KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE Western Cape, South Africa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT KERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE Western Cape, South Africa STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT PROCESS REPORT COMPILED BY FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DATE: DECEMBER 2019 FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 1 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE TABLE OF CONTENTS NR HEADING PAGE i) Copyright and disclaimer 4 ii) Tables 5 iii) List of figures 5 iv) List of Appendices 5 v) Abbreviations 6 1 BACKGROUND 7 2 THE PROCESS OF STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT 10 3 INTERESTED AND AFFECTED PARTIES 12 3.1 Database of key stakeholders 12 4 NOTIFICATION OF STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT PROCESS 12 4.1 Development of the communications material 12 4.2 Notifications sent via e-mail and agendas 13 4.3 Notification posted on the CapeNature Web-site 13 4.4 Notification in local newspapers 14 5 DRAFT PROTECTED AREA MANAGEMENT PLAN (DPAMP) 15 5.1 Availability of the Draft Plan 15 6 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT MEETINGS 17 6.1 Logistical arrangements 17 6.2 Presentation 18 6.3 Attendance at the meetings 18 6.4 Minutes of the stakeholder meetings 19 FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 2 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE 6.5 Confirmation of the correctness of stakeholder meeting minutes 26 7 COMMENTS AND RESPONSES 29 7.1 Comments from general public 29 7.2 Comments from the external reviewer 30 8 CONCLUSION AND KEY RECOMMENDATIONS 56 9 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT 56 10 REFERENCE 56 FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 3 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE i) Copyright and Disclaimer Copyright in this information vests with FOOTPRINT Environmental Services (FES) and the unauthorised copying thereof or making of extracts thereof is illegal. Any representation, statement opinion, or advice expressed or implied in this document is made in good faith on the basis that FES , its agents and employees are not liable (whether by reason of negligence, lack of care or otherwise) to any person for any damage or loss whatsoever which has occurred or may occur in relation to that person taking or not taking (as the case may be) action in respect of any representation, statement or advice referred to above. Although the greatest care has been taken to ensure that all mapping data is up to date and spatially accurate, FES gives no warranty, express or implied, as to the accuracy, reliability, utility or completeness of this data. Users of the data in this report assume all responsibility and risk for use of the data. The User expressly acknowledges and agrees that use of the data and information contained in these pages is at the User's sole risk. The data and information contained in these pages are provided "as is" and no warranties are made that the data and information contained in these pages will meet your requirements, is complete or free from error. In no event shall FES be liable for any damages whatsoever (including, but not limited to, damages for loss of business profits, loss of business information, or other pecuniary loss) arising out of the use of, or inability to use, the data and information contained in this report. FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 4 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE ii) Tables 1 Description of activities completed for each phase 11 2 Minutes of the stakeholder meeting at Vredendal 19 3 Response to additional points received 26 4 Comments from the general public 30 5 Inputs and comments from the external reviewer 53 iii) List of figures 1 Knersvlakte Nature Reserve – Extent and Locality Map 9 2 Process of Stakeholder Engagement 10 3 DPAMP’s distributed at various locations 15 4 Participants at the stakeholder meeting in Vrendedal 18 iv) List of Appendices 1 Stakeholder database 2 Notification (English and Afrikaans) 3 Proof of notification sent via e-mail 4 Notification in local newspapers 5 Attendance Register : Stakeholder Meetings 6 Presentation at the stakeholder meetings 7 Draft minutes notifications & inputs from the participants 8 Comments received (18 th November 2019 – 15 th December 2019) 9 General overview by the external reviewer FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 5 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE v) Abbreviations CPA Communal Property Association DEA Department of Environmental Affairs DEFF Department of Environment, Forestry and Fisheries DPAMP Draft Protected Area Management Plan DRDL Department of Rural Development and Land Reform DMR Department of Mineral Resources FES FOOTPRINT Environmental Services I&AP Interested and Affected Parties KNR Knersvlakte Nature Reserve MoA Memorandum of Agreement NEM:PAA National Environment: Protected Areas Act No. 57 of 2003 NGO Non-Governmental Organisation NRUG Natural Resources User Group PA Protected Area PAAC Protected Area Advisory Committee PAMP Protected Area Management Plan SANDF South African National Defence Force SEP Stakeholder Engagement Process FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 6 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE 1. BACKGROUND The Knersvlakte Nature Reserve falls within the Western Cape Province of South Africa, and is 20 km north of Vanrhynsdorp, approximately 320 km north of Cape Town. The reserve is in a state of development and not all land portions are currently consolidated. The planning scope of the Knersvlakte Nature Reserve covers an area of 90 057 ha, made up of 32 land portions, all (except one portion, Uitspanrug) was proclaimed as a provincial nature reserve terms of section 23(1) of the National Environmental Management: Protected Areas Act, 2003 (Act No. 57 of 2003) (NEM: PAA), on the 12 th September 2014 (Proclamation No.10/2014, Provincial Gazette No. 7307). All land parcels are owned by the World Wide Fund for Nature - South Africa and managed by CapeNature as part of a notarial lease and management agreement. The Succulent Karoo Biome is one of 25 internationally recognised biodiversity hotspots and is the world’s only arid hotspot. Within the Succulent Karoo Biome there are four centres of endemism, of which the Knersvlakte Bioregion is one. The reserve harbours 10 vegetation units with a rich diversity of plants, notably miniature succulents; most of which are highly endemic and many of conservation concern. Apart from the plant and associated animal diversity, the area is also rich in cultural historical heritage. To comply with the National Environment: Protected Areas Act No. 57 of 2003 (NEM:PAA), CapeNature is required to develop a Protected Area Management Plan (PAMP) for the KNR. The purpose of the PAMP is aligned to Section 17 of NEM:PAA “which is “to protect ecologically viable areas representative of South Africa’s biological diversity and its natural landscapes and seascapes in a system of protected areas”. In developing the PAMP for the KNR, CapeNature is striving to achieve the stated vision of ““To protect, promote and enhance the unique landscape, succulent plant diversity, wildlife and cultural heritage of the arid Knersvlakte corridor, through partnership, and respect and care to benefit future generations”. Section 39(3) of the NEM:PAA states that when preparing a management plan for a protected area, the management authority concerned must consult municipalities, other FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 7 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE organs of state, local communities and other affected parties which have an interest in the area. Cedarberg Conservation Services (t/a FOOTPRINT Environmental Services) (FES) were appointed by CapeNature in November 2019 to facilitate the Stakeholder Engagement Process for the KNR. The Stakeholder Engagement Process was initiated on the 14 th November 2019 and was concluded on the 15 th December 2019. FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 8 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT KERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE Figure 1 – Knersvlakte Nature Reserve – Extent & Site Locality Map (CapeNature 2019). FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 9 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT KERSVLAKTE NATURE RESERVE 2. THE PROCESS OF STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT CapeNature has adapted the South African National Parks (SANParks), Stakeholder Participation (SP) process in Developing Park Management Plans. Section 39(3) of the National Environmental Management: Protected Areas Act, (Act No. 57 of 2003) states that when preparing a management plan for a protected area, the management authority concerned must consult municipalities, other organs of state, local communities and other affected parties which have an interest in the area. Section 41(2) (e) requires that the Management Plan contains procedures for public participation, including participation by the owner (if applicable), any local community or other interested party. Figure 2 : Process of Stakeholder Engagement All stakeholders must register for the process and sign the attendance registers for workshops and meetings, records of participants must be kept at all times. Additional individuals, wishing to participate in the process, must register as stakeholders and must be accommodated to ensure that the process is as inclusive as practically possible. Figure 2 shows the stakeholder participation strategy and approval process for CapeNature Protected Areas Management Plans. Any persons having direct or indirect interest or rights in a nature reserve may be considered a stakeholder. The stakeholder process will facilitate the establishment of a comprehensive Protected Area Advisory Committee (PAAC). FOOTPRINT ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES Page 10 STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT REPORT: KNERSVLAKTE