Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Meagher & Landolt: Floral Lures Attractive To Velvetbean Caterpillar 73 BINARY FLORAL LURE ATTRACTIVE TO VELVETBEAN CATERPILLAR ADULTS (LEPIDOPTERA: NOCTUIDAE) ROBERT L. MEAGHER1 AND PETER J. LANDOLT2 1USDA, ARS, CMAVE, 1700 SW 23rd Drive, Gainesville, FL, 32608 2USDA, ARS, 5230 Konnowac Pass Road, Wapato, WA 98951 USA ABSTRACT Evaluation of combinations of flower odor compounds in northern Florida revealed that lina- lool was synergistic in attractiveness with phenylacetaldehyde (PAA) to the migratory moth velvetbean caterpillar (Anticarsia gemmatalis Hübner). This noctuid was the most common species collected from traps with a binary lure composed of PAA and linalool, with over 900 males and females collected in Sep 2005 and almost 13,000 collected in a 4-week period in Aug and Sep 2006. Different lid openings of the vials containing the chemical blend in an at- tempt to vary the release rate of the binary lure did not affect the number of velvetbean cat- erpillar moths captured. Traps baited with the binary lure and placed in May, Jun and early Jul of 2005 and 2009 failed to capture adults demonstrating the absence of adult moths early in the season. Management application of floral attractants in an attract-and-kill strategy is discussed. Key Words: floral lure, attractant, trapping, moths, Anticarsia gemmatalis RESUMEN Una evaluación de las combinaciones de olores de compuestos florales en el norte de Florida revelo que linalol era sinergista con el fenilaldehido (PAA) en la atracción a la polilla migra- toria gusano del frijol (Anticarsia gemmatalis Hübner). Este noctuido fue la especie más co- mún en trampas colectadas con cebos del compuesto binario PAA y el linalol, con más de 900 machos y hembras colectados en septiembre de 2005 y casi 13.000 recogidos en un período de 4 semanas en agosto y septiembre de 2006. Con el fin de variar la velocidad de liberación del atractivo binario se usaron tapas de diferente abertura las cuales no afectaron el número de adultos del gusano del frijol capturados. Trampas cebadas con un señuelo binario coloca- das en mayo, junio, y principios de julio del 2005 y 2009 no capturaron adultos demostrando la ausencia de polillas adultas a principios de la temporada. Se discute el manejo para la aplicación de atrayentes florales en una estrategia para atraer-y matar. Translation provided by the authors. Many species of moths are known to be at- & Jacobson 1979; Lopez et al. 2000; Landolt et al. tracted to volatile compounds emitted by flowers 2001, 2006). In Florida, PAA is a strong attrac- (Knudsen et al. 2006). Some of the flower species tant for several noctuid moths from different sub- studied include Abelia grandiflora (Haynes et al. families, but particularly for soybean looper 1991), Cestrum nocturnum L. (Heath et al. 1992), moths Chrysodeixis = Pseudoplusia includens 3 species of Gaura (Teranishi et al. 1991; Kint et (Walker) (Meagher 2001a, 2002). A recent study al. 1993; Shaver et al. 1997), Lonicera japonica showed that the floral odorants cis-jasmone, ben- (Schlotzhauer et al. 1996), Platanthera bifolia L. zyl acetate, limonene, linalool, β-myrcene, methyl (Rich.) (Plepys 2001), and Mahonia = Berberis salicylate, and methyl-2-methoxy benzoate all in- aquifolium (Pursh) (Landolt & Smithhisler 2003). creased captures of some moths when added to The volatiles released by these flowers contain traps with PAA, but responses varied among the multiple compounds. One of the compounds that moth species that were trapped (Meagher & has been shown to be attractive to moths is phe- Landolt 2008). One interesting result was that nylacetaldehyde (PAA). It has been isolated from velvetbean caterpillar moths (Anticarsia gem- many flowering plants and shrubs that are attrac- matalis Hübner) responded very strongly to PAA tive to moths (Haynes et al. 1991; Heath et al. plus linalool (Meagher & Landolt 2008). Linalool 1992; Kint et al. 1993; Pair & Horvat 1997; has been found in several species of moth-visited Landolt & Smithhisler 2003). Phenylacetalde- flowers (Bruce & Cork 2001; Honda et al. 1998; hyde as a single attractant or in mixtures has Schlotzhauer et al., 1996). been used to attract various species of moths Velvetbean caterpillar is a migratory noctuid (Smith et al. 1943; Creighton et al. 1973; Cantelo that infests cultivated legumes including soybean 74 Florida Entomologist 93(1) March 2010 Glycine max (L.) Merrill, peanut Arachis hy- iston on 6 May 2005 and removed 2 Jun 2005; in pogaea L., alfalfa Medicago sativa L., cowpeas Vi- 2009 one trap was placed on 28 May and re- gna unguiculata (L.) Walpers, and velvetbean moved 18 Aug. Lures and vaportape were re- Mucuna pruriens (L.) DC in the southeastern U.S. placed every 2 weeks. (Buschman et al. 1977; Herzog & Todd 1980; Bus- The 2 main experiments were conducted in chman et al. 1981; Slansky 1989). It apparently 2005 and 2006 at Williston. A randomized com- overwinters in central and southern Florida and plete block experimental design was used, with 5 southern Texas where it feeds on wild legumes replicate blocks for each experiment. Lures were such as clovers Melilotus spp. and Trifolium spp., replaced every 2 weeks and Vaportape was re- medics Medicago spp., kudzu Pueraria lobata placed every 4 weeks. The first experiment was (Willd.) Ohwi, and vetches Vicia spp. (Watson designed to test linalool as a single attractant 1916; Buschman et al. 1981; Slansky 1989). Mat- compared to it as a co-attractant. The 4 treat- ing behavior studies (Johnson et al. 1981) led to ments were no lure as a control, PAA alone, lina- the identification of the sex pheromone (Heath et lool alone, and PAA + linalool. Traps were placed al. 1983) and to the design of trapping systems at least 30 m apart, and treatment order was ran- (McLaughlin & Heath 1989; Mitchell & Heath domized at each sample date. Release of the 1986). However, the pheromone components are chemicals was allowed through lid opening diam- costly to synthesize and are not commercially eters of the vials of 3.2 mm. Traps were set up at available. Williston on 13 Sep and moths were removed 15, Meagher & Landolt (2008) found large num- 20, 23, 26, 28, and 30 Sep 2005. The second exper- bers of velvetbean caterpillar moths in traps iment in 2006 was designed to determine if differ- baited with a 2-component blend of PAA and lina- ent release rates from traps with the binary blend lool. Two experiments following this research (PAA + linalool) affected moth capture. Different were designed to test whether both floral volatiles release rates were achieved by changing the di- (PAA and linalool) were needed for attraction and ameter of the hole in the lid opening. The treat- if capture number was influenced by the release ments were hole diameters of 1.0, 1.6, 3.2, 6.4, rates of the chemicals. and 12 mm. This trapping test was set up 22 Aug 2006 and moths were removed 25 Aug and 7, 18, MATERIALS AND METHODS and 28 Sep 2006. Moths captured were identified to species Standard Universal Moth Traps, “Unitraps” (Kimball 1965; Covell 2005), and then sorted by (Great Lakes IPM, Vestaburg, MI, USA) were sex. Voucher specimens are deposited in the Flor- used to capture moths that were attracted to ida State Collection of Arthropods, Florida De- chemical compounds. These traps were con- partment of Agriculture and Consumer Services, structed of a white bucket, a yellow cone on top of Division of Plant Industry, Gainesville, FL. Trap the bucket, and a dark green cover above the cone. catch data were subjected to an ANOVA (PROC A 2.5 × 2.5-cm piece of Vaportape (Hercon Envi- MIXED, SAS 9.2, SAS Institute 2008), where ronmental, Emigsville, PA, USA), releasing the block, date (block), and block*treatment were pesticide dichlorvos, was stapled to a string and random variables (Littell et al. 1996). If the treat- hung inside the bucket to kill captured moths. ment variable produced a significant F value, Lures were suspended by a wire inside the bucket treatment means were separated by simple effect of the trap. Both chemicals tested were dispensed differences of the least square means. Sex ratios from 8-ml polypropylene vials (Nalg Nunc, Roch- (number of males/number of females) were ana- ester, NY, USA). Five milliliters of active ingredi- lyzed to determine if they were significantly dif- ent were added to cotton balls in the bottom of the ferent from 1.0 by a chi-square test (GraphPad vial. When 2 chemicals were tested in a single Software, Inc., San Diego, CA). trap, each chemical was dispensed from a sepa- A gravimetric method was used to estimate rate vial. Phenylacetaldehyde (W287407) and the loss of PAA and linalool from vials with lid linalool (W263508, racemic mixture) were pur- opening diameters of 1.0, 1.6, 3.2, 6.4, and 12 chased from Aldrich Chemical Co. (Milwaukee, mm that were placed outdoors and indoors. For WI, USA). both chemicals, four 8-mL vials were loaded with Traps were placed on 1.5-m metal poles along 5 mL chemical and placed in traps on 2 Jul 2009 roads and edges of 400-ha fields of commercial in Gainesville, FL. The vials were reweighed peanuts near Williston, FL (Levy County). Previ- weekly until 30 Jul. Because of high humidity ous research suggested that velvetbean caterpil- outdoors, the vials were brought inside and lar moths are not found in north-central Florida placed in a laboratory fume hood and weighed until late Jul or Aug (Watson 1916, Watson periodically until 5 Nov 2009. Vial weight change 1932). Early season samples were collected in over time was analyzed with regression analysis 2005 and 2009 with traps baited with a binary (PROC REG, SAS 9.2, SAS Institute 2008) and lure of PAA + linalool in vials with 3.2-mm lid slopes were compared by Student’s t test statis- opening diameters.