Fordham Law Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fordham Law Review Volume 40 Issue 1 Article 1 1971 Judicial Removal in New York: A New Look Edwin L. Gasperini Arnold S. Anderson Patrick W. McGinley Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/flr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Edwin L. Gasperini, Arnold S. Anderson, and Patrick W. McGinley, Judicial Removal in New York: A New Look, 40 Fordham L. Rev. 1 (1971). Available at: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/flr/vol40/iss1/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by FLASH: The Fordham Law Archive of Scholarship and History. It has been accepted for inclusion in Fordham Law Review by an authorized editor of FLASH: The Fordham Law Archive of Scholarship and History. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Judicial Removal in New York: A New Look Cover Page Footnote *Members of the New York Bar. Mr. Gasperini received his A.B. cum laude from Williams College and his LL.B. cum laude from Harvard University. He is presently a member of the firm Gasperini, ochK & Savage, New York City. Mr. Anderson received his A.B. from the City College of New York and his J.D. from Columbia University. He is presently with the firm of Winthrop, Stimson, Putman & Roberts, New York City. Mr. McGinley received his A.B. from Iona College, his J.D. from Seton Hall University, and his LL.M. from New York University. He is presently with the firm of Gasperini, ochK & Savage. During 1970-71 the authors served as counsel and assistant counsel to Hon. Charles W. Froessel, Designee of the Appellate Division, Second Judicial Department, "In the Matter of an Inquiry Into Certain Acts and Transactions Concerning Mr. Justice Michael M. D'Auria." The authors wish to express their sincere appreciation to David J. Ciminesi and Jay N. Mailman of the Fordham Law Review, and to Edward Buchholz of the Colubmia Law School, for their invaluable research and drafting assistance in the preperation of this article. ** The inspiration for this article derives from an article in volume 39 of the Fordham Law Review entitled: "Impeaching Federal Judges: A Study of the Constitutional Provisions" by John D. Feerick. This article is available in Fordham Law Review: https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/flr/vol40/iss1/1 FORDHAM LAW REVIEW 1971-1972 VOLUME XL @ 1971, 1972 by Fordham University Press EDITORIAL BOARD THoms J. KAvALER Editor-in-Chief LAWRENCE J. GANNON RAYmOND A. SANSEVERINO Articles Editor Articles Editor DAVID J. Cnnw~s MARY C. DALY STACY J.HAIoNEY Case Notes Editor Book Reviews Editor Case Notes Editor Wnxix A. SuLLivAN, III MAXImmeAN J.. WELKER, JR. Comments Editor Comments Editor Ri HARD SELDIN GARY L. McMINiME Managing Editor Writing & Research Editor ASSOCIATE EDITORS MICHAML J. CLEARY JAY N. MAILMAN FRANK J. MARCO LESTER KUSHNER ROBERT J. MINYARD MEMBERS PAUL BOCMCCHIO RONALD S. HERZOG ROBERT J. RIED GARY L. BROOKS JoHN M. HumN JoHn D. RYAN PA~MA CB GA LAWRENCE J. LAARo PETER S. SACIIS Dzmrs F. CRONIN THEODORE H. LATTY Jomr J. SHAY, JR. JANE M. CUNNINGHAM ROBERT MEADE JoiMn W. SPoL. FRANK DIAz RiCHARD I. MILLER NEAL R. STOLL EDWARD W. DoYLE MCHAEL J. MONAGHAN Euc m J. SuL VA, JR. CHARLES M. DuaRoEN JOsEM W. MUCCIA JACOB SUsLovIcH JoHN EymwAN J=EY J. Mum=x ANDREW H. TANANDAU3M PATRICIA FARREN JoHN M. O'CoNNoR JAMES P. TRACY THOm s R. FrrzERALD, JR. CmARzs K. O'NEI ROBERTA L. Thoss HUGH D. F JoHN E. OSNATO R ARD VINDIONI ROBERT G. HAILE PAtnL J. OsTIjNG HOWARD I. WAss RONALD HELLER BARNET PeLIps, IV EDWARD H. WINKLER RAwmoND L. HERBERT CONSTANTN RALLI DANIIE F. ZENDE KEVIN C. REiLLY ANN V. SuL.uvAN Business Secretary EDITORIAL AND GENERAL OFFICES Lincoln Center, 140 West 62nd Street, New York, N.Y. 10023 Published four times a year-October, December, March, and May-by the Heffernan Press Inc., at 35 New St., Worcester, Massachusetts. Second class postage paid at Worcester, Mass. Member, National Conference of Law Reviews. SuBscR'ozTN PRICE $7.50, SINGLE Issuu $3.50. Make checks payable to FORDUIAM LAW REvIEW. Subscription renewed automatically unless notified to contrary. TABLE OF LEADING ARTICLES-TITLES ALLOCATION OF TH Psi or Loss IN THE TRANSPORTATION or FREIGHT-T=l Fu c non or INSuRANCr. Saul Sorkin .................................................. 67 THE COimINATIo OF FuNCrIoNs IN AsmassAmxrn Acn0Ns: AN ExAimATi0N or EuaRoFF AL rr i-vs. Ronald D. Rotunda ................................ 101 Coim=y. M nLn IsTRncr LzIATIO'0 ANnu = FrDERAL Cou srs.Stanley J. Levy ...... 41 CoNucrs BETwan SAm 's REmDIES Am WaREiq'Cs Com.rEsATioN AcTs. Arthur Larson ............................................................ 473 CoNscxanoN, T~m CoNsmuroN mm TH FRAmERS: Az; HISRCAL AnALysis. Michael J. M albin .................................................................. 805 THE CoNsTnoul-boNAL Rm= Or PUBLc ScHooL Purnrs. Richard Gyory ........... 201 THE ART OF FRmxnwG. Joseph G. Cook .......................................... 789 INDEPENDENT JvnIcIA Rrvmw or Anim,,STRATIVE RATS- MA=G: Tim Riss AND D Es or THE Ben Avon Docivmm Leslie A. Glick .......................... 305 INTERNATIONAL LAW AND TE PROInoN or THE Oc.ANs mROM PoLrLuoN. Ludwik A. Tecaff .................................................................. 529 JuDIcIAL R EovAL IN NEw YoRx: A NEw Lo=. Edwin L. Gasperini, Arnold S. Ander- son and Patrick W. McGinley .............................................. 1 TAE MIrRANT LABOR CA_r: ENcrvEs oF IsoLATION IN OuR Mmsr. Elizabeth J. duFresne and John J. McDonnell............................................. 279 THE RFcovyan Or A~ausmy's FRns: A NEw MEmOnD or FINANCING LzAL SERvicEs. Gerald T. McLaughlin ...................................................... 761 THm RELATIONSHp B=EEN CORPORATE DisCLosuRB AZn CoRPoRA RsPo.,smmnIT. Thomas J. Schoenbaum .................................................... 565 THE REQuIRE?ENT OF CORROBORATION IN PROSECUInONS FOR SEX OFrmSrS IN; Naw YoRK. Irving Younger ...................................................... 263 TABLE OF LEADING ARTICLES-AUTHORS Coox, JosE-- G., The Art of Frisking .......................................... 789 DuFRE-sN, Fznn J., .Nw McDoNNTXL, JoHN J., The Migrant Labor Camps: Enclaves of Isolation in Our Midst .......................................... 279 GAsPERINI, EDwIN L.; ANDERSON, AmxoxD S.; AND McGna.y, PATrIxC W., Judicial Removal in New York: A New Look ........................................ 1 GLIcx, LES= A., Independent Judicial Review of Administrative Rate-Making: The Rise and Demise of the Ben Avon Doctrine .................................... 105 GyoaT, RICHARD, The ConstitutionalRights of Public School Pupils .................. 201 LARsoN, ARTHuR, Conflicts Between Seamen's Remedies and Workmen's Compensation Acts ...................................................................... 473 Lvy, SrANxr J., Complex Multidistrict Litigation and the Federal Courts .......... 41 MAL I, MICHAEL J., Conscription, the Constitution and the Framers: An Historical Analysis ................................................................... sos MCLA 'G aN, GERA n T., The Recovery of Attorney's Fees: A New Method of Financ- ing Legal Services .......................................................... 761 RoTUNDA, RONAlD D., The Combination of Functions in Administrative Actions: An Examination of European Alternatives ........................................ 101 iv FORDHAM LAW REVIEW [Vol. 40 ScHoEsAum, THoms J., The Relationship Between Corporate Disclosure and Corpo- rate Responsibility .......................................................... 565 SORKNe, SAuL, Allocation of the Risk of Loss in the Transportation of Freight-The Function of Insurance ...................................................... 67 TEcLAFF, Ltmwix A., International Law and the Protection of the Oceans from Pollu- tion ...................................................................... 529 YoRNGER, IRvING, The Requirement of Corroborationin Prosecutions for Sex Offenses in New York .............................................................. 263 TABLE OF BOOKS REVIEWED BAum: TOWARD A FREE HOUSING M 4AsR=. Harold W. Young ...................... 445 CAPETITI: J-DticxA REv3Ew nT mm ColnzioRARY WORLD. Barry Hawk ............................ 1007 Joseph M. Perillo ....................... 1011 DUNSCOeNE: R. AsIAN AND Lrrro, RIGHTS. Richard C. Ausness ................ 185 GRNsPooN: MARIHuANA REcoNsmoRaD. Maureen Mileski .......................... 447 KEELEY: THE Lmr-LEANmro ANTE A. John B. Sherman .......................... 454 KRAuSE: IrzGrrnMAcY: LAW AN SOCIAL Poucy. Francis C. Cady .................. 733 LAY: TAX AND ESTATE PLANNING FOR COMMUNITY PROPERTY AND THE MIORANT CLIENT. Jack F. Bonanno .......................................................... 451 Lowi: THm PoLrxICs OF DisoxurD. Morton Gitelman .............................. 1014 NovAcx: DxmocRcy AND REvoLUToIN. Gardner Cromwell ...................... 742 PETERS: COMmERmCIAL TRANSACTIONS: CASES, TEXT AND PROBLFMS oN CONTRACTS DEAL- ING wrr PEmsOwALTY, REALTY AND SERvicEs. Frederick H. Miller ............. 746 R1cE: AuTHORTY Aim REBr-nuON. Robert M. Byrn ................................ 187 SCHOELD: THE STRANGE CASE or PoT. William A. Lovett ...................... 456 ScHwEBEL: THE ErPxwnviEss oF INTERNATIONAL DECISIONS: PAPERS AND PROCEED- INGs or THE AmERcAN SOCIETY oF INmNATIONAL LAW. F.L. Hartman .......... 1017 SEp: CREDIT REPORTING ja PRxvAcY: THE LAW IN CANADA AND THE U.S.A. Hon. John D. Caemmerer .................................................. 195 WALKER: CEnhis, COURTS AND FIGURES: