Of Lightsails, Ramjets, and Fusion Runways
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CHAPTER 6 OF LIGHTSAILS, RAMJETS, AND FUSION RUNWAYS Terminology is always treacherous-one field's jargon contra dicts another's unstated assumptions-but we must now make a distinction between solar sails and lightsails. The solar sail is pushed by photons from the Sun, while the lightsail is usually much larger and driven by man-made light, microwaves, or per haps some kind of particle beam. This distinction isn't exclusive, though, because even before we've launched the first free-flying solar sail, the mission planners for The Planetary Society's Cos mos 1 have plans to demonstrate both photon and microwave propulsion on the same sail. Nor is size an absolute criterion, for solar sails can be vast in their own right. The early solar sail designs NASA studied for the Halley's Comet rendezvous reached 64o,ooo square meters, fully a half-mile to the side. Better, then, to add these qualifiers: A lightsail is built in space and made of materials different from the plastic films being con sidered for near-term solar sail experiments. Not needing to be stowed for launch and later unfolded for use, lightsails can be built without the tough backing necessary to keep them from tearing on deployment, and can therefore be far lighter. "If you imagine a network of carbon-fiber strings, a spinning spiderweb kilometers across with gaps the size of football fields between the strands, you will be well on your way to imagining the structure of P. Gilster, Centauri Dreams 123 © Springer Science+Business Media New York 2004 CHAPTER 6 124 a lightsail," writes Eric Drexler, who has patented techniques for creating sails made of ultra-thin films. Drexler is a key figure in the development of nanotechnology and author of the seminal Engines of Creation. "Imagine the gaps bridged by reflecting panels built of aluminum foil thinner than a soap bubble, tied close together to make a vast, rippled mosaic of mirror. Now pic ture a load of cargo hanging from the web like a dangling para chutist, while centrifugal force holds the spinning, web-slung mirror taut and flat in the void." Thus one vision of a sail that could take us to the stars, a lightsail pushed by beams of energy. Although solar sails seem more at home in warmer, light-filled interplanetary environments, they can be adapted for interstellar purposes. In fact, physicists Gregory Matloff and Eugene Mallove explored interstellar missions for solar sails in a classic 1981 paper, later refining them in their book The Starflight Hand book. The two envisioned a sail that would approach the Sun for a gravity assist, with a close pass by the solar furnace using an asteroid as a heat shield. With the sail unfurled and hidden in the asteroid's shadow, the spacecraft and occulting asteroid would swing as close as 0.01 AU (930,000 miles) from the heart of the Sun, skimming a scant 430,000 miles over the solar surface. At the critical moment, the sail would emerge from behind the asteroid, unfurling as acceleration builds. In later studies, Matloff and Mallove would demonstrate solar sail designs that reach Alpha Centauri in approximately one thousand years. Depending on the sail materials developed by future technology and the velocity created by the solar pass, an automated mission might be possible whose transit time would be no more than several hundred years. Nor is the sail through when propulsion ends. Having achieved maximum acceleration, the starship could wrap the sail around its payload as a barrier to cosmic rays, perhaps deploying it again as a braking system upon arrival in the new planetary system. Matloff and Mallove's starship would experience huge accel erations, up to sixty times that of Earth's gravity (6o g) if fully unfurled at perihelion, the moment of closest approach to the Sun. That puts the burden on sail materials, one reason the two proposed using cables made of diamond to attach the payload to the sail. As for the sail itself, Eric Drexler has shown that a tech- OF LIGHTSAILS, RAMJETS, AND FUSION RUNWAYS 125 nique called vacuum deposition can be used to create sails far thinner than the Mylar films proposed for proof-of-concept mis sions like Cosmos 1. Using these methods, metallic foils only a few hundred atoms thick have been created. Matloff and Mallove propose that a boron sail, with melting point of 2,6oo degrees Kelvin, might be an ideal candidate for a mission this close to the Sun. An interstellar transit of several hundred years, or even a thou sand, would be an immense leap beyond what current technolo gies can achieve: the 4o,ooo years it will take Voyager 1 to drift within 1.6 light years of a star known as AC+79 3888 in the con stellation of Camelopardalis, or the 296,ooo years it will take Voy ager 2 to reach the neighborhood of Sirius. Yet the idea that we could reduce transit times even more continued to push interstel lar research through the latter half of the twentieth century. The breakthrough insight, moving well beyond currently available engineering but staying within the known laws of physics, was provided by Robert Forward in 1962. Working with the principle that the most feasible starship is the one that leaves its fuel behind, Forward began to think about pushing spacecraft with lasers. If the Sun couldn't continue to accelerate a sail much past the orbit ofJupiter, and if even the strongest gravity assist couldn't give you more than a few hundred kilometers per second, then finding a way to stream power directly to the spacecraft, pushing its sail with a high-intensity beam oflight, might be the solution. Forward had been working part time at the Hughes Aircraft Company, attending first UClA on a Hughes fellowship in pur suit of a masters degree in engineering, and then the University of Maryland to work on a PhD in physics. At UClA, he had begun compiling a bibliography on interstellar travel and com munication, corresponding with authors and offering his own tips about ways to improve their work. At Maryland in 1961, he had set up the Interstellar Research Foundation, circulating ideas among fifty fellow interstellar enthusiasts, and calling for propos als to achieve flight to another star that did not use rockets. While the response was tepid, Forward in the meantime had made his CHAPTER 6 126 own intellectual breakthrough, one drawing on the work of Theodore Maiman at Hughes Research Laboratories, who had shown how to make a functional laser in 1960. In the unfinished autobiographical essay he wrote near the end of his life, Forward recalled reading about the laser in a Maryland newspaper and thinking he had just found a way to send people to the stars. "I knew a lot about solar sails," Forward wrote, "and how, if you shine sunlight on them, the sunlight will push on the sail and make it go faster. Normal sunlight spreads out with distance, so after the solar sail has reached Jupiter, the sunlight is too weak to push well anymore. But if you can turn the sunlight into laser light, the laser beam will not spread. You can send on the laser light, and ride the laser beam all the way to the stars!" His enthusiasm growing, Forward wrote the concept up as an internal memo sent to the laboratory director at Hughes in May 1961. His first public statement of the notion came in a 1962 arti cle in Missiles and Rockets called "Pluto, Gateway to the Stars" that was reprinted in Science Digest and Galaxy Science Fiction. The latter reprint is worth noting, given Forward's growing inter est in science fiction and the strong connection between it and his scientific work. In fact, the most significant scientific article he wrote on laser-driven lightsails came two years after his novel Rocheworld, in which he laid out the essential elements that would guide his later research. Rocheworld tells the story of man's first expedition to another star, in this case, Barnard's Star, which has been chosen because earlier unmanned probes indicated the presence of planets, including the bizarre Rocheworld, a twin planet system held in the most delicate of gravitational dances. The title is drawn from nineteenth-century French astronomer Edouard Roche, whose work with gravitational forces on moons and planets led to the "Roche limit," the closest distance a moon can approach its planet without being destroyed. Forward's novel is stuffed with concepts notable not only for their ingenuity but their strict adherence to the laws of physics. The starship of Rocheworld is driven by a sail fully 300 kilome ters (186 miles) in diameter, with a 3.5oo-ton payload supporting some twenty crewmembers. How the ship-and the laser array that propelled it from an orbital station near Mercury-came to be designed is itself an interesting tale. Following his 1962 article OF LIGHTSAILS, RAMJETS, AND FUSION RUNWAYS 127 (and in the aftermath of a subsequent examination of the laser driven sail concept by George Marx in Nature in 1966), Forward had been in correspondence with science fiction writers Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle. He invited them to meet him at Hughes Research Laboratories for a chat about physics. By 1973, when he met with the two writers, Forward still had found no way to stop his laser-pushed lightsail. Any interstellar flight using it would of necessity be a flyby. Niven and Pournelle nonetheless took away from the meeting the germ of their novel The Mote in God's Eye.