Love the Stranger for You Were Strangers: the Development of a Biblical Literary Theme and Motif Helga Kisler Marquette University
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Marquette University e-Publications@Marquette Dissertations (2009 -) Dissertations, Theses, and Professional Projects Love the Stranger for You were Strangers: The Development of a Biblical Literary Theme and Motif Helga Kisler Marquette University Recommended Citation Kisler, Helga, "Love the Stranger for You were Strangers: The eD velopment of a Biblical Literary Theme and Motif" (2016). Dissertations (2009 -). 676. http://epublications.marquette.edu/dissertations_mu/676 LOVE THE STRANGER FOR YOU WERE STRANGERS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF A BIBLICAL LITERARY THEME AND MOTIF by Helga Kisler, B.A., M.A. A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School, Marquette University, in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Milwaukee, Wisconsin December 2016 ABSRACT LOVE THE STRANGER FOR YOU WERE STRANGERS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF A BIBLICAL LITERARY THEME AND MOTIF Helga Kisler, B.A., M.A. Marquette University, 2016 The Hebrew Bible recounts the development of Israel’s self-identity as “Strangers and Sojourners” and their relationship with God and other Strangers. A significant passage that connects these relationships says that God “loves the Strangers…You shall also love the Stranger, for you were Strangers in the land of Egypt” (Deut 10:17-19). In the same book that commands love for the Stranger, God tells Israel to separate themselves from foreign nations in the land that they will occupy. In order to investigate an evident disparity concerning the relationship with the Stranger, this dissertation examines the literary motif of the Stranger and the theme of God’s love for the Stranger in the Torah/Pentateuch, as well as the Book of Ruth, by looking at the different representations of the Stranger and how the motif developed with both positive (gēr) and negative implications (nēkār, and zār). The love command in Deuteronomy 10:17-19 specifically concerns the Stranger who is a sojourner (gēr), evoking Israel’s collective memory as sojourners in order to inspire their empathy and compassion. On the other hand, the Stranger who is foreign (nēkār) evokes fear and enmity. The Book of Ruth acts as a commentary on the negative perceptions of the foreigner in the Torah/Pentatuech by serving as an example of love from a Stranger. Ruth gives new meaning to the love command by broadening the sphere of compassion to include the Strangers who are traditionally viewed as foreign threats or enemies. While other research generally focuses on a particular form of the Stranger, this study expands on the research by examining the occurrences of all three forms (gēr, nēkār, and zār) in order to understand the different levels of meaning connected to the Stranger and how that meaning is dependent on the historical context of the literature, the rhetorical and theological interests of the final redactors, and the methods of interpretation by later readers. i ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Helga Kisler, B.A., M.A. I owe a depth of gratitude to all those who have supported me on the long journey that led to the completion of this dissertation. To begin with, I would like to thank my dissertation director, Dr. Deirdre Dempsey, for her scholarly guidance and support through these years of research and writing, and for her continued encouragement and optimism when there seemed to be no end in sight. I would also like to recognize and thank the readers on my board: Dr. Sharon Pace, whose Hebrew Bible class introduced me to the “Art of Biblical Narrative” and whose scholarship concerning women in the Bible has been most helpful in my research; Dr. Andre Orlov, whose insights concerning the mystical aspects of the biblical literature broadened my theological perspectives; and Dr. Michael Duffey, whose guidance on Catholic social teaching and migration when I was preparing for my doctoral exams inspired the final chapter. I would like to recognize the support of my colleagues in the Theology department at Mount Mary University, Dr. Donald Rappé and Dr. Shawnee Daniels- Sykes, and former colleague, Dr. Jennifer Laske. Every encouragement in word, gesture, and prayer was greatly appreciated. I would also like to recognize and thank Dr. Mary Beth Duffey for her support and friendship in the years that I have known her as teacher, colleague, and friend. Above all, I want thank my family for their love and support. My mother, Maria, and my daughter, Brigitte, have both been my greatest sources of strength and inspiration and their love has carried me when I felt that I could not go on. I would also like to thank my son-in-law, Eugene, for his encouragement and offering of help with tech support. Last, but certainly not least, I am thankful to my grandson, Misha, for the love and joy that he brings into my life, and for cheering me on and cheering me up on those days when I needed it most. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS…………………………………………………………. i CHAPTER 1. LOVE THE STRANGER FOR YOU WERE STRANGERS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF A BIBLICAL LITERARY THEME AND MOTIF 1.1. Introduction: The Stranger as Other......................................... 1 1.1.2. The Command to Love the Stranger…....................... 3 1.2. The Stranger in the Hebrew Bible…………………………….. 4 1.2.1. Gwr/Gēr…………………………………................... 6 1.2.2. Nēkār/Nokrî……..........................................................7 1.2.3. Zwr/Zār ……............................................................... 8 1.3. Survey of Scholarly Research 1.3.1. Ethnicity and Identity………………………………... 10 1.3.2. The Stranger as Sojourner, Alien, and Foreigner…... 12 1.3.3. The Stranger as Biblical Literary Device…………… 14 1.4. Methodology 1.4.1. Giving Attention to the Other………………………... 16 1.4.2. Literary Analysis…………………………………….. 19 1.5. Thesis and Overview of Chapters……………………………... 22 2. THE STRANGER IN THE ANCESTOR NARRATIVES 2.1. Introduction…………………………………………………….25 iii 2.2. In the Beginning………………………………………………. 25 2. 3. God and the Stranger in the Ancestor Narratives..................... 28 2. 4. Abraham the Sojourner.............................................................. 29 2. 4. 1. Wife/Sister Tales…………………………………… 30 2. 4. 2. God’s Special Concern…………………………….. 33 2. 5. Hagar the Egyptian.................................................................... 34 2. 6. A Stranger and an Alien………………………………………. 38 2. 6. 1. Conflict with the Four Eastern Kings……………… 39 2. 6. 2. Conflict over a Well………………………………... 40 2. 7. Hospitality for the Stranger....................................................... 40 2. 7. 1. Abraham “keeps the way of YHWH”...……………..41 2. 7. 2. The Visitors in Sodom…............................................ 42 2. 8. Abraham purchases a Burial Ground….................................... 44 2. 9. The Descendants of Abraham………………………………… 46 2. 9. 1. Isaac and Rebekah…………………………………. 47 2. 9. 2. Jacob and Esau.......................................................... 48 2. 9. 3. Jacob’s sojourns with Laban………………………. 50 2. 9. 4. Return and Reconciliation…..................................... 52 2. 9. 5. Jacob’s Offspring…................................................... 54 2. 10. Joseph and the Sojourn to Egypt…......................................... 57 2. 11. Conclusion…........................................................................... 60 iv 3. THE STRANGER IN EXODUS 3. 1. Introduction……........................................................................66 3. 2. The Oppression of Abraham’s Descendants….......................... 68 3. 3. Birth, Endangerment, and Rescue of the Hero……………….. 71 3. 3. 1. The Flight to Midian……………………………….. 73 3. 3. 2. Encounter at a Well………………………………... 74 3. 4. God “sees” and “hears”……………………………………... 76 3. 4. 1. God Responds to Israel’s Cries……………………. 77 3. 4. 2. God Commissions Moses…………………………... 79 3. 5. Moses Returns to Egypt………………………………………. 82 3. 5. 1. Peril on the Journey………………………………... 83 3. 5. 2. Moses and Aaron assemble the Elders of Israel…… 85 3. 5. 3. Who is YHWH?.......................................................... 86 3. 5. 4. YHWH brings Israel out of Egypt………………….. 88 3. 6. Into the Wilderness…………………………………………… 93 3. 6. 1. Crossing the Sea…………………………………… 94 3. 6. 2. The Song of the Sea: Who is YHWH?....................... 96 3. 6. 3. Israel Complains and YHWH Responds…………… 97 3. 6. 4. The Battle with Amelek and the Meeting with Jethro……………………………………. 99 3. 7. The Revelation at Sinai……………………………………….. 102 3. 7. 1. The Sinai Covenant………………………………… 104 3. 7. 2. The Book of the Covenant………………………….. 105 3. 7. 3. Rebellion and Punishment…………………………. 111 v 3. 8. Conclusion: Neither Here nor There………………………… 115 4. THE STRANGER IN ISRAELITE LAW: LEVITICUS, NUMBERS, AND DEUTERONOMY 4. 1. Introduction……………………………………………………117 4. 2. The Stranger in Leviticus: Israel is camped at Mount Sinai… 118 4. 2. 1. The gēr in Leviticus………………………………… 121 4. 2. 2. Laws concerning the gēr…………………………… 122 4. 2. 3. Punishment concerning the gēr……………………. 126 4. 2. 4. Provisions concerning the gēr……………………... 127 4. 2. 5. Love the gēr…………………………………………129 4. 2. 6. The tôšāb in Leviticus……………………………… 131 4. 2. 7. The nokrî in Leviticus……………………………….133 4. 2. 8. The zār in Leviticus………………………………… 134 4. 3. The Stranger in Numbers: Israel is in on the Move………….. 135 4. 3. 1. Insiders/Outsiders among Fellow Israelites……….. 136 4. 3. 2. The gēr in Numbers………………………………… 140 4. 3. 3. The zār in Numbers………………………………… 142 4. 3. 4. The Stranger as Foreign Nations…………………... 143 4. 4. The Stranger in Deuteronomy: Israel is on the edge of the Promised Land………………………………...146