A Comparative Analysis of the Major World Religions

Many Paths to One Goal? - A Comparative Analysis of The Major World Religions

A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE MAJOR WORLD RELIGIONS FROM A CHRISTIAN PERSPECTIVE

by Ernest Valea

The goal of this site is to investigate whether or not there is sufficient evidence to prove that world religions are complementary and equally true, according to the model inspired by an old Indian tale - that of the blind men who tried to describe an elephant. It is said that once upon a time a king gathered a few men who were born blind. They were asked to describe an elephant, but each one was presented with only a certain part of it. To one was presented the head of the elephant, to another the trunk, to another its ears, to another the leg, the body, the tail, tuft of the tail, etc. The one who was presented with the head said: "The elephant is like a pot!" The one who was presented the trunk answered, "The elephant is like a hose". The one who touched only the ears thought that the elephant was a fan, the others said that it was a pillar, a wall, a rope, a brush, etc. Then they quarreled among themselves, each thinking that he was the only one right and the others were wrong. The obvious truth is that the elephant is a unity of many parts, a unity that they could not grasp in their ignorance. According to the pattern suggested by this tale, it is often said that world religions form a unity, and only this unity provides the right perspective on ultimate truth.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/index.html (1 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:47:00 AM] Many Paths to One Goal? - A Comparative Analysis of The Major World Religions A similar syncretistic trend is encouraged by the suggestion to consider the various world religions as alternative paths to the same transcendental finality or, using a known illustration, many paths to the same mountain peak. Although this vision is arousing a lot of enthusiasm in many people today, it is important to know that it is not the only one, as Christianity and Islam each claim to be the only right path to God. Therefore the other option is that world religions are not pieces of the same puzzle (parts of the same spiritual "elephant") or alternative paths to the same goal. Judging theoretically, both possibilities exist. Therefore, a proper evaluation of such opposite views must be done before we decide on a course of action. If the first is true (all religions lead us to the same finality), and we choose the second (only one of them is right), we have not lost anything. Despite our ignorance, we will arrive at the same happy end as the other travelers who have chosen other spiritual paths. A less happy situation would be given by the second possibility, that a single spiritual path is valid and we have chosen the wrong one. In this case religious syncretism is only a way of misleading the travelers to spiritual disaster, so they at least should be warned. A third possibility, that all spiritual paths are wrong, is denied by the nature of our spiritual quest itself, which demands a real fulfillment. Otherwise, our hunger for ultimate truth could not be justified and all religions would be nothing but human fantasy. The following articles are not meant merely to generate a conflict of rational proofs for justifying one or another alternative. No matter how complex and logical the rational proofs on behalf of one or the other cause might be, it is possible to find counterpoints of the same nature, so that at a rational level, the dispute could fill a lot of books with no benefit to anyone. Nobody can be persuaded or converted to one or another religious perspective only through rational proofs. This may be possible in science, but not in religion. However, rational proofs have to be considered because we are rational beings. Reason should not be rejected and experience proclaimed the only way of knowing truth. No divorce between reason and experience should be accepted, because they are

http://www.comparativereligion.com/index.html (2 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:47:00 AM] Many Paths to One Goal? - A Comparative Analysis of The Major World Religions complementary and work together, so that neither can exclude the other. As a result, we do not have to reject a priori the proofs of reason in our spiritual quest in order to abandon ourselves to the arms of mystical experiences, whatever their nature might be. Rather than generating sterile debates, the information presented here should help the reader clarify his/her own stand toward comparative religion and develop a critical ability to analyze today's spiritual market. Suggestions, comments and critiques are strongly encouraged, with the hope that they will improve the content of this site. Please make them as specific and clear as possible. The comparative analysis presented here is focused on Christianity and the major Eastern religions, especially Hinduism and Buddhism, because they play a major role in defining today's world spirituality. This is an obvious phenomenon on the Internet too, where a lot of spiritual movements indebted to classic Eastern doctrines and practices can be found. Some may believe that a comparative analysis of the major world religions like this may fuel religious hatred and intolerance, but this is wrong. Religious tolerance and freedom cannot be built on ignorance but rather on the understanding of commonalities and differences. Jesus Christ is the perfect example of teaching love for one's neighbor despite religious differences (see The Parable of the Good Samaritan). Unfortunately, some of His followers did the opposite. Loving the person is possible even if one rejects his or her religious convictions. The Christian approach will be done on an ecumenical basis, grounded on The Nicene Creed as statement of faith, which is common to all three branches of Christianity - Roman Catholicism, Eastern Orthodoxy and Protestantism. The Holy Bible (NIV ecumenical translation) is acknowledged as the first doctrinal authority, and second the doctrinal commentaries of the Church Fathers of the first centuries AD, as far as they are accepted by each of the three branches of Christianity. The analysis will survey a comparison of the following defining aspects of all world religions: 1. God or the Ultimate Reality, and creation 2. Man’s condition

http://www.comparativereligion.com/index.html (3 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:47:00 AM] Many Paths to One Goal? - A Comparative Analysis of The Major World Religions

3. Man's salvation and eternal destiny 4. The nature of evil 5. Conclusion

Special files are available concerning critical considerations regarding Eastern religions as spiritual paths toward Ultimate Reality:

1. Reincarnation. Its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity. 2. Four criteria to evaluate any religious perspective

3. Critical considerations concerning pantheist religions and philosophies (Vedanta, Tantrism, Hatha Yoga, Tibetan Buddhism, Taoism, etc.) 4. Critical considerations regarding the dualistic Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics 5. Critical considerations regarding the Yoga technique as an instrument to attain liberation 6. Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita 7. Critical considerations regarding Buddhism 8. The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity; Jesus Christ and other Saviors and religious founders 9. Alleged Eastern equivalent sayings of Jesus Christ 10. The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Buddhism and Christianity 11. Revelation and knowledge in Christianity 12. How can those who have never heard about Christ be saved?

http://www.comparativereligion.com/index.html (4 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:47:00 AM] Many Paths to One Goal? - A Comparative Analysis of The Major World Religions The quotes used for describing each religious perspective belong to scriptures considered to be first hand authority by its followers. In presenting some special features of Christianity some useful links will be mentioned. There are also many links available for a more thoroughly comparative study of Christianity and Islam. Since the domain of comparative religion is so vast, the present analysis had to be limited to a brief account, sacrificing many details and secondary aspects, but with the hope that global relevance will not be affected. The reader is invited to study this topic further, according to his interest in it, knowing that this is neither the first nor the last attempt to discuss the complementary and divergent thought among world religions. The discussions, arguments and debates in comparative religion did not start recently and will certainly not stop until the end of the world, the time when the Truth will reveal itself in fullness. © Ernest Valea, 1999 Last modified June 7, 2000

Search this site:

options

http://www.comparativereligion.com/index.html (5 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:47:00 AM] The Nicene Creed (A.D. 325) THE NICENE CREED

We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, maker of all things visible and invisible; and in one Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, the only - begotten of his Father, of the substance of the Father, God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten, not made, being of one substance with the Father. By whom all things were made, both which be in heaven and in earth. Who for us men and for our salvation came down from heaven and was incarnate and was made man. He suffered and the third day he rose again, and ascended into heaven. And he shall come again to judge both the quick and the dead. And [we believe] in the Holy Ghost. And whosoever shall say that there was a time when the Son of God was not, or that before he was begotten he was not, or that he was made of things that were not, or that he is of a different substance or essence from the Father or that he is a creature, or subject to change or conversion - all that so say, the Catholic and Apostolic Church anathematizes them.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/creed.html [10/27/2000 9:47:02 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions

THE ULTIMATE REALITY IN WORLD RELIGIONS

Each world religion admits an Ultimate Reality that is eternal and unchanging. But is it the same? If the world religions are only parts of a global and unique spirituality, it should be the same. There are three fundamental ways in which Ultimate Reality is defined: personal being (a personal and loving God), impersonal being (as origin and target of all personal beings) or an eternal truth or principle that governs the universe. Are these three possibilities mere manifestations of the same Ultimate Reality?

The Ultimate Reality in Hinduism

Hinduism is not a unitary religion, but a multitude of religious and philosophical trends. Three main patterns can be identified among them. First, there is henotheism, the religion of the ancient Vedas and later Vaishnavism and Shaivism, which states that many gods exist, but one of them is more important than the others. Second, there is pantheism, the perspective brought by the Upanishads and later Vedanta, which considers Ultimate Reality to be an impersonal transcendent being. Third, there are the Samkhya and the Yoga darshana of Patanjali that admit two ultimate realities. Let's briefly describe them following an approximate chronological order.

The Vedic gods

The oldest sacred scriptures of Hinduism are the four Vedas (Rig, Sama, Yajur, and Atharva Veda). They are four collections of hymns (Samhita) describing deities, their works and the praises that must be addressed to them in religious rituals. Each of the four collections of Vedic hymns is associated with three other kinds of Vedic literature - the Brahmanas, the Aranyakas and the Upanishads. Together they represent the most sacred religious literature (Shruti) of Hinduism. (NB: Remember that throughout the content of this website by “Vedas” we mean only the four collections of hymns, and not the whole corpus of Vedic literature.) The hymns of the oldest Veda, the Rig Veda, are almost all praises addressed to gods. The ancient Aryans worshipped many gods, associated with the elements of nature, among which we can discern at least two important generations. The oldest supreme god, according to the Vedas, seems to be Varuna,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (1 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions the sustainer of creation and guardian of universal order. A hymn in the Atharva Veda proclaims: This earth belongs to Varuna, the King, and the heavens, whose ends are far apart. Both the oceans are the loins of Varuna, and He is merged within the small water drop. If one will go away beyond the heavens, still he cannot escape King Varuna; His envoys move about here from the heavens, and, thousand-eyed, they look upon the earth. (Atharva Veda 4,16,3-4) A second generation of Vedic gods has Indra as the most important representative. He takes over all the functions of Varuna after saving mankind from demon Vritra's influence, the embodiment of the rough aspects of nature. Vritra had locked the waters in the sky, which caused a catastrophic drought on earth. At humans' demand, Indra consumed a large quantity of ritual drink (soma), took the lightning (vajra) shaped by god Tvashtri and, with the help of other gods, killed the demon and brought back the rain on earth (Rig Veda 10,113). That is why he is praised in the hymns: Adorable Indra, our savior, Vritra-slayer and furtherer of our highest aims, May he be our protector from the end, from the middle, from behind, and from in front. Lead us to a free world, wise one, where lie divine luster, sunlight, and security. Valiant are the arms of thee, the powerful; we will take to their vast shelter. (Atharva Veda 19,15,1-2) It is important to notice that although Indra takes over the role of fertility god from Varuna, he fulfills it with much more effort than his predecessor does. Indra depends on the ritual drink soma, and consequently on the sacrifices done by people (which represents a weakness), and has to fight in order to maintain the universal order. His sovereignty over the world is not so striking as it was with Varuna. On the other hand, people appreciate him more than Varuna. They didn't understand Varuna's ways, but can influence Indra through the sacrifices and therefore get the earthly blessings they seek. Once proclaimed sovereign Lord, Indra takes over the title of maker of the universe, which he doesn't create, but rearranges after his conquest. Two other gods of this generation, with less important roles in the Vedas, but which will play major roles in later theistic Hinduism, are Rudra (forerunner of Shiva) and Vishnu. Rudra has a dual aspect; on the one hand he is monstrous, murderous and savage; on the other hand he is benevolent, divine healer and protector of cowherds. Vishnu, too, has a minor role in the Vedas, being just one of Indra's helpers in his combat against Vritra and in building the universe. At the same time, he is an intermediary between gods and people, a role that will certainly develop in his later special position. Along with praising the gods, there are passages in the Vedas that suggest another kind of Ultimate Reality of the universe, beyond the gods we mentioned. One of the most important Hindu cosmogonies is that of the golden egg (Hiranyagarbha), an entity that was the source of all existing beings and worlds:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (2 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions At first was neither Being nor Nonbeing. There was not air nor yet sky beyond. What was its wrapping? Where? In whose protection? Was Water there, unfathomable and deep? There was no death then, nor yet deathlessness; Of night or day there was not any sign. The One breathed without breath, by its own impulse. Other than that was nothing else at all. Darkness was there, all wrapped around by darkness, And all was Water indiscriminate. Then That which was hidden by the void, that One, emerging, Stirring, through the power of ardor (tapas), came to be. (Rig Veda 10,129) There are two important aspects to be noticed here: 1) water produced the One; and 2) the whole process was realized by the power of ardor (tapas). This idea is very important because it opens the way towards the notion of One (the primordial matrix that encapsulates all existence) and also toward asceticism, the cosmic creative energy through which the unmanifested becomes manifested. Another important element here is the preexistence of an impersonal reality (the One) against personal beings. Gods and men are said to have their origin in this primordial impersonal entity. Considering an impersonal Ultimate Reality above the gods is a pattern that will dominate most Hindu religious elaboration. The cosmogony of the golden egg is continued in the Brahmana texts in a similar fashion as in the Rig Veda, adding the appearance of a Creator (Prajapati) from the golden egg (Shatapatha Br. 11,1,6). The same way as the golden egg appears as a result of ardor, this Prajapati created the world using the power released by his ardor. His words are fulfilled as a result of ardor and the material out of which he builds the universe is his own body. A similar view is presented in the Purushasukta hymn (Rig Veda 10,90), that can be found in a similar version in the Atharva Veda (19,6) and in the Taittiriya Aranyaka (3,12). According to this hymn, the product of the golden egg is the giant Purusha. By his consuming himself in the fire of creation all of the worlds came into existence, including our physical world, the four-caste system, the animals and the duality of the sexes. There is no doubt that Purusha and Prajapati are equivalent, both being produced out of that impersonal One of the Rig Veda 10,129. This passing from a personal Ultimate Reality (represented by the gods) to an impersonal One is an important feature of early Hinduism that will have major implications for later developments.

The Ultimate Reality according to the Upanishads and Vedanta philosophy

Already in the Brahmana writings (Shatapatha Brahmana 6,1,1) it is stated that the whole universe has its origin in non-existence (asat), meaning that existence must be the product of manifestation of some unmanifested potentialities. This topic is made clear in the Upanishads, which claim that the origin of any manifestation is Brahman, the One of the Vedic hymns: As the spider moves along the thread, as small sparks come forth from the fire, even so from this Self [Brahman] come forth all breaths, all worlds, all divinities, all beings

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (3 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions (Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 2,1,20). According to the Upanishads, the Ultimate Reality is Brahman. It (neuter gender) is at the origin of any physical, moral or spiritual activity (see also Brihadaranyaka Up. 4, 1-2; Chandogya Up. 3,18,1-6; Taittiriya Up. 2,6; 3,1). Paradoxically, Brahman has two aspects: immanent, or manifested, and transcendent, or unmanifested. For a better understanding of this concept, we can compare it to the "Big Bang" theory on the origin of the universe. The point of infinite mass out of which all celestial bodies would have originated, according to the astronomic theory, has its ideological correspondence with the unmanifested Brahman of Hindu cosmogony. However, in the manifestation of Brahman, the product is not only matter, but also living beings, gods, humans and animals. The cause of the manifestation process is Brahman's desire to be multiplied: “Let me become many, let me be born” (Taittiriya Up. 2,6,1). (However, in a pantheistic context, this is a strange and contradictory idea, because the impersonal being cannot have desires. Probably a more accurate term would have been that of necessity of becoming manifested.) After the manifestation is completed, all its products tend to return to the initial state of unmanifestation, evolving from one level of manifestation to another. Then another manifestation will happen: As from a blazing fire, sparks of like form issue forth by thousands, even so, O beloved, many kinds of beings issue forth from the immutable and they return thither too (Mundaka Up. 2,1,1). Similar to the day and night cycle, the transformation of Brahman between the manifested state and the unmanifested one is everlasting (Kaushitaki Up. 3,3). The philosophical system (darshana) that follows the pantheistic teachings of the Upanishads is called Vedanta. The most important organizers are Badarayana (4th century AD) and Shankara (9th century AD), the one who conferred to it a pure monistic character as Advaita Vedanta - "the Vedanta of pure monism". Shankara's vision of the relation of the Absolute with the phenomenal world is reflected in an old Hindu parable, that of the rope mistakenly perceived in the dark as a snake. As the coiled rope in the dark is thought to be a snake, the same way the empirical world is mistakenly considered to have a distinct existence, independent to the Absolute, through the illusion (maya) produced by ignorance (avidya). As only the rope exists, not the snake, only Brahman has a real existence (sat) and is the true reality. The phenomenal world is real only if perceived as Brahman, as the "reality" of the snake's existence lays in the substratum that produced the confusion, namely the rope. The plurality of the phenomenal world is an illusion (maya), a veil that has to be put aside in order to perceive Brahman. The universe is not unreal, but has the same value as the snake in the parable - it produces confusion and causes man to pursue a wrong spiritual direction. All that goes beyond this vision of the world is illusion, produced by ignorance. Shankara tried to settle the relation of the Absolute Brahman (Nirguna Brahman - the One without any definable characteristics) with the origin of the world by proclaiming two distinct points of view: the absolute (paramarthika) and the relative (vyavaharika). In an absolute sense, Brahman is above any duality and external relation; nothing real exists outside him. But from our empirical and relative point of view, Brahman is the cause of the universe we know. In fact there is no real causality; the world is only an illusory sight of Brahman, as with the rope seen as a snake. Brahman's activity in the world and among human beings is nothing but lila, divine play. In conclusion, the Vedanta of Shankara is somehow different from Upanishadic philosophy; the universe is only a phenomenal appearance (vivarta-vada) of

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (4 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions Brahman and not his transformation (parinama-vada). From a substantial manifestation, the universe becomes only a dream (or self-forgetting) of Brahman.

The gods of theistic Hinduism

According to the pantheistic view of the Upanishads and Vedanta, the gods are merely inferior manifestations of the supreme impersonal Brahman. However, they continued to play an important role for the average Hindu. The gods that are worshipped today are not the same as in Vedic times. The most important ones became Vishnu and his avatars (especially Rama and Krishna), Shiva and the goddess Kali. Here is what is said in Vaishnavism about the relation between Brahman and Vishnu: Just as light is diffused from a fire which is confined to one spot, so is this whole universe the diffused energy of the supreme Brahman. And as light shows a difference, greater or less, according to its nearness or distance from the fire, so is there a variation in the energy of the impersonal Brahman. Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva are his chief energies. The deities are inferior to them; the yakshas, etc. to the deities; men, cattle, wild animals, birds, and reptiles to the yakshas, etc.; and trees and plants are the lowest of all these energies.... Vishnu is the highest and most immediate of all the energies of Brahman, the embodied Brahman, formed of the whole Brahman. On him this entire universe is woven and interwoven: from him is the world, and the world is in him; and he is the whole universe. Vishnu, the Lord, consisting of what is perishable as well as what is imperishable, sustains everything, both Spirit and Matter, in the form of his ornaments and weapons. (Vishnu Purana 1) Some pantheist thinkers consider that devotion is nothing but an easier path to the same impersonal union with the impersonal Ultimate Reality. According to them, devotion can serve to attain the extinction of personhood, the main source of illusion (maya). As the adored god is nothing but a form of Brahman, the mystical union with him would be, in this case, nothing more than the same impersonal fusion atman-Brahman. However, the theistic Hindu thinkers strongly disagree with this. They see the personal creator God (Vishnu in Vaishnavism or Shiva in Saivism) as having no preceding origin. Consequently, the One of the Rig Veda, Purusha of the Purushasukta, and Brahman of the Upanishads are considered nothing but the supreme personal God (Vishnu or Shiva). He is both the creator and the substance of the world (as a result of creating the world out of himself), the One that both creates and disintegrates the world at will, and the target of all religious rituals and devotion. The best known piece of literature representative of Hindu theism is the Bhagavad Gita, where the worshipped god is Krishna, the eighth avatar of Vishnu. Although in classic Hinduism Krishna is a manifestation of Vishnu, and Vishnu himself is one of the first manifestations of Brahman (along with Brahma and Shiva), in the Bhagavad Gita Krishna is granted a fundamental theological importance. He claims to be eternal (4,6), “the supreme Lord of all planets and demigods” (5,29) and the source of existence: “I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from me” (10,8). He is not only the creator but also the substance of the universe (9,16-19; 8,4; 10,20-42). The cycle of permanent transformation between the manifested state and the unmanifested one is characteristic for Krishna too, as it was with Brahman:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (5 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions At the end of an era (kalpa) all creatures disintegrate into my nature and at the beginning of another era I manifest them again. Such it is my nature (prakriti) to follow again and again the pattern of the Infinite manifestations and disintegrations. (Bhagavad Gita 9,7-8) Krishna has to "follow the pattern of the Infinite manifestations and disintegrations", which implies that the process is a necessity that surpasses him. He is just a detached (but also helpless) spectator to it. Therefore it is hard to accept his dominion over creation along with the periodic manifestation of nature (prakriti). Rather, we should conclude that the creation of the world is not an option for him, but a necessity at the end of each cosmic cycle, as was the case with the manifestations of Brahman of the Upanishads. Disagreeing with this, theistic commentators see this "necessity" rather as a divine play in which Krishna creates and disintegrates his creation at will. (For more information on this debate on the character of Krishna see our special file on the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita.) The excess of Krishna's superlatives and his identification with the whole existence grants him a personal portrait that is difficult to grasp. A better Hindu theism will be founded later in time by the great theistic Hindu thinkers Ramanuja (1017 - 1137 AD) and Madhva (1238 - 1317 AD). They refused the idea that the Ultimate Reality is the impersonal Brahman, who has no attributes, no initiative and no influence on man. As it is impossible to take Brahman as an object of worship, both thinkers accepted the god Vishnu as Ultimate Reality. He is not limited by karma, time, space or any other factor, and has an infinite number of attributes (unlike Nirguna Brahman), the most important being love, absolute knowledge, and compassion. According to Madhva, Vishnu is said to be totally different from the substance of the world. Neither nature nor the souls of the universe fuse with him to form an impersonal primordial state. He created the world out of a primordial substance (prakriti) and helps it to attain perfection. In fact, creation is periodic and dependent on the karma acquired by souls in previous existences. At the moment of creation, karma works out the fruits of the soul under divine providence. However, that means that the act of creation is still not totally independent, as an act of God’s sovereign will. He is not free to create the world at will, but has to create it in order that souls may work out their karma.

The Ultimate Reality in the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas

Samkhya and Yoga are two of the six Hindu orthodox schools (darshana) developed in the post-Upanishadic period. As most of their metaphysical basis is common, in the absence of any supplementary explanation, what is mentioned here is valid for both schools. The origin of the Samkhya system is attributed to Kapila (7th century BC), and the real organizer is considered to be Ishvara Krishna (5th century AD). The Yoga system was structured by Patanjali (sometime between 2nd century BC and 3rd century AD), who only systematized the ancient traditions preserved until his time. The writing in which Patanjali formulated the essence of the Yoga system, which represents today the reference writing on this topic, is the Yoga Sutra. Considering how reality is defined, Samkhya and Yoga are dualistic philosophies, stressing two fundamental notions: purusha (the equivalent of atman) and prakriti (the primordial substance). More will be said about purusha in the next file, where we focus on man's destiny in the two darshanas. Prakriti, the primordial substance, is an impersonal matrix capable of manifestation through transformation. In some way it resembles Brahman through its periodic manifestations. Unlike Brahman, it does not contain the spiritual principle purusha.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (6 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions As a result of the duality postulated by this system, the material world is the product of the manifestation of prakriti and has real existence (not illusory, as in Vedanta). Its manifestation is a result of the existence of three inner tendencies, called gunas: sattva, rajas and tamas. They are the material which evolves into the categories of existence when one or the other gains a dominating force. Sattva is the tendency that brings light, purity and knowledge; rajas is responsible for activity, energy and dynamism; and tamas opposes action, producing darkness, heaviness and ignorance. The world and individual beings came into existence as a result of the disturbance of the initial state of equilibrium between the three gunas. Any known form in which we see the world is generated by the participation of a certain proportion of the three gunas. The categories of prakriti's manifestation are, in hierarchical order, as follows: 1) mahat, the first product of manifestation, considered to be a mass of pure energy appeared as a result of the guna sattva domination. Its psychic aspect is the intellect, buddhi. 2) from mahat evolves ahamkara, the principle of individuation (the sense for the "I"). 3) after producing ahamkara, the evolutionary process bifurcates. Under the influence of the guna sattva, the psychical evolutes are produced: mind (manas), the five cognitive sense organs (sight, hearing, touch, taste and smell) and the five conative sense organs (speech, movement, prehension, excretion and reproduction). Under the influence of the guna tamas the physical evolutes are produced: the five subtle essences (the essences of color, sound, touch, taste and smell) and the five gross elements, which emerge from the essences (the five fundamental elements in Hindu cosmology - earth, water, air, fire and ether). The guna rajas provides the force required for this evolution. The majority of the Yoga darshana metaphysics, at it was systematized by Patanjali, comes from Samkhya. It only adds the existence of a divinity, Ishvara. However, this Ishvara is not a personal god, but rather a macro-purusha that was never involved with psycho-mental activity and the law of karma (Yoga Sutra 1,24). We will return to this subject later, in discussing man's possible relation with Ishvara as it is stated in the Yoga darshana.

The Ultimate Reality in Tantrism and Hatha Yoga

As a distinct spiritual trend, Tantrism appeared in the 4th century AD. It is possible that it doesn’t have Vedic origin, because its theology is grounded on two deities that did not belong to the Vedic pantheon: Shiva and the Mother Goddess (Shakti), the goddess of land, fertility and life. The two deities Shiva and Shakti became the fundamental terms in which Tantrism developed a pantheistic view of life, Shiva as the transcendental aspect, the pure existence, and Shakti as the immanent and dynamic aspect, through which the phenomenal manifestation occurs. Hatha Yoga is also a pantheistic school, which shares the same metaphysic with Tantrism. Its forerunner is considered to be Goraknath (13th century AD). He and his followers used three sources to ground the new doctrine: Tantrism, devotional Saivism and ascetic practices of the so-called siddhas (the perfect ones). Hatha Yoga reached its full development through Svatmarama (15th century AD), the author of the Hatha Yoga Pradipika treatise. Other important writings are the Gheranda-Samhita and the Shiva-Samhita. They all belong equally to Tantrism.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (7 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions For both Tantrism and Hatha Yoga, the Ultimate Reality of the universe is the god Shiva. Together with his divine consort Shakti, they form a state of primordial unity and unmanifestation that corresponds in the Advaita Vedanta to Brahman Nirguna, the unmanifested Brahman. The world and the human beings came into existence through the dissociation of the primordial unity of Shiva and Shakti. In the Shiva-Samhita 1,92, it is stated: Out of the combining of the spirit, that is Shiva, with matter, that is Shakti, and by the interaction of one on the another, all creatures were born. The same manifestation of the Absolute in creation, as stated by the Upanishads, is presented in the Shiva-Samhita 1,52;69-77. The philosophy and ritual of Tantrism have penetrated most forms of today's Hinduism. It can be found in Buddhism too (where it generated the Vajrayana school), and also in Chinese Taoism, seeming to be a true panasiatiac movement.

The Ultimate Reality in Buddhism

Buddhism is another important Eastern religion that extended beyond the boundaries of India, shortly after it was proclaimed by its founder, Siddharta Gotama - the Buddha (6th century BC). Two main forms of Buddhism are known today: the conservative branch, represented by the Theravada school, spread mainly in Sri Lanka and southeast Asia, and the liberal branch - Mahayana, spread in China, Tibet, Korea and Japan. The Theravada school, which claims to have guarded the unaltered message of its founder, teaches that there is neither a personal god, nor a spiritual or material substance that exists by itself as Ultimate Reality. The world as we know it does not have its origin in a primordial being such as Brahman. It exists only as a mental construction shaped by the senses. What we see is only a product of transitory factors of existence, which depend functionally upon each other. The Buddha said: The world exists because of causal actions, all things are produced by causal actions and all beings are governed and bound by causal actions. They are fixed like the rolling wheel of a cart, fixed by the pin of its axle shaft (Sutta-Nipata 654). That gods exist is not rejected, but they are only temporary beings that attained heaven using the same virtues as any human disciple. Gods are not worshipped, do not represent the basis for morality, and are not the givers of happiness. The Ultimate Reality is nothing but a transcendent truth, which governs the universe and human life. The Buddha expressed it in the following words: There is grief but none suffering, There is no doer though there is action. There is quietude but none tranquil. There is the path but none walks upon the path. (Majjhima Nikaya 1; Visuddhi Magga 16) We will analyze these concepts in the document aimed at analyzing man's destiny in Theravada Buddhism. The Buddha was concerned only with finding a way out of suffering. Therefore he refused to speak about things considered to be irrelevant or even hindrances in reaching nirvana, and this included a definition of Ultimate Reality.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (8 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions The other branch of Buddhism was grounded later, probably in the 1st century AD, and organized by Nagarjuna in the 2nd century AD. Although the texts of Mahayana Buddhism claim to be a recollection of early speeches of the Buddha, they sometimes contradict conservative doctrines of the Theravada school. It is said that the latter texts were revealed many years after the master's death, because at that time there were too few people able to understand them. Mahayana takes a different stand on the person of Siddharta Gotama. According to the traditional view he was a physical being, the founder of the "four noble truths" and the first man that reached nirvana. In Mahayana Buddhism he is considered to be only one of the many humans who attained the state of a boddhisattva, the celestial being that helps other humans to find liberation. Reality, according to Mahayana Buddhism, has three levels of perception, known also as the three bodies (trikaya) of Buddha: nirmanakaya, the physical body of the founder, that is subject to change; sambhogakaya, the body of the boddhisattvas; and dharmakaya, the ultimate nature of all things. The dharmakaya state is also called suchness or emptiness (devoid of attributes). Although any resemblance to the Hindu Vedanta is denied, there are at least two important aspects that suggest the contrary. First, the pure state dharmakaya, the absolute body of the Buddha and, at the same time, the fundamental nature of the universe is described in the same way as Brahman: How should enlightened beings see the body of Buddha? (dharmakaya) They should see the body of Buddha in infinite places. Why? They should not see Buddha in just one thing, one phenomenon, one body, one land, one being - they should see Buddha everywhere. Just as space is omnipresent, in all places, material or immaterial, yet without either arriving or not arriving there, because space is incorporeal, in the same way Buddha is omnipresent, in all places, in all beings, in all things, in all lands, yet neither arriving nor not arriving there, because Buddha's body is incorporeal, manifesting a body for the sake of sentient beings. (Garland Sutra 37) This statute of the Buddha allows him to become manifested whenever people become ignorant, have no more interest in getting spiritual wisdom, and are too concerned with carnal lusts. The same message appears in the discourse of Krishna of theistic Hinduism (Bhagavad Gita IV,7-8). The resemblance is even greater by the fact that the boddhisattva beings (as the Hindu avatars) are mediators between humans and Ultimate Reality. This is the second resemblance, the substitution of the Hindu gods with the Buddhist boddhisattvas, which might be interpreted as a penetration of the Hindu bhakti tradition in Buddhism. In conclusion, Mahayana Buddhism is a pantheistic religion, with an impersonal Ultimate Reality (the dharmakaya) and personal beings (the boddhisattvas) acting as intermediaries between humans and it.

Ultimate Reality in other Eastern Religions

Taoism

Like the Hindu Vedanta or Buddhist Mahayana, Taoism states an impersonal Ultimate Reality that is both the creator principle and the eternal truth of universe. It is the Tao, the immutable and unchanging principle that is the basis of multiplicity and the impulse that generates all forms of life. The founder of Taoism, Lao Tse (6th century BC), stated in his important writing, Tao-te Ching:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (9 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions There was something undifferentiated and yet complete, Which existed before heaven and earth. Soundless and formless, it depends on nothing and does not change. It operates everywhere and is free from danger. It may be considered the mother of the universe. I do not know its name; I call it Tao. (Tao-te Ching 25) In the same way as the Hindu Brahman or Buddhist Dharmakaya, Tao is the source in which originate and return all the manifestations of the world: All the flourishing things Will return to their source. This return is peaceful; It is the flow of nature, An eternal decay and renewal. (Tao-te Ching 16) Tao holds two complementary and opposite modalities that are present in all creation: Yin and Yang (Yin - the female principle of darkness, potentiality, regression; and Yang - the male principle of light, activity and progress). Their dynamic and the proportions in which they become mixed at a certain moment determine any given aspect of nature or living beings: day and night, seasons, life and death. Any personal existence, gods or humans, receive their wisdom from Tao, being merely inferior and temporary forms of its manifestation: [Tao] is its own source, its own root. Before heaven and earth existed it was there, firm from ancient times. It gave spirituality to the spirits and gods; it gave birth to heaven and to earth. (Chuang Tzu 6) The Taoist divinities are probably reminiscences of an ancient Chinese pantheon, many of them being humans at their origin and then proclaimed gods as time passed. This is probably the result of a late syncretism that tried to combine devotion to the ancient Chinese gods with classic Taoism, as a way of making it more acceptable to the lay people. Later religious developments such as deities, temples, priests, rites and symbolic images are foreign to the spirit of Taoism. Deities like the Jade Emperor (Yu-huang) and The First Principal (Yuan-shis Tien-Tsun) are considered in some traditions to be gods, while other deities like the three Pure Ones (San-ch’ing) are more like Buddhist bodhisattvas, acting as manifestations of Lao Tse.

Confucianism

Rather than a religion, Confucius (6th century BC) founded an ethical system in order to harmonize social relations in the Chinese state. For this reason it is hard to say that Confucianism, at least in its original form, is a true religion. Although Confucius respected the religious traditions of his time, he gave them a mere ethical interpretation. The supreme principle in the universe according to him is the moral law, a universal principle, omnipresent, hidden and eternal: There is no place in the highest heavens above or in the deepest waters below where the moral law is not to be found.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (10 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions (Doctrine of the Mean 12) Following the moral principles means to conform oneself to the will of heaven, but more metaphysical speculations about heaven and afterlife are useless (Analects 7,20).

ULTIMATE REALITY AS A PERSONAL GOD IN THE THREE MONOTHEISTIC RELIGIONS OF THE WORLD - CHRISTIANITY, JUDAISM AND ISLAM

The three great monotheistic religions of the world have a personal God as Ultimate Reality. First we will present the difference brought by Christianity among the world religions in defining what God is, and then show the distinctive aspects of Judaism and Islam.

The personal and triune God of Christianity

Christianity presents an Ultimate Reality totally different to all we have found in the other religions. The intuition of the wise men of the East almost never diverged from pantheism as the determinant view of existence. Brahman of the Upanishads or of Shankara's Vedanta, Shiva of Tantrism, the Dharmakaya of Mahayana Buddhism or the Chinese Tao, all represent an impersonal Ultimate Reality. Most forms of theistic Hinduism are no exception, as their gods are merely inferior manifestations of the impersonal Absolute. Christianity holds a totally different position. The Ultimate Reality of the universe is the personal and triune God. He exists as God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit, without beginning and without having his origin in a primordial impersonal essence. As an early church creed states: In this Trinity there is nothing before or after, nothing greater or less, but the whole three Persons are co-eternal together and coequal. There are some important things to clear up about the origin and meaning of the term "person" (Latin persona, Greek prosopon). Initially used in the Greek ancient theater for the actors’ mask, the term designated in Hellenistic philosophy "the masked face of the impersonal being". The term used for the impersonal essence of reality was ousia, and its determined, singular forms were called hypostasis. If Christian theology had been only a form of Hellenistic philosophy, it should have said that the hypostases - Father, Son and Holy Spirit - are mere functional aspects of the divine nature ousia. The novelty brought by Christian theology is the fact that each person of the Holy Trinity has the fullness of divine nature, and the ontological character of the Ultimate Reality is defined only by the reality and relation that exists between the three hypostases, in the Holy Trinity "of one substance". A major contribution in defining this aspect was made by the Cappadocian fathers of the Church (Basil the Great, Gregory of Nyssa and Gregory of Nazianzen). The Holy Trinity should be understood neither as a sum of three Gods (tri-theism), nor as a mono-personal God that assumes successively three distinct forms (the modalistic heresy). God’s being does not exist outside the three persons, but only as Father, Son and Holy Spirit, and they are the only way for God's existence. So there cannot exist an Ultimate Reality "beyond" or "above" the Holy Trinity,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (11 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions as in pantheism (Brahman as the ultimate nature of the gods). Therefore none of the three hypostases, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, can be considered a kind of Hindu Ishvara, a first manifestation of the impersonal Brahman. Christian theology overthrew the values of Hellenistic metaphysics in order to adapt its terms to the new revealed reality. In defining divinity, the accent must be transferred from an impersonal Ultimate Reality to the personal character of the Holy Trinity and the relation between the three hypostases. Here is the origin of the term "divine person" (from the Latin persona), and (derived from it) the term "human person". The triune God of Christianity exists by Himself. He proclaimed to Moses: "I am who I am" (Exodus 3,14). He is sufficient in Himself and by Himself, not depending on any exterior element. His existence is expressed through love, omnipotence and omniscience, among which there is perfect unity and harmony. None is manifesting itself by infringing on the other because the Holy Trinity is perfect in love, will and deed. Associated with these characteristics are justice and immutability. God’s immutability is not a reminder of Brahman Nirguna's immobility, but an absolute stability in truth and good. Likewise, when the Apostle John proclaims that "God is love" (1 John 4,8) this should not be interpreted as an expression of the impersonal primordial energy, but as form of expressing the supreme unity of the tri-personal communion. It doesn't just mean that God has love, as a quality, but that He is love, that this is His way of being in the Trinity, each person existing not just for himself, but for the others, in a perfect communion of love. (The following links should be helpful for understanding the concept of Holy Trinity: Gregory of Nyssa, On the Holy Trinity, and of the Godhead of the Holy Spirit; On "Not Three Gods"; Early Christians on the Trinity) The God that presents Himself in the Bible cannot be equated with any god of the Hindu pantheon. They are only aspects of an impersonal Absolute, manifestations that will finally be absorbed by it. The triune God of Christianity is different from Krishna, who is a slave to the cyclic manifestation and annihilation of the universe (Bhagavad Gita 9,7-9). According to Christianity, God does not create the same world many times, but just once, and then not out of a necessity that surpasses him. Neither can He be equated with the "Hindu trinity" Brahma (the Creator), Vishnu (the preserver) and Shiva (the destroyer). The three Hindu gods are reminiscences of the old Vedic polytheism, from where they have been later assimilated as primary products of Brahman's manifestations. The "Hindu trinity" cannot be an equivalent of the Christian Holy Trinity, but rather a kind of pagan tri-theism. The God of the Bible has no equivalent in the other world religions. There is no deeper Ultimate Reality above him, a kind of Brahman, as Meister Eckhart suggested. He is not an Ishvara manifested out of Brahman (or a Deus manifested out of Deitas, according to Eckhart), a god that comes and goes, located far beyond the impersonal absolute. The triune God of Christianity does not admit the existence of a "deeper reality" in which He originated, because He says: I am the first and I am the last; apart from me there is no God (Isaiah 44,6). As a consequence, it is absurd to define a superior and esoteric way (apara-vidya), that aims at the impersonal Absolute, and an inferior exoteric way (para-vidya) for those who are so limited that they are satisfied with a personal manifestation of the absolute. Christianity cannot be assimilated as a form of bhakti-yoga, a way accessible for the inferior and weak people to attain the impersonal Ultimate Reality of the world. We will return to this aspect in a further file.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (12 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions The nature of creation in Christianity

Directly linked to what we accept as Ultimate Reality is the significance we grant to the physical world. Being consequent to the idea of the fundamental unity of the world in Brahman, pantheism has to consider the physical world and man as manifestations of Brahman, manifestations of the same primordial essence to which they are destined to return. For this reason, it can be said that the impersonal Absolute is incomplete without his "creation", i.e. without the manifestation of his potentiality. The manifestation of Brahman is a necessity derived from its very nature. A similar situation is to be found in the Samkhya-Yoga, where prakriti (the primordial substance) transforms itself into the forms of the world. In Eastern religions creation is always a transformation (or manifestation) of a primordial impersonal unity. It is not a replacement of "nothingness" with "something", but a transformation of the Ultimate Reality from one ontological condition into another. What once existed in unity becomes multiplicity and manifestation, an actualization of preexistent virtualities. Things are different with the creation presented in the Bible. An unprecedented element in world religions, God creates the universe out of nothing (ex nihilo) and not out of his own substance (ex Deo). This "nothing" has no ontological statute, it is not a primordial substance, because prior to creation, nothing existed except God. Creation ex nihilo is not an artifice of Christian philosophy, but the only possibility compatible with the existence of a personal God as Ultimate Reality. The psalmist writes about the act of creation: In the beginning you laid the foundations of the earth, and the heavens are the work of your hands. They will perish, but you remain; they will all wear out like a garment. Like clothing you will change them and they will be discarded. But you remain the same, and your years will never end. (Psalm 102,25-27) The creation presented in the book of Genesis is an act intended and completed by the Creator, not out of necessity, but of desire and love. The beginning or cause of the world is not an impersonal necessity or a blind manifestation of an undetermined nature, but the product of the free choice of the personal and triune God.

God and creation in Judaism and Islam

The God of Judaism is the God of the Old Testament, God the Father of Christianity, so that the Old Testament is common to the two religions. Although there are some hints pointing to the Triune God in the Old Testament, Judaism accepts only God the Father as the true God. The rejection of Jesus Christ as God the Son represented precisely the appearance of Christianity as a new world religion. The God of orthodox Judaism is the same as God the Father of Christianity, having the same attributes. In time, however, some Judaic sects, such as the Kabbalah for instance, rejected the personal God and adopted a pantheistic view of Ultimate Reality: “Bear in mind, that before the emanations were emanated and the creatures were created, the upper simple light has filled entire existence” (The Tree of Life, 1). This “simple light” or “endless light” is not the personal creator of the Old Testament, but rather an equivalent of the Hindu Brahman. The other great monotheistic religion of the world, Islam, also has a personal god as Ultimate Reality. Allah is presented in the Quran as an eternal being, transcendent and almighty. In the 112th Surra it is

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (13 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions stated: Say, He is God, the One! God, the eternally Besought of all! He neither begets nor was begotten. And there is none comparable unto Him. Allah seems to have the same attributes as God the Father of the Old Testament, since the influence of the Old Testament on the Quran is beyond doubt, given the many episodes taken over from the Bible and reinterpreted. The following links should be helpful for understanding how the content of the Bible and the Quran was transmitted during history: “The Bible and the Quran” - An Historical Comparison (manuscript, documentary and archaeological analysis) “The Textual history of the Quran and the Bible”, by John Gilchrist. The Triune God of Christianity is considered to be a heresy, both in Judaism and Islam, an attempt against monotheism. Therefore, Allah cannot be the same with God the Father of the Old Testament, because he clearly states that belief in the Trinity is one of the worst possible heresies and sins: Surely, unbelievers are those who said, "Allah is the third of the three [in a Trinity]". But there is no god but One God. And if they cease not from what they say, verily, a painful torment will befall the unbelievers among them (Quran 5,73). However a strictly mono-personal, not tri-personal, God cannot be perfect in his personal attributes because some of them are defined only in relation with another person (for instance love, goodness, and compassion). Such a god is conditioned by his creation in order to be loving, caring and good, because otherwise he has no one toward whom to express these attributes. A god that depends on his creation (mankind) to be perfect (or perfect since creation) in his personal attributes is less than perfect. A possible solution to this problem would be that God and creation should always coexist, but this would mean that God is not the creator, and that is absurd. The only possible solution is the Holy Trinity "of one substance" in which there is an absolute communion of nature, will and deed, who creates man not out of necessity, but out of his superabundant love.

Conclusion

The world's religions hold very different views on Ultimate Reality. More than different, they are even irreconcilable one with another. Indeed, the impersonal Brahman of the Upanishads, who balances between the manifested state and unmanifestation (the same as Shiva in Tantrism), or the lack of any transcendental being, as stated by Theravada Buddhism, are positions that cannot be reconciled with the personal God of the monotheistic religions. Even among the many branches of Hinduism are stated irreconcilable positions (see for instance the gods of the Vedas, the Brahman of Vedanta, Vishnu of the theistic trends stated by Ramanuja and Madhva, and Ishvara of the Yoga darshana). On the other hand, a personal God as Ultimate Reality cannot be at the same time a manifestation of an impersonal Absolute (as in some cases of Hindu theism) and a being above whom there is no deeper reality (as the monotheistic religions claim). Even the three great monotheistic religions of the world

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (14 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] The Ultimate Reality in world religions state irreconcilable positions concerning the nature of God. He must be either tri-personal (the triune God of Christianity), or mono-personal (as in Judaism and Islam). Considering all these alternatives, we cannot accept the claim that the world's religions are parts of a unique spirituality, or parts toward the same transcendental finality.

Next article: Man’s condition

http://www.comparativereligion.com/god.html (15 of 15) [10/27/2000 9:47:16 AM] Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita

Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita

The Bhagavad Gita (henceforth referred to as the Gita) was probably composed sometime between the 7th and the 6th centuries BC and later incorporated into the great Hindu epic Mahabharata. It stated a new path towards liberation, a new kind of asceticism at hand for any human, independent of social status. It requires neither withdrawal from social life as the Upanishads do, nor performing severe austerities as the Hatha and Raja Yoga. This probably explains its great success both in the East and the West. The new Yoga presented in the Gita is mostly concerned with one's attitude of mind when performing normal social duties, and could be defined as a combination of Karma, Bhakti and Buddhi Yoga. Karma Yoga in the Gita means the performance of one's duties in a spirit of renunciation, of not being bound to its fruits (5,1-2), Bhakti Yoga is one's effort to bring all actions as sacrifices to Krishna (14,26), while Buddhi Yoga is a particular kind of wisdom one has to develop in understanding life (2,49; 10,10; 18,57). Let us analyze the way this new kind of Yoga works, as well as its natural implications.

Yoga according to the Gita

The Gita is an episode of the great epic Mahabharata (6,25-42), which narrates the dialogue of Arjuna, one of the five sons of the Pandava family, and the Hindu god Krishna, an avatar of Vishnu. A major battle is about to begin in which Arjuna sees himself playing a contradictory role, that of fighting against his relatives, the Kaurava family. Caught between his warrior duty and the ethical meaning of fighting against his cousins, between his social duty and the threat of karma, he chooses to not fight and be killed rather than have his conscience loaded with the killing of his relatives. At this moment Krishna reveals himself to the distressed warrior and helps him understand the situation from a transcendental point of view. He performs a spiritual exegesis of Arjuna's situation, stating: "Not by abstaining from work can one achieve freedom from karma, nor by renunciation alone can one attain perfection" (3,4). "Abstaining from work" is practically impossible according to Krishna, as "everyone is forced to act according to the tendencies (gunas) he has acquired from the modes of material nature (prakriti)" (3,5). As a warrior, Arjuna must always follow his caste duties, in other words, his dharma. On this basis the Gita founds a new element in Hindu philosophy: Spiritual perfection is not attained by asceticism or abandoning

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Gita.html (1 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:20 AM] Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita action, but by giving a new meaning to action - that of detachment from its fruits, an attitude that does not feed karma and reincarnation. Krishna formulates the famous principle: Be focused on action and not on the fruits of action. Do not become confused in attachment to the fruit of your actions and do not become confused in the desire for inaction (2,47). Therefore one should not withdraw from the world of social involvement but live in it detached from the fruits of actions, as "action is better than inaction" and "renunciation of all action is impossible" (3,8). As a result, Krishna's command to Arjuna is: "Always act with detachment to the fruits of actions. The one who is acting without attachment attains God" (3,19). This is Karma Yoga, the path of attaining liberation through accomplishing one's normal duties with a totally detached attitude toward personal benefit. In his given context, Arjuna has to fight no matter who is going to die on the battlefield. There is also a new meaning for sacrifice and Bhakti Yoga. Written at the time when the authority of the Vedas has heavily decreased, the Gita states a hierarchy in the value of different kinds of sacrifice, with the lowest being the Vedic sacrifice, brought to a god in order to get personal favors, the next being the inner sacrifice of Raja Yoga (that of breathing - 4,29; of the mind and senses - 4,27; and that of empirical knowledge 4,33) and the best being that of detached action. Acting like this, one brings his actions as sacrifices to Krishna and therefore they do not generate karmic seeds anymore: Consider all your acts as acts of devotion to me, whether eating, offering, giving away, performing austerities. Perform them as an offering to me. In this way you will be free from karma, you will be liberated and you will come to me (9,27). According to this new understanding of Bhakti Yoga, there is no need for any kind of material sacrifices, rituals or other kind of performances, but only to act in a worshipping attitude toward Krishna, as if all acts are dedicated to him. This particular mindset in judging particular situations in life is called Buddhi Yoga. Following it, one should attain liberation.

Krishna, karma and grace

A first inconsistency of the Gita concerns the relation between the law of karma and the grace granted by Krishna in helping his followers attain liberation. On the one hand it seems that Krishna is sovereign over the law of karma, using it as an instrument for punishment or reward. He says: "Those who are envious and mischievous, who are the lowest among men, I perpetually cast into transmigration, into various demoniac species of life" (16,19). And also: "Those who worship me and surrender all their activities unto me, being devoted to me without hesitation, engaged in devotional service and meditating unto me, I deliver them quickly from the ocean of birth and death" (12,6-7). On the other hand, karma seems to be a self-functioning rule that produces effects by its own power. One has to struggle alone against its drive and attain better incarnations from one existence to the next: "When the Yogi engages himself in making further progress, being washed of all karma, he achieves liberation after many, many births" (6,45). In the meanwhile, Krishna holds a detached position toward all humans: "I see all creatures equally disposed and I am not partial to anyone" (9,29). These two positions can hardly be reconciled. In trying to explain the relation between karma and the grace of Krishna, the Hindu analysts of the Gita had to choose between holding to the supremacy of Krishna and the ultimate power of karma in ruling the world. Consequently, we have theistic and pantheistic interpretations (and even translations) of the Gita, indebted to one or the other alternative.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Gita.html (2 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:20 AM] Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita The first see Krishna as a super-personal god using karma as an instrument for awakening humans from ignorance, and the second see him as a mere form of Brahman's manifestation, with no real power in controlling karma. As the two positions contradict each other and the Gita leaves enough room for both, we wonder which could actually be the relation between karma and grace. In order to attain liberation, Arjuna is advised to strive hard to realize a detached attitude of mind, called Buddhi Yoga (2,49): To those who are constantly devoted to serve me, I give them the Buddhi Yoga by which they can come to me. I show my mercy to them by destroying their ignorance with the lamp of knowledge (10,10-11). Here it looks like Krishna burns karma by his grace only if one strives hard to deserve it. Therefore the major role in salvation belongs to the individual who performs Buddhi Yoga. The grace granted by Krishna is far away from the meaning it got later in the prapatti devotional trend. Therefore, Krishna must be understood rather as a kind of meditation object than a personal god who gets himself involved in one's reincarnation journey. He resembles Ishvara of the Yoga darshana of Patanjali from this point of view (i.e. one has to concentrate on Krishna and imitate his way of being in order to advance toward liberation). The only grace one benefits from Hrishna is receiving his advice. The rest depends on the disciple.

Dharma and karma

In anyone's life the conditioning couple of dharma and karma is at work. The "duty" that forces Arjuna to fight (2,33) is his dharma, i.e. his caste-duty as warrior. In turn, Arjuna's dharma is generated by his karma. Therefore the real impetus of Arjuna's actions is his karma, which pushes him into action independently of his present intentions. Krishna states: "When you become confused in your false ego you say to yourself, 'I will not fight' you are misled. By your nature you must fight" (18,59). This "nature" is prakriti or, more specifically, the way the three gunas influence one's mind under the influence of past karma. Therefore, Arjuna is not free to fulfill his dharma, but is compelled by his karma to act according to it. The action that "is better than inaction" (3,8) is not a free decision of man, it does not follow the understanding of one's social duty, but is the way of accepting a pre-ordained scenario. Such an action is devoid of any sense of freedom, being a mere resignation to fate. The only freedom left to Arjuna is to give a certain meaning to his predetermined actions, that of sacrifices to Krishna: "Consider all your acts as acts of devotion to me, whether eating, offering, giving away, performing austerities. Perform them as an offering to me. In this way you will be free from karma, you will be liberated and you will come to me" (9,27).

Krishna as avatar and the periodical creation of the world

Another inconsistency of the Gita is regarding the character of Krishna. According to classic Vaishnavism, Krishna is only an incarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu (which according to Vedanta is only a form of Brahman's manifestation). In the Gita Krishna becomes the Supreme Lord of the Universe (5,29), eternal (4,6) and the source of all existence: "I am the source of all spiritual and material worlds. Everything emanates from me" (10,8). Contrary to Vedanta, Krishna becomes the source of Brahman

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Gita.html (3 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:20 AM] Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita (14,27) and contrary to Vaishnavism he is the instrument of attaining fusion with Brahman (14,26). Although the intention of the Gita is to present Krishna as super-personal, he is rather a heterogeneous mixture of theistic, dualistic and pantheistic kinds of Ultimate Reality. He is not only the creator but also the substance of the universe (9,16-19; 8,4; 10,20-42). The cycle of permanent transformation between the manifested state and the unmanifested one is characteristic for Krishna too, as it was with Brahman: At the end of an era (kalpa) all creatures disintegrate into my nature and at the beginning of another era I manifest them again. Such it is my nature (prakriti) to follow again and again the pattern of the Infinite manifestations and disintegrations (9,7-8). Krishna has to "follow the pattern of the Infinite manifestations and disintegrations" (avasham prakriteh vashat, lit. "automatically, under the obligation of prakriti"), which implies that the process is a necessity that surpasses him as personal god. He is just a detached (but also helpless) spectator to it. Therefore it is hard to accept his dominion over creation along with the periodic manifestation of nature (prakriti). Rather, we should conclude that the creation of the world is not an option for him, but a periodic duty at the end of each cosmic cycle, as was the case with the manifestations of Brahman. S. Dasgupta comments on the contradictory personal character of Krishna: The Gita combines together different conceptions of God without feeling the necessity of reconciling the oppositions or contradictions involved in them. It does not seem to be aware of the philosophical difficulty of combining the concept of God as unmanifested, differenceless entity with the notion of Him as the super-person Who incarnates Himself on earth in the human form and behaves in the human manner. It is not aware of the difficulty that, if all good and evil should have emanated from God, and if there be ultimately no moral responsibility, and if everything in the world should have the same place in God, there is no reason why God should trouble to incarnate Himself as man, when there is a disturbance of the Vedic dharma. If God is impartial to all, and if He is absolutely unperturbed, why should He favour the man who clings to Him, and why, for his sake, overrule the world-order of events and in his favour suspend the law of karma? (S. Dasgupta, Indian Philosophy, Motilal Banarsidass, 1991, vol.2, p. 533).

Acting without attachment to the fruit of actions

The very demand to act in the world without attachment to the fruits of action seems itself contradictory. Could it actually be possible to act like this? How could one really perform his social duties without being attached to them? Otherwise what motivation remains for acting in the world? That of a robot, devoid of any personal input to his acts? The philosophy of the Gita itself aims at fulfilling a very personal fruit - liberation from reincarnation, which is useful for nobody else than oneself. Should this fruit be treated with detachment too? Could one act detached regarding his eternal destiny? If the philosophy of detached acting cannot be valid for the major aspect of existence, how can we know it works in other respects? On the other hand, how much could one know about his dharma, especially in a Western society, where the caste system doesn't exist? At what extent can one be sure he is fulfilling his dharma and not a personal attachment to a certain egoistic motivation? Where is the limit between my dharma and my neighbor's? Therefore, under the cover of religiosity, anyone can masquerade, pretending he follows his dharma, but having no altruistic motivations at all in what he does.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Gita.html (4 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:20 AM] Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita The Gita and morality

When Arjuna found himself in the process of choosing between his duty as warrior and the killing of his relatives (a severe violation of Vedic morality), Krishna explained to him that he must give another meaning to traditional morality. Traditional ethical values should not be a hindrance to acting detached to the fruits of action. He argued: "The wise men who reached true knowledge see with as equally a brahman (priest), a cow, an elephant, a dog and a dog-eater" (5,18). As only the soul (atman) is immortal, Krishna argues that it is actually impossible to kill anyone: "Those who think that they can kill or those that think they can be killed are confused in the manifestations of ignorance. The infinite, immortal soul can neither kill or be killed" (2,19). Therefore Arjuna is free to kill his relatives, considering them only temporary abiding forms for the eternal self, mere mortal frames. S. Dasgupta states in his commentary: The theory of the Gita that, if actions are performed with an unattached mind, then their defects cannot touch the performer, distinctly implies that the goodness or badness of an action does not depend upon external effects of the action, but upon the inner motive of action. If there is no motive of pleasure or self-gain, then the action performed cannot bind the performer; for it is only the bond of desires and self-love that really makes an action one's own and makes one reap its good or bad fruits. Morality from this point of view becomes wholly subjective, and the special feature of the Gita is that it tends to make all actions non-moral by cutting away the bonds that connect an action with its performer (Ibid, p. 507). The contrast with traditional morality is obvious. Its representative is another important character in the battle of Kurukshetra, Yudishthira, Arjuna's brother. He tried to expiate his sin of killing his relatives in battle through repentance, gifts, asceticism and pilgrimages (Mahabharata 12,7). For him a bad conscience could not be cleansed by a right attitude of mind, but by compensatory acts. On the other hand, the same mindset that Arjuna should have had in securing a clear conscience (Gita 2,19) was used by the demon Kamsa in the Bhagavata Purana (10,4,22) in order to comfort Krishna's parents and justify the killing of their other sons by him: In the bodily conception of life one remains in darkness without self-realization, thinking "I am being killed" or "I have killed my enemies". As long as a foolish person thus considers the self to be the killer or the killed, he continues to be responsible for material obligations, and consequently he suffers the reactions of happiness and distress. If the same "detached" perspective on moral values can be used both by the demon Kamsa, who caused the corruption of the dharma, and the divine avatar who came to save it (Gita 4,6-7) and kill the demon, it is hard to accept that such an approach could represent a true basis for morality.

Conclusion

Rather than a consistent philosophy, S. Dasgupta considers the Gita only a manual of conduct: The Gita was probably written at a time when philosophical views had not definitely crystallized into hard-and-fast systems of thought, and when the distinguishing philosophical niceties, scholarly disputations, the dictates of argument, had not come into fashion. The Gita, therefore, is

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Gita.html (5 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:20 AM] Critical considerations regarding the philosophy of the Bhagavad Gita not to be looked upon as a properly schemed system of philosophy, but a s a manual of right conduct and right perspective of things in the light of a mystical approach to God in self-resignation, devotion, friendship and humility. (p.534) The Gita falls short of coherence and viability. A god that rules the world by the "help" of karma cannot be the super-personal embodiment of perfection. One's (mostly unknown) dharma fed by past lives' deeds cannot provide any real meaning for freedom. Acting without attachment to its results cannot be a valid solution for fulfilling one's social duty. And a morality that considers people temporary frames of the eternal self cannot grant social harmony. Therefore, it as hard to accept the message of the Gita as a proper teaching of conduct, especially in the Western world.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Gita.html (6 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:20 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions

MAN’S SALVATION AND ETERNAL DESTINY IN WORLD RELIGIONS

As we have seen in the previous file on the human condition, one of the few elements that world religions share is the fact that man doesn’t live in harmony with the Ultimate Reality. In other words, man doesn’t manifest his purpose of existence. Life is far away from pursuing the ideal claimed by religion, so that man needs salvation from his present condition. However, following how Ultimate Reality and human nature are stated, the meaning of salvation and eternal destiny differ to a great extent from one religion to another. Three important aspects must be analyzed here: The nature of the resources needed for attaining salvation, the actual way of getting saved and the meaning of salvation from an eternal perspective. Concerning the first two aspects, some religions claim that salvation can be attained by using only inner human resources. They demand the use of meditation, accumulation of wisdom, asceticism, performing rituals, good deeds, etc. Other religions state man can be saved only through the grace granted by an external personal agent. This can be God, a bodhisattva, an avatar, etc. Man’s duty is to recognize his impossibility to get saved by his own effort, and therefore accept grace unconditionally. There are also combinations of the two cases. As concerning the meaning of salvation from an eternal perspective, there are also important distinctions to mention. As emphasized in the previous file, the monotheistic religions state that the barrier between man and God is sin. Salvation means removing this moral barrier and restoring a personal communion with God, which will endure forever. Pantheist religions consider the human self a part of the impersonal Ultimate Reality, and therefore man’s problem is epistemological. Salvation means liberation from ignorance and corresponds to the fusion of the impersonal self with the Absolute, meaning dissolution of subject and object, knower and known. Other Eastern religions, such as Buddhism and Taoism, take salvation as an illumination, meaning a discovery of and conformity of oneself with an eternal law that governs existence. Dualistic religions see man’s salvation as a return to an initial angelic state, from which he has fallen in a physical body. In this file we will analyze closer these alternatives, trying to understand to what extent they can still be compatible with each other.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (1 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions Salvation and eternal destiny in Hinduism

The Upanishads and Vedanta philosophy

As we have seen in the file on the human condition, the Upanishads view the problem man has to face as belonging to the domain of knowledge. The self is one with Brahman, but illusion prevents man from grasping it. The liberation of atman from the chain of reincarnation can be attained only during a human existence, so we are in a privileged stage of spiritual evolution. We have a better position even than gods do. They are in a stage of reaping one’s positive merits during a lifetime, as animals are the opposite, the stage of reaping bad merits. That is why devotion to a god is not a valid way toward liberation, as it perpetuates the illusion of personal existence. The following text indicates that the gods like to encourage man’s ignorance: Now, if a man worships another deity, thinking, “He is one and I am another,” he does not know. He is like an animal to the gods. As many animals serve a man, so does each man serve the gods. Even if one animal is taken away, it causes anguish to the owner; how much more so when many are taken away! Therefore it is not pleasing to the gods that men should know the truth. (Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 1,4,10) Atman’s liberation from samsara is called moksha and represents its return to Brahman. This kind of liberation is actually an impersonal fusion of atman with Brahman, resembling the fusion of a drop of rain with the ocean, thus becoming one with it: “As rivers flow into the sea and in so doing lose name and form, so even the wise man, freed from name and form, attains the Supreme Being, the Self-luminous, the Infinite. He who knows Brahman becomes Brahman” (Mundaka Upanishad 3,2,8-9). At this point any element of personhood is annihilated and the process of reincarnation ceases. First mentioned in the Brahmanas as necessary for knowing the laws of sacrifice, intuitive knowledge (jnana, vidya) here receives its full spiritual meaning. Vedic sacrifice (according to Mundaka Up. 1,2,7) and the knowledge of the Vedas (Chandogya Up. 7,1,3) have no value in attaining liberation. The cycle avidya-karma-samsara can be broken only by knowing and destroying its primary cause, which is desire. (This trend gets special attention in the Bhagavad Gita and also in Buddhism.) According to the Upanishads, the process of attaining intuitive knowledge of atman and liberation from desires requires passing through three states of consciousness, categorized as the wakeful state, the state of sleep with dreams and the dreamless sleep (Brihadaranyaka Up. 4,3,9-19). The first state of consciousness, the wakeful state (jagrat), represents the normal human state, in which the phenomenal world is completely involved in one’s psycho-mental activity. In the stage corresponding to sleep with dreams (svapna) the psycho-mental is detached from the objective world and engaged in a virtual world, a mere projection of the real one. Participation in the phenomenal world stops only in the dreamless state (susupti), when the world’s illusion ceases to manifest itself (Brihadaranyaka Up. 4,3,32). Some later developments concluded that in this stage atman is only temporarily united with Brahman, and for this reason a fourth state (turiya) was defined, when the unity of atman-Brahman is perfectly attained. There is no need to mention here actual methods for attaining liberation, since they are not yet fully developed in the Upanishads. Two important meditation formulas (mantras) are Aham Brahma asmi (“I am Brahman” - in the Brihadaranyaka Up. 1,4,10) and Tat tvam asi (“You are that” - in the Chandogya Up. 6,8-15). There is also to be noticed the importance of the sacred syllable OM (AUM), which is said to exert a powerful influence on the one who knows to use it and understands its metaphysical importance. The Mandukya Upanishad establishes a correspondence between the three letters that compound it (A, U,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (2 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions and M) and the three states of conscience mentioned above. The Mundaka Upanishad (2,2,4) states: “The syllable aum is the bow; one’s self, indeed, is the arrow. Brahman is spoken of as the target of that. It is to be hit without making a mistake. Thus one becomes united with it as the arrow [becomes one with the target].” The same finality is stated in Shankara’s Vedanta. The liberation of atman is attained through intuitive knowledge. There are four qualifications prescribed for the one who follows this path: 1) discrimination of the eternal from the non-eternal; 2) no attachment to the things belonging to this or any other world; 3) possession of six virtues: calmness, equanimity, turning away from sense-objects, forbearance, concentration and faith in the doctrine; and 4) longing for release. The method that has to be pursued has three parts: study of the doctrine, reflection and contemplation. For a critique of pantheism, the way it states liberation and its significance click here and see our special file on this topic.

The Samkhya and Yoga darshanas

Liberation in the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas represents detaching purusha from any manifestation of prakriti, out of the domain of psycho-mental experience. The way of attaining it, in Samkhya, is metaphysical knowledge, i.e. analyzing and understanding the external and internal structures of nature and psycho-mental activity. It is stated that neither through sacrifices (Samkhya Sutra 1,84), nor by doing good deeds (1,56) nor by the help of Vedas (3,25-26), but only through getting spiritual knowledge can liberation be attained. It involves abandoning all common values that are created by our mind and thus do not belong to purusha. By knowing the absolute state of purusha, the confusion generated by the physical and mental world ceases, they are absorbed into prakriti and the self finds liberation (Samkhya Sutra 3,69). This is the way humans understand the liberation of the self, but as thinking itself belongs to prakriti, Samkhya holds that liberation is a mere acquaintance with purusha’s eternal freedom, unable to be normally perceived because of ignorance. The moment when discrimination (viveka) between the two categories has been fully realized, prakriti with all its manifestations departs from purusha, “like a dancer who leaves after satisfying her master’s wish” (Samkhya Karika 59). The self escapes from the illusory relation with prakriti and has nothing to do with it anymore. From that moment on the liberated purusha contemplates only itself and has no concern about the relation of other purushas with prakriti. The finality in this darshana is a world of free and totally isolated purushas, between which no relation can exist. In the Yoga darshana of Patanjali there are two elements added: 1) Ishvara, an entity improperly called God; and 2) the fact that liberation cannot be attained by spiritual knowledge only, but that a specific ascetic technique is needed. Ishvara is not a personal god, but rather a macro-purusha that has never been involved with psycho-mental activity or with karma. Having no personal status, Ishvara cannot have a personal relationship with man. It is rather a metaphysical sympathy, resembling that existing between a compass and the magnetic field of the Earth. Ishvara can help the Yogi towards liberation only as he is chosen as the object of meditation. The instinctual relationship between purusha and Ishvara is possible only because of the similarity of their structures, so that in the Yoga darshana of Patanjali, Ishvara is considered to be a “God” just of the Yogis. The liberation of purusha has the same meaning as in Samkhya. He remains isolated forever,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (3 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions contemplating himself and without any relation with other purusha or with Ishvara. For more information on the Yoga technique as described by Patanjali see our special file on this topic. There is also available a special file aimed at analyzing some difficulties of the Samkhya and Yoga metaphysics.

Tantrism and Hatha Yoga

Both schools are pantheistic, viewing liberation as the return of the self to the impersonal Ultimate Reality represented by Shiva. It is a process similar to the fusion of atman with Brahman, as stated in the Upanishads and Vedanta. In order to get a brief description of the actual techniques used by these two schools, and also an evaluation of the experiences they produce, see our special file on this topic. Here we summarize just a few key elements in order to get a global understanding of them. The self, represented in the form of kundalini energy, has to be awakened through complicated physical exercises (in Hatha Yoga) and also sexual practices (in Tantrism), joined with respiratory techniques. Then kundalini traverses a spiritual channel of the subtle body, which corresponds physically to the spine, and the moment it reaches the top of the head it unites with Shiva, the Ultimate Reality of the universe. This goal cannot be attained just by spiritual knowledge, as in other Hindu schools (Vedanta or Samkhya). The help of a teacher (guru) in assisting the practitioner is absolutely necessary, as the awakening and rising of kundalini is full of potential dangers for the Yogi. Although both schools are pantheistic, they hold a different view than Vedanta philosophy concerning the role of the human body. While the Upanishads and Vedanta despise the body, considering it the primary source of illusion that holds atman captive in the reincarnation cycle, Tantrism and Hatha Yoga take the body as the main instrument in attaining liberation. However, the attention granted to the body has a single purpose: to make it fit for getting control over the mind and thus liberating the self. Despite the fact that it is sometimes believed that Hatha Yoga is only a kind of harmless physical training, the most important writing of this school, the Hatha Yoga Pradipika, clearly states that Hatha Yoga has to be taught only in order to reach the Raja Yoga level (1,2), which means “the integration of mind in a state where the subject-object duality does not exist” (4,77), or in other words, merging with the impersonal Ultimate Reality.

Hindu theism

The liberation of self (atman or purusha) through metaphysical knowledge (jnana, vidya) or asceticism (tapas), as was the case in the previous schools of Hinduism, cannot be a valid solution for the average Hindu. This is the reason why most people adopt a certain devotional practice (called bhakti) in order to transcend the world of suffering. The most important gods worshipped today are Vishnu and his avatars (especially Rama and Krishna), Shiva and the goddess Shakti (called also Kali or Durga). Consequently, Hindu theism has three main branches: Vaishnavism, Shaivism and Shaktism. They have the following defining characteristics: acceptance of a personal god as Ultimate Reality, performance of a certain ritual in order to worship him, invocation of his help to attain salvation and understanding salvation as uniting with god or attaining a perfect and eternal relation with him. We will not discuss here salvation according to the most famous piece of Hindu theism, the Bhagavad Gita. There is available a special file on this topic. Out of the many schools of theistic Hinduism existing

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (4 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions today, we will limit ourselves to a brief presentation of the Vaishnava schools grounded by the great thinkers Ramanuja and Madhva, and mention a few elements of their understanding about man’s salvation and eternal destiny. They stated the most coherent forms of Hindu theism known today as opposed to the traditional pantheistic schools, especially to the Advaita Vedanta of Shankara. (Similar views have been developed in the Shaivite tradition, but they are less important and we will not refer to them.) According to Madhva (1238 - 1317 AD), liberation can be attained only by the grace of Vishnu. Man has to realize that his independence from God is illusory and that material cravings distance him from God. Vishnu uses reincarnation to help the soul discover his true spiritual nature. The way of attaining liberation requires devotion, moral perfection and knowledge of God. The more God is known, the more he is loved, the more he is loved, he is known; these are two inseparable aspects. The moment the soul attains liberation, he does not lose his individuality in order to become one with God (as in Vedanta), but becomes perfect and shares an eternal communion and harmony with God. Although Madhva’s theism is genuine, there are some weak points in the way it defines free will and the role of karma. He stated that nothing can happen in the world or to souls without God’s will and initiative. Man can attain liberation only by God’s grace. On the other hand, souls are subject to karma, and God reveals himself only to the ones who deserve it. However, if all souls are entirely dependent on God for their functioning and he is the one who causes the creation, sustenance and dissolution of the world (and consequently of physical bodies), this implies that any spiritual progress of the soul is nothing but God’s work. If God’s will is responsible for both bondage by karma and liberation, how is it possible that some souls deserve liberation, while others do not? In other words, how can a just balance be set up in this system, between God’s grace and karma? The solution offered by Madhva to this dilemma is the idea that souls have a certain inner inclination, according to an innate nature. There are three kinds of souls according to these inner inclinations: those of noble inclination (sattvika), those of mixed inclination (rajasa) and those with base inclination (tamasa). Only those of the first category will reach liberation by God’s grace, the others being left to themselves. To avoid total predestination, Madhva stated that they are granted a small amount of free will (dattasvatantrya) and therefore can perform a small improvement of their nature from one existence to another. But by giving this solution, God is no longer the one who determines the souls’ actions, and his total control over them is abrogated. This contradiction arises out of the impossibility to reconcile the role of karma with the grace of an omnipotent god. According to Ramanuja (1017 - 1137 AD), man is responsible for his acts and capable of choosing between good and evil. What we experience now as evil in the world is the result of people’s past ignorant deeds against God. Liberation from the bondage of ignorance can be attained only by devotion. Once liberated, the soul is not dissolved in the Ultimate Reality, but becomes perfect through his integration into the functionality of God. Using a proper illustration, liberation is not the union of the raindrop with the ocean (as in Vedanta), but the adding of a new cell to a living body, without losing its individuality and conscious existence. Through this kind of liberation neither the transcendental supremacy of God is lost, nor the identity of the soul. There are basically two classical viewpoints on grace in theistic Hinduism, well-illustrated by two famous analogies, that of the monkey and that of the cat. The first view (the markata school) states that man has to cling to God like a monkey clings to its mother, thus having an important contribution in attaining salvation. The following elements are included: discrimination of food, freedom from passions,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (5 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions longing for God and continuous meditation on him, doing good to others, having good intentions and truthfulness, integrity, cheerfulness and hope. So it is not only about stimulating positive feelings, but also using the intellect and will in order to love God with both heart and mind. Starting from this point, where man plays a certain role in his liberation (through the rituals and moral obligations he has to fulfill), Ramanuja grounded an even more radical way towards liberation, called prapatti, where there is no more room left for personal merit. This is the second view on grace (the marjara school), stating that the devotee must be like a young kitten, totally dependent on its mother’s will, picked up by her and carried here and there. Therefore man has to give up the control of his life to Vishnu and leave to him all responsibility for salvation. Two important notions here are the transferring of merits (bhara-samarpana) from God to man and taking refuge under God’s feet (sharanagati). The one engaged in prapatti acknowledges that he is not good enough to deserve liberation by performing rituals and moral obligations. He asks God to undertake the control of his life and use him as instrument in the world, so that the whole merit for attaining liberation pertains to God. There is no doubt that from the laborious techniques of other Hindu schools, that stressed the attainment of liberation through personal effort, to the prapatti alternative, where man is humble and helpless before God, Hindu spirituality went through radical transformations. In a few words, the whole prapatti philosophy can be summarized in a single verse, written by Vedanta Deshika, a 14th century follower of Ramanuja: Lord, I, who am nothing, conform to your will and desist being contrary to it, and with faith and prayer, submit to you the burden of saving my soul (Nyasadashaka 2).

Man’s salvation and eternal destiny in Buddhism

Theravada Buddhism

Salvation, according to Gotama Buddha, is possible only for the one who accepts and follows the four noble truths: 1) The nature of life is suffering. 2) Suffering is caused by desire, or thirst (tanha) to experience existence. 3) The complete cessation of desires leads to the cessation of suffering. 4) In order to escape suffering and attain enlightenment, one has to follow the Noble Eightfold Path, consisting of the eight practices of self-training. Before discussing the eightfold path towards liberation (nirvana), it is important to mention that the one who engages in it has to rely exclusively on his own inner strength. The Buddha taught: So, Ananda, you must be lamps unto yourselves. Rely on yourselves, and do not rely on external help. Hold firm to the truth as a lamp and a refuge, and do not look for refuge to anything beside yourselves. A brother becomes his own lamp and refuge by continually looking on his body, feelings, perceptions, moods, and ideas in such a manner that he conquers the cravings and depressions of ordinary men and is always strenuous, self-possessed, and collected in mind. Whoever among my disciples does this, either now or when I am dead, if he is anxious to learn, will reach the summit.... (Digha Nikaya 2,99-100)

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (6 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions There is no grace available from a personal god, because any personal existence belongs to the domain of illusion: Oneself, indeed, is one’s savior, for what other savior could there be? With oneself well-controlled one obtains a savior difficult to find. (Dhammapada 160) The point where the “chain of conditioned generation” can be broken is the ninth link, desire, which once eliminated prevents man from entering a new existence. The eight practices of self-training, which make the way out of suffering, can be classified in three categories: morality (sila), concentration (samadhi) and full knowledge (panna). Morality means right speech, action and livelihood. It has to generate a perfect state of self-control and contentment. Concentration requires perfection in efforts (right attitude of the mind in all deeds), mindfulness (awareness of mental and physical processes) and concentration (introversion and cessation of empirical consciousness). Full knowledge represents attaining perfection in all views (through understanding the impermanent nature of each phenomenon) and thoughts (renouncing all that is temporary and attaining equanimity in thought, speech and deeds). The techniques used in the concentration of mind are meditation and contemplation. Meditation is aimed at attaining tranquillity of mind and inner calm. By the use of contemplation, one seeks to destroy all attachments produced by the physical body, feelings, states of mind and objects of mind. Once man has attained nirvana, he becomes an arhat (“living enlightened one”). His karma is burned and at the time of his death he will cease to exist. Nirvana is neither a re-absorption in an eternal Ultimate Reality, because such a thing doesn’t exist, nor an annihilation of a self, because there is no self to annihilate. It is rather an annihilation of the illusion of an existing self. The proper image to describe it is the flame of the candle that is blown out. This represents the end of suffering but at the same time the end of any aspect that may define existence. (For some critical comments on the way Theravada Buddhism defines its fundamental doctrines, including nirvana, see our special file on this topic.)

Salvation in Mahayana Buddhism. The devotional way.

The first significant difference between Mahayana and Theravada Buddhism is a new goal to be pursued in life. Instead of seeking nirvana just for himself in order to become an arhat, the disciple of Mahayana Buddhism aims to become a bodhisattva, a celestial being that postpones his own entrance into parinirvana (final extinction) in order to help other humans also attain it. The bodhisattva even swears not to enter nirvana until he fulfills this noble mission. Here is a part of a bodhisattva’s vow: I should accept all sufferings for the sake of sentient beings, and enable them to escape from the abyss of immeasurable woes of birth and death. I should accept all suffering for the sake of all sentient beings in all worlds, in all states of misery, for ever and ever, and still always cultivate foundations of goodness for the sake of all beings. Why? I would rather take all this suffering on myself than to allow sentient beings to fall into hell. I should be a hostage to those perilous places - hells, animal realms, the nether world - as a ransom to rescue all sentient beings in states of woe and enable them to gain liberation. “I vow to protect all sentient beings and never abandon them. What I say is sincerely true, without

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (7 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions falsehood. Why? Because I have set my mind on enlightenment in order to liberate all sentient beings; I do not seek the unexcelled Way for my own sake. (Garland Sutra 23) For its selfish way of seeking nirvana, the Theravada school was considered an inferior spiritual path, valid only for those who cannot accept the idea of becoming a bodhisattva (Saddharmapundarika, 2). From here derives the name given to the two branches of Buddhism: Mahayana means “the larger/superior path” (that of becoming a bodhisattva), while Hinayana is the “narrow/inferior path”, that reduces its goal in becoming an arhat. As stated in Theravada, nirvana is considered only an intermediary step of becoming, a kind of incentive toward a higher becoming. The true enlightenment is the becoming of a bodhisattva being (Saddharmapundarika, 3). Thanks to the help granted by the bodhisattvas, it is said that all beings will attain perfection: The Dharma of the Buddhas by the constant use of a single flavor Causes the several worlds universally to attain perfection, By gradual practice all obtain the Fruit of the Way. (Saddharmapundarika Sutra 5) As was the case with the Hindu avatars of Vishnu, the bodhisattva beings are mediators between man and Ultimate Reality. Man has to earn their favors through devotion and thus attains liberation. This new development was interpreted as a penetration of the Hindu bhakti tradition in Buddhism. The pattern of devotion, which seems to be a natural tendency of the human soul, works here the same way as in Hinduism. This trend will become the religious path for lay Buddhists, for whom liberation through intuitive knowledge is not at hand. The most famous bodhisattva of Tibet is Avalokiteshvara, who is said to be able to help anybody, even if one only hears his name and memorizes it. In his great compassion he assumes as many forms as necessary in order to save all beings (including people and demons in hell), if they simply accept the doctrine he preaches to them. Today it is considered that the Dalai Lama, the spiritual leader of Tibetan Buddhists, is a reincarnation of this bodhisattva. The mantra used for his invocation is Om manipadme hum. Other important bodhisattvas are Amithabha (Amida in Japanese), who became very important after the 8th century AD; Manjushri; Vajrapani; and Kuan Yin (the last one important mostly for the Chinese women). Taking Amida as the most important bodhisattva, a very influential form of devotional Buddhism known as Pure Land Buddhism was founded in Japan. According to its doctrine, Amida (the Buddha of Infinite Light) is able to save even the most despised sinner by his grace (tariki). In his vow, he promised to save all sentient beings that would only repeat his name ten times: Let him utter the name, Buddha Amida. Let him do so serenely with his voice uninterrupted; let him be continually thinking of Buddha until he has completed ten times the thought, repeating, “Adoration to Buddha Amida.” On the strength of [his merit of] uttering the Buddha’s name he will, during every repetition, expiate the sins which involve him in births and deaths during eighty million kalpas. (Meditation on Buddha Amitayus 3,30) The reward for invoking Amida with sincere devotion is rebirth in his Western Paradise, Sukhavati (known also as Pure Land or Pure Realm). It is not possible to get there using other means as meditation or good deeds, but only by his grace.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (8 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions In Tibetan Buddhism it is stated that the help of the bodhisattvas is available even after death. According to the Tibetan Book of the Dead (8th century AD) the five bodhisattvas of Tibetan Buddhism (the Dhyani-Buddhas, or mental Buddhas) help the dead to avoid a bad reincarnation, trying to lead them toward happier lives in which they will be able to attain nirvana easier. Concerning the form in which the dead person survives in the transitory world and is punished in the temporary hells, Tibetan Buddhism (as the Yogachara Buddhist school too) accepts a self that reincarnates (a kind of atman), which represents an important distinction from classical Buddhism. However, this impersonal entity cannot really suffer, which means that the torments one has to suffer (because of his ignorance during lifetime) are in fact all hallucinations generated by his bad karma. According to the text, the dead is advised: When it happens that such a vision arises, do not be afraid! Do not feel terror! You have a mental body made of instincts; even if it is killed or dismembered, it cannot die! Since in fact you are a natural form of voidness, anger at being injured is unnecessary! The Yama Lords of Death are but arisen from the natural energy of your own awareness and really lack all substantiality. Voidness cannot injure voidness! (Tibetan Book of the Dead, 12) Although the bodhisattvas offer their help to the dead person, he is unable to accept it because of the projection of his bad karma and the attraction of “samsaric impurities”, which make him fall deeper and deeper into the intermediary state (bardo). For this reason it is wrong to pretend that the bodhisattvas save the dead through their grace, as only the merits he accumulated during lifetime make him able to accept the “rays of grace”. As was the case in theistic Hinduism, we are again faced with the incompatibility of grace, granted by an external agent (a bodhisattva), and the law of karma. In conclusion, we can see that Mahayana has brought significant changes to classic (Theravada) Buddhism. As Dr. Stcherbatsky writes: “When we see an atheistic, soul-denying, philosophic teaching of a path to personal final deliverance, consisting in an absolute extinction of life and a simple worship of the memory of its human founder - when we see it superseded by a magnificent High Church with a supreme God, surrounded by numerous pantheon and a host of saints, a religion highly devotional, highly ceremonious and clerical, with an ideal of universal salvation of all living creatures, a salvation by the divine grace of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, a salvation not in annihilation but in eternal life - we are fully justified in maintaining that the history of religions has scarcely witnessed such a break between new and old within the pale of what nevertheless continues to claim common descent from the same religious founder” (The Conception of Buddhist Nirvana, p. 36).

Salvation in Mahayana Buddhism. The way of intuitive knowledge.

Liberation through knowledge is the other important trend in Mahayana Buddhism. New doctrinal developments on the theme of non-existence of a self were the basis for founding a new doctrine, known as the doctrine of the void (shunyata). It was first stated in the Prajnaparamita Sutra(1st century BC) and then developed by Nagarjuna (2nd century AD). According to this doctrine, the true nature of the world is the void (shunya), which is not non-existence, but an Ultimate Reality free of any determinations, duality and limitations. Like Brahman, the void can be characterized only by using negations. Although Mahayana Buddhism rejects the major Vedantic notions, the void is nothing but an acceptance of Brahman in a new form. The world is considered to be the manifestation of shunya, which is altogether

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (9 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions the fundamental nature of any being. This true nature (called also Buddha Nature) has to be discovered by man through mystical introspection and liberation from the illusion of duality. It is nothing but an actualization in Mahayanic context of the atman-Brahman identity, as can be observed in the following text: Every being has the Buddha Nature. This is the self. Such a self is, since the very beginning, under cover of innumerable illusions. That is why a man cannot see it. O good man! There was a poor woman who had gold hidden somewhere in her house, but no one knew where it was. But there was a stranger who, by expediency, speaks to the poor woman, “I shall employ you to weed the lawn.” The woman answered, “I cannot do it now, but if you show my son where the gold is hidden, I will work for you.” The man says, “I know the way; I will show it to your son.” The woman replies, “No one in my house, big or small, knows where the gold is hidden. How can you know?” The man then digs out the hidden gold and shows it to the woman. She is glad, and begins to respect him. O good man! The same is the case with a man’s Buddha Nature. No one can see it. It is like the gold which the poor woman possessed and yet could not locate. I now let people see the Buddha Nature which they possess, but which was hidden by illusions. The Tathagata shows all beings the storehouse of enlightenment, which is the cask of true gold - their Buddha Nature. (Mahaparinirvana Sutra 214-15) Reality has three levels of perception, known also as the three bodies (trikaya) of Buddha. The first is nirmanakaya, the physical body, subject to change. The second is sambhogakaya, the body that appears in visions and, at the same time, the body of the boddhisattvas. The real body of Buddha is dharmakaya, which represents the ultimate nature and unity of all things. Those who surpass the duality of the world attain the perfection of wisdom and become identical with this absolute nature of the Buddha. It is no doubt an annihilation of personhood, identical to the one stated in Hindu pantheism.

Man’s liberation and eternal destiny in Taoism

Given the human condition in Taoism, the solution for attaining perfection is not holding Confucian morality or rituals, but controlling the inner universe by practicing the principle of non-acting (wu-wei), a similar concept to the demand of Krishna presented in the Bhagavad Gita (3,19). Wu-wei does not literally mean to do nothing, but to follow the natural order of things, to be spontaneous in all actions, understand them and not strive against nature: The sage desires no-desire, Values no-value, Learns no-learning, And returns to the places that people have forgotten (childhood); (Tao-te Ching 64) In order to attain harmony with Tao a combination of the following different methods can be used, according to the different Taoist schools: a special form of physical and spiritual exercises (Thai Chi), alimentary diet, breath control (tai-yin), sexual techniques (fang-shong shu) similar to the Tantric ones, psychedelic drugs, meditation, etc. These methods are considered to revitalize the vital fluid of the body and assure long life. However, Lao Tse taught neither physical immortality nor personal survival after death. There are no clues in the Tao-te Ching indicating such things, so they have to be later additions to Taoism.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (10 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions The seeking of physical immortality seems to have been added to Taoism at the time when it became mixed with alchemy (the search for an “elixir of life”) and religious rituals. It is foreign to the initial spirit of Taoism, which taught indifference to life and death as a condition for one’s integration in the flow of nature. Wang Ch’ung, an important Taoist thinker of the 1st century AD, had to correct the superstitions that invaded his religion, stating clearly that there is no involvement of deities in peoples’ lives and man does not become a ghost at death. The only true spiritual knowledge is the mystical one, attained when any duality is surpassed, when the disciple understands that life and death are only two aspects of the same Ultimate Reality. A famous parable of Chuang Tzu says: Once I, Chuang Tzu, dreamed I was a butterfly, and was happy as a butterfly. I was conscious only of my happiness as a butterfly, unaware that I was Tzu. Soon I awaked, and there I was, veritably myself again. Now I do not know whether I was then a man dreaming I was a butterfly, or whether I am now a butterfly, dreaming I am a man. Between a man and a butterfly there is necessarily a distinction. The transition is called the transformation of things. Therefore, empirical and mystical knowledge are interchangeable. One does not know what reality is: the state as man or as butterfly. The great awakening is a return in the primordial state of non-being, where all transformations cease and personal existence is annihilated: By cultivating one’s nature one will return to virtue. When virtue is perfect, one will be one with the Beginning. Being one with the Beginning, one becomes vacuous, and being vacuous, one becomes great. One will then be united with the sound and breath of things. When one is united with the sound and breath of things, one is then united with the universe. This unity is intimate and seems to be stupid and foolish. This is called profound and secret virtue, this is complete harmony. (Chuang Tzu 12)

Man’s salvation in the monotheistic religions

Unlike the pantheistic religions of the East, the three monotheistic religions of the world - Judaism, Christianity and Islam - do not regard salvation as an impersonal merging with the Absolute, but as liberation from the bondage of sin and re-establishing a personal communion with the Creator. However, there are some basic differences between them on how sin is to be overcome by man, on the identity of Jesus Christ, the role He plays in salvation and what our attitude should be towards Him.

Man’s salvation in Christianity

According to Christianity, sin did not mark an irreconcilable end of God’s relation with man. After stating that all mankind is sinful, the next and final doctrine of the Bible is not the judgment and eternal damnation of man. Although the triune God is perfect in His justice and holiness, implying that sin should have kept man eternally separated from His presence, His love for us is also perfect. Out of this balance of God’s character and attributes, Christianity states a unique doctrine of salvation, completely foreign to any other religion.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (11 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions The remission of sins in the Old Testament vs. religious patterns of other nations

The account of man’s restoration from his fallen state begins in the first book of the Old Testament. God called Abraham to leave his country and his father's household and follow Him to an unknown land, promising that he would become the ancestor of a blessed nation. Abraham trusted God against all odds, and this attitude, called faith, determined that God would declare him righteous and the beneficiary of an overwhelming promise: He took him outside and said, "Look up at the heavens and count the stars-- if indeed you can count them." Then he said to him, "So shall your offspring be." Abraham believed the Lord, and he credited it to him as righteousness (Genesis 15,5-6). The nation born out of Abraham is Israel, God’s chosen people to make Himself known in the midst of nations and correct their wrong patterns in understanding Him. This was meant in a time when mankind turned its back to the real God and sin became man’s “true inner nature”. Although all nations had priests, offerings and temples - showing that communion with God was always man’s greatest need - all ritualism was wrong oriented and needed correction. In the book of Exodus is recorded how God redeemed Israel from the Egyptian bondage through His grace (1-19), presented the law according to which they should live (20-24) and then indicated the way to solve any trespassing of the law, through the tabernacle (25-40), which was later replaced by the Jerusalem temple. This given order redemption-law-temple was not randomly chosen. God instituted the Mosaic Law as a covenant with His people after redeeming the nation. Israel had to obey God and to live according to the demands of the law in order to have a right relation with Him (Exodus 19,5). The tabernacle (and later the temple) was the place where sacrifices were brought in order to solve the trespassing of the law and to keep in mind their total dependence on God. Obedience to the law was of first importance and the sacrifices in the temple were second, prescribed only as solution for repairing the failures in fulfilling God’s demands. The other nations of that time had a different view of worship. They were attempting to satisfy their gods and even fulfill their needs through the religious rituals performed in temples. Following this principle, the nations that surrounded ancient Israel (and many more) had to bring more and more substantial offerings in order to accumulate more and more influence on the gods. Soon they came to perform even human sacrifices. In this way their priests reached a point where they were actually manipulating the gods and considered themselves (through the rituals performed) the keepers of universal order, providers of fertility, wealth, victory over enemies, etc. The tendency to manipulate the gods is obvious in Vedic ritualism and was the cause for its decline. The priests held the ropes of heaven and soon became more important than the gods. After all, it was their sacrifices that kept the universe properly functioning. No wonder that asceticism appeared as a revolt against this order. The temple and the sacrifices in the Old Testament have different meanings from the other religions of that time. In the Old Testament, the condition for maintaining a proper relation with God was obeying and conforming to His revealed standards, not the performance of religious rituals that could empower Him to fulfill His divine attributes. Sacrifices are not necessary for Him, but for the sake of sinful people, as the solution for their trespassing of the law. If not absolved, the sins of the people would have brought God’s punishment on the nation. Therefore, the sacrifice had to perform its work in man, not in God. This is why the tabernacle and the sacrificial system is added to the covenant with Israel (Exodus 20-24), as a further grace. Although Israel also had, as the other nations, a temple, priests and sacrifices, their

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (12 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:42 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions role was different. This perverted way of relating to God had to be corrected through Israel. God commanded: The Lord your God will cut off before you the nations you are about to invade and dispossess. But when you have driven them out and settled in their land, and after they have been destroyed before you, be careful not to be ensnared by inquiring about their gods, saying, "How do these nations serve their gods? We will do the same." You must not worship the Lord your God in their way, because in worshipping their gods, they do all kinds of detestable things the Lord hates. They even burn their sons and daughters in the fire as sacrifices to their gods. See that you do all I command you; do not add to it or take away from it (Deuteronomy 12,29-32). Out of the many sacrifices and religious feasts mentioned in the Old Testament, we will emphasize the significance of the Day of Atonement (Yom Kippur), described in Leviticus chapter 16. It was performed once a year, only by the high priest and for the benefit of all God’s people. Its purpose was to remove all the sins committed during the year and mark the rededication of the nation to God. The high priest had to offer first a bull as an atoning sacrifice for his own sins. Only in this way was he cleansed of his sins and therefore capable of performing the atonement ritual for the nation. Then he took two goats and established one for the Lord and the other as scapegoat. The goat for the Lord was slaughtered and the blood sprinkled on the atonement cover, located in the Most Holy Place of the temple. Under the atonement cover were kept the Ten Commandments carved on stone. As they represented the witness of the high standards of God that were transgressed by the people, the act of the priest symbolized the covering of the transgressions with blood, as ransom price paid for their remission. Then the high priest had to “lay both hands on the head of the live goat and confess over it all the wickedness and rebellion of the Israelites - all their sins - and put them on the goat's head. He shall send the goat away into the desert in the care of a man appointed for the task” (v. 21). This symbolically represented the fact that the sins were carried away from the people, so that their relation with the Holy God could continue. The Israelites thus learned that any trespassing of the Mosaic Law is a sin and any sin demands a specific sacrifice, in order that God, the giver of the law, could forgive the sinner. The principle pointed to the fact that the punishment for sin had to be borne by an innocent animal, as substitute for the sinner. Through the ritual performed by the priest, it was clearly shaped in the mind of any Israelite the fact that his sins are forgiven due to the animal sacrifice, or more specifically, through its blood. The animal became man’s substitute in order to fulfill God’s justice. However, as the Old Testament indicates, the Israelites did transgress the Mosaic Law very often and seriously, especially by worshipping other gods, an act forbidden by the very first command. At the time the prophet Jeremiah lived (627-580 BC), the function of the Temple itself was perverted, and those who came to worship there were condemned for performing empty rituals aimed at gaining God’s goodwill, according to the idolatrous patterns of other religions, without any desire to obey God’s Law (see Jeremiah 7,1-11; 22-23). As a result of this attitude they were punished by the Babylonian captivity. It seemed that all the sacrifices failed to produce a change of attitude in the people’s hearts. A better sacrifice was required to solve the problem of sin once for all, one that should be perfect and unique, and also available for all nations. This is what the New Testament speaks about.

Jesus Christ, the perfect solution for our sins

The Apostle Paul expresses God’s attitude toward sin in very straightforward terms:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (13 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of men who suppress the truth by their wickedness (Romans 1,18). Although God is omnipotent, He could not simply erase all people’s sins by a decree, as some people suggest. He could have thrown us all into hell instead, as He is holy and just and we are all sinners. However, God is perfect not only in power and justice, but also in His love for us. This is why the solution for the problem of sin could not be a simplistic one. His love would not be perfect if not united with His justice, wisdom and power. His wrath toward sin, on the one side, and His love for man and desire to bring him back into communion with Him, on the other side, could have been reconciled only by His initiative, by His power and wisdom. It is important to remember here that Satan is not the one that had to receive satisfaction, as if he became the one in charge of man’s destiny and therefore should have received a reasonable price in order to set him free again, but God Himself. The Apostle Paul makes this point clear in the first chapter of his Letter to the Romans, where he doesn’t even mention Satan. Man came under the dominion of Satan because he deliberately rejected God, but this doesn’t mean that Satan has any rights over man at the moment he wants to return to his rightful master. The New Testament reveals how God took the initiative to solve the problem of sin by using the most dramatic solution ever stated in the world religions: God the Son willingly left His divine glory, took a human body and descended into our world through the virgin birth, limiting Himself into space and time in order to be the perfect and unique sacrifice for us. The Apostle Paul states: Christ Jesus, being in very nature God, did not consider equality with God something to be grasped, but made himself nothing, taking the very nature of a servant, being made in human likeness (Philippians 2,6-7). This “making Himself nothing” performed by God the Son is called in theology “the kenosis of Christ” (lit. = “emptying”). It does not mean a subtraction of deity, but the addition of humanity with its consequent limitations. Although taking a human nature was a real humbling for God the Son, it did not involve the giving up of any divine attributes. The doctrine of the kenosis involves the veiling of His preincarnate glory (John 17,5), taking on Himself the likeness of human sinful flesh (Romans 8,3) and the temporary nonuse of divine attributes during His earthly ministry. The kenosis of Christ was His free will initiative and not a necessity imposed by His nature, as is the case with the periodical incarnations of Vishnu. According to Christianity, Jesus Christ is the only incarnation of God, descended into our world with a unique and non-repeatable mission in history. He is not a mere avatar, a periodical incarnation of a Hindu god, but the unique incarnation of God the Son, become God the Man, perfect in both His divine and human nature. This double nature of Jesus Christ is the key for understanding His mission of reconciling man with God. In Vaishnava Hinduism none of the avatars has a perfect union of the two natures. As they have no historical basis, it is very difficult to speculate on how their divine nature combined with the physical one (animal or human). Due to considering the physical body a mere garment that is put on and off (according to Bhagavad Gita 2,22), there cannot be any real association of god with a physical body. Christ came to redeem the physical body as well, therefore His association with it was real. For the same reason there is so much accent laid on His physical resurrection, which for a Hindu avatar would be completely absurd. Therefore the avatar fits best in the Docetic understanding of Christ (the appearance of a physical body, with no intrinsic value to it), which is considered a classic heresy in Christianity. (For more information on classic Christian heresies click here). The double nature of the incarnated Christ, divine and human, is of fundamental importance for His mission. Here is a fragment of the definition of Chalcedon on this topic:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (14 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions Following, then, the holy fathers, we unite in teaching all men to confess the one and only Son, our Lord Jesus Christ. This selfsame one is perfect both in deity and in humanness; this selfsame one is also actually God and actually man, with a rational soul and a body. He is of the same reality as God as far as his deity is concerned and of the same reality as we ourselves as far as his humanness is concerned; thus like us in all respects, sin only excepted. Before time began he was begotten of the Father, in respect of his deity, and now in these "last days," for us and behalf of our salvation, this selfsame one was born of Mary the virgin, who is God-bearer in respect of his humanness. We also teach that we apprehend this one and only Christ-Son, Lord, only-begotten -- in two natures; and we do this without confusing the two natures, without transmuting one nature into the other, without dividing them into two separate categories, without contrasting them according to area or function. The distinctiveness of each nature is not nullified by the union. Instead, the "properties" of each nature are conserved and both natures concur in one "person" and in one reality . They are not divided or cut into two persons, but are together the one and only and only-begotten Word of God, the Lord Jesus Christ. Thus have the prophets of old testified; thus the Lord Jesus Christ himself taught us; thus the Symbol of Fathers has handed down to us. We do not intend to analyze here some important historical issues of Christianity. Historical and archaeological research have proved that the New Testament is a reliable information source on the life and teachings of Jesus Christ. There are enough reasons to accept that it was not written later than the first century AD. You can use the following links for getting information on this: Dating the Oldest New Testament Manuscripts, by Peter van Minnen; Textual Criticism and Manuscript Interpretation; The Gospels As Historical Sources For Jesus, The Founder Of Christianity, by Prof. R. T. France Now let us turn to the significance of the life and death of Jesus Christ. He always claimed to be divine, having the same nature with the Father. For an analysis of Jesus' sayings concerning His divinity, see the following articles: Jesus' Claims to be God, by Sue Bohlin; Beyond Blind Faith; by Paul Little; The Uniqueness of Jesus, Liar, Lunatic, or Lord?, by Pat Zukeran; The Deity of Christ, by Don Closson; A Response to "From Jesus to Christ", by Rick Wade. The are also other resources available for evaluating the claims that Jesus was a remarkable man who only became a deity in the minds of his followers. The sayings of Jesus concerning His divinity must not be interpreted from a pantheistic point of view, as being valid for anyone. He didn’t preach in India to some pantheist gurus, who believe that everything is a manifestation of Brahman and the spiritual masters are special incarnations of the divine. If He had preached there, surely He would not have been sentenced to death. Therefore, when interpreting His sayings, we have to remember that Jesus Christ came to Israel, to the only monotheistic culture of that time, not to the Far East. Unlike other religions of the world, Judaism clearly stated the notion of a personal and unique God. Anyone daring to claim divine attributes was guilty of blasphemy and had to

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (15 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions be sentenced to death. This means that the formula "Aham Brahma Asmi" ("I am Brahman") and Jesus’ words "I and the Father are one" (John 10,30) have a totally different meaning, because they are addressed to a totally different context. Jesus could not give pantheistic teachings in a strictly monotheistic culture such as the Judaic one. Such a schizophrenic attitude would be the last thing of which He could be accused. On the contrary, He was always extremely explicit, using common language, so that anyone could understand Him. As a result, the claims about His divinity were interpreted as blasphemy by those who refused to see in Him the fulfillment of the Old Testament’s messianic prophecies. Another attempt to find Eastern connotations in the New Testament uses the prologue of John’s Gospel, where it is stated that “the Word was God” (v. 1) and “through Him all things were made” (v. 3). However, this “Word” was neither the sacred syllable AUM, nor the manifestation of Brahman as Ishvara (the Hindu Logos), but the Person of Jesus Christ, who took the initiative to descend into His own creation: “The word became flesh and made His dwelling among us” (John 1,14). Jesus Christ was not the manifestation of an impersonal Ultimate Reality, but the Person of God the Son. This and all other speculations that try to prove the equivalence of His sayings with those of the East ignore the cultural and religious context in which they were taught. The same is true of the hypothesis that He lived in India from the age of 12 until 30. (Click here for more information on this topic.) He never did teach as a Hindu guru, exhorting people to find their “forgotten divine nature”. Because of this, Gnosticism and its writings present a false portrait of Jesus, totally out of His real context. Jesus Christ cannot merely be placed in an equal position with other spiritual leaders of the world because He is God the Son, who came into our world to reconcile us with the Creator. According to the syncretistic trend of our days, Jesus Christ should be considered as one of the great spiritual masters of the world, but not the only Son of God; one to be followed, but not to be worshipped. Gandhi, the great Indian leader, put it like this: "I cannot ascribe exclusive divinity to Jesus. He is as divine as Krishna or Rama or Mohammad or Zoroaster" (M. Gandhi, Christian Missions, Ahmadabad, 1941, p. 113). However, given His identity, Jesus is more than a great teacher; He is the Master of masters and has no equal among them. Even if there are attempts to find some similarities between His life and that of other important religious leaders, they cover only a few aspects of His life. The most striking differences concern His death. Here we reach the turning point of His incarnation: Jesus had to die on the cross for our redemption from sin and reconciliation with God. The Apostle Peter states in his epistle: He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, so that we might die to sins and live for righteousness; by his wounds you have been healed (1 Peter 2,24; see also 1,18-21; 3,18). Jesus Christ as “the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world” (John 1,29), is the cornerstone of Christianity and its non-paralleled element. Toward this fulfillment pointed the sacrifices of the Old Testament (see Hebrews 9,12-14) and the highlights of prophecies. If man had the slightest chance to rehabilitate himself through his own power or wisdom, such an extreme solution would have been absurd. The tragedy of the cross proves the reality and gravity of human sin, the spiritual misery in which we are all stuck and the impossibility of saving ourselves. Mocked and spit upon by the human race, nailed on a cross and forsaken by the Father, Jesus Christ took our place in punishment. The prophet Isaiah wrote about this event about seven centuries before it happened: Surely he took up our infirmities and carried our sorrows, yet we considered him stricken by God, smitten by him, and afflicted. But he was pierced for our transgressions, he was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was upon him, and by his wounds we are healed

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (16 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions (Isaiah 53,4-5). Although man did his best, he couldn’t destroy Him. On the contrary, the most horrible crime ever committed by mankind - the crucifixion of the incarnated God - was reversed to become the very source of our salvation. While dying on the cross, Jesus shouted, “It is finished” (John 19,30). In Greek, the expression used was “Tetelestai”, which means, “the debt was paid in full”. What was meant here is the debt that man deserved to pay for his sins in hell, through eternal torment. By His death, Jesus paid in full the price required for the salvation of mankind from sin. Was the suffering of Christ on the cross a mere illusion? Obviously not! His torment and death were so real that none of those who saw it could expect a future victory over death. This proves the full incarnation of God the Son. He did not die only in physical appearance, as the Docetist heresy suggests, but as a poor miserable man, experiencing suffering in its fullest sense. His death proves both the seriousness of our sin and the unfathomable love of God, as Jesus once proclaimed: For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life (John 3,16). His death on the cross put an end to the sacrificial system of the Old Testament. Jesus Christ is the perfect fulfillment of the Day of Atonement (Yom Kippur). He fulfilled both the role of the goat for the Lord, by the fact that He shed His blood for us, and of the scapegoat, as He took our sins away from the presence of God. However, death and hell had no power over Christ and couldn’t hold Him captive, because He had no sin. The Gospel (“The Good News”) does not end with the crucifixion. If so, Christianity would have been a hopeless religion, bound by the impossibility of conquering suffering and injustice. But Christianity holds a unique element: the morning of the Resurrection. Of what use would have been a special spiritual master if he too, as all others, could not defeat death? What meaning would His teachings and His example have for us? Without His resurrection, the best way to confront suffering would have been Eastern pessimism. Escape from suffering by the destruction of personhood, by the negation of life, would have been the natural result of man’s failure in his combat against evil and suffering. Christianity is not a pessimistic religion, demanding the abolition of life, but an optimistic one, full of affirmation of life, according to the model represented by Jesus Christ. This is emphasized by the fact that the Resurrection was a physical one, in the body, not only in the spirit. According to the Eastern view, the resurrection of the body is absurd, as the liberation of the self cannot be a return to the physical wrapping. A physical resurrection does not solve anything from an Eastern point of view; it only brings man back to his initial unsolved problem. For this reason the resurrection of Jesus is usually understood as a physical resuscitation of His body (as some Yogis can do today), or as a purely spiritual resurrection, a view which holds that the physically resurrected body was only an illusion. Given the cruelty of the crucifixion method, the first possibility is out of the question. Concerning the second, although the resurrected body was a transformed one, it was not an ethereal form, as those produced in spiritualistic manifestations, but one completely liberated from any terrestrial limitation. (Click here for an examination of the Gnostic interpretation of Jesus' mere spiritual and mystical resurrection.) During the 40 days He spent with His disciples after the Resurrection, Jesus appeared to “more than five hundred of the brothers at the same time” (1 Corinthians 15,6), so that people could accept the reality of His bodily resurrection. Despite the fact that there are legends in the mythology of other nations telling stories of other “resurrected saviors” - as Osiris, Attis, Mithra, Adonis, Tammuz, etc. - in comparison with the resurrection of Jesus, they are nothing but non-historical legends. You can use the following links for getting more information about the proofs of Jesus’ resurrection:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (17 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions Contemporary Scholarship and the Historical Evidence for the Resurrection of Jesus Christ, The Bodily Resurrection of Jesus, The Historicity of the Empty Tomb of Jesus, The Disciples' Inspection of the Empty Tomb, by Prof. William Lane Craig Evidence for the Resurrection, by Josh McDowell Not only did Jesus keep His physical body after the Resurrection, but He also ascended “at the right hand of the Father” in this body. The reality of the resurrected body overthrows misconceptions about the illusory state of the physical world and emphasizes the value of life here and now. Only if we are convinced that this earthly life is important can we engage in solving its problems. If the only victory of Jesus over death had been the survival of his spirit, the value of this present physical life would have remained unclear and our interest placed only on the other side of the grave. But Christianity proclaims the victory over death to be won here and now, and this embodied victory gives us hope and strength in our struggle with suffering and sin. It is true that Eastern religions also claim the possibility of attaining liberation during the physical life. There exists the concept of jivan-mukta in Hinduism (the “liberated from rebirth while living in a human body”) and that of arhat in Buddhism. They are said to have pierced the veil of cosmic illusion and realized their true spiritual nature. The difference to be emphasized here is that jivan-mukta despises his body and awaits to get rid of it at physical death, when he will survive in his true spiritual essence - of atman or purusha. True liberation (moksha) is defined against any personal existence and must break any bondage of the physical body. The jivan-mukta has to act in the world completely detached, taking care not to involve himself in any association with the physical world. The resurrection of Jesus contradicts such a perspective, indicating that the created matter has nothing wrong or illusory in itself. The true problem of man is not his involvement in the physical world, rather it is a moral problem called sin, which is a personal attitude toward the Creator. According to Christianity, liberation (salvation) is not deliverance from personal existence, but redemption out of slavery to sin and Satan, into a transformed life of eternal communion with God. By His atoning death, Jesus Christ crushed the power of Satan over us (1 John 3,8) and liberated us from the curse of sin. Another crucial element of Christianity is the fact that Jesus Christ is not one of the many ways to God, but the only way to God, as He claimed Himself: I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me (John 14,6). This statement is very bold, clear and embarrassing for those who try to find other ways to God, ignoring the atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ. However, this does not mean that those who never heard about Christ are damned to spend all their eternity in hell, simply because they had no opportunity to hear about Him. (On this topic see our special file How can those who never heard about Christ be saved?) The Eastern religions are not so exclusive regarding liberation because they are not grounded on such a dramatic solution for our salvation as the one Jesus Christ offers. These religions emphasize the role of one's own efforts in order to reach the Ultimate Reality, by rituals, sacrifices, morality, asceticism, meditation, etc. As most of them cultivate trust only in the efficiency of one's own resources, they reject any possibility of accepting a Savior. The doctrine of karma has a strong contribution to this attitude. The idea of finding liberation through the merits of an external savior cannot be reconciled by any means with karma without contradicting its basic demands. There can be no escape from the consequences of karma by grace, because the personal forms of manifestation of the impersonal Ultimate Reality cannot be above this law. Sins have to be paid for, not forgiven. (See our file on the Parable of the Prodigal Son

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (18 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions in Christianity and Buddhism.) In Christianity, the situation is completely different: Man has no chance to save himself. He cannot ascend by himself from the misery of sin, therefore God the Son had to descend to man’s state and lift him up. Unlike the founders of other religions, Jesus Christ didn’t bring us only wisdom and parables, but also His flesh and blood. This is the major difference, which cannot simply be ignored.

The meaning of salvation in Christianity

According to the Bible, the sacrifice of Jesus Christ is our only chance for returning to a communion relation with our Creator. This solution is the gift of God to mankind, an undeserved gift, called grace in Christian theology. Without God’s grace, no one can deserve salvation on the basis of his own resources. The Apostle Paul wrote: For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith - and this not from yourselves, it is the gift of God - not by works, so that no one can boast (Ephesians 2,8-9). Most Eastern religions refuse this possibility, as they consider that all resources to attain liberation are inherent to human nature. The major spiritual paths for attaining liberation in Hinduism are karma yoga (the way of good deeds and fulfillment of social duties), bhakti yoga (the way of devotion toward a personal deity in order to accumulate merits), raja yoga (the way of controlling the mind, as the ascetic technique of Patanjali requires) and jnana yoga (the way of getting spiritual knowledge). Excepting some developments in bhakti yoga, all are based on human effort and capacity for attaining liberation. In most Eastern religions, man doesn’t need forgiveness, because there is no personal God as Ultimate Reality against whom one could sin. Consequently, sin is mere ignorance, so that the “sinner” needs only help to reason the right way and realize that he is responsible for his actions, for which he must pay the consequences in samsara. If there is no need for forgiveness, the need for grace cannot exist either. Although Mahayana Buddhism accepts the help of the bodhisattva beings, it has no equivalent to the Christian idea of grace. The bodhisattvas help people by bringing them to heavenly realms where they have the privilege to hear the proper doctrine. Only by perseverance on this doctrine can liberation be attained. However, there are also trends that invoke the necessity of grace from a personal god. Remember the theistic schools grounded by Ramanuja and Madhva in India. They stated that grace is an absolute necessity to attain liberation, which represents a remarkable similarity to the Christian view of grace. A similar situation is to be found in Pure Land Buddhism. Although remarkable, these theistic trends have only secondary importance in Eastern religions. The Christian perspective on salvation is that no one can deserve the grace of God by performing rituals, good deeds, asceticism or meditation, because grace is the result of His initiative. However, this does not mean that man has no responsibility and is saved whatever his attitude toward the Savior might be. In order to be forgiven and brought back into a personal relation with God, it is not enough that the grace of God exists, as potential solution. It must be accepted personally by the sinful man. Only then can the atoning death of Christ become an actual solution for one’s sins. The recognition of one’s sinful state, followed by personal acceptance of the atoning sacrifice of Christ as the God-given solution for salvation, is called repentance. The Apostle Peter used this term in his preaching on the Day of Pentecost (Acts 2,38). In that given context, repentance had a wider meaning

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (19 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions than simply regretting the mistakes of the past. We are all sorry for the mistakes we do, but this is not repentance as required in the Bible. When the Holy Spirit descended at Pentecost, repentance meant to be sorry for rejecting Jesus Christ as Savior (see Acts 2,22-37), accompanied by a subsequent change of mentality: If until that moment the Jews considered Jesus to be only a strange guy that pretended to be equal with God, the Scripture describes a total change of that mentality, toward considering him God the Son, incarnated for their salvation. The same change of attitude toward Jesus is required today. He was not a mere man, prophet, guru or something similar, but the Savior of the world, the only “name under heaven given to men by which we must be saved" (Acts 4,12). The “effort” man has to do in order to be saved is to open his heart and receive the free gift of God, through faith. Saving faith means more than to know that God exists and what He says is true. This is a knowledge that even demons believe “and shudder” (James 2,19). Faith requires total trust in God's promises. In the Epistle to the Hebrews faith is defined as “being sure of what we hope for and certain of what we do not see” (11,1). It is the proper human response to God’s initiative, not a mere form of positive thinking. Faith has as object the Person of God, while positive thinking requires trust in oneself. The initiative of God to make Himself known to us, without which we couldn’t know anything about Him by our initiative, is called in theology revelation. It was progressive in the Old Testament and reached its climax in the incarnation of Christ, an undeniable historical event. God’s revelation touched human history, which is why the Christian faith requires trust in a certain line of historical events that culminate with the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus. This historical element confers to the Christian faith enough relevance to be set apart from both positive thinking and the parallel concept in Hinduism, that of shraddha. Hindu “faith” has its origin in Vedic ritualism and meant trust in the efficiency of the ritual, being in fact just a form of positive thinking. (Only in the bhakti movements it came to be oriented toward a god or a guru, but then also mostly as an instrument to accumulate merits.) Christianity is often criticized because its solution to man’s present condition is too simple. “How could it be possible to attain salvation only by the merits of Christ?”; “How could one receive it without hard perseverance, through asceticism and meditation?”; etc. Although man’s desire to do something for his salvation seems to be justified, under this attitude stays hidden an offended pride. In order to accept God’s free gift in Christ, man has to constantly admit his failure to attain salvation by himself. This situation conflicts sharply with his tendency toward self-justification, with his pride. On the other hand, pride is a bad product of personhood, and we therefore meet another paradox: The follower of Eastern spirituality refuses the grace of God as a result of his pride, an attitude he should have eradicated from his life, according to his own Eastern religious teaching. Paradoxically, he seeks to destroy his personhood, rather than a bad attachment of it (pride). This raises important questions about the Eastern religion’s consistency within itself. As man finds it so hard to give up his pride, preferring to attain salvation by his own efforts, even if it would take several lives, we could ask: Which of the two alternatives is harder to follow: the one which requires abandonment of self-justifying pride or the one of personal hard striving? If Christianity is such a simple way, why is it refused by so many? Is it not really harder to constantly defeat your pride and consider yourself powerless before God, than to continue your asceticism? Looking for an answer in human nature, corrupted by sin and full of rebellion against God, the answer is obviously positive. This means that Christianity isn’t at all a “simple” alternative, as it demands us to abandon the very thing we love most: our pride, the tendency to prove our independence from God. God wishes that all people should accept His gift of salvation (see 1 Timothy 2,4; 2 Peter 3,9), but

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (20 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions without forcing anybody to do it. Jesus Christ says: I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in and eat with him, and he with me (Revelation 3,20). The responsibility for “opening the door” belongs to each of us, without exception. However, the one who continues to ignore Christ in this life will after death spend the rest of his eternal existence behind the closed door. Christianity does not proclaim universalism, the doctrine of universal salvation of all souls, regardless of their spiritual option during this earthly life. Universalism is rather a characteristic of Eastern religions, but not as a result of divine love, but rather of the necessity imposed by the cyclic manifestations of the Ultimate Reality. Nor does Christianity support the idea of some people being predestined to hell while others to paradise. Being chosen in the Bible has to do with God's sovereign will in choosing some people for a special ministry, for instance the prophets in the Old Testament and Jesus’ apostles in the New Testament. But this has nothing to do with others being rejected from attaining salvation. In other words, one's salvation does not depend on if he is chosen or not for a certain ministry appointed by God. It is possible that even chosen people may end in eternal damnation. For instance, Balaam among the prophets (Numbers 22-24) and Judas among the apostles were both chosen for a special ministry, but because of their disobedience were rejected from salvation. Therefore it depends solely on humans, on how they respond to God's grace, to be saved. It is hard to imagine a loving God who chooses to enter our world and die on a cross, who could randomly choose some people and reject others. Christianity proclaims man’s free will and responsibility toward God. Spiritual freedom is the real possibility offered to man to choose one out of two eternal destinations, heaven or hell. A third option, that of absolute independence, is impossible, as Jesus Christ himself stated: “He who is not with me is against me, and he who does not gather with me scatters” (Matthew 12,30). On the other hand, in the Eastern religions, karma discredits any notion of individual freedom. The only “freedom” left to man is the possibility to give a detached sense to his predetermined actions (see Bhagavad Gita 18,59-60). In other words, the only freedom left is that of “choosing” the predetermined destiny stated by karma, which means resignation to fate. Not having available (at least) two possible destinations to express a real choice (God or Satan), but only one (the unique impersonal Ultimate Reality), a real freedom of will cannot be defined. Whatever man chooses, finally he has to return to the impersonal origin of all existence. Refusing karma and reincarnation, the Christian point of view states that we live only once in this physical world, and then follows the judgment of God (Hebrews 9,27). (For more information on reincarnation and its relation to Christian theology click here.) After death man either enters into a close and eternal communion with God, or into a state of total isolation from Him, according to the option chosen during this earthly existence. Although the second possibility is frightening (and because of this some people accuse God of being cruel), He doesn’t allow it without first offering us as solution the free gift of salvation through the atoning death of Jesus Christ. Nothing can save us from this unwanted destiny except Him. Instead of calling Him cruel, we should remember that God the Son was so deeply concerned with mankind that He entered space and time, took a human body and died on a cross as our substitute. What more do we expect from God as proof of His love and concern for us? In order to accept His sacrifice, one life is enough. The Christian solution is much better than those of the East, which leave man alone in his endless struggle with karma.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (21 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions On the other hand, if God would not isolate evil, if He would accept in His eternal presence those who do not want it, He wouldn’t be just. If someone persists in his rebellion toward Him, manifested through indifference or desire for independence, God does not force him to enter into the kingdom of heaven, where this man should worship Him against his will. This would be an abuse against man’s freedom. Hell is the result of man's choice to be independent from God and reject His offer. There is nothing unfair or cruel in God’s withdrawing any intervention from this alternative existence. The fact that hell is an eternal torment (according to Matthew 25,41,46) cannot be called a cruelty on God’s part. Those who will be there will know why, without questioning divine justice (see the parable of Lazarus in Luke 16,19-31). (Click here for some comments of the Early Church Fathers on hell and eternal punishment.) In conclusion, it has to be remembered that according to Christianity, the eternal destiny of man is not the annihilation of soul and personhood, but a state of perfect and eternal communion with God. Belief in the survival of personhood after death is not an illusion but is grounded on the creation of man as a person, on the promises of the Bible and the resurrection of Christ. God does not intend to annihilate our personhood in order that we might discover an impersonal hidden nature, but to annihilate sin and its products which compromise His image in us. Therefore, the highest experience human beings could have is not merging with an impersonal Ultimate Reality but entering into a perfect communion of reciprocal love with God our Creator.

Man’s salvation in Islam Unlike Christianity, Islam teaches salvation by works, not by faith. Although all people are sinners (Quran 16,61), salvation can be attained through observing the Five Pillars of Islamic practice: 1) the belief that Allah is the only god and Muhammad his messenger; 2) performing the five daily prayers; 3) fasting throughout the month of Ramadan; 4) charity, giving to the poor; 5) the pilgrimage to Mecca at least once in a lifetime, if one can afford it. By performing these works, the Muslim hopes that at the judgment day his good deeds will exceed the bad ones, and so he will reach the paradise of material and sensual delights (56,16-41). Yet, despite all deeds, Allah reserves the absolute right to send the deceased to wherever he pleases, paradise or hell. Those who do not conform their lives to the demands of Islam will surely be thrown into hell, a place of extreme physical pain (56,42-45; 94-95). Christianity is not the only religion that claims to be the only valid way to God. Islam states the same: “Whoever seeks a religion other than Islam, it will never be accepted from him and in the hereafter he will be one of the losers” (3,85). Jews and Christians are all said to be misled by their religions (9,30-31), because they reject Muhammad as the most important prophet of God. Jesus Christ has a totally different character in the Quran than in the Bible. It is said that he was created out of clay, like Adam (3,60), that he was not God (5,17-72), not crucified (4,157-158) and that he announced the coming of Muhammad (61,6). There are some useful sites we invite you to visit in order to get more information on a comparison between Islam and Christianity:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (22 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions The Person of Christ in the Gospel and the Quran, by Abd al-Fadi Sin and Atonement in Islam and Christianity, by Iskander Jadeed The Cross in the Gospel and the Qur’an, by Iskander Jadeed Christ in Islam and Christianity, by John Gilchrist A Question that Demands an Answer, by Abd al-Masih The Textual History of the Qur’an and the Bible, by John Gilchrist Six Muslim Beliefs and a Christian Response, by Jay Smith The Bible and the Qur’an, An Historical Comparison

Conclusion

Considering all these views on salvation and man’s eternal destiny, it is hard to believe that they could ever be reconciled. The world’s religions hold rather irreconcilable positions in all of the three aspects mentioned in the beginning of this file: the nature of the resources needed for attaining salvation, the actual way of getting saved and the meaning of salvation from an eternal perspective. The resources for attaining salvation belong strictly to our human nature according to most of the Eastern religions, excepting some schools of devotional Hinduism and Buddhism. Man needs only to know the right things in order to be saved, having the ability to pursue the religious path by his own strength. Christianity holds the opposite view, stating that our “true inner nature” is sin and therefore all our efforts aimed to earn God’s favor are useless. Based on the resources human nature has, the actual way of getting saved will take two divergent possibilities. Religions that claim we have all the resources in ourselves for attaining salvation naturally stress personal effort, materialized as good deeds, devotional rituals, meditation techniques, physical asceticism, accumulating wisdom, etc. This is the case with most religions in the world. While pantheistic religions stress certain meditation and ascetic techniques aimed at discovering man’s inner nature, most theistic religions demand good deeds and devotional rituals in order to earn God’s grace and therefore deserve heaven. The situation in Christianity is again opposite, stating that we cannot do anything to deserve salvation and eternal communion with God, but only to accept His grace revealed in Jesus Christ. By no means can man have God indebted to him. Only God can save man, at His initiative. Therefore the course of action in salvation has an opposite sense in Christianity vs. most other religions. It is God who takes the initiative and descends into His own creation in order to save man, not man accumulating merits and working out his way toward God, by his own strength. Concerning the meaning of salvation from an eternal perspective, the views are again irreconcilable. In the pantheistic religions salvation means liberation from ignorance and corresponds to the fusion of the impersonal self with the Absolute, implying dissolution of subject and object, knower and known. Others, such as Buddhism and Taoism, take salvation as an illumination, meaning a discovery of and conformity of oneself with an eternal law that governs existence. For most Eastern religions liberation leads to extinction of any personal existence, whether the self remains eternally isolated (according to the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas), merges with the Ultimate Reality (in pantheism), or is itself an illusion that ceases to exist (in Buddhism). Dualistic religions see man’s salvation as a return to an initial angelic

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (23 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Man's salvation and eternal destiny in world religions state, from which he has fallen into a physical body. The monotheistic religions define salvation as entering a state of eternal communion with God, which means that personhood will not be abrogated but perfected. However, they differ greatly on the way man can be saved and on the role Jesus Christ has in it. According to Judaism and Islam, salvation is attained by performing good deeds and following the moral law. According to Christianity this is not enough and the role of Jesus Christ as Savior is essential. Given these facts, it is impossible that the world’s religions could be only aspects of the same true spirituality, as present day syncretism suggests. The contradictions between them are so significant that there can be no way to reconcile them.

Next article: The nature of evil

http://www.comparativereligion.com/salvation.html (24 of 24) [10/27/2000 9:47:43 AM] Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies

Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies

We will now proceed to evaluate how the first three criteria mentioned in the previous file are fulfilled by a pantheistic view of life. The classic example of pantheist philosophy was stated by the Upanishads (7th to 5th century BC) and then developed by the Hindu philosopher Shankara to become the well-known Advaita Vedanta philosophy.

1) Internal consistency of Hindu pantheism

As mentioned in a previous file on the Vedantic view on liberation, it is claimed that the unity atman-Brahman is perfectly attained during the last level of meditation, called turiya. The Mandukya Upanishad (12), considered by Shankara to express the quintessence of Vedanta philosophy, ends with the following verse: The fourth state has cognizance of neither what is inside nor what is outside, nor of both together: it is not a mass of wisdom, it is not wise nor yet unwise. It is unseen; there can be no commerce with it; it is impalpable, has no characteristics, unthinkable; it cannot be designated. Its essence is its firm conviction of the oneness of itself; it causes the phenomenal world to cease; it is tranquil and mild, devoid of duality. Such do they consider this fourth to be. He is the Self; he it is who should be known. (Translated by R.C. Zaehner, in Mysticism - Sacred and Profane, p. 154) This passage emphasizes the necessity for transcending any duality in order to know Brahman (the Self). However, there is a logical contradiction between these two elements. When transcending any duality, nothing can be known anymore, because the elementary duality between knower (subject) and known (object) is obliterated. Duality is essential for any type of epistemological process. When the subject is atman and the object Brahman, no normal knowledge can be involved, because atman and Brahman are one. The point here is that Ultimate Reality cannot be known in a pantheist religion. Man cannot know something with which he has to impersonally merge. Although the Hindu Vedanta claims that Brahman is known at the moment of liberation, this has no logical basis. (The laws of logic are the result of our dual thinking, which makes differences and operates with them, so logic itself does not work in a system where any duality is excluded.) S. Radhakrishnan defines liberation as “the highest experience where all intellectual activity is transcended and even self-consciousness is obliterated” (Indian Philosophy, vol. II,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/pantheism.html (1 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:49 AM] Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies p. 640). But who actually has this experience? Who can confirm that liberation is the highest point of one’s existence, if personhood ceases to exist? An impersonal atman, that is beyond any duality? If any personal attribute is lost, there is nothing left to describe the liberation experience. As a result, the "knowledge of atman-Brahman identity" cannot be considered a real epistemological process. S. Radhakrishnan states: “As the distinction between the highest self and the individual is one of false knowledge, we get rid of it by true knowledge.” (Ibid., p. 622). This “true knowledge” corresponds to experiencing a pantheistic perspective on reality. Therefore, a better term that replaces the concept of knowing, is that of experiencing unity with Ultimate Reality, through certain meditation techniques. Meditation is a way of transcending duality through entering altered states of consciousness, or, in other words, a way of deliberately perverting one’s natural cognitive faculties (senses and mind). It doesn’t represent an actual process of knowing, but rather a way of imposing a non-dual reality to one’s consciousness. Terms such as “direct knowledge of truth” represent the actual experiences one has in meditation. In order to find out more about the veracity of these experiences, click here. On the other hand, in this given context, when there are no real distinctions between atman and Brahman, it is not the individual knower who has the cognitive experience, but only Brahman. If the cognitive experience belongs not to man but to Brahman, not even one’s own experience (called “true knowledge”) can really be a valid way of knowing Brahman, because Brahman can only know himself. We reached this strange conclusion as a result of both denying the importance of man’s personal status distinct from Ultimate Reality, and considering real only that which is one with Brahman. In conclusion, the pantheistic premise of oneness generates internal inconsistencies in the system (or at least an incoherent epistemology).

2) The requirement for harmony between empirical and absolute knowledge in Hindu pantheism

Not only knowing Ultimate Reality is impossible in a pantheist system, but also balancing empirical and absolute knowledge. This consequent difficulty results from the doctrine of world-illusion (maya), according to which the phenomenal world is ultimately illusory. Therefore, the senses, through which we interact with the phenomenal world, as well as mind, which operates with this data, are considered to provide illusory and confusing information when trying to grasp spiritual reality. They perpetuate man’s ignorance (avidya) of the true reality, which is Brahman, and therefore feed karma. The problem with this way of interpreting empirical knowledge is that we can consider it illusory only by using an objective standard as reference. As long as the knower is inside the system, bound to its illusion, he cannot know what is wrong with his empirical way of knowing. In other words, in a closed system where illusion works as a rule, we can prove that empirical knowledge is true or false only by comparing it to an absolute standard, which must not belong to the same system. Without this epistemological basis we cannot make objective judgments on reality. What could be the standard for establishing the illusory value of empirical knowledge? If it is a god, a being external to our system and able to communicate with humans, we arrive at what is called revelation in a theistic system. In this situation, which represents a totally different religious perspective, we should accept duality and intelligible communication inside a dualistic system, but this obviously cannot be the case. If the required standard were an internal one, such as experience (the effect of living out “reality” in one’s personal life, or experiencing life as suffering), we arrive at another contradiction of an epistemological nature: If we knew from experience that

http://www.comparativereligion.com/pantheism.html (2 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:49 AM] Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies phenomenological knowledge is false, then no room would be left for reaching “absolute knowledge” because it is always introduced and mediated by empirical, or first hand, experience. In other words, as long as all information we get about spiritual reality is mediated by our senses (sight and hearing) and mind, and these have ultimately illusory value, how can we know that the pantheist perspective itself is not a deceptive illusion? (We learn about it primarily by using the same empirical knowledge, which is false, so it should be rejected.) Because of the impossibility of harmonizing absolute and empirical knowledge, a supplementary difficulty arises in discerning between what is real and what is not. A pantheist can reach the same existential doubt as Chuang Tzu, and say “I do not know whether I was then a man dreaming I was a butterfly, or whether I am now a butterfly, dreaming I am a man”. Although this may seem to be too speculative, there are enough people practicing Eastern meditation who have real problems in discerning between what belongs to real life and what (really) is illusion. From an ontological point of view, it is impossible to state a logical balance between absolute reality and worldly illusion. In Advaita Vedanta the option was to consider the world either an illusion (maya), or a result of ignorance (avidya). But as illusion and ignorance belong themselves to the phenomenal reality, one cannot explain its existence in regard to absolute truth.

3) The viability of Hindu pantheism

Let us now examine the meaning of human life in a pantheist view of reality, and understand to what extent it can work at personal and social level. As long as atman, the core entity that defines human existence, has an impersonal nature, personhood is a hindrance to attaining liberation and, consequently, has to be abolished. This is a logical necessity given by the fact that all forms of Brahman’s manifestation (including man) have to return to the primordial state of non-manifestation at the end of each cosmic cycle. The oblivion of personhood does not refer only to some of its products, such as egoism, but to the very existence of the psycho-mental faculties which define it - intellect, will, emotions, consciousness, communion, etc. All these are said to belong to the inferior ego, totally distinct from the self (atman). Between them no possible relation can exist. However, it is only personhood that makes us distinct humans and confers personal identity, not the impersonal atman devoid of any attributes. Therefore, it is hard to accept that liberation from personhood and merging with an impersonal Absolute (according to the model of the raindrop that falls into the ocean and becomes one with it) could represent any form of spiritual fulfillment or progression. The extinction of self-consciousness and entering a state of “absolute silence” is rather a terrible perspective on human destiny. Such a frightening end should raise serious doubts to those who become adherents of pantheist religions. Therefore it is not surprising that discussing the meaning and consequences of liberation is constantly avoided by turning the adherents’ attention to the practice of meditation and the experiences which accompany it. But no matter how convincing such experiences could be, they end in a tragic kind of liberation, which does not correspond to our personal status. As personal beings, we tend to attain personal fulfillment in the afterlife. The result of rejecting personhood is that some important human values are thoroughly affected. We will briefly examine some aspects concerning freedom, morality, social involvement and compassion, trying to understand their actual meaning in pantheism.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/pantheism.html (3 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:49 AM] Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies The first of them, freedom, is discredited by the doctrine of karma. As the self is forced to enter a new material existence until all karmic debt is paid, man’s present life is shaped according to the dictates of karma. Whatever man chooses to do, finally he has to return to the impersonal origin of all existence. Therefore, for the one searching for liberation, the only freedom left is that of avoiding being trapped in new attachments (by the use of his free will) and submitting to fate. According to the pantheist view, real freedom is experienced only at liberation. But this means liberation out of personhood, not becoming a free person. Pantheism does not view freedom as being free to make your own choices but as liberation from karma, and, as a result, from personal existence. However, the kind of freedom one experiences at the moment of liberation cannot be called real freedom, because when the self gets merged with Brahman, there is no conscious agent left to experience it. Second, consequent pantheist teaching does not offer a solid ground for morality. As emphasized in a previous file reincarnation is not a good stimulant for moral living. From an ontological point of view, if all things are manifestations of the same unique essence, good and evil are relative and therefore a real distinction between them cannot be stated, nor a sound motivation for ethical action. (It would be useful here to review our file on The nature of evil in Eastern religions.) S. Radhakrishnan states: The moral world, which assumes the isolation and independence of its members, belongs to the world of appearances. <...> So long as we occupy the standpoint of individualistic moralism, we are in the world of samsara, with its hazards and hardships. <...> The end of morality is to lift oneself up above one’s individuality and become one with the impersonal spirit of the universe (Indian Philosophy, vol. II, p. 625-26). But who could live consistently with the conviction that moral values are ultimately illusory? In fact, it is that old-fashioned “individualistic moralism” that holds our society in balance. Actually, pantheism does not demand immorality, but amorality, which represents indifference to well-established moral values. However, in everyday life the adherents of pantheism do not reject morality, but consider it important only for the inferior stages of one’s quest toward liberation. In other words, morality is necessary at first, but then becomes a hindrance in attaining liberation by the attachments it produces. But this is nothing but another inconsistency of pantheism. How could one pursue a moral conduct if convinced that all good or bad things ultimately belong to the world of illusion? Third, social involvement of the individual person is not encouraged by a pantheist view of life. In order to attain liberation, one should abandon social life because its basis is the illusory world of duality, which produces attachments. This is a hindrance toward realizing the truth of non-duality and should be avoided. One possible solution would be that only those who have already attained liberation (jivan mukta) can participate in social life, as they have gone beyond dualism and therefore cannot accumulate karma anymore. A second possible solution is suggested in the Bhagavad Gita (selfless action as karma yoga), and will be discussed in another file. A third possible solution for social involvement is proposed by the Upanishadic tradition of the four ashramas, which holds that withdrawing from social life should occur only at a certain age. According to it, a man should first be a young disciple, then have a family, and only when his children are big enough to support themselves is he allowed to leave them and society. However, this solution is not followed today. (Which guru asks his disciples to first establish a family, raise their children until they become independent, and only then dedicate their life to the quest for liberation?) Even if it were followed, it is doubtful that one could truly get himself involved in family affairs, knowing that all attachments are illusory and produce bad karma.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/pantheism.html (4 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:49 AM] Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies Fourth, there is a strange way of understanding compassion in pantheism. Compassion is not recommended as being intrinsically good for the sake of the other persons in need, as in theistic religions, but as an efficient instrument for liberating one’s own mind of the erroneous idea of individual personality. Man cannot be helped as an individual, because it is individuality (non-integration into oneness) which is the source of his problems. Compassion is therapeutically good for the one who performs it, and does not primarily aim to improve the condition of the person in need. In other words, compassion (as well as morality) may be considered useful only as an aid for oneself’s journey towards knowledge and union with the impersonal Absolute. Otherwise it may conflict with the manifestation of karma in the life of the one who is suffering (and needs compassionate help), which would be bad for him and bad for the “compassionate” helper.

Similar criticism is valid for other pantheist religious schools

The same comments can be addressed to other pantheist religious schools such as Tantrism, Hatha Yoga and Tibetan Buddhism. In Tantrism and Hatha Yoga, instead of the Brahman-atman impersonal fusion, we have that of Shiva-Shakti (Shakti being represented in man as the kundalini spiritual energy). In Tibetan Buddhism it is consciousness that merges with the impersonal essence of the world (shunya). The epistemological inconsistencies (see the first two criteria) are the same as in Vedanta. The viability of these schools face similar problems. Difficulties concerning morality arise especially in Tantrism of the left-hand school, where liberation is experienced through sexual union. In order to symbolize and overcome the duality Shiva-Shakti, man assumes the role of Shiva and the woman that of Shakti. The preliminary ritual requirements break many traditional taboos, by consuming fish, meat and wine. Although all elements need to be interpreted at a purely spiritual level, there are many cases (especially in the West) in which so-called Tantric procedures become pretexts for abandoning oneself to lustful instincts and embracing the less spiritual path of today’s “total sexual freedom”.

Scientific pantheism

Attempts are made today to ground a so-called scientific pantheist view of life, which should get rid of all the embarrassing religious stuff and be accepted by the scientific community. Developments toward this new ideology were encouraged by the latest discoveries in science, especially in the field of quantum physics. Research on elementary particles revealed that an equivalence between matter and energy can be stated, according to Einstein’s principle, E=mc2. Therefore it can be considered that any aspect of our material universe is a manifestation of energy. This was believed to confirm the fact that there is a unique reality at the basis of our universe corresponding to Brahman, the impersonal Ultimate Reality of Hindu Vedanta. In other words, as religious pantheism holds that our world is a manifestation of Brahman, in a similar way the so-called scientific pantheism states that energy is the source of any given aspect of the universe. Consequently, “scientific pantheism” replaces Brahman with energy. This new "religion" claims to reconcile traditional religion and science. It is stated that “it requires no faith other than common sense, no guru other than yourself” and also that it accepts “all evidence that is either a matter of common experience, or that is scientifically validated”. Because of its “scientific” orientation, it rejects even the basic tenets of traditional pantheism, such as reincarnation and any form of afterlife. According to the new way of understanding afterlife, “mind is an aspect of the body, and at

http://www.comparativereligion.com/pantheism.html (5 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:49 AM] Critical considerations regarding pantheist religions and philosophies death dissolves with the body to merge into the elements from which it was formed”. Instead of worshipping any god, scientific pantheism worships nature, which is not at all considered to be illusory. However, the problem with “scientific pantheism” is that being so “scientifically” oriented, it isn’t at all a religion, but only a new form of atheism. It is a new form of rejecting anything that passes human understanding, a trend that isn’t new at all in mankind’s history. “Scientific pantheism” and scientific atheism are synonyms, nothing but forms of rejecting traditional religions, and therefore have nothing to do with the goal of this site.

Conclusion

Pantheism states that Ultimate Reality has an impersonal nature. It can be known only by merging with it and thus by abolishing personhood. However, this can have no cognitive meaning. It is also impossible to state a logical balance between absolute reality and empirical experience. From a pragmatic point of view, as long as we cannot live consistently with rejecting the reality of the phenomenal world and aiming toward the annihilation of personhood, as long as we cannot live amorally and reject social involvement, pantheism cannot provide a viable way of living. It is contrary to reason, personhood, common sense and society. Anything we do in this world is based on the premise that distinctions are real, and therefore knowledge is possible, moral values are necessary, as well as social involvement. Abandoning these values would not lead us to a direct experience of Ultimate Reality, but rather toward spiritual schizophrenia.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/pantheism.html (6 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:47:49 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence

Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence

In the previous files we dealt with the metaphysical basis of some important Eastern religions, the way they define Ultimate Reality, man’s conditions and the meaning of liberation. As it is usually taught that one cannot grasp the meaning of these important issues without getting involved in practicing the actual path toward liberation, we will now analyze the famous discipline of Yoga and understand to what extent it could be the answer to one's quest toward transcendence. The origin of Yoga as ascetic discipline is probably found in the ascetic practices of a religious group called the Vratyas in the Atharva Veda (XV). They are the first mentioned to practice the control of breathing and some sexual rituals, with the goal of attaining ecstatic trance states. The term “yoga” has its root in the Sanskrit word yuj, which means “to yoke”. In its present meaning, this term was first used in the Taittirya and Katha Upanishads (around the 5th century B.C). In the second, the god of death (Yama) explains to a young disciple how to attain the perfect knowledge of Brahman and thus merge with it, through restraining the senses and concentration. The parable of the chariot states:

Know the self (atman) as the lord of the chariot and the body as, verily, the chariot, know the intellect as the charioteer and the mind as, verily, the reins. The senses are the horses; the objects of sense the paths; the self associated with the body, the senses and the mind - wise men declare - is the enjoyer. He who has no understanding, whose mind is always unrestrained, his senses are out of control, as wicked horses are for a charioteer. He, however, who has understanding, whose mind is always restrained, his senses are under control, as good horses are for a charioteer (Katha Up. 1,3,3-6). The lord of the chariot (the self) is silently enduring the foolishness of the charioteer (the mind) and the madness of the horses (the senses). Yoga is here defined as the method through which the mind (the charioteer) can bridle the wicked senses, in order that the self may get off the body and be united with Brahman: “This, they consider to be Yoga, the steady control of the senses” (Katha Up. 2,3,11). There are two major meanings for Yoga in Hindu spirituality. The first designates the specific darshana organized by Patanjali, while the second has a broader sense, implying any effort undertaken in order to attain liberation, independent of its meaning. Therefore, any spiritual discipline aimed at liberating the self can be called Yoga. As a result, the term is used with various meanings, having more or less in

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (1 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence common with the Yoga darshana of Patanjali. For instance, Mantra Yoga is the method that consists of using mantras in order to attain liberation (as in Transcendental Meditation). Kundalini Yoga follows a Tantric view, stressing the awakening of kundalini and its final reunion with Shiva. The same goal is to be pursued in Hatha Yoga, but following a strict physical discipline. Jnana Yoga follows a Vedantic ideology, aiming to find liberation mostly by one's effort to achieve a monistic view of reality, laying less emphasis on physical effort. Karma Yoga refers to a specific mindset that has to be followed in social life, i.e. the demand to act completely detached from personal interests and desires, which may complicate one’s karma. This trend was best stated in the Bhagavad Gita and will be analyzed in another file. Bhakti Yoga is the name given to the large variety of devotional practices of Hindu theism, aimed at pleasing a god and earning eternal abode in his realm. In this file we will refer to the Yoga technique as organized by Patanjali, usually called Raja Yoga (“the royal Yoga”), and also to the Hatha Yoga school. Few elements will be mentioned about the metaphysical differences between them, as this topic was already discussed in previous files.

Brief description of the Raja Yoga path toward liberation

In the period of the late Upanishads (Yogatattva, Dhyanabindu, Nadabindu and some other 15 composed after the 5th century BC), the tendency appeared to consider that spiritual liberation cannot be attained exclusively by the means of contemplation but has to be accomplished experimentally, by following a certain ascetic technique. The Shvetashvatara Up. (2,8-15) had already described some instructions for body postures, breathing control and focusing the mind exercises for being able to perceive Brahman. In grounding the new Yoga darshana, Patanjali used the technical elements brought by these Upanishads and used them as a tool for achieving the goal of the Samkhya metaphysics, the liberation of purusha from the bondage of prakriti. The Raja Yoga of Patanjali is properly described in his treatise called Yoga Sutra. The purpose of Yoga is clearly stated from its very beginning (1,2): “the inhibition of the modifications of the mind” (citta vritti nirodhah). The normal states of consciousness are the product of ignorance (avidya), which generates the sense duality and separatedness from others (asmita) and the will to live (abhinivesha). The continuous flux of thoughts and mental representations induced by such a mindset is called a sum of "modifications of the mind”. They perpetuate ignorance and the captivity of purusha in the world of prakriti’s manifestations. In order that liberation may be attained it is necessary that empirical consciousness be extinguished and replaced by a different state of consciousness, in which the experience gained through senses and mind (produced by prakriti) is replaced by extra-sensory and extra-rational experience. The above mentioned “modifications of the mind” are produced not only through interacting with the phenomenal world, but also by a category of latent tendencies present in our subconscious mind called vasanas. They are considered to be conglomerate results of subconscious impressions (samskaras) created in previous lives through ignorant experience. During the present life they tend to manifest in the mental realm, being a further obstacle in attaining liberation. Therefore, the control of the mental states as required in Yoga has a double focus: Both the external illusion (the false identification of purusha with the psycho-mental fluctuations) and the internal source

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (2 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence of illusion produced by the vasanas have to be conquered and burned. The Yoga technique shows the practical way in which the entire human potential, both physical and psycho-mental, is brought under control (“yoked”) in order to attain the liberation of purusha. According to Patanjali (Y.S. 2,29), there are eight steps to be followed, a reason for which the method is also called Ashtanga Yoga (the Yoga of the eight limbs): 1. Restraints (yama) 2. Observances (niyama) 3. Postures (asanas) 4. Breath control (pranayama) 5. Withdrawal of the senses (pratyahara) 6. Concentration (dharana) 7. Contemplation (dhyana) 8. Enstasis (samadhi) Here is a brief description of what each of them involves: 1) The restraints (Y.S. 2,30) are five important moral rules that the Yogi has to observe: ● non-violence (ahimsa) - abstinence from harming any living creature; ● truthfulness (satya) - concordance between speech, deeds and thoughts; ● honesty (asteya) - nonstealing; ● continence (brahmacarya) - controlling lustful desires; ● non-acceptance of gifts (aparigraha) - refusing attachments to any material goods.

2) The observances (Y.S. 2,32) are also five physical and psychical disciplines: ● purity (shaucha) - avoiding impurity in body and mind; ● contentment (samtosha) - seeking joy and serenity, independent of life’s sorrows; ● austerity (tapas) - accepting any extreme condition in life; ● scriptural study (svadhyaya); ● concentration on Ishvara (Ishvara-pranidhana) - imitating Ishvara's way of being. This is not devotion toward Ishvara, because he is nothing more than an impersonal macro-purusha (Y.S. 1,24), and there cannot exist any personal relation between him and man.

3) Practicing the postures (Y.S. 2,46) is the first stage of physical asceticism. Its aim is to immobilize the body, bring it under control and refuse movement, with the only goal of helping concentration. Therefore, the purpose of performing asanas is not (as often believed in the West) to confer harmony and health to the body, provide relaxation, etc, but to be a physical support for concentration.

4) Breath control (Y.S. 2, 49-51) means the refusal of breath, following the refusal of movement by performing the asanas. It is believed that just as psycho-mental tension affects the rhythm of breath, likewise the action of stilling the breath can contribute to stilling the “modification of the mind”. Therefore, pranayama is an important instrument in attaining a perfect state of concentration.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (3 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence However, pranayama has a deeper meaning than just controlling breath. It rather represents the control of prana flow through the human body, which is the energy that controls any possible process or movement. Vivekananda defined it as following: It is the Prana that is manifesting as motion; it is the Prana that is manifesting as gravitation, as magnetism. It is the Prana that is manifesting as the actions of the body, as the nerve currents, as thought force. From thought down to the lowest force, everything is but the manifestation of Prana. The sum total of all forces in the universe, mental or physical, when resolved back to their original state, is called Prana (Vivekananda, The Complete Works, 1931, p. 148). As psycho-mental activity is itself generated by prana, and breathing is the main channel for prana’s influx into the body, it has to be strictly controlled in order to attain control over the mind. In the Hatha Yoga practice, which has strict observances for controlling breath, the reducing of prana influx is realized by progressively retarding the rhythm of breathing. One begins with an inhalation/exhalation ratio of 1/2, then a retention of the inhaled air is introduced in between, attaining a ratio inhalation/retention/exhalation (puraka/kumbhaka/rechaka) of 1/2/2, which in the advanced practitioners becomes 1/4/2. The total amount of time for a breathing cycle can therefore attain several minutes. Theos Bernard, the author of a famous book on Hatha Yoga (Hatha Yoga, Rider & Co., London, 1982), mentions that “until the breath suspension (kumbhaka) had been developed to at least three minutes nothing of any significance could be done” (p. 89). 5) The withdrawal of the senses (Y.S. 2,54-55) is the result one achieves through the previous stages of physical asceticism. At this stage the senses do not disturb the mind anymore, so it becomes shut down against all impressions from outside. Therefore the battle for stilling the mind is easier to win. 6) Concentration is defined by Patanjali as “confining the mind within a limited mental area” (Y.S. 3,1). It is not a simple exercise of attention control, but a way of slowing down mental activity by focusing it on a particular spot, i.e. on a particular object of meditation. 7) Contemplation is an “uninterrupted flow of the mind towards the object of meditation” (Y.S. 3,2). In this stage meditation is undisturbed and the object of meditation assimilated and penetrated to its utmost level. 8) Enstasis (Y.S. 3,3) is attained when the sense of self-identity is lost, and all products of prakriti’s manifestation fade away. Purusha is liberated from involvement with prakriti and remains eternally isolated. Through the continuous practice of concentration, contemplation and enstasis (together called samyama) some practical results for the Yogi are said to appear, the so-called psychic powers (siddhi). In the 3rd chapter of the Yoga Sutra the following such phenomena are mentioned: knowledge of the past and future (16), comprehension of the meaning of sounds uttered by any living being (17), knowledge of the previous birth (18), knowledge of the mind of others (19), invisibility of the body (20), knowledge of the time of death (23), strength of an elephant (25), knowledge of the solar system (27), knowledge of the arrangement of stars and their movements (28-29), knowledge of the organization of the body (30), cessation of hunger and thirst (31), entering another’s body (39), levitation (40), superphysical hearing (42) and passage through space (43). Once he attains this spiritual level, the Yogi is tempted by gods and other spiritual beings to use his powers for selfish desires, or to participate in their divine condition (Y.S. 3,52). However, following such

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (4 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence temptations would lead the Yogi to interrupt his spiritual journey toward final liberation. Although he could reach the spiritual level of becoming a god, this would be a spiritual failure. Therefore, such temptations have to be rejected. When, finally, liberation is attained, purusha becomes free of karma and independent. Its state is called one of total isolation (kaivalya).

Liberation techniques in Hatha Yoga

As the pantheistic metaphysics of the Hatha Yoga school was analyzed in previous files, the emphasis will be laid here on the actual way it prescribes in order to attain the final reunion of Shakti with Shiva. Shakti, the self, is located at the base of the spine as the dormant spiritual energy called kundalini. The ascetic practice demanded for awakening kundalini consists in certain physical exercises joined with respiratory techniques. After kundalini awakens, it travels through a spiritual channel (sushumna) of the subtle body, which corresponds physically to the spine, crossing seven important points called chakras. Each chakra corresponds to a Hindu guardian deity and is associated with its mantra and governing cosmogonical element. This is a supplementary reason for acknowledging the religious character of the Hatha Yoga practice.

Chakra Guardian Mantra Cosmogonic deity element

1. Brahma lam Earth muladhara

2. Vishnu vam Water svadhishtana

3. manipura Maharudra ram Fire

4. anahata Ishvara yam Air

5. vishuddha Sadashiva ham Ether

6. ajna Shiva AUM

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (5 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence

7. sahasrara

Once kundalini reaches the last chakra, it returns to its primordial union with the impersonal Ultimate Reality, represented by Shiva. The awakening and rise of kundalini through the sushumna channel is achieved by following a precise ascetic technique in which the body plays an important role. Given its religious background, Hatha Yoga must not be understood as a mere harmless physical training, as it is sometimes claimed. The most important writing of this school, the Hatha Yoga Pradipika, clearly states that Hatha Yoga has to be taught only in order to reach the Raja Yoga level (1,2), which means “the integration of mind in a state where the subject-object duality does not exist” (4,77), or in other words, only for merging the self with the impersonal Ultimate Reality. Therefore, the attention granted to the body has a single purpose: to make it fit for getting control over the mind and thus liberating the self. The steps to be followed in order to attain liberation are similar to the Ashtanga Yoga of Patanjali. The Hatha Yoga Pradipika describes them as following: 1. cleansing practices (dhauti), needed for both physical and mental health; 2. body postures (asana) (H.Y.P. 1,17); 3. breath control (pranayama) (H.Y.P. 2); 4. locks (bandha, which temporarily restrict local flows of prana) and hand gestures (mudra), which regulate the flow of prana (H.Y.P. 3). They combine body postures, breath control and concentration; 5. samadhi (H.Y.P. 4), which combines the withdrawal of the senses (pratyahara), concentration (dharana), contemplation (dhyana) and enstasis (samadhi) of the Ashtanga Yoga of Patanjali (H.Y.P. 4,87-97). The help of a teacher (guru) in assisting the practitioner is absolutely necessary, as the awakening and rising of kundalini is full of potential dangers for the Yogi. This and other aspects of the Yoga practice will be analyzed in the following section.

Critical evaluation of the Yoga practice

The moral demands

Although the moral demands Yama and Niyama (also called "The 10 Commandments of the Yogi") have nothing intrinsically bad, in the larger context of the Yoga metaphysics they demonstrate some inherent contradictions. One is regarding the very precept of non-injury (ahimsa). The demand for a strict vegetarian diet has its root in the religious precept that meat and other animal food are related to the slaying of animals, which are living beings endowed with spiritual essence (atman), as well as us humans. But why should this principle be limited only to the animal kingdom? Plants are considered living beings too. For instance, while explaining reincarnation, the Katha Upanishad (2,2,7) states: "Some souls enter into a womb for embodiment; others enter stationary objects according to their deeds and according to their thoughts" (see also The Laws of Manu 12,6). As the term "stationary objects" (sthanum) is mostly translated as "plants" (see, for instance, Swami Sharvananda, Kathopanishad, Mylapore, 1968), the ahimsa principle should apply to them as well. Another, even more convincing,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (6 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence paragraph that questions vegetarianism is the following in the Chandogya Upanishad, which explains the mechanism of the self returning to the physical world in the reincarnation cycle: After having become mist they become cloud, after having become cloud they rain down. They are born here as rice and barley, herbs and trees, as sesamum plants and beans. From thence the release becomes extremely difficult for whoever eats the food and sows the seed he becomes like unto him (Chandogya Up. 5,10,6). So why are plants “killed” for preparing food? Even more, bacteria should also be spared by not boiling water when preparing food. Although such requirements are practically absurd, they should be respected in order to be consistent with the ahimsa principle. A second aspect concerns the fact that the moral demands in Yoga do not have the purpose of achieving social harmony, but only to feed the Yogi's own spiritual progress. One should not have in mind what is good for his neighbor, but only his personal quest toward liberation. Considering the meaning of liberation (detaching purusha from its psycho-mental attachments), one has to surpass moral values, attain a state of total detachment toward them, and not become attached to them. Only in this way can one act without accumulating new karmic debt. As long as morality makes sense only in communion with other people, and Yoga demands detaching oneself from the illusory status of such involvement, the Yama and Niyama morality is different from what we commonly understand by morality, i.e. following positive demands in order to seek what is good for our neighbor. Another paradoxical aspect is that, while advancing in practice, many Yogis (especially in the West) forget the basic moral requirements and become arrogant, acquiring a feeling of superiority toward the profane world. Instead of being humble and pure (shaucha), they often behave like they feel pity for the inferior fellow-humans. Although they claim that the ego has to disappear, as it is a primitive character feature, their pride and contempt grows. This reveals a lack of truthfulness (satya), self-control and purity (shaucha) of mind. Far from detaching from any egoistic attachments, the result a Yogi often reaches is weakening or even breaking his relations with "ignorant people" (usually the family) and establishing an idolatrous relation toward the guru, the one in charge of interpreting his experiences and keep him moving along the right path. The relation with the guru usually becomes very subservient, with the disciples surrendering their entire life to him and even worshiping him as a god. Therefore, the requirement of abandoning personal attachments seems to be valid only toward the profane world, while the strongest personal relation (attachment) becomes that with the guru. The scriptures seem to encourage this attitude: When the sleeping kundalini awakens by favor of a guru, then all the chakras are pierced through (H.Y.P. 3,2). There is no doubt that the Guru is father, mother, and even god. He has to be served with all thoughts, words and deeds. By the favor of the guru, everything that is bound to the self can be attained. Therefore, the guru has to be served day and night; else nothing of great value can be attained (Shiva Samhita 3,13-14).

The postures

It is usually taught today that Yoga is nothing more than a method of maintaining body fitness, physical vigor and mental health, etc., having nothing in common with religion. This way of defining Yoga regards primarily the practice of asanas, well known today as an effective way for inducing relaxation. However, as mentioned above, the purpose of the asanas is to immobilize the body, bring it under

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (7 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence control and refuse movement, in order to help concentration. If the asanas are performed without following the 10 moral precepts and not as a step on one's spiritual path toward liberation, they have nothing in common with true Yoga. Through the symbol each posture represents (the locust, the fish, the candle, etc.), it involves a change of personality and is prescribed by the guru according to the spiritual needs of his disciple, so that he may easier surpass his ignorant condition. Therefore, Yoga cannot be reduced to a mere form of psychophysical therapy. It has always been considered a path toward transcendence, a way of surpassing our world of illusion and reaching the Ultimate Reality. It was and will always be religious. This aspect has never been doubted in the East. Only after it was brought in the Western world, the terms in which it was described were changed. However, its goal has not changed. It still aims to annihilate man's psycho-mental life and anything that can define personhood.

Breath control

Just as the asanas are not aimed at enhancing physical fitness, but the immobilization of the body, neither is the purpose of breath control (pranayama) to enhance the respiratory flow, but rather its refusal in order to attain a perfect state of concentration. The reason is the "metabolism" of prana, that form of subtle energy in which any form of physical and mental activity originates. As Yoga practice aims at “inhibiting the modifications of the mind” (Yoga Sutra 1,2), and these modifications are sustained by the prana flow through the organism, it is believed that psycho-mental activity can be slowed down and even stopped by reducing the respiratory inflow of prana. Theos Bernard, the author of a famous book on Hatha Yoga (Hatha Yoga, Rider & Co., London, 1982), mentions that “until the breath suspension (kumbhaka) had been developed to at least three minutes nothing of any significance could be done” (p. 89). In the Shiva Samhita treatise it is mentioned that one has to reach 90 minutes in the retention of the inhaled air (kumbhaka) in order to attain the psychic powers (3,53), 180 minutes in order to attain the withdrawal of senses (pratyahara) (3,57) and 150 minutes for each chakra in order that dharanamay be attained (3,64-65). The Hatha Yoga Pradipika treatise (2,11) recommends the practice of 320 breathing suspensions (kumbhaka) daily. The mudras are important aids in attaining such performances. (For instance the khecari mudra requests a progressive sectioning of the tongue fraenum, until the tongue is fit to get down the throat and lock breathing.) One possible effect of dramatically reducing the rhythm of respiration is hypoxia (the decrease of the oxygen concentration in blood below a certain limit of safety for one's health). The pathologic manifestations of hypoxia mentioned in medical literature are convulsions, body shaking beyond control, itching sensations, muscles contracting unexpectedly, headaches, and perspiration. Curiously, such manifestations appear during the practice of pranayama. Even the sacred texts acknowledge them: In the beginning there is perspiration, in the middle stage there is quivering, and in the last or the third stage one obtains steadiness; and then the breath should be made steady or motionless (Hatha Yoga Pradipika 2,12). In the first stage of Pranayama the body of the Yogi begins to perspire. [. . .] In the second stage there takes place the trembling of the body; in the third, the jumping about like a frog; and when practice becomes greater, the adept walks in the air. (Shiva Samhita 3,40-41). Far from being considered dangerous, they are considered normal and transient. Interesting to mention

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (8 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence are also the known mental experiences provoked by the increase of carbon dioxide concentration in blood as a result of hypoxia: "sensations of light and brightness, a sense of bodily detachment, the revival of past memories, a sense of communicating telepathically with a religious or spiritual presence, and feelings of great spiritual ecstasy and significance" (E. Hillstrom, Testing the Spirits, IVP, 1995, p. 94). Could it be a simple coincidence between the appearance of such manifestations and the practice of pranayama, so that hypoxia could not be involved?

Stilling the mind through meditation and mystical experiences that accompany it

Meditation and its experiences are considered key elements in any Eastern path toward liberation. The last three of the eight steps prescribed by Patanjali, called together samyama, aim at attaining the perfect control of the mind, which results in annihilating any influence generated by prakriti. Consequently, the final liberation of purusha must follow. It is therefore wrong to consider the practice of samyama as mere "relaxing techniques" for eradicating one's daily stress. Relaxation may be a result of meditation exercises, but it is only a by-product on the way toward liberating the impersonal self from reincarnation. A paradoxical aspect to be mentioned here is the appearance of the psychic powers (the siddhis) through the practice of samyama. From a naturalistic viewpoint, it seems that they are nothing more than illusions induced by the practice of meditation. For instance, although the Yoga Sutra mentions the attainment of powers such as the profound knowledge of the solar system (3,27) and that of the organization of the body (3,30), all the knowledge we have in this area was produced by classic scientific research, and never as a result of meditation insights. But if such knowledge is truly available through the practice of samyama, and as the demands for such knowledge are not egoistic at all, why has nothing been revealed until now? Although the purpose of Yoga is not to provide such information, there is no other way to prove that the so-called psychic abilities are real. Therefore, the experience of having such powers must be subjective, useful only for the spiritual advance of the Yogi but with no relation to the external world of empirical experience. The most intriguing aspect of these "psychic powers" is the fact that they can be attained by using other means as well. The Yoga Sutra (4,1) mentions "drugs (aushadi), mantras and severe austerities (tapas)". What could be the connection between them? Let us first analyze what meditation could have in common with the use of drugs. The Hindu tradition knows the use of hallucinogenic drugs from ancient times. The oldest reference is to the use of the soma drink by the Vedic priest during the sacrificial ceremony (Rig Veda 9). Similar ecstatic potions were used in other ancient religions (for instance in shamanism, in its worldwide forms of manifestation). Although the way of attaining mystical experience through Yoga and drugs is different, the actual experiences are similar. The psychedelic drug users also claim to attain a superrational, superconscious level of liberation from profane existence, a sense of fulfillment and finding a deeper meaning of existence, etc. For instance, it is a known fact that Aldous Huxley experienced mystical states induced by the use of mescaline and concluded this must be a valid path toward experiencing unity with Brahman: The beatific vision, Sat Chit Ananda, Being-Awareness-Bliss, for the first time I understood, not on

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (9 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:05 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence the verbal level, not by inchoate hints or at a distance, but precisely and completely what those prodigious syllables referred to (The Doors of Perception, 1963, p. 18). Although the use of drugs in the practice of Yoga is forbidden, the meditation experiences are amazingly close to those obtained by the use of hallucinogenic drugs. For more information on this topic, see the article: Do Psychedelic Drugs Mimic Awakened Kundalini? Hallucinogen Survey Results, by Donald J. DeGracia. It tests the hypothesis that the effects of psychedelic drugs (e.g. LSD, mescaline, peyote, etc.) are similar to the effects of the awakening of kundalini, or, in other words, the phenomenology of both states overlaps to a considerable degree. This data suggests that the awakening of kundalini and the "psychic powers" which accompany it have a physiological basis. In order to understand their effect on consciousness, we must analyze deeper the meaning and goal of meditation exercises. They play a major role in detaching oneself from the world of illusion. As empirical experience (that produces false attachments) is mediated by the mind, ignorance (avidya) cannot manifest itself apart from mindful experience and therefore can be annihilated by stopping the natural way of the mind's functioning. This means that the normal state of consciousness has to be abolished and replaced with a new one, which does not perpetuate illusion. On the way toward attaining such a state, the sensorial input of the senses has to be shut down (pratyahara) and the mind forced to ignore any normal psycho-mental experience, by performing concentration on a single point (an exercise called ekagrata). However, by forcing the mind to work in totally opposed conditions to what is natural, it will naturally get distorted perceptions of reality. The practice of samyama breaks the normal sensorial input from its normal functioning in serving consciousness. As a result, the senses come to a point where they do not process a continuous flux of information from the outer world that varies much from one moment to the next. Instead they stay immobilized on the same stimulus. As a result, one gets a totally distorted view of surrounding reality and one's own body. The very sensation of unity with the outer world can be a result of distorting the sense of perception, as Elizabeth Hillstrom points out in her book Testing the Spirits (IVP, 1995): In addition to the enhancement of boundaries in our visual systems, we have a built-in, highly developed tactile sense of the boundaries of our own body. This sense is apparently maintained by the continual flow of sensory information from the surface of our skin (feelings of touch, pressure, stretching of skin and muscles, and the like). If experiencers' awareness of the flow is significantly reduced, as it is during sensory deprivation and other altered states, they could easily conclude that their body boundaries were suddenly dissolving or that they were expanding or merging with other objects, even with God or the entire universe. Other features of the unity experience may be due to the fact that experiencers are in an altered state and realize that they have just reached a highly prized and hard-won goal. Acting together, these factors could produce profound feelings of reality, sacredness, ultimate meaning, bliss and ecstatic sensations throughout the body (p. 126). Scientists have been studying the psycho-physiological results of sensory deprivation for many years. Many reports indicate that as sensory deprivation deepens, the hallucinations experienced by the subjects of such induced experiments become more significant, consisting in visual, auditory, tactile hallucinations, out-of-body experiences, visions of other worlds, and even encounters with spirits (Hillstrom, p. 60-63). Similar distortions of perception can be the result of other extreme austerities (mentioned in the Yoga Sutra 4,1 as tapas), known long before Patanjali. These experiences seem to the one involved as very real because of the psycho-physiological conditions in which they appear, and also because of his expectations (usually induced by the guru). However, despite the fact that much of what

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (10 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:06 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence one is experiencing in the Yoga practice can be explained on a physiological basis, a mere naturalistic theory isn't adequate to cover all its aspects. As E. Hillstrom points out: Unusual effects, like automatically assuming difficult yoga postures, the inability to control or stop the kundalini process, speaking in unlearned languages, temporary manifestations of clairvoyant abilities and the like, certainly suggest that something supernatural is afoot. There are parallels between kundalini symptoms and symptoms that are currently associated with demonized states, including deranged thinking, emotional extremes (deep melancholy, ecstasy), trancelike states or periods of unconsciousness, apparent seizure activity, and unusual pain unrelated to illness and injury (p. 128). This leads us to consider another way of producing the psychic powers mentioned in the Yoga Sutra (4,1), namely the repeating of mantras. More than a simple formula used as a tool for concentrating the mind, the mantra is a name of a Hindu god and a tool for invoking him and his powers. If the siddhis are attained as a result of invoking a god, they are likely to originate in him, and not out of developing one's own inner potential. This leads us to search for explanations for the psychic powers in a realm that does not belong to physical existence. The common element in meditation, the repeating of mantras and, to some extent, the use of psychedelic drugs is the annihilation of critical thought and normal state of consciousness. This is considered of primary importance for entering the appropriate state of consciousness for liberating the self. However, shutting down the mind in order to grasp irrational higher realities and giving up critical discernment opens the way for the phenomenon of spiritual possession, i.e. the taking of control of one's life by an external personal being. As during meditation such openness toward external spirit guides exists, the experience of meeting certain spiritual beings occurs pretty often. Could they be harmless, or even trustable? The answer depends on the authority we use in order to judge them. Taking a Christian standpoint, such external spirits may be demons, treacherous beings that present themselves as angels of light (2 Corinthians 11,14). A weird fact is that the same psychic powers attained by the Yogis while practicing samyama are available to some people involved in black magic. The knowledge of the past and future, reading one's thoughts, dematerialization, acquiring supernatural physical powers, telekinesis, clairvoyance, entering another person's body, levitation, etc., are abilities that such people also claim, but acknowledging the fact that their source is the world of demons. Could this be a simple coincidence? The Apostle Peter warns: Be self-controlled and alert. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour (1 Peter 5,8). Knowing the fact that demons use any given opportunity to take over one's body and use it as an instrument, why should they not use the proper mindset offered by a Yogi while practicing meditation? Despite the fact that the mantra is associated with a Hindu protector god, why should we reject the possibility that by calling his name, instead of a god being the one who awakens dormant energies inside us, a demon may come instead, take over consciousness and then manifest psychic powers which actually belong to him? Could the intensity of the experience be a sufficient reason to be assured that there is no evil entity involved in producing it? Why should we reject the possibility that a demon is wise enough to avoid violent manifestations (which normally describe demonic possession) in order to delude us? As examples of how so-called deities are invited to enter one's body, we can look at most forms of Eastern initiation. For instance, in Tantrism are prescribed specific rituals in order to omologate the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (11 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:06 AM] Critical considerations regarding Yoga as spiritual path towards transcendence deities with different parts of the body. The maithuna ritual even represents a sexual union with a woman in which Hindu spirits are residing. While performing the mandala ritual the disciple has to locate the gods in his heart, with the climax being the descent of the god essence into him and fusion with his consciousness. Possession-like states are reported very often during the initiation ritual, sometimes perceived as the entering of the guru into the disciple's body (Shakti-diksha), or the uniting of the disciple's being with that of the guru (Anavi-yaugi-diksha). Far from being considered dangerous, such experiences are considered useful, necessary for one's spiritual growth. Therefore Yoga practice can lead to a quite different end from that much-advertised peace of mind and inner balance. The experiences it produces may be very dangerous because they are either the premise or the actual experience of demonic possession. If this interpretation seems absurd for some, in what other way could we explain the experience of Eastern initiation, especially when trying to be consistent with Christian theology? Back to Top | Back to Contents | E-Mail

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Yoga.html (12 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:48:06 AM] Critical considerations regarding the dualistic Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics

Critical considerations regarding the dualistic Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics

In order to emphasize some basic difficulties of the dualistic Samkhya and Yoga darshanas, we will use the same criteria of internal consistency, harmony between empirical and absolute knowledge, and viability. (Remember that it is the specific Yoga darshana of Patanjali endorsed here, and not other of the many modern Yoga schools that exist today.) As their metaphysical basis is mostly common, in the absence of any supplementary explanation, what will be mentioned here is valid for both schools.

1) The internal consistency of the Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics is affected by the way it states the plurality of souls (purushas). As purusha is devoid of any attributes that could individualize it (which was also the case with atman), there no difference can be made between one purusha and another, and therefore we cannot admit their plurality. S. Radhakrishnan makes the following comment from a Vedantic point of view: The self is without attributes or qualities, without parts, imperishable, motionless, absolutely inactive and impassive, unaffected by pleasure or pain or any other emotion. All change, all character belong to prakriti. There does not seem to be any basis for the attribution of distinctness to purushas. If each purusha has the same features of consciousness, all-pervadingness, if there is not the slightest difference between one purusha and another, since they are free from all variety, then there is nothing to lead us to assume a plurality of purushas. Multiplicity without distinction is impossible (Indian Philosophy, vol. II, p. 322). 2) As a result of the way it states the relation existing between purusha and prakriti (nature), the Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics also lacks harmony between empirical and absolute knowledge. Here is how S. Radhakrishnan appreciates the contradictory relation between the two elements: When the Samkhya breaks up the concrete unity of experience into the two elements of subject and object and makes them fictitiously absolute, it cannot account for the fact of experience. When purusha is viewed as pure consciousness, the permanent light which illuminates all objects of knowledge, and prakriti as something opposed to consciousness and utterly foreign to it, the latter can never become the object of the former. The Samkhya cannot get across the ditch which it has dug between the subject and the object. [...] Unless the subject and object are akin to each other, how can the one reflect the other? How can buddhi, which is non-intelligent, reflect purusha? How can the formless purusha which is the constant seer be reflected in buddhi which is changing? The two cannot, therefore, be absolutely opposed in nature (Indian Philosophy, vol. II, p. 303-4).

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Samkhya.html (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:48:11 AM] Critical considerations regarding the dualistic Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics In other words, the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas dissociate knowledge into two distinct realms (absolute and empirical) between which stands an insurmountable gap. Because they belong to different worlds, purusha cannot know prakriti, and on the other hand, prakriti and all its forms of manifestation cannot do anything to help liberation. Between the domain of empirical knowledge produced by prakriti and the absolute knowledge of purusha, no possible relationship can exist. An attempt to solve this epistemological difficulty was done by postulating the fact that prakriti operates instinctively for purusha’s liberation. The Samkhya-Sutra (3,47) states that “creation (prakriti) works for the sake of purusha, so that it may attain supreme knowledge”. The Yoga-Sutra of Patanjali (2,21) also mentions that prakriti exists only for the sake of serving purusha's liberation. But in the absence of a personal creator god who could “inspire” a teleological instinct to prakriti, such a postulate is absurd. The Samkhya darshana rejects the existence of a creator god, since he could be conceived only as a liberated self, or a self bound to karma (Samkhya-Sutra 1,93). However, neither a self enslaved by karma can be the creator, nor a free purusha, because, being totally detached from matter (prakriti), it could not have perception, desire for action or any means to influence matter. To this second category belongs Ishvara of the Yoga darshana. He is not a personal god, but rather a macro-purusha that was never involved with the psycho-mental activity and the law of karma (Yoga-Sutra 1,24), being devoid of any creative abilities. The teleological instinct of prakriti was explained the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas by using the image of a horse that pulls a wagon out of his instinct, an act to which the wagon driver is a simple spectator. In the same way, prakriti would conduct purusha toward liberation without any external directive. It is omitted, however, in this example, that the horse was first trained by the driver before he knew the way home. Samkhya metaphysics does not allow such an external “coach” for prakriti to learn how to liberate purusha. Another poor illustration used by the Samkhya followers is that of a blind man and a lame man helping each other on their journey. Neither can this be a valid illustration to symbolize the teleological instinct of prakriti, because both the blind man and the lame man possess intelligence and language, and therefore can cooperate in realizing a common purpose. Such cooperation between purusha and prakriti cannot exist, because they have nothing in common. Therefore, the epistemological problem generated by the impossible communication between purusha and man’s psycho-mental abilities cannot be properly solved. How could intellect help to distance purusha from prakriti, if intellect itself is a category of prakriti? Another solution suggested to explain the purusha-prakriti relation was that a certain similarity could exist between buddhi (pure intellect) and purusha, a similarity given by the guna sattva. According to this opinion, when the guna sattva is dominating one’s psycho-mental life, the intellect can become as pure as purusha, and therefore capable of perfectly reflecting it, a moment which precedes their separation and, consequently, purusha’s liberation. However, there are two major problems arising from such a hypothesis: 1) How could the intellect possibly attain the purity of purusha? By its very essence, intellect is a category of prakriti, different from purusha’s immutability. 2) If such purity of intellect could be attained only at the moment of liberation, how can buddhi and purusha cooperate all the way prior to reaching this stage? In other words, how can intellect, a category of prakriti, be purified in order to reflect purusha while it is still dominated by the gunas rajas and tamas? Not even “knowing the knowledge” of buddhi by purusha, through purusha’s reflection in the intellect, can be a solution. In order that communication might be possible between two totally different entities (one being purusha and the other one the psycho-mental abilities, which belong to prakriti), one's data

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Samkhya.html (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:48:11 AM] Critical considerations regarding the dualistic Samkhya-Yoga metaphysics have to be “translated” to the other one, a requirement which is impossible to fulfill according to the Samkhya and Yoga. Although this translator (or mediator) role was attributed to purusha’s reflection in the intellect, it was not stated to which category this reflection belongs. If it belongs to prakriti, it brings nothing new in solving the dilemma. It also cannot belong to purusha (as its product or attribute), because it would institute a new category, intermediary and different to both purusha and prakriti, which is absurd. The epistemological dilemma we face here is similar to that encountered in pantheism. The same illusory status of empirical knowledge makes communication impossible between the self and the world. Therefore, empirical knowledge is of no use in attaining liberation. The gap that exists between empirical knowledge (psycho-mental data) and absolute knowledge (purusha’s self-knowledge) is impossible to cross.

3) As a result of the illusory status granted to personhood, the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas face similar problems to those of pantheism concerning their viability. Personhood is considered to be a product of prakriti’s manifestation, a sum of psycho-mental experiences that cease to exist at the moment of liberation. Instead of the pantheist view of liberation, consisting of an impersonal merging of the self with the Absolute, the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas state that the liberated self (purusha) remains eternally isolated, devoid of any relation with other purushas (or Ishvara, in Yoga) and having as the only possibility that of knowing itself. But given the fact that purusha is devoid of any attributes, it is hard to grasp what could that self-contemplation possibly consist of. Due to the same attitude toward personhood, the problems faced in defining freedom, morality, compassion and social involvement are similar to those mentioned in analyzing pantheism, and therefore will not be repeated. The solution for passing over all the above-mentioned inconsistencies is considered to be practice, or, in other words, having a direct experience of Ultimate Reality. This is why we dedicate the next file to examining the Yoga practice and appreciating to what extent it could provide the answer for man’s spiritual quest for transcendence.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Samkhya.html (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:48:11 AM] Critical considerations regarding Buddhism

Critical considerations regarding Buddhism

Although it was meant to bring a whole new perspective on what Hinduism had to say on Ultimate Reality, man and liberation, Theravada Buddhism could not escape some basic inconsistencies. Let us summarize the most debated:

Reincarnation without a self

One of the key elements in Theravada Buddhism is the denial of a self (atman). The illusion of personal existence (puggala) is considered to be the product of five aggregates (skandha), which are in a cause-effect relationship and suffer from constant becoming. Therefore, human existence is nothing but impermanence (anitya), a constant process of transformation devoid of any abiding principle. The rejection of a self is considered important mostly for practical reasons. One should not engage in philosophical debates concerning the existence of a self (as well as the character of the universe and the existence of an Ultimate Reality), because this will only generate suffering and lead one astray from seeking liberation (Majjhima-nikaya 1,426). But if there is no self, what reincarnates from one existence to another? Buddha stated that only karma passes from one life to another, determining a new configuration of the five aggregates in the next existence. Therefore samsara works without implying a self, relying only on a causal chain of determination. Such a strange definition of reincarnation has naturally raised strong objections from the opponents of Buddhism. Not only they contradict it, but even the Buddhist scriptures contain passages that are inconsistent with the lack of a self. Some of them seem to confirm the continuity of personal existence, or at least of an impersonal self along the reincarnation process. For instance, although the five aggregates are supposed to break apart after death and personhood to vanish, it is stated that the dead will be judged by Yama, the god of death, and afterwards sent into hell and tormented for his sins (Khuddaka-nikaya 10,1,59). However, hell is not eternal, so the soul will eventually return as an animal and then continue to reincarnate until he reaches again the human state. There is no doubt that this Vedic reminiscence is totally inconsistent with the Buddhist doctrine of no-self. On the other hand, if there is no self, on what basis could the Buddha have said, "This is my last birth, I will have no further existence" (Majjhima-nikaya 3)? Whose last birth is it, if there is no self to rebirth? There are also the texts in Khuddaka-nikaya 10, referring to the previous lives of Buddha and his friends, in which each one's identity is always perfectly known. Such passages suggest that the doctrine of no-self was hard to accept even for the one who proposed it.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Buddhism.html (1 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:15 AM] Critical considerations regarding Buddhism

The liberation of no self

The Buddhist term for liberation (nirvana) derives from the verbal root va (lit. "to blow") and the negation nir, from which its significance corresponds to the blowing out of a candle. Once man attains nirvana, the five aggregates are scattered forever without entering a new combination again. This corresponds to a total extinction of any ontological element that could define human existence. The scriptures state: When a man is free from all sense pleasures and depends on nothingness he is free in the supreme freedom from perception. He will stay there and not return again. It is like a flame struck by a sudden gust of wind. In a flash it has gone out and nothing more can be known about it. It is the same with a wise man freed from mental existence: in a flash he has gone out and nothing more can be known about him. When a person has gone out, then there is nothing by which you can measure him. That by which he can be talked about is no longer there for him; you cannot say that he does not exist. When all ways of being, all phenomena are removed, then all ways of description have also been removed. (Sutta Nipata 1072-76) Once the adherent of Theravada Buddhism has attained nirvana, he becomes an arhat (“living enlightened one”). His karma is considered extinct and at the time of his death he will cease to exist. However, from a Buddhist point of view, this perspective isn't horrifying at all, because it represents the cessation of an illusion. When human existence is blown out, nothing real disappears because life itself is an illusion. Nirvana is neither a re-absorption in an eternal Ultimate Reality, because such a thing doesn’t exist, nor the annihilation of a self, because there is no self to annihilate. It is rather an annihilation of the illusion of an existing self. Unlike in Hindu pantheism, which defines liberation as the fusion of atman with Brahman, no one and nothing is attaining liberation. This means that nirvana is a state of supreme bliss and freedom without any subject to experience it. Paradoxically, Buddhism confers reality to this ultimate stage of moving toward nothingness, and the only proof of it, as expected, is the mystical experiences one has on the way toward it. As the one engaged on the way to nirvana experiences gradual liberation from illusory attachments, by extrapolation it is speculated that there will follow a moment of reaching total freedom from the present conditioned state. However, this reasoning is false, because the domain of definition (the substratum of existence) ends before reaching the desired result. Nirvana is a state beyond any description, knowledge and experience, with nobody and nothing left to reach it. Therefore, this liberation of no-self, or in other words, the liberation of an illusory combination of impermanent elements, seems to be nothing more than sheer nonsense.

The meaning of morality

Following other impersonal Eastern religions, Buddhism values morality only as an instrument for transcending personal existence, which is seen as the major hindrance in attaining liberation. Morality has no ultimate importance, but is only an instrument used for developing a detached status toward personal attachments and interests in life. Moral perfection (sila), i.e. right speech, action and livelihood,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Buddhism.html (2 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:15 AM] Critical considerations regarding Buddhism aims at annihilating one's false attachments to the world of illusion, by no way encouraging one's social involvement. As long as man is not an everlasting entity (a personal soul in theistic religions, or an impersonal atman in pantheism), but a mere mechanism which appears and disappears according to its karma, compassion toward one's neighbor is absurd. According to Buddhist teaching, bad habits such as envy, anger, gossip and pride must be abandoned, but not because other people may be hurt by them, but because they feed one's false ego and the thirst (trishna) for experiencing personal existence. Because of its radical way of defining human existence, Theravada Buddhism cannot be a valid way of living for modern man. How could one become socially involved in a world that is considered nothing but an illusion shaped by his own mind? Buddhism can be followed best by monks, in retreat, away from any kind of social involvement. As a result, contrary to its claims, Buddhism cannot solve the problem of human suffering but only to ignore it by redefining its meaning; it cannot help one have a positive role in society but only a passive one; and it cannot give strength for overcoming life's stress and tensions but only to teach withdrawal from its harsh realities. No wonder then that Buddhism is criticized for developing a fatalist view of life.

Buddhist meditation and its experiences

The actual techniques used for attaining liberation belong to three categories: meditations (jhana), contemplations (samapatti) and concentrations (samadhi). The most important are those belonging to the second category, the contemplations, revealed by the Buddha in the famous Satipatthana-sutta (Majjhima-nikaya 10, Digha-nikaya 22). The four contemplation exercises focus on the physical body (kaya), the feelings (vedana), the mental states (citta) and the mental objects (dhamma). The false attachments they produce must be destroyed so that one can understand their impermanent nature. As was the case in Yoga, psychologist Elizabeth Hillstrom points out in her book Testing the Spirits that instead of being glimpses of the impermanent nature of things, the experiences that accompany Buddhist contemplation can be explained as misperceptions of the surrounding reality due to imposing on the senses and mind an abnormal way of functioning: As meditators passively watch their own mental states come and go without trying to control them, these begin to fluctuate more and more rapidly and unpredictably. After a while this chaotic activity creates the strong impression that the mental events are springing into life on their own, from some separate source, rather than the observer's own mind. As meditators persist with this practice, they also notice that there is a definite separation between the mental events being observed and the mind that is doing the observing. As meditation progresses still further, both the mental events and the observing mind begin to seem alien and impersonal, as if they do not really belong to the observer. At about this point the meditator's sense of "self" becomes confused and weakened, and finally it disappears entirely for brief periods of time. This experience of dissolution strongly reinforces the Buddhist notion that there actually is no such thing as an "I" or "myself" - that such concepts are actually false constructions of the mind. At still deeper levels, meditators eventually reach a stage in which their awareness of events and the events themselves seem inextricably bound together and the whole scene churns in a wild state of flux. Ideas, images and thoughts seem to appear and then dissolve into nothingness with great rapidity. At this point every aspect of mental life (and the physical world itself) seems impermanent, transitory and alien, and disturbed meditators desperately want it all to stop. Relief

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Buddhism.html (3 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:15 AM] Critical considerations regarding Buddhism finally comes when meditators break through Nirvana, a state in which all awareness of physical and mental phenomena ceases, at least for a short time. Reaching this stage ostensibly produces permanent changes in consciousness. Inner processes are set in motion which fill the meditator with equanimity and bliss. These presumably destroy defiling mental states like self-interest, ambition, greed and hatred, and ensure advanced placement in the next life. When interpreted through Eastern lenses, these experiences strongly reinforce the Buddhist belief that the physical universe, our concepts of self and even our inner mental life are only illusions. (E. Hillstrom, Testing the Spirits, IVP, 1995, p. 114-15) The meditator's prior expectations, as induced by the guru, as well as the refusal of any conscious control over the process, probably contribute to a great extent to one's accepting the truthfulness of these experiences. However, as long as they depend heavily upon forcing the mind to work in improper conditions, it is more likely that they rather represent perceptions of defective cognitive phenomena than true perceptions of an Ultimate Reality. Therefore they cannot be trusted.

Mahayana Buddhism and Hindu pantheism

According to the doctrine of momentariness (kshanikavada), not only the self is to be considered illusory, but also the five aggregates and all other aspects of the world. All things are impermanent and follow a continuous process of becoming. Therefore from an ontological point of view, everything is but a succession of transitory moments. The true nature of the world is the void (shunya), which is not non-existence or nothingness, but an Ultimate Reality free of any limitation, duality or determination. Like the Hindu Brahman, the void can be characterized only by refusing any positive attributes. Although Mahayana Buddhism rejects the major Vedantic notions, the void is nothing but an acceptance of Brahman in disguise. Following the pattern of Hindu pantheism, the world is considered to be the manifestation of shunya, which is altogether the fundamental nature (also called Buddha Nature) of any being that has to be discovered through mystical introspection. This is nothing but an actualization in the Mahayanic context of the atman-Brahman identity, and therefore much of the criticism addressed to pantheism is valid here as well.

The boddhisattvas and grace

Instead of seeking nirvana just for himself and become an arhat, as Theravada Buddhism demands, the disciple of Mahayana Buddhism aims to become a bodhisattva, a celestial being that postpones his own entrance into parinirvana (final extinction) in order to help other humans also attain it. As was the case with the Hindu avatars of Vishnu, the bodhisattvas are mediators between man and Ultimate Reality. Through devotion and proper moral conduct humans receive their grace and attain liberation. This new development has been interpreted as a penetration of the Hindu bhakti tradition into Buddhism. However, we meet here the same contradiction between karma and grace as in theistic Hinduism. For instance, according to the Tibetan Book of the Dead, although the bodhisattvas offer their help to the dead person in order that he may attain a better new birth or even final liberation, he is unable to accept it

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Buddhism.html (4 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:15 AM] Critical considerations regarding Buddhism because of the projection of his bad karma and the attraction of “samsaric impurities”, which make him fall deeper and deeper into the intermediary state (bardo). For this reason it is wrong to pretend that the bodhisattvas save the dead through their grace, as only the merits he has accumulated during lifetime make him able to accept the “rays of grace”. Therefore, it is either karma that rules one's existence and journey toward liberation, or the grace of the bodhisattvas. The two elements are hard to reconcile. On the other hand, due to the rejection of any abiding principle that could define human existence, the idea of grace becomes absurd. Who is suffering and who needs the boddhisattvas' grace in order to be liberated, if all existence is nothing but illusion? S. Dasgupta comments on this absurd situation: The saint (bodhisattva) is firmly determined that he will help an infinite number of souls to attain nirvana. In reality, however, there are no beings, there is no bondage, no salvation; and the saint knows it but too well, yet he is not afraid of this high truth, but proceeds on his career of attaining for all illusory beings illusory emancipation from illusory bondage. The saint is actuated with that feeling and proceeds in his work on the strength of his paramitas, though in reality there is no one who is to attain salvation in reality and no one who is to help him attain it (S. Dasgupta, Indian Philosophy, vol. 1, p. 127). The equivalence of samsara and nirvana

A further consequence of the doctrine of the void in Mahayana Buddhism is the equivalence of samsara and nirvana. If voidness is to be projected not only on personal existence, but on any concept and experience, it means that all major Buddhist terms such as aggregates, karma, samsara, nirvana and the four noble truths, must also be void. Therefore they are nothing but conventional truths, products of momentariness which are operational only in language use. If samsara is impermanent and has no abiding subject, it cannot have a true nature. The same is true about nirvana. If samsara and nirvana are both void, they must be identical, and any difference empirically experienced between them must also be illusory from the absolute point of view. Therefore the two pillars of early Buddhism are abolished in Mahayana. What then remains of the whole Buddhist philosophy? Once we arrive here we have to face the same objection as in pantheism: Empirical knowledge cannot be correlated with absolute knowledge because ultimate truth cannot be expressed through language. However, there is an inconsistent attitude to this conclusion because there has been a huge amount of literature produced trying to express "the inexpressible". The very statement of Mahayana Buddhism that "any conventional term is void" is self-contradictory, as it itself must be void in order to be true. Otherwise it cannot communicate anything and the best way of transmitting Buddhist doctrine would be silence. See also on this topic: Comparing Christianity & Buddhism, by Peter Kreeft

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Buddhism.html (5 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:15 AM] The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity

The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity

The only religions that admit a true incarnation of Ultimate Reality in human form and consider it very important in their theology are Vaishnava Hinduism and Christianity. They both assume that God descended into the world and dwelt among humans in order to save them. Vaishnava Hinduism ascribes ten incarnations (avatars) to the god Vishnu, while Christianity proclaims the sole incarnation of God the Son in Jesus Christ. Could they be equivalent? In other words, could Jesus Christ be considered a mere Western avatar, come into our world according to the Hindu pattern? On the other hand, could the avatars of Vishnu have fulfilled the same goal as Jesus? Or are there irreconcilable differences between them? As we witness today many claims that they express a similar theology, a proper investigation is necessary for unveiling the mystery that surrounds this topic. The following analysis will investigate why the incarnation of God was necessary, how the problem arose that he came for, what the form of the divine embodiment is and how it actually solves the problem.

The periodical manifestation and dissolution of the world

Vaishnava Hinduism states in its major writings, the Puranas, that the god Vishnu causes a cyclic manifestation and dissolution of the world. Each cosmic cycle (mahayuga) has four ages (Krita Yuga - 1.728.000 years, Treta Yuga - 1.296.000 years, Dvapara Yuga - 864.000 years and Kali Yuga - 432.000 years) followed by the dissolution (pralaya) of the physical world. The whole cycle is repeated 994 times, which is a period called kalpa, and then a dissolution (pralaya) of both the physical and subtle world follows. 36.000 kalpas and pralayas make the lifespan of Brahma, the creator god, which is followed by a total dissolution (mahapralaya) of the physical, subtle and causal world. Then all worlds, time and space return into Brahman, and the whole cycle starts again in an endless process of manifestation and dissolution. In Christianity, on the other hand, the world was created only once, and not as a necessity (as the cyclic manifestation of Vishnu implies) but out of God's superabundant love. Although the world became corrupted by sin, this situation doesn't belong to a normally repeated scenario (as in Hinduism) but is the result of a wrong human response to God's love. Despite the fact that our world is different from what God has originally intended, it will not follow a repeated cycle of manifestation and dissolution. The "new heaven and new earth" presented at the end of the Revelation account (21,1) is not a new creation similar to the one presented in Genesis. Otherwise it would indeed confirm a cyclic manifestation of the world according to the Hindu pattern. The Bible doesn't confirm such a mechanism. The "new heaven and new earth" is rather an everlasting world where sin is eradicated and there will be "no more death or mourning or crying or pain" (Revelation 21,4). It will belong to those who accepted His grace through Jesus Christ (21,27) and will never have a pralaya to end it.

The ten avatars of Vishnu

The god Vishnu is said to descend ten times into our world during each cosmic cycle (mahayuga) in order to restore the balance between good and evil. His incarnations (avatars) vary depending on the Hindu writing that describes them. The Mahabharata gives three lists of Vishnu's avatars: First there are mentioned four, then six, and finally there is a list of ten, in the form of: (1) swan, (2) tortoise, (3) fish, (4) boar, (5) man-lion, (6) dwarf, (7) Bhargava Rama, (8) Dasaratha Rama, (9) Krishna, and (10) Kalki. The Garuda Purana lists 19 avatars of Vishnu, while the Bhagavata Purana lists 22 in one place and 23 in another. Since the time of the Bhagavata Purana the number of avatars has been uniformly recognized as ten. Therefore we will use the following list in the present analysis: (1) fish, (2) tortoise, (3) boar, (4) man-lion, (5) dwarf, (6) Parasurama, (7) Rama, (8) Krishna, (9) Buddha and (10) Kalki. The first nine have occurred already and the last one is still to come. Let us give a brief description of each avatar and see what its goal was and the method used for fulfilling it. (1) The fish (Matsya). The Vedas were stolen from Brahma by a demon, so the gods sent a flood on the earth to drown him and thus recover the holy scriptures. Vishnu took the form of a fish, predicted the coming deluge to the saint Manu and saved him together with his family by leading his ship to safety. (2) The tortoise (Kurma). During the deluge that destroyed the world the cream of the milk ocean (amrita), by which the gods renewed their youthfulness and avoided death, was lost. Both gods and demons together set about producing amrita by churning the ocean of milk, using a mountain as churning stick and the incarnation of Vishnu as a pivot on which to rest it. Their action was successful and the amrita recovered.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/avatars.html (1 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:24 AM] The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity

(3) The boar (Varaha). Brahma had been forced to grant the boon of immortality to a demon that had performed austerities. Under the cover of this boon, the demon persecuted both men and gods and even stole the Vedas from Brahma and dragged the earth under the ocean, down to his dark abode. However, he forgot to mention the boar when reciting the name of gods, men and animals from which to be immune, so Vishnu took the form of a huge boar, descended into the ocean, killed the demon with his tusks, recovered the Vedas and released the earth. (4) The man-lion (Narasinha). A demon had obtained the boon of immunity through asceticism from the attacks of men, beasts and gods. He had the assurance from Brahma that he could not be killed either day or night, inside or outside his house. This demon grew very powerful and forbade the worship of all gods and substituted it with worship for himself. Vishnu took the form of half-man, half-lion (neither man nor beast) and tore the demon into pieces in the evening (neither in the day nor in the night) in the doorway of his palace (neither inside nor outside it). (5) The dwarf (Vamana). The king Bali had gained too much power by his sacrifices, so the gods were endangered of losing their heavenly position to him. Therefore Vishnu was incarnated as a dwarf and asked the king the gift of three paces of land. Once accepted, the dwarf suddenly grew to an enormous size and covered all the earth and the heavens by his paces and Bali was left with only the nether regions. (6) Parasurama (Rama with the ax). The warrior caste (kshatriya) was exercising tyranny over all men, especially over the Brahmins, so the priestly caste was endangered. Vishnu came to earth as Parasurama and exterminated the whole kshatriya caste with his ax. While he was still on earth, the next avatar (Ramachandra) came and the two had to struggle. Ramachandra defeated him in a trial of strength and broke his bow. (Both the Ramayana and the Mahabharata recollect this episode. In the Mahabharata Parasurama is knocked senseless by Ramachandra.) (7) Ramachandra (Rama), the hero of the Ramayana epic. The demon Ravana had practiced austerities in order to propitiate Brahma, who had granted him immunity from being killed by gods, gandharvas and demons. Under this cover, Ravana persecuted gods and men. Vishnu took the human form of prince Rama, for Ravana was too proud to ask immunity from men. Many adventures followed in his trip to save his wife Sita, who was kidnapped by the demon and taken to the Lanka Island. Rama raised an army of monkeys and bears led by the monkey-god Hanuman and a great battle was fought in front of the gates of the city. Rama used a magic weapon infused by the power of many gods, killed Ravana and rescued his wife. (8) Krishna. The objective of Vishnu's incarnation as Krishna was to kill the demon Kamsa, who had become a tyrannical king, killing children and banning the worship of Vishnu. Krishna's mission had three phases: childhood, youth and middle age. During childhood he performed many feats of strength, killing all demons sent against him by Kamsa. In his youth, Krishna had many amorous adventures with married cowgirls. At last, in his middle-age, he killed Kamsa and took part in the Bharata war (with the most famous episode being the one recollected in the Bhagavad Gita). His mission accomplished, Krishna retreated into the forest in meditation. A hunter mistook his foot for a deer and shot it, thus piercing Krishna's one vulnerable spot and mortally wounding him. (9) Buddha. The demons had stolen the sacrificial potions of the gods and performed asceticism, so the gods could not conquer them. Vishnu incarnated as a man of delusion in order to propagate false ideas and lead them astray from their old faith. Buddha preached that there is no creator, that the three major gods (Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva) were just ordinary mortals, that there is no dharma, that death is total annihilation, that there is no heaven and hell and that the sacrifices are of no value. Obviously, Buddha as avatar of Vishnu has no historical background. He was a kind of devil's advocate who managed to weaken the opponents of the gods. The demons became Buddhists, abandoned the Vedas and consequently were killed by the gods. This story was first presented in the Vishnu Purana (5th century AD) and is obviously an attempt to subordinate Buddhism to Hinduism. (10) Kalki. The last avatar, who is still to come, puts an end to the degenerated earth, accomplishing the final destruction of the wicked and preparing the way for the renewal of creation and the resurgence of virtue in the next mahayuga.

The following table summarizes the meaning of Vishnu's past 9 avatars:

Topic Which avatar's case fits into this scenario

A demon performed austerities and gained too much power over 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 the gods

The avatar came to save the gods 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9

The avatar came to save humans 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8

The avatar kills a demon 3, 4, 7, 8

http://www.comparativereligion.com/avatars.html (2 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:24 AM] The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity

The avatar's form of embodiment Animal (1, 2, 3), half-beast, half-human (4), human (5, 6, 7, 8, 9) according to how the demon had to be deceived.

Now let us turn to the nature of the divine incarnation in Christianity by presenting an excerpt from a previous file on the nature of salvation in Christianity.

God the Son incarnated as Jesus Christ

The Christian account of divine incarnation presents God the Son willingly leaving His divine glory, taking a human body and descending into our world through the virgin birth. The Apostle Paul states: Christ Jesus, being in very nature God, did not consider equality with God something to be grasped, but made himself nothing, taking the very nature of a servant, being made in human likeness (Philippians 2,6-7). This “making Himself nothing” performed by God the Son is called in theology “the kenosis of Christ” (lit. = “emptying”). It does not mean a subtraction of deity, but the addition of humanity with its consequent limitations. Although taking a human nature was a real humbling for God the Son, it did not involve the giving up of any divine attributes. The doctrine of the kenosis involves the veiling of His preincarnate glory (John 17,5), taking on Himself the likeness of human sinful flesh (Romans 8,3) and the temporary nonuse of divine attributes during His earthly ministry. The kenosis of Christ was His free will initiative and not a necessity imposed by His nature, as is the case with the periodical incarnations of Vishnu. According to Christianity, Jesus Christ is the only incarnation of God, descended into our world with a unique and non-repeatable mission in history. He is not a mere avatar, a periodical incarnation of a Hindu god, but the unique incarnation of God the Son, become God the Man, perfect in both His divine and human nature. This double nature of Jesus Christ is the key for understanding His mission of reconciling man with God. In Vaishnava Hinduism none of the avatars has a perfect union of the two natures. As they have no historical basis, it is very difficult to speculate on how their divine nature combined with the physical one (animal or human). Due to considering the physical body a mere garment that is put on and off (according to Bhagavad Gita 2,22), there cannot be any real association of god with a physical body. Christ came to redeem the physical body as well, therefore His association with it was real. For the same reason there is so much accent laid on His physical resurrection, which for a Hindu avatar would be completely absurd. Therefore the avatar fits best in the Docetic understanding of Christ (the appearance of a physical body, with no intrinsic value to it), which is considered a classic heresy in Christianity. The most striking difference from Hindu avatars regards Christ's death. This was the crux of His incarnation: He had to die on the cross for our redemption from sin and reconciliation with God. The Apostle Peter states in his epistle: He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree, so that we might die to sins and live for righteousness; by his wounds you have been healed (1 Peter 2,24; see also 1,18-21; 3,18). Jesus Christ as “the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world” (John 1,29) is the cornerstone of Christianity and its non-paralleled element. Mocked and spit upon by the human race, nailed on a cross and forsaken by the Father, Jesus Christ took our place in punishment. While dying on the cross, Jesus shouted, “It is finished” (John 19,30). In Greek, the expression used was Tetelestai, which means, “the debt was paid in full”. What was meant here is the debt that man deserved to pay for his sins in hell, through eternal torment. By His death, Jesus paid in full the price required for the salvation of mankind from sin. Was the suffering of Christ on the cross a mere illusion, as some esoteric interpretations suggest? Obviously not! His torment and death were so real that none of those who saw it could expect a future victory over death. This proves the full incarnation of God the Son. He did not die only in physical appearance, as the Docetist heresy suggests, but as a poor miserable man, experiencing suffering in its fullest sense. His death proves both the seriousness of our sin and the unfathomable love of God, as Jesus once proclaimed: For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life (John 3,16).

Parallels between the Hindu avatars and Jesus Christ

What are demons?

According to Hinduism, demons are either beings that appeared through the primordial act of manifestation, or humans that didn't follow their duty (dharma) or performed bad deeds during their lifetime. Consequently they reincarnate as evil beings which cause much suffering in the world. However, the evil they do is not arbitrary, as the law of karma makes sure that the humans afflicted by demons are justly punished for their own bad deeds performed in previous lives. Therefore, from a global point of view the demons' bad deeds must be seen as necessary in balancing karma. On the other hand, the demon stage of existence is limited, and eventually there is reincarnation back into human form and

http://www.comparativereligion.com/avatars.html (3 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:24 AM] The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity henceforth a new chance given to attain liberation. Keeping this in mind, it becomes absurd that Vishnu has to intervene in the world by descending as an avatar to save it. Save it from what? From the consequences of karma, a spiritual law that can never be abolished? As long as karma operates in the world, the killing of a demon has a very limited effect. It doesn't guarantee that the demon will not create problems in his next existence. According to the reincarnation doctrine, only one's physical frame can be "killed" (see Bhagavad Gita 2,19), not the "infinite, immortal soul". For this reason, demons never stop creating problems, so there are necessary periodical incarnations of the divine, at least 10 in each mahayuga. As the periodical manifestation of the world created by Vishnu never ends, so does the affliction of it by the demons. Therefore, the solution of killing the demons by the avatars is only a short-term solution to the problem of evil in the world. On the other hand, in Christianity, demons have a different nature and destiny. They are fallen angels who will never reincarnate, return to their initial status or attain salvation. As the present world has a limited time span and there is no re-manifestation of it, the demons will be eternally separated from the Kingdom of God at the judgment day. (For more information on the nature of demons in Christianity click here.)

How did the demons attain power over the gods?

A very interesting fact in Hinduism is that anyone - god, human or demon - can attain the same magical power through performing austerities (tapas). Once this power is attained, nobody can break it. In fact, the 3rd, 4th, 7th, 8th and 9th avatars of Vishnu all came because a demon performed so many austerities that the god Brahma was forced to grant him the boon of immortality as a reward. The mechanism of attaining such power is beyond the control of the gods, which proves their weakness in ruling the world. As a result, the avatar has to find a way of killing the demon without breaking the promises made to him by Brahma. The solutions are sometimes very funny (see for instance the 3rd and the 4th avatar). On the other hand, in Christianity demons have no possible way of blackmailing God. They cannot attain more power than they were left with at the fall. Neither angels nor demons could ever represent a threat for God. According to Christianity, such a power as that attained by the Hindu demons cannot be attained by any creature in our world, by any possible way of asceticism. Power can only be given by God, in a limited measure, and only in order to recognize the true source of power, who is God himself.

Who did the divine incarnation came to save, gods or humans?

In Hinduism not only can demons force the gods to admit their merits, but the descent of the divine into human form is more concerned with saving the world of the gods than that of humans. For instance, there are 8 avatars (no. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8 and 9) involved in saving the world of gods from the power attained by demons, while only 6 (no. 1, 3, 4, 6, 7 and 8) are concerned with saving humans. This proves that the gods have a very fragile position and are more concerned about themselves than the problems of humankind. In Christianity the idea of God becoming incarnate to save Himself is absurd. God is not affected at all by anything demons could do. From this point of view, the coming of Christ could never have occurred as necessary. The only purpose of God's incarnation in Jesus Christ is the salvation of humans from the effect of sin. The problem in Christianity is not that demons are a threat to God, but that man has chosen to disobey God. Through the act of the divine incarnation man can gain a chance to return to personal communion with his Creator.

How does the divine incarnation save?

Usually the Hindu avatar kills the demon (no. 3, 4, 7, 8, only the demon-king Bali is spared and sent to hell by no. 5). The killing is performed with much caution, so that the promises made by the god Brahma should not be broken. However, due to reincarnation this "killing" is not of much effect, being only a limited solution to the problem of evil. On the other hand, in Christianity, Jesus Christ didn't literally kill Satan. In accordance with the sacrificial system of the Old Testament, Jesus let Himself be crucified for our sake. This was the "gift of God" (Romans 6,23) as ransom for our sins, a chance offered to us to be set free from the power of Satan and sin. According to the Bible, the final destruction of demons' power will only occur at the judgment day (Revelation 20,10).

Contradictory aspects of the Hindu avatars

A weird fact to mention here is the conflicts between two contemporary avatars of the Treta Yuga (Parasurama and Ramachandra). How can this be? How could two incarnations of the same god wrestle with one another? Isn't each avatar under divine control? Why didn't the first Rama leave in time? Or why couldn't he solve the problem for which the next avatar came, if he was present anyway in the world? On the other hand, how could the gods cooperate with demons at the time of the second avatar's (Kurma) coming? How is it possible to become allies and to be both threatened by the absence of amrita? This leads us to believe that both gods and demons are of the same nature and use the same source of power.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/avatars.html (4 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:24 AM] The divine incarnation in Hinduism and Christianity

Could Jesus Christ be assimilated with a Hindu avatar?

Christianity is a religion that breaks into history, presenting Jesus Christ as a historical God-man who was born, lived and died nearly 2.000 years ago. If his life were not a unique historical event, His whole teaching would be absurd. His claims, miracles, passion and resurrection, if taken out of history, leave nothing to Christianity. On the other hand, Hinduism is not concerned with historicism, so it can accept any tales of the repeated divine incarnation. The spiritual message of the avatars is the only element that matters, not their historical presence. Having this mindset, Hindus accept Jesus Christ as an avatar (of the Western world) with a powerful message, but being nothing more than any other avatar. On the one hand, Hinduism is very syncretistic, including even Buddha among the avatars, the one who rejected the basic tenets of Hinduism. On the other hand, Christianity is very exclusivistic when it comes to characterizing the descent of the divine into human form. Jesus Christ cannot be just another avatar, a mere variant of an eternal myth. This would deprive Him of His true identity. His passion, death on the cross and resurrection give Him a totally different portrait than the Hindu avatars. Rabindranath Maharaj summarized it in his book Death of a Guru in the following words: Jesus said he is the way, not a way; so that eliminates Krishna and everyone else. He did not come to destroy sinners - like Krishna said of himself - but to save them. And no one else could. Jesus is not just one of many gods. He is the only true God, and he came to this earth as a man, not just to show us how to live but to die for our sins. Krishna never did that. And Jesus was resurrected, which never happened to Krishna or Rama or Shiva - in fact, they never existed. (R. Maharaj Death of a Guru, Philadelphia, A.J. Holman Co., 1977, p. 148)

Jesus Christ and other Saviors and religious founders

Suggested links:

On Jesus and Mahomed: The Person of Christ in the Gospel and the Quran, by Abd al-Fadi Christ in Islam and Christianity, by John Gilchrist

On Jesus and Gotama Buddha: Buddha and Christ, by Prof. Johannes Aagaard

On Jesus as a Gnostic teacher of wisdom: Gnosticism and the Gnostic Jesus, by Douglas Groothuis

Easter: Myth, Hallucination, or History?, by Edwin Yamauchi. It examines the evidences for claiming that the Resurrection of Christ is a myth patterned after the prototypes of dying and rising fertility gods.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/avatars.html (5 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:48:24 AM] How can those who never heard about Christ be saved?

How can those who never heard about Christ be saved?

This question is a natural result when Christians state that Jesus Christ’s sacrifice on the cross is the only possibility for man’s salvation. From the very beginning, we have to emphasize an important aspect when dealing with this issue: Such a question can be raised only by those who have heard about Jesus Christ, but in most cases do not accept Him as Savior. Consequently, they use it as an excuse for ignoring their responsibility toward Christ and for adhering either to atheism or to other religions. It is obvious that none of the readers of this site belongs to the category of those who never heard about Christ, as the entire Western history and culture has a Christian background. However, finding a proper answer to this question is important for many people today. It may help them understand better the fact that Christ’s sacrifice is indeed the solution for any human in this world, including those who lived prior to his incarnation, or after this event, in geographical areas not reached by Christian missionaries. Two extremes should be avoided when addressing the salvation of those who have never heard about Christ. First, if humans could be saved only by hearing about Him, the multitudes which never had this chance during their lifetime would necessarily be damned to eternal suffering in hell. It is obvious that this cruel kind of God cannot be the God who died for them on the cross as absolute proof of His love. If He is all-loving, all-knowing and all-powerful, He must have a solution for those who have never heard about His final revelation in Jesus Christ. Second, if all other religions were valid ways to God, the Christian claim of Christ’s sacrifice on the cross being the only possibility for man’s salvation should be rejected. If any human could have worked out his salvation by performing righteous deeds, rituals, meditations, etc., as his native religion requires, God shouldn’t have adopted such a dramatic and absurd solution for our sins as the crucifixion. The rise of Christianity as a new world religion would have been useless, and Jesus only one savior among many. However, Jesus Himself claimed to be the only possibility for any human’s salvation and reconciliation with God. He said: “I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14,6). He commanded his disciples to go and proclaim this truth in the entire world (Matthew 28,18-20; Mark 16,15-16) and they did it (Acts 4,12). If other religions were as good as Christianity in attaining salvation, the effort of Christian missionaries would be absurd. Why would so many have sacrificed their lives, only to proclaim one of the many alternatives man has to reach God? Therefore we cannot sacrifice the importance of Jesus’ atonement on the altar of modern syncretism. According to Christianity, salvation is provided only as a result of the specific historical acts performed by Jesus Christ in His life, death on the cross, resurrection and ascension. What He did is absolutely

http://www.comparativereligion.com/neverheard.html (1 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:48:35 AM] How can those who never heard about Christ be saved? essential for the salvation of any human being who has ever lived, whether thousands of years BC or nowadays. Without Christ, no human could ever share eternal life with God. As a result of the above considerations, we have to face a dilemma: Jesus Christ is the only way to God, but it cannot be possible that only those who have heard about Him can be saved. Salvation must be available also for those who haven't heard about Christ. The element which solves this dilemma is the criteria according to which God will judge those who never heard about Christ and grant them salvation. The Bible states that God is holy and will judge humans with justice (Acts 17,31), according to the available measure of revelation they had and their response to it, expressed through their deeds (Romans 2,6), words (Matthew 12,36-37) and thoughts (Hebrews 4,12). The amount of revelation one has determines a consequent measure of responsibility on his part (Luke 12,47-48). In the Western world, anyone has elementary knowledge about Christianity, and therefore the terms of one's salvation are clear. As to those who never had the chance to hear the Christian message, it is obvious that their judgment will require other criteria than responding to the historical Jesus Christ. God’s desire for all humans to be saved cannot be questioned. The Apostle Paul states: “God wants all men to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2,4). The same is stated by the Apostle Peter (2 Peter 3,9). The important thing to clarify, then, is how does God show His grace to those who die without ever having heard about Jesus Christ?

General revelation

There is no doubt that any human has been presented God’s general revelation, which is through nature, conscience and culture. According to how they respond to it, the Apostle Paul proves (in the first three chapters of his Epistle to the Romans) that all humans are sinful and deserve condemnation, even in the absence of any coherent Christian message. This is the result of consciously rejecting general revelation; both the external one, that of creation, and the internal one, that of conscience. Creation is by itself a testimony about the Creator available to any human, as a kind of symbolic preaching that anyone can understand: For since the creation of the world God's invisible qualities - his eternal power and divine nature - have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse (Romans 1,20). Out of all things that have been made by Him, man is the highest of all. Man was created in God's image and likeness, as a personal agent that is now in search of meaning and fulfillment. If the external revelation of nature is not enough, then the internal one, that of conscience, is even more significant. Man’s conscience knows intuitively God’s moral standards and warns when they are trespassed: Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law, they are a law for themselves, even though they do not have the law, since they show that the requirements of the law are written on their hearts, their consciences also bearing witness, and their thoughts now accusing, now even defending them (Romans 2,14-15). Anyone who performs evil is consciously acting contrary to the demands of his conscience. (However, conscience can become perverted itself, but only after a process of constantly rejecting its natural right demands.) The true problem of man is not the lack of revelation, but a wrong way of responding to it

http://www.comparativereligion.com/neverheard.html (2 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:48:35 AM] How can those who never heard about Christ be saved? (Romans 1,21-23). Therefore, God could find enough reasons to judge and condemn those who never heard about Christ. Due to the fact that He could condemn them on the basis of their response to general revelation, the next point is to see how they could still be saved.

Grace attributed retroactively

If those who never heard about Christ could be saved only as a result of their response to general revelation, we should also accept that salvation can be attained as a reward for one’s good deeds. But the Bible states clearly that nobody can earn his salvation through morality or good deeds (Ephesians 2,8-9). However, the Bible also speaks about people who never heard about Christ but still are saved (Hebrews 11). Before analyzing these cases, it should be emphasized that if salvation depended exclusively on how much information one had about Christ, we would fall into the trap of Gnosticism (salvation through attaining right knowledge). Knowledge doesn't save us, but only God, as we respond in faith to His revelation, no matter how limited it might be. God does not limit His grace to those who have enough information of Him. As the examples mentioned in The Letter to the Hebrews (chapter 11) prove, the salvation of those who never heard about Christ depends on two basic requirements: 1) their response to the amount of revelation they had, which is their responsibility; 2) the retroactive conferring of Christ’s sacrifice, on the basis of the faith they manifested through properly responding to general revelation, which is God’s responsibility. Let us analyze how this works. The 11th chapter of the Letter to the Hebrews gives many examples of people who lived in the Old Testament time and were saved without hearing about Jesus Christ. Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Rahab, David and others, are all considered heroes of faith, despite the fact that none of them heard about Christ. Jacob (Genesis 49,10), Moses (Deuteronomy 18,15) and David (Psalm 22) prophesied about His coming, but didn’t understand too much about its soteriological value. Others like Rahab (Joshua 2,1-21; Hebrews 11,31), Naaman the Syrian (2 Kings 5,1-19; Luke 4,27), Melchizedek (Genesis 14,17-20; 7,2,15-17) and Jethro, the father-in-law of Moses (Exodus 18), were saved although they didn’t even belong to the people of Israel. They accepted the small amount of revelation they got, responded in faith and as a result God conferred on them the atoning sacrifice of Christ. Faith is the key element here. It means trusting in the promises of God and responding through effective action to His initiative (Hebrews 11,1-3). Faith is not limited to understanding the doctrine of atonement, but rather engaging in a trusting relationship with God. While analyzing these famous examples of the Old Testament, we can observe the various kinds of revelation they had from God: Noah was warned about the imminent coming of the flood; his response proved his faith in God’s promise to save him together with his family (Genesis 6-9). Abraham trusted God’s promise that he would be blessed with a son and become the ancestor of a big nation (Genesis 12-22; Hebrews 11,8-19). God proclaimed him righteous because of his faith: “Abram believed the Lord, and He credited it to him as righteousness” (Genesis 15,6). Isaac, Jacob and Joseph, the descendants of Abraham, trusted in God and were blessed. Moses trusted that God would free the Jewish nation from Egyptian bondage and lead them into the Promised Land (Hebrews 11,20-22). Not only people belonging to the chosen people of Israel were saved in the Old Testament time, but also Gentiles. Melchizedek was called “priest of the God Most High” (Genesis 14,18) without having any blood relation to Abraham. He worshipped the same God, and Abraham even paid tithes to him. Jethro,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/neverheard.html (3 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:48:35 AM] How can those who never heard about Christ be saved? the father-in-law of Moses, finding out what God has done through the Jewish nation, accepted by faith that the God of Moses is the true god. Rahab, the prostitute (!), hearing about the approaching of Israel, risked her life in order to hide the Jewish scouts (Joshua 2,1-21; Hebrews 11,31). This was the effective way she expressed her faith in the true God and therefore was counted among the heroes of faith. Naaman the Syrian (2 Kings 5,1-19; Luke 4,27) banished his pride when he understood who the true God is, showing his faith by his decision to abandon idolatry. All these people of the Old Testament, heroes of faith, have not been saved through their merits, but through the grace of Christ’s sacrifice on the cross, retroactively attributed to them. Their faith was the instrument through which God granted them salvation, the same instrument He uses today for all people who accept the sacrifice of Christ as the atoning solution for their sins (Hebrews 11,39-40). Although the type of revelation differs (today we have available the final revelation of God, through Christ), the object of faith remains the same - God, and the basis of His forgiveness cannot be other than Christ’s sacrifice. For both those who lived before and after Jesus’ crucifixion, God’s forgiveness was always granted through grace and not by one’s own merits, and the proper way of accepting grace was and will always be faith. The sacrifice of Christ is the element that validates the faith of humans who lived both before and after His incarnation.

Neither those who lived prior to the incarnation of Christ, nor those living after His death but without knowing anything about it, can be saved exclusively through their religion. A clear example is that of Naaman the Syrian, who had leprosy. The prophet Elisha didn’t suggest that he should bring more sacrifices to the Syrian god Rimmon, didn’t encourage him to be more honest and devoted to his native religion, but sent him to the Jordan River. By his initial refusal, Naaman is a symbol of man’s opposition toward God’s special revelation. The desire to earn salvation (in Naaman’s case through bathing in the holy Syrian rivers, making offerings, etc.) is a natural product of a false religion. Very often the adherents of Eastern religions fit into this category. They refuse God’s grace, claiming to be able to attain salvation (liberation) by their own efforts. However, God cannot validate this effort, as it is a product of pride, of man’s attitude of independence toward God. Following the ancient promise “you will be like God” (Genesis 3,5), by using a great variety of teachings and techniques, more or less sophisticated, while refusing grace, cannot be a valid way to God.

Salvation for those who never heard about Christ but accept the importance of grace

The above considerations do not imply that all those who don’t know anything else than their native religion are automatically condemned. There have been enough spiritual masters who recognized the necessity of grace and the impossibility of reaching salvation by one’s own efforts. Ramanuja and

http://www.comparativereligion.com/neverheard.html (4 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:48:35 AM] How can those who never heard about Christ be saved? Madhva are brilliant examples in the Hindu tradition, as is Shantideva in Mahayana Buddhism. More than that, the entire spiritual trend called prapatti in Hinduism, or the Pure Land school of Buddhism, focuses on grace as the only solution for attaining liberation. According to them, the whole merit for getting saved belongs to the god (in Hinduism) or bodhisattva (in Buddhism) they worship. There are also many cases of tribal religions in which grace plays a key role in salvation. The God who reveals Himself in the Bible knows man’s inner attitude and his motivation for performing certain religious duties. All efforts which point toward self-justification are of no value, no matter how impressive they could be. However, if man’s attitude is one of humility, recognizance of his own weakness, and acceptance of grace, which God offers unconditionally, the situation in completely different. We have observed this attitude in the prapatti devotional trend of Hinduism, which demands giving up the control of one's personal life to the god Vishnu and leaving to him all responsibility for attaining salvation. The adherent of this trend has to acknowledge that he is not good enough to deserve liberation by performing rituals and moral obligations. As mentioned in a previous file, the whole prapatti philosophy can be summarized in the following verse, written by Vedanta Deshika, a 14th century follower of Ramanuja: Lord, I, who am nothing, conform to your will and desist being contrary to it, and with faith and prayer, submit to you the burden of saving my soul (Nyasadashaka 2). The same is the case with the Pure Land School of Mahayana Buddhism, which flourished in Japan. According to its doctrine, the bodhisattva Amida (the Buddha of Infinite Light) is able to save even the most despised sinner by his grace (tariki). To reach his paradise by human efforts (performing meditation or good deeds) is impossible. This can be attained only through Amida’s grace. Such spiritual trends in other religions prove that the Holy Spirit is at work in the world, convincing people of their sin and turning their hearts toward God. According to the character displayed by the God of Christianity, He will save such people, by the grace available for all in Jesus Christ. They will be saved not through their native religion, but despite of it, as a reward for their humility and recognition of the need for grace. If there are many or few people in this category we cannot know. A classic example of how people belonging to cultures completely foreign to the Judeo-Christian world can still have a revelation of God and meet him is the Magi from the east mentioned in Matthew 2,1-12. Despite the fact that they were astrologers and probably believed that human destiny is shaped by the stars, which is contrary to biblical teaching, they still were granted a special revelation from God regarding His major intervention on earth to save humankind from sin. They worshipped Jesus as King of the Jews and brought Him gifts worthy of a king. Some theological speculations see the gifts as pointing to His divine nature (gold), His divine priesthood (incense) and sacrifice (myrrh was used for embalming). Their coming to Judea was obviously not customary. It was not a rule for the Magi to worship the kings there at their birth. This episode was rather a surprise for all, and a serious reason for Herod to feel his throne threatened. This example shows that God can use unorthodox methods to reveal Himself to those who are completely foreign to His revelation in the Bible. He has sufficient means to do it all over the earth. The most important factor, again, is human response to His revelation, as the Magi could have ignored the Bethlehem star. However, their journey proves their faith and brings them to worship the true God. Man’s problem has never been the lack of revelation, but only pride and refusal to change his attitude towards grace. People do not respond to the amount of revelation they already have; they know what to

http://www.comparativereligion.com/neverheard.html (5 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:48:35 AM] How can those who never heard about Christ be saved? do, but refuse to do it. Most of Jesus’ contemporaries rejected Him because they refused to believe, despite all fulfilled prophecies, miracles, healings and even His resurrection. The Parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus (Luke 16,19-31) is extremely relevant here. People are given everything they need in order to be saved, but if they refuse the available revelation, they are fully responsible for it and cannot be justified at God’s judgment. The crucifixion of Jesus Christ tells us that man lacks any chance to please God by his own efforts, that God’s grace in Jesus was an absolute necessity and His love for us was big enough to save us from the spiritual disaster to which our illusory independence would have brought us. One more aspect should be addressed here: If people can be saved without ever hearing about Christ, does it mean that Christian missions are futile? There are two important reasons to reject this hypothesis. Before mentioning them, it should be acknowledged that if the salvation of tribes living in remote areas depended entirely on missionaries’ preaching, a lot of people will suffer eternal damnation in hell only because Christian missionaries didn’t manage to reach their part of the world in time. More than that, in many cases the disobedience of Christians to go into remote parts of the world would be responsible for that. However, condemning people to hell because of the sin of some Christians isn’t at all consistent with God’s perfect justice and love for the lost. There are two important reasons for Christian mission in the world. First, Jesus himself commanded it (Matthew 28,18-20). He is the final revelation of God and His message of salvation has to be proclaimed “to the ends of the earth” (Acts 1,8). That people can be saved without hearing about Christ is only a temporary solution, which operates only until His message will reach all humans. Second, all people should share the fullness and blessings of the Christian life, not only in eternity, but also during this present earthly life. The love of God in a personal relation with Him and also in the Christian community can be experienced starting from now, as Jesus came to redeem our earthly life as well. In conclusion, God didn’t leave the world without a proper testimony about Him (Acts 14,17) and doesn’t condemn anybody without first revealing His grace. Although this article on the question “How can those who never heard about Christ be saved?" may not satisfy some of you, remember that nobody’s salvation depends on how convincing such an answer could be. The sacrifice of Christ on the cross is and remains the only ground for human salvation. Rejecting it (by those who heard about Him) cannot be justified by the lack of intellectual satisfaction one gets from polemical debates foreign to our spiritual context.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/neverheard.html (6 of 6) [10/27/2000 9:48:35 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism

The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism

Most of you know the Parable of the Prodigal Son as it appears in Luke's gospel, but probably few are aware that it has a Buddhist parallel in one of the major writings of Mahayana Buddhism. Although both parables seem to convey a similar message regarding God's compassion for humans, a closer look will reveal fundamental differences in their teaching and consequently between Christianity and Buddhism. Let us quote both parables and then analyze them. First, here is the text in the Gospel According to Luke: There was a man who had two sons. The younger one said to his father, "Father, give me my share of the estate." So he divided his property between them. Not long after that, the younger son got together all he had, set off for a distant country and there squandered his wealth in wild living. After he had spent everything, there was a severe famine in that whole country, and he began to be in need. So he went and hired himself out to a citizen of that country, who sent him to his fields to feed pigs. He longed to fill his stomach with the pods that the pigs were eating, but no one gave him anything. When he came to his senses, he said, "How many of my father's hired men have food to spare, and here I am starving to death! I will set out and go back to my father and say to him: Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son; make me like one of your hired men." So he got up and went to his father. But while he was still a long way off, his father saw him and was filled with compassion for him; he ran to his son, threw his arms around him and kissed him. The son said to him, "Father, I have sinned against heaven and against you. I am no longer worthy to be called your son." But the father said to his servants, "Quick! Bring the best robe and put it on him. Put a ring on his finger and sandals on his feet. Bring the fattened calf and kill it. Let's have a feast and celebrate. For this son of mine was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found." So they began to celebrate. Meanwhile, the older son was in the field. When he came near the house, he heard music and dancing. So he called one of the servants and asked him what was going on. "Your brother has come," he replied, "and your father has killed the fattened calf because he has him back safe and sound." The older brother became angry and refused to go in. So his father went out and pleaded with him. But he answered his father, "Look! All these years I've been slaving for you and never disobeyed your orders. Yet you never gave me even a

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (1 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism young goat so I could celebrate with my friends. But when this son of yours who has squandered your property with prostitutes comes home, you kill the fattened calf for him!" "My son," the father said, "you are always with me, and everything I have is yours. But we had to celebrate and be glad, because this brother of yours was dead and is alive again; he was lost and is found." (Luke 15:11-32)

The Buddhist parable is longer: A young man left his father and ran away. For long he dwelt in other countries, for ten, or twenty, or fifty years. The older he grew, the more needy he became. Wandering in all directions to seek clothing and food, he unexpectedly approached his native country. The father had searched for his son all those years in vain and meanwhile had settled in a certain city. His home became very rich; his goods and treasures were fabulous. At this time, the poor son, wandering through village after village and passing through countries and cities, at last reached the city where his father had settled. The father had always been thinking of his son, yet, although he had been parted from him over fifty years, he had never spoken of the matter to anyone. He only pondered over it within himself and cherished regret in his heart, saying, "Old and worn out I am. Although I own much wealth - gold, silver, and jewels, granaries and treasuries overflowing - I have no son. Some day my end will come and my wealth will be scattered and lost, for I have no heir. If I could only get back my son and commit my wealth to him, how contented and happy would I be, with no further anxiety!" Meanwhile the poor son, hired for wages here and there, unexpectedly arrived at his father's house. Standing by the gate, he saw from a distance his father seated on a lion-couch, his feet on a jeweled footstool, and with expensive strings of pearls adorning his body, revered and surrounded by priests, warriors, and citizens, attendants and young slaves waiting upon him right and left. The poor son, seeing his father having such great power, was seized with fear, regretting that he had come to this place. He reflected, "This must be a king, or someone of royal rank, it is impossible for me to be hired here. I had better go to some poor village in search of a job, where food and clothing are easier to get. If I stay here long, I may suffer oppression." Reflecting thus, he rushed away. Meanwhile the rich elder on his lion-seat had recognized his son at first glance, and with great joy in his heart reflected, "Now I have someone to whom I may pass on my wealth. I have always been thinking of my son, with no means of seeing him, but suddenly he himself has come and my longing is satisfied. Though worn with years, I yearn for him." Instantly he sent off his attendants to pursue the son quickly and fetch him back. Immediately the messengers hasten forth to seize him. The poor son, surprised and scared, loudly cried his complaint, "I have committed no offense against you, why should I be arrested?" The messengers all the more hastened to lay hold of him and brought him back. Following that, the poor son, thought that although he was innocent he would be imprisoned, and that now he would surely die. He became all the more terrified, fainted away and fell on the ground. The father, seeing this from a distance, sent word to the messengers, "I have no need for this man. Do not bring him by force. Sprinkle cold water on his face to restore him to consciousness and do not speak to him any further." Why? The

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (2 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism father, knowing that his son's disposition was inferior, knowing that his own lordly position had caused distress to his son, yet convinced that he was his son, tactfully did not say to others, "This is my son." A messenger said to the son, "I set you free, go wherever you will." The poor son was delighted, thus obtaining the unexpected release. He arose from the ground and went to a poor village in search of food and clothing. Then the elder, desiring to attract his son, set up a device. Secretly he sent two men, sorrowful and poor in appearance, saying, "Go and visit that place and gently say to the poor man, 'There is a place for you to work here. We will hire you for scavenging, and we both also will work along with you.'" Then the two messengers went in search of the poor son and, having found him, presented him the above proposal. The poor son, having received his wages in advance, joined them in removing a refuse heap. His father, beholding the son, was struck with compassion for him. One day he saw at a distance, through the window, his son's figure, haggard and drawn, lean and sorrowful, filthy with dirt and dust. He took off his strings of jewels, his soft attire, and put on a coarse, torn and dirty garment, smeared his body with dust, took a basket in his right hand, and with an appearance fear-inspiring said to the laborers, "Get on with your work, don't be lazy." By such means he got near to his son, to whom he afterwards said, "Ay, my man, you stay and work here, do not leave again. I will increase your wages, give whatever you need, bowls, rice, wheat-flour, salt, vinegar, and so on. Have no hesitation; besides there is an old servant whom you can get if you need him. Be at ease in your mind; I am, as it were, your father; do not be worried again. Why? I am old and advanced in years, but you are young and vigorous; all the time you have been working, you have never been deceitful, lazy, angry or grumbling. I have never seen you, like the other laborers, with such vices as these. From this time forth you will be as my own begotten son." The elder gave him a new name and called him a son. But the poor son, although he rejoiced at this happening, still thought of himself as a humble hireling. For this reason, for twenty years he continued to be employed in scavenging. After this period, there grew mutual confidence between the father and the son. He went in and out and at his ease, though his abode was still in a small hut. Then the father became ill and, knowing that he would die soon, said to the poor son, "Now I possess an abundance of gold, silver, and precious things, and my granaries and treasuries are full to overflowing. I want you to understand in detail the quantities of these things, and the amounts that should be received and given. This is my wish, and you must agree to it. Why? Because now we are of the same mind. Be increasingly careful so that there be no waste." The poor son accepted his instruction and commands, and became acquainted with all the goods. However, he still had no idea of expecting to inherit anything, his abode was still the original place and he was still unable to abandon his sense of inferiority. After a short time had again passed, the father noticed that his son's ideas had gradually been enlarged, his aspirations developed, and that he despised his previous state of mind. Seeing that his own end was approaching, he commanded his son to come, and gathered all his relatives, the kings, priests, warriors, and citizens. When they were all assembled, he addressed them saying, "Now, gentlemen, this is my son, begotten by me. It is over fifty years since, from a certain city, he left me and ran away to endure loneliness and misery. His former name was so-and-so and my name was so-and-so. At that time in that city I http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (3 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism sought him sorrowfully. Suddenly I met him in this place and regained him. This is really my son and I am really his father. Now all the wealth which I possess belongs entirely to my son, and all my previous disbursements and receipts are known by this son." When the poor son heard these words of his father, great was his joy at such unexpected news, and thus he thought, "Without any mind for, or effort on my part, these treasures now come to me." World-honored One! The very rich elder is the Tathagata, and we are all as the Buddha's sons. The Buddha has always declared that we are his sons. But because of the three sufferings, in the midst of births-and-deaths we have borne all kinds of torments, being deluded and ignorant and enjoying our attachment to things of no value. Today the World-honored One has caused us to ponder over and remove the dirt of all diverting discussions of inferior things. In these we have hitherto been diligent to make progress and have got, as it were, a day's pay for our effort to reach nirvana. Obtaining this, we greatly rejoiced and were contented, saying to ourselves, "For our diligence and progress in the Buddha-law what we have received is ample". The Buddha, knowing that our minds delighted in inferior things, by his tactfulness taught according to our capacity, but still we did not perceive that we are really Buddha's sons. Therefore we say that though we had no mind to hope or expect it, yet now the Great Treasure of the King of the Law has of itself come to us, and such things that Buddha-sons should obtain, we have all obtained.

(Saddharmapundarika Sutra 4)

The parable in its context

In Luke, the parable reveals the nature of God in Christianity, His expectation that all sinners may return to a father-son relationship with Him. Jesus told this parable to a large public consisting of both "religious experts" of the day, the Pharisees, and the people most despised by them, the tax collectors, prostitutes and other outcasts (Luke 15,1-2). The Pharisees considered these "sinners" to be outside the acceptable boundary of God's kingdom and accused Jesus for enjoying their company. In contrast to their attitude, He told the previous two parables in the same chapter (The Lost Sheep and The Lost Coin), in order to emphasize His initiative in seeking and saving such sinners. In response, they acknowledged their sinful life and came to Jesus for healing and forgiveness, while the Pharisees considered themselves good enough according to God's standards (see the Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector - Luke 18:9-14). Thus the Parable of the Prodigal Son reveals both God's love for those who were ready to accept it (the prodigal son who returns to his father), and His rejection of the Pharisees' hypocrisy and self-centered righteousness (the older son in the parable). Although the contrast between the two sons is an important point in the parable, as the Buddhist parable speaks only of a prodigal son, the teaching about the older son in Luke will be ignored in this comparison. * The Buddhist parable is part of the famous Saddharmapundarika Sutra (also called the Lotus Sutra, composed at the end of the second century AD), which revealed the new teaching of Mahayana Buddhism regarding the bodhisattva beings. The discourse of the Buddha is said to have taken place in front of a very large public, consisting of arhats, nuns, bodhisattvas, gods and other beings. His teaching

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (4 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism was addressed to those who have reached the arhat stage of becoming and are supposed to advance further by becoming a bodhisattva. As the son in the parable shouldn't be satisfied by his lower status, the Buddhist disciples should also aspire to a higher position, that of becoming a bodhisattva. It will eventually be attained step by step after a long instructing and testing process.

The characters

In the gospel the father represents God, the Ultimate Reality in Christianity, while the prodigal son is the one living in sin who finally repents and returns to a fellowship relation with God. In the Sutra the father is Buddha (or more specifically, the Buddha nature - Dharmakaya), while the son is the one struggling to become an enlightened bodhisattva being.

The son's departure and miserable condition

The prodigal son in Luke declares he has had enough of staying home in obedience to his father and wants to be on his own. Not only does he want to leave home, but he even dares to claim his inheritance, the fortune he is supposed to get at his father's death. Such a demand is extremely outrageous, especially in the Middle Eastern context. However, instead of rebuking or even denouncing his son, the father grants his request. Soon after this, the son left for a distant country and there he squandered his entire fortune in wild living. This probably was a quite new and interesting experience for him, but it brought him to bankruptcy. Now he had to find a job to make a living in that country, and the best offer he had was to feed someone's pigs. In a Jewish context, the pigs are considered unclean animals; therefore being hired to feed them and even being hungry enough to long for their food illustrates the worst possible situation one can reach. The spiritual meaning of the prodigal son's leaving his home is assimilated in Christianity with man's rebellion against God, his heavenly father. God does not oppose one's freedom of will in choosing how to live. As the son in the parable claimed his inheritance and then squandered it, humans use all that God has granted them (wealth, health, time and relationships) not for serving Him in obedience, but against His will. This attitude is called sin, and brings humans to the lowest possible stage of decadence. Although living in sin is first very attractive and pleasant, in the end it leads to destruction, both from an existential and a spiritual point of view. Another important observation here is that although the father in the parable gave a large fortune to his son, he was still rich after the son's departure. However, the father's only concern proved to be his son's personal safety and return to the family. His wealth plays no role for him. As the rich man in the parable didn't become poor by his son's departure, God does not lose anything by our decision to live in rebellion to Him. The only one who is losing everything is man. * The prodigal son of the Buddhist Sutra leaves home without any fortune from his father. His departure

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (5 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism looks more like running away in secrecy. He also becomes more and more needy but is still able to make a living. The father doesn't seem to have been rich at the moment of his son's departure. He rather became rich after this episode, in another city than the one in which he previously lived with his son. Therefore the son had no wealthy position to remember from home and to eventually return to. Even if he would have, the father had left it, so there was no place for him to return. Regarding the father's concern in this story, he seems more worried about having an heir than about making his son happy again. The meaning of the son's wandering in the Buddhist tale is that there is no initial position to lose in one's spiritual becoming. As the son leaves his home poor and remains poor, humans have no other inheritance than karma, which makes them wander from one bad incarnation to another. The only truth that governs human existence is suffering and karma, which leads to an endless wandering in the world, with no original position to return to. The only spiritual fulfillment is a permanent growth toward an impersonal liberation. This is the Buddhist treasure to be discovered by any cost.

The way back home

The prodigal son of the gospel finally "came to his senses" and acknowledged his dramatic condition. Ashamed, he planned to return to his father, confess his sin and ask to be hired as a servant. This position, no matter how humiliating it could be in front of his brother and the other servants, was a much better choice than staying with the pigs. The process of one's "coming to his senses" is called repentance in Christian theology. It involves acknowledging the bad condition of living in sin and making the decision to leave it. * The Buddhist prodigal son made no decision to return to his father. He continuously wandered from town to town until he unexpectedly arrived at his father's palace. The son didn't even recognize his father, whose situation had changed a lot since his departure. More than this, the father's wealth inspired fear in the son and made him try to run away again in order to not enter into more trouble. Eventually, at the father's command, the attendants seized him and brought him to the palace against his will. The son's wandering in the world can be interpreted as the effect of karma and reincarnation in one's life. They constantly push man on the one-way of becoming. However long the process of being reincarnated in different bodies may be, one has to finally reach liberation (that's why the attendants seize the son against his will). One constantly experiences suffering until he has to accept that the best solution for his life is nirvana. Although reaching the status of a bodhisattva (a being that helps other humans attain liberation) seems to confer a personal afterlife destiny, the ultimate stage of becoming is shunya, the void, where nothing personal can remain.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (6 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism What happens back home?

According to Luke's parable, the father was waiting for his prodigal son. He probably knew that the son couldn't find true satisfaction in what the world had to offer him. Instead of punishing him for his foolish behavior, "while he was still a long way off, his father saw him and was filled with compassion for him; he ran to his son, threw his arms around him and kissed him" (v. 20). Instead of humiliating the son as a repayment for the shame he cast on his father at departure, the father humiliates himself by running to meet him. Such a behavior was totally indignified according to Jewish standards of the time. After the son recited half of his prepared speech, acknowledging he was wrong, the father interrupted him and commanded the servants to bring him the best robe, put a ring on his finger and sandals on his feet. The fattened calf was slaughtered and a feast ordered to celebrate his return. All these symbols prove a 100% forgiveness and rehabilitation of the son to his prior status. The robe was a sign of great distinction, the ring the sign of authority, the sandals a luxury (only slaves were bare-footed) and the slaughter of the fattened calf the sign of a very important celebration in the family. Instead of becoming a hired servant as he hoped, the son was fully restored to the position he had abandoned long before. * The Sutra presents in a whole different way the prodigal son's return home. The father unexpectedly recognized him standing at his gate and sent his attendants to seize him and compel him to come to the palace. The son didn't understand the situation and became terrified. The father initially treated him like a stranger because of his "inferior disposition". A sudden restoration was out of the question. Understanding his son's mindset, the father set him free and managed that he be hired as a scavenger. Although filled with compassion, the father could not reveal his identity until the son deserved his proper place in the family. He met his son in disguise and encouraged him to be honest in his work in order to be promoted. He promised to increase his salary and provide for his basic needs. The son had first to prove high qualities before being accepted back into the family. So he lived for 20 years in a small hut while still being employed in scavenging. The testing process would have probably continued if the father hadn't become ill, feeling his death to be imminent. Even at this time the son was not fully accepted into the family but only promoted to a higher position, that of accountant over all his father's riches. Without abandoning his sense of inferiority, the son became acquainted with all the goods. Noticing that his son's ideas had gradually changed for the good and that he despised his former status, only then did the father gather all his relatives and friends and declare the former servant to be his son and heir.

The teaching of the parable in Christianity and Buddhism

The Christian meaning of the parable is clear. All humans need to return to God in repentance and faith. He does not compel humans to do it, so it must be a personal decision. God's forgiveness is not conditioned by attaining high spiritual performances but only by repentance. The price for our reconciliation with God was paid by Jesus Christ, through His death on the cross and His resurrection. There is nothing more to add and one life is enough to accept it. The parable depicts the amazing availability of God to forgive and restore us, His unlimited grace to

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (7 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism bestow upon us, His great love to accept us independently of our status and past. This should give us courage to come to Him in repentance and faith, without fear, and inherit His Kingdom, where personal communion with Him will be everlasting. * The Buddhist parable has a different message. Both the process of being liberated (acknowledged as son) and the meaning of liberation (inheriting the father's estate) have a different meaning. One cannot simply attain liberation at once. The process is very long and demands a progressive accumulation of wisdom until one deserves his place in the hierarchy. Escaping from ignorance and suffering, attaining nirvana and the becoming of a bodhisattva is a hard-to-win prize that has to be attained gradually by a day-by-day effort in training the mind and overcoming karma. Grace, in Buddhism, cannot be shown directly, but only as the disciple deserves it, which in fact is no grace at all. There is also a major difference from Christianity in defining the status of the liberated person. Personhood has no room in the system. Although the bodhisattva is a personal being, he acts as a temporary catalyst for the sake of other humans that they may also find nirvana. The true ultimate stage of spiritual progress is shunya, the void, where no personal communion can ever exist. It is the final blowing out of the candle. This means that an eternal communion with a Father in His Kingdom makes no sense in traditional Buddhism. Ultimately, there is no Father to have communion with.

The following table summarizes the teaching of the two parables and also reveals some basic contradictions between the two religions:

Topic in the parable Meaning in Christianity Meaning in Buddhism

The context Jesus is teaching sinners, Buddha is teaching spiritually emphasizing their need and advanced disciples (arhats) opportunity to be reconciled the need for attaining a higher with God. position, that of a bodhisattva.

The characters God and the sinners Buddha (the ultimate impersonal Buddha nature) and the ones struggling to attain it

The meaning of the son's The human attitude of Ignorance starts the wheel of departure from home rebellion against God, called karma. sin

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (8 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Christianity and Buddhism

The son's miserable condition The human condition under Karma and reincarnation force the power of sin, away from one to wander from one personal communion with physical existence to the next God

The decision to return home A personal decision to leave Karma and reincarnation lead sin, called repentance one to the proper level where wisdom and spiritual progress can be attained.

The father's attitude at the Complete forgiveness of sin Buddha's "grace" makes one son's arrival and restoration to personal progress little by little toward fellowship with God liberation. One has to deserve his position by a process of spiritual development.

Who pays the damage for the Jesus Christ paid the price for The disciple has to "pay lost fortune our forgiveness through His himself" the price for erasing death and resurrection. his ignorance, by constantly accumulating wisdom.

The son's inheritance Eternal communion with God Attaining an impersonal in His kingdom Ultimate Reality (shunya), where there is no room for personal communion

http://www.comparativereligion.com/prodigal.html (9 of 9) [10/27/2000 9:48:40 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity

REINCARNATION Its meaning and consequences

A) Reincarnation in world religions; B) Past-life recall as proof for reincarnation; C) Reincarnation and cosmic justice; D) Reincarnation and Christianity.

D) Reincarnation and Christianity

Today’s religious syncretism not only accepts reincarnation as one of its basic doctrines but also tries to prove that it can be found in the Bible and in the history of the Church. We will therefore analyze the basic texts in the Bible which are claimed to imply reincarnation, examine the position of some important Church fathers who were suspected of having accepted it, emphasize the basic antagonism of this doctrine with Christian teaching, and then find a proper explanation for the past life recall experiences mentioned earlier, an explanation that should be compatible with Christian thought.

Reincarnation and the Bible

Biblical texts that seem to imply reincarnation

The most "convincing" texts of this kind are the following: 1) Matthew 11,14 and 17,12-13, concerning the identity of John the Baptist; 2) John 9,2, "Who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?"; 3) John 3,3, "No one can see the kingdom of God unless he is born again"; 4) James 3,6, "the wheel of nature"; 5) Galatians 6,7, "A man reaps what he sows". 6) Matthew 26,52, ”all who draw the sword will die by the sword”. 7) Revelation 13,10, ”If anyone is to go into captivity, into captivity he will go. If anyone is to be killed with the sword, with the sword he will be killed.”

1. The first text concerns the identity of John the Baptist, supposed to be the reincarnation of the prophet Elijah. In Matthew 11,14 Jesus says: "And if you are willing to accept it, he (John the Baptist) is the Elijah who was to come." In the same Gospel, while answering the apostles about the coming of Elijah, Jesus told them: "But I tell you, Elijah has already come, and they did not recognize him, but have done

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (1 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity to him everything they wished. In the same way the Son of Man is going to suffer at their hands." The commentary adds: "Then the disciples understood that he was talking to them about John the Baptist." (Matthew 17,12-13; see also Mark 9,12-13) At first sight, it may seem that these verses imply the reincarnation of the prophet Elijah as John the Baptist. The prophecy of the return of Elijah was stated in the last verses of the Old Testament, in the book of the prophet Malachi (3,1; 4,5-6): "See, I will send you the prophet Elijah before that great and dreadful day of the Lord comes." Right before this prophecy was fulfilled, through the birth of John the Baptist, an angel announced to his father Zechariah: "And he will go on before the Lord, in the spirit and power of Elijah, to turn the hearts of the fathers to their children and the disobedient to the wisdom of the righteous-- to make ready a people prepared for the Lord" (Luke 1,17). What could be the meaning of the words "in the spirit and power of Elijah"? According to other Biblical passages that refer to Elijah and John the Baptist, they do not teach reincarnation. At the time when John the Baptist began his public preaching, the priests in Jerusalem asked him about his identity. They asked: "Are you Elijah?" (John 1,21) In such circumstances a true "guru" wouldn’t have hesitated to state his position in the succession of spiritual masters (the guru parampara) of the tradition he is representing. However, John the Baptist answered simply: "I am not." His negation suggests another meaning to the words quoted from Matthew 11,14 and 17,12-13. John the Baptist was rather a kind of Elijah, a prophet who had to repeat the mission of Elijah in a similar context. The same as Elijah did, John the Baptist had to suffer persecution from the royal house of Israel and acted in the context of the spiritual degeneration of the Jewish nation, with the mission of bringing the people back to the right worship of God. John the Baptist had the same spiritual mission as the prophet Elijah, but not the same soul or self. For this reason the expression "in the spirit and power of Elijah" should not be interpreted as reincarnation of a person, but as a necessary repetition of a well-known episode in the history of Israel. Another Biblical text that contradicts the reincarnation theory in this case is the story of Elijah’s departure from this world. Elijah didn’t die in the proper sense of the word, but "went up to heaven in a whirlwind" (2 Kings 2,11). According to the classic theory of reincarnation, a person has to die physically first in order that his self may be reincarnated in another body. In the case of Elijah this didn’t happen. So it must be considered an exception to both the natural process of death, and to the rule of reincarnation. Finally, the experience of the three apostles at the Mount of Transfiguration has to be remembered (Matthew 17,1-8, Mark 9,2-8; Luke 9,28-36), when Elijah was identified by the apostles without being confused with John the Baptist.

2. The next disputed text is the introduction to the healing of the man born blind in John 9,2. Considering the apostles' question: "Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?", it is obvious that the first option (the man was born blind because of his sin) implies that he could sin only in a previous life. According to the classic theory of reincarnation, he might have been a cruel dictator who got the just reward for his bad deeds. However, the apostles' question about the possibility of having sinned before birth should not necessarily be judged as indicating an existing belief in reincarnation at that time in Israel. It rather confirms that some religious factions believed that the fetus can sin in his mother womb. If Jesus had considered reincarnation to be true, surely He would have used this opportunity - as was His custom - to explain to them the law of karma and reincarnation, as an immediate application to that man’s situation. Jesus never missed such occasions to instruct his disciples on spiritual matters, and reincarnation would have been a

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (2 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity crucial doctrine for them to understand. Nevertheless, by the answer Jesus gave to them, He rejected both options suggested by the apostles. Both the idea of sinning before birth and the punishment for the parents' sins were wrong. Jesus said: "Neither this man nor his parents sinned, but this happened so that the work of God might be displayed in his life" (John 9,3). "The work of God" is described in the next verses, when Jesus healed the blind man as a proof of His divinity (v. 39).

3. In the Gospel According to John Jesus said to Nicodemus: "I tell you the truth, no one can see the kingdom of God unless he is born again" (John 3,3). Out of its context, this verse seems to suggest that reincarnation is the only possibility for attaining spiritual perfection and admission into the "kingdom of God". Nicodemus’ following question indicates that he understood by these words a kind of physical rebirth in this life, and not classic reincarnation: "How can a man be born when he is old? Surely he cannot enter a second time into his mother's womb to be born!" (v. 4). Jesus rejected the idea of physical rebirth and explained man’s need for spiritual rebirth, during this life, in order to be admitted into God’s kingdom in the afterlife. Jesus further explained the meaning of His words by referring to a well-known episode in Israel’s history: "Just as Moses lifted up the snake in the desert, so the Son of Man must be lifted up" (John 3,14). That episode occurred while the Israelites were traveling in the wilderness toward the Promised Land under the command of Moses (see Numbers 21,4-9). They spoke against God and against Moses, and then God punished them by sending poisonous snakes against them. Grasping the gravity of the situation, they recognized their sin and asked for a saving solution. God’s solution was that Moses had to make a bronze copy of such a snake and put it up on a pole. Those who had been bitten by a snake had to look at this bronze snake, believing that this symbol represented their salvation, and were healed. Coming back to the link Jesus made between that episode and His teaching, He said: "Just as Moses lifted up the snake in the desert, so the Son of Man must be lifted up, that everyone who believes in him may have eternal life" (John 3,14-15). In other words, as Moses lifted up the bronze snake 1400 years earlier, in the same way was He to be lifted up on the cross, in order to be the only solution, the only antidote to the deadly bite of sin. As the Jews had to believe that the bronze snake was their salvation from death, the same way had Nicodemus, his generation and the entire world to believe that Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross is the perfect solution provided by God for the sins of the world. Therefore the kind of rebirth Jesus was teaching (as well as Paul – see Titus 3,5) is not the Eastern concept of reincarnation but a spiritual rebirth that any human can experience in this life.

4. A fourth text interpreted as indicative for reincarnation is found in the Epistle of James 3,6, where some translations (such as the American Standard Version) mention "the wheel of nature" which seems to resemble the cycle of endless reincarnation stated by the Eastern religions. However, in this context the reference is made to the control of speech in order not to sin. The ASV translation states: "And the tongue is a fire: the world of iniquity among our members is the tongue, which defileth the whole body, and setteth on fire the wheel of nature, and is set on fire by hell." The tongue out of control is compared with a fire that affects all aspects of existence, thought and deed, in a vicious cycle. This means that sinful speech is at the origin of many other sins, which are consequently generated, and conduct man to hell. The NIV translation is clearer at this point: "The tongue also is a fire, a world of evil among the parts of the body. It corrupts the whole person, sets the whole course of his life on fire, and is itself set on

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (3 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity fire by hell."

5. A classic example of suggesting karma and samsara in the Bible is often claimed to be represented by the words of the Apostle Paul in Galatians: "Do not be deceived: God cannot be mocked. A man reaps what he sows" (Galatians 6,7). This "sowing and reaping" process would allegedly represent someone’s acts and their consequences as dictated by karma in further lives. However, the very next verse here indicates that the point here is judging the effects of our deeds from the perspective of eternal life, as stated in the Bible, without a further earthly existence being involved: "The one who sows to please his sinful nature, from that nature will reap destruction; the one who sows to please the Spirit, from the Spirit will reap eternal life" (6,8; see also the entire chapter). "Reaping destruction" means eternal separation from God in hell, while "eternal life" represents eternal communion with God in heaven. In their given context, these verses cannot suggest the reincarnation of the soul after death. According to Christianity, the supreme judge of our deeds is God, and not impersonal karma.

6. After Peter had cut off the ear of the high priest’s servant in his attempt to prevent Jesus’ arrest in Gethsemane, Jesus rebuked him by saying: "All who draw the sword will die by the sword" (Matthew 26,52). Could this be the justice of karma in action? All four gospels give account of Jesus’ rebuke to Peter’s initiative. Although heroic, it went against God’s plan ("How then would the Scriptures be fulfilled that say it must happen in this way?" – verse 54). Peter was in this case sinning and, according to the well-known Old Testament law of sin retribution, the sinner must be punished consistently ("Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed; for in the image of God has God made man" - Genesis 9,6; see also Exodus 21,23-25; Leviticus 24,19-20; Deuteronomy 19,21). However, throughout the Old Testament this law was referring solely to one’s present physical life, by no means to future lives. Otherwise Jesus’ words would lead to an absurd implication. If He meant that killing someone in this life with a sword will require that the doer will be killed at his turn with a sword in a future life, then His crucifixion (which followed soon after) must have been a punishment for His sins done in previous lives and not a solution for other people’s sins as He claimed.

7. "If anyone is to go into captivity, into captivity he will go. If anyone is to be killed with the sword, with the sword he will be killed" (Revelation 13,10). This verse belongs to a prophecy that speaks about the end times, when Satan and his subjects will have temporary power on earth. Adherents of reincarnation must be aware that it is a quotation from the Old Testament: "And if they ask you, 'Where shall we go?' tell them, 'This is what the LORD says: "'Those destined for death, to death; those for the sword, to the sword; those for starvation, to starvation; those for captivity, to captivity'" (Jeremiah 15,2). This sentence was written by Jeremiah just before the fall of Jerusalem and the Babylonian exile (586 BC) and expresses God’s punishment of the sinful Jewish nation at that time, which had rejected Him. It is not the impersonal law of karma here but the will of the personal creator God. He chooses how to punish those who have rejected Him. (See also Jeremiah 43,11, which uses the same words for announcing the punishment of Egypt for its sins.) The author of Revelation used this quotation for assuring those involved in the events to come that God will do justice again, as He did in the ancient times. Therefore they should act in "patient endurance and faithfulness" as Revelation 13,10 adds.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (4 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity * As it can be observed, in all situations where "Biblical proofs" for reincarnation are mentioned, the context is always ignored. Other passages used as indications of reincarnation mean, in fact, the existence of Christ prior to His human birth (John 8,58), the continuity of the souls' existence after death (John 5,28-29; Luke 16,22-23; 2 Corinthians 5,1), or the spiritual rebirth of believers in their present life (Titus 3,5; 1 Peter 1,23), without giving any plausible indication for reincarnation.

Did the clergy rewrite the Bible, so that the passages teaching reincarnation were removed?

Some people hold that the Bible contained many passages teaching reincarnation in an alleged initial form, but they were erased and forbidden by the clergy at the fifth ecumenical council, held in Constantinople in the year 533 AD. The reason for this would have been the spiritual immaturity of the Christians, who could not grasp the doctrine at that time, or the desire of the clergy to manipulate the masses. However, there is no proof that such "purification" of the Biblical text has ever occurred. The existing manuscripts, many of them older than AD 533, do not show differences from the text we use today. There are enough reasons to accept that the New Testament was not written later than the first century AD. In order to get more information on the accuracy of the present text of the Bible use the following sites: Dating the Oldest New Testament Manuscripts, by Peter van Minnen Textual Criticism and Manuscript Interpretation The Gospels As Historical Sources For Jesus, The Founder Of Christianity, by Prof. R. T. France At the same time, if the clergy had, as alleged, decided to erase from the Bible the "compromising" passages about reincarnation, why did they keep the ones mentioned above (concerning the identity of John the Baptist, etc.)? On the other hand, it is obvious that there are many texts in the Bible that clearly contradict the idea of reincarnation, explicitly or implicitly. (See for instance 2 Samuel 12,23; 14,14, Job 7,9-10, Psalm 78,39, Matthew 25,31-46, Luke 23,39-43, Acts 17,31, 2 Corinthians 5,1;4;8, Revelation 20,11-15.) Here is one verse in the New Testament which contradicts reincarnation as clearly as possible: Just as man is destined to die once, and after that to face judgment, so Christ was sacrificed once to take away the sins of many people; and he will appear a second time, not to bear sin, but to bring salvation to those who are waiting for him (Hebrews 9,27-28). The Christian teaching that we live only once is a fact beyond doubt, being as true as the fact that Jesus had to die only once for our sins. In other words, the unique historical act of Jesus’ crucifixion and the fact that we live only once are equally true and cannot be separated. This text cannot possibly be interpreted otherwise. The judgment that follows death is obviously not the judgment of the impersonal karma, but that of the personal almighty God, after which man either enters an eternal personal relation with Him in heaven, or an eternal separation from Him in hell.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (5 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity Did the early Church fathers believe in reincarnation?

Early Christianity spread in a world dominated by Greek philosophy. Many important figures of the early church had this spiritual background when they were converted. When addressing their world with the Christian message, they had to do it without any syncretistic compromise to Greek philosophy. To what extent could they have been influenced by the doctrine of reincarnation? In order to answer this, we first have to understand what was actually taught about reincarnation at that time.

Reincarnation according to Platonism

The dominant form of reincarnation known by ancient Greek philosophy during the first three Christian centuries belongs to Platonism. Unlike the Eastern spiritual masters, Plato taught that human souls existed since eternity in a perfect celestial world as intelligent and personal beings. They were not manifested out of a primordial impersonal essence (such as Brahman) or created by a personal god. Although the souls lived there in a pure state, somehow the divine love grew cold in them and, as a result, they fell in physical bodies to this earthly, imperfect world. Plato writes in Phaedrus about this: But when she

Origen and Origenism

The most controversial early church father concerning his alleged beliefs on reincarnation is undoubtedly

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (6 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity Origen (185-254). Many adherents of reincarnation mention him today as a classic example proving the alleged early Christian belief in reincarnation, which is supposed to have been condemned and forbidden by the fifth ecumenical council (Constantinople, 533 AD). Although it is a fact that Origen was strongly influenced by Platonism prior to his conversion to Christianity, the claim that he believed in reincarnation is absurd. Before using any quotes from his writings, we strongly advise you to read the file Origen and Origenism in order to get a brief description of Origen’s life, writings and teachings. This article will give you a sound perspective on what he actually taught and what was later condemned as Origenism. Then see the act of refuting Origenism by the fifth ecumenical council, The 15 Anathemas Against Origen. As it can easily be observed, there is no clear concept of reincarnation mentioned at this council of the early church, but only the Platonist ideas concerning the pre-existence of souls, besides universalism and a wrong form of Christology, as main heresies to be rejected. Origenism has incorporated these Platonistic ideas and they were condemned at the council of Constantinople, certainly not some classic form of reincarnation, as is claimed today. For instance, the fourth anathema states: If anyone shall say that the reasonable creatures in whom the divine love had grown cold have been hidden in gross bodies such as ours, and have been called men, while those who have attained the lowest degree of wickedness have shared cold and obscure bodies and are become and called demons and evil spirits: let him be anathema. The condemned ideas are very close related to what Plato has stated in Phaedrus. Therefore it cannot be stated that Origenism taught a classic form of reincarnation. In fact, Origen rejected plainly this doctrine in his Commentary on Matthew (Book XIII,1), written in the last years of his life. He refutes the speculation of considering John the Baptist the reincarnation of Elijah (Matthew 11,14; 17,12-13), a text we mentioned earlier. Origen writes: In this place it does not appear to me that by Elijah the soul is spoken of, lest I should fall into the dogma of transmigration, which is foreign to the church of God, and not handed down by the Apostles, nor anywhere set forth in the Scriptures; for it is also in opposition to the saying that "things seen are temporal," and that "this age shall have a consummation," and also to the fulfillment of the saying, "Heaven and earth shall pass away," and "the fashion of this world passeth away," and "the heavens shall perish," and what follows. In the same commentary, under the title "The spirit and power of Elijah" - not the soul - were in the Baptist, Origen adds: "For, observe, he did not say in the ‘soul’ of Elijah, in which case the doctrine of transmigration might have some ground, but ‘in the spirit and power of Elijah.’" Origen’s whole commentary on this text is a refutation of the reincarnation theory. Therefore it is obvious that he cannot be considered at all an "early Christian adherent of reincarnation".

Other early church fathers vs. Reincarnation

Here are some quotations from other early church fathers concerning their opinion on reincarnation, which prove that it cannot have been one of their beliefs. Use the links in order to get a larger picture on their writings.

Justin Martyr (100-165)

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (7 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity His opinion on reincarnation is plainly stated in the following fragment of his Dialogue with Trypho (155 AD), chapter 4, where he discusses Platonism with Trypho the Jew: Trypho: "'What, then, is the advantage to those who have seen [God]? Or what has he who has seen more than he who has not seen, unless he remember this fact, that he has seen?' Justin: "'I cannot tell,' I answered. Trypho: "'And what do those suffer who are judged to be unworthy of this spectacle?' said he. Justin: "'They are imprisoned in the bodies of certain wild beasts, and this is their punishment.' Trypho: "'Do they know, then, that it is for this reason they are in such forms, and that they have committed some sin?' Justin: "'I do not think so.' Trypho: "'Then these reap no advantage from their punishment, as it seems: moreover, I would say that they are not punished unless they are conscious of the punishment.' Justin: "'No indeed.' Trypho: "'Therefore souls neither see God nor transmigrate into other bodies; for they would know that so they are punished, and they would be afraid to commit even the most trivial sin afterwards. But that they can perceive that God exists, and that righteousness and piety are honourable, I also quite agree with you,' said he. Justin: "'You are right,' I replied.

Irenaeus (130-200)

In his well-known treatise Against Heresies (Book II), Irenaeus entitled the 33rd chapter "Absurdity of the Doctrine of the Transmigration of Souls". The whole chapter criticizes this doctrine, emphasizing the futility of an alleged reincarnation devoid of any memory of past lives: They (the souls) must of necessity retain a remembrance of those things which have been previously accomplished, that they might fill up those in which they were still deficient, and not by always hovering, without intermission, round the same pursuits, spend their labour wretchedly in vain.

Tertullian (145-220)

In his Treatise on the Soul (see ch. 28-33), Tertullian traces the origin of reincarnationist ideas down to Pythagoras. He writes: If, indeed, the sophist of Samos is Plato's authority for the eternally revolving migration of souls out of a constant alternation of the dead and the living states, then no doubt did the famous Pythagoras, however excellent in other respects, for the purpose of fabricating such an opinion as this, rely on a falsehood, which was not only shameful, but also hazardous. His conclusion is that "we must likewise contend against that monstrous presumption, that in the course of the transmigration beasts pass from human beings, and human beings from beasts".

Gregory of Nyssa (335-395)

Finally, the master theologian of that time rejected in his turn any idea of predestination (as an impersonal law like karma might impose) in his writing Against Fate, and also the concept of

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (8 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity reincarnation in the 28th chapter of his treatise On the Making of Man: Those who assert that the state of souls is prior to their life in the flesh, do not seem to me to be clear from the fabulous doctrines of the heathen which they hold on the subject of successive incorporation: for if one should search carefully, he will find that their doctrine is of necessity brought down to this. They tell us that one of their sages said that he, being one and the same person, was born a man, and afterwards assumed the form of a woman, and flew about with the birds, and grew as a bush, and obtained the life of an aquatic creature; - and he who said these things of himself did not, so far as I can judge, go far from the truth: for such doctrines as this of saying that one soul passed through so many changes are really fitting for the chatter of frogs or jackdaws, or the stupidity of fishes, or the insensibility of trees. (See also: Reincarnation - A Catholic Viewpoint. This well-researched article refutes the notion that the early church believed in reincarnation, using many references to support its argument; What did early Christians believe about reincarnation) All these early church fathers lived before the fifth ecumenical council (Constantinople, AD 533), so it cannot be true that the doctrine of reincarnation was condemned and forbidden only as a result of that council, as a brutal act of manipulating Christianity by the clergy. Although reincarnation was taught by some non-Christian movements of that time, such as the Gnostics and the Neo-Platonists, it has nothing in common with the teachings of the early church, being always rejected as heresy by the early church fathers.

Why cannot Christianity accept reincarnation?

The idea of reincarnation was never accepted by Christianity because it undermines its basic tenets. First, it renders futile God’s sovereignty over creation, transforming Him into a helpless spectator of the human tragedy. Because He is sovereign and omnipotent over creation, God can punish evil and will do it perfectly well at the end of history (see Matthew 25,31-46; Revelation 20,10-15). There is no need for impersonal karma and reincarnation to play this role. Second, believing in reincarnation may affect one’s understanding of morality and motivation for moral living. An extreme application of reincarnationist convictions could lead to adopting a detached stand to crime, theft, lying and other such social plagues. They could be considered nothing else but normal debts to be paid by their victims, originated in their previous lives. Following this reasoning, social injustice should not be punished at all in order to not complicate even more someone’s karmic debt. Therefore it is hard to believe that accepting reincarnation would transform us into better people, pursuing moral values with more conviction, as reincarnationists usually claim. The amorality proposed by Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita, the demand to act totally detached from what results, is the highest moral status that can be reached as the result of accepting karma and reincarnation. Third, reincarnation represents a threat to the very essence of Christianity: the need for Christ’s redemptive sacrifice for our sins. If we are to pay for the consequences of our sins ourselves in further lives and attain salvation through our own efforts, the sacrifice of Christ becomes useless and absurd. It wouldn’t be the only way back to God, but only a stupid accident of history. In this case Christianity would be a mere form of Hindu Bhakti-Yoga.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (9 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:53 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity As a result, no matter how many attempts are made today to find texts in the Bible or in the history of the Church that would allegedly teach reincarnation, they are all doomed to remain pure speculations.

If reincarnation isn’t true, how can the experiences of past life recall be explained?

An answer compatible with Christian theology can be found following the attempts of psychiatry to find an equivalence between evoking "personalities from past lives", by the use of hypnosis, and the multiple personality phenomenon. As was previously mentioned, there remains an unexplained element in the attempt to understand both phenomena on a purely naturalistic basis: How are the personalities distributed in their roles, or who decides which one is to act next in the show? It cannot be a random process. Using the words of Ian Wilson, "the show must have a ‘director’". Parapsychologists tend to attribute the "director’s" role to some personal external entities, which act through the process of channeling. Hypnosis generates perfect conditions for contacting these entities as a result of abolishing normal consciousness. Instead of presenting their true identity, they could introduce themselves as personalities evoked from previous lives. Until now enough cases of external spirit interference in producing reincarnation stories have been discovered. Most people are not aware of these undesirable parasitic attachments while recollecting alleged past lives stories. Those who are aware of them accept them as precious aids in the recollection process. The only reason for rejecting the hypothesis that past life recall stories are pure fiction invented by these entities is the sheer belief in their honesty. Now if we pass from the realm of parapsychology to Christian teaching, it appears obvious that such "external personal entities" exist, and have sufficient reason to lie us about spiritual reality. They are called demons and have developed most ingenious techniques to fool mankind about spiritual reality. The Apostle Paul states: And no wonder, for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light. It is not surprising, then, if his servants masquerade as servants of righteousness. Their end will be what their actions deserve (2 Corinthians 11,14-15). If we accept Biblical revelation, admitting that demons exist and do their best to fool us about spiritual reality, why not accept their possible involvement in producing reincarnation proofs, a concept that blatantly contradicts the essence of Christianity but at the same time fits well with their purpose? If the best conditions are created to express themselves through the person undergoing hypnosis (when self-consciousness is abolished), why should they not act? Why should they not respond to the invitation to fulfill their purpose in such a fascinating way for a credulous and ignorant public? The experience of spirit possession represents full or partial takeover of a human by an external spiritual entity (a demon). This phenomenon is known to most religions. The parasite spirit exerts control over the behavior, mental functioning and emotions of the person involved, being capable of producing sensations and symptoms in the physical body. This picture is obviously very close to what is happening during hypnotic regression. Why then reject its explanation as spirit possession and believe in past life recall? As to the information they produce from alleged previous lives in the form of historical accounts that correspond to some extent with reality (but always are most suited to win people’s trust), if humans know them, how much more are they available for demons? If humans are capable of creating historical

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (10 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:54 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity scenarios using the facts they know, how much more could demons prove equally creative? In the case of "spontaneous past life recall" by children, the mechanism could be similar. At the age when they recall the alleged past lives (generally between two and five years of age) their spiritual discernment is not formed yet, which makes them vulnerable to demon manipulation. In a previous section on this phenomenon we have seen that there are cases when the alleged soul’s reincarnation overlaps with the personality of the child, presenting typical symptoms of demonic possession. In conclusion, there is no possible way to reconcile Christianity and reincarnation. As Ian Stevenson, a well-known researcher of past life recall experiences, concluded in his book Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation that they are only "suggesting" reincarnation and not "proving" it. From a Christian perspective however, they rather suggest demon possession and therefore should not be used as a method of getting information on spiritual reality.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation3.html (11 of 11) [10/27/2000 9:48:54 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions

THE PROBLEM OF EVIL IN WORLD RELIGIONS

The problem of evil is a touchstone of any religion. Evil is present everywhere: in our society, in the environment, around us and even inside us. Out of our direct confrontation with evil results suffering, and thus endless questions about the meaning of life. That is why all religions have to give a proper answer regarding the origin, nature and end of evil. There are three major religious alternatives in explaining evil, stated by the pantheistic, dualistic and monotheistic religions. Pantheistic religions regard evil as ultimately unreal. Human suffering is a product of spiritual ignorance gathered in previous lives and distributed in the present one according to the dictates of karma. In the dualistic religions, good and evil are two eternal and rival principles. Neither has created the other one and each acts according to its own nature. In the monotheistic religions, evil has a personal identity. It is a being that has fallen from an initial good status as a result of misusing his freedom of will. Let us analyze these perspectives and see to what extent they are compatible with one another.

Evil in Eastern religions

Evil in Hinduism

As mentioned in a previous article, Hinduism is a complex mixture of religious trends. Concerning the relation between Ultimate Reality and evil, there are at least three major perspectives, given by: 1) the Vedas; 2) the Upanishads and the whole corpus of pantheistic writings; 3) the Epics and Puranas.

Evil in the Vedas

The oldest Vedic hymns consider Varuna to be the sovereign god. As god of heaven, omnipresent, omniscient and infallible, he has no comparable opponent in the Vedic pantheon. Evil is a matter of not fulfilling his laws by humans or not performing the ritual properly. Very often it has a moral significance, meaning that people are evil-minded or commit adultery (Rig Veda 4,5; 10,10). Those who

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (1 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions commit evil deeds repent before Varuna (Rig Veda 5,85) and try to repair their faults through ritual sacrifices. The next generation of Vedic gods has Indra as sovereign god. However, he doesn’t have the same power over creation as Varuna. He has to fight with the demon Vritra in order to save mankind. In this fight he needs to be strengthened by the sacrifices performed by humans and also needs help from other gods. Starting with the hymns addressed to Indra, the combat against personalized evil becomes a main feature in Hindu mythology, which will develop in the Epics and Puranas.

Evil in the Upanishads

The Upanishads ground a pantheistic perspective on Ultimate Reality and introduce karma as explanation of human suffering. The only true substance of the universe is Brahman, so that evil cannot be real. Ignoring the one and only reality of Brahman launches karma into action and therefore brings suffering to the soul in further lives. Although it is difficult to determine the very beginning of karma’s manifestation, a text in Kausitaki Upanishad (3,8) indicates that Brahman himself causes the good and evil done by humans, and so he must be the one responsible for the origin of karma: He (Brahman) causes him whom he wishes to lead up from these worlds to perform good action. This one, indeed, also causes him whom he wishes to lead downward, to perform bad action. As the manifestations and dissolutions of the world are eternal, so is karma, meaning that suffering is a part of the eternal cosmic cycle. Logically then, the ultimate origin of karma must be in Brahman, because he is the source of any manifestation and the origin of souls. Man cannot be considered guilty for the evil in the world, not even for his own bad deeds, because all of them originated in past lives, of which he cannot be aware. Suffering in the present life is the natural consequence of past lives’ ignorance and it has to be endured without questioning. (For more details on karma and reincarnation, the way they act and solve the problem of evil, see our article on reincarnation) The real problem of man is to get the impersonal self (atman) out of the cycle ignorance-karma-reincarnation and find liberation. The belief in the real statute of evil is a major hindrance in attaining liberation, as well as granting value to human personhood. As only a personal witness can experience evil, the solution for escaping it is getting rid of our sense of personhood and withdrawal from this world of illusions, by taking a right view on reality through meditation. (For more information on the nature of Eastern meditation and its trustworthiness as source of knowing truth, click here.)

Evil in Samkhya-Yoga

Although the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas are not pantheistic, they follow a close reasoning in defining evil. As philosophies that grant no significance to human personhood, evil is a matter of how much one is caught in the psycho-mental illusions generated by the primordial substance (prakriti). It contains the three gunas, and two of them (rajas and tamas) are causing the manifestations of what we call evil in the world, both in the physical aspect and the mental one. Evil is a part of nature and man has to get along with it from one existence to another through his karma. The true problem is finding liberation from the manifestations of prakriti through meditation and asceticism, and this means complete cessation of

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (2 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions suffering.

Evil in the Epics and Puranas

These writings adopt a middle way in explaining evil, between the dictates of karma and the responsibility of the gods in producing it as sovereign agents in the universe. As these two elements are irreconcilable and mutually exclusive, the solutions to the problem of evil are themselves contradictory. The character of the gods becomes ambiguous in the Epics and Puranas. They are responsible for producing both good and evil. Here are some examples: Indra, the ex-hero of the Vedas, commits adultery in the Skanda Purana (2,7,23,8-40) and justifies himself by the effect of his past karma. In the Mahabharata (12,258,42) he is excused for seducing Gotama’s wife by being in a process of working out a result of karma. No wonder that in the Ramayana (7,30,20-45) he is accused of having brought adultery into the world by his bad example. In a late Upanishad he even encourages his followers to act immorally: “I killed the three-headed son of Tvashtri and delivered the ascetics to the jackals; I broke a treaty and overcame the demon Prahlada and the descendants of Puloman. Yet not a hair of my head was harmed. So he who understands me is not injured by any deed, not even by stealing, killing an embryo, matricide or parricide. If he has committed any evil, he does not become pale.” (Kausitaki Up. 3,1) Although Krishna points to himself as the example for his followers in the Bhagavad Gita (3,23), when committing adultery in the Puranas he justifies himself in reference to human behavior, saying: “Since even the sages are uncontrolled and act as they please, how could one possibly restrain Vishnu when he becomes voluntary incarnate?” (Bhagavata Purana 10,33,35). Brahma, the creator god, is often accused of being creator of both good and evil. In one situation described in the Mahabharata, he grew jealous of people and their heavenly destiny and planned to delude them: “Formerly, all creatures were virtuous, and by themselves they obtained divinity. Therefore the gods became worried, so Brahma created women in order to delude men. Then women, who had been virtuous, became wicked witches, and Brahma filled them with wanton desires, which they in turn inspired in men. He created anger, and henceforth all creatures were born in the power of desire and anger (Mahabharata 13,40,5-12). According to the Vishnu Purana (1,5,1-18), evil precedes and accompanies Brahma’s creation, this being the reason why mankind is evil: “His fourth creation produced creatures in whom darkness and passion predominated, afflicted by misery; these were mankind.” In the Markandeya Purana (45,40) it is said that he created both “cruel creatures and gentle creatures, dharma and adharma, truth and falsehood”. Not only is evil inevitable in creation, it is said to be a good thing, a necessary dynamic factor in the universe. For instance, in the Devibhagavata (4,13), Brihaspati, the guru of the gods says: “All creatures, even gods, are subject to passions. Otherwise the universe, composed as it is of good and evil, could not continue to develop.” According to the Vishnu Purana (1,5,59-65), the evil in creation is both the will of Brahma the creator and the result of karma’s obligation: “Brahma’s power is the will to create, and he is impelled by the powers of things to be created.” In the same situation is Vishnu (Linga Purana 2,6,1-57), who also creates both good and evil, “good people and bad people, those who follow the right path, but also the heretics”. These ambiguous solutions to the problem of evil in Hindu mythology are caused by the fact that the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (3 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions gods cannot be at the same time sovereign, manifestations of an impersonal Ultimate Reality (Brahman) and also in tune with karma. As an effect of the cyclical manifestations of Brahman, good and evil follow one after another during the four ages (yuga) of each manifestation, so that nothing in the universe is eternal and nothing dies, neither good nor evil. Man is not responsible for the evil in the world, but only the impersonal karma or the gods of mythology. If the gods are responsible, they either create it willingly (and are evil themselves) because the universe has to contain it, or are forced to create it by the higher law of karma or fate (and then are consequently weak). There is no significant distinction between these two variants. The universe must contain good and evil and so it is created by a certain god. In conclusion, in Hinduism and the other pantheistic religions in general, there is no central concern to understand and solve the problem of evil. Good and evil are often confused. The attempt to define them is itself a false problem that gets the treatment false problems deserve. The major concern is spiritual ignorance, in relation to which evil and morality have a secondary importance. Through knowledge, it is said that man reaches above good and evil, attaining an impersonal domain that justifies this attitude.

Evil in Buddhism

Buddhism rejects the authority of the Vedas and the other writings of Hinduism, explaining the nature of evil through the process of constant becoming. Evil is the perpetuation of illusion by the factors that maintain the chain of dependent origination (paticca-samuppada). The Buddha proclaimed that the whole of existence is suffering: The Noble Truth of Suffering (dukkha) is this: Birth is suffering; aging is suffering; sickness is suffering; death is suffering; sorrow and lamentation, pain, grief, and despair are suffering; association with the unpleasant is suffering; dissociation from the pleasant is suffering; not to get what one wants is suffering - in brief, the five aggregates of attachment are suffering. (Samyutta Nikaya 56,11) The cause of suffering is desire to experience existence in a personal form, because personhood is nothing but an illusory result of the temporary gathering of five aggregates (skandhas): body-form, feeling, perception, mental activity, and consciousness. As the desire to perpetuate this illusion produces suffering, its extreme solution is to abolish any personal existence. There is no suffering if there is no person left to perceive it. Unfortunately, the cost of this solution is the abolition of life itself.

The paradox of evil and suffering in Eastern religions

The general pattern in Eastern religions is to consider evil illusory, derived from a wrong way of understanding reality. Consequently, suffering emerges from not putting the right view into practice. For this reason, the first noble truth proclaimed by Gotama Buddha states that the only reality of human existence is the all-pervading reality of suffering. This perspective is valid for most of the Eastern religious thinkers that followed the period of the Upanishads. The only possibility to escape suffering is to know the true nature of things, or in other words, the impersonal Ultimate Reality. Proper spiritual knowledge can be attained by the practice of meditation, which requires withdrawing oneself from the world.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (4 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions On the other hand, considering one's personal suffering to be real leads to bad attachments (kleshas), which are hindrances on the way towards liberation. Therefore we reach a significant inconsistency in understanding the relation between suffering and liberation, as two contradictory principles are stated: ● The all-pervading reality of suffering leads man to seek liberation. ● In order to attain liberation, man has to ignore evil and suffering, which do not belong to the realm of true existence. In other words, according to most Eastern religions, on the one hand suffering derives from ignoring Ultimate Reality and prompts man to seek it, and on the other hand, the way of knowing Ultimate Reality and escaping suffering demands ignoring suffering. The question that arises naturally from here is: What has true ontological nature, suffering or the impersonal Ultimate Reality? If suffering is real, man's personal status has to be real too, because suffering can be perceived only at personal level. In this case the impersonal Ultimate Reality has to be questioned. On the other hand, if impersonal Ultimate Reality has true ontological nature, human personhood and suffering are illusory, so that suffering cannot be accepted as the true generator of man's quest for liberation. Paradoxically, spiritual practice demands that suffering should be ignored in order to find the "true reality" towards which it prompts us. Eastern religions promise to help man escape suffering, but while on the way towards liberation they ask us to ignore human suffering. Not only is this contradictory, but such denial of suffering can be accomplished only by denying life itself, a situation that is the ground for the pessimistic view of Eastern religions on human existence. The ultimate cause of this situation is the lack of a personal Creator, directly involved in man's condition by his grace.

Evil in Taoism

As long as any aspect of the world is a manifestation of Tao, corresponding to a different participation of the Yin and Yang principles, nothing can be considered to be truly evil in the world. Even if Yin is considered a negative principle, it never manifests itself alone. In the Tao-te Ching it is stated: When beauty is abstracted Then ugliness has been implied; When good is abstracted Then evil has been implied. (Tao-te Ching 2) Every positive factor involves its negative or opposing one. What is usually called evil, both the physical and mental aspects, corresponds to a bigger participation of the Yin principle, the result of a lack of balance between the two opposing principles. Evil belongs to the nature of the world, so man has to subscribe to the universal harmony and respect the equilibrium of the two polarities. Tao is eternal and so are the two principles Yang and Yin, so that good and evil must be eternal, as necessary elements of our world.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (5 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions Evil in dualistic religions

According to the dualistic religions there are two antagonist and (usually) coeternal deities involved in creation and in governing the destiny of man. Zoroastrianism probably stated the first true religious dualism. Ahura Mazda and Angra Mainyu (or, according to a later tradition, Ohrmazd and Ahriman) are the two coeternal gods responsible for the existence of good and evil in the world. The Yasna (30,3) states: “There are two fundamental spirits, twins which are renowned to be in conflict.In thought and in word, in action, they are two: the good and the bad.” In the latter tradition of Zurvanism, Ohrmazd and Ahriman are twin brothers, each one creating according to his own nature:

The first of the good lands and countries which I, Ahura Mazda, created, was Paradise, by the good river Araxes. Thereupon came Angra Mainyu, who is all death, and he counter-created by his witchcraft the serpent in the river and winter, a work of the devils. The second of the good lands and countries which I, Ahura Mazda, created, was the plains in Samarkand. Thereupon came Angra Mainyu, who is all death, and he counter-created by his witchcraft the fly Skaitya, which brings death to the cattle. The third of the good lands and countries which I, Ahura Mazda, created, was the strong, holy Merv. Thereupon came Angra Mainyu, who is all death, and he counter-created by his witchcraft sinful lusts.... (Videvdad 1,3-5). Man is in the center of this eternal conflict, having the duty to choose always the good and thus help it defeat the evil. Most dualistic religions that developed after the 1st century AD were influenced by the Genesis account of creation but interpret it in a totally different manner. Their position is sharply anti-Judaic and anti-Christian, being aimed at undermining their basic tenets. Marcionism, Gnosticism, Manicheism, Bogomilism and Catharism (as well as other dualistic religions that swept through the medieval world) all acknowledge the God of the Old Testament as creator but deny his goodness, and see the physical world as the product of his ignorance of higher spiritual deities (the Aeons). His creation is therefore hazardous and generates nothing but problems. Contrary to the Bible, man is superior to his creator due to the fact that he was endowed with a spiritual essence by the Aeons. However, his physical body keeps him bound to a miserable condition, which perpetuates through reincarnation. The only way out of this is the attainment of true knowledge (gnosis). In Gnosticism the creator god (Ialdabaot) ignores the higher deities whose descendent he is and creates a world over which he claims to be the only god. However, man is superior to him due to the fact that he received the spirit of life from a higher Aeon (Sophia, the mother of Ialdabaot). Satan and Jesus are the enemies of Ialdabaot and teach humans how to attain true knowledge that may save them from ignorance. (For a more detailed description of Gnostic doctrine see the article The Gnostics, by Maged S. Mikhail.) A detailed study of Gnosticism and its contradictions and incompatibilities with Christianity can be found in Irenaeus' treatise Against Heresies. A similar stand was adopted by Manicheism, a new religion that appeared in Persia in the 3rd century AD. Matter and the physical body are considered intrinsically evil as they derive from the bodies of the dead forces of evil (the Archons). As a result of his captivity in the bodily prison, the soul is overwhelmed by ignorance and forgets his true origin. Reincarnation occurs until the soul is released

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (6 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions from its earthly sufferings. Manicheism was confronted successfully by Augustine in many of his writings in the 4th century AD. See On the Morals of the Manichaeans and Concerning the Nature of Good, Against the Manichaeans. In Catharism the god of the Old Testament is considered to be the ultimate representative of evil himself. He created the physical bodies of humans and locked angels inside them. According to radical Catharism, human souls are angels who served the good God but were tempted by Satan to experience earthly pleasures and could not resist them. The original bodies and spirits of these angels remained in heaven, but their souls fell into physical bodies. Reincarnation works until one recognizes his heavenly origin and purifies himself in order to be accepted back where he belongs. In conclusion, according to these dualistic religions, matter in general and the physical body in particular are evil and produce suffering to the captive soul. This reality hinders man from knowing his true spiritual identity, that of a spiritual being fallen or imprisoned in a physical body. Ignoring this reality leads to suffering and reincarnation into various bodies (human or animal) until true knowledge (gnosis) is attained.

Evil in Christianity

According to Christianity, God created all things, but this doesn’t make Him the creator of evil. The Apostle John states: “God is light; in him there is no darkness at all” (1 John 1,5). When God finished His creation, He appreciated that “all that He had made was very good” (Genesis 1,31). However, anyone can clearly see that evil exists in our world, in an awful measure. From here arises one of the major accusations brought by the opponents of Christianity: If God is all-good, He should want to stop evil; if He is omnipotent, He could stop it; but evil exists in the world, so God lacks either all-goodness (if He can stop evil but does not want to) or omnipotence (if He wants to stop evil, but cannot), or both. As God is declared to be all-good (1 John 4,8) and all-powerful (Revelation 19,6), how could this puzzle be solved? First we have to define what evil really is, an impersonal substance (as a part or a form of our world), a personal being or a mere illusion. According to Christian theology, only God has in Himself and by Himself Absolute being. Only He exists by Himself, according to the formula “I am who I am” of Exodus 3,14. He is the only personal subject that is eternal and immutable (James 1,17; Malachi 3,6). In other words, the Absolute is the Triune God, not an impersonal substance as in pantheism, and beside Him there is nothing else with the same attributes. This means that evil is neither an inherent quality pertaining to God or to His creation, nor an eternal personal being (as in polytheistic or dualistic religions). In this case could it be true that evil does not exist, that it is merely an illusion? If we use the terms that characterize only God’s existence, yes, it is true that evil cannot exist by itself, claiming as God: “I am who I am” (Exodus 3,14). This is what the Church Fathers mean in some of their writings by the fact that evil is without substance, reality, being or existence. For instance, in his writing On the Incarnation of the Word, Ch. 1, Athanasius says that "God alone exists, evil is non-being". This is not an affirmation of the illusory status of evil, but an ontological perspective on the fallen state of God's creatures that lost communion with God. The context of his words is as following:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (7 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions For the transgression of the commandment was making them turn back again according to their nature; and as they had at the beginning come into being out of non-existence, so were they now on the way to returning, through corruption, to non-existence again. The presence and love of the Word had called them into being; inevitably, therefore when they lost the knowledge of God, they lost existence with it; for it is God alone Who exists, evil is non-being, the negation and antithesis of good. The same meaning is attached to the words of Gregory of Nyssa when mentioning that "there is no evil other than wickedness" in his Great Catechism, Ch. 7. The context here is his address to the heretics that claimed that man is the creation of an evil deity (in order to explain the fallen human nature). Gregory of Nyssa states that God is not responsible for man's turning away from Him through sin. This act separates man from His presence and consequently from real existence, as only God is the source for it. Here is Gregory of Nyssa's commentary on the nature of evil: Since, if their thoughts had taken a loftier view, and, withdrawing their minds from this disposition to regard the gratifications of the senses, they had looked at the nature of existing things dispassionately, they would have understood that there is no evil other than wickedness. Now all wickedness has its form and character in the deprivation of the good; it exists not by itself, and cannot be contemplated as a subsistence. For no evil of any kind lies outside and independent of the will; but it is the non-existence of the good that is so denominated. Now that which is not has no substantial existence, and the Maker of that which has no substantial existence is not the Maker of things that have substantial existence. Therefore the God of things that are is external to the causation of things that are evil, since He is not the Maker of things that are non-existent. He Who formed the sight did not make blindness. Although evil has no ontological status with reference to the nature of God, one cannot say evil doesn't exist. Evil existed even before the creation of man. Its origin is to be found in the world of angels. God created them in time immemorial, as personal and immaterial beings endowed with free will, in order to integrate themselves into the divine harmony through obedience and communion. They were created ex nihilo, the same way as the material universe, and thus have a nature different from God’s. These beings have mind (Acts 12,7-10; 1 Peter 1,12), feelings (Luke 15,10), will (Jude 6) and are not limited by a physical body. Their number was very large and had a hierarchy among them (Hebrews 12,22). Evil appeared in the world of angels when Lucifer, one of God’s archangels, rebelled against this order. In the book of the prophet Ezekiel we can read the following metaphorical description of this incident: You were blameless in your ways from the day you were created till wickedness was found in you. Through your widespread trade you were filled with violence, and you sinned. So I drove you in disgrace from the mount of God, and I expelled you, O guardian cherub, from among the fiery stones. Your heart became proud on account of your beauty, and you corrupted your wisdom because of your splendor. So I threw you to the earth; I made a spectacle of you before kings (Ezekiel 28,15-17). This archangel, who became Satan (“adversary”) out of Lucifer (“angel of light”), was expelled from heaven together with all the other angels who joined him in his act of rebellion. The cause of his fall was pride, the desire to be independent from God, to refuse submission and inferiority to Him. Lucifer wanted to be by himself more than his created status could permit him. Satan’s fall couldn’t have occurred without a real freedom of choice. He had the ability to choose either to obey God or a selfish way, aimed at considering himself the source of his existence. His choice for the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (8 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions second alternative constitutes the origin of evil in the universe. Evil is not created by God, but is a perversion of His creation, a result of using free will against the very purpose it was created for (against free will obeisance to God in a communion relation based on love). Evil was not intended by God and is not linked to the essence of God and creation. Was the creation of beings endowed with free will a mistake of God (as it could be used against its very purpose)? No, because this was the only possibility to have free communion with His creatures. Without free will, angels and mankind would only have been a lifeless world of robots. In order to have perfect communion with the Creator, a created being needs the possibility to choose it freely. This is why God allows to exist starvation, disease, murder, war, etc, in our world. Although such facts constitute reasons for atheism, they represent the cost of preserving our (misused) free will. As mentioned before, evil is a parasite of good, a diminishing of existence, a loss of what really constitutes the support of existence. That is why Satan and the demons (the fallen angels) do not keep in themselves any remainder of good, nothing from the good categories with which they were created. “Pure” evil became their new nature after the fall. Jesus Christ said to the Pharisees who didn’t believe in Him: You belong to your father, the devil, and you want to carry out your father's desire. He was a murderer from the beginning, not holding to the truth, for there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks his native language, for he is a liar and the father of lies (John 8,44). Having this nature, Satan and the demons do their best to thwart God’s plan with mankind, knowing that humans are created to succeed where they (the fallen angels) failed. According to God’s justice (and not weakness), they will exist forever, but without the chance to return to the spring of real existence and communion with God. Their eternity is that of spiritual death, of irrevocable departure and closing toward the Source in which they should have found their fulfillment. This is hell, the place where Satan and demons are granted the liberty to eternally renew their wish to exist “by themselves” and express their hate toward God. It is conscious loneliness, because communion is a good thing that cannot exist there. (For a very short, but excellent article about the origin of the term and the logic of hell see The Eschatology of Hell, by R.J. Rushdoony.) The doctrine of hell, as horrifying as it looks to be, proves that evil has an end, that is has no eternal existence in God’s creation. The Eastern religions have no equivalent for Satan as evil personified. Although in Hinduism exist devilish beings called asuras, which can cause problems in people’s lives, they are considered to be immature souls caught temporarily in the abyss of deception. They do evolve and are not permanently in this state. The same is the case with the “devil” Mara, who tempted the Buddha while on his way toward nirvana. However, the temporary status of evil and hell in Eastern religions is not a result of divine love, but rather a necessity imposed by the cyclic manifestations of Ultimate Reality. According to Christianity, evil entered our world as a result of Satan’s fall, so it has a personal character. Jesus Christ spoke directly with Satan at the moment of His temptation (Matthew 4,1-11; etc.). He cast out demons (Mark 1,21-28; etc.), and the apostles did also (Acts 5,16; etc.), so they were not addressing illusions. The Apostle Peter warned his fellow Christians that Satan is a real and dangerous presence: “Be self-controlled and alert. Your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour” (1 Peter 5,8). Likewise, the Apostle Paul emphasizes that “Satan himself is masquerading as an angel of light” in order to deceive humans (2 Corinthians 11,14). These passages and many more cannot be ignored in order to suggest an illusory status of evil.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (9 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions Although Satan is the initiator of evil, it is man that bears the responsibility for spreading it into our world through sin. No matter how bad Satan can be, man cannot be affected by him as long he persists in obedience to God. By submitting himself to Satan’s temptation and misusing the freedom of choice granted by the Creator, man became the perpetuator of evil in our world through sin. The Apostle Paul writes: “Sin entered the world through one man, and death through sin, and in this way death came to all men, because all sinned” (Romans 5,12). Sin affected thoroughly our nature, compromised our relation with other people, and also the physical world in which we live. As a result of this situation, but also in order to defend ourselves from the consequences of other people's sin, we need laws and police. This is the way in which we try to limit the effects of sin in our society. However, the basic problem of sin remains unsolved, no matter how much progress could be attained in perfecting the way democracy works. It is not enough to try to limit the effects of sin, but we should address the problem of sin itself. Satan is not the only one guilty for the evil in our world and we are not just victims lacking any responsibility. God has put a limit to Satan’s power against us humans, so that he can never overwhelm us (1 Corinthians 10,13). Therefore we have real freedom in refusing evil. Despite the fact that the devil is doing his best to delude man, our free will can resist him; it could resist him in Eden and it can resist him now, with the help of God. As man does not resist evil, he distances himself from God and also closes himself toward his neighbors. Out of the selfish relations he develops in this state, evil expands in our world. According to Christianity, evil is neither created nor a natural or necessary element. It is a parasite state that perpetuates itself by misusing God’s good resources and by following a wrong direction. It is the illness of beings that are no longer in communion with God. But since evil exists, it has to submit to the order over which God is sovereign. God has limited Satan’s power and He permits evil to manifest itself only for the benefit of fallen man, in order to awaken him from the spiritual lethargy produced by sin. If man can misuse God’s good creation, why wouldn’t God be able to use for good those who perform evil? Augustine argued that the providence of God goes so far that even Judas' betrayal, although it is undoubtedly an evil act, can be reversed to produce good: “Satan is evil, Judas is evil; as the doer, so his instrument. But God used both for our sake. Both tried to destroy us, but God used their effort for our salvation.” (Sermon CCCI, ch.4). Two aspects should be added here in order to understand properly the relation between God and evil. First, since evil is expanding in our world primarily through people, a major reason for not extinguishing all evil in the world in an instant is that such an act would necessarily involve the damnation of all those who perform it. This would cancel any possibility for them to repent and be reconciled with God. As He takes no pleasure “in the death of the wicked”, but rather wants “that they turn from their ways and live” (Ezekiel 33,11), a sudden extinction of all evil would contradict His love for mankind. Which one of us would pass the test of God’s holiness after all, if such extinction of all evil would be performed apart from His love? God’s attitude in tolerating evil in our world was perfectly expressed by Jesus in the Parable of the Weeds (Matthew 13,24-43): The kingdom of heaven is like a man who sowed good seed in his field. But while everyone was sleeping, his enemy came and sowed weeds among the wheat, and went away. When the wheat sprouted and formed heads, then the weeds also appeared. The owner's servants came to him and said, “Sir, didn't you sow good seed in your field? Where then did the weeds come from?” “An enemy did this,” he replied. The servants asked him, “Do you want us to go and pull them up?”

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (10 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions “No,” he answered, “because while you are pulling the weeds, you may root up the wheat with them. Let both grow together until the harvest. At that time I will tell the harvesters: First collect the weeds and tie them in bundles to be burned; then gather the wheat and bring it into my barn” (13,24-30). The explanation to this parable, according to Jesus, is the following: The one who sowed the good seed is the Son of Man. The field is the world, and the good seed stands for the sons of the kingdom. The weeds are the sons of the evil one, and the enemy who sows them is the devil. The harvest is the end of the age, and the harvesters are angels. As the weeds are pulled up and burned in the fire, so it will be at the end of the age. The Son of Man will send out his angels, and they will weed out of his kingdom everything that causes sin and all who do evil. They will throw them into the fiery furnace, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. Then the righteous will shine like the sun in the kingdom of their Father. He who has ears, let him hear (37-43). God tolerates “weeds” among “wheat”, until a certain moment. His purpose in doing so is that “weeds” could be properly differentiated from “wheat” and pulled up at the right moment. As the parable refers to humans, the people who may be called “weeds” still have the chance of converting and becoming “wheat”. This can happen only as long as they can benefit from God’s grace, that is during their earthly lifetime. It is God’s grace that allows evildoers to live, not his lack of justice or power, in the hope that they may still have the chance to meet Him, repent and return to a personal relationship with Him. The problem of evil and suffering, often used by the opponents of Christianity to reject God’s grace, should rather induce repentance and humble thankfulness for the prolonged chance granted in order to escape the final extinction of all evil at God’s final judgment. Second, God could stop any particular manifestation of evil, but this would annihilate the freedom of personal creatures. The world in which God constantly intervened to stop any manifestation of evil would become a world of robots. Keeping evil under control and using it for our sake serves two purposes: it helps fulfill His plan with mankind (its return to communion with the Creator) and also maintains the creature’s freedom. In this context, suffering is a good tool for destroying the self-sufficient illusion of those who think they don’t need God and His forgiveness, who consider themselves better and wiser than their neighbor. The Apostle Paul writes to the Christians in Rome: “We know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him” (Romans 8,28). At the same time, God never permits that evil manifests itself overwhelmingly in our lives, as the same author mentions in 1 Corinthians 10,13: No temptation has seized you except what is common to man. And God is faithful; he will not let you be tempted beyond what you can bear. But when you are tempted, he will also provide a way out so that you can stand up under it. One of the fundamental aspects of suffering in Christian theology is its use as a tool for our salvation, in order to awake those who are departed from God, and also for the sanctification of those who have already restored their relation with God (see for this 1 Peter 1,6-9; 2,20-21; 3,14; 4,1-2; 4,12-19). However, this does not mean that man can be saved through the endurance of sufferings only. Salvation is granted only by God, through the most supreme expression of suffering that could ever be conceived, which was at the same time its everlasting solution: the vicarious death of Jesus Christ on the cross (see 1 Peter 2,24). As a result, man’s attitude toward evil should be neither one of resignation, as in the Eastern religions (in

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (11 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] The problem of evil in the world's religions order to stop the accumulation of karma), nor of rebellion against God, but one of a conscious and responsible participation in the world. Evil has an end, as well as human suffering. What is requested from us while waiting for it is to fight against evil and suffering, especially against our sinful nature, which perpetuates both our suffering as well as that of our neighbor. As the God of Christianity does not stand impassively toward the fallen man, but meets his needs and has already descended into his problems and misery, He urges action in imitating His compassion in daily living. Although we are not spared from troubles and many times we do not understand their meaning, we should always remember that Jesus promised His help and power in order to conquer them. He said: I have told you these things, so that in me you may have peace. In this world you will have trouble. But take heart! I have overcome the world" (John 16,33). Returning to the questions raised at the beginning of this article, there is no doubt that God is omnipotent and all-good. He did not create evil in the world. Evil is the result of misusing free will by his creatures. Evil is not everlasting. God can stop it, and He will stop it one day forever (Revelation 20,10). But until then He allows evil to exist in our world for our benefit, in order to preserve our freedom of will and to use it as an instrument in our salvation. There is no contradiction in God's character; it is only sin that prevents us from understanding what evil really is and from stopping to spread it around us.

Conclusion

Outside the Christian solution to the problem of evil there are possible only pantheistic or dualistic solutions. According to the pantheistic religions, the origin of evil has its root in the manifestation of the impersonal Ultimate Reality, which (at the immanent level of reality) launches karma into action. Considering evil from a transcendental point of view, it is only an illusion that has to be scattered away through the right (pantheist) understanding of reality, acquired through meditation. In the dualistic religions, evil is coeternal with good. The absolute good cannot be an all-good and omnipotent person, because there cannot be two Absolutes. This is the case with Gnosticism, Manicheism and the polytheistic religions (see also the Hindu mythology). From a Christian point of view, both solutions are not satisfactory in explaining evil, because they lack as fundamental elements the creation ex nihilo, the doctrine of the fall, and redemption through God's grace. Without these, evil cannot be understood and defeated.

Next article: Conclusion

http://www.comparativereligion.com/evil.html (12 of 12) [10/27/2000 9:49:04 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity

REINCARNATION Its meaning and consequences

A) Reincarnation in world religions; B) Past-life recall as proof for reincarnation; C) Reincarnation and cosmic justice; D) Reincarnation and Christianity.

C) Reincarnation and cosmic justice

The most important argument for reincarnation is of a moral nature. It says that karma and reincarnation provide the perfect way to realize justice in our world, by rewarding all one’s deeds and thoughts in further lives. They will manifest as good or bad happenings and circumstances, with mathematical exactitude, so that everything one does will be justly punished or rewarded, at both a quantitative and a qualitative level. This would explain all inequalities we see among people, comfort those who cannot understand their present bad situation and also give hope for a further better life. According to karma, there is no forgiveness for the "sins" of the past, but only accumulation of karmic debt, followed by paying the consequences in further lives. Swami Shivananda states: If the virtuous man who has not done any evil act in this birth suffers, this is due to some wrong act that he may have committed in his previous birth. He will have his compensation in his next birth. If the wicked man who daily does many evil actions apparently enjoys in this birth, this is due to some good Karma he must have done in his previous birth. he will have compensation in his next birth. He will suffer in the next birth. The law of compensation is inexorable and relentless. (Swami Shivananda, Practice of Karma Yoga, Divine Life Society, 1985, p. 102) As the karmic debt man recorded in his past is considerably large, a single life is not enough to consume it. Therefore, in order to attain liberation, many lives become a necessity. In pantheism, where a personal god as Ultimate Reality is absent, man is alone in his struggle with his past. Even the theistic branches of Eastern religions are incapable of solving man’s loneliness in this struggle, as karma and God’s grace cannot be properly reconciled without totally compromising one of them. Grace, granted by a god or a guru, contradicts the basic role of karma and would render useless its action. As a result, the claims of some gurus to be able to erase the karma of their disciples are absurd. Through asceticism and meditation, man has to work out his salvation alone, or rather to bear alone the dictates of karma. Although it may seem that the mechanism of karma and reincarnation is the proper way to realize social justice, there are two main objections which contradict it:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation2.html (1 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:49:08 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity 1) As long as suffering (or the reward for good deeds) can be experienced only at a personal level (physical and psychical), and man ceases to exist as person at physical death, it implies that another person, generated in another physical body, will actually bear the consequences dictated by the karma of the deceased person. The impersonal self (atman or purusha) which reincarnates has nothing to do with suffering; it is a simple observer of the ongoing psycho-mental life. If, at the moment of death, there is no more karmic debt left, the separation of the self from the illusory involvement with the physical and psycho-mental world is permanent, and this represents liberation. If not, the self is forced to enter a new illusory association with personhood until all fruits of past lives are consumed. In order to realize this, a new person is born each time the self enters a new human body. The new person will bear the karma produced by the previous persons inhabited by the same self. This mechanism, of one person accumulating karma and another bearing the consequences, is rather unfair, fundamentally contradicting the idea of realizing perfect justice. This is why natural disasters, plagues and accidents that affect innocent people cannot be explained away as being generated by karma. For this reason, the saying "a man reaps what he sows" cannot be used as a way of expressing one’s reincarnationist ideas. (Actually this saying is taken from the New Testament, Galatians 6,7, but there it has a different meaning.) According to the reincarnation mechanism one person sows and another one reaps, since no personal characteristics can be preserved from one incarnation of the impersonal self to the next. In Buddhism, where the very idea of a self who transmigrates is rejected, the idea of sowing and reaping is even more absurd. See for instance the following text: If it be that good men and good women, who receive and retain this discourse, are downtrodden, their evil destiny is the inevitable retributive result of sins committed in their past mortal lives. By virtue of their present misfortunes the reacting effects of their past will be thereby worked out, and they will be in a position to attain the Consummation of Incomparable Enlightenment (Diamond Sutra 16). Who will actually work out the effects of his past? A new distribution of the five aggregates? Or who will actually attain enlightenment? A certain configuration of those impersonal five aggregates? How could this process render perfect justice? Perfect justice for whom? For an illusory personhood that disappears at physical death? 2) A second objection concerns the actual possibility of attaining liberation from karma and reincarnation. Normally it is supposed that the person who is living out the consequences of his karma should do it in a spirit of resignation and submission. But this ideal is far from reality. Instead of adopting a passive attitude concerning the hardships that have to be endured, man almost always reacts with indignation, and so accumulates a constantly growing karmic debt. Common human experience proves that evil almost always generates evil and therefore a balance between good and evil cannot be reached. As a result, a vicious cycle is generated in which karmic debt is constantly growing. This happens with most people of our planet, as it is said that most of us live in ignorance (avidya). From one generation to the next, the sum of karmic debt is always growing and this situation can never be solved. What kind of a justice is that which starts more problems than it solves? If it is most likely that one will always accumulate new karma instead of getting rid of it, probably the best solution to attain liberation from reincarnation would be the Jain fasting to death, as stated by Mahavira: If this thought occurs to a monk, "I am sick and not able, at this time, to regularly mortify the flesh," that monk should regularly reduce his food; regularly reducing his food and diminishing

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation2.html (2 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:49:08 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity his sins, he should take proper care of his body, being immovable like a beam; exerting himself he dissolves his body.... This is the truth: speaking truth, free from passion, crossing the samsara, abating irresoluteness, knowing all truth and not being known, leaving this frail body. Overcoming all sorts of pains and troubles through trust in this, he accomplishes this fearful religious death. Even thus he will in due time put an end to existence. This has been adopted by many who were free from delusion; it is good, wholesome, proper, beatifying, meritorious. Thus I say. (Acaranga Sutra 1,7,6) This should be the logical solution for anyone trying to escape his karma. However, this radical solution is far from being accepted by most adherents of reincarnation. But even if they would literally fast to death, it still could not guarantee the decrease of mankind’s karmic debt, as one accumulates more karma till the moment he adopts this kind of "holy" mortification than he could annihilate by using it.

Let’s take an example and see how the two objections actually work in the case of a real person. If we take the case of Adolf Hitler, the results are astounding. (For a detailed study of this case and other important aspects of reincarnation see Mark Albrecht’s book Reincarnation - InterVarsity Press, 1982.) There is no doubt that all adherents of reincarnation agree that many lives are needed for consuming his karmic debt. Hitler died in 1945 and had to reincarnate as a child in order to bear the harsh consequences of his monstrous deeds. The two objections can be stated as following: 1) The person of Hitler ceased to exist at the moment of his physical death. Only the impersonal self will reincarnate, accompanied by its karmic deposit. However, there is no continuity between the person of Hitler and that of the individual who has to endure the hardships imposed by Hitler’s karma. The newborn person doesn’t know that he has to work out Hitler’s karma. After the cruel life and death of this person, other millions of reincarnations will succeed with the same tragic destiny. The most disgusting fact is that the person of Hitler, the only one who should have endured at physical and psychical level the results of his foolish deeds, was dissolved at his physical death, while other persons, totally unaware of this situation and innocent, have to work out his bad karma.

2) As a result of the hardships that have to be endured by the new incarnations of Hitler, it is almost certain that they will react with indignation instead of resignation to their situation, and thus will accumulate a growing karmic debt. Each new reincarnation of Hitler becomes a source of newly acquired karma, initiating a new chain of individuals who have to pay the consequences. The same happened in the case of Hitler himself. Whoever he was in a previous life, he made his karma a lot worse during the years of The Third Reich. Therefore, instead of solving the puzzle of global justice, the problem worsened. Starting with a single individual such as Hitler, we reach a huge number of persons who pay his karma and accumulate a new one. This is just one case of human history. Any attempt to imagine what happens at a larger human scale would reveal a catastrophe impossible to ever be solved. As a result, karma and reincarnation cannot provide any kind of justice. Reincarnation cannot solve the problem of evil but only amplify it, leaving the original evil unpunished. If reincarnation were true, Hitler will never be punished for his deeds because he ceased to exist, right before any human person or circumstance of life could truly punish him.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation2.html (3 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:49:08 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity Even if disagreement persists in accepting the growth of evil as an effect of karma and reincarnation, at least its conservation should be admitted in human history. This results from analyzing the links that exist between people and their karma from a global perspective. There are two points to be made here. First, there is a moral issue involved. As suffering is the result of one’s bad deeds performed in previous lives, a possible way of reacting consistently with the law of karma might lead to a total lack of compassion toward people who suffer. One might think that the person who suffers deserves to be equitably punished, and anyone who dares to help him interferes with the unrolling of his karma and consequently is gathering bad karma for himself. Second, the man who is the instrument of karma’s punishment records bad karma for himself and therefore will have to be punished at his turn, in a next life. Then the next person who acts as the instrument of karma will have to be punished in his turn, etc. A possible solution to this endless cycle would be that the one who acts as the instrument of karma in another one’s life should do it in a completely detached manner, without any interest in the results, according to the demand of Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita (2,47; 3,19; etc.). In this case it is considered that he doesn’t acquire new karma. However, such a solution would be limited, at best, to the few "detached" people that actually follow this rule, and thus has no significance on the larger scale of human society. Most people are far from considering themselves as detached executioners of karma in their neighbor’s life. Let’s examine these two points in the case of the millions of Jews who were killed in gas chambers by the Nazis during World War II. First, it would seem absurd to have any feeling of compassion towards them, because they deserved to be killed like that, as a result of crimes done by them in previous lives. One could conclude that, after all, the Nazis did the right thing against the Jews, according to the dictates of karma. Using this reasoning any conceivable crime of the past or present could be justified, without bothering about moral values. This opens a horrifying perspective on the past and future of mankind, with implications difficult to grasp. Second, the killing of millions of Jews requires that their executioners should be killed in their turn, in a similar way, in further lives. But this implies that the executioners of the reincarnated Nazis will be killed in their turn, etc., etc. The cycle would never end. The same reasoning could be used also back in time, which would require finding in each generation those millions of people executed and their executioners. An objection to this could be that killers may be punished (killed) in turn by other means, not necessarily by involving other new acquirers of karma. Natural calamities such as earthquakes could be the instrument of karma. However, this option doesn’t work because karma is generated not only by the actions themselves, but also by the desires that lead to the actions. The desire to kill has to be rewarded as well, not only the killing. Therefore, if reincarnation were a logical concept, it would imply that it has neither a beginning nor an end. This cannot be a solution for justice, but only a kind of eternal circus. A further analysis of karmic justice proves that the basic principle of Hindu morality, that of non-killing (ahimsa), is absurd. According to this principle we should not participate in the killing of any living being, otherwise we will reincarnate in order to pay the consequences. (This is the basis of eastern religious vegetarianism.) For instance, the butcher who slaughters a pig will have to reincarnate as a pig in order to be slaughtered in his turn. However, the very principle of reincarnation contradicts the meaning of ahimsa and proves it to be futile. The pig had to be slaughtered, because he probably was the reincarnation of another butcher, who had to be punished that way. Neither in this case can the vicious cycle be stopped by natural means (i.e. the pig dying of a disease) because the butcher’s desire to kill the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation2.html (4 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:49:08 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity animal (for food or to earn his salary) also generates karma. Therefore the infringement of the non-violence principle becomes a necessity in order to fulfill karmic justice. The butcher was at the same time the instrument of working out one’s karmic debt and the generator of a new one for himself. In a strange and contradictory way, the fulfilling of karmic debt requires the punishment of its executioners. In other words, karma paradoxically acts through condemning the executioners of its "justice". In conclusion, the concept of reincarnation stands in contradiction with logic, social justice, morality and even common sense. Looking beyond the apparent comfort it provides to this life by promising further lives in which perfection may be attained, belief in reincarnation cannot bring any beneficial result, but only resignation and despair in facing fate. Why then accept it as a major spiritual belief?

Next: Reincarnation and Christianity

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation2.html (5 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:49:08 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity

REINCARNATION Its meaning and consequences

The concept of reincarnation seems to offer one of the most attractive explanations of man’s origin and destiny. There is an increasing interest in this topic today, sustained especially by books and magazines, TV broadcasts, movies and conferences. Most of them are related to the world of esoterical wisdom and occult phenomena. Reincarnation is a hot topic also on the Internet, as you may have already noticed. Not only adherents of Eastern religions or New Age spirituality accept it currently, but also many who don’t share such esoteric interests and convictions. Reincarnation seems to give hope for continuing one’s existence in further lives and thus having a better chance to attain liberation. This is a source of great comfort, especially for those who seek liberation on the exclusive basis of their inner resources. On the other hand, reincarnation is a way of rejecting the Christian teaching of the soul’s final judgment by a holy God, with the possible result of being eternally condemned to suffer in hell. Another major reason for accepting reincarnation by so many people today is the fact that it allegedly explains the differences that exist between people. Some are healthy, others are tormented their whole life by physical handicaps. Some are rich, others at the brink of starvation. Some have success without being religious; others are constant losers, despite their religious dedication. Eastern religions explain these differences as a result of previous lives, good or bad, which bear their fruits into the present one through the action of karma. Therefore reincarnation seems to be a perfect way of punishing or rewarding one’s deeds, without the need of accepting a personal God as Ultimate Reality. Given the overwhelming impact this ideology can have in the life and beliefs of any person, let us analyze the following major topics: A) Reincarnation in world religions; B) Past-life recall as proof for reincarnation; C) Reincarnation and cosmic justice; D) Reincarnation and Christianity.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (1 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity A) Reincarnation in world religions

The reincarnation of an entity defined as the core of human existence (atman or purusha) following a cycle that implies many lives and bodies, is not such an old concept as it is pretended today. It is neither a common element for most of the oldest known religions, nor does its origin belong to an immemorial past. The classic form of the reincarnation doctrine was formulated in India, but certainly not earlier than the 9th century BC, when the Brahmana writings were composed. After the Upanishads (7th to 5th century BC) clearly defined the concept, it was adopted by the other important Eastern religions which originated in India, Buddhism and Jainism. Due to the spreading of Buddhism, reincarnation was later adapted in Chinese Taoism, but not earlier than the 3rd century BC. The ancient religions of the Mediterranean world developed quite different kinds of reincarnationist beliefs. For instance, Greek Platonism stated the pre-existence of the soul in a celestial world and its fall into a human body due to sin. In order to be liberated from its bondage and return to a state of pure being, the soul needs to be purified through reincarnation. In stating these beliefs Plato was strongly influenced by the earlier philosophical schools of Orphism and Pythagoreanism. The first important Greek philosophical system that adopted a similar view on reincarnation to Hinduism was Neo-Platonism, born in the 3rd century AD, under certain Eastern influences. In the case of ancient Egypt, The Egyptian Book of the Dead describes the travel of the soul into a next world without coming back to earth. As it is well known, the ancient Egyptians embalmed the dead in order that the body might be preserved and accompany the soul into that world. This rather suggests their belief in resurrection than in reincarnation. Likewise, in many cases of ancient tribal religions that are credited today with holding to reincarnation, it is rather a belief in the pre-existence of the soul before birth or its independent survival after death that is taught. This has no connection with the classic idea of transmigration from one physical body to another, according to the demands of an impersonal law such as karma.

Reincarnation in Hinduism

The origin of samsara has to be searched for in Hinduism and its classic writings. It cannot have appeared earlier than the 9th century BC because the Vedic hymns, the most ancient writings of Hinduism, do not mention it, proving that reincarnation wasn’t stated yet at the time of their recording (13th to 10th century BC). Let us therefore analyze the development of the concept of immortality in the major Hindu writings, beginning with the Vedas and the Brahmanas.

Immortality in the Vedic hymns and the Brahmanas

At the time the Vedic hymns were written, the belief was that man continues to exist after death as a whole person. Between man and gods was stated an absolute distinction, as in all other polytheistic religions of the world. The concept of an impersonal fusion with the source of all existence, as later

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (2 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity stated in the Upanishads, was far away. Here are some arguments for this thesis that result from the exegesis of the funeral ritual: 1. As was the case in other ancient religions (for instance those of Egypt and Mesopotamia), the deceased was buried with food and clothing necessary in the afterlife. More than that, the belief of ancient Aryans in the preservation of personal identity after death led them to incinerate the dead husband together with his (living) wife and bow so that they could accompany him in the afterlife. In some parts of India this ritual was performed until the British colonization. 2. Similar to the tradition of ancient Chinese religion, the departed relatives constituted a holy hierarchy. The last one deceased was commemorated individually for a year after his departure and then included in the mortuary offerings of the monthly shraddha ritual (Rig Veda 10,15,1-11). This ritual was necessary because the dead could influence negatively or positively the life of the living (Rig Veda 10,15,6). 3. According to Vedic anthropology, the components of human nature are the physical body, ashu and manas. Ashu represents the vital principle (different from personal attributes), and manas the sum of psycho-mental faculties (mind, feeling and will). The belief in the preservation of the three components after death is proved by the fact that the family addressed the departed relative in the burial ritual as a unitary person: "May nothing of your manas, nothing of the ashu, nothing of the limbs, nothing of your vital fluid, nothing of your body here by any means be lost" (Atharva Veda 18,2,24). Yama, the god of death (mentioned in old Buddhist and Taoist scriptures too) was sovereign over the souls of the dead and also the one who received the offerings of the family for the benefit of the departed. In the Rig Veda it is said about him: "Yama was the first to find us our abode, a place that can never be taken away, where our ancient Fathers have departed; all who are born go there by that path, treading their own" (Rig Veda 10,14,2). Divine justice was provided by the gods Yama, Soma and Indra, not by an impersonal law such as karma. One of their attributes was to cast the wicked into an eternal dark prison out of which they can never escape (Rig Veda 7,104,3-17). The premise for reaping the reward of one’s life in a new earthly existence (instead of the heavenly afterlife) appeared in the Brahmana writings (9th century BC). They stated a limited heavenly immortality, depending on the deeds and the quality of the sacrifices performed during life. After reaping the reward for them, man has to face a second death in the heavenly realm (punarmrityu) and therefore return to an earthly existence. The proper antidote against this situation came to be considered esoteric knowledge, attainable only during one’s earthly existence.

Reincarnation in the Upanishads

The Upanishads were the first writings to move the place of one’s "second death" from the heavenly realm to this earthly world, considering its proper solution the knowledge of the atman-Brahman identity. Ignorance of one’s true self (atman or purusha) launches karma into action, the law of cause and effect in Eastern spirituality. Its first clear formulation can be found in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (4,4,5): "According as one acts, according as one behaves, so does he become.The doer of good becomes good. The doer of evil becomes evil. One becomes virtuous by virtuous action, bad by bad action." Reincarnation (samsara) is the practical way in which one reaps the fruits of his deeds. Therefore, the self is forced to enter a new material existence until all karmic debt is paid: "By means of thought, touch,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (3 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity sight and passions and by the abundance of food and drink there are birth and development of the (embodied) self. According to his deeds, the embodied self assumes successively various forms in various conditions" (Shvetashvatara Upanishad 5,11). There can be observed a fundamental mutation in the meaning of afterlife in comparison with the Vedic perspective. Abandoning the desire to have communion with the gods (Agni, Indra, etc.), attained as a result of bringing good sacrifices, the Upanishads came to consider man’s final destiny to be the impersonal fusion atman-Brahman, attained exclusively by esoteric knowledge. In this new context, karma and reincarnation are key elements that will mark from now on all particular developments in Hinduism.

Reincarnation in the Epics and Puranas

In the Bhagavad Gita, which is a part of the Mahabharata, reincarnation is clearly stated as a natural process of life that has to be followed by any mortal. Krishna says: Just as the self advances through childhood, youth and old age in its physical body, so it advances to another body after death. The wise person is not confused by this change called death (2,13). Just as the body casts off worn out clothes and puts on new ones, so the infinite, immortal self casts off worn out bodies and enters into new ones (2,22). In the Puranas the speculation on this subject is more substantial and therefore specific destinies are figured for each kind of "sin" one performs: The murderer of a brahmin becomes consumptive, the killer of a cow becomes hump-backed and imbecile, the murderer of a virgin becomes leprous - all three born as outcastes. The slayer of a woman and the destroyer of embryos becomes a savage full of diseases; who commits illicit intercourse, a eunuch; who goes with his teacher’s wife, disease-skinned. The eater of flesh becomes very red; the drinker of intoxicants, one with discolored teeth.... Who steals food becomes a rat; who steals grain becomes a locust... perfumes, a muskrat; honey, a gadfly; flesh, a vulture; and salt, an ant.... Who commits unnatural vice becomes a village pig; who consorts with a Sudra woman becomes a bull; who is passionate becomes a lustful horse.... These and other signs and births are seen to be the karma of the embodied, made by themselves in this world. Thus the makers of bad karma, having experienced the tortures of hell, are reborn with the residues of their sins, in these stated forms (Garuda Purana 5). Similar specific punishments are figured by The Laws of Manu (12, 54-69).

Who or what reincarnates in Hinduism?

According to the Upanishads and Vedanta philosophy, the entity that reincarnates is the impersonal self (atman). Atman lacks any personal element, reason for which the use of the reflexive pronoun "self" is not quite right. Atman can be defined only through negating any personal attributes. Although it constitutes the existential substrata of man’s existence, atman cannot be the carrier of one’s "spiritual progress", because it cannot record any data produced in the illusory domain of psycho-mental existence. The spiritual progress one accumulates toward realizing the atman-Brahman identity is recorded by karma, or rather by a minimal quantity of karmic debt. According to one’s karma, at (re)birth the whole physical and mental complex man consists of is reconstructed, all that pertains to the world of illusions.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (4 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity At this level, the newly shaped person experiences the fruits of "his" actions from previous lives and has to do his best to stop the vicious cycle avidya-karma-samsara. As a necessary aid in explaining the reincarnation mechanism, Vedanta adopted the concept of a subtle body (sukshma-sharira), attached to atman as long as its bondage lasts, which actually records the karmic debts and transmits them from one life to another. However, this "subtle body" cannot be a form of preserving one’s personal attributes, as it does not offer any actual data belonging to previous lives to the present conscious psycho-mental life. All this kind of data is erased, so that the facts recorded by the subtle body are a sum of hidden tendencies or impressions (samskara) imprinted by karma. They will materialize unconsciously in the life of the individual, without giving him any hint for understanding his actual condition. There is no possible form of transmitting conscious memory from one life to another, because its domain belongs to the world of illusions and dissolves at death. In the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas, the entity that reincarnates is purusha, an equivalent of atman. Given the absolute duality stated between purusha and prakriti (substance), nothing that belongs to the psycho-mental life can pass from one life to the other because it belongs to prakriti, which has a mere illusory relation with purusha. However, in the Yoga Sutra (2,12) is defined a similar mechanism of transmitting the effects of karma from one life to another, as was the case in Vedanta. The reservoir of karmas is called karmashaya. It accompanies purusha from one life to another, representing the sum of impressions (samskara) that could not manifest themselves during the limits of a certain life. In no way can it be a kind of conscious memory, a sum of information that the person could consciously use or a nucleus of personhood, because karmashaya has nothing in common with psycho-mental abilities. This deposit of karma merely serves as a mechanism for adjusting the effects of karma in one’s life. It dictates in an impersonal and mechanical manner the new birth (jati), the length of life (ayu) and the experiences that must accompany it (bhoga).

Reincarnation in Buddhism

Buddhism denies the reality of a permanent self, together with all things pertaining to the phenomenal world. The appearance of human existence is generated by a mere heap of five aggregates (skandha), which suffer from constant becoming and have a functional cause-effect relation: 1) the body (material form and senses), 2) sensation (product of the senses), 3) perception (built on sensation), 4) mental activity and 5) consciousness. All five elements, as well as the whole assembly they construct, are impermanent (anitya), undergo constant transformation and have no abiding principle or self. Man usually thinks that he has a self because of consciousness. But being itself in a constant process of becoming and change, consciousness cannot be identified with a self that is supposed to be permanent. Beyond the five aggregates nothing else can be found in man. However, something has to reincarnate, following the dictates of karma. When asked about the differences between people in the matters of life span, illnesses, wealth, etc., the Buddha taught: Men have, O young man, deeds as their very own, they are inheritors of deeds, deeds are their matrix, deeds are their kith and kin, and deeds are their support. It is deeds that classify men into high or low status (Majjhima Nikaya 3,202). If there is no real self, who inherits the deeds and reincarnates? Buddha answered that only karma is

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (5 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity passing from one life to another, using the illustration of the light of a candle, which is derived from other candle without having a substance of its own. In the same manner there is rebirth without the transfer of a self from one body to another. The only link from one life to the next is of a causal nature. This is without doubt the weirdest definition of reincarnation ever stated. In the Garland Sutra (10) we read: According to what deeds are done Do their resulting consequences come to be; Yet the doer has no existence: This is the Buddha’s teaching. The Yogachara and Vajrayana (Tibetan Buddhism) schools of Mahayana Buddhism consider that there actually is an entity that reincarnates, namely consciousness (one of the five aggregates), thus having the same function as the atman of Vedanta. The Tibetan Book of the Dead describes in detail the alleged experiences one has in the intermediary state between two incarnations, suggesting that the deceased keeps some personal attributes. Although it is not clear what actually survives after death in this case, there is mentioned a mental body that cannot be injured by the visions experienced by the deceased: When it happens that such a vision arises, do not be afraid! Do not feel terror! You have a mental body made of instincts; even if it is killed or dismembered, it cannot die! Since in fact you are a natural form of voidness, anger at being injured is unnecessary! The Yama Lords of Death are but arisen from the natural energy of your own awareness and really lack all substantiality. Voidness cannot injure voidness! (Tibetan Book of the Dead, 12) Whatever the condition of the deceased after death might be, any hypothetical personal nucleus vanishes right before birth, so there can be no psycho-mental element transmitted from one life to another. The newborn person doesn’t remember anything from previous lives or trips into the realm of intermediary state (bardo).

Reincarnation in Taoism

Reincarnation is a teaching hard to find in the aphorisms of the Tao-te Ching (6th century BC), so it must have appeared later in Taoism. Although it is not specified what reincarnates, something has to pass from one life to another. An important scripture of Taoism, the Chuang Tzu (4th century BC), states: Birth is not a beginning; death is not an end. There is existence without limitation; there is continuity without a starting point. Existence without limitation is space. Continuity without a starting point is time. There is birth, there is death, there is issuing forth, there is entering in. That through which one passes in and out without seeing its form, that is the Portal of God (Chuang Tzu 23).

Reincarnation in modern thinking

Once the Eastern concept of reincarnation arrived in Europe, its meaning changed. During the Middle Ages it was a doctrine reserved for the initiates of some occult traditions (Hermetism, Catharism, etc.), who have taken it over from Neo-Platonism. A larger acceptance of reincarnation was promoted in the Western world only beginning with the last century, by the efforts of Theosophy, and later Anthroposophy. Their intense ministry, combined with that of many Eastern gurus, and especially the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (6 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity efforts of the New Age movement, determined a wide acceptance of reincarnation in our society today, so that this concept became one of the most fascinating doctrines in explaining the origin and meaning of life. However, its modern version is substantially different from what Eastern religions stated. Far from being a torment out of which man has to escape by any price through abolishing personhood, New Age thinking considers reincarnation as an eternal progression of the soul toward higher levels of spiritual existence. Influenced by the Christian cultural context but totally opposing Eastern classic ideology, many consider today that the entity that reincarnates is our soul, which preserves the attributes of personhood from one life to another. This compromise obviously emerged from the desire to adopt the reincarnation doctrine to Western thought. The concept of an impersonal atman reincarnating was too abstract to be easily accepted, so Westerners needed a milder version of this doctrine. Although this tendency proves the soul’s yearning for a personal destiny, it doesn’t bear too much resemblance to classical Eastern spirituality, which rejects it as totally perverted. The above information about the meaning of reincarnation in the Eastern religions and the nature of the entity which is reincarnating will be helpful in examining the modern proofs for it, which are so popular today. While analyzing them, we need to remember that according to the Eastern concept of reincarnation there cannot be any personal element that could wander from one life to the next.

Next: Past-life recall as proof for reincarnation Reincarnation and cosmic justice Reincarnation and Christianity

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation.html (7 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:14 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity

REINCARNATION Its meaning and consequences

A) Reincarnation in world religions; B) Past-life recall as proof for reincarnation; C) Reincarnation and cosmic justice; D) Reincarnation and Christianity.

B) Past-life recall as modern proof for reincarnation

Many people who accept reincarnation in the West today claim that it can be scientifically proven. They usually ground their belief on so-called past life recall experiences, which represent the ability of certain persons to recall facts of alleged previous lives. There are two categories of this phenomenon. One is observed under hypnosis, while regressing certain persons beyond the date of birth. The other is produced by some children who spontaneously remember a previous life identity, amazing their neighbors with specific details that match with the life of a deceased person. Could these experiences really be proofs for reincarnation?

Hypnotic regression as proof for reincarnation

Hypnosis can be defined as a method of inducing an altered state of consciousness, which causes a person to become very receptive to the hypnotist’s suggestions. The method has been used in psychoanalysis for treating psychic diseases by evoking the painful events which caused them in the past (especially during childhood) and then transmitting suggestions meant to heal these wounds which still affect one’s present. Although there are some encouraging results in using it as a psychiatric healing therapy, it is a fact that hypnosis can mix fantasy with real memories or even create entirely fictitious episodes. In deep states of hypnosis, some subjects have had out-of-body experiences and claimed to have traveled in mysterious spiritual realms. Others have had a mystical experience of oneness with the universe. Hypnotic regression started to be used as a "past lives recall" method in 1952, when Ruth Simmons from Colorado, USA, was regressed "back in time" beyond the date of her birth. Suddenly she started to talk using a specific Irish accent, claiming that her name was Bridey Murphy and she lived in Ireland in the year 1890. Her brief descriptions seemed to describe properly the Irish society of the late 19th century. It was therefore believed that a scientific proof for reincarnation had been found. As a result, the method

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (1 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity was used by a growing number of hypnotists in order to get information about alleged previous lives of their patients. Recently the method has gained a scientific aura, being used as therapy for releasing current fears and explaining certain personality tendencies as results of past lives experiences. By simply being asked to go back in time beyond the date of their birth and describe their impressions, some patients tell impressive stories in which some characteristics match with past and distant cultures of human history. They usually adopt a totally different personality, with a changed voice, behavior and facial expression. All the information they produce is the result of a dialog between the hypnotist and his patient, in which the questions have to be easy and clear in order to get a proper answer. As long as the information they produce couldn’t have been normally learned during their life span, it is supposed that they really recall past lives. However, this conclusion raises some difficulties, as there are other possibilities to explain how the "novelties" are produced, without accepting the past-life recall hypothesis. One possible explanation, valid in a few cases, is cryptoamnesia. As hypnosis can be used in refreshing forgotten memories of one’s past, facts that are not available anymore in the conscious memory, in the same way can it be used for evoking information heard from other people, read in books, or seen in movies, in which the subject of hypnosis is involving himself as participant. His subconscious memory has kept this information stored and hypnosis determines its use in a completely fictitious scenario. Detailed studies of the alleged recalled lives prove that in most cases there is only general information produced, or details that cannot be historically confirmed. An intriguing aspect of the testimonies recorded under hypnosis is the fact that they always depend on the already existing data in current historic knowledge. In many cases, although the information corresponds to generally acknowledged historical data, further archaeological discoveries contradict them, casting serious doubts on the veracity of "past lives". Ian Wilson, one of the important researchers of this phenomenon, describes several such cases in his book Reincarnation (p. 88-90). One of them refers to a "person" who lived during the reign of the Egyptian pharaoh Ramses III. Instead of indicating the name No for the capital city, he used the name Thebes, given by the Greeks much later. On the other hand, a true ancient Egyptian could not have known the pharaoh’s name by a number, as the numbering of pharaohs was adopted by Victorian Egyptologists during the 19th century. Another fault was mentioning the use of the sestertius coin, which was introduced by the Romans a thousand years later. Another case reported Vikings making a landfall in North America during the 11th century. According to the description, they were wearing helmets with horns, which cannot be historically true. In recent years scholars have proved that this idea is false, as Vikings wore in fact conic, close-fitting caps. Horned helmets were worn only in religious ceremonies by individuals of high rank. This and other cases prove that the "past life recall" experiences depend heavily on the historical knowledge mankind had at the time when the hypnotic regression was performed, but which are often contradicted by later discoveries. How could it be possible that the present personality could influence the knowledge of its "previous lives", some predating it with hundreds or thousands of years? How could people who lived four thousand years ago use the BC (before Christ) year numeration system? How can it be that some hypnotists can even "recall" future lives of their patients (which are obviously influenced by current science fiction literature)? These facts indicate that the alleged previous lives are culturally and religiously conditioned, casting serious doubts on their veracity. This is why the writers who are favorable to rebirth stories usually avoid mentioning specific data which might challenge their beliefs. Another possible explanation that could overrule the veracity of past life recall is the influence of the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (2 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity hypnotist, whose suggestion ability is a sine qua non condition for the efficiency of hypnosis. The other necessary factor is the receptivity of the patient to the hypnotist’s suggestions. Although the two conditions determine the efficiency of hypnosis when used as psychiatric treatment, when expecting to get information from alleged past lives, the suggestion ability of the hypnotist becomes an important hindrance in obtaining true information, because it can contaminate the patient’s story. Under hypnosis, the subject is ready to accept all kinds of distortions, having his reality shaped according to what the hypnotist dictates. As in most cases the hypnotist expects a confirmation of the reincarnation theory, or at least expects it subconsciously, together with the verbal suggestions concerning relaxation and different phases of regression, he can transmit his own convictions concerning past lives and custom scenarios of this kind. In many cases it is easy to discern the religious convictions of the hypnotist in the stories told by his patients, his understanding of life as eternal return into a different body. The risk of inventing completely fictitious scenarios through hypnosis cannot be ignored. It actually has happened many times. Remember the many cases of women who came for hypnotic treatment for their common problems, and over the course of therapy discovered incidents of sexual abuse by parents during childhood, which proved to be false. Even Freud abandoned hypnosis as a treatment method when he discovered so many cases of fake memories. More than that, it was observed that the memories "discovered" under hypnosis can replace the true memories after the hypnotic session is over and distort completely one’s personal life. This is called false memory syndrome. Courts of law know these dangers and most do not accept testimonies produced under hypnosis or from witnesses that have been previously hypnotized. The same way as alleged sexual abuses in childhood discovered through hypnosis have been proved to be false, past lives can be also fake scenarios. Another compromising factor in getting true "past life stories" is the preparation the patient undergoes before hypnosis. He is informed about its purpose, which induces in him a high expectancy state. The conscious desire to know "his previous lives" undoubtedly influences his response under hypnosis. A third possibility to explain testimonies from alleged previous lives belongs to psychiatry. This medical branch suggests that past lives testimonies are nothing but the result of inducing the phenomenon of multiple personality through hypnosis, as there are many behavioral similarities between this phenomenon and past life regression cases. Multiple personality is a common feature of schizophrenia, which causes somebody to exchange in a short period of time up to 20 distinct personalities, as if playing successive roles. These contradicting personalities have different mentalities, behaviors, voices and even sexes than the real person. Usually it happens that one of them knows and observes the acts and thoughts of the others, and is even able to speak in the name of all. Inducing new personalities by the use of hypnosis has actually happened in several cases of schizophrenia. Used to uncover covert personalities and reintegrate them with the main personality, most cases of hypnosis have produced new personalities that didn’t manifest previously in one’s normal state. They first appeared during hypnotic treatment, and then remained active after the session was over. So there really is possible to create new personalities or "past life recalls" through hypnosis. However, there still remains an enigma to which the above naturalist-scientific interpretation doesn’t have a satisfactory answer: How are the "past live" personalities distributed in their roles, or who decides which one will be next in the show? It cannot be a random process. Ian Wilson writes in his book: "Somewhere, somehow, the show must have a ‘director’. It is like watching a puppet show; we can see the puppets, see some of the strings by which they are made to work, but cannot see the puppet master."

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (3 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity Who could be this hidden director of the multiple personality show? The naturalistic explanation says that it must be in the person’s mind, where consciousness is divided into separate entities, one of them taking the role of the director. The data supporting it is that sometimes, under hypnosis, a certain part of the mind stays conscious, continuing to receive data from the real surrounding area. The unsolved problem with this explanation is the motivation of such an entity (remained conscious in the person’s mind) to act like that. Why should it fool the people around about past lives? Thus we come to another possible explanation of past life recall. In parapsychology it is called channeling, representing the phenomena of transmitting information generated by spiritual entities which are external to our world. They act through certain persons called mediums while being in altered states of consciousness. In channeling there are always external personal beings (spirits) involved in providing information through mediums. The annihilation of normal consciousness through hypnosis creates optimal conditions for contacting such external teachers, who can present themselves as personalities of one’s past lives. The only reason for rejecting this hypothesis is the presumption that the entity which is communicating through the medium has no reason to lie when it claims to be a reincarnated personality and not an external spirit. Although there have been many cases when such entities were caught lying, we will analyze in a later section their possible identity from a Christian point of view, and also their motivation for doing so. In conclusion, the only criteria in establishing the veracity of "past life recall" is our trust in the hypnotist and his "past life recall" interpretation. There is no other way of relating the scenario of an alleged past life to one’s actual person. This is why we will now examine the other "strong evidence" for reincarnation through past life recall.

Spontaneous past life recall by children as proof for reincarnation

Another category of experiences credited as proofs for reincarnation are the cases when certain people, almost all children under the age of 10, spontaneously recall events of alleged past lives, insisting to be someone else who lived in the past. The details they mention concerning places, persons and happenings of the past, about which they could not normally know anything, prove to be true when investigations are performed in the indicated area. Although the cases of spontaneous past life recall by children are much fewer than testimonies produced under hypnosis, they seem to be more convincing. However, there are other possibilities to interpret them, overruling the reincarnation explanation. One alternative explanation is the possibility of these children's contacting external spirits, through channeling. In this case the medium would be the child, without necessarily being conscious of it. However, this explanation is not too convincing, especially because the children do not seem to be skilled in communicating with spirits. A better explanation would be the possession of these children by external spiritual entities. This phenomenon is related to channeling, but this time the human person is forced to transmit the messages of a spirit without having any conscious contribution to the whole process. In other words, possession implies that the invading spirit enters the body and takes over entirely the control of human consciousness, acting as if a past life personality would be manifesting itself. This explanation is more likely to be valid for the following reason: Almost all cases of spontaneous past life recall experiences

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (4 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity are produced by children who manifest them between the age of two and five, when their spiritual discernment is almost nonexistent, especially concerning spirits. This situation makes them easier to be manipulated by external spirits. As the child grows up, the entities lose their power of influence upon him, which could explain why the past life memories are lost after the age of 10. Again, one argument against this explanation is the presupposition that such external spirits have no reason to lie about their true identity. Another argument is the fact that the child does not manifest the classic symptoms of violent possession. However, acting violent is not the only possible form of manifesting spiritual possession. A confirmation of the possession hypothesis is the cases when the possessing spirit enters the child’s body a long time after he was born, and then produces the past life recall experience interfering with the actual personality of the child. There are enough such cases described in literature. Here is a brief description of two mentioned by Ian Stevenson, a famous researcher of this phenomenon, in his book Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation: First, there is the case of an Indian boy named Jasbir, aged three and a half, who was very ill and lapsed into a coma which his family temporarily mistook for death. He revived a few hours later, and after several weeks displayed a completely transformed behavior, claiming to be a Brahmin named Sobha Ram, who died in an accident while he (Jasbir) was sick. As Sobha Ram died when Jasbir was already three and a half years old, his "past life recall" obviously cannot be a proof of reincarnation. More than that, it is likely that the "reincarnation" of Ram’s soul took place even before he had physically died, according to the timing of his accident and the illness of Jasbir. For the previous 3.5 years both persons lived physically in nearby villages. While speaking through Jasbir, the "reincarnated Mr. Ram" said that he was advised by a saint to take cover in Jasbir’s body. So at a certain moment there were present two personalities in Jasbir’s body: the one of the child and the one of Mr. Ram. This suggests that it cannot be a case of reincarnation here, but rather a possession of Jasbir’s body by the so-called spirit of Mr. Ram. Second, there is the case of Lurancy Vennum, a one-year-old girl who began to display the personality of Mary Roff when she (Mary Roff) died. This situation lasted several months, while Mary Roff claimed to have occupied the vacated body of the little girl. After this period Mary Roff departed and Lurancy Vennum resumed control. The overlapping of personalities and messages displayed during that period are strong indications of possession, excluding any possibility for reincarnation. Ian Stevenson admits in his book that "other cases of the present group of 20 cases may be instances of similar ‘possessing influences’ in which the previous personality just happened to die well before the birth of the present personality’ body" (p. 381). A further indication for understanding spontaneous past life recall experiences by children is the fact that they are culturally dependent. Most cases are reported in India and other Eastern countries, where reincarnation is fully accepted. The Asian cases are always richer in details than the Western ones. Western children who have such experiences give only poor details that could permit verification. When checking some verifiable details is possible, they usually turn out to be past experiences of other members of the family. Cultural conditioning certainly plays an important role in these phenomena. For this reason Ian Stevenson, the well known researcher of this phenomena, was forced to admit in his book Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation that the cases he studied, as the very title of his book indicates, are only suggesting reincarnation and cannot be considered proofs for it. If this is the case, they could be also suggestive of spirit possession.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (5 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity

Metaphysical reasons for rejecting past life recall experiences as proofs for reincarnation

Even if hypnotic regression and spontaneous recall of past life by children were free of any contradiction, there still would be another major argument against their veracity: According to the classic doctrine of reincarnation, the entity which reincarnates is the impersonal self (atman or purusha), accompanied by karmic debt. Any psycho-mental element that defines personhood does not belong to the self or to the subtle body, and therefore ceases to exist at physical death. Memory is such an element. It acts only inside the limits of a physical life and vanishes at death. If things were different, if memory could pass to further lives through reincarnation, it would have the same ontological nature as the self, which is absurd, because memory belongs to the psycho-mental realm of personhood. Usually it is said that the vehicle that carries the psychic impressions from one life to another is the subtle body (sukshma sharira in Vedanta) or the karmic deposit (karmashaya in Samkhya-Yoga). Although some say that these two elements act as a kind of unconscious memory of previous lives, they cannot represent a third ontological nature (different to both the self and the psycho-mental realm), which could play the role of a transmissible personal memory from one life to another. Karmashaya and sukshma sharira are a mere expression of the way karma records the debts of the past. As karma represents an impersonal and mechanical law which functions with mathematical precision, karma itself cannot justify one’s state at a certain moment. In other words, man cannot communicate with his karma. Karma is simply pushing the self into a foreordained scenario, without communicating which debts are to be paid from previous lives. Even though some special meditative techniques are mentioned, which could render some limited information about past lives (for instance Yoga-Sutra 3.18 mentions the possibility to know the previous birth through practicing samyama), they are available only for the advanced Yogi. Even so, the veracity of the information gotten in altered states of consciousness is doubtful. (Click here for more information.) One’s karmic debts could at best be imagined intuitively. For instance, it is supposed that a man who was murdered took his just reward for a murder he did himself in a previous life. Not even the past life recall experiences give any information about the "sins" one did in his previous life, but only figure out cases when he was a victim or a simple observer of life around him. These kinds of experiences do not attempt to prove the justice of karma, but only that past lives are real. In other words, the "recalled" scenarios do not indicate which facts of the previous life produced the present incarnation, but only try to prove that we lived previous lives, that reincarnation is true and has to be accepted in our belief. Because of the metaphysical considerations mentioned above, most Eastern gurus do not consider experiences of past life recall as valid proofs for reincarnation. These experiences are appreciated mostly by Westerners, probably as a result of misunderstanding the original doctrine of reincarnation and also because of their pseudo-scientific outlook. The main argument for reincarnation in the East has another nature and will be analyzed next.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (6 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Reincarnation, its meaning and consequences. Reincarnation and Christianity Next: Reincarnation and cosmic justice Reincarnation and Christianity

http://www.comparativereligion.com/reincarnation1.html (7 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:49:23 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal?

SUMMARY Are all religions heading toward the same goal?

The following table summarizes a comparison of the major topics analyzed in the previous files on world religions. Please do not jump in here without first reading the previous articles. Otherwise this short abstract may seem confusing.

Topic In the Eastern religions In Christianity

1. Ultimate In most cases impersonal. God is triune and Reality personal (the Holy Hindu pantheism proclaims the impersonal Brahman Trinity), distinct from as the source of any existence. The gods are mere His creation. products of its manifestation. In Tantrism and Hatha Yoga, Shiva and Shakti are the two aspects (static and (In Judaism and Islam, dynamic) corresponding to Brahman. God is also personal, but not triune.) In the Yoga-darshana of Patanjali, Ishvara is an impersonal macro-purusha, with a symbolic role in the system. Theistic Hinduism accepts personal gods as Ultimate Reality, but karma and the periodical dissolution of the universe limit them. Theravada Buddhism is agnostic about it; no Ultimate Reality is stated. Mahayana Buddhism states the impersonal void (shunya) as Ultimate Reality. In Taoism there is the Tao as impersonal principle that rules the universe.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (1 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal?

2. The Manifestation of the impersonal Ultimate Reality (in God’s creation out of physical Hindu pantheism, Mahayana Buddhism, Taoism), and nothing (ex nihilo). world generator of illusion from which man has to detach Matter is not illusory and himself. is not bad in itself. Manifestation of the primordial substance (prakriti) in the dualistic Samkhya-Yoga. Transformation of a primordial substance by the gods of Hindu theism. (In Gnosticism and other dualistic philosophies matter is the creation of an evil god.)

3. Man Manifestation of the Ultimate Reality, according to Creation of God with a the pantheistic schools, which has in itself a divine personal status. essence (atman, purusha) of an impersonal nature. Personhood has nothing Product of the five aggregates, according to Theravada bad or illusory in itself. Buddhism, which generate the illusion of personal However, man does not existence. Personhood is always illusory and a have the divine nature of hindrance in attaining liberation. God. (In Gnosticism man is a spiritual being imprisoned in a material body.)

4. Man’s Ignorance in getting to know his true divine nature. Fallen into a state of present Ignorance and karma are closely linked and force man alienation from God, condition into the reincarnation cycle. called sin.

5. The According to the pantheistic religions, detachment Return to a personal meaning of from the illusion of personal existence and merging of relation with God, salvation the divine self with the impersonal Ultimate which will endure Reality. In the Samkhya-Yoga darshanaspurusha forever. remains forever isolated from prakriti. In Theravada Buddhism, annihilation of any existence. (In Gnosticism salvation means souls' return to the original angelic state.)

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (2 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal?

6. The way of Man has all resources in himself for attaining Man cannot attain attaining liberation. He can choose the way of devotion (bhakti salvation by his own salvation marga), the way of selfless living (karma marga), or efforts. God took the the way of knowing his divine nature (or the illusion initiative and gave the of any permanent existence - in Buddhism) by only solution for man’s meditation and asceticism (jnana marga). salvation through the sacrifice of Jesus Christ In most cases of theistic Hinduism and devotional on the cross. Man has to Buddhism, the gods (or bodhisattvas) can help man accept this grace. only if he deserves it, as a result of his own efforts. Grace plays a minor role, except in a few particular (In Islam and Judaism cases (prapatti in Hinduism and Pure Land man is not saved by Buddhism). grace, but by the good deeds he has to perform.)

7. The Only spiritually evolved masters can attain liberation This is our only life moment of during one life. Most people need many lives to live (Hebrews 9:27) and is attaining out the consequences of karma and overcome illusion enough in order to accept salvation and ignorance. God’s grace.

8. The The present life is shaped entirely according to the Man didn’t live previous meaning of dictates of one’s karma. There cannot be real lives and is free to man’s freedom in this condition, so man has to accept his choose his eternal freedom preordained destiny. destiny. Although man inherits a fallen nature, he can always accept God’s grace.

9. The Guru, avatar, enlightened master, saint, etc. He is a God the Son incarnated, identity of perfect example of what any of us can become. one of the hypostases of Jesus Christ The Holy Trinity. (In Islam just a prophet, in Judaism a blasphemer against God.)

10. The Irrelevant. Man can escape from his karma and find The only solution for meaning of liberation only by his own efforts. our salvation, sufficient Jesus’ death for all mankind (John on the cross (According to Gnosticism it was either an illusion or a 14,6). historical hoax.) (In Islam it is not accepted as true. In Judaism it is the right punishment Jesus got for blasphemy.)

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (3 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal?

11. The view Absurd. Spiritual progress cannot mean a return to the The proof of His divinity on Jesus’ physical body. and efficient atonement physical for our salvation. resurrection (According to Gnosticism a ghostly appearance.) (In Islam and Judaism not accepted as true.)

12. The Illusory, as all existence is a manifestation of the Evil is real, although not nature of evil Ultimate Reality. Suffering is a result of karma and of the same ontological man’s ignorance of his true nature. nature as that of God. Its origin is a being, Satan, who once rebelled against God and now acts against Him and man. Man’s sin is perpetuating evil and suffering in our world.

13. The Evil (as illusion) is generated by the manifestation of Satan is opposed to God, relation the impersonal Ultimate Reality. Without its acts against Him, but between the manifestation there would be no subject to experience will be isolated forever Ultimate evil. in hell at the judgment Reality and day. evil

14. God’s None, as evil is illusory. Man has to work out his God solved the problem solution for own karma and do his best to escape suffering by of evil through the the problem transcending personhood. The Hindu avatars are just atoning sacrifice of of evil reminders of the right spiritual path. Buddhist Jesus Christ. At the end bodhisattvas help people to attain a spiritual realm of history He will judge where they can hear the proper doctrine and attain and punish all evildoers. liberation easier.

15. Man’s Ignoring the problem, withdrawal from its reality. He Man has to oppose attitude can only accept the misfortunes of his life and that of suffering, according to toward others as dictates of karma. Any opposition would the principle of loving suffering only worsen his future condition. your neighbor (Matthew 22,39).

16. The role Mere instruments for one’s cleansing oneself of Means of expressing of compassion egoistic attachments. They do not seek the welfare of one's new identity in and charity the one that is suffering, but are only means for Christ, following His escaping the world of illusion by the one who example, for the benefit performs them. of others (John 13,34).

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (4 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal?

17. Man’s Absurd, it would be an obstacle in attaining The Christian has to be social liberation because of the attachments it produces. an example of social involvement Only detached social involvement is possible, devoid involvement in the of any personal motivation (as the Bhagavad Gita society (Matthew 5,16). requires).

18. The Morality has no value in itself, as it produces false There are positive and meaning of attachments. It can be used in attaining liberation as negative moral values, moral values an instrument for defeating egoism. between which one has to exercise discernment (Galatians 5,17-23).

19. The view Cyclical. Periodical dissolution of the universe Linear. Human history of history determines an endless repetition of world’s history. has a beginning and an end.

20. The way Christianity is, at best, a mere inferior way (a bhakti As man cannot attain the two type) of attaining liberation. salvation by himself, and perspectives Jesus said He is the only consider each way to God (John 14,6), other other religions cannot play the same role.

Conclusion

The obvious conclusion is that the meanings of the major topics in world religions are fundamentally opposed, especially in the case of Eastern religions towards Christianity. Out of this result two important implications: ● The teaching of the Hindu tale of the blind men (who tried to describe the elephant) is valid only for the multitude of pantheistic religions. They are all heading toward the same impersonal Ultimate Reality, using similar means. However, Christianity definitely rejects this view and therefore cannot be included in it, by any means. ● Christianity cannot be used as an ingredient in order to produce a “homogenous mixture” with other religions, according to the demands of today’s world syncretism, or else it would be totally compromised. Despite these implications, there are a lot of attempts to “reconcile” Christianity with “the big family” of world religions. At the beginning of the 2nd century AD Gnosticism appeared and then Neoplatonism (3rd century AD) as the first syncretistic products of pantheism and Christianity. During the Middle Ages, Gnosticism flourished and generated several subsequent movements such as Manicheism, Catharism, Bogomilism, Albigensianism, the Knight Templars, Hermeticism, etc. The apogee of this trend began last century, in 1875, when Theosophy was grounded by Helena Blavatsky, and later Anthroposophy by Rudolf Steiner. The fact that these movements are closer to Eastern spirituality than to

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (5 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal? Christianity is obvious when examining their main tenets: Ultimate Reality is not a personal God, but the all-pervading oneness; the world is a manifestation of the impersonal Ultimate Reality; man has a divine inner nature which is the higher self; karma and samsara are fully accepted; one’s true spiritual nature is to be found by engaging in the three steps of Vedanta meditation; the chakras have to be activated by spiritual exercises, etc. In fact, these movements are not attempts to find a middle way between Christianity and Eastern religions, but rather to adopt Christianity in the big family of pantheist ideologies. Apart from Theosophy and Anthroposophy, there are many Eastern masters today who travel all over the world in order to present their teachings in a “suitable” manner to the Western world. As a result, we can see many worldwide cults promoting Eastern teachings in a most attractive way for their adherents. The ultimate product of adapting pantheist teachings in the Western culture is called New Age spirituality. The element that makes it so attractive is the virtuosity it proves in combining the essence of Eastern pantheism with the occult traditions and the individualistic mentality of the West. It tries to get rid of Eastern pessimism, of its understanding of life as suffering, and replace it with an optimistic view of eternal progression of the self towards superior levels of existence. All occult traditions are accepted under its umbrella as various perspectives on the same ultimate truth: The divine nature of man has to be discovered inside oneself. The "unpopular" demands of Christianity, such as accepting we are all sinners and need repentance, God’s grace through Jesus Christ, etc, are all rejected. One of the major claims of the New Age syncretism is that Christianity cannot give all the answers to our spiritual quest, so that it is necessary to accept also the teachings of Eastern spirituality in order to get a comprehensive picture of the meaning of life. But does Christianity really need such “completion” or “crutches”? Does it have gaps that can be filled only by the help of Eastern spirituality? The Apostle Paul’s answer is negative. Reading his Epistle to the Colossians, we can figure out that his readers were struggling with the same issue, religious syncretism. He writes about the option of Christians’ finding spiritual help in the Hellenistic philosophy of that time: See to it that no one takes you captive through hollow and deceptive philosophy, which depends on human tradition and the basic principles of this world rather than on Christ. For in Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form, and you have been given fullness in Christ, who is the head over every power and authority (Colossians 2,8-10). If we can have “fullness in Christ”, what other completion can the Eastern religions bring us? Any element added to this “fullness” would only compromise its essence and efficiency. Therefore, it is absurd to combine Christianity with the “highlights” of Eastern spirituality. Any Eastern contribution that should “help” us better understand the Bible, can only alter its message. In fact, Jesus Christ warned us against such attempts: Watch out that no one deceives you. For many will come in my name, claiming, “I am the Christ”, and will deceive many (Matthew 24,4-5). The Apostle Paul states that this deception is organized by Satan, who “masquerades as an angel of light” (2 Corinthians 11,14), and by the demons, who “masquerade as servants of righteousness” (11,15). These things are happening today and we should stay alert in order to avoid deception. Present day syncretism cannot bring spiritual progress and peace, as is claimed by the New Age Movement, but only confusion and spiritual delusion. The God of the Bible is totally opposed to spiritual syncretism, as the very first command of the Mosaic Law requires no compromise in this area (Exodus 20,3-5). The people of Israel met disaster precisely

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (6 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal? because they didn’t obey it and worshipped the gods of other nations. The climax of this situation was reached during the reign of king Manasseh, when God stated through the prophet Jeremiah: “I will make them abhorrent to all the kingdoms of the earth because of what Manasseh son of Hezekiah king of Judah did in Jerusalem” (Jeremiah 15,4). What Manasseh did was the following: Manasseh did evil in the eyes of the Lord, following the detestable practices of the nations the Lord had driven out before the Israelites. He rebuilt the high places his father Hezekiah had demolished; he also erected altars to the Baals and made Asherah poles. He bowed down to all the starry hosts and worshiped them. He built altars in the temple of the Lord, of which the Lord had said, "My Name will remain in Jerusalem forever." In both courts of the temple of the Lord, he built altars to all the starry hosts. He sacrificed his sons in the fire in the Valley of Ben Hinnom, practiced sorcery, divination and witchcraft, and consulted mediums and spiritists. He did much evil in the eyes of the Lord, provoking him to anger. He took the carved image he had made and put it in God's temple, of which God had said to David and to his son Solomon, "In this temple and in Jerusalem, which I have chosen out of all the tribes of Israel, I will put my Name forever. I will not again make the feet of the Israelites leave the land I assigned to your forefathers, if only they will be careful to do everything I commanded them concerning all the laws, decrees and ordinances given through Moses." But Manasseh led Judah and the people of Jerusalem astray, so that they did more evil than the nations the Lord had destroyed before the Israelites. The Lord spoke to Manasseh and his people, but they paid no attention (2 Chronicles 33,2-10). The worst thing Manasseh could do, that no other king did before him, was to bring the idols inside the temple, generating a double worship system in God’s temple, which perverted the only possibility for reconciling the nation with God. Even if his deeds might have been politically justified (in order to have peace and be accepted by the other nations), spiritually it was against the clear command of God. Although Manasseh later repented, religious syncretism entered people’s hearts. They reached a point where repentance was impossible and spiritual confusion became so great that God had to punish them according to the Mosaic covenant (see Leviticus 18,24-30). So there is no sign of encouraging spiritual syncretism in the Old Testament. The same situation is presented in the New Testament. Jesus Christ did not claim to be one of the many ways to God, but the only one: I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me (John 14,6). This statement doesn’t need too many comments. It should be very embarrassing for those who try to find alternative ways to God, or maybe even a middle way through religious syncretism. If all religions would have been valid alternatives to God, what use would Jesus' dramatic death on the cross have had? Why such an extreme solution for our sins, if each of us could reach God by diligently following the already existent religious traditions at hand? Although it is sometimes claimed that this solution for salvation was valid only for the Israelites of his time, Jesus himself dismissed this hypothesis by commanding his disciples: Go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age (Matthew 28,19-20). Why would Jesus have commanded this, if the religions of all nations had been valid ways to God? Why would so many Christian martyrs die in order to proclaim one of the many alternative ways to God? It seems obvious that Christianity does not accept religious syncretism. As the conclusion of our quest, we

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (7 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] Are all religions heading toward the same goal? can state that spiritual truth is not a matter of both-and (both Christianity and other religions are true), but one of either-or. World religions cannot be all equally true. The choice for one or another belongs to you. Back to Top | Back to Contents | E-Mail |

http://www.comparativereligion.com/conclusion.html (8 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:49:30 AM] 5th Ecumenical Council (2nd Constaninople) - Anathemas against Origen THE FIFTH ECUMENICAL COUNCIL THE SECOND COUNCIL OF CONSTANTINOPLE A.D. 553

THE ANATHEMAS AGAINST ORIGEN.

I IF anyone asserts the fabulous pre-existence of souls, and shall assert the monstrous restoration which follows from it: let him be anathema. II. IF anyone shall say that the creation (thu paragwghn) of all reasonable things includes only intelligences (noas) without bodies and altogether immaterial, having neither number nor name, so that there is unity between them all by identity of substance, force and energy, and by their union with and knowledge of God the Word; but that no longer desiring the sight of God, they gave themselves over to worse things, each one following his own inclinations, and that they have taken bodies more or less subtile, and have received names, for among the heavenly Powers there is a difference of names as there is also a difference of bodies; and thence some became and are called Cherubims, others Seraphims, and Principalities, and Powers, and Dominations, and Thrones, and Angels, and as many other heavenly orders as there may be: let him be anathema. III. IF anyone shall say that the sun, the moon and the stars are also reasonable beings, and that they have only become what they are because they turned towards evil: let him be anathema. IV. IF anyone shall say that the reasonable creatures in whom the divine love had grown cold have been hidden in gross bodies such as ours, and have been called men, while those who have attained the lowest degree of wickedness have shared cold and obscure bodies and are become and called demons and evil spirits: let him be anathema,. V. IF anyone shall say that a psychic (yukikhn) condition has come from an angelic or archangelic state, and moreover that a demoniac and a human condition has come from a psychic condition, and that from a human state they may become again angels and demons, and that each order of heavenly virtues is either all from those below or from those above, or from those above and below: let him be anathema. VI. IF anyone shall say that there is a twofold race of demons, of which the one includes the souls of men

http://www.comparativereligion.com/anathemas.html (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:49:33 AM] 5th Ecumenical Council (2nd Constaninople) - Anathemas against Origen and the other the superior spirits who fell to this, and that of all the number of reasonable beings there is but one which has remained unshaken in the love and contemplation of God, and that that spirit is become Christ and the king of all reasonable beings, and that he has created(1) all the bodies which exist in heaven, on earth, and between heaven and earth; and that the world which has in itself elements more ancient than itself, and which exists by themselves, viz.: dryness, damp, heat and cold, and the image (idean) to which it was formed, was so formed, and that the most holy and consubstantial Trinity did not create the world, but that it was created by the working intelligence (Nous dhmiourgos) which is more ancient than the world, and which communicates to it its being: let him be anathema. VII. IF anyone shah say that Christ, of whom it is said that he appeared in the form of God, and that he was united before all time with God the Word, and humbled himself in these last days even to humanity, had (according to their expression) pity upon the divers falls which had appeared in the spirits united in the same unity (of which he himself is part), and that to restore them he passed through divers classes, had different bodies and different names, became all to all, an Angel among Angels, a Power among Powers, has clothed I himself in the different classes of reasonable beings with a form corresponding to that class, and finally has taken flesh and blood like ours and is become man for men; [if anyone says all this] and does not profess that God the Word humbled himself and became man: let him be anathema. VIII. IF anyone shall not acknowledge that God the Word, of the same substance with the Father and the Holy Ghost, and who was made flesh and became man, one of the Trinity, is Christ in every sense of the word, but [shall affirm] that he is so only in an inaccurate manner, and because of the abasement (kenwsanta), as they call it, of the intelligence (nous); if anyone shall affirm that this intelligence united (sunhmmenon) to God the Word, is the Christ in the true sense of the word, while the Logos is only called Christ because of this union with the intelligence, and e converse that the intelligence is only called God because of the Logos: let him be anathema. IX. IF anyone shall say that it was not the Divine Loges made man by taking an animated body with a yukh logikh and noera, that he descended into hell and ascended into heaven, but shall pretend that it is the Nous which has done this, that Nous of which they say (in an impious fashion) he is Christ properly so called, and that he is become so by the knowledge of the Monad: let him be anathema. X IF anyone shall say that after the resurrection the body of the Lord was ethereal, having the form of a sphere, and that such shall be the bodies of all after the resurrection; and that after the Lord himself shall have rejected his true body and after the others who rise shall have rejected theirs, the nature of their bodies shall be annihilated: let him be anathema. XI. IF anyone shall say that the future judgment signifies the destruction of the body and that the end of the

http://www.comparativereligion.com/anathemas.html (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:49:34 AM] 5th Ecumenical Council (2nd Constaninople) - Anathemas against Origen story will be an immaterial yusis, and that thereafter there will no longer be any matter, but only spirit nous): let him be anathema. XII. IF anyone shall say that the heavenly Powers and all men and the Devil and evil spirits are united with the Word of God in all respects, as the Nous which is by them called Christ and which is in the form of God, and which humbled itself as they say; and [if anyone shall say] that the Kingdom of Christ shall have an end: let him be anathema. XIII. IF anyone shall say that Christ [i.e., the Nous is in no wise different from other reasonable beings, neither substantially nor by wisdom nor by his power and might over all things but that all will be placed at the right hand of God, as well as he that is called by them Christ [the Nous, as also they were in the reigned pre-existence of all things: let him be anathema. XIV. IF anyone shall say that all reasonable beings will one day be united in one, when the hypostases as well as the numbers and the bodies shall have disappeared, and that the knowledge of the world to come will carry with it the ruin of the worlds, and the rejection of bodies as also the abolition of [all] names, and that there shall be finally an identity of the gnpsis and of the hypostasis; moreover, that in this pretended apocatastasis, spirits only will continue to exist, as it was in the reigned pre-existence: let him be anathema. XV. IF anyone shall say that the life of the spirits (nopn) shall be like to the life which was in the beginning while as yet the spirits had not come down or fallen, so that the end and the beginning shall be alike, and that the end shall be the true measure of the beginning: let him be anathema.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/anathemas.html (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:49:34 AM] The human condition in world religions

THE HUMAN CONDITION IN WORLD RELIGIONS

Ever since he existed, man has been attracted by life's mystery: its origin, meaning, and finality. The author of Shvetashvatara Upanishad asks: “Whence are we born? Whereby do we live, and whither do we go?” (1,1). Consequently, not only Hinduism, but all religions need to give an answer to the fundamental questions concerning creation, life, and death. What is man? According to pantheist religions, a small part of the Ultimate Reality locked up by the illusion of physical experience. According to monotheistic religions, a person created in the image and likeness of God. According to others, like Theravada Buddhism, nothing but an illusion, a temporary combination of five aggregates, none of which is ultimately real. Dualistic religions, like Gnosticism and Manicheism, state that man is a spiritual being originated in another world, a kind of angel fallen in his present miserable condition. What is man's present condition? Are we departed from the created status as a result of sin, defined as a moral barrier against our Creator? Or are we rather a product of the periodical manifestation of the Ultimate Reality, and thus ignoring our true spiritual nature? Do we have a soul that predated our birth or not? Is our personal character illusory, or do we keep it for a further existence? Is our destiny limited to this present existence or do we inherit an eternal one, and if eternal, is it personal or impersonal, conformed with the character of the Creator or absorbed into the impersonal nature out of which all things emanated? These are some of the aspects that define human condition in the world’s religions. Closely related to how human nature is defined are the values we pursue in life and the kind of relation we have with our neighbors. In the previous file, we have seen that the world religions do not agree on what they hold as Ultimate Reality. Could it then still be possible that humans share the same condition? The same destiny? Following the pattern used in the previous file, we will analyze the way man is defined in relation to Ultimate Reality, his origin and present condition. Beginning with Hinduism, we will continue with the other Eastern religions and finish with the perspective of monotheistic religions, especially Christianity.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (1 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:51 AM] The human condition in world religions Man’s condition in Hinduism

The Vedas

According to the Vedic cosmogony of the golden egg (Hiranyagarbha), both gods and men have their origin in an impersonal primordial entity (Rig Veda 10,129). The Brahmana texts add the appearance of a Creator (Prajapati) from the golden egg (Shatapatha Br. 11,1,6), who created the world and humans out of his own body, by the power of his ardor (tapas). The Purushasukta hymn (Rig Veda 10,90) states that the product of the golden egg is the giant Purusha, and through his sacrifice by the gods the physical world was built, the four caste system, the animals and the duality of sexes. Although the Vedic hymns do not clearly state what role the most worshipped gods played in the creation of man, man is responsible to them for how he lives his life. The prayers people address to Varuna, Indra, Agni or other gods denote a sinful human nature. Man constantly asks for forgiveness for the sins he does, which are either errors in performing the right religious ritual, or faults against one’s neighbor: If we have sinned against the man who loves us, Have wronged a brother, a dear friend, or a comrade, The neighbor of long standing or a stranger, Remove from us this stain, O King Varuna. (Rig Veda 5,85,7) To the fire god Agni, who burns away sins through the fire ritual, people ask for forgiveness, but also for material welfare: Shining brightly, Agni, drive away our sin, and shine wealth on us. Shining bright, drive away our sin. For good fields, for good homes, for wealth, we made our offerings to you. Shining bright, drive away our sin. (Rig Veda 1,97,1-2) According to the hymns of the Rig Veda, man is a personal being dependent on the gods, and his destiny is eternal life in a celestial world. Here is how the worshippers of Indra express their longing for personal immortality: Make me immortal in the realm where the son of Vivasvat (Yama) reigns, Where lies heaven’s secret shrine, where are those waters that are ever young. For Indra, flow you on, Indu! Make me immortal in that realm where movement is accordant to wish, In the third region, the third heaven of heavens, where the worlds are resplendent. For Indra, flow you on, Indu! (Rig Veda 9,113,8-9)

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (2 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:51 AM] The human condition in world religions Yama, the god of death (mentioned in old Buddhist and Taoist scriptures too), is sovereign over the souls of the dead and also the one who receives the offerings of the family for the benefit of the departed. Divine justice was assured by the gods Yama, Soma and Indra, not by an impersonal law such as karma. One of their functions was to cast the wicked into an eternal dark prison from which they can never escape (Rig Veda 7,104,3; 17). It is important to keep in mind that the Vedas do not consider man as a part of an impersonal Absolute, with whom he should fuse after death. According to Vedic anthropology, the components of human nature are the physical body, asu and manas. Asu is the vital principle (different from personal attributes), and manas is the sum of psycho-mental faculties (mind, feeling and will). The belief in the preservation of the three components after death is proved by the fact that the family addressed the departed relative in the burial ritual as a unitary person: May nothing of thy manas, nothing of the asu, nothing of the limbs, nothing of thy vital fluid, nothing of thy body here by any means be lost (Atharva Veda 18,2,24). As was the case in ancient Chinese religion too, the departed relatives constituted a holy hierarchy. The last one deceased was commemorated individually for a year after his departure and then included in the mortuary offerings of the monthly shraddha ritual (Rig Veda 10,15,1-11). This ritual was necessary because the dead could influence toward good or bad the life of the living (Rig Veda 10,15,6). Beginning only with the Brahmana writings (after the 9th century BC), which are the first to mention a primitive idea of karma and reincarnation, did the tendency appear to abandon the idea of preservation of personhood after death. However, this was not the spirit of early Hinduism.

The unity atman-Brahman in the Upanishads and Vedanta

At a macrocosmic level, the Upanishads state that there is an ultimate unity of the world in Brahman, the impersonal matrix equivalent to the One of the Rig Veda (10,129). In their search for a fundamental entity of human nature, something that should be the unifying principle of all psycho-mental faculties, but above their temporal fluctuations, the Hindu rishis defined the concept of atman. In the Chandogya Upanishad (5,1,1) it is stated that breath (prana) is the “oldest and the best” principle that assures the functioning of all other psycho-mental capacities (sight, speech, hearing, thought). That is why from the notion of breath (Sanskrit “an” = “breathing”) derived the notion atman (reflexive pronoun), which came to designate the self, man’s spiritual being. Therefore atman is not the seat of personhood, or man’s soul, as it is sometimes mistakenly translated, but a spiritual entity distinct to personhood and to the physical body. Unlike all other manifestations of Brahman, atman is of the same ontological quality with Brahman; it does not fluctuate, it is expressionless, irreducible, eternal and pure: The self is not this, not this. He is incomprehensible for he is never comprehended. He is indestructible for he cannot be destroyed. He is unattached for he does not attach himself. He is unfettered, he does not suffer, he is not injured (Brihadaranyaka Up. 4,2,4). Given his condition as a product of Brahman’s manifestation, man's purpose in life is to join the returning process of all manifestations to the initial state of non-manifestation. This is possible only through dissociating the self (atman) from the corporeal and psycho-mental experience (that has an illusory value, as we’ll see later), and realizing the identity between his self and Brahman. However, there is an important aspect to emphasize here: Man’s return to Brahman is a concept that could raise

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (3 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:51 AM] The human condition in world religions confusion. In fact, Brahman is already present in man, both at a transcendent and an immanent level, that is, both as the absolute atman and the relative (gross) manifestations (body and psycho-mental faculties). Discerning between the two conditions is possible by gaining a deep mystical knowledge of atman: “The self is to be meditated upon for in it all these become one. This self is the foot-trace of all this, for by it one knows all this, just as one can find again by footprints (what was lost)” (Brihadaranyaka Up. 1,4,7). “Meditating on the self” means getting the knowledge of his essential identity with Brahman, and this knowledge is equivalent with attaining effectively the atman-Brahman identity, as the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad states: This is the great unborn self who is undecaying, undying, immortal, fearless, Brahman. Verily, Brahman is fearless. He who knows this becomes the fearless Brahman (4,4,25). However, there is the obstacle of illusion (maya) against getting this intuitive knowledge. Maya deceives man about the true nature of existence, channeling his wishes toward the phenomenal world that is ever changing. At the same time, maya strengthens the confusion of atman with the psycho-mental activity and the physical body. As a result of illusion, man grants true spiritual value to what is unstable and changing instead of knowing his eternal immutable self. This ignorance (avidya) is the cause of atman’s captivity in the world of material experience: Just as those who do not know the field walk again and again over the hidden treasure of gold and do not find it, even so all creatures here go day after day into the Brahma-world and yet do not find it, for they are carried away by untruth (Chandogya Up. 8,3,2). As a result of ignorance, in the spiritual world a process develops similar to the law of action and reaction that works in the physical world. This is karma, the law of action and retribution according to one’s deeds. Its origin is found in the exegesis of the benefits of sacrifice. It was thought that the same way sacrifices bring good results to the one who performs them, all his other acts need a reward too. This prevents him from entering the celestial world after death or limits his stay there, forcing him to come back in this life and reap the fruits of his deeds. (For more information on the subject of reincarnation, see our special file on this topic. As a result of karma, any action performed by man has an effect on its performer. The practical way one reaps the fruits of his deeds is reincarnation (samsara). It teaches that we live further lives as humans or, according to how badly we acted and how gross our ignorance was in detaching from the material world, as animals or plants. The first clear mention of samsara is in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (3,2,13), where it is mentioned that “one becomes good by good action, bad by bad action”. It is also stated that the reincarnation cycle is started by desire: “As is man’s desire so is his will; as is his will, so is the deed he does, whatever he does, that he attains” (4,4,5). The “desire” is that of experiencing the physical world, and consequently illusion, and “that he attains” is the fruit reaped in a further life, as a result of karma’s retribution. Karma is the direct link between desire and reincarnation, which builds a total inter-conditioning mechanism between the previous, the present and the next lives. As a result of karma’s retribution, any thought, word or deed of this life will find its reward in the next life, at the same level. In the Katha Upanishad (2,2,7) it is stated: “Some souls enter into a womb for embodiment; others enter stationary objects according to their deeds and according to their thoughts.” An important aspect to emphasize here is the fact that reincarnation should not be understood only as solution for punishing bad deeds. Reincarnation functions independently of how good or bad actions are. It follows only the necessity imposed by karma, an impersonal and amoral law. Between atman and moral values there is no possible connection: “He (atman) does not become greater by good works nor

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (4 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:51 AM] The human condition in world religions smaller by evil works. (. . .) What he has done or what he has not done does not burn him” (Brihadaranyaka Up. 4,4,22). Good deeds only provide a short reward in heaven, but then the soul has to return to earth and continue its struggle. In the Mundaka Upanishad (1,2,10) is stated: These deluded men, regarding sacrifices and works of merits as most important, do not know any other good. Having enjoyed in the high place of heaven won by good deeds, they enter again this world or a still lower one. The Upanishads mark a transition from the point where man's condition is determined by divine personal agents (such as the Vedic gods), to the situation of being totally controlled by the impersonal law of karma. As we anticipated before, from the polytheistic perspective of the Vedas, of a universe governed by a sovereign god (such as Varuna) through a law that was subordinated to him (rita), we arrived at the pantheistic view of the Upanishads, where the impersonal law of karma is ruling the world. In this situation man is alone facing his destiny, having the duty to escape by his own efforts from the vicious cycle avidya-karma-samsara, an objective that will be foundational to all Hindu religious systems.

Man’s condition in the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas

As we have seen in the previous file, these two darshanas are dualistic, accepting the real status of primordial substance (prakriti) beside purusha (the equivalent of atman). None is the manifestation of the other. Purusha and prakriti have different natures and do not aim to reconstruct a unique essence, as was the case in pantheism. Purusha, the self, is the spiritual entity that defines human existence from a transcendental point of view. It is the eternal substrata of the individual being, devoid of any attributes and relations, without beginning or end, indifferent, autonomous, immutable and perfect, above senses, intellect, time and space. All these categories belong to prakriti. Purusha can have relations only with itself. It can know only itself and contemplate itself. On the other hand, prakriti, the primordial substance, is capable of manifestation and produces all the physical and mental aspects of the world. Not only the physical world is a product of prakriti’s manifestation, through the loss of balance of the three gunas, but also the world of psycho-mental phenomena. Sattva produces virtue, wisdom and goodness; rajas produces passion, contradiction, agitation and wickedness; and tamas is responsible for generating ignorance, confusion, indifference and depression. The psychological human states are combinations of effects produced by the three gunas. For instance, when the sattva dominates, the soul is calm and tranquil; when rajas dominates there is passion and nervousness; and with tamas in control man is inert, lazy, and ignorant. Although there is not much known about how the initial balance between the three gunas was affected and how purusha got involved with the manifestations of prakriti, this situation is the source of all problems, the cause of purusha’s captivity in the illusion of psycho-mental activity. The confusion of the two opposite realities, the eternal purusha and the sum of psycho-mental activities, is maya, illusion. Persistence in this state is a result of ignorance (Yoga Sutra 2,24) and starts the process of karma and reincarnation. Purusha will reincarnate as many times as needed, according to the deeds performed by the individual in ignorance toward his true identity. All actions demand a fulfillment, or consummation, in the present or further lives. Samsara works the same way as in pantheism, until true knowledge about the nature of purusha is attained.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (5 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:51 AM] The human condition in world religions

Man’s condition in Hindu Tantrism and Hatha Yoga

As both Hindu Tantrism and Hatha Yoga describe in a similar way man’s condition in the world, we will analyze them together, emphasizing the differences just where it is needed. The world and mankind appeared through the dissociation of the primordial unity of Shiva and Shakti. In the Shiva Samhita (1,92), a text that is common to both religious schools, is stated: Out of the combination of spirit, which is Shiva, with matter, which is Shakti, and through the interaction of one with the other, all creatures were born. The self (atman) is considered to be Shakti, who lives in the human body as a spiritual energy called kundalini. Following the pattern of other pantheist schools, the goal to be pursued is the return of self (Shakti, corresponding to atman) in the Ultimate Reality represented by Shiva (the equivalent of Brahman). Illusion (maya), ignorance (avidya), karma and reincarnation are described in a similar way with other Hindu schools. Personhood and empirical knowledge are two main categories that produce false attachments and have to be surpassed.

Man’s condition in theistic Hinduism

The main Hindu theistic schools are those who worship Vishnu (including his avatars such as Rama and Krishna), Shiva and Shakti (called also Durga or Kali). Out of the many forms of theistic Hinduism that exist in the present, we will analyze briefly only some aspects of Vaishnavism as it was stated by the great theistic Hindu thinkers Ramanuja and Madhva. (There is also available a special file aimed to analyze the theism of the well-known poem Bhagavad Gita. The works of Ramanuja and Madhva represent an extraordinary contribution to Hindu spirituality, by the special way they understood the relation between man and divinity and the significance of salvation. According to them, man has a totally different nature from Vishnu, the personal god who is accepted as Ultimate Reality, and there is no impersonal atman-Brahman fusion that has to be attained. According to Ramanuja, God’s relation to the world is similar to that existing between soul and body. As the body cannot exist separately from the soul, the existence of the universe and of individual beings depends totally on God. He conducts the souls, they cannot exist without him, but have also energies and activities of their own. The individuality of each soul (jiva) is not an illusion that has to be discarded through knowledge, but a metaphysical fact. Although they depend entirely on God, individual souls are real, unique, eternal, and possess intelligence and conscience. The main causes of their present state are ignorance (defined as the illusory idea of independence from God) and the desire for seeking material goods. The souls enter into connection with material bodies according to the karma they acquired in previous forms of existence. Karma is an instrument used by God to remind humans their true status and what they should actually seek in life. But the question of how souls first came under the power of karma is unanswered, because the cosmic process has no beginning. For Madhva too, matter and mankind depend totally on God. The ontological differences between God, humans and matter are fundamental and eternal. There are three phases in the existence of a soul: 1) the dormant state; 2) the transmigration process; 3) the liberated state. God is the one who introduces the soul into the stream of transmigration so that he might discover his spiritual nature. In the incarnated

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (6 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions state, the physical and subtle bodies produce the illusion of independence toward God and also attachment to the physical world, perpetuating in this way the chain of samsara.

Man’s condition in Buddhism

Following the ascetic tradition of his time, Buddha described the human condition in very harsh terms: Behold this painted body, a body full of wounds, put together, diseased, and full of many thoughts in which there is neither permanence nor stability. This body is worn out, a nest of diseases and very frail. This heap of corruption breaks in pieces, life indeed ends in death. What delight is there for him who sees these white bones like gourds cast away in the autumn? Of the bones a citadel is made, plastered over with flesh and blood, and in it dwell old age and death, pride and deceit. (Dhammapada 147-150) The all-pervading reality of suffering as motivation for seeking liberation is not a new element in Hindu spirituality. The Upanishads exploited this topic long before Buddhism appeared. Following the existent branches of Hinduism, Buddhism adopted a similar attitude towards the futility of empirical knowledge (provided by senses and psycho-mental activity). This kind of information is considered to be illusory, feeding the sense of individuality and the bondage of karma. From this point Buddha went further than the ideologies of his time, including in the domain of illusion even the fundamental concepts of Upanishadic philosophy: atman and Brahman. His new doctrine was centered on two other fundamental pillars: suffering (dukkha) and nirvana, its radical solution. In a famous text he stated: There is grief but none suffering, There is no doer though there is action. There is quietude but none tranquil. There is the path but none walks upon the path. (Majjhima Nikaya,1) This means that Buddhism denies the reality of atman, together with all things pertaining to the phenomenal world. The appearance of human existence is generated by a mere heap of five aggregates (skandha), which suffer from constant becoming and have a functional cause-effect relation: 1) the body (that consists of material form and senses), 2) sensation (product of the senses), 3) perception (built on sensation), 4) mental activity and 5) consciousness. The heap of aggregates generates the illusion of personal existence, the false notions of person (puggala), vital principle (jiva) and atman. All the five elements, as well as human existence itself, are impermanent (anitya), undergo constant transformation, and have no abiding principle or self. Man usually thinks that he has a self because of consciousness. But being itself in a constant process of becoming and change, consciousness cannot be identified with a self, which is supposed to be permanent. Therefore, beyond the five aggregates nothing else can be found in man. The rejection of a self has most of all a practical significance. All discussions and philosophical debates on the existence and definition of atman have as the only result persistence in suffering, and are hindrances in attaining liberation. The Buddha argued that the answers we would like to know about the character of the universe, the existence of a soul or a transcendent Ultimate Reality, start debates that lead us astray from our real problem, which is escaping from suffering (Majjhima Nikaya 1,426). He discouraged speculative thinking on these issues in order to concentrate all one's efforts in reaching nirvana, a state where they all lose any importance, not because the answers are found, but because in

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (7 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions nirvana there is no one left to get them. Some immediate problems raised against Buddhism came from the way it described man as having no abiding principle or self. If there is no self, who is actually suffering the pain of which Buddha was speaking so much? The question didn’t receive a proper answer. Other problems arise concerning the significance of reincarnation. If there is no self, what is reincarnated from one existence to another? Buddha answered that only karma is passing from one life to another, using the illustration of the light of a candle, which is derived from other candle without having a substance of its own. In the same manner, there is rebirth without the transfer of a self from one body to another. The only link from one life to the next one has a causal nature. This is without doubt the weirdest definition of reincarnation ever stated. (For some critical comments concerning the way Theravada Buddhism defines its fundamental doctrines, see our special file on this topic.)

Man’s condition in other Eastern religions

Confucianism

Confucius did not establish a new religion, and not even a new philosophical system. All his efforts were channeled into finding an ethical system that could solve the chaos of the Chinese society of his time (6th century BC). His main concern was man, his social life, and the principles that should govern it in order to assure social balance and peace in the society, family, and personal life. Although Confucius respected the existent Chinese religious traditions, he gave them a mere ethical interpretation. Human perfection, according to him, cannot be attained by religious rituals or meditations, but only by using proper education and respecting moral values. Therefore, religious traditions have value only as means of moral living. The most important ethical principles emphasized by Confucius were reciprocity (shu) (“what you do not want others do to you, don’t do to them”), doing good for the benefit of others (jen) and loving and respecting your parents. Following the moral principles means implicitly to conform oneself to the will of Heaven, but metaphysical speculations on this topic and on life after death are futile (Analects 7,20). The same is true with regard to worshipping gods or spirits. Confucius denied their importance saying: “If you cannot serve people, how could you serve the spirits?” (Analects 11,11). In conclusion, early Confucianism had no religious beliefs; it pursued only the perfection of human character by fulfilling one’s social and familial duties, according to what is true and morally right.

Taoism

Unlike Confucianism, which understands man as a rational and moral being, with certain moral duties toward society, Taoism states that man is a being that has to align his life to the pulse of nature. All instincts, feelings and imagination have to be allowed to manifest freely, imitating nature. The Confucianist morality is criticized because it is considered to be an illusory and dangerous way of departing from the essence of Tao: When the Tao is forgotten

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (8 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions Duty and justice appear; Then knowledge and wisdom are born Along with hypocrisy. When harmonious relationships dissolve Then respect and devotion arise; When a nation falls to chaos Then loyalty and patriotism are born. [. . .] If we could abolish duty and justice Then harmonious relationships would form; (Tao-te Ching 18-19) Man is a reflection of the universe. He is a small universe permeated by the Tao, with which he has to be in resonance (gan ying). Like the universe itself, man has an ascending life and a descending one, which ends in death. The ascending life is considered to be the intrauterine one, which leads him to the climax of his existence, birth. For this reason it is said in the Tao-te Ching that the one ”who is filled with harmony is like a newborn” (55). Physical life, unlike the intrauterine one, is chaotic because man does not know how to keep up his vital force. He dies as a result of his ignorance, before yin and yang can naturally separate and his being return into the Tao. Progression and regression are constant developments in the universe and also in the human body. Because of his ignorance, man cannot understand this dynamic and subscribe to it. The natural result is reincarnation, repeating physical existence until liberation is attained. (However, reincarnation is a topic developed only later in Taoism, probably two centuries after Lao Tse.)

Man’s condition in the monotheistic religions

Man’s creation and condition in Christianity

As the triune God of Christianity is completely different from the Ultimate Reality of the other world religions, the same is the situation with the nature of man and his present condition. According to the Christian teaching, God creates the universe out of nothing (ex nihilo) and not out of his own substance (ex Deo). This "nothing" has no ontological statute, it is not a primordial substance, because prior to creation, nothing existed except God. Creation ex nihilo is not an artifice of Christian philosophy, but the only possibility compatible with the existence of a personal God as Ultimate Reality. The creation of man follows the act of creating the physical universe, as is mentioned in the Genesis account: The Lord God formed the man from the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and the man became a living being (Genesis 2,7). There is no ontological continuity between the nature of God and that of man, as between Brahman and atman, but a fundamental difference that excludes any pantheistic resemblance. Unlike the physical world, man has a physical dimension (the body) and a spiritual one (the soul). Both are created by God at the same time, so that man is not a pre-existent celestial soul fallen into a material body as Platonism, Origenism or some dualistic philosophies tried to speculate. The two dimensions generate the unity of human being according to the Creator's design.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (9 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions

Another important aspect to be emphasized here is the fact that the creation of man was not a necessity for God. He would not have been incomplete without man, because the communion among the hypostasis of the Holy Trinity was sufficient and perfect. God's only motivation for creating mankind was the over-abundance of His love. According to the Genesis account, man was created to have communion with God and to rule “over all the creatures that move along the ground” (Genesis 1,27). Although man was created to be a witness of God’s glory and to enjoy it, this is not a necessity for God’s being, but the only condition in which man can be in harmony with his Creator. In other words, God created man not for His sake, but for man's sake, so that man may have eternal communion with the Ruler of the universe. (The Vedic ritual suggests a different situation. Here the sacrifices performed by the priests are necessary in order to sustain the universe and the gods.)

Image and likeness

Then God said, "Let us make man in our image, in our likeness, and let them rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air, over the livestock, over all the earth, and over all the creatures that move along the ground." So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them (Genesis 1,26-27). The fact that man was created in the image (eikon) and likeness (omoiosis) of God does not imply that God has a physical nature, but suggests that man received by creation an existence resembling that of the Persons (hypostases) of the Holy Trinity. According to the Church fathers of the first centuries, the “image” conferred to man represents the personal character of God, as ontological fact of creation. In the same way in which God exists only as Person, human nature, too, exists only as person. Man’s personal character is defined by self-consciousness, ability to think, feel and will, and especially by his ability to have communion with his Creator and other people. As the hypostases of the Holy Trinity are defined only in relation with each other, in the same way the human hypostasis is defined only in relation with God and other humans. This relation is a reciprocal fellowship, accomplished by a personal unfolding of each toward the other. It is by no means a subject - innate object relation. If God's image is imprinted on man and remains in him as his personal character, the “likeness” is defined as a way of being. It corresponds to a free will relation of obedience to the Creator. While the image is an ontological fact of human nature, the likeness is an attribute that has to be built up through exercising the relation with God. This position is held by most Church fathers of the first centuries, Clement of Alexandria, Irenaeus of Lyon, the Cappadocians, etc. Man does not have the nature of God, but only qualities resembling His. Therefore, “the breath of life” (Genesis 2,7), which God has transmitted to man, is not a small part of God’s essence (a kind of atman), but the act of life giving, which marked the beginning of experiencing self-consciousness or personal identity. According to Christianity, human personhood has real and unique value. It has nothing in common with the Eastern doctrine of illusion (maya). Both body and soul define human personhood and neither of them is intrinsically bad or illusory. Christian soteriology does not state any need for detaching the soul from an illusory association with the body, as was the case with purusha and prakriti in the Samkhya and Yoga darshanas. The command says: ”Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind” and “Love your neighbor as yourself" (Luke 10,27). Nor do the elements of psycho-mental life have anything bad in themselves, reason for which Christianity demands the renewal of mind (Romans 12,2), discernment between good

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (10 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions and bad feelings (Galatians 5,16-23) and using the will for good purposes (Tit 3,8). Nowhere in the Holy Scripture is it taught that they should be annihilated in order to grasp a higher impersonal Ultimate Reality. On the other hand, pantheist religions all agree concerning the illusory status of the personal character of man and the hindrance it represents in attaining liberation. The annihilation of personhood is a necessity in most Eastern religions. Ahamkara, the principle of individuation (the sense of the "I", of duality and separatedness from others) is considered to be one of the most important causes of illusion and suffering in the world, as well as abhinivesha - the will to live. Unfortunately, in Hinduism there is not stated a clear differentiation between personhood and egoism, both terms being translated as ahamkara. In Christianity, on the other hand, not the sense of the “I” itself is the cause of problems (as it belongs to our created status), but the wrong usage of it generates bad products, such as egoism. Without personhood and self-consciousness, in other words without the quality that makes one person different from another (which should not be understood as individualism), the idea of personal communion with God, the very reason man was created, is absurd. Because in the pantheistic religions Ultimate Reality is impersonal, all that belongs to personhood has no room in the system and therefore personal communion with God cannot be the purpose of man's existence. Except the impersonal self (atman or purusha), any other element that may define human existence belongs to the domain of illusion (maya), is a source of karma and by consequence has to be annihilated. (In Buddhism there is a similar situation. Personhood is only a result of the coming together of the five skandhas, a source of illusion and karma. In order to reject any element that may lead to attachments, Buddhism rejects even the notion of atman in defining human nature.) Another consequence of our personal status is that desire does not have an evil nature in itself, as does the Hindu trishna (the desire to experience existence). It belongs to the nature of man, with the role of being used in order to attain likeness with God. This is of fundamental importance to man’s condition. The spiritual gifts that God has put in human nature must awake in us the desire to live in his likeness. Desires are a product of our free will and have to be channeled to function in obedience to God, not to be annihilated. There is no room in Christianity for a Buddhist “no-mind” attitude or practice. In conclusion, Christianity brings a major difference in defining human nature. Man is created as a personal being by a personal God, but without having the same essence with Him. Personhood holds nothing wrong in itself, but is the premise for grounding a personal relation with the Creator. In pantheism man is a manifestation of the impersonal Absolute and therefore his self (atman or purusha) has an impersonal nature too. All elements that define personhood have an illusory value and have to be annihilated. Some other contrasts will be emphasized in defining man's present condition. Before this, we should examine some aspects that define the nature of evil in Christianity.

The origin and essence of evil in Christianity

Evil exists since before the creation of man. Its origin is to be found in the world of angels. God created them in time immemorial, as personal and immaterial beings endowed with free will, in order to integrate themselves in the divine harmony through obedience and communion. They were created ex nihilo, like the material universe, and thus have a nature different from that of God. These beings have mind (Acts 12,7-10; 1 Peter 1,12), feelings (Luke 15,10), will (Jude 6) and are not limited by a physical body. Their

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (11 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions number was very large and had a hierarchy among them (Hebrews 12,22). Evil appeared in the world of angels when Lucifer, one of God’s archangels, rebelled against this order. In the book of the prophet Isaiah we can read the following metaphorical description of this incident: You said in your heart, "I will ascend to heaven; I will raise my throne above the stars of God; I will sit enthroned on the mount of assembly, on the utmost heights of the sacred mountain. I will ascend above the tops of the clouds; I will make myself like the Most High." (Isaiah 14,13-14) This archangel, who is now called Satan (“adversary”), was expelled from heaven together with all the angels who joined him in his act of rebellion. The cause of his fall was pride, the desire to be independent of God, not submitted or inferior to Him. Lucifer wanted to be by himself more than his created status could permit him. As mentioned in our file on the nature of evil in Christianity, evil is not created by God, but is a perversion of His creation, a result of using free will against the very purpose for which it was created (obedience to God in a communion relation based on love). Evil was not intended to exist in God's creation and is not linked to the essence of God. It is a parasite of good, a rebelled existence against God. Having this nature, Satan and the demons do their best to thwart God’s plan with mankind, knowing that humans are created to succeed where they (the fallen angels) failed.

The nature of sin

By creating a new kind of beings endowed with freedom of will, God assumed again “the risk” that they may rebel against Him. This element of risk is not a proof of God’s incapacity to create infallible beings, because freedom of will is the most important element that defines personhood and makes us different from robots. It also makes possible real communion among personal beings, including communion with God, the very purpose of man’s creation. However, freedom of will could be wrongly used and turned against the very purpose of its creation, as happened in the realm of angels. God’s command to man was: You are free to eat from any tree in the garden; but you must not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, for when you eat of it you will surely die" (Genesis 2,16-17). Here must be emphasized the following important aspect: The knowledge (gnosis) of good and evil does not have the meaning of getting some new information. It is neither a kind of a science (episteme), nor abstract information. It is not a matter of conceptual elaboration, a science of good and evil that would explain rationally two opposite concepts without judging them morally. In this Biblical text, knowledge (gnosis) means experiencing and getting mixed with another reality. It is an ontological process rather than an epistemological one. Rather than to know (as we understand it), gnosis means to be in communion with something and live according to it. The same way as knowing God is not just a mental operation, but a participation and subscribing to His will, the knowledge of good and evil is an existential experience, an accommodation to a state that is not indifferent to human nature. In this context, God’s command is not a hindering from getting necessary knowledge or an artificial limitation of man’s freedom, but a warning concerning the possibility of getting involved with the nature of evil, of participating in another reality than that intended by God. This other reality was the world of Satan and the fallen angels. As man's source for meaning cannot be found in himself but only in his Creator, his status in the spiritual world can better be described as a river bed rather than a spring. We are not meant to find an inner "true

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (12 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions spiritual nature" or a "higher self" inside us, but to adjust to the character of God, to attain likeness with Him. Therefore we are a river bed that chooses what spring will flow through it. This is the ultimate ability we have in attaining "a higher spirituality". As a river bed is clean or dirty according to the water that flows through it, man's identity (and obviously his morality) is fashioned by the spiritual source he chooses to obey - God or the devil. As a result, neutrality is not a possible option. Being envious of man's destiny and seeking to perpetuate his own fallen nature, Satan tempted him, casting doubt on the justice of God’s demands: “Did God really say, ‘You must not eat from any tree in the garden’?" The woman said to the serpent, “We may eat fruit from the trees in the garden, but God did say, ‘You must not eat fruit from the tree that is in the middle of the garden, and you must not touch it, or you will die.’” “You will not surely die,” the serpent said to the woman. “For God knows that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.” (Genesis 3,1-5) An analysis of this text reveals that Satan suggested that any interdiction should be excluded, that God’s command is not just and that rebellion against Him would bring total freedom. His temptation can be summed up as “to be like God”, that is, to find all resources in oneself and follow the same path of rebellion he had followed earlier, in order to find (an illusory) auto-determination. His temptation was more effective by the fact that it presented a mixture of evil and an appearance of good. Only an appearance of good, because the Absolute Good is God himself and there cannot be anything good in separation from Him. What good thing could man get to know from one who was totally and eternally separated from God? Unfortunately, as it can be seen in the Genesis account and in all human history, man has chosen rebellion against his Creator. This attitude is called sin in the Bible. The fall into sin is the breaking point in man’s relation with God, with other people, with himself and even with the physical world. The “good” thing that Adam and Eve came to know was the fact that they were naked (3,7), which already was a barrier between them. They found out that they were separated from God and also from the perfect environment where they lived (3,24). Creation itself suffered (3,17) and continues to suffer because of sin (Romans 8,22). The biblical meaning of sin does not correspond to some pantheist interpretations, which consider it to be the loss of a pantheist view of reality (“the perception of the ONE”) and the subsequent appearance of duality and illusion. The human fall is a consequence of man’s wrong decision toward independence from God; it is an act of perverting the relation established by God in His creation. The Bible states that mankind has fallen into a rebellious position against God and his demands. The Apostle Paul draws a remarkable description of this situation in the Epistle to the Romans, mentioning deeds consciously done against the standards revealed by God (see 1,18 - 3,20). In order to define sin, one of the most used terms in the New Testament is the Greek word hamartia, literally translated “to miss the mark”. It suggests that man has missed the mark that God has intended for him. Calling us sinners, God blames us for what we know is wrong but still do, not for unknown mistakes done against some unknown laws of God (see Romans 2,1-15). In his conclusion, the Apostle Paul states that “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (3,23). Instead of finding total freedom, as the devil promised, man became slave to sin (Romans 6,17) and to Satan (John 8,44). In the spiritual world there is no possible option for independence, but only for obeying or disobeying God. Jesus Christ said, “He who is not with me is against me, and he who does not gather with me, scatters” (Luke 11,23). According to God’s justice, the consequence of this situation

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (13 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions would have been that God should respect man’s desire to live a separate existence from Him (as a guarantee of his free will), and to abandon man in a world where God withdraws His presence and any intervention, where the separation from Him and any good thing He created is eternal. This world is hell, a place where Satan and all demons will be isolated for all eternity (see Matthew 25,41). (For a very short, but excellent article about the origin of the term and the logic of hell see The Eschatology of Hell, by R.J. Rushdoony. See also some comments of the Early Church Fathers on hell, death and life after death.) The Eastern concept of hell is different from the Christian one. In Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism hell is analogous to the Catholic concept of Purgatory. It is not an eternal damnation, but only a place to expiate bad karma, in order that the purified soul can continue his advance toward liberation (see Markandeya Purana 13-15, Sutta Nipata 672-76, The Tibetan Book of the Dead). The punishments man has to bear in hell are according to his karma, and Yama, the lord of hell, acts in accordance to the demands of karma. He cannot forgive, but only be the instrument of this impersonal law. However, the temporary statute of hell in Eastern religions is not a result of divine love, but rather a necessity imposed by the cyclic manifestations of Ultimate Reality. According to Christianity, hell was not intended for humans, but for demons. However, since man rejects God and follows the devil during his life, he will reach the same destination as his leader. Living in that world, in total isolation and privation of any good aspect of existence, accompanied only with the attitude of rebellion against God, is a suffering that surpasses any imagination. It is often questioned: How can a loving God condemn man to such a horrifying punishment? First, it has to be remembered that the decision for independence from God belongs to man, hell being only a real chance offered to him to spend all eternity outside His presence. Would not God be unjust if He would force humans to live in His presence against their will? Second, God has prepared a solution for those who want to return to communion with Him. (See our next file on salvation in Christianity.) Sin has thoroughly affected human nature, conferring to it a hereditary perverted status. This is called “the sinful nature” or “original sin” (see Romans 7-8), which we all inherit. It represents a natural tendency toward evil and manifests itself through the conscious sins we do with our thought, speech and deeds. It is important to notice here that we neither inherit the particular sins of our ancestors, nor sins we have done in alleged previous lives, but the sinful nature of mankind. In other words, what we inherit is not karma. Man does not “pay” for sins committed out of ignorance in previous lives, but for individual and conscious sins committed here and now. In Christianity there is no room for the impersonal law of karma and reincarnation. (There is available a special file on this topic.) Karma is a concept that does not fit in Christianity, where the Absolute judge is God, the Creator. Man will certainly be judged for the way he lived, but by God and not by karma, and also not by being sent into another body, but by being sent to hell, the place deserved by those who reject his love. Therefore the attempt to reconcile God and karma is absurd, somehow trying to affirm that karma is the will of God. The two are mutually exclusive. Another aspect that must be emphasized here is the fact that we are all equal before God through our “merits”. What we all deserve is the same prize: death. The biblical meaning of this term is not passing into nothingness, but separation. (For instance, physical death means separation of soul and body). In the expression used by the Apostle Paul “you were dead in your transgressions and sins” (Ephesians 2,1; Colossians 2,13), “death” means a state of separation between man and God, determined by sin. The “death” Adam and Eve received at the moment of their sinning was separation from God, by getting out

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (14 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions of the communion with Him. This is why the banishment from Eden was not a revenge of God, but a necessity after sin has been committed. According to the Church Fathers, the new condition of man’s being mortal is suggested by the expression “garments of skin”, with which God clothed Adam and his wife after the fall (Genesis 3,21). Therefore, these “garments of skin” are not the physical body, in which man was allegedly trapped after being a purely spiritual being, according to some Gnostic interpretations. Man didn’t get his physical body after the fall, but at the moment of creation. Mortality was added after the fall, and therefore does not represent a constitutive element of man, but a cure for sin. In his Great Catechism, chapter 8, Gregory of Nyssa explains: He who is the healer of our sinfulness, of His foresight invested man subsequently with that capacity of dying which had been the special attribute of the brute creation. Not that it was to last for ever; for a coat is something external put on us, lending itself to the body for a time, but not indigenous to its nature. This liability to death, then, taken from the brute creation, was, provisionally, made to envelope the nature created for immortality. Physical death is a result of the fall but at the same time an instrument to stop the effects of sin. What would our world become if there would be no death to sinners? Death is added to our fallen condition in order that we could still inherit spiritual immortality, by returning to God, the giver of life, and be cured of sin. Although it looks more like a punishment, physical death is the gate toward spiritual life, if man accepts God's terms for receiving it. The notion of sin, as stated in Christianity, has no correspondent in the Eastern religions. Although there are some Hindu terms translated as "sin" (papa - any form of wrongdoing; adharma - acting against one's own dharma; aparadha - mistake), they do not represent a crime against God, but an act against dharma (the moral order) and against one's own self (leading to accumulation of karma). The origin of "sinful" conduct is spiritual ignorance (avidya). Therefore, a “sinner” needs only instruction and not condemnation. He needs help to reason the right way and realize that he is responsible for his actions, for which he must pay the consequences in samsara. Being a manifestation of the Absolute, man has in himself the divine nature (atman, purusha) and all resources to overtake his state of ignorance. According to Christianity, this attitude is a result of spiritual pride, the very cause of man’s (and Satan’s) fall. The Bible teaches that man does not possess an intrinsic divine nature, and thus is incapable of saving himself from his fallen state. The situation is like this because man has a sinful nature. This is the only “true inner nature” of man. Jesus Christ stated: For from within, out of men's hearts, come evil thoughts, sexual immorality, theft, murder, adultery, greed, malice, deceit, lewdness, envy, slander, arrogance and folly. All these evils come from inside and make a man 'unclean.' (Mark 7,21-23) According to the Judaic understanding of man, which was the context of Jesus’ saying, the “heart” is the core of man’s being, the headquarters of mental, emotional and volitional life. Consequently, in the New Testament, the heart is depicted as something that can think and understand (Matthew 9,4; 13,15), be troubled (John 14,1; Romans 9,2), rejoice (Ephesians 5,19), make decisions (2 Corinthians 9,7) and also participate in salvation by expressing faith (Romans 10,9-10). There is no deeper level of man’s nature that could hide a superior spiritual self. From a Christian point of view, the central problem of mankind is sin, which is not an illusion or a lack of perfection, but a moral barrier between man and his Creator. The prophet Isaiah proclaimed: “Your iniquities have separated you from your God; your sins have hidden his face from you, so that he will not hear” (59,2). Sin has produced the perversion of our mind (2 Corinthians 4,4; Romans 1,28), will

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (15 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions (Romans 1,28), heart (Ephesians 4,18), and our being as totality (Romans 1,18 - 3,20). No matter how many efforts are made today by psychoanalysis to redefine sin as imperfection (an idea developed by C.G. Jung from Eastern religions), man continues to be accused by his conscience for the failures of his moral living (see Romans 2,14-15). He does not live in harmony with a moral system that he did not create and that surpasses him. To deny the reality of sin means to deny not only the truth of the Bible, but also the entire human experience.

Man’s condition in Judaism

As the Old Testament belongs equally to Judaism and Christianity, the Judaic view of man’s creation and present sinful condition is similar to the Christian one. However, late commentaries on the Old Testament, such as the Talmud, present some deviations from Orthodox Judaism. For instance, it is stated that God created man with an evil inclination and gave him the Mosaic Law as antidote: The words of the Torah are like a perfect remedy. This may be compared to a man who inflicted a big wound upon his son, and then put a plaster on his wound, saying, “My son! As long as this plaster is on your wound you can eat and drink what you like, and bathe in cold or warm water, and you will suffer no harm. But if you remove it, it will break out into sores.” Even so did God say to the Israelites, “My children! I created within you the Evil Inclination, but I created the Law as its antidote. As long as you occupy yourselves with the Torah, the Evil Inclination will not rule over you. But if you do not occupy yourselves with the Torah, then you will be delivered into its power, and all its activity will be against you.” (Kiddushin 30b) According to the mystical tradition of the Kabbalah, man is perfect from the Creator’s point of view, but still needs improvement in order to discover his spiritual identity and feel the spiritual worlds above him. This demand is very similar to the Eastern idea of surpassing ignorance (avidya) in order to know his true spiritual nature (atman). Other elements that suggest the relation with Eastern philosophy are the belief in reincarnation and the need for mystical experiences, as necessary elements in order to reach the highest level of spiritual development. This is why the mystical view of the Kabbalah is closer to Eastern religions than to Orthodox Judaism in defining man and his relation with God.

Man’s condition in Islam

The Quran describes the creation and fall of man in a way similar to the Judeo-Christian tradition. In fact, the doctrine of the fall is a logical teaching only in the monotheistic religions, which state that God is the only Creator, creation was good in itself and evil has a personal existence, being contrary to the purpose of creation. Islam teaches that man and angels were created to worship Allah (Quran 51,56). However, the creation of man, as described in the Quran, has a major difference from the Biblical account. The Quran states that evil was not yet present in the world at the moment of man's creation. God created man and commanded all angels to worship him. Satan (Iblis) opposed this command and only then was banished from heaven: And surely, We created you (your father Adam) and then gave you shape (the noble shape of a

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (16 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions human being), then We told the angels, “Prostrate to Adam”;, and they prostrated, except Iblis (Satan), he refused to be of those who prostrate. Allah said: “What prevented you Iblis, that you did not prostrate, when I commanded you?” Iblis said: “I am better than him (Adam), You created me from fire, and him You created from clay. Allah said: “O, Iblis, get down from this (Paradise), it is not for you to be arrogant here. Get out, for you are of those humiliated and disgraced.” (Quran 7,11-13) After this episode Iblis planned to deceive man and make him disobedient to God, which he accomplished in a similar way to that described in the Biblical account (see Quran 7,20-21). However, in Islam there is no such thing as original sin. Although Adam and Eve sinned, they repented and were forgiven, so that their sin had no repercussions for the rest of human race. In his present condition, man is exhorted not to repeat the mistake of Adam, and also warned that the devil attempts to cheat him by all means (Quran 7,27). However, all people sin because of the passion to which they are subjected by Satan and because they are careless about the demands of the Quran. All sins and good deeds a man is performing are noted by two angels, that will present the records at the final judgment: Behold, two guardian angels appointed to learn [man’s doings] learn and note them, one sitting on the right and one on the left. Not a word does he utter but there is a sentinel by him, ready to note it. And the stupor of death will bring truth before his eyes, “This was the thing which you were trying to escape!” (Quran 50,17-19) (In order to understand other basic differences between Christianity and Islam see the article Six Muslim Beliefs and a Christian Response, by Jay Smith.

Conclusion

The way world religions state what Ultimate Reality is inherently determines their teaching on human condition. The two elements are inseparable. An impersonal Ultimate Reality determines that the essence of man, or his innermost nature, is also impersonal. This is the case in the pantheistic religions. Beginning with the Upanishads, Hinduism (excepting some theistic trends) stated that the core of human nature is the impersonal self (atman), of the same essence with Ultimate Reality (Brahman in Vedanta, or Shiva in Tantrism). Man's present condition is governed by karma, an impersonal law started by spiritual ignorance that forces the self to reincarnate until true knowledge is attained. Buddhism denies the reality of any permanent self residing in man, defining human condition as a mere process of becoming in which are involved the five aggregates, of an impermanent nature too. The only reality of human existence is that of suffering. Although reincarnation is fully accepted, it deals only with the passing of karma from one life to another, without any permanent self being involved. The monotheistic religions state man's personal created status as a fundamental element of their theology. Personhood has nothing bad or illusory in itself, being the major condition for having personal communion with God. Karma and reincarnation are excluded. They have no room in Judaism, Christianity and Islam, because the role of Supreme Judge belongs only to God. The major problem that defines human existence is sin, understood not as ignorance for one's "true inner nature", but as crime against the Creator. The barrier between man and God has a moral nature, not an epistemological one, as in the Eastern religions. The result of sin is hell, a state of definitive separation from God, according to

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (17 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] The human condition in world religions man's decision during this single earthly life. In conclusion, there is no harmony among the world's religions concerning the status of man and his present condition. Their position is too divergent for a possible reconciliation to be stated. Therefore, the attempt to formulate a common doctrine on man would surely contradict their major tenets.

Next article: Man's salvation and eternal destiny

http://www.comparativereligion.com/man.html (18 of 18) [10/27/2000 9:49:52 AM] Four criteria to evaluate any religious perspective

Four criteria to evaluate any religious perspective

All religions try to formulate a unitary and comprehensive perspective on Ultimate Reality and how man should relate to it. However, before accepting a certain religion as our own spiritual path toward Ultimate Reality, we have to evaluate it critically, using criteria with enough relevance to anyone. As we do not accept almost anything without first examining it critically, whether it is food, drink or any other elementary need, we should have a similar attitude when dealing with our quest for Ultimate Reality. Finding relevant criteria to test a spiritual path is not an easy task, especially considering the fact that they should cover all domains of human experience. We suggest the use of the following four: 1) internal consistency; 2) harmony between empirical knowledge and absolute (religious or mystical) knowledge; 3) viability; 4) contradiction with other religious perspectives.

Let us explain what they mean: 1) Internal consistency requires that no obvious internal contradiction should exist in the religious or philosophical system we study. If it states that the law of non-contradiction (and logic, in general) does not work here because logic has to be transcended in order to grasp higher realities, our capacity to know and discern between truth and falsehood would be dramatically affected by incoherence. However, even if a certain religious system seems to lack any obvious inconsistencies, it does not necessarily mean that it should be accepted on this single basis. Hypothetically, many coherent systems could exist, not just one, but without being true spiritual paths. This criterion proves what is false, but cannot establish by itself what must be the truth. For this we need the next criteria.

2) The criterion of harmony between empirical and absolute knowledge requires, as its name suggests, that a certain religion should state a harmonious relation between empirical knowledge, obtained through man’s normal knowing abilities (sensory and mental), and what is called direct knowledge of the Ultimate Reality. In other words, a religion should not state an insurmountable barrier

http://www.comparativereligion.com/4criteria.html (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:49:54 AM] Four criteria to evaluate any religious perspective between empirical and absolute knowledge, as if they were mutually exclusive. From this requirement it does not follow that Ultimate Reality should be known exclusively using our empirical abilities of knowledge. In this case we would belong to an atheist system of thought. The religions we analyze admit both an empirical and an absolute way of knowledge, so that this criterion requires a right balance between them, harmony and complementarity. However, neither would this criterion be enough in determining its truthfulness, if a certain religion lacked viability.

3) The criterion of viability (or pragmatism) requires that a certain religion should work in personal and social life. As a result of the given possibility to know what Ultimate Reality is, a religion should have relevant answers to the fundamental questions of human existence, such as those posed by the author of the Shvetashvatara Upanishad (1,1): “Whence are we born? Whereby do we live, and whither do we go?" or in other words, “What is the meaning of our existence?” In answering these questions, a religion should not demand that one ignore social life. Man is by his very essence a social being and needs right patterns in order to live in harmony with his neighbors. The religion that fails to regulate social life, giving no pattern to integrate all the members of society in a viable system, may be valid only for the hermit. In other words, we should accept as principles only those we would like to be followed by all members of society. Anything else should be abandoned. For instance, if we were to accept lying as a valid principle of social conduct, we should accept all lies as being valid. But when all have the right to lie, nobody will be trusted anymore, and no liar would ever benefit from his lies. So the principle of admitting lies turns against its very purpose (making one’s life easier, for instance) and undermines its own use. In our situation as socially interdependent beings, we cannot ignore the need for pragmatic principles of conduct. Starting from here, a specific understanding of some related issues such as freedom, morality, and compassion will necessarily develop.

4) If all religions address the same issues and there are basic contradictions between them, the principle of external contradiction suggests that they cannot all be equally true. As we have seen in the previous files on how the world religions define Ultimate Reality, man’s condition, salvation and the nature of evil, there are major disagreements between them, especially when compared to Christianity. This point should already be clear, so there is no need to re-emphasize it over and over in the following analysis of different religious perspectives.

The four above-mentioned criteria rest only on our natural abilities of testing the truthfulness of a certain religion. However, all religious perspectives necessarily include a supernatural dimension, which is beyond our natural abilities of investigation. Far from trying to reduce Ultimate Reality to what our limited mind could comprehend (which would be an atheistic approach to religion), we still need to emphasize the importance of the second criterion mentioned above. Although all religions’ aim is to formulate a right relation between man and Ultimate Reality and not only to give a theoretical understanding of it, an intelligent approach to religion should still be possible. Far from being purely rationalistic, such an approach should not be refused by stating that religion is the domain of pure mysticism. Quoting Shankara, the well known Hindu philosopher, “that which is accepted or believed in without sufficient inquiry is not only bad philosophy, but also prevents one from reaching the goal of

http://www.comparativereligion.com/4criteria.html (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:49:54 AM] Four criteria to evaluate any religious perspective perfection and results in evil” (from T.M.P. Mahadevan, Invitation to Indian Philosophy, p. 5).

http://www.comparativereligion.com/4criteria.html (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:49:54 AM] Alleged Eastern equivalent sayings of Jesus Christ

Alleged Eastern equivalent sayings of Jesus Christ

Most of the examples of such sayings are analyzed in previous files, so please take a look at the following links:

Jesus' sayings that allegedly suggest reincarnation:

1) Matthew 11:14 and 17:12-13, concerning the identity of John the Baptist as Elijah reincarnated

2) John 9:2, “Who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” 3) John 3:3, “No one can see the kingdom of God unless he is born again" 4) Matthew 26,52, “All who draw the sword will die by the sword”

Jesus' sayings that allegedly imply that humans have a hidden divine nature that has to be discovered through introspective meditation:

1) John 10:30, "I and the Father are one", regarding the unity with Ultimate Reality that any human could eventually attain. 2) Luke 17:21, "the kingdom of God is within you". This statement is sometimes interpreted as confirming the Eastern concept of an inner divine self (atman) that has to be discovered in order to find liberation. Therefore, a brief commentary may be useful here. The context of this saying is the following: Once, having been asked by the Pharisees when the kingdom of God would come, Jesus replied, "The kingdom of God does not come with your careful observation, nor will people say, 'Here it is,' or 'There it is,' because the kingdom of God is within you" (Luke 17:20-21). The Kingdom of God can be defined as the sphere in which His rule is fully acknowledged. It first comes without being in the range of the natural power of observation (as Jesus states in this text), as an inner transformation in the heart of the individual believer under the power and grace of Christ. There is also a further aspect of it, that refers to the time when God will assert His universal rule, and the Kingdom will be manifest to all (Matthew 25:31-34). Why had Jesus addressed these words to the Pharisees, knowing that His relation with them was always very tense? On the one hand, the Pharisees had constantly rejected Jesus as the Messiah and considered Him a blasphemer. Their expectations from the Messiah were totally different from what Jesus had to offer. On the other hand, He constantly rebuked them for their hypocrisy (in Luke, see 11:39-43; 12:1; 16:14-15; 18:10-14), so they couldn't belong to the Kingdom Jesus was announcing. Therefore it is

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Easternsayings.html (1 of 2) [10/27/2000 9:49:56 AM] Alleged Eastern equivalent sayings of Jesus Christ absurd to believe that, despite all the antagonism between them, Jesus had acknowledged the inherent divine nature of the Pharisees as a kind of hidden treasure to be discovered by any human. Otherwise why didn't He teach it to his devoted disciples? Were they not fit to accept it, while the Pharisees were? If so, He should have chosen his disciples out of the Pharisees, which is again absurd. The phrase "within you" (gr. entos hymon) must have another meaning than an acknowledgment of a divine human nature. It is better translated as "in your midst", "among you" or "within your reach". Jesus, the one who was standing in the midst of the Pharisees, was the divine representative of the Kingdom to come. This truth is what they had to acknowledge, that the Kingdom was already present in their midst in the person of its king, by no means an inner spiritual nature they would allegedly possess. As mentioned in a previous file, the only “true inner nature” of man is sin. Back to Top | Back to Contents | E-Mail

http://www.comparativereligion.com/Easternsayings.html (2 of 2) [10/27/2000 9:49:56 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity

Revelation and knowledge in Christianity

A previous file mentioned the necessity of critically evaluating a certain religious path before accepting it as a spiritual path toward Ultimate Reality. Four criteria were proposed: 1) internal consistency, 2) harmony between empirical knowledge and absolute (religious or mystical) knowledge, 3) viability and 4) contradiction with other religious perspectives. The moment has come to see how Christianity fulfills the first three criteria. As to the fourth, the files on the nature of Ultimate Reality, human nature, salvation and the nature of evil have already exposed the fact that world religions are irreconcilable on these topics, so they cannot be all equally true. This point should already be clear, so there is no need to re-emphasize it. Before going on with our topic, an important clarification is needed: This file does not add anything to the many theological debates on the nature of revelation and knowledge in Christianity. There is a huge amount of literature available on this topic. (Have a look at the Christian links suggested in our special file.) The goal pursued here is only to provide a necessary answer to objections raised in previous files against Eastern pantheism, dualism and Buddhism regarding their basic inconsistencies. This is a limited objective and therefore the reader should not expect an exhaustive theological debate here.

Revelation as the only way of knowing God

How do we know what Ultimate Reality is? What is the adequate way of communication between God and limited, mortal man? To what extent can we trust our empirical abilities of knowledge (our senses and mind) in order to get the right picture about ultimate truth? The Eastern religions state that Ultimate Reality has an impersonal nature and cannot be grasped by empirical means. The only way of getting a glimpse of it is shutting down normal perception and entering alterate states of consciousness, when the sense of unity with Ultimate Reality can be experienced. The best example for this is Yoga practice, which demands the abolition of body movement, breath, sensorial and mental activity. However, as mentioned in a previous file, the accompanying experiences can be explained as a mere result of forcing our senses and mind to function in a totally inadequate way, so that "mystical" experiences can be nothing more than hallucinations or distorted perceptions of reality. As long as such experiences can be obtained (to some extent) by the use of drugs or hypnosis, it is doubtful that ultimate truth can be grasped by such doubtful methods. On the other hand, if normal human capacity of perception alone were sufficient for grasping what

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (1 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity Ultimate Reality is, we would fall into the trap of atheist naturalism and consider that the physical universe is all that there is and that science is the best tool to research it. Even if atheist naturalism may be satisfactory for some in explaining the way our physical world functions, it can never offer a satisfying answer to the meaning of life. If the physical world is all there is, life would have no ultimate meaning at all. As a result, the atheist ideologies that swept through history have led only to the destruction of human dignity. The Christian answer in solving this dilemma is given by God's initiative to make Himself known to man. This process is called in theology revelation. It does not diminish man's empirical abilities of knowledge, but unveils facts that are beyond these abilities. The Apostle Paul wrote about the object of God's revelation in the Bible: All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work (2 Timothy 3:16-17). Revelation is informative and personal, using the sense of logic and requiring a personal response to it. Its ultimate purpose is to redeem man from his fallen condition and help him experience salvation.

Mystical experiences in Christianity

God's revelation in the Scripture is enough for man to be saved. For more information on this topic see our file on salvation in Christianity. There is no need for entering altered states of consciousness in order to get a glimpse of Ultimate Reality, as such experiences may be deceptive. However, there are many cases mentioned in the Bible and others recollected by the Church, in which God allowed some people to have "a closer look" at things that are beyond our world, or to receive direct instructions from Him. Therefore it is important to evaluate the meaning and importance of Christian mystical experiences, and see to what extent they are compatible with those of other religions. There are five points here that emphasize the main differences: 1) Mystical experiences in Christianity are always initiated by God, in His grace, and never induced by believers using special meditative techniques or asceticism. As examples see the special revelations granted to the apostles Peter (Acts 10,9-16), Paul (2 Corinthians 12,2-4) and John (Revelation 1,10-19). 2) Those who were granted such special revelations had to remember a coherent spiritual message in the normal state of consciousness and transmit it to their fellow believers. The content was mostly informative and specific, not a mere "neti, neti" type of Hindu glimpse of the impersonal Brahman that cannot be communicated. 3) Special revelations are associated with external confirmations of their truth. For instance, the Apostle Peter was met by the men sent by Cornelius (Acts 10,21-22), Paul was forced not to boast by "a thorn in his flesh" (2 Corinthians 12,7) and John had to transmit his message to seven earthly churches that were confronted with earthly problems (Revelation 2-3). The same is the case with the Old Testament prophets. Although many of them had visions of other-world realities (Isaiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, Zechariah), the message they got was meant to correct an earthly situation, in most cases Israel's apostasy.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (2 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity 4) Mystical experiences in the Bible and in Church tradition always confirm previous revelation in the Scripture. They never contradict it or make Christian doctrine depend on them. Christianity does not proclaim mystical experience as the only way of knowing ultimate truth, as Eastern religions do. Experience is not the primary instrument of knowing God, but of confirming the revelation already received from Him in the Scripture and accepted by faith. Experience always has to be subject to revelation and faith because those experiences that contradict revelation may be of demonic origin. 5) Mystical experiences never give the feeling of atman-Brahman oneness. The Christian mystic never unites with the being of God, but only with His will in a higher communion relation. This is what is meant by being "transformed into His likeness with ever-increasing glory, which comes from the Lord" (2 Corinthians 3,18). Consequently, the Christian mystics use rather the term of the soul's "marriage" with God, than that of "absorption" or "merging" with the essence of Ultimate Reality. In order to avoid deception by meeting a foreign spiritual world (1 Peter 5,8), they have to obey some basic requirements to be guarded against falling into heresy. The most important concern is abiding in Christian doctrine and morals. The First Epistle of John in the New Testament is a wonderful instrument for evaluating it. On the other hand, the best proof that the Christian mystic has gotten lost in pantheism is the abandoning of fundamental concepts such as sin, evil, reverence toward God, and considering himself to have attained a realm beyond good and evil. This will necessarily develop into isolation from other "profane" people, which is another indication of a wrong direction (1 John 4,7-21). Instead of attaining a special communion relation with God, heretical mystics feel they become "one with the essence of God". Therefore Eastern mysticism and Christianity hold irreconcilable positions concerning the meaning and importance of mystical experiences. There is no meeting point between them, not even on this ground.

Revelation and the three testing criteria

In the context given by God's revelation to man, Christianity does not encounter the basic inconsistencies of Eastern religions in fulfilling the three above mentioned criteria because of two basic elements: 1) both God and man are personal beings; and 2) both man and the physical world were created by the same God. According to the Bible, man was created by a personal God in His image and likeness (Genesis 1,27-28) and lives in the midst of His physical creation. (There is no need to explain again the meaning of man's creation in God's image and likeness, as it is part of a previous file.) Neither personhood nor the physical world have anything intrinsically bad (Genesis 1,31). For this reason Christianity has internal consistency, can state a right balance between empirical and absolute knowledge and is also pragmatic. Let us briefly analyze these claims.

The use of logic in Christianity

Eastern religions state that there is only one reality pervading all aspects of existence and therefore the sense of duality is ultimately illusory. As duality is the basis on which logic operates, it is required that logic should be transcended by the use of meditation techniques in order to attain oneness with the impersonal Ultimate Reality. This generates some internal inconsistencies in Eastern religions (especially

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (3 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity in the pantheist religions.) Christianity holds a different approach to logic. The word "logic" has its etymological root in the Greek "logos". Ancient Greek philosophy considered the Logos to be a rational element in nature that generates and controls its order. The apostle John gave another meaning to this term in his gospel. He chose to use it to designate God the Son, who was incarnated as Jesus Christ (John 1,1-14). Therefore, the Christian Logos is not a mere manifestation of an impersonal Ultimate Reality, but is personified as God Himself. As a result, logic has its origin in God, the creator of all, who laid it at the ground of His creation. In other words, the order in the universe is not a product of the manifestation of an impersonal being (as Brahman), but the product of God's eternal and perfect mind. Because the Logos (God the Son) is rational, creation is intelligible for the humans He created into His image and likeness. This is of fundamental importance in balancing empirical and absolute knowledge, the second criterion a spiritual path should meet.

Empirical and absolute knowledge in Christianity

By the fact that the same God created both our empirical abilities of knowledge (senses and mind) and the physical world to be known, there is correspondence between them. The senses give us true information about a true physical world around us, and the mind is able to make true judgments. Even if our senses deceive us sometimes (as they make us believe the sun rotates around the earth), we can reach the right perspective not by rejecting sense observation, but by being more careful in observations and their logical inferences (as Galileo Galilei did, being a Christian). God could not give us unreliable rational powers and senses while making us think they are reliable. He could not be capable of such a deception. As a result, absolute knowledge (knowing God) does not contradict empirical knowledge but completes it. In other words, a personal relationship with God is not against the mind but beyond it, and faith works beyond what our mind can grasp but without destroying it. If there were an irreconcilable barrier between empirical and absolute knowledge (as Eastern religions state), revelation would be impossible. Not only was man created in God's image, as a personal being, so that personhood has nothing intrinsically bad, but the fullest revelation of God to man, i.e. the incarnation of God in Jesus Christ, was also in personal form. Jesus Christ was a historical person who lived on this earth in a physical body. As a Person of the Holy Trinity, He is the same God that created man and the physical world, inspired the Bible, and descended in the world in order to save it from its fallen state. What better way of bridging the gap between empirical and absolute knowledge could we ask than the descending of Ultimate Reality to us in human form? This element unparalleled by other religions, the historical incarnation of God, is the key element for both defining our true nature and finding our way back to God.

Empirical knowledge and the possibility for science to exist

Our minds are capable of understanding the world we live in because we are created by a rational God. Rationality in nature and rationality in man are therefore correlated. This context makes science possible as a way of understanding God's creation in order to govern it properly, according to the mandate entrusted by God in Genesis 1,28:

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (4 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air and over every living creature that moves on the ground (Genesis 1,28). On the basis of his given abilities, man can know and understand God's creation and "subdue" it. For this reason, science has developed in Western culture, in a Christian background, and not in the East. The Eastern concepts of researcher and researched being ultimately one, or matter being illusory or evil, could not have given a proper context for science. If the physical world is defined as a source of suffering, the only solution is to withdraw from it, cut away any sensation and intellectual thought deriving from it. This doesn't mean that the East doesn't acknowledge nowadays the importance of science, but that science can only grow where the physical world is objective. Although science has eventually developed during the last century in the East as well, it is obviously grounded on a Western pattern.

Is Christianity viable?

Christianity offers the right pattern for living in our physical universe and in harmony with our neighbors. This results from two basic commands in the Bible: 1) "Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it. Rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air and over every living creature that moves on the ground" (Genesis 1,28). 2) "Love your neighbor as yourself" (Matthew 22,39; Mark 12,31; Luke 10,27). The best moral rule for harmonious social living is the 10 commandments (Exodus 20,1-17). Although very old, they still cannot be replaced by a better moral rule. Even if Christian history has recorded a lot of falling short from practicing its moral rule (the often mentioned abuses of the Inquisition, crusades, holy wars, etc.), the fault is not with the religion, but with the people who disobey it. Christianity is only responsible for what it teaches, not for what its so-called adherents do contrary to its teachings. In fact, our whole educational system has its roots in Christianity. In the Middle Ages schools and universities were first grounded around churches. The reformers emphasized the need for education so that the believer could read his Bible. Christian missions brought literacy to many parts of the world. J. Herbert Kane writes in his book: There are 860 known languages and dialects in Africa. A hundred years ago fewer than 20 had a written form. Since then 500 have been reduced to writing - all the work of missionaries (J. Herbert Kane, A Concise History of the Christian World Mission, Baker Book House, 1978, p. 166). The missionaries had to start from scratch - inventing scripts, writing textbooks, and opening schools. For many decades they were the sole purveyors of education. The british did as good a job as anyone in Africa, but in 1923 only 100 of the 6,000 schools in British Africa were government schools. As late as 1961, 68% of all the school children in Africa were still in mission schools (p. 141). It had the same impact on human rights: By precept and example they [the missionaries] inculcated the ideas and ideals of Christianity - the sanctity of life, the worth of the individual, the dignity of labor, social justice, personal integrity, freedom of thought and speech - which have since been incorporated in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights drawn up by the United Nations" (Kane, p. 169).

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (5 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity The worldwide efforts in grounding orphanages, homes for the aged, hospitals, all kinds of care and charity institutions are also known. These are all practical deeds in the spirit of love for one's neighbor with which Christ has filled His followers. Mother Teresa was an internationally known example of living out this spirit of Christianity. She didn’t only teach compassion, but also practiced it and was eventually rewarded with the Nobel Prize for peace in 1979. As the same prize was awarded to the Dalai Lama in 1989, it is interesting to observe the difference between their lifestyles. Although both taught compassion, they had a different understanding of it. The Eastern meaning of compassion (karuna) is an impersonal mindset rather than a factual commitment to one’s neighbor. Christian compassion (agape), on the other hand, leads to action, to the fulfillment of real needs in one’s neighbor’s life. That is why Mother Teresa got the prize for her work with the poorest in India (that no Hindu or Buddhist cared for), while the Dalai Lama got it for his political stand for Tibet. This difference speaks for itself. Kane concludes in his book: By all odds the missionaries of the nineteenth century were a special breed of men and women. Single-handedly and with great courage they attacked the social evils of their time; child marriage, the immolation of widows, temple prostitution, and untouchability in India; footbinding, opium addiction, and the abandoning of babies in China; polygamy, the slave trade, and the destruction of twins in Africa. In all parts of the world they opened schools, hospitals, clinics, medical colleges, orphanages, and leprosaria. They gave succor and sustenance to the dregs of society cast off by their own communities. At great risk to themselves and their families they fought famines, floods, pestilences, and plagues. They were the first to rescue unwanted babies, educate girls, and liberate women" (p. 100). No other religion has produced at least a small part of such an impact on human civilization, so Christianity has no real competitor in changing our world for the good. Unfortunately, critics today are used to seeing and commenting only the bad side of human history and blame Christianity for it, ignoring the difference between genuine followers of Christ and counterfeits. In other words, they throw out the baby with the bathwater.

Appendix "Who are you, the writer of this web site?"

This was the subject of an e-mail received by me, "the writer of this web site", some time ago. I use it here as a title for a short confession concerning my findings on the spiritual path toward God. Following the Eastern tradition of answering tough questions by parables, I will use the story of a pantomime play I saw years ago on a student campus. Although the play took only a few minutes, its message is so dense that it describes my whole life. Imagine the main character in the pantomime standing alone in his room, looking at nothing, sad and disappointed with his life. Let's call him John. He seems to be too tired to go on looking for answers to life's questions in a hostile world like ours. This dramatic atmosphere is emphasized by the melancholic music that is accompanying the play. Suddenly there is a knock at the door. Roused from his lethargy, John approaches the door and looks through the peephole to see who is there. It is a friend, his drinking companion, in a very good mood, coming to have another drink together. Before opening, John goes to

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (6 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity the wardrobe, opens a drawer and takes out an object that he puts on his face. It is a mask. Suddenly his mood changes and he becomes as cheerful as his visitor is. He opens the door and the two have a nice party together, with a lot of drinks, jokes and fun. Then John sees his dear old pal off and closes the door. He approaches the wardrobe, takes off his mask and puts it away. Instantly he returns to his initial icy state. Another knock at the door follows. Again John looks through the peephole and sees his girl friend, with earphones on and her body moving to the rhythm of the music. (However, the only musical background in the play is the same sad and monotonous music, which makes her even more ridiculous.) Before opening, he takes another mask and puts it on. His transformation into her likeness occurs immediately. They dance and have a good time together. But this episode also has to end and the mask is put back where it belongs, in the wardrobe. Again there is loneliness and iciness, as if nothing had happened. The next knock at the door is from a humped beggar. The mask of pity is put on and John opens the door. Very compassionate and merciful, he gives some money and gently directs him to other neighbors. Finally here comes a wandering ascetic to visit him, the embodiment of false godliness, holding his hands together as if he were praying. Our man takes a similar mask, spends some time miming the same "godliness", but gently invites "the holy man" to go, pushing him toward the door with his prayer postured hands. (In the context of this web page inquiry, a better illustration would have been that this visitor be a Yogi, and the two performing some body postures (asanas) together.) At last John is again alone, in his normal "state of consciousness", with all masks carefully stored in the wardrobe. Unexpectedly, a new knock at the door is heard. Exhausted, John goes to see who is next to bother him. Through the peephole he sees an unknown fellow, all dressed in white. It is Christ. Very confused, our man doesn't know which mask to choose and takes the first one. Failure. Instead of accepting the invitation to have a drink together, the stranger snatches John's mask and breaks it. Getting even more confused, John takes the next mask and puts it on. But the stranger snatches this mask as well and breaks it. The third and the fourth masks are also tried on but with the same result. Dreadfully scared, John searches for another mask in the wardrobe, but there is none left. In his despair, he feels a gentle touch on his shoulder and reluctantly turns his face to the stranger, beginning to understand who He really is. Christ makes a sign of rejection toward the broken masks lying on the ground and draws the sign of the heart on his chest, pointing his hands toward John in a demanding attitude. Yes, Christ is asking for his heart, the core of his true identity, which is beyond all masks. John repeats this sign as if testing that he truly has understood Christ's demand. He answers affirmatively and keeps waiting with his hands outstretched. After a moment of uncertainty, John puts his hands on his chest and then stretches them toward Christ, as if offering his heart to him. Christ accepts it and then stretches his hands horizontally, miming the Crucifixion, the price He paid for renewing John's heart. Our man falls in his knees before Him and is transfigured. His face becomes shiny; all despair is gone and replaced by real joy, gratitude and hope. Paradoxically, although the music is the same in the play, it seems to produce a different feeling, as if it is accompanying the new life that has begun. Although my masks were slightly different, something similar has happened with me, "the writer of this web site". I too am indebted to Christ for bringing me to light from behind the masks and giving me a new life. He liberated me from the yoke of being a stranger to myself, from the illusion I was administrating to myself, and then gave me true freedom: freedom from the uncertainties of life, from

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (7 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Revelation and knowledge in Christianity pride and competition for prestige, from the fear of not being accepted by worldly standards - in other words, freedom from the power of sin. Although the world I live in is the same, as the musical background in the play, life with Christ is totally different. It is a life full of hope, full of meaning and certitude. In the midst of a world that seeks to fulfill only its own interest at all costs, regardless of the means, Christ can give true peace, joy and fulfillment. The condition is to put your faith in the true Christ, the historical Christ that was incarnated and crucified for our sins, not in one created by someone's imagination and "wisdom", as there are many such New Age productions today. More than a transformed life, He promises eternal life in His heavenly kingdom, which is more than anyone could expect from religion. There are probably many of you that look condescendingly on this confession. Many may be skeptical and many may be smiling tolerantly. I would only ask them to remember the healing of the man born blind by Jesus (John 9), so wonderfully pictured by Franco Zeffirelli's internationally known film Jesus of Nazareth. Remember how people laughed at him while he sought to reach the Pool of Siloam with his eyes covered with mud. However, although it may have been quite a spectacle, the eyes of the blind opened, and the laughter froze. It is possible that I too may be ridiculed for what I have written here, due to our post-modern mindset but, as the healed man said once, "One thing I do know. I was blind but now I see!" (John 9,25). This is Christ's gift for me, so precious that I cannot stop being thankful to Him. See also this one: Marcia's story: a strange but true spiritual journey, by Marcia Montenegro

http://www.comparativereligion.com/revelation.html (8 of 8) [10/27/2000 9:50:02 AM] Links to Other Useful Web Sites

Links to Other Web Sites

CrossSearch A Massive Online Christian Resource Directory

Academic Info Christianity, An independent directory compiled by Mike Madin, a graduate of the University of Washington's Comparative Religion program.

Virtual Religion Index, Links for Research on Religion, designed by Prof. Mahlon H. Smith, Rutgers University.

"The Elephant's Eye", the Dialog Center's Information Service on New Religious Movements. Here you can find factual information on many New Religious Movements.

The Muslim-Christian Debate Website It aims to stimulate genuine debate between Christians and Muslims on a wide range of topics. The Good Way Is the best way to God the way of the Torah, the way of the Gospel or the way of the Qur'an? Good articles and downloadable books on this site.

Classic Christian books in electronic format, selected for your edification. There is enough good reading material here to last you a lifetime, if you give each work the time it deserves! World Wide Study Bible -- Scripture, commentaries, sermons, etc. Early Church Fathers, 38 volumes -- The most important writings from the first 800 years of the church.

StudyWeb - a place for anyone doing research to find the information they need as easily as possible.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/links.html (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:50:11 AM] Links to Other Useful Web Sites CyberU.com - a comprehensive guide to online education for consumers and businesses.

Adherents.com - Statistics, Overviews, Index about classical religions and new religions. A goldmine of information!

GoSearch Web Directory:

Exact Phrase Any Keywords All Keywords in: Add URL | New Sites | Browse

CrossDaily.com has Awesome Christian Sites where you can vote for this site & other great ones. Christian search engine, directory & voting index. You'll find Bible, chat, churches, jobs, music, reviews, software, theology, & more. See the best sites! Religious Resources on the Net is a comprehensive, searchable database of religious web sites on the Internet. Visitors to the web site can browse through over 100 topics or use the search engine to generate a listing of resources containing selected keywords.

Apologetics Index provides a database and glossary of information on cults, sects, new religious movements, doctrines, apologetics and counter-cult organizations.

Karma and Reincarnation. An extensive scholarly examination of the theory of karma by Joseph F. Morales, an author whose conclusion is: “The more closely I have looked into the topic, the less satisfied I have become with the whole theory.”

CANA - Christian Answers for the New Age, by Marcia Montenegro

Search Engines

http://www.comparativereligion.com/links.html (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:50:11 AM] Links to Other Useful Web Sites Back to Contents | E-Mail

http://www.comparativereligion.com/links.html (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:50:11 AM] Other page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Other Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou other sites. This

LinksToYou Automotive Page category covers sites that do not fit our other categories, that are not similar to LinksToYou Business Page those topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Other Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00other09.htm (1 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:50:31 AM] Other page AndersonsPolicePage LEO home page with free graphics, animations, gifs, poems,crime preven DAN'S MEMORIAL Jimmy Camp The story of an historic campground along the Cherokee Trail in what i Firstborn Sons of th History of a midwestern branch of the Gehling family. Old Coach House B&B The Old Coach House bed and breakfast accommodation in Kirkby Stephen, Orthodoxy Expository and Comparative Orthodoxy. Analysis of doctrines of the Ea Jodi's Dog House A site dedicated to my Siberian Huskies and other fun dog stuff. Martin Family Tree Family tree: Martin, Saville, Golding, Grimani, Starosta, Stewart, etc CompReligion Investigates if world religions are complementary and equally true Fagan's Grave Scott Scheibe From Greece ... Private Homepage in German and Greece. Some content is useful :-))) Eyes of Sophia The rest of the story & articles & links on consciousness,love,unity EXP Funny t-shirts for you and also you can hire us to fix your PC! Tales of the Colorad Stories of the old west. The Historical Garde The human history of the Garden of the Gods. The Northrup Zone The Northrup Zone is the personal web site of the Northrup family in R CRYSTAL LIGHTING WE HIRE AND SELL LIGHTS TO THE ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY Richard Hills - Astr In-depth consultations for individuals, couples, and parents for child Astrology_Ephemeris Free comprehensive Astrology resources for all here (250 pages). Incl LEGG Genelaogy and F The family history of my children contains over 8300 relatives, and ke Christian E-Links Randy's Christian E-Links to other Christian webpages Growing up in Iowa A country boy's experiences growing up in Iowa at mid-century. CanineWorld.com Speedway! Everything for the speedway fan Realm of Slywy Writer, thinker, poet. Life, love, books. Etc. Flats fishing Florida Keys flats fishing with well-known flyfishing guide, Bob Rodge Eve´s sida Svensk sida med tips om att tjäna pengar på webben Robert Hall's Homepa Personal Homepage of Robert Hall, Includes resume, personal intrest su Dog Racing Australia Greyhound Racing Info Australia FB Table Tennis Very friendly table tennis site, lots of info. Welcome to visit us. Elaine''s Web Home Computer Tips & Tricks, Poetry, Romance, and More! Viana Roofing VIANA Roofing & Sheet Metal Ltd. undertakes work in institutional, Ind Assorted Bean Compan Largest selection of TY, DISNEY and other BEANIES at the BEST PRICES. Holiday Recipes Warba.NET The on-line community of Warba, Minnesota. Stop by and say Hi!! Cemetery Stones Dollhouse Miniatures Lake of the Ozarks A Lake of the Ozarks area Community of local information and services Welcome to Milen ... Personal WEB site including resume of Electronics engineer - IC design Unitel TFAG Far Away Gunner A great site all about ARSENAL FC with the lastest results and fixture Links World Web Directory including Christianity, Computing Resources, and more...

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00other09.htm (2 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:50:31 AM] Other page Bingeman.net Jokes, Stories, Text Chat, Real Time Chat with Fire Talk, & much more PowerNet Connections We provide everything free e-mail, e-commerce, e-shop & e-astrology THE COLLECTION A resource for Collectors & Collectibles, buy or sell using my Auction CONNE Anton's HomePage! My site contains: 3D Art, ComputerGames, Fantasy, Roleplaying, Winamp. ToL Euro 2000 A wealth of information about the final phase of the tournament such a TowyValeHamstery Information on Hamster Clubs, Hamster Shows and lots of Hamster pictur My homepage Pge about offshore racing,vacations,boats auto slalom,parties Riverannan Riverannan, Scotland - one website for the whole river. Produced with Asto Logic Cherokee Trail The Final Call Bible truths, bible studies and bible prophecies - Daniel & Revelation Blondy's Place A collection of pages from silly to serious, plus helpful links. Funny Things STEVE''S WORLD I am Steve and you are invited to share a little part of my world. About David RalphHosking Yachts and Aircraft Sedgefield75 ASC Exotic Pets Vet NewCal Aviation NewCal Aviation has been supporting the operational requirements of De RadonSeal sealer rjlo land Modern Revivals BrianUK`s Webpage A Personal Webpage with lots of MoneyMaking Ideas and Links,Free Softw The Sanctuary Intercomm Investigat NeedleGraphics NeedleGraphics-Downunder global supplier of craft products and craft s Cheating Spouse Callback 1 Big Brother Watches Big Brother is Watching you! What do I know about you? Find out here. Special Operations C Official Member Lost Child/MissingKids Broadcast System. POW/MIA Team Astrology @ Planet Z Zodiac aphesis astrology software and free birth chart analysis tips b Good Luck to You Good Luck to you! Couldn't we all use a little luck at times. Cosmic Awareness Cosmic Awareness Communications - Helping People Become Aware n3noa's Web immobilier Destinee's Homepage Something for everyone. Poetry, Graphics, Greeting cards, Links. BlackStar Studio Resource site for body piercing and piercing aftercare information. People Search People Search M-beat's homepage This site contains almost anything incl. linkz and stuff like that ;-) Jonathan Maravilla Jonathan Maravilla Official Website McWilliams Family Visit our family site and see how you can build one and make money $ $

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00other09.htm (3 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:50:31 AM] Other page Cosmic Awareness Cosmic Awareness Communications - Helping People Become Aware Plush Stuffed Toys Courtney's e-Store Stuffed Plush Toys Gifts Die Cast Models Pandora''s Pals This site contains resources on animal advocacy, for those who foster. Richardson Animal Ho Veterinarian services; surgery, ultrasound and endoscopy. Reach for the Sky You are invited to 'Reach for the Sky' together. Find ideas that could mariekythe 's site add your link, cute links, sailormoon, anime, animations, graphics, vo Jesus Christ saves, Check out my personal site, Jesus is life and can save you from hell Spirit Winds Monthly Christian newsletter - Stories, quotes, poems, recipes. Death Deception Satan's original deception still lives on: "You shall not surely die." Jonathan''s Web Page Information about and pictures of various military jets and helicopter Eagle''s Places Home page of Roger Brown Eagle Brown's websites. Brown Eagle Traders Native American sites and links, pow-wow schedules Pekingese Dogs Aust Pekingese Pet Dog Information Australia Exotic Pets Vet Informative site about exotic pets from an Exotic Pets Vet. Glow Sticks Best Prices on glow sticks, glow necklaces, and glow bracelets McWilliams Family McWilliams family in Texas. My family photos and die-cast collection. Up 'N' Over DTC Dog Training. Basic training, Obedience, Agility or Socialisation. A s Tommy's Cool Links Visit here to check out some cool links! Babaji Haidakhan Babaji Homepage Tools Check out the great tools you can use if you want to make a webpage Slavs This site urges all American Slavs to unite. MyBigBass.com Pictures and stories dedicated to the one that didn't get away. Free Trials Free Trials, Free Information Requests, Free Trial Subscriptions Spyprogtech.com Private Investigators software selection Body Armour UK The UK's Premier Supplier of Covert Bulletproof & Stabproof Vests Astrology We provide everything from free e-mail to e-commerce, e-shop & e-astro Jobs, Pharmacies & F Guides on work at home jobs, International Pharmacies, Classified Adve Ummamum''s Hideout A Fun Family Site with um...Variety! Photos/Crafts/Weather/Web Design Angel Psychic internationally known, 40 years experience, $2 minute - 30-min minimum MyDeadbeatX.com Paybacks's hell and the stories are hot.

LinksToYou GUARANTEE If your web site has been on the list 30 days and LinksToYou has not added at least 500 links pointing to your web site from other websites (The LinksToYou Counter may take much longer since search engines must index the links), we will give you 500 free exposures of a banner, courtesy of BannersXChange.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00other09.htm (4 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:50:31 AM] Other page What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00other09.htm (5 of 5) [10/27/2000 9:50:31 AM] Arts page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Arts Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou arts related sites.

LinksToYou Automotive Page This category covers sites about crafts, dance, film, literature, painting, LinksToYou Business Page photography and similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Arts Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00arts09.htm (1 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:50:35 AM] Arts page Ogden's Prose Poetry Contemporary prose poetry and spoken word poems. These poems are spiri CelestialHealingArts J Lance Photography Color and B&W Limited Edition Photographs of National Parks, Landscape Monte Guynes Art AAA Photography AAA MELC Studios Art Avalon fotostockphotos Stock Photography/ pictures animals flowers people environment nature World of Names Family name histories, meaning of names and surnames, coat of arms Portrait Artist://ww Acrylic and pastel portraits painted from photos or sittings. Wood Sculpture Detailed figurative wood sculpture, influenced by the Medieval traditi Doll Designs Original Designer Artist dolls sculpted by Michelle Lightner, Links Accent on Artists An original fine art collection showcasing Niagara Region Canadian art Angel withs Harp Music and Gifts for the Heart and Soul, Angel Song CD Out there Photo Photography from around the world. Art, stock and assignment photos. Bridge Art Gallery We showcase watercolour landscape paintings and art work by artists ba The House of Saphiri A place where Kirin and Kiwa share their art and stories to everyone. House of Saphiria AARTI art for sale Contemporary artists selling their work Simiya Greeting Cards Hand signed Cool Cats Collection of fine greeting cards for all events ArtCumbria Artists, groups and visual arts organisations based in the UK Folio Gallery Featuring a wide variety of fine art, sculpture and photography. Fractals Galore Fractals Galore is a site which promotes fractal art. It has downloads bronze statue founta export import bronze statues sculptures fountains new designs arts The WoodCarvers Web Carvers, Galleries, and Businesses comprehensive listings, also Onli Beyond Reason An exploration of Schizophrenia by artist Aidan Shingler Refrigeration Refrigeration air conditioning and catering equipment Quotes for today Over 100 famous, business and inspiration quotes. Photo quotes too! Dale Studios Wedding photography, childrens portraits, family portraits. Dahls Art Production Limited edition and original watercolor paintings MELC Studios Rafael Jimenez Art The most recent work of this young colombian artist and designer. Heartsong Books Celebrating the interconnectedness of all life Aboriginal Arts Bout Selling genuine Australian Aboriginal art & artefacts at reasonable pr Classic Bookshelf Electronic books to read online with a Java Powered reading applet. Daniel Heiss' Online View Daniel Heiss' Art On Line!Spirital Surrealism is the name of this HJJager Photography Fine art photography by Hendrik Jan Jager dotcom-Art the Virtual Art Gallery where only the best works of art are shown PLAYWRITES.COM Where reader meets writer Galeri Riyadh Fannil Gardens of Islamic Arts containing the manuscripts to the Al-Quran Mus Stephers Inc. Hand P Stephers Inc. Manufactures Hand Painted greeting cards for every holid Mantra in Metal offers a 13 inch metal plaque of the tibetan buddhist mantra of compas

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00arts09.htm (2 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:50:35 AM] Arts page Pencil portraits Pencil portraits of celebrities and family members AmericanPoems.com AmericanPoems.com brings you the very best of classic American verse. graphic design graphic design from servicepoint Lisa Angelina''s Pag Lisa presents her book Nothing Hidden, a story of deception and lies. Elegant Photographs Photos of landscapes, cityscapes, people, animals, jazz musicians in c Glass Designs Unique, original, and traditional Stained Glass Designs including lamp Wood and Metal Storefront with books and tools for metalworking and woodworking Wilson Illustrations Dallas area Graphic Design and Illustration, traditional, computer Masterpieces of Digi Masterpieces of XXI century contemporery fine art photography includin American Artists focuses on biography of artists and displays new and reprinted works Art District Buy and sell art and prints. Water Spirits Handcrafted miniature model canoes. airblot.com photos free to download Okanagan Touch Wood The Wooden Flower Shop.....Plus Many Other Unique Gifts & Creations Good Mtn Press Books Fabulous reviews of literate authors, Rudolf Steiner, etal. Rebirth art &craft South African Africa,art craft,music,drums,oil paintings, nelson mand The Talewagger New stories for children, from 7 years old to 70 years young. Thread Artist Design We have unique and artistic embroidery designs and Great supplies. MARIARTE Download 1000's cross-stitch patterns 4 free ! EMBROIDERY Dance Terpsichore DK Dancetheatre performing modern-ethnic dance inspired by rituals. villagecrier Original art and home to towncriers museum Free wallpapers Hundreds of free high quality wallpapers (800x600 -> 1600x1200) Quicksilverdirect Ph Custom Photography Outdoor & Nature Photography Landscapes & Scenics S QuiltersWarehouse Quilt pattern designers at the QuiltersWarehouse showcase online catal Jay Wegter Fine Art Original watercolor fine art of nature, seascapes and gardens Goddess Art Free Web and clip art for you to download, plus Poster Shop and sugges Aleena. New fantasy novel. Aleena of the Lantern by The Talewagger. Peter's Picture Gall The Show-case for Original Photographic Art by Peter Sandilands. Photo 1000 Woodcuts! Gallery of fine woodcut prints by Maria Arango & printmaking resources Patrick Cook Photogr Photographer Fashion, Glamour, Models Portfolios, Seniors, and Art Arts - work from pos Arts - work from posters to fantasy, erotic, tatoo body art, humanitie River theater Astoria's local theater for the arts. Community theater for every one.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00arts09.htm (3 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:50:35 AM] Arts page LinksToYou GUARANTEE If your web site has been on the list 30 days and LinksToYou has not added at least 500 links pointing to your web site from other websites (The LinksToYou Counter may take much longer since search engines must index the links), we will give you 500 free exposures of a banner, courtesy of BannersXChange.

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00arts09.htm (4 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:50:35 AM] Automotive page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Automotive Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou automotive

LinksToYou Automotive Page related sites. This category covers sites about boating, cars, motorcycles and LinksToYou Business Page similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Automotive Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00automotive09.htm (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:50:41 AM] Automotive page Ferrari Turbo Site A Ferrari web site with pictures and facts on every Ferrari ever made. Oil-tech Environmentally conscious oils and filter products that extend the lif Pete''s homepage Petes' Homepage, talking 'bout Renaults, twin engine cars, bikes, Loui auto engine tune auto engine tune swindon,all make car repairs & servicing,mot testing, Wolftrax Quality leather motorcycle riding gear and unique riding accessories The Auto Lift Shop Your on-line source for auto lifts, lift parts and shop equipment www.56meteor.com Facts & pictures of these classic Canadian cars. IMPORT AUTO PARTS We have parts for all Foreign Cars, Specializing in VW parts, restorat Days of Past cRazy Willy Alignment Masters Alignment Masters, in business since 1984, specializes in repairing au The Classic Car Shop The Classic Car Shop buy and sell quality British and European cars Morris Motorcycle A Harley Davidson aftermarket shop in Lake of the Ozarks, Missouri. Dons Auto Pages International and NZ automotive and motorsport info and links Catalytic Converters OEM remanufactured catalytic converters for all cars and trucks. R J Brown Racing R J brown Racing your Fastwax Connection On Line Sales of Fastwax Vicstate Auto Centre Australia's largest auto recycled parts warehouse Exotic Cars Today's Hottest Exotic Cars, Acura NSX, Ferrari, Lamborghini, Etc. CarInfo.com ftctransmissions.com Automatic transmission parts and rebuilt units just for you CycleMart Daewoo Cars Independent that buys and sells used Daewoo cars. IMG Cars Sales of Quality Motor Vehicles at Sensible Prices A1 AUTO PARTS A complete on-line automotive supply store with parts and accessories Snooper Radar Detect Snooper Speed Camera and Speed Trap Radar Detectors For The UK. Buy On LeaseTips.com Consumer info on leasing. Top 10 Leasing Scams and how to avoid them. A1 AUTO WORLD A1 Auto World provides links to quality new and used car and truck sup Harley Classifieds American Motorcycle Classifieds - hundreds of used Harleys and parts. AMS Racing Performance racing parts and automotive machine shop. VW Parts Your International Connection for your Air Cooled VW Restoration Rent A Car In Boston Rent a Car In Boston-- An Exotic One! Automobile Financing Automobile financing . It's fast , easy and with any type of credit. Suspension Parts Suspension parts & suspension products for car, trucks and Obsolete Parts Hard-to-find engine parts for classic cars, trucks and tractors. New Ford trucks,cars New Ford trucks,cars,SUV's.USA.Bi-fuel,Superduty-SUV's-Vans ThermoKingNorthern Transport temperature control and air conditioning Model Car Hub The Site For Model Car Fans - Die-Cast or Kits autocarcircle autocar Bad Credit Car Loans Bad credit car loans from 1-800 AUTO YES! Hitches For Trailers Hitches for Trailers for your Boat, Horse, Car, Truck and RV. Salvage Auto Search Free reference site for auto salvage yards, used car parts dealers.... Car insurance Car insurance Mr. Sponsorship ALL FORMS OF RACING SPONSORSHIP LOCATOR.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00automotive09.htm (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:50:41 AM] Automotive page

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00automotive09.htm (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:50:41 AM] Business page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Business Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou business related

LinksToYou Automotive Page sites. This category covers sites about advertising, commerce, industry, LinksToYou Business Page marketing, trade and similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Business Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (1 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page Emergency24 Inc. We monitor: burglar, fire, holdup, medical emergencies, boilers or s Ryan TelCom Discounted Long Distance Services at lowest rates! FREE pagers, FREE s Seventrees Corp. Provides special security, corporate intelligence, & investigations. www.dsutton.com Internet hosts for aircraft, transport, acupuncture & truck sales. Editorial Services Writing, editing, and proofreading for websites, multimedia, and print ICS-NETWORK.NET Profit Source 250+ FREE Hot Business Start-Up Reports - Secret Inside Information Cheap Long Distance Cheap long distance telephone service and calling cards Rubric Apparel Rubric Apparels is a buying house from India meeting all your garment Ellio Martina Guitar Handmade Basses and Guitars. Electric, acoustic & archtops. BassMute TAKE TIME OUT... Comprehensive bookkeeping service for small businesses No Worries Catering Gourmet catering for weddings and private parties, from 25 to 500+ gue A7alarms.com A7Alarms, Nationwide burglar alarms, fire, holdup security alarm insta ReduceDebt NewCreditCards EstablishCredit RentCell Low Rates to Rent Wireless Cell Phones Worldwide Olsen Sports J and J Sports Cards We have, Sports Cards, Baseball,Football,Hockey,Basketball,and Racing Tele Freedom Flat rate telephone service #1 place to get Need Welcome to NeedfulStuff.com...an American Express Online Merchant ...a Sakati Associates The entry page to Sakati Associates' Web site. Sells books in Excel, P ConsolidateDebt DebtProgram QualifyForCredit * BestRates Search * Long Distance, Calling Cards, Dial-Around, IP... We Search,You Choose! Viking White Sewing Promote for FREE 1000s of resources that you can use to promote your web site for FREE. EARTHBIZ.COM Internet Business Success Center And Online Mall! SourceWeb.Com Tools & Resources For Starting Your Profitable Online Business! CreditCardsForYou Time to Surf - explo Time to Surf - Get paid to surf, online activities that generate cash Marcon 2000 Royal Antiques,FSBO realty listigs,business directory,german russians Fundraising Products Free fundraising information from 100 top fundraising companies All Fundraising Comp 1200+ fundraising companies. Free fundraising ideas & information Free Secret Reports Site about Free Secret Reports of Powerful Internet Marketing (free ti Phonezone Serving the world for over 6 years with low cost telecommunications LowestCostPhone Gateway to the lowest cost long distance phone rates of more than a do Oliveweb links to The RockSite - the home of rock music, Olive Index of Health Direct Marketing Con Direct Marketing Concepts Ltd specialist telemarketing, direct marketi Free For All Site Su Free For All Links remote submission site powered by AutoLinkPro for T Best Phone Rates Low Rate Long Distance, Calling Cards, Toll Free services, Wireless Ebusiness

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (2 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page DyConn Sales Equipment and tool sales. Some novelty items Book and literature FreeMoneyWorld.com CT Express Expedited trucking service at standard rates. James Bain Ltd TOTAL QUALITY TRANSPORTATION SOLUTIONS Richard Jolly Richard Jolly Construction Consultant Christian BLAIR BRININGER, A Houston, Texas law firm specializing in ERISA litigation. We publish P.C Popsnet Online Infor Popsnet Online Information on Surf for Pay Income Opportunities lists The Bindery Digital Bookprinters of Books ,Manuals, Memoirs, Biographies, or repri NET-LINK INDEX UK Aircraft, UK Boats, UK Waterside Property, For Sale & Rent. UNIQUE WOOD Specializing in unique wood products, gifts, and custom woodworking. O PRODUCTS Asset Recovery Providing our clients the opportunity to recapture Capital Investment Zemansky & Zemansky, Insurace Brokers - Zemansky & Zemansky - Sadler & Company Insu Ruthian Internationa Financial Freedom through International Internet Opportunities Carmarthen Business Rubber Stamps Custom Rubber Stamps from Simonstamp.com Boilers Including Firetube Boilers, Watertube Boilers, Packaged and Power boil for-Quotes.com Insurance Quotes for all your family's needs nationwide FREE MARKETING Free Internet Marketing Advice, email, & Top Money Making Opportunity TIPS CallingMall.com Innsitting Services Innsitters, innsitting, inns, bed-and-breakfast, training, workshops Financial Synergy Superannuation administration software, superannuation funds, self man Newcastle IBF CWTaylor Foundry Steele Musik East Music Instrument retailer of Taylor SantaCruz Larrivee Cort Samick Mon Pattayacitythailand RCM LLC Tosalena -Furniture Exporter of Furniture from Indonesia including Hand Carved Mahogany, C Asset Finance Providing credit & leasing facilities for aquiring business assets Typing Fast 6 steps to typing as fast as you talk, Speed Typing Secrets Shown! Credit Cards ReducingBills * www.LDSearch.Com * Discount Long Distance Services Search! We Search, You Choose! Ad-Ventures Online Internet Marketing, Resources, Business Opportunities Futurecard ApplyForVisa GetVisaCards DebtQuote Denlore Photography Digital photography, graphics and web design. EasyCall Telecom Choose from a variety of discount long distance and internet services

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (3 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page Qwest Word Noise new media development specializing in audio production and voice work ZeroHype Work at Hom Dedicated to ZeroHype Opportunities, SuccessNow4U.com shows you how to China Stones Export Hi Quality China Granite Supplier with quarries & factories Etiquetas en Linea Transformamos, distribuimos y producimos todo lo relac con etiquetas MidSouth Information Criminal Records Checks in all 50 states Carolina Information Direct Access to North Carolinas' Criminal and Civil Records Carolina Search Inc. North Carolina's public record research CashLinks CashLinks Affiliate Program with Tonogan.Com Wessenden Marketing Media consultants: research and reports on the UK magazine market FLUX A/S Flux A/S is a vendor with own production. We specialice in high freque Bakery Equipment Scobie & McIntosh (Bakery Engineers) Ltd have a history of over 100 ye Herbal Incense France-OK French food & wine - food products and tours on food & wine Business HELPS Business Helps, Great Products & Services important for your Hompage. Stewart Engineers Civil engineering consultants Stewart Engineers Limited ExpertsAvenue!! How Looking for new clients? We would like to bring your attention to a ne CIGARETTES for LESS Cigarette go MLM !! -ALL Cigarettes for less - Referral Income too Silk Elephant Sparta Tennessee - C Certified Locksmith serving White County and surrounding areas. Electr ENETPLACE Rezulin Help teak patio garden fu garden furniture teak patios lawn sales direct retail wholesale brass Free Classifieds Free classified ads and Free Internet Services SignIndustry.com A business-to-business resource and community for the sign industry. Accu Trak Tool Corp. Manufacturers of Precision Knurling Tools & Holders Creative business eM COMMISSIONit the e-Marketplace for creative services and products prov Access Authority Cal We offer very low rates and high quality service for international lo RSVP etc. Delta Funding Factoring - Immediate Cash for Your Invoices. BizFonts.com MICR, OCR and Bar Code Fonts including PDF417, Code 39 and Code 128 fundraising Free fundraising on the internet Vistaphonezone Offering low cost long distance services since 1994 ! Event Meeting Guide Discount Long Distan Discount Long Distance, Lowest Rates for Interstate, Intrastate, and I Zig Ziglar Network M Stacy Hupp's Downline of the Zig Ziglar Network MLM. ZZN is the sourc Keed Packing Machine wholesale watches Dynamic Typesetting FREE Home Business Earn Commissions and Overides Reselling discount Long Distance Network Business Pag Viking White Sewing CNC Machine Programs

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (4 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page Lease Financing Boat Ladders Business Opportunity E MONEY CENTER In association with Internet Marketing Center, we provide tips, method NDS- Products for En Northern Data Systems provides radio telemetry SCADA systems, software FLUX Int. ABC Printer Repair o Newsletter Mailing The Web Marketing Ce The Insider Secrets to Marketing on the Internet. Tips, tricks and too Olsen's G Scale Trai G Scale trains for sale online. The Front Page Busin The Front Page Businesss Opportunity News has information on new and Carmarthenshire BBAN RecycTonerCartridges Toner Cartridges new and remanufactured at discount prices. Free shipp Money Makers Discover How To Make Money On The Net! A Simple Plan To Start You On South Hylton Legion BeverlyVChatMall Boating Solutions Free Money Online Guide to Earning Free Money on the net including Be an ISP, free inter Financial Help 4U Financial assistance for people in debt. Help Pay Bills Consolidate debts, pay off bills, save thousands! Printing Services Steeley Print offers full color printing & book production services Art in Glass 3D Laser etched glass giftware & corporate gifts A7 Alarms Chicago burglar and fire alarm monitoring electronic security systems The Tobacco Lawyers D & N Communications One source for all your low price long distance calling needs! ARD Tools Design & Manufacture of high quality Tools for Thermoforming. Awards ClickDoughTerraShare Datatone Business Hotel Devon Information Free directory of fundraising information & fundraising ideas Granite stone granite masonry stone landscaping boulders granite rock Welcome to Elliot La Discover Elliot Lake, Ontario, Canada and the three main areas: CityCo Marketing Tech APAlexander Personalberatung, Unternehmensberatung UK Aircraft For Sale Aircraft for sale and group flying in the UK. Ds-sewing ePIPO Money Makers Sea Eagle Publicatio Publishing Australian business books & Training Resource Packages Ecommerce Sponsors Callback LD Columbus-Phenix City Quality, Affordable Business Website Solutions for the new Small Busin

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (5 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page InfoXchange Inc. Fax broadcasting, voice broadcasting, fax on demand, never busy fax, v Millennium Profits QMM Direct Mail Mark QMM provides direct mail marketing, list, printing, and data services Web Site Promotion Search engine optimization-website promotion & registration evisionLink Mktg evisionLink...a home based business with international opportunities! Domain name appraisa Top appraiser of domain names and/or websites. How much is your domai Turbines Condensing Steam Turbines, Extraction Steam Turbines , Non-Condensing CalSaver Discount long distance plans for California residents and businesses. SUBMIT your Ad Completely automated online marketing system! The Front Page Busin Business Opportunity News Ruthian Intl. Financial Freedom through International Internet Opportunities Web Site Promotion Free Internet Marketing, Website Promotion, Search Engine Ranking Help QBS Online Free site promotion and resources plus books, music and videos Buddha Sculptures Crystal buddha, sandalwood elephant, herbal incense distributors Linguestate Equity stakes - raising business capital without debt or loss of contr Diesel World Diesel World connects buyers and sellers of engines and generator sets Net2Phones Save up to 100% on your international long distance calling! Credit Repair Report credti repair, credit reports, credit bureaus Fortune-Sites High-profit home based business opportunity: make money on the interne LMK Engineering Ltd Manufacturer of industrial induction drum heaters under THERMOSAFE bra factoring Factoring Get out of Debt Free online debt consolidation quote Ira Osman Reps Representative for Manufacturers including Emjoi, Homedics & More. Power Generation Equ used Power Generation Equipment UK Boats For Sale Yachts and motor boats for sale in the UK. P.C. HYDRAULICS Specialists on Hydraulic/Pneumatic Hoses, Adaptors, Fittings & Couplin A & B technical serv gas fireplace & heating, parts for myson, cannon, RW, british fires Replica Furniture Huge Range Of Solid Oak & Mahogany Reproduction Furniture Domains Everything about Domain names! Dot-Coms Have you been dreaming of ways to become the next Dot-Com multi-Millio Advertising If you ever dreamed of marketing effectively online with next to nothi Business Each month we focus on exceptional FREE and low-cost resources to help Calling Card Guru Discount calling cards. Order online and get PINS in 12-24 hours! UKWEBMALL Web Mall - Health, Lifestyle, vital living department stote! Waste chemicals We buy waste solvents and chemicals. office supplies uk office supplies from service point ChinaBusinessConsult Awide consultancy network in China, free promote to our members Home Based Job You won't get rich quick, but you can work your way to riches!!!!!!!!! Foam Surplus Closed cell foam products and Insulation at surplus discount prices AMAZING FORMULA Discover the amazing formula that sells product like crazy. It WORKS!! STD Group Scaffolding training for UK and overseas Phenix-City.Com Quality, affordable website solutions for new business owners 50% OFF LinkBee-E-Commerce LinkBee is the innovator in e-commerce solutions. Linking your e-store

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (6 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page Inkjet cartridge ink inkjet cartridge refills for most inkjet,bubblejet ink printers,color Maplan machines Maplan, uw partner voor rubberspuitgietmachines Ecommerce Marketing All the necessary information to make your business an online success Horsesales, Inc. Horsesales, Inc. advertises racing and other sport horses for sale wit Extruders Sales of Extruders. Bafco Kiddie Rides L Bafco Limited is a major UK coin operated 'kiddie ride' manufacturer a Tonogan.Com Classifi Classified Ads Placement powered by AdLandPro for Tonogan.Com New Monterey dot com The "new" Monterey area business listings pages which include Carmel, Free Debt Quote Offers nationwide financial help for people in debt Amy''s Gifts 2 Go Offers custom-made gift baskets containing gourmet delicacies. Soaring Eagles Successful & experienced network marketers only- -new product launch OK Aircraft Aircraft sales - from light singles to Cessna Citations. Lern to Perm Hair at Learn how to do great home perms with the Haircutting School Home Perm TWP Marketing Books, Maps ands Software for Collectors, Webmasters and Surfers Fibrecast(UK) Ltd Fibrecast(UK)Limited composites, phenolics,fibreglass products GLAMOUR Fashion photographer based in France. Site in English. PHOTOGRAPHER eBook Marketing eBook marketing resources Long Distance Discount long distance and toll free services, phone cards & more! Phone Calling Cards "Looking for LOW rates on calling cards and long distance services?" Insurance UK "Insurance in a Box" for UK Residents. Special cover...great rates. CTronics Medical Electronics Sales and Maintenance Rosenoel in Berlin - Wir verkaufen reinstes, naturbelassenes Rosenoel aus erstklassiger Pro Online evisionLink web hosting, site building templates, ecommerce mall, email and more evisionLink ecommerce mall, web hosting, site building templates and more E-pub more trafic BANNER BUSINESS Accueil suisse exchange free of charge. Photo coffee mug t-s Custom made photo mouse pads T-shirts coffee mugs and wildlife prints FREE Long Distance Get 100 FREE minutes when you register with OPEX ----> PICTURES <---- Fashion pictures and models (plus guestbook) Netcash Kings Free P Unlimited hour online pay programs..free internet services..webpage pr Taylor s Foundry Iron foundry supplying grey, ductile and alloy iron castings Associate Success Your guide to revenue producing programs to help you earn more A&B Technical, Gas f Gas fireplaces sales and service, Parts, infra red heating SMS - bigger profits Sales And Marketing Consultancy, Books, Tapes, Seminars and Free Resou Fundraising Ideas Fundraising for PTO's, PTA's, sports teams, churches, & schools. Haircutting School Learn how to cut hair at home with the Haircutting School book and kit Wright Machine Tool Manufacturer of Saw Sharpening, and Stellite tipping equipment HowToFormACorp Demonstrate how to form a corporation and LLC properly San Diego Lawyer San Diego lawyers-attornies referral directory Virginia Decking Deck-Porch-Gazebo Plans from $29.95 - Custom Design & Build, too! Worldwide Telecom Omniconnection.com offers the world telecommunications services! EasiHealthBiz Healthy Pie - Produsts, information and e-commerce. LaserPro Plus Save up to 50% on Inkjet & Toner Cartridges, Ribbons, Paper and Fusers

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (7 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page Home Loan Systems We specialize in equity loans, 2nd mortgages, debt consolidation loans Home Loan Systems We specialize in equity loans, 2nd mortgages, debt consolidation loans TTI Long Distance Quality, reliable, low cost long distance and internet access. OPEX Low cost long distance services On Tap Online On Tap is DC's largest monthly entertainment guide, with listing of ov 1derWorld Lingerie Intimate clothing for women Sexy Lingerie Sexy Lingerie Gallery Cheao Web Hosting cheap and free web hosting IMC international consultants in public sector management Cash Creators Profitable home businesses, affiliate programs & marketing services WebDebtConsolidation Offers debt consolidation, bill consolidation services online. DeFFIL International DEBT FREE A Source of Business Opportunities! eMoneyGram eMoneyGram is the online telegram with news from the emoney world... Buying an Aircraft? Tips, tools and resources for aircraft buyers and sellers. Aircraft ap World Of Gifts Specialty wholesaler of gifts and collectibles for flea markets etc... Funeral Associates Helping Families with, Funerals, Funeral Services, Funeral Planning, A Snorkel Gear Distributor of wholesale and retail snorkeling equipment. Cleaners Express Cleaners Express is Idaho's first online dry cleaningservice. All you Fastener World Canada's most comprehensive listing of industrial fasteners and growin Make Commissions Make commissions with this Viagra affiliate program. Get Wealthy This affiliate program helps you reach your dreams of wealth. Allan Webb Ltd For document conversion to any format and the production of technical FBC Electric F.B. Culley, Electric - Custom Design and Installation - N. California Earn Easy Money Affiliate program to earn referal commissions coming from your wesite. Richard Jolly Richard Jolly Construction Consultant Christian Snoreless Snoring? Quit snoring today with Snoreless. Search Engine Search Engine Optimization, Search Engine Placement, Top Rankings Euro Conversions Offering refills, online order status, discount prices. Barebags sleeping bag manufacturers based in south africa WhiteKnight Services Home Maintenance Conception D Conseils aux entreprises en conception de produits nouveaux Texoma Lake Come to the Lake Texoma Paradise... Fun for the Whole Family!!! Sherman Texas Chambe Sherman, Texas Chamber of Commerce Website Cweb Communications Cweb Communications is the versatile source for all of your Web needs. Search Traffic Search Engine Traffic. Increase you search engine rankings. Cognigen Comm. Cognigen Communications long distance and telecom services Global petroleum Exploration,refining,marketing crude oil & petroleum products ReduceYourBills Consolidate your debt. Free consultation and consolidating quote. AMERICAN Time Quality Time and Attendance Systems & Time Clocks humus wyse,waste dis humus wyse,waste disposal,Recycling Organic Waste,house hold waste,con Internet Marketing Internet Marketing CapitalOne.com CapitalOne.com online credit card application. Doce Imagem Fotografias comestíveis para decoração de bolos, tortas, bombons, ou b

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (8 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page FindInsuranceAgent Your number one place to post ads for your business & find agents Debt Consolidation Free online get out of debt and help paying bills quote Credit Bureau Report Credit bureaus and credit reports. Trw, Trans Union, Equifax Organizaton Communic Proposal Consulting and Management services Reprint Right Wealth Building wealth with reprint rights Childhood Fntasies Your shoppe for irresistible bears, hares, and collectables! The Detective Agents Suppliers of Net Detective, Genealogy Detective and Investor Detective Johnson's Insurance We are dedicated to both your commercial and personal insurance needs. Federal Attorney Federal Attorneys ready to help with all federal legal matters. Direct Mail Marketin Direct Mail Bootcamp Wholesale Shortbread Wholesale and handmade. Made fresh, shipped fresh, none better. Wholesale brass Sea Wholesale nautical brass to upscale retail nationwide. Global Income Entrepreneur's Resource Centre. Free 2-Tier affiliate programs. Free m TX Insurance Agent Texas auto, business, home, life & health & overseas medical insurance Epson Ink Cartridges Epson inkjet cartridges @ HUGE savings Real Magic New Epson Inkjet Cartridges 100% Guaranteed! Insurance Quotes Now Health Care Insurance, Term Life, Blue Cross - Blue Shield ACN Utility Unlimited Income Business Opportunity from Deregulated Utilities PNG 4.5 cent long distance services My Free Rewards Visit here to check out some great domain names for sale. eMarketInvestors eMarketInvestors has domain names and websites for sale or lease... Term Life Insurance Online term life insurance quotes. Get free quotes from top brokers! Online Bankruptcy Prepare bankruptcy documents 100% online without paper forms Perfect Imprints Adv 1000's of promotional items available for screen printing of your comp Guaranteed Credit Ca Reserve your Guaranteed Credit Card Now!! Instant Online Approval!! Ho Website Promotion Free tutorials on web marketing, promotion and search engine strategy Cheap Calling Cards We bring you the cheapest pre-paid calling cards and phone cards. car insurance uk ironsure car insurance Direct Marketing UK Direct marketing services UK direct mailing services. No obligation Non Status Mortgages Non status mortgage UK poor credit help free phone buy to let mortgage Property Finance Providing a range of innovative and competitive mortgage products Factoring Solutions specialists in arranging Factoring and Invoice Discounting facilities commercial printing commercial printing from printpricer Credit Cards Plus! Personal Credit, Business Credit, Student Credit, Credit For All! business planning business planning from everywoman share prices share prices from dlj direct web hosting uk web hosting uk from activ-e Internet Wealth Hit DEAD Center Creating Internet Wealth for Everyone Dave Nelson Enterpri Free website tuneup, free money, free business ops, free income stream Search Engine International Search Engine Optimization QuickBizLoans! Small business loans sources who lend money fast! Online Credit Cards Unsecured credit cards can be found here. Bad, poor, and no credit ok. Internet Financial Check out many online sites to obtain unsecured credit cards.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (9 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Business page 1 VMH Translation 1 hour VMH Translation - English to Russian quick MLM Monthly Resources for MLM Network Marketers Free Home Based Busi How to start a free home based business without spending a dime Spinning Wheels Repair and renovation of Spinning Wheels - UK based company. Limousin Beef Cattle Limousin beef producer, pedigree limousin cattle, British beef farmer, Cognigen Communicati Cognigen offers a free global business and ways to save you money Macaw Telecom Lowest price phone services from name brand carriers. Low Cost Long Distan Low cost long distance Cash-Paradise - Prom Get paid to surf, read and process. Tudor Chemicals Range of automotive, industrial and catering cleaning supplies www.urecure.com Oldest monitoring station for security, first computerized monitoring. Radio Features Corp Radio Features produces classical music programs for radio. APAlexander Personalberatung,Unternehmensberatung,Webdesign,Grundstücke The Local World.com Consumer complaint resolution, advocacy, law, Better Business Bureau Kayty''s Promotional Promotional Products and Advertising Specialities

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00business09.htm (10 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:50:54 AM] Computer-Internet page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Computer-Internet Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou computer &

LinksToYou Automotive Page Internet related sites. This category covers sites about computing, hardware LinksToYou Business Page & software, Internet, and similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Computer-Internet Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (1 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page Soho Software.NET Soho Software.NET provides over 250,000 software titles online. We car Chasterfind.com A free stuff, advertising, contest and long distance site; a must see! Home Cookin Easy to use cooking software for Windows. Includes an easy to use reci SoftPOWER Paid to Surf Get paid to surf the web Web site traffic Internet search engine top placement GUARANTEED! DTA Computer Systems A description of DTA's smart card software and hardware systems "Top Dog" Spot ARK COMPUTERS COMPUTER HARDWARE: Video cards, audio cards, motherboards, hard drive SpiderBait SpiderBait guaranties to improve your company ranking on search result Computers for Sale The Web Mistress Website design services SANDMAN DESIGN Web Development and Graphic Design Services. Get Paid to surf the we EXPERT COMPUTER Choose A High Performance Computer for your Home or Office from the Ex BannersXChange Free banner exchange advertising network BrowserAccelerator Surf faster, Browser accelerator, up to 20 times faster with any brows Altitude Marketing Professional search engine promotion and website marketing VB Paradise ForSites Corp. Website consulting services and laptop computer visors and cases Accord Web Tech Web Hosting on NT and Unix Platforms with 99.9% Uptime Guarantee Internet Design Web Hosting, Design, Promotion - Brisbane, Melbourne, Hobart. IT Consultant Information Technology Consultant for Web Hosting, Design, Security The Scorpions Den A Guide to Web Site Resources, Graphics, HTML Tutorials and Software Banner Design Banner Ad Creation, Graphics, 50% discounts for LinksToYou members Worm-Hole Network If you want more visitors to your web site, join Project Worm-Hole. Distinct Design Everything you need to master the internet! Visit our sites - www.bull Cyberomics Cyberomics (rhymes with economics) offers economical solutions to yo Internetop The site devoted to providing consumers with information to save and m Browser Accelerator IndoPage Free FFALP, Games, WebRings, 22,000 Hits Free, Free Money, Video, MP3 Good-Computers.com Affordable Discount Computer Parts - Custom Built PCs Web design services We offer complete web site development services at affordable prices,w VV Website Design Website design, custom graphic design, quality & affordability! Cooking Software An easy to use recipe database, grocery manager, and meal planning cal Jaylene's Designs Jaylene's Web & Graphic Designs specializes in personal, effective and Rosys Computers Computer parts, Drivers, product info, Tips, spotlights, specials and CRABILL Complete computer solutions, off the shelf systems plus custom built s TECHNOLOGIES HOTMAT FREE Get a free mouse pad with free delivery world-wide. Custom Pads. MOUSEPAD SG Laptop Sales Websites Online, Inc Spell check for Word Spell and grammar check for Word 97. Languages: German, Spanish, Frenc

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (2 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page VB Web Over 150 downloads, and 60+ Tutorials on Controls, Internet, WinSock, RedHotDomainNames Find, price and buy domain names plus website design and hosting Get Paid To Surf! Get paid to surf, read e-mail, play trivia, etc, etc. All FREE! Macinfos online Global Computing InfoTrain Promotion & Marketing Information for Your Site. Get a free email acco Jim's Linux Pages Linux enhancements and fixes, UDMA Aladdin V AGP, MS Wheel Mouse, PCI6 Akoss Imaging Picture Scanning and ebay picture hosting, boxlot picture hosting, ya Cyber Scans Domain name registration and other web site resources GraphicDesignStudio Website with 3D gallery , Modelling, animation,Grapdic design with the Webisers Flash detec Wrestling Flash web design Investigations internet busisness free Freesurfuk British Freebies! Hosting Services Cast Software Home of cool FREE pc games Hosting & Design Affordable website hosting with features you won't find on other hosti BP Information Internet Tips Domain Web Hosting Web hosting, design, promotion and domain registration services. A Hosting Services Cast Software AL Systems-FileMaker Custom FileMaker Database Development, consulting and Website Design JACKBOX JackBox WebDesign UK - Ecommerce. Corporate website consultants, desig WEBDESIGN The Gem of the Web Free downloads for webmasters and web surfers. Also, free services whi Free Links The Free For All Links Page at Sale Bazaar. Promote your site for fre Y2000 Internet & WWW Y2000 Internet & WWW Consulting Services - assisting businesses to get Eurowebs Internet Business Class Windows 2000 Based Web Site Hosting Services A 1-Stop Web Design Web site design and submissions Red Hot Memory Memory upgrades at greatly discounted prices. Web Site Designing Our Website services include speedy, reliable and affordable packages. Internet Jingles Internet jingles, web commercials and music scores for corporate and e Cheap Calling Cards ExcitedEYE ( o ) website design that POPs! web promotion that gets HITS! Submit Web DOMAINS123.COM Domain Sales,Domain Names For Sale,Web Sites For Sale,Domains For Sale QualityFreeStuff a general free stuff site offering totally free stuff and freebies onl Capitol Techworks The portal to every technology solution you'll ever need! Absolute Best Web WS Domains FREE WEB PAGE JustPages Web Site Design Tutorials and Services thecomputerplace For All Your Computer Upgrade Needs. At Low Prices!! Available Domains Quality domain names available for sale or lease

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (3 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page DISCOUNT The best in computers, software, and accessories. Deeply discounted COMPUTERS Net2Phone guessmail.com All For Free More than 3000 freebies and all free stuff Investigate Anyone Tips, tools, polls, advice, and more on do-it-yourself investigations. Cheap ATARI-PC Stuff Sale of new and used software and hardware for computers and games con The PacificRoot $5.00 Domain Registrations / Websites, Programming, & Internet Service Knoledge management knoledge management, exchange2000, windows2000, migration The World of DVD Everything you need to know about DVD + DVD Guides and software. Rippe Cyber-Seeker Submission service to over 8000 sites including over 140 search engine Shery Internet MP3 Mogul MP3 Mogul - Your One Stop for free MP3 software downloads and more! Nethear 2 4 1 Banners We give you more than any banner network on the internet! AB's WebArea AB's web site consultancy, design, creation, hosting. Release RAM AAA ECONO WEB Most Economical Web Sites w/ E-Commerce & ALL the Tools for Bus on Int SITES MarketNet Consulting Internet Marketing, Search Engine Positioning, Website Evaluations Free Site Submission Free web site submission tools. Submit to thousands of search engines Romz-Land: N64 romz N64 romz, and other roms. Get paid to surf.... Earn money to surf the web for free. Most sites pay you cash by the ho Database development Digital Products is a company, which specializes in database software KaMi's Winamp Skins Skins for Winamp. QuickPassword.com This FREE Site will Generate Random Passwords for use at Web Sites, Po FoxyWeb Web Design in France in English or French Bananasurf Affordable hosting Here you can get website hosting for an affordable rate. B2 Improve Position FREE Trial downloads, search engine information & resources BizFonts.com MICR, POSTNET, OCR and Barcode Fonts Internet Marketing Your eCommerce Shop Screensavers Screensavers and Screen Savers with Wallpaper. Domainforeveryone!!! Jim's Linux Pages Ark Computers RENT-A-PAGE Ready made web sites for rent, hosting, web site creations, internet s Web Design Australia Welcome to Paulls Internet Services Queensland Beginning Internet UnusedDomainNames FFApost LowCostHosts

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (4 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page Redlaws PC Games The widest and latest choice of PC games. Top Website Promotio The best in professional web site promotion My Site Sells BBI Web Design Web design and maintenance for personal or business needs. Muis Netwerken Online software bestellen, Extern systeembeheer op afroep. Capitol Techworks Pulsar Computers Cheap web sites Cheap web site design and hosting with unlimited bandwidth and e-comme A1 Custom Printed Mo A1 custom prints YOUR graphic on a variety of mouse pads, including CL MyLake Marketing Ser Web site design, creation, and hosting from MyLake Marketing Services BizURLs.com Prestigious & High-Profile Domain Names For Sale At BizURLs! Ezwebresources Web masters tools and marketing resources #1 Search #1 Search links to Computers,DVD,Formula 1 Motorsport Gambling Odds TheWebProspector 350MB website for $24.99. 10GB per month. Free domain registration.... LinksToYou LinksToYou Generates free Links Pointing To You Web Site. A1 Hosting Wholesale Internet presence server for advertisers & other re-sellers Starways3d we offer the BEST web design in the world!!!!!!! duWebs (Web) Things Web Info & Articles for the less reverent. Freebies. Blue Ribbon Award Beta-Q SportsTrainer Sports Training Analysis Software SoleContact SoleContact Tasmania: Internet & eCommerce Resources Free For All Links High Traffic Free For All Links - Not A Network Webscite.com Domain names PC Specialist On Site Computer Repair, Upgrade, Networking. We build custom PCs. Spy Software Background Checking Link Paradise Site with 1000 links. You can add your own URL for free! GlobalMAQUE-webhost The source for complete webhosting solutions GlobalMARQUE-webhostThe source for complete webhosting solutions Bulk Email Software The bulk email software store Pocker Reader Unoff. The Unofficial Pocket Reader Homepage: Software, documentation, answ Free Internet Access Free Internet Access - free ISPs offering free dialup and free DSL Extracash-usa Get PAID TO SURF or use your screen saver! Play real internet casino a Net2Phone Cybermed Marketing Web Site Design Internet Consulting Domains 4 U Prime Domain Names for Sale or Lease. Communications, Adult, Unusual, FREE Graphics FREE GRAPHICS for your Get Paid to Surf webpages. Come and get 'em Softech Computers As well as being a provider of computer hardware, software and on-site Private Eye Cases Privacy-enhancing and glare-reducing laptop computer visors and cases. Web Marketing Domain Registration Domain Registration Academic Software BasementNoises Free ezine with high-quality tips for Windows and MS Office Users.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (5 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page BasementNoises Free ezine with high-quality tips for Windows and MS Office Users. Fan Free Internet Mall Want to sell something online permanently, then get a FREE mall E-Commerce Services IdeasNetwork Webhost AB's Web Services FoxNet Search Engine FoxNet Search Engine reviews and rates the fastests search engines, di Web Hosting Web Hosting packages from $12.95 with free domain registration. Awesome Free Stuff Awesome collection of free offers available on the Internet Academic Software Di Academic software discount pricing from Microsoft and Corel for colleg Ads, Listings Get a Free Ad Page on the Internet for Anything that you want to sell! Cyber-Seeker Website submissions to over 140 search engines. Ads, Listings, etc. Get a free web page to list items that you would like to sell. Two Dollar Ezine Ads Wholesale Ezine Advertising for Your Product or Service - $2 Per Ad! Warp2k Net Resources Warp2k Internet Resources - The Best of the Internet! Add Reciprocal Link Add Your Reciprocal Link here with Webmasters who want to trade links. Add Your Reciprocal Reciprocal Links with Columbus-Phenix City Business Community Network. RwD Wallpapers This site contains 100% FREE pictures of hot babes and celebrities ENET-WORLD Enet-World Services provides links to suppliers of the highest quality SERVICES MCSE Online Learning MCSE MCP 65+ courses for $99.99.Less than one dollar each course. Free COMPUTERESOURCE Network and Computer Solutions serving Southern California IO-TECHNOLOGY Provider of Professional Network and PC Solutions in So. California 24/7 Monitoring Affordable 24/7 Network Monitoring from Sciodata Sciodata Corporation 24/7 Outsourced Network Management and Remote Network Monitoring A 1-Stop Web Design Web Site Design and Submissions Renée Lord Concepteur de sites Internet de la région de Montréal. free_downloads Free downloads for webmasters and web surfers! index2 Tutorials for webmasters and much more! Web Paranoia Computer Security and Internet Privacy FREE Solutions Searchengines Search with 8 different searchengines, generate meta tags and submit Software-4-Free Free and Discount Software Proofing tools. Spel Spell check for French, Spanish, German, Russian, Italian ... Proofing ElDoradoMoney How to earn money on the Internet - legally, morally and efficiently ProFunda Software Threedimensional Mac spreadsheet for handling data in layers WebWorks Tech. All of your Website, Internet, Computer and Networking needs! Binary Marketing Binary Marketing is a Canadian representative for international. Net Speed NU compression software, InSat Modem, games and internet software. Quality, Cheap PCs Mail Order suppliers of Quality PC Computer Systems FREE Would you believe that almost anything you can think of is probably av BusinessNet A search engine positioning service based in South Africa. UKWEBMALL Web Design and Marketing. Distinct Web Design Worldwide web site design, publishing, hosting and maintenance. Perl P Automated Time Clock Datamatics TC-1 System. Solutions for attendance record keeping, emplo

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (6 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page Hosting & Design Christian Web Hosting & Design ESKIMO Software ESKIMO Software distribute simple but smarter software products InfoWizards Designs InfoWizards Web site design and Flash development My Websites For Sale We sell websites that are easy to remember and priced to sell. Internet Advertising Internet Advertising, Search Engine Ranking, Affiliate Programs HTML Site Design Innovative, Interactive and Affordable Web Site Designs. Check our pri Delta-Vee Web Design bespoke web site design ,corporate image, 2D & 3D illustration domain name web host web hosting for the busy professional. Learn why our web hosting servi The Computer Geek Professional Web page design services for your business or personal ne Promoting Online Search Engine Registration and Submission - Get Top Listing Netwares Web Page Design on a Budget, serving Nova scotia. The LinkSwap Network A UK only banner exchange aimed to promote your site around the UK. W Power Submitter - Re Fully AUTOMATE submissions to over 1000 TOP Free Classifieds (includ AdondeTa Search site in Brazil Palm Free Downloads Palm Free Download Page with free games, utilities, and more software. domain name web host web hosting for the busy professional. Learn why our web hosting servi Jipco cheap domain r Jipco cheap Domain Registration, Register your domain at discount pric www.parting.nu NHL 2000, NFS 4, NFS 5 and Quake 3 add-ons and tools. Also a lot of pr Used games.cc Largest selection of used pc games on the web, over 200 search engines Web designers Classified directory of web site designers DelNetExchange.com Buy computers, new and used laptops from Toshiba, Dell,Compaq,and IBM Keyword City Your free source for keyword combinations. Tonogan.Com Classifi Classified Ads Placement - Tonogan.Com powered by AdLandPro Webmaster Central Webmaster Central offers Webmaster Resources, FFA links & freeware New Site Owners Club Marketing and advertisement for new sites 0Hosting Web Hosting and Domain Names. Cheap virtual website servers. High spe Submit Pro 3000 Websites Increase your traffic. Submit to over 3000 search engines. Custom Web Affordable web page design and friendly, expert consultation. Developwebsites A website development company developing internet strategies Extractor Pro Extractor Pro bulk email / opt-in marketing software makes it easy to Submission Wiz Pro Submission Wiz makes it easy to submit your site to 1000's of search e Desktop Server 2000 Desktop Server 2000 turns your PC into a REAL bulk email server! MULTISOFTdp.de - Die MULTISOFTdp.de - die gute Adresse für Wissen um Kommunikation (u. Soft Internet reclame Internet reclame door Professionele Web Site Promotie Impacting The Web Professional web site design, hosting, Internet service provider CMS - Neuruppin CMS - die Firma für Spieleverleih, -verkauf und Software in Neuruppin Internet Advertising Web site promotion and links exchange do make your site rank higher. WebPosition Gold AWARD-WINNING Web Site Promotion Sitescope Test Ultra Sitescope Test and other Web Tools 4site Webs Get results with this professional UK web site design company. Increas Korcanltd.com web bulundurma dizayn ve eticaret cozumleri / web hosting and design Computer Software computer components, products, and software at Frankopolis Cybernovae Free promotion tools for webmaster!

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (7 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page Tools For More Hits Link Trades, Marketing and Advertising Tools to get More Hits for YOU eVendi Canada Canada's Computer Price Comparison Website. Find the best prices on th DuMall.Com At DuMall you can send greeting cards, get a free redirector, and more Web bulundurma web bulundurma web dizayn eticaret web tasarim MicroTurk web design and web hosting services Web Design&Hosting Best prices for ecommerce solutions on the net InfoNet Yugoslavian portal site with news, links and shop. Soon on english! - RIO MP3 PLAYER Rio Mp3 Player Review, Pictures and Buying Info More Links 2 U More Links 2 U - Improve your search engine ranking Spy Online Remote PC spy software, aol spy, keystroke recorders and much more QuickPassword.com FREE Site will Generate Random Passwords for use at Web Sites, Portals Wicked Webs Creative Web Design For Your Business Accounting Software Accounting software developed in Australia to suit small business and ON-Target Review ON-Target Review- Your usability experts for today's web sites. myCustomCGI.com Ultracheap CGI solutions using Perl, PHP, and mySQL. 50,565 visits a day 50,565 HITS PER DAY TO YOUR WEBSITE FOR FREE GUARANTEED Web Hosting,Servers rdsindia.com Provides Web Hosting, Dedicated Servers, Reseller Service Traffic Generators Traffic is ogygen for all websites and some times money. Make more tra Get your FREE pager! You can get your own FREE pager with activation! BUSINESS WEB SITES! Internet business sites, e-commerce, free software & information! Email Address Lists How to succeed using Bulk Email - Tips & Lists for Sale Domain Names Your Great Names @ Our Great Prices Search Engine Rank Search Engines, ranking submissions service WebHostJunction Instant account creation! Never has it been easier to host your site! Submit Pro 3000 Register to over 3000 search engines and Link Pages. govComputers.com govComputers.com offers discount pricing for Government & Business Flying Frog Co Illustrations and Animations for all your web site needs. N64 Central The central source for Nintendo 64 cheats, hints, and reviews Ulsterpages.com Web site promotion and design. Web directory, banner exchange and FFA Get Paid to Surf Join the best paid to surf programs on the planet for free. PhoneNet Phonenet at the Barber's - Wellington's friendliest cyber cafe and you Submit 4 Less Offering low cost web site submission and promotion services. Web & Graphic Design Strategic Web and Graphic Design Specialists Website Promotion Internet advertising website promotion free search engine submission Make Net Money Shows you several ways of making money on the Internet Smrtko''s site Web design, mIRC scripting, online games, and many stuphs PowerPage Website Se Full featured website hosting and design, plus FREE websites! Excel Media Co web design hosting and promotion E marketing E marketing newsletter subscription Web site promotion Web site promotion Precios 10 Ordenadores y móviles. La mejor calidad al mejor precio. ExchangePOP3Connect Exchange POP3 Connector Gateway POPcon Downloads POP3 Mail Free Stuff Place Rates and reviews free sites in a variety of categories

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (8 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page Smart Data Systems Information Management Systems Advertise 4 you Visit here for the lowest priced website submission service around. CRM Technology Implementing crm, sfa and customer relationship management technology POPcon Download pop3 email to exchange server gateway Traffic Results Traffic Results Internet marketing PC-NETSERVICES Professional Network Services, Your PC and Network Solution. Free Stuff for every For freebies on the Web, no one does it better than our Free Stuff Cen Dawson Con. Grp. Money Producing Affiliate & Associate Partnership Programs Digital Scratchpad affordable web design/hosting services for personal & small businesses IntraMailServer Mail Server, keeps email on server, supports Outllook shared folders ronknights.com Computer Simulations, Internet Info. Love story. Have fun. Mackey Web Design Professional webdesign, Flash animation, search engine positioning Intelsoft2000.com Original Spy And Privacy Software Resource Cheap Domain Names FAST, EASY, CHEAP Domain Names - as low as $16.50/year! Fast Hosting Fast Hosting offers web hosting solutions at affordable prices, reliab CIW Study Site This site is for those studying for CIW (certified internet webmaster) dinofunk.com Nordens første og eneste søkemotor for elektronikk, søk blant anet på Track My Hours Track My Hours is a free service that lets you track your time on proj Stefa''s news Stefans homepage Computer Training On Computer Training, Distance Learning Center, Handtech.com, Hardware, Absolute Web Service Absolute Web Services your number one place for all you e-business zulos javapage java applets,sourcecode,games, free slideshow applet with source T&R Computers T&R Computer has the latest in computer, internet and webmaster ne 4 the WebMaster The Ultimate Web Masters Resource! Website Promotion Website Promotion, Marketing, Tools and Submissions jrmac Enterprises FREE software downloads,shareware,freeware,anti virus and much more. s e submission search engine submission from activ-e web design uk web design uk from crest online Punktde4you Suchmaschineneintragsservices computer games computer games from playstation europe Software Junction Guide to download FREEware. computer hardware computer hardware and software online superstore. YourTechie.net Your source for online technical support, computer systems, hardware, Web site promotion Web promotion service guarantees Top search engine placement On Time Submission Free url submission, Web Hosting, Ranking, Optimization, Meta tags, et CD duplication, soft Best quality CD duplication, software manufacturing at lowest price. InternetMarketingToo Find the internet marketing tools you'll need to succeed on line, we f PC-NETSERVICE Professional Network Services, Your PC and Network Solution. Webarea Web hosting, domain registration and consultancy. Free Internet Access Get the cheapest the internet has these services - phone calls, server The Web Mistress Web Site Design, tutoring Bula''s Homepage Homepage with info on making money while surfing the internet AbodeDomains Domain Names broker site - Offering domain names for sale and auction.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (9 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Computer-Internet page Academic Software Di Academic software student teacher discount pricing Microsoft Corel Site Webmaster Web site maintenance, updating and upgrading exclusively. AKfamily Get paid, make money, earn cash, search engine, a guide to internet Word 2000 spell chec Spell check for Word 2000. Spanish, French, German, Russian, Italian, Mousepadvertising Custom mouse pads keep your advertising message at their fingertips. Eclipse Web Design Affordable Website Design starting at $75.00. Let me be your designer E-Commerce Builder E-Commerce Website Builder, Design, Web Site Host, Hosting RvrWinds Web Design We pride ourselves in developing your website the way YOU want it. FireWire Products FireWire cards, drives, cables and more. Everything for IEEE-1394! PageDziner Hand-crafted web pages. Stunning graphics and reasonable cost. Commercial Domains site related to industrial and commercial domains names,buy and sell,

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00computerinternet09.htm (10 of 10) [10/27/2000 9:51:10 AM] Education page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Education Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou education related

LinksToYou Automotive Page sites. This category covers sites about financial aid, schools, teaching, LinksToYou Business Page universities and similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Education Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00education09.htm (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:51:14 AM] Education page HighNoon Toastmaster Provides a safe and fun environment to practice communication skills SpanishSchool TEFL/TESL Index Index of useful websites for learners and teachers of English Eliana's - homework "Educational reference site for the family, with interactive grammar q Learning disability Find information about learning disabilities and learning disaorders. Pannonhalma 1989 Social life of formal classmates graduated in Pannonhalma, Hungary. school fundraising school fundraising Al's Higher Educatio The site provides numerous free distance learning, traditional and non LMC STUDENT School rules, chemistry teaching, photos of school life and places.... DISCIPLI Micronet Education MicroNet Technical and Educational Services serving clients in the Gre Learn Spanish Langua Learn Spanish language, get help, translators, dictionaries, lessons Cheap Textbooks Cheap textbooks online. Save buy buying new and used discount textboo Web Based Training Tutor4Computer offers web-based (online learning)computor training A Research Guide Virtual Library of Useful URLs. Document sources using MLA style. Child Daycare Center Detour 2 Discovery is a full-time Day School located in Chicago, IL MCSE Online Training Holocaust Project Holocaust/Genocide Project (Grades 7-12) Study Abroad All types of courses for international students in USA, UK, Canada... FreeBooknotes.com Get free cliff notes and book summaries for over 200 books. VS im Lichtental Informationen über die 'Volksschule im Lichtental - Marktgasse': Leh Rotary Odyssey 2001 A Rotary conference in D9980 of Rotarians in May 2001. research papers FREE Publish and download research papers FREE Study Spanish Abroad The best courses in Mexico, Spain, Costa Rica, Chile, Ecuador, etc. Mr. Essay Free essays, custom made essays over novels, short stories, etc. Stichting IJVO IJVO, de leukste kindervakantieweek van ijsselstein en omstreken Degree.com Degree.com, home of The Monterrey Institute for Graduate Studies Discovery Ed. Soft. CD-Roms for learners of English as a foreign or second language Family Interplay Resouces for parents and classroom teachers; educational videos, socia ManualShop Manuales en formato electrónico para institutos y usuarios finales MCSE Training Online Online interactive MCSE training in USA School Supplies in a We sell school supply packages. Learn Something New ylsned.com - You Learn Something New Every Day. Fact, quote of the day Water Testing Center Drinking water testing kits, free info on water contamination Barker Butts to reunite those who attended Barkers Butts Secondary School, Coventry Dream Learn to improve your psi power - Free psychic test

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00education09.htm (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:51:14 AM] Education page LinksToYou GUARANTEE If your web site has been on the list 30 days and LinksToYou has not added at least 500 links pointing to your web site from other websites (The LinksToYou Counter may take much longer since search engines must index the links), we will give you 500 free exposures of a banner, courtesy of BannersXChange.

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00education09.htm (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:51:14 AM] Entertainment page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Entertainment Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou entertainment

LinksToYou Automotive Page related sites. This category covers sites about food, games, jokes, music and LinksToYou Business Page other similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Entertainment Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00entertainment09.htm (1 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:22 AM] Entertainment page Crossroads Blues agency specialized on producing european tours for American blue Beautiful Music Hear 6 Albums of Music to Soothe Your Soul on the web, or get CD's notboring.com Magician Alan Watson - professional magician - New Zealand PsychicEncounters psychics astrology mediumship and Spiritualism #1Joke AJokeADay.com #1Joke a joke a Day, full time professionally maintained, humor site, Emazdad the magician The best for Magic Shows, Games, Balloon Modelling, Close-up Magic The Best Movies The best movies now playing, top films rated by your peers, the people The Prisoner Music, artwork and an episode guide relating to The Prisoner TV series ITS ALL HERE HEY YOU, COME HERE, FUN , GAMES , JOKES AND MORE Age of Ruin Age of Ruin Mike's Guitar Site Picadillo! The web's largest Latin Music site AUSTRALIA LIVE Live web cams in Australia..From surf cams to personal cams to traffic CAMS Danman's Music Gameview Australian Directory A directory of live streaming web cams & online radio in Australia POKER Products The largest online source for Poker Tables, Poker Chips, Playing Cards PETITE Magazine The only fashion and glamour magazine that features petite models, h drive magazine magazine on line about rock culture, movies, comics and fiction. It fe JasonQG's Homepage Nelson Dump GamblerParadise.com The Net's BEST Online Casino and Gambling Sites. Slots, Poker, Blackja Voltron's Tales Intriguing stories and information about Voltron. Dinos Home-Page Welcome to Dinos Home-Page fun for the entire family,bands,rottweilers Appie's Chess Page Chess related information and products. DVD Malaysia Your guide to Region 1 & 3 DVD reviews in Malaysia Best Gambling System CASINOS NEBULA Olley's Place Over 350mb of funny pictures, jokes, movies, funny sounds, flash and s Vegas Sports Free Sports picks, handicapping service, betting odds, NFL, NBA, MLB pickandsend.com Golf Orient,Thailand Golf tours in Thailand. Golf Orient. Thailand golf vacations and tours Andy's Fun Stuff-gam Internet For Kids! Games,activities, puzzles, magic,holiday crafts for Mr. G's Coasters!! Rollercoaster site w/ links, pictures, reviews, coaster physics, etc. Bernie''s Portal Mixture of Fun and Useful Stuff. Meet Alce's! Enjoy the Sun Eclipse! -=INETLOTTO=- Welcome to INETLOTTO, site where you can win $100 with just one click! Djembe drumming Online hand drumming tutorial, drumming CDs, tuning a djembe, reskinni X Files Office Site for all X Philes with pics, sounds, polls, fanfic, fun stuff, cha Phantasm This is the website of Phantasm the heavy rockers from Stratford. Come Boy Bands Suck.com The place to go if you hate boy bands! Mewfour's Pokemon HQ Home of the original Mewfour! Pokemon episode guide, game boy guide,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00entertainment09.htm (2 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:22 AM] Entertainment page Opslagstavle.dk Gratis opslag med dansk humor, vittigheder og andre morsomme kommenta Ballistic Drumming Learn to play your feet EXACTLY like your hands! free sound clips MP3 Mogul MP3 Mogul - Your One Stop source for free MP3 software downloads! Pyramid Sportsbook Online casino & sportsbook Wines of New Zealand Information & links to New Zealands best wines Mp3 - Free mp3 songs Get free mp3 songs; mp3 player reviews; original mp3 search 3D Glasses Direct Manufacturer of 3D Glasses, Fireworks Glasses and Solar Eclipse Viewer CRYSTAL LIGHTING LIGHTING HIRE FOR THE ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY passion music music site dislaying the best in dance music Alta and Cherie''s Free Music,Midis,Waves,Mp3s, Corner Store,Cool Hats,Yummy Goodies Abiza Casino Online casino games to play, bet and win real money. shop latest game Aspenvalley Film A production guide for the Aspen Colorado area featuring award winning FunnyEmailCards Dance pages & Holiday cards; with Smiles of Love you can send Friends! Free Lotto Game Win up to $2000 every week MIDI Web Music Pro Soul Music progressive music for the masses-radio, MP3, games, downloads & more Sound Strokes Studio JingleRadio Freebie Paradise A collection of free offers, services, games, and pay to surf programs Web Freebies Online Freebies and Website Resources. Dan Zen Dan Zen - mad inventor meets Internet finds peace. Zany original Web Free Food and Fun win at lotto SMITHS Emazdad the magician The best for Magic Shows, Games, Balloon Modelling, Close-up Magic, Roach Piano Services Entertainment Center Afgen.com Entertainment offers CD's and electronic equipment. mfiles music files Free music files to play and download, MIDI, MP3, sheet music, scorch. AnimeSpider.com The comprehensive anime directory and search engine resources, includi Puget Sound Sports L Puget Sound Sports League (PSSL) fantasy baseball. Here you can find f AutoInteractive Pubblica on-line le recensioni delle tue opere preferite e vinci uno s TUGAP-Phonics Game Fusion Entertainment Sheree''s FunPage! Free fun games, pictures, exe files, programs, & useful links Earth Astrology Skyburst Fireworks Displays,Sales,Organiser’s Guide. Bristol International Balloon Fiesta The Worm-Hole The RockSite the home of rock and roll music - with pictures, sounds and links Doom Wad Station Tudela La web mas cachonda de Tudela. Phonics Game TUGAP Cwols' Joke Ezine Subscribe to our Weekly Joke Mailing List to receive free jokes!!

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00entertainment09.htm (3 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:22 AM] Entertainment page Allnoise Promotes unsigned UK bands and musicians. Presses CDs, produces T-shir 1-On-1 Free Basketba Take on the World with this Unique, Free Online Game! 10,000+ players PETITE Magazine The only fashion and glamour magazine featuring petite women. JasonQG's Homepage My site covers colorful evil, Nowhere Man, cupcakes, short stories, an Cartoon Astrology Down To Earth Astrology with photos and caricatures Tarot by Valorie FREE Tarot readings, weekly drawings, giveaways and more! Unique Amusements We sell all of the Plush Looney Tunes Cartoon Characters Cash Dash Lotto The Internets FASTEST Free Online Lottery Gospel Crib Gospel and Christian Music source. Contains RealAudio and MP3 links, G Aussies in Canada Aussie/Canadian stuff.Croc Dundee,F1 racing,Aussie rules footy +more. Aces & 8's Casino Online casino with blackjack, slots, video poker and sportsbook. Yu Target Prvi domaci sajt posvecen nagradjivanju svojih posetilaca. Erin's Page The semi-interactive promotional page of model/actress/singer Erin H. Free Games Online Links to thousands of play-for-fun free games online. Entertainment Anything you can imagine we have, Videos, Music, Games, even FREE down The BarStool Online The BarStool is DC's largest monthly entertainment guide. Hockeyheaven Hockeyheaven brings you hockey lifestyle and etailing Gem Casino and Sport Gem Casino and Sportsbook the greatest casino and sports wagering Yee Fun's Crappage My personal webpage that is full of crap. Manns Music Online Music Shop - Stocks everything from Guitars to Pianos Games ''n'' Stuff Fun free site with addictive games, great stories/poems and much more. WWW.Gilgamesh.Co.UKThe only source for free games, applications and mp3's. The Lotto Player's B Your #1 source for lottery software and information. AAHoroscopes Free horoscopes by email, plus detailed astrology reports to buy. Sounds And Pressure Established Record & CD Music Collectors Mail Order Company - All type Nick''s NTN Trivia The source for NTN Trivia Info -- Game Info, Tips, Links, Players Plus LotsaLaffs Fresh jokes and cartoons DAILY! Joke of the Day; Gibbleguts, Curtoon, Karaoke Unlimited karaoke mp3 music, thousands of titles, karaoke players, karaoke mics Cryptic Undertaker A More Undertaker pictures, videos, sounds and exclusives; faster loadin Free Greeting Cards Send Free Greeting Cards .Select from over 20 languages ! U2 * World World news, pictures, lyrics, fan-clubs, mail, newsgroup.... Abiza Casino Online casino games to play, bet and win real money. Digitraker used game Find used pc games with the "digitraker",also download mp3's and movie Click2amuse.com Teen fun site with games, jokes, love, tests, horoscopes and lots more ABMovies VHS to web - your home movies on the internet. ALL BOOKS MUSIC All Books-Music-Games is a one-stop source for games, music ,and books GAME Free Stuff Directory All the latest free stuff and cool links from around the net. ToimToim.com.br Portal de Entretenimento Toim Toim,com músicas, prêmios, humor, etc. Las Vegas Online Cas nternet casino games playable online for free or real money. $$ gift ! League Maker 2000 League & Tournament software for sports Japanese celebrities we offer many japanese sweet,young,sexy celebrities images free(but no Japan images japanese girls images, freebies,sweeps,games,casino

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00entertainment09.htm (4 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:22 AM] Entertainment page Webspace Gamein Download new mp3 and check out cheats and trainers for gamez Timba.com Timba, salsa cubana A TODOHUMOR Pagina de humor con muchos chistes graficos,de texto,bromas y mas LottoLaunch.com Will Generate Random Lotto Numbers "FREE" for people who play State Lo Gambling Online! Gambling Online! Sports Wagering! Casino Games! Play for fun or Real! Brad Reddekopp Band Original independent blues-rock band - The Brad Reddekopp Band. Downlo Banned Systems The best lottery, football and racing systems. All make a big profit RELIEF is here RELIEF is here - Download Free MP3's, Pictures, Information, Games... Casinohills Gambling Casino and Sportsbook at Casino Hills Welcomes You! Emuholic.com Updated hourly with the latest emulation news and releases! drive magazine magazine on line about rock culture, movies, comics and fiction Ladies Love Everything you ever wanted to know about LL Cool J can be found here. trevorflack''shomepa local hebburn youth football photographs and games EmPeaFreeze 1900+ CD tracks in MP3 format Karamba Experience Karamba Experience - Specialist tour operator. World music and dance c Thoroes Casino Site Get Links,Tips and tricks to 3 top-rated online casinos ! Lusthuset Massor av kontaktannonser Best Casinos Online Best Casinos Online- Quality casinos for internet gambling. ZapTheMonkey.com ZapTheMonkey.com Casino Gambler Netwo Casino and gambling search engine and portal. Ultimate Teen Site Teen Site BETTING ONLINE BETTING ONLINE AND GAMBLING ONLINE Ace in the Hole Over 20 cutting edge casino games. Sports Book, Lottery, Bingo, More playstation2 Sony Playstation2 - cheats, win a playstation2, where to buy and more All About Scorpio 40 Articles 179 pages on Scorpio - 3 Free Astrology profiles - 3 Daily Betcrawler Casino Betcrawler Online Casino and Gambling Guide Rowdy Roadie The New Generation Of Rock, Download Music & Buy Merchandise. Alice In Wonderland Music, graphics, film reviews of Lewis Carroll's Alice In Wonderland iRIDDLER.com Riddles, puzzles, brain teasers, logic games, illusions and more!!! The Soda Shop The Soda Shop has over a dozen java arcade games online and ways to ma FreeBees ! Hand-picked free stuff links, contests, sweeps, software, games, more! BandShack.com Directories of New England bands and musicians with music resources MP3 CDs Classic Rock, Country and Blues MP3 CDs $12.50 each. sydney 2000 olympics sydney 2000 olympic games - events, news, results, cheats, downloads CasinoGamblinCentral Directory of Internet Casinos, Sportsbooks, Lottery Sites, etc. NetMonster Home Help the NMRC defend the Internet! Tarot High Priestess tarot card readings at reasonable rates all credit cards accepted Flowers Restaurant Restaurant at Argeles sur Mer France ONELOVESTUFF Find links to free online sweepstakes, contests, and games including f Sweeps High Desert Casino Online casino wagering at it's best. Over twenty games, and sportsbook Tots to Teens Expo Baby Aaron Productions' Tots to Teens Expo - The Complete Family Show The Entrance Cinema central coast cinema providing current movies weekly,

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00entertainment09.htm (5 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:22 AM] Entertainment page field hockey field hockey from hockeyheaven JKB Come on in... Check out the latest Fun + Games + Gizmos + Sweepstakes DJ Town FREE classifieds for DJ equipment. Bridal registry and DJ directory dvd players playstations dvd player sports bar le bouchon's sports bar Classic Video Games Buy, sell, trade, and view pictures of classic video games. Daddy''s Page The funniest download games and videos on the internet are right here Teen Chat Rooms A free teen chat site with easy to use flirt chat rooms for teens! Free Casinos NO Dpst Free Casinos, FREE CHIPS to gamble with no deposit! no strings WIN!!!! Vegas Royale Casino Your internet gambling destination of choice. Play for free or real! Gamers Homepage Complete gaming site for gamers. Hints, reviews, downloads, chat, foru Speedway Grand Prix Speedway Grand Prix European Style Mark's Pages This site shows all of the weird websites I have made. I have sites ab Internet Casino Club Offers multiplayer internet casino gambling games. The Ticket Company We buy and sell tickets to popular events worldwide. I WiLL 4 U 637 Kyoko Fukada - Pictures, Multimedia, Links, Etc. emedia Emedia.Webprovider.com- great deals, books, music, CDs, DVDs, software Free mp3s Free Music, mp3s.

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00entertainment09.htm (7 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:22 AM] Health page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Health Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou health related

LinksToYou Automotive Page sites. This category covers sites about diet, fitness, healthcare, medical LinksToYou Business Page conditions, medicine and similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Health Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (1 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Health page IBDUK Information on Crohns and Colitis Increase Breast Size Definition® firms, enlarges, and uplifts the bust safely & naturally. Acne and Roaccutane Victims of Violent C DOVE, a violent crime victim support network is dedicated to serve vic Nutritionist Home of Iris Studies ophthalmologic physiology to iridologic bridge, complete and unique TEPES Mdsem Designed for health professionals - Medical Searches, Evaluations, and Essential Organics Quality herbal extracts and tinctures. Over 100 different herbs. herbalife diets Tons of information on herbalife diets- secure online ordering Psychodrama The most powerful method for thgerapy and individual, relationship, gr Dental Implants NYC Dental implants can replace lost teeth and give you back your smile Bornfeld Dental Bowen Research Stress reduction pain reducation Lyme Research Bowen Certification USA Metabolife 356 Low prices and fast shipping on Metabolife 356, America's #1 weight lo Healthylives Healthylives - Good Nutrition, health and wealth without winning the l BodyFix Health The secret to getting rid of acne, pimples and zits forever. hadassah main Hadassah medical organization is the renown leader of the Israeli medi HMS90 Whey Protein HMS90: clinically proven to improve immune function safely & naturally Women''s Health Amer Women's Health America serves the unique health needs of women. Agepage Agepage.com Metabolife Products What Is Viagra? Site provides Viagra, erectile dysfunction (impotence) remedy. Chiropractic Wellnes Chiropractor practicing in Arlington, Virginia #1 Diet Shop low cost source for metabolife diet supplement products. natural woman ltd health,natural products,alternative health products,menopause,menopaus Your Health 2000 one of the Largest conglomerations of health-related Links on the web 1click-viagra NaturalyPure FastFoodDiet low carbo diet essentials online - free sample intro of e-book SLRG Küsnacht Homepage der Schweizerischen Lebensrettungs-Gesellschaft Kuesnacht (SL Pathweaver & Company We are dedicated to holistic health - health of body, mind & spirit child care child care from everywoman Silver Cross Sourcing New and Used mobility equipement across North America 1-800-therapist.com The 1-800-THERAPIST NETWORK is a unique referral organization which ha Nu-Vit Health Foods Health Foods, Organic Foods from Nu-Vit an Australian Wholesaler Metabolife 356 LightLinks Healthy resources and inspirational guidance from the islands of aloha Alternative Medicine Board Certified Physician discusses herbs and other treatments. Eating Disorders ePrescribe Pharmacy ePrescribe pharmacy offers online prescriptions for diet pills. Hair Fantastique Get your hair back, go see results. Perpetua Herbals - N Neem Healthcare products Eternal HGH All natural HGH - Anti-aging human growth hormone supplement

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (2 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Health page E'OLA Products E'OLA products for weight loss, natural hormone creams for women. Nut HGH National Kidney Foun Non-profit charity, provide education and assistance concerning kidney Pure,swiss skin care All natural,herbal and botanical skincare,healthcare, cosmetics and vi metabolife 356 diet metabolife 356 dietary supplement for weight loss and energy Viagra Drug Side Eff Site provides viagra prescription drug information, online doctor pres Body Type Analysis Learn about yourself with this on-line analysis. New insight for you. Natural Viagra-like Natural Viagra-like pill to increase sexual energy for men and women! Diet pills Green Tea The SpineTimes The Web's resources for information about Back Pain and Neck Pain Citronella Insect Re Singapore Citronella Non toxic wrist bands & stick-on strips. Sexy uni Best Acne Treatment Acne treatment that works, natural skin care solutions, advice & info Reduce Spider Veins! Herbal remedy to reduce unsightly spider veins! Weight loss PNT200 A natural alternative to stress and insomnia prescription medications Smiths Swimming Squa A swimming club for all ages and abilities in Eastbourne East Sussex Arthritis, Natural H Weight Loss, Self Improvement, Arthritis, Self Improvement and Natural VIAGRA CHEAP BUY VIAGRA ONLINE FAST!!! ONLINE HGH,NONIJuice,Omega3HGH, Noni Juice, Omega3, Healthy Heart, E-Lite and many more!!! VIAGRA ONLINE VIAGRA ONLINE AT THE CHEAPEST PRICES!!!!!! metabolife Chronic Fatigue Suff Chronic fatigue syndrome resources, advice, support for sufferer and c Drugs-Central Viagra mind body spirit livebetter Anabolic Steroids London Hypnotherapy Boost confidence, stop smoking, fears, anxiety, phobias and relax Missing Children Help to find Missing & Exploited Children Viagra Frequently As What is Viagra and how it works? Viagra prescription drug information, FAST FOOD DIET.com Beverly Sassoon & Co The thrust of the company comes from a product line scented with the p Internet Pharmacy Fountain of Youth Order Viagra UK Afford. Supplements offers bodybuilding supplements from EAS, Cytodyne, Muscletech. Online Dietitian Online access to the services offered by a registered dietitian. SMT Natual Health Natural Health and home business solutions. Nutraceuticals, alternativ Optimal health Mannatech's optimal health products with Ambrotose,secure ordering Sam's General Store Discount Prices on Innovative Family Nutrition. Scar Remover by Phyt Remove scars, wrinkles with my amazing product. I am even giving out Health 4 Us Guaranteed Nutrition,Weight Loss,Skin Care,Cosmetics,Hair Care etc

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (3 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Health page HGH,NONIJuice,Omega3HGH, Noni Juice, Omega3, Healthy Heart, E-Lite and many more!!! Acupuncture.cc Free Online Consultation, Acupuncture.cc offers an online Herb Store Growth Hormone we market growth hormone SGM Enterprises Health & Nutrition products - Nutrition for Life. Support4Hope Support4Hope: Depression and Bipolar Chat and Support Order VIAGRA Online Order VIAGRA Online ! Make money selling VIAGRA ! Order CELEBREX ! Celebrex is used to treat osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis. NEW Order PROPECIA ! Get PROPECIA, the world's leading hair loss drug ! Order XENICAL ! NEW wonder slimming-drug - XENICAL - It has taken Europe by storm ! Bontril Bontril, a weight loss medication can be ordered online. weight loss Metabolife 356 weight loss diet Buy Viagra Buy Viagra doses for $4.50 no prescriptions. Doctors Link The Leading Online Index for New and Recommended Perscription Drugs !!!BUY VIAGRA !!!BUY VIAGRA CHEAP!!! ONLINE ONLINEPILLS.COM VIAGRA,PROPECIA,XENICAL,CLARITIN,CELEBREX Health You and your families health! PROPECIA PROPECIA ONLINE AT CHEAPEST PRICES XENICAL CHEAP XENICAL NEW FATBLOCKER CHEAP UKWEBMALL Healthylives with nutrition for life - health, wealth, lifestyle. halls.md Body Surface Area, Body Mass Index and Breast Cancer Risk Calculators HerbalSensations Herbal sensations - Virility & lifestyle products, etc. KwikMed-Viagra Propecia, Xenical, Viagra, Celebrex for Arthritis, etc. Metabolife SAM Natl. Metabolife 356 Discount Distributor SAM National sport nutrition sport nutrition from hockeyheaven Sports Supplements A comprehensive directory of UK based Sports Supplement Companies. Weight Loss - 1st Ch 1st Choice Weight Loss - Fast, Easy, Safe, Natural Weight Loss Product Arthritis Sufferers Site provides the new FDA-approved wonder drug which is used to treat 1st Cosmetic Surgery Cosmetic Surgery discounts available to the public. Hypnosis training Hypnosis training, self-hypnosis programs, online hypnotherapy Hospital General de Nos dedicamos al cuidado integral de su salud y la de su familia Holistic Health Site devoted to the concept of Holistic Health and healing. Aloe Vera Healing Aloe Vera natural health and healing Nutrition Advisor Immunocal®, Calorad® and Definition® at wholesale prices buy viagra online Order Viagra, Xenical, Propecia, Celebrex, Claritin online pharmacy. Colon care Online Alternative health care and colon care online. The Ultimate Resource. Elicina Natural Skin Skin care natural cream repairs & heals dry, aged, hyperpigmented, sca VIAGRA - PROPECIA VIAGRA - PROPECIA PHARMACY LOW PRICES!!! Julie Fitness Corner Personal fitness information, and links to other fitness sites. Dr Link Xenical, Celebrex, Propecia, Viagra online info metabolife Metabolife products at discounted prices - including Metabolife 356 Bio T 350 Bio-T 350, the most effective weight loss product on the market! Andes Healthy Rose anti wrinkle anti aging rose hip oil and cream - source of natural re

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (4 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Health page Abate Acne & Scars acne & scars can be abated with naturally occurring protein cream Breast Enlargement Enlarging your breasts with surgery or alternatives. Adipex Weight Loss The diet pill of your choice--Adipex Home of NPCWheeler Links to wheelchair and bodybuilding sites. VIAGRA-IMPOTENCE VIAGRA - IMPOTENCE MESSAGE BOARD 1getfit.com UK & European site for aromatherapy, slimming & fitness products. A New Age of Health Free! Genetic Profile Nutrition survey with proper foods selection gui Weight Loss Program Kyto-Trim 2000 is an all natural herbal weight loss program Phentermine-Pharmacy Your Online Source to Losing Weight with Phentermine. Diet Pills Online DietPill.Org is your diet pill informational site. Beaches Healthcare Beaches Healthcare, Terry Brant, Board Certified Acupuncture Physician #1-AAA-metabolife Metabolife 356 at low prices VitaminCart Pro-hGH Symbiotropin and weight loss. Dental Phobia Gentle care for dental phobics other apprehensive dental patients. Quit Smoking Program Quit smoking in only 7 days with all natural herbal Smoke-Away Michigan Health Ins. Best health insurance at the lowest possible prices Metaboloss Metaboloss Gold helps burns fat, Metaboloss Gold increases energy. Dragonslayer Herbal How I came free from the Dragon -- Hep C! Free Download. Shake Away Pounds Stop the yo-yo dieting , Turn your body into a fat fighting machine Shake Away Pounds Stop the yo-yo dieting, turn your body into a fat fighting maching Egan Enterprise Reliv Business Opportunity - Make Lots of CASH XenicalNet XenicalNet offers Xenical trial packs and budget packs, consultation a Dietmasters Helping you Master your Diet and Health. Fitness, exercise, diet, wei discount weight loss comprehensive herbalife weight loss site with discounts, product info Aloe Vera Forever Living Aloe Vera Diet With Meridia The diet pill, Meridia, is available online now. Brenda''s Beauty Beautiful complexions, vital eyes, radiance, Retin-A, Renova, Valtrex Immunocal Physicians Information on Immune enhancement using IMMUNOCAL® for Physicians only Worship Song Worship Song Health Products...available at wholesale prices! Zyban for Smokers The smoking cessation medication, Zyban, is available online. Ginkgo Biloba Ginkgo Biloba increases brain function and enhances the memory. BugMastersEnterprise Non-toxic Citronella Insect Repelling Wrist Bands & Stick-on Strips. CLARITIN CHEAP CLARITIN ONLINE FAST AND CONVENIENT!!! **NATURAL SupraLife mineral toddy natural organic major and trace minerals, Anti COLLOIDAL Weight loss Finally a book on weight loss and nutrition that makes sense! Arbonne Skin Care Pure, Swiss Skin by Arbonne Aromatherapy Ezine Essential oils are many times more powerful than dried herbs. Scar Treatment Rose Scar tissue treatment with natural trans retinoic acid to speed new ce Nature's RX Index Nature's RX The Lowest Price for Sam-e Chitosan Collagen Glucosamine US Viagra Sales Offering refills, online order status, discount prices. Quoterunner Fastest Online Life Insurance Quotes! Give us a try! Heroes M&F Heroes Muscle & Fitness - Maximuscle, Reflex Nutrition and Nutrisport.

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (5 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Health page A1A Market Place Bio-T 350 for Fast Weight Loss metabolife Low cost discount source of Metabolife products-Great Service! Laparoscopia Avanzad Solucion de padecimientos a traves de Cirugia Laparoscópica Fitness nutrition fitness nutrition and weight loss products Viagra Order Order Viagra, Celebrex, Xenical or Propecia at Kwikmed ! Pharmacy Prices Find the lowest prices on pharmacy in the Internet Viagra Prescription Prescription Drugs! Viagra, Xenical, Propecia Online Orders HerbalV viagra HerbalV all natural viagra alternative for men Anabolic Steroids Anabolic Steroid suppliers and parmaceutical resources DietBreakThru.Com Diet Supplements and Weight Loss products at Discount Prices! PNT-200 PNT-200 is a safe, natural alternative to Valium for stress & Insomnia Reflexology Reflexology charts videos and seminars Medical supplies Medical supplies, catheters, wheelchairs, and more Dermawand Skin Care Tool for Acne, blemishes, Fine Lines and Wrinkles Nutrition For Health Site dedicated to enhancing health through proper nutrition. Retinitis Pigmentosi Resources and links concerned with retinitis pigmentosis AKA night bli Herbal Viagra Xtreme Order X-treme-V ( herbal viagra ) online ! Order Viagra Order Viagra -2 u.com Order Viagra Nature''s Wisdom Wide selection of vitamins, herbs, info and more. Collectibles too! viagra online viagra online, propecia xenical and celebrex - kwikmed Formula One Diet SAM Original Formula One Diet Supplement SAM National Distributor Metabolife SAM Ntl-2 Metabolife 356 Discount Distributor SAM National of Texas TeePee Healthcare TeePee Healthcare, Assurance of a healthy, wealthy & wise lifestyle Arne Herbs 742 varieties of herbs, wild flowers and rare plants. Search database Gym RatZ (Internatio Sports Supplements and Nutrition from the UK's top producers and most BUY VIAGRA ONLINE VIAGRA, XENICAL, PROPECIA, CELEBREX AT DISCOUNT ONLINE ORDERING Excelsior Eldercare Excelsior Care Centers -Assisted living care & eldercare rest, nursing Look Younger Anti-aging, Turn Back the Clock 20 Years With Reliv ReversAge. Transfer Factor Weig Transfer Factor weight loss nutrition, the most advanced site of immun Buy Viagra Buy Viagra Find more about Buy Viagra.And Physician discusses Viagra ! skin care skin care from ready2 Alternative Medicine Alternative Medicine - European Laser Hair Diagnostics-Enhance Health Xenical Plan weight management guide for xenical users Pharmacy Guide Find best prices to buy prescriptions,herbal remedies and vitamins IMGs and Residency Info for Foreign Medical Graduates alcoholics anonymous alcoholics anonymous speaker tapes Pharmacy Information Legally get your your medications online without a prescription SAVE Walk Right Orthotics Purhase arch supports, orthotics, silicone orthosis, corn protectors. Stimulife 750 The Next Generation EPHEDRINE FREE weight loss supplement Immunocal OnLine Innovative Health Technology - Your Source for Immunocal Online QikHealth Simpler Health Searches - Collected Health Search Engines Immunocal ONLINE!! Information on Immune / GSH enhancement using IMMUNOCAL®, Order Online

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (6 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Health page VIAGRA PHARMACY- BUY VIAGRA from OUR USA licensed PHARMACY !!! USA First-Alert Medical ID Cards

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00health09.htm (7 of 7) [10/27/2000 9:51:28 AM] Job-Career page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Job-Career Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou job & career

LinksToYou Automotive Page related sites. This category covers sites about careers, jobs, working and similar LinksToYou Business Page topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Job-Career Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00jobcareer09.htm (1 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:51:31 AM] Job-Career page Piney Mountain Press A center for Assessment, Career Planning and Applied Resources. For 20 Hi Tech Jobs For You Find Your NEXT Hi-Tech Position (mid to upper level) through us. NECA association of workforce development professionals 1st Treasures Everything you need to find a home based job or run your home business Jobs career Resumes Employment911.com Search 3 Million+ jobs on 150+ sites in one click!!! Job Listings for Can Canadian Job Postings and Listings from Employer's own Websites: Alber Land That Job! We offer MS Word cover letter and resume templates for job seekers Professional CVs CV's written to win you the job you want fast. FREE Guide Pacific Employment Job - Australia,NewZealand,Fiji Islands,Cook Islands,Samoa,Vanuatu Ads 2000 Web space for Entrepreneurs, free auction, free e-cards, home pages, g Bharatcareers provides database of Jobs and Resumes for jobs seekers, employers Proactive Job Search Proactive jobsearch is a winning strategy - FREE Guide College Recruiting College recruiting services, outsourced for employers by On-Campus.com Actuary Jobs Actuary employment for actuaries, like actuarial consulting insurance Resume to Referral Affordable resume services and directory The New Feng Shui Use this site to improve your employment picture, relationship & more Land That Job! We offer MS Word cover letter and resume templates for job seekers Lands Of Money Make FREE EASY MONEY Ju$t by $urfing, Emailing, PLAYING and more! $$$$ Action Firefighters Truck Co. #54 Firefighting site.Fires,fire-fighting photos,t-shirts,gi Work At Home Jobs Read this free report to find the work at home job of your dreams Career Directory Post or view jobs and resumes

What we do not GUARANTEE When and if search engines will index your website address for each site on the list

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00jobcareer09.htm (2 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:51:31 AM] Job-Career page

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00jobcareer09.htm (3 of 3) [10/27/2000 9:51:31 AM] Lifestyle-Recreation page

Home Register Help Update Counter

OCTOBER 00 LinksToYou.com

LinksToYou Español Pages on Your Site Lifestyle-Recreation Page

LinksToYou Arts Page These are LinksToYou lifestyle &

LinksToYou Automotive Page recreation related sites. This category covers sites about home repair, hobbies, LinksToYou Business Page relationships, sports & similar topics. LinksToYou Computer-Internet Page LinksToYou Education Page LinksToYou Entertainment LinksToYou Generates Links Pointing Page To Your Web Site! LinksToYou Health Page Join LinksToYou To Improve Your Web LinksToYou Job-Career Page Sites: Traffic, Link Popularity and LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Page Search Engine Rankings! LinksToYou Money Page Any Web Site Can Join! LinksToYou News & Media Page Visit our Instructions page to view the LinksToYou Politics-Govt Page three easy steps on how to join the LinksToYou Real Estate Page LinksToYou Program. LinksToYou Reference Page

LinksToYou Shopping Page

LinksToYou Science-Tech Page

LinksToYou Travel Page

LinksToYou Other Page

OCTOBER LinksToYou Lifestyle-Recreation Sites

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00liferec09.htm (1 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:52:10 AM] Lifestyle-Recreation page Denlore Morgans A Morgan Horse breeding and showing facility. Gaia''s Love & Chat Love & chat connections from around the world - chatrooms galore! Central Coast Sports Central Coast Sports,results,information,photos,news,profiles on the C ProWeddingPhotos.com Takis-on-Line Up-to-date results and tables for several European soccer leagues I Love You Lord Christian Web Site Borduren van Honden Borduur pakketten van Honden, Katten en andere dieren. teddy bears CreativeSpirit Intuition Classes and tapes, spiritual readings and more! Welcome.... Mencik's Sportscards Search online database to find your favorite player cards Accents In Pine Free woodcraft patterns, woodworking and water garden tips, techniques Personal-Ads-Network A guide that features only the best personal-classified ads websites. Grilla's Romance Coca Cola Coke Colle CocaCola Coca Cola Coke collecting The Tae Kwon Do Net Tae Kwon Do information, equipment and supplies Dating Now International dating, matchmaking & Penpal personal ads Pacesetter Personals romantic personal dating & marriage ads from around the world Red Shoe Personals Personals and Dating for Singles and Swingers Country Roads A Non Profit Organization that promotes group riding on motorcycles. Florida Keys Fishing Fishing the Fl. Keys for bonefish, tarpon or redfish on fly or spin. STEVE"S UMPIRE Comprehensive baseball source for umpires & all fans of the game. PAGE Russian Dating Russian dating service-free personals,russian women dating,marriage Get Lost Camp Gear Gear to get you lost and gear to get you found! Camping, Backpacking.. resurrection Church of the Resurrection located in Alexandria, VA (Episcopal) True Romantics Online dating agency for selective singles seeking a soul mate or mate Rainbow's Refuge A Christian site where Jesus Christ is honoured as Lord and the Bible Cosmic Soul Mates Matchmaking to Criteria. Optional Astrological Compatibility Matching. The Real McKoi A beginners guide to koi carp and pond construction together with hint HoppersHarleysFamily A family site featuring a photo gallery of Harley-Davidson motorcycles Coreyland Dogs Coreyland Dogs is a small, family-run breeder of Olde English Bulldogg Arizona Association The premier recreational GOLD prospecting and mining club in Arizona! The Inner Sanctum Wicca and Witchcraft resources with FREE astrology & more Kayak Korner Kayak fishing for beginners through advanced. Mike's Brew Page This is a site dedicated for those with a thirst for great hand crafte home garden home and garden ideas from everywoman Kafka's Cybercafe Kafka's Cybercafe is a combination cybercafe/magazine rack/used bookst freindsnlove CarbineforCollectors Information and pictures pertaining to the collection of Mosin Nagant, Home & Hearth Net Fundraising Internet fundraising for non-profit organizations, schools, clubs, chu All World make $ DCF Horse Sanctuary horse pictures, rescue stories, FFA links, horse for sale, animal pics

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00liferec09.htm (2 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:52:10 AM] Lifestyle-Recreation page dating personals Shamanic drumming Shamanic drumming and dancing, sweat lodge, trance dance, UK workshops ToL Cyprus Football Up-to-date results and tables for all four divisions in Cyprus and a w Rock-N-Horse Farm Horse pictures, animal pics, family pics, ffa links, free site submit Hollycombe Steam Edwardian Steam Fair, Railways, Traction engines, Farm Machinery. Fishing in Alaska Awesome Alaska fishing on the beautiful Kenai River for monster salmon BERGLI BOOKS BOOKS ON SWITZERLAND (and other places) IN ENGLISH PGAProfessional.com All about Golf - PGA Golf instruction web site, featuring free golf ti Fergal Crawford fergal crawford,football,manchester united,red devils,skydiving,fvwm2 cooking recipe cooking recipe from foodndrink Online personals Amazing online personals, dating, matchmaking and romance - FREE! foodndrink london restaurant guide Asset Finance Sterling Capital Reserve Asset Finance provide competitive equipment f Disabled Personals A matchmaking and friend finder club for Amputees and Disabled men & w E-Cookbooks.net Due North Sport Fish Links to Sport Fishing and Big Game Hunting in Alaska and Canada. Hong Kong Wedding Wedding site of Paul and Fionas Hong Kong wedding Dr. Putt putting advice, tips, and instruction personalized to solve your put Scuba Diver from Lan Scuba diving links, auction, dive sites, u/w fotos page creation The Epicentre Spices The Epicentre site provides information about spices and ethnic cuisin Dateing Singles Pers Online dating agency featuring photo personals of single women and men Morals, family value eBare.com Bareboats Web Entry Portal for Bareboat Chartering. Links to all companies! Dating Advice Tips jiu-jitsu the Art Overcome your attacker in just a few seconds,pictures,mpegs,techniques Russia Direct Russian ladies looking for love and marriage, translations to and from Friend Finder Club Civil Union Law The comprehensive gay and lesbian online marriage directory. Dating In The USA Free Picture Personals Genesearcher Western PA genealogical and historical information. Free Ladylove Dating Meet beautiful and sexy personals from all over the world Interior Gardens Hydroponics Kits,Grow Lights, organic seeds, hand lotions, gardening Gay Sermons GayGospels are sermons (homilies) for gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and t ANGEL Psychic, Business, Tarot, Angel Readings. Special:ONE FREE QUESTION 1 CONNECTIONS Akoss Kitty Kam Try and spot one of the Akoss Family kitties. Located in Rochester, NY Personal-Ads-Network A guide that features only the best personal-classified ads websites. 22 Dating Secrets 22 Secrets to becoming irresistible in dating, love, romance, singles Dream Kitchens Kitchen and Bath Remodeling serving all of Long Island LDS Singles List LDS Singles discussion list home page Dating place It's the real site helpful for singles! Wide Personals with pictures. Woman_2000 Discreet dating service for men ane women. Coulpes Of interest to couples!

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00liferec09.htm (3 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:52:10 AM] Lifestyle-Recreation page MySportsTeam.com Amateur sports community for youth, college, and adult teams. City of Love Romance Dating, Personals, Relationship Advice, Love, Romance, Send Flowers Marbles we have them Glass Marbles for sale Doyletics - 21st Cen Troubled by fear, anger, anxiety, phobia, acrophobia, trauma, breech b Saltwater fishing Daily saltwater fishing reports, guides, charters, equipment... A PERSONAL A Personal Match! pprovides access to a free internet personals site, MATCH! Montana Wisdom Site The Montana Wisdom Site - Because Life Throws Curve Balls, Too. Whirlwind 5K Run Whirlwind 5K Run/Walk home page (Tishomingo, Oklahoma; annual event). Friends On Wheels for those who are disabled in wheelchairs, or may have friends in them Your Sixth Sense Your one stop site for information on tarot, I-Ching,astrology, runes, Charlotte Church Current and archived features and news, literary and graphic art, MIDI Dating Insider .com We Take Off Everything! Lessons in sex appeal, dating advice, etc... SeniorSomething SeniorSomething.com because being senoir is more than just getting old Losthunter.com Hunting site providing hunting information and links. The Fireworks Guys Your e-fireworks store...for family fun and entertainment Divorcedoc Custody Divorce and Child custody Information and Resources, Legal Separation Find Cupid Soulmate Free soulmate test compares you with the opposite sex. Online matchmaking Online matchmaking services for you to get online dating,romance,love. Bert Hellinger Famil Family Constellations Systemic Psychotherapy. Unravelling the hidden d Biggoat.com Goat resource page all about goats and goats for sale 1NJLA Civil War Artillery, specializing in live fire artillery shooting. KE3QE Ham Radio KE3QE Amateur Radio Home Page Dold Uhren Cuckoos Dold Uhren Cuckoo Clocks, Old World Charm at Affordable Prices

http://www.comparativereligion.com/00liferec09.htm (4 of 4) [10/27/2000 9:52:10 AM]