(Public Pack)Agenda Document for Planning Committee, 03/04/2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Public Document Pack PLANNING COMMITTEE WEDNESDAY, 3RD APRIL, 2019, 6.00 PM SHIELD ROOM, CIVIC CENTRE, WEST PADDOCK, LEYLAND PR25 1DH AGENDA 1 Welcome and Introduction 2 Apologies for Absence 3 Declaration of Interest Members are requested to indicate at this stage in the proceedings any items on the agenda in which they intend to declare an interest. Members are reminded that if the interest is a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest (as defined in the Members’ Code of Conduct) they must leave the room for the whole of that item. If the interest is not a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest, but is such that a member of the public could reasonably regard it as being so significant that it is likely that it would prejudice their judgement of the public interest (as explained in the Code of Conduct) then they may make representations, but then must leave the meeting for the remainder of the item. 4 Minutes of the Meeting on Wednesday, 6 March 2019 (Pages 5 - 8) To be signed as a correct record by the Chair. 5 Minutes of the Meeting on Monday, 11 March 2019 (Pages 9 - 12) To be signed as a correct record by the Chair. 6 Appeal Decisions The Director of Planning and Property will provide an update at the meeting. 7 07/2019/1571/FUL - 2-4 Spinners Square, Bamber Bridge (Pages 13 - 28) Report of the Director of Planning and Property attached. 8 07/2018/8493/PIP - 25 Midge Hall Lane, Midge Hall, (Pages 29 - 36) Leyland Report of the Director of Planning and Property attached. Meeting contact Dianne Scambler or email [email protected] 9 07/2019/7012/FUL - Railway Bridge at Asland Close and (Pages 37 - 46) Brennand Close, Bamber Bridge Report of the Director of Planning and Property attached. Heather McManus CHIEF EXECUTIVE Electronic agendas sent to Members of the Planning Committee Councillors Jon Hesketh (Chair), Rebecca Noblet (Vice-Chair), Renee Blow, Malcolm Donoghue, Bill Evans, Derek Forrest, Mick Higgins, Ken Jones, Jim Marsh, Jacqui Mort, Peter Mullineaux, Mike Nelson, Caleb Tomlinson, Graham Walton and Barrie Yates The minutes of this meeting will be available on the internet at www.southribble.gov.uk Forthcoming Meetings 6.00 pm Wednesday, 24 April 2019 - Level 2, Civic Centre, West Paddock, Leyland PR25 1DH Procedure of Debate at Planning Committee Whenever a planning application is dealt with by Planning Committee the Council is keen to allow the local community to participate in the process. The procedure that will ordinarily be followed is that:- Up to five members of the public who wish to speak against an application will be allowed to speak. Each will have up to four minutes in which to state their case. Up to five members of the public who wish to speak in favour of an application will then be allowed to speak. Again each will have up to four minutes in which to state their case. Borough councillors (not on Planning Committee) will then have the opportunity to make representations about the application. Each will have up to four minutes to state their case – whether for or against. The applicant/agent will then be invited to speak in support of the application. Ordinarily he/she will have up to four minutes to speak. The application will be then be discussed by Committee. At this point members of the public, the applicant and other councillors not on Committee will not be able to speak further. Planning Committee will then take a vote on the matter. No paperwork, plans or photographs will be allowed to be circulated by the applicant/agent or member of the public at the meeting. The Chairman of Planning Committee has discretion to vary these rules when dealing with a particular application if he considers it appropriate. Whenever members of the public speak (whether in opposition to a proposal or in favour of it) they should avoid repeating the same points made by other speakers. Filming/Recording Meetings The Council will allow any member of the public to take photographs, film, audio- record and report on any Planning Committee meeting. If anyone is intending to record any such meeting (or part of such a meeting) then it would be very helpful if they could give prior notice of their intention to the Council's Democratic Services Team. Ideally 48 hours' notice should be given. When exercising the rights to record a Planning Committee meeting a member of the public must not in any way be disruptive to that meeting. They must not provide an oral commentary on the meeting whilst it is continuing. If disruption is caused then the Chairman of the meeting may exclude that person from the rest of the meeting. Members of the public will not be entitled to stay in the meeting if any confidential (exempt) items of business are being discussed. Full details of planning applications, associated documents including related consultation replies can be found on the Public Access for planning system, searching for the application using the Simple Search box. http://publicaccess.southribble.gov.uk/online-applications/ This page is intentionally left blank Agenda Item 4 MINUTES OF PLANNING COMMITTEE MEETING DATE Wednesday, 6 March 2019 MEMBERS PRESENT: Councillors Jon Hesketh (Chair), Renee Blow, Malcolm Donoghue, Bill Evans, Derek Forrest, Mick Higgins, Ken Jones, Jim Marsh, Jacqui Mort, Peter Mullineaux, Mike Nelson, Caleb Tomlinson, Graham Walton and Barrie Yates OFFICERS: Charlotte Lynch (Trainee Governance and Member Services Officer), Dave Whelan (Legal Services Manager/Interim Monitoring Officer), Jonathan Noad (Director of Planning and Property), Linda Ashcroft (Planning Assistant), Janice Crook (Planning Officer), Debbie Roberts (Planning Officer) and Chris Sowerby (Interim Assistant Planning Manager (Development Management)) OTHER MEMBERS Councillor Colin Clark (Cabinet Member (Corporate Support AND OFFICERS: and Assets)), Councillor Michael Green, Councillor Michael Titherington (Deputy Leader of the Opposition and Deputy Leader of the Labour Group) and Councillor Matthew Tomlinson PUBLIC: 22 109 Welcome and Introduction The Chair, Councillor Jon Hesketh, welcomed members of the public to the meeting, introduced the committee, and explained the roles of its members and proceedings. 110 Apologies for Absence An apology for absence was received from Councillor Rebecca Noblet. 111 Declaration of Interest Councillor Ken Jones declared a personal interest in Item 6 – Land at School Lane and Golden Hill Lane – and would not take part in the vote but was able, under the Code of Conduct for Elected Members, to remain in the meeting during the consideration of the application. 112 Minutes of the Last Meeting RESOLVED: (Unanimously) That the minutes of the meeting held on Thursday, 7 February 2019 be signed as a correct record by the Chair. Planning Committee Wednesday 6 March 2019 Page 5 2 113 Appeal Decisions The Director of Planning and Property informed the Committee of three appeals which had been referred to the Inspector relating to: 1. 25 Turpin Green Lane, Leyland – dismissed. 2. Howick Cross Service Station, 248 Liverpool Road, Penwortham – dismissed. 3. Brindle Road, Bamber Bridge – allowed. 114 07/2018/8309/FUL - Land at School Lane and Golden Hill Lane, Leyland Speakers: 5 Objectors, Ward Councillor Mick Titherington, Ward and County Councillor Matthew Tomlinson, and the Applicant (Mr Stuart Parks, Property Director for Aldi Stores) Address: Land at School Lane and Golden Hill Lane, Leyland Applicant: Aldi Stores Ltd Agent: GVA How Planning, Norfolk House, 7 Norfolk Street, Manchester, M2 1DW Development: Erection of single storey food store (Class A1) with associated works and car parking following demolition of existing buildings. An amendment was moved by Councillor Barrie Yates and seconded by Councillor Peter Mullineaux that the application be deferred to allow further dialogue to take place with the Applicant regarding design and highways provision. It was requested that a review of how the School Lane and Golden Hill Lane junction would operate with additional right turn traffic from the site be provided by Lancashire County Council Highways. The vote on the Amended Motion was Yes: 7, No: 5 and Abstain: 2 and the Chair declared that the Amended Motion was carried. 115 07/2019/0458/HOH - 36 Howick Cross Lane, Penwortham Speakers: None Address: 36 Howick Cross Lane, Penwortham Applicant: Mr E Rampling Agent: Mr J Mulkerrin, 250 Dill Hall Lane, Accrington, BB5 4DG Development: First floor side extension above existing garage RESOLVED: (Unanimously) That the application be approved with conditions. Planning Committee Wednesday 6 March 2019 Page 6 3 116 07/2018/5820/OUT - Land at 448 Croston Road, Leyland Speakers: Councillor Michael Green Address: Land at 448 Croston Road, Farington Moss, Leyland, PR26 6PJ Applicant: Mr and Mrs Mark and Denise Chamberlain Agent: Mr David Poole, Hollandia, Greta Urswick, Ulverston, LA12 0SP Development: Outline application for residential development of 12no. dwellings with all matters reserved. RESOLVED: (Unanimously) That the application be refused for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development would result in piecemeal development which would not integrate well with the wider proposal for the comprehensive development of ‘Site W’. The proposal is therefore contrary to the requirements of Policy C3 of the South Ribble Local Plan. 2. The submission fails to demonstrate that a residential development can be accommodated on the site without appearing ‘shoe-horned in’, to the detriment of the character and appearance of the area. The proposal is therefore contrary to Policy 17 of the Core Strategy and Policy G17 of the South Ribble Local Plan. 3. The submission fails to demonstrate that a residential development on the site can be accessed without resulting in an unacceptable impact on highway safety. The proposal is therefore contrary to para. 109 of the NPPF and Policy G17 of the South Ribble Local Plan.