SOCIETY FOR FRENCH HISTORICAL STUDIES OFFICERS AND EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

Keith Michael Baker, , Co-President

Carolyn Lougee Chappell, Stanford University, Co-Presideni Society for French

Jeremy Popkin, University of Kentucky, Executive Director

Sylvia Schafer, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Vice Historical Studies President

B. Robert Kreiser, George Mason University/American 51S T ANNUAL MEETING Association of University Professors, Financial Officer Stan ford University • 17-19 March 2005 Jo Burr Margadant, Santa Clara University, FHS Editor

Ted Margadant, University of California, Davis, FHS Editor

David Kammerling Smith, Eastern Illinois University. H-France Representative Lenard R. Berlanstein, University of Virginia, Past 1 SCHEDULE OF EVENTS Director

Nancy Green, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociak-s. Para. Events take place in Lane History Corner unless First Past Co-President otherwise indicated

Edward Berenson, , First Past Co-President Thursday, March 17 Jeffrey Merrick, University of Wisconsin, Milwaul Co-President REGISTRATION Julius Ruff, Marquette University, Second Past Co-President 7:00-9:00 pm Laura Mason, University of Georgia, Member At Large Sh eraton Palo Alto, Lobby Sarah Farmer, University of California, Irvine. Meir.rver Ai WELCOMING RECEPTION Lynne Taylor, University of Waterloo, Member Ai Large 7:30-10:00 pm Sh eraton Palo Alto Cash bar Co-sponsored by the Stanford History Department

LIBRARY EXHIBIT

Fac e t s of French History: Primary Sources m Stanford's Library Collections

Peterson Gallery, Bing Wing 2nd Floor. Green Lin (Enter Green Library by door facing the Quad)

Front cover: A "Burgher of Calais" from rhe Stanford Rodir Stanford News Service Friday, March 18 Elisabeth Claire, New York University Revolution of the Dancing Couple: Suspended in the Pleasure of Vertigo MORNING COFFEE 7:45-10:45 am Remi Hess, Universite de Paris VIII Wallenberg Hall LEcriture du soi, faire des traces Hosted by Duke University Press

1C: Liberty and Slavery in Eighteenth-Century REGISTRATION AND BOOK EXHIBIT 8:00 am-5:00 pm French Thought Lane 30 Wallenberg Hall Chair: Sue Peabody, Washington State University

Steph en Auerbach, University of Nevada, Reno SESSION ONE 8:30-10:15 am La traite des esclaves et la lumiere du commerce Matthew Adkins, University of Dayton Science and Polity: Responses to Charles The Liberal Apprenticeship: Antislavery and Condorcet's Coulston Gillispie Revolutionary Ideology Lane 2 Jeremy D. Popkin, University of Kentucky Chair: Keith Michael Baker, Stanford Universitv Nation, Empire, and Slavery: The Debate over Colonial

Dorinda Outram, University of Rochester Representation in the National Assembly, June-July 1789 State, Community, and Science During the French Comment: Alyssa Sepinwall, California State Revolution University, San Marcos Roger Hahn, University of California, Berkeley

The Institutionalization of French Science ID: Revisiting the H i s t o r y of Feminism in

Jed Buchwald, California Institute of Technology- France, 1900-1930s Lane 34 Fren ch Mathematics and Experiment under the New Regime Chair: Claire Moses, University of Maryland, J.B. Shank, University of Minnesota College Park Scien ce and Polity and Political Culture since 1980: An Assessment Karen Offen, Stanford University "Fran ce's Foremost Feminist" or Who in the World is Comment: Charles Coulston Gillispie, Princeton Madame Avril de Sainte-Croix? University Lenard R. Berlanstein, University of Virginia The Most Important Feminist Publication of the Belle IB: Fragment, suspension, trace: forme et Epoque? mouvement de I'impact de la Revolution a la peripheric Mary Lynn Stewart, Simon Fraser University Lane 202 Hybrid Feminisms in the Interwar Fashion Press

Chair and Comment: William Weber, California Scare Comment: Linda Clark, Millersville University University, Long Beach

Charlotte Hess, Universite de Paris VIII Les romantiques d'lena aujourd'hui: aux risques du fragmem

2 IE: Colonial Sciences, Colonial Silences: New 1G: Finance, Economics, and W a r Preparations, Readings of Imperial Knowledge 1900-1945 Lane 305 Lane 303

Chair: Michael Miller, University of Miami Chair and Comment: Simon Kitson, University of Birmin gh am Caroline Ford, University of California, Los Angeles "Reboisem en t, colonisation, et civilisation": Martin Horn, McMaster University Environmental Knowledges in Colonial France Fren ch Financial Preparations for War before the First World War Alice Conklin, Ohio State University What is Colonial Science? Anthropology at the Margins Andrew Barros, Universite du Quebec, Montreal in Interwar France Reparations and the Economic Potential for War: French Alice Bullard, Georgia Institute of Technology Assessments of the German Economy, 1919—1925 Imperial Networks and the Pursuit of In depen den ce: Martin Thomas, University of Exeter The Transition from Colonial to Transcultural Psychiatry The French Empire and the Approach of War, 1936—1939 in Senegal Talbot Imlay, Universite Laval, Quebec Comment: Kapil Raj, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Fren ch Financial Preparations for War before the Second Scien ces Sociales World War

IF: Useful Icons: Transatlantic 1H: Mistresses, Bastards, and t h e P o l i t i c s of Representations of French and American Royal Sex Public Figures in t h e T w e n t i e t h Century Lane 205 Lane 303 Chair and Comment: Dena Goodman, University of Chair: Isser W oloch, Michigan Scott Gunther, Wellesley College Katherine Crawford, Vanderbilt University Representations of Jean-Paul Sartre in The New York Fren ch Bastards and the Problem of Early Modern Times, 1945-1964 Subjectivity Dominique Laurent, Dickinson College Kathleen Wellman, Southern Methodist University Woodrow Wilson in the French Political Press during the Political Discourse and the Royal Mistress Paris Peace Conference, December 1918—June 1919 Thomas E. Kaiser, University of Arkansas Joh n Hill, Immaculata College The Royal Mistress as Diplomat: Madame de Pompadour "A n able, forceful man and I think also a sincere man": and the Reversal of Alliances of 1756 Pierre Laval in American Eyes, 1931—1945

Comment: Christopher Chiwis, Johns Hopkins University

> < < a a K LL. L L SESSION TWO Richard Fogarty, Bridgewater College 10:45 am-12:30 pm Race and Sex in France during the Great War: Colonial Soldiers, European Women, and Imperial Rule 2A: The State of French Revolutionary Jen n ifer E. Sessions, University of Pennsylvania Historiography The Honor, the Horror: Militarism and Masculinity in Lane 2 the Conquest of Algeria Chair: Ted Margadant, University of California, Davis Comment: Jean E. Pedersen, University of Rochester Jean -Clemen t Martin, Universite de Paris I Les multiples dimensions de la Revolution frangaise: a la 2D: The " N e w H i s t o r i e s " and Political recherche de leurs interactions Commitments of Aries, Roupnel and F a y Comments: Lynn Hunt, University of California, Lane 203 Los Angeles and Timothy Tackett, University of Chair: Jo B. Margadant, Santa Clara University California, Irvine Philip Whalen, Coastal Carolina University The Polemics of Folk Regionalism in Inter-War France 2B: Protestants under Louis XIV: Census, Survival, Prophecy Patrick Hutton, University of Vermont Lane 202 Philippe Aries on the Margins of the Annales

Chair: Carol L. Loats, Colorado State University, Pueblo Joh n L. Harvey, St. Cloud State University Bernard Fay and the Birth of American Studies in France Robert B. Scafe, Stanford University Counting Protestants: Fenelon, the Huguenots, and the Comment: Edward Berenson, New York University Politics of Population

Christine Sample W ilson , St. Edward's Universitv 2E: Creating Outsiders: The Practice of Staying Protestant: A Strategy for Surviving the Reign of Exclusion in Interwar and W o r l d War II France Louis XIV Lane 34

Gregory Monahan, Eastern Oregon University Chair: Michelle K. Rhoades, Wabash College Are These People Crazy? Protestant Prophets after the Julie Fette, University of Maryland-Baltimore County Revocation Xenophobia and Exclusion in the Professions in Interwar Comment: Keith Luria, North Carolina State Universitv Fran ce

Nicole Dombrowski Risser, Towson University 2C: The Gender of Imperialism: Race and S e x Refugees Struggle to Survive in Free France, 1940—1941 i n France and I t s Colonies Sh an n on L. Fogg, University of Missouri, Rolla Lane 30 The Youngest Refugees: Children, Daily Life, and Chair: Barry H. Bergen, Gallaudet University Material Shortages during the Second World War

Carolyn J. Eichner, University of South Florida Comment: Cheryl A. Koos, California State Fem in ism , Race, and Agency: Portrayals of African and University, Los Angeles Asian Women in La Citoyenne, 1881-1891 2F: Managing Immigrants during the Trente Roundtable: Glorieuses Marie-France Wagner, Concordia University, Montreal Lane 205 Joh n Nassichuk, University of Western Ontario Daniel Vaillancourt, University of Western Ontario Chair: Amelia Lyons, Claremont McKenna College Comment: Michael Wintroub, University of Jim Miller, University of Chicago California, Berkeley Managing the Exploitation of Tradition in the "Modern' Moselle: Regional Elites, Immigration, and the i Desirability of Difference CHEQN Todd Shepard, University of Oklahoma 1 1:00-2:30 pm Turning Repatriates into "Harkis": Applying Repatriate Oak Lounge, Tresidder Union Status during the 1962 "Exodus"from Algeria Presiding: Carolyn Lougee Chappell, Stanford Jean n ette Miller, Pennsylvania State University University, Co-President Actions "non-glorieuses": The Encampment of the Speaker: Annette Becker, Universite de Paris X "Hark ies" during the Trente Glorieuses, 1962—1975 The Great War in the Twentieth Century Comment: Sarah Sussman, Stanford University

2G: Philosophy, Religion, and National Identity i n Nineteenth-Century France Lane 303

Chair and Comment: Jonathan Beecher, University of 3A: Celebrating the 2 5 0 t h Anniversary of California, Santa Cruz Rousseau's Second Discourse Lane 203 Edward Castleton, The Camargo Foundation How the French Discovered Common Sense: Pierre-Joseph Chair: Mark Hulliung, Brandeis University Proudhon James Miller, New School University Ellen Astrid Koehler, University of California, The Abyss of Philosophy: Rousseau's Concept of Freedom Los Angeles Christopher Kelly, Boston College Reappropriating Pascal in Mid-Nineteenth-Century Rousseau's "peut-etre": Reflections on the Status of the Fran ce State of Nature Edmund Burke, III, University of California, Santa Cruz Helena Rosenblatt, Hunter College Tocqueville/Beaumont and MarxlEngels on Algeria and Rousseau's "Gift" of the Second Discourse Ireland: A Comparative Historical Perspective Robert Wbkler, Yale University Rousseau's Reading of the Book of Genesis and the 2H: The Canadian Project for t h e S t u d y and Theology of Commercial Society Publishing of L e s p e c t a c l e de pouvoir: les Entrees solennelles des Rois dans les villes Comment: The Audience francaises au XVIeme siecle Lane 305

Chair: Lawrence M. Bryant, California State University, Chico 8 S 3B3B:^ . Absolutism and Society Twenty Years 3D: Status as a Category of Analysis from the Later: The Past, Present, and Future of Old Regime to t h e T h i r d Republic Absolutism Lane 30 Lane 34 Chair: Terence Murphy, American University in Paris Chair: Mark Potter, University of Wyoming Gail Bossenga, College of William and Mary Roundtable: Why Do We Need Status as a Category of Analysis in the Sarah Chapman, Oakland University Old Regime? Joh n J. Hurt, University of Delaware Christine Adams, St. Mary's College of Maryland Guy Rowlands, University of Durham Citizenship, Status, and Sex: Female Philanthropy in David Kammerling Smith, Eastern Illinois University Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century France William Beik, Emory University Laurence H. Winnie, Rochester Institute of Technology Comment: The Audience Moral Critique and Status in Modern France

Comment: Katharine Norris, American University 3C: Ideologies and M o d e s of Intellectual Engagement Lane 305 3E: In the W a k e of Liberation: Recriminations and New Departures Chair: Hines Hall, Auburn University Lane 2 K. Steven Vincent, North Carolina State University Chair: J. P. Daughton, Stanford University Benjamin Constant and the Politics of Intellectual Engagement Joh n Kim Munholland, University of Minnesota The Gravediggers of France at the Ch&teau d'ltter, Paul Mazgaj, University of North Carolina, Greensboro 1943-1945 The Maurrassian Mystique: Nationalist Engagement and the "Generation of1930" Isser W oloch, Columbia University Left, Right, and Center: The MRP in the Postwar Moment Sean Kennedy, University of New Brunswick Establishment Engagement: Andre Siegfried and the Guillaume Piketty, Institut d'Etudes Politiques Promotion of Liberalism The Free French and the Challenge of Liberation

Comment: Samuel Kalman, St. Francis Xavier Brun o Cabanes, Universite de Limoges University The Aftermath of War: Perspectives of Research

Comment: The Audience

10 11 1 3F: Cosmopolitanism in Construction 3H: Selling Science, Pushing Hygiene Lane 303 Lane 205

Chair and Comment: Lloyd Kramer, University of Chair and Comment: Mary Pickering, San Jose State North Carolina, Chapel Hill University

Ihor Junyk, Trent University Christine Blondel, CNRS Eastern European Emigres and the Neoclassical Revival Wonders, Prodigies, and Tricks in Eighteenth-Century in Interwar Paris Experimental Physics

Nancy L. Green, Ecoles des Hautes Etudes en Scien ces Cherilyn Lacy, Hartwick College Sociales Name Your Poison: Advertising, Education, and American Colony or Cosm opolitan Elite? Paris, Medicine in Nineteenth-Century France 1880-1940 Lori Weintrob, Wagner College Mobilizing Healthy Citizens: Art, Hygiene Manuals, and

3G: Reshaping Gender Politics Insurance Lane 202 Eileen S. DeMarco, Georgetown University Chair and Comment: Rachel Fuchs, Arizona State Cultural Police: The Colportage Commission and University Hachette's Bibliotheque des Chemins de Fer Matthew D. Gerber, University of Colorado, Boulder "N Bastards and Foun dlin gs in the Discourse of En ligh t en ed (RECEPTION] Reform: the Case of the Academy ofMetz Essay •>30-8:U0"pm Competition of 1786 Iris and B. Gerald Cantor Center for Visual Arts

Laura S. Schor, City University of New York Co-Hosted by the French Consulate, San Francisco The Societe pour I'etablissement des jeunes files Israelites and the School of H u m a n i t i e s and Sciences, Stanford

Gil Mihealy, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales Virility and Authority: Army and Masculinity in France from the Restoration to th e Third Republic

Magali Delia Sudda, Ecole Normale Superieure The Ligue patriotique des francaises and the Italian 1 Unione fra le donne cattoliche d'ltalia: A Conservative i Response to Women's Exclusion from "Citizenship", a 1902-1930 ^ -

12 13

Y / FRIDA ; r Saturday, March 19 4B: Time, Space, and Matter: Managing Resources in Revolutionary France Lane 34 MORNING COFFEE 7:45-10:30 am Chair: Rebecca L. Spang, University College, London Wallenberg Hall Dana Simmons, Max Planck Institute, Berlin/ University of California, Riverside REGISTRATION AND BOOK EXHIBIT Glass Balloons, Pinwheels, and the Political Economy of 8:00 am-5:00 pm Ventilation Wallenberg Hall Emmanuel Saadia, University of Chicago The Medium is the Message: The French Revolution and the Telegraph SESSION FOUR 8:30-10:15 am Ben jamin Kafka, Paper Betrayals: Keeping Offices Supplied in 4A: Identity and Segregation in t h e Colonial Revolutionary France Context Comment: William M. Reddy, Duke University Lane 305

Chair: Patricia Lorcin, University of Minnesota 4C:j Early Modern Bodies Anne Raffin, National University of Singapore ^ane 30 Urban Apartheid: Pondicherry under Colonial Rule Chair: Colin Jones, University of Warwick Michael G. Vann, Santa Clara University Building a White City on the Red River: Race in French Graeme Murdock, University of Birmingham Colonial Urban Planning in Hanoi Sight, Sin, and Sexuality: The Sixteenth-Century Huguenot Body Spen cer Segalla, State University of New York, Nassau Cathy McClive, Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes Difference and Authenticity in French Colonial Schools "V oir et visiter": The Rise of M edical Examinations in for Moroccan Muslims, 1912—1956 Early Modern France Comment: Gary Wilder, Pomona College Penny Roberts, University of Warwick The Kingdom's Two Bodies: Corporeal Rhetoric and Royal Authority during the Religious Wars

Comment: S. Annette Finley-Crosswhite, Old Dominion University

14 15 4D: Identity, Gender, and Republicanism, 4F: Conflicting Views of French Security: 1850-1900 Citizens, Policymakers, and t h e M i l i t a r y Lane 303 Lane 205

Chair and Comment: Raymond Jonas, University of Chair: Norman Ingram, Concordia University, Washington Montreal

Venita Datta, Wellesley College Carl Bouchard, Universite du Quebec, Montreal Aristocratic Heroines and Republican Heroes: Images of Prendre le parti de Torganisation internationale: des Male and Female Heroism in the Bazar de la Charite citoyens francais face a la creation de la Societe des Fire of1897 Nations

Carol E. Harrison, University of South Carolina Thomas Richard Davies, New College, Oxford Reassessing the Clerical Threat: Women, Ultramontanism, Fran ce and the Quest for Disarmament through the and Citizenship League of Nations, 1919-1934

Jam e s R. Lehning, University of Utah Martin Laberge, Universite de Montreal Corrupt Men, Persuasive Women: Melodrama and the La marine, la SDN et la limitation des armements Memory of the Revolution navals: a la recherche de la puissance et de I'independance, 1930-1939

4E: French Experiences of Exile and Comment : Andrew Barros, Universite du Quebec, Detention Montreal Lane 202

Chair: Dena Goodman, University of Michigan 4G: Governing the S o c i a l : Science, Solidarity, and the State Miranda Spieler, Lane 203 Leaving the Republic? Legal Fictions of Absence and Revolutionary Terror: The Case of the Emigres Chair: Cheryl A. Koos, California State University, Los Angeles Gillian Weiss, Case Western Reserve University Barbary Captivity in Colonial Context: The Sinking of Paul V. Dutton, Woodrow Wilson International the Medusa Center for Scholars Health of Republics: France and the United States Ju d i t h DeGroat, St. Lawrence University "Con dam n ee a la transportation": Female Political Bruno Valat, Universite de Toulouse-le-Mirail/CNRS- Prisoners in the Early Second Empire FRAMESPA Des sciences sociales aux politiques sociales : la naissance Comment: Joshua Cole, University of Michigan de I'economie de la sante en France, 1920—fin des annees 1960

Timothy B. Smith, Queen's University The Mitterrand Experiment, Path Dependency, and the Crisis of the French Welfare State in International Perspective

s Comment: Jonah D. Levy, University of California, Berkelev

16 17 4H: War, Revolt, and Exceptionalism in 5B: Other Itineraries: Race, Nation, and Twentieth-Century France Gender in French Women's Travel Writing, I Wallenberg Hall 127 1863-1924 Wallenberg Hall 127 Chair: Wayne Northcutt, Niagara University Chair and Comment: Naomi Andrews, Santa Clara Elizabeth Ann Fordham, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en University Scien ces Sociales/ European University Institute Fren ch Intellectuals on the Eve of the Great War: The Rachel Nunez, Stanford University Agathon Enquiry Reconsidered Disrupting Gender and Nation: The Cosmopolitanism of Olympe Audouard Michael Seidman, University of North Carolina, Wilmington N . Christine Brookes, Central Michigan University The Historiography of May 1968 An Other in an Otherland: Carla Serena and Marie de Ujfalvy-Bourdon's Travels to Russia Melanie Bailey, South Dakota State University Apres Marianne, le Deluge: In Defense of French Margaret McColley, University of Virginia Republican Exceptionalism Pour la Vie: Anarchism, Feminism, and Francophone Women's Travel Comment: Aron Rodrigue, Stanford University

5C: Culture, Class, and t h e C i t y in t h e E r a o f Revolution SESSION FIVE Lane 203 10:30 am-12:15 pm Chair: Gregory Brown, University of Nevada,

OkX 5A: Does Capitalism Still Matter for the Las Vegas History of the F r e n c h Revolution? Victoria Thompson, Arizona State University Lane 34 "Jean -Jacques Went on Foot": Louis-Sebastien Mercier Chair: Clare Crowston, University of Illinois and the Democratization of Parisian Space

William H. Sewell, Jr., University of Chicago Maria Riasanovsky, Stanford University The Return of M arx? Eighteenth-Century Capitalism, Remaking the City: Catholic Missionaries in Restoration The Commodity Form, and the French Revolution Fran ce

Joh n Shovlin, Hobart and William Smith Colleges David Shafer, California State, Long Beach Political Economy, Capitalism, and the Origins of the Class Conflict, Cultural Identities, and the Paris Fren ch Revolution Commune

Rebecca L. Spang, University College London Comment: Gregory Shaya, College of Wooster Equivalents, General and Specific: Revolutionary Taxation and Theories of Value

Comment: Paul Cheney, University of Chicago

18 19 5D: The Cultivation of Expertise 5F: Cultures of the G r e a t War: Mobilization, Lane 303 Demobilization, and Remobilization Lane 305 Chair: Robert Kreiser, George Mason University/ American Association of University Professors Chair and Comment: Martha Hanna, University of Colorado, Boulder Sean Takats, University of Michigan The Scientist in the Kitchen: Cooking, Expertise, and Susan Grayzel, University of Mississippi Authority in Eighteenth-Century France "Th e State of the Soul of the Poilus "; Exploring the Militarization of Civilians in First-World-War France George R. Trumbull IV, Yale University In a Dimly-Lit Cafe in Tlemcen: Expertise, Narrative Mona Siegel, California State University, Sacramento Authority, and Ethnographic Methodology in Colonial Cultural Demobilization: History, Truth, and Franco- Algeria, 1871-1914 German Reconciliation between the W ars

Deborah Neill, University of Toronto Roxanne Panchasi, Simon Fraser University Between Europe and the Colonies: French Scientists, Remobilization: Imagining Civilian Vulnerability in European Cooperation, and the Rise of Tropical Fran ce, 1919-1939 Medicine, 1900-1914

Comment: Tessie Liu, 5G: Representations of Public Power under the Old Regime Lane 205 5E: Managing Uncertainty in Twentieth- Century Thought and Politics Chair: Carolyn Lougee Chappell, Stanford University Lane 30 Fanny Cosandey, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Chair: Julian Wright, University of Durham Sociales Structure dynastique et puissance monarchique: les Michael Behrent, College of Wooster/New York paradoxes de la modernite politique en France sous University TAncien Regime Right-W ing Foucauldianism? Francois Ewald, the Refondation Sociale, and the Rhetoric of Social Risk Comments: Kathryn Norberg, University of California, Los Angeles and Jean-Marie Apostolides, Jo e l Revill, Duke University Stan ford University Managing the Crisis of Reason: Brunschvicgs Philosophy of Science as Political Thought

5H: The History of Immigration in France: Jo s h u a Humphreys, New York University The State of Research The Sovereignty of Desire: Consumer Citizenship and the Lane 2 Social Crisis of Democratic Thought in the Late Third Republic Chair: George M. Fredrickson, Stanford University

Comment: Eric Kocher-Marboeuf, Universite de Marie-Claude Blanc-Chaleard, Universite de Paris I Poitiers L'Histoire de Timmigration en France: histoire neuve dune vieille nation

Comments: Tyler Stovall, University of California, Berkeley and Mary D. Lewis, Harvard University

20 21 BUSINESS AND AWARDS LUNCHEON 6C: "Ni d r o i t e , ni gauche": French 12:30-1:45 pm Intellectuals and Politicians Between Left and Faculty Club Right Lane 202

Chair: Sean Kennedy, University of New Brunswick

SESSION SIX Laurent Kestel, Universite de Paris I 2:00-3:45 pm L'Engagement politique de Bertrand de Jouvenel au sein du Parti populaire francais, juin 1936—Janvier 1939

6A: Rethinking Aristocracy, 1750-1830 ~ Diane N. Mason Labrosse, McGill University Lane 30 Gaston Bergery, the Frontiste Party, and the Foundation Chair and Comment: Johnson Kent Wright, Arizona of the Vichy State State University W . Brian Newsome, Alfred University Jay M. Smith, University of North Carolina, Designing the Modern French Community: Francois Chapel Hill Bloch-Laine and the Democratization of Urban Becoming Medieval: Noble Honor and French Patriotism Planning in the Eighteenth Century Comment: William Irvine, York University Steph en Miller, University of Alabama Nobles, Honor, and Absolutism in Eighteenth-Century 6D: The Politics of Common Sense Fran ce Lane 205

Chair: Jan E. Goldstein, University of Chicago 6B: Politics, Piety, and Gender Wallenberg Hall 127 Soph ia Rosenfeld, University of Virginia The Slow Disappearance of Bon Sens Chair: Elizabeth Marvick, Los Angeles David Bates, University of California, Berkeley Mitylene Myhr, St. Edward's University Human Analogies: The Politics of Intuition in the Ju st Who Is In Charge Here? Leadership Crisis in the Enlightenment Ursuline Community of Bordeaux Jessica Riskin, Stanford University Susan Dinan, Long Island University Magic and the Politics of Debunking The Politics of Avoiding Enclosure Comment: Carla Hesse, University of California, Tatyana Bakhmetyeva, University of Rochester Berkeley "Un e Mere de TEglise": Sophie Swetchine and the French Liberal Catholic Movement

Comment: Karen Lenore Taylor, Sidwell Friends Sch ool/Georgetown University 6E: Healing the R e p u b l i c : The Politics o f 6G: Marketing Class and G e n d e r in T w e n t i e t h - Medical Catastrophe in Modern France Century Popular Culture Lane 303 Lane 305

Chair: Marie-Pierre Ulloa, Stanford University/ Chair and Comment: Stephen L. Harp, University of Institut d'Etudes Politiques Akron

Jun ko Takeda, Stanford University Katherine Foshko, Yale University Plague, Discipline, and Punishment in Marseille, The Ballets Russes and Popular Culture in Interwar France 1669—1723: A Republic's Confrontation With Physical Eric S. Reed, Western Kentucky University and Moral Catastrophe Sporting Masculinity, Women, and Mass Marketing dur- Andrew Aisenberg, Scripps College ing the Tour de France Beyond Climatic Catastrophe: Fever, Acclimatization, Joelle Neulander, The Citadel and the Politics of Settlement in French Algeria, "Th e Call of Two Hearts": Interwar Sentimental Novels 1830-1860 and Models for Women's Class Uplift Richard Keller, University of Wisconsin, Madison Heat and Death in 2003: The Social Ecology of 6H: Degrees of Accommodation: French Catastrophe in France Adaptation to t h e N a z i Occupation, Comment: Dora B. Weiner, University of California, 1940-1944 Los Angeles Lane 34

Chair: Lynne Taylor, University of Waterloo 6F: Policy Intellectuals f r o m the T h i r d to the Kenneth Moure, University of California, Fifth Republic San ta Barbara Lane 203 The Rising Cost of M isery : Controlling Prices and Black Chair: Marion Fourcade-Gourinchas, University of Markets during the Occupation, 1940—1944 California, Berkeley Dominique Veillon, Institut d'Histoire du Temps Philip Nord, Princeton University Present Pierre Schaeffer and Jeune France La haute couture francaise pendant la Seconde guerre mondiale : degres divers d'accommodation Herrick Chapman, New York University Michel Debre: The Power of Ideas and the Exercise Norman Ingram, Concordia University, Montreal of Power Collaboration or Resistance ? The Ligue des droits de I'homme in Occupied France Claire Andrieu, Institut d'Etudes Politiques The Club Jean Moulin, the Algerian War, the Comment: John F. Sweets, University of Kansas Constitution, and the Party System, 1958—1970

Comment: Patrick Fridenson, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales

24 25 SESSION SEVEN 7C: Political Culture in Sixteenth- a n d 4:00-5:45 pm Seventeenth-Century France Lane 303 7A: The T h e m e of a New A r i s t o c r a c y i n Chair: William Beik, Emory University Nineteenth-Century France Lane 2 Megan Armstrong, University of Utah The Franciscan Body Politic and the Emergence of Chair: Keith Michael Baker, Stanford University Catholic Absolutism, 1588-1594 Lucien Jaume, Institut d'Etudes Politiques Michael De Waele, Universite Laval, Quebec The Theme of a New Aristocracy in Nineteenth-Century La place de la religion dans la fin des Guerres de Religion Fran ce Sara Beam, University of Victoria Comments: Andrew Jainchill, Queen's University, Je su it Theatre and the Discourse of Absolutism Ontario and Aurelian Craiutu, Indiana University Comment: James Collins, Georgetown University

7B: Ideas and Practices in Eighteenth-Century

^Commerce 7D: The Left Re-Thought: Intellectuals o n t h e Lane 202 Fringes of Socialism, 1890-1939 Lane 30 Chair: Alan Williams, Wake Forest University Chair: Joshua Humphreys, New York University Amalia D. Kessler, Stanford University Reconceiving Trade as Free Private Exchange: Jurisdictional K\ iinghw an Oh, University of Chicago Conflict and the Eighteenth-Century Parisian Merchant New Republicanism, Depopulation, and the Social Court Question, 1880-1914

Henry C. Clark, Canisius College Ju l i an Wright, University of Durham Merchants' Guilds in Revisionist Perspective: The Bourse / The Problem of Independent Socialism: Joseph Paul- in Toulouse, 1735—1787 Boncour, Intellectual Engagement, and Reformist Socialism in the Third Republic Comment: Raymond Birn, University of Oregon Emanuel Rota, University of California, Berkeley The Pontigny Experiment: Saving French Socialism at the End of the 1930s

Comment: William Logue, Northern Illinois University

26 27 7E: Religion and R e v o l u t i o n on t h e Periphery 7G: Sex, S o c i e t y , and t h e State in T w e n t i e t h - Lane 305 Century France Lane 205 Chair and Comment: Dale Van Kley, Ohio State University Chair: Rae Beth Gordon, University of Connecticut

Edw ard J. Woell, Western Illinois University Le la Felter-Kerley, University of Florida Revolution and Religion in Small-Town France "La Femme Nue" in Belle Epoque Body Politics

Eric E Johnson, Santa Monica Community College Richard I. Jobs, Pacific University Catholic Ritual and Political Discourse in Revolutionary Brigitte Bardot: "la femme-enfant" Avignon, 1789-1791 Richard Sonn, University of Arkansas Jo s h u a Schreier, Vassar College "Y our Body is Yours": Anarchism, Birth Control, and Religion, Reform, and Revolution in Algeria Eugenics in Interwar France

Comment: Judith Surkis, Harvard University 7F: The P o l i t i c s o f Patrimony during t h e Second World War 7H: Food and D r i n k in t h e F r e n c h Empire: Lane 203 Algeria, Indochina, and F r e n c h Sudan Chair: Karen Lenore Taylor, Sidwell Friends School/ Lane 34 Georgetown University Chair: Patricia Lorcin, University of Minnesota Elizabeth C. Karlsgodt, University of Colorado, Roundtable: Denver Catherine M. Bogosian, Wayne State University Rethinking Resistance: The Evacuation of French Art Marie-Paule Ha, University of Hong Kong Collections during the Second World War Jo h n Strachan, University of Manchester Kirrily Freeman, University of Waterloo Erica J. Peters, Stanford University/University of Regionalism and Resistance: The Case of the Statue of MaryJand University College Mistral in Aries Comment: The Audience Sylvie L. Waskiewicz, Bennington College Paradox or Prescription? The Legacy of Wartime BANQUET Film m ak in g on French Film Policy ~:15 pm Comment: Theresa M. McBride, College of The Sh eraton Palo Alto Holy Cross Presiding: Keith Michael Baker, Stanford University 1 Co-President

>r-r.L.-;cr: Dominique Pestre, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales Scirmrr in the Cold War: France and the United States

>- > < < Q a K

I - < <

28 29 SPECIAL GUESTS Fourcade-Gourinchas, Marion 6F Kitson, Simon 1G Fredrickson, George M . 5H Kocher-Marboeuf, Eric 5E Annette Becker, Universite de Paris X (Friday Luncheon) Freeman, Kirrily 7F Koehler, Ellen Astrid 2G Marie-Claude Blanc-Chaleard, Universite de Paris I (session 5H) Fridenson, Patrick 6F Koos, Cheryl A. 2E, 4G Fuchs, Rachel 3G Kramer, Lloyd 3F Fanny Cosaiidey, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales Gerber, Matthew D. 3G Kreiser, Robert 5D (session 5G) Gillispie, Charles Coulst jn 1A Laberge, Martin 4F Lucien Jaume, Institut d'Etudes Politiques (session 7A) Goldstein, Jan E. 6D Labrosse, Diane N. Mason 6C Goodman, Dena 1H, 4E Lacy, Cherilyn 3H Je an - Cl e m e n t Martin, Universite de Paris I (session 2A) Gordon, Rae Beth 7G Laurent, Dominique IF Leh ning, James R. Dominique Pestre, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales Grayzel, Susan 5F 4D Levy, Jonah D. (Saturday Banquet) Green, Nancy L. 3F 4G Gum her, Scott IF Lewis, Mary D. 5H Ha. Marie-Paule 7H Liu, Tessie 5D PARTICIPANTS Castleton, Edward 2G Hahn. Roger 1A Loats, Carol L. 2B Adams, Christine 3D Chapman, Herrick 6F Hall. Hines 3C Logue, William 7D Adkins, Matthew 1C Chapman, Sarah 3B Hanna. Martha 5F Lorcin, Patricia 4A, 7H Aisenberg, Andrew 6E Chappell, Carolyn Lougee 5G Hap, Stephen L. 6G Luria, Keith 2B Andrews, Naomi 5B Chiwis, Christopher IF Harrison. Carol E. 4D Lyons, Amelia 2F Andrieu, Claire 6F Cheney, Paul 5A Harsry. John L. 2D Margadant, Jo B. 2D Apostolides, Jean-Marie 5G Claire, Elisabeth IB Hess. Charlotte IB Margadant, Ted 2A Armstrong, Megan 7C Clark, Henry C 7B Hess. Remi IB Martin, Jean-Clement 2A Auerbach, Stephen 1C Clark, Linda I D Hesse. Carta 6D Marvick, Elizabeth 6B Bailey, Melanie 4H Cole, Joshua 4E HB. John IF Mazgaj, Paul 3C Baker, Keith Mich ael 1A, 7A Collins, James 7C Hm» Martin 1G McBride, Theresa M . 7F Bakh metyeva, Tatyana 6B Conklin, Alice IE " tk j. Mnl 3A McClive, Cathy 4C Barros, An dr ew 1G, 4F Cosandey, Fanny 5G T JMiUdm) ). Joshua 5E, 7D McColley, Margaret 5B Bates, David 6D Coulston Gillispie, Charles 1A rW-Unn 2A Mihealy, Gil 3G Beam, Sara 7C Craiutu, Aurelian 7A Hat. John J. 3B Miller, James 3A Becker, Annette Fri. Lunch Crawford, Katherine 1H Hanon. Patrick 2D Miller, Jeannette 2F Beech er, Jonathan 2G Crowston, Clare 5A Ub*. Talbot 1G Miller, Jim 2F

Beh ren t, Michael 5E Datta, Venita 4D " — - — Norman 4F, 6H Miller, Michael IE Beik, William 3B, 7C Daughton, J. P. 3E Smnt William 6C Miller, Stephen 6A Beren son , Edward 2D Davies, Thomas Richard 4F jaiodiiO. Andrew 7A Monahan, Gregory 2B Bergen , Barry H. 2C De Wade, Michael 7C Jau m e . Lucien 7A Moses, Claire I D Berlan stein , Lenard R. I D DeGroat, Judith 4E Jo b s , Richard I. 7G Moure, Kenneth 6H Birn , Raymond 7B Delia Sudda, Magali 3G Joh n son , Eric F. 7E Munholland, John Kim 3E Blan c-Ch aleard, Marie-Cl 3ude5H DeMarco, Eileen S. 3H Jo n as . Raymond 4D Murdock, Graeme 4C Blon del, Christine 3H Dinan, Susan 6B Jo n e s . Colin 4C Murphy, Terence 3D Bogosian , Catherine M. 7H Dutton, Paul V. 4G J-rrt Ihor 3F Myhr, Mitylene 6B Bossen ga, Gai! 3D Eichner, Carolyn J. 2C 4B Nassichuk, John 2H Bouch ard, Carl 4F Felter-Kerley, Lela 7G Kiaa A m E. 1H Neill, Deborah 5D Brookes, N. Christine 5B Fette, Julie 2E Um. Samuel 3C Neulander, Joelle 6G Brown , Gregory 5C Finley-Crosswhite, S. Annette 4C Uapat. Ozabeth C. 7F Newsome, W. Brian 6C Bryan t, Lawrence M. 2H Fogarry, Richard 2C 6E Norberg, Kathryn 5G Buch wald, Jed 1A Fogg, Shannon L. 2E MtHi i il 3A Nord, Philip 6F Bullard, Alice IE Ford, Caroline IE Ti—i mi Se» 3C6C Norris, Katharine 3D Burke, Edmund III 2G Fordham, Elizabeth Ann 4H 7B Northcutt, Wayne 4H Cabanes, Bruno. 3E Foshko, Katherine 6G 6C Nunez, Rachel 5B

30 Offen, Karen I D Smith , Jay M. 6A PROGRAM COMMITTEE Oh, Kyunghwan 7D Smith , Timothy B. 4G Keith Michael Baker, Stanford University Outram, Dorinda 1A Son n , Richard 7G Panchasi, Roxanne 5F Span g, Rebecca L. 4B, 5A Susanna Barrows, University of California, Berkeley Peabody, Sue 1C Spieler, Miranda 4E David W. Bates, University of California, Berkeley Pedersen, Jean E. 2C Stewart, Mary Lynn I D Pestre, Dominique Sat. Banquet Stovall, Tyler 5H Jo n at h an Beecher, University of California, Santa Cruz Peters, Erica J. 7H Strach an , John 7H Philippe Buc, Stanfotd University Pickering, Mary 3H Surkis, Judith 7G Piketty, Guillaume 3E Sussman , Sarah 2F Carolyn Lougee Chappell, Stanford University Popkin, Jeremy D. 1C Sweets, Joh n E 6H J. P . Daughton, Stanford University Potter, Mark 3B Tackett, Timoth y 2A Raffin, Anne 4A Takats, Sean 5D Caria Hesse, University of California, Berkeley Raj, Kapil IE Takeda, Junko 6E Geffrey Koziol, University of California, Berkeley Reddy, William M. 4B Taylor, Karen Lenore 6B, 7F Reed, Eric S. 6G Taylor, Lynne 6H Maria Riasanovsky, Stanford University Revill, Joel 5E Thomas, Martin 1G Je s s i c a Riskin, Stanfotd University Rhoades, Michelle K. 2E Thompson, Victoria 5C Riasanovsky, Maria 5C Trumbull, George R. IV 5D Aron Rodrigue, Stanford University Riskin, Jessica 6D Ulloa, Marie-Pierre 6E Peter SabJins, Univetsity of California, Berkeley Risser, Nicole Dombrowski 2E Vaillancourt, Daniel 2H Roberts, Penny 4C Valat, Btuno 4G Trier Stovall, University of California, Berkeley Rodrigue, Aron 4H Van Kley, Dale 7E Rosenblatt, Helena 3A Vann, Michael G. 4A Rosenfeld, Sophia 6D Veillon, Dominique 6H ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Rota, Emanuel 7D Vincent, K. Steven 3C Rowlands, Guy 3B Wagner, Marie-France 2H SFHS expresses its warm thanks to the following for theit gen- Saadia, Emmanuel 4B Waskiewicz, Sylvie L. 7F : of this meeting and their assistance with its Scafe, Robert B. 2B Weber, William IB Sch or, Laura S. 3G Weiner, Dora B. 6E Sdnoi of Humanities and Sciences, Stanford University Sch reier, Joshua 7E Weintrob, Lori 3H Segalla, Spencer 4A Weiss, Gillian 4E I Cultural Service Seidman , Michael 4H Wellman, Kathleen 1H I Consulate. San Francisco Sepin wall, Alyssa 1C Whalen, Philip 2D Session s, Jennifer E. 2C Wilder, Gary 4A it of History, Stanford University Sewell, William H. Jr 5A Williams, Alan 7B rraaoe-Stanford Center. Stanford University Sh afer, David 5C Wilson, Christine Sample 2B Sh an k, J.B. 1A Winnie, Laurence H . 3D Sh aya, Gregory 5C Wintroub, Michael 2H Sh epard, Todd 2F Woell, Edward J. 7E ( Sh ovlin , John 5A Wokler, Robert 3A Siegel, Mona 5F Woloch, Isser IF, 3E Simmon s, Dana 4B Wright, Johnson Kent 6A SFHS 52^0 ANNUAL MEETING Smith , David Kammerling 3B Wright, Julian 5E, 7D 21-23 April 2006 of Illinois. Lfbana-Champaign Co-Presidents: and Mark Stephen Micale •

32