DOCSLIB.ORG

Operational Risk Assessment of Public Financial Management Reform in Nepal: a Review of Challenges and Opportunities

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Operational Risk Assessment of Public Financial Management Reform in Nepal: a Review of Challenges and Opportunities Operational risk assessment of public financial management reform in Nepal: a review of challenges and opportunities Philipp Krause, Stephanie Sweet, Edward Hedger, and Bhola Chalise August 2013 1 Contents List of figures, boxes, and tables................................................................................................................... 4 Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................................... 5 Acronyms and abbreviations ......................................................................................................................... 6 Executive summary ....................................................................................................................................... 9 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................. 14 1.1 Objectives ...................................................................................................................................... 14 1.2 Approach and methods .................................................................................................................. 15 2. The environment of public finances ........................................................................................................ 18 2.1 Economic context .......................................................................................................................... 18 2.2 Donor engagement in PFM............................................................................................................ 20 2.3 Political context ............................................................................................................................. 22 3. Institutional arrangements for PFM ........................................................................................................ 28 3.1 Central ministries ........................................................................................................................... 28 3.2 Spending ministries ....................................................................................................................... 31 3.3 Local government bodies............................................................................................................... 35 3.4 External control and oversight bodies ........................................................................................... 37 4. Policy framework and development planning ........................................................................................ 40 4.1 National development planning frameworks ................................................................................. 40 4.2 Local planning and budget preparation ......................................................................................... 40 4.3 Sector planning: health and roads .................................................................................................. 41 5. Budget formulation ................................................................................................................................. 44 5.1 Forecasting and planning ............................................................................................................... 44 5.2 Budget preparation process ........................................................................................................... 46 6. Budget execution .................................................................................................................................... 49 6.1 Institutions and processes .............................................................................................................. 49 6.2 Sectoral and local budget execution: roads and health .................................................................. 54 7. Accounting, reporting, and audit............................................................................................................. 56 7.1 In-year budget monitoring and reporting ....................................................................................... 56 7.2 Annual reporting and financial statements .................................................................................... 57 7.3 Internal control and audit ............................................................................................................... 57 7.4 External audit ................................................................................................................................. 58 7.5 Parliamentary scrutiny and audit follow-up .................................................................................. 59 8. Diagnosis: interpreting the evidence ....................................................................................................... 60 8.1 Strengths and challenges ............................................................................................................... 60 8.2 Problem analysis ............................................................................................................................ 64 9. The way forward ..................................................................................................................................... 69 9.1 Entry points ................................................................................................................................... 71 9.2 PFM reform and implications for service delivery ....................................................................... 78 9.3 Options for external engagement and joint monitoring of progress ............................................. 80 Appendix A: Mapping of donor support to national and local PFM reforms ............................................. 84 Appendix B: List of people interviewed ..................................................................................................... 88 Appendix C: Summary matrix of challenges, entry points, and recommendations .................................... 91 Notes ........................................................................................................................................................... 92 References…………………………………………………………………………………………………91 2 3 List of figures, boxes, and tables Figure 1: GDP and inflation in Nepal, 2006/07 to 2012/13 ........................................................................ 18 Figure 2: Public debt and deficits, 2006/07 to 2012/13 (percentage of GDP) ............................................ 19 Figure 3: Revenue and expenditures, 2006/07 to 2012/13 (percentage of GDP) ....................................... 19 Figure 4: Expenditure composition, 2007/08 to 2011/12 (percentage of total expenditures and GDP) ..... 20 Figure 5: Nepal district spending per capita (NRs) ..................................................................................... 23 Figure 6: Nepal’s accountability and budget cycle ..................................................................................... 25 Figure 7: Professionalism and impartiality of the bureaucracy in Nepal .................................................... 27 Figure 8: Line management structure of the MoHP in Nepal ..................................................................... 33 Figure 9: Management structure of the government roads sector in Nepal ................................................ 35 Figure 10: Central to local level organogram ............................................................................................. 37 Figure 11: Comparison of Nepal with a “typical” budget calendar ............................................................ 48 Figure 12: Timing of capital expenditures for different government ministries, 2009 to 2012 .................. 51 Figure 13: Variance in budgeted and actual expenditure, 2007/08 to 2011/12........................................... 52 Figure 14: Fishbone diagram of public spending problems ........................................................................ 65 Box 1: PFM assessments 2002 to 2012 ...................................................................................................... 21 Box 2: The 14-step planning process .......................................................................................................... 41 Box 3: Treasury Single Account introduction ............................................................................................ 50 Box 4: PFM reform trends in post-conflict countries ................................................................................. 63 Box 5: Potential PFM improvement monitoring indicators ........................................................................ 82 Table 1: Conditions for strong budget authority in Nepal .......................................................................... 26 Table 2: List of ministers of finance, 2003 to 2013 .................................................................................... 29 Table 3: MTEF vs. Red Book budget ceilings (for selected ministries) ..................................................... 45 Table 4: Budget calendar in Nepal .............................................................................................................. 46 Table 5: Budget approval dates ..................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Download Download
    Journal of International Affairs Vol. 3, 1-41, 2020 Doi: https://doi.org/10.3126/joia.v3i1.29077 Department of International Relations and Diplomacy Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, Nepal North-Western Boundary of Nepal Dwarika Dhungel Jagat Bhusal Narendra Khanal Abstract Following the publication of new political maps by India on 2nd and 8th November 2019, the issues related to the source of Mahakali River and Indian occupation of the Nepali territory east of the river, have, once again, come to the surface. And, the Nepali civil society has come out strongly against the newly published political maps of India, prepared a new map of Nepal, showing the whole of the territory east of Mahakali River (about 400 sq. km) as Nepalese land on the basis of Treaty of Sugauli signed in 1816 by East India Company of Great Britain and Raja of Nepal. An analysis of the maps, so far available, shows that changes have been made in the names of the river and places, and there is cartographic aggression and manipulation by India in relation to Mahakali River and its boundary with Nepal’s northwest. It has also been found that Nepal has published a map in the past showing its international boundary without any basis of the treaties and other historical documents. Analysis clearly shows that the river originating from Limpiyadhura is the Mahakali (called Kalee/Kali River) as per Article 5 of the Sugauli treaty and it forms the international boundary between the two countries. Keywords: Anglo-Nepal War, Sugauli Treaty, Cartographic Aggression, Nepal-India Territorial Disputes 1 Dwarika Dhungel, Jagat Bhusal & Narendra Khanal/North-Western … Vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Federalism Is Debated in Nepal More As an ‘Ism’ Than a System
    The FEDERALISM Debate in Nepal Post Peace Agreement Constitution Making in Nepal Volume II Post Peace Agreement Constitution Making in Nepal Volume II The FEDERALISM Debate in Nepal Edited by Budhi Karki Rohan Edrisinha Published by United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Support to Participatory Constitution Building in Nepal (SPCBN) 2014 United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Support to Participatory Constitution Building in Nepal (SPCBN) UNDP is the UN’s global development network, advocating for change and connecting countries to knowledge, experience and resources to help people build a better life. United Nations Development Programme UN House, Pulchowk, GPO Box: 107 Kathmandu, Nepal Phone: +977 1 5523200 Fax: +977 1 5523991, 5523986 ISBN : 978 9937 8942 1 0 © UNDP, Nepal 2014 Book Cover: The painting on the cover page art is taken from ‘A Federal Life’, a joint publication of UNDP/ SPCBN and Kathmandu University, School of Art. The publication was the culmination of an initiative in which 22 artists came together for a workshop on the concept of and debate on federalism in Nepal and then were invited to depict their perspective on the subject through art. The painting on the cover art titled ‘’Emblem” is created by Supriya Manandhar. DISCLAIMER: The views expressed in the book are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of UNDP/ SPCBN. PREFACE A new Constitution for a new Nepal drafted and adopted by an elected and inclusive Constituent Assembly (CA) is a key element of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) of November 2006 that ended a decade long Maoist insurgency.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Outcome Report 2019: Democracy in Action
    INTERNATIONAL IDEA Supporting democracy worldwide DEMOCRACY IN ACTION Annual Outcome Report 2019 www.idea.int @Int_IDEA InternationalIDEA DEMOCRACY IN ACTION Annual Outcome Report 2019 Graphic design: Vision Communication ISBN: 978-91-7671-304-4 DOI: https://doi.org/10.31752/idea.2020.12 International IDEA SE–103 34 Stockholm © 2020 International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance SWEDEN +46 8 698 37 00 International IDEA publications are independent of specific national or political [email protected] interests. Views expressed in this publication do not necessarily represent the www.idea.int views of International IDEA, its Board or its Council of Member States. 2 Annual Outcome Report 2019 International IDEA 3 Annual Outcome Report 2019 Contents Reclaiming democracy’s promise................................................................................................................1 Mentoring elected local officials in Nepal .........................................................................................42 Letter from the Secretary-General .....................................................................................................1 International IDEA looks to regional governance in Bolivia to bolster development .............................44 Introduction .....................................................................................................................................2 Training for increased women's political participation in Myanmar ...................................................46
    [Show full text]
  • Year Book of Senior Citizens Nepal, 2012 Page 1 of 23
    Message from the Chair Mr. Bharat Mohan Adhikari I am pleased that finally we took this first step of bringing out a Year Book of Senior Citizens. However small step this may be, but I am happy that initiation has been taken to fill the ever existing data gap on senior citizens of Nepal, which has been the major bottle neck for starting the evidence based planning process. Numbers presented in this book are important not for their accuracy of counting of events or incidents, but as indicators of the trend and major issues of senior citizens in Nepal as represented by the media and police reports. We look forward to receiving comments and suggestions by users of this book so that we could serve better with disintegrated time series data on senior citizens of Nepal. We look forward to your kind cooperation and support to improve on this first step we took. Sincerely Bharat Mohan Adhikari Chair, Manmohan Memorial Foundation Sanepa, Lalitpur, Nepal. Year Book of Senior Citizens Nepal, 2012 Page 1 of 23 About this Year Book Many countries have come up with new policies and programmes in their efforts to comply with Madrid International Plan of Action (MIPAA) since 2002. However, most of the outcomes of their sincere efforts have been arbitrary in nature as they were prepared in absence of a strong national data base. This is also true for Nepal. This "Year Book" is the first step jointly taken by Manmohan Memorial Foundation and Ageing Nepal to fill this ever existing data gap at the national level.
    [Show full text]
  • Leaving No One Behind in the Health Sector an SDG Stocktake in Kenya and Nepal
    Report Leaving no one behind in the health sector An SDG stocktake in Kenya and Nepal December 2016 Overseas Development Institute 203 Blackfriars Road London SE1 8NJ Tel. +44 (0) 20 7922 0300 Fax. +44 (0) 20 7922 0399 E-mail: [email protected] www.odi.org www.odi.org/facebook www.odi.org/twitter Readers are encouraged to reproduce material from ODI Reports for their own publications, as long as they are not being sold commercially. As copyright holder, ODI requests due acknowledgement and a copy of the publication. For online use, we ask readers to link to the original resource on the ODI website. The views presented in this paper are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the views of ODI. © Overseas Development Institute 2016. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non-Commercial Licence (CC BY-NC 4.0). Cover photo: A mother brings her child to be vaccinated for TB during routine vaccinations at a district public health office, immunisation clinic, Pokhara, Nepal. © Jim Holmes for AusAID. Acknowledgements This report has been contributed to and written by an international and multidisciplinary team of researchers comprising: Tanvi Bhatkal, Catherine Blampied, Soumya Chattopadhyay, Maria Ana Jalles D’Orey, Romilly Greenhill, Tom Hart, Tim Kelsall, Cathal Long, Shakira Mustapha, Moizza Binat Sarwar, Elizabeth Stuart, Olivia Tulloch and Joseph Wales (Overseas Development Institute), Alasdair Fraser and Abraham Rugo Muriu (independent researchers in Kenya), Shiva Raj Adhikari and Archana Amatya (Tibhuvan University, Nepal) and Arjun Thapa (Pokhara University, Nepal). We are most grateful to all the interview participants we learnt from during the course of the work and to the following individuals for their support and facilitation of the research process: Sarah Parker at ODI.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepal Donors Consultation Meeting- 2008, Special Issue MAGH 2064 JAN-FEB 2008
    FINANCEFINANCE NEWS AND VIEWS Nepal Donors Consultation Meeting- 2008, Special Issue MAGH 2064 JAN-FEB 2008 Government of Nepal Ministry of Finance Singhdurbar, Kathmandu, Nepal In the presence of Hon'ble Finance Minister Dr. Ram Sharan Mahat and Vice President of the World Bank Mr. Praful Patel, Finance Secretary Mr. Vidyadhar Mallik and Country Director of the World Bank in Nepal Ms. Susan Goldmark, signing agreement on 31 January 2008 in Kathmandu. Government of Nepal Ministry of Finance Singhdurbar, Kathmandu, Nepal Tel: ++977-1-4211379 Fax: ++977-1-4211770 E-mail: [email protected] Web: mof.gov.np g]kfn ;/sf/ cy{ dGqfno s]Gb|Lo cg'udg OsfO{sf] ;"rgf g]kfn ;/sf/n] ljut aif{x? b]lvg} /fh:jsf] d"n cfwf/sf] ?kdf d"No clej[l4 s/sf] sfof{Gjog ub{} cfPsf] Aoxf]/f pBdL Aoj;foLx?nfO{ ljlbt} 5 . ljlnË k|0ffnL k|efjsf/L ePdf dfq d"No clej[l4 s/sf] ;kmn sfof{Gjog x'g ;Sg] / v/Lb u/]sf] ;fdfgsf] jf/]06L, Uof/]06L tyf b]z ljsf;sf] nflu klg ljn lng] lbg] ug{' x'g ;DalGwt ;a}df cg'/f]w ul/G5 . cfkm"n] laqmL u/]sf] dfna:t'sf] ljn lbg' laqm]tfsf] st{Ao xf] eg] cfkm"n] v/Lb u/]sf] dfna:t'sf] lan k|fKt ug{' v/Lbstf{sf] clwsf/ / bfloTj klg xf] . t;y{, v/Lb tyf laqmL stf{n] lan lng ] lbg ] sfodf{ cfkm\gf ] stAo{ tyf bfloTjsf ] kfngf u/L ;/sf/sf] /fh:j ;+sng ug{] sfo{df ;d]t ;xof]u k'¥ofpg cy{ dGqfno ;DalGwt ;a}df cfu|x ub{5, ;fy} ljlnË k|0ffnLsf] cg'udg ug{ gkfn] ;/sf/af6 vl6O { cfpg ] sdrf/Lx?nfO{ { cfjZos ;xofu] ul/ lbg' x'g ;d]t ;DalGwt ;a}df clkn ub{5 .
    [Show full text]
  • Kathmandu NEPAL Area
    Development and Operation of Dry Ports in Nepal Sarad Bickram Rana, Executive Director, Nepal Intermodal Transport Development Board (NITDB) Kathmandu, Nepal 1 Presentation Overview • Key Information on trade and transit situation • Policy Guidelines • Institutional Arrangements • Related Act and Regulations • Expected Benefit • Some Major Problems • Summary 2 NEPAL Area : 147,181 Sq. Km. Population: 26.5 Mill. GDP Per capita : 700 $ Kathmandu 3 Foreign Trade Situation Status of Nepal as per Doing 177th out of 189 Business Report Export Cost per container US$ 2,400 Export Time 42 days Import cost per container US$ 2,295 Import Time 39 days Stream Share of Total Trade(2012/13) Export 11% Import 89% 100% India 66% Overseas 34 % 100% 4 Transit Provision Through Treaty of Transit between Nepal and India • Gateway Port (Out of major ports Kolkata Port is a designated port ) • 26 Border Crossing point • 1 rail head Through Rail-Service Agreement between Nepal and India • 1 rail based Through Nepal-China Agreement • 6 Border crossing point 5 Trade Corridors (Major) Yari Nechung Rasuwa Kimathanka Olangchungola Dryports/ Inland Clearance Depots under operations Dryport under construction Proposed for future construction 6 Transport Infrastructure (2013) Roads Local Roads (50,943 Km) Strategic Roads (11,636 Km) Railways Jayanagar (India) - Janakpur (Nepal) Raxaul (India) – Birgunj (Nepal) (51 KM) (5 KM) Airfields 48 Nos. (registered) Dryports Road based (3+1) Rail based(1) 7 Policies for Development of Dry ports • Eighth Five Year Plan (1992-97)
    [Show full text]
  • EBHR 37 Cover Page.Indd
    56 EBHR-37 Minority Rights and Constitutional Borrowings in the Drafting of Nepal’s 1990 Constitution Mara Malagodi This article aims to investigate the reasons for and modalities of the rejection of the minority approach in Nepal’s 1990 Constitution-making experience.1 The analysis is conducted in light of the country’s post- Panchayat process of re-democratisation and vis-à-vis the high degree of socio-cultural diversity of the Nepali polity in which no group amounts to a numerical majority.2 The 1990 Constitution-making process was articulated in two phases: (a) the drafting of the document by the nine-member Constitution Recommendation Commission (CRC) between 31 May and 10 September 1990, and (b) the finalisation of the draft by a three-member Cabinet Committee, leading to the promulgation of the document on 9 November 1990.3 The expression ‘minority approach’ is employed here to indicate the specific array of choices made by Constitution-makers in designing state institutions reflective of a country’s socio-cultural diversity and giving 1 The present article is based on my presentation at the MIDEA workshop on Constitutionalism and Diversity held in Kathmandu, 22-24 August 2007 (see http://www.uni-bielefeld.de/ midea/whats%20new/previous_events.html). I am grateful to the MIDEA workshop’s organisers and participants for their insightful comments on my paper and to the EBHR reviewers for their detailed and perceptive observations which significantly helped improve my paper. My doctoral research in Nepal in 2006 and 2007 was supported by a generous grant from the University of London Central Research Fund in 2006.
    [Show full text]
  • Water of Discord, Water of Unity: an Ethnographic Study of The
    WATER OF DISCORD, WATER OF UNITY: AN ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY OF THE STRUGGLE FOR WATER RIGHTS IN UPPER MUSTANG, NEPAL by GOVINDA BAHADUR BASNET (Under the Direction of ROBERT E RHOADES) ABSTRACT Although water rights and property relations have become issues of strategic importance in recent water policy debates, legislation, and rural development initiatives, there is still a gap of understanding about what water rights in practice are, how they are created and contested, and how these contestations modify social institutions. This ethnographic research, by integrating historical and comparative approaches, investigated how water rights are defined and contested in a cold, arid region of upper Mustang in Nepal. The struggle for water rights was found to take place at three levels: (1) to acquire and defend rights to access water; (2) to defend to take part in collective decision making, and defining water rights contents; and (3) to legitimize contesting claims. Social differentials, like classes created on the basis of inheritance of parental property, were the most decisive factors in defining an individual’s access to water and participation in the decision making process. The impartible primogeniture inheritance system, followed traditionally in the research villages, had created two classes of people, those inheriting the property, and those not inheriting the property. The struggle for water rights has abolished the distinction between such classes in some villages. The inter-village contestation for control of water sources was largely dictated by the political power a village held and the local understanding of hydrology. These inter-village struggles for water rights were found to be instrumental in developing cohesion within a village.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepal and Bhutan in 2011 Cautious Optimism
    SARA SHNEIDERMAN AND MARK TURIN Nepal and Bhutan in 2011 Cautious Optimism ABSTRACT Nepal’s political transition to a democratic federal republic remains incomplete. A November 2011 agreement on post-conflict integration and rehabilitation offers reason for hope. Continued disagreements over the structure of the federal state and its form of government have delayed the constitution-making process. Corruption, impunity, and weak infrastructure combine to erode Nepali confidence in effective governance. Bhutan’s democratic exercise continues to be carefully controlled by entrenched elites, but the country held its first-ever local elections successfully and economic growth stabilized. KEYWORDS: Nepal, Bhutan, democratic transition, constitution-making, state restructuring NEPAL *e year "(## began with the termination of the United Nations Mission in Nepal (UNMIN). With UNMIN’s departure in January, Nepal’s peace process entered unmonitored territory for the +rst time since the mission’s inception four years ago. Although controversial and ever-uncomfortable with the terms of its mandate, the U.N. intervention established the condi- tions for implementing the November "((' Comprehensive Peace Agree- ment that ended the decade-long civil con,ict between state security forces and the Maoist People’s Liberation Army (PLA). With its recent focus on the most intractable aspect of the peace process—establishing a procedure for integrating eligible Maoist ex-combatants into the Nepal Army (NA) and rehabilitating the remainder—UNMIN’s presence had exerted continued S-.- S/01231.4-0 is Assistant Professor of Anthropology at Yale University. M-.5 T6.20 is Associate Research Scientist in South Asian Studies at Yale University and Research Associate at the University of Cambridge.
    [Show full text]
  • Shiva.MST Job 1
    Chapter 3 Evolution of Communist Movement in Nepal till 1990 Early Years, Development after 1960, Splits within the Movement 1. Formation of Communist Party of Nepal: Its Initial Documents As described (See p.43), disillusioned by Regmi’s activities Pushpalal left for Calcutta. On reaching there, he says, “His contact with Nripen Chakraborty and Ratanlal Brahmin and … his belief that the International Communists would instantaneously support the launch of a Communist Party in Nepal encouraged him to open Nepal Communist Party” (Pushpalal, Itihas 32). Further, he notes, “Revolutionary friends from Kathmandu Valley and from Eastern and Western Nepal were also conferring with me on the issue” (35). From then onwards, describing the formation of Nepal Communist Party, he writes: On 22nd of April 1949 a meeting was held among Pushpalal, Niranjan Govind Vaid, Narayanvilas Joshi and Narbahadur at Shyambazar, 28, Naveen Sarkar Lane, Calcutta. Meanwhile, Durgadevi had also arrived from Kathmandu so she was also included as the founding member in the organisational committee of the Party. This committee appointed Pushpalal as the general secretary of the Party and gave him the responsibility of organising the Party at the Central level. The responsibility of organising the Party in Bara, Parsa and Rautahat was given to Niranjan Govind Vaid, because he had played an active role in Birganj area during the 1947 Satyagraha movement. Narayanvilas and Durgadevi were asked to look after Kathmandu Valley and Narbahadur was given the responsibility of working among the workers of Biratnagar and Jogbani (35). However, there exists a controversy regarding the exact date when the Party was formed and regarding the number of founding members.
    [Show full text]
  • Nepal Rastra Bank Press News
    Nepal Rastra Bank Press News SAARCFINANCE Governors' Symposium in Nepal Nepal Rastra Bank hosted SAARCFINANCE Governors' Symposium on "Food Inflation in SAARC Region" on 16th May 2012 in Pokhara, Nepal. SAARCFINANCE is a regional network of the SAARC Central Bank Governors and Finance Secretaries. Dr. Fazeel Najeeb, Chairperson of the SAARCFINANCE and Governor of Maldives Monetary Authority inaugurated the Symposium. Welcoming the guests and delegates to the Symposium, Mr. Gopal Prasad Kaphle, Deputy Governor of Nepal Rastra Bank stated that food inflation has become a challenge to the central banks. The dimensions of food inflation are both domestic and international. He urged about necessary reform in monetary policy for attaining the price stability which is one of the main objectives of all the central banks. Dr. Kalpana Kochhar, Chief Economist from the World Bank South Asia Region addressed the opening ceremony as a guest speaker. She discussed causes and impacts of food inflation in the region vis-à-vis the global context and emphasized on framing appropriate policy measures to address food inflation issue. Dr. Yuba Raj Khatiwada, Governor of Nepal Rastra Bank presented a thematic paper on "Food Inflation in SAARC Region". Governor Dr. Khatiwada viewed that high labor cost, global prices, low level of food production, lack of support for food production are the main causes of food inflation. Dr. Khatiwada stated that the food inflation has negative impact on macroeconomic situation and it hits the poor section of the population the most. Governor Khatiwada opined that the member central banks in the region need to implement credit policy measures to promote food production and help control food inflation in the region.
    [Show full text]