Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
FINAL RESETTLEMENT AUDIT REPORT
Prepared By: Romeo B. Cleto Resettlement Consultant Specialist October 2008
Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
ABBREVIATIONS ADB - Asian Development Bank AP/AH - Affected Person/Affected Household CAM - Cambodia CARM - Cambodia Resident Mission (ADB) DBST - Double Bituminous Surface Treatment DMS - Detailed Measurement Survey IRC - Inter-ministerial Resettlement Committee IRC-WG - IRC Working Group (IRC Resettlement Unit) km - Kilometer MEF - Ministry of Economy and Finance MOU - Memorandum Of Understanding MPWT - Ministry of Public Works and Transport NGO - Non-Government Organization NR - National Road PCR - Project Completion Report PGC - Provincial Grievance Committee ROW - Right-Of-Way RRP - Report and Recommendation of the President RP - Resettlement Plan SRP - Summary Resettlement Plan RU-IRC - Resettlement Unit - IRC
Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
CONTENTS Page
1. GENERAL INTRODUCTION 3 A. Background 3 B. Subsequent Resettlement Issues Following Loan Effectiveness 8 C. The Resettlement Audit 9 2. STUDY DESIGN 13 A. Analytical Framework for the Resettlement Audit 13 B. Data Gathering Strategy 13 C. Data Processing and Analysis 15 D. The Resettlement Audit Team 15 E. Timeframe 15 3. FINDINGS 17 A. Resettlement Plan 17 B. Review of AP Records with RU-IRC 24 C. Field Interview 29 D. Focus Group Discussion 32 4. RECOMMENDATIONS 33
APPENDICES 1. Copy of Section VI, Assurances, of the RRP and the SRP 2. 30 June 2000 faxed letter of ADB declaring Loan 1697-CAM effective 3. 6 October 2003 letter of complaints of the NGO Forum 4. Summary of findings of the 14-15 October 2003 ADB resettlement review mission 5. 18 May 2005 letter of CARM to MEF introducing the Resettlement Audit Team 6. Master list of APs provided by IRC to the audit team 7. English translation of the audit household survey 8. 14 September 2007 letter of IRC informing CARM about the completion of payment of outstanding claims brought forward by the NGO Forum on behalf of the APs 9. Approval by MEF of the unit rates for compensating affected assets 10. Replacement cost study report 11. Contract of the external monitoring agency 12. Ledger of payments made to the EMA 13. Copy of 2 monthly reports of the EMA 14. June 2006 document faxed by IRC to CARM summarizing the number of compensated APs the total amount paid 15. Reconstructed master list of APs in NR 5 with DMS and payment records reviewed by the audit team 16. Reconstructed master list of APs in NR 6 with DMS and payment records reviewed by the audit team 17. Reconstructed master list of APs in NR 7 with DMS and payment records reviewed by the audit team 18. Compensated structures in NR 5 per DMS and payment records reviewed at IRC 19. Compensated structures in NR 6 per DMS and payment records reviewed at IRC
1 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
20. Compensated structures in NR 7 per DMS and payment records reviewed at IRC 21. List of APs interviewed in NR 5 with unpaid claims 22. List of APs interviewed in NR 6 with unpaid claims 23. List of APs interviewed in NR 7 with unpaid claims 24. Highlights of the focus group discussions
TABLES Table 1-1 Communes Traversed by the Road Project ...... 5 Table 3-1 Number of Affected Main Structures...... 20 Table 3-2 Entitlements for Affected Land in ROW ...... 21 Table 3-3 Inventory of Perennial Crops and Timber Trees in the COI...... 21 Table 3-4 Unit Costs of Affected Buildings...... 22 Table 3-5 Unit Costs of Affected Trees (in US$)...... 22 Table 3-6 Unit Costs of Affected Miscellaneous Structures ...... 22 Table 3-7 Summary of APs and Allocated Compensation and Entitlements ...... 24 Table 3-8 Summary of Compensated APs per IRC Report...... 24 Table 3-9 Summary of Record of APs Reviewed by the Audit Team ...... 25 Table 3-10 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings in NR 5...... 26 Table 3-11 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings (NR6)...... 27 Table 3-12 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings (NR7)...... 28 Table 3-13 Pursat Province (NR 5)...... 29 Table 3-14 APs Interviewed by Survey Team in NR 5 (Not Found in the DMS List)...... 29 Table 3-15 Battambang Province (NR 5)...... 30 Table 3-16 Kompong Thom Province (NR 6)...... 30 Table 3-17 APs Interviewed by Survey Team in NR 6 (Not Found in DMS List) ...... 31 Table 3-18 Kampong Cham Province (NR 7) ...... 31 Table 3-19 Kratie Province (NR 7)...... 32 Table 3-20 APs Interviewed by Survey Team in NR 7 (Not Found in DMS List) ...... 32
LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Project Location Map...... 11 Figure 2: Typical Cross-section of the Road...... 12
2 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
1. GENERAL INTRODUCTION
A. Background
1. Loan 1697-CAM (Primary Roads Restoration Project) was approved by the Bank on 21 September 1999 and the Loan Agreement signed on 4 November 1999. As a condition for loan effectiveness, the Government had to submit an updated resettlement plan (RP) acceptable to the ADB, which it did in June 2000, paving the way for the Bank to declare the loan effective on 30 June 2000. The Ministry of Public Work and Transport (MPWT) was the executing agency.
1. Project Location
a. National Road (NR) 5
2. NR5 starts from Phnom Penh and follows a northwestern course to the west of the Tonle Sap (Lake) before ending in Poipet at the border with Thailand. The road traverses the provincial capital towns of Kompong Chhnang, Pursat, Battambang, and Sisophon. Lowland rain-fed rice farming, along with sugar palm cultivation and raising cattle, is the main economic activity in most areas traversed by the road. The Province of Battambang is a major rice-producing area. Also, the provincial capital towns of Pursat and Battambang are major commercial centers. Battambang is a key transit point of goods and people to and from Thailand. NR5 is a major road artery that links Thailand with Phnom Penh and Vietnam.
b. National Road (NR) 6
3. NR6 starts from Phnom Penh, initially following a northward direction before turning northwest at Kompong Thmor, Province of Kompong Thom, running to the east of the Tonle Sap before ending at Sisophon, Province of Battambang, where it joins NR5 close to the Thai border.
c. National Road (NR) 7
4. NR7 breaks off from NR6 at Skun, Province of Kompong Cham, generally following an eastern course until Krek, near the border with Vietnam, from where it curbs northward to the border with Laos in the Province of Stung Treng. NR7 crosses the provinces of Kompong Cham, Kratie, and Stung Treng. The section of NR7 that is covered by Loan 1697 starts from Thnol Totoeung (also known as Chup) and ends at Kratie. (See Figure 1 for the Project Location Map)
2. Scope of Civil Works
5. Previous to the restoration Project, the 3 roads had a 4 ~ 6 m wide macadam pavement. Under the Project, the carriageway had been widened to 7 m of DBST (double bituminous surface treatment) pavement. Moreover, a 1.5 m sealed shoulder on each side and a roll over of 0.5 m at the edge of each of the shoulders had been provided. Flood- prone sections of the road had been raised on embankment to a height of 3 ~ 6 m. (See Figure 2 for the Typical Cross-section of the Road)
3 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
6. Under Prakas (Order) No.6, the statutory road right-of-way (ROW) for NR5 is 60 m, while for both NR6 and NR7, the ROW is 50 m.1 However, Government decided to narrow down the corridor of impact (COI) between 25 ~ 26 m.2 Said corridor had been cleared of people and structures permanently. Civil works had all been completed in December 2005.3 The loan closing date was originally targeted on 31 January 2004 in the loan agreement. The actual closing of the project was 4 August 2006 and a completion report (PCR) was prepared in November 2006.
a. National Road (NR) 5
7. Originally, the restoration of NR5 under Loan 1697-CAM was envisaged to start from Phnom Penh to Sisophon, to be carried out in 6 contract packages (i.e., 5A, 5B, 5C, 5D, 5E, and 5E1). The scope of the restoration project was later modified to cover only contract packages 5B, 5C, 5E and 5E1. 5B had a length of 50 km, while 5C was 83 km long. Contract packages 5E and 5E1 were bridge construction works. The 20 communes traversed by the 133 km long section of NR5 that had been restored under the Project are shown in Table 1.
b. National Road (NR) 6
8. Originally, the restoration of NR6 was to start from the point where NR7 breaks off from it at Skun, Province of Kompong Cham, heading northward up to the political boundaries of Kompong Thom Province and Siem Reap Province. The restoration works were to be carried out in 2 contract packages (i.e., 6A and 6B). The scope of the restoration project was later modified, however, covering only contract package 6B, which had a length of 70 km. The 10 communes traversed by the restoration of NR6B are shown in Table 1.
c. National Road (NR) 7
9. The restoration of the 204 km section of NR7 under the Project was divided into 5 contract packages, namely, 7A (74 km long), 7B (17 km), 7C (15 km), 7D (15 km), and 7E (83 km). Another contract package, 7E-1, involved the construction of a bridge. The 24 communes traversed by the road section are shown in Table 1 overleaf.
3. Resettlement Planning Documents during Appraisal and Loan Negotiation
10. The preliminary road designs and the results of the social impact survey were among the outputs of the project preparatory technical assistance (PPTA) 2722-CAM that facilitated the Project loan’s approval. The results of the social impact survey were incorporated in the preliminary resettlement action plan (preliminary RP) that was prepared by MPWT and the TA consultants. The Bank, through the Social Development Division (SOCD), found the preliminary RP acceptable which paved the way for loan negotiation in August 1999. 4
1 Prakas No. 6, entitled Measures to Crackdown on Anarchic Land Grabbing and Encroachment, was issued by the Office of the Prime Minister on 27 September 1999. The Order sets a ROW of 60 m for NR Nos. 1, 4, and 5; and a 50 m ROW for NR Nos. 2, 3, 6, and 7. Prakas No. 6 directs the military, the police, and relevant government agencies to enforce the Order. 2 The RP claims a COI averaging 19 m only. This corridor should be clear of people and structures permanently. 3 The report and recommendation of the President in 1999 projected the Project to start in April 2000 and would be completed in 40 moths, or in July 2003. Civil works would be carried out from April 2000 to March 2003. 4 A Fact-finding Mission was fielded in Cambodia from 6-21 March 1997 to formulate the Project. An Appraisal Mission was fielded from 8-23 May 1997 as part of Project preparation. Two more Appraisal Missions (in
4 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Table 1-1 Communes Traversed by the Road Project National Road 5 Pursat Province Battambang Province District Commune District Commune Bakan Boeng Khnar Moung Ruessei Kear Ou Ta Paong Moung Russei Snam Preah Prey Svay Svay Doun Kaev Prey Touch Trapeang Chong Ruessei Krang Krakor Tnaot Chum Sangkae Anlong Vil Sampov Meas Lolok Sa Kampong Preah Phteah Prey Kampong Preang Prey Nhi Ou Dambang Pir Svay at Roleab National Road 6 (Kampong Thom Province) District Commune District Commune Kampong Svay San Kor Stueng Saen Achar Leak Trapeang Ruessei Kampong Krabau Stoung Chamnar Kraom Prey Ta Hu Kampong Chen Cheung Kampong Chen Tboung Pralay Samprouch National Road 7 Kompong Cham Kratie District Commune District Commune Memot Dar Kratie Bos Leav Memot Dar Tramung Kantuot Treak Kratie Ponhea Kraek Kandaol Chrum Ou Ruessei Kaong Kang Thma Kreae Kraek Snuol Khsuem Popel Snuol Veal Mlu Srae Char Tboung Khmum Anhchaeum Chob Moung Riev Sralab Suong Vihear Luong
11. The preliminary RP was condensed into a Summary Resettlement Plan (SRP) and attached as Appendix 9 to the 26 August 1999 Report and Recommendation of the President (RRP). The RRP reported that MPWT had agreed with Bank representatives that a 5 m setback from the toe of the road embankment would define the limit of the area of the ROW
January 1998 and in February 1999 were fielded before formal loan negotiations were held in Phnom Penh from11 to 12 August 1999.
5 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
that would be cleared of all structures and fixed assets. Project affected persons (APs) would be allowed to rebuild their affected structures within the ROW but outside of the 5 m setback area following completion of civil works in a given stretch of the road. The intention here was to avoid unnecessary land acquisition and resettlement.5 The SRP in paragraphs 1 and 2 was confident that it would “not be necessary to purchase land outside of the existing right- of-way for the relocation of APs” as they could “be resettled on their existing land by moving their structures back from the widened roads”. Section 6, Paragraph 89 (iv), of the RRP echoed Government’s assurance that “land acquisition and resettlement activities (would be) implemented in accordance with the plan agreed upon with the Bank during project preparation and loan processing…”
12. The SRP summarized the preliminary estimates of Project impacts, thus: a. 135 ha of land would be needed within the existing road right-of-way (ROW) for the widening and improvement of the road sections covered by the Project; b. Approximately 2,207 APs households (made up of 11,474 persons) were found along the edges of the then 4 ~ 6 m wide roads within the existing ROW; c. More than 90.0% of the 1,150 affected structures were wooden vendor stalls with corrugated plastic or thatch roofing; only 18 of the affected structures had wooden walls and a wooden or concrete flooring; and d. Two percent of the affected structures were used purely for residence, 7.0% for residence and business, and 91.0% for business, mainly temporary vendor stalls.
13. Additionally, the SRP contained the following provisions: a. Compensation for all structures will be at replacement cost and must be sufficient to completely rebuild the structure at the time of compensation. No deduction (will be made) for salvageable materials. (Paragraph 16) b. APs experiencing a loss of more than 10 percent of their holding6 will receive land of equivalent value, while those losing less than 10 percent will receive cash compensation. Farmers using land within the demarcated reserve7 will be considered to have rights of usufruct and will be entitled to the same compensation benefits as farmers losing less than 10 percent of their land. Agricultural land will be compensated at market prices. (Paragraph 19) c. AP having more than 60 square meters (m²) of remaining area8 will reconstruct on the existing site. AP with less than 60 m² but more than 30 m² will have the option to relocate or rebuild. AP with less than 30 m² will relocate and have the option to accept a plot at a resettlement site…(Paragraphs 20, 21, and 22) d. AP who reconstruct on the same site will receive cash compensation for land lost according to compensation schedules presented in the detailed RP. No distinction will be made between legal and illegal APs. Illegal APs will be provided with land certificates by the district authorities at no cost. (Paragraph 23) e. APs will receive a site of equivalent or greater value than their former site. No contribution will be required from APs if the value of the relocation site is greater
5 Section 2 (Social Impacts), paragraph 64, of the RRP. 6 Arable land 7 The ROW 8 Residential or commercial land
6 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
than their former location. On-site services will be provided by the district authorities who will receive a compensation rate of $300 per household, if a resettlement site is required. f. Loss of crops and trees will be compensated at full replacement value including crop development costs. (Paragraph 25) g. Relocation sites will take into account the wishes of the APs and sites will have the same advantages as the former location. The area of each plot will be the same as the original and never less than 60 m². (Paragraph 23) h. People occupying illegal structures will receive the same assistance and compensation as those with legal title. (Paragraph 17) i. MPWT through the contractor will assist APs to dismantle, relocate, and reconstruct their structures affected by the Project free of costs. (Paragraph 16) j. Detailed resettlement and land compensation schedules will be completed before construction activities begin in an area. APs will be given at least 2 months final notice prior to demolition or land acquisition, and all compensation payments will be paid and resettlement sites, if required, identified at least 1 month prior to the actual dislocation. (Paragraph 28)
14. The SRP in paragraph 5 stated that a final determination of the people and assets to be affected by the Project would be done through a detailed measurement survey (DMS) following completion of detailed engineering design and before the start of civil works. The results of the DMS would facilitate the updating of the preliminary RP and which would have to be implemented before civil works could begin.
15. The Board of Directors of ADB on 21 September 1999 approved Loan 1697-CAM. (See Appendix 1 for a copy of Section VI, Assurances, of the RRP and the SRP).
4. Conditions for Loan Effectiveness and Particular Covenants
16. Article IV (Particular Covenants), Section 4.01 (b) of the Loan Agreement stipulates that in “the carrying out of the Project and operation of the Project facilities, the Borrower shall perform, or cause to be performed, all obligations set forth in Schedule 6 to (the) Loan Agreement”. Furthermore, as an additional condition to loan effectiveness, Article VI, Section 6.01 requires Government to prepare and approve a detailed compensation and resettlement action plan (as mentioned in paragraph 1 above) acceptable to the Bank.
17. On the basis of the DMS of affected assets undertaken on March 30 to May 10, 2000 by the Inter-Ministerial Resettlement Committee (IRC), a final RP was prepared by MPWT, with assistance from the TA consultants, and submitted in June 2000 to ADB. On 30 June 2000, the Program Department West of ADB faxed a letter to H.E. KEAT Chhon, Senior Minister of the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF), declaring Loan 1697 effective on the same day. (See Appendix 2 for a copy of the 30 June 2000 faxed letter of ADB declaring Loan 1697-CAM effective).
18. According to the approved RP, the Project would adversely affect 12,868 persons in 2,415 households and would require the acquisition of 1,531 houses and stalls, in addition to 7 temporary fuel pumps9 and 2 market areas; 2,331 miscellaneous or “other” structures, such
9 Manually operated pumps on top of diesel or gasoline 200 liter barrels.
7 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
as fences and water wells, graves, gates, etc.; and 2,600 perennial crops/trees. The RP estimated the total costs of resettlement at $1,157,928.88, broken down as follows: compensation and entitlements - $724,690.73; incremental (administrative) costs - $240,250; and contingencies - $192,988.15.
19. Two areas of concerns in Schedule 6 of the Loan Agreement are herein stressed. The first concerns project implementation. Schedule 6 identifies MPWT as the Executing Agency for the Project, responsible for the overall supervision and implementation of the Project. Within MPWT, a project management unit (PMU) would be responsible for day-to- day concerns in Project implementation, including “coordinating all Project Activities with…relevant national and provincial agencies of the Borrower”. The PMU would report to an inter-ministerial body, the Project Coordination Committee (PCC), tasked with overseeing overall Project implementation. The PCC would be headed by the MPWT Minister, together with a Secretary of State of MPWT as Vice Chairman. The PCC would “meet at least once every six months and shall assist in resolving issues concerning inter-Ministry matters and provide guidance to the PMU on policy directions”.
20. The second area of concern pertains to land acquisition and resettlement. Paragraph 4 of Schedule 6 spells out the following obligations: a. The Borrower shall ensure that all land acquisition, the compensation and resettlement action plan and monitoring programs agreed with the Bank are carried out promptly and efficiently, and that all persons affected by the acquisition of land required for the Project are compensated and resettled in accordance with the compensation and resettlement action plan in a manner that they shall be at least as well-off as they would have been in the absence of the Project. b. Adequate funds shall be made available by the borrower in a timely manner for land acquisition and resettlement activities. c. MPWT shall provide the Bank with status reports on the land acquisition and resettlement process as part of the Project’s monthly progress reports.
B. Subsequent Resettlement Issues Following Loan Effectiveness
21. A letter dated 6 October 2003 to ADB Cambodia Resident Mission (CARM) from the NGO Forum on Cambodia on behalf of 118 APs cited cases of non-compliance by Government to the resettlement provisions of the Loan Agreement. The cases of these APs had all been brought to the attention of the IRC in 2001 and 2003. (See Appendix 3 for a copy of the 6 October 2003 letter of the NGO Forum). The grievances of the APs pertained to the following: a. APs did not receive any compensation and IRC compensation identification card despite being covered in the detailed measurement survey (DMS) and being included on the IRC list. b. APs did not receive any compensation despite being on the IRC list and despite having been issued IRC compensation identification card. c. Partial compensation received for lost structures. d. No compensation for affected crops (e.g., pepper).
8 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
e. APs did not receive compensation and were not included in the IRC compensation list despite being covered in the DMS. f. Severely affected APs were paid for lost house but were not provided replacement residential plot. g. APs were forced by local authorities to move out of the ROW before the DMS and, therefore, did not receive compensation.
22. The findings of subsequent Resettlement Missions10 fielded by the Bank have confirmed that the complaints raised by the NGO Forum on Cambodia had merits. On the basis of the findings of the 14-15 October 2003, the Bank recommended that a resettlement audit be conducted and, if warranted, APs be paid retroactively as per the approved updated RP (See Appendix 4 for a copy of the Summary of Findings of the Resettlement Review on 14-15 October 2003 Mission). These findings were re-confirmed in another Resettlement Review Mission in May 2004. Also during the May 2004 Mission, a consensus was reached with the staff of IRC that a resettlement audit was needed and would be conducted jointly by IRC, the NGO Forum on Cambodia, and COMFREL (the external monitoring agent hired by IRC for the Primary Roads Restoration Project). It was further agreed that the resettlement audit report would be submitted to ADB in October 2004.
23. The conduct of the resettlement audit did not commence until May 2005, however, and only after the signing of the May 11-12, 2005 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the Government and ADB. The May 10-12, 2005 MOU was signed by H.E. Vongsey Vissoth for the Cambodian Government and by Mr. Shyam Bajpai, then Country Director of CARM.
C. The Resettlement Audit
24. The resettlement audit of the Primary Roads Restoration Project commenced on May 17, 2005. A team of local researchers had been recruited to assist the Staff Consultant Resettlement Specialist tasked to do the work. The Government was informed about the composition of the research team on 18 May 2005 letter by Mr. Bajpai to H.E. Vissoth. (See Appendix 5 of the 18 May 2005 letter of CARM to MEF introducing the Resettlement Audit Team). The design of the audit was patterned after that of the resettlement audit of the Phnom Penh to Ho Chi Minh City Highway Improvement Project (Loan 1659-CAM).
1. Objectives and Scope
25. As agreed by the Government of Cambodia and the ADB the resettlement audit was to look into the following resettlement concerns: a. In what way were people affected b. What they were entitled to c. What they received d. What is their current situation, and e. What compensation or other assistance they still need.
10 October 14-15, 2003 and May 11-21, 2004.
9 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
2. Funding for the Audit
26. Funds for the audit were provided by ADB. IRC, on the other hand, provided a room at the MEF for the use of the researchers of the Audit Team.
10 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Figure 1: Project Location Map
11 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Figure 2: Typical Cross-section of the Road
12 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
2. STUDY DESIGN
A. Analytical Framework for the Resettlement Audit
27. The resettlement audit was guided by ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement as enunciated in the Loan Agreement and all pertinent documents that came with it, such as the RRP and the approved updated RP. For this reason, the following provisions of Paragraph 4, Schedule 6 of the Loan Agreement are herein reiterated: a. The Borrower shall ensure that all land acquisition, the compensation and resettlement action plan and monitoring programs agreed with the Bank are carried out promptly and efficiently, and that all persons affected by the acquisition of land required for the Project are compensated and resettled in accordance with the compensation and resettlement action plan in a manner that they shall be at least as well-off as they would have been in the absence of the Project. b. Adequate funds shall be made available by the borrower in a timely manner for land acquisition and resettlement activities. c. MPWT shall provide the Bank with status reports on the land acquisition and resettlement process as part of the Project’s monthly progress reports.
28. Section VI, Paragraph 89 (iv), of the RRP declaring Government’s assurance that “land acquisition and resettlement activities (would be) implemented in accordance with the plan agreed upon with the Bank during project preparation and loan processing…” is likewise reiterated.
B. Data Gathering Strategy
29. Data gathering methods involved a review of available government records, notably those at the office of the IRC Working Group (IRC-WG); interview with concerned MEF and MPWT personnel; survey of AP households; focus group discussions with APs in selected communities; and a market study to retroactively determine the market rates of affected assets at 2000 levels.
1. Review of Government Records
30. Pertinent government records reviewed in detail were: a. Master list of affected people (411 APs in NR5, 288 APs in NR6, and 1,178 APs in NR7) which contained information on the amount paid for each AP (See Appendix 6 for the Master list of APs provided by IRC to the audit team); b. Payment record of each AP containing receipt of payment, contract of obligation in exchange for the payment received, particulars of the detailed measurement survey (DMS), a copy of the identification card of the AP, and the accomplished household survey; and c. June 2000 RP.
13 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
2. Meetings with the IRC Working Group and the PIU
31. The meetings with concerned Government personnel revolved around the updating and implementation of the RP. The queries centered specifically on the conduct of the DMS and in the valuation of affected assets, supervision and monitoring of RP implementation, and grievance redress. The Working Group for NR5 of the IRC was under the ADB Division of the Department of Investment and Cooperation of the MEF. The Project Implementation Unit (PIU) that supervised the civil works was under the MPWT. Meetings with concerned personnel of the ADB Division of the Department of Investment and Cooperation were also conducted.
3. Survey of AP Households
32. The household survey covered all APs that could be located and who were still living in the Project area. As starting point in identifying and locating the APs, the master list of APs provided by the Resettlement Unit of the IRC (RU-IRC) served as reference. The survey instrument was translated into Khmer, and was divided into the following sections: a. Basic information about the AP household; b. Detailed information about the affected assets, compensation and entitlements received, and resettlement; c. Public participation and grievance redress; and d. Livelihood and standard of living before and after resettlement. (See Appendix 7 for an English translation of the Household Survey Questionnaire)
4. Focus Group Discussions
33. The FGDs were organized in coordination with village chiefs. The FGDs were held in communities chosen by the audit team mainly based on the number of APs in the locality. With the use of the master list of APs that was provided by the RU-IRC, the resettlement audit team purposively chose the participants to the FGDs based on severity of losses. Separate sessions were organized for female and male APs to provide the women greater latitude to speak out their minds and participate in the discussion. The FGDs revolved around the following concerns: a. Level of Information about the project b. Public information, consultation and participation c. Affected assets and valuation d. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlements e. Grievance redress mechanism f. Level of satisfaction g. Impacts on the lives of the people h. Suggestions of the people.
14 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
5. Reconstruction of 2000 Market Prices of Affected Assets
34. The audit team property appraiser was tasked to find out whether or not the unit costs used in the compensation for lost assets were within market rates during the period 2000 and 2001. In this connection, the following were carried out in the market rates study: a. Review of available documents used by government in compensation paid for all fixed assets to establish a table of unit cost b. Survey of construction material costs at hardware shops found along NR 5, 6 and 7 c. Interview with contractors/builders to see labor costs for construction in 2000 and 2006 d. Discussion with government official involved in compensation and cost estimation of assets in NR 5, 6, and 7 to understand how compensation costs were estimated
C. Data Processing and Analysis
35. Data culled from documents with the IRC, such as the individual records of the APs and the results of the DMS, were tabulated on a spreadsheet using Excel Program. On the other hand, the results of the household survey were processed using the Statistical Program for the Social Sciences (SPSS). The Excel spreadsheet contains data on fixed assets lost and compensation and other entitlements received by each AP. The spreadsheet provided information on whether or not the documented affected assets had been compensated for and if the payments given were at market rates.
36. Basically, the information from the household survey, the FGDs, and the market study were used to validate Government data, and to find out any outstanding resettlement issues.
D. The Resettlement Audit Team
37. The resettlement audit team was organized from among local (Phnom Penh-based) researchers affiliated with a domestic consulting firm. Other than the team coordinator, the other members of the group was a property appraiser, a statistician, 4 household survey enumerators and their supervisor, 2 researchers who reviewed government records, and 2 encoders.
E. Timeframe
38. The household survey, market study and review of IRC records commenced on 17 May 2005 and were completed by the end of August 2005. Processing of data was completed in the third week of November 2005. In the last week of February 2006, the statistical findings of the audit were discussed with personnel of the Resettlement Unit of the IRC (RU-IRC) and it was agreed that they would be given time to sort out the big discrepancies the audit team discovered in the data the RU-IRC made available to the audit team during its data gathering, such as (i) the 1,877 names in the master list of APs provided before the start of the audit team’s data gathering, of which only 1,455 had been found to have payment records; and (ii) the existence at the IRC office of payment records of 272 other persons who received compensation but whose names did not appear in the master list of APs. After the RU-IRC had sorted out the discrepancies, the resettlement consultant (audit
15 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
team) and RU-IRC were to meet again to discuss the findings of the audit per (i) review of DMS and payment records with the IRC, and (ii) survey of AP households and the holding of focus group discussions in selected communities in the project roads. Together, the audit team and RU-IRC would decide on how to resolve any outstanding resettlement issues. The audit report was to be written following such a meeting.
39. The RU-IRC never found the time to sort out the conflicting records in its custody, however. On numerous occasions that the resettlement consultant was in Phnom Penh for some other assignments in the second and third quarters of 200611, he reminded the RU-IRC about the need to fix their records. In December 2006, the resettlement consultant was fielded yet again to Phnom Penh to, among other ADB-assisted project, look into the status of reconciling the records with the IRC. That too did not yield anything as the RU-IRC personnel were into many other pressing concerns.
40. The resettlement consultant was informed sometime in the last quarter of 2007 by the SEID senior social development/resettlement officer that the IRC had reportedly completed settling all complaints brought to its attention by the NGO Forum. A letter to this effect was sent by H.E. Nhean Leng, IRC Chairperson, to CARM on 14 September 2007 (see Appendix 8 for the 14 September 2007 letter of IRC informing CARM about the completion of payment of outstanding claims brought forward by the NGO Forum on behalf of the APs). In light of this development, and considering the fact that the Project had officially closed in August 2006 with a PCR (dated November 2006), the resettlement consultant obliged to prepare the audit report based purely on the audit’s own findings and without consideration for any of the complaints raised by the NGO Forum and any agreements reached between the Government, the Bank, and the NGOs/APs on the latter. The resettlement consultant was not privy to any dialogues between the three parties on resettlement issues in the Primary Roads Project following the conclusion in April 2006 of his contract as staff consultant of the ADB Mekong Infrastructure Division (MKID).
11 The contract of the resettlement consultant under which term the audit of the Primary Roads Restoration Project was carried ended in mid-April 2006.
16 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
3. FINDINGS
41. This chapter summarizes the results of the data gathering activities of the resettlement audit, including the audit team’s comments on how resettlement had been carried out.
A. Resettlement Plan
1. Project Resettlement Policy and Government Prakas No. 6
42. Section 1.4 of the final approved RP stated that the document had been “finalized taking into account the guidelines and policy approved by the Government and the ADB in the Resettlement Implementation Plan (RIP) for the Phnom Penh to Ho Chi Minh City Highway Project Loan 1659-CAM”. This statement is in itself worrisome; the resettlement plan for Loan 1659-CAM was by no means a model worth emulating.12
43. Notwithstanding the aforementioned, the June 2000 updated RP for the Primary Roads Restoration Project seems consistent with the loan agreement and with the Bank’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement.13 In line with the avowed principle of avoiding if not minimizing impact to the extent possible, the RP provided for the following, among other measures: a. The area to cleared to allow construction to proceed (i.e., corridor of impact or COI) will be typically about 19 meters, 9.5 meters either side or 10 meters to 15 meters of the road centerline. b. Between this area and the ROW, boundary existing use of the land by APs will continue and APs who require complete relocation will be permitted to settle in this area. c. APs that remain in the residual ROW will be advised that they are living on Government land, which could be acquired in the future. 44. One legal obstacle in effectively implementing the objective of the RP of avoiding or minimizing impacts is Prakas (Order) No. 6, entitled Measures to Crackdown on Anarchic Land Grabbing and Encroachment. Issued by the Office of the Prime Minister on 27 September 1999, The Order sets a ROW of 60 m for NR Nos. 1, 4, and 5; and a 50 m ROW for NR Nos. 2, 3, 6, and 7. The military, the police, and relevant government agencies have been mandated to enforce the Order. However, the RP for Loan 1697-CAM did not anticipate nor take any position regarding the eminent clash between the Project resettlement policy and Prakas No. 6.
12 ADB gave its approval to the October 1999 updated Loan 1659-CAM RIP by declaring the loan effected on 9 November 1999 thinking that what had been submitted was the improved version of the July 1999 Cambodia Resettlement Action Plan (CRAP) which the “Bank had reviewed and accepted in principle”. Due to mounting complaints from the NGOs on behalf of APs, ADB in 2002 investigated how resettlement was being undertaken in the Loan 1659 Project. The Bank realized that the RIP deviated from the preliminary RP prepared in 1997 during project preparation (and also from the July 1999 CRAP) and that it was not compliant with the Loan Agreement or with ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement. (Resettlement Audit: Phnom Penh to Ho Chi Minh Highway (Loan 1659-CAM). 13 The concern that is being raised here is that neither the Government nor the TA consultants who prepared the RP for the Primary Roads Restoration Project does not know what is an acceptable RP, and what is not.
17 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
45. Project authorities had the lead time to take the needed steps to deal with Prakas No. 6 and yet nothing had been done to ensure that residents then living in the ROW were not displaced ahead of implementation. Preparation for Loan 1697-CAM started with the approval by the ADB Board on 19 December 1996 of TA 2722-CAM: Transport Network Improvement Project. Thereafter, a preliminary RP was prepared sometime in February 1997 and a fact-finding mission fielded on 6-21 March 1997, followed by a loan appraisal mission on 8-23 May 1997. Two more Appraisal Missions (in January 1998 and in February 1999) were fielded before formal loan negotiations were held in Phnom Penh from11 to 12 August 1999. The Bank approved Loan 1697-CAM on 21 September 1999, loan signing followed on 4 November 1999. A detailed measurement survey (DMS) of affected assets was undertaken on March 30 to May 10, 2000, following which the 1997 preliminary RP was updated and submitted by MPWT to ADB on 30 June 2000.
46. The failure of Project authorities to understand the intent and purpose of the Bank’s social safeguards policy, on one hand, and not being able to see the implications of Prakas No. 6, on the other hand, have resulted to complications and problems in the implementation of resettlement. In the 14 focus group discussion held in selected communities along the Project roads, scores of residents had reportedly relocated their shops and/or houses, presumably between December 1999 and the time of the DMS, after having been told by commune officials and the police to vacate the ROW. In the FGDs, most of the participants said that they were asked by local officials to get out of the ROW because of the Project. This may not be accurate; the reason could well be Prakas No. 6. Consequently, the audit team encountered a number of people who reportedly were included in the original count of APs (presumably during the inventory of losses or IOL in 1997) but who did not receive any compensation from the IRC starting in 2001. The biggest irony here is that those who resisted orders to vacate the ROW were included in the DMS and got compensated for their losses. Details on those who received compensation and those who have unpaid claims are provided in the succeeding sections.
2. Organization for Resettlement
47. The Ministry of Public Works and Transport (MPWT) was the Executing Agency (EA) for the Project. According to the loan agreement, being the EA, the MPWT would exercise overall supervision and execution of the Project.14 The MPWT was also tasked to provide ADB status reports on land acquisition and resettlement as part of the Project’s monthly progress report. Within the MPWT, a Project Management Unit (PMU) was set up and was responsible for the day-to-day implementation of the Project. During Project preparation, the PMU and the TA consultants prepared the final updated RP, with assistance from the IRC.15
48. But, how much assistance or influence did the IRC have in the preparation and implementation of the final updated RP? Despite being a “mere” committee, the IRC16
14 The Loan Agreement provided for the creation of an inter-ministerial oversight body called the Project Coordination Committee (PCC) which would oversee the overall implementation of the Project. Per information gathered from MPWT, however, it was learned that the PCC was only active during the bidding process for contractors. 15 Earlier during project processing, staff members of the Public Works Research Center (PRC) who used to work in the PMU of NR 1 (Loan 1659) were the ones involved in data gathering and in the preparation of the preliminary RP in collaboration with the TA consultants. Following approval of Loan 1697, a new PMU was set up. However, some members of the staff of PRC who earlier handled resettlement concerns continued providing inputs in the preparation of the June 2000 RP. 16 The IRC was first established to oversee resettlement in NR 1 (Loan 1659) but has since been overseeing land acquisition in other foreign-assisted projects of the national Government. Its members included representatives
18 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
arrogated upon itself the function of planner, implementer, and monitor of resettlement in the Primary Roads Project. The IRC, through its Working Group (later to evolve into the IRC Resettlement Unit17), spearheaded the DMS, determined and approved who would be included among the list of APs; approved the unit rates to use for compensating for lost assets; secured the funds for resettlement from the national treasury and remitted the same to its provincial counterparts, the provincial resettlement sub-committee; investigated and resolved grievances of APs; prepared the TOR and contracted the resettlement external monitor; and served as the Project’s internal monitor.
49. Despite being the EA, the MPWT (through its PMU 3) had nominal role in the updating and practically no role in the implementation of resettlement. Project monthly progress report contained very little information, if anything at all, about the status of resettlement. The MPWT did not have the data base of the results of the DMS. Said data base was the source of information for preparing the final list of APs that were eligible to receive compensation and other forms of assistance from the IRC. To date, nobody really knows who has got this data base. What came out during the audit were a number of master lists of APs; all of which came from the Resettlement Unit of IRC (RU-IRC) on separate occasions. Why RU-IRC could not come up with a single master list is really a mystery. A simple task of preparing a compiled list of people who received compensation for various losses seems to be a complicated task. As mentioned in paragraphs 38 and 39, the RU-IRC to date has not reconciled the conflicting lists of APs the resettlement audit discovered in 2005.
50. Moving forward beyond the mystery surrounding the data base of APs and those who received compensation for various losses, Project authorities would be better off if the IRC stuck to a regulatory function of ensuring that the preparation and implementation of resettlement is compliant with the loan agreement, leaving the task of spearheading the conduct of the DMS, including the creation and maintenance of the data base, with the MPWT. The EA would seek the endorsement of the IRC for the approval of the resettlement budget, and the funds will be remitted directly to the provincial resettlement sub-committees from the national treasury. IRC, on the other hand, will monitor disbursements and use of resettlement funds, being the internal monitoring arm of the Government. Apparently, however, IRC would like maximum control over the resettlement funds; thus, the monopoly over key functions in the updating and implementation of resettlement.
3. Implementation of Resettlement
a. Affected Assets
51. The final updated RP reported a total of 1,531 affected main structures (i.e., buildings), classified under one of four types18 of buildings based on the construction
of the Council of Ministers; MPWT; Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries; representatives of Municipal Council of Phnom Penh; governors and deputy governors of project affected provinces. 17 The IRC-WG was supposed to be managed by a Resettlement Unit (RU) of the IRC. The RU did not materialize until the end of 2004, however. Therefore, for Loan 1697, the day-to-day operation of the IRC-WG was managed by the head of the ADB Division of the Department of Investment and Cooperation, Ministry of Economy and Finance. 18 Type 1: Type 1: thatch or wooden walls with bamboo or earth floor and thatch or metal roof on wooden stilts or on the ground (10 m²); Type 2: wooden walls and wood or cement floor with metal, tile or plastic sheet roof on wooden stilts or on the ground (35 m²); Type 3: brick or mortar walls with concrete or wooden floor and metal or tiled roof on concrete stilts or on the ground – single storey (56 m²); and Type 4: brick or mortar walls with concrete or wooden floor and metal or tiled roof on concrete stilts or on the ground – multiple floors (90 m²).
19 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
materials used on the walls, floor and roof. 759 (49.58%) of these structures were classified under Type 1, while 656 (42.85%) were determined to be Type 2. In other words, almost all of the affected main structures (92.42%) were basically made of wooden and/or weak materials. The affected structures were mostly found in NR7 (870 units or 56.83%), followed by NR5 with 379 (24.76%). There were 282 (18.42%) affected main structures in NR6. Additionally, APs with affected main structures (i.e., buildings, like dwelling units and stores) were to be provided the following allowances: a. Loss of income: Riel equivalent of US$4019 intended to compensate for lost income during the time of dismantling and reconstruction of fixed structures, including temporary kiosks20 of ambulant vendors that could easily be moved elsewhere. b. Shifting allowance: Riel equivalent of US40 for those who have to relocate.
52. As mentioned earlier, however, no accounting of the assets of people who relocated ahead of the DMS following the issuance of Prakas No. 6 was made. This is one sticky issue because resettlement in the Project cannot really be put to closure unless and after all claims of relocation ahead of the DMS have been investigated and resolved. Table 3-1 Number of Affected Main Structures Building Type NR5 NR6 NR7 Total 1 148 24 587 759 2 219 254 183 656 3 11 4 62 77 4 1 - 38 39 Total 379 282 870 1,531
53. The updated RP reported that other than buildings, the Project would also affect 7 fuel filling stations (4 in NR5 and 3 in NR7); 2 small markets in NR7 with an aggregate area of 1,505 m²; 8 pagoda entrances; 47 wells; 29,587 linear meters of fences; 7 wooden and 2 concrete bridges belonging to the community.
54. Kiosks deemed movable by the IRC had been excluded from the DMS, however. One problem with excluding these so-called moveable kiosks is that one cannot have a clear picture of how many people depended on the road as their source of livelihood and what impact, if there was any, the project had on the roadside livelihood activities of these people.
55. No inventory of affected plots of land was conducted because they were all within the ROW and affected houses could move behind the COI. A number of plots planted to annual crops, such as rice, within the ROW had been documented in the DMS. No amount was allocated for these annual crops because they were allowed to be harvested prior to the start of civil works. In lieu of compensation for affected land, the updated RP provided for various entitlements based on the severity of impact. (See Table 3-2 for the details). What was provided budget for in the RP were trees of commercial value that had to be cut. (See Table 3-3 for a count of the affected trees).
19 The breakdown of this amount is as follows: $10 as outright cash payment, and a monthly cash allowance of $10 for 3 months. 20 These kiosks were not included among the structures that had to be compensated for.
20 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
56. The resettlement audit takes note of the fact that presently, areas between the edge of the road’s embankment and the edge of the ROW are being used by the residents, mainly for planting rice. Table 3-2 Entitlements for Affected Land in ROW Use of Land Degree of Loss Resettlement Options/Entitlements Residential Remaining is <60m² but >30m² Relocate or reorganize behind the COI but in ROW without security of tenure and AP could not make major improvements to the building because the land could be used by Government in future Remaining is <30m² Self-relocate or accept a plot of not less than 30 m² in government relocation site and with amenities similar at least to their former location Remaining is >60m² Reorganize behind the COI Farm Severity of impact not defined +2 months advance notice on land operationally. acquisition with COI +Assistance in relocating to similarly accessible land elsewhere within the ROW or on other land as close as possible to the affected plot +Un-harvested rice: 250 Riels/m² +Market gardens: 500 Riels/m² Shops Remaining is <30m² +May reorganize business on remaining land and be entitled to live in the relocation site
Table 3-3 Inventory of Perennial Crops and Timber Trees in the COI Crops NR5 NR6 NR7 Total Mango 257 233 259 749 Coconut 118 62 243 423 Sugar Palm 85 53 27 165 Tamarind 0 0 4 4 Bamboo (stand) 0 11 0 11 Various trees 128 292 828 1,248 Total 588 651 1,361 2,600
b. Valuation of Affected Assets
57. The IRC approved the unit rates for structures and perennial crops and timber trees. (See Appendix 9 for the approval letter by MEF of the unit rates for compensating affected assets). For comparison, the resettlement audit conducted a replacement cost study (RCS) to determine retroactively the market rates for said affected assets. (See Appendix 10 for a copy of the Replacement Cost Study Report). Interestingly, with the exception of building types 1 and 2, the unit rates used by IRC for building types 3 and 4 were within the same range as the ones calculated by the audit team. The problem really with the method of grouping structures in the project corridor according to building classifications models is that it was very difficult to fit the affected kiosks, which constituted the bulk of the affected structures, into the first 2 types of buildings because they were mostly made of a combination of recycled and temporary materials; thus they could not really fit in the building models. On
21 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
the other hand, types 3 and 4 structures were the relatively well-constructed residences, and, therefore, could easily fit into the building classification models. Thus, the unit rates used by IRC to compensate for the affected kiosks could be within the range of replacement cost. Table 3-4 Unit Costs of Affected Buildings Building Type Average Floor Unit Cost (US$/m²) Area (m²) IRC Audit Team 1 10 4.50 14.54 2 35 12.00 33.30 3 56 85.00 85.98 4 90 140.00 143.31
58. With the exception of sugar palm, the findings of the audit team were not far from the unit rates used by the IRC. Table 3-5 Unit Costs of Affected Trees (in US$) Type of Tree Assumptions Used by IRC Unit Cost per Tree (US$) Cost of Value of Value of Lost IRC Audit Team Seedling Annual Yield for 5 Produce Years Mango 1.50 5.70 28.50 30.00 35.63 Coconut 1.50 2.70 13.50 15.00 19.95 Sugar Palm 0.50 1.50 7.50 8.00 34.20 Tamarind 0.50 1.90 9.50 10.00 7.13 Bamboo 0.50 2.90 14.50 15.00 4.75 Rubber 5.00 9.00 45.00 50.00 - Others 1.00 0.80 4.00 5.00 -
59. Table below gives a comparison of the rates used by IRC and the findings of the audit team for other structures. Table 3-6 Unit Costs of Affected Miscellaneous Structures Structures Unit of Cost (US$) Measure IRC Audit Team Wells Piece 50.00 ~ 75.00 30 ~ 90 Fences Meter 0.75 ~ 5.00 0.67 ~ 8.51 Tomb Piece 50.00 ~ 120 -
c. Assistance to Vulnerable Groups
60. Three vulnerable groups had been identified in the RP, namely, female-headed households, household heads with physical disability, and households with a monthly income of less than US$10 (i.e., officially classified as poor). AP households belonging to these groups were each entitled to an additional assistance of the Riel equivalent of US$20.
61. The resettlement audit did find any evidence that would suggest that Government did not give the aforementioned assistance to vulnerable APs.
22 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
d. Public Consultation and Grievance Redress
62. No public information campaign was launched prior to the DMS and the census of APs. Government, however, held public meetings when the IRC-WG and the PRSC–WG conducted the verification of the identities of APs in preparation for the delivery of compensation and other entitlements. In said public meetings, the IRC-WG and its local counterparts distributed an information booklet on the Project, containing information on the types and severity of impacts, calculation of compensation and entitlements, schedule of the delivery of compensation and entitlements, and grievance redress procedures.
63. The updated RP provided for the creation of a Provincial Grievance Committee (PGC) for each of the provinces traversed by the Project. Headed by the provincial governor or a deputy, the other members of the PGC were the provincial heads of the Public Works and Transport (PDPWT) and the Economy and Finance, the external monitoring agency, and a village elder of the community the aggrieved AP came from. An AP had 28 days upon notification of his/her entitlements to lodge a complaint, while the PGC had 21 upon receipt of the complaint to act on it. If the decision of the PGC was favorable to the aggrieved AP, project authorities had 14 days to carry out the ruling of the Committee. Strangely, however, the RP did not provide a mechanism for appeal, in case the decision of the PGC was not favorable to the aggrieved AP. The resettlement audit finds the inclusion of the EMA in the grievance redress structure as anomalous.
e. Monitoring and Evaluation
64. The updated RP provided for the monitoring of resettlement implementation; internally, by the RU-IRC, and externally, by a non-government organization (NGO). The areas of concern for monitoring, both internal and external, as explained in the RP were stated in general terms and basically revolved around the timeliness and adequacy of compensation provided to the APs. The terms of reference (TOR) attached to the service contract of the Committee for Free and Fair Elections in Cambodia (COMFREL), the external monitor hired by Government, outlined the scope and methodology of monitoring activities. The service contract signed by COMFREL with the IRC covered a period of one (1) year, from 15 February 2001 until 15 February 2002. (See Appendix 11 for a copy of the Contract of the External Monitoring Agency).
65. The resettlement audit finds it strange for the IRC to not having extended the contract of the EMA after the completion of its one year term. Resettlement implementation went beyond February 2002, and the EMA could have provided assistance in finding a solution to the complaints raised by the NGO on 6 October 2003. When quizzed about this matter, none at the RU-IRC or at the PMU 3 could provide an answer as to why the contract of COMFREL was not extended, notwithstanding the fact that there was still $17,187.53 un- disbursed amount left in the EMA’s contract. (See Appendix 12 ledger of payments made to the EMA). Moreover, the IRC could not provide the audit team a copy of the final monitoring report of the EMA. What was learned during the audit though was that COMFREL had also brought to the attention of IRC a number of complaints from the APs. (See Appendix 13 for a copy of 2 monthly reports of the EMA).
23 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
f. Compensation and Cash Assistance Provided
66. As in the confusion and mystery surrounding the number of APs, the actual amount of compensation and cash assistance paid by Government had not been determined during the audit. As mentioned in Chapter 2, the RU-IRC21 provided the resettlement audit team a master list of APs before the team went to the field to interview the APs who were still living within the Project area. The master list contained the names of 1,877 AP household heads22 from 47 communes and for whom $493,675.98 in compensation and other cash assistance had been allocated. The master list was based on the DMS conducted in 2000. Table 3-7 Summary of APs and Allocated Compensation and Entitlements Road Section & Province No. of Communes N0. of AP HH Allocation (US $) NR5 Battambang 10 119 11,847.68 NR5 Pursat 11 292 60,130.70 NR6 Kompong Thom 6 288 53,571.97 NR7 Kompong Cham 13 957 319,812.68 NR7 Kratie 7 221 48,312.95 Total 47 1,877 493,675.98
67. However, in a document faxed by IRC to CARM in June 2006, IRC claimed that a total of 1,579 APs had been compensated amounting to $886,704.37, presumably during the implementation of the updated RP in 2001 – 2002. (See Appendix 14 for a copy of the June 2006 document faxed by IRC to CARM summarizing the number of compensated APs the total amount paid). Certainly, the IRC needs to reconcile all the lists and summaries of APs that have appeared during and following the resettlement audit. Table 3-8 Summary of Compensated APs per IRC Report Road Section & Number of APs Paid Amount (US$) Province NR5 Battambang 107 16,375.53 NR5 Pursat 380 148,710.01 NR6 Kompong Thom 205 145,566.35 NR7 Kompong Cham 699 529,817.61 NR7 Kratie 188 46,234.87 Total 1,579 886,704.37
B. Review of AP Records with RU-IRC
68. When the audit team in May and June 2005 reviewed the DMS and payment records at the RU-IRC, they were not able to find the records of 422 AP household heads in the master list provided to the audit team by RU-IRC in 2005. Of this number, 329 AP households were from NR 7 Kompong Cham Province, while 93 from NR6 Kompong Thom Province. On the other hand, records of 272 AP Households not included in the master list were found by the audit team. All in all, therefore, the audit team was able to review the DMS and payment records of 1,727 APs. (See Appendices 15, 16, and 17 for the reconstructed masterlist of APs in NR 5, 6, 7 with DMS and payment records reviewed by the audit team). The RU-IRC could not provide any plausible explanation when quizzed about the discrepancies.
21 The master list of APs bore the name of the Public Works Research Center of the MPWT. 22 The approved RP reported 1,879 AP households.
24 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
69. The succeeding sections give a summary of the findings of the resettlement audit in the review of DMS and payment records at the IRC office, including the results of its field interviews. Table 3-9 Summary of Record of APs Reviewed by the Audit Team Road Section & DMS/Payment Records of APs Reviewed Master List of APs given by Province IRC to the Audit Team In Master list Additional Total Number Distribution APs in the Given to Audit Names (Not of APs with of APs in the Master List Team and with In Master list Records Master List with No DMS DMS or Payment Given to Reviewed by or Payment Records Audit Team) Audit Team Records Found
NR5 Battambang 119 162 281 119 - NR5 Pursat 292 98 390 292 - NR6 Kompong Thom 195 - 195 288 93 NR7 Kompong Cham 628 - 628 957 329 NR7 Kratie 221 12 233 221 - Total 1,455 272 1,727 1,877 422
1. NR 5
70. A total of 314 main structures of various construction types had been acquired and compensated for in NR 5. 193 (or 61.46%) of these were classified as type 2, while 84 (26.75) were classified as type 1. 26 (8.28%) other structures were classified as type 3, while 11 (3.50%) were categorized as type 4. With an aggregate area of 4,922.28 m², the total replacement cost for said structures was $114,530.96. However, for unexplained reason, payment records showed that IRC paid $721.75 more than what was computed in the DMS records. More seriously, though, is the fact that the records show that a total of $12,335.02 in compensation had not been paid, mostly in Pteas Prey Commune. (See Table 3-10 for the details). (See Appendix 18 for the compensated structures in NR 5 per DMS and payment records reviewed at IRC).
2. NR 6
71. A total of 191 main structures had been acquired in NR 6. 117 (or 61.26%) of these were classified as type 2, while 44 (23.04) were classified as type 1. 19 (9.95%) other structures were classified as type 3, while 11 (5.76%) were categorized as type 4. The aggregate area of said structures was 4,663.45 m² with a replacement cost of $120,275.54. Payment records reviewed by the audit team showed that IRC paid $914.01 more than what was computed in the DMS records. However, IRC seemed to have not paid a total of $200.97 in compensation for acquired buildings, mostly in Somprouch Commune and Kompongkrabao. (See Table 3-11 for the details). (See Appendix 19 for the compensated structures in NR 6 per DMS and payment records reviewed at IRC).
25 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Table 3-10 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS Records)
Area Excess No. of Building Type Acquired Amount Due Amount Paid Balance to be APs Commune 1 2 3 4 (m2) (US$) (US$) Paid (US$) 7 Anlung Vel 2 5 0 0 75.55 708.15 0.00 0.00 5 Au dombong II 3 2 0 0 81.54 601.68 0.00 0.00 2 Boeng Khnar 1 1 0 0 45.51 321.12 0.00 0.00 6 Kear 3 3 0 0 106.90 992.18 0.00 0.01 24 Kom Pung Preang 17 7 0 0 395.87 2,787.47 0.00 0.02 14 Kompongpreas 11 3 0 0 113.21 906.95 0.00 0.04 22 Lor Lork Sor 2 14 4 2 408.19 20,455.42 51.73 0.00 2 Mong 0 2 0 0 7.48 89.76 0.00 0.00 8 Ou Tapoang 2 6 0 0 124.64 1,222.68 0.00 0.00 43 Prey Gny 5 28 8 2 533.94 18,161.66 75.07 1.70 13 Prey Svay 6 7 0 0 151.62 1,211.87 0.00 0.01 19 Prey Touch 17 2 0 0 301.21 1,629.72 0.09 0.03 52 Pteas Prey 3 37 7 5 904.04 32,691.60 499.98 12,255.11 48 Ronob 4 35 7 2 856.46 24,006.61 40.02 0.01 1 Rosey Krong 0 1 0 0 2.80 33.60 0.00 0.00 1 Snam Pras 0 1 0 0 14.40 172.80 0.00 0.00 25 Svay Art 1 24 0 0 437.47 5,186.87 0.00 0.09 7 Svay Daun Keo 1 6 0 0 101.31 1,047.57 0.00 78.00 2 Thnout Choum 2 0 0 0 49.20 221.40 0.00 0.00 13 Trapeang Chorng 4 9 0 0 210.94 2,081.88 54.86 0.00 314 TOTAL 84 193 26 11 4,922.28 114,530.96 721.75 12,335.02
26 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Table 3-11 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS Records)
No. Area Excess Balance to of Building Type Acquired Amount Due Amount be Paid APs Commune 1 2 3 4 (m2) (US$) Paid (US$) (US$) 6 Archar Lak 0 3 3 0 136.29 6,040.74 75.02 0.00 14 Bralay 12 2 0 0 351.20 2,118.44 103.36 0.00 16 Chomnarkroum 10 5 1 0 431.85 5,298.07 75.00 0.00 1 no data 1 0 0 0 15.30 68.85 0.00 0.00 37 Kompong Chentbong 0 25 6 6 997.00 46,744.86 189.02 0.00 47 Kompong Chenchueng 3 43 1 0 797.59 9,177.73 188.53 0.20 22 Kompongkrabao 1 12 5 4 671.35 30,185.39 33.03 75.00 9 Prey Tahou 1 5 2 1 269.20 10,279.02 0.00 0.00 17 Somprouch 8 8 1 0 520.85 6,013.19 150.05 125.77 18 Sun Kor 8 10 0 0 448.61 4,058.73 100.00 0.00 4 Trapang Russei 0 4 0 0 24.21 290.52 0.00 0.00 191 TOTAL 44 117 19 11 4,663.45 120,275.54 914.01 200.97
27 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Table 3-12 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS Records)
No. Area Excess of Building Type Acquired Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be APs Commune 1 2 3 4 (m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) Paid (US$) 13 Ang Cheum 1 8 4 0 539.84 15,393.36 14,186.03 0.00 1,207.33 53 Chub 1 49 3 0 1,537.47 19,951.61 20,743.91 2,784.84 1,992.54 9 Dar (Kratie) 7 2 0 0 134.13 930.79 930.79 0.00 0.00 53 Dar(Kompong Cham) 27 16 9 1 1,033.63 28,130.89 28,086.89 56.00 100.00 8 Khsoeum 4 4 0 0 150.08 1,170.81 1,170.81 0.00 0.00 44 Koang Kang 4 30 10 0 1,315.35 27,178.96 26,805.78 75.95 338.25 26 Kondol Chrum 2 14 8 2 899.91 24,838.46 23,750.85 618.60 1,706.21 42 Kontout 24 18 0 0 891.53 7,076.80 7,153.81 499.41 422.40 13 Kratie 10 3 0 0 353.23 2,152.47 4,400.58 2,248.11 0.00 60 Krek 12 38 10 0 1,595.11 30,489.04 30,000.78 1,170.29 1,658.55 100 Me Mut 11 57 16 16 2,960.59 98,556.28 100,737.54 2,184.96 3.70 9 Morng Reav 0 9 0 0 228.24 2,728.88 2,501.30 20.00 247.58 32 Orussey 21 11 0 0 561.45 4,453.23 4,642.75 190.12 0.60 55 Snour 20 35 0 0 1,574.21 17,735.84 17,837.40 102.00 0.44 102 Sourng 3 16 56 27 1,623.97 141,155.38 75,975.85 0.00 65,179.53 7 Srolobb 5 2 0 0 103.62 633.98 633.98 0.00 0.00 2 Svay Chras 0 2 0 0 43.44 521.28 521.28 0.00 0.00 8 Treak 1 5 2 0 199.58 6,115.43 6,115.43 0.00 0.00 24 Tror Mung 9 7 8 0 699.86 16,729.20 16,535.89 138.99 314.30 47 Tun Lung 36 11 0 0 952.34 6,847.60 6,346.58 0.70 501.72 1 Vihear Loung 1 0 0 0 30.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 135.00 708 GRAND TOTAL 199 337 126 46 17,427.58 452,925.29 389,078.22 10,089.97 73,808.15
28 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
3. NR 7
72. There were a total of 708 main structures acquired in NR 7. 337 (or 47.60%) of these were classified as type 2, while 199 (28.11) were classified as type 1. 126 (17.80%) other structures were classified as type 3, while 46 (6.50%) were categorized as type 4. The aggregate area of said structures was 17,427.58 m² with a replacement cost of $452,925.29. Payment records reviewed by the audit team showed that IRC paid $10,089.97 more than what was computed in the DMS records. However, IRC apparently have not paid a total of $73,808.15 in compensation for acquired buildings, mostly in Sourng, Chub, Kondol Chrum, Krek, and Ang Cheum. (See Table 3-2 for the details). (See Appendix 20 for the compensated structures in NR 7 per DMS and payment records reviewed at IRC).
C. Field Interview
73. The resettlement audit was able to interview in Pursat province 248 APs of the 292 names in the masterlist provided by the IRC. 44 others in the masterlist had moved away or could not be located. In addition, 7 persons claiming to be APs but whose names did not appear in the IRC master list had been interviewed.
Table 3-13 Pursat Province (NR 5)
From the IRC Master List of APs Not in IRC IRC Moved Dead/ Master Master Commune/Village Interviewed away Reject List (New) Total list Tnouet Chhum 2 0 0 0 2 2 Prey Ngi 41 10 0 0 51 51 Roleab 36 8 0 0 44 44 Loloksor 23 4 0 0 27 27 Phtas Prey 71 7 0 3 81 78 Svay At 30 9 0 1 40 39 Snam Pras 3 0 0 0 3 3 Tropeang Chhung 28 4 0 2 34 32 Boeung Khnar 2 0 0 0 2 2 Prey Svay 1 0 0 0 1 1 Otapourng 11 2 0 1 14 13 Total 248 44 0 7 299 292
Table 3-14 APs Interviewed by Survey Team in NR 5 (Not Found in the DMS List)
Address Assets/Properties Year HH Head Village Commune District Affected Demolished Kol Yen Svay Att Sompov Meas Pursat Main structure/building ND Rorm Vannak O'Tapoang Bakan Pursat Other fixed assets ND Sok Sitha Ptash Prey Sompov Meas Pursat Land and fixed assets >5 years ago Seng Kimtem Ptash Prey Sompov Meas Pursat Other fixed assets ND Sin Phalla Ptash Prey Sompov Meas Pursat Other fixed assets ND Ouam Youn Tropang Chong Bakan Pursat Land and fixed assets >5 years ago Khiev Chai Tropang Chong Bakan Pursat Land and fixed assets >5 years ago ND= No Data
29 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
74. In the province of Battambang, the audit team was able to locate and interview 102 of the 119 APs in the list provided by the IRC. No new APs had been found in the province.
Table 3-15 Battambang Province (NR 5)
From the IRC Master List of APs Not in IRC Moved Dead/ Master IRC Commune/Village Interviewed away Reject List (New) Total Master list Svay Doun Koa 7 0 0 0 7 7 Russey Krang 1 1 0 0 2 2 Prey Svay 16 1 0 0 17 17 Kea 8 0 0 0 8 8 Moung 2 0 0 0 2 2 Prey Touch 17 6 1 0 24 24 Kompong Preang 25 4 0 0 29 29 Kompong Pras 15 2 0 0 17 17 Odambong 5 0 0 0 5 5 Anlongvil 6 2 0 0 8 8 Total 102 16 1 0 119 119
75. Moreover, 168 APs in Pursat and Battambang (NR 5) alleged that Government had not paid them for their affected assets. (See Appendix 21 for the list of APs interviewed in NR 5 with unpaid claims).
76. In Kampong Thom province (NR 6), the audit team was able to locate and interview 241 of the 288 APs in the list provided by the IRC. The team also interviewed 5 persons claiming to be APs but whose names did not appear in the IRC list.
Table 3-16 Kompong Thom Province (NR 6)
From the IRC Master List of APs Not in IRC Moved Dead/ Master IRC Commune/Village Interviewed away Reject List (New) Total Master list San Kor 3 2 0 4 9 5 Cham Nakrom 3 0 1 0 4 4 Som Prouch 5 1 0 0 6 6 Kompong Chin Tbaung 189 30 11 0 230 230 Kompong Chin Chheng 32 0 0 1 33 32 Brolay 9 2 0 0 11 11 Total 241 35 12 5 293 288
30 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Table 3-17 APs Interviewed by Survey Team in NR 6 (Not Found in DMS List)
Address Assets/ Properties Year HH Head Village Commune District Affected Demolished Phun Sinau Keing Krosang Sunkor Kompong Svay Main structure ND Bee Ull Keing Krosang Sunkor Kompong Svay Main structure ND Dy Nang Keing Krosang Sunkor Kompong Svay Main structure ND Tan Krem Keing Krosang Sunkor Kompong Svay Main structure ND Oun On Tnot Kampong Chenchueng Stong Main structure ND ND= No Data
77. The audit team likewise gathered the names of 205 APs in NR 6 with claims for unpaid affected assets. (See Appendix 22 for the list of APs interviewed in NR 6 with unpaid claims).
78. In Kampong Cham (NR 7), the audit team was able to locate and interview 818 APs of the 957 in the masterlist provided by the IRC. The audit team also interviewed an addition of 3 persons not found in the master list.
Table 3-18 Kampong Cham Province (NR 7)
From the IRC Master List of APs Not in IRC Moved Dead/ Master IRC Commune/Village Interviewed away Reject List (New) Total Master list Chub 92 19 1 0 112 112 Moung Rive 13 2 0 0 15 15 Soung 175 32 1 0 208 208 Vihea Lourng 3 1 0 0 4 4 Sror Lorb 61 10 0 0 71 71 Angcheum 14 2 0 0 16 16 Kandol Chhrum 56 7 0 0 63 63 Kourng Kang 105 14 0 0 119 119 Krek 115 14 0 2 131 129 Da 47 10 1 0 58 58 Memot 111 14 0 1 126 125 Tro Moung 20 9 0 0 29 29 Treak 6 2 0 0 8 8 Total 818 136 3 3 960 957
79. On the other hand, the audit team was able to locate and interview 196 of the 221 APs in the list provided by the IRC. An addition of 2 persons claiming to be APs but whose names did not appear in the IRC list had been interviewed also. Likewise, the audit team gathered the names of 684 APs with alleged unpaid affected assets. (See Appendix 23 for the list of APs interviewed in NR 6 with unpaid claims).
31 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
Table 3-19 Kratie Province (NR 7)
From the IRC Master List of APs Not in IRC Moved Dead/ Master IRC Commune/Village Interviewed away Reject List (New) Total Master list Kratie 31 3 1 0 35 35 Sre Char 3 0 0 2 5 3 Orussei 51 5 0 0 56 56 Dar 13 0 0 0 13 13 Kantourt 44 8 0 0 52 52 Khsoeb 1 0 0 0 1 1 Snoul 53 6 2 0 61 61 Total 196 22 3 2 223 221
Table 3-20 APs Interviewed by Survey Team in NR 7 (Not Found in DMS List)
Address Assets/Properties Year HH Head Village Commune District Affected Demolished Uoch Sareurn Am Pok Krek Pon Nhear Krek Main structure ND Sean Lau Krek Tbong Krek Pon Nhear Krek Main structure ND Ouang Tong Tbong Wat Me mut Me mut Main structure ND Seng Van Kbal Trach Sre Cha Snourl Main structure ND Chhay Sor Kbal Trach Sre Cha Snourl Other fixed assets ND ND= No Data
D. Focus Group Discussion
80. A total of 14 FGDs were held, 7 with male APs and another 7 for female APs. The reason for holding separate sessions for male and female APs was to allow the women more freedom to express their views. A report on each of the FGDs conducted is provided. (See Appendix 24 for the highlights of the focus group discussion).
81. The results of the FGDs add credence to claims by APs interviewed by the audit team of instances where people had been asked to remove their stalls and houses from the ROW in line with Prakas No. 6 but ahead of the DMS. Consequently, a number of participants in the FGDs claimed that they did not get compensated for their demolished structures. These participants expressed displeasure over the fact that some people got compensated for their demolished assets.
82. There was limited public information conducted by the Government and the level of awareness of the participants regarding the Project and the resettlement policy was very low. Some of the participants recalled attending meetings called by local authorities about clearing the ROW in line with Prakas No. 6, but they thought this was in relation to the planned improvement of the highway.
83. The participant claimed that majority of those affected were roadside vendors. Thus, during the construction of the road, their business operation had been disrupted but with no compensation from the Government for income loss.
32 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
4. RECOMMENDATIONS
84. Below are the recommendations of the resettlement audit. 1. RU-IRC has to reconcile the DMS and payment records in its custody, come up with a FINAL list of APs per the DMS done in 2000 and a final accounting of how much had been paid in compensation and allowances to the APs in 2001-2002. 2. RU-IRC will look into cases of over-payment and non-payment of assets as discovered by the audit team during the review of DMS and payment records at the IRC. Unpaid assets will be settled as soon as possible. 3. RU-IRC will review the names of APs gathered by the audit team who have unpaid claims and check which of them were in the list of unpaid claims submitted by the NGO Forum. For those not in the NGO Forum’s list, RU-IRC will conduct full investigation of each case for appropriate action, 4. IRC will inform the ADB on actions taken by the government regarding the aforementioned.
85. It is further recommended that during the preparation of future ADB-assisted projects, the Bank should insist a clear delineation of the functions of the Executing Agency, on one hand, and of the IRC, particularly its resettlement unit, on the other hand. The EA should have full responsibility over the project, and this includes resettlement, and will be fully accountable for the success and failure of any aspects of the project. This means that data base on project impacts will be generated and maintained by the EA through its own social or resettlement unit. Said unit should have the capacity to prepare and implement resettlement plans.
86. With regard to the IRC, this committee should function as a regulatory body of the Government, ensuring that resettlement in the project is planned and carried out according to agreements between the ADB and the Government. The IRC, through its resettlement unit, will review and endorse the resettlement plan, including the budget for resettlement, prepared by the EA, conducting field verification as needed (not re-doing the survey or DMS done by the EA). It is, however, the EA that will request the national treasury for the release of funds for resettlement, with endorsement by the IRC. Funds for resettlement will be remitted directly to the Provincial Resettlement Sub-committee, though. IRC will monitor that funds for resettlement are used judiciously and according to the approved resettlement plan.
33 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
APPENDICES
Appendix 1
34 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
35 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
36 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
37 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
38 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
39 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
40 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
41 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Restoration Project (National Roads 5, 6, and 7)
42
Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Improvement Project (Loan 1697-CAM)
Appendix 7
HOUSEHOLD SURVEY QUESTIONNIARE
IRC ID Code: ......
Good day! I am a member of an independent research group doing a resettlement audit of National Road (NR) 5, NR6, and NR7. We are interviewing families affected by the improvement of these national roads to find out how Government carried out the resettlement of people affected by the road improvement project starting in 2000. Your answers and identity will be held in confidence. We ask you, therefore, to provide us your honest answer/information to the questions asked. res_99/ Name of Respondent in the DMS conducted between March to May 2000: ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember res_05/ Name of Respondent today: ...... Code?/ Relationship of today’s Respondent to the Household Head in the 2000 DMS: ….……………….
I. Information about the Household and the Affected Assets a / Name of household head in the 2000 DMS: ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember b/ Gender of household head in 2000 DMS: 1 Male 2 Female 8888 Don’t Know/Remember c/ Physical Condition of household head in the 2000 DMS: 1 Normal 2 Disabled 8888 Don’t Know/Remember d/ Present (Year 2005) address: d1/ Village ...... d2/ Commune ...... d3/ District ...... d4/ Province ...... d5/ Specific location relative to the road: 1 Inside COI 2 Outside COI but inside ROW 3 Outside of ROW e/ Address in Year 2000 during the DMS: e1/ Village ...... e2/ Commune ...... e3/ District ...... e4/ Province ...... e5/ Specific location relative to the road: 1 Inside COI 2 Outside COI but inside ROW 3 Outside of ROW 8888 Don’t Know/Remember f/ Assets Affected by the Road Project f1/ Land (ask Qg) f2/ Main Structure/building, e.g. house, shop and stall (ask Qh) f3/ Crops/trees (ask Qi) f4/ Other fixed assets, e.g. water well, fence, pagoda gate, grave/stupa, etc. (ask Qj)
II. Affected Assets, Compensation and Entitlement g/ Land (see f1, otherwise skip to Qh) g1/ Tenure Status over the affected/lost property during the 2000 DMS 1 With full land title 2 Owner still awaiting release of title by Land Titles Department 3 With land use right 4 Under lease or paying land rent from legal owner
1 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Improvement Project (Loan 1697-CAM)
5 Occupation and use of land not recognized by government 6 Communal property 7 Other (specify) ………………………………….. 8888 Don’t Know/Remember g2/ Years in possession/occupying/using affected land prior to the 2000 DMS: 1 Less than 5 years 2 More than 5 years but after 1979 3 Before 1979 8888 Don’t Know/Remember g3/ Type of land use 1 Residential 5 Vacant/idle/unused land 2 Commercial 6 Other (specify): ...... 3 Farm 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 4 Water/fish pond g4/ Total area (m2) of land holding...... m2 8888 Don’t Know/Remember g5/ Area (m2) of the land acquired by the Project...... m2 8888 Don’t Know/Remember g6/ Amount of cash compensation AGREED with IRC: 1 ...... (US$ or Riels) 3 No Agreement Reached 2 No cash compensation given for affected land (skip to g8) 8888 Don’t Know/Remember g7/ If cash compensation was paid for the acquired land, indicate amounts actually received and then skip to Qh): 1d First payment: ...... (US$) 3d Third payment: ...... (US$) 1r First payment: ...... (Riels) 3r Third payment: …...... (Riels) 2d Second payment: ...... (US$) 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 2r Second payment: ...... (Riels) g8/ If no cash compensation was provided, what other forms of compensation were you provided? 1 Replacement land in the same village 4 Nothing 2 Replacement land in a nearby village 5 Other (specify): ...... 3 Replacement land in far away village 8888 Don’t Know/Remember g9/ If you did not receive compensation for land, do you know the reason why? …...... …...... h/ Main Structure/Building e.g. house, shop and stall (see f2 above, otherwise skip to Qi) h1/ Ownership status 1 Owner 4 Using without permission from the owner 2 Tenant and paying rent to the owner 5 Other (specify) ……………………………. 3 Using for free and with permission from the owner 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h2/ Use of affected structure/building (NOTE: After answering this question, legal and illegal tenants will skip to h11_6) 1 Exclusively for residence 5 Government 2 Residence with store 6 Other (specify) …………………………………… 3 Purely commercial (independent shop) 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 4 Worship h3/ Please describe the constructional materials used in your affected/lost building 1 Floor: ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 2 Wall: ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 3 Roof: ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 4 No. of Floor: ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember Other (specify): ......
2 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Improvement Project (Loan 1697-CAM)
h4/ Under what building type was your affected structure classified by the IRC? 1 Type 1 (thatch or wooden walls with earth or bamboo floor and thatch or metal roof on wooden stilts or on the ground 2 Type 2 (wooden walls and wood or cement floor with metal, tile or plastic sheet roof on wooden stilts or on the ground 3 Type 3 (brick or mortar walls with concrete or wooden floor and metal or tiled roof on concrete stilts or on the ground – single floor 4 Type 4 (brick or mortar walls with concrete or wooden floor and metal or tiled roof on concrete stilts or on the ground – multiple floors 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h5/ Total floor area of affected structure/building: ...... m2 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h6/ Floor area of the acquired/demolished portion of the building: ...... m2 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h7/ Amount of cash compensation AGREED with IRC: 1 ...... (US$ or Riels) 3 No Agreement Reached 2 No cash compensation given for affected structure (skip to h10) 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h8/ If cash compensation was paid for the acquired building, indicate amounts actually received: 1d First payment: ...... (US$) 3d Third payment: ...... (US$) 1r First payment: ...... (Riels) 3r Third payment: ...... (Riels) 2d Second payment: ...... (US$) 8888 Don’t Know/Remember 2r Second payment: ...... (Riels) h9/ Was the amount of compensation you received sufficient to rebuild the structure/building affected by the Project? 1 Yes, the amount of compensation was sufficient to build a similar structure 2 The amount of compensation was not enough to build a similar structure, so I built a smaller one 3 No, I had to borrow money from outside source to build a similar structure 4 No, because I built a bigger/better structure 5 I did not rebuild the affected building/structure anymore h10 / Was the entire residential/commercial building demolished/acquired by the Project? 1 Yes 2 No (Skip to h12)
If the answer to h10 is YES, h11_1/ What were the relocation options available to you in year 2000: 1 Relocated on my own because the building and the land were both compensated for. 2 I was not paid for the land but I still had enough space behind the COI to reconstruct 3 I was not paid for the land but I had another land nearby or in the same village to relocate 4 I was not paid for the land and I did not have land to relocate (i.e. Landless PAP) 5 Other (specify): ......
h11_2/ When did you receive compensation for your building(s)? 1 Before demolition/reorganization 2 During demolition/reorganization 3 After demolition/reorganization 4 I was not paid compensation
h11_3/ Where did you receive your compensation payment? 1 At my home 2 At the commune/village center 3 In Phnom Penh 4 Other (specify): ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember
3 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Improvement Project (Loan 1697-CAM)
h11_4/ How many days did IRC give you to demolish your building after receiving your compensation? 1 1 week 2 2 weeks 3 1 month 4 2 months 5 I did not demolish/reorganize my building because I did not receive any compensation 6 Other (specify) …………………….. h11_5/ For Landless PAP, what assistance did IRC provide you? ……………………………………..
h11_6/ For tenants (i.e., renting, occupying for free or without the owner’s permission) of severely (entire) affected buildings, what assistance did IRC provide you? 1 Cash for transporting belongings: ...... (US$ or Riels) 2 Other (specify): ...... 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h12/ By how many meters from the road centerline were you told to move your affected building? 1 By 10m 2 By 15m 3 By 25m h13 / Were you assisted by the IRC and/or contractor in demolishing your affected structure/building? 1Yes 2 No 8888 Don’t Know/Remember h14/ If assistance was provided by IRC and/contractor in the demolition of the affected structure, specify the assistance provided: …………………………………………………………. h15/ After demolition, who kept the salvaged building materials? 1 Owner 2 IRC working group 3 Local officials 4 Other (specify): ...... i/ Affected Crops and Trees (See answer f3 otherwise skip to Qj)
Type Number Amount (US$ or Riels) Annual Crop i1/...... i1_1/...... Fruit trees i2/...... i2_1/...... Other trees i3/...... i3_1/...... 8888 Don’t know/Remember j/ Other Affected Fixed Assets (see answer f4)
Type Number Amount (US$ or Riels) Water well j1/...... j1_1/...... Water line j2/...... j2_1/...... Electric line j3/...... j3_1/...... Fence j4/…………... j4_1/……………….. Worship j5/...... j5_1/...... Tomb j6/...... j6_1/...... Other (Specify)…………… j7/………….. j7_1/……………….. 8888 Don’t know/Remember k/ Other Assistance Provided by IRC k1/ For disturbance allowance: ...... in US$ or Riels k2/ For female headed household: ...... in US$ or Riels k3/ For disabled headed household: ...... in US$ or Riels k4/ For household income < US$10/month: ...... in US$ or Riels k5/ For shifting/relocation (entire affected): ...... in US$ or Riels
4 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Improvement Project (Loan 1697-CAM)
k6/ Other (specify)…………………………. 8888 Don’t know/Remember Other (specify) ......
III. Participation and Grievance Redress l/ Were you invited to a public meeting before the DMS (conducted from March 30 to May 10, 2000) 1 Yes 2 No (skip to m)
l1/ If Yes, what was the meeting about, please describe? ...... m/ Were you invited to public meeting after the DMS? 1 Yes 2 No (skip to n)
m1/ If Yes, what was the meeting about, please describe? ...... n/ Did you receive an ID card as proof that you were a PAP and entitled to compensation? 1 Yes 2 No 8888 Don’t know/Remember o/ Did you receive a copy of the public information booklet? 1 Yes 2 No (skip to p)
o1/ If Yes, when did you receive it? 1 Before DMS 2 During DMS 3 After DMS 8888 Don’t know/Remember
o2/ If Yes, what kind of information were included in that booklet? ...... p/ Were you informed about the policy on cut-off date (10 May 2000)? 1 Yes 2 No 8888 Don’t know/Remember q/ Did you sign any payment acceptance contract? 1 Yes (ask q1 and q1_2) 2 No (skip to q2) q1/ If Yes, what was the condition? ......
q1_2/ If Yes, where did you sign the contract? 1 At home 2 At the commune/village center 8888 Don’t know/Remember
q2/ If No, Why did you not sign the contract? ...... r/ Did IRC explain to you how it calculated your compensation? 1 Yes 2 No s/ Have you ever lodged (in writing or verbally) a complaint with the IRC? 1 Yes 2 No (skip to IV)
s1/ If Yes, What was your complaint about? ......
s2/ If Yes, was it resolved to your satisfaction? 1 Yes 2 No (go to s2_1)
s2_1/ If No (in s2) Why not? ......
IV. Livelihood and Standard of Living t. Before the project (year 2000), what were your household’s main sources of livelihood (occupation)? Main occupation Other occupation t1_1/ First…...... t2_1/ First………………………...... t1_2/ Second...... t2_2/ Second ……………………......
5 Resettlement Audit: Primary Roads Improvement Project (Loan 1697-CAM)
t1_3/ Third...... t2_3/ Third……………………...... 8888 Don’t know/Remember u/ Before and project (year 2000), what was your household monthly average income? ...... US$ or Riels or Dong 8888 Don’t know/Remember v. Presently (year 2005), what are your household’s main sources of livelihood (occupation)? Main occupation Other occupation v1_1/ First...... v2_1/ First...... v1_2/ Second...... v2_2/ Second...... v1_3/ Third...... v2_3/ Third...... 8888 Don’t know/Remember w/ Presently (year 2005), what is your household’s monthly average income? ...... US$ or Riels or Dong 8888 Don’t know/Remember x. What are the impacts of the project to your household? x1/ Negative impacts or losses, if any …………………………………………………………………..
x2/ Positive impacts or benefits, if any…………………………………………………………………...
x3/ Observations/comments, if any………………………………………………………………………
......
Done by: ______Date: ______Interviewer
Checked by: ______Date: ______Supervisor
6
~~
"..; ( .Vi, -;0.
~~'o"""""-.I..~i;nn-'"'\nt:"l"'\-.~C::--,",", ::)~. ..;. n. ~"J~ :I3"J~.3~"J~:t;~"J~i,G1 MINISTIZY OF ECO~OMY AND FINANCE KINGDOM OF CAMOOlJl/\ Fax/Phone: (855) 23 725134 I No/io/7 -RC!/igio/7 -King <'rv ~: CI) 6'/) c§!' Crv tf) ~ fux c.e.
co " - .~ 6 0 tHUi .. \ruJ.ruwu W~I O'~( 10., o..~ ~.,. . " ~ .' <;=>0 t ~.c,'i;) ~F' 't:>nc.k cvttr~ F-~--r-~
99 t~H~m ~ a.n 0,0 "i(.l't.Q.
Cj)lD tBHHnru r( 'J...MCA. ri " cL <.vtB u ~ rc..e. rl-<])O 5-10 ~ c;>m tBtTt~n p~ \ t:"'\. 'cor.e e. q; i B H '(" rCQ.- d.oo 21 (;) tBtr '" <;i)cS' <1>r1.00 tl1tT~~v C 0<:' 0 t'-A.1.G \:6"
, ...1 ""IJ /"""",,""'- r;; :;; ,~~-""--~~ ---"-':- a -Q~ - ,--' f":II (,: f /,\" {I/t.v ~ '> );, . t"'!'!. 1- " /'~. ~~"'1~1~(,""'~_@:':':-;~ ~~~:G11~~ 1 ~ ~ u-'~ c:,;.." ---'" G ""' .' ~' ,'- ,-. ".-':'"':"": ." ~.'~:::, . ,. () ,r!, ..,. "C~'lt..' --,~'"' /",..,.,"'I"",'-~ I.)..:'-"~ -~ ~-- Ctl..-: {'Jf ~ I: ('.I~.' . I. '"",~-~."""~...",-..~~",~,...,~M"_"._"~~-"~:~--""'~ "~~...~~~, """'. \ "'0;.;;. ~.b ,-, j- ~ II t ", ,;-"1-' ~ -,'," ..., ., -:;;";; Ai"'\" ,.()/} 1;'.1; t 'i.5i"i' / -..) ,~p -,'" 0 f I :r'1 I, ..'0 ' "" JJ 2-1) {j ;~'~rH~V~.~;:."" oj /' \\} "-! LI\ \- ~ 1 ~ ,f.e u r, , '"1 'V I ,.. ) ~t'-':: '" ~) ~--~-- ,,' \'-:,or:. _"r-':-.' v \V ;;i ~ , ,$1 0 , " ,..,',"" ;~- ";,. ,.,:-,.')'/ '"'" -;T" , -, .~,..,.,..,. -/;.- II ;:. NJJ'" u,1) 11{ r FJ 'I a-~,~ ~,~,72,_.",." '~~~~~~;;7 ?
'! .. " -I, ~ .J ~- I' ,. , .-' J' ." I ,/ .l.. "'.'"\ l \ r'1 /. ..I? I' J ! ') / ( .. A~ '-"'... .;. I Appendix 10
Replacement Cost Study Sections of National Road No. 5, 6 and 7 by EA Sophy
Road network is the vein of economic growth. With this recognition the government of Cambodia proposed to upgrade sections of National Road 5,6 and 7, using funds from the Asian Development Bank under Primary Roads Restoration Project, with 50 meters right of way (25 meters each site of the centerline). To minimize social dislocation the project will not clear this right of way, but will require only the corridor of impact (9.5meters each side of the centerline) to be cleared of all people and structure.
It is estimated that more than two thousand households are affected. Therefore, this study is trying to find out unit cost of the structures affected by road upgrading.
1. Methodology
The methodologies used for the survey are as follows: - Review available documents used by government in compensation paid for all fixed assets to establish a table of unit cost - Interview with and survey construction material cost of hardware shop in main locations along National Road No.5, 6 and 7 (along project sections) - Interview with contractors/ builders to see labor cost for construction in 2000 and 2006 - Discuss with government official involved in NR5,6,7 compensation and cost estimation of all assets/DMS to understand how compensation cost were estimated
2. Work Schedule
Interview Schedule Week1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 July July July July 1 Review unit cost used by RGC xxxxxxxx 2 Interview hardware shop along xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx NR5, 6, 7, builders, contractors 3 Interview people for the cost of xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxx trees and other plant and discuss with agricultural specialist 4 Discuss/ interview with MEF xxxx xxxx and MPWT officer 5 Develop table for unit cost xxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx
3. Unit Cost Used by Government
With ADB's resettlement guideline the government of Cambodia is trying to fulfill its roles in compensation people negatively affected by the project. Schedule of compensation rates were
Resettlement Audit- 1 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7 established and approved by Ministry of Economic and Finance. See appendix for table of compensation to assets set by government for different road rehabilitation projects.
Below is the comparison of unit cost used by government in compensation for assets affected by road rehabilitation/ widening, i.e. National Road No.1, National Road No.5,6 and 7, and National Road 51.
Unit Rate USD No. Description Unit NR1* NR5,6,7 NR51 1999 2000 2002-03 I. House Thatch wall, thatch roof, wood column on ground or above Type 1 ground level 1 m2 94.5
Type 2 Wood wall, tile or galvanize roof, on ground or cement column 1 m2 19.5 12 Type 3 One floor flat house 1 m2 59 85 Type 4 Two floor flat house 1 m2 156.5 140
II. Land 1 Rice Field 1 m2 0.5 2 Village land 1 m2 2
III. Other structure 3 Dig well 1 30 50 4 Bore well 1 47.37 75 5 Tomb 1 50 6 Stupa 1 2000 7 Wood or wire fence 1 m 0.75 8 Brick fence 1 m 4.86
IV. Trees 9 Mango 1 30 25-30 13.85 10 Tamarin 1 5 5-10 23 11 Sugar Palm 1 15 8 37.7 12 Coconut 1 15 15 29.5 13 Bamboo thicket 5 10-15 5.12 14 Jackfruit 1 10-15 15.38 15 Kvet (kind of fruit tree) 1 10 16 Oval custard-apple ¬eTob)araMg¦ 1510 17 Round custard-apple (eTobExμr) 1 3 5.13 18 Papaya 1 2-2.5 1.5 19 Good quality tree 1 20-25 20 Banana 1 0.08 0.51 21 Lemon 1 3-5 1.28 22 Guava (RtEbk) 12-2.55.1 23 Spiny tree with flat, round, sour fruit 24 Krasang ¬RksaMg¦ 1 10.25 25 Smach ¬sμac:¦ 1 26 Pring ¬RBIg¦ 1 15.38 27 Cashew ¬sVaycnÞI¦ 120 28 Eucalyptus ¬eRbgxül;¦ 1 29 Kangork ¬ek¶ak¦ 1 30 Makak ¬máak;¦ 110 31 Tuk Doh Kor ¬TwkedaHeKa¦ 1 10.25 32 Rubber 50 V.Others 33 Vegetable/ Vegetable garden
Note: Resettlement Audit- 2 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7 * ADB, Cambodia Resettlement Implementation Plan, Ho Chi Min City to Phnom Penh Highway Improvement Project, October 1999. However, another study of GMS road improvement project (Addendum to the August 2002 resettlement plan, 2005) suggested 14 types of schedule rates for housing and classified into 4 categories.
Schedule of compensation cost for houses, shops and stalls (MPWT, GMS: Cambodia Road Improvement Project; Addendum to the August 2002 Resettlement Plan, 2005)
Roof Wall Floor Column Storey Type Materials Labor Total Unit Cost ($) Cost ($) Cost ($/m2) Thatch None or weak Pole Single 1A 6.50 1.50 8.00 Thatch Solid Pole Single 1B 9.50 1.50 11.00 Thatch More than 25% More than 25% permanent permanent material material Pole Single 1C 11.50 1.50 13.00 Zin, Fibro or Pole or Thatch None or weak Plastic Timber Single 1D 13.50 2.00 15.50 Pole or Zin, Fibro None or weak Timber Single 2A 17.50 2.50 20.00 Metal, Fibro or Pole or Plastic Sheet Wood None or weak Timber Single 2B 22.00 4.00 26.00 Wood Wood or concrete Timber Single 2C 30.00 7.00 37.00 Metal, Fibro or Plastic Sheet Brick Concrete Concrete Single 2D 40 15 55 Tile Roof Wood or Brick Wood or concrete Timber Single
Metal, Fibro or Timber or Plastic Sheet concrete Wood or Brick Wood or concrete Multi 2E 73.50 20.00 93.50
Timber or concrete Tile Roof Wood or Brick Wood or concrete Multi 2F 77.00 23.00 100.00 Tile Roof Wood or Brick Concrete Concrete Single 3A 51.00 30.00 81.00 Concrete Brick Concrete Concrete Single 3B 152.00 38.00 190.00 Ground 95.00 32.00 127.00 Tile Roof Wood or Brick Concrete Concrete 4A First 51.00 30.00 81.00 Ground 152.00 38.00 190.00 Concrete Brick Concrete Concrete First 4B 140.50 49.50 190.00 Second 140.50 76.00 216.50
Other structures No. Type of Assets Unit Unit Cost (US$) 1 Dug Well (d=6m) 1 53 2 Concrete well (d=6m) 1 140 3 Pumped well 1 80 4 Grave (earth) 1 50 5 Grave (concrete) 1 1250 6 Chedey/stupa (2x2m) 1 1750 7 Forecourt or patio/concrete 1m2 8 8 Culvert (0.8mx1m) 1 15 9 Pond (v=60m3) 1 50
FENCE 10 Timber post with bamboo 1lm 0.7 11 Timber post with wire 1lm 0.9 12 Concrete post with wire 1lm 2.5 13 Brick wall, 100mm 1lm 13 14 Brick wall, 200mm 1lm 20
Resettlement Audit- 3 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7
Resettlement Audit- 4 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7 4. Construction Material Survey
Construction material survey in main supplier shops along NR5,6,7 was carried out to see the present cost and to find its average for unit cost for each location. Pursat Moung Kampong Kampong BBang NR 5 Stoung NR 6 Suong Kratie NR 7 Town Russei Thom Cham CEMENT 1 Elephant cement 1 ton 65.00 63.00 60.00 62.67 68.50 69.00 68.75 71.00 70.00 75.00 72.00 2 Mountain cement 1 ton 58.00 56.50 57.25 59.00 59.00 68.00 3 Dragon cement 1 ton ______66.00 _ 66.00 4 Diamond cement 1 ton 64.00 62.00 57.00 61.00 62.00 68.00 65.00 _ 68.00 _ 68.00 5 Tiger cement 1 ton 57.00 _ 56.00 56.50 66.00 _ 66.00 67.00 66.00 67.00 66.67 6 Bayon cement 1 ton 67.00 _ _ 67.00 65.50 _ 65.50 68.00 _ 73.00 70.50 7 Crocodile cement 1 ton _ 61.00 _ 61.00 _ 65.50 65.50 ____ 8 Eagle cement 1 ton _ _ _ _ 69.00 _ 69.00 _ _ 71.00 71.00
STEEL 9 Vietnam brand name Ø6,8 1 ton 480.00 460.00 495.00 478.33 490.00 540.00 515.00 480.00 490.00 530.00 500.00 10 Vietnam brand name Ø10 1 ton 480.00 460.00 500.00 480.00 480.00 540.00 510.00 490.00 470.00 530.00 496.67 11 Vietnam Ø12, 14, 16 or 18mm 1 ton 480.00 460.00 470.00 470.00 470.00 530.00 500.00 480.00 470.00 500.00 483.33
PLYWOOD 12 Paper ply 1 piece 2.60 2.75 2.50 2.62 _2.802.80 2.80 2.80 3.00 2.87 13 Wooden ply 1200x2400x3 1 piece 3.40 3.50 3.25 3.38 3.40 3.50 3.45 3.00 3.20 3.30 3.17 14 Wooden ply 1200x2400x4 1 piece 4.00 4.50 4.25 4.25 _4.504.50 4.00 4.50 _ 4.25 15 Wooden ply 1200x2400x6 1 piece 6.00 6.00 _ 6.00 6.00 6.20 6.10 5.50 5.50 _ 5.50
FLOORING 16 Khmer tile, 200x200 1 m2 2.20 2.50 _ 2.35 2.50 2.70 2.60 _2.702.502.60
Floor tile, Chinese brand 400x400 17 1m25.505.005.005.17 5.50 5.50 5.50 4.40 5.00 5.00 4.80 18 Floor tile, Thai brand 400x400 1 m2 6.00 7.00 6.25 6.42 6.50 6.50 6.50 6.00 6.50 6.50 6.33
DOOR Wood door, Duong Chem wood: 19 80x2000 1 set 65.00 60.00 60.00 61.67 56.00 55.00 55.50 60.00 55.00 55.00 56.67 20 Plastic door 1 set 17.00 16.00 16.00 16.33 16.00 18.00 17.00 15.00 17.00 18.00 16.67 Wood window, Duong Chem: 21 80x1200 1 set 25.00 _ 24.00 24.50 25.00 25.00 25.00 20.00 25.00 24.00 23.00
Resettlement Audit- 5 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7
Item Description Qty Unit Price (US$) Price (US$) Price (US$) Average Price (US$) Price (US$) Average Price (US$) Price (US$) Price (US$) Average Moung Kampong Kampong Pursat Town BBang NR 5 Stoung NR 6 Suong Kratie NR 7 Russei Thom Cham PAINTING 22 Internal U90 1 container 11.00 10.50 11.00 10.83 11.00 12.00 11.50 10.50 10.50 10.00 10.33 23 External U90 1 container 16.00 16.50 17.00 16.50 16.00 17.00 16.50 15.80 15.80 16.00 15.87 24 Internal FM09 1 container 8.50 8.00 8.00 8.17 8.00 9.00 8.50 _7.509.008.25 25 External FM09 1 container 12.00 11.50 12.00 11.83 11.50 12.50 12.00 _ 11.50 12.00 11.75 26 Internal Star 1 container 8.00 _ _ 8.00 ___ 7.70 _ _ 7.70 27 External Star 1 container ______28 White wash 10 litters 1.00 0.90 1.00 0.97 0.88 1.00 0.94 0.85 0.85 1.20 0.97
ROOF COVER 29 CPAC fiber cement: 550x1200 1 piece 1.70 1.80 1.60 1.70 1.75 2.00 1.88 1.70 1.70 2.00 1.80 30 White tin: 650x2000 1 piece 2.20 2.38 2.20 2.26 2.50 3.00 2.75 2.20 2.38 3.00 2.53 31 White tin: 650x 2400 1 piece 2.50 2.63 2.50 2.54 2.70 3.50 3.10 2.63 2.63 3.50 2.92 32 White tin: 650x3000 1 piece 3.20 3.25 3.30 3.25 3.50 4.00 3.75 3.13 3.25 4.00 3.46 33 Cambodian tile roof 100 pieces 6.50 6.50 6.25 6.42 7.00 8.75 7.88 6.25 6.50 6.20 6.32 34 CPAC tile roof 1 piece 0.40 0.36 0.34 0.37 3.60 0.40 2.00 0.40 0.38 0.43 0.40 35 Thatch 10 bunches 1.50 1.40 1.45 1.50 2.00 1.75 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.50
OTHERS 36 Gravel: 1x2 1 m3 12.00 13.00 10.00 11.67 14.00 9.00 11.50 11.00 11.00 11.00 11.00 37 Gravel: 4x6 1 m3 10.00 10.00 9.50 9.83 9.50 10.00 9.75 6.00 6.00 5.00 5.67 38 Claybrick 100 pieces 3.00 2.75 2.50 2.75 2.00 2.38 2.19 2.00 1.88 2.50 2.13 39 Sand 1 m3 6.00 6.25 7.50 6.58 3.75 5.00 4.38 2.75 3.50 2.50 2.92 40 Fence wire 1 kg 0.75 0.70 0.70 0.72 0.70 1.00 0.85 0.75 0.70 0.70 0.72 41 Nail 1 pakage 3.50 3.20 3.20 3.30 3.20 3.50 3.35 3.50 3.20 3.50 3.40 42 Bamboo strip 1 bundle 0.80 0.75 1.00 0.85 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.25 1.08 43 Timber structure 1 m3 195.00 200.00 200.00 198.33 155.00 170.00 162.50 200.00 200.00 100.00 166.67
Resettlement Audit- 6 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7
5. Schedule of Unit Cost 5.1 Land
Land use in the right of way in the project area is predominantly for rice production. However, we can classify land and land use into three categories i.e. rice field, village land and commercial land. Survey of present land market in the project was established from the interviewed of people along national road 5, 6 and 7 and also obtained from people who own "land for sale" along the project area. This method, however, is not accurate but it also gives a clue of land price at present market rate. There is no data or survey available regarding land price before or during the project implementation.
Below is the summary table of land price from the project study and its actual price from interviewing people along the national road.
Government compensation Average Price ($) per m2 No. Category Cost per m2 ($) for NR 1 (1999) (2005) 1 Rice field 0.50 1.00 - 2.00 2 Village land 2.00 2.00 - 4.00 3 Commercial land/ provincial town 3.00 - 44.00
5.2 Buildings and other Structure
As the house and other structures along the project area are made of different construction materials, costing for its different component parts is more realistic. And for foundation or piles, it is suggested that there is a need to have discussion with the owner and based on available house plan if they have any. Labor cost for housing and other structure was assessed at market rate with guidance of local contractor in each main location. The basic construction material prices in each main location were survey as shown in earlier table.
Learning the construction materials and based on the engineering practice the unit cost can be established as below table. This unit cost is simplified and transparent and the affected people can easily do the calculation themselves of affected structures. In addition, the unit cost reflects the survey questionnaire used for the DMS that asked all the different parts of house structure and its affected quantity. However, it is suggested that this unit cost should be discussed further to reach a common consensus, to meet people satisfaction and submit for further government action.
The calculation of unit cost at pre-project market rate is based on exchange rate at 2000 and 2005. In 2000 the exchange rate was 3800 riels per dollar and now we assume that the exchange rate is 4200 riels per dollar. Thus, the market rate at 2000 was calculated with the formula as below:
Rate at year 2000 = Rate at year 2005 – (2005 price x 400riels/4200)
Resettlement Audit- 7 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7
Item Description Qty Unit Unit Cost USD Unit Cost USD Unit Cost USD NR 5 NR 6 NR 7 2000 2005 2000 2005 2000 2005 Building and other Structure Floor 1 Soil floor 1 m2 0 0 0 2 Plank (house on still) 1 m2 7.14 7.89 5.85 6.47 6.00 6.63 3 Bamboo strip 1 m2 2.36 2.61 2.47 2.73 2.54 2.81 4 Concrete; no tile 1 m2 4.23 4.68 4.39 4.85 3.76 4.16 5 Concrete; with tile 1 m2 8.91 9.85 9.36 10.35 8.11 8.96
Column Wood (quantity can be obtained from 6 the site) m3 179.44 198.33 147.02 162.50 150.80 166.67 7 Concrete column m3 103.37 114.25 103.45 114.34 104.22 115.19
Wall 8 Thatch 1 m2 4.03 4.45 4.28 4.73 4.03 4.45 9 Plank 1 m2 13.93 15.40 11.42 12.62 11.71 12.94 10 Tin/ fibercement 1 m2 1.99 2.20 2.31 2.55 2.15 2.38 11 Clay brick; hollow; 100mm 1 m2 3.48 3.85 3.11 3.44 3.09 3.42 12 Clay brick; hollow; 200mm 1 m2 5.78 6.39 5.12 5.66 5.09 5.63
Roof 13 Thatch 1 m2 4.03 4.45 4.28 4.73 4.03 4.45 14 Tin/ fibercement 1 m2 1.99 2.20 2.31 2.55 2.15 2.38 15 Khmer Tile 1 m2 3.86 4.27 4.07 4.50 4.07 4.50 16 Thai Tile 1 m2 3.90 4.32 4.07 4.50 4.07 4.50 17 Terrasse with reinforced concrete 1 m2 10.34 11.43 10.34 11.43 10.42 11.52
Fence 18 Timber post with bamboo 1 lm 0.62 0.69 0.67 0.74 0.67 0.74 19 Timber post with wire 1 lm 1.76 1.95 2.03 2.24 1.81 2.00 20 Concrete post with wire 1 lm 3.00 3.32 3.22 3.56 3.00 3.32 21 Brick wall; 100mm 1 lm 9.07 10.02 8.37 9.25 8.51 9.41 22 Brick wall; 200mm 1 lm 15.50 17.13 14.51 16.04 14.52 16.05
Well 23 Open well 1 set 30 30 30 24 Deep well 1 set 90 90 90
Classification of each type of house, government used for structural compensation, can also be calculated based on the above cost estimation. But total floor have to be assumed for each type of house. Generally and practically floor are of rural house is vary from 16sqm to 150sqm for single story. The average floor, however, according to field observation, it is assumed as 36sqm of house type I and II and 48sqm for house type III and IV. See below the calculation of each type of house government used for compensation and based on total area of floor assumption (the total floor area from government compensation list doest not show how it was calculate and none of government people interviewed can answer).
Resettlement Audit- 8 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7
House Description Qty Unit NR5,6,7 Type 2000 2005 Thatch wall, thatch roof, wood column on ground or 1 above ground level 1 m2 14.54 16.08 Wood wall, tile or galvanize roof, on ground or 2 cement column 1 m2 33.30 36.80 3 One floor flat house 1 m2 85.98 95.04 4 Two floor flat house 1 m2 143.31 158.39
5.3 Trees and other plants
The unit cost of trees was calculated based on type of tree, yield, number of given years and lump sum for some trees. The yield of each tree obtains from discussion with affected people, people living along the National Road and horticulture department of Prek Leap National School of Agriculture.
Please note that the price in the below table is only for trees of five years or over. Hence, it is suggested that all rate of trees should be classified to three types:
1. from 1-3 years- should not get compensation as it can re-plant 2. from 3-5 years- should get only 2/3 of full price 3. more than 5 years- should get full compensation as calculated in the below table
Resettlement Audit- 9 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7 Item Description Unit Qty Yield per year Years for Unit cost Total Price Total Price Unit Qty compen- USD USD USD sation Year 2005 Year 2000 1 Mango tree 1 5 7.5 37.5 35.63 2 Tamarin tree 1 5 1.5 7.5 7.13 3 Sugar Palm tree 1 kg 30 8 0.15 36 34.20 4 Coconut tree 1 fruit 30 7 0.1 21 19.95 5 Bamboo 5 4.75 6 Jackfruit tree 1 fruit 5 4 1.125 22.5 21.38 7 Kvet (kind of fruit tree) tree 1 fruit 50 7 0.075 26.25 24.94 8 Oval custard-apple ¬eTob)araMg¦ tree 1 kg 6 3 0.75 13.5 12.83 9 Round custard-apple (eTobExμr) tree 1 50fruits 2 2 1.2 4.8 4.56 10 Papaya tree 1 fruit 10 1 0.2 2 1.90 11 Good quality tree tree 1 25 23.75 12 Banana tree 1 cluster 4 1 0.075 0.3 0.29 13 Lemon tree 1 fruit 40 3 0.025 3 2.85 14 Guava (RtEbk)tree1kg530.232.85 15 Spiny tree with flat, round, sour fruit, Krasang ¬RksaMg¦ tree 1 fruit 50 5 0.05 12.5 11.88 16 Smach ¬sμac:¦ tree 1 8 1 8 7.60 17 Pring ¬RBIg¦ tree 1 5 4.75 18 Cashew ¬sVaycnÞI¦ tree 1 kg 2 3 4 24 22.80 19 Eucalyptus ¬eRbgxül;¦ tree 1 5 4.75 20 Kngork ¬ek¶ak¦ tree 1 5 4.75 21 Makak ¬máak;¦ tree 1 50fruits 2 3 1.2 7.2 6.84 22 Tuk Doh Kor ¬TwkedaHeKa¦ tree 1 50fruits 3 4 1 12 11.40
6. Conclusion
Type of housing structure is difference from one province to another, from village to village, from higher and lower income generation household. The poorer the cheaper house structures plus mixing of construction materials. Value calculation of combinations housing structure is not easy. It is very confused to classify house type e.g. tin roof with mixed of bamboo and plank wall and with soil floor.
From the study by MPWT, GMS (Cambodia Road Improvement Project; Addendum to the August 2002 Resettlement Plan, 2005) there are four categories with 14 house types. This classifications and types are much more detail than schedule of compensation rate approved by the MoEF (Ministry of Economic and Finance) which classify only into three types.
Based on the field survey, it is, however, difficult to classify some types of housing structure as different material were used for an element of the house structure. Hence it is suggested in this study to use the schedule of unit rate for each element of house structure i.e. type of floor, columns, wall, roof, etc… Further more, the detailed measurement survey, which agreed and thumb printed by respondent (house owner), also provides quantity of construction materials used.
Resettlement Audit- 10 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7 In this case and from the practical survey it is no need to classify housing type nor category. Costing of each structure element is more realistic and logic if trying to achieve compensation at replacement cost.
Resettlement Audit- 11 Sections of National Road No. 5, 6, 7
Appendix 14
Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 1231231 23 123 1 002002 Kourm Somnang Anlung Vel 1 2.46 4.5 11.07 156000 0 0 0 156000 11.07 1 01/02/2001 2 003001 Dorm Phana Anlung Vel 2 5.5 12 66 156000 78000 0 0 0 66 1 01/02/2001 3 002001 Vann Saveurn Anlung Vel 1 24 4.5 108 156000 0 0 0 156000 108 1 01/02/2001 4 004001 Horn Yat Anlung Vel 2 5.94 12 71.28 156000 0 0 0 0 71.28 1 01/02/2001 5 001001 Dum Doy Anlung Vel 2 6.5 12 78 156000 0 0 0 0 78 1 01/02/2001 6 001002 Puy Heurn Anlung Vel 2 21.7 12 260.4 156000 0 0 0 0 260.4 1 01/02/2001 7 004002 Hun Vebull Anlung Vel 2 9.45 12 113.4 156000 0 0 0 156000 113.4 1 01/02/2001 8 Heurng Leab Anlung Vel 9 Pan Denn Anlung Vel 10 Pen Chom Nab Anlung Vel 11 Chaub Tub Anlung Vel 12 Keo Sockhum Anlung Vel 13 Theurn Sameurn Anlung Vel 14 Pat Siyunn Anlung Vel 15 Meurn Hert Anlung Vel 16 Boo Norb Anlung Vel 17 Heurn Chheurn Anlung Vel Total 17 75.55 0 0 708.15 0 0 1092000 78000 0 0 468000 708.15 0 0 18 004003 Lai Kek Au dombong II 2 12.5 12 150 156000 0 0 0 156000 150 1 01/02/2001 19 003002 Yeurn Sdeng Au dombong II 1 27.9 4.5 125.55 156000 0 0 0 0 125.55 1 01/02/2001 20 003003 Chan Lach Au dombong II 1 16.1 4.5 72.45 156000 0 0 0 156000 72.45 1 01/02/2001 21 001003 Chea Chao Au dombong II 2 18.8 12 225.6 156000 0 0 0 156000 225.6 1 01/02/2001 22 002003 Chey Lim Au dombong II 1 6.24 4.5 28.08 156000 0 0 0 156000 28.08 1 01/02/2001 23 Leing Ran Au dombong II 24 Uch Salonn Au dombong II Total 7 81.54 0 0 601.68 0 0 780000 0 0 0 624000 601.68 0 0 25 004046 Leang Sokha Au Tapaung 2 28 12 336 156000 0 78000 0 0 336 1 26/03/2001 26 002055 Much Cheat Au Tapaung 2 14.4 12 172.8 156000 0 0 0 0 172.8 1 26/03/2001 27 003051 Yeom Neurn Au Tapaung 2 16 4.5 72 156000 0 0 0 0 72 1 26/03/2001 28 003051 Kouk Chheng Au Tapaung 2 10.4 12 124.8 156000 0 0 0 0 124.8 1 26/03/2001 29 002056 Oum Ken Au Tapaung 2 8.6 12 103.2 156000 0 0 0 0 103.2 1 26/03/2001 30 002057 Gnor Gnar Au Tapaung 2 6.3 12 75.6 156000 0 0 0 0 75.6 1 26/03/2001 31 003053 Sok Ni Au Tapaung 2 14.94 12 179.28 156000 0 0 0 0 179.28 1 26/03/2001 32 004047 Kang Heurb Au Tapaung 1 20.4 4.5 91.8 156000 0 0 0 0 91.8 1 26/03/2001 Total 8 119.04 0 0 1155.48 0 0 1248000 0 78000 0 0 1155.48 0 0 33 003079 Mom Thol Boeng Khnar 4 14 0.75 10.5 10.5 1 dk 34 001074 Luon Soheang Boeng Khnar 4 21 0.75 15.75 15.75 1 dk 35 001072 Ek Sokhum Boeng Khnar 4 22 0.75 16.5 16.5 1 dk 36 001070 Heng Chhev Boeng Khnar 4 25 0.75 18.75 18.75 1 dk 37 001069 Morn Sorn Boeng Khnar 4 25 0.75 10.87 10.87 1 dk 38 001068 Seng Seurn Boeng Khnar 4 27 0.75 20.25 20.25 1 dk 39 003073 Teang Yut Boeng Khnar 4 15 0.75 11.25 11.25 1 dk 40 001073 Soem Lunkanul Boeng Khnar 4 28.6 0.75 21.45 21.45 1 dk 41 003080 Souy Kimseng Boeng Khnar 4 21.5 0.75 16.12 16.12 1 dk 42 003078 Chhin Samat Boeng Khnar 4 17 0.75 12.75 12.75 1 dk 43 003074 Sok Vat Boeng Khnar 4 38.5 0.75 28.87 28.87 1 dk 44 001067 Ke Eng Boeng Khnar 4 60 0.75 45 45 1 dk 45 004052 Phan Rom Boeng Khnar 4 21.6 0.75 16.2 16.2 1 dk 46 003077 Kaov Heang Boeng Khnar 4 19.7 0.75 14.77 14.77 1 dk 47 003075 Suy Keat Boeng Khnar 4 24.3 0.75 18.22 18.22 1 dk 48 003050 Toang Run Boeng Khnar 2 15.51 12 186.12 156000 0 0 0 0 186.12 1 24/3/2001 49 004045 Poch Porn Boeng Khnar 1 30 4.5 135 156000 0 0 78000 156000 135 1 25/3/2001 Total 17 425.71 0 0 598.37 0 0 312000 0 0 78000 156000 598.37 0 0 50 Som Peseth Kear 51 Ly Hourn Kear 52 Chea Chei Kear 53 Rung Hak Kear 54 Koeung Heurng Kear 55 Seik Sovann Kear 56 Khloeung Pech Kear 57 Laus Koeum Kear 58 Som Sin Kear 59 Sang Rum Kear
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 60 Chan Vanthai Kear 61 Rum Sombau Kear 62 Lein Thun Kear 63 Loeum Serkung Kear 64 Kung Lak Kear 65 Khun Chib Kear 66 Yourn Yorn Kear 67 Vann Seurm Kear 68 Prum Vesna Kear 69 Mum Ri Kear 70 002028 Tell Reth Kear dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 71 004020 Mum Phally Kear 2 11.75 12 141 156000 0 0 0 156000 141 1 02/02/2001 72 002020 Pheing Gnaur Kear 2 12 12 144 156000 0 0 0 156000 144 1 02/02/2001 73 001018 Kre Salort Kear 1 11.2 4.5 50.4 156000 0 0 0 156000 50.4 1 02/02/2001 74 003018 Chhai Sophall Kear 2 44.4 12 532.8 156000 0 0 0 156000 532.8 1 02/02/2001 75 001019 Ken Seirn Kear 1 18.8 4.5 84.6 156000 0 0 0 156000 84.6 1 02/02/2001 76 002019 Gnourn Yeurn Kear 1 8.75 4.5 39.37 156000 0 0 0 156000 39.37 1 02/02/2001 77 004021 Sor Phun Kear dk dk dk dk 156000 78000 0 0 156000 dk 1 21/03/01 78 Chheurn Buntheurn Kear 79 Bei Ak Kear 80 Seurn Yeurn Kear 81 Vann Sreurn Kear 82 Heing Muy Kear 83 Nin Saa Kear 84 Pov Phi Kear 85 Orn Sophornn Kear Total 36 106.9 0 0 1032.17 0 0 1092000 78000 0 0 1092000 1032.17 0 0 86 002011 Soeung Pai Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 0 1 01/02/2001 87 002009 Oeum Chen Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 156000 1 01/02/2001 88 001010 Ork Ken Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 0 1 01/02/2001 89 002008 Seing Yan Kom Pung Preang 1 9.12 4.5 41.04 156000 0 0 0 156000 41.04 1 01/02/2001 90 004010 Koeum Keng Kom Pung Preang 1 32.3 4.5 145.35 156000 0 0 0 0 145.35 1 01/02/2001 91 003008 Koeum Chanra Kom Pung Preang 1 4.8 4.5 21.6 156000 0 0 0 0 21.6 1 01/02/2001 92 002007 Sorn La Kom Pung Preang 1 29.15 4.5 131.175 156000 0 0 0 0 131.175 1 01/02/2001 93 001007 Horng Sareurn Kom Pung Preang 1 20.35 4.5 91.57 156000 0 0 0 0 91.57 1 01/02/2001 94 003007 Pheing Veasna Kom Pung Preang 2 25.35 12 304.2 156000 0 0 0 0 304.2 1 01/02/2001 95 001010 Dek Ken Kom Pung Preang 1 14.28 4.5 64.26 156000 0 0 0 0 64.26 1 01/02/2001 96 002011 Soeung Pei Kom Pung Preang 2 25.2 12 302.4 156000 0 0 0 0 302.4 1 01/02/2001 97 002009 Oeum Chen Kom Pung Preang 1 14 4.5 63 156000 0 0 0 156000 63 1 01/02/2001 98 001008 Chann Sombath Kom Pung Preang 1 18.2 4.5 81.9 156000 0 0 0 156000 81.9 1 01/02/2001 99 004013 Keo Tha Kom Pung Preang 1 11.96 4.5 53.82 156000 0 0 0 156000 53.82 1 01/02/2001 100 001012 Moung Kachreb Kom Pung Preang 1 10 4.5 45 156000 78000 0 0 156000 45 1 01/02/2001 101 001009 Reurn Theurn Kom Pung Preang 2 10.5 12 126 156000 0 0 0 156000 126 1 01/02/2001 102 001012 Pen Reurm Kom Pung Preang 1 11.55 4.5 51.97 156000 0 0 0 156000 51.97 1 01/02/2001 103 001011 Chhoeum Bunchhung Kom Pung Preang 2 4.65 12 55.8 156000 0 0 0 156000 55.8 1 01/02/2001 104 003010 Chhoeum Sophunn Kom Pung Preang 2 20.14 12 241.68 156000 0 78000 0 0 241.68 1 01/02/2001 105 003017 Cheark Meas Kom Pung Preang 2 31.2 12 374.4 156000 0 0 0 156000 374.4 1 01/02/2001 106 003009 Yoeum Kung Kom Pung Preang 2 1701 12 205.2 156000 78000 0 0 0 205.2 1 01/02/2001 107 002010 Meak Saven Kom Pung Preang 1 10.14 4.5 45.63 156000 78000 0 0 156000 45.63 1 01/02/2001 108 SC4026 Chhourn Chheat Kom Pung Preang dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 109 SC003023 Kheurn Vanna Kom Pung Preang dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 110 SC003022 Chhourn Yeing Kom Pung Preang dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 111 SC001027 Sou Korn Kom Pung Preang dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 112 SC002026 So Chheurb Kom Pung Preang dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 113 004009 Sours Buntha Kom Pung Preang 1 19.2 4.5 86.4 156000 78000 0 0 156000 86.4 1 01/02/2001 114 040011 Kegn Theur Kom Pung Preang 1 26.46 4.5 119.07 156000 0 0 0 156000 119.07 1 01/02/2001 115 003011 Chen Sunn Kom Pung Preang 1 8.82 4.5 39.69 156000 78000 0 0 156000 39.69 1 01/02/2001 116 003016 Heing Hery Kom Pung Preang 1 11.2 4.5 50.4 156000 0 0 0 0 50.4 1 01/02/2001 117 004012 Ros Sareurn Kom Pung Preang 1 10.2 4.5 45.9 156000 78000 78000 0 0 45.9 1 01/02/2001 118 003007 Pheng Vesna Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 0 1 01/02/2001 119 003008 Kim Chanra Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 0 1 01/02/2001 120 002008 Seing Yan Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 156000 1 01/02/2001 121 002007 Sorn La Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 0 1 01/02/2001 122 001007 Horng Sareurn Kom Pung Preang 156000 1 01/02/2001
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 123 001008 Chann Sombath Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 156000 1 01/02/2001 124 004010 Koeum Keng Kom Pung Preang 156000 0 0 0 0 1 01/02/2001 125 Ork Kimlin Kom Pung Preang 126 Him Phorn Kom Pung Preang 127 Thul Mok Kom Pung Preang 128 Tit Loy Kom Pung Preang 129 Kim Ki Kom Pung Preang 130 Khoeum Phl Kom Pung Preang 131 Kung Sok khorm Kom Pung Preang 132 Hourn Bour Kom Pung Preang 133 Brach Ding Kom Pung Preang 134 Korng Chea Kom Pung Preang 135 Gna Sopha Kom Pung Preang 136 Tem Savuth Kom Pung Preang 137 Sieng Yan Kom Pung Preang 138 Ork Ken Kom Pung Preang 139 Pech Sareurn Kom Pung Preang 140 Choeum Bunya Kom Pung Preang Total 55 2079.77 0 0 2987.455 0 0 5304000 468000 156000 0 2496000 2987.455 0 0 141 Eab Hok Chin Kom pung Pres 142 Long Veurt Kom pung Pres 143 Chea Reurn Kom pung Pres 144 Thuy Mon Kom pung Pres 145 Than Krum Kom pung Pres 146 Yai Yeurn Kom pung Pres 147 Reim Rourng Kom pung Pres 148 Yeurn Kheurb Kom pung Pres 149 Kong Leam Kom pung Pres 150 Phourng Lagn Kom pung Pres 151 Buk Sareurn Kom pung Pres 152 Chea Bunrt Kom pung Pres 153 Khen Deit Kom pung Pres 154 Khel Duk Kom pung Pres 155 Doeum Sarert Kom pung Pres 156 Prak Sareurn Kom pung Pres 157 Sun Thea Kom pung Pres 158 SC002001 Kov Mert Kompungpreas dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 159 SC4001 Teip Keurt Kompungpreas dk dk dk 40 40 1 16803/01 160 SC1001 Sau Hort Kompungpreas dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 161 001006 Buth Seing Kompungpreas 1 1023 4.5 46.03 156000 78000 0 0 156000 46.03 1 01/02/2001 162 001004 Teip Sareurn Kompungpreas 1 1.4 4.5 6.3 156000 0 0 0 156000 6.3 1 01/02/2001 163 004007 Tann Rotha Kompungpreas 2 16.5 12 198 156000 0 0 0 0 198 1 01/02/2001 164 003005 Bau Bi Kompungpreas 1 4.2 4.5 18.9 156000 0 0 0 156000 18.9 1 01/02/2001 165 004004 Hoeum Chhin Kompungpreas 1 10 4.5 22.81 156000 0 0 78000 156000 22.81 1 01/02/2001 166 000001 Pech Mao Kompungpreas 1 5.07 4.5 22.81 156000 0 0 0 156000 22.81 1 01/02/2001 167 002005 Chen Kmao Kompungpreas 1 5.58 4.5 25.11 156000 0 0 0 0 25.11 1 01/02/2001 168 004006 Meth Savat Kompungpreas 1 7.25 4.5 32.62 156000 0 0 0 156000 32.62 1 01/02/2001 169 004005 Sour Chhum Kompungpreas 1 8.75 4.5 34.37 156000 0 0 0 0 34.37 1 01/02/2001 170 002004 Chheing Habb Kompungpreas 1 2.52 4.5 11.34 156000 11.34 1 01/02/2001 171 002006 Sngeun Pheap Kompungpreas 1 1.25 4.5 5.62 156000 78000 0 78000 156000 5.62 1 01/02/2001 172 003006 Horm Kun Kompungpreas 2 18.52 12 222 156000 0 0 0 0 222 1 01/02/2001 173 001005 Rum Pheurn Kompungpreas 1 3.96 4.5 17.82 156000 0 0 0 156000 17.82 1 01/02/2001 174 003004 Bun Vanny Kompungpreas 2 18 12 216 156000 0 0 0 0 216 1 01/02/2001 175 Sung Chourn Kompungpreas 176 Song Sert Kompungpreas 177 Song Seat Kompungpreas 178 Chham Chhert Kompungpreas 179 Chea Cheang Kompungpreas 180 Horb Nell Kompungpreas 181 Phlang Spean Kompungpreas 182 Neit Neurng Kompungpreas Total 42 1126 0 0 999.73 0 0 2184000 156000 0 156000 1248000 999.73 0 0 183 2039 NOUN Mao Lor Lork Sor 4 6 4.86 16.83 16.83 1 05/02/2001 184 3032 CHOU Eng Huk Lor Lork Sor 4 18.5 4.86 89.91 89.91 1 05/02/2001
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 185 4026 MOK Sokun Lor Lork Sor 4 10.5 4.86 51.03 51.03 1 05/02/2001 186 2041 Leang Eng Lor Lork Sor 2 13.2 12 158.4 156000 78000 0 0 0 158.4 1 05/02/2001 187 2042 HUT Seng Lor Lork Sor 4 5.8 4.86 28.18 28.18 1 05/02/2001 188 2040 CHI Vanna Lor Lork Sor 2 12.25 12 147 156000 0 0 0 0 147 1 05/02/2001 189 3034 MOK Sahan Lor Lork Sor 2 4 19.25 6.1 12 4.86 231 29.64 156000 0 0 0 0 231 29.64 1 05/02/2001 190 4027 KEO Seng Yorn Lor Lork Sor 1 4 19.84 2.9 4.5 4.86 89.28 14.09 156000 0 0 78000 156000 89.28 14.09 1 05/02/2001 191 4028 CHEAM Lorn Lor Lork Sor 3 26.18 85 2225.3 156000 0 0 0 0 2225.3 2 15/2/2001 192 4029 CHOURB Chy Lor Lork Sor 4 12 4.86 58.32 58.32 1 05/02/2001 193 3035 SEN Somreth Lor Lork Sor 2 10.5 12 126 156000 78000 0 0 0 126 1 05/02/2001 194 4030 MA Roun Lor Lork Sor 2 8.4 12 108.8 156000 78000 0 0 0 108.8 1 05/02/2001 195 1033 VA Chanthorn Lor Lork Sor 2 18.4 12 220.8 156000 0 78000 0 0 220.8 1 05/02/2001 196 2113 SOU Sokha Lor Lork Sor 2 22.13 12 265.56 156000 0 0 0 0 265.56 1 DK 197 SC 3010 TEA Phythou Lor Lork Sor DK DK 1 30/3/2001 198 2109 HEUN Tep Lor Lork Sor 4 34.4 140 4816 156000 0 0 0 0 4816 3 DK 199 2109 CHEA Eng Lor Lork Sor 3 21 85 1785 156000 0 0 0 0 1785 2 DK 200 2111 KONG Chomreun Lor Lork Sor 4 25 140 3500 159000 0 0 0 0 3500 3 DK 201 2110 CHEA Chheang Lor Lork Sor 3 14.7 85 1249.5 156000 0 0 0 0 1249.5 2 DK 202 2107 SOK Kea Lor Lork Sor 3 50 85 4250 156000 0 0 0 0 4250 3 DK 203 SC 3011 THEAM Bunthy Lor Lork Sor 1 01/04/2001 204 2108 KA Kruch Lor Lork Sor 2 15.3 12 183.6 156000 0 0 0 0 183.6 1 DK 205 2076 YU Try Lor Lork Sor dk DK DK 500 500 1 24/4/2002 206 SC 2015 HUN Deb Lor Lork Sor DK DK DK 40 40 1 DK 207 SC 3012 CHOR hongLay Lor Lork Sor 1 01/04/2001 208 DK SOEUM Phon Lor Lork Sor 209 IRC 002043 AET Chhun Lor lork Sor 1 8.6 4.50 38.70 156000 0 78000 0 0 38.70 1 05/02/2001 210 IRC 003036 CHEA Vanny Lor lork Sor 4 14.8 4.86 71.92 71.92 1 05/02/2001 211 IRC 003037 POA Kimsrun Lor lork Sor 2 20.44 12.00 245.28 156000 0 0 0 0 245.28 1 05/02/2001 212 IRC 002044 LY Vantha Lor lork Sor 2 17.55 12.00 210.60 156000 0 0 0 0 210.60 1 05/02/2001 213 IRC 002045 LOA hangKrey Lor lork Sor 2 13.25 12.00 159.00 156000 0 0 0 0 159.00 1 05/02/2001 214 IRC 004031 IN Hy Lor lork Sor 2 8.4 12.00 100.80 156000 0 0 78000 156000 100.80 1 05/02/2001 215 IRC 004032 NGIN Vat Lor lork Sor 2 6.4 12.00 76.80 156000 0 0 0 0 76.80 1 05/02/2001 216 IRC 003038 PENG Savchan Lor lork Sor 2 23 12.00 276.00 156000 0 0 0 156000 276.00 1 05/02/2001 Total 34 475.79 9 0 21319.61 43.73 0 3435000 234000 156000 156000 468000 21319.61 43.73 0 217 002018 Gneirt Beurn Mong 2 4.6 12 55.2 156000 0 0 0 156000 55.2 1 02/02/2001 218 004019 NovTheang Mong 2 2.88 12 34.56 156000 0 0 0 0 34.56 1 02/02/2001 219 Keo Sarem Mong 220 Lang Krut Mong 221 Meth Rorth Mong 222 Seing Chet Mong 223 Hum Sareurn Mong 224 Unn Sokhorn Mong 225 Svay Somm Mong Total 9 7.48 0 0 89.76 0 0 312000 0 0 0 156000 89.76 0 0 226 SC 004001 BUN Try Ou Tapoang 1 30/3/2001 227 SC 002001 RETH Rom Ou Tapoang 1 28/3/2001 228 SC 003005 SANG Savann Ou Tapoang 1 30/3/2001 229 3082 SRUN Kim Ou Tapoang 4 20.8 0.75 15.6 15.6 1 DK 230 SC 004004 LENG Mov Ou Tapoang 1 30/1/2001 231 3081 RET Rorm Ou Tapoang 4 51 0.75 38.25 38.25 1 DK 232 1075 PHAN Buntheun Ou Tapoang 4 10 0.75 7.5 7.5 1 DK 233 3083 SUN Leang Heng Ou Tapoang 4 11.5 0.75 8.62 8.62 1 DK 234 3085 CHHEAN Norng Ou Tapoang 4 12.5 0.75 76.87 76.87 1 DK 235 SC 2016 SAN Hong Ou Tapoang DK DK 40 40 1 DK 236 3084 CHHEAN Nang Ou Tapoang 4 30.2 0.75 22.65 22.65 1 DK 237 SC 003001 SIEV Hean Ou Tapoang 1 30/3/2001 238 002057 Gnor Gnar Ou Tapoang 2 6.30 12 75.6 75.6 DK 239 004047 Kang Heurb Ou Tapoang 1 20.40 4.5 91.8 91.8 DK 240 003051 Kouk Chheng Ou Tapoang 2 16.00 12 192 192 DK 241 004046 Leang Sokha Ou Tapoang 2 28.00 12 336 336 DK 242 002055 Much Cheat Ou Tapoang 2 14.40 12 172.8 172.8 DK 243 002056 Oum Ken Ou Tapoang 2 8.60 12 103.2 103.2 DK 244 003053 Sok Ni Ou Tapoang 2 14.94 12 179.28 179.28 DK 245 003051 Yeom Neurn Ou Tapoang 1 16.00 4.5 72 72 DK Total 20 260.64 0 0 1432.17 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1432.17 0 0
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 246 2105 SEM Kosal Phatass Prey 3 34.2 85 2907 156000 0 0 0 0 2907 1 DK 247 1008 MEAS Chomreun Phatass Prey dk 1 30/3/2001 248 3014 CHEM Sunly Phatass Prey 1DK 249 206 Kruch Sat Phatass Prey 1 28/3/2001 250 207 MEAS Mol Phatass Prey 1 28/3/2001 251 4009 LOEUM Horng Phatass Prey 1 30/3/2001 252 1046 CHAN Sokha Phatass Prey 2 12 176.4 156000 0 0 0 0 176.4 1 30/3/2001 253 4006 KEO Nam Phatass Prey dk 1 30/3/2001 254 3008 PENH Saron Phatass Prey 1 30/3/2001 255 4007 LOEUM Sivpey Phatass Prey 1 30/3/2001 256 2063 CHEANG Roun Phatass Prey 1 9.25 4.5 41.62 156000 0 0 0 0 41.62 1 28/3/2001 257 1007 OAK Rithy Phatass Prey dk 1 30/3/2001 258 3009 AUM Muy Phatass Prey 1 30/3/2001 259 2005 Sou Ponlork Phatass Prey 1 28/3/2001 260 2101 TEV Kean Phatass Prey 4 20 140 2800 156000 0 0 0 0 2800 1 DK 261 2106 CHHOEUM Saroeum Phatass Prey 4 11.25 140 1575 156000 78000 0 0 0 1575 1 DK 262 2104 Keang Chomreun Phatass Prey 3 33.7 85 2864.5 156000 0 0 0 0 2864.5 1 DK 263 2008 SOAM Ratha Phatass Prey 40 40 1 DK 264 4008 CHEA Touch Phatass Prey 1 30/3/2001 265 2078 MA Keang Phatass Prey 4 0.75 17.25 17.25 1 DK 266 1009 SORN Sary Phatass Prey DK 267 2061 HEM Kimsri Phatass Prey 1 11 4.5 49.5 156000 0 0 0 0 49.5 1 28/3/2001 268 8020 NGET Seyha Phatass Prey 40 40 1 DK 269 2062 BUN Narom Phatass Prey 2 15.5 12 186 156000 0 0 0 0 186 1 28/3/2001 270 2097 TENG Chung Eng Phatass Prey 3 21.2 85 1802 156000 0 0 0 0 1802 1 DK 271 2103 LAY Seng Phatass Prey 3 30 85 2550 156000 0 0 0 0 2550 1 DK 272 2102 MUK Vat Phatass Prey 3 25.5 85 2167.5 156000 0 0 0 0 2167.5 1 DK 273 2098 MEN Nay Phatass Prey 4 28 140 3920 156000 0 0 0 0 3920 1 DK 274 2099 CHHAK Sokhorn Phatass Prey 3 36 85 3060 156000 0 0 0 0 3060 1 DK 275 2100 KHLOAK Touch Phatass Prey 4 15 140 2100 156000 78000 0 0 0 2100 1 DK 276 003028 Kuoy Ny Pteas Prey 2 20.25 12 243 156000 78000 0 0 0 243 1 04/02/2001 277 003026 Hun Mao Pteas Prey 1+2 4.6 12.4 4.5 12 20.7 148.8 156000 0 0 0 0 20.7 148.8 1 04/02/2001 278 003025 Seng Sreng Pteas Prey 2 10.6 12 123.12 156000 0 0 0 0 123.12 1 04/02/2001 279 002034 Men Dom Pteas Prey 2 27.03 12 324.36 156000 0 0 0 0 324.36 1 04/02/2001 280 002033 Brak Sokhun Pteas Prey 2 13.75 12 165 156000 165 1 04/02/2001 281 001028 Eurn Savon Pteas Prey 1 12.21 4.5 54.94 156000 78000 0 0 156000 54.94 1 04/02/2001 282 001027 Sem Nout Pteas Prey 2 13.5 12 162 156000 0 0 0 0 162 1 04/02/2001 283 003033 Lay Tola Pteas Prey 4 24 4.86 116.64 116.64 1 04/02/2001 284 001032 Sou Chamreurn Pteas Prey 4 6.1 4.86 29.64 29.64 1 04/02/2001 285 002050 Leang Lay Pteas Prey 4 2.3 4.86 11.16 11.16 1 20/3/2001 286 001031 Cheam Loan Pteas Prey 4 30 4.86 145.8 145.8 1 04/01/2001 287 003023 Chem Sunchheang Pteas Prey 2 13.5 12 162 156000 0 0 0 0 162 1 04/02/2001 288 002032 Chheang Khandy Pteas Prey 2 21 12 252 156000 0 0 0 0 252 1 04/02/2001 289 002031 Kang Chea Pteas Prey 4 12 4.86 58.32 58.32 1 04/02/2001 290 001025 Hun Yeurn Pteas Prey 2 4 11.25 8.8 4.86 4.86 177.76 156000 156000 0 0 0 177.76 1 04/02/2001 291 001024 Chan Et Pteas Prey 4 14.8 4.86 71.92 71.92 1 04/02/2001 292 001023 Chan Sophal Pteas Prey 4 12.1 4.86 58.8 58.8 1 04/02/2001 293 003024 Heurn Huny Pteas Prey 2 41.3 12 495.6 495.6 04/02/2001 294 002025 Ph Srey Pteas Prey 4 19.5 4.86 94.77 94.77 04/02/2001 295 002028 Pol Dy Pteas Prey 2 21 12 252 156000 78000 0 0 0 252 1 04/02/2001 296 002027 Seng Thai Pteas Prey 2 22.5 12 270 156000 0 0 0 0 270 1 04/02/2001 297 002035 Keav Khun Pteas Prey 2 5 12 60 156000 78000 0 0 0 60 1 04/02/2001 298 001022 Brak Sovannary Pteas Prey 2 4 9.4 12 4.86 112.8 36.45 156000 0 0 0 0 112.8 36.45 1 04/02/2001 299 002026 Seng Dos Pteas Prey 4 4.86 43.74 43.74 1 04/02/2001 300 003019 Em Phuvibut Pteas Prey 2 88.2 12 88.2 156000 0 0 0 0 88.2 1 04/02/2001 301 002030 Brach Noem Pteas Prey 4 20 4.86 97.2 97.2 1 04/02/2001 302 001026 Loem Manich Pteas Prey 4 17.4 4.86 84.56 84.56 1 04/02/2001 303 004017 Kar Heurm Pteas Prey 2 18.4 12 220.8 156000 0 0 0 0 220.8 1 04/02/2001 304 004016 Kar Heurm Pteas Prey 2 22.56 12 270.72 156000 0 0 0 0 270.72 1 04/02/2001 305 004015 Tep Sok Pteas Prey 2 14.04 12 168.48 156000 0 0 0 156000 168.48 1 04/02/2001 306 003021 Chea Sambo Pteas Prey 2 14 12 168 156000 0 78000 0 0 168 1 04/02/2001 307 003022 Gnuy Visoth Pteas Prey 2 28.52 12 342.24 156000 0 0 0 0 342.24 1 04/02/2001 308 003020 Norng Bunmeng Pteas Prey 2 14 12 168 156000 0 0 0 0 168 1 04/02/2001 309 004020 Svay Met Pteas Prey 4 12 4.86 58.32 58.32 1 04/02/2001
5 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 310 004019 Chan Eurn Pteas Prey 2 7.5 12 90 156000 78000 0 78000 0 90 1 04/02/2001 311 004018 Chin Savly Pteas Prey 4 12 4.8 0.75 4.86 9 23.32 9 23.32 1 04/02/2001 312 003018 Chheng Kimhuy Pteas Prey 4 6.3 4.86 30.6 30.6 1 04/02/2001 313 002029 Tith Sameurn Pteas Prey 3 4 6.3 6.24 28 4.86 85 4.86 30.618 530.4 136.08 30.618 530.4 136.08 1 04/02/2001 314 002037 Lem Kheang Pteas Prey 2 7.75 12 93 156000 0 0 0 0 93 1 04/02/2001 315 002038 Leng Kimsrey Pteas Prey 2 10.8 12 129.6 156000 0 0 0 0 129.6 1 04/02/2001 316 001030 Men Sovan Pteas Prey 2 6.82 12 81.84 156000 0 0 0 0 81.84 1 04/02/2001 317 004025 Preab Von Pteas Prey 2 4 8.14 12 4.86 97.68 26.73 156000 0 0 0 0 97.68 26.73 1 04/02/2001 318 003031 Hor Chheng Pteas Prey 2 4 10.5 12 4.86 126 20 156000 0 78000 0 0 126 20 1 04/02/2001 319 001029 Suong Saeurn Pteas Prey 2 10 12 120 156000 0 0 0 0 120 1 04/02/2001 320 004024 Tan Kimchheang Pteas Prey 2 16.4 12 196.8 156000 0 0 0 0 196.8 1 04/02/2001 321 003030 Uon Yan Pteas Prey 2 45.45 12 545.4 156000 0 0 0 0 545.4 1 04/02/2001 322 003029 Pol Heng Pteas Prey 2 18.45 12 221.4 156000 0 0 0 0 221.4 1 04/02/2001 323 004021 Lem Horng Pteas Prey 4 12 13.39 13.39 1 04/02/2001 324 004023 Mao Sokhun Pteas Prey 2 26.64 12 319.68 156000 0 0 0 156000 319.68 1 04/02/2001 325 004022 Ly Ny Pteas Prey 2 9 12 108 156000 0 0 0 0 108 1 04/02/2001 326 003027 Nov Brak Pteas Prey 2 18.85 12 226.2 156000 0 0 0 156000 226.2 1 04/02/2001 327 002036 Ho Yeurng Pteas Prey 2 27.84 12 334.08 156000 0 0 0 0 334.08 1 04/02/2001 328 001050 San Sophal Pteas Prey 4 20.5 0.75 15.37 15.37 1 dk 329 001049 Pin Soriya Pteas Prey 4 14.5 0.75 10.87 10.87 1 dk 330 001053 Soth Sitha Pteas Prey 4 19 0.75 14.25 14.25 dk dk 331 001054 Neang Gkech Pteas Prey 4 19 0.75 14.25 14.25 dk dk 332 001048 You Srun Pteas Prey 4 34 0.75 25.5 25.5 2001 333 001049 Chem Sunan Pteas Prey 4 19.8 0.75 14.85 14.85 2001 334 003057 Bit Theurn Pteas Prey 4 20.2 0.75 15.15 15.15 dk 335 002066 Chhem Yorm Pteas Prey 4 18 0.75 13.5 13.5 2001 336 003062 Saum Sokun Pteas Prey 4 46.4 0.75 34.8 34.8 dk 337 003066 Chhor Hongly Pteas Prey 4 12.5 0.75 9.37 9.37 dk 338 003067 Khem Kimeng Pteas Prey 4 14 0.75 10.5 10.5 dk 339 001055 Kuch Sithal Pteas Prey 4 16 0.75 12 12 dk 340 003064 Sun Phalla Pteas Prey 4 22 0.75 16.5 16.5 dk 341 003063 Seng Kimtim Pteas Prey 4 18.2 0.75 13.65 13.65 dk Total 96 1450.25 32.24 28 34382.4 785.7 136.08 7644000 702000 156000 78000 624000 34382.398 785.7 136.08 342 002095 Out Sim Prey Gny 2 20.77 12 249.24 156000 0 0 0 0 249.24 1 dk 343 002094 Ouk Theab Prey Gny 3 25.2 85 2142 156000 0 0 0 0 2142 2 dk 344 002064 Houm Heurn Prey Gny 4 18 0.75 13.5 13.5 dk dk 345 002096 Try Hong Prey Gny 4 11.25 140 1575 156000 0 0 0 0 1575 2 dk 346 002067 Tith Chhun Prey Gny 4 32 0.75 24 24 1 2001 347 002093 Tuoch Penghuor Prey Gny 4 10.8 140 1512 156000 0 0 0 0 1512 2 dk 348 002091 Seang Saroan Prey Gny 2 21.09 12 253.08 156000 0 0 0 0 253.08 1 dk 349 002092 Seng Yorn Prey Gny 2 20 12 240 156000 0 0 0 0 240 1 dk 350 002090 Chuong Khut Prey Gny 3 7.7 85 657.5 156000 0 0 0 0 657.5 1 dk 351 002070 Earn Kimchhung Prey Gny 4 0.75 18.67 18.67 1 dk 352 003056 Ly Chhin Prey Gny 4 14.2 4.86 69.01 69.01 dk dk 353 002069 Sok Leabeng Prey Gny 4 31 0.75 23.25 23.25 1 2001 354 002065 Sin Sophalla Prey Gny 4 26 0.75 19.5 19.5 dk dk 355 SC2014 Te Hongngib Prey Gny dk dk dk 20 20 1 dk 356 SC2013 Ros Try Prey Gny dk dk dk 20 20 1 dk 357 003003 Ke Lun Prey Gny 2 7.8 12 94.08 156000 0 0 0 0 94.08 1 01/02/2001 358 002007 Men Seurn Prey Gny 1 2.3 4.5 10.4 156000 0 78000 0 0 10.4 1 01/02/2001 359 004002 Sun Khvoy Prey Gny 2 6.72 12 80.64 156000 0 0 0 0 80.64 1 01/02/2001 360 003002 Tea Theng Prey Gny 2 10.45 12 125.4 156000 0 0 0 0 125.4 1 01/02/2001 361 002006 Chhem Puk Prey Gny 2 8.55 12 102.6 78000 78000 0 0 0 102.6 1 01/02/2001 362 002005 Bin Ra Prey Gny 2 5.2 12 62.4 156000 0 0 0 0 62.4 1 01/02/2001 363 002004 Huot Say Prey Gny 2 9.4 12 112.8 156000 0 0 0 0 112.8 1 01/02/2001 364 001006 Chiv Sueng Prey Gny 3 6.1 85 518.5 156000 0 0 0 0 518.5 1 01/02/2001 365 001005 Chok Savareurn Prey Gny 2 7.2 12 86.4 156000 0 0 0 0 86.4 1 01/02/2001 366 001004 Nov Neang Prey Gny 1 19.8 4.5 59.1 156000 0 0 0 156000 59.1 1 01/02/2001 367 004001 Ngin Pak Prey Gny 2 7.5 12 90 156000 0 0 0 0 90 1 01/02/2001 368 003001 Rem Sameurn Prey Gny 2 1.44 12 17.28 156000 0 0 0 0 17.28 1 01/02/2001 369 002003 Touch Seng Prey Gny 1 3.05 4.5 13.73 156000 0 0 0 0 13.73 1 01/02/2001 370 002002 Bin Sarat Prey Gny 2 39.6 12 475.2 156000 0 0 0 0 475.2 1 01/02/2001 371 001002 Chhem Sameurn Prey Gny 1 9.6 4.5 43.2 156000 0 0 0 156000 43.2 1 06/02/2001 372 001003 Mok Pim Prey Gny 1 18.24 4.5 82.08 156000 0 0 78000 156000 82.08 1 01/02/2001
6 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 373 001009 Em Raksmey Prey Gny 2 20.75 85 1763.75 156000 0 0 0 0 1763.75 2 01/02/2001 374 004008 Hang Heam Prey Gny 3 11.16 85 948.6 156000 0 0 0 0 948.6 2 01/02/2001 375 003006 Tang Hangyun Prey Gny 2 8.96 12 107.52 156000 0 0 0 0 107.52 1 01/02/2001 376 003005 Kim Ly Prey Gny 3 12.32 85 1047.2 156000 0 0 0 0 1047.2 2 01/02/2001 377 002009 Chea Chhunleng Prey Gny 2 6.72 12 80.64 156000 0 0 0 0 80.64 1 01/02/2001 378 004004 Huon Thailong Prey Gny 2 6.24 12 74.88 156000 0 0 0 0 74.88 1 01/02/2001 379 003004 Van Ny Prey Gny 2 9 28.3 12 180+20 156000 78000 0 0 0 180 20 1 01/02/2001 380 002008 Chea Sambo Prey Gny 2 12 339.6 156000 0 0 0 0 339.6 1 01/02/2001 381 001008 Cheurng Bunry Prey Gny 2 21.06 12 252.72 156000 0 0 0 0 252.72 1 01/02/2001 382 001007 Chhun Veng Prey Gny 2 11.6 12 139.2 156000 78000 0 0 0 139.2 1 01/02/2001 383 004003 Cheurm Horn Prey Gny 3 9.3 85 790.5 156000 0 0 0 0 790.5 2 01/02/2001 384 1021 CHHOEUN Sovouthy Prey Gny 3 17.85 85 1517.25 156000 0 0 0 0 1517.25 2 16/2/2001 385 2011 ENG Se Prey Gny 3 17.4 85 1479 156000 0 0 0 0 1479 2 03/02/2001 386 1011 KHOUY Nary Prey Gny 2 5.2 12 62.4 156000 0 0 0 0 62.4 1 01/02/2001 387 4006 OUK Lay Ngoun Prey Gny 2 17.75 12 213 156000 0 0 0 0 213 1 01/02/2001 388 4005 LAY Ngim Prey Gny 2 6.75 12 81 156000 0 0 0 0 81 1 01/02/2001 389 4007 KOEUM Seun Prey Gny 2 13.25 12 159 156000 78000 0 0 0 159 1 01/02/2001 390 2012 LOEUM Bunthy Prey Gny 2 13.87 12 166.44 156000 0 0 0 0 166.44 1 01/02/2001 391 3007 POV Horn Prey Gny 2 7.14 12 85.68 156000 0 0 0 0 85.68 1 01/02/2001 392 2010 YOEUM Meat Prey Gny 2 9.5 12 144 156000 0 0 0 0 144 1 01/02/2001 Total 51 626.78 28.3 0 18262.94 0 0 6630000 312000 78000 78000 468000 18442.94 20 0 393 004022 Ke Suvann Prey Svay 2 12 12 144 156000 0 0 0 0 144 1 21/03/01 394 004024 Hum Phun Prey Svay 2 6 12 72 156000 0 0 0 0 72 1 21/03/01 395 004023 Keo Savat Prey Svay 2 9.89 12 118.68 156000 0 0 0 156000 118.68 1 21/03/01 396 003019 Khun Chin Prey Svay 156000 0 0 0 156000 1 21/03/01 397 SC.4.028 Saut Reing Prey Svay dk dk dk 40 40 1 16/03/01 398 SC.003024 Korb Ny Prey Svay 40 40 1 20/03/01 399 003021 Kim Sovann Prey Svay 1 14.7 4.5 66.15 156000 0 0 0 156000 66.15 1 21/03/01 400 001021 Phun Pheap Prey Svay 2 11.16 12 133.92 156000 0 0 0 156000 133.92 1 21/03/01 401 001022 Srey Phunn Prey Svay 1 27 4.5 121.5 156000 0 0 0 156000 121.5 1 21/03/01 402 002021 Kov Chomrernn Prey Svay 1 10.56 4.5 47.52 156000 0 0 0 156000 47.52 1 02/02/2001 403 002023 Ornn Chourn Prey Svay 1 10 4.5 45 156000 78000 0 0 156000 45 1 21/03/01 404 003020 Uch Soeum Prey Svay 1 6 4.5 27 156000 0 0 0 0 27 1 21/03/01 405 001020 Sarei Sockchea Prey Svay 2 12.92 12 155.04 156000 0 0 156000 0 155.04 1 02/02/2001 406 001023 Korb Korm Prey Svay 2 8.14 12 97.68 156000 78000 0 0 0 97.68 1 21/03/01 407 002022 Chin Ork Prey Svay 1 12.75 4.5 57.37 156000 0 0 0 156000 57.37 1 21/03/01 408 Vegn Cheurn Prey Svay 409 Phen Mab Prey Svay 410 Nub Nem Prey Svay 411 Som Chem Prey Svay 412 Sot Sum Prey Svay 413 Mi Heurn Prey Svay 414 Heng Sockhum Prey Svay 415 Siev Theurn Prey Svay 416 Gnoeuk Chem Prey Svay 417 Mey Sockhourn Prey Svay 418 Lunn Heing Prey Svay 419 Chum Phorl Prey Svay 420 Hin Sat Prey Svay 421 Ros Heing Prey Svay 422 Yoeum Som at Prey Svay 423 Keo Ra Prey Svay 424 Rong Chorn Prey Svay 425 Choeuk Chom renn Prey Svay 426 Bau Chhorn Prey Svay 427 Veing Kimhorng Prey Svay 428 Gnet Borra Prey Svay 429 Tum Sophal Prey Svay 430 Reng Phan Prey Svay 431 Gnan Peich Prey Svay 432 Vorn Yeurn Prey Svay 433 Yonn Heang Prey Svay 434 Heing Long Prey Svay 435 Em Mein Prey Svay
7 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 436 Chan Thour Prey Svay 437 Lai Vorn Prey Svay 438 Veurn Buntheurn Prey Svay 439 Roos Phorn Prey Svay 440 2074 SARAY Chem Prey Svay 2 10.5 12 126 156000 0 0 78000 0 126 1 19/03/2002 Total 48 151.62 0 0 1291.86 0 0 2184000 156000 0 234000 1248000 1291.86 0 0 441 004016 Sang Sophea Prey Touch 2 20.25 12 243 156000 0 0 0 156000 243 1 02/02/2001 442 004014 Morm Deab Prey Touch 1 21.35 4.5 96.07 156000 78000 0 0 156000 96.07 1 02/02/2001 443 003013 Cheb Thul Prey Touch 1 12.65 4.5 56.92 156000 0 0 0 156000 56.92 1 02/02/2001 444 001014 Sourn Phan Prey Touch 1 7.5 4.5 33.75 156000 0 78000 0 156000 33.75 1 02/02/2001 445 001013 Kim Ny Prey Touch 1 12 4.5 54 156000 78000 0 0 156000 54 1 02/02/2001 446 003012 Vorn Sa Van Prey Touch 1 23.2 4.5 104.4 156000 0 0 0 156000 104.4 1 02/02/2001 447 002013 Mork Sothea Prey Touch 1 21.84 4.5 98.28 156000 0 0 0 156000 98.28 1 02/02/2001 448 002014 Gnet Pheap Prey Touch 1 21.84 4.5 22.68 156000 0 78000 0 156000 22.68 1 02/02/2001 449 004017 Chhonn Vann Prey Touch 1 13.6 4.5 61.2 156000 78000 0 0 156000 61.2 1 02/02/2001 450 004015 Rorn Bau Prey Touch 1 7.77 4.5 34.96 156000 0 0 0 156000 34.96 1 02/02/2001 451 004018 Peing Gneit Prey Touch 1 10 4.5 45 156000 78000 0 0 156000 45 1 02/02/2001 452 002016 Heang Hein Prey Touch 1 9.6 4.5 43.2 156000 0 0 0 156000 43.2 1 02/02/2001 453 002027 Hourt Chey Prey Touch 40 156000 0 0 0 0 40 1 16/03/01 454 001002 Srey Sun Prey Touch 40 40 1 16/03/01 455 004003 Key Sang Prey Touch 40 40 1 16/03/01 456 004003 Mork Mab Prey Touch 1 9.5 4.5 42.75 156000 0 0 0 156000 42.75 1 02/02/2001 457 001016 Hey Sarornn Prey Touch 1 20.8 4.5 93.6 156000 78000 0 0 156000 93.6 1 02/02/2001 458 003015 Tov Kha Prey Touch 1 13.5 4.5 60.75 156000 78000 0 0 156000 60.75 1 02/02/2001 459 001015 Sau Seurn Prey Touch 1 11.75 4.5 52.87 156000 0 0 0 156000 52.87 1 02/02/2001 460 002015 Ri Rorn Prey Touch 2 16.32 12 195.84 156000 0 0 0 156000 195.84 1 02/02/2001 461 003014 Kai Heurn Prey Touch 1 10.54 4.5 47.43 156000 0 0 0 156000 47.43 1 02/02/2001 462 001017 Chin Kim ann Prey Touch 1 54 4.5 243 156000 0 0 0 156000 243 1 02/02/2001 463 Sourng Sovann Prey Touch 464 Lorng Nai Prey Touch 465 Hourk Yann Prey Touch 466 Nen Yann Prey Touch 467 Ourch Ren Prey Touch 468 Chov Dy Prey Touch 469 Lach Meit Prey Touch 470 Pho Kim Prey Touch 471 Chheurn Seit Prey Touch 472 Sem Pov Prey Touch 473 Lunn Soben Prey Touch 474 Thai Thin Prey Touch 475 Gna Gnourn Prey Touch 476 Chhory Ya Prey Touch 477 Long Phat Prey Touch 478 Soeum Sophat Prey Touch 479 Chheurm Reith Prey Touch 480 Mer Mull Prey Touch 481 Eurn Born Prey Touch 482 Thorn Thert Prey Touch 483 Yan Nov Prey Touch 484 Sieb Bunheing Prey Touch 485 Nov Pheurk Prey Touch 486 Cheang Sochan Prey Touch 487 Soeum Yorn Prey Touch 488 Sot Ny Prey Touch Total 48 318.01 0 0 1749.7 0 0 3120000 468000 156000 0 2964000 1749.7 0 0 489 1012 HORN Leng Ronob 1 18 4.5 81 156000 78000 0 0 156000 81 1 03/01/2001 490 1013 KOEUM Phearin Ronob 2 30 12 360 156000 0 0 78000 156000 360 1 03/02/2001 491 2014 SOK Chhunny Ronob 1 28.29 4.5 127.3 156000 0 0 0 156000 127.3 1 03/02/2001 492 2013 EM Pech Ronob 1 31.9 4.5 143.55 156000 0 0 0 0 143.55 1 03/02/2001 493 3008 CHAN Sophal Ronob 1 21 4.5 95.5 156000 0 0 78000 156000 95.5 1 03/02/2001 494 4009 TAING Meng Ronob 2 24.05 12 288.6 156000 0 0 0 156000 288.6 1 03/02/2001 495 4010 HORNG Serevatana Ronob 2 7.56 12 90.72 156000 0 0 0 156000 90.72 1 03/02/2001 496 1014 CHHUN Yen Ronob 2 9.92 12 119.04 156000 0 0 0 156000 119.04 1 03/02/2001 497 1015 CHOU Mao Ronob 2 37.4 12 448.8 156000 0 0 0 0 448.8 1 03/02/2001
8 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 498 1016 DET Sokha Ronob 2 23.1 12 277.2 156000 0 0 0 0 277.2 1 03/02/2001 499 2015 SAING Saret Ronob 2 24 12 288 156000 0 0 0 0 288 1 03/02/2001 500 2016 SENG Bonlong Ronob 2 14.3 12 171.6 156000 0 0 0 0 171.6 1 03/02/2001 501 2017 CHHOEUM Song Ronob 2 16.5 12 198 156000 0 0 0 0 198 1 03/02/2001 502 3009 CHEA Koeum Ronob 2 30.24 12 362.88 156000 78000 0 0 0 362.88 1 03/02/2001 503 3010 HORM Chomreun Ronob 2 17.2 12 206.4 156000 0 0 0 0 206.4 1 03/02/2001 504 3011 LAI Tao Ronob 2 3.2 12 38.4 156000 0 0 0 0 38.4 1 03/02/2001 505 4011 LOEUM Hong Ronob 2 15 12 180 156000 78000 0 0 0 180 1 03/02/2001 506 4012 ROEUM Rous Ronob 2 21.83 12 261.96 156000 0 0 0 0 261.96 1 03/02/2001 507 4013 HENG Kimsay Ronob 2 13.25 12 159 156000 78000 0 0 0 159 1 03/02/2001 508 2018 YEN Laisrin Ronob 2 27.65 12 331.8 156000 0 0 0 0 331.8 1 03/02/2001 509 1014 LOEUM Long Ronob 2 11.02 12 132.26 156000 0 0 0 0 132.26 1 03/02/2001 510 1019 Khat Yen Ronob 2 12.1 12 145.2 156000 78000 0 0 0 145.2 1 03/02/2001 511 1017 DUCH Sompaos Ronob 2 29.61 12 355.32 156000 0 0 0 0 355.32 1 03/02/2001 512 1018 LAT Lay Ronob 2 12.5 12 150 156000 0 0 0 0 150 1 03/02/2001 513 2020 LACH Bros Ronob 2 14 12 168 156000 0 0 0 0 168 1 03/02/2001 514 2019 CHHENG Heng Ronob 2 14 12 168 156000 0 0 78000 0 168 1 03/02/2001 515 2021 KHOEUM Chiv Ronob 2 12.5 12 150 156000 78000 0 0 0 150 1 03/02/2001 516 3012 YU La Ronob 2 5.2 12 62.4 156000 0 0 0 0 62.4 1 03/02/2001 517 3013 HEM Sotheary Ronob 2 10 12 120 156000 78000 78000 0 0 120 1 03/02/2001 518 4014 HUY Gnab Ronob 2 11.25 12 135 156000 0 0 0 0 135 1 03/02/2001 519 2022 SEAK Nai Ronob 2 12.42 12 149.04 156000 78000 0 0 0 149.04 1 03/02/2001 520 3015 SONG Lay Ronob 2 12 12 144 156000 78000 0 0 0 144 1 03/02/2001 521 3016 REM Sovan Ronob 4 4.86 59.46 0 0 0 0 0 59.46 1 03/02/2001 522 1020 CHHUN Houn Ronob 2 10 12 120 156000 0 0 0 0 120 1 03/02/2001 523 2023 MOUNG Pom Ronob 2 14 12 168 156000 0 0 0 0 168 1 03/02/2001 524 2024 SOEUM Bunleng Ronob 2 11.4 12 136.8 156000 0 0 0 0 136.8 1 03/02/2001 525 3017 OUK Leng Ronob 2 15.5 12 186 156000 78000 0 0 0 186 1 03/02/2001 526 2088 SOK Somreun Ronob 3 23.75 85 2018.75 156000 0 0 0 0 2018.75 2 DK 527 3060 OungSeak Ronob 4 20 0.75 15 15 1 DK 528 2068 SVAY Savet Ronob 4 42 0.75 31.5 31.5 1 2001 529 3059 HOUN Bonet Ronob 4 44 0.75 33.37 33.37 1 DK 530 2063 THOU Chab Ronob 4 25 0.75 18.75 18.75 1 DK 531 3055 CHEA KimAn Ronob 4 11.5 4.86 55.89 55.89 1 DK 532 2079 OUN Nob Ronob 4 17.1 140 2394 156000 0 0 0 0 2394 2 DK 533 286 SOM Kim Ronob 3 13 85 1275 156000 0 0 0 0 1275 2 DK 534 2085 Sompao Ronob 3 19.2 85 1632 156000 0 0 0 0 1632 2 DK 535 2083 VAN Mabb Ronob 3 16.42 85 1395.7 156000 0 0 0 0 1395.7 2 DK 536 2082 MOEUNG Saim Ronob 2 22.8 12 273.6 156000 0 0 0 0 273.6 1 DK 537 2081 EU Veasna Ronob 4 9.3 140 1302 156000 0 0 0 0 1302 2 DK 538 2080 LIM Seng Ronob 2 22.5 12 270 156000 0 0 0 0 270 1 DK 539 284 BOU Pov Ronob 3 19.2 85 1632 156000 0 0 0 0 1632 2 DK 540 2089 SOM San Ronob 3 30.4 85 2584 156000 0 0 0 0 2584 2 DK 541 287 PECH Neang Ronob 3 28 85 2380 156000 0 0 0 0 2380 2 DK 542 SC 2010 LAV Gach Chhang Ronob dk 20 20 1 DK 543 SC 2019 KOY Reun Ronob dk 40 40 1 DK 544 SC 2011 CHAING Sou Ronob dk DK 20 20 20 1 DK 545 SC 2012 CHENG pov Ronob dk DK 20 20 20 1 DK 546 SC 2009 KIM Keun Ronob dk DK 20 20 20 1 DK 547 2077 HENG Sotha Ronob 2 10.9 12 170.8 170.8 1 DK Total 59 996.96 0 0 24381.59 0 0 7332000 780000 78000 234000 1092000 24381.59 0 0 548 Gneng Eurm Rosey Krong 549 Teb Lorn Rosey Krong 550 En Chantha Rosey Krong 551 Sann Tourch Rosey Krong 552 Sorn Sareurn Rosey Krong 553 Sorn Ra Rosey Krong 554 Pregn Neang Rosey Krong 555 Chum Khi Rosey Krong 556 Som Phat Rosey Krong 557 Yoeung Tourch Rosey Krong 558 Oeung Sambath Rosey Krong 559 Dourng Mom Rosey Krong 560 Phern Sophon Rosey Krong
9 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 561 Nourn Hourn Rosey Krong 562 Toy Ti Rosey Krong 563 Toeum Sarath Rosey Krong 564 Thorn Hun Rosey Krong 565 001024 Phi Su vong Rosey Krong dk dk dk dk 156000 78000 0 0 156000 dk 1 21/03/01 566 002024 Phorng Phnn Rosey Krong 2 2.8 12 33.6 156000 0 0 0 0 33.6 1 21/03/01 Total 19 2.8 0 0 33.6 0 0 312000 78000 0 0 156000 33.6 0 0 567 1065 AOV Sokhany Snam Pras 4 0.75 15.37 15.37 1 DK 568 1056 HUN Thary Snam Pras 4 0.75 19 19 DK 569 1003 KHEN Thoaky Snam Pras 1 30/3/2001 570 2017 PROM Chandeng Snam Pras 40 40 1 DK 571 3045 LY Sochet Snam Pras 2 14.4 12 172.8 156000 0 0 0 0 172.8 1 23/3/2001 Total 5 14.4 0 0 247.17 0 0 156000 0 0 0 0 247.17 0 0 572 1047 SVAY Sokhanna Svay Art 2 15.5 12 186 156000 0 0 0 0 186 1 30/03/2001 573 SOUEM Ta Svay Art 2 DK DK 574 SC 001006 AOEUNG Tei Svay Art DK 1 30/03/2001 575 SC 001005 SEK Soam Svay Art DK DK 1 30/03/2001 576 SC 002004 KUL Phoul Svay Art DK DK 1 28/3/2001 577 SC 003007 KAING Kosal Svay Art dk 1 30/3/2001 578 SC 001004 GNOEUM Saveun Svay Art dk 1 30/3/2001 579 SC 004005 KOV Ponleu Svay Art dk 1 30/3/2001 580 SC 003013 KORNG SomBor Svay Art dk 1DK 581 IRC 003058 SENG Chanthou Svay Art 4 15.2 0.75 11.4 11.4 1 DK 582 IRC 001052 CHEA Kimhor Svay Art 4 18 0.75 13.5 13.5 1 DK 583 IRC 004050 PECH Narethy Svay Art 4 19.2 0.75 14.4 14.4 1 2001 584 IRC 002071 CHHET Savat Svay Art 4 9.6 0.75 7.2 7.2 1 2001 585 IRC 003061 LIM Sokha Svay Art 4 12.4 0.75 9.3 9.3 1 DK 586 IRC 001045 SENG Ngoun Svay Art 4 125 0.75 93.75 93.75 1 28/3/2001 587 IRC 002072 KOEUM Reun Svay Art 4 12.5 DK 9.37 9.37 1 2001 588 IRC 003065 TEP SoeungVech Svay Art 4 11.5 0.75 8.62 8.62 1 DK 589 IRC 001051 MEN Thorng Svay Art 4 27 0.75 20.25 20.25 1 05/05/2002 590 IRC 002073 SENG KimTeng Svay Art 4 15.5 0.75 11.62 11.62 1 05/03/2002 591 IRC 002074 MOM Chanthol Svay Art 4 17.5 4.86 85.05 85.05 1 08/05/2002 592 001034 Eung Tei Svay Art 2 2.34 12 28 156000 0 0 0 0 28 1 06/02/2001 593 002046 Ros Senara Svay Art 2 36 12 432 156000 0 0 0 0 432 1 06/02/2001 594 003040 Eur Savuon Svay Art 1 8.37 4.5 37.66 156000 156000 0 0 0 37.66 1 06/03/2001 595 003039 Seng Bora Svay Art 2 26.5 12 318 156000 0 0 0 0 318 1 06/02/2001 596 004033 Vach Phuong Svay Art 2 23.4 12 280.8 156000 0 0 0 0 280.8 1 06/02/2001 597 004034 Vach Phuong Svay Art 2 32.4 12 388.8 156000 78000 0 0 0 388.8 1 06/02/2001 598 004035 Seung Samei Svay Art 2 11.4 12 136.8 156000 0 0 0 0 136.8 1 06/02/2001 599 001035 He Kimchhun Svay Art 2 11.52 12 138.24 156000 156000 0 0 0 138.24 1 06/02/2001 600 002048 Kuoch Sokha Svay Art 2 28.8 12 345.6 156000 0 0 0 0 345.6 1 dk 601 004037 Morm Mao Svay Art 2 4.2 12 50.4 156000 0 0 0 0 50.4 1 602 002047 Mao Sorn Svay Art 2 16.5 12 198 156000 78000 0 0 0 198 1 06/02/2001 603 001039 Lok Sam Svay Art 2 28 12 336 156000 0 0 0 0 336 1 23/3/2001 604 003041 Pham Bunsith Svay Art 2 9 12 108 156000 0 0 0 0 108 1 06/02/2001 605 002049 Seng Hau Svay Art 2 13.2 12 158.4 156000 0 0 0 0 158.4 1 23/3/2001 606 003043 Roat Nara Svay Art 4 4.86 65.61 65.61 1 23/3/2001 607 003044 Ly Kimnorn Svay Art 2 14.25 12 171 156000 78000 0 0 0 171 1 23/3/2001 608 001038 Kauv Gnau Svay Art 2 20.5 12 246 156000 78000 0 78000 156000 246 1 23/3/2001 609 002051 Roam Neurn Svay Art 2 10 12 120 156000 0 0 0 0 120 1 23/3/2001 610 004040 Kim Huot Svay Art 2 8.68 12 104.16 156000 0 0 0 0 104.16 1 23/3/2001 611 004039 Say Buntheurn Svay Art 2 14.88 12 178.56 156000 0 0 0 0 178.56 1 23/3/2001 612 004036 Gnean Thida Svay Art 2 33.95 12 407.4 156000 78000 0 0 0 407.4 1 06/02/2001 613 001037 Nuon Sareurn Svay Art 2 9.62 12 115.44 156000 78000 0 0 156000 115.44 1 23/3/2001 614 Mao Thary Svay Art 2 22.26 12 267.12 156000 0 0 0 156000 267.12 1 23/3/2001 615 004038 In Chansokha Svay Art 2 26 12 312 156000 78000 0 0 156000 312 1 23/3/2001 616 001036 Nuon Sareurn Svay Art 2 10.2 12 122.4 156000 0 0 0 0 122.4 1 dk Total 45 720.87 0 0 5536.85 0 0 3900000 858000 0 78000 624000 5536.85 0 0 617 3054 SEUN Srouy Svay Daun Keo 2 13.95 12 167.4 156000 0 0 0 0 167.4 1 28/3/2001 618 1044 NGOAL Meng Svay Daun Keo 1 22.42 4.5 100.89 156000 0 0 0 156000 100.89 1 28/3/2001 619 1078 KONG SokHeun Svay Daun Keo 4 0.75 37.5 37.5 1 DK 620 1076 YEAN Yun Svay Daun Keo 4 0.75 12 12 1 DK 621 2058 Pao Synoun Svay Daun Keo 2 15 12 180 156000 78000 0 0 0 180 1 28/3/2001
10 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 15 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per Other Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting(Rie Number of Last Date No. IRC Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name House Structure Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) l) US$ Riel Payment of Payment 622 1043 NGOUN Lagn Svay Daun Keo 2 6.5 12 78 456000 0 0 0 156000 78 1 28/3/2001 623 1077 EV Meng Svay Daun Keo 4 0.75 20.1 20.1 1 DK 624 2060 SENG Bunmeng Svay Daun Keo 2 16.6 12 199.2 156000 0 0 0 0 199.2 1 28/3/2001 625 4048 YOUM York Svay Daun Keo 2 11.84 12 142.08 156000 0 0 0 156000 142.08 1 28/3/2001 626 2059 CHEA Sao Svay Daun Keo 2 15 12 180 156000 0 0 0 0 180 1 28/3/2001 Total 10 101.31 0 0 1117.17 0 0 1392000 78000 0 0 468000 1117.17 0 0 627 001001 Chan Vichit Thnout Choum 1 14.4 4.5 64.8 156000 0 0 0 0 64.8 1 01/02/2001 628 002001 Mao Mit Thnout Choum 1 34.8 4.5 156.6 156000 0 0 78000 156000 156.6 1 01/02/2001 Total 2 49.2 0 0 221.4 0 0 312000 0 0 78000 156000 221.4 0 0 629 004041 Meas Mom Trapeang Chorng 2 9.03 12 108.36 156000 0 0 0 0 108.36 1 24/3/2001 630 002054 Seng Chanthea Trapeang Chorng 2 19.25 12 231 156000 0 0 0 0 231 1 24/3/2001 631 001041 Suon Saroan Trapeang Chorng 2 23.04 12 276.48 156000 0 0 0 0 276.48 1 24/3/2001 632 001042 Yuok Yung Trapeang Chorng 1 9.52 4.5 42.84 156000 0 0 0 0 42.84 1 24/3/2001 633 004044 Kim Cheang Trapeang Chorng 2 15.81 12 189.72 156000 0 0 0 0 189.72 1 24/3/2001 634 003049 Soth Sovantha Trapeang Chorng 1 12.6 4.5 56.7 156000 0 0 0 0 56.7 1 23/3/2001 635 004043 Gnem Hong Trapeang Chorng 2 13.44 12 161.28 156000 0 0 0 156000 161.28 24/3/2001 636 003048 Ou Chanbupha Trapeang Chorng 2 30 12 360 156000 78000 0 0 0 360 1 23/3/2001 637 003047 Suon Sophal Trapeang Chorng 2 1 15.3 12 50 183.6 50 156000 0 0 0 0 183.6 50 1 23/3/2001 638 004042 Toem Touch Trapeang Chorng 2 4 6.75 1 12 4.86 81 4.86 156000 0 0 0 0 81 4.86 1 24/3/2001 639 002053 Suon Sophal Trapeang Chorng 2 18.4 12 220.8 156000 0 0 0 0 220.8 1 24/3/2001 640 002052 Iv Socheat Trapeang Chorng 1 25 4.5 112.5 156000 0 0 0 0 112.5 1 24/3/2001 641 001040 Vi Ponlork Trapeang Chorng 1 12.8 4.5 57.6 156000 78000 0 0 156000 57.6 1 24/3/2001 642 003046 Ngouv Ty Trapeang Chorng 1 50 50 50 1 23/3/2001 643 SC 004003 LOEUNM Ve Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 644 3071 EK Sochet Trapeang Chorng 4 20 0.75 15 15 1 DK 645 1059 ENG Chanthy Trapeang Chorng 4 18 0.75 13.5 13.5 1 DK 646 1058 VORNG Kimsan Trapeang Chorng 4 21 0.75 15.75 15.75 DK DK 647 1060 DEN Sy Det Trapeang Chorng 4 29.5 0.75 22.12 22.12 1 DK 648 3069 KEV Vech Trapeang Chorng 4 39.5 0.75 29.62 29.62 1 DK 649 1071 Pao Yut Trapeang Chorng 4 22 0.75 16.5 16.5 1 DK 650 3076 OUK Sophanna Trapeang Chorng 4 44 0.75 33 33 1 DK 651 1066 NORNG SomAul Trapeang Chorng 4 25.3 0.75 18.97 18.97 1 DK 652 3068 EK Yun Trapeang Chorng 4 46 0.75 3450 3450 1 DK 653 3070 MOM Phely Trapeang Chorng 4 30 0.75 22.5 22.5 1 DK 654 3072 THEAY Phorn Trapeang Chorng 4 20.5 0.75 15.37 15.37 1 DK 655 1061 OUM Sitha Trapeang Chorng 4 36 0.75 27 27 1 DK 656 1064 PEANG Horn Trapeang Chorng 4 25 0.75 18.75 18.75 1 2001 657 1063 SIM Ngoun Trapeang Chorng 4 12 0.75 9 91DK 658 4051 SIM Sum Trapeang Chorng 4 16.6 0.75 12.45 12.45 1 DK 659 1057 NUB Ly Trapeang Chorng 4 23 0.75 17.25 17.25 DK DK 660 SC 004002 GNOEUK Lim Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 661 SC 001062 KHUT Setha Trapeang Chorng 4 9 0.75 6.75 6.75 1 DK 662 2003 MEAS Vouthy Trapeang Chorng 1 28/3/2001 663 SC 003040 GNEB Vouthy Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 664 DK YOUK Yong Trapeang Chorng DK DK 665 SC 003006 HENG Hout Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 666 SC 003003 KOU Lin Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 667 SC 001001 SOUN Sareung Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 668 SC 002002 PHAN Kreung Trapeang Chorng 1 28/3/2001 669 SC 003002 OU Chan Bopha Trapeang Chorng 1 30/3/2001 670 2003 LACH Kea Trapeang Chorng 1 28/3/2001 Total 42 648.34 1 0 5875.41 54.86 0 2028000 156000 0 0 312000 5875.41 54.86 0 Grand Total 670 9838.56 70.54 28
11 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 16 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per IRC Area Acquired Unit Cost Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting No. of Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name Affected Assets (m2) $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels Payment of Payment House Other 12121 2 1 2 3 4 5 1231 1 001138 Koeum Buntha Achar Lak 2 35.7 12 428.4 156000 428.4 156000 1 2 001139 En Borom Achar Lak 2 GR 21.6 12 259.2 2000 156000 2259.2 78000 78000 2 3 001140 Vat Nam Achar Lak 3 20.25 85 1721.25 156000 78000 1721.26 117000 117000 2 4 001141 Soam Dul Achar Lak 3 20.25 85 1721.25 156000 1721.26 78000 78000 2 5 001142 Aet Lang Achar Lak 2 PW 30.02 12 75 360.24 75 156000 435.24 156000 1 6 001143 Tech Seang Achar Lak 3 18.24 85 155.4 156000 78000 1550.4 78000 78000 2 Total 6 146.06 4645.74 2075 936000 156000 8115.76 663000 351000 7 001106 San Chengleang Bralay 2 48.4 12 580.8 156000 580.8 156000 1 8 004008 Thurn Parn Bralay 1 9.6 4.5 43.2 156000 78000 156000 43.2 390000 1 9 004007 Thearn Bearn Bralay 1 22.5 4.5 101.25 156000 156000 101.25 312000 1 10 004005 Yon Yam Bralay 1 17.64 4.5 79.38 156000 156000 79.38 312000 1 11 001008 Arn Pearn Bralay 1 18.76 4.5 84.42 156000 78000 156000 187.78 390000 1 12 001006 Chhearng Ty Bralay 1 41.73 4.5 187.78 156000 78000 156000 187.78 390000 1 13 003004 Phorn Pearn Bralay 1 39.22 4.5 176.49 156000 156000 176.49 312000 1 14 002005 Dearb Chok Bralay 1 12.5 4.5 56.25 156000 78000 156000 56.25 390000 1 15 001007 Peing Keark Bralay 1 30.03 4.5 135.13 156000 78000 156000 135.13 390000 1 16 002004 Seng Bunthang Bralay 1 2 16.92 10.34 4.5 12 76.14 124.08 156000 200.22 156000 1 17 003005 Bou Mao Bralay 1 28.9 4.5 130.05 156000 156000 130.05 312000 1 18 004006 Hun Ly Bralay 1 7.36 4.5 33.12 156000 78000 78000 156000 33.12 468000 1 19 001083 Lim Peng Bralay 2 13 12 156 156000 78000 156 234000 1 20 003086 Choub Lorn Bralay 1 34.3 4.5 154.35 156000 78000 156000 154.35 390000 1 Total 14 340.86 10.34 1994.36 124.08 2184000 234000 468000 1716000 2221.8 4602000 21 004051 Seath Sok Chamnar Kroam 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 156000 78000 156000 60.48 390000 1 22 004050 Loeub Eav Chamnar Kroam 1 16.72 4.5 75.24 156000 78000 156000 75.24 390000 1 23 004048 Torn Nan Chamnar Kroam 1 12.24 4.5 55.08 156000 78000 78000 156000 55.08 468000 1 24 004047 Son Ra Chamnar Kroam 1 15.48 4.5 69.66 156000 78000 78000 156000 69.66 468000 1 25 004046 Pauch Bail Chamnar Kroam 1 16.8 4.5 75.6 156000 78000 156000 75.6 390000 1 26 001108 Churb Nhoung Chamnar Kroam dk dk dk 156000 DK 156000 1 27 001107 Prastechkun Sea Sun Chamnar Kroam 3 dk dk 40 156000 DK 156000 1 28 001003 Tech Sour Chamnar Kroam 1 40 4.5 180 156000 78000 156000 180 390000 1 29 004002 Kourch Tearn Chamnar Kroam 1 24 4.5 108 156000 108 234000 1 30 002002 Sun Tharn Chamnar Kroam 1 29.3 4.5 131.85 156000 78000 78000 156000 131.85 468000 1 31 003002 Larnh Da Chamnar Kroam 1 24.97 4.5 112.36 156000 78000 156000 112.36 390000 1 32 001171 Mao Yeng Chamnar Kroam 2 19.74 12 236.88 156000 2236.88 78000 78000 2 33 001172 Houn Seng Chamnar Kroam 3 PW 28.5 dk 85 75 24225 75 156000 2497.5 78000 78000 2 34 001173 Kang Hengkruy Chamnar Kroam 2 22.36 12 268.32 156000 268.32 156000 1 35 001174 Yus Hul Chamnar Kroam 1 69 4.5 310.5 156000 156000 310.5 312000 1 36 001175 Heng Savy Chamnar Kroam 2 GS 17.5 12 210 2000 156000 2210 78000 78000 2 37 001176 Keov Polin Chamnar Kroam 2 32.4 12 288.8 156000 78000 388.8 234000 1 38 001177 Kong Soy Chamnar Kroam 2 GR 49.4 12 2000 592.8 2000 156000 156000 2592.8 156000 156000 2 Total 18 431.85 27040.57 4075 2808000 390000 546000 1560000 11373.07 4992000 390000 39 004049 Hay Voon no data 1 15.3 4.5 68.85 156000 78000 156000 68.85 390000 1 Total 1 15.3 68.85 156000 78000 156000 68.85 390000 40 001109 Port Sarim Kompong Chentbong 2 30.1 12 361.2 156000 78000 361.2 231000 1 41 004088 Sik Min Kompong Chentbong 2 57.12 12 685.44 156000 685.44 156000 1 42 001110 Chan Posan Kompong Chentbong 2 89.12 12 1079.52 156000 1079.52 156000 1 43 001111 Chan Tu Kompong Chentbong 2 39 12 468 156000 468 156000 1 44 001112 Thorn Chantha Kompong Chentbong 2 22.72 12 272.64 156000 272.64 156000 1 45 004085 Chea Hout Kompong Chentbong F 11.36 4.86/m 55.2 156000 55.2 156000 1 46 003085 Arng Bharnphea Kompong Chentbong 2 9.5 12 114 156000 114 156000 1 47 003084 Te Comaret Kompong Chentbong 2 12 12 144 156000 78000 144 234000 1 48 040093 Yi Banpeat Kompong Chentbong 2 23.49 12 281.88 156000 281.88 156000 1 49 002093 Sourng Kha Im Kompong Chentbong 2 12.69 12 152.28 156000 152.28 156000 1 50 004089 Kourch Seng Kompong Chentbong 2 16.2 12 194.4 156000 194.4 156000 1 51 004086 Ly Sikea Kompong Chentbong 2 15 12 216 156000 216 156000 1 52 001082 Sary Meng Kompong Chentbong 2 25.9 12 310.8 156000 310.8 156000 1 53 001081 Tith Hongliv Kompong Chentbong 2 10.25 12 123 156000 78000 123 234000 1 54 001065 Von Bunchorn Kompong Chentbong 2 24.44 12 293.28 156000 293.28 156000 1 55 001113 Heng Chea Kompong Chentbong 2 8.4 12 100.8 156000 100.8 156000 1 56 002094 Pouk Saron Kompong Chentbong 2 17.68 12 212.16 156000 212.16 156000 1 57 001109 Pot Sarim Kompong Chentbong 2 30.1 12 361.2 156000 78000 361.2 234000 1 58 001163 Chary Engly Kompong Chentbong 3 34.44 85 2927.4 156000 2927.4 78000 78000 2 59 001154 Rus Mengchu Kompong Chentbong 4 34.2 140 4788 156000 4788 78000 46800 31200 2 20/11/02
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 16 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per IRC Area Acquired Unit Cost Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting No. of Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name Affected Assets (m2) $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels Payment of Payment 60 001155 Yim Sakhearn Kompong Chentbong 3 15.98 85 1358.3 156000 1358.3 78000 78000 2 61 001156 Som Bein Kompong Chentbong 3 32.8 85 2788 156000 2788 78000 78000 2 62 001157 Ngou Samate Kompong Chentbong 2 31.5 12 378 156000 78000 378 234000 1 63 001158 Lim Suy Kompong Chentbong 2 PW 19.32 12 75 231.84 75 156000 306.84 156000 1 64 001159 Yourn Meng Kompong Chentbong 4 34 140 4760 156000 4760 78000 46800 31200 3 20/11/02 65 001160 Dom Searn Kompong Chentbong 2 12 12 383.76 156000 383.76 156000 1 66 001161 Kong Meng Kompong Chentbong 4 32 140 4480 156000 4480 78000 46800 31200 3 20/11/02 67 001162 Chary Kimlar Kompong Chentbong 4 140 140 4257.4 156000 4257.4 78000 46800 31200 3 20/11/02 68 001144 Ouk Chantha Kompong Chentbong 2 36.9 12 442.8 156000 78000 442.8 234000 1 69 001145 Soeum Po Kompong Chentbong 2 33.97 12 407.64 156000 407.64 156000 1 70 001146 Kiang Ounglay Kompong Chentbong 3 16.87 85 1433.95 156000 78000 1433.96 117000 117000 2 71 001147 Lorng Kimsy Kompong Chentbong 3 34.83 85 2960.55 156000 2960.56 78000 78000 2 72 001148 Seang Leng Kompong Chentbong 3 14.7 85 1249.5 156000 78000 1249.5 117000 117000 2 73 001149 Iang saybo Kompong Chentbong 2 22.4 12 268.8 156000 268.8 156000 1 74 001150 Heng Bora Kompong Chentbong 2 PW 19 12 75 228 75 156000 303 156000 1 75 001151 Say Kimlong Kompong Chentbong 4 38.54 140 5395.6 156000 5395.6 78000 46800 31200 3 20.11.02 76 001152 Ngoun Va Kompong Chentbong 4 17.55 140 2457 156000 2457 78000 78000 2 77 001153 Yin Lykeng Kompong Chentbong 2 18.06 12 216.72 156000 78000 216.72 234000 1 Total 38 1094.13 46839.06 150 5928000 312000 312000 78000 46989.08 5613000 858000 156000 78 004013 Earb Chorng Kompong Chenchueng 2 8.5 12 102 156000 102 156000 1 79 001013 Ly Vuth Kompong Chenchueng 2 8.4 12 100.8 156000 100.8 156000 1 80 002014 Kearn Sihout Kompong Chenchueng 2 8.58 12 102.96 156000 102.96 156000 1 81 001020 Sao Sriv Kompong Chenchueng 2 12 12 144 156000 144 156000 1 82 001011 Prum Sophat Kompong Chenchueng 2 6 12 72 156000 72 156000 1 83 003009 Keng Chan Roth Kompong Chenchueng 2 16.8 12 201.6 156000 201.6 156000 1 84 002009 Heng Changpary Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.68 12 116.16 156000 116.16 156000 1 85 004011 Kang Tech Kompong Chenchueng 2 7 12 84 156000 84 156000 1 86 001009 Hearng Kimkhurn Kompong Chenchueng 2 3.5 12 42 156000 42 156000 1 87 003012 Lay Hearng Kompong Chenchueng 2 22.6 12 271.2 156000 271.2 156000 1 88 004009 Kang grech Kompong Chenchueng 2 2.49 12 29.88 156000 78000 29.88 234000 1 89 002008 Hurb Vanni Kompong Chenchueng 2 4.1 12 49.2 156000 49.2 156000 1 90 003011 Chea Kimsurt Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.3 12 111.6 156000 111.6 156000 1 91 004018 Ang Vannai Kompong Chenchueng 2 25 12 300 156000 300 156000 1 92 003014 Vorng Long Kompong Chenchueng 2 12.96 12 155.52 156000 155.52 156000 1 93 004017 Chur Vearn Kompong Chenchueng 2 11 12 132 156000 132 156000 1 94 002010 Heng Tech Kompong Chenchueng 2 15.36 12 184.32 156000 184.32 156000 1 95 002013 Keng Heng Kompong Chenchueng 2 7.8 12 93.6 156000 93.6 156000 1 96 003015 Lou Vannar Kompong Chenchueng 2 25.8 12 309.6 156000 309.6 156000 1 97 001010 Hourn Cheasim Kompong Chenchueng 2 3.98 12 47.76 156000 78000 47.769 234000 1 98 001015 Chea Kimhong Kompong Chenchueng 2 18.76 12 225.12 156000 225.12 156000 1 99 003008 Yearn Yim Kompong Chenchueng 1 18.5 4.5 83.25 156000 78000 78000 156000 83.25 468000 1 100 001012 Khun Seng Kompong Chenchueng 2 28 12 336 156000 336 156000 1 101 001014 Nov Chandy Kompong Chenchueng 2 13.2 12 158.4 156000 78000 158.4 234000 1 102 004019 Larng Par Kompong Chenchueng 2 14.4 12 172.8 156000 172.8 156000 1 103 004015 Hong Santhai Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.9 12 118.8 156000 118.8 156000 1 104 004010 Hurt Kim Leng Kompong Chenchueng 2 21.9 12 262.8 156000 262.8 156000 1 105 001018 Khhun Hearm Kompong Chenchueng 2 25 12 300 156000 300 156000 1 106 003013 Hiv Hum Kompong Chenchueng 2 36.52 12 438.24 156000 438.24 156000 1 107 002015 Tort Norng Kompong Chenchueng 2 23.85 12 286.2 156000 78000 286.2 234000 1 108 004020 Suy Hurai Kompong Chenchueng 2 20 12 240 156000 240 156000 1 109 004016 Sok Sorn Kompong Chenchueng 2 4.29 12 51.48 156000 240 156000 1 110 002012 Kan Bunna Kompong Chenchueng 2 16.75 12 201 156000 201 156000 1 111 001019 Heng Bunthon Kompong Chenchueng 2 30 12 360 156000 360 156000 1 112 002007 Pay Voneart Kompong Chenchueng 1 4 4.5 18 156000 18 156000 1 113 001017 Seng Lim Kompong Chenchueng 2 12 12 144 156000 144 156000 1 114 003010 Yearn Kon Kompong Chenchueng 2 15.9 12 190.8 156000 190.8 156000 1 115 002011 Chan Chaikhy Kompong Chenchueng 2 19.6 12 235.2 156000 235.2 156000 1 116 002006 Thang Hury Kompong Chenchueng 2 6.72 12 80.64 156000 78000 80.64 234000 1 117 003007 Tarb Somnang Kompong Chenchueng 1 2 30 4.5 135 156000 156000 387 312000 1 118 004014 Hun Prum Kompong Chenchueng 2 22.75 12 273 156000 273 156000 1 119 004021 Chor Lim Kompong Chenchueng 2 10 12 120 156000 120 156000 1 120 004112 Cheark Menghour Kompong Chenchueng 2 9 12 108 156000 78000 108 234000 1 121 003017 Kim Num Kompong Chenchueng 2 18.5 12 222.2 156000 222.2 156000 1 122 001016 Kearm Chomrern Kompong Chenchueng 2 96.9 12 1162.8 156000 1162.8 156000 1
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 16 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per IRC Area Acquired Unit Cost Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting No. of Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name Affected Assets (m2) $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels Payment of Payment 123 003006 Leng Heng Kompong Chenchueng 2 4.9 12 58.8 156000 58.8 156000 1 124 002016 Koav Somnarng Kompong Chenchueng 2 24.4 12 292.8 156000 292.8 156000 1 Total 47 776.59 0 8925.53 0 7332000 390000 78000 156000 312000 9366.059 8268000 0 0 125 003021 Cheng Heak Kompongkrabao 2 39.06 12 468.72 156000 156000 468.72 312000 1 126 003020 Hean Chu Kompongkrabao 2 15.18 12 182.16 156000 78000 78000 78000 182.16 312000 1 127 002024 Chan Koklim Kompongkrabao 2 41.18 12 494.16 156000 78000 494.16 234000 1 128 003018 Ngent Chouy Kompongkrabao F OW 40.72 4.34 4.86 12 197.89 52.08 156000 249.47 156000 1 129 001024 Kheam Sina Kompongkrabao 2 F 18.5 4.74 12 4.86 222 23.03 156000 78000 245.03 234000 1 130 002022 Lim Kimleang Kompongkrabao 2 51.15 12 613.8 156000 78000 613.8 234000 1 131 003022 Teav Buntean Kompongkrabao 2 39 12 468 156000 468 156000 1 132 003019 Mao Sara Kompongkrabao 2 46.75 12 561 156000 561 156000 1 133 002023 Chu Kaseng Kompongkrabao 2 25.5 12 306 156000 78000 306 234000 1 134 001117 Lim Seang Kompongkrabao 2 35.32 12 422.76 156000 78000 422.76 234000 1 135 001118 Peng Bora Kompongkrabao 2 39.92 12 287.04 156000 287.04 156000 1 136 001119 Ngourn Leanghak Kompongkrabao 3 34.76 85 2954.6 156000 2954.6 78000 78000 2 137 001120 Chin Nara Kompongkrabao 3 47.88 85 4069.8 156000 4069.8 78000 46800 31200 3 17/11/02 138 001130 Koav Chan Thy Kompongkrabao 4 18.9 140 2646 156000 2646 78000 78000 2 139 001121 Nhem Borith Kompongkrabao 3 17.1 85 1453.5 156000 1453.5 78000 78000 2 140 001122 Thoung Syna Kompongkrabao 2 37.74 12 452.88 156000 78000 527.88 234000 1 141 001123 Larg Brem Kompongkrabao 4 21.15 140 2961 156000 2961 78000 78000 2 142 001124 Hearng Say Kompongkrabao 4 31.35 140 4389 156000 4389 78000 46800 31200 3 17/11/02 143 001125 Li Yun Kompongkrabao 1 24.75 4.5 111.37 156000 78000 111.37 234000 1 144 001126 Soum Sadin Kompongkrabao 4 18.9 140 2646 156000 2646 78000 78000 2 145 001127 Hourn Lau Kompongkrabao 2 35.5 12 426 156000 426 156000 1 146 001128 Tung Keng Kompongkrabao 3 18.9 85 1606.5 156000 1606.5 78000 78000 2 147 001129 Tuch Yeng Kompongkrabao 3 28.86 85 2453.1 156000 2453.1 78000 78000 2 Total 23 728.07 9.08 30393.28 75.11 3588000 390000 78000 312000 156000 30542.89 3744000 639600 62400 148 001131 Kit Poren Prey Tahou 2 35.88 12 430.56 156000 78000 430.56 234000 1 149 001132 Hean Mom Prey Tahou 2 20.66 12 247.92 156000 247.92 156000 1 150 001131 Lau Par Prey Tahou 3 35.32 85 3002.62 156000 3002.62 78000 46800 31200 3 17/11/2002 151 001134 Yeam Saly Prey Tahou 3 17.32 85 1472.2 156000 1472.2 78000 78000 2 152 001135 Hourn Kheng Prey Tahou 3 17.32 85 1472.2 156000 1472.2 78000 78000 2 153 001136 Huk Polen Prey Tahou 1 62.72 4.5 282.24 156000 156000 282.24 312000 1 154 001137 Sok Chantha Prey Tahou 4 18.24 140 2553.6 156000 2553.6 78000 78000 2 155 101114 Long Nhim Prey Tahou 2 53.34 12 640.08 156000 640.08 156000 1 156 101115 Heak Menghak Prey Tahou 2 14.8 12 177.6 156000 177.6 156000 1 Total 9 275.60 0 10279.02 0 1404000 78000 0 0 156000 10279.02 1326000 280800 31200 157 004003 Sao Say Somprouch 1 20 4.5 90 156000 78000 90 234000 1 158 001004 Khard Dearn Somprouch 1 2 30.6 12.6 4.5 12 137.7 151.2 156000 288.9 156000 1 159 001005 Tun Sokha Somprouch 2 33.3 12 399.6 156000 78000 399.6 234000 1 160 002003 Khan So Somprouch 1 32.76 45 147.42 156000 156000 147.42 312000 1 161 001164 Yim Sarum Somprouch 2 GR 34.8 12 2000 417.6 2000 156000 2417.6 156000 1 162 001165 Kit Vat Somprouch 2 PW 90 12 75 1080 75 156000 156000 1155 156000 156000 2 163 001166 Ngouch Son Somprouch 1 53.4 4.5 240.3 156000 78000 156000 240.3 390000 1 164 001167 Pok Saley Somprouch 2 GR 28 12 2000 336 2000 156000 2336 78000 78000 2 165 001168 Kim Se Somprouch 2 15.75 12 189 156000 78000 189 234000 1 166 001169 Lau Kim Hy Somprouch 2 PW 36.45 12 75 437.4 75 156000 512.4 156000 1 167 001170 You Kimleng Somprouch 3 15.75 85 1338.75 156000 1338.76 78000 78000 2 168 003003 Ku Kun Somprouch 1 27.95 4.5 125.77 156000 78000 156000 0 169 004004 Lon Heang Somprouch 1 14.3 4.5 64.35 156000 78000 64.35 234000 1 170 004045 Yat Khin Somprouch 1 10.85 4.5 48.82 156000 48.82 468000 1 171 004044 Jhoeum Torn Somprouch 1 15.2 4.5 68.4 156000 78000 156000 68.4 390000 1 172 004043 Som Ri Somprouch 2 25.62 12 307.44 156000 78000 78000 156000 307.44 468000 1 173 004042 Ang Chenda Somprouch 2 36.12 12 433.44 156000 433.48 156000 1 Total 17 520.85 12.6 5861.99 4301.2 2652000 156000 78000 468000 936000 10037.47 3900000 312000 0 174 001105 Phon Sino Sun Kor 2 21.84 12 262.08 156000 156000 262.08 312000 1 175 001001 Noum Lungheng Sun Kor 2 OW 47.5 12 50 570 50 156000 620 156000 1 176 001002 kan Tha Sun Kor 2 25.62 12 307.44 156000 156000 307.44 312000 1 177 002001 Say Khun Pen Sun Kor 2 OW 44.64 12 50 535.68 50 156000 585.68 156000 1 178 003001 Jhoeum Thout Sun Kor OW 50 50 50 1 179 004001 Tes Proeum Sun Kor OW 50 50 50 1 180 004023 Dy Mearng Sun Kor 2 19.06 12 228.72 156000 228.72 312000 1 181 004022 Huth Hout Sun Kor OW 50 1 50 1 182 004039 Porn Korn Sun Kor 1 18.8 4.5 84.6 156000 78000 156000 84.6 390000 1
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 16 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL APs (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per IRC Area Acquired Unit Cost Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting No. of Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Commune's Name Affected Assets (m2) $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels Payment of Payment 183 004040 Hou Chea Sun Kor 2 17.22 12 206.64 156000 78000 156000 206.64 390000 1 184 004041 Sim Seng Sun Kor 1 16.12 4.5 72.45 156000 78000 156000 72.54 390000 1 185 004030 Chea Somhol Sun Kor 2 7.02 12 84.24 156000 84.24 156000 1 186 002089 Leart Samheng Sun Kor OW 50 156000 50 1 187 004031 Vok Heng Ny Sun Kor OW 50 50 1 188 004032 Horng Luy Sun Kor 1 27.3 4.5 122.85 156000 78000 78000 156000 122.85 468000 1 189 004033 Searn Din Sun Kor OW 50 50 1 190 004034 Chor Hokleang Sun Kor OW 50 50 1 191 004035 Tak Hery Sun Kor OW 50 50 1 192 004036 Chreb Lean Sun Kor OW 50 50 1 193 004037 Chhun Bunlung Sun Kor 2 OW 17.64 12 211.68 50 156000 261.68 156000 1 194 004038 Saom Team Sun Kor 2 28 12 336 156000 78000 78000 156000 336 468000 1 195 004029 Seun Don Sun Kor 1 30 4.5 135 156000 78000 78000 156000 135 468000 1 196 004028 Chor Harn Sun Kor 1 20.09 4.5 90.4 156000 78000 90.4 234000 1 197 004027 Put Sareun Sun Kor 2 43.46 12 521.52 156000 1 156000 521.52 312000 1 198 004026 Saing Art Sun Kor 1 16.81 4.5 75.64 156000 1 156000 75.64 312000 1 199 004024 Eang Kor Sun Kor 1 14.08 4.5 63.36 156000 78000 78000 156000 63.36 468000 1 200 004025 Tan Kreup Sun Kor 1 33.41 4.5 150.34 156000 78000 156000 150.34 390000 1 Total 27 448.61 0 4508.64 150 2964001 312000 0 702002 1872000 4658.73 5538000 312000 0 201 002017 Soeum Bonhor Trapang Russei 2 12 12 144 156000 144 156000 1 202 002018 Pein Thol Trapang Russei OW 50 50 1 203 002019 Siv Sok Trapang Russei 2 8.06 12 96.72 156000 96.72 156000 1 204 002020 Ther Somoul Trapang Russei 2 2.15 12 25.8 156000 25.8 156000 1 205 002021 Yon Yian Trapang Russei 2 2 12 24 156000 78000 24 234000 1 Total 5 24.21 0 340.52 0 624000 0 0 78000 0 340.52 702000 0 0 Grand-Total 205 4,802.13 32.02 140,897.56 10,950.39 30,576,001 2,418,000 546,000 2,886,002 6,864,000 133,993.25 39,738,000 3,143,400 249,600
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected Assets Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment House Other 123123 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 51231 231 1 001052 YE OunNeang Ang Cheum 3 49.64 85 4219.4 156000 156000 2109.7 1265.82 843.88 156000 93000 62400 3 DK 2 001051 AOEUM Chea Ang Cheum 2 56.12 12 680.4 156000 156000 680.4 312000 1 DK 3 001050 AUN Aeun Ang Cheum 2 37.44 12 449.28 156000 156000 449.28 312000 1 DK 4 001049 MA Ti Ang Cheum 2 58.5 12 702 156000 156000 702 312000 1 DK 5 001048 VA Neang Ang Cheum 3 32 85 2720 156000 156000 1360 816 544 156000 93600 62400 3 DK 6 001047 SUN Mang Ang Cheum 2 45 12 540 156000 156000 540 3121000 1 DK 7 001046 REAM Oun Ang Cheum 2 59.44 12 713.28 156000 156000 713.28 312000 1 DK 8 001055 SREANG Cheun Ang Cheum 2 48.2 12 579.6 156000 156000 579.6 312000 1 DK 9 004034 CHHORN KimHung Ang Cheum 2 31.08 12 372.96 156000 156000 372.76 312000 1 DK 10 004035 PHORN Lang Ang Cheum OW 0 50 50 50 1DK 11 004033 LEANG Sreang Ang Cheum 1 19.98 4.5 89.91 156000 156000 89.91 312000 1 DK 12 001054 SUNG Tha Ang Cheum 3 25.2 85 2142 156000 156000 1071 642.6 156000 93600 2 Feb-01 13 001053 ART SaL Ang Cheum 2 60.59 12 727.08 156000 156000 727.08 312000 1 DK 14 001030 GNUNN Houng Ang Cheum 3 15.97 85 1357.45 156000 678.72 78000 1 DK Total 14 539.16 0 0 15343.36 0 0 2028000 0 0 0 1872000 10123.73 2724.42 1387.88 6163000 280200 124800 15 001025 Chen Vanthar Chub 1 12.83 12 153.96 156000 156.96 156000 1 15/01/01 16 Sreng Bunnarith Chub dk OW 50 50 50 1 15/01/01 17 004001 Earng Sinart Chub dk F 8.2 4.86 39.85 39.85 1 15/01/01 18 002007 Sok Rarny Chub dk F F 16.3 5.54 4.86 0.75 79.21 4.15 83.36 1 15/01/01 19 004008 Thy Somphan Chub dk PW F 20.5 75 4.86 75 99.63 174.63 1 15/01/01 20 003004 Pov Sovan Chub 1 6.875 4.5 30.93 156000 78000 30.93 234000 1 15/01/01 21 005003 Lim Silun Chub dk F 29 4.86 140.94 140.94 1 15/01/01 22 005001 Lek Pov Chub 2 36.19 12 434.28 156000 434.28 156000 1 15/01/01 23 004006 Koa Searnghour Chub dk 15.75 12 189 156000 156000 189 312000 1 15/01/01 24 004002 Pov Chanthar Chub dk OW 0 50 50 50 1 15/01/01 25 001006 Bun thong Chub 2 41.05 dk 492.6 156000 246.3 78000 1 15/01/01 26 001009 Chang Bunnar Chub 2 31.35 12 376.2 156000 376.2 156000 1 15/01/01 27 004007 Poung Piseth Chub dk 28.81 12 345.72 156000 156000 345.72 312000 1 15/01/01 28 005005 Khun Norm Chub 9 37.82 12 453.84 156000 453.84 156000 1 15/01/01 29 003010 Soi Chantha Chub 2 15.3 12 183.6 156000 183.6 156000 1 15/01/01 30 003008 Tuy Vannar Chub 2 29.24 12 350.88 156000 156000 Dk dk 31 001004 Hel Sorm Ol Chub 2 12.4 12 148.8 156000 148.8 156000 1 15/01/01 32 001005 Chin Srun Chub 2 16.73 12 200.76 156000 200.76 156000 1 15/01/01 33 002003 Larch Hearn Chub 2 13.16 12 157.92 156000 157.92 156000 1 15/01/01 34 002002 Sok Chanthy Chub 2 13.02 12 156.24 156000 156.24 156000 1 15/01/01 35 002005 Sok Putheavy Chub 2 11.2 12 134.4 156000 134.4 156000 1 15/01/01 36 001007 Sat Chan thol Chub 2 21.08 12 252.96 156000 259.96 156000 1 15/01/01 37 003007 Hearng Pirun Chub 2 12.838 12 154.05 156000 156000 154.05 312000 1 15/01/01 38 004004 Searng Try Chub 2 26.4 12 316.8 156000 316.8 156000 1 15/01/01 39 001010 Dom Somun Chub 2 30 23.25 23.25 1 15/01/01 40 002006 Pang Chanthim Chub 2 8.25 12 99 156000 99 156000 1 15/01/01 41 003002 Seak Vouchorng Chub 2 12.9 12 154.8 156000 154.8 156000 1 15/01/01 42 003002 Lary Hun Chub 4 8.4 0.75 6.3 6.3 156000 1 15/01/01 43 005004 Vinh Meang Chub 2 11.4 12 136.8 156000 136.8 156000 1 15/01/01 44 005002 Dourng Yeang Chub OW 0 50 50 78000 50 78000 1 15/01/01 45 003003 Kong Earv Chub 2 4.125 12 49.5 156000 49.5 156000 1 15/01/01 46 001008 Seang Sairong Chub 2 2 8.28 20.14 12 12 99.36 241.68 156000 341.04 312000 1 15/01/01 47 002001 Li Mat Chub 2 14.4 12 172.8 156000 Dk 15/01/01 48 003006 Yourng Heng Chub 2 50.84 12 610.08 156000 Dk 15/01/01 49 005006 Koa Sophal Chub F 42 4.86 204.12 Dk 15/01/01 50 003011 Sing Kimhean Chub 2 7.04 12 84.48 156000 Dk 15/01/01 51 003009 Nov Vudi Chub 2 23.04 12 276.48 156000 Dk 15/01/01 52 001043 LAY Phang Chub 0 0.00 156000 156000 1 DK 53 003005 YAN Them Chub F 3.66 0.75 2.75 2.74 1 28/02/2002 54 002010 TY Bot Chub 3 23.60 85 1203.60 156000 645 156000 1 15/01/2001 55 002004 HEM Teun Chub F F 10.60 2.00 0.75 4.86 7.95 9.27 17.67 1 28/02/2002 56 002020 Meas Ny Chub 0 0 156000 337.5 337.5 78000 78000 2 dk 57 002021 Ngoun Try Chub 0 0 156000 300 300 18000 78000 2 dk 58 002023 Chhiv Hy Chub 0 0 156000 547.2 156000 1 15.01.01 59 002022 Chin Seir Chub 0 0 156000 414 414 78000 78000 2 dk 60 002024 Ty Koy Chub 0 0 156000 312 156000 1 15.01.01 61 002025 Bouy Mongheng Chub 0 0 156000 210 156000 1 15.01.01 62 002026 Noun Sinoun Chub 0 0 156000 384 156000 1 15.01.01 63 002027 Sun Kimhim Chub 0 0 156000 324 324 78000 78000 2 dk 64 002028 Lorn Hy Chub 0 0 156000 225 156000 1 15.01.01 65 002031 Krouch Kimva Chub 0 0 156000 442.8 156000 1 15.01.01 66 002030 Mak Tey Chub 0 0 156000 436.8 156000 1 15.01.01 67 002029 Souen Orng Chub 0 0 156000 374.44 374.44 78000 78000 2 dk 68 002029 Ol Pov Chub 0 0 172.53 1 15.01.01 69 201001 Kim Sokha Chub 0 0 525 1 2001 70 001043 Lay Peng Chub 0 0 156000 156000 1dk 71 001026 Ty Mot Chub 0 0 156000 78000 156000 601.8 195000 1 dk 72 002001 Chhon Sithach Chub 0 0 156000 156000 235.68 156000 1 2.2001 73 002008 Mel Chhon Chub 0 0 156000 325.8 156000 1 15.01.01 74 002010 Uok Borin Chub 0 0 156000 322.5 322.5 7800 78000 2 dk 75 002013 Our Sopear Chub 0 0 156000 444.96 156000 1 15.01.01 76 002014 Hak iayrong Chub 0 0 156000 680 408 272 78000 46800 31200 3 15.01.01 77 002015 Kim Son Chub 0 0 156000 427.5 427.5 78000 78000 2 dk 78 001009 Oung Kimhorn Chub 0 0 156000 384.2 384.2 78000 78000 2 dk
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 79 002016 Hak Kimporn Chub 0 0 156000 78000 350.4 234000 1 15.01.01 80 002012 Lorng Chhon iy Chub 0 0 156000 330 156000 1 15.01.01 81 002017 Chhoeum Savat Chub 0 0 156000 78000 735.25 441.15 294.1 117000 70200 46800 3 dk 82 002018 Meak Nol Chub 0 0 140.94 1 15.01.01 83 002011 Ear Nyra Chub 0 0 156000 405.6 156000 1 15.01.01 84 002019 Som Thet Chub 0 0 156000 289.22 289.22 78000 78000 2 dk 85 401008 Heab Limhong Chub F 23 4.86 111.78 111.78 1dk Total 71 717.078 48.18 0 8260.99 354.73 0 8580000 312000 0 78000 936000 172801.54 4022.51 566.1 7669800 819000 78000 86 304032 Marv Mes Dar 2 42.5 12 510 156000 156000 510 312000 1 dk 87 301042 Sin Sek Dar 3 24.96 0 2121.6 156000 156000 1060.8 1060.8 156000 156000 2 dk 88 304034 Seng Meng Dar 3 22.31 1896 1896.35 156000 78000 948.175 948.175 117000 117000 2 dk 89 304035 Kheng Tri Dar 3 29.25 2486 2486.25 156000 156000 1243.125 1243.125 156000 156000 2 dk 90 301043 Meng Kheang Dar 3 32 0 2720 156000 156000 1360 1360 156000 156000 2 dk 91 303045 Sun Sopheap Dar 3 16.64 0 1414.4 156000 707.2 707.2 78000 78000 2 dk 92 304033 Hour Leang Dar 3 16.85 0 1432.25 156000 716.125 716.125 78000 78000 2 dk 93 303046 Kri Ya Dar 3 27.5 2337.5 156000 1168.75 1168.75 78000 78000 2 dk 94 301044 Koav Khim Dar 3 20.84 1771.4 156000 885.7 885.7 78000 78000 2 dk 95 301035 Veng Nhor Dar 3 20.8 1768 156000 884 884 78000 78000 2 dk 96 203013 Mat Kai Dar 2 29.4 12 352.8 156000 156000 352.8 312000 1 23.02.02 97 203014 Sles Soeuk Dar 1 32.24 4.5 145.08 156000 156000 145.08 312000 1 23.02.02 98 203015 Teab Him Dar 1 10.56 4.5 47.52 156000 156000 47.52 312000 1 23.02.02 99 203017 Mot Sash Dar 1 15.84 4.5 71.28 156000 78000 156000 71.28 390000 1 23.02.02 100 203016 Met Math Dar 1 13.76 4.5 61.92 156000 156000 61.92 312000 1 23.02.02 101 202028 Sos Sit Dar 1 26.1 4.5 117.45 156000 78000 78000 156000 117.45 468000 1 23.02.02 102 202029 Ly Him Dar OW 0 50 50 156000 50 1 23.02.02 103 202032 Hoeum Taluas Dar 2 33 12 396 156000 156000 396 312000 1 23.02.02 104 202030 Krim Oun Dar 1 14.24 4.5 64.08 156000 156000 64.08 312000 1 23.02.02 105 401003 Uy Sok Dar dk 0 0 40 78000 40 78000 1 dk 106 401004 Siv Heng Dar 2 30.08 12 360.96 156000 156000 360.96 312000 1 dk 107 401005 Leng Thum Dar dk 0 0 40 40 1dk 108 301013 Oeung Evmeng Dar 4 7 19.09 13.66 140 140 2677.6 1147.44 156000 1910.02 1146.01 764.01 78000 46800 312000 3 dk 109 203022 Noun Hean Dar 2 OW 18.84 12 50 266.08 50 156000 156000 316.08 312000 1 23.02.02 110 201030 Sok Ban Dar 2 7.59 12 91.08 156000 91.08 156000 1 23.02.02 111 302002 Pov Sun Dar OW 0 50 50 50 1 23.02.02 112 302003 Lov Karon Dar OW 0 50 50 50 1 23.02.02 113 201031 Pejh La Dar OW 0 50 50 50 1 23.02.02 114 202038 Vén Jhork Dar OW 0 50 50 50 1 23.02.02 115 302004 Och Doungren Dar 1 15.2 4.5 68.4 156000 68.4 156000 1 23.02.02 116 201032 Ma Chhan Dar 2 19.55 12 234.6 156000 234.6 156000 1 23.02.02 117 201033 Mok Buntheng Dar 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 23.02.02 118 203023 Jhem Ret Dar 2 29.9 12 358.8 156000 358.8 156000 1 23.02.02 119 202042 Jhoeub Heang Dar 1 34.08 4.5 153.36 156000 78000 156000 153.36 390000 1 23.02.02 120 202039 Sok Teang Dar 1 12.24 4.5 50.08 156000 78000 156000 55.08 390000 1 23.02.02 121 202040 Nut Tu Dar 2 10.25 12 123 156000 123 156000 1 23.02.02 122 202041 Chea Channy Dar 1 8.25 4.5 37.12 156000 37.12 156000 1 25.02.02 123 201028 Ly Thet Dar 1 14.61 4.5 65.74 156000 156000 65.74 312000 1 23.02.02 124 202033 Peak Ye Dar 1 20.5 4.5 92.25 156000 156000 92.25 312000 1 23.02.02 125 202034 Chor Krong Dar 1 26.65 4.5 119.92 156000 78000 156000 119.92 39000 1 23.02.02 126 202035 Sim Tha Dar 2 19.32 12 231.84 156000 231.84 156000 1 23.02.02 127 202036 Mey Ran Dar 1 12.54 4.5 56.43 156000 156000 56.43 312000 1 25.02.02 128 202037 Leang Bonsru Dar 2 10 12 120 156000 156000 120 312000 1 23.02.02 129 203018 Chan Ny Dar 1 19.25 4.5 86.62 156000 156000 86.62 312000 1 23.02.02 130 203020 Sok Thorn Dar 2 21.42 12 257.04 156000 156000 157.04 312000 1 23.02.02 131 203019 Kong Khhorn Dar 2 22.2 12 266.4 156000 156000 266.4 312000 1 23.02.02 132 203021 Yoeum Pearak Dar 2 16.28 12 196.36 156000 156000 195.36 312000 1 23.02.02 133 202031 Sos Nas Dar 1 31 4.5 139.5 156000 78000 156000 139.5 39000 1 23.02.02 134 201022 Phass kei Dar 2 31 12 92.4 156000 156000 92.4 312000 1 23.02.02 135 201023 Kav Jhor Dar 1 9.13 4.5 41.08 156000 156000 41.08 312000 1 23.02.02 136 201029 Tam Tey Dar 1 9.84 4.5 44.28 156000 78000 78000 156000 44.28 465000 1 23.02.02 137 201024 Nuo Savouen Dar 1 15.97 4.5 71.86 156000 156000 71.86 312000 1 23.02.02 138 201026 Bouy Net Dar 1 16.53 4.5 74.38 156000 156000 74.38 312000 1 23.02.02 139 201025 Ban Houen Dar 1 23.4 4.5 105.3 156000 156000 105.3 312000 1 dk 140 201027 Bech Srim Dar 1 22.5 4.5 101.25 156000 156000 101.25 312000 1 23.02.02 141 202043 Chea Channy Dar 1 PW 17.02 4.5 50 76.59 50 126.59 156000 156000 126.59 312000 1 25.02.02 142 303003 Ngoun Sokchea Dar 2 24.75 12 297 156000 297 156000 1 23.02.02 143 303002 Chhon Nak Dar 1 10.5 4.5 47.25 156000 47.25 156000 1 23.02.02 Total 58 1044.27 13.66 0 27240.45 1247.44 126.59 7956000 624000 0 234000 5460000 17142.035 10480.845 764.01 12048000 1333800 312000 144 Boch Samen Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 145 Do Dimong Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 146 Khon Nen Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 147 Chhen Chhon Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 148 Hout Chou Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 149 Sok Ny Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 150 E Seng Dar (Kratie) Dk 0 Dk Dk 151 003026 Oung Hout Dar (Kratie) 1 8.68 4.5 39.06 156000 39.06 156000 1 2001 152 001024 Horn Hen Dar (Kratie) 1 4.6 4.5 20.25 156000 20.25 156000 1 2001 153 003023 Reach Chea Dar (Kratie) 2 15.17 12 182.04 156000 182.04 312000 1 2001 154 003025 Pen Art Dar (Kratie) 1 21.73 4.5 97.78 156000 156000 97.78 312000 1 2001 155 002024 Lun chanthy Dar (Kratie) dk 28.52 12 342.24 156000 156000 342.24 312000 1 2001 156 002023 Meas Vothy Dar (Kratie) 1 10.4 4.5 46.8 156000 156000 46.8 312000 1 2001
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 157 001022 Mé Chea Dar (Kratie) 1 15.75 4.5 70.87 156000 78000 78000 78000 156000 70.78 546000 1 2001 158 001023 Sok Hun Dar (Kratie) 1 15.75 4.5 70.87 156000 156000 70.87 312000 1 2001 159 003024 Ratt Mot Dar (Kratie) 1 13.53 4.5 60.88 156000 60.88 156000 1 2001 Total 16 134.13 0 0 930.79 0 0 1404000 78000 78000 78000 780000 930.7 0 0 2574000 0 0 160 Prom Rom Khsoeum dk 0 Dk dk 161 203019 Tak Deu Khsoeum 2 9.2 12 110.4 156000 110.4 156000 1 29/3/02 162 203023 Sin Va Khsoeum 2 16.27 12 195.24 156000 156000 195.24 312000 1 29/3/02 163 203022 Sung Phat Khsoeum 1 19.2 4.5 86.4 156000 78000 156000 86.4 390000 1 29/3/02 164 203020 Mao Meng Khsoeum 2 27.09 12 325.08 156000 156000 325.08 312000 1 29/03/02 165 203021 Top Lay Khsoeum 1 22.62 4.5 101.79 156000 78000 156000 101.79 390000 1 29/3/02 166 201018 Phann Morn Khsoeum 2 13.5 12 162 156000 162 156000 1 29/3/02 167 204009 Ten Chheang Khsoeum OW 0 50 50 50 dk 1 29/3/02 168 204011 Chhoun Yen Khsoeum OW 0 50 50 50 1 29/3/02 169 202020 Heang Oun Khsoeum dk 28.2 4.5 126.9 156000 156000 126.9 312000 1 29/3/02 170 201017 Ross Sophea Khsoeum 1 14 4.5 63 156000 156000 63 312000 1 29/3/02 Total 11 150.08 0 0 1270.81 0 0 1248000 0 78000 78000 936000 1270.81 0 0 2340000 0 0 171 201019 LY Sokmy Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 172 201021 LIM YeakTang Koang Kang 2 15.12 12 181.44 156000 181.44 156000 1 dk 173 201020 SUN PengIEy Koang Kang 2 12.32 12 147.84 156000 147.84 156000 1 dk 174 202025 SEA MuyAea Koang Kang 2 26 12 312 156000 312 156000 1 2001 175 201017 NY SokHeang Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 176 202026 SOK Mean Koang Kang 2 12 12 144 156000 144 156000 1 dk 177 202027 PENG Lunn Koang Kang 2 8 12 192 156000 96 156000 1 dk 178 202024 LENG Phalla Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 179 KIM San Koang Kang dk 0 dk 180 201016 CHHEUNG SyMon Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 181 202023 LENG Phalla Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 182 201015 KUL DungKosal Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 183 202022 KEU SokLeng Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 184 LIM HuyAeang Koang Kang dk 0 Dk dk 185 TEA MuyHeang Koang Kang dk 0 Dk dk 186 201018 SOCH LyHung Koang Kang 2 16 12 192 156000 192 156000 1 dk 187 004039 YANG Buk Koang Kang dk OW 0 50 50 50 1 2001 188 AOUNG SoMuy Koang Kang dk 0 Dk dk 189 004041 LY Khey Koang Kang dk F 17.2 0.75 12.9 12.9 1 2001 190 004040 KEU SokLeang Koang Kang dk F 18.4 0.75 13.8 13.8 1 2001 191 001041 SAM SyHeng Koang Kang 2 15.96 12 191.52 156000 191.52 156000 1 DK 192 005040 KHEM Savy Koang Kang DK 32.2 4.5 144.9 156000 78000 156000 144.9 390000 1 15/02/2001 193 005038 CHHEANG Sopheap Koang Kang DK 22.26 4.5 100.17 156000 156000 100.17 312000 1 15/02/01 194 005039 LEANG Hoeun Koang Kang 1 37 4.5 166.5 156000 78000 156000 166.5 390000 1 15/02/01 195 005037 CHHI Chhey Koang Kang 1 32.59 4.5 146.65 156000 156000 146.65 312000 1 15/02/01 196 201023 NGUN SomAun Koang Kang 2 65.6 12 787.2 156000 78000 156000 393.6 156000 1 DK 197 201022 KEUT Sothea Koang Kang 2 PW 52.8 12 75 633.6 75 156000 156000 354.3 354.3 156000 156000 2 DK 198 201024 KEAM Jnor Koang Kang 3 16 1360 156000 680 680 78000 78000 2 DK 199 202030 CHHIM Chang Koang Kang 3 22.4 85 1904 156000 156000 952 952 156000 156000 2 DK 200 203013 HOK Chhin Koang Kang 2 47.3 12 567.6 156000 321.3 321.3 78000 78000 2 DK 201 201025 CHHUN TainVuchLeng Koang Kang 2 PW 41.66 12 75 499.92 75 78000 297.46 297.46 78000 78000 2 DK 202 202028 KRIN Sen Koang Kang 3 26.2 85 2227 156000 113.5 113.5 78000 78000 2 DK 203 202031 HEANG YoeungVa Koang Kang 2 45 12 540 156000 156000 270 270 156000 156000 2 DK 204 202029 LI M Kong Koang Kang 3 15.2 85 1292 156000 646 646 78000 78000 2 DK 205 203017 SU Lang Koang Kang 2 70 12 840 156000 420 420 78000 78000 2 DK 206 203016 CHAN Lin Koang Kang 2 PW 37 12 75 444 75 156000 259.5 259.5 78000 78000 2 DK 207 203014 LAK Leng Koang Kang 3 19.6 85 1666 156000 833 833 78000 78000 2 DK 208 203020 CHEA Huy Koang Kang 3 16 85 1360 156000 680 680 78000 78000 2 DK 209 203015 CHHENG Nang Koang Kang 2 67.5 12 810 156000 78000 156000 415 415 156000 156000 2 DK 210 203018 LY LengKim Koang Kang 2 F 55.18 20.6 12 4.86 662.16 100.12 156000 381.14 381.14 78000 78000 2 DK 211 201027 LY Mom Koang Kang 2 PW 42.6 12 75 511.2 75 156000 293.1 293.1 78000 78000 2 DK 212 201028 AOEUNG Chea Koang Kang 2 54.6 12 655.2 156000 327.6 327.6 78000 78000 2 DK 213 201026 HEI Sokha Koang Kang 3 23 85 1955 156000 156000 977.5 977.5 156000 156000 2 DK 214 202034 CHANG Aunn Koang Kang 2 PW 47.9 12 75 574.8 75 156000 324.9 324.9 78000 78000 2 DK 215 202033 KKUN Mom Koang Kang 2 61.74 12 740.88 156000 156000 370.44 370.44 156000 156000 2 DK 216 201029 CHHEN Luna Koang Kang 3 16 85 1360 156000 680 680 78000 78000 2 DK 217 202032 THAONG Sopheap Koang Kang 3 27.28 85 2318.8 156000 156000 1159.4 1159.4 156000 156000 2 DK 218 202035 LAM Yunn Koang Kang 3 16 85 1360 156000 680 680 78000 78000 2 DK 219 203019 EAN MengHeng Koang Kang 2 41.2 12 494.4 156000 156000 494.4 312000 1 DK 220 001036 TAING Sokunthea Koang Kang F 37.9 4.86 184.19 DK DK 221 001037 PECH Vannak Koang Kang F 33.3 4.86 161.83 DK DK 222 001038 NONG Nak Koang Kang 1 13.94 4.5 62.73 156000 156000 DK DK 223 001039 KOEUM Pheang Koang Kang 2 22.96 12 275.52 156000 156000 DK DK 224 001040 KRIM Sen Koang Kang 2 9.24 12 110.88 156000 DK DK Total 54 1422.15 20.6 0 29698.63 475.12 0 6864000 234000 78000 78000 2340000 15567.86 11436.14 0 6318000 2262000 0 225 202042 Kim Sung Kondol Chrum 3 27.9 85 2371.5 156000 156000 1185.75 1085.75 156000 156000 2 dk 226 202041 Ngun Tunnic Kondol Chrum 3 27 85 2295 156000 1147.5 1147.5 78000 78000 2 dk 227 203022 Tuy Pearny Kondol Chrum 2 PW 50.15 12 75 601.8 75 20 156000 78000 156000 591.2 312000 1 dk 228 203023 Phar Vida Kondol Chrum 3 14.8 85 1258 156000 629 629 78000 78000 2 dk 229 201035 Keng Sour Kondol Chrum 3 16 85 1360 156000 680 680 78000 78000 2 dk 230 203024 Kouch Ny Kondol Chrum 2 PW 50.15 12 75 601.8 75 20 156000 78000 156000 348 348 156000 156000 2 dk 231 201037 Tiv Sithar Kondol Chrum 2 70.2 12 842.4 20 862.4 156000 156000 421.2 421.2 156000 156000 2 dk 232 202043 Sok Kry Kondol Chrum 3 24.8 85 2108 156000 1054 1054 78000 78000 2 dk 233 203025 Khang Chany Kondol Chrum 2 64.08 12 768.96 156000 156000 384.48 384.48 156000 156000 2 dk
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 234 201036 Morm Pov Kondol Chrum 3 16.8 85 1428 156000 714 714 78000 78000 2 dk 235 202040 Tuy Lun Kondol Chrum 2 46.08 12 552.96 156000 105 156000 1 dk 236 001034 Penh Ol Kondol Chrum 2 8.75 12 105 156000 105 156000 1 dk 237 003051 Learng Horn Kondol Chrum 2 17.155 12 205.86 156000 78000 156000 205.86 312000 1 15/02/01 238 003053 Kim Sean Kondol Chrum 4 40.5 0.75 30.75 30.37 1 15/02/01 239 004037 Horn Sophal Kondol Chrum 1 10.72 4.5 48.26 156000 156000 48.26 312000 1 15/02/01 240 030525 Kourch Murykea Kondol Chrum 2 19.28 12 231.36 156000 78000 231.36 234000 1 15/02/01 241 004043 Seang Nhor Kondol Chrum 1 20 4.5 90 156000 90 156000 1 00/2/2001 242 004038 Leng Chai Lun Kondol Chrum F 16.3 4.86 79.21 79.21 1 15/02/01 243 005041 Nhem Heam Kondol Chrum F 13.85 4.86 67.31 67.31 1 15/02/01 244 Sek Neang Kondol Chrum OW 0 50 50 50 1 15/02/01 245 Mork Sarun Kondol Chrum OW 0 50 50 50 1 15/02/01 246 201033 PEN Roeun Kondol Chrum 2 53.12 12 637.44 156000 156000 318.72 318.72 156000 156000 1 DK 247 202036 PEN Nat Kondol Chrum 3 24 85 2040 20 2060 156000 1020 78000 1 DK 248 202039 CHET Huy Kondol Chrum 2 63.82 12 765.84 156000 156000 382.92 382.92 156000 156000 2 DK 249 202037 LAY Sombatt Kondol Chrum 2 63 12 756 156000 156000 378 378 156000 156000 2 DK 250 201031 CHAN Thon Kondol Chrum 3 29.2 85 2482 156000 1241 1241 78000 78000 2 DK 251 203021 BUN Thy Kondol Chrum 2 PW 44 12 75 528 75 156000 156000 603 312000 1 DK 252 202038 KOEUM Sorn Kondol Chrum 2 OW 55.04 12 50 660.48 50 156000 156000 355.24 355.24 156000 156000 2 DK 253 201032 BAKK Ngang Kondol Chrum 2 40 12 480 156000 156000 480 312000 1 DK 254 201034 SUK Teang Kondol Chrum 4 15 140 2100 156000 1050 1050 78000 78000 2 DK 255 201030 TY Montha Kondol Chrum 2 56.95 12 683.4 156000 156000 341.9 341.9 156000 156000 2 DK Total 31 998.645 0 0 26279.33 315 2962.4 4056000 312000 0 0 2184000 14388.28 10531.71 0 4290000 1950000 0 256 Heng Keng Kontout Dk 0 Dk Dk 257 Chren Phany Kontout Dk 0 Dk Dk 258 Key Peng Kontout Dk 0 Dk Dk 259 Ouen Kimhean Kontout Dk 0 Dk Dk 260 Sok Phea Kontout Dk 0 Dk Dk 261 001038 Seang Thy Kontout 1 34 4.5 153 156000 156000 153 312000 1 dk 262 002034 Lev Ly Kontout 1 14.8 4.5 66.6 156000 156000 66.6 312000 1 2001 263 002035 Né Somnang Kontout 1 27.06 4.5 121.77 156000 156000 121.77 312000 1 2001 264 003040 Seng Song Kontout 1 OW 30.08 4.5 135.36 50 156000 156000 185.36 312000 1 2001 265 003039 Pov Sokkean Kontout 2 18.3 12 219.6 156000 78000 219.6 234000 1 2001 266 001037 Sok Phear Kontout 2 32.5 12 390 156000 156000 390 312000 1 dk 267 003038 Liv Mom Kontout 1 21.93 4.5 98.68 156000 78000 156000 98.68 390000 1 2001 268 003037 Deun Sran Kontout 1 24.8 4.5 108.36 156000 156000 108.36 312000 1 2001 269 002033 Dong Chanthy Kontout 1 16.43 4.5 73.93 156000 78000 156000 73.93 390000 1 2001 270 002026 Chiv Sokhang Kontout OW 0 50 50 1dk 271 003028 Meung Kong Kontout 2 B 21 13.49 12 4.5 252 60.7 156000 312000 156000 1 2001 272 003029 Mok Va Kontout B 18.4 4.5 82.8 82.8 1 2001 273 002025 Srim Srey Kontout 1 16.56 4.5 74.52 156000 78000 156000 74.52 390000 1 2001 274 001025 Na SreyNoun Kontout 1 11.4 4.5 51.3 156000 156000 51.3 312000 1 2001 275 003027 Trouch Mom Kontout 2 18.5 12 22200 156000 156000 222 312000 1 2001 276 002038 Yeun Chheun Kontout 1 14.4 4.5 64.8 156000 156000 64.8 312000 1 2001 277 002037 Norn Phy Kontout 1 8.75 4.5 39.37 156000 156000 39.37 312000 1 2001 278 003041 Ouk Dy Kontout 1 21.5 4.5 96.75 156000 156000 96.75 312000 1 2001 279 003042 Khev Tha Kontout 1 15.54 4.5 69.93 156000 156000 69.93 312000 1 2001 280 001039 Bun Beun Kontout 1 25 4.5 112.5 156000 156000 112.5 312000 1 2001 281 003035 Chen Chang Kontout 1 14.44 4.5 64.98 156000 78000 156000 64.98 390000 1 2001 282 001033 Nai Pheach Kontout 1 18 4.5 81 156000 156000 81 312000 1 2001 283 002030 Pat Thoeuk Kontout 1 21 4.5 94.5 156000 156000 94.5 312000 1 2001 284 002031 Chheun chhay Kontout 1 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 285 001031 Tay Sokhum Kontout 2 32.5 12 390 156000 156000 390 312000 1 2001 286 001030 Chea Huch Kontout 2 20 12 240 156000 156000 240 312000 1 2001 287 003033 Chin Top Kontout 2 21.2 12 254.4 156000 156000 254.4 312000 1 2001 288 003034 Chem Kheng Kontout 1 16 4.5 72 156000 156000 72 312000 1 2001 289 002028 Broeum Nan Kontout 1 23.4 4.5 105.3 156000 105.3 312000 1 2001 290 002029 Hoa Hout Kontout B 13.75 4.5 61.87 61.87 dk 1 2001 291 003032 Phoy Phal Kontout 2 30 12 360 156000 156000 360 312000 1 2001 292 001028 Khut Savat Kontout 2 17.5 12 210 156000 156000 210 312000 1 2001 293 003030 Hong Kheng Kontout 2 38.4 12 460.8 156000 156000 460.8 312000 1 2001 294 001027 Lort Hout Kontout 2 23.4 12 280.8 156000 156000 280.8 312000 1 2001 295 002027 Chhoy ChhunHong Kontout OW 50 50 dk 1 2001 296 001029 Chhom Thol Kontout 2 8.6 12 103.2 156000 103.2 156000 1 2001 297 003031 Haing Chhay Kontout 2 12.75 12 153 156000 153 156000 1 2001 298 001026 Chan Ny Kontout 2 15 12 180 156000 180 156000 1 dk 299 001032 Khy Phou Kontout 2 6 12 72 156000 72 dk 1 dk 300 002036 San Vandy Kontout 2 10.2 12 122.4 156000 122.4 156000 1 2001 301 001035 Khut Vet Kontout 2 37 12 444 156000 156000 444 312000 1 2001 302 001036 Chea Sin Kontout 1 35 4.5 157.5 156000 156000 157.5 312000 1 2001 303 002032 Po Ko Kontout F 3.5 4.86 17.01 17.01 422.4 312000 1 2001 304 001034 Yun Pheap Kontout 2 35.2 12 422.4 156000 156000 2001 305 003036 Sao Kim Kontout 1 49.64 4.5 223.38 156000 156000 223.38 312000 1 2001 Total 50 913.43 13.49 0 29171.81 110.7 0 6240000 390000 0 0 4992000 318569.41 422.4 0 11622000 0 0 306 Sa Neang Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk 307 Houl Simhour Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk 308 Sor Sopon Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk 309 Kim Sopon Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk 310 In Theany Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk 311 Seng Hour Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 312 Seck Sihan Kratie Dk 0 Dk Dk 313 001007 Sok Sara Kratie 1 15.4 4.5 69.3 69.3 1 2001 314 002006 Sean Koeumseng Kratie B 12 4.5 54 54 1 2001 315 001003 Oul Sreng Kratie 1 33.75 4.5 151.87 151.87 1 2001 316 002007 Loeung Kimsan Kratie B 38.5 4.5 173.25 173.25 1 2001 317 001004 Chhan Thom Kratie 1 32 4.5 144 144 1 2001 318 002004 Beat SouHan Kratie B 16.5 4.5 74.25 74.25 1 2001 319 003005 Vann Mean Kratie B 32 12 384 384 1 2001 320 003006 Theun Kratie B 19.6 4.5 82.2 88.2 1 2001 321 001008 Chan Choun Kratie 1 9.5 4.5 42.75 42.75 1 2001 322 003002 Hong Ches Kratie B 16 4.5 72 72 1 2001 323 003001 San Moun Kratie B 17.94 12 215.28 215.28 1 2001 324 002010 Sao Penh Kratie FB 1 34.65 4.86 4.5 4.86 155.92 160.78 1 2001 325 001002 Eu Chhen Kratie 2 15.96 12 191.52 191.52 1 2001 326 003008 Khat Sokheun Kratie B 26.4 4.5 100.3 100.3 1 2001 327 003008 Chhoeum Seun Kratie B 14.28 4.5 64.26 64.26 1 2001 328 003004 Touch Narin Kratie B 16.92 4.5 76.14 76.14 1 2001 329 003007 Mé Pitou Kratie B 9.75 4.5 43.87 73.87 1 2001 330 002003 Om Sarin Kratie B 16.8 12 201.6 201.6 1 2001 331 002009 Vong Et Kratie B 33.6 4.5 151.2 151.2 1 2001 332 001005 Keak hout Kratie 1 55 4.5 247.5 247.5 1 2001 333 001006 Koeum Sophorn Kratie 1 10.64 4.5 47.88 47.88 1 2001 334 001001 Ngoun Sitha Kratie 1 78 4.5 351 351 1 2001 335 002005 Chorn Senghear Kratie 2 18.56 12 222.72 156000 156000 222.72 312000 1 2001 336 002008 Norng Malai Kratie B 22 4.5 99 99 1 2001 337 003003 Mang Engheang Kratie B 19.55 4.5 87.97 87.97 1 2001 338 001009 Chan Vouthea Kratie B 14 4.5 63 63 1 2001 339 002001 Loa Heang Kratie B 28.81 19.61 12 4.5 345.72 88.24 156000 433.96 156000 1 2001 340 002002 Heng Chhai Neng Kratie B F 36.8 8 12 4.86 441.6 38.88 480.48 1 2001 341 201019 Chheang Char Kratie B 15 12 180 180 1 29/3/02 Total 36 676.26 62.26 0 4383.04 283.04 0 312000 0 0 0 156000 4702.08 0 0 468000 0 0 342 203030 Sorn Sophan Krek 3 18 85 153 156000 765 765 78000 78000 2 dk 343 202044 Kheav Searn Krek 2 OW 49.6 12 595.2 50 20 156000 78000 156000 332.6 332.6 156000 156000 2 dk 344 203031 Sek Sab Krek 2 76.36 12 916.32 156000 458.16 156000 2 dk 345 202046 Ya Somnarng Krek 3 16 8.5 590.4 156000 680 680 78000 78000 2 dk 346 203032 Pich Sopeap Krek 2 49.2 12 590.4 156000 156000 590.4 312000 1 dk 347 203033 Koav Thon Krek 2 OW 69.84 12 838.08 50 156000 156000 444.04 585.6 156000 156000 2 dk 348 201044 Touch Sarrieun Krek 2 48.8 12 585.6 156000 156000 585.6 312000 1 dk 349 201042 Sourn Narin Krek 2 PW 51.2 12 614.4 75 156000 156000 344.7 344.7 156000 156000 2 dk 350 201043 Lim Sokheang Krek 3 21.8 85 1853 156000 926.5 926.5 78000 78000 2 dk 351 201045 Hem Sokha Krek 3 17.5 85 1487.5 156000 743.5 78000 2 dk 352 202002 Kri Va Krek 2 21.45 12 257.4 156000 156000 Dk dk 353 201025 Cheng Seng Heang Krek 2 12 12 144 156000 144 156000 1 dk 354 202004 Heng Vana Krek 2 18.72 12 224.64 156000 156000 Dk dk 355 201004 Searn Lau Krek 1 15.6 4.5 70.2 156000 70.2 156000 1 dk 356 201006 Chea Sokorn Krek 2 19.52 12 234.24 156000 156000 234.24 312000 1 dk 357 202005 Nourn Teary Krek dk F 34.5 4.86 86.75 dk 358 201007 Kong Bros Krek dk F 17.85 4.56 86.75 86.75 1dk 359 202006 You Chan Krek dk F 7.9 4.86 38.89 dk 360 203005 Heang Pum Krek 2 10 12 120 156000 120 156000 1 2001 361 202007 Kol Mearn Krek dk F 17 4.86 82.62 dk 362 203008 Meas Keat Krek dk F F 40.5 11 4.86 0.75 196.83 8.25 205.08 1 2001 363 201008 Pin Sarak Krek 2 17.95 12 215.4 156000 215.4 156000 1 dk 364 203006 Kim Heak Krek dk OW 0 0 50 50 1 2001 365 202009 Long Khearm Krek 1 33.84 4.5 152.28 156000 dk dk 366 202010 Var Chenda Krek dk OW 0 dk 50 dk dk 367 203028 Hear Limhearng Krek 2 72 12 864 156000 156000 432 432 156000 156000 2 dk 368 203029 Heart Kearm Krek 2 50.4 12 604.8 156000 156000 302.4 302.4 156000 156000 2 dk 369 201038 Kearm Thavy Krek 2 53.24 12 638.88 156000 156000 319.44 319.44 156000 156000 2 dk 370 203026 Chum Rearng Krek 2 PW 46.5 12 558 75 156000 156000 316.5 316.5 156000 156000 2 dk 371 203027 Bark Pou Krek 2 41.6 12 499.2 156000 156000 499.2 312000 1 dk 372 202045 Cheark Sokly Krek 3 26.49 85 2244 156000 156000 1122 1122 156000 156000 2 dk 373 201039 Hong Hun Krek 3 14 85 1190 156000 595 595 78000 78000 2 dk 374 020207 Ney Peark Krek 3 18.3 85 1555.5 156000 777.75 777.75 78000 78000 2 dk 375 201040 Saray Chanthy Krek 2 PW 47 12 564 75 156000 319 312 78000 78000 2 dk 376 201041 Prark Sophearn Krek 2 PW 62 12 744 75 156000 405.5 409.5 78000 78000 2 dk 377 203034 Hok Chang Krek 2 44.5 12 534 156000 156000 534 312000 1 dk 378 202048 Ney Rin Krek 2 46.3 12 555.6 156000 555.6 156000 1 dk 379 203036 Yeam Kimlin Krek 3 17.2 85 1462 156000 731 78000 1 dk 380 203035 Um Keat Krek 3 18 85 1530 156000 156000 765 765 156000 156000 2 dk 381 203037 Rus Sarearn Krek 2 43.8 12 525.6 20 156000 78000 545.6 156000 1 dk 382 203001 SUK Sim Krek 1 OW 21.2 4.5 95.4 50 156000 78000 156000 145.4 390000 1 01/02/2001 383 201002 BUT An Krek 1 8.5 4.5 38.25 156000 156000 DK DK DK DK DK 384 201003 NEANG Sothy Krek 1 14.48 4.5 65.16 156000 78000 156000 65.16 390000 1 DK 385 202001 KIM Sokna Krek 2 10.34 12 124.08 156000 DK DK 386 203004 CHIV Voeung Krek 1 15.18 4.5 68.31 156000 156000 68.31 312000 1 DK 387 203007 TET Sophann Krek OW 0 50 50 1DK 388 202003 YU Dy Krek F F 13.4 7.7 4.86 0.75 65.12 5.77 DK DK DK DK 389 203002 HUN Sinat Krek 2 6 12 72 156000 72 156000 1 01/02/2001 390 203003 PHE Chea Krek F OW 3 4.86 14.58 50 64.58 1 01/02/2001
5 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 391 202016 HEM Sytha Krek 3 3 12.48 15.68 85.00 85.00 1060.80 799.68 156000 156000 930.24 930.24 156000 156000 2 28/02/2002 392 201009 CHHOEUM Thy Krek 2 26.06 12 312.72 156000 156000 312.72 312000 1 DK 393 203011 SUN Phalla Krek DK 0 156000 DK 156000 1 DK 394 203009 KHEK Srey Krek 1 23.4 4.5 105.3 156000 156000 105.3 312000 1 2001 395 202011 PHIN Soaphoann Krek 1 19.84 4.5 89.28 156000 156000 89.28 312000 1 DK 396 202012 SEANG Nak Krek 1 14.72 4.5 66.24 156000 156000 66.24 312000 1 DK 397 203010 OUK Chansy Krek OW 0 50 50 50 1 2001 398 201010 SUM Chen Krek OW 0 50 50 50 1DK 399 201011 AING Sunheag Krek 2 21.28 12 255.36 156000 78000 156000 255.36 390000 1 DK 400 202017 NUCH Phim Krek 2 27.2 12 326.4 156000 156000 326.4 312000 1 DK 401 202013 HANG Nanna Krek 2 10.92 12 131.4 156000 131.4 156000 1 DK 402 202014 CHHEM Phallet Krek 2 12.48 12 149.76 156000 149.76 156000 1 DK 403 202015 KIM Roung Krek 2 9.5 12 114 156000 144 156000 1 DK 404 202021 POV Vichet Krek 2 19 4.5 85.5 156000 156000 85.5 312000 1 DK 405 202018 HENG Chuk Krek 2 20.8 12 249.6 156000 156000 249.6 312000 1 DK 406 202019 KORNN Nim Krek 1 8.32 4.5 37.44 156000 78000 78000 156000 37.44 468000 1 DK 407 202020 PROM Nin Krek 1 17.64 4.5 79.38 156000 156000 79.38 312000 1 DK 408 203012 NUM Naren Krek 1 24 12 288 156000 156000 288 312000 1 2001 409 201013 CHHEUNG Kosal Krek 2 14.04 12 168.48 156000 168.48 156000 1 DK 410 201014 MEAS Kunthea Krek F 36 4.86 174.96 174.96 1DK 411 001001 BRAS Srey Krek 2 F 11.47 5.27 12 4.86 137.3 25.61 156000 163.31 156000 1 15/01/2001 412 001002 IY KimHark Krek 2 14.17 12 170.04 156000 170.04 156000 1 15/01/2001 413 001003 TAING Eng Krek 2 12.24 12 146.88 156000 78000 146.88 234000 1 15/01/2001 414 004003 HANG Sotheary Krek OW 0 50 50 50 1 15/01/2001 415 001024 KHENG MengHong Krek 2 9.38 12 112.56 156000 112.56 156000 1 15/01/2001 416 202008 Duch Saran Krek 2 10.2 12 122.04 156000 dk dk Total 75 1753.7 39.65 0 29429.82 1359.31 20 9516000 546000 0 78000 4992000 20018.46 9916.23 0 11310000 2106000 0 417 302035 Cheav Pi Me Mut 2 40.32 12 483.84 156000 483.84 156000 1 25/02/02 418 301015 Kaov Menghak Me Mut 2 32.38 12 388.56 156000 388.56 156000 1 25/02/02 419 301016 Tea Kimhourt Me Mut 2 29.88 12 358.56 156000 358.56 156000 1 25/02/02 420 304055 Chhay Buntha Me Mut dk 0 156000 1239 1239 78000 78000 2 dk 421 303053 Ven Yeng Me Mut dk 0 156000 683.26 312000 1 dk 422 303049 Yorng Srangyon Me Mut dk 0 156000 1263.5 1263.5 312000 78000 2 dk 423 304053 Sim Sokna Me Mut dk 0 156000 798.15 798.15 78000 78000 2 dk 424 304045 Chea Rat Me Mut dk 0 156000 156000 1960 1960 78000 78000 2 dk 425 303058 Srey Meng Me Mut dk 0 156000 1960 782 78000 78000 2 dk 426 303052 Siv Hour Me Mut dk 0 156000 775.625 775.625 78000 78000 2 dk 427 303056 Hem Sengkeav Me Mut dk 0 156000 78000 1274 1274 117000 117000 2 dk 428 303051 Say Yek Me Mut dk 0 156000 383.1 383.1 156000 156000 2 dk 429 304049 Lean Kimsoy Me Mut dk 0 156000 156000 597.6 312000 1 dk 430 301054 Cham Domdek Me Mut dk 0 156000 156000 712.8 312000 1 dk 431 301051 Nai Teang Me Mut dk 0 156000 156000 372.96 372.96 156000 156000 2 dk 432 304054 Eng Seang Me Mut dk 0 156000 78000 903.12 903.12 195000 195000 2 dk 433 303050 Tea Kimkhuy Me Mut dk 0 156000 781.25 781.25 78000 78000 2 dk 434 303051 Tea Kimhun Me Mut dk 0 156000 156000 882 882 156000 156000 2 dk 435 304051 Yem Chorm Me Mut dk 0 156000 78000 756.5 756.5 117000 117000 2 dk 436 304044 Hung Keng Me Mut dk 0 156000 1358.88 1358.88 78000 78000 2 dk 437 304046 Meng Tai Me Mut dk 0 156000 752.25 752.25 78000 78000 2 dk 438 301048 Thorn Buntharn Me Mut dk 0 156000 799 799 78000 78000 2 dk 439 301047 Seng Sean Hor Me Mut dk 0 156000 1309 1309 78000 78000 2 dk 440 304047 Soum Heng Me Mut dk 0 156000 782 782 78000 78000 2 dk 441 302042 Chea Menghong Me Mut 2 17.12 12 205.44 156000 205.44 156000 1 25/02/02 442 302043 Keov Sarat Me Mut 1 49.82 4.5 224.19 224.19 dk 1 25/02/02 443 302041 Sok Tri Me Mut 2 12.5 12 150 156000 1500 156000 1 25/02/02 444 302044 Nov Van Me Mut 8 dk 0 41 156000 dk 156000 1 25/02/02 445 303025 Sim Chayhong Me Mut 1 33.17 450 149.26 156000 156000 14926 312000 1 25/02/02 446 303022 Sok Chany Me Mut 2 17 12 204 156000 156000 204 312000 1 25/02/02 447 303023 Nim Soy Me Mut 1 26.04 4.5 117.18 156000 156000 117.18 312000 1 25/02/02 448 301028 Long Chamtean Me Mut dk 24 4.5 108 156000 156000 108 312000 1 25/02/02 449 303024 Sun Marn Me Mut 2 25 12 300 156000 156000 300 312000 1 25/02/02 450 301029 Sok Ky Me Mut dk 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 25/02/02 451 304013 Veng Horl Me Mut 2 B 13.75 28.125 12 4.5 165 126 156000 291.56 156000 1 25/02/02 452 304011 Chiv Songheng Me Mut 2 OW 25.62 12 50 307.44 50 156000 156000 357.44 312000 1 25/02/02 453 304012 Nourn Sour Me Mut 2 18.6 12 223.2 156000 156000 223.2 312000 1 25/02/02 454 304007 Sun Ly Me Mut 2 14.1 12 169.2 156000 78000 169.2 234000 1 25/02/02 455 304006 Meas Thai Me Mut 2 14.26 12 171.12 156000 171.12 156000 1 25/02/02 456 301023 Chourn Ngov Me Mut dk 13.14 12 157.68 156000 157.68 156000 1 25/02/02 457 304026 Sim Kimheang Me Mut dk 13.5 12 162 156000 162 156000 1 25/02/02 458 301024 Arng Tong Me Mut 13.74 12 164.88 156000 164.88 156000 1 25/02/02 459 301021 Mar Kihourt Me Mut 13.46 12 161.52 156000 161.52 156000 1 25/02/02 460 303013 Trang Min Me Mut 2 14.227 12 170.72 156000 170.72 156000 1 25/02/02 461 303014 Seak Thor Me Mut 2 14.31 12 171.72 156000 171.72 156000 1 25/02/02 462 331022 Mom Kourng Me Mut dk 12.46 12 149.52 156000 149.52 156000 1 25/02/02 463 303019 Hour Menghourt Me Mut 2 13.115 12 157.38 156000 157.37 156000 1 25/02/02 464 304008 Keat Heavly Me Mut 2 58.24 12 698.88 156000 349.44 349.44 78000 78000 2 07/03/2002 465 301027 Huch Hum Me Mut dk 13.1 12 157.2 156000 157.2 156000 1 25/02/02 466 301025 Chin Ta Me Mut dk 12.97 12 155.64 156000 155.64 156000 1 25/02/02 467 303020 Sean Sombor Me Mut 2 14.4 12 172.8 156000 172.8 156000 1 25/02/02 468 304015 Nhes Hong Me Mut F 14 4.86 48.04 68 1 25/02/02 469 304014 Vit Chuch Me Mut 1 14 4.5 63 156000 63 156000 1 25/02/02
6 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 470 303021 Sin Moa Me Mut 2 12 12 144 156000 156000 144 312000 1 25/02/02 471 302036 Hong Peng Me Mut 2 33.89 12 406.68 156000 406.68 156000 1 25/02/02 472 301010 Yarn Kong Me Mut 3 5.85 85 149.17 156000 149.17 156000 1 25/02/02 473 301009 Lort Buntheng Me Mut 3 5.85 85 149.17 156000 149.17 156000 1 25/02/02 474 304004 Ly Hong Me Mut 2 31.5 12 378 156000 378 156000 1 25/02/02 475 301017 Tea Kimhean Me Mut 2 33.62 12 403.44 156000 403.44 156000 1 25/02/02 476 303012 Pou Kimlarng Me Mut 2 32.89 12 394.68 156000 78000 394.68 234000 1 25/02/02 477 301019 Thourng Chea Me Mut 2 31.92 12 383.04 156000 383.04 156000 1 25/02/02 478 301018 Hean Punleu Me Mut 2 31.95 12 383.4 156000 383.4 156000 1 25/02/02 479 303016 Kim Hang Me Mut 2 36.19 12 434.28 156000 434.28 156000 1 25/02/02 480 304050 Tuy Channta Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 78000 156000 460.86 460.86 195000 195000 2 dk 481 301052 Touch Sarrieun Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 156000 476.16 476.16 156000 156000 2 dk 482 303054 Saoum Sophal Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 380.16 380.16 156000 156000 2 dk 483 301050 Saoum Sikearn Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 156000 630 630 156000 156000 2 dk 484 303057 Lim Hok Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 490.02 490.02 156000 156000 2 dk 485 303055 Heng Bunchan Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 484.64 485.64 156000 156000 2 dk 486 304052 Hars Narvy Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 156000 711 312000 1 dk 487 301049 Chea Khon Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 156000 481.02 481.02 156000 156000 2 dk 488 304048 Khearv Hout Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 156000 338.52 338.52 156000 156000 2 dk 489 301053 Yin Sivon Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 751.5 751.5 78000 78000 2 dk 490 303052 Sboung Sichorm Me Mut dk 0 0 156000 850 850 78000 78000 2 dk 491 301020 Ly Lyhau Me Mut 2 36.4 12 346.8 156000 436.8 156000 1 25/02/02 492 303015 Ary Chu Me Mut 2 17.64 12 211.68 156000 211.68 156000 1 25/02/02 493 302040 Chin Chanlearng Me Mut 2 PW 27.36 12 328.32 75 156000 78000 403.32 234000 1 25/02/02 494 301001 Heark Hearn Me Mut 1 20.21 4.5 90.94 156000 156000 90.94 312000 1 25/02/02 495 301002 Pen Searn Me Mut 1 6.5 4.5 29.25 156000 156000 29.25 312 1 25/02/02 496 303004 Prark Phal Me Mut 1 12.6 4.5 56.7 156000 156000 56.7 312 1 25/02/02 497 303003 Huch Norb Me Mut 1 18.29 4.5 82.3 156000 78000 156000 82.3 390 1 25/02/02 498 301004 Hit Chin Me Mut dk OW 0 0 50 50 1 25/02/02 499 301005 Vour Chomreurn Me Mut dk OW 0 0 50 50 1 25/02/02 500 303005 Ket Kunthy Me Mut 1 10.24 4.5 46.08 156000 156000 46.08 312000 1 25/02/02 501 301006 Sun Sokeng Me Mut 2 17 12 204 156000 204 156000 1 25/02/02 502 302039 Hearn Me Mut 2 9.46 12 113.52 156000 113.52 156000 1 25/02/02 503 301008 Seng Arn Me Mut 2 15.75 12 189 156000 198.72 234000 1 25/02/02 504 301014 Kim Larng Me Mut 2 32.3 12 387.6 156000 387.6 156000 1 25/02/02 505 303010 Keart Kim Ngong Me Mut 2 35.216 12 422.59 156000 422.59 156000 1 25/02/02 506 303011 Ly Num Hearng Me Mut 2 33.488 12 401.85 156000 401.85 156000 1 25/02/02 507 303006 Eang Lai Me Mut F 34 4.86 165.24 165.24 1dk 508 401007 Loeum Mom Me Mut 3 11.4 85 969 156000 969 156000 1 dk 509 401002 Sok Meng Me Mut F F 45 5.5 10.04 0.75 4.86 12 33.75 26.73 180.96 180.96 1 26.06.03 510 303009 Pon Kong Me Mut 4 6 19.048 13.999 140 140 2666.79 1175.91 156000 1921.353 1152.811 768.541 78000 46800 31200 13 13.03.02 511 304010 Keo Chhay Me Mut 3 13.5 85 688.5 156000 344.25 344.25 78000 78000 2 13.03.02 512 303018 Chea Kim Me Mut 4 15.2 140 1276.8 156000 638.4 383.04 255.36 78000 46800 31200 3 13.03.02 513 301011 Houng Peng Me Mut 4 A 18.36 13.5 140 140 2570.4 1134 3704.4 156000 1852.2 1111.32 740.88 78000 46800 31200 3 13.03.02 514 304002 Mork Dany Me Mut 4 A 18.405 13.5 140 140 2576.7 1134 156000 1855.35 1113.21 742.14 78000 46800 31200 3 13.03.02 515 304001 Ev Sony Me Mut 4 A 18.9 13.95 140 140 2646 1171.8 3817.8 156000 1908.9 1145.34 763.56 78000 46800 31200 3 13.03.02 516 304003 Hak Palla Me Mut 4 A 19.08 13.275 140 2671.2 156000 1893.15 1135.89 757.26 78000 1 13.03.02 517 304005 Ung Dorn Me Mut 4 A 19.38 13.543 140 140 2713.2 1137.62 3850.82 156000 1925.41 1155.246 770.164 78000 46800 31200 3 13.03.02 518 304009 Tea Kimhoueng Me Mut 4 13.95 140 1171.8 156000 585.9 585.9 78000 78000 2 13.03.02 519 303007 Maov Thavry Me Mut 4 A 21.074 15.8 140140*60% 2950.36 1327.87 156000 2139.11 1283.46 855.64 78000 46800 31200 3 dk 520 303008 Ly Chan Me Mut 4 A 18.45 13.725 140140*60% 2583 1152.9 156000 1867.95 1120.77 747.18 78000 46800 31200 3 dk 521 301012 Thab Yin Me Mut 4 A 18 13.5 140140*60% 2520 1134 156000 1827 1096.2 730.8 78000 46800 31200 3 dk 522 302037 Var Laysearm Me Mut 2 12.05 12 144.6 156000 78000 144.6 234000 1 25/02/02 Total 106 1512.133 158.417 10.04 759.36 12 41030.8 9645.83 11553.98 15600000 624000 0 78000 3900000 75407.638 34493.092 7131.525 15991014 3931200 280800 523 004009 Peth Oun Morng Reav dk 0 156000 156000 257.58 156000 1 15.01.01 524 003014 Soeum Sophat Morng Reav dk 0 156000 233.28 156000 1 15.01.01 525 001011 Kim Sokom Morng Reav dk 0 156000 156000 195.84 312000 1 15.01.01 526 002038 Koe Engly Morng Reav dk 0 156000 78000 412.8 234000 1 15.01.01 527 002033 Bot Chantha Morng Reav dk 0 156000 300 156000 1 15.01.01 528 002037 Chhom Sitha Morng Reav dk 0 156000 276 156000 1 15.01.01 529 002035 Meas Sroy Morng Reav dk 0 156000 78000 249.6 234000 1 15.01.01 530 002034 Korng Noeum Morng Reav dk 0 156000 78000 266 234000 1 15.04.01 531 002036 Chhok Vanna Morng Reav dk 0 156000 310.2 156000 1 17.04.01 Total 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 1404000 78000 156000 0 312000 2251.7 249.6 0 1560000 234000 0 532 Tep Khonthea Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 533 Tong Toro Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 534 Chem Lim Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 535 Chor Veng Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 536 Oueng Soan Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 537 Ton Sokhon Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 538 Ket Va Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 539 Nhim Beat Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 540 Va Soun Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 541 Kat Pal Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 542 Kim Do Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 543 Cho Kimthach Orussey Dk 0 Dk Dk 544 Pov Kim Orussey dk 0 Dk dk 545 Kek Sok Orussey dk 0 Dk dk 546 Bonly Som Aol Orussey dk 0 Dk dk 547 Kong Chhay Orussey dk 0 Dk dk
7 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 548 Hem Vorn Orussey dk 0 Dk dk 549 Ban Eun Orussey dk 0 Dk dk 550 002016 Leun Khouch Orussey 1 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 551 002014 Sun Channang Orussey 1 22.88 4.5 102.96 156000 78000 156000 102.96 390000 1 2001 552 003017 Toun Ly Orussey 2 30.24 12 362.88 156000 362.88 156000 1 2001 553 003015 Chat Chan Orussey 1 14.4 4.5 64.8 156000 64.8 156000 1 2001 554 003016 Vorn Chorn Orussey 1 24.8 4.5 111.6 156000 156000 111.6 312000 1 2001 555 002015 Ek Sindeun Orussey 2 15.51 12 186.12 156000 186.12 156000 1 2001 556 001015 Ros Sareun Orussey 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 156000 156000 60.48 312000 1 2001 557 001014 Ouk Hean Orussey 1 23.2 4.5 104.4 156000 156000 104.4 312000 1 2001 558 001013 Thai Sdeung Orussey 2 7.5 12 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 559 003014 Hat Bros Orussey 1 9 4.5 40.5 156000 78000 156000 40.5 390000 1 2001 560 002018 Chao Nhy Orussey dk 10.88 4.5 48.96 156000 156000 48.96 312000 1 2001 561 003018 Somreth Pech Orussey 2 14.62 12 175.44 156000 156000 175.44 312000 1 2001 562 001016 Mok Phalla Orussey 1 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 563 002017 Yun Mach Orussey 2 20 12 240 156000 156000 240 312000 1 2001 564 003013 Seung Van Orussey B 5.25 4.5 23.62 23.62 1dk 565 002013 Seng Hor Orussey B 12.25 12 195 195 1 2001 566 003012 Dong Chhom Orussey B 33.32 4.5 74.97 74.97 1 2001 567 001012 Rotha Phalla Orussey B 3 4.5 13.5 13.5 1 2001 568 002012 Aet Pin Orussey B 119 4.5 53.55 53.55 1 2001 569 003011 Sdeung Sok Orussey B 19.5 4.5 87.75 87.75 1 2001 570 001011 Tann Phally Orussey B 16.25 4.5 73.12 73.12 1 2001 571 001010 Phon Mach Orussey B 25.8 12 309.6 309.6 1 2001 572 003010 Chhen Saseun Orussey B 17.5 4.5 78.78 78.75 1 2001 573 002011 Seang Eung Orussey B F 2.53 9.6 4.5 4.86 11.38 46.65 58.03 1 2001 574 003021 Chap Leun Orussey 1 8.96 4.5 40.32 156000 78000 156000 40.32 390000 1 2001 575 003022 Soun Lim Orussey 1 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 576 002021 Ly Kong Orussey 2 20.91 12 250.92 156000 78000 156000 250.92 390000 1 2001 577 003020 Puk Sophal Orussey 2 27.01 12 324.12 156000 156000 324.12 312000 1 2001 578 001020 Hin Sokhen Orussey 1 11.2 4.5 50.4 156000 78000 156000 50.4 390000 1 2001 579 001019 Yong Yean Orussey 1 12.25 4.5 55.12 156000 156000 55.12 312000 1 2001 580 002022 Thong Bon Orussey 1 14.4 4.5 64.8 156000 78000 156000 64.8 390000 1 dk 581 001018 Dean Dina Orussey 1 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 582 001021 Heng Khourch Orussey 2 19.57 12 234.84 156000 156000 234.84 321000 1 2001 583 003019 Long Kiman Orussey 2 17.6 12 211.2 156000 78000 156000 211.2 390000 1 2001 584 001017 Hem Vann Orussey 1 20 4.5 90 156000 156000 90 312000 1 2001 585 002020 Leng Von Orussey B 10.5 4.5 47.25 47.25 1 2001 586 002019 Chhen Sopal Orussey 2 33.75 12 450 156000 156000 405 312000 1 2001 Total 55 737.02 9.6 0 257 4.86 0 4688.38 46.65 0 4056000 468000 0 78000 3588000 4690 0 0 8199000 0 0 587 201004 Hon Sinean Snour 2 18.4 12 220.8 156000 156000 220.8 312000 1 28.03.02 588 204002 Chhon Ny Snour 2 2 14.63 18.91 12 12 105.33 226.92 332.25 156000 332.25 156000 1 28.03.02 589 204003 Long Hor Snour 2 22.67 12 272.04 156000 156000 272.04 312000 1 28.03.02 590 204004 Loch Son Snour 2 23.23 12 278.76 156000 78000 278.76 234000 1 28.03.02 591 202005 Bet Bounhean Snour 1 30.01 4.5 135.04 156000 156000 135.04 312000 1 28.03.02 592 202006 Bet Bonhan Snour 1 15.18 4.5 68.31 156000 156000 68.31 312000 1 28.03.02 593 201006 Peng Ouen Snour 1 18 4.5 81 156000 156000 81 312000 1 28.03.02 594 201005 Kong Many Snour 2 23.56 12 282.72 156000 156000 81 312000 1 18.03.02 595 203007 Chhon Vanna Snour 2 25.44 12 171.72 156000 156000 282.72 312000 1 28.03.02 596 203009 Sean Chea Snour 1 38.16 4.5 140.4 156000 156000 171.72 312000 1 28.03.02 597 203010 Kong Bai Snour 1 OW 31.2 4.5 50 50 190.4 156000 156000 190.4 312000 1 28.03.02 598 202016 Loeum Kon Snour 2 OW 20.7 12 50 148.4 50 298.4 156000 78000 298.4 468000 1 28.32002 599 204012 Sat Ret Snour 2 OW 61.6 12 50 739.2 50 789.2 156000 156000 394.6 394.6 156000 156000 2 28/3/02 600 201013 Heng Mom Snour 1 OW 14 4.5 50 63 50 113 156000 156000 113 312000 1 28/3/02 601 201012 Ké Mei Snour 1 OW 20 4.5 50 90 50 140 156000 156000 140 312000 1 28/3/02 602 203016 Chip Sann Snour 1 OW 16 4.5 50 72 50 12 156000 78000 156000 122 390000 1 28/3/02 603 204007 Koeum SengKim Snour 2 77 12 924 156000 156000 462 462 156000 156000 2 28/3/02 604 201009 Sam San Snour 2 18.9 12 226.8 156000 226.8 156000 1 28/3/02 605 201010 Yean Sophean Snour 1 34.96 4.5 157.32 156000 156000 157.32 312000 1 28/3/02 606 201008 Saom Nakry Snour 1 OW 19.24 4.5 50 86.58 50 136.58 156000 156000 136.58 312000 1 28/3/02 607 202017 Pa Buntheun Snour 2 40.8 12 50 50 539.6 156000 156000 539.6 312000 1 28/3/02 608 202011 Thav Tho Snour 1 21.6 4.5 97.2 156000 78000 156000 97.2 390000 1 28/3/02 609 202014 Theng Vanak Snour 2 56.26 12 675.12 156000 156000 675.12 312000 1 28/3/02 610 202015 Chiv Mein Snour 1 15.17 4.5 68.26 156000 156000 68.26 312000 1 28/3/02 611 204005 Kem Sareun Snour 2 66 12 792 156000 156000 396 396 156000 156000 2 28/3/02 612 202012 Chhang Vech Snour 2 17.5 12 210 156000 156000 210 312000 1 28/3/02 613 203018 Sor Ret Snour 2 20.01 12 240.12 156000 240.12 156000 1 28/3/02 614 203012 Chhang Neang Snour 2 37.44 12 449.28 156000 156000 449.28 312000 1 28/3/02 615 203013 Tear Khang Snour 2 26.46 12 317.52 156000 156000 317.52 312000 1 28/3/02 616 204010 Chhang Yen Snour 1 25.37 4.5 114.16 156000 156000 114.16 312000 1 28/03/02 617 201011 Soam Bross Snour 2 32 12 384 156000 156000 384 312000 1 28/3/02 618 203011 Men Vongdy Snour 1 13.02 4.5 58.59 156000 58.59 156000 1 28/3/02 619 203004 Phan Pheun Snour 2 16.64 12 199.68 156000 156000 199.68 312000 1 28/3/02 620 202019 Kong Kroueng Snour OW 0 50 50 50 1 28/3/02 621 204001 Sen Lip Snour 2 17.91 12 215.28 156000 215.28 156000 1 28/3/02 622 202002 Vanna Nalin Snour 2 16 12 192 156000 78000 192 234000 1 28/3/02 623 202003 Heng Hong Snour 10 13 4.5 58.5 58.5 1 28/3/02 624 203003 So Seun Snour 2 19.84 12 238.08 156000 78000 156000 238.08 390000 1 28/3/02 625 203006 Sok Sorin Snour B 14.72 4.5 66.24 66.24 1dk 626 203005 Ming Kha Snour 1 15.58 4.5 70.11 156000 78000 156000 70.11 390000 1 28/3/02
8 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 627 201003 Doung Pach Snour 2 30 12 360 156000 78000 156000 360 390000 1 28/3/02 628 202010 Sé Viseth Snour 2 18.13 12 217.56 156000 217.56 156000 1 28/3/02 629 202004 Yen Monoarom Snour 2 17.62 12 211.44 156000 156000 211.44 312000 1 28/3/02 630 201007 Nou Loun Snour 1 45.36 4.5 204.12 156000 156000 204.12 312000 1 28/3/02 631 202009 Soeum Nai Orn Snour 1 20.58 4.5 92.61 156000 78000 156000 92.61 390000 1 28/3/02 632 202008 Hout Maran Snour 1 OW 15.5 4.5 50 69.75 50 119.75 156000 156000 119.75 312000 1 28/3/02 633 203014 Tronu Snour 2 30.24 12 362.88 156000 156000 362.88 312000 1 28/3/02 634 203008 Pen Sara Snour 2 68.04 12 816.48 156000 156000 408.24 408.24 156000 156000 2 28/3/02 635 201002 Out Vothy Snour 2 OW 45.9 12 50 550.8 50 600.8 156000 156000 300.4 300.4 156000 156000 2 28/3/02 636 202018 Tear Hark Snour 2 OW 60.06 12 50 720.72 50 770.72 156000 156000 770.72 312000 1 28/3/02 637 204006 Ton Bro Snour 2 24.2 12 290.4 156000 156000 290.4 312000 1 28/3/02 638 202013 Morn Chem Snour 2 28.06 12 336.72 156000 156000 336.72 312000 1 28/3/02 639 Hem Sareun Snour dk 0 Dk dk 640 Sor Saret Snour dk 0 Dk dk 641 Phang Man Iy Snour dk 0 Dk dk 642 Soun Sophé Snour dk 0 Dk dk 643 Mat Soeub Snour dk 0 Dk dk 644 Hun phalla Snour dk 0 Dk dk 645 Hark Sokhorn Snour dk 0 Dk dk 646 203015 Korn Heng Snour 2 38.5 12 462 156000 462 390000 1 28/3/02 647 203017 Hong Kheun Snour 2 44 12 528 156000 156000 528 312000 1 28/3/02 648 202007 Seng hy Snour 2 9.35 12 112.2 156000 112.2 156000 1 28/03/02 649 204008 Meun Chhout Snour 2 31.53 12 378.36 156000 156000 378.36 312000 1 28/4/02 Total 63 1555.27 18.91 0 560 0 14523.6 917.32 3852.3 8268000 546000 78000 78000 6552000 13959.88 1961.24 0 15210000 780000 0 650 302030 Thouv Chantha Sourng 3 18.18 85 1545.3 156000 772.65 78000 1 25/06/02 651 302031 Min Thai Sourng 3 18.04 85 1533.4 156000 78000 766.7 117000 1 25/06/02 652 302032 Nang Bunsan Sourng 3 19.4 85 1649 156000 156000 824.5 117000 1 25/06/02 653 302033 Tek Lemheng Sourng 2 8.1 12 97.2 156000 97.2 156000 1 25/06/02 654 003034 SOUNG Hean Sourng 3 9.6 85 816 156000 408 78000 1 17/01/01 655 003021 KIM NgounHeng Sourng F 8 4.86 38.88 38.88 1 17/01/2001 656 004013 CHHEAK Sopheap Sourng F 8.3 4.86 40.33 40.33 1 17/01/2001 657 003022 MAO Sok Sourng F OW 12 4.86 50 58.32 50 108.32 108.32 1 17/01/2001 658 004014 MUY Keang Sourng F OW 20 4.86 50 97.2 50 147.2 1 17/01/2001 659 005009 TRI Vannak Sourng F 38.3 4.86 137.54 137.54 1 17/01/2001 660 004015 YOEUNG KimOrn Sourng OW 0 50 50 50 1 17/01/2001 661 005010 SEUR Heun Sourng F 5 4.86 24.3 24.3 1 17/01/2001 662 005012 Neang Sourng F 5.5 4.86 26.73 26.73 1 17/01/2001 663 001015 VECH Pang Sourng PW F 810 75 4.86 75 39.36 114.36 114.36 1 17/01/2001 664 005011 CHHEAK Sopeap Sourng F 18.13 4.86 88.11 88.11 1 17/01/2001 665 003023 VA Srey Sourng F 21.5 0.75 16.12 16.12 1 17/01/2001 666 003024 KHANN Sotha Sourng F 9.5 4.86 46.17 46.17 1 17/01/2001 667 302012 KHANN Sothoeun Sourng 4 18.80 140 2632.00 156000 1316 78000 1 DK 668 302011 SOM Saret Sourng 4 17.09 140 2392.60 156000 1196.3 78000 1 DK 669 302010 HENG Deun Sourng 4 16.40 140 2296.00 156000 1148 78000 1 DK 670 302009 OUK Hur Sourng 4 16.00 140 2240.00 156000 1120 78000 1 DK 671 302008 HONG SothyLa Sourng 4 16.40 140 2296.00 156000 1148 78000 1 DK 672 302007 PANG Sruy Sourng 3 16.62 85 1412.70 156000 706.35 78000 1 DK 673 302006 CHHEY Srun Sourng 3 16.40 85 1394.00 156000 697 78000 1 DK 674 302016 TAING Chour Sourng 3 14.06 85 1195.10 156000 597.55 78000 1 DK 675 302017 SAIM Heang Sourng 3 13.70 85 1164.50 156000 582.25 78000 1 DK 676 302018 YU NgounEang Sourng 3 14.00 85 1190.00 156000 595 78000 1 DK 677 003029 KONG Sokun Sourng 2 8.61 12 103.32 156000 103.32 156000 1 28/02/2002 678 004044 CHEANG Sinila Sourng 4 PW 16.80 140 2352.00 75.00 156000 DK DK DK DK 679 01028 TOEUK Kimsrun Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 680 001022 LEANG Hang Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 681 001020 POEUK Chhunny Sourng 4 16.4 140 2296 156000 78000 1148 117000 1 17/01/2001 682 005013 HUR YuThai Sourng 4 22.56 140 3158.4 156000 1579.2 78000 1 17/01/2001 683 005016 LOA SyHoung Sourng 4 22.56 140 3158.4 156000 1579.2 78000 1 17/01/2001 684 003040 KOR Trey Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 685 005019 THAI Ngonn Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 686 003039 NGAND Ky Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 687 004036 KHUY Hong Sourng 3 18 85 1530 156000 765 459 306 78000 46800 31200 6 17/01/2001 688 004018 KAING TaiHang Sourng 2 3.75 12 45 156000 45 156000 1 17/01/2001 689 004026 TAING Ngonn Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 690 003038 LIM Try Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 7800 1 17/01/2001 691 005023 HU Yuthai Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 692 005023 CHHUN Chang Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 693 001014 SARO Sytha Sourng F 15.5 4.86 75.33 75.33 1 15/01/2001 694 004017 YU Ly Sourng F 15.5 4.86 75.33 75.33 1 17/01/2001 695 003018 PAL Salim Sourng F 36 4.86 174.96 174.96 1 17/01/2001 696 003035 MENG Kong Sourng 3 9.6 85 816 156000 408 78000 1 17/01/2001 697 003036 KIM Eang Sourng 3 12.6 85 1071 156000 535.5 78000 1 17/01/2001 698 003045 SEAV Im Sourng 3 13.05 85 1109.25 156000 554.62 78000 1 17/01/2001 699 004021 AOEUNG Muyheang Sourng 2 11.25 12 135 156000 135 156000 1 17/01/2001 700 004022 PHEN Sreang Sourng 2 11.25 12 135 156000 135 156000 1 17/01/2001 701 004023 PHEN Aang Sourng 2 11.57 12 138.9 156000 78000 138.9 234000 1 17/01/2001 702 004024 MUY Heang Sourng 2 11.325 12 135.9 156000 135.9 156000 1 17/01/2001 703 004025 BRAK Long Sourng 2 11.75 12 141 156000 141 156000 1 17/01/2001 704 005022 Seang KimSreang Sourng 3 20.4 85 1734 156000 78000 867 117000 1 17/01/2001 705 005024 KKAV Mang Sourng 2 11.25 12 135 156000 135 156000 1 17/01/2001
9 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 706 005028 KONG Hort Sourng DK 11.88 12 142.56 156000 142.56 156000 1 17/01/2001 707 005031 Peng Tong Sourng DK 28 85 2380 156000 1190 78000 1 17/01/2001 708 005027 LAY Srun Sourng 3 14.55 85 1236.75 156000 618.38 78000 1 17/01/2001 709 003046 LY Sok Kheang Sourng 4 21.165 140 2963.1 156000 1481.55 78000 1 17/01/2001 710 004031 YANG Dat Sourng 4 18 140 2520 156000 1260 756 78000 46000 2 17/01/2001 711 004029 SRUN SukHang Sourng 4 18.91 140 2648.77 156000 1324.38 794.63 529.76 78000 46800 31200 2 17/01/2001 712 004030 SUN Nhe Sourng 3 21.75 85 1848.75 156000 924.37 554.62 369.76 78000 1 17/01/2001 713 004028 TOUCH Lyphu Sourng 4 18.91 140 2648.77 156000 1324.38 794.63 529.76 78000 46800 31200 2 17/01/2001 714 005025 CHRER Phuy Sourng 4 12.3 140 1722 156000 861 156000 1 17/01/2001 715 005026 SUN Heang Sourng 3 14.1 85 1198.5 156000 599.25 78000 1 17/01/2001 716 005030 Sourng BunAeng Sourng 3 18 85 1530 156000 765 78000 1 17/01/2001 717 001032 TRY Sok Sourng 2 9.5 12 114 156000 114 156000 1 17/01/2001 718 005032 SOA Aeng Sourng F 19.5 4.86 94.77 94.77 1 17/01/2001 719 005033 AOEUNG Soyunn Sourng F 10.2 4.86 49.57 49.57 1 17/01/2001 720 003025 CHANN Thorn Sourng 4 16 140 2240 156000 1120 78000 1 17/01/2001 721 001018 BUN Srun Sourng 4 16.3 140 2282 156000 1141 78000 1 17/01/2001 722 003015 Eng Sothea Sourng F 23.6 4.86 114.7 144.7 1 17/01/2001 723 005008 HENG Sopheap Sourng F 14.5 4.86 70.47 70.47 1 17/01/2001 724 004016 CHEAM Thok Sourng F 24 4.86 117.61 117.61 1 17/01/2001 725 005007 BUN Ly Sourng F 22.1 4.86 107.4 107.4 1 17/01/01 726 004010 CHANN Ban Sourng F 30 4.86 145.8 145.8 1 17/01/2001 727 004011 KHUN Vichet Sourng F 4.9 4.86 23.81 23.81 1 17/01/2001 728 003020 LONG Thuk Sourng 1 18.92 4.5 85.14 156000 156000 85.14 312000 1 17/01/2001 729 003017 NIV Nea Sourng F 18 4.86 87.48 87.48 1 17/01/2001 730 003016 CHHEANG PengHoa Sourng 1 49 4.5 220.5 156000 156000 220.5 312000 1 17/01/2001 731 003019 TAING NaiSeng Sourng 2 70 12 840 156000 156000 420 156000 1 17/01/2001 732 001017 MEAS Ly Sourng 2 OW 34.88 12 50 418.56 50 468.56 156000 78000 156000 468.56 390000 1 17/01/2001 733 004012 MOANH Lyheang Sourng 1 6.72 4.5 31.36 156000 31.36 156000 1 17/01/2001 734 001016 YU Iv Sourng F 28.25 4.86 137.29 137.29 1 17/01/2001 735 302013 Tea Sreng Sourng 4 21.18 140 2965.2 156000 1482.6 78000 1 25.06.02 736 302014 Chhay Niam Sourng 4 18.22 140 2550.8 156000 1275.4 78000 1 25.06.02 737 302015 Oung Mengly Sourng OW 1.00 50 50 1 25.06.02 738 302024 Heng Sokhai Sourng 4 18.58 140 2601.2 156000 1300.6 7800 1 25.06.02 739 302034 Miam Toma Sourng 2 8.10 12 97.2 156000 97.2 156000 1 25.06.02 740 302019 Pau Suyheang Sourng 4 18.63 140 2608.2 156000 1304.1 7800 1 25.06.02 741 302023 Cheang Leanggegh Sourng 4 18.63 140 2608.2 156000 1304.1 7800 1 25.06.02 742 302020 Soeum Sithov Sourng 4 18.31 140 2563.4 156000 1281.7 7800 1 25.06.02 743 302021 Moeung Senghout Sourng 4 18.58 140 2601.2 156000 1300.6 78000 1 25.06.02 744 302022 Chea Menghav Sourng 4 18.45 140 2583 156000 1291.5 78000 1 25.06.02 745 302025 Tiang Seang Sourng 3 18.22 85 1548.7 156000 774.35 7800 1 25.06.02 746 302026 Toeuk Sron Sourng 3 18.38 85 1562.3 156000 481.15 78000 1 25.06.02 747 302027 Kim Heng Sourng 3 18.40 85 1564 156000 782 78000 1 25.06.02 748 302028 Keat Chhin Sourng 3 18.18 85 1545.3 156000 772.65 78000 1 25.06.02 749 302029 Yoeum Hour Sourng 3 18.42 85 1565.7 156000 782.85 78000 1 25.06.02 750 401006 Heng Douen Sourng F 4.86 174.96 174.96 1 25.06.02 751 001013 Kim Thia Sourng 8 0 40 40 156000 50 156000 1 dk 752 003027 MEY Sytha Sourng 4 17.1 140 2394 156000 1197 78000 1 17/01/01 753 003026 LY Keu Sourng 4 17.1 140 2394 156000 1197 78000 1 17/01/01 754 003028 LIM SokLay Sourng 2 16.75 12 201 156000 201 156000 1 17/01/01 755 005015 HUY VanDeun Sourng 2 28.83 85 2450.55 156000 1225.27 78000 1 17/01/01 756 001023 SOEUM Sok Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 757 003031 CHEA An Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 758 003030 CHHEANG Lang Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 759 005018 TAING PokHeng Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 760 001027 SSONG Pha Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 761 001026 HUY Son Sourng 3 16 85 1360 156000 680 78000 1 17/01/01 762 005020 KEK Hung Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 763 004027 PHEANG Njok Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 764 003033 EAP BunHey Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 765 001021 POV Phang Sourng 3 18.26 85 1552.1 156000 776.05 78000 1 17/01/01 766 003032 SOK Kim Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 767 004019 KEO Vud Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 768 001029 THEAM Nov Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 769 005029 ENG Vibol Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 770 003042 YU Hong Sourng 3 9 85 765 156000 382.5 78000 1 17/01/01 771 005017 LY Kornn Sourng 3 18 85 1530 156000 78000 765 117000 1 17/01/01 772 005014 BUN Norn Sourng 3 18 85 1530 156000 765 78000 1 17/01/01 773 005021 LY LongSrun Sourng 3 45.9 85 3901.5 156000 1950.75 78000 1 17/01/01 774 003043 VOV Chhung Sourng 3 0 85 3684.75 156000 1842.375 78000 1 17/01/01 775 003044 ROV Sophal Sourng 3 9.75 85 828.75 156000 414.37 78000 1 17/01/01 776 003041 KHAN Srey Sourng 3 13 85 1360 156000 680 78000 1 17/01/01 777 003037 TAING LeakChay Sourng 3 9.6 85 816 156000 445.5 78000 1 17/01/01 Total 128 2780.25 0 0 141153.96 264.36 691.24 15756000 390000 78000 0 780000 71675.225 3358.88 1735.28 9757800 186400 93600 778 004032 AEL Phoass Srolobb 1 23.76 4.5 106.92 156000 78000 78000 156000 106.92 468000 1 2001 779 004042 YAP SaiNob Srolobb 1 16.45 4.5 74.02 156000 78000 156000 74.02 390000 1 2001 780 005034 KIM Leng Srolobb 1 12 4.5 54 156000 78000 54 234000 1 01/02/2001 781 001031 MOKK KimLang Srolobb 2 10.21 12 122.52 156000 78000 122.52 234000 1 01/01/2001 782 001033 POL An Srolobb PW 0 75 75 75 1 01/02/2001 783 003047 GNI Heng Srolobb 2 12.15 12 145.8 156000 145.8 156000 1 01/02/2001 784 003048 DA Srolobb 1 12.71 4.5 57.19 156000 156000 57.19 312000 1 01/02/2001
10 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 785 003049 BAN HungInn Srolobb 1 16.34 4.5 73.53 156000 156000 73.53 312000 1 01/02/2001 786 003050 TECH Tha Srolobb OW 0 50 50 50 1 01/02/2001 Total 9 103.62 0 0 758.98 0 0 1092000 312000 0 78000 624000 758.98 0 0 2106000 0 0 787 204014 Heang Seng Svay Chras 2 22.32 12 287.84 156000 78000 267.84 234000 1 29/5/02 788 204013 Chhuy Vanny Svay Chras 2 21.12 12 253.44 156000 253.44 156000 1 29/3/02 Total 2 43.44 0 0 541.28 0 0 312000 0 0 78000 0 521.28 0 0 390000 0 0 789 302001 Phoeum Savet Treak 1 10.07 4.5 45.31 156000 156000 45.31 312000 1 25.02.02 790 302005 Chor Yoeum Treak 2 6.27 12 75.24 156000 75.24 156000 1 25.02.02 791 303001 Min Thy Treak 2 9 12 108 156000 108 156000 1 25.02.02 792 301045 Kour Mengleang Treak 3 35 0 2975 156000 156000 1487.5 1487.5 156000 156000 2 dk 793 301046 Kim Mong Treak 2 36.2 0 434.88 156000 156000 434.88 312000 1 dk 794 303047 Hout Bros Treak 2 48 576 576 156000 156000 576 312000 1 dk 795 304043 Dim SreyThat Treak 3 17 0 1445 156000 722.5 722.5 78000 78000 2 dk 796 303048 Douen Vannouen Treak 2 38 456 456 156000 156000 456 312000 1 dk Total 8 199.54 0 0 6115.43 0 0 1248000 0 0 0 780000 3449.43 2666 0 1482000 546000 0 797 304016 Dou Ngokam Tror Mung 2 25.2 12 302.4 156000 302.4 156000 1 26/02/02 798 304017 Kim Chu Tror Mung OW 0 50 50 50 1 26/02/02 799 304018 Tea Kimhuy Tror Mung 2 F 49 12 12 4.86 588 24.3 156000 156000 306.15 306.15 156000 156000 2 07/03/2002 800 304019 Tem Choung Tror Mung 1 17.76 4.5 79.92 156000 156000 79.92 312000 1 26/02/02 801 302038 Sun Nari Tror Mung 3 12.6 51 642.6 156000 312.3 78000 1 13/03/02 802 301007 Hourng Sokheang Tror Mung dk OW 15.075 85 50 1281.37 50 156000 665.687 399.412 266.276 78000 46800 31200 3 dk 803 303006 Sok Chang Tror Mung 3 PW 14.52 85 75 1234.2 75 156000 654.6 392.76 261.84 78000 46800 31200 3 dk 804 303017 Hut Ormrin Tror Mung 3 20.46 85 1739.1 156000 869.55 521.73 347.82 78000 46800 31200 3 dk 805 304041 Keav Kun Tror Mung 2 57.8 12 693.6 156000 156000 693.6 312000 1 dk 806 304029 Kuov Sru Tror Mung 3 15.4 85 13.9 156000 654.5 654.5 78000 78000 2 dk 807 304029 Kim Chanthol Tror Mung 3 18.5 85 1572.5 156000 785.25 785.25 78000 78000 2 dk 808 304042 Houen Hong Tror Mung 3 19.8 85 1683 156000 841.5 841.5 78000 78000 2 dk 809 304036 Leng Nary Tror Mung 2 51.3 12 615.6 156000 156000 615.6 312000 1 dk 810 304040 Taing Soytry Tror Mung 2 54.3 12 651.6 156000 651.6 156000 1 dk 811 304038 Mouy Ngim Tror Mung 3 32.4 85 2754 156000 1377 1377 78000 78000 2 dk 812 301030 Chhoy Sreang Tror Mung dk 9.91 4.5 44.59 156000 156000 44.59 312000 1 26.02.02 813 401001 Seang Siphan Tror Mung F 20.6 4.86 138.99 138.99 1dk 814 302045 Kim Lot Tror Mung OW 0 50 50 1 50 1 26.02.01 815 302046 Ly Chheng Tror Mung 2 19.72 12 237.12 156000 156000 237.12 312000 1 26.02.01 816 302047 Sian Yort Tror Mung 1 15.92 4.5 71.64 156000 156000 71.64 312000 1 26.02.01 817 303036 Ky Sophy Tror Mung 2 13.95 12 167.4 156000 167.4 156000 1 26.02.02 818 302050 Ngin Ry Tror Mung 1 9 4.5 40.5 156000 156000 40.5 312000 1 26.02.02 819 304020 Seit Sunheng Tror Mung F 15 0.75 11.25 11.25 1 26.02.02 820 304021 Teab Naret Tror Mung F 27 0.75 20.25 20.25 1 26.02.02 821 303029 Sin Mab Tror Mung 1 8.06 4.5 36.27 156000 156000 36.27 312000 1 26.02.02 822 303030 Rous Khhoun Tror Mung 1 9 4.5 40.5 156000 156000 40.5 312000 1 26.02.02 823 302051 Meas Saret Tror Mung 1 10.5 4.5 47.25 156000 156000 47.25 312000 1 26.02.01 824 303028 Tong Keaseng Tror Mung 1 158.6 4.5 713.7 156000 156000 356.85 356.85 156000 156000 2 26.02.02 825 302049 Som Souen Tror Mung 1 40.74 4.5 183.33 156000 156000 183.33 312000 1 26.02.02 Total 29 762.115 12 0 15704.58 149.3 0 3744001 0 0 0 2028000 10305.597 5635.152 875.936 4836000 764400 93600 826 302058 Mearn Vannar Tun Lung 1 15.47 4.5 69.61 156000 156000 69.61 312000 1 26/02/02 827 302059 Hum Hing Tun Lung 1 12.67 4.5 57.01 156000 156000 57.01 312000 1 26/02/02 828 303039 Bhork Pearn Tun Lung 1 14 4.5 63 156000 78000 156000 63 390000 1 26/02/02 829 304026 Sim Hearn Tun Lung 1 15.4 4.5 69.3 156000 156000 69.3 312000 1 26/02/02 830 304024 Vik Ni Tun Lung 1 18.8 4.5 84.6 156000 78000 156000 84.6 390000 1 26/02/02 831 304022 Nhor Hearn Tun Lung 1 8.1 4.5 36.45 156000 78000 156000 36.45 390000 1 26/02/02 832 304023 Kol Smean Tun Lung 1 10.24 4.5 46.08 156000 78000 156000 46.08 390000 1 26.02.02 833 304027 Mogn Somnang Tun Lung dk 0 dk 156000 dk 156000 1 26.02.02 834 302061 Theng Chhon Tun Lung 2 38.98 12 467.76 156000 156000 467.76 312000 1 26.02.02 835 302062 Chiang Kimsreang Tun Lung 2 59.06 12 708.72 156000 78000 156000 354.36 195000 1 26.02.02 836 302063 Hoeum Srouen Tun Lung 2 15.78 12 189.36 156000 156000 189.36 312000 1 26.02.02 837 304031 Chhoun Khoun Tun Lung 1 21 4.5 94.5 156000 78000 156000 94.5 390000 1 26.02.02 838 304030 Chhoun Korm Tun Lung 1 22.26 4.5 100.17 156000 78000 156000 100.17 390000 1 26.02.02 839 304029 Seang Sary Tun Lung 1 55.89 4.5 251.5 156000 156000 251.5 312000 1 26.02.02 840 304028 Seang Chanthy Tun Lung 1 8.58 4.5 38.61 156000 78000 156000 38.61 390000 1 26.02.02 841 303038 Phal Phea Tun Lung 1 14.19 4.5 63.85 156000 156000 63.85 312000 1 26.02.02 842 303035 Pein Thy Tun Lung 1 14.82 4.5 66.69 156000 78000 156000 66.69 390000 1 26.02.02 843 304025 Chhoeung Sok Tun Lung 1 18.15 4.5 81.67 156000 156000 81.67 312000 1 26.02.02 844 303036 Pov Ren Tun Lung 1 22.62 4.5 101.79 156000 156000 101.79 312000 1 26.02.02 845 303037 Aul Ouen Tun Lung 1 11.88 4.5 53.46 156000 78000 156000 53.46 390000 1 26.02.02 846 302052 Pouk man Tun Lung 2 41.81 12 501.72 156000 dk dk Dk 26.02.02 847 301031 Toch chenda Tun Lung 2 53.72 12 644.64 156000 156000 322.32 322.32 156000 156000 2 26.02.02 848 301032 Louem Simouv Tun Lung 2 25.42 12 305.04 156000 305.04 156000 1 26.02.02 849 302056 Pang Kimlohn Tun Lung 2 30.23 12 362.76 156000 78000 362.76 234000 1 26.02.02 850 302060 Kan Sokhem Tun Lung 2 26 12 312 156000 312 156000 1 26.02.02 851 302055 Kan Doer Tun Lung 2 18.51 12 222.12 156000 156000 222.12 312000 1 26.02.02 852 301034 Din Ne Tun Lung 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 156000 60.48 156000 1 26.02.02 853 301037 Ngoun Chear Tun Lung 2 11.78 12 141.36 156000 78000 156000 141.36 390000 1 26.02.02 854 301033 Ouen Chenda Tun Lung 1 34.31 4.5 154.4 156000 154.4 156000 1 26.02.02 855 301035 Chan Cheun Tun Lung 1 12.8 4.5 57.6 156000 156000 57.6 312000 1 26.02.02 856 302057 Soy Chanda Tun Lung 1 13.16 4.5 59.22 156000 78000 78000 156000 59.22 468000 1 26.02.02 857 303041 Khen Khorn Tun Lung 1 20.397 4.5 91.78 156000 156000 91.78 312000 1 26.02.02 858 303040 Tang Ren Tun Lung 1 12.4 4.5 55.8 156000 156000 55.8 312000 1 26.02.02 859 303042 Peon Heng Tun Lung 1 30.6 4.5 137.7 156000 156000 137.7 312000 1 26.02.02 860 303043 Seng som Tun Lung 1 6.3 4.5 28.35 156000 156000 28.35 312000 1 26.02.02
11 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 17 COMPENSATION AND OTHER ENTITLEMENTS RECEIVED BY ALL PAPs (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and IRC records)
Total Acquired Fixed Assets Other Assistance Amount Paid Income <$10 per No. of IRC Commune's Disturbance Female Disable month Shifting Paymen Last Date No. Code HH Head's Name Name Affected AssetsArea Acquired (m2) Unit Cost $/m2 Total Amount (Riel) head (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) (Riel) US$ Riels t of Payment 861 305001 Ly Heng Tun Lung 1 9.84 4.5 44.28 156000 156000 44.28 312000 1 26.02.02 862 305002 Pov Hong Tun Lung 1 11.2 4.5 50.4 156000 156000 50.4 312000 1 26.02.02 863 305004 Lunch Sorn Tun Lung 1 9.57 4.5 43.06 156000 156000 43.06 312000 1 26.02.02 864 305005 En Sisophan Tun Lung 1 9.86 4.5 44.37 156000 156000 44.37 312000 1 26.02.02 865 303031 Soy Sitha Tun Lung 1 26.46 4.5 119.07 156000 156000 119.07 312000 1 26.02.02 866 303032 Chhon Chay Tun Lung 2 20.415 12 244.98 156000 156000 244.98 312000 1 26.02.02 867 303033 Kong Jha Tun Lung 1 17.042 4.5 76.69 156000 156000 76.69 312000 1 26.02.02 868 301038 Koe Yeng Tun Lung 1 17.82 4.5 80.19 156000 156000 80.19 312000 1 26.02.02 869 301039 Meas Chan Tun Lung 1 14.28 4.5 64.26 156000 156000 64.26 312000 1 26.02.02 870 301041 Tho Somnang Tun Lung 1 16.56 4.5 74.92 156000 156000 74.92 312000 1 26.02.02 871 303034 Yean Sorn Tun Lung 1 5.28 4.5 23.76 156000 78000 78000 78000 156000 23.76 546000 1 26.02.02 872 305003 Toch Saren Tun Lung 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 156000 156000 60.48 312000 1 26.02.02 873 301040 En Sotheary Tun Lung 1 31.72 4.5 142.74 156000 156000 142.74 312000 1 26.02.02 Total 48 952.254 0 0 6848.3 0 0 7488000 546000 78000 702000 6396000 5323.9 668.32 0 14001000 858000 0 874 001042 Po Thet Vihear Loung dk 0 156000 156000 0 0 dk dk 875 001019 VAO Chhung DK 4 16 140 2240 156000 1120 78000 1 17/01/01 Total 2 16 2240 312000 156000 1120 78000 Grand-Total 875 17,010.55 396.77 10.04 405,614.34 15,168.80 19,206.51 107,484,001 5,460,000 624,000 1,716,000 49,764,000 764,978.54 98,566.54 12,460.73 138,413,614 16,051,000 982,800
12 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Area Excess Buildin Acquired Unit Cost Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be No. IRC Code HH Head Commune g Type (m2) ($/m2) Amount Due ($US) (US$) Paid (US$) 1 003001 Dorm Phana Anlung Vel 2 5.50 12.00 66.00 66.00 0.00 0.00 2 001001 Dum Doy Anlung Vel 2 6.50 12.00 78.00 78.00 0.00 0.00 3 004001 Horn Yat Anlung Vel 2 5.94 12.00 71.28 71.28 0.00 0.00 4 004002 Hun Vebull Anlung Vel 2 9.45 12.00 113.40 113.40 0.00 0.00 5 002002 Kourm Somnang Anlung Vel 1 2.46 4.50 11.07 11.07 0.00 0.00 6 002001 Vann Saveurn Anlung Vel 1 24.00 4.50 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 7 001002 Puy Heurn Anlung Vel 2 21.70 12.00 260.40 260.40 0.00 0.00 Total 7 APs 75.55 708.15 708.15 0.00 0.00 8 003003 Chan Lach Au dombong II 1 16.10 4.50 72.45 72.45 0.00 0.00 9 001003 Chea Chao Au dombong II 2 18.80 12.00 225.60 225.60 0.00 0.00 10 002003 Chey Lim Au dombong II 1 6.24 4.50 28.08 28.08 0.00 0.00 11 004003 Lai Kek Au dombong II 2 12.50 12.00 150.00 150.00 0.00 0.00 12 003002 Yeurn Sdeng Au dombong II 1 27.90 4.50 125.55 125.55 0.00 0.00 Total 5 APs 81.54 601.68 601.68 0.00 0.00 13 004045 Poch Porn Boeng Khnar 1 30.00 4.50 135.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 14 003050 Toang Run Boeng Khnar 2 15.51 12.00 186.12 186.12 0.00 0.00 Total 2 APs 45.51 321.12 321.12 0.00 0.00 15 003018 Chhai Sophall Kear 2 44.40 12.00 532.80 532.80 0.00 0.00 16 002019 Gnourn Yeurn Kear 1 8.75 4.50 39.38 39.37 0.00 0.01 17 001019 Ken Seirn Kear 1 18.80 4.50 84.60 84.60 0.00 0.00 18 001018 Kre Salort Kear 1 11.20 4.50 50.40 50.40 0.00 0.00 19 004020 Mum Phally Kear 2 11.75 12.00 141.00 141.00 0.00 0.00 20 002020 Pheing Gnaur Kear 2 12.00 12.00 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 Total 6 APs 106.90 992.18 992.17 0.00 0.01 21 001008 Chann Sombath Kom Pung Preang 1 18.20 4.50 81.90 81.90 0.00 0.00 22 003017 Cheark Meas Kom Pung Preang 2 31.20 12.00 374.40 374.40 0.00 0.00 23 003011 Chen Sunn Kom Pung Preang 1 8.82 4.50 39.69 39.69 0.00 0.00 24 001011 Chhoeum Bunchhung Kom Pung Preang 2 4.65 12.00 55.80 55.80 0.00 0.00 25 003010 Chhoeum Sophunn Kom Pung Preang 2 20.14 12.00 241.68 241.68 0.00 0.00 26 001010 Dek Ken Kom Pung Preang 1 14.28 4.50 64.26 64.26 0.00 0.00 27 003016 Heing Hery Kom Pung Preang 1 11.20 4.50 50.40 50.40 0.00 0.00 28 001007 Horng Sareurn Kom Pung Preang 1 20.35 4.50 91.58 91.57 0.00 0.01 29 040011 Kegn Theur Kom Pung Preang 1 26.46 4.50 119.07 119.07 0.00 0.00 30 004013 Keo Tha Kom Pung Preang 1 11.96 4.50 53.82 53.82 0.00 0.00 31 003008 Koeum Chanra Kom Pung Preang 1 4.80 4.50 21.60 21.60 0.00 0.00 32 004010 Koeum Keng Kom Pung Preang 1 32.30 4.50 145.35 145.35 0.00 0.00 33 002010 Meak Saven Kom Pung Preang 1 10.14 4.50 45.63 45.63 0.00 0.00 34 001012 Moung Kachreb Kom Pung Preang 1 10.00 4.50 45.00 45.00 0.00 0.00 35 002009 Oeum Chen Kom Pung Preang 1 14.00 4.50 63.00 63.00 0.00 0.00 36 001012 Pen Reurm Kom Pung Preang 1 11.55 4.50 51.98 51.97 0.00 0.01 37 003007 Pheing Veasna Kom Pung Preang 2 25.35 12.00 304.20 304.20 0.00 0.00 38 001009 Reurn Theurn Kom Pung Preang 2 10.50 12.00 126.00 126.00 0.00 0.00 39 004012 Ros Sareurn Kom Pung Preang 1 10.20 4.50 45.90 45.90 0.00 0.00 40 002008 Seing Yan Kom Pung Preang 1 9.12 4.50 41.04 41.04 0.00 0.00 41 002011 Soeung Pei Kom Pung Preang 2 25.20 12.00 302.40 302.40 0.00 0.00 42 002007 Sorn La Kom Pung Preang 1 29.15 4.50 131.18 131.18 0.00 0.00 43 004009 Sours Buntha Kom Pung Preang 1 19.20 4.50 86.40 86.40 0.00 0.00 44 003009 Yoeum Kung Kom Pung Preang 2 17.10 12.00 205.20 205.20 0.00 0.00 Total 24 APs 395.87 2,787.47 2,787.46 0.00 0.02 45 003005 Bau Bi Kompongpreas 1 4.20 4.50 18.90 18.90 0.00 0.00 46 003004 Bun Vanny Kompongpreas 2 18.00 12.00 216.00 216.00 0.00 0.00 47 001006 Buth Seing Kompongpreas 1 10.23 4.50 46.04 46.03 0.00 0.01 48 002005 Chen Kmao Kompongpreas 1 5.58 4.50 25.11 25.11 0.00 0.00 49 002004 Chheing Habb Kompongpreas 1 2.52 4.50 11.34 11.34 0.00 0.00 50 004004 Hoeum Chhin Kompongpreas 1 10.00 4.50 45.00 45.00 0.00 0.00 51 003006 Horm Kun Kompongpreas 2 18.50 12.00 222.00 222.00 0.00 0.00 52 004006 Meth Savat Kompongpreas 1 7.25 4.50 32.63 32.62 0.00 0.01 53 000001 Pech Mao Kompongpreas 1 5.07 4.50 22.82 22.81 0.00 0.01 54 001005 Rum Pheurn Kompongpreas 1 3.96 4.50 17.82 17.82 0.00 0.00 55 002006 Sngeun Pheap Kompongpreas 1 1.25 4.50 5.63 5.62 0.00 0.00 56 004005 Sour Chhum Kompongpreas 1 8.75 4.50 39.38 39.37 0.00 0.01 57 004007 Tann Rotha Kompongpreas 2 16.50 12.00 198.00 198.00 0.00 0.00 58 001004 Teip Sareurn Kompongpreas 1 1.40 4.50 6.30 6.30 0.00 0.00 Total 14 113.21 906.95 906.92 0.00 0.04 59 002043 AET Chhun Lor Lork Sor 1 8.60 4.50 38.70 38.70 0.00 0.00 60 002110 CHEA Chheang Lor Lork Sor 3 14.70 85.00 1,249.50 1,249.50 0.00 0.00
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Area Excess Buildin Acquired Unit Cost Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be No. IRC Code HH Head Commune g Type (m2) ($/m2) Amount Due ($US) (US$) Paid (US$) 61 002109 CHEA Eng Lor Lork Sor 3 21.00 85.00 1,785.00 1,785.00 0.00 0.00 62 004028 CHEAM Lorn Lor Lork Sor 3 26.18 85.00 2,225.30 2,225.30 0.00 0.00 63 002040 CHI Vanna Lor Lork Sor 2 12.25 12.00 147.00 147.00 0.00 0.00 64 002109 HEUN Tep Lor Lork Sor 4 34.40 140.00 4,816.00 4,816.00 0.00 0.00 65 004031 IN Hy Lor Lork Sor 2 8.40 12.00 100.80 100.80 0.00 0.00 66 002108 KA Kruch Lor Lork Sor 2 15.30 12.00 183.60 183.60 0.00 0.00 67 004027 KEO Seng Yorn Lor Lork Sor 1 19.84 4.50 89.28 103.37 14.09 0.00 68 002111 KONG Chomreun Lor Lork Sor 4 25.00 140.00 3,500.00 3,500.00 0.00 0.00 69 002041 Leang Eng Lor Lork Sor 2 13.20 12.00 158.40 158.40 0.00 0.00 70 002045 LOA hangKrey Lor Lork Sor 2 13.25 12.00 159.00 159.00 0.00 0.00 71 002044 LY Vantha Lor Lork Sor 2 17.55 12.00 210.60 210.60 0.00 0.00 72 004030 MA Roun Lor Lork Sor 2 8.40 12.00 100.80 108.80 8.00 0.00 73 003034 MOK Sahan Lor Lork Sor 2 19.25 12.00 231.00 260.64 29.64 0.00 74 004032 NGIN Vat Lor Lork Sor 2 6.40 12.00 76.80 76.80 0.00 0.00 75 003038 PENG Savchan Lor Lork Sor 2 23.00 12.00 276.00 276.00 0.00 0.00 76 003037 POA Kimsrun Lor Lork Sor 2 20.44 12.00 245.28 245.28 0.00 0.00 77 003035 SEN Somreth Lor Lork Sor 2 10.50 12.00 126.00 126.00 0.00 0.00 78 002107 SOK Kea Lor Lork Sor 3 50.00 85.00 4,250.00 4,250.00 0.00 0.00 79 002113 SOU Sokha Lor Lork Sor 2 22.13 12.00 265.56 265.56 0.00 0.00 80 001033 VA Chanthorn Lor Lork Sor 2 18.40 12.00 220.80 220.80 0.00 0.00 Total 22 408.19 20,455.42 20,507.15 51.73 0.00 81 002018 Gneirt Beurn Mong 2 4.60 12.00 55.20 55.20 0.00 0.00 82 004019 NovTheang Mong 2 2.88 12.00 34.56 34.56 0.00 0.00 Total 2 7.48 89.76 89.76 0.00 0.00 83 002057 Gnor Gnar Ou Tapoang 2 6.30 12.00 75.60 75.60 0.00 0.00 84 004047 Kang Heurb Ou Tapoang 1 20.40 4.50 91.80 91.80 0.00 0.00 85 003051 Kouk Chheng Ou Tapoang 2 16.00 12.00 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 86 004046 Leang Sokha Ou Tapoang 2 28.00 12.00 336.00 336.00 0.00 0.00 87 002055 Much Cheat Ou Tapoang 2 14.40 12.00 172.80 172.80 0.00 0.00 88 002056 Oum Ken Ou Tapoang 2 8.60 12.00 103.20 103.20 0.00 0.00 89 003053 Sok Ni Ou Tapoang 2 14.94 12.00 179.28 179.28 0.00 0.00 90 003051 Yeom Neurn Ou Tapoang 1 16.00 4.50 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00 Total 8 124.64 1,222.68 1,222.68 0.00 0.00 91 002005 Bin Ra Prey Gny 2 5.20 12.00 62.40 62.40 0.00 0.00 92 002002 Bin Sarat Prey Gny 2 39.60 12.00 475.20 475.20 0.00 0.00 93 002009 Chea Chhunleng Prey Gny 2 6.72 12.00 80.64 80.64 0.00 0.00 94 002008 Chea Sambo Prey Gny 2 28.30 12.00 339.60 339.60 0.00 0.00 95 004003 Cheurm Horn Prey Gny 3 9.30 85.00 790.50 790.50 0.00 0.00 96 001008 Cheurng Bunry Prey Gny 2 21.06 12.00 252.72 252.72 0.00 0.00 97 002006 Chhem Puk Prey Gny 2 8.55 12.00 102.60 102.60 0.00 0.00 98 001002 Chhem Sameurn Prey Gny 1 9.60 4.50 43.20 43.20 0.00 0.00 99 001021 CHHOEUN Sovouthy Prey Gny 3 17.85 85.00 1,517.25 1,517.25 0.00 0.00 100 001007 Chhun Veng Prey Gny 2 11.60 12.00 139.20 139.20 0.00 0.00 101 001006 Chiv Sueng Prey Gny 3 6.12 85.00 520.20 518.50 0.00 1.70 102 001005 Chok Savareurn Prey Gny 2 7.20 12.00 86.40 86.40 0.00 0.00 103 002090 Chuong Khut Prey Gny 3 7.70 85.00 654.50 657.50 3.00 0.00 104 001009 Em Raksmey Prey Gny 2 20.75 85.00 1,763.75 1,763.75 0.00 0.00 105 002011 ENG Se Prey Gny 3 17.40 85.00 1,479.00 1,479.00 0.00 0.00 106 004008 Hang Heam Prey Gny 3 11.16 85.00 948.60 948.60 0.00 0.00 107 004004 Huon Thailong Prey Gny 2 6.24 12.00 74.88 74.88 0.00 0.00 108 002004 Huot Say Prey Gny 2 9.40 12.00 112.80 112.80 0.00 0.00 109 003003 Ke Lun Prey Gny 2 7.84 12.00 94.08 94.08 0.00 0.00 110 001011 KHOUY Nary Prey Gny 2 5.20 12.00 62.40 62.40 0.00 0.00 111 003005 Kim Ly Prey Gny 3 12.32 85.00 1,047.20 1,047.20 0.00 0.00 112 004007 KOEUM Seun Prey Gny 2 13.25 12.00 159.00 159.00 0.00 0.00 113 004005 LAY Ngim Prey Gny 2 6.75 12.00 81.00 81.00 0.00 0.00 114 002012 LOEUM Bunthy Prey Gny 2 13.87 12.00 166.44 166.44 0.00 0.00 115 002007 Men Seurn Prey Gny 1 2.30 4.50 10.35 10.35 0.00 0.00 116 001003 Mok Pim Prey Gny 1 18.24 4.50 82.08 82.08 0.00 0.00 117 004001 Ngin Pak Prey Gny 2 7.50 12.00 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 118 001004 Nov Neang Prey Gny 1 19.80 4.50 89.10 89.10 0.00 0.00 119 004006 OUK Lay Ngoun Prey Gny 2 17.75 12.00 213.00 213.00 0.00 0.00 120 002094 Ouk Theab Prey Gny 3 25.20 85.00 2,142.00 2,142.00 0.00 0.00 121 002095 Out Sim Prey Gny 2 20.77 12.00 249.24 249.24 0.00 0.00 122 003007 POV Horn Prey Gny 2 7.14 12.00 85.68 85.68 0.00 0.00 123 003001 Rem Sameurn Prey Gny 2 1.44 12.00 17.28 17.28 0.00 0.00
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Area Excess Buildin Acquired Unit Cost Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be No. IRC Code HH Head Commune g Type (m2) ($/m2) Amount Due ($US) (US$) Paid (US$) 124 002091 Seang Saroan Prey Gny 2 21.09 12.00 253.08 253.08 0.00 0.00 125 002092 Seng Yorn Prey Gny 2 20.00 12.00 240.00 240.00 0.00 0.00 126 004002 Sun Khvoy Prey Gny 2 6.72 12.00 80.64 80.64 0.00 0.00 127 003006 Tang Hangyun Prey Gny 2 8.96 12.00 107.52 107.52 0.00 0.00 128 003002 Tea Theng Prey Gny 2 10.45 12.00 125.40 125.40 0.00 0.00 129 002003 Touch Seng Prey Gny 1 3.05 4.50 13.73 13.80 0.07 0.00 130 002096 Try Hong Prey Gny 4 11.25 140.00 1,575.00 1,575.00 0.00 0.00 131 002093 Tuoch Penghuor Prey Gny 4 10.80 140.00 1,512.00 1,512.00 0.00 0.00 132 003004 Van Ny Prey Gny 2 9.00 12.00 108.00 180.00 72.00 0.00 133 002010 YOEUM Meat Prey Gny 2 9.50 12.00 114.00 114.00 0.00 0.00 Total 43 533.94 18,161.66 18,235.03 75.07 1.70 134 002022 Chin Ork Prey Svay 1 12.75 4.50 57.38 57.37 0.00 0.01 135 004024 Hum Phun Prey Svay 2 6.00 12.00 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00 136 004022 Ke Suvann Prey Svay 2 12.00 12.00 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 137 004023 Keo Savat Prey Svay 2 9.89 12.00 118.68 118.68 0.00 0.00 138 003021 Kim Sovann Prey Svay 1 14.70 4.50 66.15 66.15 0.00 0.00 139 001023 Korb Korm Prey Svay 2 8.14 12.00 97.68 97.68 0.00 0.00 140 002021 Kov Chomrernn Prey Svay 1 10.56 4.50 47.52 47.52 0.00 0.00 141 002023 Ornn Chourn Prey Svay 1 10.00 4.50 45.00 45.00 0.00 0.00 142 001021 Phun Pheap Prey Svay 2 11.16 12.00 133.92 133.92 0.00 0.00 143 002074 SARAY Chem Prey Svay 2 10.50 12.00 126.00 126.00 0.00 0.00 144 001020 Sarei Sockchea Prey Svay 2 12.92 12.00 155.04 155.04 0.00 0.00 145 001022 Srey Phunn Prey Svay 1 27.00 4.50 121.50 121.50 0.00 0.00 146 003020 Uch Soeum Prey Svay 1 6.00 4.50 27.00 27.00 0.00 0.00 Total 13 151.62 1,211.87 1,211.86 0.00 0.01 147 003013 Cheb Thul Prey Touch 1 12.65 4.50 56.93 56.92 0.00 0.01 148 001017 Chin Kim ann Prey Touch 1 54.00 4.50 243.00 243.00 0.00 0.00 149 004017 Chhonn Vann Prey Touch 1 13.60 4.50 61.20 61.20 0.00 0.00 150 002014 Gnet Pheap Prey Touch 1 5.04 4.50 22.68 22.68 0.00 0.00 151 002016 Heang Hein Prey Touch 1 9.60 4.50 43.20 43.20 0.00 0.00 152 001016 Hey Sarornn Prey Touch 1 20.80 4.50 93.60 93.60 0.00 0.00 153 003014 Kai Heurn Prey Touch 1 10.54 4.50 47.43 47.43 0.00 0.00 154 001013 Kim Ny Prey Touch 1 12.00 4.50 54.00 54.00 0.00 0.00 155 004003 Mork Mab Prey Touch 1 9.50 4.50 42.75 42.75 0.00 0.00 156 002013 Mork Sothea Prey Touch 1 21.84 4.50 98.28 98.28 0.00 0.00 157 004014 Morm Deab Prey Touch 1 21.35 4.50 96.08 96.17 0.09 0.00 158 004018 Peing Gneit Prey Touch 1 10.00 4.50 45.00 45.00 0.00 0.00 159 002015 Ri Rorn Prey Touch 2 16.32 12.00 195.84 195.84 0.00 0.00 160 004015 Rorn Bau Prey Touch 1 7.77 4.50 34.97 34.96 0.00 0.01 161 004016 Sang Sophea Prey Touch 2 20.25 12.00 243.00 243.00 0.00 0.00 162 001015 Sau Seurn Prey Touch 1 11.75 4.50 52.88 52.87 0.00 0.01 163 001014 Sourn Phan Prey Touch 1 7.50 4.50 33.75 33.75 0.00 0.00 164 003015 Tov Kha Prey Touch 1 13.50 4.50 60.75 60.75 0.00 0.00 165 003012 Vorn Sa Van Prey Touch 1 23.20 4.50 104.40 104.40 0.00 0.00 Total 19 301.21 1,629.72 1,629.80 0.09 0.03 166 002033 Brak Sokhun Pteas Prey 2 13.75 12.00 165.00 165.00 0.00 0.00 167 001022 Brak Sovannary Pteas Prey 2 9.40 12.00 112.80 149.25 36.45 0.00 168 002062 BUN Narom Pteas Prey 2 15.50 12.00 186.00 186.00 0.00 0.00 169 004019 Chan Eurn Pteas Prey 2 7.50 12.00 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 170 001046 CHAN Sokha Pteas Prey 2 14.70 12.00 176.40 176.40 0.00 0.00 171 003021 Chea Sambo Pteas Prey 2 14.00 12.00 168.00 168.00 0.00 0.00 172 002063 CHEANG Roun Pteas Prey 1 9.25 4.50 41.63 41.62 0.00 0.01 173 003023 Chem Sunchheang Pteas Prey 2 13.50 12.00 162.00 162.00 0.00 0.00 174 002099 CHHAK Sokhorn Pteas Prey 3 36.00 85.00 3,060.00 1,530.00 0.00 1,530.00 175 002032 Chheang Khandy Pteas Prey 2 21.00 12.00 252.00 252.00 0.00 0.00 176 002106 CHHOEUM Saroeum Pteas Prey 4 11.25 140.00 1,575.00 478.15 0.00 1,096.85 177 003019 Em Phuvibut Pteas Prey 2 7.35 12.00 88.20 88.20 0.00 0.00 178 001028 Eurn Savon Pteas Prey 1 12.21 4.50 54.95 54.94 0.00 0.01 179 003022 Gnuy Visoth Pteas Prey 2 28.52 12.00 342.24 342.24 0.00 0.00 180 002061 HEM Kimsri Pteas Prey 1 11.00 4.50 49.50 49.50 0.00 0.00 181 003024 Heurn Huny Pteas Prey 2 41.30 12.00 495.60 495.60 0.00 0.00 182 002036 Ho Yeurng Pteas Prey 2 27.84 12.00 334.08 334.80 0.72 0.00 183 003031 Hor Chheng Pteas Prey 2 10.50 12.00 126.00 279.19 153.19 0.00 184 003026 Hun Mao Pteas Prey 2 12.40 12.00 148.80 169.50 20.70 0.00 185 001025 Hun Yeurn Pteas Prey 2 11.25 4.86 54.68 177.76 123.09 0.00 186 004016 Kar Heurm Pteas Prey 2 22.56 12.00 270.72 270.72 0.00 0.00
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Area Excess Buildin Acquired Unit Cost Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be No. IRC Code HH Head Commune g Type (m2) ($/m2) Amount Due ($US) (US$) Paid (US$) 187 004017 Kar Heurm Pteas Prey 2 18.40 12.00 220.80 220.80 0.00 0.00 188 002104 Keang Chomreun Pteas Prey 3 33.70 85.00 2,864.50 1,432.25 0.00 1,432.25 189 002035 Keav Khun Pteas Prey 2 5.00 12.00 60.00 60.00 0.00 0.00 190 002100 KHLOAK Touch Pteas Prey 4 7.50 140.00 1,050.00 1,050.00 0.00 0.00 191 003028 Kuoy Ny Pteas Prey 2 20.25 12.00 243.00 243.00 0.00 0.00 192 002103 LAY Seng Pteas Prey 3 30.00 85.00 2,550.00 1,275.00 0.00 1,275.00 193 002050 Leang Lay Pteas Prey 4 2.30 4.86 11.18 11.16 0.00 0.02 194 002037 Lem Kheang Pteas Prey 2 7.75 12.00 93.00 93.00 0.00 0.00 195 002038 Leng Kimsrey Pteas Prey 2 10.80 12.00 129.60 129.60 0.00 0.00 196 004022 Ly Ny Pteas Prey 2 9.00 12.00 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 197 004023 Mao Sokhun Pteas Prey 2 26.64 12.00 319.68 319.68 0.00 0.00 198 002034 Men Dom Pteas Prey 2 27.03 12.00 324.36 324.36 0.00 0.00 199 002098 MEN Nay Pteas Prey 4 28.00 140.00 3,920.00 1,960.00 0.00 1,960.00 200 001030 Men Sovan Pteas Prey 2 6.82 12.00 81.84 84.84 3.00 0.00 201 002102 MUK Vat Pteas Prey 3 25.50 85.00 2,167.50 1,083.75 0.00 1,083.75 202 003020 Norng Bunmeng Pteas Prey 2 14.00 12.00 168.00 168.00 0.00 0.00 203 003027 Nov Brak Pteas Prey 2 18.85 12.00 226.20 108.00 0.00 118.20 204 002028 Pol Dy Pteas Prey 2 21.00 12.00 252.00 252.00 0.00 0.00 205 003029 Pol Heng Pteas Prey 2 18.45 12.00 221.40 221.40 0.00 0.00 206 004025 Preab Von Pteas Prey 2 8.14 12.00 97.68 124.41 26.73 0.00 207 002105 SEM Kosal Pteas Prey 3 34.20 85.00 2,907.00 1,453.05 0.00 1,453.95 208 001027 Sem Nout Pteas Prey 2 13.50 12.00 162.00 162.02 0.02 0.00 209 003025 Seng Sreng Pteas Prey 2 10.60 12.00 127.20 123.12 0.00 4.08 210 002027 Seng Thai Pteas Prey 2 22.50 12.00 270.00 270.00 0.00 0.00 211 001029 Suong Saeurn Pteas Prey 2 10.00 12.00 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 212 004024 Tan Kimchheang Pteas Prey 2 16.40 12.00 196.80 196.80 0.00 0.00 213 002097 TENG Chung Eng Pteas Prey 3 21.20 85.00 1,802.00 901.00 0.00 901.00 214 004015 Tep Sok Pteas Prey 2 14.04 12.00 168.48 168.48 0.00 0.00 215 002101 TEV Kean Pteas Prey 4 20.00 140.00 2,800.00 1,400.00 0.00 1,400.00 216 002029 Tith Sameurn Pteas Prey 3 6.24 85.00 530.40 666.48 136.08 0.00 217 003030 Uon Yan Pteas Prey 2 45.45 12.00 545.40 545.40 0.00 0.00 Total 52 904.04 32,691.60 20,936.47 499.98 12,255.11 218 000284 BOU Pov Ronob 3 19.20 85.00 1,632.00 1,632.00 0.00 0.00 219 003008 CHAN Sophal Ronob 1 21.00 4.50 94.50 94.50 0.00 0.00 220 003009 CHEA Koeum Ronob 2 30.24 12.00 362.88 362.88 0.00 0.00 221 002019 CHHENG Heng Ronob 2 14.00 12.00 168.00 168.00 0.00 0.00 222 002017 CHHOEUM Song Ronob 2 16.50 12.00 198.00 198.00 0.00 0.00 223 001020 CHHUN Houn Ronob 2 10.00 12.00 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 224 001014 CHHUN Yen Ronob 2 9.92 12.00 119.04 119.04 0.00 0.00 225 001015 CHOU Mao Ronob 2 37.40 12.00 448.80 448.80 0.00 0.00 226 001016 DET Sokha Ronob 2 23.10 12.00 277.20 277.20 0.00 0.00 227 001017 DUCH Sompaos Ronob 2 29.61 12.00 355.32 355.32 0.00 0.00 228 002013 EM Pech Ronob 1 31.90 4.50 143.55 143.55 0.00 0.00 229 002081 EU Veasna Ronob 4 9.30 140.00 1,302.00 1,302.00 0.00 0.00 230 003013 HEM Sotheary Ronob 2 10.00 12.00 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 231 004013 HENG Kimsay Ronob 2 13.25 12.00 159.00 159.00 0.00 0.00 232 002077 HENG Sotha Ronob 2 10.90 12.00 130.80 170.80 40.00 0.00 233 003010 HORM Chomreun Ronob 2 17.20 12.00 206.40 206.40 0.00 0.00 234 001012 HORN Leng Ronob 1 18.00 4.50 81.00 81.00 0.00 0.00 235 004010 HORNG Serevatana Ronob 2 7.56 12.00 90.72 90.72 0.00 0.00 236 004014 HUY Gnab Ronob 2 11.25 12.00 135.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 237 001019 Khat Yen Ronob 2 12.10 12.00 145.20 145.20 0.00 0.00 238 002021 KHOEUM Chiv Ronob 2 12.50 12.00 150.00 150.00 0.00 0.00 239 001013 KOEUM Phearin Ronob 2 30.00 12.00 360.00 360.00 0.00 0.00 240 002020 LACH Bros Ronob 2 14.00 12.00 168.00 168.00 0.00 0.00 241 003011 LAI Tao Ronob 2 3.20 12.00 38.40 38.40 0.00 0.00 242 001018 LAT Lay Ronob 2 12.50 12.00 150.00 150.00 0.00 0.00 243 002080 LIM Seng Ronob 2 22.50 12.00 270.00 270.00 0.00 0.00 244 004011 LOEUM Hong Ronob 2 15.00 12.00 180.00 180.00 0.00 0.00 245 001014 LOEUM Long Ronob 2 11.02 12.00 132.24 132.26 0.02 0.00 246 002082 MOEUNG Saim Ronob 2 22.80 12.00 273.60 273.60 0.00 0.00 247 002023 MOUNG Pom Ronob 2 14.00 12.00 168.00 168.00 0.00 0.00 248 003017 OUK Leng Ronob 2 15.50 12.00 186.00 186.00 0.00 0.00 249 002079 OUN Nob Ronob 4 17.10 140.00 2,394.00 2,394.00 0.00 0.00 250 000287 PECH Neang Ronob 3 28.00 85.00 2,380.00 2,380.00 0.00 0.00 251 004012 ROEUM Rous Ronob 2 21.83 12.00 261.96 261.96 0.00 0.00
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Area Excess Buildin Acquired Unit Cost Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be No. IRC Code HH Head Commune g Type (m2) ($/m2) Amount Due ($US) (US$) Paid (US$) 252 002015 SAING Saret Ronob 2 24.00 12.00 288.00 288.00 0.00 0.00 253 002022 SEAK Nai Ronob 2 12.42 12.00 149.04 149.04 0.00 0.00 254 002016 SENG Bonlong Ronob 2 14.30 12.00 171.60 171.60 0.00 0.00 255 002024 SOEUM Bunleng Ronob 2 11.40 12.00 136.80 136.80 0.00 0.00 256 002014 SOK Chhunny Ronob 1 28.29 4.50 127.31 127.30 0.00 0.01 257 002088 SOK Somreun Ronob 3 23.75 85.00 2,018.75 2,018.75 0.00 0.00 258 002089 SOM San Ronob 3 30.40 85.00 2,584.00 2,584.00 0.00 0.00 259 000286 SOM Kim Ronob 3 15.00 85.00 1,275.00 1,275.00 0.00 0.00 260 002085 Sompao Ronob 3 19.20 85.00 1,632.00 1,632.00 0.00 0.00 261 003015 SONG Lay Ronob 2 12.00 12.00 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 262 004009 TAING Meng Ronob 2 24.05 12.00 288.60 288.60 0.00 0.00 263 002083 VAN Mabb Ronob 3 16.42 85.00 1,395.70 1,395.70 0.00 0.00 264 002018 YEN Laisrin Ronob 2 27.65 12.00 331.80 331.80 0.00 0.00 265 003012 YU La Ronob 2 5.20 12.00 62.40 62.40 0.00 0.00 Total 48 856.46 24,006.61 24,046.62 40.02 0.01 266 002024 Phorng Phnn Rosey Krong 2 2.80 12.00 33.60 33.60 0.00 0.00 Total 1 2.80 33.60 33.60 0.00 0.00 267 003045 LY Sochet Snam Pras 2 14.40 12.00 172.80 172.80 0.00 0.00 Total 1 14.40 172.80 172.80 0.00 0.00 268 001034 Eung Tei Svay Art 2 2.34 12.00 28.08 28.00 0.00 0.08 269 003040 Eur Savuon Svay Art 1 8.37 4.50 37.67 37.66 0.00 0.01 270 004036 Gnean Thida Svay Art 2 33.95 12.00 407.40 407.40 0.00 0.00 271 001035 He Kimchhun Svay Art 2 11.52 12.00 138.24 138.24 0.00 0.00 272 004038 In Chansokha Svay Art 2 26.00 12.00 312.00 312.00 0.00 0.00 273 001038 Kauv Gnau Svay Art 2 20.50 12.00 246.00 246.00 0.00 0.00 274 004040 Kim Huot Svay Art 2 8.68 12.00 104.16 104.16 0.00 0.00 275 002048 Kuoch Sokha Svay Art 2 28.80 12.00 345.60 345.60 0.00 0.00 276 001039 Lok Sam Svay Art 2 28.00 12.00 336.00 336.00 0.00 0.00 277 003044 Ly Kimnorn Svay Art 2 14.25 12.00 171.00 171.00 0.00 0.00 278 002047 Mao Sorn Svay Art 2 16.50 12.00 198.00 198.00 0.00 0.00 279 003042 Mao Thary Svay Art 2 22.26 12.00 267.12 267.12 0.00 0.00 280 004037 Morm Mao Svay Art 2 4.20 12.00 50.40 50.40 0.00 0.00 281 001036 Nuon Sareurn Svay Art 2 10.20 12.00 122.40 122.40 0.00 0.00 282 001037 Nuon Sareurn Svay Art 2 9.62 12.00 115.44 115.44 0.00 0.00 283 003041 Pham Bunsith Svay Art 2 9.00 12.00 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 284 002051 Roam Neurn Svay Art 2 10.00 12.00 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 285 002046 Ros Senara Svay Art 2 36.00 12.00 432.00 432.00 0.00 0.00 286 004039 Say Buntheurn Svay Art 2 14.88 12.00 178.56 178.56 0.00 0.00 287 003039 Seng Bora Svay Art 2 26.50 12.00 318.00 318.00 0.00 0.00 288 002049 Seng Hau Svay Art 2 13.20 12.00 158.40 158.40 0.00 0.00 289 004035 Seung Samei Svay Art 2 11.40 12.00 136.80 136.80 0.00 0.00 290 001047 SVAY Sokhanna Svay Art 2 15.50 12.00 186.00 186.00 0.00 0.00 291 004033 Vach Phuong Svay Art 2 23.40 12.00 280.80 280.80 0.00 0.00 292 004034 Vach Phuong Svay Art 2 32.40 12.00 388.80 388.80 0.00 0.00 Total 25 437.47 5,186.87 5,186.78 0.00 0.09 293 002059 CHEA Sao Svay Daun Keo 2 15.00 12.00 180.00 180.00 0.00 0.00 294 001044 NGOAL Meng Svay Daun Keo 1 22.42 4.50 100.89 100.89 0.00 0.00 295 001043 NGOUN Lagn Svay Daun Keo 2 6.50 12.00 78.00 0.00 0.00 78.00 296 002058 Pao Synoun Svay Daun Keo 2 15.00 12.00 180.00 180.00 0.00 0.00 297 002060 SENG Bunmeng Svay Daun Keo 2 16.60 12.00 199.20 199.20 0.00 0.00 298 003054 SEUN Srouy Svay Daun Keo 2 13.95 12.00 167.40 167.40 0.00 0.00 299 004048 YOUM York Svay Daun Keo 2 11.84 12.00 142.08 142.08 0.00 0.00 Total 7 101.31 1,047.57 969.57 0.00 78.00 300 001001 Chan Vichit Thnout Choum 1 14.40 4.50 64.80 64.80 0.00 0.00 301 002001 Mao Mit Thnout Choum 1 34.80 4.50 156.60 156.60 0.00 0.00 Total 2 49.20 221.40 221.40 0.00 0.00 302 004043 Gnem Hong Trapeang Chorng 2 13.44 12.00 161.28 161.28 0.00 0.00 303 002052 Iv Socheat Trapeang Chorng 1 25.00 4.50 112.50 112.50 0.00 0.00 304 004044 Kim Cheang Trapeang Chorng 2 15.81 12.00 189.72 189.72 0.00 0.00 305 004041 Meas Mom Trapeang Chorng 2 9.03 12.00 108.36 108.36 0.00 0.00 306 003048 Ou Chanbupha Trapeang Chorng 2 30.00 12.00 360.00 360.00 0.00 0.00 307 002054 Seng Chanthea Trapeang Chorng 2 19.25 12.00 231.00 231.00 0.00 0.00 308 003049 Soth Sovantha Trapeang Chorng 1 12.60 4.50 56.70 56.70 0.00 0.00 309 001041 Suon Saroan Trapeang Chorng 2 23.04 12.00 276.48 276.48 0.00 0.00 310 002053 Suon Sophal Trapeang Chorng 2 18.40 12.00 220.80 220.80 0.00 0.00 311 003047 Suon Sophal Trapeang Chorng 2 15.30 12.00 183.60 233.60 50.00 0.00
5 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Area Excess Buildin Acquired Unit Cost Amount Paid Amount Paid Balance to be No. IRC Code HH Head Commune g Type (m2) ($/m2) Amount Due ($US) (US$) Paid (US$) 312 004042 Toem Touch Trapeang Chorng 2 6.75 12.00 81.00 85.86 4.86 0.00 313 001040 Vi Ponlork Trapeang Chorng 1 12.80 4.50 57.60 57.60 0.00 0.00 314 001042 Yuok Yung Trapeang Chorng 1 9.52 4.50 42.84 42.84 0.00 0.00 Total 13 210.94 2,081.88 2,136.74 54.86 0.00 Grand Total 314 APs 4,922.28 114,530.96 102,917.76 721.75 12,335.02
6 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 18 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings in NR 5 (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS Records)
Area Excess No. of Building Type Acquired Amount Due Amount Paid Balance to be APs Commune 1234(m2) (US$) (US$) Paid (US$) 7 Anlung Vel 2500 75.55 708.15 0.00 0.00 5 Au dombong II 3200 81.54 601.68 0.00 0.00 2 Boeng Khnar 1100 45.51 321.12 0.00 0.00 6 Kear 3300 106.90 992.18 0.00 0.01 24 Kom Pung Preang 17 7 0 0 395.87 2,787.47 0.00 0.02 14 Kompongpreas 11 3 0 0 113.21 906.95 0.00 0.04 22 Lor Lork Sor 2 14 4 2 408.19 20,455.42 51.73 0.00 2 Mong 0200 7.48 89.76 0.00 0.00 8 Ou Tapoang 2600 124.64 1,222.68 0.00 0.00 43 Prey Gny 5 28 8 2 533.94 18,161.66 75.07 1.70 13 Prey Svay 6700 151.62 1,211.87 0.00 0.01 19 Prey Touch 17 2 0 0 301.21 1,629.72 0.09 0.03 52 Pteas Prey 3 37 7 5 904.04 32,691.60 499.98 12,255.11 48 Ronob 4 35 7 2 856.46 24,006.61 40.02 0.01 1 Rosey Krong 0100 2.80 33.60 0.00 0.00 1 Snam Pras 0100 14.40 172.80 0.00 0.00 25 Svay Art 1 24 0 0 437.47 5,186.87 0.00 0.09 7 Svay Daun Keo 1600 101.31 1,047.57 0.00 78.00 2 Thnout Choum 2000 49.20 221.40 0.00 0.00 13 Trapeang Chorng 4900 210.94 2,081.88 54.86 0.00 314 TOTAL 84 193 26 11 4,922.28 114,530.96 721.75 12,335.02
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 19 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Excess Balance to IRC Building Area Acquired Unit Cost Amount Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. Code HH Head Commune Type (m2) ($/m2) Due (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 1 001138 Koeum Buntha Achar Lak 2 35.70 12 428.4 428.4 0.00 0.00 2 001139 En Borom Achar Lak 2 21.60 12 259.2 259.2 0.00 0.00 3 001140 Vat Nam Achar Lak 3 20.25 85 1721.25 1721.26 0.01 0.00 4 001141 Soam Dul Achar Lak 3 20.25 85 1721.25 1721.26 0.01 0.00 5 001142 Aet Lang Achar Lak 2 20.25 12 360.24 435.24 75.00 0.00 6 001143 Tech Seang Archar Lak 3 18.24 85 1550.4 1550.4 0.00 0.00 Total 6 136.29 6,040.74 6,115.76 75.02 0.00 7 001106 San Chengleang Bralay 2 48.40 12 580.80 580.80 0.00 0.00 8 004008 Thurn Parn Bralay 1 9.60 4.5 43.20 43.20 0.00 0.00 9 004007 Thearn Bearn Bralay 1 22.50 4.5 101.25 101.25 0.00 0.00 10 004005 Yon Yam Bralay 1 17.64 4.5 79.38 79.38 0.00 0.00 11 001008 Arn Pearn Bralay 1 18.76 4.5 84.42 187.78 103.36 0.00 12 001006 Chhearng Ty Bralay 1 41.73 4.5 187.78 187.78 0.00 0.00 13 003004 Phorn Pearn Bralay 1 39.22 4.5 176.49 176.49 0.00 0.00 14 002005 Dearb Chok Bralay 1 12.50 4.5 56.25 56.25 0.00 0.00 15 001007 Peing Keark Bralay 1 30.03 4.5 135.13 135.13 0.00 0.00 16 002004 Seng Bunthang Bralay 1 2 16.92 10.34 4.5 200.22 200.22 0.00 0.00 17 003005 Bou Mao Bralay 1 28.90 4.5 130.05 130.05 0.00 0.00 18 004006 Hun Ly Bralay 1 7.36 4.5 33.12 33.12 0.00 0.00 19 001083 Lim Peng Bralay 2 13.00 12 156.00 156.00 0.00 0.00 20 003086 Choub Lorn Bralay 1 34.30 4.5 154.35 154.35 0.00 0.00 Total 14 340.86 10.34 2,118.44 2,221.80 103.36 0.00 21 004051 Seath Sok Chamnar Kroam 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 60.48 0.00 0.00 22 004050 Loeub Eav Chamnar Kroam 1 16.72 4.5 75.24 75.24 0.00 0.00 23 004048 Torn Nan Chamnar Kroam 1 12.24 4.5 55.08 55.08 0.00 0.00 24 004047 Son Ra Chamnar Kroam 1 15.48 4.5 69.66 69.66 0.00 0.00 25 004046 Pauch Bail Chamnar Kroam 1 16.80 4.5 75.60 75.60 0.00 0.00 26 001003 Tech Sour Chamnar Kroam 1 40.00 4.5 180.00 180.00 0.00 0.00 27 004002 Kourch Tearn Chamnar Kroam 1 24.00 4.5 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 28 002002 Sun Tharn Chamnar Kroam 1 29.30 4.5 131.85 131.85 0.00 0.00 29 003002 Larnh Da Chamnar Kroam 1 24.97 4.5 112.36 112.36 0.00 0.00 30 001171 Mao Yeng Chamnar Kroam 2 19.74 12 236.88 236.88 0.00 0.00 31 001172 Houn Seng Chamnar Kroam 3 28.50 85 2,422.50 2,497.50 75.00 0.00 32 001173 Kang Hengkruy Chamnar Kroam 2 22.36 12 268.32 268.32 0.00 0.00 33 001174 Yus Hul Chamnar Kroam 1 69.00 4.5 310.50 310.50 0.00 0.00 34 001175 Heng Savy Chamnar Kroam 2 17.50 12 210.00 210.00 0.00 0.00 35 001176 Keov Polin Chamnar Kroam 2 32.40 12 388.80 388.80 0.00 0.00 36 001177 Kong Soy Chamnar Kroam 2 49.40 12 592.80 592.80 0.00 0.00 Total 16 431.85 5,298.07 5,373.07 75.00 0.00 37 004049 Hay Voon no data 1 15.30 4.5 68.85 68.85 0.00 0.00 Total 1 15.30 68.85 68.85 0.00 0.00 38 001109 Port Sarim Kompong Chentbong 2 30.10 12 361.20 361.20 0.00 0.00 39 004088 Sik Min Kompong Chentbong 2 57.12 12 685.44 685.44 0.00 0.00 40 001110 Chan Posan Kompong Chentbong 2 89.96 12 1,070.52 1,079.52 9.00 0.00 41 001111 Chan Tu Kompong Chentbong 2 39.00 12 468.00 468.00 0.00 0.00 42 001112 Thorn Chantha Kompong Chentbong 2 22.72 12 272.64 272.64 0.00 0.00 43 003085 Arng Bharnphea Kompong Chentbong 2 9.50 12 114.00 114.00 0.00 0.00 44 003084 Te Comaret Kompong Chentbong 2 12.00 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 45 040093 Yi Banpeat Kompong Chentbong 2 23.49 12 281.88 281.88 0.00 0.00 46 002093 Sourng Kha Im Kompong Chentbong 2 12.69 12 152.28 152.28 0.00 0.00 47 004089 Kourch Seng Kompong Chentbong 2 16.20 12 164.40 194.40 30.00 0.00 48 004086 Ly Sikea Kompong Chentbong 2 18.00 12 216.00 216.00 0.00 0.00 49 001082 Sary Meng Kompong Chentbong 2 25.90 12 310.80 310.80 0.00 0.00 50 001081 Tith Hongliv Kompong Chentbong 2 10.25 12 123.00 123.00 0.00 0.00 51 001065 Von Bunchorn Kompong Chentbong 2 24.44 12 293.28 293.28 0.00 0.00 52 001113 Heng Chea Kompong Chentbong 2 8.40 12 100.80 100.80 0.00 0.00 53 002094 Pouk Saron Kompong Chentbong 2 17.68 12 212.16 212.16 0.00 0.00 54 001109 Pot Sarim Kompong Chentbong 2 30.10 12 361.20 361.20 0.00 0.00 55 001163 Chary Engly Kompong Chentbong 3 34.44 85 2,927.40 2,927.40 0.00 0.00 56 001154 Rus Mengchu Kompong Chentbong 4 34.20 140 4,788.00 4,788.00 0.00 0.00 57 001155 Yim Sakhearn Kompong Chentbong 3 15.98 85 1,358.30 1,358.30 0.00 0.00 58 001156 Som Bein Kompong Chentbong 3 32.80 85 2,788.00 2,788.00 0.00 0.00 59 001157 Ngou Samate Kompong Chentbong 2 31.50 12 378.00 378.00 0.00 0.00 60 001158 Lim Suy Kompong Chentbong 2 19.32 12 231.84 306.84 75.00 0.00 61 001159 Yourn Meng Kompong Chentbong 4 34.00 140 4,760.00 4,760.00 0.00 0.00 62 001160 Dom Searn Kompong Chentbong 2 31.98 12 383.76 383.76 0.00 0.00 63 001161 Kong Meng Kompong Chentbong 4 32.00 140 4,480.00 4,480.00 0.00 0.00 64 001162 Chary Kimlar Kompong Chentbong 4 30.41 140 4,257.40 4,257.40 0.00 0.00 65 001144 Ouk Chantha Kompong Chentbong 2 36.90 12 442.80 442.80 0.00 0.00 66 001145 Soeum Po Kompong Chentbong 2 33.97 12 407.64 407.64 0.00 0.00 67 001146 Kiang Ounglay Kompong Chentbong 3 16.87 85 1,433.95 1,433.96 0.01 0.00 68 001147 Lorng Kimsy Kompong Chentbong 3 34.83 85 2,960.55 2,960.56 0.01 0.00
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 19 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Excess Balance to IRC Building Area Acquired Unit Cost Amount Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. Code HH Head Commune Type (m2) ($/m2) Due (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 69 001148 Seang Leng Kompong Chentbong 3 14.70 85 1,249.50 1,249.50 0.00 0.00 70 001149 Iang saybo Kompong Chentbong 2 22.40 12 268.80 268.80 0.00 0.00 71 001150 Heng Bora Kompong Chentbong 2 19.00 12 228.00 303.00 75.00 0.00 72 001151 Say Kimlong Kompong Chentbong 4 38.54 140 5,395.60 5,395.60 0.00 0.00 73 001152 Ngoun Va Kompong Chentbong 4 17.55 140 2,457.00 2,457.00 0.00 0.00 74 001153 Yin Lykeng Kompong Chentbong 2 18.06 12 216.72 216.72 0.00 0.00 Total 37 997.00 46,744.86 46,933.88 189.02 0.00 75 004013 Earb Chorng Kompong Chenchueng 2 8.50 12 102.00 102.00 0.00 0.00 76 001013 Ly Vuth Kompong Chenchueng 2 8.40 12 100.80 100.80 0.00 0.00 77 002014 Kearn Sihout Kompong Chenchueng 2 8.58 12 102.96 102.96 0.00 0.00 78 001020 Sao Sriv Kompong Chenchueng 2 12.00 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 79 001011 Prum Sophat Kompong Chenchueng 2 6.00 12 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00 80 003009 Keng Chan Roth Kompong Chenchueng 2 16.80 12 201.60 201.60 0.00 0.00 81 002009 Heng Changpary Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.68 12 116.16 116.16 0.00 0.00 82 004011 Kang Tech Kompong Chenchueng 2 7.00 12 84.00 84.00 0.00 0.00 83 001009 Hearng Kimkhurn Kompong Chenchueng 2 3.50 12 42.00 42.00 0.00 0.00 84 003012 Lay Hearng Kompong Chenchueng 2 22.60 12 271.20 271.20 0.00 0.00 85 004009 Kang grech Kompong Chenchueng 2 2.49 12 29.88 29.88 0.00 0.00 86 002008 Hurb Vanni Kompong Chenchueng 2 4.10 12 49.20 49.20 0.00 0.00 87 003011 Chea Kimsurt Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.30 12 111.60 111.60 0.00 0.00 88 004018 Ang Vannai Kompong Chenchueng 2 25.00 12 300.00 300.00 0.00 0.00 89 003014 Vorng Long Kompong Chenchueng 2 12.96 12 155.52 155.52 0.00 0.00 90 004017 Chur Vearn Kompong Chenchueng 2 11.00 12 132.00 132.00 0.00 0.00 91 002010 Heng Tech Kompong Chenchueng 2 15.36 12 184.32 184.32 0.00 0.00 92 002013 Keng Heng Kompong Chenchueng 3 7.80 12 93.60 93.60 0.00 0.00 93 003015 Lou Vannar Kompong Chenchueng 2 25.80 12 309.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 94 001010 Hourn Cheasim Kompong Chenchueng 2 3.98 12 47.76 47.77 0.01 0.00 95 001015 Chea Kimhong Kompong Chenchueng 2 18.76 12 225.12 225.12 0.00 0.00 96 003008 Yearn Yim Kompong Chenchueng 1 18.50 4.5 83.25 83.25 0.00 0.00 97 001012 Khun Seng Kompong Chenchueng 2 28.00 12 336.00 336.00 0.00 0.00 98 001014 Nov Chandy Kompong Chenchueng 2 13.20 12 158.40 158.40 0.00 0.00 99 004019 Larng Par Kompong Chenchueng 2 14.40 12 172.80 172.80 0.00 0.00 100 004015 Hong Santhai Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.90 12 118.80 118.80 0.00 0.00 101 004010 Hurt Kim Leng Kompong Chenchueng 2 21.90 12 262.80 262.80 0.00 0.00 102 001018 Khhun Hearm Kompong Chenchueng 2 25.00 12 300.00 300.00 0.00 0.00 103 003013 Hiv Hum Kompong Chenchueng 2 36.52 12 438.44 438.24 0.00 0.20 104 002015 Tort Norng Kompong Chenchueng 2 23.85 12 286.20 286.20 0.00 0.00 105 004020 Suy Hurai Kompong Chenchueng 2 20.00 12 240.00 240.00 0.00 0.00 106 004016 Sok Sorn Kompong Chenchueng 2 4.29 12 51.48 240.00 188.52 0.00 107 002012 Kan Bunna Kompong Chenchueng 2 16.75 12 201.00 201.00 0.00 0.00 108 001019 Heng Bunthon Kompong Chenchueng 2 30.00 12 360.00 360.00 0.00 0.00 109 002007 Pay Voneart Kompong Chenchueng 1 4.00 4.5 18.00 18.00 0.00 0.00 110 001017 Seng Lim Kompong Chenchueng 2 12.00 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 111 003010 Yearn Kon Kompong Chenchueng 2 15.90 12 190.80 190.80 0.00 0.00 112 002011 Chan Chaikhy Kompong Chenchueng 2 19.60 12 235.20 235.20 0.00 0.00 113 002006 Thang Hury Kompong Chenchueng 2 6.72 12 80.64 80.64 0.00 0.00 114 003007 Tarb Somnang Kompong Chenchueng 1 2 30.00 21 4.5 387.00 387.00 0.00 0.00 115 004014 Hun Prum Kompong Chenchueng 2 22.75 12 273.00 273.00 0.00 0.00 116 004021 Chor Lim Kompong Chenchueng 2 10.00 12 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 117 004112 Cheark Menghour Kompong Chenchueng 2 9.00 12 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 118 003017 Kim Num Kompong Chenchueng 2 18.50 12 222.20 222.20 0.00 0.00 119 001016 Kearm Chomrern Kompong Chenchueng 2 96.90 12 1,162.80 1,162.80 0.00 0.00 120 003006 Leng Heng Kompong Chenchueng 2 4.90 12 58.80 58.80 0.00 0.00 121 002016 Koav Somnarng Kompong Chenchueng 2 24.40 12 292.80 292.80 0.00 0.00 Total 47 776.59 21 9,177.73 9,366.06 188.53 0.20 122 003021 Cheng Heak Kompongkrabao 2 39.06 12 468.72 468.72 0.00 0.00 123 003020 Hean Chu Kompongkrabao 2 15.18 12 182.16 182.16 0.00 0.00 124 002024 Chan Koklim Kompongkrabao 2 41.18 12 484.16 494.16 10.00 0.00 125 001024 Kheam Sina Kompongkrabao 2 18.50 12 222.00 245.03 23.03 0.00 126 002022 Lim Kimleang Kompongkrabao 2 51.15 12 613.80 613.80 0.00 0.00 127 003022 Teav Buntean Kompongkrabao 2 39.00 12 468.00 468.00 0.00 0.00 128 003019 Mao Sara Kompongkrabao 2 46.75 12 561.00 561.00 0.00 0.00 129 002023 Chu Kaseng Kompongkrabao 2 25.50 12 306.00 306.00 0.00 0.00 130 001117 Lim Seang Kompongkrabao 2 35.32 12 422.76 422.76 0.00 0.00 131 001118 Peng Bora Kompongkrabao 2 23.92 12 287.04 287.04 0.00 0.00 132 001119 Ngourn Leanghak Kompongkrabao 3 34.76 85 2,954.60 2,954.60 0.00 0.00 133 001120 Chin Nara Kompongkrabao 3 47.88 85 4,069.80 4,069.80 0.00 0.00 134 001130 Koav Chan Thy Kompongkrabao 4 18.90 140 2,646.00 2,646.00 0.00 0.00 135 001121 Nhem Borith Kompongkrabao 3 17.10 85 1,453.50 1,453.50 0.00 0.00 136 001122 Thoung Syna Kompongkrabao 2 37.74 12 452.88 527.88 0.00 75.00 137 001123 Larg Brem Kompongkrabao 4 21.15 140 2,961.00 2,961.00 0.00 0.00 138 001124 Hearng Say Kompongkrabao 4 31.35 140 4,389.00 4,389.00 0.00 0.00
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 19 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the APs for Lost Buildings (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS records)
Excess Balance to IRC Building Area Acquired Unit Cost Amount Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. Code HH Head Commune Type (m2) ($/m2) Due (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 139 001125 Li Yun Kompongkrabao 1 24.75 4.5 111.37 111.37 0.00 0.00 140 001126 Soum Sadin Kompongkrabao 4 18.90 140 2,646.00 2,646.00 0.00 0.00 141 001127 Hourn Lau Kompongkrabao 2 35.50 12 426.00 426.00 0.00 0.00 142 001128 Tung Keng Kompongkrabao 3 18.90 85 1,606.50 1,606.50 0.00 0.00 143 001129 Tuch Yeng Kompongkrabao 3 28.86 85 2,453.10 2,453.10 0.00 0.00 Total 22 671.35 30,185.39 30,293.42 33.03 75.00 144 001131 Kit Poren Prey Tahou 2 35.88 12 430.56 430.56 0.00 0.00 145 001132 Hean Mom Prey Tahou 2 20.66 12 247.92 247.92 0.00 0.00 146 001131 Lau Par Prey Tahou 2 35.32 85 3,002.62 3,002.62 0.00 0.00 147 001134 Yeam Saly Prey Tahou 3 17.32 85 1,472.20 1,472.20 0.00 0.00 148 001135 Hourn Kheng Prey Tahou 3 17.32 85 1,472.20 1,472.20 0.00 0.00 149 001136 Huk Polen Prey Tahou 1 62.72 4.5 282.24 282.24 0.00 0.00 150 001137 Sok Chantha Prey Tahou 4 18.24 140 2,553.60 2,553.60 0.00 0.00 151 101114 Long Nhim Prey Tahou 2 53.34 12 640.08 640.08 0.00 0.00 152 101115 Heak Menghak Prey Tahou 2 8.40 12 177.60 177.60 0.00 0.00 Total 9 269.20 10,279.02 10,279.02 0.00 0.00 153 004003 Sao Say Somprouch 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 154 001004 Khard Dearn Somprouch 1 30.60 4.5 288.90 288.90 0.00 0.00 155 001005 Tun Sokha Somprouch 2 33.30 12 399.60 399.60 0.00 0.00 156 002003 Khan So Somprouch 1 32.76 45 147.42 147.42 0.00 0.00 157 001164 Yim Sarum Somprouch 2 34.80 12 417.60 417.60 0.00 0.00 158 001165 Kit Vat Somprouch 2 90.00 12 1,080.00 1,155.00 75.00 0.00 159 001166 Ngouch Son Somprouch 1 53.40 4.5 240.30 240.30 0.00 0.00 160 001167 Pok Saley Somprouch 2 28.00 12 336.00 336.00 0.00 0.00 161 001168 Kim Se Somprouch 2 15.75 12 189.00 189.00 0.00 0.00 162 001169 Lau Kim Hy Somprouch 2 36.45 12 437.40 512.40 75.00 0.00 163 001170 You Kimleng Somprouch 3 15.75 85 1,338.75 1,338.76 0.01 0.00 164 003003 Ku Kun Somprouch 1 27.95 4.5 125.77 0.00 0.00 125.77 165 004004 Lon Heang Somprouch 1 14.30 4.5 64.35 64.35 0.00 0.00 166 004045 Yat Khin Somprouch 1 10.85 4.5 48.82 48.82 0.00 0.00 167 004044 Jhoeum Torn Somprouch 1 15.20 4.5 68.40 68.40 0.00 0.00 168 004043 Som Ri Somprouch 2 25.62 12 307.44 307.44 0.00 0.00 169 004042 Ang Chenda Somprouch 2 36.12 12 433.44 433.48 0.04 0.00 Total 17 520.85 6,013.19 6,037.47 150.05 125.77 170 001105 Phon Sino Sun Kor 2 21.84 12 262.08 262.08 0.00 0.00 171 001001 Noum Lungheng Sun Kor 2 47.50 12 570.00 620.00 50.00 0.00 172 001002 kan Tha Sun Kor 2 25.62 12 307.44 307.44 0.00 0.00 173 002001 Say Khun Pen Sun Kor 2 44.64 12 535.68 585.68 50.00 0.00 174 004023 Dy Mearng Sun Kor 2 19.06 12 228.72 228.72 0.00 0.00 175 004039 Porn Korn Sun Kor 1 18.80 4.5 84.60 84.60 0.00 0.00 176 004040 Hou Chea Sun Kor 2 17.22 12 206.64 206.64 0.00 0.00 177 004041 Sim Seng Sun Kor 1 16.12 4.5 72.54 72.54 0.00 0.00 178 004030 Chea Somhol Sun Kor 2 7.02 12 84.24 84.24 0.00 0.00 179 004032 Horng Luy Sun Kor 1 27.30 4.5 122.85 122.85 0.00 0.00 180 004037 Chhun Bunlung Sun Kor 2 17.64 12 211.68 211.68 0.00 0.00 181 004038 Saom Team Sun Kor 2 28.00 12 336.00 336.00 0.00 0.00 182 004029 Seun Don Sun Kor 1 30.00 4.5 135.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 183 004028 Chor Harn Sun Kor 1 20.09 4.5 90.40 90.40 0.00 0.00 184 004027 Put Sareun Sun Kor 2 43.46 12 521.52 521.52 0.00 0.00 185 004026 Saing Art Sun Kor 1 16.81 4.5 75.64 75.64 0.00 0.00 186 004024 Eang Kor Sun Kor 1 14.08 4.5 63.36 63.36 0.00 0.00 187 004025 Tan Kreup Sun Kor 1 33.41 4.5 150.34 150.34 0.00 0.00 Total 18 448.61 4,058.73 4,158.73 100.00 0.00 188 002017 Soeum Bonhor Trapang Russei 2 12.00 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 189 002019 Siv Sok Trapang Russei 2 8.06 12 96.72 96.72 0.00 0.00 190 002020 Ther Somoul Trapang Russei 2 2.15 12 25.80 25.80 0.00 0.00 191 002021 Yon Yian Trapang Russei 2 2.00 12 24.00 24.00 0.00 0.00 Total 4 24.21 290.52 290.52 0.00 0.00 Grand-Total 191 4,663.45 120,275.54 121,138.58 914.01 200.97
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 19 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings (NR6) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS Records)
Area Excess No. of Building Type Acquired Amount Due Amount Paid Balance to be APs Commune 1 234 (m2) (US$) (US$) Paid (US$) 6 Archar Lak 0 330 136.29 6,040.74 75.02 0.00 14 Bralay 12 200 351.20 2,118.44 103.36 0.00 16 Chomnarkroum 10 510 431.85 5,298.07 75.00 0.00 1 no data 1 000 15.30 68.85 0.00 0.00 37 Kompong Chentbong 0 25 6 6 997.00 46,744.86 189.02 0.00 47 Kompong Chenchueng 3 43 1 0 797.59 9,177.73 188.53 0.20 22 Kompongkrabao 1 12 5 4 671.35 30,185.39 33.03 75.00 9 Prey Tahou 1 521 269.20 10,279.02 0.00 0.00 17 Somprouch 8 810 520.85 6,013.19 150.05 125.77 18 Sun Kor 8 10 0 0 448.61 4,058.73 100.00 0.00 4 Trapang Russei 0 400 24.21 290.52 0.00 0.00 191 TOTAL 44 117 19 11 4,663.45 120,275.54 914.01 200.97
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 1 001052 YE OunNeang Ang Cheum 3 49.64 85 4,219.40 4,219.40 0.00 0.00 2 001051 AOEUM Chea Ang Cheum 2 56.7 12 680.40 680.40 0.00 0.00 3 001050 AUN Aeun Ang Cheum 2 37.44 12 449.28 449.28 0.00 0.00 4 001049 MA Ti Ang Cheum 2 58.5 12 702.00 702.00 0.00 0.00 5 001048 VA Neang Ang Cheum 3 32 85 2,720.00 2,720.00 0.00 0.00 6 001047 SUN Mang Ang Cheum 2 45 12 540.00 540.00 0.00 0.00 7 001046 REAM Oun Ang Cheum 2 59.44 12 713.28 713.28 0.00 0.00 8 001055 SREANG Cheun Ang Cheum 2 48.3 12 579.60 579.60 0.00 0.00 9 004034 CHHORN KimHung Ang Cheum 2 31.08 12 372.96 372.76 0.00 0.20 10 004033 LEANG Sreang Ang Cheum 1 19.98 4.5 189.91 89.91 0.00 100.00 11 001054 SUNG Tha Ang Cheum 3 25.2 85 2,142.00 1,713.60 0.00 428.40 12 001053 ART SaL Ang Cheum 2 60.59 12 727.08 727.08 0.00 0.00 13 001030 GNUNN Houng Ang Cheum 3 15.97 85 1,357.45 678.72 0.00 678.73 Total 13 539.84 0 15,393.36 14,186.03 0.00 1,207.33 14 001025 Chen Vanthar Chub 2 12.83 12 153.96 156.96 0.00 0.00 15 002007 Sok Rarny Chub dk dk 4.86 0.75 0.00 83.36 83.36 0.00 16 003004 Pov Sovan Chub 1 6.88 4.5 30.93 30.93 0.00 0.00 17 005001 Lek Pov Chub 2 36.19 12 434.28 434.28 0.00 0.00 18 004006 Koa Searnghour Chub 2 17.75 12 189.00 189.00 0.00 0.00 19 004002 Pov Chanthar Chub dk dk 50 0.00 50.00 50.00 0.00 20 001006 Bun thong Chub 2 41.05 dk 492.60 246.30 0.00 246.30 21 001009 Chang Bunnar Chub 2 31.35 12 376.20 376.20 0.00 0.00 22 004007 Poung Piseth Chub 2 28.81 12 345.72 345.72 0.00 0.00 23 005005 Seng Meng Chub 2 37.82 12 453.84 453.84 0.00 0.00 24 003010 Soi Chantha Chub 2 15.30 12 186.60 183.60 0.00 0.00 25 003008 Tuy Vannar Chub 2 29.24 12 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 26 001004 Hel Sorm Ol Chub 2 12.40 12 0.00 148.80 148.80 0.00 27 001005 Chin Srun Chub 2 16.73 12 0.00 200.76 200.76 0.00 28 002003 Larch Hearn Chub 2 13.16 12 0.00 157.92 157.92 0.00 29 002002 Sok Chanthy Chub 2 13.02 12 0.00 156.24 156.24 0.00 30 002005 Sok Putheavy Chub 2 11.20 12 0.00 134.40 134.40 0.00 31 001007 Sat Chan thol Chub 2 21.08 12 0.00 259.96 259.96 0.00 32 003007 Hearng Pirun Chub 2 12.84 12 0.00 154.05 154.05 0.00 33 004004 Searng Try Chub 2 26.40 12 0.00 316.80 316.80 0.00 34 002006 Pang Chanthim Chub 2 0.25 12 99.00 99.00 0.00 0.00 35 003002 Seak Vouchorng Chub 2 12 0.00 154.80 154.80 0.00 36 005004 Vinh Meang Chub 2 11.4 12 136.80 136.80 0.00 0.00 37 003003 Kong Earv Chub 2 4.125 12 49.50 49.50 0.00 0.00 38 001008 Seang Sairong Chub 2 28.42 12 12 341.04 341.04 0.00 0.00 39 002001 Li Mat Chub 2 14.4 12 172.80 0.00 0.00 172.80 40 003006 Yourng Heng Chub 2 50.84 12 610.08 0.00 0.00 610.08
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 41 003011 Sing Kimhean Chub 2 7.04 12 84.48 0.00 0.00 84.48 42 003009 Nov Vudi Chub 2 23.04 12 276.48 0.00 0.00 276.48 43 002010 TY Bot Chub 2 53.75 85.00 645.00 645.00 0.00 0.00 44 002020 Meas Ny Chub 2 56.25 675.00 675.00 0.00 0.00 45 002021 Ngoun Try Chub 2 50 600.00 600.00 0.00 0.00 46 002023 Chhiv Hy Chub 2 45.6 547.20 547.20 0.00 0.00 47 002022 Chin Seir Chub 2 69 828.00 828.00 0.00 0.00 48 002024 Ty Koy Chub 2 26 312.00 312.00 0.00 0.00 49 002025 Bouy Mongheng Chub 2 17.5 210.00 210.00 0.00 0.00 50 002026 Noun Sinoun Chub 2 32 384.00 384.00 0.00 0.00 51 002027 Sun Kimhim Chub 2 54 648.00 648.00 0.00 0.00 52 002028 Lorn Hy Chub 2 18.8 225.60 225.00 0.00 0.60 53 002031 Krouch Kimva Chub 2 36.9 442.80 442.80 0.00 0.00 54 002030 Mak Tey Chub 2 36.4 436.80 436.80 0.00 0.00 55 002029 Souen Orng Chub 2 62.406 748.88 748.88 0.00 0.00 56 002029 Ol Pov Chub dk dk 0.00 172.53 172.53 0.00 57 201001 Kim Sokha Chub dk dk 0.00 525.00 525.00 0.00 58 001026 Ty Mot Chub 3 23.6 1,203.60 601.80 0.00 601.80 59 002001 Chhon Sithach Chub 2 19.64 235.68 235.68 0.00 0.00 60 002008 Mel Chhon Chub 2 27.15 325.80 325.80 0.00 0.00 61 002010 Uok Borin Chub 2 53.75 645.00 645.00 0.00 0.00 62 002013 Our Sopear Chub 2 37.08 444.96 444.96 0.00 0.00 63 002014 Hak iayrong Chub 3 16.00 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 64 002015 Kim Son Chub 2 71.25 855.00 855.00 0.00 0.00 65 001009 Oung Kimhorn Chub 2 64.04 768.48 768.48 0.00 0.00 66 002016 Hak Kimporn Chub 2 29.2 350.40 350.40 0.00 0.00 67 002012 Lorng Chhon iy Chub 2 27.5 330.00 330.00 0.00 0.00 68 002017 Chhoeum Savat Chub 3 17.3 1,470.50 1,470.50 0.00 0.00 69 002011 Ear Nyra Chub 2 33.8 405.60 405.60 0.00 0.00 70 002019 Som Thet Chub 2 35 420.00 578.44 158.44 0.00 71 401008 Heab Limhong Chub dk dk 4.86 0.00 111.78 111.78 0.00 Total 58 1537.47 0.00 19,951.61 20,743.91 2,784.84 1,992.54 72 304032 Marv Mes Dar 2 42.50 12 510.00 510.00 0.00 0.00 73 301042 Sin Sek Dar 3 24.96 dk 2,121.60 2,121.60 0.00 0.00 74 304034 Sun Nari Dar 3 22.31 85 1,896.35 1,896.35 0.00 0.00 75 304035 Kheng Tri Dar 3 29.25 85 2,486.25 2,486.25 0.00 0.00 76 301043 Meng Kheang Dar 3 32.00 dk 2,720.00 2,720.00 0.00 0.00 77 303045 Sun Sopheap Dar 3 15.64 dk 1,414.40 1,414.40 0.00 0.00 78 304033 Hour Leang Dar 3 16.85 dk 1,432.25 1,432.25 0.00 0.00 79 303046 Kri Ya Dar 3 27.50 2,337.50 2,337.50 0.00 0.00 80 301044 Koav Khim Dar 3 20.84 1,771.40 1,771.40 0.00 0.00
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 81 301035 Veng Nhor Dar 3 20.8 1,768.00 1,768.00 0.00 0.00 82 203013 Mat Kai Dar 2 29.4 12 352.80 352.80 0.00 0.00 83 203014 Sles Soeuk Dar 1 32.24 4.5 145.08 145.08 0.00 0.00 84 203015 Teab Him Dar 1 10.56 4.5 47.52 47.52 0.00 0.00 85 203017 Mot Sash Dar 1 15.84 4.5 71.28 71.28 0.00 0.00 86 203016 Met Math Dar 1 13.76 4.5 61.92 61.92 0.00 0.00 87 202028 Sos Sit Dar 1 26.1 4.5 117.45 117.45 0.00 0.00 88 202032 Hoeum Taluas Dar 2 33 12 396.00 396.00 0.00 0.00 89 202030 Krim Oun Dar 1 14.24 4.5 64.08 64.08 0.00 0.00 90 401003 Uy Sok Dar 1 dk dk 40.00 40.00 0.00 0.00 91 401004 Siv Heng Dar 2 30.08 12 360.96 360.96 0.00 0.00 92 401005 Leng Thum Dar 1 dk dk 40.00 40.00 0.00 0.00 93 301013 Oeung Evmeng Dar 4 19.09 13.66 140 140 3,820.04 3,820.04 0.00 0.00 94 203022 Noun Hean Dar 2 18.84 12 50 266.08 316.08 50.00 0.00 95 201030 Sok Ban Dar 2 7.59 12 91.08 91.08 0.00 0.00 96 302004 Och Doungren Dar 1 15.2 4.5 68.40 68.40 0.00 0.00 97 201032 Ma Chhan Dar 2 19.55 12 234.60 234.60 0.00 0.00 98 201033 Mok Buntheng Dar 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 99 203023 Jhem Ret Dar 1 29.9 12 352.80 358.80 6.00 0.00 100 202042 Jhoeub Heang Dar 1 34.08 4.5 153.36 153.36 0.00 0.00 101 202039 Sok Teang Dar 1 12.24 4.5 55.08 55.08 0.00 0.00 102 202040 Nut Tu Dar 2 10.25 12 123.00 123.00 0.00 0.00 103 202041 Chea Channy Dar 1 8.25 4.5 37.12 37.12 0.00 0.00 104 201028 Ly Thet Dar 1 14.61 4.5 65.74 65.74 0.00 0.00 105 202033 Peak Ye Dar 1 20.5 4.5 92.25 92.25 0.00 0.00 106 202034 Chor Krong Dar 1 26.65 4.5 119.92 119.92 0.00 0.00 107 202035 Sim Tha Dar 2 19.32 12 231.84 231.84 0.00 0.00 108 202036 Mey Ran Dar 1 12.54 4.5 56.43 56.43 0.00 0.00 109 202037 Leang Bonsru Dar 2 10 12 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 110 203018 Chan Ny Dar 1 19.25 4.5 86.62 86.62 0.00 0.00 111 203020 Sok Thorn Dar 2 21.42 12 257.04 157.04 0.00 100.00 112 203019 Kong Khhorn Dar 2 22.2 12 266.40 266.40 0.00 0.00 113 203021 Yoeum Pearak Dar 2 16.28 12 195.36 195.36 0.00 0.00 114 202031 Sos Nas Dar 1 31 4.5 139.50 139.50 0.00 0.00 115 201022 Phass kei Dar 2 7.7 12 92.40 92.40 0.00 0.00 116 201023 Kav Jhor Dar 1 9.13 4.5 41.08 41.08 0.00 0.00 117 201029 Tam Tey Dar 1 9.84 4.5 44.28 44.28 0.00 0.00 118 201024 Nuo Savouen Dar 1 15.97 4.5 71.86 71.86 0.00 0.00 119 201026 Bouy Net Dar 1 16.53 4.5 74.38 74.38 0.00 0.00 120 201025 Ban Houen Dar 1 23.4 4.5 105.30 105.30 0.00 0.00 121 201027 Bech Srim Dar 1 22.5 4.5 101.25 101.25 0.00 0.00
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 122 202043 Chea Channy Dar 1 17.02 4.5 50 76.59 76.59 0.00 0.00 123 303003 Ngoun Sokchea Dar 2 24.75 12 297.00 297.00 0.00 0.00 124 303002 Chhon Nak Dar 1 10.5 4.5 47.25 47.25 0.00 0.00 Total 53 1019.97 13.66 28,130.89 28,086.89 56.00 100.00 125 003026 Oung Hout Dar (Kratie) 1 8.68 4.5 39.06 39.06 0.00 0.00 126 001024 Horn Hen Dar (Kratie) 1 4.60 4.5 20.25 20.25 0.00 0.00 127 003023 Reach Chea Dar (Kratie) 2 15.17 12 182.04 182.04 0.00 0.00 128 003025 Pen Art Dar (Kratie) 1 21.73 4.5 97.78 97.78 0.00 0.00 129 002024 Lun chanthy Dar (Kratie) 2 28.52 12 342.24 342.24 0.00 0.00 130 002023 Meas Vothy Dar (Kratie) 1 10.40 4.5 46.80 46.80 0.00 0.00 131 001022 Mé Chea Dar (Kratie) 1 15.75 4.5 70.87 70.87 0.00 0.00 132 001023 Sok Hun Dar (Kratie) 1 15.75 4.5 70.87 70.87 0.00 0.00 133 003024 Ratt Mot Dar (Kratie) 1 13.53 4.5 60.88 60.88 0.00 0.00 Total 9 134.13 0.00 930.79 930.79 0.00 0.00 134 203019 Tak Deu Khsoeum 2 9.20 12 110.40 110.40 0.00 0.00 135 203023 Sin Va Khsoeum 2 16.27 12 195.24 195.24 0.00 0.00 136 203022 Sung Phat Khsoeum 1 19.20 4.5 86.40 86.40 0.00 0.00 137 203020 Mao Meng Khsoeum 2 27.09 12 325.08 325.08 0.00 0.00 138 203021 Top Lay Khsoeum 1 22.62 4.5 101.79 101.79 0.00 0.00 139 201018 Phann Morn Khsoeum 2 13.50 12 162.00 162.00 0.00 0.00 140 202020 Heang Oun Khsoeum 1 28.20 4.5 126.90 126.90 0.00 0.00 141 201017 Ross Sophea Khsoeum 1 14.00 4.5 63.00 63.00 0.00 0.00 Total 8 150.08 0.00 1,170.81 1,170.81 0.00 0.00 142 201019 LY Sokmy Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 143 201021 LIM YeakTang Koang Kang 2 15.12 12 181.44 181.44 0.00 0.00 144 201020 SUN PengIEy Koang Kang 2 12.32 12 147.84 147.84 0.00 0.00 145 202025 SEA MuyAea Koang Kang 2 26 12 312.00 312.00 0.00 0.00 146 201017 NY SokHeang Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 147 202026 SOK Mean Koang Kang 2 12 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 148 202027 PENG Lunn Koang Kang 2 8 12 96.00 96.00 0.00 0.00 149 202024 LENG Phalla Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 150 201016 CHHEUNG SyMon Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 151 202023 LENG Phalla Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 152 201015 KUL DungKosal Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 153 202022 KEU SokLeng Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 154 201018 SOCH LyHung Koang Kang 2 16 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 155 001041 SAM SyHeng Koang Kang 2 15.96 12 191.52 191.52 0.00 0.00 156 005040 KHEM Savy Koang Kang DK 32.2 4.5 144.90 144.90 0.00 0.00 157 005038 CHHEANG Sopheap Koang Kang 1 22.26 4.5 100.17 100.17 0.00 0.00 158 005039 LEANG Hoeun Koang Kang 1 37 4.5 166.50 166.50 0.00 0.00 159 005037 CHHI Chhey Koang Kang 1 32.59 4.5 146.50 146.65 0.15 0.00
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 160 201023 NGUN SomAun Koang Kang 2 65.6 12 787.20 787.20 0.00 0.00 161 201022 KEUT Sothea Koang Kang 2 52.8 12 75 633.60 633.60 0.00 0.00 162 201024 KEAM Jnor Koang Kang 3 16 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 163 202030 CHHIM Chang Koang Kang 3 22.4 85 1,904.00 1,904.00 0.00 0.00 164 203013 HOK Chhin Koang Kang 2 47.3 12 567.60 642.60 75.00 0.00 165 201025 CHHUN TainVuchLeng Koang Kang 2 41.66 12 75 499.92 499.92 0.00 0.00 166 202028 KRIN Sen Koang Kang 3 26.2 85 227.00 227.00 0.00 0.00 167 202031 HEANG YoeungVa Koang Kang 2 45 12 540.00 540.00 0.00 0.00 168 202029 LI M Kong Koang Kang 3 15.2 85 1,292.00 1,292.00 0.00 0.00 169 203017 SU Lang Koang Kang 2 70 12 840.00 840.00 0.00 0.00 170 203016 CHAN Lin Koang Kang 2 37 12 75 444.00 444.00 0.00 0.00 171 203014 LAK Leng Koang Kang 3 19.6 85 1,666.00 1,666.00 0.00 0.00 172 203020 CHEA Huy Koang Kang 3 16 85 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 173 203015 CHHENG Nang Koang Kang 2 67.5 12 810.00 810.00 0.00 0.00 174 203018 LY LengKim Koang Kang 2 55.18 12 4.86 662.16 662.16 0.00 0.00 175 201027 LY Mom Koang Kang 2 42.6 12 75 511.20 511.20 0.00 0.00 176 201028 AOEUNG Chea Koang Kang 2 54.6 12 655.20 655.20 0.00 0.00 177 201026 HEI Sokha Koang Kang 3 23 85 1,955.00 1,955.00 0.00 0.00 178 202034 CHANG Aunn Koang Kang 2 47.9 12 75 574.00 574.80 0.80 0.00 179 202033 KKUN Mom Koang Kang 2 61.74 12 740.88 740.88 0.00 0.00 180 201029 CHHEN Luna Koang Kang 3 16 85 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 181 202032 THAONG Sopheap Koang Kang 3 27.28 85 2,318.80 2,318.80 0.00 0.00 182 202035 LAM Yunn Koang Kang 3 16 85 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 183 203019 EAN MengHeng Koang Kang 2 41.2 12 494.40 494.40 0.00 0.00 184 001038 NONG Nak Koang Kang 1 13.94 4.5 62.73 0.00 0.00 62.73 185 001039 KOEUM Pheang Koang Kang 2 22.96 12 275.52 0.00 0.00 275.52 186 001040 KRIM Sen Koang Kang 2 9.24 12 110.88 0.00 0.00 110.88 Total 45 1315.35 0 27,178.96 26,805.78 75.95 338.25 187 202042 Kim Sung Kondol Chrum 3 27.90 85 2,371.50 2,260.75 0.00 110.75 188 202041 Ngun Tunnic Kondol Chrum 3 27.00 85 2,295.00 1,147.50 0.00 1,147.50 189 203022 Tuy Pearny Kondol Chrum 2 47.60 12 75 571.20 591.20 20.00 0.00 190 203023 Phar Vida Kondol Chrum 3 14.80 85 125.80 629.00 503.20 0.00 191 201035 Keng Sour Kondol Chrum 3 16.00 85 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 192 203024 Kouch Ny Kondol Chrum 2 50.15 12 75 601.00 696.00 95.00 0.00 193 201037 Tiv Sithar Kondol Chrum 2 70.20 12 842.40 842.40 0.00 0.00 194 202043 Sok Kry Kondol Chrum 3 24.80 85 2,108.00 2,108.00 0.00 0.00 195 203025 Khang Chany Kondol Chrum 2 64.08 12 768.96 768.96 0.00 0.00 196 201036 Morm Pov Kondol Chrum 3 16.80 85 1,428.00 1,428.00 0.00 0.00 197 202040 Tuy Lun Kondol Chrum 2 46.08 12 552.96 105.00 0.00 447.96 198 001034 Penh Ol Kondol Chrum 2 8.75 12 105.00 105.00 0.00 0.00 199 003051 Learng Horn Kondol Chrum 2 17.16 12 205.86 205.86 0.00 0.00
5 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 200 004037 Horn Sophal Kondol Chrum 1 10.72 4.5 48.26 48.26 0.00 0.00 201 030525 Kourch Murykea Kondol Chrum 2 19.28 12 231.36 231.36 0.00 0.00 202 004043 Seang Nhor Kondol Chrum 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 203 201033 PEN Roeun Kondol Chrum 2 53.12 12 637.44 637.44 0.00 0.00 204 202036 PEN Nat Kondol Chrum 3 24 85 2,040.00 2,040.00 0.00 0.00 205 202039 CHET Huy Kondol Chrum 2 63.28 12 765.84 765.84 0.00 0.00 206 202037 LAY Sombatt Kondol Chrum 2 63 12 756.00 756.00 0.00 0.00 207 201031 CHAN Thon Kondol Chrum 3 29.2 85 2,482.00 2,482.00 0.00 0.00 208 203021 BUN Thy Kondol Chrum 2 44 12 75 528.00 528.00 0.00 0.00 209 202038 KOEUM Sorn Kondol Chrum 2 55.04 12 50 660.48 660.48 0.00 0.00 210 201032 BAKK Ngang Kondol Chrum 4 15 12 480.00 480.00 0.00 0.00 211 201034 SUK Teang Kondol Chrum 4 15 140 2,100.00 2,100.00 0.00 0.00 212 201030 TY Montha Kondol Chrum 2 56.95 12 683.40 683.80 0.40 0.00 Total 26 899.91 0.00 24,838.46 23,750.85 618.60 1,706.21 213 001038 Seang Thy Kontout 1 34.00 4.5 153.00 153.00 0.00 0.00 214 002034 Lev Ly Kontout 1 14.80 4.5 66.60 66.60 0.00 0.00 215 002035 Né Somnang Kontout 1 27.06 4.5 121.77 121.77 0.00 0.00 216 003040 Seng Song Kontout 1 30.08 4.5 135.36 135.36 0.00 0.00 217 003039 Pov Sokkean Kontout 2 18.30 12 219.60 219.60 0.00 0.00 218 001037 Sok Phear Kontout 2 32.50 12 390.00 390.00 0.00 0.00 219 003038 Liv Mom Kontout 1 21.93 4.5 98.68 98.68 0.00 0.00 220 003037 Deun Sran Kontout 1 24.80 4.5 108.36 108.36 0.00 0.00 221 002033 Dong Chanthy Kontout 1 16.43 4.5 73.93 73.93 0.00 0.00 222 003028 Meung Kong Kontout 2 21.00 12 4.5 252.00 312.00 60.00 0.00 223 003029 Mok Va Kontout 1 dk 4.5 82.80 82.80 0.00 0.00 224 002025 Srim Srey Kontout 1 16.56 4.5 74.52 74.52 0.00 0.00 225 001025 Na SreyNoun Kontout 1 11.40 4.5 51.30 51.30 0.00 0.00 226 003027 Trouch Mom Kontout 2 18.50 12 222.00 222.00 0.00 0.00 227 002038 Yeun Chheun Kontout 1 14.40 4.5 64.80 64.80 0.00 0.00 228 002037 Norn Phy Kontout 1 8.75 4.5 39.37 39.37 0.00 0.00 229 003041 Ouk Dy Kontout 1 21.50 4.5 96.75 96.75 0.00 0.00 230 003042 Khev Tha Kontout 1 15.54 4.5 69.93 69.93 0.00 0.00 231 001039 Bun Beun Kontout 1 25.00 4.5 112.50 112.50 0.00 0.00 232 003035 Chen Chang Kontout 1 14.44 4.5 64.98 64.98 0.00 0.00 233 001033 Nai Pheach Kontout 1 18.00 4.5 81.00 81.00 0.00 0.00 234 002030 Pat Thoeuk Kontout 1 21.00 4.5 94.50 94.50 0.00 0.00 235 002031 Chheun chhay Kontout 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 236 001031 Tay Sokhum Kontout 2 32.50 12 390.00 390.00 0.00 0.00 237 001030 Chea Huch Kontout 2 20.00 12 240.00 240.00 0.00 0.00 238 003033 Chin Top Kontout 2 21.20 12 254.40 254.40 0.00 0.00 239 003034 Chem Kheng Kontout 1 16.00 4.5 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00
6 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 240 002028 Broeum Nan Kontout 1 23.40 4.5 105.30 105.30 0.00 0.00 241 002029 Hoa Hout Kontout 1 13.75 4.5 61.87 61.87 0.00 0.00 242 003032 Phoy Phal Kontout 2 30.00 12 360.00 360.00 0.00 0.00 243 001028 Khut Savat Kontout 2 17.50 12 210.00 210.00 0.00 0.00 244 003030 Hong Kheng Kontout 2 38.40 12 460.80 460.80 0.00 0.00 245 001027 Lort Hout Kontout 2 23.40 12 280.80 280.80 0.00 0.00 246 001029 Chhom Thol Kontout 2 8.60 12 103.20 103.20 0.00 0.00 247 003031 Haing Chhay Kontout 2 12.75 12 153.00 153.00 0.00 0.00 248 001026 Chan Ny Kontout 2 15.00 12 180.00 180.00 0.00 0.00 249 001032 Khy Phou Kontout 2 6.00 12 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00 250 002036 San Vandy Kontout 2 10.20 12 122.40 122.40 0.00 0.00 251 001035 Khut Vet Kontout 2 37.00 12 444.00 444.00 0.00 0.00 252 001036 Chea Sin Kontout 1 35.00 4.5 157.50 157.50 0.00 0.00 253 002032 Po Ko Kontout dk dk 4.86 0.00 439.41 439.41 0.00 254 001034 Yun Pheap Kontout 2 35.20 12 422.40 0.00 0.00 422.40 255 003036 Sao Kim Kontout 1 49.64 4.5 223.38 223.38 0.00 0.00 Total 43 891.53 0.00 7,076.80 7,153.81 499.41 422.40 256 001007 Sok Sara Kratie 1 15.40 4.5 69.30 69.30 0.00 0.00 257 001003 Oul Sreng Kratie 1 33.75 4.5 151.87 151.87 0.00 0.00 258 001004 Chhan Thom Kratie 1 32.00 4.5 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 259 003005 Vann Mean Kratie dk dk 12 0.00 384.00 384.00 0.00 260 003006 Theun Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 88.20 88.20 0.00 261 001008 Chan Choun Kratie 1 9.50 4.5 42.75 42.75 0.00 0.00 262 003002 Hong Ches Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 72.00 72.00 0.00 263 003001 San Moun Kratie dk dk 12 0.00 215.28 215.28 0.00 264 002010 Sao Penh Kratie dk dk 4.86 4.5 0.00 160.78 160.78 0.00 265 001002 Eu Chhen Kratie 2 15.96 12 191.52 191.52 0.00 0.00 266 003008 Khat Sokheun Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 100.30 100.30 0.00 267 003008 Chhoeum Seun Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 64.26 64.26 0.00 268 003004 Touch Narin Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 76.14 76.14 0.00 269 003007 Mé Pitou Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 73.87 73.87 0.00 270 002003 Om Sarin Kratie dk dk 12 0.00 201.60 201.60 0.00 271 002009 Vong Et Kratie dk dk 4.5 0.00 151.20 151.20 0.00 272 001005 Keak hout Kratie 1 55.00 4.5 247.50 247.50 0.00 0.00 273 001006 Koeum Sophorn Kratie 1 10.64 4.5 47.88 47.88 0.00 0.00 274 001001 Ngoun Sitha Kratie 1 78.00 4.5 351.00 351.00 0.00 0.00 275 002005 Chorn Senghear Kratie 2 18.56 12 222.72 222.72 0.00 0.00 276 002008 Norng Malai Kratie 1 22.00 4.5 99.00 99.00 0.00 0.00 277 003003 Mang Engheang Kratie 1 dk 4.5 87.97 87.97 0.00 0.00 278 001009 Chan Vouthea Kratie 1 14.00 4.5 63.00 63.00 0.00 0.00 279 002001 Loa Heang Kratie 2 28.81 19.61 12 4.5 433.96 433.96 0.00 0.00
7 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 280 002002 Heng Chhai Neng Kratie dk dk 12 4.86 0.00 480.48 480.48 0.00 281 201019 Chheang Char Kratie dk 12 0.00 180.00 180.00 0.00 Total 26 333.62 19.61 2,152.47 4,400.58 2,248.11 0.00 282 203030 Sorn Sophan Krek 3 18 85 1,530.00 1,530.00 0.00 0.00 283 202044 Kheav Searn Krek 2 49.6 12 595.20 665.20 70.00 0.00 284 203031 Sek Sab Krek 2 76.36 12 0.00 458.16 458.16 0.00 285 202046 Ya Somnarng Krek 3 16 8.5 1,360.00 1,360.00 0.00 0.00 286 203032 Pich Sopeap Krek 2 49.2 12 590.40 590.40 0.00 0.00 287 203033 Koav Thon Krek 2 69.84 12 838.08 1,029.64 191.56 0.00 288 201044 Touch Sarrieun Krek 2 48.8 12 585.60 585.60 0.00 0.00 289 201042 Sourn Narin Krek 2 51.2 12 614.40 689.40 75.00 0.00 290 201043 Lim Sokheang Krek 3 21.8 85 1,853.00 1,853.00 0.00 0.00 291 201045 Hem Sokha Krek 3 17.5 85 1,487.50 1,487.00 0.00 0.50 292 202002 Kri Va Krek 2 21.45 12 257.40 0.00 0.00 257.40 293 201025 Cheng Seng Heang Krek 2 12 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 294 202004 Heng Vana Krek 2 18.72 12 224.64 0.00 0.00 224.64 295 201004 Searn Lau Krek 1 15.6 4.5 70.20 70.20 0.00 0.00 296 201006 Chea Sokorn Krek 2 19.52 12 234.24 234.24 0.00 0.00 297 203005 Heang Pum Krek 2 10 12 120.00 120.00 0.00 0.00 298 201008 Pin Sarak Krek 2 17.95 12 215.40 215.40 0.00 0.00 299 202009 Long Khearm Krek 1 33.84 4.5 152.28 0.00 0.00 152.28 300 203028 Hear Limhearng Krek 2 72.00 12 864.00 864.00 0.00 0.00 301 203029 Heart Kearm Krek 2 50.40 12 604.80 604.80 0.00 0.00 302 201038 Kearm Thavy Krek 2 53.24 12 638.88 638.88 0.00 0.00 303 203026 Chum Rearng Krek 2 46.50 12 558.00 633.00 75.00 0.00 304 203027 Bark Pou Krek 2 41.60 12 499.20 499.20 0.00 0.00 305 202045 Cheark Sokly Krek 3 26.40 85 2,244.00 2,244.00 0.00 0.00 306 201039 Hong Hun Krek 3 14.00 85 1,190.00 1,190.00 0.00 0.00 307 020207 Ney Peark Krek 3 18.30 85 1,555.50 1,555.50 0.00 0.00 308 201040 Saray Chanthy Krek 2 47.00 12 639.00 631.00 0.00 8.00 309 201041 Prark Sophearn Krek 2 62.00 12 744.00 744.00 0.00 0.00 310 203034 Hok Chang Krek 2 44.5 12 534.00 534.00 0.00 0.00 311 202048 Ney Rin Krek 2 46.3 12 555.60 555.60 0.00 0.00 312 203036 Yeam Kimlin Krek 3 17.2 85 1,462.00 731.00 0.00 731.00 313 203035 Um Keat Krek 3 18 85 1,530.00 1,530.00 0.00 0.00 314 203037 Rus Sarearn Krek 2 43.8 12 525.60 545.60 20.00 0.00 315 203001 SUK Sim Krek 1 21.2 4.5 95.40 145.40 50.00 0.00 316 201002 BUT An Krek 1 8.5 4.5 38.25 0.00 0.00 38.25 317 201003 NEANG Sothy Krek 1 14.48 4.5 65.16 65.16 0.00 0.00 318 202001 KIM Sokna Krek 2 10.34 12 124.08 0.00 0.00 124.08 319 203004 CHIV Voeung Krek 1 15.18 4.5 68.31 68.31 0.00 0.00
8 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 320 203002 HUN Sinat Krek 2 6 12 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00 321 202016 HEM Sytha Krek 3 28.16 85.00 85.00 1,860.48 1,860.48 0.00 0.00 322 201009 CHHOEUM Thy Krek 2 26.06 12 312.72 312.72 0.00 0.00 323 203011 SUN Phalla Krek DK DK 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 324 203009 KHEK Srey Krek 1 23.4 4.5 105.30 105.30 0.00 0.00 325 202011 PHIN Soaphoann Krek 1 19.84 4.5 89.28 89.28 0.00 0.00 326 202012 SEANG Nak Krek 1 14.72 4.5 66.24 66.24 0.00 0.00 327 201011 AING Sunheag Krek 2 21.25 12 255.36 255.36 0.00 0.00 328 202017 NUCH Phim Krek 2 27.2 12 326.40 326.40 0.00 0.00 329 202013 HANG Nanna Krek 2 10.92 12 131.40 131.40 0.00 0.00 330 202014 CHHEM Phallet Krek 2 12.48 12 149.76 149.76 0.00 0.00 331 202015 KIM Roung Krek 2 9.5 12 114.00 144.00 30.00 0.00 332 202021 POV Vichet Krek 1 15 4.5 85.50 85.50 0.00 0.00 333 202018 HENG Chuk Krek 2 20.8 12 249.60 249.60 0.00 0.00 334 202019 KORNN Nim Krek 1 8.32 4.5 37.44 37.44 0.00 0.00 335 202020 PROM Nin Krek 1 17.64 4.5 79.38 79.38 0.00 0.00 336 203012 NUM Naren Krek 2 24 12 288.00 288.00 0.00 0.00 337 201013 CHHEUNG Kosal Krek 2 14.04 12 168.48 168.48 0.00 0.00 338 201014 MEAS Kunthea Krek dk 4.86 0.00 174.96 174.96 0.00 339 001001 BRAS Srey Krek 2 11.47 12 4.86 137.70 163.31 25.61 0.00 340 001002 IY KimHark Krek 2 14.17 12 170.04 170.04 0.00 0.00 341 001003 TAING Eng Krek 2 12.24 12 146.88 146.88 0.00 0.00 342 001024 KHENG MengHong Krek 2 9.38 12 112.56 112.56 0.00 0.00 343 202008 Duch Saran Krek 2 10.2 12 122.40 0.00 0.00 122.40 Total 62 1595.11 0 30,489.04 30,000.78 1,170.29 1,658.55 344 302035 Cheav Pi Me Mut 2 40.32 12 483.84 483.84 0.00 0.00 345 301015 Kaov Menghak Me Mut 2 32.38 12 388.56 388.56 0.00 0.00 346 301016 Tea Kimhourt Me Mut 2 29.88 12 358.56 358.56 0.00 0.00 347 304055 Chhay Buntha Me Mut 4 17.7 2,478.00 2,478.00 0.00 0.00 348 303053 Ven Yeng Me Mut 2 56.94 683.26 683.26 0.00 0.00 349 303049 Yorng Srangyon Me Mut 4 18.05 2,527.00 2,527.00 0.00 0.00 350 304053 Sim Sokna Me Mut 3 18.78 1,596.30 1,596.30 0.00 0.00 351 304045 Chea Rat Me Mut 4 28 3,920.00 3,920.00 0.00 0.00 352 303058 Srey Meng Me Mut 3 18.4 1,564.00 2,742.00 1,178.00 0.00 353 303052 Siv Hour Me Mut 3 18.25 1,551.25 1,551.25 0.00 0.00 354 303056 Hem Sengkeav Me Mut 4 18.2 2,548.00 2,548.00 0.00 0.00 355 303051 Say Yek Me Mut 2 57.6 691.20 766.20 75.00 0.00 356 304049 Lean Kimsoy Me Mut 2 49.8 597.60 597.60 0.00 0.00 357 301054 Cham Domdek Me Mut 2 59.4 712.80 712.80 0.00 0.00 358 301051 Nai Teang Me Mut 2 62.16 745.92 745.92 0.00 0.00 359 304054 Eng Seang Me Mut 3 21.25 1,806.25 1,806.25 0.00 0.00
9 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 360 303050 Tea Kimkhuy Me Mut 3 17.5 1,487.50 1,562.50 75.00 0.00 361 303051 Tea Kimhun Me Mut 2 147 1,764.00 1,764.00 0.00 0.00 362 304051 Yem Chorm Me Mut 3 17.8 1,513.00 1,513.00 0.00 0.00 363 304044 Hung Keng Me Mut 3 31.75 2,715.75 2,717.76 2.01 0.00 364 304046 Meng Tai Me Mut 3 17.7 1,504.50 1,504.50 0.00 0.00 365 301048 Thorn Buntharn Me Mut 3 18.8 1,598.00 1,598.00 0.00 0.00 366 301047 Seng Sean Hor Me Mut 4 18.7 2,618.00 2,618.00 0.00 0.00 367 304047 Soum Heng Me Mut 3 18.4 1,564.00 1,564.00 0.00 0.00 368 302042 Chea Menghong Me Mut 2 17.12 12 205.44 205.44 0.00 0.00 369 302043 Keov Sarat Me Mut 1 49.82 4.5 224.19 224.19 0.00 0.00 370 302041 Sok Tri Me Mut 2 12.5 12 150.00 150.00 0.00 0.00 371 302044 Nov Van Me Mut dk dk dk 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 372 303025 Sim Chayhong Me Mut 1 33.17 450 149.26 149.26 0.00 0.00 373 303022 Sok Chany Me Mut 2 17 12 204.00 204.00 0.00 0.00 374 303023 Nim Soy Me Mut 1 26.04 4.5 117.18 117.18 0.00 0.00 375 301028 Long Chamtean Me Mut 1 24 4.5 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 376 303024 Sun Marn Me Mut 2 25 12 300.00 300.00 0.00 0.00 377 301029 Sok Ky Me Mut 1 20 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 378 304013 Veng Horl Me Mut 2 13.75 12 4.5 291.56 291.56 0.00 0.00 379 304011 Chiv Songheng Me Mut 2 25.62 12 50 307.44 357.44 50.00 0.00 380 304012 Nourn Sour Me Mut 2 18.6 12 223.20 223.20 0.00 0.00 381 304007 Sun Ly Me Mut 2 14.1 12 169.20 169.20 0.00 0.00 382 304006 Meas Thai Me Mut 2 14.26 12 171.12 171.12 0.00 0.00 383 301023 Chourn Ngov Me Mut 2 13.14 12 157.68 157.68 0.00 0.00 384 304026 Sim Kimheang Me Mut 2 13.5 12 162.00 162.00 0.00 0.00 385 301024 Arng Tong Me Mut 2 13.74 12 164.88 164.88 0.00 0.00 386 301021 Mar Kihourt Me Mut 2 13.46 12 161.52 161.52 0.00 0.00 387 303013 Trang Min Me Mut 2 14.227 12 170.72 170.72 0.00 0.00 388 303014 Seak Thor Me Mut 2 14.31 12 171.72 171.72 0.00 0.00 389 331022 Mom Kourng Me Mut 2 12.46 12 149.52 149.52 0.00 0.00 390 303019 Hour Menghourt Me Mut 2 13.115 12 157.38 157.37 0.00 0.01 391 304008 Keat Heavly Me Mut 2 58.24 12 698.88 698.88 0.00 0.00 392 301027 Huch Hum Me Mut 2 13.1 12 157.20 157.20 0.00 0.00 393 301025 Chin Ta Me Mut 2 12.97 12 155.64 155.64 0.00 0.00 394 303020 Sean Sombor Me Mut 2 14.4 12 172.80 172.80 0.00 0.00 395 304014 Vit Chuch Me Mut 1 14 4.5 63.00 63.00 0.00 0.00 396 303021 Sin Moa Me Mut 2 12 12 144.00 144.00 0.00 0.00 397 302036 Hong Peng Me Mut 2 23.89 12 406.68 406.68 0.00 0.00 398 301010 Yarn Kong Me Mut 3 5.85 85 149.17 149.17 0.00 0.00 399 301009 Lort Buntheng Me Mut 3 5.85 85 149.17 149.17 0.00 0.00 400 304004 Ly Hong Me Mut 2 31.5 12 378.00 378.00 0.00 0.00
10 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 401 301017 Tea Kimhean Me Mut 2 33.62 12 403.44 403.44 0.00 0.00 402 303012 Pou Kimlarng Me Mut 2 32.89 12 394.68 394.68 0.00 0.00 403 301019 Thourng Chea Me Mut 2 31.92 12 383.04 383.04 0.00 0.00 404 301018 Hean Punleu Me Mut 2 31.95 12 383.40 383.40 0.00 0.00 405 303016 Kim Hang Me Mut 2 36.19 12 434.25 434.28 0.03 0.00 406 304050 Tuy Channta Me Mut 2 70.56 846.72 921.72 75.00 0.00 407 301052 Touch Sarrieun Me Mut 2 79.36 952.32 952.32 0.00 0.00 408 303054 Saoum Sophal Me Mut 2 63.36 760.32 760.32 0.00 0.00 409 301050 Saoum Sikearn Me Mut 2 105.00 1,260.00 1,260.00 0.00 0.00 410 303057 Lim Hok Me Mut 2 75.42 905.04 980.04 75.00 0.00 411 303055 Heng Bunchan Me Mut 2 74.69 896.28 970.28 74.00 0.00 412 304052 Hars Narvy Me Mut 2 59.25 711.00 711.00 0.00 0.00 413 301049 Chea Khon Me Mut 2 73.92 887.04 962.04 75.00 0.00 414 304048 Khearv Hout Me Mut 2 56.42 677.04 677.04 0.00 0.00 415 301053 Yin Sivon Me Mut 3 16.80 1,428.00 1,503.00 75.00 0.00 416 303052 Sboung Sichorm Me Mut 3 20.00 1,700.00 1,700.00 0.00 0.00 417 301020 Ly Lyhau Me Mut 2 36.40 12 436.80 436.80 0.00 0.00 418 303015 Ary Chu Me Mut 2 17.64 12 211.68 211.68 0.00 0.00 419 302040 Chin Chanlearng Me Mut 2 27.36 12 328.32 403.32 75.00 0.00 420 301001 Heark Hearn Me Mut 1 20.21 4.5 90.94 90.94 0.00 0.00 421 301002 Pen Searn Me Mut 1 6.50 4.5 29.94 29.25 0.00 0.69 422 303004 Prark Phal Me Mut 1 12.60 4.5 59.70 56.70 0.00 3.00 423 303003 Huch Norb Me Mut 1 18.29 4.5 82.30 82.30 0.00 0.00 424 303005 Ket Kunthy Me Mut 1 10.24 4.5 46.08 46.08 0.00 0.00 425 301006 Sun Sokeng Me Mut 2 17.00 12 204.00 204.00 0.00 0.00 426 302039 Hearn Me Mut 2 9.46 12 113.52 113.52 0.00 0.00 427 301008 Seng Arn Me Mut 2 15.75 12 189.00 198.72 9.72 0.00 428 301014 Kim Larng Me Mut 2 32.30 12 387.60 387.60 0.00 0.00 429 303010 Keart Kim Ngong Me Mut 2 35.22 12 422.59 422.59 0.00 0.00 430 303011 Ly Num Hearng Me Mut 2 33.49 12 401.85 401.85 0.00 0.00 431 303006 Eang Lai Me Mut dk dk 4.86 0.00 165.24 165.24 0.00 432 401007 Loeum Mom Me Mut 3 11.1 85 969.00 969.00 0.00 0.00 433 401002 Sok Meng Me Mut dk dk 0.75 4.86 12 0.00 180.96 180.96 0.00 434 303009 Pon Kong Me Mut 4 19.048 13.999 140 140 3,842.70 3,842.70 0.00 0.00 435 304010 Keo Chhay Me Mut 3 13.5 85 688.50 688.50 0.00 0.00 436 303018 Chea Kim Me Mut 4 15.2 140 1,276.80 1,276.80 0.00 0.00 437 301011 Houng Peng Me Mut 4 18.36 13.5 140 140 3,704.40 3,704.40 0.00 0.00 438 304002 Mork Dany Me Mut 4 18.405 13.5 140 140 3,710.70 3,710.70 0.00 0.00 439 304001 Ev Sony Me Mut 4 18.9 13.95 140 140 3,817.80 3,817.80 0.00 0.00 440 304003 Hak Palla Me Mut 4 19.08 13.275 140 3,786.30 3,786.30 0.00 0.00 441 304005 Ung Dorn Me Mut 4 19.38 13.543 140 140 3,850.82 3,850.82 0.00 0.00
11 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 442 304009 Tea Kimhoueng Me Mut 4 13.95 140 1,171.80 1,171.80 0.00 0.00 443 303007 Maov Thavry Me Mut 4 21.074 15.8 14040*60% 4,278.23 4,278.23 0.00 0.00 444 303008 Ly Chan Me Mut 4 18.45 13.725 14040*60% 3,735.90 3,735.90 0.00 0.00 445 301012 Thab Yin Me Mut 4 18 13.5 14040*60% 3,654.00 3,654.00 0.00 0.00 446 302037 Var Laysearm Me Mut 2 12.05 12 144.60 144.60 0.00 0.00 Total 103 2835.79 124.79 98,556.28 100,737.54 2,184.96 3.70 447 004009 Peth Oun Morng Reav 2 42.93 505.16 257.58 0.00 247.58 448 003014 Soeum Sophat Morng Reav 2 19.44 233.28 233.28 0.00 0.00 449 001011 Kim Sokom Morng Reav 2 16.32 195.84 195.84 0.00 0.00 450 002038 Koe Engly Morng Reav 2 34.4 412.80 412.80 0.00 0.00 451 002033 Bot Chantha Morng Reav 2 25 300.00 300.00 0.00 0.00 452 002037 Chhom Sitha Morng Reav 2 23 276.00 276.00 0.00 0.00 453 002035 Meas Sroy Morng Reav 2 20.8 249.60 249.6 0.00 0.00 454 002034 Korng Noeum Morng Reav 2 20.5 246.00 266.00 20.00 0.00 455 002036 Chhok Vanna Morng Reav 2 25.85 310.20 310.20 0.00 0.00 Total 9 228.24 0 2,728.88 2,501.30 20.00 247.58 456 002016 Leun Khouch Orussey 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 457 002014 Sun Channang Orussey 1 22.88 4.5 102.96 102.96 0.00 0.00 458 003017 Toun Ly Orussey 2 30.24 12 362.88 362.88 0.00 0.00 459 003015 Chat Chan Orussey 1 14.40 4.5 64.80 64.80 0.00 0.00 460 003016 Vorn Chorn Orussey 1 24.80 4.5 111.60 111.60 0.00 0.00 461 002015 Ek Sindeun Orussey 2 15.51 12 186.12 186.12 0.00 0.00 462 001015 Ros Sareun Orussey 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 60.48 0.00 0.00 463 001014 Ouk Hean Orussey 1 23.20 4.5 104.40 104.40 0.00 0.00 464 001013 Thai Sdeung Orussey 2 7.50 12 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 465 003014 Hat Bros Orussey 1 9.00 4.5 40.50 40.50 0.00 0.00 466 002018 Chao Nhy Orussey 1 10.88 4.5 48.96 48.96 0.00 0.00 467 003018 Somreth Pech Orussey 2 14.62 12 175.44 175.44 0.00 0.00 468 001016 Mok Phalla Orussey 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 469 002017 Yun Mach Orussey 2 20.00 12 240.00 240.00 0.00 0.00 470 003013 Seung Van Orussey dk dk 4.5 0.00 23.62 23.62 0.00 471 002013 Seng Hor Orussey 2 16.25 12 195.00 195.00 0.00 0.00 472 003012 Dong Chhom Orussey dk dk 4.5 74.97 74.97 0.00 0.00 473 001012 Rotha Phalla Orussey 1 3.00 4.5 13.50 13.50 0.00 0.00 474 002012 Aet Pin Orussey 1 11.90 4.5 53.55 53.55 0.00 0.00 475 003011 Sdeung Sok Orussey dk dk 4.5 0.00 87.75 87.75 0.00 476 001011 Tann Phally Orussey 1 16.25 4.5 73.12 73.12 0.00 0.00 477 001010 Phon Mach Orussey 2 25.80 12 309.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 478 003010 Chhen Saseun Orussey dk dk 4.5 0.00 78.75 78.75 0.00 479 002011 Seang Eung Orussey 1 9.60 2.53 4.5 4.86 58.03 58.03 0.00 0.00 480 003021 Chap Leun Orussey 1 8.96 4.5 40.32 40.32 0.00 0.00
12 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 481 003022 Soun Lim Orussey 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 482 002021 Ly Kong Orussey 2 20.91 12 250.92 250.92 0.00 0.00 483 003020 Puk Sophal Orussey 2 27.01 12 324.12 324.12 0.00 0.00 484 001020 Hin Sokhen Orussey 1 11.20 4.5 50.40 50.40 0.00 0.00 485 001019 Yong Yean Orussey 1 12.25 4.5 55.12 55.12 0.00 0.00 486 002022 Thong Bon Orussey 1 14.40 4.5 64.80 64.80 0.00 0.00 487 001018 Dean Dina Orussey 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 488 001021 Heng Khourch Orussey 2 19.57 12 234.84 234.84 0.00 0.00 489 003019 Long Kiman Orussey 2 17.60 12 211.80 211.20 0.00 0.60 490 001017 Hem Vann Orussey 1 20.00 4.5 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 491 002019 Chhen Sopal Orussey 2 37.75 12 405.00 405.00 0.00 0.00 Total 36 558.92 2.53 4,453.23 4,642.75 190.12 0.60 492 201004 Hon Sinean Snour 2 18.40 12 220.80 220.80 0.00 0.00 493 204002 Chhon Ny Snour 2 33.54 12(60%)2(100%) 332.25 332.25 0.00 0.00 494 204003 Long Hor Snour 2 22.67 12 272.04 272.04 0.00 0.00 495 204004 Loch Son Snour 2 23.23 12 278.76 278.76 0.00 0.00 496 202005 Bet Bounhean Snour 1 30.01 4.5 135.04 135.04 0.00 0.00 497 202006 Bet Bonhan Snour 1 15.18 4.5 68.31 68.31 0.00 0.00 498 201006 Peng Ouen Snour 1 18.00 4.5 81.00 81.00 0.00 0.00 499 201005 Kong Many Snour 2 23.56 12 282.72 282.72 0.00 0.00 500 203007 Chhon Vanna Snour 2 25.44 12 305.28 305.28 0.00 0.00 501 203009 Sean Chea Snour 1 38.16 4.5 171.72 171.72 0.00 0.00 502 203010 Kong Bai Snour 1 31.20 4.5 50 140.40 140.40 0.00 0.00 503 202016 Loeum Kon Snour 2 20.70 12 50 298.40 298.40 0.00 0.00 504 204012 Sat Ret Snour 2 61.60 12 50 739.20 739.20 0.00 0.00 505 201013 Heng Mom Snour 1 14.00 4.5 50 63.00 63.00 0.00 0.00 506 201012 Ké Mei Snour 1 20.00 4.5 50 90.00 90.00 0.00 0.00 507 203016 Chip Sann Snour 1 16.00 4.5 50 72.00 72.00 0.00 0.00 508 204007 Koeum SengKim Snour 2 77.00 12 924.00 924.00 0.00 0.00 509 201009 Sam San Snour 2 18.90 12 224.80 226.80 2.00 0.00 510 201010 Yean Sophean Snour 1 34.96 4.5 157.32 157.32 0.00 0.00 511 201008 Saom Nakry Snour 1 19.24 4.5 50 86.58 86.58 0.00 0.00 512 202017 Pa Buntheun Snour 2 40.80 12 50 439.60 439.60 0.00 0.00 513 202011 Thav Tho Snour 1 21.60 4.5 97.20 97.20 0.00 0.00 514 202014 Theng Vanak Snour 2 56.26 12 675.12 675.12 0.00 0.00 515 202015 Chiv Mein Snour 1 15.17 4.5 68.26 68.26 0.00 0.00 516 204005 Kem Sareun Snour 2 66.00 12 792.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 517 202012 Chhang Vech Snour 2 17.50 12 210.00 210.00 0.00 0.00 518 203018 Sor Ret Snour 2 20.01 12 240.12 240.12 0.00 0.00 519 203012 Chhang Neang Snour 2 37.44 12 449.28 449.28 0.00 0.00 520 203013 Tear Khang Snour 2 26.46 12 317.52 317.52 0.00 0.00
13 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 521 204010 Chhang Yen Snour 1 25.37 4.5 114.60 114.16 0.00 0.44 522 201011 Soam Bross Snour 2 32.00 12 384.00 384.00 0.00 0.00 523 203011 Men Vongdy Snour 1 13.02 4.5 58.59 58.59 0.00 0.00 524 203004 Phan Pheun Snour 2 16.64 12 199.68 199.68 0.00 0.00 525 204001 Sen Lip Snour 2 17.94 12 215.28 215.28 0.00 0.00 526 202002 Vanna Nalin Snour 2 16.00 12 192.00 192.00 0.00 0.00 527 202003 Heng Hong Snour 1 13.00 4.5 58.50 58.50 0.00 0.00 528 203003 So Seun Snour 2 19.84 12 2,380.08 2,380.08 0.00 0.00 529 203006 Sok Sorin Snour 1 14.72 4.5 66.24 66.24 0.00 0.00 530 203005 Ming Kha Snour 1 15.58 4.5 70.11 70.11 0.00 0.00 531 201003 Doung Pach Snour 2 30.00 12 360.00 360.00 0.00 0.00 532 202010 Sé Viseth Snour 2 18.13 12 217.56 217.56 0.00 0.00 533 202004 Yen Monoarom Snour 2 17.62 12 211.44 211.44 0.00 0.00 534 201007 Nou Loun Snour 1 45.36 4.5 204.12 204.12 0.00 0.00 535 202009 Soeum Nai Orn Snour 1 20.58 4.5 92.61 92.61 0.00 0.00 536 202008 Hout Maran Snour 1 15.50 4.5 50 69.75 119.75 50.00 0.00 537 203014 Tronu Snour 2 30.24 12 362.88 362.88 0.00 0.00 538 203008 Pen Sara Snour 2 68.04 12 816.48 816.48 0.00 0.00 539 201002 Out Vothy Snour 2 45.90 12 50 550.80 600.80 50.00 0.00 540 202018 Tear Hark Snour 2 60.06 12 50 770.72 770.72 0.00 0.00 541 204006 Ton Bro Snour 2 24.20 12 290.40 290.40 0.00 0.00 542 202013 Morn Chem Snour 2 28.06 12 336.72 336.72 0.00 0.00 543 203015 Korn Heng Snour 2 38.50 12 462.00 462.00 0.00 0.00 544 203017 Hong Kheun Snour 2 44.00 12 528.00 528.00 0.00 0.00 545 202007 Seng hy Snour 2 9.35 12 112.20 112.20 0.00 0.00 546 204008 Meun Chhout Snour 2 31.53 12 378.36 378.36 0.00 0.00 Total 55 1574.21 0.00 17,735.84 17,837.40 102.00 0.44 547 302030 Thouv Chantha Sourng 3 18.18 85 1,545.30 772.65 0.00 772.65 548 302031 Min Thai Sourng 3 18.04 85 1,533.40 766.70 0.00 766.70 549 302032 Nang Bunsan Sourng 3 19.40 85 1,649.00 824.50 0.00 824.50 550 302033 Tek Lemheng Sourng 2 8.10 12 97.20 97.20 0.00 0.00 551 005020 KEK Hung Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 552 004027 PHEANG Njok Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 553 003033 EAP BunHey Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 554 001021 POV Phang Sourng 3 18.26 85 1,552.10 776.05 0.00 776.05 555 003032 SOK Kim Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 556 004019 KEO Vud Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 557 001029 THEAM Nov Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 558 005029 ENG Vibol Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 559 003042 YU Hong Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 560 005017 LY Kornn Sourng 3 18 85 1,530.00 765.00 0.00 765.00
14 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 561 005014 BUN Norn Sourng 3 18 85 1,530.00 765.00 0.00 765.00 562 005021 LY LongSrun Sourng 3 45.9 85 3,901.50 1,950.75 0.00 1,950.75 563 003043 VOV Chhung Sourng 3 43.35 85 3,684.75 1,842.38 0.00 1,842.37 564 003044 ROV Sophal Sourng 3 9.75 85 828.75 414.37 0.00 414.38 565 003041 KHAN Srey Sourng 3 16 85 1,360.00 680.00 0.00 680.00 566 003037 TAING LeakChay Sourng 3 9.6 85 816.00 445.50 0.00 370.50 567 003034 SOUNG Hean Sourng 3 9.6 85 816.00 408.00 0.00 408.00 568 302012 KHANN Sothoeun Sourng 4 18.80 140.00 2,632.00 1,316.00 0.00 1,316.00 569 302011 SOM Saret Sourng 4 17.09 140.00 2,392.60 1,196.30 0.00 1,196.30 570 302010 HENG Deun Sourng 4 16.40 140.00 2,296.00 1,148.00 0.00 1,148.00 571 302009 OUK Hur Sourng 4 16.40 140.00 2,240.00 1,120.00 0.00 1,120.00 572 302008 HONG SothyLa Sourng 4 16.40 140.00 2,296.00 1,148.00 0.00 1,148.00 573 302007 PANG Sruy Sourng 3 16.62 85.00 1,412.70 706.35 0.00 706.35 574 302006 CHHEY Srun Sourng 3 16.40 85.00 1,394.00 697.00 0.00 697.00 575 302016 TAING Chour Sourng 3 14.06 85.00 1,195.10 597.55 0.00 597.55 576 302017 SAIM Heang Sourng 3 13.70 85.00 1,164.50 582.25 0.00 582.25 577 302018 YU NgounEang Sourng 3 14.00 85.00 1,190.00 595.00 0.00 595.00 578 003029 KONG Sokun Sourng 2 8.61 12.00 103.32 103.32 0.00 0.00 579 004044 CHEANG Sinila Sourng 4 16.80 140.00 2,352.00 0.00 0.00 2,352.00 580 001028 TOEUK Kimsrun Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 581 001022 LEANG Hang Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 582 001020 POEUK Chhunny Sourng 4 16.4 140 2,296.00 1,148.00 0.00 1,148.00 583 005013 HUR YuThai Sourng 4 22.56 140 3,158.40 1,579.20 0.00 1,579.20 584 005016 LOA SyHoung Sourng 4 22.56 140 3,158.40 1,579.20 0.00 1,579.20 585 003040 KOR Trey Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 586 005019 THAI Ngonn Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 587 003039 NGAND Ky Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 588 004036 KHUY Hong Sourng 3 18 85 1,530.00 1,530.00 0.00 0.00 589 004018 KAING TaiHang Sourng 2 3.75 12 45.00 45.00 0.00 0.00 590 004026 TAING Ngonn Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 591 003038 LIM Try Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 592 005023 HU Yuthai Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 593 005023 CHHUN Chang Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 594 003035 MENG Kong Sourng 3 9.6 85 816.00 408.00 0.00 408.00 595 003036 KIM Eang Sourng 3 12.6 85 1,071.00 535.50 0.00 535.50 596 003045 SEAV Im Sourng 3 13.05 85 1,109.25 554.62 0.00 554.63 597 004021 AOEUNG Muyheang Sourng 2 11.25 12 135.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 598 004022 PHEN Sreang Sourng 2 11.25 12 135.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 599 004023 PHEN Aang Sourng 2 11.57 12 138.90 138.90 0.00 0.00 600 004024 MUY Heang Sourng 2 11.325 12 135.90 135.90 0.00 0.00 601 004025 BRAK Long Sourng 2 11.75 12 141.00 141.00 0.00 0.00
15 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 602 005022 Seang KimSreang Sourng 3 20.4 85 1,734.00 867.00 0.00 867.00 603 005024 KKAV Mang Sourng 2 11.25 12 135.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 604 005028 KONG Hort Sourng 2 11.88 12 142.56 142.56 0.00 0.00 605 005031 Peng Tong Sourng 3 28 85 2,380.00 1,190.00 0.00 1,190.00 606 005027 LAY Srun Sourng 3 14.55 85 1,236.75 618.38 0.00 618.37 607 003046 LY Sok Kheang Sourng 4 21.165 140 2,963.10 1,481.55 0.00 1,481.55 608 004031 YANG Dat Sourng 4 18 140 2,520.00 2,520.00 0.00 0.00 609 004029 SRUN SukHang Sourng 4 18.91 140 2,648.77 2,648.77 0.00 0.00 610 004030 SUN Nhe Sourng 3 21.75 85 1,848.75 1,848.75 0.00 0.00 611 004028 TOUCH Lyphu Sourng 4 18.91 140 2,648.77 2,648.77 0.00 0.00 612 005025 CHRER Phuy Sourng 4 12.3 140 1,722.00 861.00 0.00 861.00 613 005026 SUN Heang Sourng 3 14.1 85 1,198.50 599.25 0.00 599.25 614 005030 Sourng BunAeng Sourng 3 18 85 1,530.00 765.00 0.00 765.00 615 001032 TRY Sok Sourng 2 9.5 12 114.00 114.00 0.00 0.00 616 003025 CHANN Thorn Sourng 4 16 140 2,240.00 1,120.00 0.00 1,120.00 617 001018 BUN Srun Sourng 4 16.3 140 2,282.00 1,141.00 0.00 1,141.00 618 003020 LONG Thuk Sourng 1 18.92 4.5 85.14 85.14 0.00 0.00 619 003016 CHHEANG PengHoa Sourng 1 49 4.5 220.50 220.50 0.00 0.00 620 003019 TAING NaiSeng Sourng 2 70 12 840.00 420.00 0.00 420.00 621 001017 MEAS Ly Sourng 2 34.88 12 50 418.56 418.56 0.00 0.00 622 004012 MOANH Lyheang Sourng 1 6.97 4.5 31.36 31.36 0.00 0.00 623 302013 Tea Sreng Sourng 4 21.18 140 2,965.20 1,482.60 0.00 1,482.60 624 302014 Chhay Niam Sourng 4 18.22 140 2,550.80 1,275.40 0.00 1,275.40 625 302024 Heng Sokhai Sourng 4 18.58 140 2,601.20 1,300.60 0.00 1,300.60 626 302034 Miam Toma Sourng 2 8.10 12 97.20 97.20 0.00 0.00 627 302019 Pau Suyheang Sourng 4 18.63 140 2,608.20 1,304.10 0.00 1,304.10 628 302023 Cheang Leanggegh Sourng 4 18.63 140 2,608.20 1,304.10 0.00 1,304.10 629 302020 Soeum Sithov Sourng 4 18.31 140 2,563.00 1,281.70 0.00 1,281.30 630 302021 Moeung Senghout Sourng 4 18.58 140 2,601.20 1,300.60 0.00 1,300.60 631 302022 Chea Menghav Sourng 4 18.45 140 2,583.00 1,291.50 0.00 1,291.50 632 302025 Tiang Seang Sourng 3 18.22 85 1,548.70 774.35 0.00 774.35 633 302026 Toeuk Sron Sourng 3 18.38 85 1,562.30 481.15 0.00 1,081.15 634 302027 Kim Heng Sourng 3 18.40 85 1,564.00 782.00 0.00 782.00 635 302028 Keat Chhin Sourng 3 18.18 85 1,545.30 772.65 0.00 772.65 636 302029 Yoeum Hour Sourng 3 18.42 85 1,565.70 782.85 0.00 782.85 637 001013 Kim Thia Sourng 2 dk 40 0.00 50.00 0.00 50.00 638 003027 MEY Sytha Sourng 4 17.1 140 2,394.00 1,197.00 0.00 1,197.00 639 003026 LY Keu Sourng 4 17.1 140 2,394.00 1,197.00 0.00 1,197.00 640 003028 LIM SokLay Sourng 2 16.75 12 201.00 201.00 0.00 0.00 641 005015 HUY VanDeun Sourng 3 28.83 85 2,450.55 1,225.27 0.00 1,225.28 642 001023 SOEUM Sok Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50
16 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 643 003031 CHEA An Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 644 003030 CHHEANG Lang Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 645 005018 TAING PokHeng Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 646 001027 SSONG Pha Sourng 3 9 85 765.00 382.50 0.00 382.50 647 001026 HUY Son Sourng 3 16 85 1,360.00 680.00 0.00 680.00 648 001019 VAO Chhung Sourng 4 16 140 2,240.00 1,120.00 0.00 1,120.00 Total 102 1623.97 141,155.38 75,975.85 0.00 65,179.53 649 004032 AEL Phoass Srolobb 1 23.76 4.5 106.92 106.92 0.00 0.00 650 004042 YAP SaiNob Srolobb 1 16.45 4.5 74.02 74.02 0.00 0.00 651 005034 KIM Leng Srolobb 1 12 4.5 54.00 54.00 0.00 0.00 652 001031 MOKK KimLang Srolobb 2 10.21 12 122.52 122.52 0.00 0.00 653 003047 GNI Heng Srolobb 2 12.15 12 145.80 145.80 0.00 0.00 654 003048 DA Srolobb 1 12.71 4.5 57.19 57.19 0.00 0.00 655 003049 BAN HungInn Srolobb 1 16.34 4.5 73.53 73.53 0.00 0.00 Total 7 103.62 0.00 633.98 6.33.98 0.00 0.00 656 204014 Heang Seng Svay Chras 2 22.32 12 267.84 267.84 0.00 0.00 657 204013 Chhuy Vanny Svay Chras 2 21.12 12 253.44 253.44 0.00 0.00 Total 2 43.44 0.00 521.28 521.28 0.00 0.00 658 302001 Phoeum Savet Treak 1 10.07 4.5 45.31 45.31 0.00 0.00 659 302005 Chor Yoeum Treak 2 6.27 12 75.24 75.24 0.00 0.00 660 303001 Min Thy Treak 2 9 12 108.00 108.00 0.00 0.00 661 301045 Kour Mengleang Treak 3 35 dk 2,975.00 2,975.00 0.00 0.00 662 301046 Kim Mong Treak 2 36.24 dk 434.88 434.88 0.00 0.00 663 303047 Hout Bros Treak 2 48 576 576.00 576.00 0.00 0.00 664 304043 Dim SreyThat Treak 3 17 dk 1,445.00 1,445.00 0.00 0.00 665 303048 Douen Vannouen Treak 2 38 456 456.00 456.00 0.00 0.00 Total 8 199.58 0 6,115.43 6,115.43 0.00 0.00 666 304016 Dou Ngokam Tror Mung 2 25.5 12 302.40 302.40 0.00 0.00 667 304018 Tea Kimhuy Tror Mung 2 49 12 4.86 588.00 588.00 0.00 0.00 668 304019 Tem Choung Tror Mung 1 2 17.76 4.5 79.92 79.92 0.00 0.00 669 302038 Sun Nari Tror Mung 3 12.6 85×60% 642.60 312.30 0.00 312.30 670 301007 Hourng Sokheang Tror Mung 3 15.075 85 50 1,281.38 1,281.38 0.00 0.00 671 303006 Sok Chang Tror Mung 3 14.52 85 75 1,234.20 1,234.20 0.00 0.00 672 303017 Hut Ormrin Tror Mung 3 20.46 85 1,739.10 1,739.10 0.00 0.00 673 304041 Keav Kun Tror Mung 2 57.8 12 693.60 693.60 0.00 0.00 674 304029 Kuov Sru Tror Mung 3 15.4 85 1,309.00 1,309.00 0.00 0.00 675 304029 Kim Chanthol Tror Mung 3 18.5 85 1,572.50 1,570.50 0.00 2.00 676 304042 Houen Hong Tror Mung 3 19.8 85 1,683.00 1,683.00 0.00 0.00 677 304036 Leng Nary Tror Mung 2 51.3 12 615.60 615.60 0.00 0.00 678 304040 Taing Soytry Tror Mung 2 54.3 12 651.60 651.60 0.00 0.00 679 304038 Mouy Ngim Tror Mung 3 32.4 85 2,754.00 2,754.00 0.00 0.00
17 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 680 301030 Chhoy Sreang Tror Mung 1 9.91 4.5 44.59 44.59 0.00 0.00 681 401001 Seang Siphan Tror Mung dk dk 4.86 0.00 138.99 138.99 0.00 682 302046 Ly Chheng Tror Mung 2 19.76 12 237.12 237.12 0.00 0.00 683 302047 Sian Yort Tror Mung 1 15.92 4.5 71.64 71.64 0.00 0.00 684 303036 Ky Sophy Tror Mung 2 13.95 12 167.40 167.40 0.00 0.00 685 302050 Ngin Ry Tror Mung 1 9 4.5 40.50 40.50 0.00 0.00 686 303029 Sin Mab Tror Mung 1 8.06 4.5 36.27 36.27 0.00 0.00 687 303030 Rous Khhoun Tror Mung 1 9 4.5 40.50 40.50 0.00 0.00 688 302051 Meas Saret Tror Mung 1 10.5 4.5 47.25 47.25 0.00 0.00 689 303028 Tong Keaseng Tror Mung 1 158.6 4.5 713.70 713.70 0.00 0.00 690 302049 Som Souen Tror Mung 1 40.74 4.5 183.33 183.33 0.00 0.00 Total 25 699.855 0 16,729.20 16,535.89 138.99 314.30 691 302058 Mearn Vannar Tun Lung 1 15.47 4.5 69.61 69.61 0.00 0.00 692 302059 Hum Hing Tun Lung 1 12.67 4.5 57.01 57.01 0.00 0.00 693 303039 Bhork Pearn Tun Lung 1 14.00 4.5 63.00 63.00 0.00 0.00 694 304026 Sim Hearn Tun Lung 1 15.40 4.5 69.30 69.30 0.00 0.00 695 304024 Vik Ni Tun Lung 1 18.80 4.5 84.60 84.60 0.00 0.00 696 304022 Nhor Hearn Tun Lung 1 8.10 4.5 36.45 36.45 0.00 0.00 697 304023 Kol Smean Tun Lung 1 10.24 4.5 46.08 46.08 0.00 0.00 698 302061 Theng Chhon Tun Lung 2 38.98 12 467.76 467.76 0.00 0.00 699 302062 Chiang Kimsreang Tun Lung 2 59.06 12 708.72 708.72 0.00 0.00 700 302063 Hoeum Srouen Tun Lung 2 15.78 12 189.36 189.36 0.00 0.00 701 304031 Chhoun Khoun Tun Lung 1 21 4.5 94.50 94.50 0.00 0.00 702 304030 Chhoun Korm Tun Lung 1 22.26 4.5 100.17 100.17 0.00 0.00 703 304029 Seang Sary Tun Lung 1 55.89 4.5 251.50 251.50 0.00 0.00 704 304028 Seang Chanthy Tun Lung 1 8.58 4.5 38.61 38.61 0.00 0.00 705 303038 Phal Phea Tun Lung 1 14.19 4.5 63.85 63.85 0.00 0.00 706 303035 Pein Thy Tun Lung 1 14.82 4.5 66.69 66.69 0.00 0.00 707 304025 Chhoeung Sok Tun Lung 1 18.15 4.5 81.67 81.67 0.00 0.00 708 303036 Pov Ren Tun Lung 1 22.62 4.5 101.79 101.79 0.00 0.00 709 303037 Aul Ouen Tun Lung 1 11.88 4.5 53.46 53.46 0.00 0.00 710 302052 Pouk man Tun Lung 2 41.81 12 501.72 0.00 0.00 501.72 711 301031 Toch chenda Tun Lung 2 53.72 12 644.64 644.64 0.00 0.00 712 301032 Louem Simouv Tun Lung 2 25.42 12 305.04 305.04 0.00 0.00 713 302056 Pang Kimlohn Tun Lung 2 30.23 12 362.76 362.76 0.00 0.00 714 302060 Kan Sokhem Tun Lung 2 26 12 312.00 312.00 0.00 0.00 715 302055 Kan Doer Tun Lung 2 18.51 12 222.12 222.12 0.00 0.00 716 301034 Din Ne Tun Lung 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 60.48 0.00 0.00 717 301037 Ngoun Chear Tun Lung 2 11.78 12 141.36 141.36 0.00 0.00 718 301033 Ouen Chenda Tun Lung 1 34.31 4.5 154.40 154.40 0.00 0.00 719 301035 Chan Cheun Tun Lung 1 12.8 4.5 57.60 57.60 0.00 0.00
18 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Amount Paid and Balance Due to the PAPs for Lost Buildings (NR7) (Data to come from DMS records)
Buildi Excess Balance to ng Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid No. IRC Code HH Head Commune Type Area Acquired (m2) Unit Cost ($/m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 720 302057 Soy Chanda Tun Lung 1 13.16 4.5 59.22 59.22 0.00 0.00 721 303041 Khen Khorn Tun Lung 1 20.397 4.5 91.78 91.78 0.00 0.00 722 303040 Tang Ren Tun Lung 1 12.4 4.5 55.80 55.80 0.00 0.00 723 303042 Peon Heng Tun Lung 1 30.6 4.5 137.70 137.70 0.00 0.00 724 303043 Seng som Tun Lung 1 6.3 4.5 28.35 28.35 0.00 0.00 725 305001 Ly Heng Tun Lung 1 9.84 4.5 44.28 44.28 0.00 0.00 726 305002 Pov Hong Tun Lung 1 11.2 4.5 50.40 50.40 0.00 0.00 727 305004 Lunch Sorn Tun Lung 1 9.57 4.5 43.06 43.06 0.00 0.00 728 305005 En Sisophan Tun Lung 1 9.86 4.5 44.37 44.37 0.00 0.00 729 303031 Soy Sitha Tun Lung 1 26.46 4.5 119.07 119.07 0.00 0.00 730 303032 Chhon Chay Tun Lung 2 20.415 12 244.28 244.98 0.70 0.00 731 303033 Kong Jha Tun Lung 1 17.042 4.5 76.69 76.69 0.00 0.00 732 301038 Koe Yeng Tun Lung 1 17.82 4.5 80.19 80.19 0.00 0.00 733 301039 Meas Chan Tun Lung 1 14.28 4.5 64.26 64.26 0.00 0.00 734 301041 Tho Somnang Tun Lung 1 16.65 4.5 74.92 74.92 0.00 0.00 735 303034 Yean Sorn Tun Lung 1 5.28 4.5 23.76 23.76 0.00 0.00 736 305003 Toch Saren Tun Lung 1 13.44 4.5 60.48 60.48 0.00 0.00 737 301040 En Sotheary Tun Lung 1 31.72 4.5 142.74 142.74 0.00 0.00 Total 47 952.34 0.00 6,847.60 6,346.58 0.70 501.72 738 001042 Po Thet Vihear Loung 1 30 135.00 0.00 0.00 135.00 Total 1 30 0 135.00 0.00 0.00 135.00 Grand-Total 636.00 0.00 0.00 15,643.01 160.59 311,769.91 #VALUE! 10,089.97 73,808.15
19 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 20 Summary of Payments made for Acquired Buildings (NR7) (Data culled from IRC-RU and DMS Records)
Area Excess Balance to No. of Building Type Acquired Amount Due Amount Paid Amount Paid be Paid APs Commune 1234 (m2) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 13Ang Cheum 1 8 4 0 539.84 15,393.36 14,186.03 0.00 1,207.33 53Chub 1 49 3 0 1,537.47 19,951.61 20,743.91 2,784.84 1,992.54 9Dar (Kratie) 7 2 0 0 134.13 930.79 930.79 0.00 0.00 53Dar(Kompong Cham) 27 16 9 1 1,033.63 28,130.89 28,086.89 56.00 100.00 8Khsoeum 4 4 0 0 150.08 1,170.81 1,170.81 0.00 0.00 44Koang Kang 4 30 10 0 1,315.35 27,178.96 26,805.78 75.95 338.25 26Kondol Chrum 2 14 8 2 899.91 24,838.46 23,750.85 618.60 1,706.21 42Kontout 24 18 0 0 891.53 7,076.80 7,153.81 499.41 422.40 13Kratie 10 3 0 0 353.23 2,152.47 4,400.58 2,248.11 0.00 60Krek 12 38 10 0 1,595.11 30,489.04 30,000.78 1,170.29 1,658.55 100Me Mut 11 57 16 16 2,960.59 98,556.28 100,737.54 2,184.96 3.70 9Morng Reav 0 9 0 0 228.24 2,728.88 2,501.30 20.00 247.58 32Orussey 21 11 0 0 561.45 4,453.23 4,642.75 190.12 0.60 55Snour 20 35 0 0 1,574.21 17,735.84 17,837.40 102.00 0.44 102Sourng 3 16 56 27 1,623.97 141,155.38 75,975.85 0.00 65,179.53 7Srolobb 5 2 0 0 103.62 633.98 633.98 0.00 0.00 2Svay Chras 0 2 0 0 43.44 521.28 521.28 0.00 0.00 8Treak 1 5 2 0 199.58 6,115.43 6,115.43 0.00 0.00 24Tror Mung 9 7 8 0 699.86 16,729.20 16,535.89 138.99 314.30 47Tun Lung 36 11 0 0 952.34 6,847.60 6,346.58 0.70 501.72 1Vihear Loung 1 0 0 0 30.00 135.00 0.00 0.00 135.00 708GRAND TOTAL 199 337 126 46 17,427.58 452,925.29 389,078.22 10,089.97 73,808.15
1 Resettlement Audit Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 21 APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost Address No Household Head Village Commune Land Building Other Structure Tree/crops 1 Nuom Samnang Chum Chik Anlong Vil Land Main structure/building . . 2 Hun Vibol Puk Chmar Anlong Vil Land Main structure/building . . 3 Chhay Saran Svay Kong Anlong Vil Land Main structure/building . . 4 Dam Douy Svay Kong Anlong Vil Land Main structure/building . . Total 4 5 Sray Cham Prey Svay Beoung Knar Land Main structure/building . . Total 1 6 Kim Searn Deum Sral Kear Land Main structure/building . . 7 Peng Ngol Kear III Kear Land . Other fixed assets . 8 Chay Pol Oh Kreit Kear Land Main structure/building . . 9 Krey Salout Oh Kreit Kear Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . Total 4 10 Herm Lern Kompong Preah Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 11 Hom Koun Kompong Preah Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 12 Cheng Hab Kompong Preah Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 13 Pech Mov Pann Nha Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 14 Rom Pheurt Prey Svay Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 15 Sou Choum Prey Thoch Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 16 Sourn Hourt Sras Keo Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 17 Bon Seng Sras Keo Kompong Preah Land Main structure/building . . 18 Seung Pai Ous Touk Kompong Preng . Main structure/building . . 19 Seng Yan Ous Touk Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . . 20 Son La Ous Touk Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . . 21 Kim Kerng Ous Touk Kompong Preng . Main structure/building . . 22 Chan Sombat Ous Touk Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . . 23 Moung Kacheab Sala Trav Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . . 24 Rous Sarern Sala Trav Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . . 25 Yem Koung Thmey Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 26 Heng Heury Thmey Kompong Preng Land Main structure/building . . Total 17 27 Nourn Meo Oh Takouy Lolok Sor . . Other fixed assets . 28 Chea Sovanny Oh Takouy Lolok Sor . . Other fixed assets . 29 Theam Channy Oh Takouy Lolok Sor Land Main structure/building . . 30 Chourb Chy Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land . Other fixed assets . 31 Chhay Ngin Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land . Other fixed assets . 32 You Try Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land . Other fixed assets . 33 Mak Su kunn Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 34 Thai Sokhoun Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land Main structure/building . . 35 Hout Seng Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land . Other fixed assets . 36 Sin Samrith Po Takouy Lolok Sor Land Main structure/building . . Total 10 37 Cher Chav Dombok Khpus Oh Dombong Pey Land Main structure/building . . Total 1 38 Kheang Sokha Oh Tapong Oh Tapong Land Main structure/building . . 39 Rorm Vannak Oh Tapong Oh Tapong . . Other fixed assets . 40 Houn Hearn Oh Tapong Oh Tapong . Main structure/building . . 41 Moch Phat Oh Tapong Oh Tapong Land Main structure/building . . Total 4 42 Heng Se Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 43 Tai Hung ngit Spein Thmor Prey Nhy . . Other fixed assets . 44 Ly Chin Spein Thmor Prey Nhy . . Other fixed assets . 45 Seng Piset Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 46 Chea So Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 47 Yoeum Pann Spein Thmor Prey Nhy . . Other fixed assets . 48 Chea Lychhun Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 49 Chan Siem Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 50 Bin Ra Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 51 Tha Soch lang Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 52 Em Sneou Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 53 Kim Ly Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 54 Huon Thailong Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . 55 Ke Lun Spein Thmor Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 56 Chhoeum Sameurn Sras Srong Prey Nhy Land Main structure/building . . Total 15 57 Kob Kam Krolom Pluk Prey Svay Land Main structure/building . . 58 Kob Ny Krolom Pluk Prey Svay Land Main structure/building . .
1 Resettlement Audit Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 21 APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost Address No Household Head Village Commune Land Building Other Structure Tree/crops 59 Sout Neng Krolom Pluk Prey Svay Land Main structure/building . . 60 Oun Choung Prey Prel Prey Svay Land Main structure/building . . 61 Samrith Eurn Prey Svay Prey Svay Land Main structure/building . . 62 Samrith Eurn Prey Svay Prey Svay Land Main structure/building . . Total 6 63 Keuy Sang Dub Krosang Prey Thoch Land Main structure/building . . 64 Chen Kim An Kon Klung Prey Thoch . Main structure/building . . 65 Peng Hnoun Prey Thoch Prey Thoch Land Main structure/building . . 66 Tao K Prey Thoch Prey Thoch Land Main structure/building . . 67 Ven Vern Thmey Prey Thoch Land Main structure/building . . 68 Ren Bounreaty Thmey Prey Thoch Land Main structure/building . . Total 6 69 Chhearng Khandy Pel Nhek Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 70 Sam Mouy Pel Nhek Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 71 Brak Sokhun Pel Nhek Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 72 Kim Soka Pel Nhek Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 73 Chhem Yom Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 74 Loeum Manech Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 75 Pol Dy Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 76 Chan Et Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 77 Chim Ln Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey . . Other fixed assets . 78 Chin Saoly Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 79 Chan Sopal Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 80 Kang Chear Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 81 Chem Sunchearng Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets . 82 Mao Son Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 83 Oum Siyon Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 84 Ma Kearng Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 85 Sam Nout Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 86 Chheng Kimsuoy Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 87 Mas Chamrearn Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 88 Sorm So kun Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . . Crops/Trees 89 Meo Sophorn Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 90 Nong Bunmeng Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 91 Sok Sitha Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 92 Hem Kimsoan Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 93 Chou Sreal Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 94 Svay Meit Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 95 Sang Dos Pel Nhek I Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 96 Chearm Lon Po Takouy Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 97 Learng Lay Ra Ptash Prey Land . Other fixed assets . 98 Hrob Von Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 99 San Sothol Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 100 Lay Koun Ra Ptash Prey . . Other fixed assets . 101 Seng Srang Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 102 Sin Phalla Ra Ptash Prey . . Other fixed assets . 103 Men Sovanny Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 104 Suong Saveurn Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 105 Seng Kimtem Ra Ptash Prey . . Other fixed assets . 106 Oum Sach Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 107 Nov Brak Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . 108 Hem Kim sry Ra Ptash Prey Land Main structure/building . . Total 40 109 Ram Sovann Morn Chei Ronorb Land . Other fixed assets . 110 Hon Leng Po Andot Ronorb Land . . . 111 Choun Say Po Andot Ronorb Land . . . 112 Tourch Sang Prey Ohmal Ronorb .. Other fixed assets . 113 Ear Chhet Spein Thmor Ronorb Land . . . 114 Hang So pha Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . 115 Lov Kech chhang Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . 116 Seak Nai Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . 117 Koy Rearn Spein Thmor Ronorb Land . Other fixed assets . 118 Van Heang Spein Thmor Ronorb .. . . 119 Duch Sam phors Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . 120 Huy Gnam Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . 121 Song Lay Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . .
2 Resettlement Audit Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 21 APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost Address No Household Head Village Commune Land Building Other Structure Tree/crops 122 Lach Brus Spein Thmor Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . 123 Horng Sarey vattana Tnal Bombek Lek Ronorb . Main structure/building . . 124 Tong Mang Tnal Bombek Lek Ronorb Land Main structure/building . . Total 16 125 Ly So chat Kompeng Snay Snam Preah Land Main structure/building . . 126 Prum Chan nein Snam Preah Snam Preah Land Main structure/building . . Total 2 127 Roat Nara Stany Svay Att Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 128 Sang Chanthol Stany Svay Att Land . Other fixed assets . 129 Chhen Savat Stany Svay Att Land . Other fixed assets . 130 Pech Narith Stany Svay Att Land . Other fixed assets . 131 Kuoch Sokha Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 132 Mum Chan thol Stany Svay Att .. Other fixed assets . 133 Prom Chanthol Stany Svay Att .. Other fixed assets . 134 Tep Nang Stany Svay Att Land . Other fixed assets . 135 Kol Sengkry Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . . 136 Yen Chan socka Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 137 Rs Sen Nara Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 138 Ly Kim han Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . . 139 Gnann Thy da Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . . 140 Sang Haur Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . . 141 Gnoeum Sa vearn Stany Svay Att Land Main structure/building . . Total 15 142 Ngol Mang Svay Donkeo Svay Donkeo Land Main structure/building . . 143 Searn Souy Svay Donkeo Svay Donkeo Land Main structure/building . . Total 2 144 Chan Vichet Takeo Leou Tnot Chum Land Main structure/building . . 145 Mov Met Takeo Leou Tnot Chum Land Main structure/building . . Total 2 146 Lay Korn Bakan Tropang Chong . . Other fixed assets . 147 Sourn Sareurng Kdey Chnoul Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . Crops/Trees 148 Vy Pounlouk Kdey Chnoul Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 149 Larg Tan Koh Keo Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 150 Phan Tean Koh Keo Tropang Chong . Main structure/building . . 151 Va Chanrat Koh Svay Tropang Chong Land . Other fixed assets . 152 Sau Sophall Koh Svay Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 153 So Sophal Koh Svay Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 154 Ros Bunnel Koh Svay Tropang Chong . . Other fixed assets . 155 Our Chan bo pha Koh Svay Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 156 Our Chan bo pha Koh Svay Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 157 Kim Chheang Krol Krobey Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 158 Yem Buthoan Krol Krobey Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 159 Ros Sareurn Trapang Chong Tropang Chong . . Other fixed assets . 160 Gnov Ty Trapang Chong Tropang Chong . . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 161 Svay Som eurn Trapang Chong Tropang Chong . . Other fixed assets . 162 Khiev Chai Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land . Other fixed assets . 163 Ouam Youn Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land . Other fixed assets Crops/Trees 164 Toeum Tourch Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 165 Gnem Hung Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 166 Suth So vantha Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . 167 Suon Saroan Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets . 168 Lach Kar Trapang Chong Tropang Chong Land Main structure/building . . Total 23 Grand-Total 168
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 22 APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
No Household Head Address Properties/Assets Lost Village Commune Land Building Crops/Trees Other Structure 1 Phat Vanna Ang Klang Brolay Land Main structure/building . . 2 Chhearng Tet Ong Klom Brolay Land Main structure/building . . 3 Sang Kim thang Prey Klar Brolay Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . Total 3 4 Khoan Se Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land . Crops/Trees . 5 Chan Pang an Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 6 Pa Yov nath Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 7 Chhun Earm Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 8 Khang Chanrt Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 9 Soy Ourai Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 10 Lay Hearng Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 11 Chour Veurn Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 12 Earng Sang kruy Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 13 Tang Tech Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 14 Lav Pa Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 15 Yan Kon Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 16 Ang Kimkhun Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 17 Huon Chhaysim Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land . Crops/Trees . 18 Kev Sonang Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building . . 19 Prom Sopha Tnot Kompong Chenchueng Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . Total 16 20 Kourch Sangtech Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 21 Math Put thara Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 22 Sim Sokunra Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 23 Sray Cheng Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 24 Cheng You Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 25 Ang Buntha Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 26 Kang Kimla Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 27 Mut Siyon Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 28 Sol Mack Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 29 Ngouv Earngkruy Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 30 Ouang Sanoun Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 31 Meng Tang Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 32 Prom Pout Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 33 Hong Khin Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 34 Tan Chengrearn Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 35 Lao Chear Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 36 Searng MouyChhengCheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 37 Ki Pin Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 38 Chhor Kimheng Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 39 Tev Kimsong Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 40 Chear Thong Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 41 Ly Meck Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 42 You Bunnan Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 43 Lav Long Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 44 Lem Kimnan Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 45 Hoeung Pagna Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 46 oeung Pagna Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 47 Chear Soka Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 48 Lim Housai Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 49 Chan Kimsear Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 50 Eung Kukhuor Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 51 Eung Tykear Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 52 Luern Sony Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 53 Ong Hunlon Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 54 Sam Yorn Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 55 Seng Savuth Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 56 Ke Rami Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 57 Ky Chenghout Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 58 Chal Mach Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 59 Kang Kearng Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 60 Yuk Sinthan Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 61 Mom Han Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 62 Kang Vong Cheou Teil Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 63 Sok Yun Dombok Khpus Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 64 Sourng Li Sell Dombok Khpus Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 65 Lai Chhang Dombok Khpus Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . .
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
No Household Head Address Properties/Assets Lost Village Commune Land Building Crops/Trees Other Structure 66 Oeung Siev hong Dombok Khpus Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 67 Suong Khagnim Kompong Kdey Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 68 Chab Mel Kompong Kdey Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 69 Hang Hang ly Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 70 Heng Hokan Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 71 Sot Kimheng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 72 Sam Von Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 73 Kim Yi Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 74 Chal Houng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 75 Prum Sokhay Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 76 Prom Ry Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 77 Chea Hort Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 78 Aon Eark Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 79 Hich Mon Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 80 Ang Yuon Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 81 Hearng Layrun Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 82 Kav Som Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 83 Tect Hongsel Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 84 Yea Chaylang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 85 Hang Pa Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 86 Som Pornn Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 87 Theng Mov Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 88 Koy Ret Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land . Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 89 Ky Pout Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 90 Len Kimsuong Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 91 Nour Thavy Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 92 Suong Sokha Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 93 Seung Khoung Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 94 Ngol Kimsearng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 95 York Kimlen Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 96 Ear Laysrun Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land . . Other fixed assets 97 Hang Your tan Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . Other fixed assets 98 Chim Chin Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 99 Beng Sokhang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 100 Sorm Han Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 101 Pao Ray Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 102 Ouang Sannon Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 103 Ke Chhunty Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 104 Kon Kot Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 105 Nam Hang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 106 Chhay Hai Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 107 Lach Yon Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 108 Lav Menghong Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 109 Kout Chamrearn Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 110 Sim San Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 111 Be Lach Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 112 Oeung Suy hor Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 113 Ya Kimleng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 114 Lim Sothean Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 115 Ouel Han Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 116 Pa Sock Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 117 Yea Chiev Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 118 Sout Vout Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 119 Heng Pengan Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 120 Chal Nara Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 121 Chear Sotheara Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 122 Ham Hern Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 123 Kang Chantha Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 124 Ly Sikear Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 125 Kert Pon Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land . . Other fixed assets 126 Pa Phanna Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 127 Chim By Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 128 Lauy Hak Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 129 Yem Kanon Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 130 Thourn Chhunly Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 131 Theng Peck Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 132 Sray Ouengdy Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 133 Lav Bonlis Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees .
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
No Household Head Address Properties/Assets Lost Village Commune Land Building Crops/Trees Other Structure 134 Eng Kouy Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 135 Loun Srang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 136 Theng Kouny Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 137 Hong Vann Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 138 Ouam Lihor Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 139 Hon Ouat Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 140 Hao Eur Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 141 Thoeung Hai Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 142 Cheng Hai Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 143 Cheng Ma Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 144 Lang Polmai Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 145 Sang Keng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 146 Cheng Kar Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 147 Loun Manghor Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 148 Sai Ouang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 149 Seng Kirirum Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 150 Tang Se Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 151 Choun Yan Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 152 Oeung Hourt Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 153 Ke Chaok Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 154 Pov Daut Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 155 Chhor Penghuy Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 156 Siev Sa horn Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 157 Tear Siv Lung Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 158 Yeng Manghor Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 159 Gnoeum Phoeum soLeb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 160 Kang La Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 161 Ly Kimhor Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 162 Ly Kimchao Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 163 Chear Kimsang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 164 Ouan Houckseng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 165 Kuoch Suong Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 166 Suong Khangim Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 167 Ang Kimngou Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 168 Ouang Banpear Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 169 Tear Chivthong Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 170 Pen Yeb Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 171 Leng Kimhoung Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 172 Ching Heng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 173 Tap Soborith Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 174 Lao Menghak Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 175 Ly Bun ny Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 176 Phav Sophal Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 177 Ching Mouhy Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 178 Chil Moulin Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 179 Lem Khuyhou Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 180 Lim Koyhol Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 181 Suon Chhunheng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 182 Tan Thai hang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 183 Yol Kimra Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 184 Lim Simhock Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 185 Ly Sikear Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 186 Lam Nal Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 187 Hav Kimeng Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 188 Ngon Ouerngly Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 189 Sam Kiheurn Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 190 Heng Nary Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 191 Leng Lerang Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 192 Kang Mengra Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 193 Heng Kry Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 194 Ki Mengsok Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 195 Yan Pouki Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 196 Hang Hong Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 197 Thuch Phan Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 198 Lim kimhouy Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 199 Yiv Sock Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . . 200 Pech Chunlay Leb Tong Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 201 Long Sok Prey Prel Kompong Chentbong Land Main structure/building . .
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
APs in Household Survey with Unpaid Claims (Data from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
No Household Head Address Properties/Assets Lost Village Commune Land Building Crops/Trees Other Structure Total 182 202 Kour Kun Brodith Somproch Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees . 203 Sav Say Slak Kranh Somproch Land Main structure/building . . Total 2 204 Tan Krem Keing Krosang Sunkor Land Main structure/building . . 205 Gnem Thaut Sunkor Khor Sunkor Land . . Other fixed assets Total 2 Grand-Total 205
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 1 Prum Va Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building 2 Sreng Cheurn Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 3 Yei On nang Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building 4 Oeum Chea Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building 5 Eurm On Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 6 Ma Te Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 7 Sun Mang Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building 8 Sung Tha Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 9 Leang Sreing Dom Nakchar An Chem Land Main structure/building 10 Hat Sall Dom Nakchar An Chem Main structure/building 11 Un Eurn Dom Nakchar An Chem Main structure/building 12 Meo Um Kon Tmart An Chem Other fixed assets Total 12 9 11 4 2 13 Pen Saran Chrok Chombok Chub Main structure/building Crops/Trees 14 Som Sameth Chrok Chombok Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 15 Im Chhen Chrok Chombok Chub Land Main structure/building 16 Men Kimsan Chrok Chombok Chub Crops/Trees 17 Sat Kim srorn Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 18 Chen Se Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 19 Eab Eng Chub Krov Chub Crops/Trees 20 Tev Kuy Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 21 Ti Kuy Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 22 Loeuk Pov Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 23 Lem Silaon Chub Krov Chub Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 24 Meas Ny Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 25 Chhiv Hy Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 26 Put Lemheang Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 27 Pot Chheng arn Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 28 Yung Heng Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 29 Duong Yeurn Chub Krov Chub Other fixed assets 30 Sak Sopea Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 31 Chen Tean Chub Krov Chub Main structure/building
1 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 32 Nay Sinat Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 33 Khun Sothea Chub Krov Chub Main structure/building 34 Sun Kimhym Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 35 Meng Hol Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 36 Hung Ly Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 37 Nour Neang Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 38 Dom Chum un Chub Krov Chub Other fixed assets 39 Buth Eurn Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 40 Heng Heang Chub Krov Chub Other fixed assets 41 Nav Vudy Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 42 Oual Pov Chub Krov Chub Land Other fixed assets 43 Kroch Kimva Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 44 Lon He Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 45 Nop Chauy Chub Krov Chub Other fixed assets 46 Sea Channy Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 47 Poung Pesit Chub Krov Chub Main structure/building 48 Poung Pesit Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 49 Keo Sing hour Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 50 Kim Chinthuon Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 51 Moury Morng hean Chub Krov Chub Land Main structure/building 52 Morm Savat Slab Kdoung Chub Crops/Trees 53 Meach Nul Slab Kdoung Chub Other fixed assets 54 Pov Chantha Slab Kdoung Chub Other fixed assets 55 Im Phally Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 56 Suon Sun Slab Kdoung Chub Crops/Trees 57 Yan Thim Slab Kdoung Chub Other fixed assets 58 Im Phalla Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 59 Yan Chem Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 60 Touch Ry Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 61 Phorn Ny Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 62 Theing Leing Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 63 Sourn Bupha Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees
2 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 64 Hong Suthary Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 65 Hak Kim porn Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 66 Ly Mat Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 67 Sem Tha Slab Kdoung Chub Other fixed assets 68 Khiv Phally Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 69 Ung Kimhorn Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 70 Oul Sopea Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 71 Houl Mouny Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 72 Brack Srey Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 73 Ear Thira Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 74 Suon Houn Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 75 Mom Mony Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 76 Sok Channy Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 77 Chhin Srun Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 78 Kim Son Slab Kdoung Chub Land Main structure/building 79 Chhon Sithach Tnal Toteoung Chub Other fixed assets 80 Sreng Bunnarith Tnal Toteoung Chub Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 81 Mell Chhourn Tnal Toteoung Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 82 Heng Makara Tnal Toteoung Chub Land Main structure/building 83 Em Chhorn Veal Kondeang Chub Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 84 Yim San Veal Kondeang Chub Other fixed assets Total 72 54 56 17 18 85 Khorn Nan Agn Chagn Dar Land Main structure/building 86 Muk Pekthang Chomkar Kor Dar Land Main structure/building 87 Bourn Nang Dar Dar Land Main structure/building 88 Gnem Reit Dar Dar Land Main structure/building 89 Lein Phary Dar Dar 90 Mea Chea Dar Dar Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 91 Reach Chea Dar Dar Land Main structure/building 92 Sok Ny Dar Dar Other fixed assets 93 Ma Chhan Dar Kondal Dar Land Main structure/building 94 Gnoeum Heang Dar Kondal Dar Land Main structure/building
3 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 95 Ra Ny Dar Psar Dar Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 96 Sok thorn Dar Psar Dar Main structure/building 97 Nourn Hearn Dar Psar Dar Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 98 Kim Chang Dar Psar Dar Land Main structure/building 99 Bun Leng Dar Psar Dar Land Main structure/building 100 Soeum Tha Dar Psar Dar Land Main structure/building 101 Chan Ny Dar Psar Dar Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 102 Sen Soeuk Pram Py Markar Dar Land Main structure/building 103 Math Koi Pram Py Markar Dar Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 104 Gnor Nea Somrong CherngDar Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 105 Cham Mackara Songkum Mean Dar Main structure/building 106 Chhen Chhun Stoeung Svay Dar Land Other fixed assets 107 Bauch Samin Stoeung Svay Dar Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 108 Hourt Chou Stoeung Svay Dar Land Main structure/building 109 Do Dymong Stoeung Svay Dar Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 110 E Seng Stoeung Svay Dar Land Main structure/building Total 26 22 22 7 5 111 Chea Sin Allorch Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building 112 Chen Tob Chror Vakrom Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building 113 Chea Huch Chror Vakrom Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building 114 Hear Kim Hean Kan tourt Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building 115 Heng Si Kan tourt Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building 116 Heng Pang Kan tourt Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building 117 Mok Va Kan tourt Kan Tourt Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 118 Lork Hourt Tourl Kan Tourt Land Main structure/building Total 8 8 7 1 1 119 Chhou Chin Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Other fixed assets 120 Sok Tri Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Main structure/building 121 Kheng Channy Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 122 Mom Pov Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 123 Vann Pov Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 124 Seck Neang Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets
4 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 125 Mak Sa run Bot Ponlear Kondol Chrum Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 126 Back Ngeng Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 127 E Eng Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 128 Sok Teang Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 129 Keng Souck Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 130 Kim Vanna Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 131 Ly Pang Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 132 Ly Pang Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 133 Lay Phoan Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 134 Kim Sung Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 135 Long Kheng Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 136 Ly Gnor Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 137 Kong Chiv Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 138 Yo Pov Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 139 Kouch Ny Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 140 Hak Meng Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 141 Chit Sara Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 142 Theng Veng Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 143 Oung Vannack Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 144 Chhou Piny Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 145 Pha Vida Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 146 Chin Houl Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 147 Ly Hour Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 148 Thung So phol Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 149 Hong Phang Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 150 Ty Thom Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 151 Gnan Thun nech Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 152 Gnan Thun nech Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 153 Hang You Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 154 Ly Hong Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 155 Phourng Nang Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 156 Suom Saret Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Main structure/building
5 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 157 Then Pin Kondal Chrum Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 158 Ok Chheing kuy Phsar Kondol ChKondol Chrum Land Other fixed assets 159 Sey Kheurng Po Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 160 Nuon Son Po Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 161 Chet Hoy Po Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 162 Pech Phally Po Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 163 Oueng Sipan Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 164 Yen Samuon Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 165 Long Sun Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 166 Vuoch Sokhum Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 167 Seang Nhol Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 168 Louek Chhailon Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Other fixed assets 169 Khan Vuthy Sbek Kur Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 170 Kheam Chhung Toul Po Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building 171 Pegn Ull Toul Po Kondol Chrum Land Main structure/building Total 53 49 48 11 5 172 Sing Pov Kondol Koung Kong Kang Crops/Trees 173 Liv Kheang Kondol Koung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 174 Yi Ouach Kondol Koung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 175 Chhoeung Si mun Kondol Koung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 176 Kung Kem Law Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 177 Chhy Chhai Law Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 178 Mauch Maly Law Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 179 Chang Chhun tang Po Rong Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 180 Chhem Cheng Po Rong Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 181 Ket Sothea Po Rong Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 182 Keurm Gnor Po Rong Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 183 Bun Kea Po Rong Keout Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 184 Mout Tear Po Rong Keout Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 185 Krim Sen Po Rong Leou Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 186 Krim San Po Rong Leou Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 187 Gnourn Sam un Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Main structure/building
6 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 188 Si Meng Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 189 Pok Soheang Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 190 Cheak Tai Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 191 Long Theam Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Other fixed assets 192 Bech Vannak Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Other fixed assets 193 Long Theam Po Rong Lich Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 194 Path Da vuth Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 195 Seing Sin Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 196 Keng Bunna Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 197 Nai Yeam Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 198 Chhen Kan Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 199 Chhay Souch Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 200 Chann Sem Po Srok Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 201 Tes Toum Steoung Kong Kang Crops/Trees 202 Eung Chea Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 203 Keu Sokleng Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 204 Ly Khai Steoung Kong Kang Land Other fixed assets 205 Ly Khai Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 206 Leang Huo Steoung Kong Kang Crops/Trees 207 Pau Seng Steoung Kong Kang Crops/Trees 208 Chev Our Steoung Kong Kang 209 Chea Huy Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 210 Ly Voeung Steoung Kong Kang Land Crops/Trees 211 Lim gnun Chheang Steoung Kong Kang Land Crops/Trees 212 Tang Kimlang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 213 Leang Kea Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 214 Sek Sina Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 215 Tha Sroy Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 216 Tong Kimlang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 217 You Sokha Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 218 Chheng Peang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 219 Sao Vatha Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building
7 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 220 Soem Sus Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 221 Soem Sus Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 222 Kim Sean Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 223 Sut So dath Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 224 Chhev Chhong Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 225 Chhev Chhong Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 226 In Chheng Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 227 Thy Sok lang Steoung Kong Kang Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 228 Kruy Sochea Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 229 Chhun tong vuch seinSteoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 230 Loeum Ly Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 231 Ly Hourt Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 232 Ly Kung Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 233 Tha Hak Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 234 Chhiv Srun Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 235 Sin Peing E Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 236 Heing Your Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 237 Ly Tong hang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 238 Tong Hour Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 239 Earb Chhang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 240 Sok Teang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 241 Hock Chhin Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 242 Cheng Kuy Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 243 The Tongmeang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 244 Sen Nary Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 245 Bun Seing Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 246 Chan Lin Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 247 Loem Kong Steoung Kong Kang Land 248 Chhom Hong Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 249 Soun Sokhom Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 250 Chea Sok Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 251 Tong Yi hang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees
8 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 252 Hang Chang Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building 253 Bun Heng Steoung Kong Kang Land Main structure/building Total 82 77 70 21 5 254 Uoch Sareurn Am Pok Krek Land Main structure/building 255 Say Reang Am Pok Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 256 Seang Hun Am Pok Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 257 Nov Kung Am Pok Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 258 Uk Chansy Am Pok Krek Land Other fixed assets 259 Tourch Sareurn Am Pok Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 260 Nub Sam nang Andong Chey Krek Land Main structure/building 261 Yoeum Vannak Andong Chey Krek Land Main structure/building 262 Chey Si pin Andong Chey Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 263 Srey Chhorn Andong Chey Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 264 Yaa Andong Chey Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 265 Dem Eng Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 266 Ny Rin Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 267 Leang Chhayleng Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 268 Loeng Rom Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 269 Hun Sophat Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 270 Hang Duk Chi Pang Krek Land Other fixed assets 271 Hang Dok Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 272 Hour Socknang Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 273 Loeum Sok hang Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 274 Bun Tha Chi Pang Krek Main structure/building 275 Hok Chang Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 276 Tourch Lang hi Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 277 Som Thong iy Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 278 Gnourn Thy Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 279 Chhem Phalla Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 280 Roat Meurn Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 281 Suon Narat Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 282 Ang Song heang Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building
9 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 283 Chuob Chun Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 284 Ke Kimrong Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 285 Sourn Naren Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 286 Tear Soury Chi Pang Krek Land Main structure/building 287 Nang So thyC Houy Keout Krek Land Main structure/building 288 Thuy Sophat Houy Keout Krek Land Main structure/building 289 Kong Hor Houy Keout Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 290 Chein Pol Houy Keout Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 291 Lai Meo Houy Keout Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 292 Chhom Neng Krek Cheoung Krek Land Main structure/building 293 Eung Try1 Krek Cheoung Krek Other fixed assets 294 Gnourn Lyna Krek Cheoung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 295 Nai Heak Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 296 Hak Huor Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 297 Kung Bros Krek Tboung Krek Land Other fixed assets 298 Lean Phalla Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 299 Heak Keam Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 300 Saray Chanthy Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 301 Mi Sokull Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 302 Tam Thavy Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 303 Gnuon Theavy Krek Tboung Krek Land Other fixed assets 304 So Nal Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 305 Prum Eurn Krek Tboung Krek Land . 306 Pai Chea Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 307 Pak Pau Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 308 Chhoeun Sang HorngKrek Tboung Krek Main structure/building 309 Yi Hong Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building 310 Chun Senghun Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 311 Ouk Sameurn Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 312 Chay Nhur Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 313 Your Chhein Krek Tboung Krek Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 314 Siek So pheab Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building
10 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 315 Yeb Vall Krek Tboung Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 316 Sourng Sarean Krosang Khor Krek Land Main structure/building 317 Va Chinda Laak Krek Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 318 Long Kheurm Pek Krek Land Main structure/building 319 Vy Nann Pek Krek Land Main structure/building 320 Bin Srey norn Pek Krek Land Main structure/building 321 Soan Suophaon Pek Krek Land Crops/Trees 322 Sek Suom Pek Krek Main structure/building Crops/Trees 323 Kouv Seurn Pek Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 324 Oum peat Sak Orm Krek Main structure/building 325 Seng Pola Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building 326 Hong Sokha Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building 327 Mas Khonthea Sak Orm Krek . Other fixed assets 328 Ou San Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building 329 Oum Sokpen Sak Orm Krek Main structure/building 330 Kok At Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building 331 Ros Sarean Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building 332 Song Poly Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 333 Chong Neng Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building . 334 Khat Sreyra Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 335 Chea Senghean Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 336 Prum Nin Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 337 Kuk Sath Sak Orm Krek Land Main structure/building 338 Eang Pisith Toul Ang Krong Krek Land Main structure/building 339 Ear Loeum ing Toul Ang Krong Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 340 Pen Sophorn Toul Ang Krong Krek Land Main structure/building 341 Ya Samnang Trosith Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 342 Kao Thon Trosith Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 343 Keoun Bunteing Trosith Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 344 Brak Sophorn What Krek Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Total 91 83 84 34 11 345 Haur Soeumhour Au Rosei Kror Ches Land Main structure/building
11 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 346 Khi Pheng Boeung ChreangKror Ches Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 347 Chor Veng Kro Ches Kror Ches Land Main structure/building 348 Koeum Dau Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 349 Our So Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets 350 Vong Et Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets 351 Chan Vochthea Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets 352 Oum Sarin Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets 353 Sean Kimseng Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets 354 Sok Sara Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets 355 Khorn Sokheang Tropang Preeng Kror Ches Land Other fixed assets Total 11 11 4 1 9 356 Va Lay Seirm Agn Chagn Me Mut Land Main structure/building 357 Mor Morn Chi Pes Me Mut Land Main structure/building 358 Kao Sitheurn Chi Pes Me Mut Land Main structure/building 359 Saus Sok Chi Pes Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 360 Uk Vanna Chi Pes Me Mut Land Main structure/building 361 Norng Sopheap Chi Pes Me Mut Land Main structure/building 362 Ly Nanghang Ma mut tbong Me Mut Land Main structure/building 363 Seurk Th Ma mut tbong Me Mut Land Main structure/building 364 To Ny sha Ma mut thmei Me Mut Land Main structure/building 365 Tap Sotheavy Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 366 Sok Channy Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 367 Te Saieng Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land 368 Te Koeumsan Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 369 Uk Sophy Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 370 Hang Vanna Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 371 Heng Hi Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 372 Long Sarum Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 373 Sun Man Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 374 Uk Sokhum Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 375 Pen Savath Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 376 Vet Chuch Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building
12 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 377 Chea Khun Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 378 Hang Bunchann Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 379 Kheav Hourt Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 380 Sok Mang Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 381 Lim Huk Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 382 Sen Mao Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 383 Som Sophall Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 384 Sbaurng Sichorm Machin Toeuk Me Mut Land Main structure/building 385 Meng Tray Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 386 Siv Gnor Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Main structure/building . 387 Soeum Sokna Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 388 Siv Hour Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 389 Im Songkea Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 390 Yorng Srengyong Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 391 Seng Seng hor Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 392 Chay Buntha Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 393 Ouing Khon Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Main structure/building 394 Chhen Kear Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Main structure/building 395 Chea Menghoung Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Main structure/building 396 Sin Sombo Me Mut Kondal Me Mut Land Main structure/building 397 Teur Kim Khun Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 398 Ti Kimhorn Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 399 Gnourn Long Orn Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 400 Hong Kheing Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 401 Tong Sivlak Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 402 Yem Chhorm Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 403 Mas Pha Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 404 Lang Sarin Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 405 Ouy On Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Main structure/building 406 Hy Sovanna Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 407 Eurng Lay Psar Me Mut Me Mut Land Other fixed assets 408 Heurn Senghorn Songkum Mean Me Mut Main structure/building
13 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 409 Leing Hakseurng Songkum Mean Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 410 Nike Teang Songkum Mean Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 411 Your Yourn Songkum Mean Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 412 Prak Phal Songkum Mean Me Mut Main structure/building 413 Chem Chorn Songkum Mean Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 414 Ven Yeng Songkum Mean Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 415 Hour Peng Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 416 Kao Kimhorn Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 417 Seng Ann Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 418 Thy Hourpeing Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 419 Chhen Chanleng Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 420 Mas Thai Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 421 Ma Kim hout Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 422 Som Kong Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 423 Chhoun Ngov Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 424 Tea Kimhean Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 425 Thong Chea Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 426 Koeum Eang Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 427 Tram Men Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building 428 Eav Ly Tboung Wat Me Mut Land Main structure/building Total 73 71 57 14 18 429 Mean Sroy Cheoung Khal Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 430 Kong Nem Cheoung Khal Mourng Rev Main structure/building Crops/Trees 431 Sim Sopha Cheoung Khal Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building 432 Keo Chhai Cheoung Khal Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 433 Veng Mengkry Morng Mourng Rev Other fixed assets 434 Oueak Saron Pon Mourng Rev Crops/Trees 435 Loeng Mit Pon Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building 436 Kao Engly Pon Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building 437 Sok Hour Pon Mourng Rev Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 438 Te Thong Pon Mourng Rev Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 439 Teth Chhai lang Pon Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees
14 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 440 But Chantha Tneoung Mourng Rev Land Main structure/building Total 12 9 8 6 4 441 Long Kimsan Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 442 Kong Chhay Ka Po O' Russei Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 443 Keurt Sok Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building 444 Vorn Thorn Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building 445 Pov Phim Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building 446 Tun Sokun Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 447 Uch Mean Ka Po O' Russei Land Other fixed assets 448 Lay Meng Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 449 Song Supi Ka Po O' Russei Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 450 Ban Eurn Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building 451 Hem Vorn Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building 452 Bun Ly Som oll Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building 453 Chu Kimthan Ka Po O' Russei Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 454 Khat Phorl Ka Po O' Russei Land Other fixed assets 455 Eurng Som an Kla Steas O' Russei Land Main structure/building 456 Thoung Bon Kr P O' Russei Land Main structure/building 457 Ly Kong Kr P O' Russei Land Main structure/building 458 Chim Lim Oh Rusey I O' Russei Land Main structure/building 459 Hau Pros Oh Rusey II O' Russei Land Main structure/building 460 Gnoeum Beat Oh Rusey II O' Russei Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 461 En Theany Phsa deam klec O' Russei Land Other fixed assets Total 21 21 16 6 6 462 Nev Meng Au Rosei Snourl Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 463 Hem Sarean Kat Day Snourl Land Main structure/building 464 Sok Somnang Kat Day Snourl Land Main structure/building 465 Mol Sokhom Kat Day Snourl Land Main structure/building 466 Sa Ret Kat Day Snourl Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 467 Sorh Reth Kat Day Snourl Land Main structure/building 468 Vorn Savouen Pha ak Snourl Land Main structure/building 469 Thav Thor Pha ak Snourl Land Main structure/building
15 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 470 So Sean Phsa Snourl Snourl Land Main structure/building 471 Hiak Sokkhorn Snourl Snourl Land Main structure/building 472 Sourn Sothai Snourl Snourl Land Main structure/building 473 Phian Phouen Snourl Snourl Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 474 Hun Phalla Thpong Krav Snourl Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Total 13 13 12 3 2 475 Chhorn Mony Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 476 Chou Samun Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 477 Beng Sroy Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 478 Ouck Hour Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 479 Duok Chhunna Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 480 Chheang peing ho Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 481 Eng Sothea Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 482 Chhay Sroun Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 483 Som Sareth Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 484 Khan Sothean Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 485 Keo Laur Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 486 Heng Dern Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 487 Yo Ly Choung Long Soung Land Crops/Trees 488 Sa Rositha Choung Long Soung Land Other fixed assets 489 He Som at Choung Long Soung Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 490 Hie Sam At Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 491 Hy Som at Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 492 Hak Seing Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 493 Suy Yeknguor Choung Long Soung Main structure/building 494 Try Vannak Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 495 Sok Punthan Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 496 Heng Thy Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 497 Thy Long Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 498 Seur Heurn Choung Long Soung Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 499 Heng Dean Choung Long Soung Land Other fixed assets 500 Heng Sopheap Choung Long Soung Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets
16 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 501 Niv Chea Choung Long Soung Land Other fixed assets 502 Mao Sok Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 503 Va Sri Choung Long Soung Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 504 Chren So pheap Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 505 Pa Saloem Choung Long Soung Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 506 Chheak Sopheap Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 507 Lay Bunna Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 508 Seur Heurn Choung Long Soung Main structure/building 509 Bun Ly Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 510 Meas Ly Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 511 Yeagn Kim orn Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 512 Chhik So pheap Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 513 Chheng Sokpeng Choung Long Soung Land Main structure/building 514 Boury Kang Choung Long Soung Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 515 Kim Gnourn heing Choung Long Soung Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 516 Leang Heang Choung Long Soung Main structure/building 517 Chan Ban Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 518 Khan Sitha Choung Long Soung Land Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 519 Thai Vuthy Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 520 Kao Sophal Choung Long Soung Other fixed assets 521 Khon Sanon Choung Long LicSoung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 522 Yo Ouav Choung Long LicSoung Other fixed assets 523 Long Thouck Choung Long LicSoung Main structure/building 524 Kang Samorn Pun Rey Soung Land Main structure/building 525 Kong Sokhon Pun Rey Soung Land Main structure/building 526 Sun Mourk Pun Rey Soung Land Main structure/building 527 Cheng Sok Pun Rey Soung Main structure/building 528 Boul Soyhang Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 529 Huy Kung Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 530 Ly Khan Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 531 Tith Thavi Soung Soung Main structure/building 532 Heing So hai Soung Soung Land Main structure/building
17 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 533 Toek Srun Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 534 Tang Sang Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 535 Sim Sithov Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 536 Lao Sihuong Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 537 Nget Sophany Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 538 Saur Eing Soung Soung Other fixed assets 539 Sean Kim srean Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 540 Lay Srun Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 541 Kong Hort Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 542 Yeng Det Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 543 Tang Leakchhay Soung Soung Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 544 Son Nhel Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 545 Long Vichet Soung Soung Main structure/building 546 Heng Seang Soung Soung Land Other fixed assets 547 Nov Sophal Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 548 Searng Khn Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 549 Kim heang Soung Soung Land Main structure/building 550 Seat Khoun Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 551 Hour Yothai Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 552 Seng Hourt Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 553 Chheck Kimleng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 554 Bun Srun Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 555 Tang Leakheng Soung Lich Soung Main structure/building 556 Meng Leang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 557 Tang Menglim Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 558 Seam Heang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 559 Chhuong Leng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 560 Keang Theng Soung Lich Soung Main structure/building 561 Siv Khem Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 562 Cheang Eang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 563 Chhai Lunn Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 564 Ouin Mengkheng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building
18 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 565 Khuoy Hong Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 566 Pov Theang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 567 Hung Tekho Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 568 Hoy Oun Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 569 Uong Mengly Soung Lich Soung Other fixed assets 570 Tang Chour Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 571 Tang Gkechnai Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 572 Orm Peset Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 573 Lim Sengchan Soung Lich Soung Main structure/building 574 Gnourn Mov Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 575 Kn Vign chng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 576 Siev Hour Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 577 Koeum Paur Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 578 khoeum Leirng Soung Lich Soung Land Other fixed assets 579 Ly Ny Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 580 Sok Kang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 581 Sok Khang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 582 Chiv Hoy Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 583 Chuv Chantha Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 584 Oum Dem Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 585 Moury Heang Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 586 Bun Lean Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 587 Ou Namseng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 588 Ngen Eng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 589 Kheang Leng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 590 Ouang Tong Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 591 Nang Bunsan Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 592 Lim Yong Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 593 You Nguoneng Soung Lich Soung Land Main structure/building 594 Huy Neing Vihear Kpos Soung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets Total 120 95 95 15 32 595 Seng Van Kbal trach Sre Cha Land Main structure/building
19 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 596 Chhay Sor Kbal trach Sre Cha Land Other fixed assets Total 2 2 1 0 1 597 Man Thos Dong Kambit Srolob Main structure/building 598 Ell Torl Dong Kambit Srolob Main structure/building 599 Sus Sainub Dong Kambit Srolob Land Main structure/building 600 No Mat Dong Kambit Srolob Land Main structure/building 601 Man Pov Dong Kambit Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 602 Suon Pengsea Phsr Kna Srolob Land Main structure/building 603 Kim Thai Preah Teat Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 604 Yea Sopheap Preah Teat Srolob Land Main structure/building 605 Ly Try Preah Teat Srolob Main structure/building 606 Ein So Kear Preah Teat Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 607 Mov Saran Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 608 Suon Mengsea Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 609 Sok Pheing Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 610 Moak Pengleang Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 611 Tang Soklang Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 612 Sem Chan vesna Trapang Ku Srolob Main structure/building 613 Chhay Bros Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 614 Me Na Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 615 Hong Tray Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 616 Suon Im Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 617 Hong Chav Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 618 Cheing Ourng Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 619 Chem Chheing Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 620 Vann Kheing Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 621 Than Chan dy Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 622 Tai Nai Srein Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 623 Hak Heurn Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 624 Chhor Ke Trapang Ku Srolob Main structure/building 625 Teang Thao Trapang Ku Srolob Main structure/building Crops/Trees 626 Tich Tha Trapang Ku Srolob Other fixed assets
20 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 627 Chhun Hongeng Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 628 Keam Makara Trapang Ku Srolob Main structure/building 629 Trea Tra Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 630 Seang Peng Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 631 Douch Teang Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 632 Hel Sour Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 633 Chom Monly Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 634 Suon Seng Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 635 Lang Sopheap Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 636 Tong Sok Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 637 Prom Khon Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 638 Hao Kimso Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 639 Leang Hy Trapang Ku Srolob Main structure/building 640 Hack Mab Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 641 Thong Chen Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 642 Sreng Chanda Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 643 E Von Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 644 Pol Earn Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building Other fixed assets 645 Tang Yongi Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 646 Bou Phanghuoy Trapang Ku Srolob Land . 647 Suon Im Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 648 Tang Pengleang Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 649 Tel Bol Trapang Ku Srolob Land Main structure/building 650 Hak Sophal Veal Knach Srolob Land Main structure/building 651 Heng Huch Veal Knach Srolob Land Main structure/building 652 Khon Seckleng Veal Knach Srolob Land Main structure/building 653 Chhun Sara Veal Knach Srolob Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Total 57 48 56 13 3 654 Seng Hour Rosei Cha Thmor Kre Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets Total 1 1 1 1 1 655 Hout Pros Plark Somrong Treak Land Main structure/building 656 Kim Mong Somrong Tboun Treak Land Main structure/building
21 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 657 Men Ty Somrong Tboun Treak Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 658 Kour Mengneang Somrong Tboun Treak Land Main structure/building Total 4 4 4 1 0 659 Ros Khourn Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building 660 Vegn Ny Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Other fixed assets 661 Moury Gnoeum Chorm Treak Tror Moung 662 Kim Chanthul Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building 663 Kim Chour Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets 664 Hoeun Hong Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building 665 Mao Chenda Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building 666 Leng Nary Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building 667 Tong Suytry Chorm Treak Tror Moung Land Main structure/building 668 Sen Mab Khnorng KrorhpeTror Moung Land Main structure/building 669 Ok Gna Marady Khnorng KrorhpeTror Moung Land Other fixed assets 670 Kao Srour Psar Tmey Tror Moung Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Total 12 11 9 2 3 671 Kong Sopanet Kro Nhung Veal Mlou Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 672 Thuong Sopheap Kro Nhung Veal Mlou Land Main structure/building Total 2 2 2 1 0 673 Yeirm Mom Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Main structure/building 674 Oum Eng Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Main structure/building 675 Yol Navy Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building 676 Chhai Leang Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Main structure/building 677 Tork Ny Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building 678 Doan Cheang Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building 679 Soy Ngonseng Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building 680 Morn Nai Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building 681 Hai Chantho Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building 682 Yam Vuthy Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 683 Lim Leng Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees 684 Morn Nein Tnal Thmey Vihear Lourng Land Main structure/building Total 12 9 12 2 0
22 Resettlement Audit of Loan 1697-CAM: Primary Roads Restoration Project
Appendix 23 PAPs in Household Survey with Unpaid Assets (NR7) (Data to come from Household Survey conducted by Audit Team)
Properties/Assets Lost No Address Household Head Village Commune Land Main structure/building Crops/Trees Other fixed assets Grand-Total 684 599 575 160 126
23 Appendix 24
Tap Code B1 FGD in Roleab Commune: Female Group NR 5 Total Participants = 8 Date: August 5, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was conducted on August 5, 2005 in a house of PAP located in Roleab Commune, Posat Province. There were only 8 female participants from Roleab commune attended in this discussion because most of them seem not to be interested with any program related to the resettlement work. And only apart of their house was affected by the project.
2. Information about the project
There were calls for a meeting one in this commune, two months before the project started, but few among people in the group complained that they have no call for meeting. It meant that the information related to the project not fully knew by all PAPs. The meeting was conducted by the provincial and communal officers at a pagoda in Roleab Commune in order to tell the people that the road would be widened.
My husband was also called for a meeting related to the road construction project. “People need to retreat 12 meters from the road side” the officer said.
“PAPs would be removed any assets which is affected by the road land, because government needs to widen the road” the officer said.
A day before the meeting conducted I was called by the village chief. Even I was very busy with my income earning, I still availed oneself of time to joint.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
Only few of the people among group received the information, consultation and participated in the consulting work. Few of them complained that they were be absented and did not attend in the public meeting. So they received nothing related to the process of the project and consulting work.
We were told that if we have any affected assets or trees on the road land the government will be compensated.
One day after the meeting was conducted; the IRC’s working group come and did their measurement and consulting work all the houses along the road side.
My cement hedge was told by the working group to remove and it will be compensated. Appendix 24
4. Affected assets and valuation
Most people in this group had their partly affected assets by the project. The affected assets were includes grocery shops, houses, pump well, hedges, and some trees. Few among them complained of the valuation were not equal to the current market.
Two meters of my houses was affected by the project, instead of removing it I received $200 for compensation.
The IRC’s working group asked me to retreat 12 meters from the middle of the road. A part of my house was affected, but I need to remove at all, they valuated to me only the affected size.
A part of my grocery store was valuated by the IRC’s working group but I get nothing after I was removed.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Resulting from the public meeting was held not too much clear to the people; most of them among group seem unclear of awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement.
When the IRC’s working group assigned me to remove, I was quickly destroyed my cement hedge without measuring from them, I get nothing.
Because I don’t want to be blamed from the authority, I was retreated my entire houses to the back.
I would be compensated to my entire affected houses; my house left was too small to live.
I don’t know whether my grocery store having any compensation or not, they just told me and than I removed it.
6. Grievance redress
Because most of people among group were not know clearly about the project policy and entitlement and received little of the consultation, they were not complain too much to the working group related to the valuated rate. Most people among this group said they want to make an argument about their compensation that is not faire and equal to the current market price. But, they did nothing, because they seem unfaith to the IRC’s working group. Only few were little argued of increasing valuated price.
Appendix 24
I also requested more money of $130 to a part of my affected house from the valuation team, but they told me my house is in type one, so I must to get it. In fact, I was spent $250 for building that house in the last two year.
I was complained to the IRC’s working group to resolve my affected assets but they said that is the government policy.
I don’t know whether I have the right to complain to the working group or not, if know, I would be not give them my fingerprint.
I think, I am a people living in the rural area, how can I fight with the government official.
I have no choice rather than accepting what they were given. If I ask them more compensation they would not pay me even 100Riel.
7. Level of satisfaction
In this group discussion, most of them seem not satisfy with IRC’s resettlement work. According to my observation, they also not too much interested with what we are doing because they seem unfaith.
I received only $200 in removing my entire house, so I borrowed $200 from my relative for rebuilding.
Because of removing my cement hedge I have not enough money to rebuild a new one, instead of removing I can only build it by wood.
Some people haven’t removed yet as they are not sure whether they can get compensation so they have to live on.
The compensation would be equal to the current market price, and would be faired to all PAPs.
8. Impacts
According to the people in this group, project seem not badly affected to their living condition because most of them were affected only small part of houses and business store and hedge only. But, only few among them complained it caused to their family financial. It means that during the time of rebuilding their fix assets they have to borrow money with high rate of interest. Beside of this, project seems to cause the positive point to them like the improving of transportation, business, and their health.
During removing my house I was borrowed $300 with 5% of interest rate, up to now I don’t have enough money to retune it yet.
After the road was be widened, I can quickly access to everywhere especially related to my business. If compare to the past, I spend only 50% of time of transportation and expenditure. Appendix 24
Tap Code B2 FGD in Prey Nhy commune, Posat: Male Group
Total Participants = 15 Date: August 5, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The Focus Group Discussion was held on August 5, 2005 in a house of PAP located in Prey Nhy commune, Posat province. There were 15 male of PAPs came from Prey Nhy commune where most of them received the compensation.
2. Information about the project
The information related to the project was clearly known by all PAPs. Before the project started, there were called for meeting conducted by the provincial and communal official that the government need to be widened the road. Most people among this group were attended in the meeting.
I was called for a meeting that the road would be widened, people who are living along the road land needs to be retreated.
“The government is very poor, instead of removing PAPs would be received only apart of compensation” the officer said in the meeting.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
People in this group almost received the public information, consultation and participated with the IRC’s working group related to the project process. IRC’s working group was conducted their consulting work after the first meeting was held by explaining to the PAPs about compensation policies and then did their measurement work. Eventhough, people seem not clear what IRC’s working group did.
They were told me that only the resident will be compensated of appropriate price including repairing value and transportation.
The compensation will be provided according to the type of affected assets. Trees are the public property, it will no compensation.
During consulting work was conducted, IRC’s working group briefing me in detail related the resettlement policies. Up to now, I can not remember it at all. But I can understand that they just negotiated PAPs to accept what they want to compensate, government policies.
Appendix 24
4. Affected assets and valuation
Most people among this group discussion had their partly affected by the project. Only few, complained they were affected 50% of their house, but they also received the compensation. The affected assets were includes grocery stores, houses, business stores, and trees. Most of them were received the compensation for their affected assets.
I, Ly Chhin was affected 2.2m x 16m of my cement hedge; I received only $69 instead of removing.
1.5m x 4.5m of my affected house were destroyed, instead of removing I received $82 for affected size and 160,000 Riel for the cost of removing fee.
They asked me to retreat 15.5m from the middle of the road, so my house was affected for 9 square meters. The IRC’s working group was valuated only small amount of money for affected size it’s not possible to rebuild it.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Even they were attended in the meeting and consultation conducted by IRC’s working group, they still not clear about their entitlement. Most of them think that what they were received is limited, because the government is now very poor.
The compensation that I was received, clearly inadequate with what I lost, but I must to get it, if not I will got nothing.
The IRC’s working group said that, “the valuation is not the compensation, but it is the payments amount as a gift from the government”.
They told me that the payment is only for the house or resident, not for pump well and trees
“This is the special case that Posat province have the compensation, despite of this no other provinces received” IRC’s working group said.
6. Grievance redress
Because of consultation was not too clear to PAPs, most people among group complained they don’t know how to make an argument and complaints with unacceptable compensation. They said, if they know clearly about their right related to the unacceptable compensation, they must be not accepting what the IRC’s working group valuated.
Appendix 24
The IRC’s working group was not told us related to PAP’s right, if I have the right to complain with the valuation, I would not give them my fingerprint and removing my house.
They told me that the valuation price of my affected asset is the gift of the government not fully compensation if not accept, I still remove it without payment. So I have no other choice rather than accept what they were given.
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction of people among this group was not too low because most of the PAPs in this community were received the compensation. Most of them complained that the compensation was not adequate to their affected assets. It means that the compensations were not valuated by the current market rate. Furthermore, few of them worried about the quality of the road because now some part was broken down.
50% of my concrete house was affected by the project, IRC’s working group paid me only $100 instead of removing. In fact, I spent $3000 to rebuild it. I really not satisfied what they was given, but they told me if not accept, I will got nothing.
2m x 4.5m of my houses was affected and other PAP nearby me also affected the same size, as the result, I received only $60 but the other one got $85. Why don’t they be faire?
The quality of the road seem not have a good quality, according to my observation in this community, because many part of the road side was broken down.
8. Impact
The project seems not caused too much in this commune because most of them were compensated even the level of satisfaction not too much satisfied. Beside of the compensation with the affected assets they also received other service from the IRC’s working group. But, two point of negative impact of this project are the quality of the road and pipe system. Most of them complained that because of the road build without pipe system; their houses were flooded during the rainy season.
During rainy season, all the houses along the road side were flooded by rain water because the road is too higher than and there have no pipe system here.
I don’t know why government spent too much to build poor quality of the road. The road will be destroyed during the period of 5 year only as my expectation. Appendix 24
Tap code 26 FGD in Kaung Kang Commune, Kampong Cham: Female Group
Total Participants: 13 Date: August 13, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was conducted on August 13, 2005 in Kampong cham province, Ponnhear Krek district, Kaung Kang commune, Po Srok village in a house of PAPs where the most of them were not received the compensation. There were 13 women who participated in this discussion. Most of them among group were partly affected to their houses and few affected the entire business store especially grocery stores. All of them among group were not received any compensation.
2. Information about the project
It appears that people among this group discussion received very little or not at all the information related project implementation. There were no called for meeting in this community. What they heard just hearsay that the government needs to widen the road and then it’s turned true.
No one called me for meeting. I heard from the local authority, the provincial officers come and assigned the people who live along the road side needs to remove.
The authority asked me to retreat 25m from the middle of the road, no one called me for meeting. I heard information about the project by the village chief.
I know information about the project almost none. It was too surprised that I just known while the IRC’s working group arrived in front of my houses.
3. Public information, Consultation and Participation
Resulting from the meeting was not conduct in this community PAPs clearly not received the consultation and any participation related to the project implementation. However, most of people know some information by informal talk heard from the village chief and other villagers.
During the construction, I really known nothing related to the project. What I heard from the village chief it was that the road would be widened.
I did not receive any information related to project implementation. I never saw the project officials come to explain me of policy of the project before it was started.
Appendix 24
4. Affected assets and Valuation
All PAPs among group were affected their assets including small business stores, balconies, apart of the houses, and some trees. In fact, few participants complained they lost entire store while other lost only part of it and houses. Most of them did not receive the compensation for their assets. There was no valuation on effected assets.
Apart of my house was affected by the project. I did not receive any compensation instead of removing. They just told me to retreat 25 meter from the middle of the road.
My grocery store was build since 1996 in front of my houses, they [IRC] asked me to remove the entire without valuation and measurement.
Part of my store was affected, it was made from wooden and zinc roof. I received nothing instead of removing.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement among this group discussion were almost none. Because of the project was not conducted the meeting and consultation before they started.
During IRC’s working group conducted the measurement, they told me that my entire store was affected and need to relocated it not they would be removed.
IRC’s working group asked me to valuate the part of my affected houses, but they said nothing related to the compensation.
6. Grievance redress
Resulting of meeting, consultation, and participation were not conducts in this community people seem not complain too much with the working group. Most of them complained that they are clearly not satisfied what the governments do, but it’s their duty. People seem they had no other choice rather than accepting what they were determined to remove their houses and stores.
My entire business store, 4.5m x 10m were affected by the project and it also removed by the working group without getting any compensation.
I also complained and asked too much to the working group to pay me the compensation but they said my affected assets were built on the road land.
Appendix 24
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction among the people in this group discussion was too low. They complained that they did not receive anything as compensation. As the result, people among group assumed that the process of project was unfair and corruption.
We are not happy with this project because we wonder the project may be corruption. We heard hearsay from other villagers received the compensation from the RGC instead of removing their affected assets.
8. Impacts
The project seems to cause on PAPs livelihood households in this area. Most of them complained they loss the entire business store, it’s clearly lost their income earning especially during construction. Eventhought, most of them seem too satisfied with the good quality of the road.
I lost my whole store, so my business was closed. Up to now I turned of selling grocery to do the farming.
Since constructing work was finished, my business was too low. Most of my customers did not stop their vehicle to buy the products; they go to buy in the provincial town.
Before the project start I got 6000Reil as my daily profit from my grocery store, but during the construction I lost it so I got nothing of income.
Because of the project was destroyed my business store during the construction, now I become a mobile business seller in the village.
Constructing work was started during rainy season that caused of difficulty in doing our business for long time.
Instead of losing our business stores we also happy of getting the new road that can quickly and easily access to Phnom Penh and the market. Furthermore, it can reduce any expenses related to the transportation. Appendix 24
FGD in Kaung Kang Commune, Kampong Cham: Male Group
Total Participants: 10 Date: August 13, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was held on August 13, 2005 in a houses of PAP located in Po Srok village, Kaung Kang commune, Ponnhear Krek district, Kampong Cham province. There were 10 male participants come from Kaung Kang commune attended in this discussion. Most of people who participated in discussion were removed/retreated their affected assets before the project start. Up to now they still receive any compensation from the RGC.
2. Information about the project
People in this area had received very little of information related to the project implementation. Most of information they heard just only informal talk and hearsay from other villagers and turned true. Furthermore, village chief was also spread the information to the people before the working group come that the road would be widened.
There were no calls for meeting related to road widening. What I heard just only hearsay from other villagers and then it turned true.
I knew the project when village chief told me at my houses. “The RGC need to widen the road, people who live along the road land must be removed” village chief said.
3. Public information, Consultation and Participation
Because of the meeting was not conduct in this community, consultation and participation were almost none. People in group discussion received information of project by informal talk.
IRC’s working group was told me that RGC needs to widen the road during their measurement work and the affected assets need to retreat. They just did their work without saying anything related to the project policy.
I and my family members tried to move the house to the back after the village chief told there has no consulting work was conducted.
4. Affected assets and valuation
All people in this group had their assets affected by the project especially small business stores a long the road and few houses and trees. Most of them were removed affected assets before DMS conducted. As the result, they did not receive compensation for affected assets. People were complained that the IRC’s working group provided in short time of removing. Appendix 24
My store was affected as a whole. I was removed it before the IRC’s working group measured.
I had one store in front of my house. When I heard that the road need to be widening, I was removed it quickly. After that, IRC’s working group come to conduct their measurement, and then they did not tell me any compensation related policies.
6.5m x 11m of my zinc roof houses was relocated to the back, instead of removing it I got nothing.
I was cutting my 8 mango trees off located in front of my house. Before that, IRC’s working group told me it will be compensated for all instead of removing it, but I didn’t receive it yet.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement were almost none resulting of absented of public information and consultation. People seem to know too little of any policies and entitlement related to resettlement work.
Nobody of us knew more clearly about the compensation and the policy related to the project policy. What we know is that the RGC need to widen the road and assigned us to relocate.
IRC’s working group asked me to valuate my affected assets to them, and then they didn’t say anything related to the compensation policies.
6. Grievance redress
Resulting of no public information, consultation, and valuation, most people among group said that they were not agreeing with the government policy but they have no choice. All PAPs think that the government needs the road land so they kept of their complaint and tried to retreat to the back without an argument. Few of them complained too much of unfair with other commune that received the compensation.
My entire house was affected by the project. I really disagree of no compensation, I asked to the working group for the compensation but they said my house was built on the road land, it has no compensation.
24 square meters of my entire grocery store was affected by the project and IRC’s working group also measured it but they said nothing of compensation. After, I was removed it to the back without asking them related to the compensation because I think the RGC need the road land.
Appendix 24
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction among group was too low related to the compensation because all of them who participated in this group discussion got nothing. Few among them also mentioned that there have a handicap people in the village received compensation for his entire house. Eventhought, Most of them are very satisfied with the new road that provides them safely of transportation and there has no air pollutions.
I heard from the other villagers that if I’m a PAP people I will be compensated, but resulting my affected house was received nothing.
My 8 sweet mango trees provide me the benefit every year, 300,000 riel per year for each, instead of removing it I would get the compensation. How can I satisfy with this project?
Even not satisfied with no of compensation, I very satisfied of getting new road that cam help me access quickly to work in the provincial town.
8. Impacts
The project seems to cause not too much to the residents in this community even they haven’t received any compensation and little information related to the policy because they have enough land for resettlement. Most of them are selling anything along the road side, so project mainly affected to their business situation especially income earning during road construction.
I was removed my motorcycle repairing store at all. Now, I remain my house only, so I lost my business income earning. Up to know I turned my business to the market, but I paid too much money to buy the new one.
My grocery store was removed by the project, so now I changed it to sell the CD/VCD because during the constructing work I was closed it.
After my 8 mango trees were cutting off, it benefit 2,400,000 riel per year as the big amount of my family income, now I become a mobile seller in the village.
At the movement, the road is good to access easily to everywhere especially to work and doing my business. It can save my time and expense.
Because the road was built without the sign of traffic and central line, it cause of increasing of traffic accident in this community. I really worry of my children’s security. Appendix 24 Tape Code D2 Focus Discussion Group Srolob Commune: Female Group NR 6 Total of participants: 9 Date: June 26, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was held on June 26, 2005 in Srolob commune, Tbong Khmom district, Kompong Cham province. There were 9 participants come from Srolob commune attended in this discussion. The project has an adverse effect on the people’s livelihoods. Most of the affected assets were houses, business stores and trees. The affected assets are located closely to the road land, so when the road was widened of 25 meters away from the middle line of the road, most their assets were partly affected.
2. Information about the project
There was no formal information released to the residents for retreat of their affected assets. They only knew the road would be widened, by all accounts, be widened some time, but they didn’t know when the project would be started.
I only heard that the government planned to widen the road, so they required us to move 25 meters away from the middle of the road. Therefore, I was completely moved before the deadline of 27, 2000.
I didn’t know whether they have compensation to the affected people at all. The IRC’s working group and the village headman didn’t tell me about this while they came to my store, they just forced me to remove before the deadline.
3. Public Information, Consultation and Participation
The village chief played an important role in telling the residents to remove people’s affected assets from the road land areas. Therefore, there was no any public information released to the affected people. It seems different from the resettlement policies because the village chief told residents afterward the IRC’s working group conducted the DMS.
While I was staying at my business store, the IRC’s working group arrived. Then they told me to move my store away from the project areas ahead of deadline on 27, 2000.
After the DMS was completed, the village chief came to invite the affected residents to attend the meeting. But he didn’t invite the public to participate in it, in which only affected people were invited.
I joined the meeting at Khnar high school because my business store and house were affected by the project.
1 Appendix 24 The residents didn’t get any consultation from the IRC’s working group even though the former asked for help from the latter.
I am very afraid when the IRC’s working group was arrived my store. They told me to remove the store before deadline on 27, 2000. If I don’t move my house, they will damage it. Then I asked for the compensation, but they refused to tell me that it didn’t rely on the compensation principles because the store was built for live. Therefore, I decided to completely remove it on 25, 2000. When I had removed affected assets already, there were nothing happen after the deadline on 27, 2000.
The people took part in the project activities. They decided to remove the affected assets away from the affected areas.
I removed my business store away before the deadline because I was afraid of laws even though the IRC’s working group refused to give any the compensation.
4. Affected assets and Valuation
The affected assets in these areas were grocery stores, houses, trees and wells. Some respondents lost the land after they retreated 25 m from the middle line the road and others lost a part of the assets.
I had the land only 15 meters from the road. As a consequence, when I removed 25 m I was nothing left to relocate. In this regard, I didn’t get the compensation at all.
I had the big tree in the front of my house, so IRC’s working group assigned me to cut it off. I spent 160,000 riel to cut it off, instead of cutting off, I didn’t get the compensation at all.
The affected people didn’t get the valuation to the affected assets at all along the resettlement and DMS.
The IRC’s working group did not tell me any valuation and compensation to my assets. They just forced me to remove immediately while I asked the compensation.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Resulting of no called for meeting, public information, and consultation before the project start, people in this community didn’t aware of the resettlement policies and the entitlement. In this regard, the seriously affected people were permitted to the meeting talked about the compensation policies after the DMS was conducted, but the little affected people were not allowed.
The meeting told us about the resettlement policies, compensation and removing the affected assets from the project area.
2 Appendix 24 Although, she had joined the meeting she seems not clears and remember the compensation rate. Beside this the respondents didn’t aware of the entitlement too. That is why; they had no choice rather than removed their affected assets without getting compensation at all.
I was afraid the IRC’s working group damaged my property, so I decided to remove it without getting anything.
I loosed a big tree without getting compensation. Beside this, the IRC’s working group told me that it didn’t belong to me, but it belonged to the public.
6. Grievance Redress
The residents had loosed the assets and even didn’t get the compensation. They still didn’t lodge to the IRC at all. The respondents might unaware of the grievance redress and were afraid of the IRC’s working group.
I didn’t brave to lodge to the IRC’s working group. I thought it was impossible. Especially, I was afraid them because I was a widow.
7. Level of Satisfaction
The most of the respondents didn’t satisfy to the compensation practice because the compensation was not fair for all the affected people.
It was not fair for all the affected people because I knew that some other affected people got the compensation, but I got nothing for my removal.
I satisfied for the compensation practice while we all had gotten the compensation or didn’t get together, but I unsatisfied when I hadn’t get the compensation and the others had.
8. Impacts
There were negative and positive impacts to the livelihood of the residents. The project was awaited too long to implement, so it was supposed to ban the residents’ livelihood. Some of the respondents had supposed the project provided the initiative to making the good living condition.
It was easy to transport. I spent a short time to reach the destination.
It could support to our living while we can transport easily.
While some of the residents were happy with the achievement, but the others was regret and hadn’t the land to relocate.
I had not land to settle, so I had been lived with my mother and even loosed my business.
3 Appendix 24 I spent money twice to buy the pump for fixing the canal. Firstly, when I completely fixed the pump to the canal, the IRC’s working group damaged it by telling that it wasn’t suitable for the canal system. Therefore, I bought the new one.
I loosed my business store, so I had never done business from that time. As a consequence, I loosed the family income.
4 Appendix 24 Tape Code D1 Focus Group Discussion Srolob Commune, Tbong Khmom District, Kompong Cham province: Male Group
Total of Participants = 8 Date: June 25, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sereivouth
1. Introduction
The focus group discussion was held on June 25, 2005 in a Srolob commune, Tbong Khmom district, Kompong Cham province in a house of PAP. There were 8 male respondents participated in this discussion. We found out that there isn’t seriously impact to the affected people even though some of them had gotten little compensation and the others got nothing.
2. Information about the project
There was no formal information related to the project before the project start, what the people heard just only hearsay and turned true when the IRC’s working group came to conduct their measurement work. After the measurement, they [IRC] called people who affected by the project attending in a meeting. The meeting were told the people that the road would be widened, so the people who live along the road side need to retreat 25 meters from the middle of the road.
After they measured 25 meters from the middle of the road, my house and the grocery store were affected. Afterward, IRC’s working group was called me to joint the meeting, and they told me that my house was affected to the road land.
They didn’t call me to joint the meeting, because they said that my house was not affected. In fact, 75 percent of my entire house was affected by the project if they require 25 meters from the middle of road.
3. Public Information, Consultation and Participation
Most of people said there was public information to show the project activities, but they didn’t tell the real information about compensation policies for affected assets. The IRC’s working groups held the consultation with the residents but didn’t explain to them the value in the list of compensation policies. They just gave a 5-page book to some participants. After that the former read the value to the latter, but the implementation seems different from what is said in the book.
In the list I would be gotten $45 for my affected assets, but I virtually received nothing. Therefore, it really has corruption with this compensation.
At the first meeting was conducted, IRC’s working group provided to people the 5-pages book that talked about the compensation policies and the project activities.
1 Appendix 24 4. Affected assets and valuation
The IRC’ working group gave the misunderstanding of compensation for affected assets to the residents. All affected assets would be given the compensation, but IRC‘s working groups refused to give the compensation for the some affected assets. Most of the affected assets in this area were the business stores and the roof ending.
I didn’t get anything because IRC’s working group refused it. They said that it was not in compliance with the compensation principles. Business stores are for doing business not for live, so it is unsuitable for receiving the compensation, they added.
Some participants knew the valuation for the compensation principles if they got the compensation guidebook, but the others didn’t know at all because they didn’t get it.
I knew the valuation for the compensation through the provided book. The affected tree cost $0.73 per square meter and houses made of zinc roof, wooden wall, concrete floor cost $12 per square meter.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Some of the people were aware of the resettlement policy because there were two meetings organized, but the others didn’t know. If they got the compensation guidebooks, they would really understand it clearly. Although IRC’s working group told it in the meeting, it was really difficult to understand and very complicated. In the meeting, the IRC’s working group provided the rights for affected people to file complaints, but the complaints were cancelled later.
In the meeting, they mentioned that you have rights to complain for the compensation and valuation. It wasn’t true because I lodged complaints, but my suit was not responded and even cancelled.
6. Grievance redress
There were allowed the grievance redress for the compensation complaint, but majority of the respondents complained about the way the project officers handled the grievances.
Business store was constructed for business even though it wasn’t for live, but it was my property so I have rights to get the compensation. I sought help from human rights organizations. As a result, I got nothing from the IRC because they refused my proposal.
7. Level of satisfaction
The level of the satisfaction among them was really good. It means that they are satisfied with the government’s achievements. Although some of them didn’t get
2 Appendix 24 the compensation or got the little compensation, It wasn’t matter for them because it only effected the business store and the roof ending. It wasn’t really seriously affected assets so it made them satisfy the compensation and persuasion.
8. Impacts
There is no serious impact on the livelihoods in this area. It just has the problem with the canal along the road. Therefore, house owners spent money to buy the pump to fix it. Some of them spent it two times so it caused them to waste money.
It wasn’t really affected. I was very happy when I have the road for transportation. Although I spent money two times to rebuild the pump through the canal, I am still happy for having the newly constructed road.
3 Appendix 24 Tape code D4 Focus Group Discussion Chub village, Tnal Toteung commune, Tbong Khmom district, Kompong Cham province
Total of Participation: 10 Date: June 26, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The focus group discussion held on June 26, 2005 in the Chub village, Tnal Toteung commune, Tbong Khmom district, Kompong cham province. There were 10 male PAPs participated in the meeting. They were all complained about the compensation practice because the IRC’s working group didn’t provide the faithful compensation to the PAPs by telling that the government didn’t had enough money to compensate.
2. Information about the project
Before the project had implemented the PAPs didn’t knew the information yet. The PAPs didn’t receive any information at all, but they received the information while IRC’s working group applied the measurement.
At that time, I didn’t get the information at all because no one told me or heard from others, but I knew the information while the IRC’s working group conducted the measurement through the affected assets along the road.
3. Public information, Consultation and participation
The IRC’s working group held three meetings to inform the PAPs about the valuation and compensation. The respondents were unclear about the public information policies because the IRC’s working didn’t invite all the PAPs to participate in the meeting. They only invited the heavy PAPs to the meeting, but the little PAPs weren’t invite. Especially, in the compensation meeting only heavy PAPs were invited to participate. It wasn’t faithful through compensation because the PAPs who participated in the meeting would be got the compensation and the others weren’t participate in received nothing.
The project was affected my balcony. The IRC’s working thought that it was the little affect so they didn’t invite me to the compensation meeting. Therefore, I received nothing for my removing.
Through the meeting, the IRC’s working group informed us about the project activities and compensation. Firstly, they claimed to provide the compensation for all the affected people, but they refused it later by telling that the government hadn’t enough money to compensate all the affected assets so they compensated only the heavy affected assets. When I knew it, I had nothing to say then I accepted it.
1 Appendix 24 4. Affected assets and Valuation
The PAPs had been living this area for many years ago. Therefore, the affected assets were located before the government planned to widen the road. It was suitable to get the compensation and valuation for all the affected assets even though it seems a slightly affected. But for this area the IRC’s working group didn’t provide the compensation if they thought that it was a slightly affected by the project. Moreover it wasn’t faithful through the compensation. The affected assets in this area were balconies and the others were houses and wells.
My house was affected by the project about 3m when they measured 12.5m from the middle line of the road. It was two steps house, the upstairs made of wooden wall, zinc roof and downstairs made of cement. The IRC’s working group valuated it into 2nd type on the list. I get the compensation already but it was too little compared to the affected assets.
My balcony was affected by the project. Once the IRC’s working group told me to valuate my affected assets by myself so my wife valuate about $400 for removing, but when they provided the compensation they refused to give me the compensation by telling that it was the slightly affected and compensated for only house but not for the balcony.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
The PAPs didn’t aware of the resettlement policy clearly because the IRC’s working group didn’t tell them in detail. The resettlement policy seems didn’t match to the market price at all. Because they didn’t aware of the entitlement and afraid of IRC’s working group, the PAPs didn’t accused against them at all.
The IRC’s working group had measured my balcony already, but they didn’t tell me how much I could obtain or told me the resettlement policy. They asked to wait the compensation which was coming soon. When they provided the compensation I didn’t get it because they refused to give me.
The compensation and resettlement policy weren’t associated with the market price. Therefore, I needed to add some money to the compensation if I constructed newly assets.
I wasn’t aware of the entitlement to complain to the IRC’s working group at all.
I was afraid of the IRC’s working group. If I didn’t agree and followed the policy I received nothing for my removing. Moreover, they would be asked me to pay the fee if they removed my affected assets by themselves.
6. Grievance redress
As a result of unclear information, resettlement policy and entitlement, the PAPs weren’t able to complain the IRC’s working group. They were very afraid of the IRC’s working group while we had advised them to allege against IRC’s working group. Moreover, the PAPs might misunderstand the resettlement policy and
2 Appendix 24 entitlement because the IRC’s told them that it was the government policies so no one could break or complain it.
I knew the resettlement policy didn’t match to the market price, but I was impossible to complain about it because it was the government policy.
The IRC’s working group told me that the resettlement policies were conducted by the government so no one could complain about it at all. Therefore, I accepted it.
7. Level of satisfaction
The compensation and valuation wasn’t adequate to the real value of affected assets. The PAPs who had the badly affected assets got the compensation, but the little affected received nothing. It wasn’t transparency to all the PAPs for get the compensation while they are all having the same affected assets.
The compensation was so little compared to the affected assets. We couldn’t use this money to buy newly assets. So I must to spend my own money to repair or construct it.
I received only $100 for my affected assets. I thought it didn’t match to the affected assets.
8. Impacts
The project had many affected to the people’s livelihood because of careless of the IRC’s working group on the canal along the road. They didn’t construct the water system when the project completed, therefore it was a flood in the rainy season flew into the residents’ house along the canal. Moreover, some of the people buy culvert to fill it, but the others weren’t so the water didn’t run through the canal directly. The residents were complain about the water flew to the house when it had the heavy raining.
It was the flood in my house when it was a heavy raining. It was very trouble with our family living condition. No one had solved these problems, so I myself couldn’t afford to carry out this work.
I spent much money buy culvert and land to fill in the canal in front of my house. When the project completed I bought 12 culverts cost 40,000 riel per piece and land 9 trucks cost 25000 riel per truck. So I spent much money to construct it.
I was the vendor so when it had a canal in my in front of my store, it made me got the little customer compared before the project was implemented.
Some people hadn’t enough money to buy the culvert at the same size and the others didn’t buy it. Therefore, it was many problems appeared related to the culvert system because of the culverts weren’t matching to each others when they constructed it. As a result, there were flood in raining season.
3 Appendix 24 I hadn’t enough money to buy culvert and land so I temporarily constructed wood bridge until I had enough money to construct it.
Even though there were many negative impacts by the projected through the peoples’ livelihood, but the positive impacts were appeared to make a comfortable condition through the people.
I wasn’t dust along the road. Especially, I spent short time to reach the destination.
It was good selling because of the city citizens always came across this area so I could sell my product easily.
4 Appendix 24 Tape Code D3 Focus Group Discussion Chub village, Tnal Toteung commune, Tbong Khmom district, Kompong Cham province Female Group Total of Participation: 10 Date: June 26, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The focus group discussion held on June 26, 2005 at the Chub village, Tnal Toteung commune, Tbong Khmom district, Kompong Cham province. There were 10 female respondents participated in the discussion. The most of respondents complained about the compensation practice even though they received the compensation already because there were corruptions in it. The IRC’s working group didn’t provide full compensation, meanwhile, they withdrew some money from the PAPs.
2. Information about the project
The respondents didn’t get any information about the project by any officials or IRC’s working group before it carried out. They didn’t know when the project was implemented, but they knew the road was widened while the IRC’s working group had applied the measurement.
No body told me the information when the project was widened. I was wonder when I saw the official measured the affected assets along the road. I didn’t get any information about the project even though I had the affected assets.
3. Public information, Consultation and Participation
People didn’t receive the information before the project implemented, but there were two meetings held after the IRC’s working group conducted the DMS. Some of the respondents participated in the meeting and the others weren’t. Through the meeting the IRC’s working group didn’t consult people in public to complain when they didn’t satisfy their need, but they told only few PAPs during DMS. Therefore, people were afraid to complain the compensation practice.
Through the meeting, the IRC’s working group didn’t encourage us to file against them when we weren’t satisfied with compensation or valuation.
The IRC’s suggested me to complain when I was disagreed with compensation.
4. Affected assets and Valuation
Most of the affected assets in this area were the balconies because it built at the same sizes fixed one to others and some other affected assets were houses, business stores. The people had been gave the fingerprint into list already, but they didn’t get the compensation yet. Therefore, they complained about the
1 Appendix 24 compensation practices because it was only on the valuation list, but not for the compensation practice.
My house was located closely to the road so it was completely affected by the project. It made of the wooden wall, wooden floor about 6 m width and 12 m long; therefore, IRC’s working group assigned my house in the 2nd type. I couldn’t valuate it by myself because I didn’t know the market prices so they valuated it instead of me about $700 into their list. I agreed it then I gave the fingerprint, but I didn’t get the compensation up to now.
I affected the balcony about the 4m width and 9 m long by the project. The IRC’s working group told me to provide the fingerprint on the unknown list, but I still gave it because they told me that it was for the valuation to my affected assets for getting the compensation. So I agreed it, but I still didn’t get it until now.
My balcony about 5m was affected while measured the 12m from the middle line of the road. They IRC’s working group valuated $154 per whole affected assets by telling that it was the reasonable prices.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
The people seem didn’t understand clearly the resettlement policy. Through the focus group discussion the only one respondent knew the prices or resettlement policies and the others weren’t. The IRC’s working group had suggested them to complain when they didn’t satisfy through the compensation.
The IRC’s working group had set the value $12 per square meter to my affected assets, so the total prices were $700.
The IRC’s working group told me to file against them if I didn’t satisfy to the valuation and compensation.
6. Grievance redress
The people had received the information and aware of the entitlement already, but they weren’t able to complain IRC’s working group. Firstly, they didn’t know the way the file them. Secondly, they were afraid the IRC’s working group and lastly it was slightly affected so it was necessary to lodge them.
It was slightly affected to my property, so I didn’t need to complain about it.
No one complained about the compensation, so I myself wasn’t able to file against the IRC’s working group.
7. Level of satisfaction
The people were much pleasured while the government constructed newly road for transportation. They congratulated for the achievement, meanwhile, they weren’t satisfy about the compensation practice.
2 Appendix 24 I was very happy when the government constructed the road because it didn’t appear a dust in front of my house.
It was easy to transport because it spent short time to reach the destination.
But there were many mistakes appeared through the compensation practice because it might be a corruption in its. The list had assigned the mane of people who get the compensation, but they didn’t get the compensation at all.
I wasn’t satisfy with the compensation at all, if I did not accept I will receive nothing.
I saw the list writing that I was received $3020 for compensation to my affected assets. But it wasn’t true because I received nothing.
The prices $12 per square mater it wasn’t suitable compared to the market prices at that time because I couldn’t build the same construction with this prices.
I had received the compensation, but it wasn’t the full compensation because the IRC’s working group withdrew some money.
8. Impacts
There were many affected to the people’s livelihood because they spent much money to buy culvert and land to fill into the canal along the road. Therefore, they must to spent money on other things beside food. It seems that the project forced them to misuse the money on the right thing.
The IRC’s working group dug the canal in front of my house, it was ugly through my house. Moreover, they forced me to buy culvert and land to fill in the canal. I need to spend on food first and the others later.
I spent money to buy culvert and hire the mason to construct the culvert system. It spent $600 so I must to borrow it from money lender.
While it had the heavy rain, the water flows into my house. Sometime I spent much time to take it off. Once, there were heavy flood in my house so I need to use water machine to take it off. It was very difficult in the rainy reason.
3 Appendix 24 Tape Code B4 Focus Group Discussion Kompong Preang Commune: Male Group
Total of Participation: 10 Date: August 06, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sereivouth
1. Introduction
The focus group discussion held on August 06, 2005 at a small house of villager located in Ous Touk village, Kompong Preang commune, Sangke district, Battambong province. There were 10 male head of household participated in this discussion. The people didn’t get any official information related to the project activities. Therefore, they didn’t understand the resettlement policies and entitlements as well.
2. Information about the project
The people surprised when the project implemented and started to demolish the affected assets along the road. There weren’t any meeting was held to inform the project activities, resettlement policies and compensation. Beside this, they knew the information about the project by all accounts through the village, but some of the respondents in the group were inform by IRC’s working group when they measured their affected assets.
No body told me about the project implementation and any information about the project at all, but I knew from by all account in my village. I knew nothing about the removing the affected assets along the road. I removed my grocery store without understand the information at all.
After I heard the information from my neighbor, the IRC’s working group told me the information while they measured my affected assets.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
There weren’t any public information held to inform the people. Therefore, the people were misunderstood about the project activities and knew nothing about the project. Beside this, they didn’t provide any consultation to the people about the resettlement policies.
I lost my mango tree, but I didn’t know the compensation policy or consultation from the IRC’s working group. So I got nothing to my affected assets now.
No body consulted me while I called for help through my affected assets. Meanwhile, IRC’s working group forced me to remove the affected assets away the project location
1 Appendix 24
4. Affected assets and valuation
The affected assets in this area were mostly grocery stores and houses, wells and trees. Most of the respondents said that the IRC’s working group didn’t measure the affected assets before they started to demolish it and even made any official letter to the people, but the others had.
I lost completely my grocery store about 4 m width and 6 m long made of zinc1 roof, zinc mixed wooden wall and concrete floor. I didn’t receive any official letter from the IRC’s working group for measurement my store, I had never provided the fingerprint on any letter too.
I lost my grocery store about 4m width and 6m long made of zinc roof, zinc mixed wooden wall and cement floor. The IRC’s working group didn’t tell or measured my assets at all, so I was afraid when they started demolish the affected assets along the road.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
People seem didn’t aware at all of the resettlement policies and the entitlement because they had never complained to the IRC’s even though their affected assets were completely demolished by the project.
I didn’t know at all about compensation. If I knew I would be let the IRC’s working group to pay back for my property.
I lost many mango trees, but I didn’t know the compensation and entitlement at all. Therefore, I didn’t get the compensation.
6. Grievance redress
The most of respondents didn’t accuse against the IRC’s working group at all. These reasons were coming up when the respondents didn’t clear or understand the resettlement policies and entitlement.
I completely lost my property, I didn’t file against the IRC’s at all. I thought it was impossible.
7. Level of satisfaction
The IRC’s working group was careless about the compensation practice. They seem didn’t have the good plan to provide it, therefore some of the people get and the others received nothing through the compensation. The people who got the compensation felt happy and support the resettlement policy while the others complained about it.
I lost my grocery store about 7m long and 5m width, but I got the compensation already. I satisfied the compensation because it located on the corridor of impact. It was suitable to get the compensation and remove it.
1 Corrugated color-coated or galvanized steel sheet 2 Appendix 24
Some of the people didn’t satisfy to the compensation practice because it wasn’t enough compensation compared to the affected assets and the others didn’t get the compensation at all.
My business store demolished through the project implementation. It made of zinc roof, wooden wall and wooden floor about 5 m width and 6 m long. The IRC’s working group pledged to give the compensation for the affected asset, but I still didn’t get the compensation up to now. As a result, I decided to rebuild the new store on the same location after project completed.
8. Impacts
The project had been implemented and slightly affected to the resident livelihood. It was affected to family condition because people had been spent money to fill the land to the ground floor of their house. Therefore, they spent much money to the other practice beside food.
It was difficult during the rainy season because the water flew to my house. So I spent much money to fill the land into the ground floor perhaps 925,000 riel.
It was easy to transport both go and back.
3 Appendix 24 Tape Code B3 Focus Group Discussion Rusei Krang Commune: Female Group
Total of Participation: 15 Date: August 06, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sereivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was held in the Tnal Bot village, Russei Krang commune, Mong Russei district, Battam Bong province on August 06, 2005. Only 15 female participants were participated in the meeting, they might be ignorable while the information about the project was release by the government officials. Moreover, they didn’t remember the valuation on the affected assets when we asked them for the valuation of the IRC’s working group to the assets.
2. Information about the project
The majority of the respondents didn’t get the information clearly related to the project activities. One of them knew the information from the IRC’s working group told her while they conducted interviewing at her home and the others know from policeman and by all account in the village.
The IRC’s working group interviewed me and asked me to choose the land or the money for the compensation. Then I choose the land because I had no land to live, she applied.
They told me about the compensation policy, but I forgot it now.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
There weren’t the public meeting was held to release information about the project activities. Some of respondents knew the information from the policeman telling them at home and the others form all account.
The policeman told me to remove my house because the government planned to widen the road, but he didn’t set the deadline yet. When I had removed the affected assets I will get the compensation, he confirmed.
I heard from other people for removing the affected assets, they told me to remove it and will get the satisfy compensation.
The IRC’s working group didn’t set the deadline to the resident for removing their property at all. They only forced us to remove. When they started to demolish the assets along the road made me and people fear of them and tried to demolish it by myself.
So far, I had never joined the meeting discussing the compensation or consultation with the IRC’s working group at all.
1 Appendix 24 4. Affected assets and valuation
The project had implemented, but it was affected to the residents’ livelihood along the project location. Most of the residents claimed about the project implementation, compensation practice. The affected assets mostly in this area were business store, houses and gate. Some of the respondents loosed their house completely, so they have no land to settle and the others loosed some part of its. Moreover, they didn’t get the compensation at all even though they had complained to the IRC’s working group.
I loosed my business store and even house about 6m long and 4m Width. It made of zinc roof and wooden wall, but I didn’t get the compensation yet.
I had loosed my business store made of the zinc roof and wooden wall about 5m long and 3m Width, but I didn’t get the compensation too.
My house was completely affected because it located closely to the road. The IRC’s working group need me to remove it, I agreed and complained for the compensation. They agreed me, but I didn’t get the compensation and waited for it from that time.
I had the small land to locate, when they forced me to remove I leaf too small land to relocate and lived on the ugly water now. Moreover, I wasn’t get the compensation for my removing.
The IRC’s working group had valuated the affected assets for checking the consistency of the compensation policy. Most of the affected assets were valuated, but the respondent was forgot it.
The IRC’s working group told me to sign on the valuation letter after they had valuated my house and suggested me to wait for the compensation. They had told me the valuation for my house, but now I was forgotten it because the IRC’s didn’t give the valuation letter to me at all.
They [IRC officials] valuated my house about $3,000; I didn’t get the compensation yet. I thought that it was the on the paper but not for the practice.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Most of the respondents didn’t know clearly about the compensation policy and entitlement because there weren’t public meeting was held. As a result, they weren’t able to complain with the IRC’s working group. So the affected people had no other choices rather than accepted what was given.
I was afraid for lodge the IRC’s working group because they didn’t tell me the way to complain them.
2 Appendix 24 6. Grievance redress
The people weren’t able to file the grievance redress fighting against the IRC’s working group. Moreover, the former had the low education and didn’t know the way to lodge latter.
I thought it was impossible to lodge the IRC’s working group. I had no power, so how could I fight against them.
7. Level of satisfaction
The most of respondents didn’t satisfy to the compensation policy and compensation practice. They claimed about the compensation payment were not faithful to affected people compared to others in different village. The compensation was not on time and many people waited for the compensation up to now, but they didn’t get the compensation yet.
I lost land and even my house, so I needed to borrow money from the money lender for buying land and new house. I thought, if the compensation came on time I didn’t borrow the money with the high rate of interest.
8. Impact
Many impacts to the people’s livelihood were appeared during the project implementation. The family income was the main impact to the respondent’s living condition because some of them was lose there income during the project was implemented.
I had lost my store and even my business. As a result, I had nothing to earn money for my family. Moreover, I failed to do my business from that time. I was worry about my future, she added.
Before the project implemented, I could earn 10,000 riel per day. But when the IRC’s working group demolished my business store, I lost the income for feeding my family.
It was very trouble while having the canal in front of my house. Some of children were fall down and the others drowned in the water through the canal.
When IRC’s working group was demolished my house, I had no place to settle. So I must to lend some money from money lender. No one can help me in that circumstance, she complained.
There were many accidences during the project was completed.
I must to spend some money buy a land to fill in the canal and ground floor of my house for equality to the road level.
While my house was demolished so I hadn’t land to settle. Then I lend 3,600,000 Riel from money lender to rebuild new house. Until now I could not
3 Appendix 24 afford to pay back yet. Beside this, I must to pay the interest 540,000 Riel per month to money lender.
If my house didn’t demolish, so I can buy anything like motorbike and more. But it just the dream because I needed to build house first after demolished. Therefore, I had nothing now.
4 Appendix 24
Tap Code B5 FGD in Kampong Chen Tbong commune: Female Group NR 6 Total Participants = 13 Date: August 7, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was conducted on August 7, 2005 in a house of PAP located in Kampong Chen Tbong commune, Kampong Thom Province. There were 13 female participants from Kampong Chen Tbong commune where most of people were affected to their house and business store. Most of their affected assets were ready valuated by the IRC’s working group but did not receive the payment yet.
2. Information about the project
It appears that people had information about the project or any policy related to the project. However, most of them among group told that there were calls for meeting. The meeting was conducted by the provincial officers that the road would be widened.
I and my neighbors were attended in a meeting once conducted by the provincial officers that the road would be widened.
During the meting was conducted, the provincial officer said that “The government needs to widen the road, all people who live along the road land need to remove from the road size”.
Provincial officer assigned each of village chief of this commune to call all of people along the road side to come for meeting.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
Most of people said they received fully public information, consultation and they also joined with those activities.
We were told that if we have any affected assets or trees on the road land the government will be compensated.
One day after the meeting was conducted, the IRC’s working group come and did their measurement work all the houses along the road side.
I received fully consulting from the government related to the project during the meeting and I knew clearly about the policy by the leaflet provided by the working group.
Appendix 24
4. Affected assets and valuation
Most people in this group had their partly affected assets by the project. The affected assets were includes grocery shops, houses, pump well and some trees. Few among them complained of the valuation were not equal to the current market. The valuation to the affected assets was not yet pays because the government has not enough money to be paid.
A part of my houses was affected by the project but instead of removing it I didn’t receive any compensation as they were valuated.
There were 24m2 in total of a part of my houses were affected by the project; I knew they valuated me with $12 per square meter but I didn’t receive it yet.
A part of my grocery store was valuated by the IRC’s working group but I get nothing after I was removed.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Resulting from the public meeting was held publicly to the people; most of them among group have awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement.
I agree with the valuation but if they have not give me the payment I would not remove my store.
My pump well is affected by the project; I and my neighbors use it everyday if they don’t pay me I still use it.
I have three big coconut trees that I always benefits from it every year, but they have not pay me even 100 Reil after I was removed not like they told me in the public meeting.
6. Grievance redress
Because most of people among group were knew clearly about the project policy and entitlement they were also complained too much to the working group related to the valuation rate. But, what they were got still unacceptable and unfair.
They valuate a part of my house only $1200, this is not equal to the rate that I was build. I complained too much and made an argument with the working group but I get nothing.
I was complained to the commune officer to resolve my affected assets but they said the government not yet has money to be paid.
Appendix 24
If I know that affected assets will be not compensated, I would not give the fingerprint to remove.
I also complained to the survey team to increase the value of my affected assets, but I don’t know the ways how to get success because the government has no money.
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction among the group was low. Most of them complained why the project not pay them what they was valuated.
They just give me a piece of valuation paper but I have not received the money yet even my store already moved.
I would be received $80 per square meter of my affected house as they valuated to me, but they didn’t pay me even 100 Riel.
Some people haven’t removed yet as they are not sure whether they can get compensation so they have to live on.
The compensation would be equal to the current market price, if not I will be not move my store.
8. Impacts
The project seems to cause not too much to the residents even they haven’t received any compensation yet. However, most of people in this group were affected to their business and the income earning in the period and after the road construction. Few among them were lost their grocery business store and shifted to other job. Moreover, because of people there have not moved yet from the road side so their living house are seems very close to the road side. It meant that they are in high risk situation of traffic accidents.
I hope the working group will be paid to me, I spent my own money to remove apart of my grocery store, up to now I have no money to rebuild it because my business seems too low than before.
My houses is very close to the road side, my children always run and play along it, I really worry about their security.
Because of the road was widened, taxi and travelers were not stop to buy anything in my store, so I need to stop my business and try to expense my cultivating work in the farm.
During the road construction, I and my children frequently ills because of the environmental pollution from the constructing work.
Even the project was not paying me the compensation, I still benefits from the road, I can access quickly to the market and especially to Phnom Penh. Appendix 24
Tap Code B6 FGD in Chamnar Kream commune: Male Group NR 6 Total Participants = 10 Date: August 7, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The FGD was conducted on August 7, 2005 in a small house of PAP located in Spean Krong village, Chamnar Kream commune, Kampong Thom Province. There were 10 male participants from Chamnar Kream commune where the PAPs not yet received any compensation.
2. Information about the project
It surprises that people had no information about the project or any policy related to the project. However, few among group claimed that there were no calls for meeting. The information was only spreading by the village chief and commune police officers.
There were no calls for meeting. We had some information from village chief and commune police officer about the project that the road would be widened and any assets along the road side need to remove without saying any compensation to the assets.
Village chief was told me that the road would be widened and asked me to register in to the list of PAPs and my house would be removed to 25 meters from the middle of the road. No one call me for meeting.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
It appears that people didn’t receive adequate public information or didn’t receive at all. Consultation was almost none, just only informal talk heard from the village chief and commune police officers. Before the project started, there was hardly any participation in discussion by the people in the community. IRC’s working group didn’t hold any consultation with the residents and explained to them about compensation policies, but just did their work and urging the people to move the house.
We were told that if we have any affected assets or trees on road land we had to remove or cut them off.
They come into my house and told me to cut the trees off; if not I will be paid the power diesel instead they cut it off.
My house was immediately asked to remove after I came from my home land at Kampongcham province.
Appendix 24
4. Affected assets and valuation
Most people in this group had their assets affected by the project. But their asset was not badly affected because most of it was reusable after removing includes some small grocery shops, houses and some trees. Few people said that they have some land left for resettlement, other complained of having too little land remain for resettlement. Most of them complained that despite having removed their assets, they haven’t received any compensation. There was no valuation to the assets affected by the project during resettlement, excepted two PAPs in the village which was not yet removed.
My house was affected. They asked me to retreat 25 meters from the middle of the road, but I was moved only half because my land left only 2 meters, it is so little for resettlement.
My house was urgent removed after commune police officers told, before the project start, then the working group comes and did their measurement work without paying any compensate.
I and my neighbors tried to help each other to move the house to the back and spent our own money for rebuilding the house.
My grocery store was told to remove by commune police officers, and then I was moved but I didn’t know any measurement and valuation policy from the working group.
After I and my neighbors resettled to the back, two villagers who were not complied the commune police officer was received some money as the part of compensation from the IRC’s working group.
IRC’s working group told me that my house and two hug trees were moved before the measurement work so I haven’t get any compensation.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Awareness of resettlement policy was apparently none. This clearly appears to be the result of absence of public information or consultation. People seemed to have no other choice than removing the house by them self.
Commune police officers assigned me to give fingerprint to the affected assets and need to resettle, if not I would be responsible when the project start.
When I heard the road would be widened, I have no choice rather than tried to find helping from my neighbor.
During measurement work conducted by a working group like provincial officers were told me if I removed already I have no any compensation from the government.
Appendix 24
I have no money for resettlement, but I must try to do it because I fear of government will be forced me to pay for removing my house.
At first I would be not removed, later on most of people in the village were moved their house so I need to move too.
6. Grievance redress
Resulting from no call for the public meeting and unclear about the information of the project, all of the respondents in this group so far doesn’t know the grievance policy.
After I resettled my house and grocery store, a man with gun and mobile phone told me that if people not agree what the government do we can complaint to the authority or working group. But I don’t know how to complaint because my affected assets already removed.
I was gave fingerprint complied with the commune authority even I don’t want to remove.
If I know that affected assets will be compensated, I would not give the fingerprint to remove. Why the people who not give fingerprint and not yet moved receive compensation from the government?
I also complained to the working group but I don’t know the ways how to get success because my house was moved ready. I don’t know how to deal with this!
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction among the group was low. Most of them complained why the project was not told them the true and would be paid some money for resettlement. All of them was spent their money in removing the affected assets, they sometime spent 3 to 4 day for cutting down the trees. However, few among them were satisfied with the project even they haven’t get any compensation because they want the government would be widened the road.
I respect the law acquired by the authority so I must to remove from the road land, but the government should pay me some money to relocate because I spent too much money including my daily time.
I spent 180,000 Riel to buy land 40 tractors to fulfill my back canal in order to rebuild my house; this amount not yet included any expenses for the constructors and construction materials.
The resettlement work was run so quickly like forcing from the government; they need my house to remove for three days after they told. If not they will be moved by tractors and I would be paid to them for this moving action.
Appendix 24
Government should be fair, If have no compensation policies it would be no one receive the compensation.
8. Impacts
The project seems to cause not too much to the residents even they haven’t received any information too much related to the project and resettlement policy. However, most of people in this group were affected to their business and the income earning in the period of road construction. Few among them were benefited from the project.
My sister who is living with two young children was lost her small grocery store and now she is selling her labor force at the Kompong Cham province. Before she got the profit 5,000 Reil per day, but during the construction work she got nothing so she decided to go to her hometown.
My son’s finger was oppressed by the main column when I was moving my house to the back. Now he is become a handicap person.
When I was moving my house, I have no time enough to find food for my children because I fears of the working group will be moved my house badly and asked me to pay the money to them.
Even the project was not paying me the compensation, I still benefits from the road, I can access quickly to the market than before. After the road was constructed I spent only 1 hour and half to Kompongthom provincial, but before I spent 3 hours.
Now I can run my new grocery store better than before and our health is also good because of the road is much cleaned.
Appendix 24
Tape Code 28 FGD in Kratie Commune: Female Group
Total Participants: 10 Date: August 14, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The Focus Group Discussion (FGD) was held on August14, 2005 in the house of village chief located in Trapangprang village. There were 10 females participants from Kratie commune, Kratie province where the road not yet built. But most of PAPs were received the compensation.
2. Information about the project
There were called for a meeting once in this commune conducted by the communal and provincial officer at the commune office. Prime Minister Hun Sen at the time of schooling inaugurate in this community, he also claimed that the road will be widened soon.
The village chief was invited to all PAPs who affected their assets by the road land to joint a meeting conducted by commune official; then leaflet was given by commune officer to the participants in meeting.
Even I was too busy at that time, my husband also attended the meeting conducted by the communal officer related to widening road project.
In the meeting they was told me that the RGC need to widened the road. People who live along the road side need to retreat 15 meters from the middle of the road. And than, they provided people a list of information [leaflet] for each.
I was sent my daughter to joint the meeting, when she came back she told me that the government needs to widen the road.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
Most of them seems known clearly that the road would be widened. Some of them said they received the consultation related to the project from the working group during the measurement. Few of them complained of no consulting work conducted and they knew only the road widening. It means that consultation work was not fully conducted to all PAPs.
What we knew was that government widened this road and announced to the house owner to retreat 15 meters from the middle of road without getting any consultation related to the project.
After the meeting was conducted not too long, there were a working group [IRC] come to measure my house and explained me the policy in detail Appendix 24
related project implementation and the compensation. They [IRC] told me the size of impact and the way they calculate it, but I can’t remember.
4. Affected assets and valuation
Most of people among group were partly affected to the houses, business stores, trees, and especially the house’s bridges. The valuation was fully conducted to all affected assets and most of PAPs also received the compensation according to the valuated assets.
The IRC’s working group told me that my concrete bridge will be paid by $12 per square meter and other two mango trees would not paid. And then they asked me to agree with $170 of the total value of affected size.
Part of my house was affected and it also affected to the bridge, IRC’s working group valuated me the house only, they said my bridge was too old.
My wooden bridge was affected and they valuated to me $4 per square meter so I got $250 of total amount of affected size.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement was not too low, but it still limit. Resulting of having meeting and consultation conducted in this community, people among this group discussion seem more understanding related to the project implementation and especially resettlement policy and their entitlement.
During the meeting was conducted, they told me that if the valuation to assets is not adequate or not appropriate to the current market price, people have the right to complaint or refusal.
Even they told me of complaining right to the project; I still unfaith of working group because I heard that “Kratie is a lucky province that has the compensation to the affected assets but other have nothing”, member of working group said.
6. Grievance address
Because of the road not yet build in this community and people not badly affected by the project, there were not too much of argument with the IRC officials. Arguments were made as the informal talk during the IRC’s working group conducted the measurement.
Appendix 24
During the IRC’s working group measuring my house I made lot of argument in order to get higher compensate. Afterward, I got more compensation than before.
I don’t want to make an argument or complaint to the RGC because they also paid me the compensation to the part of my affected size. The first I want them to build me the road as soon as possible.
We are the people, what we need is living in peace and justice. If RGC give us the justice, we would not complain.
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction among discussion group was not too low whether few complained of compensation inadequate to the current market rate, but it still acceptable to them. On the other hand, respondents were hopeless with the working group why they don’t construct the road.
My wooden bridge in front of my house was affected by project. Instead of removing it I received $73 in total for the affected size. This value is adequate to the current market price comparing to the assets.
Project was partly affected to my tile roof house, IRC’s working group paid me only $200 instead of removing. In fact, I would get $700 if compare to the current market price. Even thought, this value is still acceptable if they build me the new road.
It’s hard to buy the wood in rebuilding the bridge, they paid me only $120. In fact, I spent $500 when I was built it for the last three year.
8. Impacts
The project it self seem disturbed to people’s living condition related to their daily activities since it started and up to now because the project does not functioning. It means that people don’t know whenever they [RGC] build the road. Most of their business store was closed because of removing activities especially grocery stores, motor-washing outlets and drug stores. So it can cause to their daily income earning. Few of them complained of had an incident of falling down in to the water of their family members including children and any material using in the house especially motorbike because the bridge was removed.
Before the project started, I was benefited 12000 Riel per day. After I was removed it my business also closed. Up to now I borrowed money from my relative to buy the new store at the market in the high rate to continue it.
My husband and children were also failing-down to the water in often, so I decided to rebuild my bridge even they not yet build the road. Appendix 24
I was a motor-cleaning at my house because it affected to the project I removed it by getting $200 instead of removing. Afterward I have changed my business to be a CD/VCD seller in the market with a small rental store.
My income is lower than before because I lost my grocery store which was built on the bridge. Because of the road not yet build I don’t know whether to continue or stop doing my business.
Appendix 24
Tape Code 27 FGD in Kratie Commune: Male Group
Total Participants: 10 Date: August 14, 2005 Moderator: Tem Sareivouth
1. Introduction
The Focus Group Discussion (FGD) was held on August14, 2005 in the house of village chief located in Trapangprang village. There were 10 male participants from Kratie commune, Kratie province where the road not yet built. But most of PAPs were received the compensation.
2. Information about the project
It appears that people were called for meeting related to the project implementation. However, majority of household head was joined meeting at commune hall conducted by provincial and communal officials. Prime Minister Hun Sen at the time of schooling inaugurate in this community, he also claimed that the road will be widened soon.
We were called to join a meeting conducted by commune authority related to the road widening and removing of residence that affected by road land.
“The RGC need to widen the road soon, so people who live along the road land need to retreat 15 meters from the middle of the road and affected asset would be compensate” said Hun Sen.
During the meeting was conducted, I received lot of document related to the project and they also provided me a leaflet that talked about project process and the compensation policies.
3. Public information, consultation and participation
Most people among group were received higher consultation and participated with the public information conducted by working group related to the project.
They [IRC official] told me that any assets which were affected by the road widening project would be compensated before the measurement work only. If any, after of the measurement work it would be not.
I known that the bridge was divided in three types, and the compensation will be comply by each type. And my affected bridge was divided in to type one.
Appendix 24
There was a committee [IRC official] conducting their measurement work to the affected assets along the road land. When they did this work they also explained to the assets owner.
4. Affected assets and valuation
Because of the people’s house in this community build on the water canal, and project acquire to retreat 15 meter from the middle, most of people’s house clearly affected to the bridge in front. According to this group discussion PAPs complained that the project mostly affected to the bridges and business stores.
My wooden bridge was built by the good type of wood, and it also affected by the project. IRC’s working group valuated me $4 per square meter, and I got $112 for the total of 24.5 square meters.
45 square meter of my wooden bridge were affected by the project, instead of removing it I got only $3.33 per square meter.
IRC’s working group valuated my affected bridge $4.5 per square meter. In total I got $99 for 22 square meter lost.
5. Awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement
The people among group seem to have high awareness of resettlement policy and entitlement related to the project. It’s resulting from the meeting and consultation was fully conducted to all PAPs in this community. Even though, people seem not understand clearly related to their right to make an argument or complaint with what they disagree.
I was attended two time of meeting conducted by the working group, so I clearly known how they would do with the affected assets and the whole process of the project. But I don’t know why they did not build the road. As I known, most of PAPs were received the compensation already.
If we build any assets after the measurement work was conducted, we would not received the compensation and must be removed it.
I know clearly how much compensate would I get because they showed me out in detail, during the measurement they told me the affected size and the value per square meter. And then, they asked me to give them the fingerprint in order to agree with what I lost.
They didn’t tell me related to the right of argument and complaining to the unacceptable valuation.
Appendix 24
6. Grievance address
Project officials were handled the grievance to the PAPs. Few among group said that a PAP in the village were made grievance until he got the compensation.
At the first time IRC’s working group did not valuate to his affected assets afterward he was complained until IRC officials agree for the compensation.
I complained too much to the IRC’s working group in order to get higher value to my affected bridge. As the result, I got higher value from them.
7. Level of satisfaction
Level of satisfaction among group was not too low. Most of them satisfied with the policies of the project that provided them the compensation even it were not adequate to the current market rate. Only few, complained of getting too little compensation that it not enough to rebuild their assets. Moreover, most of people suggest to the RGC to build the road as soon as possible.
I was removed my bridge after I got $76 from the working group of my compensation. This value is not adequate to my asset, but I want the new road.
The compensation of $470 as it could not be enough for us to relocate, acquire new land and building is need over the price which was paid by project official.
In fact, my bridge was spent $200 to build it, but IRC’s working group paid me only $66 instead of removing. Furthermore, I bought many tractors of soil to fulfill the water canal instead of the bridge.
I really satisfied with the valuation conducting by the working group, but the first I need is that the road would be functioned as soon as possible.
8. Impacts
The project it self seem disturbed to people’s living condition related to their daily activities since it started and up to now because the project does not functioning. It means that people don’t know whenever they [RGC] build the road. Most of their business store was closed because of removing activities especially grocery stores, motor-washing outlets and drug stores. So it can cause to their daily income earning. Few of them complained of had an incident of falling down in to the water of their family members including children and any material using in the house especially motorbike because the bridge was removed.
Appendix 24
Before the project started, I was benefited 10,000 Riel per day. After I was removed it my business also closed. Up to now I have no business to do.
I and my children were also failing-down to the water in often, so I decided to rebuild my bridge even they not yet build the road.
Because of the project removed my bridge my uncle was failing-down to the water and her head was also break. If the road builds, I think this problem would not happen to us.
My income is lower than before because I lost my grocery store which was built on the bridge. Because of the road not yet build I don’t know whether to continue or stop doing my business.