Supplementary Online Material Table of Contents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Supplementary Online Material Table of Contents S-1 Coding Instructions – U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations 2 S-2 Coding Sheet – U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations 3 S-3 U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations 4 S-4 U.S. National Climate Change Counter-movement Income Data 2003 – 2010 5 S-5 U.S. National Climate Change Counter-movement Income Distribution 2003 – 2010 36 S-6 Foundation Funding of U.S. National Climate Counter-movement By Foundation and Year 39 S-7 .Foundation Funding of U.S. National Climate Counter-movement By Organization and Year 43 S-8 Foundation Funding of U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations – By Foundation 45 S-9 Foundation Funding of U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations – By Recipient 79 S 10 Climate Change Counter-movement Network Dimensions 113 S 11 Climate Change Counter-movement Network - Relative Node Strength 114 S 12 Climate Change Counter-movement Network - Relative Node Degree 115 Figure S-1 116 Methods Appendix 117 1 S-1 Coding Instructions – U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations The purpose of this organizational coding is to identify the organizations that make up the climate counter-movement in the United States. Definition of climate counter-movement – organizations that advocate against government policies to take substantive action to mitigate climate change. Specifically, this movement opposes mandatory restrictions on GHG emissions, either through regulations or a carbon fee. The advocacy of this community contains several different arguments, such as: 1. Climate change is not occurring. 2. Climate change is occurring, but it is not due to humans. 3. Climate change is occurring, and it is due to humans. But it does not pose a sufficient threat to justify large scale action or climate change will be beneficial. 4. Climate change is occurring, and it is due to humans. But it is too expensive to deal with. 5. Climate change is occurring, and it is due to humans. However, voluntary actions will be sufficient to address this issue. Your task is to review information about this organization, and assign a code that describes the role of this organization in this movement. There are four codes that you can assign to the organization: 1. Climate Counter-movement single focus organization - climate change sole focus 2. Climate Counter-movement multiple focus organization – climate change substantive focus, but not sole focus 3. Climate Counter-movement Peripheral Organization – climate change minor focus 4. Not Climate Counter-movement Organization Coding Steps To code an organization, the first step is to examine its participation in several well-known climate counter-movement events or coalitions. These are participation or sponsorship of the ICC conference, or participation in the Global Climate Coalition, Alliance for Climate Strategies, or the Cooler Heads Coalition. Generally, participation in these coalitions signifies a minimum coding of 3 for this organization. Information about participation in these events or coalitions is available on the organization Excel spread sheet. Enter the results of this review in the External Activities blocks on the coding sheet. The second step is to do a Google search of the organization. Generally, this will turn up the site of the organization, and in a large majority of cases, a Wikipedia site, and organizational description sites developed by both “Source Watch” and Greenpeace. You should read these descriptions and first enter the type of organization in the Nature of Organization box on the coding sheet. You then need to decide if there is evidence that this organization is generally perceived to be part of the climate counter- movement. You should enter the results on the External Web Site Descriptions blocks. The fourth step is to go to the organization’s web site. You should read the organization’s mission (usually listed in the tab labeled “about us.”) Then look over the web site, looking for statements regarding the extent and nature of the organization’s involvement with climate change. You should answer the questions on the coding sheet under the headings of Organization Web Site Review, Nature of Arguments Presented Regarding Climate Change, and Actions Advocated to Address Climate Change. The fifth step is to review the most recent copy of the organization’s IRS 990 form. Go to www.guidestar.org, and enter the organization’s name. This will bring up information regarding the organization, as well as links to the IRS forms of the organization. Open the most recently available IRS 990 form, and fill out the blocks in the IRS 990 Review section of the coding form. The final step is to code the organization into one of four categories. Based on the information obtained about the organization, enter a code of 1-4 in the block Organizational Coding. 2 S-2 Coding Sheet – U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations Climate Change Counter-movement Organization Coding Sheet Name of Organization ____________________________________________________________________ Nature of Organization 1. Advocacy Org 5. University Affiliated Research Institute 2. Think Tank/Research Institute 6. Professional Association 3. Trade Association 7. Foundation 4. Coalition 8. Other ____________________________________ External Activities No Yes 1. Has the organization sponsored the Heartland Conference? 2. Has a representative from this organization spoken at the Heartland Conference? 3. Did the organization belong to the Global Climate Coalition? 4. Does the organization belong to the Alliance for Climate Strategies? 5. Does the organization belong to the Cooler Heads Coalition? External Web Site Descriptions 1. Is the org described on a Wikipedia Site? If so, does it appear to be a counter-movement org? 2. Is the org described on a Source Watch page? If so, does it appear to be a counter-movement org? 3. Is the org described on a Greenpeace page? If so, does it appear to be a counter-movement org? Organization Web Site Review 1. Is global warming/climate change mentioned in the orgs purpose statement, mission, or objectives? 2. Are there other issues mentioned in the organization’s purpose/mission/objectives? 3. Are statements, issue advisories, editorial statements or reports available on the web site regarding global warming/climate change? Nature of Arguments Presented Regarding Climate Change Absent Present 1. Climate change is a hoax/not happening 2. The science of climate change is uncertain 3. Climate change is not caused by human activities 4. Climate change is caused by human activities, but it is not of concern 5. Climate change will be beneficial for humans 6. Addressing climate change is too expensive 7. There are other problems that should be addressed before climate change 8. Other Actions Advocated to Address Climate Change Absent Present 1. No action 2. Voluntary action 3. Expansion/increase use of carbon energy sources 4. Technology research 5. Energy efficiency 6. Price on Carbon (Carbon Tax or Cap & Trade) 7. Carbon Regulations 8. Government Investments 9. Government Subsidies IRS 990 Review No Yes 1. Is global warming/climate change mentioned in the organization’s mission? (Line 1, page 2) 2. Is there a separate statement on global warming /climate change in the organization’s achievements? (Line 4, page 2) 3. Is there a specific funding amount listed that is identified as being spent on global warming/climate change activities? (Line 4, page 2) 4. If funding on global warming/climate change is listed, enter amount. 5. What are the total expenses reported for the most current year IRS 990? (Line 18, page 1) Organizational Coding 1. Climate Counter-movement Single Focus Organization 2. Climate Counter-movement Multiple Focus Organization 3. Climate Counter-movement Peripheral Organization 4. Not Climate Counter-movement Organization Coded By _________________ Date __________ Entered By_________________ Date __________ 3 S-3 U.S. National Climate Counter-movement Organizations 60 Plus Committee For A Constructive Tomorrow International Climate And Environmental Change Advancement Of Sound Science Center Inc. The) Competitive Enterprise Institute InternationalAt PjtClimate (I) Science Coalition Alliance For Climate Strategies (ACS) Congress Of Racial Equality International Policy Network American Coal Foundation Consumer Alert/National Consumer Coalition James Madison Institute American Coalition For Clean Coal Electricity (ACCCE) Consumer Energy Alliance John Locke Foundation American Conservative Union Foundation Cooler Heads Coalition Landmark Legal Foundation American Council For Capital Formation Cornwall Alliance For The Stewardship Of Creation Manhattan Institute For Policy Research American Council For Capital Formation Center For Policy Research Edison Electric Institute Manhattan Libertarian Party American Energy Alliance/Institute For Energy Research Energy Citizens Media Research Center American Energy Freedom Center Energy Makes America Great Mercatus Center, George Mason University American Enterprise Institute For Public Policy Research Environmental Literacy Council Mountain States Legal Foundation American Farm Bureau Federation For American Coal, Energy And Security National Association Of Manufacturers American Friends Of The Institute Of Economic Affairs Free Enterprise Action Institute/Free Enterprise Education Institute National Center For Policy Analysis American Gas Association Freedom Action National Center For Public