Coral Reef Monitoring in Kofiau and Boo Islands Marine Protected Area, Raja Ampat, West Papua. 2009—2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
August 2012 Indo-Pacific Division Indonesia Report No 6/12 Coral Reef Monitoring in Kofiau and Boo Islands Marine Protected Area, Raja Ampat, West Papua. 2009—2011 Report Compiled By: Purwanto, Muhajir, Joanne Wilson, Rizya Ardiwijaya, and Sangeeta Mangubhai August 2012 Indo-Pacific Division Indonesia Report No 6/12 Coral Reef Monitoring in Kofiau and Boo Islands Marine Protected Area, Raja Ampat, West Papua. 2009—2011 Report Compiled By: Purwanto, Muhajir, Joanne Wilson, Rizya Ardiwijaya, and Sangeeta Mangubhai Published by: TheNatureConservancy,Indo-PacificDivision Purwanto:TheNatureConservancy,IndonesiaMarineProgram,Jl.Pengembak2,Sanur,Bali, Indonesia.Email: [email protected] Muhajir: TheNatureConservancy,IndonesiaMarineProgram,Jl.Pengembak2,Sanur,Bali, Indonesia.Email: [email protected] JoanneWilson: TheNatureConservancy,IndonesiaMarineProgram,Jl.Pengembak2,Sanur,Bali, Indonesia. RizyaArdiwijaya:TheNatureConservancy,IndonesiaMarineProgram,Jl.Pengembak2,Sanur, Bali,Indonesia.Email: [email protected] SangeetaMangubhai: TheNatureConservancy,IndonesiaMarineProgram,Jl.Pengembak2, Sanur,Bali,Indonesia.Email: [email protected] Suggested Citation: Purwanto,Muhajir,Wilson,J.,Ardiwijaya,R.,Mangubhai,S.2012.CoralReefMonitoringinKofiau andBooIslandsMarineProtectedArea,RajaAmpat,WestPapua.2009-2011.TheNature Conservancy,Indo-PacificDivision,Indonesia.ReportN,6/12.50pp. © 2012012012201 222 The Nature Conservancy AllRightsReserved.Reproductionforanypurposeisprohibitedwithoutpriorpermission. AllmapsdesignedandcreatedbyMuhajir. CoverPhoto: Datacollectionactivity©Purwanto/TNC Availablefrom: IndonesiaMarineProgram Asia-PacificResourceCentre TheNatureConservancy TheNatureConservancy Jl.Pengembak2 245RiversideDrive Sanur80228,Bali WestEnd,QLD4101 Indonesia Australia Orviatheworldwidewebat: www.nature.or.id www.conservationgateway.org/ vii Acknowledgements TheauthorswouldliketothankAndreasMuljadi,ReinhartPaatandMarkusKrey,who participatedinthe2009and2010monitoring,andKofiauresidentsNaftaliManggaraand NicoMambraku,whoactivelyparticipatedinthereefhealthmonitoringinKofiauandBoo IslandsMarineProtectedArea.WewouldalsoliketothanktheRajaAmpatFisheriesand MarineAffairsAgency(DinasPerikanandanKelautan )andtheWestPapuaNature ResourceConservationAgency(BalaiBesarKonservasiSumberDayaAlam )whoarealso supportthemonitoring.SpecialthankstoDariusAronggearandUsielWatem,whoin additiontodrivingthespeedboat Jou ,frequentlyhelpedlaytransectswhencollectingdata. WearegratefultoAlisonGreenwhoprovidedextensivefeedbackandtrainingonfishdata analyses.Lastly,wewouldliketothankourdonors,inparticulartheWaltonFamily Foundationandprivatedonorswhosegeneroussupportallowedthesemonitoringactivitiesto beundertaken. viii Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS .................................................................................................................... VIII CONTENTS .............................................................................................................................................. IX LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................................................... X 1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 1 2. METHODS ......................................................................................................................................... 2 2.1. Kofiau Marine Protected Area ...........................................................................................................2 2.2. Zoning plan ...............................................................................................................................................2 2.3. Location and site selection ...................................................................................................................2 2.4. Reef Health monitoring – fish and benthic communities .........................................................2 2.4.1. Fish community surveys ............................................................................................................................ 3 2.4.2. Benthic community surveys ....................................................................................................................... 4 2.4.3. Data analysis – comparing zones.............................................................................................................. 5 2.5. Location and site selection ................................................................................................................... 5 2.5.1. Field surveys .............................................................................................................................................. 5 2.5.2. Data analyses ............................................................................................................................................ 6 2.6. Surface water temperature .................................................................................................................. 6 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ............................................................................................ 9 3.1. Fish communities ................................................................................................................................... 9 3.1.1. Fish biomass by location and monitoring year ........................................................................................... 9 3.1.2. Fish communities in each zone ................................................................................................................. 12 3.1.3. Differences among zones for select families of fish ................................................................................... 14 3.1.4. Fish biomass, density and families recorded during long swims ................................................................. 15 3.1.5. Sharks and rays ....................................................................................................................................... 16 3.2. Benthic cover .......................................................................................................................................... 17 3.2.1. Benthic composition of reef communities in Kofiau MPA ...................................................................... 17 3.2.2. Benthic community composition by zone type ..........................................................................................19 3.2.3. Coral bleaching ....................................................................................................................................... 20 3.3. Surface water temperature ................................................................................................................ 23 4. CONCLUSIONS ...................................................................................................................... 26 5. RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................................................................................... 27 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................................... 28 APPENDICES ............................................................................................................................................ 30 ix List of Figures Figure 1. Map of coral reef health monitoring locations and designated zones in Kofiau Marine Protected Area. Site pengamatan tambahan = Additional Site, Site pengamatan tetap = permanent site. .................................................................................................................................................. 7 Figure 2. The average biomass (kg/ha) and density (number/ha) of fish from all sites around Kofiau and Boo Islands from 2009-2011. Error bars = standard error. .....................................................10 Figure 3. Average fish biomass (kg/ha +SE) by location in Kofiau and Boo Islands in all monitoring years. Large schools of fish of the family Caesionidae in Lampu Bay and Tomna in 2010 are not included. .....................................................................................................................................................10 Figure 4. Biomass (kg/ha) of all families of fish in each survey year 2009-2011 at Kofiau Marine Protected Area. Error bars = standard error. .......................................................................................... 11 Figure 5. Average fish biomass (kg/ha) and density (number/ha) for sites in each zone of Kofiau Marine Protected Area from 2009-2011. Error bars = standard error. ....................................... 13 Figure 6. Annual average biomass of most important fish families in Kofiau MPA between no take and use zones, from 2009-2011. These fish are important to local communities as a source of food or income – grouper, emperor, sweetlip, snapper, pelagic and/or important to the ecology of the reef (i.e. herbivore families surgeonfish, rabbitfish and parrotfish). The zones were designated and became locally enforced in October 2011, after the March 2011 monitoring. Error bars = standard error. ................................................................................................ 15 Figure 7. Average fish biomass (kg/ha +SE) and density (individuals/ha +SE) in all locations and all monitoring years.............................................................................................................................................