DOCSLIB.ORG

Don't Treat Autistic People Like They're a Problem, Because

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Don't Treat Autistic People Like They're a Problem, Because “Don't treat autistic people like they're a problem, because we're not!”: An exploration of what underpins the relationship between masking and mental health for autistic teenagers Louise Chapman D.Clin.Psy Thesis (Volume 1), 2020 University College London 1 UCL Doctorate in Clinical Psychology Thesis declaration form I confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources, I confirm that this has been indicated in the thesis. Signature: Name: Louise Chapman Date: 11th July 2020 2 Overview Autistic people have described masking, or ‘camouflaging’, parts of the self in order to avoid repeated bullying, discrimination, social rejection and in order to meet neuro-normative social expectations. This thesis explores the relationship between autistic people’s experiences of masking and mental health. This thesis is one of multiple UCL doctoral projects investigating masking in autistic teenagers. Part 1 is a conceptual introduction to autism, mental health and masking. Explanations for the increased prevalence of mental health difficulties for autistic people are explored. Masking is identified as a potential factor mediating this relationship. The review discusses different ways of conceptualising masking and explores the drivers and consequences of masking for autistic people. The review concludes with a summary of existing research into the relationship between masking and mental health difficulties. Part 2 is a qualitative study seeking to understand autistic teenager’s experiences of masking and how this relates to their mental health. Semi structured interviews were conducted with 20 autistic teenagers and transcripts were analysed using thematic analysis. Bidirectional relationships between masking and negative mental health related factors, and conversely between authenticity and positive mental health related factors, were described. Both processes were driven by social and environmental factors. The findings support a broader conceptualisation of masking and have implications for diagnostic and therapeutic clinical services. Part 3 is a critical appraisal of the research process. Personal reflexivity is used to consider the impact of the researcher’s perspective on the research. Introspection is used to identify broader theoretical perspectives to inform system- 3 level implications of the research. Reflections on the essentiality of co-production are also presented. 4 Impact Statement Academically, this study broadens the existing conceptualisation of autistic masking. It adds detailed qualitative descriptions from autistic teenagers about their experiences of masking. The sample includes 10 autistic teenagers who identified as male and 10 who identified as female which is particularly useful as previous research into masking has often focused on autistic girls. Previous research has identified that autistic teenagers are more likely to experience mental health difficulties and that there is a statistical association between masking and mental health. The current study identifies some of the factors and processes involved in these relationships. The current study also provides suggestions for improvements to academic teaching about autism, in order to change social narratives about autistic people. Outside of academia the current research has several clinical implications. As an understanding of masking develops, clinicians in autism diagnostic services can improve their identification of autistic young people who do not meet inadequate criteria or outdated clinical profiles. Diagnostic tools can also be improved according to a more detailed understanding of masking. The results of this study can also help to inform post-diagnostic support and information offered to families. It emphasises the importance of the information giving being non-pathologising and aiming to foster a positive autistic identity and support to identify environments likely to facilitate authentic expression and interactions. Additionally, this study has important implications for therapeutic interventions for autistic young people experiencing mental health difficulties. Therapists must have a good understanding of masking, the social environmental 5 drivers of both masking and mental health difficulties and the mental health consequences of masking. Masking, social and environmental factors, and societal messages about autism should be built into psychological formulations. A further impact of this study is highlighting the potential long-term negative consequences of social skills groups for autistic young people. The study should be used to encourage identity positive group interventions, which are co-produced and facilitated by autistic adults. Finally, this study highlights a need for system-level changes across clinical, research and educational settings in order to move away from the damaging deficit- based narratives of autism currently embedded. 6 Table of Contents Overview ..................................................................................................................... 3 Impact Statement ....................................................................................................... 5 List of Tables and Figures ....................................................................................... 10 Acknowledgements ................................................................................................... 11 Part I: Conceptual Introduction ............................................................................. 12 Abstract ................................................................................................................... 13 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 14 What is autism? .............................................................................................. 14 Autism and learning disabilities ..................................................................... 16 How likely are autistic people to experience mental health difficulties? ............... 17 Why are autistic people more likely to experience mental health difficulties? ...... 19 Hypothesis one ............................................................................................... 19 Hypothesis two ............................................................................................... 19 Hypothesis three ............................................................................................. 20 Hypothesis four .............................................................................................. 21 What is masking? ................................................................................................... 24 Terminology and definition............................................................................ 25 The “female camouflage effect”? .................................................................. 27 Measuring masking ....................................................................................... 29 Why do autistic people mask? ................................................................................ 31 Impression management................................................................................. 31 Social connection ........................................................................................... 32 Assimilation ................................................................................................... 33 Shame ............................................................................................................. 34 Safety.............................................................................................................. 34 Being undiagnosed ......................................................................................... 35 What are the mental health consequences of masking? ......................................... 35 Stress and anxiety ........................................................................................... 35 Burnout and exhaustion.................................................................................. 36 Depression ...................................................................................................... 37 Loss of identity ............................................................................................... 37 Social isolation and disconnection ................................................................. 38 Suicidality ...................................................................................................... 38 Are there any positive consequences of masking on mental health? ............. 39 Understanding the relationship between mental health and masking? ................... 40 The social model of disability ........................................................................ 40 7 Suppression of emotional expressivity........................................................... 41 Autistic burnout .............................................................................................. 42 A lack of appropriate support ......................................................................... 42 Minority stress model ..................................................................................... 42 What is the relationship between masking and mental health for autistic teenagers? ...............................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Autism Entangled – Controversies Over Disability, Sexuality, and Gender in Contemporary Culture
    Autism Entangled – Controversies over Disability, Sexuality, and Gender in Contemporary Culture Toby Atkinson BA, MA This thesis is submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Sociology Department, Lancaster University February 2021 1 Declaration I declare that this thesis is my own work and has not been submitted in substantially the same form for the award of a higher degree elsewhere. Furthermore, I declare that the word count of this thesis, 76940 words, does not exceed the permitted maximum. Toby Atkinson February 2021 2 Acknowledgements I want to thank my supervisors Hannah Morgan, Vicky Singleton, and Adrian Mackenzie for the invaluable support they offered throughout the writing of this thesis. I am grateful as well to Celia Roberts and Debra Ferreday for reading earlier drafts of material featured in several chapters. The research was made possible by financial support from Lancaster University and the Economic and Social Research Council. I also want to thank the countless friends, colleagues, and family members who have supported me during the research process over the last four years. 3 Contents DECLARATION ......................................................................................... 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................. 3 ABSTRACT .............................................................................................. 9 PART ONE: ........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Committee Business
    IACC Committee Business IACC Full Committee Meeting April 19, 2018 Susan A. Daniels, Ph.D. Director, Office of Autism Research Coordination Executive Secretary, IACC National Institute of Mental Health Thanks to OARC Staff Susan Daniels, Ph.D. Director Oni Celestin, Ph.D. Julianna Rava, M.P.H. Science Policy Analyst Science Policy Analyst Rebecca Martin, M.P.H Matthew Vilnit, B.S. Public Health Analyst Operations Coordinator Angelice Mitrakas, B.A. Jeff Wiegand, B.S. Management Analyst Web Development Manager Karen Mowrer, Ph.D. Science Policy Analyst April is National Autism Awareness Month NIMH Special Event for Autism Awareness Month The Story Behind Julia, Sesame Street’s Muppet with Autism April 9, 2018 • Panel presentation featuring speakers from Sesame Workshop, the nonprofit educational organization behind Sesame Street • Meet-and-greet with a costumed Julia character Archived video available: https://iacc.hhs.gov/meetings/autism- events/2018/april9/sesame- street.shtml#video Autism Awareness Month News • 2018 Presidential Proclamation: President Donald J. Trump Proclaims April 2, 2018, World Autism Awareness Day • 2018 UN Secretary-General Message: António Guterres' Message on World Autism Awareness Day Autism Awareness Month Events • Autism Awareness Interagency Roundtable Indian Health Service April 2, 2018; Bethesda, MD • Empowering Women and Girls with Autism United Nations April 5, 2018; New York, NY Event page: https://www.un.org/en/events/autismday/ Archived video available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tyhm7p8Gr2A
    [Show full text]
  • Becoming Autistic: How Do Late Diagnosed Autistic People
    Becoming Autistic: How do Late Diagnosed Autistic People Assigned Female at Birth Understand, Discuss and Create their Gender Identity through the Discourses of Autism? Emily Violet Maddox Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy The University of Leeds School of Sociology and Social Policy September 2019 1 Table of Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................................................... 5 ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................................................... 6 ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................................................................. 7 CHAPTER ONE ................................................................................................................................................. 8 INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................................. 8 1.1 RESEARCH OBJECTIVES ........................................................................................................................................ 8 1.2 TERMINOLOGY ................................................................................................................................................ 14 1.3 OUTLINE OF CHAPTERS ....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Inclusive Practices for Neurodevelopmental Research
    Current Developmental Disorders Reports https://doi.org/10.1007/s40474-021-00227-z AUTISM SPECTRUM (A RICHDALE AND LH LAWSON, SECTION EDITORS) Inclusive Practices for Neurodevelopmental Research Sue Fletcher-Watson1 & Kabie Brook2 & Sonny Hallett3 & Fergus Murray3 & Catherine J. Crompton4 Accepted: 9 March 2021 # The Author(s) 2021 Abstract Purpose of Review Inclusive research practice is both a moral obligation and a practical imperative. Here we review its relevance to the study of neurodevelopmental diversity in particular, briefly describing a range of inclusive research models and justifying their use. The review itself is inclusively co-authored with three autistic collaborators and community leaders who all have extensive experience of research involvement. Recent Findings Drawing on theoretical arguments and specific exemplar projects, we describe six key considerations in the delivery of inclusive research. These are the following: taking the first steps towards inclusive practice; setting expectations; community-specific inclusion measures; inclusion and intersectionality; the role of empowerment; and knowledge exchange for inclusion. Together, these sections provide an illustrated guide to the principles and process of inclusive research. Summary Inclusive research practice is both beneficial to and a requirement of excellence in neurodevelopmental research. We call for greater engagement in this participatory research agenda from grant-awarding bodies to facilitate not just inclusive but also emancipatory research. Keywords Participatory research . Inclusion . Neurodiversity . Patient and public involvement . Participation Introduction for its use. We then illustrate six key facets of inclusive re- search in neurodevelopment, drawing on our own experiences What Is Inclusive Research Practice? and including illustrative examples from the literature. Arnstein’s ladder of participation [4•] provides a rudimentary Inclusive research takes place with members of the relevant model for thinking about inclusive research practice.
    [Show full text]
  • Real-Time 3D Graphic Augmentation of Therapeutic Music Sessions for People on the Autism Spectrum
    Real-time 3D Graphic Augmentation of Therapeutic Music Sessions for People on the Autism Spectrum John Joseph McGowan Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of Edinburgh Napier University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy October 2018 Declaration I, John McGowan, declare that the work contained within this thesis has not been submitted for any other degree or professional qualification. Furthermore, the thesis is the result of the student’s own independent work. Published material associated with the thesis is detailed within the section on Associate Publications. Signed: Date: 12th October 2019 J J McGowan Abstract i Abstract This thesis looks at the requirements analysis, design, development and evaluation of an application, CymaSense, as a means of improving the communicative behaviours of autistic participants through therapeutic music sessions, via the addition of a visual modality. Autism spectrum condition (ASC) is a lifelong neurodevelopmental disorder that can affect people in a number of ways, commonly through difficulties in communication. Interactive audio-visual feedback can be an effective way to enhance music therapy for people on the autism spectrum. A multi-sensory approach encourages musical engagement within clients, increasing levels of communication and social interaction beyond the sessions. Cymatics describes a resultant visualised geometry of vibration through a variety of mediums, typically through salt on a brass plate or via water. The research reported in this thesis focuses on how an interactive audio-visual application, based on Cymatics, might improve communication for people on the autism spectrum. A requirements analysis was conducted through interviews with four therapeutic music practitioners, aimed at identifying working practices with autistic clients.
    [Show full text]
  • The National Autism Project: Aims and Objectives
    The National Autism Project: aims and objectives The National Autism Project: Address for correspondence aims and objectives E-mail: ian@ nationalautismproject. org.uk C Ian Ragan, London Editorial comment Dr Ian Ragan is the director of the National Autism Project (NAP), launched in April 2015 and funded by The Shirley Foundation. In this paper, he describes the key aims of the project and the advisers and organisations who are contributing to this work. He makes the case that the spending on autism, relative to other conditions, is very low and that this has limited the progress on identifying the most effective interven- tions. It is hoped that data will be gathered on the cost-benefit of different services and strategies which can then be used strategically to inform future practice in health, education and social care and the voluntary sector. Readers of the GAP Journal who would like to read more about NAP or contribute to its work can visit the website www.nationalautismproject.org.uk. Note: The term autism is used throughout this paper to denote all individuals on the autism spectrum, including those with Asperger syndrome. Introduction All charities face the issue of deciding how best to spend for young people and adults? Can we be sure that ‘ben- their money and to justify their existence to their donors, efits’, as normally defined by the neurotypical majority, supporters and beneficiaries. They can augment their are really meeting the needs of the autistic minority? in-house expertise with the opinions of independent It was to try and find answers to such questions that experts but every organisation still needs to develop Dame Stephanie (Steve) Shirley with others developed its own strategy, its future direction, and its goals and the idea of the National Autism Project (NAP) which was ambitions.
    [Show full text]
  • Autistica Action Briefing: Adult Mental Health
    Autistica Action Briefing: Adult Mental Health Harper G, Smith E, Simonoff E, Hill L, Johnson S, Davidson I. March 2019 Autistica is the UK’s autism research charity. This briefing summarises the most important scientific findings about mental health in autistic adults. It was developed in collaboration with leading researchers and autistic people with experience of the topic as an insight into the latest evidence. We strongly urge the Department of Health and Social Care, NHS policy-makers, commissioners, services and public research funders to act on this information. The evidence about mental health in autistic adults has moved on; services and policies to improve mental health must now do so as well. www.autistica.org.uk/AutismStrategy “If a neurotypical person was afraid to leave the house, that wouldn’t be seen as normal or okay. But if you’re 1 autistic you should just accept that that is the way your life is going to be.” What we know “The main problem with mental health services is that no one seems to want the responsibility 1 of putting him on their books… He keeps getting passed around departments” ▪ Almost 8 in 10 autistic adults experience a mental health problem.2 Autism is not a mental health condition itself, but mental health problems are one of the most common and serious challenges experienced by people across the spectrum. ▪ Up to 10% of adults in inpatient mental health settings are autistic,3 even though only 1% of the population is on the spectrum.4 ▪ Autistic people are often unable to access community mental health
    [Show full text]
  • Suggerimenti Operativi Per L'integrazione Scolastica Degli Allievi Con Autismo O Disturbi Pervasivi Dello Sviluppo
    Direzione Generale “Suggerimenti operativi per Uff. I – Dirigente Stefano Versari l’integrazione scolastica degli allievi autistici o disturbi pervasivi dello Nota prot. 16922 del 12 novembre 2008 sviluppo” SUGGERIMENTI OPERATIVI PER L’INTEGRAZIONE SCOLASTICA DEGLI ALLIEVI CON AUTISMO O DISTURBI PERVASIVI DELLO SVILUPPO [email protected] 1 Direzione Generale “Suggerimenti operativi per Uff. I – Dirigente Stefano Versari l’integrazione scolastica degli allievi autistici o disturbi pervasivi dello Nota prot. 16922 del 12 novembre 2008 sviluppo” INDICE PARTE PRIMA Autismo e disturbi pervasivi dello sviluppo: di cosa stiamo pag. 3 parlando? PARTE SECONDA Caratteristiche di un programma funzionale pag. 6 PARTE TERZA Prima dell’arrivo a scuola: acquisire le informazioni pag. 14 PARTE QUARTA Organizzare gli spazi pag.17 PARTE QUINTA Organizzare i tempi pag. 26 PARTE SESTA Strategie didattiche: l’uso dei rinforzi pag. 30 Strategie didattiche: l’analisi del compito pag. 32 Strategie didattiche: l’uso del prompt pag. 34 PARTE SETTIMA Attivita’ e metodi didattici pag. 35 Analisi delle competenze dell’allievo pag. 36 Prevalenza del canale visivo pag. 37 Ampliare le capacità di attenzione e di concentrazione pag. 41 Ampliare le capacità di memoria pag. 42 PARTE OTTAVA Approfondimento sulle aree di maggiore difficoltà delle persone pag. 45 autistiche: percezione PARTE NONA Lo sviluppo delle capacità cognitive pag. 48 Un esempio di didattica dell’artimetica: la cardinalità del pag. 51 numero Il supporto delle nuove tecnologie pag. 55 PARTE DECIMA I comportamenti problema pag. 57 Sviluppo delle competenze sociali e rapporto con i pari di età pag. 60 [email protected] 2 Direzione Generale “Suggerimenti operativi per Uff.
    [Show full text]
  • The Diagnosis of Autism: from Kanner to DSM‑III to DSM‑5 and Beyond
    Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-021-04904-1 S:I AUTISM IN REVIEW: 1980-2020: 40 YEARS AFTER DSM-III The Diagnosis of Autism: From Kanner to DSM‑III to DSM‑5 and Beyond Nicole E. Rosen1 · Catherine Lord1 · Fred R. Volkmar2,3 Accepted: 27 January 2021 © The Author(s) 2021 Abstract In this paper we review the impact of DSM-III and its successors on the feld of autism—both in terms of clinical work and research. We summarize the events leading up to the inclusion of autism as a “new” ofcial diagnostic category in DSM-III, the subsequent revisions of the DSM, and the impact of the ofcial recognition of autism on research. We discuss the uses of categorical vs. dimensional approaches and the continuing tensions around broad vs. narrow views of autism. We also note some areas of current controversy and directions for the future. Keywords Autism · History · Dimensional · Categorical · DSM It has now been nearly 80 years since Leo Kanner’s (1943) frst described by Kanner has changed across the past few classic description of infantile autism. Ofcial recognition of decades. When we refer to the concept in general, we will this condition took almost 40 years; several lines of evidence use the term autism, and when we refer to particular, ear- became available in the 1970s that demonstrated the valid- lier diagnostic constructs, we will use more specifc terms ity of the diagnostic concept, clarifed early misperceptions like autism spectrum disorder, infantile autism, and autistic about autism, and illustrated the need for clearer approaches disorder.
    [Show full text]
  • Educational Inclusion for Children with Autism in Palestine. What Opportunities Can Be Found to Develop Inclusive Educational Pr
    EDUCATIONAL INCLUSION FOR CHILDREN WITH AUTISM IN PALESTINE. What opportunities can be found to develop inclusive educational practice and provision for children with autism in Palestine; with special reference to the developing practice in two educational settings? by ELAINE ASHBEE A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY School of Education University of Birmingham November 2015 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. Amendments to names used in thesis The Amira Basma Centre is now known as Jerusalem Princess Basma Centre Friends Girls School is now known as Ramallah Friends Lower School ABSTRACT This study investigates inclusive educational understandings, provision and practice for children with autism in Palestine, using a qualitative, case study approach and a dimension of action research together with participants from two educational settings. In addition, data about the wider context was obtained through interviews, visits, observations and focus group discussions. Despite the extraordinarily difficult context, education was found to be highly valued and Palestinian educators, parents and decision–makers had achieved impressive progress. The research found that autism is an emerging field of interest with a widespread desire for better understanding.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Book of Abstracts
    12th Autism-Europe International Congress September 13-15th 2019 ABSTRACT BOOK TABLE OF CONTENTS Foreword by Zsuzsanna Szilvásy - President of Autism-Europe p. 1 Foreword by Danièle Langloys - President of Autisme France p. 1 Scientific Committee p. 2 Honorary Scientific Committee p. 3 Index by session p. 4 First author index p.17 Index by Keywords p.26 Abstracts p.28 We are glad to invite you to the 12th In- how to shape better lives for autistic people. have happy and fulfilling lives. ternational Congress of Autism-Europe , which is organized in cooperation with Au- On the occasion of this three-day event With kindest regards, tisme France, in the beautiful city of Nice. people from all over the world will come Our congresses are held every three years, together to share the most recent deve- and we are delighted to be back in France, lopments across the field of autism. The 36 years after the congress of Paris. It will congress will address a wide range of is- be a great opportunity to take stock of the sues, including: diagnostic and assess- progress achieved and look at the opportu- ment, language and communication, ac- nities ahead. cess to education, employment, research and ethics, gender and sexuality, inclusion The 2019 congress’ motto is “A new Dyna- and community living, mental and physical mic for Change and Inclusion”, in keeping health, interventions, strategic planning with our aspiration that international scienti- and coordination of services as well as fic research on autism should be translated rights and participation. into concrete changes and foster social in- clusion for autistic people of all ages and We hope you will enjoy this Congress, needs.
    [Show full text]
  • Autism Spectrum Disorder: a Neurodevelopmental Disorder
    Sarah Spence MD PhD Autism spectrum disorder: A NEUROdevelopmental Disorder Autism spectrum disorder: A NEUROdevelopmental disorder Sarah Spence MD PhD Co-Director, Autism Spectrum Center Boston Children’s Hospital Harvard Medical School Copyright © 2020 Boston Children’s Hospital 1 Sarah Spence MD PhD Autism spectrum disorder: A NEUROdevelopmental Disorder Disclosures I will discuss non-FDA approved medications used in Autism Spectrum Disorder. Member of APA DSM 5 Neurodevelopmental workgroup. Current and past grant support from Cure Autism Now, Autism Speaks, MIND Institute, Simons Foundation Autism Research Initiative (SFARI), Nancy Lurie Marks Family Foundation, NIH Past consultant for Seaside Therapeutics for Arbacolfen Past co-investigator in clinical trial of a novel compound led by Hoffman LaRoche pharmaceuticals. Current co-investigator in clinical trial of a novel compound led by Servier pharmaceuticals. Consultant to Yanmo pharmaceuticals for new compund being tested in ASD Copyright © 2020 Boston Children’s Hospital 2 Sarah Spence MD PhD Autism spectrum disorder: A NEUROdevelopmental Disorder Overview Epidemiology Diagnosis Heterogeneity Etiological theories Medical co-morbidities Treatments Neurodiversity Copyright © 2020 Boston Children’s Hospital 3 Sarah Spence MD PhD Autism spectrum disorder: A NEUROdevelopmental Disorder Epidemiology: 2020 MMWR report 2020 data (cohort of 8 year olds from 2016) 1 in 54 children or 1.8% or 18.5/1,000 (range 13.1-31.4/1,000) Fist time there were equal rates for most different
    [Show full text]