CAPITALISM, SOCIALISM AND DEMOCRACY When Joseph Schumpeter’s book first appeared, the New English Weekly predicted that ‘for the next five to ten years it will certainly remain a work with which no one who professes any degree of information on sociology or economics can afford to be unacquainted’. The prophecy has been justified, but how much more fully than its maker anticipated. A generation later, it is more widely read than when it first appeared. The mixed economy has become established in North America as well as in the countries of the European Community, while in the socialist countries there has been a move towards various forms of decentralisation and of a market economy. In this new context the issues that Schumpeter raises are still matters of lively debate. CAPITALISM, SOCIALISM AND DEMOCRACY Joseph A.Schumpeter INTRODUCTION BY RICHARD SWEDBERG Stockholm University London and New York First published in the USA This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2003. First published in the UK in 1943 First impression 1944 Second edition 1947 Third edition 1950 First impression 1952 Fourth edition 1954 Eighth impression 1974 Fifth edition 1976 Third impression 1981 New in paperback 1994 © George Allen & Unwin (Publishers) Ltd 1976 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN 0-203-20205-8 Master e-book ISBN ISBN 0-203-26611-0 (Adobe eReader Format) ISBN 0-415-10762-8 (Print Edition) CONTENTS Introduction by Richard Swedberg ix PART I: THE MARXIAN DOCTRINE 1 Prologue 3 I. Marx the Prophet 5 II. Marx the Sociologist 9 III. Marx the Economist 21 IV. Marx the Teacher 45 PART II: CAN CAPITALISM SURVIVE? 59 Prologue 61 V. The Rate of Increase of Total Output 63 VI. Plausible Capitalism 72 VII. The Process of Creative Destruction 81 VIII. Monopolistic Practices 87 IX. Closed Season 107 X. The Vanishing of Investment Opportunity 111 XI. The Civilization of Capitalism 121 XII. Crumbling Walls 131 I. The Obsolescence of the Entrepreneurial Function 131 II. The Destruction of the Protecting Strata 134 III. The Destruction of the Institutional Framework of Capitalist Society 139 XIII. Growing Hostility 143 I. The Social Atmosphere of Capitalism 143 II. The Sociology of the Intellectual 145 XIV. Decomposition 156 PART III: CAN SOCIALISM WORK? 165 XV. Clearing Decks 167 XVI. The Socialist Blueprint 172 XVII. Comparison of Blueprints 187 I. A Preliminary Point 187 II. A Discussion of Comparative Efficiency 188 III. The Case for the Superiority of the Socialist Blueprint 193 v vi Contents XVIII. The Human Element 200 A Warning 200 I. The Historical Relativity of the Argument 200 II. About Demigods and Archangels 202 III. The Problem of Bureaucratic Management 205 IV. Saving and Discipline 210 V. Authoritarian Discipline in Socialism; a Lesson from Russia 212 XIX. Transition 219 I. Two Different Problems Distinguished 219 II. Socialization in a State of Maturity 221 III. Socialization in a State of Immaturity 223 IV. Socialist Policy Before the Act; the English Example 228 PART IV: SOCIALISM AND DEMOCRACY 232 XX. The Setting of the Problem 235 I. The Dictatorship of the Proletariat 235 II. The Record of Socialist Parties 237 III. A Mental Experiment 240 IV. In Search of a Definition 243 XXI. The Classical Doctrine of Democracy 250 I. The Common Good and the Will of the People 250 II. The Will of the People and Individual Volition 252 III. Human Nature in Politics 256 IV. Reasons for the Survival of the Classical Doctrine 264 XXII. Another Theory of Democracy 269 I. Competition for Political Leadership 269 II. The Principle Applied 273 XXIII. The Inference 284 I. Some Implications of the Preceding Analysis 284 II. Conditions for the Success of the Democratic Method 289 III. Democracy in the Socialist Order 296 PART V: A HISTORICAL SKETCH OF SOCIALIST PARTIES 303 Prologue 305 XXIV. The Nonage 306 XXV. The Situation that Marx Faced 312 XXVI. From 1875 to 1914 320 I. English Developments and the Spirit of Fabianism 320 II. Sweden on the One Hand and Russia on the Other 325 III. Socialist Groups in the United States 331 Contents vii IV. The French Case; Analysis of Syndicalism 336 V. The German Party and Revisionism; the Austrian Socialists 341 VI. The Second International 349 XXVII. From the First to the Second World War 352 I. The “Gran Rifiuto” 352 II. The Effects of the First World War on the Chances of the Socialist Parties of Europe 354 III. Communism and the Russian Element 358 IV. Administering Capitalism? 363 V. The Present War and the Future of Socialist Parties 373 XXVIII. The Consequences of the Second World War 376 I. England and Orthodox Socialism 377 II. Economic Possibilities in the United States 380 1. Redistribution of Income through Taxation 381 2. The Great Possibility 382 3. Conditions for Its Realization 385 4. Transitional Problems 391 5. The Stagnationist Thesis 392 6. Conclusion 398 III. Russian Imperialism and Communism 398 PREFACES AND COMMENTS ON LATER DEVELOPMENTS Preface to the First Edition, 1942 409 Preface to the Second Edition, 1946 411 Preface to the Third Edition, 1949 415 The March into Socialism 421 Index 433 INTRODUCTION This is a book to be read not for the agreement or disagreement it provokes but for the thought it invokes. John Kenneth Galbraith Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy is one of the great classics in twentieth century social science. What makes Schumpeter’s book so brilliant are three things in particular: its novel view of democracy; its heretic analysis of the workings of the capitalist economy; and its provocative argument that capitalism is bound to disappear—not because of its failure, but because of its success. Schumpeter’s style, it should be emphasized, also makes the book a pleasure to read: “Even if, in places, you may dislike what Schumpeter says”, as one reviewer put it, “you will like the way he says it”.1 In this introduction I shall say, first, a few words about the writing of Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy and its place in Schumpeter’s output as a whole (Part I). I shall provide then a reader’s guide to Schumpeter’s book, which may be of assistance to those who are approaching it for the first time. This will also enable the hurried reader to go straight to the most important parts of Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (Part II). The third and final part of the introduction deals with the contemporary relevance of Schumpeter’s work. Schumpeter, for example, argued that socialism is about to replace capitalism—an opinion that seems totally wrong today, especially after the disintegration of state socialism in the Soviet Union and East-Central Europe (Part III). I. THE MAKING OF CAPITALISM, SOCIALISM AND DEMOCRACY AND ITS PLACE IN SCHUMPETER’S WORK AS A WHOLE The story of how Schumpeter came to write Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy can be sketched in a few lines. Towards the end of the 1930s, Schumpeter decided to write a small book on socialism. To cite his wife, Elizabeth Boody Schumpeter: “J.A.S. had finished his monumental Business Cycles in 1938 and sought relaxation in Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, which he regarded as a distinctly ‘popular’ offering that he expected to finish in a few months.”2 Schumpeter’s book, however, took longer to complete than he had expected, and it was not published until 1942. It was very well received, both in England and in the United States, and its reputation grew as further editions were published in 1947 and 1950. Today, according to John Kenneth ix x Introduction Galbraith, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy is the main work by which Schumpeter is remembered.3 A summary account of this type fails, however, to do justice to the making of Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy in at least two important ways. First, Schumpeter’s work draws very much on his earlier research and personal experience. In the preface to the first edition, Schumpeter says that his book was the result of “almost forty years’ thought, observation and research on the subject of socialism”.4 Gottfried Haberler—one of the foremost authorities on Schumpeter—has added that the book “sums up, brings up-to-date and slightly modifies the result of Schumpeter’s life-long work and study [not only of socialism but of economic theory as well]”.5 There is also the fact that the period during which Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy was written was a particularly turbulent and dramatic one in Schumpeter’s life. He was, for example, investigated during these years by the FBI for possible espionage, and there were rumours, (as there still are), that he was pro-Nazi. He was also going through a personal crisis—reevaluating himself and his work. Through its exuberant style, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy may give the impression that it was written by someone who was happy and carefree, but that was far from the case. If Schumpeter’s book has its origin in events “almost forty years ago”, we need to know more about Schumpeter around the year 1900. At this time the young Schumpeter, (who was born in 1883 in the small town of Triesch, the son of a textile manufacturer), was about to enter the University of Vienna. He had just finished his studies at Theresianum, an exclusive private school for the elite of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.