Statement in Support of Overturning Buckley V. Valeo in Its 1976

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Statement in Support of Overturning Buckley V. Valeo in Its 1976 Statement in Support of Overturning Buckley v. Valeo In its 1976 decision, Buckley v. Valeo, the Supreme Court of the United States held that mandatory campaign spending limits are an unconstitutional denial of free speech. We believe that the Buckley decision should be overturned. The decision overstated the extent to which reasonable limits on campaign expenditures impinge on free speech. The Court also underestimated the corrosive effect of unlimited campaign expenditures on the integrity of our political process. We the undersigned call for the reconsideration and overturning of the Buckley decision. This statement was organized jointly by: Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law National Voting Rights Institute U.S. Public Interest Research Group 209 Scholars Opposing Buckley v. Valeo Prof. Lee A. Albert Prof. Robert Aronson Professor of Law Professor of Law SUNY at Buffalo School of Law University of Washington School of Law Prof. George J. Alexander Elizabeth H. & John A. Sutro Professor Prof. Gerald G. Ashdown & Director, Institute of International & Professor of Law Comparative Law West Virginia University College of Santa Clara University School of Law Law Prof. Dean Alfange, Jr. Prof. Gordon E. Baker Professor of Political Science Professor Emeritus of Political Science University of Massachusetts at Amherst, University of California at Santa Barbara Political Science Dept. Prof. Thomas E. Baker Prof. Francis A. Allen James Madison Chair in Constitutional Huber C. Hurst Eminent Scholar Law and Director of the Constitutional Emeritus Law Resource Center University of Florida, College of Law Drake University Law School Prof. José Julián Alvarez González Prof. Fletcher N. Baldwin, Jr. Professor of Law S.D. Dell Research Scholar & Professor University of Puerto Rico School of Law of Law University of Florida, College of Law Prof. Howard C. Anawalt Professor of Law Prof. William C. Banks Santa Clara University School of Law Professor of Law Syracuse University College of Law Prof. Claudia Angelos Professor of Clinical Law Prof. Loftus E. Becker, Jr. New York University School of Law Professor of Law University of Connecticut School of Prof. Ellen P. April Law Professor of Law Loyola University School of Law Prof. Patricia A. Behlar Associate Professor of Social Science Prof. Peter Arenella Pittsburg State University Professor of Law UCLA School of Law Prof. Robert W. Benson Professor of Law Loyola University School of Law Scholars Opposing Buckley v. Valeo Cont. Page 2 Prof. Gary L. Blasi Prof. Sarah E. Burns Professor of Law Professor of Clinical Law UCLA School of Law New York University School of Law Prof. Vincent A. Blasi Prof. William G. Buss David Lurton Massee, Jr. Professor Of O.K. Patton Professor of Law Law University of Iowa College of Law University of Virginia School of Law Prof. Richard M. Buxbaum Prof. Henry J. Bourguignon Jackson H. Ralston Professor & Dean, Professor of Law & Distinguished International & Area Studies University Professor University of California at Berkeley University of Toledo College of Law School of Law Prof. Craig M. Bradley Prof. Bert C. Buzan James Louis Calamaras Professor of Professor of Political Science Law California State University, Fullerton Indiana University School of Law, Bloomington Prof. Paulette M. Caldwell Professor of Law Prof. Mark E. Brandon New York University School of Law Assistant Professor of Political Science University of Michigan Prof. Lief H. Carter McHugh Family Distinguished Prof. Daan Braveman Professor Dean & Professor of Law The Colorado College Syracuse University College of Law Prof. Paul G. Chevigny Prof. Richard A. Brisbin, Jr. Professor of Law Associate Professor of Political Science New York University School of Law West Virginia University Prof. Robert N. Clinton Prof. Judith Olans Brown Wiley B. Rutledge Professor Professor of Law University of Iowa College of Law Northeastern University School of Law Prof. Joshua Cohen Prof. G. Sidney Buchanan Arthur & Ruth Sloan Professor of Baker & Botts Professor of Law Political Science & Professor of University of Houston Law Center Philosophy Massachusetts Institute of Technology Prof. Thomas D. Buckley Professor of Law Prof. William Cohen Cleveland State University, Cleveland- C. Wendell & Edith M. Carlsmith Marshall College of Law Professor of Law Stanford Law School Scholars Opposing Buckley v. Valeo Cont. Page 3 Prof. Charles D. Cole Prof. David F. Dickson Lucille Beeson Professor Professor of Law Cumberland School of Law of Samford Florida State University College of Law University Prof. Victoria J. Dodd Prof. C. Michael Comiskey Professor of Law Associate Professor of Political Science Suffolk University Law School Penn State, Fayette Campus Prof. Jameson W. Doig Prof. Robert A. Dahl Professor, Department of Politics & Sterling Professor Emeritus of Political Woodrow Wilson School Science Princeton University Yale University Prof. Dennis D. Dorin Prof. David J. Danelski Professor of Political Science Mary Lou & George Boone Centennial University of North Carolina at Professor Emeritus Charlotte Stanford University Prof. Norman Dorsen Prof. Perry Dane Stokes Professor of Law Professor of Law New York University School of Law Rutgers University School of Law, Camden Prof. Donald W. Dowd Professor of Law Prof. George Dargo Villanova University School of Law Professor of Law New England School of Law Prof. Rochelle C. Dreyfuss Professor of Law & Director of the Prof. Derek H. Davis Engelberg Center on Innovation Law & Director, J. M. Dawson Institute of Policy Church-State Studies New York University School of Law Baylor University School of Law Prof. J. D. Droddy Prof. Howard E. Davis Assistant Professor of Government Professor of Political Science Western Kentucky University Randolph-Macon College Prof. Melvyn R. Durchslag Prof. John A. Davis Professor of Law Professor Emeritus of Political Science Case Western Reserve University Law City College of the City University of School New York Prof. Ronald M. Dworkin Prof. John Denvir Frank H. Sommer Professor of Law Professor of Law New York University School of Law University of San Francisco School of Law Scholars Opposing Buckley v. Valeo Cont. Page 4 Prof. Peter D. Enrich Prof. Paula Galowitz Professor of Law Professor of Clinical Law Northeastern University School of Law New York University School of Law Prof. Michael Esler Prof. Daniel G. Gibbens Assistant Professor of Political Science Regents' Professor of Law Ohio Wesleyan University University of Oklahoma College of Law Prof. Daryl R. Fair Prof. Stephen Gillers Professor of Political Science Professor of Law The College of New Jersey New York University School of Law Prof. Antonio Fernos Prof. James M. Glaser Professor of Law Associate Professor of Political Science Inter American University Law School Tufts University Prof. Nancy H. Fink Prof. Alvin L. Goldman Professor of Law Dorothy Salmon Professor Brooklyn Law School University of Kentucky College of Law Prof. Edwin B. Firmage Prof. Roger L. Goldman Samuel D. Thurman Professor of Law Professor of Law University of Utah College of Law St. Louis University School of Law Prof. James E. Fleming Prof. Sheldon Goldman Associate Professor of Law Professor of Political Science Fordham University School of law University of Massachusetts at Amherst, Political Science Dept. Prof. Edward B. Foley Associate Professor of Law Prof. Leslie F. Goldstein The Ohio State University College of Unidel Professor of Political Science Law University of Delaware Prof. W. Ray Forrester Prof. Howard A. Gordon Professor of Law Professor Emeritus University of California, Hastings City Colleges of Chicago College of the Law Prof. Howard L. Greenberger Dean Arthur N. Frakt Professor of Law Dean New York University School of Law Widener University School of Law Prof. Benjamin Gregg Prof. Beatrice S. Frank Assistant Professor of Government Clinical Associate Professor University of Texas at Austin New York University School of Law Scholars Opposing Buckley v. Valeo Cont. Page 5 Prof. David L. Gregory Prof. Thomas P. Huff Professor of Law Lecturer in Law & Professor of St. John's University School of Law Philosophy University of Montana School of Law Prof. Martin Guggenheim Clinical Professor & Director, Clinical Prof. Joseph Richard Hurt & Advocacy Programs Dean & Professor of Law New York University School of Law Mississippi College School of Law Prof. Lani Guinier Prof. Stewart M. Jay Professor of Law Professor of Law University of Pennsylvania Law School University of Washington School of Law Prof. Samuel O. Gyandoh, Jr. Professor of Law Prof. John Paul Jones Temple University School of Law Professor of Law University of Richmond, T. C. Williams Prof. Michael G. Hagen School of Law Associate Professor of Government Harvard University Prof. Ronald Kahn Monroe Professor of Politics & Law Prof. Richard L. Hasen Oberlin College Associate Professor of Law Loyola University School of Law Prof. Stephen Kanter Professor of Law (Dean 1986-1994) Prof. Francis H. Heller Lewis & Clark Northwestern School of Roy A. Roberts Professor of Law & Law Political Science Emeritus University of Kansas School of Law Prof. Kenneth L. Karst David G. Price & Dallas P. Price Prof. Helen Hershkoff Professor of Law Assistant Professor of Law UCLA School of Law New York University School of Law Prof. Thomas A. Kazee Prof. Richard A. Hesse Professor of Political Science Professor of Law Davidson College Franklin Pierce Law Center Prof. Edward Kearny Prof. Philip B. Heymann Professor
Recommended publications
  • Sharon L. Davies
    SHARON L. DAVIES The Ohio State University Michael E. Moritz College of Law Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity Drinko Hall, Room 321 33 West 11th Avenue 55 West 11th Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43201 Columbus, Ohio 43210 Telephone: (614) 688-3389 Facsimile: (614) 292-2035 E-mail: [email protected] CURRENT EMPLOYMENT Executive Director, Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity, The Ohio State University January 2012 – present John C. Elam/Vorys Sater Professor of Law, Michael E. Moritz College of Law, The Ohio State University September 2011 – present OTHER EMPLOYMENT United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, New York, New York Assistant United States Attorney, Criminal Division August 1990 – February 1995 Lord Day & Lord, Barrett Smith, New York, New York Litigation Associate Summer 1988 – August 1990 Steptoe & Johnson, Washington, D.C. Litigation Associate Summer 1987 – Summer 1988 Lord Day & Lord, New York, New York Summer Associate Summer 1986 Rheinhardt & Shachter, Newark, New Jersey Summer Associate Summer 1985 TEACHING EXPERIENCE The Ohio State University, Michael E. Moritz College of Law, Columbus, Ohio John C. Elam/Vorys Sater Professor of Law – September 2011 to present John C. Elam/Vorys Sater Designated Professor of Law – December 2002 to 2011 Associate Dean for Faculty – January 2004 to June 2006: Professor of Law – August 2002 Associate Professor of Law – August 1999 Assistant Professor of Law – August 1995 to 1999 Principal Subjects: Criminal Law; Criminal Procedures; Evidence; Advanced Topic In Criminal Justice; Race and Law University of Michigan School of Law, Ann Arbor, Michigan Visiting Professor of Law – Fall Semester 2003 Subjects: Criminal Law; Advanced Topics in Criminal Justice (seminar) St Anne’s College, University of Oxford, Oxford, England The University of Oxford – Ohio State University Summer Law Program Associate Professor of Law – Summer 2001 Subject: Comparative Trial Practice EDUCATION Columbia University School of Law, New York, New York.
    [Show full text]
  • 2003 Catalog 8/14/03 8:58 AM Page 1
    2003 Catalog 8/14/03 8:58 AM Page 1 Hamilton College Catalogue 2003-04 Hamilton College Calendar, 2003-04 2 History of the College 3 Academic Information College Purposes and Goals 5 Academic Programs and Services 8 Academic Regulations 16 Honors 30 Postgraduate Planning 32 Enrollment Admission 34 Tuition and Fees 38 Financial Aid 41 General Information Campus Buildings and Facilities 44 Student Life 49 Campus Cultural Life 53 Athletic Programs and Facilities 57 Courses of Instruction Course Descriptions and 59 Requirements for Concentrations and Minors Appendices Scholarships, Fellowships and Prizes 217 Federal and State Assistance Programs 247 The Trustees 251 The Faculty 253 Officers,Administration, Staff and Maintenance & Operations 272 Enrollment 281 Degree Programs 282 Family Educational Rights 283 Index 285 August 2003 Clinton, New York 13323 Printed on recycled paper 2003 Catalog 8/14/03 8:58 AM Page 2 Hamilton College Calendar, 2003-04 Aug. 26-30 Tuesday-Saturday New Student Orientation 30 Saturday Residence halls open for upperclass students, 9 am Sept. 1 Monday Fall semester classes begin, 8 am 5Friday Last day to add a course or exercise credit/no credit option, 2 pm Oct. 10 Friday Fall recess begins, 4 pm; Last day to declare leave of absence for Spring semester 2004 15 Wednesday Classes resume, 8 am 17-19 Friday-Sunday Fallcoming 24 Friday Last day to drop a course without penalty, 2 pm Nov. 7-9 Friday-Sunday Family Weekend 10-21 Monday-Friday Registration period for Spring 2004 courses (tentative) 25 Tuesday Thanksgiving recess begins, 4 pm Dec. 1 Monday Classes resume, 8 am 12 Friday Fall semester classes end 13-15 Saturday-Monday Reading period 16-21 Tuesday-Sunday Final examinations 22 Monday Residence halls close, noon Jan.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Download
    The International Newsletter of Communist Studies Online XV (2009), no 22 23 Kostis Karpozilos, University of Crete, Rethymno (Greece): Labor Unions, Radicalism and the Communist Left in the Greek-American Communities (1920-1950). PhD Project.1 The aim of my dissertation is the presentation of the activities of the Greek-American left focusing mainly on the 1930s, when they reached their peak due to a series of factors such as the new line of the Communist International, the New Deal, the Spanish Civil War and the emergence of the dictatorship of Metaxas in Greece. More particularly, I intend to demonstrate that the communist left arose as a considerable force within the Greek- American communities proposing a distinct cultural and political program that combined class-consciousness with the process of Americanization. This research sheds light onto a neglected aspect of the history of the Greek presence in the United States since it reveals considerable transformations and changes of allegiances within the communities. Even though the communist left was in no way the hegemonic force among Greek-Americans, a series of sources indicate that it enjoyed considerable support. My research is based mainly on primary sources of the Greek-American left, the newspapers Organosis (Organization), Fone tou Ergatou (Voice of the Worker), Empros (Forward) and Ellinoamerikaniko Vema (Greek-American Tribune), the journal Protoporos (Pioneer), the publications (books and pamphlets) of various parties and organizations in Greece and the archival collection of the Communist Party of the United States. Moreover, I have worked on files of the Greek embassy and consulates in the United States, which are now held in the archives of the Greek Foreign Ministry, while scattered documents of interest have been located in various other institutions in Greece.
    [Show full text]
  • NEWS of the American IDSTITUTE for Foreign TRADE
    NEWS OF �0 II ;31 UOt cl)o062 to be common mtttt. ;Jit iB mv rigl)t tn be uncommon - if ;lJ cttn. ;31 eeek oppor!ttnit!! - not "eruritl!. ;lJ lht not fui&q to be n kept citinn, l)umh!eh ttult ltulleh hi! l)tt\Jing tl)e etn!t look nfbr me. ;lJ funnt io tnlte tl)e cnlcultt!clt risk; to hrenm nnh to buill>, to fail nnb to :aut:cl'.eb. ,;31 refuee tn bnrbr incenti\.le for u: !tole. ;31 pnfer tl)e rl)nllenge& of life to tl)e gunrnnteeh exi&t.enre; tl)e tqril! of fulfillment tn tl)e lltttle cttlm of utopin. ;31 fuill not trttltt fruhom for bencfictttce nor mu ltigttit\! f,>r II l)nnltnut. ;lJ fuill ne\ltr cofuer he!Or2 lltrg mttster nor benlt to ""I! t1p-tnt. ;Jit iB mv l)eritnge to &tanh erect, prouh nnlt unnfrnil>; to tl)inlt nnh net for munlf, ertjol! tqe benefit of mv er.ntions anh to _fnce tqe fuorlh boll>lu unlt '"'11• t¥" ;31 qnlle l>ont. JI-ll tl)ie ie fuqnt it menne to be an Jl.merirttn. THE AmERICAn IDSTITUTE FOR FOREIGn TRADE THUNDERBIRD CAMPUS PHOENIX, ARIZONA PRESIDENT'S REPORTrttS•• October 17, 1962 Posted in his office for all to see, Dr. Schurz dis­ played a yellowed clipping he obviously treasured, for Before this semester began, I sent a letter to all the he lived by its sentiment. incoming students covering the faculty changes for the coming semester. I am sure this is of interest to you.
    [Show full text]
  • Alwood, Edward, Dark Days in the Newsroom
    DARK DAYS IN THE NEWSROOM DARK DAYS in the NEWSROOM McCarthyism Aimed at the Press EDWARD ALWOOD TEMPLE UNIVERSITY PRESS Philadelphia Temple University Press 1601 North Broad Street Philadelphia PA 19122 www.temple.edu/tempress Copyright © 2007 by Edward Alwood All rights reserved Published 2007 Printed in the United States of America Text design by Lynne Frost The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of the American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1992 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Alwood, Edward. Dark days in the newsroom : McCarthyism aimed at the press / Edward Alwood. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 13: 978-1-59213-341-3 ISBN 10: 1-59213-341-X (cloth: alk. paper) ISBN 13: 978-1-59213-342-0 ISBN 10: 1-59213-342-8 (pbk.: alk. paper) 1. Anti-communist movements—United States—History—20th century. 2. McCarthy, Joseph, 1908–1957—Relations with journalists. 3. Journalists— United States—History—20th century. 4. Journalists—United States— Political activity—History—20th century. 5. Press and politics—United States—History—20th century. 6. United States—Politics and government— 1945–1953. 7. United States—Politics and government—1953–1961. I. Title. E743.5.A66 2007 973.921—dc22 2006034205 2 4 6 8 9 7 5 3 1 In Memoriam Margaret A. Blanchard Teacher, Mentor, and Friend Do the people of this land . desire to preserve those so carefully protected by the First Amendment: Liberty of religious worship, freedom of speech and of the press, and the right as freemen peaceably to assemble and petition their government for a redress of grievances? If so, let them withstand all beginnings of encroachment.
    [Show full text]
  • IEHILATH I LI LI .J
    rim 1 IEHILATH i LI LI .J .. i 117 East 85th Street — — New York City February 25, 1944 Adar 1, 5704 ANNUAL PURIM PARTY LISA SERGIO TO ADDRESS The friendliest synagogue gather¬ RAMAZ PARENTS ing of the year is the Annual Purim The well-known radio commen¬ Party. It is sponsored by the Men's tator, Lisa Sergio, will address the Club and Sisterhood and will be Ramaz Parents Council on Tuesday, held in the Social Hall, on Sunday Feb. 29, at 8:30 P.M. in the Social evening at 6 P.M., March 12. It is a Hall of the synagogue. Lisa Sergio is time when we meet in happy re¬ one of the best informed women of membrance of an historic Jewish tri¬ our generation and her interpreta¬ umph and gather with our loved tions of world events are deep and ones to celebrate. There will be a comprehensive. Ramaz parents and buffet supper and an exceptional ar¬ their friends will be welcome. ray of stage and radio talent. Each ADULT EDUCATION PROGRAM year sees the Social Hall crowded to PLANNED V3 capacity and as we are limited in A that respect, reservations should be program of Jewish studies for adults will be made immediately. The admission inaugurated next sea¬ son to a charge is $2.50 per person. All pro¬ according decision of the Board of Trustees. An outline of the ceeds go to charity. program was presented to the Board COOPER BAR MITZVAH by Rabbi Lookstein. The Board de¬ Lawrence Elihu Cooper, son of clared its intention to make the nec¬ Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 132, Issue 9 (The Sentinel, 1911
    AMERICA'S LARGEST ANGLO-JEWISH WEEKLY Vol. CXXXII, No, 9 Thursday, December 2, 1943 Price 10c per Copy-$3.00 a year DEMAND "PROVOCATIONS" CEASE. Soviet Press Hails American Zionist Emergency Council "Alienism" Laid Jewish Girl's Braver' To Jewish Committee Asks Removal of Palestine Officials London (JPS)-A Jewish girl par- New York (JPS) -The American tisan known simply as Gania has re- New York (JPS)-"The demonstra- from Africa, the statement charged, Jewish Committee's withdrawal from ceived high praise from the Soviet tions which took place in Tel Aviv are "the Palestine Administration has set the American Jewish Conference and press on her latest feat of blowing up the direct result of a series of increas- about creating an atmosphere in Pal- "its repudiation of the Jewish aspira- a German troop train near Minsk, kill- ingly provocative actions on the part estine calculated to provoke the Jews. tions in Palestine," are matters of ing several hundred officers and men. of the Palestine Administration," the ... The theory apparently is that the "great concern to the Christian world This is her fifth such action. American Zionist Emergency Council Middle East is in an explosive condi- and to all democratic people," it is Col. Aron Karik has been awarded said in a statement calling for the re- tion, that the fuse is all ready and that stated in an editorial by Kenneth Les- the order of the Patriotic War, and moval of the officials responsible. the Jews will apply the match to it. lie, editor of The Protestant, in the Sgts.
    [Show full text]
  • NEWS and NOTES During the Past Summer, Professor James W
    NEWS AND NOTES PERSONAL AND MISCELLANEOUS Compiled by the Managing Editor During the past summer, Professor James W. Garner, of the University of Illinois, delivered addresses before the Congress of American Nations in Paris and the Royal Institute of International Affairs in London, and served as a delegate to the World Congress on the Relations of Church https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms and State at Oxford. Dr. Carl B. Swisher, author of well-known biographical studies of Justice Field and Chief Justice Taney, entered upon his duties in Septem- ber as associate professor of political science at the Johns Hopkins Uni- versity. Professor Harold W. Stoke is on leave from the University of Nebraska for the year and during the period is with the Tennessee Valley Authority as supervisor of training in public administration. Dr. George R. Sherrill, formerly of Clemson College, has been made head of a newly established department of government at the University of South Carolina. Dr. Sherrill is author of Criminal Justice in North Carolina and co-author of a recent biography of Clemson, the founder of , subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at Clemson College. Professor John M. Pfiffner, of the University of Southern California, is on sabbatical leave during the present semester and is devoting his time to gathering materials, in Chicago and Washington, on research techniques in public administration. 02 Oct 2021 at 10:13:18 Professor Roscoe G. Martin has resigned his position as professor of , on government at the University of Texas to accept appointment as head of the department of political science at the University of Alabama.
    [Show full text]
  • War Is Theme of AFL Convention by MAX D
    rent ~ u s □ 1 S t ' ™ ’ JUSTICE V ® tWTTFn STATfS fuUiiktd Ay Ike s - t s m ataO ftblklSO 5 £ => < INTERNATIONAL LADIES’ GARMENT WORKERS' UNION Vol. XXIV. No. 20. y Cily, N. J., October 15, 1942 Price 10 O n la War Is Theme of AFL Convention By MAX D. DANISH ITALIAN "ENEMY ALIEN" STIGMA IS LIFTED (S/ierial lo "Justice") IN UNITED STATES AS ANTONINI DRIVE BRINGS GOVERNMENT AND ROOSEVELT APPROVAL I | TORONTO, October 13—To those who either it ‘rom half way I discussion or public utterance are inclined to attach spec rid, the garment workers of A long drive to lift the stigma of “enemy alien" from 600,000; Australia have sent an invitation > industrial bolic significance to the fact that the first wartime conve utmaturali«d Italians living in the United States, a drive in' workers ot the United1tnd the the American Federation of Labor is taking place outside the United which First Vice President I.uigi Antonini with the full coopera- I States—in Toronto, Canada's second largest city and its biggest tiott of the 1LGWU played a leading role, came to a glorious he answer is simple and incisive: Toronto was picked as convention city by the Scattlr Convention of the AFL TORONTO................................ LOCALS.............“"in 5 October, 1941, two months before Pearl Harbor, aLaTiffle . imbus Day. October i: 2 :! IDLE GARMENT SHOPS rrss broadcast from co GIVE DOMINION prognosticators in r ; SEEN AS BENEFITING the United States still believed r FROM NEW DIRECTIVE BANNER TO ILG that the war was quite a d'ts- The employees who drew the sen- Ice Goldmine and Herbert Herc- nent Company, a sportswear man­ ufacturing company.
    [Show full text]
  • A PERSPECTIVE on the FREE SPEECH GUARANTEE Dean Alfange, Jr
    A PERSPECTIVE ON THE FREE SPEECH GUARANTEE Dean Alfange, Jr. “The New First Amendment” is an appropriate title for our gathering, for the free speech guarantee, despite the primacy of its position in the Bill of Rights, is, in practical effect, one of the newer additions to the Constitution. When I began teaching Constitutional Law, I could correctly tell my students that no act of Congress had ever been held unconstitutional as an abridgment of the freedom of speech. Yet today, some 40 years later, no term of the Supreme Court goes by without the invalidation of some number of federal laws on free speech grounds. And, 40 years ago, the various provisions of the First Amendment were not held to be directly applicable to the states, although the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment had, since 1925, been understood to incorporate the First Amendment’s free speech guarantee. Prior to then, the Due Process Clause had been held to have a substantive component that protected liberty, but the liberty it protected was limited principally, if not exclusively, to liberty of contract and did not encompass liberty of speech. Indeed, in 1922, in Prudential Insurance Co. v. Cheek, the Supreme Court categorically declared that “neither the Fourteenth Amendment nor any other provision of the Constitution of the United States imposes upon the states any restrictions about ‘freedom of speech.’” Prior to 1919, the Justices of the Supreme Court regarded with contemptuous disdain the very infrequent free speech claims that were presented to it--the lone exception being Justice Harlan, who, in an impassioned dissent in Patterson v.
    [Show full text]
  • Sharon L. Davies
    SHARON L. DAVIES The Ohio State University Michael E. Moritz College of Law Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race & Ethnicity Drinko Hall, Room 321 33 West 11th Avenue 55 West 12th Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43201 Columbus, Ohio 43210 Telephone: (614) 688-5429 (614) 688-3389 Facsimile: (614) 292-2035 E-mail: [email protected] CURRENT EMPLOYMENT Gregory H. Williams Chair in Civil Rights & Civil Liberties, Michael E. Moritz College of Law, The Ohio State University July 1, 2013 - present Executive Director, Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race & Ethnicity, The Ohio State University January 2012 – present OTHER EMPLOYMENT United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, New York, New York Assistant United States Attorney, Criminal Division August 1990 – February 1995 Lord Day & Lord, Barrett Smith, New York, New York Litigation Associate Summer 1988 – August 1990 Steptoe & Johnson, Washington, D.C. Litigation Associate Summer 1987 – Summer 1988 Lord Day & Lord, New York, New York Summer Associate Summer 1986 Rheinhardt & Shachter, Newark, New Jersey Summer Associate Summer 1985 TEACHING EXPERIENCE The Ohio State University, Michael E. Moritz College of Law, Columbus, Ohio Gregory H. Williams Chair in Civil Rights & Civil Liberties, July 1, 2013. John C. Elam/Vorys Sater Professor of Law – September 2011 to 2013 John C. Elam/Vorys Sater Designated Professor of Law – December 2002 to 2011 Associate Dean for Faculty – January 2004 to June 2006: Professor of Law – August 2002 Associate Professor of Law – August 1999 Assistant
    [Show full text]
  • Subject File
    A Guide to the Microfilm Edition of RESEARCH COLLECTIONS IN AMERICAN POLITICS Microforms from Major Archival and Manuscript Collections General Editor: William E. Leuchtenburg PRESIDENT HARRY S TRUMAN’S OFFICE FILES, 1945–1953 Part 3: Subject File UNIVERSITY PUBLICATIONS OF AMERICA A Guide to the Microfilm Edition of RESEARCH COLLECTIONS IN AMERICAN POLITICS Microforms from Major Archival and Manuscript Collections General Editor: William E. Leuchtenburg PRESIDENT HARRY S TRUMAN’S OFFICE FILES, 1945–1953 Part 3: Subject File Project Coordinators Gary Hoag Paul Kesaris Robert Lester Guide compiled by David W. Loving A microfilm project of UNIVERSITY PUBLICATIONS OF AMERICA An Imprint of CIS 4520 East-West Highway • Bethesda, Maryland 20814-3389 LCCN: 90-956100 Copyright© 1989 by University Publications of America. All rights reserved. ISBN 1-55655-152-5. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction ............................................................................................................................ v Scope and Content Note ....................................................................................................... xi Source and Editorial Note ..................................................................................................... xv Initialism List ......................................................................................................................... xvii Reel Index Reels 1–6 Agencies ................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]