δ v. Princeton A Δ v. WUSTL π v. Yale A 5-3-0 Fordham LC A WLT W L L W W W W L CS: 15 OCS: 77.5 Seth Meyers PD +8 -8 -1 +12 +4 +9 +4 -5 PD: 23 π v. Northwood A Δ v. NYU B Δ v. William & Mary π v. Harvard 2-6-0 Georgia State WLT L L L W L W L L CS: 12 OCS: 62 Jay Leno PD -8 -23 -11 +3 -4 +1 -7 -4 PD: -53 Δ v. Yale B π v. Haverford π v. Rochester A Δ v. Georgia State 4-4-0 Harvard WLT L L W L W L W W CS: 14 OCS: 59 Steve Harvey PD -3 -8 +5 -1 +8 -3 +7 +4 PD: 9 π v. Brown Δ v. Harvard π v. Penn State Δ v. NYU A 3-5-0 Haverford WLT L L L W L L W W CS: 12 OCS: 63.5 Stephen Colbert PD -8 -19 -5 +1 -6 -8 +1 +8 PD: -36 π v. Lafayette Δ v. Yale A π v. Brown Δ v. Northwestern 6-2-0 Hillsdale WLT W L L W W W W W CS: 18 OCS: 70.5 Johnny Carson PD +13 -4 -11 +3 +3 +2 +2 +11 PD: 19 Δ v. Hillsdale π v. Alabama Δ v. Tufts A π v. WUSTL 5-3-0 Lafayette WLT L W W L W L W W CS: 17 OCS: 67.5 Conan O'Brien PD -13 +4 +11 -2 +10 -2 +7 +1 PD: 16 Δ v. WUSTL π v. Xavier Δ v. Columbia π v. Princeton A 6-2-0 Minnesota A WLT L W W W W L W W CS: 13 OCS: 68 Craig Ferguson PD -13 +8 +8 +6 +10 -2 +11 +6 PD: 34 Δ v. Xavier π v. WUSTL Δ v. Princeton A π v. Hillsdale 4-4-0 Northwestern WLT W W W L L W L L CS: 15 OCS: 66 David Letterman PD +2 +8 +2 -15 -2 +4 -2 -11 PD: -14 Δ v. Georgia State π v. Rutgers A Δ v. Wesleyan A π v. BU A 4-2-2 Northwood A WLT W W W L W L* T T CS: 19 OCS: 60.5 Vanna White PD +8 +23 +12 -2 +3 -3* 0 0 PD: 41 π v. Princeton A Δ v. Wesleyan A Δ v. Xavier π v. Haverford 1-7-0 NYU A WLT L L L L L W L L CS: 15.5 OCS: 55 Jimmy Fallon PD -5 -3 -14 -12 -2 +14 -1 -8 PD: -31 The 23rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Show Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary Δ v. Rutgers A π v. Georgia State Δ v. Alabama π v. Xavier 1-7-0 NYU B WLT L L W L L L L L CS: 15.5 OCS: 53 Bill Maher PD -10 -2 +11 -3 -7 -4 -3 -1 PD: -19 π v. Wesleyan A Δ v. Columbia Δ v. Haverford π v. Alabama 2-4-2 Penn State WLT L T L L W W L T CS: 17 OCS: 61 Samantha Bee PD -2 0 -6 -4 +6 +8 -3 0 PD: -1 Δ v. NYU A π v. Fordham LC A π v. Northwestern Δ v. Minnesota A 4-4-0 Princeton A WLT W W W L W L L L CS: 16 OCS: 58.5 Bob Barker PD +5 +3 +1 -12 +2 -4 -11 -6 PD: -22 Δ v. BU A π v. William & Mary Δ v. Harvard π v. Tufts A 2-4-2 Rochester A WLT L T W L L W L T CS: 16 OCS: 61.5 Chuck Woolery PD -7 0 +11 -5 -8 +3 -2 0 PD: -8 π v. NYU B Δ v. Northwood A Δ v. Yale A π v. Columbia 6-2-0 Rutgers A WLT W W L W W L W W CS: 15 OCS: 76 Richard Dawson PD +10 +2 -12 +2 +2 -6 +6 +5 PD: 9 Δ v. William & Mary π v. BU A π v. Lafayette Δ v. Rochester A 4-3-1 Tufts A WLT W W L L L W W T CS: 15.5 OCS: 65 Regis Philbin PD +14 +7 -3 -10 -10 +2 +2 0 PD: 2 Δ v. Penn State π v. NYU A π v. Northwood A Δ v. Yale B 5-2-1 Wesleyan A WLT W T W W L W* W L CS: 15 OCS: 70.5 Chelsea Handler PD +2 0 +14 +12 -3 +3* +6 -7 PD: 27 π v. Tufts A Δ v. Rochester A π v. Georgia State Δ v. Brown 2-6-0 William & Mary WLT L L L W W L L L CS: 13.5 OCS: 60.5 Larry Wilmore PD -14 -7 -11 +5 +4 -1 -2 -5 PD: -31 π v. Minnesota A Δ v. Northwestern π v. Fordham LC A Δ v. Lafayette 2-6-0 WUSTL WLT W L L W L L L L CS: 20 OCS: 60 Pat Sajak PD +13 -8 -2 +15 -4 -9 -7 -1 PD: -3 π v. Northwestern Δ v. Minnesota A π v. NYU A Δ v. NYU B 3-5-0 Xavier WLT L L L L W L W W CS: 12 OCS: 59 Jimmy Kimmel PD -2 -8 -8 -6 +2 -14 +3 +1 PD: -32 Δ v. Alabama π v. Hillsdale π v. Rutgers A Δ v. Fordham LC A 5-3-0 Yale A WLT W W W L L W L W CS: 21.5 OCS: 62 Alex Trebek PD +7 +6 +11 -3 -2 +6 -4 +5 PD: 26 π v. Harvard Δ v. Brown Δ v. BU A π v. Wesleyan A 6-2-0 Yale B WLT W W W W W L L W CS: 19 OCS: 64.5 John Oliver PD +3 +8 +2 +17 +6 -9 -6 +7 PD: 28 R1 Coin Flip: Tails. Team Code last name closer to Z gets better rank. R3 Coin Flip: Tails. Cards switch sides. *This ballot from the round between Northwood A and Wesleyan A was found to be mistabulated. Upon further examination, Tab concluded that the Defense won this ballot by 3 points. Because this error was brought to Tab's attention after the conclusion of the tournament (and thus after the 30-minute review period for Round 3), Tab cannot retroactively change Round 4 pairings or final team rankings. However, Tab would like to recognize Northwood A for an outstanding performance at the tournament. Had all else been equal, Northwood A would have finished the tournament with 6 Wins and a CS of 18. The 23rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Show Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary OUTSTANDING TRIAL TEAMS 1 Yale B 6 Wins; CS 19; OCS 64.5 2 Hillsdale 6 Wins; CS 18; OCS 70.5 3 Rutgers A 6 Wins; CS 15; OCS 76 4 Minnesota A 6 Wins; CS 13; OCS 68 5 BU A 5.5 Wins; CS 18.5; OCS 69.5 6 Wesleyan A 5.5 Wins; CS 15; OCS 70.5 7 Yale A 5 Wins; CS 21.5; OCS 62 8 Northwood A* 5 Wins*; CS 19; OCS 60.5 9 Lafayette 5 Wins; CS 17; OCS 67.5 10 Fordham LC A 5 Wins; CS 15; OCS 77.5

OUTSTANDING ATTORNEYS 20/17 π/Δ Christopher Grant Northwood A 20 π Mike Kleynman Rutgers 19 Δ Evan Donaldson Fordham Lincoln Center A 19 Δ Mason Aberle Hillsdale 19 Δ Daniel Cohen WUSTL 18 Δ Rochelle Sun Rochester 18/17 π/Δ Elizabeth Bays Yale A 18 Δ Sarah Shapiro Brown 17 π Andrew Sullivan Columbia 17 π Natalie Garson BU A 17 π Crystal Xue Harvard 17 Δ Daniel Richardson Alabama 17 π Katelyn Frazier NYU B 17 π Travis Knoppert Fordham Lincoln Center A 17 Δ Steven Becker Tufts A

OUTSTANDING WITNESSES 19 π Joe Shipley Princeton 18 π Karli Zubek Northwood A 17 Δ Ashley Alphonse Tufts A 17 Δ Daniel Bruce Haverford 17 Δ Konrad Ludwig Hillsdale 17 π Dylan Sanders BU A 17 Δ Robert Servilio Rutgers A 17 Δ Mariana Suarez-Rebling Yale B 17 π Sean Rogers Yale B 17 Δ Ashlyn Cooper Alabama

Tabulation Director: Jeffrey Guo (Yale) Assistant Tabulation Director: Nick Beachy (HLS) Tabulation Room Volunteers: Ed Stern (BU); Rebecca Koper (North Central); Reilly Knorr (Minnesota); Anneliese Mahoney (George Washington); Andy Hogan (Xavier); Michael D'Ippolito (Brown) The 23rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Monkey Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary π v. Northwood B Δ v. Fordham LC B π v. Yale C Δ v. MIT 5-2-1 Amherst College WLT W T L W W L W W CS: 13 OCS: 74.5 Mandrill PD +3 0 -9 +5 +9 -8 +16 +22 PD: 38 Δ v. Bye π v. UMass Amherst Δ v. Vermont π v. Wesleyan B 4-4-0 Bowdoin WLT L W L L W W W L CS: 12 OCS: 65 Macaque PD -3 +7 -12 -11 +6 +1 +5 -2 PD: -9 π v. North Central Δ v. MIT π v. UMCP Δ v. Yale C 5-2-1 BU B WLT W L L W W T W W CS: 14.5 OCS: 72.5 Gorilla PD +9 -1 -1 +15 +8 0 +17 +7 PD: 54 Δ v. Vermont π v. Tufts B π v. Fordham LC B Δ v. Rochester B 6-2-0 Cornell College WLT W W W L L W W W CS: 15 OCS: 71.5 Capuchin PD +3 +19 +1 -2 -5 +10 +4 +17 PD: 47 Δ v. UMBC π v. Amherst College Δ v. Cornell College π v. Tufts B 5-3-0 Fordham LC B WLT W W W L W L L W CS: 18.5 OCS: 66.5 Langur PD +6 +8 +9 -5 +5 -10 -5 +4 PD: 12 π v. Rutgers B Δ v. GW Δ v. Northwood B π v. UPenn A 4-3-1 Georgetown WLT W L L L W W W T CS: 14 OCS: 69 Gibbon PD +12 -7 -4 -5 +13 +11 +7 0 PD: 27 Δ v. Wesleyan B π v. Rochester B Δ v. UPenn A π v. UMBC 5-3-0 Gonzaga WLT L W W L L W W W CS: 12.5 OCS: 68.5 Howler PD -9 +16 +16 -1 -16 +9 +14 +11 PD: 40 Δ v. UMass Amherst π v. Georgetown Δ v. Tufts B π v. Princeton B 6-2-0 GW WLT W W W W W L L W CS: 21 OCS: 69.5 Chimpanzee PD +4 +2 +4 +5 +14 -2 -1 +16 PD: 42 Δ v. Princeton B π v. UMBC Δ v. Rutgers B π v. UMass Amherst 4-4-0 La Salle WLT L W W L W W L L CS: 16.5 OCS: 69 Bonobo PD -9 +1 +7 -5 +9 +7 -17 -8 PD: -15 π v. Yale C Δ v. North Central Δ v. Bye π v. Vermont 3-4-1 Minnesota B WLT L L L T L W W W CS: 11 OCS: 66.5 Marmoset PD -11 -1 -12 0 -11 +4 +1 +6 PD: -24 Δ v. UPenn B π v. BU B Δ v. Princeton B π v. Amherst College 3-5-0 MIT WLT W W W L L L L L CS: 20.5 OCS: 54 Mangabey PD +5 +1 +1 -15 -1 -2 -16 -22 PD: -49 Δ v. BU B π v. Minnesota B Δ v. UMass Amherst π v. Northwood B 4-3-1 North Central WLT L W W T L L W W CS: 16.5 OCS: 59.5 Lemur PD -9 +1 +12 0 -7 -12 +7 +5 PD: -3 Δ v. Amherst College π v. Vermont π v. Georgetown Δ v. North Central 1-6-1 Northwood B WLT L T W L L L L L CS: 15.5 OCS: 58.5 Saki PD -3 0 +2 -5 -13 -11 -7 -5 PD: -42 The 23rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Monkey Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary π v. La Salle Δ v. Yale C π v. MIT Δ v. GW 5-2-1 Princeton B WLT W L W T W W W L CS: 16.5 OCS: 78 Surili PD +9 -1 +1 0 +1 +2 +1 -16 PD: -3 π v. UPenn A Δ v. Gonzaga Δ v. Wesleyan B π v. Cornell College 4-4-0 Rochester B WLT W L L W W W L L CS: 17.5 OCS: 60.5 Aye-Aye PD +5 -14 -16 +1 +2 +5 -4 -17 PD: -38 Δ v. Georgetown π v. UPenn B π v. La Salle Δ v. UMCP 3-5-0 Rutgers B WLT L W W L L L L W CS: 16 OCS: 56 Baboon PD -12 +7 +1 -3 -9 -7 -4 +6 PD: -21 π v. UMCP Δ v. Cornell College π v. GW Δ v. Fordham LC B 5-3-0 Tufts B WLT W W L W L W W L CS: 20.5 OCS: 70 Tamarin PD +4 +8 -1 +2 -14 +2 +5 -4 PD: 2 π v. GW Δ v. Bowdoin π v. North Central Δ v. La Salle 6-2-0 UMass Amherst WLT L L W W W W W W CS: 18.5 OCS: 66 Loris PD -4 -2 +12 +11 +7 +12 +17 +8 PD: 61 π v. Fordham LC B Δ v. La Salle π v. UPenn B Δ v. Gonzaga 2-6-0 UMBC WLT L L L W W L L L CS: 18 OCS: 57.5 Guenon PD -6 -8 -7 +5 +1 -9 -14 -11 PD: -49 Δ v. Tufts B π v. Bye Δ v. BU B π v. Rutgers B 3-4-1 UMCP WLT L L W W L T W L CS: 15.5 OCS: 66 Tarsier PD -4 -8 +24 +15 -8 0 +4 -6 PD: 17 Δ v. Rochester B π v. Wesleyan B π v. Gonzaga Δ v. Georgetown 3-4-1 UPenn A WLT L W W L W L L T CS: 16.5 OCS: 60.5 Bushbaby PD -5 +14 +9 -6 +16 -9 -7 0 PD: 12 π v. MIT Δ v. Rutgers B Δ v. UMBC π v. Bye 4-4-0 UPenn B WLT L L L W L W W W CS: 10 OCS: 69.5 Colobus PD -5 -1 -1 +3 -1 +9 +4 +21 PD: 29 π v. Cornell College Δ v. Northwood B π v. Bowdoin Δ v. Minnesota B 1-7-0 Vermont WLT L L L W L L L L CS: 15 OCS: 53.5 Orangutan PD -3 -19 -2 +5 -6 -1 -1 -6 PD: -33 π v. Gonzaga Δ v. UPenn A π v. Rochester B Δ v. Bowdoin 3-5-0 Wesleyan B WLT W L L W L L L W CS: 16.5 OCS: 58.5 Galago PD +9 -16 -9 +6 -2 -5 -5 +2 PD: -20 Δ v. Minnesota B π v. Princeton B Δ v. Amherst College π v. BU B 3-4-1 Yale C WLT W W L T L W L L CS: 20 OCS: 55 Indri PD +11 +1 -1 0 -9 +8 -17 -7 PD: -14 π v. Bowdoin Δ v. UMCP π v. Minnesota B Δ v. UPenn B 2-6-0 Bye WLT W L L L W L L L CS: 15 OCS: 48.5 Human PD +3 -7 -24 -15 +11 -4 -4 -21 PD: -61 R1 Coin Flip: Tails. Team Code closer to Z gets better rank. R3 Coin Flip: Tails. Cards switch sides. The 23rd Annual Yale Mock Trial Invitational December 1-2, 2018 || New Haven, Connecticut Monkey Business Division Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Summary OUTSTANDING TRIAL TEAMS 1 GW 6 Wins; CS 21; OCS 69.5 2 UMass Amherst 6 Wins; CS 18.5; OCS 66 3 Cornell College 6 Wins; CS 15; OCS 71.5 4 Princeton B 5.5 Wins; CS 16.5; OCS 78 5 BU B 5.5 Wins; CS 14.5; OCS 72.5 6 Amherst College 5.5 Wins; CS 13; OCS 74.5 7 Tufts B 5 Wins; CS 20.5; OCS 70 8 Fordham LC B 5 Wins; CS 18.5; OCS 66.5 9 Gonzaga 5 Wins; CS 12.5; OCS 68.5

OUTSTANDING ATTORNEYS 19 Δ Peter Jones UMass Amherst 19 π Gabby Cabeza UPenn B 18 π Jack Beaumaster Cornell College 18 π Luke Pfister Gonzaga 17 π Courtney Cappelli Princeton B 17 Δ Jillian Pincus Wesleyan B 17 Δ Margaret Kruzner Gonzaga 17 Δ Ian Miller Amherst College 17 Δ Samantha Myers Rochester B 17 π Maya Durnal Georgetown 17 Δ Kaylee Slusser UPenn A 17 π Samantha Paralikas George Washington

OUTSTANDING WITNESSES 20 π Julia Cohen Tufts B 20 π Jacob Garwood La Salle 18 π Lizzie Eckert BU B 18 Δ Tyler Whitacker Tufts B 18 π Kaarish Maniar Georgetown 17 π Sean Buss George Washington 16 π Abby Fritz Minnesota B 16 π Ben Ratcliff Gonzaga 16 Δ Amrita Sarma UMBC 16 π Gavin Starr UPenn B

Choice by Side Side Chosen by Judge Percentage P 107 53% D 95 47% Total 202

Agreement by Side Chosen by Judge on Side Won on Points Ballots Won Percentage P 90 78 87% D 107 78 73% Total 197 156 79%

Choice on Ties Side Chosen in Tie Percentage P 5 45% D 6 55% Total 11

Agreement by Point Differential - All Wins Chosen by Judge on PD Won on Points Ballots Won Percentage 1-5 91 63 69% 6-10 61 52 85% 11+ 45 41 91% Total 197 156 79%

Agreement by Point Differential - Plaintiff Wins Chosen by Judge on PD Won on Points Ballots Won Percentage 1-5 39 30 77% 6-10 29 28 97% 11+ 22 20 91% Total 90 78 87%

Agreement by Point Differential - Defense Wins Chosen by Judge on PD Won on Points Ballots Won Percentage 1-5 52 33 63% 6-10 32 24 75% 11+ 23 21 91% Total 107 78 73% Notes: [1] Each scoring judge was asked to answer, at the bottom of their blue ballot, this question: Which team put on the better performance? Their answer to this question constitutes their "judge's choice." [2] Six ballots (five won by the Defense, one by the Plaintiff) did not contain a judge's choice. One judge, even after having his ballot sent back, still refused to choose a team and wrote "HUNG JURY." [3] The figures above are calculated using ballot data from both divisions. [4] Raw data can be downloaded at https://app.box.com/v/judgeschoice2018yale.