Corporate Social Responsibility Practices in The

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Corporate Social Responsibility Practices in The CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY PRACTICES IN THE LEBANESE BANKING SECTOR: A REALITY OR A MYTH? _________________________________________________ A Thesis presented to the Faculty of Business Administration and Economics at Notre Dame University-Louaize _________________________________________________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Science In Business Strategy _______________________________________________________________ by MARIA CHLELA JULY2020 © COPYRIGHT By Maria Chlela 2020 All Rights Reserved Notre Dame University - Louarze Facultyof K*zz*ixx*ss1a^q2xxttyti*tyeti{tzz8*Wu"rrxtyxzz\*s Department of f&'anas*]wnt k T,La{keling We hereby approve the thesis of 7,",1,:,xt* t-.h\*l,t candidate for the degree of h4a*tsrs tsl's*,i*r:tt*, in T-lusiness strztl*gy Grade: B c 0Le Mr . {}hass an ni *\ z: t> ttthv Supe{vsttrr 6) & h,t*t'2li n" 13M,W tr7**n. t;13AI: ii TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... iv LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................. iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .................................................................................................. v ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................... vi CHAPTER 1-INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................ 1 1.1- General Background ............................................................................................ 1 1.2- Need for the Study ............................................................................................... 5 1.3- Purpose of the Study ............................................................................................ 6 1.4- Brief overview of the chapters............................................................................. 7 CHAPTER 2- REVIEW OF LITERATURE ...................................................................... 8 2.1- Introduction ............................................................................................................. 8 2.2- CSR Theories and frameworks .............................................................................. 10 2.3- Stakeholder Theory of Corporate Social Responsibility ....................................... 12 2.4- CSR Instruments .................................................................................................... 14 2.4.1-ISO 26000 ........................................................................................................ 17 2.4.2-GRI Standards.................................................................................................. 18 2.4.3-United Nations Global Compact (UNGC)....................................................... 18 2.5-CSR practices and disclosures in banks ................................................................. 19 2.5.1- International banks ......................................................................................... 21 2.5.2- Local banks ..................................................................................................... 23 2.6- Local Banks‟ exposure .......................................................................................... 25 2.7- Link between CSR and banks‟ exposure ............................................................... 27 2.8- Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 28 CHAPTER 3 - METHODOLOGY ................................................................................... 30 3.1- Introduction ........................................................................................................... 30 3.2- Research methods .................................................................................................. 30 3.3- Research approach ................................................................................................. 31 3.4- Data collection method and tools .......................................................................... 32 3.5- Sample selection .................................................................................................... 33 3.6- Research process.................................................................................................... 33 3.7- Data analysis .......................................................................................................... 34 3.8- Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 34 CHAPTER 4 - FINDINGS ............................................................................................... 35 iii 4.1- Introduction ........................................................................................................... 35 4.2- CSR and Lebanese banks ...................................................................................... 35 4.2.1- Audi bank ....................................................................................................... 35 4.2.2- BLOM Bank ................................................................................................... 41 4.2.3- Byblos Bank ................................................................................................... 46 4.2.4- Fransabank ...................................................................................................... 48 4.2.5- SGBL .............................................................................................................. 51 4.2.6- Bank of Beirut ................................................................................................ 55 4.2.7- Bankmed ......................................................................................................... 58 4.2.8- BLF ................................................................................................................. 62 4.2.9- Credit Libanais ............................................................................................... 66 4.2.10- IBL ................................................................................................................ 69 4.2.11- Lebanese and Gulf Bank (LGB) ................................................................... 71 4.2.12- Credit Bank ................................................................................................... 72 4.2.13- BBAC ........................................................................................................... 74 4.3-Findings according to ISO 26000 ........................................................................... 75 4.4- Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 78 CHAPTER 5- CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................... 79 5.1- Introduction ........................................................................................................... 79 5.2- Summary of Main Findings ................................................................................... 79 5.3- Research Limitations ............................................................................................. 82 5.4- Possible future research ......................................................................................... 83 5.6- Research Implications............................................................................................ 83 References ......................................................................................................................... 85 iv LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Different types of CSR and the scale of each one ............................................. 15 Figure 2: Plan- Do Check-Act cycle ................................................................................. 15 Figure 3: Connection between the three frameworks ....................................................... 17 LIST OF TABLES Table 1: The reporting of the CSR banking sector of 13 banks and the application with the principals of ISO 26000 .............................................................................................. 75 v ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I appreciate the support of my thesis supervisor and reader in writing this thesis. They both gave me great ideas for collecting and analyzing various data and information, and helped me to organize this thesis. I also thank my fiancé, my parents and especially my friends Hoda and Mounir Abi Aad for showing faith in me, encouraging and supporting me throughout this journey. vi ABSTRACT Purpose – The purpose of this research is to study the difference between the CSR reporting and the CSR execution in the Lebanese banking sector specially during the current financial crisis and lack of trust between the customers and the banks‟ administration as a whole. Design/methodology/approach – To proceed with this study, we used the quantitative method by extracting data and information for 13 Lebanese banks and calculating the sovereign exposure debt of all these banks separately and comparing them to their disclosed CSR practices. Findings – Our research showed that not all CSR actions are being reported, in addition not all CSR reporting are being executed and we also found that within the sample of 13 banks we studied, only three banks were compliant with the accepted sovereign
Recommended publications
  • Credit Libanais S.A.L
    C REDIT LIBANAIS S.A.L. CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROGRAM: ECONOMIC RESEARCH UNIT CREDIT LIBANAIS HEADQUARTERS A FOCUS ON THE TRANSPORTATION ADLIEH ECTOR S BEIRUT, LEBANON TEL +961.1.608000 JULY 2018 FAX +961.1.608231 [email protected] CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROGRAM: A FOCUS ON THE TRANSPORT SECTOR TABLE OF CONTENTS I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................ 3 II. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................ 5 III. OVERVIEW ...................................................................................................... 6 A. Existing Road Plans ........................................................................................... 6 i. Description & Conditions ........................................................................................ 6 B. Car Congestion ................................................................................................ 7 i. Evolution & Forecasts ............................................................................................. 7 ii. Impact of Syrian Crisis ........................................................................................... 8 IV. COSTS ............................................................................................................ 9 A. Economic Bill ................................................................................................... 9 B. Environmental Bill .........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Credit Libanais Market Watch
    5 CREDIT LIBANAIS S.A.L. Weekly Market Watch Economic Research Unit Credit Libanais Headquarters Issue No. 448 Adlieh Beirut, Lebanon Tel +961.1.608000 th th February 9 ‐ February 13 2015 Fax +961.1.608000 Ext. 1285 [email protected] TABLE OF CONTENTS LEBANON NEWS TH ECONOMIC INSIGHTS LEBANON RANKS 10 IN THE MENA REGION IN THE NATIXIS’ 2015 GLOBAL > Lebanon Ranks 10th in the MENA Region in the Natixis’ 2015 RETIREMENT INDEX Global Retirement Index 1 > Industrial Exports Shed 14.61% Y-O-Y to $2,890 Million up to According to Natixis Asset Management’s November 2014 2 report, Lebanon came in 10th in the > Commercial Banks’ Assets up by 6.60% to $175.70 Billion as th at End of Year 2014 3 region and 94 worldwide in the year > Gross Public Debt at $66.56 Billion at End of Year 2014 4 2015, with a score of 50% in the > Lebanon’s Annual Inflation Rate Stood at -1.66% in December retirement index. 2014 5 > Lebanon’s Coincident Indicator Down by 3.62% Y-O-Y in INDUSTRIAL EXPORTS SHED 14.61% November 2014 5 TO ILLION UP TO > New Car Sales Notch 2.70% Higher Y-O-Y in January 2015 6 Y-O-Y $2,890 M NOVEMBER 2014 > ABL Amends the BRR on LBP and USD Lending 7 > Beirut Port Freight Activity Drops by 18.07% in January 2015 7 Industrial exports came in 14.61% lower > The Number of Beirut Airport Passengers Adds 11.45% Y-O-Y in January 2015 8 y-o-y at $2,890 million as at the end of the first eleven months of 2014, down from just over $3,384 million during that MONETARY PERFORMANCE same period in 2013.
    [Show full text]
  • You Must Read the Following Before Continuing. The
    IMPORTANT NOTICE IMPORTANT: You must read the following before continuing. The following applies to the Prospectus following this page, and you are therefore advised to read this carefully before reading, accessing or making any other use of the Prospectus. In accessing the Prospectus, you agree to be bound by the following terms and conditions, including any modifications to them any time you receive any information from us as a result of such access. NOTHING IN THIS ELECTRONIC TRANSMISSION CONSTITUTES AN OFFER OF SECURITIES FOR SALE IN ANY JURISDICTION. THE SECURITIES HAVE NOT BEEN, AND WILL NOT BE, REGISTERED UNDER THE U.S. SECURITIES ACT OF 1933 (THE ‘‘SECURITIES ACT’’), OR THE SECURITIES LAWS OF ANY STATE OF THE UNITED STATES OR OTHER JURISDICTION, AND THE SECURITIES MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD WITHIN THE UNITED STATES OR TO, OR FOR THE ACCOUNT OR BENEFIT OF, U.S. PERSONS (AS DEFINED IN REGULATION S UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT), EXCEPT PURSUANT TO AN EXEMPTION FROM, OR IN A TRANSACTION NOT SUBJECT TO, THE REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS OF THE SECURITIES ACT AND APPLICABLE LAWS OF OTHER JURISDICTIONS. THIS PROSPECTUS MAY ONLY BE VIEWED BY (1) QUALIFIED INSTITUTIONAL BUYERS (“QIBS”) (WITHIN THE MEANING OF RULE 144A UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT) OR (2) NON- U.S. PERSONS (WITHIN THE MEANING OF REGULATION S UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT) OUTSIDE THE UNITED STATES. THE FOLLOWING PROSPECTUS MAY NOT BE FORWARDED OR DISTRIBUTED TO ANY OTHER PERSON AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED IN ANY MANNER WHATSOEVER AND ANY FORWARDING, DISTRIBUTION OR REPRODUCTION OF THIS DOCUMENT IN WHOLE OR IN PART IS UNAUTHORISED.
    [Show full text]
  • Banking in Lebanon
    BANKING IN LEBANON A special report by Executive Magazine June 2014 The taxation issue and other concerns faced by the country’s primary financial players in 2014 Tax = Torture? The dominant issue in initiatives which the Lebanese government could add to its count of “accomplishments” in the first quarter of 2017 was not, as hoped at time of this cabinet’s appointment in December 2016, an equitable or at least workable electoral law. What turned out to be the biggest in the government’s doings instead was new taxation measures, in form of increases of existing consumption taxes and corporate income taxes and in form of new taxes, direct and indirect ones that are, however, have not been debated yet to completion in Parliament and ergo not been approved at time of producing this pdf document. What is evident at the end of March 2017, however, is that the tax measures have shocked many, Lebanese citizens and corporations alike. Citizens crowded public spaces in – at times hysteric and near-violent – protest demonstrations. Economic entities, including the banking sector, raised their objections in a more civil, but no less determined matter, arguing about detriments to GDP growth as well as loss of productivity and of already battered competitiveness in the Lebanese economy. Banks, which are set to bear an unenviable part of the new tax burden, have also spoken up in protest about the fairness of the measures and the problem that the measures in their view constitute double taxation, which is incompatible with any notion of fiscal justice. This position of the banks is contrary to the perception of banking sector standpoints which the Ministry of Finance communicated to this magazine earlier in 2017.
    [Show full text]
  • The United States Hails Lebanon's Advanced Banking System
    ABL Quarterly Newsletter Issue n° 3–October 2014 ABL’s “Economic Letter” free registration is available here: www.abl.org.lb The United States hails Lebanon’s operating in Lebanon are expected to come advanced banking system under pressure in the face of unfolding developments both in the country and the Lebanon has many advanced features in its region. economy and one of these interesting landmarks is there well-developed baking But S&P stressed that the business system, according to the United States confidence and economic recovery were Department of Commerce's 2014 Country gravelly affected by the political and Commercial Guide for Lebanon (CCG). security events that has plagued the country in recent years. It added that Lebanon's key advantages include a free-market economy, the The agency believes that Lebanon cannot absence of controls on the movement of insulate itself from the rapid and dramatic capital and foreign exchange, a well- in neighboring Syria although the banking developed banking system, a highly- sector, the main pillar of the economy, educated labor force, good quality of life, managed to weather all the major storms and limited restrictions on investors. and even achieved relative growth. This is not the first time the United States It emphasized that if the banking sector and other prominent countries heaped can prosper and grow if the political and praise on the Lebanese banks and the geopolitical risks receded. financial institutions which are seen as the main pillar of the economy. The report S&P insists that Lebanon has all elements expected the business climate to remain of quick economic recovery thanks to the sensitive to domestic and regional political strong financial sector, educated and security developments.
    [Show full text]
  • IFC Mobile Money Scoping Country Report: Lebanon Alaa Abbassi, Andrew Lake, Cherine El Sayed
    IFC Mobile Money Scoping Country Report: Lebanon Alaa Abbassi, Andrew Lake, Cherine El Sayed May, 2012 Lebanon Summary Overall readiness rating 4 (Moderately high readiness for Bank Centric Mobile Money deployment in high income segments) 3 (Medium readiness for the mid market, those unable to afford smart phones) Current mobile money solution The banks have begun implementing mobile money – both mobile payments and mobile banking. This is being done by the banks on their own and in conjunction with Mobile payments suppliers within Lebanon. Population 4.14 mil * Mobile Penetration 68% 2010 (High) ** Banked Population 2.5 mil (60%) (Moderately high) *** Remittance % of GDP Outbound $3,737 mil (9.7%) *** Inbound $7,558 mil (19.6%) *** Percent under poverty line 28% * Economically Active population 1,48 mil (36%) * Adult Literacy 87.4% * Main banks Bank Audi, Blom Bank, Byblos Bank, Fransabank, Bankmed, BLF MobileIFC Opportunities Network Operators MTC Touch 1,724,854 (54%) Alfa 1,482,819 (46%) Ease of doing business Ranked 104 in the world, better than Pakistan, worse than Seychelles **** Sources: * https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/le.html ** TRA annual report 2010 *** http://elibrary-data.imf.org/DataReport.aspx?c=2529608&d=33060&e=161939 **** http://doingbusiness.org/rankings • Macro-economic Overview • Regulations • Financial Sector • Telecom Sector • Distribution Channel • Mobile Financial Services Landscape Macro-Economic Overview Key Country Statistics Insights • Population: 4.14 mil • Lebanon is a small country, both in terms of population size and geography. • Age distribution: 23% (0 – 14 years) 68% (15 - 64 years) 9% (>65 years) • It has a sophisticated banking industry which serves 60% of the population (2.48 mil • Urban/rural split: 87% urban people, through 900 branches).
    [Show full text]
  • Lebanon This Week
    Issue 162 April 19-23, 2010 Economic Research & Analysis Department LEBANON THIS WEEK In This Issue Charts of the Week Economic Indicators.....................1 Projected Real GDP Growth of Arab Countries in 2010 (%) 20 18.5 Capital Markets............................1 18 Lebanon in the News....................2 16 IMF projects real GDP at 6% in 2010, 14 economy posts fourth fastest growth globally in 2009 12 10 Structural imbalances and political 7.8 7.3 uncertainties to hinder reforms 8 6.0 5.5 6 5.2 5.0 5.0 4.7 Finance Ministry outlines tax reforms, 4.6 4.6 4.5 4.1 4.0 3.7 3.5 starts paying dues to contractors 4 3.2 3.1 1.3 Government releases national accounts 2 for 2008, official real GDP growth at 0 9.3% Iraq UAE Consumer Price Index up 4.5% annually Qatar Sudan Libya Egypt Syria Oman Yemen Algeria JordanTunisia Kuwait in March 2010 Lebanon Djibouti BahrainMorocco Mauritania Saudi Arabia Number of tourists up 32.1% in first quarter of 2010 Real GDP Growth in Lebanon (%) 10 9.0 Most tourists spending in Lebanon origi- 9.0 9 nated from Saudi Arabia and UAE in first quarter of 2010 8 7.5 7.5 7 Foreign investments of financial sector at 6.0 $4.8bn at end-June 2009 6 Corporate Highlights ...................5 5 4 Capital Intelligence affirms Byblos 3 2.5 Bank’s ratings, cites quality manage- ment, low NPLs and provision coverage 2 among strengths 1 0.6 Byblos Bank to distribute $85.4m in div- 0 idends for 2009, payout ratio at 69% 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010f PROPARCO buys 13.6 million Byblos shares Source: International Monetary
    [Show full text]
  • A Review of the Housing Market in Beirut Between 2005 and 2019 By
    A Review of the Housing Market in Beirut between 2005 and 2019 by Abdulrahman Hammoud B.Arch., Architecture, 2014 American University of Beirut Submitted to the Program in Real Estate Development in Conjunction with the Center for Real Estate in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Real Estate Development at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology February 2020 ©2020 Abdulrahman Hammoud All rights reserved The author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce and to distribute publicly paper and electronic copies of this thesis document in whole or in part in any medium now known or hereafter created. Signature of Author____________________________________________________________________________ Center for Real Estate January 10, 2020 Certified by___________________________________________________________________________________ David Geltner Associate Director of Research, Center for Real Estate Professor of Real Estate Finance Thesis Supervisor Accepted by___________________________________________________________________________________ Professor Dennis Frenchman Class of 1922 Professor of Urban Design and Planning Department of Urban Studies and Planning Director, MIT Center for Real Estate A Review of the Housing Market in Beirut between 2005 and 2019 by Abdulrahman Hammoud Submitted to the Program in Real Estate Development in Conjunction with the Center for Real Estate on January 10, 2020 in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Real Estate Development ABSTRACT This paper examines the housing market in Beirut between the beginning of 2005 to the end of 2018, focusing in particular on the slowdown in the early to late 2010s. It will be shown that this slowdown is partly attributable to a mismatch in the supply that private developers have introduced to the market and the actual demand from potential homeowners.
    [Show full text]
  • Communication on Progress UNGC
    Communication on Progress UNGC November 2018 Page 1 of 25 Contents Statement by the Chairman General Manager ................................................................................ 3 Overview of Credit Libanais Group .................................................................................................. 4 Credit Libanais Identity .................................................................................................................... 5 Credit Libanais’ Business Principles.................................................................................................. 6 Credit Libanais Group Structure....................................................................................................... 7 Facts and Figures (CL GROUP).......................................................................................................... 8 CL Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) .................................................................................... 10 CL Strategy ..................................................................................................................................... 12 Corporate Responsibility and Corporate Governance ................................................................... 13 Corporate Responsibility and Responsible Inclusive Financing ...................................................... 15 Corporate Responsibility and the Modernization of Lebanon ....................................................... 17 Corporate Responsibility and our Human Capital
    [Show full text]
  • Credit Libanais S.A.L
    THE IMPACT OF REMITTANCES ON ECONOMIC GROWTH CREDIT LIBANAIS S.A.L. ECONOMIC RESEARCH UNIT THE IMPACT OF REMITTANCES ON CREDIT LIBANAIS HEADQUARTERS ADLIEH BEIRUT, LEBANON E CONOMIC GROWTH TEL +961.1.608000 FAX +961.1.608231 MAY 2017 [email protected] THE IMPACT OF REMITTANCES ON ECONOMIC GROWTH TABLE OF CONTENTS I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................... 3 II. INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ............................................................................. 5 A. Migration around the World ................................................................................. 5 B. Migration in Lebanon ........................................................................................... 6 i. Historical Overview ................................................................................................ 6 ii. Geographical Overview ........................................................................................... 7 III. REMITTANCE INFLOWS ..................................................................................... 8 A. Remittance Inflows around the World .................................................................... 8 i. Evolution of Remittance Inflows as a Stock ............................................................... 8 ii. Evolution of Remittance Inflows as a Percentage of GDP ............................................. 9 B. Remittance Inflows in the MENA Region .............................................................. 10 i. Evolution
    [Show full text]
  • Mergers and Acquisitions Between Lebanese Banks BLOMINVEST BANK
    Mergers and Acquisitions between Lebanese banks BLOMINVEST BANK December 09, 2014 Commercial Bank Branches per 100,000 adults Contact Information Riwa Daou Research Assistant [email protected] Head of Research: Marwan Mikhael [email protected] Regional and Local Turmoil Taking its Toll on Lebanese Banks Mergers and Acquisitions between Lebanese banks S A L Lebanese Banks Accumulating Ample Liquidity Source: World Bank, ABL, BDL, Blominvest Research In a Euromoney article published in May 2014, the governor of the Central Bank of Lebanon mentioned that the number of Lebanese banks (Lebanese shareholders and Lebanese management) was slashed by almost half in the past 20 years. However, he stressed the fact that this slide was the result of a consolidation process and not a series of bank failures: A fact that preserves confidence in the sector and that enhances competition. The following gathers some thoughts on banking consolidation and details the latest in banking M&A activity. According to 2013’s national accounts, the value added of financial services represented 7% of GDP or $3.31B. Since banks are the major players of financial intermediation, it is safe to say that the banking sector occupies an important weight in the Lebanese economy. Given the importance of this sector, it is key to ensure that the market operates at high efficiency. One of the cornerstones of efficiency is assessing whether or not the number of players on the market allows healthy competition on the market. Today, several categories of banks operate on the market. In terms of commercial banks, Lebanon counts: 10 Lebanese Banks with Arab Control, 1 Lebanese bank with foreign non-Arab control, 4 foreign banks, 31 Lebanese banks, 16 investment banks and 10 Arab banks.
    [Show full text]
  • Lebanon Sovereign Ratings Rating Agency Tenor Rating Outlook Standard & Poor's Long-Term B- Stable Short-Term C
    Credit Libanais Research SUMMARY SHEET OCTOBER 2009 Main Macro Economic Indicators Key Trends & Ratios 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 GDP GDP At Current Prices (USD Millions) 21,861 22,438 25,047 28,942 31,298* Real GDP Growth 1.10% 0.60% 7.50% 8.50% 7.00%* GDP per Capita At Current Prices (USD) 59,880 6,060* 6,677* 7,617* 8,132* Public Finance (2) Net Public Debt (USD Millions) 34,756 37,418 39,020 41,500 43,051 Gross Public Debt / GDP Ratio 175.70% 179.90% 167.80% 162.50% N.A. Debt Service / Net Public Debt Ratio 6.74% 8.08% 8.40% 7.92% N.A. (2) Total Deficit (USD Millions) (1,856) (3,027) (2,545) (2,922) (1,715) (2) Total Deficit / Total Expenditures Ratio 27.42% 38.42% 30.49% 29.45% 25.22% Total Deficit / GDP Ratio 8.61% 13.49% 10.16% 10.10% N.A. External Sector (2) Balance of Trade (USD Millions) (7,460) (7,115) (8,999) (12,658) (7,297) Foreign Direct Investments (USD Millions)** 2,624 2,675 2,731 3,606 N.A. FDI / GDP Ratio 12.00% 11.92% 10.90% 12.46% N.A. Foreign Reserves (4) Foreign Assets (USD Millions) 11,657 12,975 12,395 19,732 25,688 (2) Foreign Currency Reserves (USD Millions) 9,845 10,207 9,778 17,062 22,012 (4) Gold Reserves (USD Millions) 4,736 5,807 7,640 8,032 9,246 (4) Total Reserves (USD Millions) 16,394 18,782 20,035 27,764 34,934 Money Supply (3) Broad Money Supply "M2" (USD Billions) 16.23 15.57 16.47 24.76 31.37 Monetization Level (M2 / GDP Ratio) 74.24% 69.39% 65.76% 85.55% N.A.
    [Show full text]