STDC Minutes 5/2020 Minutes of the 4Th Meeting of the Sha Tin District
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STDC Minutes 5/2020 Minutes of the 4th Meeting of the Sha Tin District Council in 2020 Date : 24 April 2020 (Friday) Time : 2:30 pm Venue : Sha Tin District Council Conference Room 4/F, Sha Tin Government Offices Present Time of joining Time of leaving the meeting the meeting Chairman : Mr CHING Cheung-ying, MH 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Vice-Chairman : Mr WONG Hok-lai, George 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Members : Mr CHAN Billy Shiu-yeung 2:30 pm 6:41 pm Mr CHAN Nok-hang 2:57 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHAN Pui-ming 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHAN Wan-tung 2:50 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHENG Chung-hang 2:50 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHENG Tsuk-man 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHEUNG Hing-wa 2:35 pm 6:28 pm Mr CHIU Chu-pong 2:52 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHOW Hiu-laam, Felix 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr CHUNG Lai-him, Johnny 2:30 pm 6:27 pm Mr HUI Lap-san 2:50 pm 7:15 pm Mr HUI Yui-yu 2:52 pm 7:15 pm Mr LAI Tsz-yan 4:04 pm 7:03 pm Dr LAM Kong-kwan 2:30 pm 4:07 pm Mr LI Chi-wang, Raymond 2:47 pm 6:48 pm Mr LI Sai-hung 3:00 pm 7:15 pm Mr LI Wing-shing, Wilson 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr LIAO Pak-hong, Ricardo 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr LO Tak-ming 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr LO Yuet-chau 2:30 pm 7:13 pm Mr LUI Kai-wing 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr MAK Tsz-kin 2:49 pm 7:15 pm Mr MAK Yun-pui, Chris 2:30 pm 3:02 pm Mr MOK Kam-kwai, BBS 2:30 pm 4:05 pm Mr NG Kam-hung 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Ms NG Ting-lam 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr SHAM Tsz-kit, Jimmy 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr SHEK William 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Mr SIN Cheuk-nam 2:30 pm 6:55 pm Mr TING Tsz-yuen 2:30 pm 6:47 pm Mr TSANG Kit 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Ms TSANG So-lai 2:57 pm 6:51 pm Mr WAI Hing-cheung 2:35 pm 7:15 pm Mr WONG Ho-fung 5:24 pm 7:15 pm Ms WONG Man-huen 2:30 pm 6:03 pm Present Time of joining Time of leaving the meeting the meeting Mr YAU Man-chun 2:47 pm 7:15 pm Mr YEUNG Sze-kin 6:00 pm 7:15 pm Mr YIP Wing 2:51 pm 7:13 pm Mr YUNG Ming-chau, Michael 2:30 pm 7:15 pm Secretary : Ms YU Wai-ting, Amy Senior Executive Officer (District Council) (Atg) / Sha Tin District Office Mr LEUNG Ho-yin, Roy Senior Executive Officer (District Council) (Atg) / Sha Tin District Office In Attendance Title Ms CHAN Yuen-man, Amy, JP District Officer (Sha Tin) Mr WONG Tin-pui, Simon Assistant District Officer (Sha Tin)1 Mr WONG Shek-hay, Sebastian Assistant District Officer (Sha Tin)2 Mr LEUNG Tsz-kin, Percy District Commander (Shatin) / Hong Kong Police Force Mr IP Cheuk-yu Police Community Relations Officer (Shatin District) / Hong Kong Police Force Mr LAI Wing-chi, Derek District Environmental Hygiene Superintendent (Sha Tin) / Food and Environmental Hygiene Department Mr CHAN Kai-lam, Allan Chief Manager / Management (Tai Po, North, Sha Tin) / Housing Department Ms LEUNG Yee-lee, Maggie District Social Welfare Officer (Shatin) / Social Welfare Department Ms LEE Mei-yee Senior Librarian (Sha Tin) / Leisure and Cultural Services Department Ms TAM Yuen-fun, Betty Senior Manager (New Territories East) Promotion / Leisure and Cultural Services Department Ms WONG Kit-yi, Pat Senior Manager (Community Programmes) / Leisure and Cultural Services Department Ms SAM Fung-mei, Esther Manager (New Territories East) Marketing and District Activities / Leisure and Cultural Services Department Ms CHAN Siu-kin, Ester Deputy District Leisure Manager (District Support) Sha Tin / Leisure and Cultural Services Department Ms WONG Sau-kuen, Joe District Leisure Manager (Sha Tin) / Leisure and Cultural Services Department Ms YIP Sau-mei, Joyce Chief School Development Officer (Sha Tin) / Education Bureau Mr CHIU Hak-pui, Christopher Principal Transportation Officer (New Territories) 1 / Transport Department Mr HAR Sung-fu, Haven Senior Engineer/7 (North) / Civil Engineering and Development Department Mr YUEN Sze-chun Administration Assistant / Lands (District Lands Office / Sha Tin) Mr WOO Tim Senior Estate Surveyor / South East / - 2 - In Attendance Title District Lands Office, Sha Tin Ms CHU Ha-fan, Jessica District Planning Officer (Sha Tin, Tai Po and North) / Planning Department In Attendance by Invitation Title Mr LEUNG Sean Man-dik Assistant Public Relations Manager – External Affairs / MTR Corporation Limited Absent Ms LUK Tsz-tung (Application for leave of absence received) Action The Chairman asked Members outside the conference room to enter expeditiously as the meeting was about to commence and said that the situation was being handled by personnel outside. 2. The Chairman welcomed Members and representatives from Government departments to the fourth meeting of this year. Due to the epidemic, the meeting of the Sha Tin District Council (STDC) originally held on 26 March had been postponed to today. 3. The Chairman informed all attendees that some members of the public, being present as observers, were taking photographs and making video and audio recordings. Due to the epidemic, the party concerned cleaned and disinfected the conference room before the meeting; and 4 hours into the meeting, at around 6:30 pm, the conference room would be disinfected again. He would adjourn the meeting if it was still going on by then, and the meeting would resume after disinfection. 4. The Chairman welcomed the following to the meeting: Mr Percy LEUNG, the new District Commander (Shatin) of the Hong Kong Police Force (HKPF); Ms Pat WONG, Senior Manager (Community Programmes); Ms Betty TAM, Senior Manager (New Territories East) Promotion; Ms Esther SAM, Manager (New Territories East) Marketing and District Activities; Ms LEE Mei-yee, Senior Librarian (Sha Tin) of the Leisure and Cultural Services Department (LCSD); Mr Sean LEUNG, Assistant Public Relations Manager – External Affairs of the MTR Corporation Limited (MTRCL); Mr Haven HAR, Senior Engineer/7 (North) representing Mr YUEN Tat-yung, Zorro, Chief Engineer / North (SD4) of the Civil Engineering and Development Department and Mr WOO Tim, Senior Estate Surveyor / South East (District Lands Office, Sha Tin) representing Mr WONG Kwok-wai, Wilson, District Lands Officer / Sha Tin of the Lands Department. 5. The Chairman said the STDC Secretariat (Secretariat) did not receive any application for leave of absence from Members before the meeting. Confirmation of the Minutes of the Meeting Held on 23 January 2020 (STDC Minutes 2/2020) 6. The Chairman said the Secretariat received 1 proposed amendment as of the start of the meeting, which was placed on the conference table. He asked Members to consider confirming the revised minutes of the meeting. - 3 - Action 7. The Council unanimously confirmed the above minutes. Confirmation of the Minutes of the Meeting Held on 10 February 2020 (STDC Minutes 3/2020) 8. The Council unanimously confirmed the above minutes. Confirmation of the Minutes of the Meeting Held on 13 February 2020 (STDC Minutes 4/2020) 9. The Council unanimously confirmed the above minutes. Responses of the Hong Kong Police Force to Matters Arising from the Meeting on 23 January 2020 (Paper No. STDC 16/2020 (Revised)) 10. The views of Mr Michael YUNG were summarised below: (a) regarding the unlawful assembly in Incident 1, he asked if the petitioners outside the conference room were an unlawful assembly or contravening the prohibition on group gathering and why the police did not issue summons to them; (b) he pointed out that the STDC had established the District Facilities Management and Security Affairs Committee (DFMSC) and asked why the police failed to attend the meetings of the DFMSC that covered security affairs; (c) he opined that the anti-crime patrol in Incident 3 showed that the police was taking enforcement actions on private premises. He claimed that the STDC Conference Room was also on private premises and asked why the police did not take enforcement actions just now; (d) he said that the District Officer once expressed the need to strengthen security and asked why security guards outside allowed petitioners to make a scene; (e) he asked if they should call the 999 hotline for police assistance; and (f) he opined that the Chairman was responsible for hosting the meeting and did not have to answer questions for departments. 11. The views of Mr CHAN Pui-ming were summarised below: (a) he pointed out that more than 4 persons gathered outside the conference room just now and asked why the Sha Tin District Office (STDO), building security guards and the police did not properly handle the situation; (b) he asked the police whether the group contravened the prohibition on group gathering, whether the police issued verbal warnings and when the police would issue summons to them; . - 4 - Action (c) regarding Incident 2, “The Unlawful Assembly near Tai Shui Hang Cycling Park on 13 November”, the police replied that there was no record of police officers pulling out their guns. He pointed out that he was there on the day of the incident to learn more about the police’s use of tear gas, and residents and reporters witnessed a police officer pointing a gun at him and residents on the scene.