DOCSLIB.ORG

Comments on Pauline Maier's Paper

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Comments on Pauline Maier's Paper DRAFT: DO NOT QUOTE OR CITE WITHOUT PERMISSION OF AUTHOR Comments on Pauline Maier’s Paper Richard Leffler, [email protected], Wisconsin Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution Project 1. “Washington did not favor the Constitution first and foremost as a check on the states.” More like Max Edling’s “fiscal-military state” A. Makes nice point that GW summarized plans of JM, Jay, and Knox before the Convention met (note 11) B. Their greatest aspiration was “to establish a nation that could in fact ‘assume among the powers of the earth’ a ‘separate and equal station’ as the Declaration of Independence promised. C. But he sounds like Galloway, Franklin, Dickinson, and Madison when he says in the circular letter “That unless the States will suffer Congress to exercise those prerogatives they are undoubtedly invested with by the Constitution [Articles], every thing must very rapidly tend to anarchy and confusion. That it is indispensable to the happiness of the individual Sates, that there should be lodged, somewhere, a supreme power, to regulate and govern the general concerns of the confederated republic, without which the Union cannot be of long duration. That there must be a faithful and pointed compliance on the part of every State with the late proposals and demands of Congress, or the most fatal consequences will ensue.⎯That whatever measures have a tendency to dissolve the Union, or contribute to violate or lessen the sovereign authority, ought to be considered as hostile to the liberty and independency of America. .” (CC, Vol. 1, 65). 2. Unlike Madison, however, Knox saw the states not as too strong and in need of checking, but like the Confederation too weak in that they lacked ‘the essential concomitant of government, the power of preserving the peace; the protection of liberty and property of the states.’ ” A. Knox to a member of Const. Convention: “the state systems are the accursed thing which will prevent our being a nation . .the vile state government are sources of pollution which will contaminate the American name for ages . smite them in the name of God and the people.” (Jensen, Making of the Constitution, 37) B. In footnote, quotes Knox as calling for “one government instead of an association of governments 2 3. Not, was the Constitution necessary but whether we needed the Constitution we got. RHL and Antifeds considered Constitution imperfect and in need of revision. A. Suppose the Congress had fixed the Constitution before sending it out for ratification by adopting Lee’s amendments.” Mentions bill of rights, privy council, no v.p. , and giving Senate proportional representation. A. The last provision was the killer B. RHL doesn’t mention Antifed. proposal to allow states to raise direct taxes (requisitions) and give federal govt. power if states don’t or in case of war. C. “Could the Constitution have been ratified with less division and less rancor, bottomed--like independence had been--on a broad national consensus [was it?]. If the Constitution had been amended as Lee proposed--with the provision on direct taxes added to his list--would the U.S. have become a ‘less respectable nation,’ unable to claim ‘an equal place’ in the community of nations? Or would the long-term result have been much the same or perhaps better?” F. Federalists hated the idea of continuing the requisition system. How would this work? 1. Many legislatures would not be in session, depending on the timing, for a year. 2.If they refused to provide funds how would it be collected? By force of arms? A prescription for civil war. G. How would amendments be achieved. 1. Couldn’t be done by Congress. States already had the Constitution proposed by the convention. If Congress does it as Congress they would have to abide by the Articles: unanimous ratification by 13 legislatures 2. Lee is calling for a second constitutional convention. Published letter to ER, 16 October: “the plan for us to pursue, will be to propose the necessary amendments, and to suggest the calling of a new convention for the purpose of considering them. To this I see no well founded objection, but great safety and much good to be the probable result.” 3. This would be a catastrophe from the Federalist point of view 4. Congress would call it for specified purposes 3 5. States would elect delegates, perhaps with severe restrictions on their freedom of action 6. Who would be elected to the Convention a. From Mass. Sam Adams, John Hancock, John Adams? b. From NY: Lansing, Yates, and Clinton? c. From Virginia: RHL, Patrick Henry; no JM? no GW d. 2nd convention would undo everything that had been done by the first convention. 7. Result would be a catastrophic failure from the Federalist point of view. And if so, consult what GW said in his 31 March letter to JM: a. “my wish is, that the Convention may adopt no temporising expedient, but probe the defects of the Constitution to the bottom, and provide radical cures, whether they are greed to or not.” b. In same letter, comments on the growth of sentiment in North in favor of monarchy. Says “I am clear, that even admitting the utility;⎯nay necessity of the form⎯yet the period is not arrived for adopting the change without shaking the Peace of the Country to its foundation. That a thorough reform of the present system is indispensable, none who have capacities to judge will deny. I hope the business will be essayed in a full Convention. I say after this essay is made, if the system proves inefficient, conviction of the necessity of a change will be dissiminated among all classes of the People. Then, and not till then, in my opinion can it [Monarchy] by attempted without involving all the evils of civil discord.” 8. The result of a second convention would be the ruination of the Constitution, which would have precipitated a coup d’etat by the nationalists led by Washington, Hamilton, Knox, Humphreys, Lincoln, Robert Morris, Gouverneur Morris, etc. The American Revolution would not only be over, it will have ended in tragedy. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • This Constitution: a Bicentennial Chronicle, Nos. 14-18
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 300 290 SO 019 380 AUTHOR Mann, Shelia, Ed. TITLE This Constitution: A Bicentennial Chronicle, Nos. 14-18. INSTITUTION American Historical Association, Washington, D.C.; American Political Science Association, Washington, D.C.; Project '87, Washington, DC. SPONS AGENCY National Endowment for the Humanities (NFAH), Washington, D.C. PUB DATE 87 NOTE 321p.; For related document, see ED 282 814. Some photographs may not reproduce clearly. AVAILABLE FROMProject '87, 1527 New Hampshire Ave., N.W., Washington, DC 20036 nos. 13-17 $4.00 each, no. 18 $6.00). PUB TYPE Collected Works - Serials (022) -- Historical Materials (060) -- Guides - Classroom Use - Guides (For Teachers) (052) JOURNAL CIT This Constitution; n14-17 Spr Sum Win Fall 1987 n18 Spr-Sum 1988 EDRS PRICE MFO1 Plus Postage. PC Not Available from EDRS. DESCRIPTORS Class Activities; *Constitutional History; *Constitutional Law; History Instruction; Instructioral Materials; Lesson Plans; Primary Sources; Resource Materials; Secondary Education; Social Studies; United States Government (Course); *United States History IDENTIFIERS *Bicentennial; *United States Constitution ABSTRACT Each issue in this bicentennial series features articles on selected U.S. Constitution topics, along with a section on primary documents and lesson plans or class activities. Issue 14 features: (1) "The Political Economy of tne Constitution" (K. Dolbeare; L. Medcalf); (2) "ANew Historical Whooper': Creating the Art of the Constitutional Sesquicentennial" (K. Marling); (3) "The Founding Fathers and the Right to Bear Arms: To Keep the People Duly Armed" (R. Shalhope); and (4)"The Founding Fathers and the Right to Bear Arms: A Well-Regulated Militia" (L. Cress). Selected articles from issue 15 include: (1) "The Origins of the Constitution" (G.
    [Show full text]
  • The Emerging Genre of the Constitution: Kent Newmyer and the Heroic Age
    University of Connecticut OpenCommons@UConn Connecticut Law Review School of Law 2021 The Emerging Genre of The Constitution: Kent Newmyer and the Heroic Age Mary Sarah Bilder Follow this and additional works at: https://opencommons.uconn.edu/law_review Part of the Legal History Commons Recommended Citation Bilder, Mary Sarah, "The Emerging Genre of The Constitution: Kent Newmyer and the Heroic Age" (2021). Connecticut Law Review. 459. https://opencommons.uconn.edu/law_review/459 CONNECTICUT LAW REVIEW VOLUME 52 FEBRUARY 2021 NUMBER 4 Essay The Emerging Genre of The Constitution: Kent Newmyer and the Heroic Age MARY SARAH BILDER In written celebration of Kent Newmyer’s intellectual and collegial influence, this Essay argues that the written constitution was an emerging genre in 1787-1789. Discussions of the Constitution and constitutional interpretation often rest on a set of assumptions about the Constitution that arose in the years and decades after the Constitutional Convention. The most significant one involves the belief that a fixed written document was drafted in 1787 intended in our modern sense as A Constitution. This fundamental assumption is historically inaccurate. The following reflections of a constitutionalist first lay out the argument for considering the Constitution as an emerging genre and then turn to Kent Newmyer’s important influence. The Essay argues that the constitution as a system or frame of government and the instrument were not quite one and the same. This distinction helps to make sense of ten puzzling aspects of the framing era. 1263 The Emerging Genre of The Constitution: Kent Newmyer and the Heroic Age MARY SARAH BILDER * In written celebration of Kent Newmyer’s intellectual and collegial influence, this Essay argues that the written constitution was an emerging genre in 1787-1789.
    [Show full text]
  • The Privileges Or Immunities Clause Abridged: a Critique of Kurt Lash on the Fourteenth Amendment
    Georgetown University Law Center Scholarship @ GEORGETOWN LAW 2019 The Privileges or Immunities Clause Abridged: A Critique of Kurt Lash on the Fourteenth Amendment Randy E. Barnett Georgetown University Law Center, [email protected] Evan Bernick Georgetown University Law Center, [email protected] This paper can be downloaded free of charge from: https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/facpub/2147 https://ssrn.com/abstract=3348680 Notre Dame Law Review, Vol. 95, Issue 2, 499. This open-access article is brought to you by the Georgetown Law Library. Posted with permission of the author. Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/facpub Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, and the Fourteenth Amendment Commons \\jciprod01\productn\N\NDL\95-2\NDL201.txt unknown Seq: 1 7-JAN-20 14:29 THE ORIGINAL MEANING OF “PRIVILEGES OR IMMUNITIES” THE PRIVILEGES OR IMMUNITIES CLAUSE, ABRIDGED: A CRITIQUE OF KURT LASH ON THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT Randy E. Barnett* & Evan D. Bernick** The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment reads: “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privi- leges or immunities of citizens of the United States . .”1 Upon confronting this language, the first question most ask is what exactly are the “privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States”? It was this very question that Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg put to attorney Alan Gura during oral argument in McDonald v. City of Chicago,2 as he was urging the Court to revive the Privi- leges or Immunities Clause to protect the right to keep and bear arms.3 “But I really would like you to answer the question that you didn’t have an oppor- tunity to finish answering, and that is: What other .
    [Show full text]
  • Anniversary Meetings H S S Chicago 1924 December 27-28-29-30 1984
    AHA Anniversary Meetings H S S 1884 Chicago 1924 1984 December 27-28-29-30 1984 r. I J -- The United Statei Hotel, Saratop Spring. Founding ike of the American Histoncal Anociation AMERICA JjSTORY AND LIFE HjcItl An invaluable resource for I1.RJC 11’, Sfl ‘. “J ) U the professional 1< lUCEBt5,y and I for the I student • It helps /thej beginning researcher.., by puttmq basic information at his or her fingertips, and it helps the mature scholar to he sttre he or she hasn ‘t missed anything.” Wilbur R. Jacobs Department of History University of California, Santa Barbara students tote /itj The indexing is so thorough they can tell what an article is about before they even took up the abstract Kristi Greenfield ReferencelHistory Librarian University of Washington, Seattle an incomparable way of viewing the results of publication by the experts.” Aubrey C. Land Department of History University of Georgia, Athens AMERICA: HISTORY AND LIFE is a basic resource that belongs on your library shelves. Write for a complimentary sample copy and price quotation. ‘ ABC-Clio Information Services ABC Riviera Park, Box 4397 /,\ Santa Barbara, CA 93103 CLIO SAN:301-5467 AMERICAN HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION Ninety-Ninth Annual Meeting A I { A HISTORY OF SCIENCE SOCIETY Sixtieth Annual Meeting December 27—30, 1984 CHICAGO Pho1tg aph qf t/u’ Umted States Hotel are can the caller turn of (a urge S. B airier, phato a1bher Saratoga Sprzng, V) 1 ARTHUR S. LINK GEORGE H. DAVIS PROFESSOR Of AMERICAN HISTORY PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESIDENT OF THE AMERICAN HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION AMERICAN HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION 4t)f) A Street SE, Washington, DC 20003 1984 OFfICERS President: ARTHUR S.
    [Show full text]
  • 2011 Annual Report 2011 Visit of the James Madison Fellows to James Madison’S Montpelier Home in Orange, Virginia
    James Madison Memorial Fellowship Foundation 2011 Annual Report 2011 visit of the James Madison Fellows to James Madison’s Montpelier home in Orange, Virginia. James Madison Memorial Fellowship Foundation 2011 Annual Report Table of Contents President’s Letter 2 Twenty Years of Fellowship Competitions 3 Education Programs 4 2011 Fellowship Program 5 Senior Fellows 6 Junior Fellows 7 Private Donors 7, 11 Summer Institute on the Constitution 8 Communication 10 James Madison Symposium 10 Development 11 Financial Statements 12 Governance 13 James Madison Fellows 14 Foundation Staff 15 President’s Letter The first James Madison Memorial Fellowship competition began in Principals and the American Association of School Fall, 1991—over twenty years ago. Today, Madison Fellows are Administrators,as well as several other national non-profit organiza- teaching in all 50 states, five territories, and the District of tions. Columbia. A handful of Fellows are retired and a few have left the teaching profession. However, the vast majority of nearly 1000 The new office building has space for all of the Foundation staff, Fellows are teaching our nation’s students; leading our nation’s edu- extensive storage capacity, and a small kitchen. A large conference cational institutions; and promoting study of our nation’s room with the latest electronic technology will enable the Constitution. As the Fellowship program moves into its third Foundation to host meetings, conference, and even webinars. decade, the Foundation has embarked on some exciting new initia- When available, we hope to offer a “visitor’s office” that can be used tives. by visiting scholars and visiting James Madison Fellows who might need a comfortable work space for a few days while they are in After spending twenty years on one of the most prestigious streets Washington, D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report July 1, 2015, to June 30, 2016
    Annual Report July 1, 2015, to June 30, 2016 ANNUAL REPORT 2015–2016 1 Preserving America’s Past Since 1791 Board of Trustees 2016 Officers Trustees William N. Thorndike A Message from the Chair of the Board & the President Charles C. Ames, Chair Benjamin C. Adams Edward L. Widmer Frederick G. Pfannenstiehl, Oliver F. Ames Life Trustees Vice Chair Frederick D. Ballou Bernard Bailyn At the close of FY2016, the celebration of our 225th anniversary was well underway. Judith Bryant Wittenberg, Levin H. Campbell, Jr. Leo Leroy Beranek Activities included two exhibitions: The Private Jefferson: From the Collections of the Secretary Joyce E. Chaplin Levin H. Campbell, Sr. Massachusetts Historical Society and Turning Points in American History, both high- Paul W. Sandman William C. Clendaniel Henry Lee lighting the strengths and little known collections of the MHS. The Private Jefferson Treasurer Herbert P. Dane is also our first traveling exhibition, making the journey to the Virginia Historical Trustees Emeriti Amalie M. Kass Society and the New-York Historical Society to further spread the word of our ex- Nancy R. Coolidge traordinary holdings. For this anniversary year, Cocktails with Clio, our annual gala, Anthony H. Leness Arthur C. Hodges ventured into new territory—that is, the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and G. Marshall Moriarty John F. Moffitt Museum—for the reception and dinner. Among the other 225 efforts were the publi- Claire Nelson James Storey cation of a companion volume to The Private Jefferson, special features on our website, Lisa B. Nurme John L. Thorndike and public programs. Byron Rushing Hiller B.
    [Show full text]
  • CSM 2013 Newsletter
    The Colonial Society of Massachusetts September Volume XVIII, Number Letter from the President Ebenezer Gay, long Curator of Scientific Instruments at Harvard, and William Bradford Osgood, a trustee of Dear Members: many Boston historical institutions, were both elected in . Marcus McCorison, President Emeritus of the he Society’s house at Mount Vernon Street has American Antiquarian Society, was elected in . Most been a very busy place this year. In addition to our deeply felt was the death in August of Pauline Maier, Tconvivial Annual Meeting and three stimulating William R. Kenan, Jr. Professor of American History at Stated Meetings, we welcomed Suffolk University’s MIT, who had served on the Society’s Council since Honors History Graduates for their awards ceremony and was Chair of our Committee on Publications. and Boston University’s American and New England Pauline was central to the Society’s work and success. We Studies Program for their spring reception for M.A. and will miss her greatly. Ph.D. students. Our Graduate Student Forum adopted a Sincerely, new format suggested by the day’s senior scholar, D R. F Professor Karen Kupperman of New York University, President which promoted lively discussion. Vice-President Robert Allison and Corresponding Secretary Martha McNa- mara convened a Boston Historic Sites Forum to discuss integrating interpretation of various historical museums to give school classes and the visiting public a stronger understanding of the city’s history. The Society co- A Revolutionary Find sponsored People and Places, a summer teacher institute for public school teachers. Offsite, we cosponsored the T eight copies of a printed subscription Winterthur Furniture Conference, New Perspectives on sheet from Boston’s first organized response to the Boston Furniture, - , that will result in a Colonial Townshend Acts, dated October , , were discovered Society publication.
    [Show full text]
  • Research Guide for Longfellow House Bulletins
    Research Guide to Longfellow House Bulletins Table of Contents by Issue Titles of Articles in Bold Subjects within articles in Plain text [Friends of the LH= Friends of the Longfellow House-Washington’s Headquarters] [NPS=National Park Service] December 1996, Vol. 1 No. 1: Welcome to the Friends Bulletin! ................................................................................. 1 Mission of the Longfellow House Bulletin Interview ......................................................................................................................... 1 Diana Korzenik, founding member and first president of the Friends of the LH Longfellow’s Descendants Donate Paintings ............................................................ 3 Lenora Hollmann Ernest Wadsworth Longfellow Frances (Frankie) Appleton Wetherell Kennedy and Kerry Win Funding for House .............................................................. 3 Senator Edward M. Kennedy Senator John Kerry Brooklyn Museum Plans to Borrow Paintings ........................................................... 4 Eastman Johnson Adopt-an-Object ........................................................................................................... 4 Dutch tall case clock at the turn of the front hall stairs, c. 1750 June 1997, Vol. 1 No. 2: Longfellow Archives Throw New Light on Japan’s Meiji Period ............................... 1 Charles (Charley) Appleton Longfellow Japan New High-School Curriculum Features Charles Longfellow .................................... 1 Charles Appleton
    [Show full text]
  • War and Constitution-Making in Revolutionary Massachusetts, 1754-1788 James Fred Hrdlicka Garfield Heights, Ohio B.A. University
    War and Constitution-Making in Revolutionary Massachusetts, 1754-1788 James Fred Hrdlicka Garfield Heights, Ohio B.A. University of Notre Dame, 2010 M.A. University of Virginia, 2012 A Dissertation presented to the Graduate Faculty of the University of Virginia in Candidacy for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Corcoran Department of History University of Virginia August 2016 Abstract Throughout the Revolutionary era, Americans embraced the capacity of constitutional government at all levels to mobilize power to achieve desired ends. This study explores how and why the inhabitants of one province-turned-state looked to the institutions, practices, and authority of constitutional government to address the myriad challenges they faced between the French and Indian War and the ratification of the United States Constitution. In these years, people in Massachusetts viewed constitutions as more than sets of theoretical propositions designed to limit the power of those who ruled, and they appreciated them not only because they provided opportunities to declare inviolable rights. Constitutions also comprised practical plans of government through which the populace could effectively mobilize power during times of greatest strain. War and its burdens thus formed the essential backdrop as inhabitants considered what made for legitimate and effective government. In no other context did government demand so much of them; at no other times were they presented with as many opportunities to consider the nature of their attachments to the state and to each other. This study properly situates the narrative of constitutional development by first examining the process by which authorities worked with the populace to mobilize men and resources for war and the specific contexts of governance in which that process occurred.
    [Show full text]
  • MU Newsletter, April 26, 1990 Office Ofni U Versity Relations
    Marshall University Marshall Digital Scholar MU Newsletter 1987-1999 Marshall Publications 4-26-1990 MU NewsLetter, April 26, 1990 Office ofni U versity Relations Follow this and additional works at: http://mds.marshall.edu/oldmu_newsletter Recommended Citation Office of University Relations, "MU NewsLetter, April 26, 1990" (1990). MU Newsletter 1987-1999. Paper 119. http://mds.marshall.edu/oldmu_newsletter/119 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Marshall Publications at Marshall Digital Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in MU Newsletter 1987-1999 by an authorized administrator of Marshall Digital Scholar. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. NEWSLETTER MARSHAL[ UNIVERSITY • OFFICE OF UNIVERSITY RELATIONS • HUNTINGTON, WEST VIRGINIA 25701 • April 26, 1990 Sales will receive honorary doctorate An aspiring sportswriter who was fired from the Mar­ entertainer during his student days shall College student newspaper for spending too much when he landed a $20-a-week job writ­ time cracking jokes and dancing in the Student Union will ing scripts for a Huntington radio sta­ receive an honorary doctorate at Marshall University's tion, ultimately becoming the area's 1990 Commencement, May 12. top-rated disc jockey. The would-be sportswriter went on to win fame through­ After graduating from Marshall in out much of the world as comedian Soupy Sales. And 41 1949, he moved to Cincinnati and his years after receiving his Marshall degree in journalism, first television show, "Soupy's Soda he's still making people laugh. Shop." He became increasingly sue- Soupy Sales Responding to MU President Dale F.
    [Show full text]
  • The Library of Congress Information Bulletin, 2002. INSTITUTION Library of Congress, Washington, DC
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 478 305 IR 058 746 AUTHOR Lamolinara, Guy, Ed.; Dalrymple, Helen, Ed. TITLE The Library of Congress Information Bulletin, 2002. INSTITUTION Library of Congress, Washington, DC. ISSN ISSN-0041-7904 PUB DATE 2002-00-00 NOTE 318p.; For Volume 60 (2001 issues), see ED 464 636. AVAILABLE FROM For full text: http://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/. PUB TYPE Collected Works Serials (022) JOURNAL CIT Library of Congress Information Bulletin; v61 n1-12 Jan-Dec 2002 EDRS PRICE EDRS Price MF01/PC13 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS *Exhibits; Library Collection Development; *Library Collections; Library Materials; *Library Services; *National Libraries; United States History IDENTIFIERS *Library of Congress ABSTRACT These 10 issues, representing one calendar year, including two double issues (2002)- of "The Library of Congress Information Bulletin," contain information on Library of Congress new collections and program developments, lectures and readings, financial support and materials donations, budget, honors and awards, World Wide Web sites and digital collections, new publications, exhibits, and preservation. Cover stories include:(1) "American Women: Guide to Women's History Resources Published"; (2) "The Year in Review";(3) "'Suffering Under a Great Injustice': Adams' Photos Document. Japanese Internment";(4) "Presenting a Stage for a Nation: Exhibition Portrays Genius of Roger L. Stevens";(5) "Swann Gallery Exhibition Features 'American Beauties'";(6) "Veterans Hear the Call: Folklife Center Sponsors History Project"; (7) "Courting Disaster: Building a Collection to Chronicle 9/11 and Its Aftermath"; (8) "Collecting a Career: The Katherine Dunham Legacy Project"; (9) "2002 National Book Festival: Second Annual Event Celebrates the Power of Words"; and (10) "The Civil War and American Memory: Examining the Many Facets of the Conflict." (AEF) Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document.
    [Show full text]
  • Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography
    THE PENNSYLVANIA MAGAZINE OF HISTORY AND BIOGRAPHY VOLUME CXXXVII January 2013 NO. 1 EDITORIAL Tamara Gaskell 7 INTRODUCTION Erica Armstrong Dunbar and Randall M. Miller 9 THE CONTESTED HISTORY OF AMERICAN FREEDOM Eric Foner 13 THE AGE OF EMANCIPATING PROCLAMATIONS:EARLY CIVIL WAR ABOLITIONISM AND ITS DISCONTENTS Richard S. Newman 33 “GOD IS SETTLEING THE ACCOUNT”: AFRICAN AMERICAN REACTION TO LINCOLN’S EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION Daniel R. Biddle and Murray Dubin 57 “YOU FEEL SO OUT OF PLACE”: GERMANTOWN’S J. GORDON BAUGH AND THE 1913 COMMEMORATION OF THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION David W. Young 79 REVIEW ESSAY “A MEASURE ALIKE MILITARY & PHILANTHROPIC”: HISTORIANS AND THE EMANCIPATION PROCLAMATION Douglas R. Egerton 95 BOOK REVIEWS 115 BOOK REVIEWS NEWMAN and MUELLER, eds., Antislavery and Abolition in Philadelphia: Emancipation and the Long Struggle for Racial Justice in the City of Brotherly Love, by Katrina Anderson 115 GRIVNO, Gleanings of Freedom: Free and Slave Labor along the Mason-Dixon Line, 1790–1860, by Howard Bodenhorn 116 DAVIS, “We Will Be Satisfied With Nothing Less”: The African American Struggle for Equal Rights in the North during Reconstruction, by W. Fitzhugh Brundage 118 COVER ILLUSTRATION: Lithograph of illustration by Thomas Nast commemorat- ing the Emancipation Proclamation in January 1863. This image appeared as an illustration in the January 24, 1863 issue of Harper’s Weekly as a celebration of President Abraham Lincoln’s decree emancipating slaves during the Civil War. At the top of the illustration, the female figure Columbia, an early symbol of the United States, cheers emancipation and a portrait of President Lincoln is inset below.
    [Show full text]