Planning for Resilience in East Africa Through Policy, Adaptation, Research, and Economic Development (Prepared)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PLANNING FOR RESILIENCE IN EAST AFRICA THROUGH POLICY, ADAPTATION, RESEARCH, AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT (PREPARED) BALANCING DEVELOPMENT AND CONSERVATION IN KENYA’S LARGEST FRESHWATER PAPYRUS WETLAND IN YALA SWAMP FINAL TECHNICAL REPORT AND LESSONS LEARNED August 2016 September 2015 This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development. It was prepared by Tetra Tech ARD International Development. It was prepared by Tetra Tech ARD This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development by Tetra Tech ARD through USAID/East Africa Contract AID-623-C-13- 00003. The report was prepared by Serah Munguti and submitted to Tetra Tech ARD as the final deliverable for the project: Balancing development and conservation in Kenya’s largest freshwater papyrus wetland in Yala Swamp. Tetra Tech ARD Contacts: John Parker Thomas McCann Senior Technical Advisor/Manager Project Manager Tetra Tech ARD Tetra Tech ARD Burlington, VT Burlington, Vermont Tel.: 802-658-3890 Tel.: 802-658-3890 [email protected] [email protected] PLANNING FOR RESILIENCE IN EAST AFRICA THROUGH POLICY, ADAPTATION, RESEARCH, AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT (PREPARED) BALANCING DEVELOPMENT AND CONSERVATION IN KENYA’S LARGEST FRESHWATER PAPYRUS WETLAND IN YALA SWAMP FINAL TECHNICAL REPORT AND LESSONS LEARNED February 2017 DISCLAIMER The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the United States Agency for International Development or the United States Government Table of Contents 1 Executive summary ........................................................................................................ 1 2 Key achievements .......................................................................................................... 4 1. Inception and Work planning workshop .............................................................................................. 4 2. Formulation of a Land Use Plan for the Yala Swamp informed by a Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA).................................................................................................................................... 4 2.1 The Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) ......................................................................... 4 2.2 Formulation of the Yala Swamp Land Use Plan .............................................................. 6 3. Ecosystem Service Assessment report finalized ..................................................................................... 9 4. Selection of community conserved areas (CCAs) and restoration of wildlife habitat ................................ 10 i. Biodiversity .............................................................................................................................. 10 ii. Intactness of the habitat .......................................................................................................... 10 iii. Hydrology of the Yala Swamp ................................................................................................... 10 5. A Framework for the development a Payment of Ecosystem Services (PES) scheme was developed .......... 12 6. Five fishponds were established ........................................................................................................ 12 i. Location ................................................................................................................................... 13 ii. Design ...................................................................................................................................... 13 iii. Construction ............................................................................................................................. 13 iv. Monitor .................................................................................................................................... 13 v. Stock ........................................................................................................................................ 13 860 kilograms of fish have been harvested from the 5 ponds out of which beneficiary households consumed 90 kilos and sold the rest for a total of Ksh. 173,000. ....................................................................................... 15 7. Training to support community livelihoods ......................................................................................... 15 Training in wildlife guiding and tourism administration and management:...................................... 15 Training in the creation and marketing of high-value papyrus products: .......................................... 16 Training on entrepreneurship for Businesses: .................................................................................... 19 a) Lessons learned video documentary produced .......................................................................... 20 3 Successes ..................................................................................................................... 20 Improved Participatory Decision Making............................................................................................ 20 To engage in decision making processes ............................................................................................. 20 Improvement of community livelihoods .............................................................................................. 21 Capacity of technical capacity of national and county government built in land use planning and strategic environmental assessment ................................................................................................... 21 Contribution to knowledge ................................................................................................................. 21 4 Lessons learned and best practices .............................................................................. 21 Balancing development and conservation in Kenya’s largest freshwater papyrus wetland in Yala Swamp List of Figures and tables Figure 1 :Location of Yala Swamp ................................................................................................................. 3 Table 1: ISSUES FOR SEA ANALYSIS ....................................................................Error! Bookmark not defined. Table 2: Number of fishponds established ................................................................................................. 15 Balancing development and conservation in Kenya’s largest freshwater papyrus wetland in Yala Swamp List of Acronyms BMU Beach Management Unit CBOs Community Based Organizations CCAs Community Conservation Areas CODIT Community and Organization Development Institute GIS Geographic Information System HoPE-LVB Health of People and the Environment in the Lake Victoria Basin ICLUPSC Inter-County Land Use Plan Steering Committee IMTC Inter-ministerial Technical Committee KASTEP Kanyango Fish Farmers and Kadenge Solidarity towards Equal Participation KEMFRI Kenya Marine and Fisheries Research Institute KIPPRA Kenya Institute of Public Policy Research and Analysis LUP Land Use Plan NEMA National Environment Management Authority PES Payment for Ecosystem Services PREPARED- Planning For Resilience In East Africa Through Policy, Adaptation, Research, And SEA Strategic Environment Assessment SSGs Site Support Groups TESSA Toolkit for Ecosystem Service Site-based Assessment Economic Development USAID United States Agency for International Development WRMA Water Resources Management Authority WRUA Water Resources Users Association YPAC Yala Planning Advisory Committee Balancing development and conservation in Kenya’s largest freshwater papyrus wetland in Yala Swamp 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The inception workshop for the project Balancing development and conservation in Kenya’s largest freshwater papyrus wetland in Yala Swamp was held at the Siaya Agricultural Training Center on Thursday 12th March 2015. Fifty nine (59) people attended the workshop comprising seventeen women and 42 men. Representation included technical officers from the county government, national government, elected officials, user groups within the swamp and community based organizations among others. The meeting was moderated by Mr. David Ruto from the Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) Siaya County. Local and national media attended the workshop with The Star newspaper featuring a small article on the launch. The grant was implemented within the period 9th March 2015 – 02nd August 2016 in Yala Swamp which is located in Siaya and Busia Counties. Its main objectives were to first develop an integrated land use plan for the Yala Swamp, guided by a Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA). These twin processes were first piloted in the Tana River Delta and through the PREPARED project were replicated in the Yala Swamp. The second objective was to develop an evidence-based ‘business case’ for the sustainable management of the Yala swamp. This was based on a pre-existing ecosystem services assessment. The business case is described in the ecosystem services assessment which explored three scenarios: continued development (business as usual), and balanced development. After indepth assessments, the ecosystem services assessment recommends that Yala Swamp land use and management policies and plans adopt a balance between development and