Belgian Science Policy Office (BELSPO) / Federal Scientific Institutes (FSIs)
I. Update on Cal/Val Activities
Jean-Christopher Lambert Royal Belgian Institute for Space Aeronomy (IASB-BIRA)
Agency Reports I WGCV Plenary # 41 Tokyo, September 5-7, 2016 Working Group on Calibration and Validation Working Group on Calibration and Validation 2
IASB - , VITO
authority USOC
- BIRA FSIs Onderzoek
BELSPO BELSPO
under
)
Technologisch
FSIs BELSPO / BELSPO Agency Reports I ULg voor
Institute for Space Aeronomy, Aeronomy, for Space Institute
Instelling
institutes
partners
Scientific Institutes ( Institutes Scientific
Université libre de Bruxelles, ULB de Bruxelles, libre Université de Liège, Université Vlaamse Belgian User Support and Operation Centre, B Centre, Operation and Support User Belgian Liège, CSL de Centre spatial Royal IRSN of Belgium, Sciences Natural of Institute Royal RMIB of Belgium, Institute Meteorological Royal ROB of Belgium, Observatory Royal Royal Belgian Belgian Royal
• • • • • • • • •
Regional
Federal Contributing Working Group on Calibration and Validation 3
) FSIs
presented BELSPO / BELSPO
Agency Reports I
methods systems
Validation Validation Validation Validation data Validation EO missions EO
Background Background information (not
• • • • Updates on: Working Group on Calibration and Validation 4
-
polarimetric SAF, O3M NOMAD/TGO CubeSat
-
NG - IASB‘s - IASI
IASI (CM
2018/10):
- PICASSO/
BIRA and
and 2 - FSIs with
IASB‘s
2017/10 UVN - 5 (L -
ExoMars
1A/1B - MSG MSG GOME
ESA
and to
processor :
mission TROPOMI, TROPOMI, BIRA
BELSPO / BELSPO
4 UVN, Sentinel 4 A/B - /PROBA (Phase B2) /PROBA - Ice on SAOCOM
DInSAR Update on missions EO Altius /
transferred MetOp
Precursor Snow/ Roscosmos
5 - - C, Sentinel - InSAR 3A L 2016/02) FTS; KNMI/NASA Aura KNMI/NASA OMI FTS; IASB‘s - - - +
and
cooperation : ESA
3 (S 3 : - MetOp Sentinel BIRA
: ago : :
CSL 1 (L 2001/10) - - ScanSAR year Oceans
months
CONAE SAR/ PROBA V (L 2013/05) EU Sentinel PROBA Approved Next Next Upcoming SAF); SAF); ACE CSA 6 Phase F: GOME, ESA GOMOS, MIPAS, SCIAMACHY Phase E: EUMETSAT
• • • •
Land, • • • • • • Atmosphere Working Group on Calibration and Validation
Working Group on Calibration and Validation
Working Group on Calibration and Validation 7
m); m); μ by
CNRS CNRS
100 by
–
provided nm
developed
;
): ):
nm
radiometers
thermal (200 thermal
3000
and μm –
nm spectrum IASB -
visible instrument’s
): 180 ): LSW (Germany) LSW
UV, UV, one Spectrophotometers -
and with ) near )
Belgium measurements
Monitor): irradiance
Extreme UV/UV UV/UV Extreme L2008)
Switzerland ( IASB ( IASB - Update missions EO on Update irradiance from 17 nm to 100 Irradiance
Irradiance BIRA
Solar Calibrating IPM (Germany) IPM -
and with
by
Formation for flying solar corona observations Space weather Space weather mission with Sun observations
Auto
SPECtral
) Variable
PMOD/WRC (Davos, (Davos, PMOD/WRC
SOLar ( SOLar partnership
( developed (L2009) (L2018) by
Belgium SOlar 2 3 ( on ISS/Columbus on ISS/Columbus - - ACES
KMI ( KMI - Support Centre: Belgian USOC Support hosted USOC Centre: by BIRA Belgian -
EUV/UV; EUV/UV;
IRM SOL SOVIM SOVIM developed SOLSPEC in (France)
99% of solar energy)
PROBA PROBA
• • • ( Measurement of solar spectral
Facility Facility SOLAR SOLAR Working Group on Calibration and Validation 8
FTIR FTIR & : WP4
campaigns
QA4ECV Sea
calibration AROMAPEX characterization
2
stations - North
and member error
FSIs CLIM WP2, over , -
Uccle TCCON/OCO
in in AROMAT in AROMAT
SeaDataNet
for Network Network (7 RT stationsBelgium+ inAntarctic Belgian parameters
]
China, GAIA China, reprocessing
, centre
with
BELSPO / BELSPO (BMDC),
campaign instruments
websites
600 nm, broadband, clouds,sunshineduration… meteorological Update on validation data calibration - campaign
Centre
harmonization DOAS DOAS 2
cooperation - on and
various [ based - based uvindex.aeronomie.be CINDI - effort AirCore+FTIRs : : centralised car shore
Visible Irradiance VisibleMonitoring chemical http://www.mumm.ac.be/datacentre - , Maritime Data
http://
and and
- -
UAV FRM4DOAS, FRM4DOAS, FRM4GHG, International International MAXDOAS bilateral AERONET, AERONET, EEA/EMEP, TCCON, NDACC, WMO/GAW Spectral irradiance 280 Solar UV Base), with
Physical Ship Belgian
• • Solar: Solar: • • • Marine: • • • • • Atmosphere Working Group on Calibration and Validation
9
IASB - IASB - measurements , BIRA , , BIRA , Bolsée IASB UV radiation IASB UV radiation Mazière -
BIRA FTIR instruments instruments FTIR and TCCON) (NDACC
W) ULg ° Contact D. Contact S, 63.9 S, ° IASB IASB and - Contact M. M. De Contact BIRA Porto Velho (8.8 Velho Porto
IASB -
, BIRA ,
Hendrick Update on validation Update validation on data , IRSN/MUMM Contribution networksto and F. and
measurements
Scory Sea
North Roozendael sondes in Uccle, H. De Backer, RMIB Backer,H. De in Uccle, sondes 3 Contact S. Contact /O IRSN/MUMM Brewer + Contact M. VanM. Contact Working Group on Calibration and Validation
=>
over : for new NDACC/TCCON FTIR NDACC/TCCON newfor
forest low low albedo Update on validation Update validation on data Brazil Paramaribo Paramaribo
aircraft due to Amazon with based remote emissions
- of
forest Rationale for atmospheric large uncertainties
ground
SWIR satelliteobservations of - Porto Velho in in Velho Porto
campaigns measurements composition FTIR Area investigatedby Heterogeneity complementarity sensing(column/profile) observations over Amazon forest the Amazon Very few NIR GHG have biogenic, biomass burning and burning biomassbiogenic, greenhouse gas Amazon rainforest = important
5. 4.
3. 2.
1. Why Working Group on Calibration and Validation 11
s
Campaign
et al., 2013
ESA sponsored campaigns in 2014/09, 2015/08, 2017 2015/08, 2014/09, in campaigns ESA sponsored AROMAT AROMAT Update on validation Update validation on data Merlaud Ref: SWING/UAV
BIRA - IASB Working Group on Calibration and Validation
12
2016
measurement results of the morning flight, 21 April 2016 April 21 flight, morning the of results measurement
AirMAP
Campaign et al., 2013 et
DOAS and and DOAS - Merlaud
Ref: Update on validation Update validation on data EUFAR/ESA sponsored campaign over Berlin, in 2016/04 in Berlin, over campaign sponsored EUFAR/ESA Fig 3. Preliminary mobile Preliminary 3. Fig AROMAPEX AROMAPEX Aeromobil
DOAS on - CAR
Merlaud
: A. : BIRA BIRA SWING on FUB Cessna - -
IASB IASB Courtesy Working Group on Calibration and Validation 13
) vs.
DQA) - sites spread
and
28 NDACC NDACC 28
bias and
in WMO/GAW WMO/GAW O3S
sites to
FSIs (WOUDC, NDACC, SHADOZ, ESRL…) SHADOZ, NDACC, (WOUDC, Sep. 2016Sep. type, type, manufacturer, solutionstrength
homogeneity
contribution (
2013; 60 WOUDC 60 2013; - archives
evaluate
DQA meeting,DQA - (2000 to
ozonesonde data
of BELSPO / BELSPO
station
approach
homogeneity
caused by caused by : D. Hubert,O3S: Update on validation data consistency Courtesy ozonesonde ensemble
network all
: mutual based - over
product -
Network Network inhomogeneity By Satellite altitude
• •
• Ozonesonde Working Group on Calibration and Validation 14
CEOS WGCV / ACC ACSG interaction ESA through OzoneCCI Being implemented QA4ECV in Atmosphere Validation (AVS) Server
cci ACC ozone protocol WGCV methods
L2 data validation
Update on AC validation AC validation on Update Generic Working Group on Calibration and Validation
protocol methods
L2 data validation
Update on AC validation AC validation on Update Generic Working Group on Calibration and Validation 16
)
" (Geneva, 2008 (Geneva,
Climate4Impact)
vocabulary) - TASTE,CCI… - methods
ENES project ( projectENES - 2016
June uncertainties
rectification, … rectification, - I/II, Multi PASODOBLE, - CEOS Workshop on QA for the GEOSS the QA foron CEOS Workshop - , QA4ECV TR,QA4ECV ,
Niemeier and S. and
Update on validation Update validation on
QA4ECV Technical Review, MSSL, Surrey, 15 June 2016 June 15 Surrey, MSSL, Review, Technical QA4ECV "Confidence in Compernolle CEOS WGCV list proposed to GEO to proposedWGCV list CEOS
slides: S. slides:
CLIM CLIM Drawn from IPCC Data distribution centre, EUPORIAS project,IS centre, EUPORIAS distribution Data from IPCC Drawn Metrology, data correlation, data harmonization, geo harmonization, data correlation, dataMetrology, - terms GUM/VIM metrology general of explanation NPL:short by note Guidance closure budget error comparison termsand specialised comparisons: ofdata D3.2.Metrology Initially metrology, remote sensing, monitoring; further enhanced with modelling aspects in MACC in aspects modelling with enhancedfurther monitoring; sensing, remote metrology, Initially MACC forprotocols QA/validationin Implemented interpretation and explanation More Heritage Heritage (e.g., VIM, sources ISOGUM, from formalTDs, NIST)literally definitions andTerms next
• • • • • • • • • CLIPC (http://www.clipc.eu/glossary) CLIPC GAIA FIDUCEO vocabulary (working draft) (www.fiduceo.eu/content/fiduceo draft) (working vocabulary FIDUCEO QA4ECV Atmosphere list: Atmosphere QA4ECV
Courtesy
• •
•
• Approaches Approaches and scopes in Climate EU Services pioneering projects Working Group on Calibration and Validation 17
" methods uncertainties
Update on validation Update validation on "Confidence in Working Group on Calibration and Validation 18
" methods uncertainties
Update on validation Update validation on
4 (systematic effect only) "Confidence in - 3 (qualitativeterm) vs 4 (numerical)
-
2 (any 2 (any deviation) vs 3 2 - -
1 1 Inconsistent definitions! Inconsistent Working Group on Calibration and Validation 19
" methods uncertainties
Update on validation Update validation on "Confidence in Working Group on Calibration and Validation 20
" methods uncertainties
Update on validation Update validation on "Confidence in Working Group on Calibration and Validation 21 - /multi -
"
, HCHO, on, CO) 2 5p MPC…) methods -
uncertainties SAF, SAF, S
- in error calculation
ozone/GHG, O3M Update on validation Update validation on ): - "Confidence in linearities
-
ongoing (
steps
mission, L2/L3, unsmoothed/smoothed…) Uncertainties on SI2N ozone profile trend assessments (single Audit of responses to this QA4ECV questionnaire of non Effects terminology, traceability chains, calculation of uncertainties Questionnaire to QA4ECV ECV producers (NO Propagation of standard terminology at working level (QA4ECV, NDACC CCI WGs, Tentative harmonization between EU H2020 projects
• • •
• •
• Next Working Group on Calibration and Validation
mep.esa.int - v -
proba V - systems http:// validation validation
on on 2018 MEP PROBA MEP -
Update Update
products
needed for
V
- V - data
derived party party projects and users - VEGETATION VEGETATION (1998) till - correlative release 2016, iterations 2016 -
Cal/Valand present PROBA SPACEBEL big and data standards TRASYS,
Pre Tools/libraries/applications AlsoMERIS and AVHRR Also Data: SPOT Engaged third Operational platform hosted by VITO; ESA pathfinderESA project
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
(MEP) PROBA (MEP) Mission Exploration Platform Platform Exploration Mission Belgian Science Policy Office (BELSPO) / Federal Scientific Institutes (FSIs)
II. Background information
Jean-Christopher Lambert Royal Belgian Institute for Space Aeronomy (IASB-BIRA)
Agency Reports I WGCV Plenary # 41 Tokyo, September 5-8, 2016 Working Group on Calibration and Validation