arXiv:0910.5821v1 [astro-ph.CO] 30 Oct 2009 Italy oon,Italy Bologna, orslete02p w-ie aeo e hs low possible whose jet been a has due of possibly case it base motions, the two-sided jet 4151 non-relativistic In pc NGC indicate 0.2 speeds Seyfert 2004). the 1 resolve al. et to type aris- (Gallimore wind free- the disk or thermal of corona the to heated from X-ray emission the ing an and radio from nucleus emission core identifica- active free the hidden the the of allowed classical of attribution has the location the of 1068 NGC of study tion galaxy VLBA mech- 2 physical the therefore Seyfert underlying example, and For the etc.) of anisms. motions, comprehension jet the temperature, the in brightness index, the nuclear spectral as the the (such of the components parameters pc- in physical radio Low- successful the the and often of of nuclei are determination Seyfert observations Indeed, (LLAGNs) of VLBI AGNs region luminosity that resolution. subpc-scale shown spatial and scale been high has with importance it them fundamental of resolve is clear. to it less much morphologies, is complex AGN RQ jets for established in case well particles the is energetic AGN lobes, from and RL ori- radiation in the synchrotron emission While 2002; as radio HU01). al. the hereinafter et of (Nagar gin 2001, level Ulvestad some & at most Ho sources that radio scale. show are sub-kpc surveys AGN the VLA sources to deep radio confined moderately is fainter However, emission much radio are AGN, their galaxies, and quiet Seyfert Radio as motions. cases such superluminal some with in cores; knots and compact jet temperatures bright brightness regions, high nuclear and showing their target lobes routinely radio observations VLBI scale large with nrdoqit(Q n ai od(L.Telte are ( latter The sources (RL). radio loud radio powerful and typically (RQ) quiet radio in lcrncades [email protected],francesca.p [email protected], address: Electronic 2 1 ic ula tutrsi otSyetglxe show galaxies Seyfert most in structures nuclear Since cieGlci uli(G)aetaiinlydivided traditionally are (AGN) Nuclei Galactic Active rpittpstuigL using 2018 typeset 9, Preprint June version Draft AFIA,vadlFsodlCvlee10 03 Roma, 00133 100, Cavaliere del Fosso del via IASF/INAF, NFIttt iRdosrnma i oet 0,40129 101, Gobetti via Radioastronomia, di Istituto INAF rmsep( steep from scnitn ihterdolmnst pe limit. upper advectio headings: luminosity an exp Subject of radio natural presence the the most with nucleus, consistent the 5273 m is are NGC physical undetected solutions underlying the outflow diverse of or sense, jet-base this In objects: 4051). (NGC features olre hn10 than larger to NC45,NC48,NC40,adNC53) hl n NC5273 (NGC one while 5033), NGC and ∼ 4501, NGC 4388, NGC 4051, (NGC anetadlatlmnu ai oe nSyetnce,gigt sub to going nuclei, Seyfert in cores 10 radio around luminous luminosities least and faintest nti etr erpr nda-rqec uoenVB Netwo VLBI European dual-frequency on report we letter, this In 100 µ y h eetdcmatnce aerte ieetrdoprop radio different rather have nuclei compact detected The Jy. 1. > α A INTRODUCTION T E H ANETSYETRDOCRSRVAE YVLBI BY REVEALED CORES RADIO SEYFERT FAINTEST THE tl mltajv 08/22/09 v. emulateapj style X 7 0 aais cie—glxe:Syet—rdocnium galaxies continuum: radio — Seyfert galaxies: — active galaxies: . n oe r ihretne rursle,i n aeaccomp case one in unresolved, or extended either are cores and K )t lgtyivre ( inverted slightly to 7) 19 Hz W acloGiroletti Marcello P r − > 1 edtc ai msinfo h ula eino orgalaxies four of region nuclear the from emission radio detect We . 10 [email protected] 22 Hz W rf eso ue9 2018 9, June version Draft α − ABSTRACT = 1 ), − 1 0 n rnec Panessa Francesca and . ) rgtestmeaue ayfrom vary temperatures brightness 1), rlidcssc that such indices tral § ms km icsinadtemi ocuin r ie in given are conclusions main the and discussion t LIosrain ffiesucswith sources five of observations VLBI ity weakest mil- the with observed of 2004; been resolution. never most have liarcsecond al. However, sample et the (Gallimore in 2004). sources available 3031, al. the NGC et are for and Bietenholz 1068 GHz while works NGC 5 e.g. 2002), dedicated have galaxies, sample al. sources brightest et the VLBI radio few (Nagar of observations sources a 2002). 9 VLBA for al. years; et pre- available the (Nagar are avail- through become sources also GHz are have sample GHz 5 observations 15 25 and at for data 1.4 VLA able at and multi- HU01, par- images in Accurate In sented radio sample. VLA this 2006). for ticular, available al. are et studies (Cappi wavelength galaxies ( Seyfert limited distance different the parameters. of sources physical determination and individual the components of for spatial These analysis important very the 2005). is that al. indicate et (Giroletti to studies AGN similarly particles radio-loud via relativistic ordinary emitted has by is con- 4278 source process NGC this the of synchrotron LLAGN On emission the radio the of 2005). that shown analysis al. VLBA et the (Ulvestad trary, plasma thermal to AA,Nryn&Y 94 xlntos h observa- in The detailed are explanations. tions 1994) us Yi Flow tell viability & Accretion Narayan the sources (ADAF, Advection-Dominated and what versus radio sources jet-base (2) individual detected of of and the physics nuclei of the weakest about properties the scale the in (sub-)parsec do even of sources presence how radio the (1) questions: is fundamental common/frequent two answering at aimed 2003). ,rsetvl.Truhu h ae,w en spec- define we paper, the Throughout respectively. 5, ntepeetlte,w eoto e ihsensitiv- high new on report we letter, present the In complete a to belong presented here sources five The − 1 Mpc aain nsvrlcss ntecase the in cases; several in lanations -oiae crto o (ADAF) flow accretion n-dominated − caim a ea oki these in work at be can echanisms 1 Ω , Λ k(V)osrain fthe of observations (EVN) rk myflxdniisadradio and densities flux -mJy < d 2. ris pcrlidcsrange indices spectral erties: sudtce ttelvlof level the at undetected is ) 0 = 2 § n h eut rsne in presented results the and 2 OBSERVATIONS S . 3adΩ and 73 ( 2Mc apeo 7nearby 27 of sample Mpc) 22 ν ) ∝ ne ylobe-like by anied ν − m α 0 = n adopt and T B . 7(pre tal. et (Spergel 27 10 = S 5 K ∼ H 0 mJy, 1 § and 4 § 70 = .A 3. 2 Giroletti & Panessa
We observed the nuclei of five Seyfert galaxies with We detect radio emission at sub-parsec scales in the European VLBI Network (EVN) at 1.6 and 5 GHz, NGC 4051 at both 1.6 and 5 GHz. At 1.6 GHz, we detect namely NGC4051, NGC4388, NGC4501, NGC5194, three sub-mJy components (see Fig. 1). Two of these, and NGC 5273; a basic summary of the observational separated by 20 parsecs, are clearly associated with the parameters is given in Table 1. We used the maximum small-scale double structure imaged with the VLA by recording rate of 1 Gbps and each source was observed Ulvestad & Wilson (1984). The third component (0.67 for about 6 hrs, switching between targets in order to mJy) is symmetric to the easternmost one with respect to improve the coverage of the (u, v)-plane. Amplitude cal- the central one, and aligned with the southwestern emis- ibration was done a priori in the standard EVN pipeline; sion revealed at larger scale. This is also associated with phase corrections were obtained using observations of emission at 8.4 GHz as shown by Kukula et al. (1995) bright nearby (0.2◦
7 highest brightness temperature limit (TB > 1.3×10 K), ity of a supermassive black hole (Falcke et al. 2000; and the smallest size limit (d < 0.27 pc, equivalent to Ulvestad & Ho 2001; Nagar et al. 2002). While some 5 1.4 × 10 RS) among our sample. of the resolved extended emission could be of thermal origin, the small linear scales (< 0.6 pc) and compar- 3.5. NGC 5273 5−7 atively high brightness temperatures (TB = 10 K) VLA observations of the Sy1.5 galaxy NGC5273 had measured in our sources suggests that the weakest Seyfert revealed an unresolved component (θ < 0.52′′) at 1.4 nuclei could also be scaled-down versions of more lumi- 5 and 5 GHz, with a rather flat spectral index (α1.4 =0.4, nous AGN. In this scenario, the origin of radio emission HU01). Nagar et al. (1999) had also revealed a 0.6 mJy can be generally attributed to synchrotron emission from compact component (θ < 0.3′′) at 8.4 GHz. the base of a jet coupled with a low-power accretion disk It is therefore remarkable that our observations do not (Falcke & Biermann 1999). Alternatively, the presence reveal any emission from the nuclear region of this source of an ADAF (Narayan & Yi 1994) is invoked to explain at neither 1.6 or 5 GHz. The 3σ upper limit peak bright- the low luminosity of these sources, although the pre- ness is 90 µJy beam−1 at 1.6 GHz and 140 µJy at 5 GHz. dicted radio emission often fails to reproduce the data, re- This implies either a significant resolution of the sub- quiring combined jet/ADAF models (see e.g., Yuan et al. arcsecond emission (> 95% of the flux density at angular 2002). On average, our results do not seem consistent scales 20 < θ/mas < 300), significant variability (by ∼ with the presence of an ADAF alone, on the basis of the one order of magnitude), or a combination of both. observed structures, sizes, flux densities, and spectral in- dices. 4. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS The two sources detected at both 1.6 and 5 GHz With the VLBI observations presented in this letter, (NGC 4051 and NGC 5033) are most easily explained in we have targeted the faintest and least luminous nuclei terms of jet-base/outflow phenomena. First, the detec- among well known local AGN, going to sub-mJy flux − tion of three aligned sub-mJy components in NGC4051 densities and radio luminosities around 1019 W Hz 1. is indeed suggestive of ejection processes. The brightness These sources belong to a complete sample of nearby temperature (T = 2 × 105 K) does not completely rule Seyfert galaxies, in which previous VLBI observations – out a thermal origin, consistent with the presence of an albeit limited to the brightest members – had revealed outflow rather than a relativistic jet, similar to the case an ubiquitous presence of sub-parsec cores and/or struc- of NGC4395, which shows an elongated low brightness tures. Similar findings had been reported on other rel- temperature nuclear structure, tracing possible outflow atively bright flat spectrum radio sources in LLAGN; emission (Wrobel & Ho 2006; Christopoulou et al. 1997). for instance, Nagar et al. (2002) found that almost all The EVN radio core is also positionally coincident with LLAGNs in the Palomar sample with SVLA,15 GHz > 2.7 a low luminosity H2O maser, suggesting that the radio mJy show mas-scale or sub mas-scale radio cores. The continuum may arise from the inner regions of a molec- 80% detection rate in the present sub-sample extends ular disk or from a nuclear wind (Hagiwara 2007). these findings to the lowest luminosity and flux density As for NGC5033, its core presents all the hallmarks of regimes. a jet-base feature, being detected and unresolved at both While the presence of sub-pc scale radio emission ap- at 1.6 and 5 GHz, with a brightness temperature lower 7 pears thus to be ubiquitous, it is remarkable that it ac- limit of TB > 1.3 × 10 K, and a flat spectrum (con- counts only for a fraction between 5% and 40% of the sistent with α = 0). While these would somewhat be emission detected on scales of a few tens of parsecs (eg. consistent with ADAF expectations, the 5 GHz luminos- as seen in VLA observations). As a consequence, a large ity is ∼ 4 times in excess of what predicted on the basis fraction of the parsec scale radio luminosity is emitted of the observed L2−10keV luminosity, implying that the in a diffuse region. This could be the case of NGC 4388 ADAF model alone fails to account for the observed radio and NGC 4501, in which we completely resolve the VLA emission. The presence of a jet or an outflow component sources at 5 GHz, but detect them at 1.6 GHz (size & 10 is therefore required and more consistent with the data. mas). Similarly, the non detection of NGC 5273 requires Indeed, the short jet-like extension found at larger scale that > 95% of the VLA 1.6 GHz flux density is emitted with VLA (HU01; P´erez-Torres & Alberdi 2007) favours on scales larger than 20 mas (1.6 pc). the jet-base hypothesis. Even though much of the intermediate scale emission With all the caveats related to the unfavourable ob- is resolved out, the majority of the nuclear regions do serving conditions at 5 GHz, the two sources detected host compact radio sources at sub-parsec scales. In Ta- only at 1.6 GHz (NGC4388 and NGC4501) seem to be ble 3, we report the multi-wavelength properties of the also at odds with an ADAF scenario. The non detec- sources presented in this letter. The common features tion at high frequency points to a steep spectral index 6 in these nuclei are: (i) their extremely low radio lu- and/or to a rather extended structure, at scales of 10 RS minosity (Cols. 4-6), at the level of the least luminous or more, in contrast with the flat/inverted spectrum and Seyfert nuclei (such as the sub-mJy source NGC 4395, the compact structure predicted by ADAF models. Al- Wrobel & Ho 2006); (ii) their extreme radio-quietness, though consistent with an angular scale of several mas, for instance the ratios between the radio and nuclear X- thermal emission is also unlikely given the & 106 K ray emission (Col. 8) are among the lowest ever measured brightness temperatures observed at 1.6 GHz. NGC4388 for LLAGN (Panessa et al. 2007; Terashima & Wilson and NGC4501 are also the only type 1.9 Seyferts in our 2003); and (iii) their low Eddington ratios (Col. 9), a sample, showing heavily absorbed/weak X-ray spectra common trait in low luminosity nuclei (Ho 2009). (Cappi et al. 2006). Radio emission from LLAGN cores is generally as- Interestingly, the only undetected source in our sam- sociated with accretion/ejection processes in the vicin- 4 Giroletti & Panessa
5 7 ple is NGC 5273, a type 1.5 Seyfert, in which the nu- ness temperatures between TB = 10 K and > 10 K; cleus is seen directly, displaying broad emission lines and the emitting regions are either extended or unresolved, a bright X-ray spectrum (Cappi et al. 2006). Either the in one source accompanied by lobe-like features and in VLA emission is resolved out or the source is variable. In- an extreme case not even detected. deed, the source was initially not revealed at 8 GHz with As long as the present data set seems generally in the VLA (S < 0.23 mJy, Kukula et al. 1995) and lately favour of jet-like or outflow interpretation for most detected with S = 0.6 mJy by Nagar et al. (1999). The sources, more data are necessary for a complete under- comparison between the X-ray and the EVN radio lumi- standing of the physical processes at work. The pecu- nosity upper limit reveals that this source is extremely liar double/triple morphology of NGC 4051 is certainly radio quiet. Indeed, this is the only case in which the worth a dedicated project (e.g. to look for proper mo- radio data are consistent with a pure ADAF accretion tion of the external components); it also seems neces- mechanism, since our upper limit for this nucleus is 4 sary to constrain the angular size and spectral index of times above the radio core luminosity derived from the NGC 4388 and NGC 4501 with new 5 GHz data, not af- observed X-rays (Yi & Boughn 1998). fected by the severe failures on short baselines faced by the present observations. Finally, even deeper observa- 5. CONCLUSIONS tions are needed to constrain the viability of an ADAF The five Seyfert galaxies presented in this letter are the scenario in NGC5273, as well as to probe the faintest faintest observed to date among a larger sample, extend- members of the parent sample. ing the availability of VLBI observations to the regime of . 1 mJy flux density. With compact components de- tected in 4/5 of our sources, we confirm that parsec scales The European VLBI Network is a joint facility of Eu- radio emission is almost ubiquitous in Seyfert nuclei. ropean, Chinese, South African and other radio astron- Despite this common trait, the observational and omy institutes funded by their national research coun- derived physical parameters display heterogeneous be- cils. This work has benefited from research funding haviours, not easy to interpret within a common phys- from the European Community’s sixth Framework Pro- ical scenario. Spectral indices range from quite steep gramme under RadioNet R113CT 2003 50 58187. (α > 0.7) to slightly inverted (α = −0.1) and bright- Facilities: EVN, VLA.
REFERENCES Barbosa, F. K. B., Storchi-Bergmann, T., Cid Fernandes, R., Mundell, C. G., Wilson, A. S., Ulvestad, J. S., & Roy, A. L. 2000, Winge, C., & Schmitt, H. 2006, MNRAS, 371, 170 ApJ, 529, 816 Bietenholz, M. F., Bartel, N., & Rupen, M. P. 2004, ApJ, 615, 173 Nagar, N. M., Falcke, H., Wilson, A. S., & Ulvestad, J. S. 2002, Cappi, M., et al. 2006, A&A, 446, 459 A&A, 392, 53 Carral, P., Turner, J. L., & Ho, P. T. P. 1990, ApJ, 362, 434 Nagar, N. M., Wilson, A. S., Mulchaey, J. S., & Gallimore, J. F. Christopoulou, P. E., Holloway, A. J., Steffen, W., Mundell, 1999, ApJS, 120, 209 C. G., Thean, A. H. C., Goudis, C. D., Meaburn, J., & Pedlar, Narayan, R., & Yi, I. 1994, ApJ, 428, L13 A. 1997, MNRAS, 284, 385 P´erez-Torres, M. A., & Alberdi, A. 2007, MNRAS, 379, 275 Falcke, H., & Biermann, P. L. 1999, A&A, 342, 49 Panessa, F., Barcons, X., Bassani, L., Cappi, M., Carrera, F. J., Falcke, H., Nagar, N. M., Wilson, A. S., & Ulvestad, J. S. 2000, Ho, L. C., & Pellegrini, S. 2007, A&A, 467, 519 ApJ, 542, 197 Spergel, D. N., et al. 2003, ApJS, 148, 175 Falcke, H., Wilson, A. S., & Simpson, C. 1998, ApJ, 502, 199 Terashima, Y., & Wilson, A. S. 2003, ApJ, 583, 145 Gallimore, J. F., Baum, S. A., & O’Dea, C. P. 2004, ApJ, 613, 794 Ulvestad, J. S., & Wilson, A. S. 1984, ApJ, 285, 439 Giroletti, M., Taylor, G. B., & Giovannini, G. 2005, ApJ, 622, 178 Ulvestad, J. S., & Ho, L. C. 2001, ApJ, 562, L133 Hagiwara, Y. 2007, AJ, 133, 1176 Ulvestad, J. S., Wong, D. S., Taylor, G. B., Gallimore, J. F., & Ho, L. C. 2009, ApJ, 699, 626 Mundell, C. G. 2005, AJ, 130, 936 Ho, L. C., & Ulvestad, J. S. 2001, ApJS, 133, 77 Wrobel, J. M., & Ho, L. C. 2006, ApJ, 646, L95 Kaspi, S., Smith, P. S., Netzer, H., Maoz, D., Jannuzi, B. T., & Yi, I., & Boughn, S. P. 1998, ApJ, 499, 198 Giveon, U. 2000, ApJ, 533, 631 Yuan, F., Markoff, S., & Falcke, H. 2002, A&A, 383, 854 Kukula, M. J., Pedlar, A., Baum, S. A., & O’Dea, C. P. 1995, MNRAS, 276, 1262 VLBI cores in Seyferts 5
TABLE 1 Log of observations
1.6 GHz observations 5 GHz observations Galaxy Date FWHM Date FWHM (mas × mas, ◦) (mas × mas, ◦) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) NGC 4051 2007 Jun 6 13.5 × 11.3, 19 2007 Jun 1 9.0 × 6.4, 50 NGC 4388 2008 Feb 28 26.1 × 20.9, 33 2008 Mar 10 4.2 × 1.3, 6 NGC 4501 2008 Feb 28 13.8 × 9.6, 2 2008 Mar 10 4.1 × 1.3, 6 NGC 5033 2007 Jun 6 11.1 × 6.2, −26 2007 Jun 1 5.0 × 3.5, 76 NGC 5273 2007 Jun 6 11.5 × 7.1, −24 2007 Jun 1 5.4 × 4.1, 70
Note. — Col. (1): galaxy name. Col. (2): date of 1.6 GHz observa- tion. Col. (3): beam size and orientation at 1.6 GHz. Col. (4): date of 5 GHz observation. Col. (5): beam size and orientation at 5 GHz.
TABLE 2 EVN observational results and model fit parameters
5 Galaxy RA (J2000) Dec. (J2000) Size1.6, PA1.6 S1.6 Size5, PA5 S5 α1.6 TB (hms) (◦ ′ ′′) (mas × mas, ◦) (mJy) (mas × mas, ◦) (mJy) (K) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) NGC 4051 12 03 09.6102 +44 31 52.678 24.8 × 8.8, 26◦ 0.45 ± 0.05 < 8.2 × 7.5, 61◦ 0.20 ± 0.02 0.7 ± 0.1 > 1.8 × 105 ··· 12 03 09.6504 +44 31 52.848 24.3 × 15.4, 71◦ 0.73 ± 0.07 ······ ··· 12 03 09.5700 +44 31 52.572 29.1 × 10.3, 81◦ 0.67 ± 0.07 ······ NGC 4388 12 25 46.7814 +12 39 43.768 15.0 × 5.9, 12◦ 1.32 ± 0.13 ··· < 0.55a > 0.7 1.3 × 106 NGC 4501 12 31 59.1529 +14 25 13.169 < 11.2 × 7.5, −5◦ 0.73 ± 0.07 ··· < 0.33a > 0.6 > 5.5 × 106 NGC 5033 13 13 27.4711 +36 35 37.924 < 5.6 × 5.8, 19◦ 0.68 ± 0.07 < 3.0 × 3.0, −42◦ 0.76 ± 0.08 −0.1 ± 0.1 > 1.3 × 107
Note. — Col. (1): galaxy name. Col. (2, 3): absolute coordinates of radio position. Col. (4): size and position angle (PA) at 1.6 GHz. Col. (5): flux density at 1.6 GHz. Col. (6): size and PA at 5 GHz. Col. (7): flux density at 5 GHz. Col. (8): spectral index between 1.6 and 5 GHz. Col. (9): brightness temperature. a The 5 GHz upper limits for NGC 4388 and NGC 4501 are 3σ rms noise levels measured on images with the same resolution of the 1.6 GHz ones
TABLE 3 Properties of the Seyfert galaxies
Galaxy D Class Log P1.6 Log L1.6 Log L5 Log LX Log L5/LX Log LX/LEdd Log MBH Log RS −1 −1 −1 −1 (Mpc) (W Hz ) (ergs s ) (ergs s ) (ergs s ) (M⊙) (pc) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) NGC 4051 9.3 S1.2 18.7 34.9 35.0 40.8 −5.80 −3.41 6.11 −6.89 NGC 4388 16.7 S1.9 19.6 35.8 <35.7 41.7 < −6.06 −3.17 6.80 −6.20 NGC 4501 16.8 S1.9 19.4 35.6 <35.4 39.6 < −4.21 −6.39 7.90 −5.10 NGC 5033 18.7 S1.5 19.4 35.7 36.2 41.1 −4.90 −4.31 7.30 −5.70 NGC 5273 16.5 S1.5 <18.5 <34.7 <35.4 41.4 < −6.02 −3.24 6.51 −6.49
Note. — Col. (1): galaxy name. Col. (2): galaxy distance. Col. (3): optical classification. Col. (4): monochromatic power at 1.6 GHz. Col. (5): luminosity at 1.6 GHz. Col. (6): luminosity at 5 GHz. Col. (7): X-ray 2-10 keV luminosity. Col. (8): ratio of radio to X-ray luminosity. Col. (9): ratio of X-ray to Eddington luminosity. Col. (10): black hole mass. Col. (11): Schwarzschild radius. Data in cols. (2), (3), (7) and (10) are taken from Panessa et al. (2007), except for NGC 4051, whose distance is from Barbosa et al. (2006). 6 Giroletti & Panessa
44 31 54.0 44 32 05 44 35
VLA D, 1.4 GHz VLA A, 1.4 GHz 53.5 VLA A, 8.4 GHz 34 00
33 53.0 31 55 32
31 52.5 50 DECLINATION (J2000) DECLINATION (J2000) DECLINATION (J2000) 30 52.0 45 29
28 51.5 40 12 03 30 25 20 15 10 05 00 02 55 50 12 03 10.5 10.0 09.5 09.0 08.5 12 03 09.70 09.65 09.60 09.55 09.50 RIGHT ASCENSION (J2000) RIGHT ASCENSION (J2000) RIGHT ASCENSION (J2000)
44 31 52.95 52.90 52.85 EVN, 1.6 GHz 52.80 52.75 52.70 52.65
DECLINATION (J2000) 52.60 52.55 52.50 12 03 09.65 09.64 09.63 09.62 09.61 09.60 09.59 09.58 09.57 RIGHT ASCENSION (J2000)
Fig. 1.— NGC 4051. Top panels are VLA data at increasing resolution from a reanalysis of archival data taken on March 1995 (left), August 1999 (middle), and June 1991 (right); lowest contour and peak brightness are (1.1, 23.5), (0.4, 6.5), and (0.2, 0.7) mJy beam−1, respectively. Bottom panel: our EVN image at 1.6 GHz, with contours traced at (−3, 3, 5, 10) × 34 µJy beam−1.