An Accidental Warrior Riting About German Jews in Service in His Sword of Honour Trilogy

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

An Accidental Warrior Riting About German Jews in Service in His Sword of Honour Trilogy VOLUME 15 NO.8 AUGUST 2015 journal The Association of Jewish Refugees An accidental warrior riting about German Jews in service in his Sword of Honour trilogy. It British uniform in last month’s was the same impenetrable and blinkered issue of the Journal brought bureaucracy that saw Lynton shipped off to Wto mind one of the most remarkable and Canada on the SS Ettrick, in the improbable entertaining autobiographical texts by a company of Hans Kahle, a convinced Jewish refugee who served in the British Communist who had commanded a division Army in the Second World War. Mark in the Spanish Civil War, and Fritz Lingen, a Lynton, author of Accidental Journey: grandson of Kaiser Wilhelm II. Lynton spent A Cambridge Internee’s Memoir of World War II several months in Canada, unable to return (Woodstock, NY: Overlook Press, 1995), to Britain until 1941 since the Home Office, was born Max-Otto Ludwig Loewenstein in believing him to have drowned when the SS Stuttgart in 1920, moving to Berlin two years Arandora Star was sunk on its way to Canada later when his father was appointed head in July 1940, had ‘mislaid’ him there. But at of a major German car manufacturer. The least the Canadian camps provided modern Loewensteins were a fairly typical assimilated comforts, equipped as they were with ‘every German-Jewish family, proudly patriotic – gadget known in the Western Hemisphere, Max-Otto’s father had won the Iron Cross some of which, I suspect, may not have in the First World War – well educated, reached England to this day’. financially secure, comfortably established in On his return to Britain, Lynton the upper reaches of the professional middle volunteered for the Pioneer Corps, serving class, and with a certain cosmopolitanism of Mark Lynton, 1920-1997 in 251 Company, in an array of more or less outlook. futile and unsuitable occupations, including That latter quality led his parents to send well-meaning British soldiers who guarded a hare-brained scheme to construct fake Max-Otto to be educated at the Lycée Pasteur, the internees; the shambles behind barbed storage tanks to divert Luftwaffe pilots in the wealthy Parisian suburb of Neuilly, wire that was Huyton, the holding camp from attacking the oil storage facilities at in 1933, and from there to Cheltenham on Merseyside where he was first taken; Avonmouth, outside Bristol. His description College in Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, in and the absurdity of the entire operation of his company on parade in their new 1936. His parents emigrated to Holland in of the mass internment of so-called ‘enemy uniforms as ‘almost indistinguishable from 1935, subsequently moving to the United aliens’, directed from Whitehall with a logic a Gräfin Mariza [operetta by Emmerich States. Lynton’s description of Cheltenham apparently deriving from Lewis Carroll. If Kálmán] rehearsal’ is classic Lynton. The as ‘an English public school of indifferent Lynton’s time at Cambridge recalls Evelyn time he spent back in Cheltenham, under academic reputation, sterling social standing, Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited, his years in the disapproving eye of retired army officers and towering military distinction’ is typical internment and in the British Army recall who had attended his old school, provided of his ability to deal out ironically back- Waugh’s darkly comic depiction of wartime him with further rich material for a satirical handed compliments to venerable British depiction of establishment British attitudes institutions. In 1938 he went up to St John’s and conduct. Eventually, he was selected for College, Cambridge, to read law. But his legal SIR NICHOLAS WINTON officer training at Sandhurst. studies took second place to his pleasurably 1909-2015 Having officially changed his name, Lt. leisured existence as a member of a highly Lynton was commissioned into the Third privileged elite at an institution that seemed Royal Tank Regiment, an elite armoured more dedicated to preserving antiquated The Association of Jewish unit with a proud record that had taken social values and customs than to learning. At Refugees expresses its it from Libya to the Normandy landings. first, the university appeared to regard the war profound sadness at the Lynton’s commanding officer was Colonel as little more than an annoying irrelevance, Teddy Mitford, brother of the five Mitford but on Whit Sunday 1940 the young passing of Sir Nicholas sisters. One of the most gripping sections of Loewenstein was rudely jolted out of his Winton. Our thoughts and the book consists of Lynton’s account of the lotus-eating languor: returning to his college stubborn fighting in the Normandy bocage, after a hard day’s punting and drinking, he prayers are with his family. followed by Eleventh Armoured Division’s was arrested and interned. It was to be nine rapid advance through France and Belgium, months before he saw Cambridge again. An obituary of during which Third RTR was involved in Lynton’s account of his internment Sir Nicholas appears on the taking of Amiens and the vital port of highlights its farcical aspects: the ‘staggeringly Antwerp, in the Battle of the Bulge, the incompetent’ but occasionally kindly and page 5. continued on page 2 journal AUGUST 2015 An accidental warrior continued Special KT Lunch Rhine crossing at Wesel and the liberation every building, assemble all his troops Wednesday 9 September 2015 of Bergen-Belsen, ending up at Flensburg on the main square, men on one side, at New North London on the Danish border. Third RTR had arms on the other, and do it all within Synagogue outfought the Wehrmacht from the sands of ten minutes, he appeared to view that Guest speaker: Barbara Winton the Western Desert to the Baltic Sea – but as an eminently sensible suggestion, Please join us for a special KT Lunch at great cost. Often in the van of the British provided he be allowed to phone his on Wednesday 9 September at the New advance, the regiment’s tanks frequently felt superiors to advise them that he was North London Synagogue, 80 East End the force of the German defences, notably retiring from this war. Road, Finchley N3. We are delighted the 88mm anti-tank guns and the dreaded that Barbara Winton, daughter of For all the apparent levity of Lynton’s the late Sir Nicholas Winton, will be our Tiger tanks. The life expectancy of a tank account of his often picaresque progress guest speaker. commander like Lynton was short; he was through the wartime years, the courage of Barbara will be talking about her fortunate to have been wounded only once the men he fought with – even when they father’s remarkable achievements and when his tank was hit, since his unit, 2,000 maintained the outer appearance of sheep- signing copies of her book men strong, suffered some 600 killed. faced British stuffed shirts of the officer class If It’s Not Impossible … The Life of Sir Nicholas Winton. Lynton describes the exhilarating but – was beyond question. bloodstained advance across north-western After the German surrender, Lynton We are also delighted that some of the Europe with gusto, and to no little comic Year 6 pupils from Akiva School will be was involved in some of the most notable in attendance to meet you and Barbara. effect. Here is a sample of his style, recounting events in the British Zone of Occupation. Please strongly encourage your families the capture of one German town: He observed the taking prisoner of Admiral to accompany you for this unique While nearing Neustadt, a small town Dönitz, Hitler’s successor as Führer, gathering. north of Hamburg, the ‘telephone caper’ and his cabinet at Flensburg, and was NB: The KT Lunch will be at the regular occurred to Teddy Mitford. He had come present by chance at army headquarters in venue at Alyth Synagogue for the August across some engineering unit restringing Lüneburg when Heinrich Himmler was and October meetings. telephone wires who had told him that held there. He participated in the arrest of they had, quite by accident, tapped into SS-Standartenführer Otto Bovensiepen, one the Neustadt Exchange a few miles up of the early senior Nazi war criminals to be the road. He summoned me to join him, caught and brought to justice. Transferred since I was the only German speaker in from Third RTR to Military Headquarters Third RTR, and suggested I try to phone at Bad Oeynhausen, Lynton was involved in the Neustadt garrison and talk them into the systematic pursuit and interrogation of Diary surrendering, rather than put everyone war criminals. The high point of his activities to the trouble of fighting for it. […] I here was his part in the arrest of Rudolf Höss, Date got hooked into the line, asked for the the commandant of Auschwitz. Interestingly, Neustadt commandant, and promptly got Lynton’s account makes no mention of put through to him. After that it became Hanns Alexander, who, according to Thomas AJRAJR LunchLunch pure farce. Harding’s bestseller Hanns and Rudolf, was Pitching my voice somewhere between the man responsible for arresting Höss; SUNDAYSUNDAY Erich von Stroheim and Dr. Anthony, perhaps unsurprisingly, Harding makes no I outlined a scenario of hundreds of mention of Lynton either, though the latter 1111 OCTOBEROCTOBER 20152015 tanks, clouds of planes, and swarms of was, or at least claimed to have been, an DetailsDetails toto followfollow paratroopers, all bunched down the road eyewitness to the arrest. for the declared purpose of obliterating After a spell in Denmark, Lynton Neustadt. The party at the opposite end, returned to occupied Germany to participate hearing of this imaginary Armageddon, in intelligence work, first in military clearly felt that Neustadt hardly warranted intelligence, then, from early spring 1946, 10-DAY VISIT TO so much attention, and politely inquired in political intelligence, with 16 SHIO what we wished him to do.
Recommended publications
  • Additional Research Notes
    Additional Research Notes Below is more information related to Joe’s story, including concen tration camps, ship transporting dislocated persons, camp for dislocated persons, camp commandants/other Nazi officials and their fate, and famous shoe companies. 1. Concentration Camps A. Auschwitz/Birkenau, Poland (Concentration Camp) Author’s Note : Joe arrived at Auschwitz on April 30, 1942 and was housed at its sister camp, Birkenau, or “Auschwitz II,” where two days a week he was forced to move the bodies of the dead from the gas chamber to open pits. He was also required to do daily calisthenics and work in many other areas around the camp, including snow removal on the massive grounds. Joe was eventually assigned to a slave labor crew working in a nearby coal mine. For a short while, the inmate miners were forced to walk several miles each day to the coal mine and back. When Joe was finally moved from Birkenau to a camp near the coal mine, he le Auschwitz for the last time, but the mining camp remained under the authority of Auschwitz. Joe permanently lost the hearing in one ear from the repeated explosions of dynamite. Documents provided by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C., show that in June 1944, Joe (Juzek Rubinsztein) was sent from the Auschwitz complex (we believe from the Jawischowitz Sub-camp/Brzeszcze Coal Mine) to Buchenwald, Germany. His official number while at Auschwitz was 34207. At Buchenwald, his number was 117.666. 1, 2 e Auschwitz Concentration Camp, located thirty-seven miles west of Krakow, near the Polish city of Oswiecim, was in an area annexed by Nazi Germany in 1939 aer its invasion of Poland.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Title the Lagermuseum Creative Manuscript and 'Encountering Auschwitz: Touring the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum' C
    Thesis Title The Lagermuseum Creative Manuscript and ‘Encountering Auschwitz: Touring the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum’ Critical Thesis Author Dr Claire Griffiths, BA (Hons), MA, PhD Qualification Creative and Critical Writing PhD Institution University of East Anglia, Norwich School of Literature, Drama and Creative Writing Date January 2015 Word Count 91,102 (excluding appendices) This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with the author and that use of any information derived there from must be in accordance with current UK Copyright Law. In addition, any quotation or extract must include full attribution. Abstract The Lagermuseum My creative manuscript – an extract of a longer novel – seeks to illuminate a little- known aspect of the history of the Auschwitz concentration and death camp complex, namely the trade and display of prisoner artworks. However, it is also concerned with exposing the governing paradigms inherent to contemporary encounters with the Holocaust, calling attention to the curatorial processes present in all interrogations of this most contentious historical subject. Questions relating to ownership, display and representational hierarchies permeate the text, characterised by a shape-shifting curator figure and artworks which refuse to adhere to the canon he creates for them. The Lagermuseum is thus in constant dialogue with my critical thesis, examining the fictional devices which often remain unacknowledged within established
    [Show full text]
  • 1956 – Year of Change
    VOLUME 13 NO.10 OCTOBER 2013 journal The Association of Jewish Refugees 1956 – year of change hich were the defining transitional the resolutely lower-class Jimmy Porter, to downtrodden, inarticulate characters in years in the history of post-war and its action takes place in the cramped, down-at-heel, sometimes sordid settings, WEurope? Many would nominate shabby, provincial flat occupied by Porter was epitomised by Wesker’s The Kitchen, 1968, the year of mass student unrest; and his wife. With its direct onslaught set in the basement kitchen of a restaurant. others would opt for 1973, the year of on the class-obsessed conformity and Like the strange and menacing early the oil price rise that put an end to the smug complacency of post-war Britain, plays of Harold Pinter, The Birthday period of high growth rates, Europe’s its distrust of established standards and Party (1958) and The Caretaker (1960), post-war ‘economic miracle’. But for values, and its general lack of respect these dramas broke decisively with the Britain, where student unrest was on well-made play’s focus on upper- and a modest scale and where the dismal middle-class characters and settings. I performance of the economy made the can still recall the sense of excitement I German Wirtschaftswunder a distant felt when, as a 14-year-old boy, I was taken prospect, neither of these years appears to to see Lindsay Anderson’s production of represent a historical turning-point. Willis Hall’s The Long and the Short and Instead, 1956 stands out as a year of the Tall at the Royal Court in 1959.
    [Show full text]
  • Einsicht 13 Bulletin Des Fritz Bauer Instituts
    Einsicht 13 Bulletin des Fritz Bauer Instituts Endphasenverbrechen Fritz Bauer Institut und frühe Strafverfolgung Geschichte und MMitit BBeiträgeneiträgen vvonon SSvenven KKeller,eller, CClaudialaudia BBade,ade, Wirkung des Holocaust SSybilleybille SSteinbacher,teinbacher, DDanielaniel BBlatman,latman, EdithEdith RaimRaim Inwieweit hat die Shoah mit ihren Folgen, hat das Editorial Naziregime mit seinen Auswirkungen die Identitäten der dreißig Frauen und Männer geprägt, die in diesem Buch Einblick in ihre Lebensgeschichte geben? Worüber haben sie nachgedacht, als sie nach ihrer Identität gefragt wurden? Identität auch in dem Zusammenhang, unausweichlich durch die Herkunft an eine der beiden Seiten gebunden zu sein: Beidseits von Auschwitz. doch noch in die Hände der Wehrmacht oder SS fi elen. Claudia Bade Nachkommen von Verfolgten – Nachkommen von untersucht Denunziationen a m Kriegsende. Häufi ge Anlässe hierfür Verfolgern. waren »Rundfunkverbrechen« (das Abhören von »Feindsendern«) und der verbotene Umgang mit Kriegsgefangenen und ausländi- Auch wenn im Hinblick auf die Verfolgten und deren schen Zivil- und Zwangsarbeitern. Sybille Steinbacher beschreibt die Nachkommen die jüdische Seite hier im Fokus steht, Befreiung des Konzentrations- und Vernichtungslagers Auschwitz. so wollten wir doch eine weitere Gruppe zu Wort Dieser Beitrag geht auf ihren Vortrag zum 70. Jahrestag der Befreiung kommen lassen. Es gelang uns, den Künstler Alfred Liebe Leserinnen und Leser, von Auschwitz am 27. Januar 2015 in der Goethe-Universität Frank- Ullrich, einen Sinto, dessen Mutter den Porajmos furt am Main zurück. Daniel Blatman befasst sich mit den Todesmär- (das „Große Verschlingen“) überlebt hat, für unser am 8. Mai 1945 endete mit der bedin- schen, auf die die SS die KZ-Häftlinge bei der Aufgabe der Lager gungslosen Kapitulation des Deutschen angesichts der näher rückenden feindlichen Truppen zwang.
    [Show full text]
  • Holocaust in Museen in London Und Berlin Debatten Über Das Thema Insgesamt Sprunghaft Zugenommen
    Holocaust in Museen in London und Berlin Debatten über das Thema insgesamt sprunghaft zugenommen. Hinzu kommt, dass Fragen nach einer angemessenen Visualisierung des Ho- locaust auch einen eigenen theoretischen Forschungszusammenhang ausgebildet haben, der oft nur oberfl ächlich von der Geschichtswis- senschaft rezipiert wird, jedoch im Bereich Fotografi e, Kunst, Film Angelika Schoder und eben Ausstellungen und Museen diskursprägend geworden ist.3 Die Vermittlung des Unbegreifl ichen. Durch beide Diskussionen – die praktische, die auf Fragen nach Darstellungen des Holocaust im Museum einer angemessenen Vermittlung basiert, und die theoretische, die Frankfurt am Main, New York: Fragen der Medialität und dem Wandel unserer Erinnerungen ad- Campus Verlag, 2014, 371 S., € 45,– ressiert – hat die Forschung einen bemerkenswerten Aufschwung erhalten. In den vergangenen Jahren entstanden gleich mehrere Zeitschriftenschwerpunkte und Studien, die sich dem Ausstellen Von Raul Hilberg ist die Bemerkung überlie- von Geschichte allgemein4 und der Repräsentation des Holocaust fert, dass jedes Holocaust-Museum einen Saal in Museen im Speziellen widmeten. Im Titel der 2012 erschienenen haben sollte, in dem es auf einem Podest unter Glas ausschließlich eine Arbeit von Katja Köhr war dann auch zutreffend von den »vielen der Dosen Zyklon B präsentiert.1 Diese sowohl provokativ als auch Gesichtern des Holocaust« im internationalen Museumsdiskurs die ernst gemeinte Äußerung aus den 1990er Jahren wurde zur vielleicht Rede.5 Auch Simone Lässig sprach vor einigen
    [Show full text]
  • This Summer the AJR's Refugee Voices Team Made A
    VOLUME 20 NO.8 AUGUST 2020 JOURNAL The Association of Jewish Refugees SUMMER READING Racism and The AJR has been extraordinarily busy over the last few weeks, hosting a record number of online events and making sure that all our members have everything they need Refugees during lockdown. We hope August brings more peaceful times for everyone and are delighted to bring you a raft of interesting The death of George Floyd, an African-American man, in May articles to read in this month’s issue. triggered off a summer of demonstrations, riots and debates on Top of the list is Joel Hockman’s both sides of the Atlantic. It started with the question of police fascinating tale of finding an unknown cousin (page 13) and our own Debra racism in America and quickly turned into a series of passionate Barnes’ account of writing her novel The Young Survivors (page 14). Continuing debates about race, colonialism and how western societies the literary theme, David Herman has should teach and remember our colonial past. written a great piece about his recent interview with the author Thomas Harding (page 5), while our Reviews page features four very different books. We hope you enjoy this issue and would be delighted to receive any comments. Educational partnerships .............................. 3 Interview with Thomas Harding ................... 4 Letter from Israel .......................................... 5 Letters to the Editor ................................ 6 – 7 Art Notes...................................................... 8 Human Rights – our legacy .......................... 9 Lives in Focus: Rabbi Harry Jacobi ...... 10 – 11 Making Connections .................................. 13 Writing The Young Survivors ...................... 14 Looking for................................................. 15 Reviews .............................................. 16 – 17 Obituaries .........................................
    [Show full text]
  • LEGACY and GRATITUDE He Annual Tribute Dinner of the Ing Remarks
    AMERICAN & INTERNATIONAL SOCIETIES FOR YAD VASHEM Vol. 40-No.2 ISSN 0892-1571 November/December 2013-Kislev/Tevet 5774 The American & International Societies for Yad Vashem Annual Tribute Dinner LEGACY AND GRATITUDE he Annual Tribute Dinner of the ing remarks. contributions of Eli Zborowski, z”l. A This year’s dinner also recognized T American Society for Yad Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg was member of the Jewish Fighters the tenth anniversary of the Columbia Vashem was held on Sunday, honored with the Yad Vashem Organization, Zborowski survived the shuttle disaster. Tributes to Petr Ginz November 10th. With inspiring Remembrance Award, given for his war in hiding along with his mother, and Col. Ilan Ramon were especially addresses from honoree Mayor visionary leadership and for his sup- sister and younger brother, and powerful, thanks to the presence of Michael R. Bloomberg, Chairman of port of Yad Vashem’s efforts to served as liaison between the Jewish Ginz’s nephew Yoram Pressburger Leonard Wilf, Rabbi Israel Meir Lau and Ambassador Ron Prosor. the Yad Vashem Council Rabbi Israel strengthen the cause of Holocaust ghettos and non-Jewish par- Meir Lau, Chairman of the Yad remembrance and education. Most tisan units. Upon arriving in Vashem Directorate Avner Shalev, recently the recipient of the presti- America, Eli immediately and Mauthausen survivor Ed gious Genesis Prize, Mayor began devoting time and Mosberg, the dinner marked thirty- Bloomberg has been a central figure resources to Holocaust two years since the Society was in empowering New York City as the remembrance. In 1981, Eli established by the Founding capital of tolerance, innovation and founded the American and Chairman Eli Zborowski, z”l, along growth.
    [Show full text]
  • Talking Book Topics January-February 2015
    Talking Book Topics January–February 2015 Volume 81, Number 1 About Talking Book Topics Talking Book Topics is published bimonthly in audio, large-print, and online formats and distributed at no cost to blind and physically handicapped individuals who participate in the Library of Congress reading program. It lists digital audiobooks and magazines available through a network of cooperating libraries and covers news of developments and activities in network library services. The annotated list in this issue is limited to titles recently added to the national collection, which contains thousands of fiction and nonfiction titles, including bestsellers, classics, biographies, romance novels, mysteries, and how-to guides. Some books in Spanish are also available. To explore the wide range of books in the national collection, access the NLS International Union Catalog online at loc.gov/nls or contact your local cooperating library. Talking Book Topics is available online in HTML at www.loc.gov/nls/tbt and in downloadable audio files on the NLS Braille and Audio Reading Download (BARD) service at http://nlsbard.loc.gov/. Library of Congress, Washington 2015 Catalog Card Number 60-46157 ISSN 0039-9183 Where to write Order talking books through your local cooperating library. If you wish to make changes in your current subscription, please also contact your local cooperating library. Patrons who are American citizens living abroad may request delivery to foreign addresses by contacting the overseas librarian by phone at (202) 707-5100 or e-mail at [email protected]. Only send correspondence about editorial matters to: Publications and Media Section, National Library Service for the Blind and Physically Handicapped, Page 1 of 133 Library of Congress, Washington DC, 20542-0002.
    [Show full text]
  • Mai 2014 Kostenlos Zum Mitnehmen
    HEvEllEr Beiderseits der Havel – Magazin für den Norden von Potsdam 6. Jahrgang/Nummer 56 • Mai 2014 Kostenlos zum Mitnehmen Wölfe in Brandenburg: „Ruhe bewahren und genießen“, meint Steve Schulz vom NABU. (Seite 6) Foto: © S.Koerner/lupovision.de Der Sacrower Jörg Martin Schüler hat ein Buch geschrieben – was er sonst noch zu erzählen hat, steht auf den Seiten 8–9. Thomas Harding findet ein Zeitdokument im Haus seiner Großeltern. Was es mit dem Alexander-Haus in Groß Glienicke auf sich hat, lesen Sie auf Seiten 28–29. Heveller · Seite 2 Anzeigen Mai 2014 Anzeige im HEVELLER: 0331/200 97 08 Mai 2014 Editorial Seite 3 · Heveller Inhalt Liebe Leserinnen, liebe Leser, Seiten 4 – 5 Region zum letzten Mal in dieser Wahl- Groß Glienicke zu einem Erinne- Seiten 6 – 7 periode hatten im Potsdamer Rat- rungsort der deutsch-jüdischen Ge- haus in der Reihe hinter den Stadt- schichte zu entwickeln. Allerdings Der Wolf vor unserer Tür verordneten auch wieder die Orts- auch hier: Die Stadt hat kein Geld. vorsteher Platz genommen. Sie sind Zurückgestellt wurde die Benen- Seiten 8 – 9 vor allem interessierte Zuhörer bei nung der Straßen im B-Plangebiet den Stadtverordnetenversammlun- 21 (Kreisel – Einkaufszentrum). Orts- Vor Secrow in die Welt gen, diskutieren aber auch mal mit, vorsteher Franz Blaser meldete Be- wenn es um ihre örtlichen Belange ratungsbedarf an, weil inzwischen Seiten 10 – 11 geht, und vermitteln die Standpunkte die Anbindung der Ullrich-Steinhau- ihrer Ortsbeiräte. Erfreulicherweise er-Straße an die Landesstraße nach Region wird das meist gehört. Seeburg infrage steht. Und warum ist das wohl so? Beschlossen wurde ebenfalls, dass Seiten 12 – 13 Mein Erklärungsversuch: Die Orts- das Rahmenkonzept für die Bürger- vorsteher haben eine andere Position und Begegnungshäuser weiterent- Historie in ihrer Funktion, wenn sie in der wickelt wird, weil sich die Kosten Stadtverordnetenversammlung auf- für Mieten und Bewirtschaftung er- Seite 14 treten, sie gehören (im Normalfall) höht haben.
    [Show full text]