Sandy Lake Tragedy, to Washington, D.C

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Sandy Lake Tragedy, to Washington, D.C Mikwendaagoziwag Timber, Minerals, and Treaties Recognizing indigenous bands as sovereign nations in Memorial at Sandy Lake Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Upper Michigan, the Mikwendaagoziwag in Ojibwe means: United States made treaties with the Ojibwe (Chippewa) We remember them. of the Lake Superior region to gain access to the land and the natural resources. One hundred and fifty years after the Sandy Lake Dominated by massive pine forests, wetlands, and tragedy, the descendants of the 1850 annuity bands gath- rugged terrain, there was little interest from white ered to dedicate a memorial to those who suffered and Americans in settling this region. United States lead- died. Perched on a glacial mound overlooking Sandy Lake, ers, however, sought raw materials like timber, copper, the Mikwendaagoziwag Memorial is situated near the rest- and iron ore to fuel western expansion and engaged ing places of the Ojibwe of 1850. The memorial stands as Indian leaders to push for land acquisitions. a tribute and invites visitors to ref lect on the past. In 1837, Ojibwe chiefs and government officials met The following 12 tribes, as modern–day successors to near present-day St. Paul, resulting in the sale, or ces- the 1850 annuity bands, helped to design and fund the sion, of 13 million acres in east-central Minnesota and memorial: northern Wisconsin. The transaction was contingent on the Ojibwe retaining rights to hunt, fish, and gather Annuity payment at Sandy Lake Indian Sub-Agency, 1850. Minnesota on the newly ceded territory. These reserved rights are commonly called "treaty rights." An additional provi- Fond du Lac Band sion to the treaty required the United States to make Attempted Removal Grand Portage Band annual payments called annuities to band members for to Minnesota Leech Lake Band 25 years. Annuity payments generally included cash, Mille Lacs Band food, and everyday utility items. Most Wisconsin and Upper Michigan Ojibwe bands Five years later, Ojibwe headmen and government rep- which negotiated the 1837 and 1842 Treaties received Michigan resentatives agreed upon a 10-million-acre land cession their annuities by early autumn at La Pointe on Made- Keweenaw Bay Indian that included portions of northern Wisconsin and Upper line Island–a cultural and spiritual center for Ojibwe Community Michigan. The treaty opened the south shore of Lake people. Some government officials in the Minnesota Superior to lumberjacks, along with iron and copper min- Territory, however, wanted the distribution site moved Lac Vieux Desert Band ers. Similar to the previous 1837 arrangement, the 1842 out of Wisconsin in order to reap the economic benefits Treaty guaranteed the Ojibwe's hunting, fishing and of a large, concentrated Indian population. Wisconsin gathering rights and promised annuity distributions. Territorial Governor and Superintendent of Indian Bad River Band Affairs in Minnesota, Alexander Ramsey, worked with Lac Courte Oreilles other officials to remove the Ojibwe from their homes Band in Wisconsin and Upper Michigan to Sandy Lake, Lac du Flambeau Band known to the Ojibwe as Gaamiitawangagaamag. The Red Cliff Band f low of annuity money and government aid to build St. Croix Band Indian schools, agencies, and farms would create wealth Sokaogon Band for Ramsey and his supporters in Minnesota. Pressured by Ramsey and others, United States Pres- ident Zachary Taylor issued an executive order in Febru- ary 1850 that sought to move Ojibwe Indians living east of the Mississippi River to their unceded lands. Initially For more information stunned by the breach of the 1837 and 1842 Treaty contact GLIFWC: P.O. Box 9 terms, Ojibwe leaders recognized that the removal order Odanah, WI 54861 clearly violated their agreement with the United States. Phone: 715-682-6619 Soon, a broad coalition of supporters–missionary E-mail: [email protected] groups, newspapers, businessmen, and Wisconsin state Web site: www.glifwc.org Ojibwe land ceded to the United States through the treaties legislators–rallied to oppose the removal effort, and of 1837, 1842 and 1854. band members refused to abandon their homes. The Tragedy of 1850-51 The Sandy Lake Legacy A delegation of Ojibwe chiefs and headmen traveled Two years later when the United States sought President Taylor's removal order had failed. Never- In the years following the Sandy Lake tragedy, to Washington, D.C. in the spring of 1852 to protest Ojibwe land in Minnesota's Arrowhead region, the theless, Ramsey and Indian Sub-agent John Watrous Ojibwe bands and their non-Indian supporters vigor- Ramsey's removal efforts and the needless suffering Ojibwe of the Lake Superior region agreed to cede more had a scheme to lure these Ojibwe into Minnesota and ously opposed further attempts at removal from Wis- that occurred at Sandy Lake. Led by Chief Buffalo of La territory in exchange for permanent reservations in trap them there over the winter. They informed band consin and Upper Michigan. Newspaper editors and Pointe, who was well into his 90s, the Ojibwe requested Upper Michigan and Wisconsin through the Treaty of members that the treaty annuity distribution site had missionaries rallied public support for the Ojibwe. an official end to removal efforts. After meeting with 1854. Driven by the events at Sandy Lake and a love for changed from La Pointe to Sandy Lake, some 285 Ramsey and Watrous tried again to bring the bands to tribal leaders, President Millard Fillmore agreed to the homeland and graves of their forefathers, these canoe miles to the west. If the Ojibwe hoped to receive Sandy Lake in 1851, but were rebuffed by survivors who rescind the removal order and pledged that overdue Ojibwe were resolved to stay in their traditional villages. anything that year, they were instructed to be at Sandy called the annuity payment site a "graveyard." and future annuities would be made at La Pointe. Lake by October 25, 1850. Ceded Lands in the 21st Century While band members from Michigan and some Few American Indian tribes successfully reserved eastern reaches of Wisconsin refused to travel with Ojibwe Country, 1850: Western Lake Superior Region hunting, fishing, and gathering rights on land they winter fast approaching, more than 5,500 Ojibwe jour- ceded. Only those Ojibwe tribes who participated in neyed to Sandy Lake that autumn. They arrived the 1837, 1842, and 1854 treaties retain those rights fatigued and hungry after the arduous journey, only to to harvest natural resources in Michigan, Wisconsin, find no one there to distribute the supplies. Wild game and Minnesota as recognized by federal courts. Ojibwe was scarce, fishing was poor, and high water had wiped Indians continue to hunt, fish, and harvest wild plants out the local wild rice crop for the second consecutive within the ceded territory boundaries. With the assis- year. For the weary tance of intertribal agencies like the Great Lakes travelers and those "Frequently seven or eight Indian Fish & Wildlife Commission, Ojibwe tribes co- Ojibwe who resided at manage these natural resources with states and the died in a day. Coffins could Sandy Lake, living not be procured, and often federal government. conditions deteriorated the body of the deceased was wrapped up in a piece rapidly. of bark and buried slightly Over a six-week under ground. All over the period as harsh winter cleared land graves were to conditions set in, band be seen in every direction, members waited near for miles distant, from the newly establish- Sandy Lake." ed Indian sub–agency. -Rev. John H. Pitezel, Without adequate food Methodist Episcopal missionary or shelter, disease and exposure ravaged Ojib- we families. More than 150 died at Sandy Lake from complications caused by dysentery and the measles. A partial annuity payment was finally completed on December 2, providing the Ojibwe with a meager three-day food supply and no cash to buy desperately Present-day Band Reservations needed provisions. The following day most of the Ojibwe broke camp, while a few people stayed behind Ojibwe Villages Mid-1800s to care for those too ill to travel. With the canoe routes Rivers / Streams frozen and over a foot of snow on the ground, families walked hundreds of miles to get back home. Another Lakes Public lands within the ceded territories provide Ojibwe people with limited harvest opportunities. 250 died on that bitter trail, and the Ojibwe vowed This map shows both historic and current Ojibwe communities. Ojibwe people traveled by birchbark canoes to Sandy never to abandon their villages in Wisconsin and Lake in the fall of 1850 and were forced to walk during the winter to get back home. (GLIFWC at LICGF) Upper Michigan for Sandy Lake..
Recommended publications
  • Ashi-Niswi Giizisoog (Thirteen Moons)
    Page 16 | Nah gah chi wa nong • Di bah ji mowin nan |July 2018 Ashi-niswi giizisoog (Thirteen Moons) The new Aabita-Niibino-giizis, Mid-summer moon, begins July 13th. Other names for this moon are Aabita-Niibino-giizis Miini-giizis, Blueberry Moon; Miskomini-giizis, Raspberry moon and Baashkawe’o-giizis, Flying moon. Mikwendaagoziwag Memorial at Sandy Lake-We Remember Them ne hundred and Upper Michigan, the United generally included cash, food, a large, concentrated Indian refused to abandon their fifty years after the States made Treaties with the and everyday utility items. population. Territorial Governor homes. OSandy Lake tragedy, Ojibwe (Chippewa) of the Lake Five years later, Ojibwe and Superintendent of Indian the descendants of the 1850 Superior region to gain access headmen and government Affairs in Minnesota, Alexander The Tragedy of 1850-51 annuity Bands gathered to the land and the natural representatives agreed upon Ramsey, worked with other President Taylor's removal to dedicate a memorial to resources. a 10-million-acre land cession officials to remove the Ojibwe order had failed. Nevertheless, those who suffered and died. Dominated by massive pine that included portions of from their homes in Wisconsin Ramsey and Indian Sub-agent Perched on a glacial mound forests, wetlands, and rugged northern Wisconsin and and Upper Michigan to Sandy John Watrous had a scheme overlooking Sandy Lake, the terrain, there was little interest Upper Michigan. The Treaty Lake, known to the Ojibwe to lure these Ojibwe into Mikwendaagoziwag Memorial from white Americans in opened the south shore of as Gaamiitawangagaamag. Minnesota and trap them is situated near the resting settling this region.
    [Show full text]
  • Salvage Tourism in American Indian Historical Pageantry A
    “We All Have a Part to Play”: Salvage Tourism in American Indian Historical Pageantry A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY KATRINA MARGARET-MARIE WILBER PHILLIPS IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Adviser: JEAN O’BRIEN MAY 2015 Acknowledgements I am, like my father, often stubborn and independent. However, as I have been reminded time and time again throughout this humbling and gratifying journey, I just can’t do it alone. First and foremost, there is my adviser, Jeani O’Brien, who has read every single word I have ever written – many of them multiple times over. I am eternally grateful for the ways in which she has motivated me, encouraged me, and guided me throughout my graduate school career. I can never repay her for the time she has dedicated to me, and I thank you from the bottom of my heart. David Chang has pushed me to challenge myself and expand my horizons, which has made me a better scholar. I thank David as well as Kat Hayes for serving as my reviewers, and their feedback was instrumental in shaping this final product. Kevin Murphy and Brenda Child have also kindly served on my committees, and I truly appreciate their time and insight. Barbara Welke’s comments during my preliminary exams urged me to look beyond the scope of my initial research. Any errors in the final product, though, are mine and mine alone. The American Indian and Indigenous Studies Workshop has been my academic home since my first year of graduate school – and special thanks to Boyd Cothran, who helped me with my senior undergraduate thesis and my graduate school applications.
    [Show full text]
  • Educator Guide for Grades 6-12
    Educator Guide for Grades 6-12 Treaty Economy A partnership of the Minnesota Indian Affairs Council and the Minnesota Humanities Center Suggested for use with Why Treaties Matter: Self Government in the Dakota and Ojibwe Nations BANNER TITLE BANNER # • Treaty Making in America 5 • U.S. – American Treaties in Minnesota 6 • Ojibwe Rights Retained 8 • Defending Treaty Rights in the 20th Century 14 • Respecting and Managing Natural Resources 17 • Sovereignty Through Economic Development 18 Why Treaties Matter educator guides are intended as supplementary resources for your curriculum or stand-alone as lessons. This guide contains estimates of preparation and instructional time, a materials list, background information, preview strategies, assessment options, extension activities, a vocabulary list, web resources, bibliography, and related reading. PREPARATION TIME Two hours depending on previous familiarity with the subject INSTRUCTIONAL TIME Two or three class periods depending on the number of activities selected MATERIALS • The Sandy Lake Tragedy video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6VaiLfy3CE, or order the DVD at http:// glifwc.org/publications/index.html) • Sandy Lake Tragedy study questions (Appendix A) and suggested answers (Appendix B) • Student Reading: “Treaty Economy” (Appendix C) • Study Questions: “Treaty Economy” (Appendix D) and suggested answers (Appendix E) • Student Activity: Minnesota Indian Nations Websites (Appendix F) • Vocabulary List (Appendix G) • Paper, pencils, markers 2 TEACHER BACKGROUND The Treaty Economy lesson begins where the Traditional Anishinaabe Economy ended. The lesson covers two periods in Ojibwe history: the Treaty Period (1837-1868 in Minnesota) and the economy in modern times (1975-present). The traditional economy did not end abruptly, and some modern Ojibwe in Minnesota continue to practice trapping for furs, fishing, hunting, gathering, and harvesting on limited tribal lands.
    [Show full text]
  • Contested Ecosystems and Expanding Tribal Jurisdiction in the Great Lakes Region
    Multiple Sovereigns and Transient Resources: Contested Ecosystems and Expanding Tribal Jurisdiction in the Great Lakes Region A Dissertation SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Laura M. Matson IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Dr. Bruce Braun & Dr. George Henderson October 2018 © Laura M. Matson 2018 Acknowledgements It seems appropriate to begin this dissertation with Acknowledgements, because it this dissertation was produced by each of these people—their guidance, feedback, ideas, edits, interviews, and support. At its root, this is a dissertation about how communities— and their laws—are shaped, negotiated, and philosophically rooted. I would not have been able to produce this work, or any of the logistical, empirical, or intellectual efforts that went into it, without the many people who contributed. First, I must thank my PhD Committee. Co-advisers Bruce Braun and George Henderson were instrumental in shepherding my intellectual development and have consistently encouraged me to push the limits of my thinking on many of the issues I explore in this dissertation. I am tremendously grateful for their support, guidance, and generosity throughout this process. Throughout law school and my PhD study, John Borrows has steadfastly been one of my most influential mentors. I first studied with John in a Tribal Courts class at the University of Minnesota Law School in the fall of 2011; that course lit a fire that set me on the path that I am on today. I am also indebted to the entire Borrows family for their kindness and hospitality. Though we did not get to know each other until later in my studies, David Wilkins’s prolific and important scholarship influenced my intellectual trajectory from the very beginning of my PhD research.
    [Show full text]
  • First Nations History 2019–2020 Mr. Ryan Description
    First Nations History 2019–2020 Mr. Ryan th Description of Course: This 11th/12 ​ grade social studies course is designed to ​ provide an understanding of the historical, cultural, political, and economic impact of Indian Nations on the state of Wisconsin and the entire United States. This course will not only explore First Nations history, but will extensively discuss ​ contemporary issues connected to American Indian Nations throughout our state and around the country within in each unit of study. The state of Wisconsin ​ mandated in 1990 that all public schools in the state of Wisconsin study Wisconsin tribal nation history, treaty rights, and tribal sovereignty issues at the high school level. This course will go far exceed the requirement outlined by this state law. We will explore events and their effects from both the native and non-native points of view. All students enrolled in this course will have the opportunity to receive three college credits through the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay. Students wishing to take this course for college credit will need to register the first week of September and enroll by the second week of the October. The cost of taking the class for 3 college credits is $300. Additionally, all students Prescott students enrolled in this course will have an opportunity to travel to the Lac Du Flambeau Indian Reservation from September 27th through September 30th and learn firsthand from experts about Ojibwe culture, history, and politics. Students will be required to: ​ A. Access information on the Internet throughout the semester. B. Bring a notebook and a writing utensil to class every day.
    [Show full text]
  • American Indian Education Program Library of Books, CD's & DVD's, and Other Resources Purchased by ISD 15 American Indian Education Program 2016
    American Indian Education Program Library of Books, CD's & DVD's, and Other Resources Purchased by ISD 15 American Indian Education Program 2016 Catagory Title Author Type Copies Comments Life/Culture The People of Minnesota: Ojibwe In Minnesota Book/soft 1 Life/Culture Ojibwe Ceremonies Book/soft 1 Life/Culture The Four Winds of Life: Ojibwe Wisdom Book/soft 1 Life/Culture The Four Winds of Life: Ojibwe Wisdom Book/hard 1 Life/Culture Celebrating the Powwow Book/soft 1 Life/Culture Powwow Summer Book/soft 3 Life/Culture Life in an Anishinabe Camp Book/soft 2 Life/Culture Nations of the Eastern Great Lakes Book/soft 1 Life/Culture Native Homes Book/soft 1 Life/Culture Life in a Longhouse Village Book/soft 1 Life/Culture Nations of the Western Great Lakes Book/soft 1 Life/Culture Food Is Medicine: Recovering Traditional Foods to Heal the People Book/Soft 1 Life/Culture Nature's Way: Native Wisdom For Living In Balance with the Earth Book/Soft 2 1 signed copy Life/Culture Women of the earth Lodges: Tribal Life on the Plains Book/Soft signed copy Life/Culture How to Track and Find game Book/Soft 1 Life/Culture Light of the Feather: A Teacher's Journey Into Native Ameican Book/Soft 1 Classroom and Culture Life/Culture Creator's Code: Planetary Survival and Beyond Book/Soft 2 Life/Culture Dakota: A Spiritual Geography Book/Soft 1 Life/Culture Kitchi Onigaming: A History of Grand Portage and Its People Book/Soft 1 Life/Culture Dibaajimowinan: Anishinabe Stories of Culture and Respect Book/Soft 1 includes CD Life/Culture Indian Clothing of the
    [Show full text]
  • Tribal Relations Strategic Framework 2015 United States Department of Agriculture for the Eastern Region, Northeastern Area and Northern Research Station
    Tribal Relations Strategic Framework 2015 United States Department of Agriculture for the Eastern Region, Northeastern Area and Northern Research Station Tribal Relations Strategic Framework for the Eastern Region, Northeastern Area State & Private Forestry, and Northern Research Station–2015 A desk guide compendium for line officers and field managers for the administration of the federal Indian trust responsibility and treaty obligations as it relates to the delivery of Forest Service programs, products and services to American Indian tribes and Native communities. The Framework is intended to guide program delivery for the next three to five years; its objective is to achieve consistent application of and adherence to the laws and policies governing our relationships with federally recognized tribes. Forest Eastern Northeastern Area Northern Service Region State & Private Forestry Research Station Grey Towers Forest Products Law Enforcement National Historic Site Laboratory and Investigations [This page intentionally left blank] The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Forest Service is a diverse organization committed to equal opportunity in employment and program delivery. USDA prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, religion, age, disability, political affiliation, and familial status. Persons believing they have been discriminated against should contact the Secretary, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington D.C. 20250, or call 202-720-7237 (voice), or 202-720-1127 (TTY). Tribal Relations
    [Show full text]
  • The Murder of Joe White: Ojibwe Leadership and Colonialism in Wisconsin
    The Murder of Joe White: Ojibwe Leadership and Colonialism in Wisconsin A Dissertation SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Erik M. Redix IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Co-advisors: Brenda Child, American Studies Jean O’Brien, History November 2012 © Erik M. Redix, 2012 Acknowledgements This dissertation is the direct result of the generous support of many individuals who have shared their expertise with me over the years. This project has its roots from when I first picked up William Warren’s History of the Ojibwe People as a teenager. A love of Ojibwe history was a part of family: my great-aunt, Caroline Martin Benson, did exhaustive genealogical research for our family; my cousin, Larry Martin, former Chair of American Indian Studies at the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire, showed me the possibilities of engaging in academia and has always been very warm and gracious in his support of my career. Entering college at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, I was anxious to learn more about Native people in North America and Latin America. I would like to give thanks to Florencia Mallon for her generous support and mentorship of my Senior Thesis and throughout my time at Madison; she was always there to answer the many questions of a curious undergrad. I am also indebted to Ned Blackhawk, Patty Loew, and Rand Valentine for taking the time to support my intellectual growth and making a big university seem much smaller. After graduation, I returned home to work at Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwe Community College (LCOOCC), and eventually served as Chair of the Division of Native American Studies.
    [Show full text]
  • The Sandy Lake Tragedy: Too Long Forgotten, a Delayed Commemoration Mariah J. Ring History 489: Senior Thesis November 2015 Copy
    The Sandy Lake Tragedy: Too Long Forgotten, A Delayed Commemoration Mariah J. Ring History 489: Senior Thesis November 2015 Copyright for this work is owned by the author. This digital version is published by the McIntyre Library, University of Wisconsin – Eau Claire with consent of the author. Contents Abstract iii Maps and Images iv Introduction 1 History of the McGregor Lakes Region 3 The Tragedy 7 Important Treaties 11 What Happened Next 14 Commemoration 17 Conclusion 23 Works Cited 26 ii Abstract The Sandy Lake tragedy was essentially a Chippewa Trail of tears, when the attempted forced removal of Ojibwe Indians from Upper Michigan and Wisconsin were sent to Sandy Lake Minnesota to collect their annuity payments leading to the deaths of some 400 Ojibwe men women and children. This event that long went without Commemoration. For 150 years it went forgotten by many, and is still not something widely discussed or known about today. This paper outlines the history of the McGregor lakes region, the treaties that transpired before and after the tragedy, and the tragedy itself. Through a description of the memorial and interviews of both white and Native American cultural groups, this paper analyzes sentiments towards the memorial, the history of the event, and the general public’s knowledge of what happened there prior to the memorial. iii Figures Figure 1 – Map of Sandy Lake 4 Figure 2 – Map of Minnesota Showcasing Aitkin County 7 Figure 3 – Alexander Ramsey 8 Figure 4 – Zachary Taylor 9 Figure 5 – Map of Ceded Territories from Treaties
    [Show full text]
  • Ojibwe Treaty Rights
    Ojibwe Treaty Rights 3 2 Great Lakes Indian 7 Fish & Wildlife Commission 6 5 1 PO Box 9 Odanah, WI 54861 715.682.6619 4 11 9 10 www.glifwc.org 8 2018 cover.indd 1 9/20/18 9:13 AM Symbolic Petition of Chippewa Chiefs, 1849 During the late 1840s, rumors circulated that the Chippewa (Ojibwe) Indians who inhabited lands south of Lake Superior were destined to be removed from their homes and sent to territories west of the Mississippi River, now Minnesota. In 1849 a Chippewa delegation traveled to Washington to petition Congress and President James K. Polk to guarantee the tribe a permanent home in Wisconsin. These delegates carried this symbolic petition with them on their journey. The animal figures represent the various “doodems,” as determined by family lineage, whose representatives made the historic appeal. Other images represent some features of the tribe’s beloved north woods. Lines connect the hearts and eyes of the various doodems to a chain of wild rice lakes, signifying the unity of the delegation’s purpose. This pictograph, originally rendered by the Chippewa on the inner bark from a white birch tree, was redrawn by Seth Eastman and appears in Henry Rowe Schoolcraft’s Historical and Statistical Information Respecting the History, Condition, and Prospects of the Indian Tribes of the United States, Vol. 1 (1851). The following legend details the pictograph’s numbered images and what they represent: 1. Osh-ca-ba-wis—Chief and leader of the delegation, representing the Crane doodem. 2. Wai-mi-tig-oazh—He of the Wooden Vessel, a warrior of the Marten doodem.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 9 Tribal Resources
    Chapter 9 Tribal Resources Chapter 9 Tribal Resources 9.1 INTRODUCTION Impacts analyzed within an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) generally rely heavily on quantitative data and a western worldview of science and its applications (Dongoske et al. 2015). Using western scientific methods to evaluate environmental impacts “fails to consider and incorporate Native American perspectives of, values about, and relationships with the environment.” The goal of this chapter is to provide an alternative, qualitative measure of the impact of Enbridge’s proposed Line 3 Replacement Project (Project) on American Indians. This chapter employs a methodology that frames the discussion to reflect American Indian perceptions of the environment and the impacts associated with constructing a pipeline through an area of traditional, cultural, spiritual, and natural resource significance. Impacts are discussed in the preceding chapters of the EIS, including impacts on reservation lands, treaty lands, resources that hold tribal significance such as wild rice and water resources, and climate change. To fully understand and appreciate the impacts of the proposed Project and its alternatives on American Indian communities and cultures, qualitative and quantitative discussions are necessary. The differences between these approaches highlights the unique impacts on tribal communities and tribal members. American Indian traditions are interwoven into the ecosystems in which they live, from subsistence gathering to sacred sites—all places that have spiritual and artistic meaning. For example, wild rice has important cultural ties to local traditions, spiritual fulfillment, and more. “Culturally important ecosystem services often cannot be measured in pounds, gallons, acres, or kilowatts” (Fletcher and Christin 2015). This chapter identifies tribal resources and details their importance to the survival of tribal traditional ways.
    [Show full text]
  • Approval of the Keweenaw Bay Indian Community's Application For
    U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGION 5 DECISION DOCUMENT: APPROVAL OF THE KEWEENAW BAY INDIAN COMMUNITY’S APPLICATION FOR TREATMENT IN A SIMILAR MANNER AS A STATE FOR THE CLEAN WATER ACT SECTIONS 303(c) WATER QUALITY STANDARDS AND 401 CERTIFICATION PROGRAMS April 2020 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents I. Introduction and Index to the EPA Decision .......................................................................................... 4 A. Introduction .......................................................................................................................................... 4 B. Index to the EPA Decision ................................................................................................................... 5 1. Application and Supporting Materials ........................................................................................... 5 2. Letters and Related Documents to/from the EPA ........................................................................ 5 3. Comments on the Tribe’s Application ........................................................................................... 5 4. Statutory and Regulatory Provisions .............................................................................................. 6 5. Policy Statements ............................................................................................................................. 6 II. Requirements for Program Eligibility Approval................................................................................
    [Show full text]