SECOND NARROWS WATER SUPPLY, VANCOUVER, BC NAVI GATION THROUGH CHANGING GEOLOGY The new Second Narrows water supply tunnel will be excavated deep under the Burrard Inlet, just east of the Ironworker’s Memorial Bridge. Due to complex geological conditions, the first ever Mixshield in Canada will be utilized in this project. With project-specific technology and s u p p o r t from the local Herrenknecht subsidiary, the 1,100 meters of new tunnel will replace the existing aging mains that convey drinking water. herrenknecht.com/secondnarrows
Client: Metro Vancouver Contractor: Traylor-Aecon General Partnership INSIDE this issue OCTOBER 2020
COVER STORY 10 Utilization of Underground Space Promotes Urban Development By Nasri Munfah A look at the role of subway construction and development in today’s cities.
FEATURES DEPARTMENTS 14 21 4 Market Spotlight: Special Sponsored Publisher’s Message By Jim Rush Roadheaders Content Section Antraquip’s Karl Mitterndorfer discusses TBM highlights the industry’s leading the latest deveopments in roadheaders. consultants, contractors, suppliers and manufacturers. 5 Business Briefs 16 News from across North America Underground Projects 41 and around the world. Project Update Forge Ahead A look at major tunneling works Jay Dee Contractors’ essential workers underway in North America. 47 keep critical infrastructure safe. Ad Index 18 47 Tunnel Lighting Upgraded lighting in Chesapeake Bay Business Cards Bridge-Tunnel results in unique, new design innovations.
TBM: Tunnel Business Magazine (ISSN 1553-2917) is published six times per year. Copyright 2020, Benjamin Media Inc., 10050 Brecksville Road, Brecksville, OH 44141. USA All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted by any means without written permission from the publisher. One year subscription rates: complimentary in the United States and Canada, and $99 in other foreign countries. Single copy rate: $20. Subscriptions and classified advertising should be addressed to the Brecksville office. POSTMASTER: send Changes of Address to TBM: Tunnel Business Magazine, 10050 Brecksville Road, Brecksville, OH 44141 USA.
tunnelingonline.com 3 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 PUBLISHER’S message PUBLISHER/EDITOR James W. Rush [email protected]
CONTRIBUTING STAFF EDITORS Sharon M. Bueno TUNNELING IN THE Brad Kramer Andrew Farr AGE OF COVID Mike Kezdi SALES + MARKETING
Director of Marketing: The topic of this month’s cover story Also in this issue, we talked with tunnel Kelly Dadich – “Utilization of Underground Space contracting firm Jay Dee, and highlight [email protected] Promotes Urban Development” – raises their projects that are playing a vital role in interesting discussion points, especially in protecting our environment, notably CSO Regional Sales Representative: light of the COVID-19 pandemic that is reduction programs. Based in Michigan Maura Bourquin impacting the country, and the world. in the heart of the Great Lakes region, Jay [email protected] Written by Nasri Munfah of AECOM, Dee has been involved with several projects Conference Sales Coordinator: a global engineering firm with deep roots that have an amazing impact on the water Meghan Squires in the transit sector, the article shows the quality of the region, restoring lakes and [email protected] beneficial impact of transit investment on rivers to swimmable/fishable goals outlined the development of our urban centers. in the Clean Water Act. Also of note, Jay PRODUCTION + FULFILLMENT Given the trends in population shifts toward Dee and tunnel contractors across the Graphic Designer/Production Coordinator: Deborah R. McManus cities and an increased need for sustainable county have been able to continue progress [email protected] and environmentally friendly transportation on projects underway due to the critical solutions, investment in mass transit should nature of the work and measures adopted Director of Web and Audience Development: be a priority. to help create safe jobsites. Mark Gorman Munfah uses New York City as a As Munfah notes in his article, “The use [email protected] backdrop to showcase how investment in of the underground space is sustainable. Audience Development/Sustainability Coordinator: an underground, urban transportation It provides isolation from the elements Cayla Poteete network has had a tremendous impact reducing power consumption and carbon [email protected] on the city. However, the current impact footprint. … The use of underground space of the COVID crisis has had substantial provides additional environmental benefits EDITORIAL COUNCIL impacts on New York’s mass transit system, in term of visual effects, air quality by Gary Brierley, P.E - Dr. Mole Inc. with similar impacts being felt across the removing vehicles from streets, less conges- Randy Essex, P.E. - Mott MacDonald - Ozdemir Engineering Inc. country. In the article, Munfah notes that tion, and a reduction of noise and vibration Dr. Levent Ozdemir, P.E. William W. Edgerton - McMillen Jacobs Associates subway ridership dropped to 10 percent resulting in a better quality of life at the Joe Gildner - Sound Transit of its daily boardings, although he wrote surface. The use of the underground facili- Paul Roy - AECOM that it is anticipated to return to its former ties improves the local and global ecological Jon Hurt - Arup levels within a year or two. cycle. … Underground facilities are more A recent article in the Economist (Sept. cost effective considering life-cycle cost and 5, 2020) reported that MTA, the agency triple bottom line since design life of all that manages the New York subway system, underground facilities exceed 100 years.” is losing $200 million a week and “is on In planning for our future, it is important the verge of financial collapse.” A Sept. 15 that we do not lose sight of the tremendous report by the American Public Transporta- benefits that underground facilities and Chief Executive Officer: tion Association (APTA) says that “six in 10 mass transit networks play in the overall Bernard P. Krzys [email protected] public transit systems will need to reduce health of our society. service and furlough employees in the President: coming months without an additional $32 Robert Krzys [email protected] billion in emergency federal funding from Congress.” APTA is urging Congress to Controller: pass new legislation that would provide $32 Marianne Saykes [email protected] billion in emergency transit funding to help agencies maintain services and workfoce 10050 Brecksville Rd. while we recover from the pandemic. Brecksville, OH 44141 USA The news for the tunneling sector is Ph: 330.467.7588 - Fax: 330.468.2289 not all bleak, however. Water and sewer Jim Rush www.benjaminmedia.com infrastructure funding remains a priority. Editor/Publisher, TBM e-mail: [email protected]
Reprint Information: Wright’s Media Ph: 877.652.5295 - Fax: 916.983.6762
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 4 tunnelingonline.com MINNEAPOLIS PLANNING BUSINESS briefs CENTRAL CITY PARALLEL STORMWATER TUNNEL CLARK COUNTY (NV) COMMISSION OKS TUNNEL EXPANSION PLAN the County Commission to move forward with our proposed passenger station and tunnel and are eager to take the next steps in creating an innovative transportation solution for our con- The City of Minneapolis Department of vention guests and visitors,” said Scott Sibella, Surface Waters and Sewers is planning to President of Resorts World Las Vegas. construct the Central City Parallel Stormwa- The decision comes after land-use applica- ter Tunnel in downtown Minneapolis. The On August 5, Resorts World Las Vegas, tion and design plans were submitted for the sandstone bedrock tunnel will be approximately the US $4.3 billion resort scheduled to open tunnel and passenger station to the Board of 4,300 ft long and range in size from 9.75-ft in summer 2021, received an approval by the County Commissioners on June 1. Marking to larger than 12-ft equivalent diameter. The Clark County Commission necessary to move an important milestone, the decision moves tunnel will outlet into a channel adjacent to the forward with constructing the resort’s pas- the landmark project into the next phase of the Mississippi River at the same location as the senger station and tunnel that will connect to permitting process. Construction is anticipated existing tunnel outlet. The tunnel will relieve the Las Vegas Convention Center campus the to begin by the end of this year. overpressurization in the undersized parallel transportation system being constructed by The The Resorts World Las Vegas passenger existing tunnel system. Boring Company. This new tunnel project will station will offer direct access to the heart of Bidding Documents will be available late transport passengers between the city’s newest the resort’s dining, retail and nightlife offerings, spring 2021 for fall 2021 construction start. integrated resort and the Las Vegas Convention as well as convenient access to the Las Vegas The project is valued at $50-$60 million. City Center (LVCC) via underground tunnels in all- Strip. Additional plans have been floated that of Minneapolis Department of Surface Waters electric Tesla vehicles in under just two minutes. would extend the tunnel through the strip and and Sewers, Attn: Joe Klejwa, Project Manager, “We are thrilled to receive approval from McCarran Airport. 1901 E 26th St, Minneapolis, MN 55404.
Delivering complex tunneling projects worldwide #AECOMTunneling
Pictured: Chinatown Station of the Central Subway Program, San Francisco, California
Contact: Nasri Munfah Director of Tunneling and Underground Engineering [email protected]
aecom.com
tunnelingonline.com 5 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 BUSINESS briefs
Updated Financial Plan Released for HUDSON TUNNEL PROJECT The Gateway Program Development continues to meet and exceed the threshold Corporation (GDC) on Aug. 28 announced for an improved rating in the CIG process. that an updated financial plan for construc- The Port Authority’s funding commitment and advancement on the project’s financial plan tion of the Hudson Tunnel Project has been alone surpasses the requirement to qualify for rating and funding. submitted in response to the Federal Transit CIG funding. The updated financial plan also – Revising the project’s estimated construc- Administration’s (FTA) annual call for proj- includes a continued Amtrak commitment of tion cost to account for the time-driven escala- ects for the Capital Investment Grant (CIG) nearly $1.3 billion. tion: after reducing the estimated construction Program. Overall construction costs for the project cost in the 2019 Financial Plan from $12.7 The project, for funding and financing increased $275 million, due to escalation from billion to $11.3 billion, the delay results in purposes, includes the construction of a new the delay in starting major construction, which a new estimated construction cost of $11.6 two-track rail tunnel beneath the Hudson cannot begin until a Final Environmental Im- billion. This includes $9.8 billion for the new River, the comprehensive rehabilitation of pact Statement (FEIS) and a Record of Decision tunnel and $1.8 billion for the rehabilitation of the existing 109-year-old North River Tunnel, (ROD) for the new tunnel and rehabilitation of the existing tunnel. and the completion of the third and final sec- the existing North River Tunnel are issued. – Requesting $5.5 billion from the FTA’s tion of the Hudson Yards Concrete Casing. Additional details of the 2020 Financial CIG Program, which continues to be more The 2020 financial plan includes a contin- Plan include: than $1 billion less than the request in the 2018 ued local share construction cost commitment – Responsibly updating the project’s pro- Financial Plan. The 2020 request represents of $5.55 billion from the State of New York, jected start of major construction by one year to 44.3% of the total project, which also continues State of New Jersey, and the Port Authority of early 2022, necessary while the project partners to be a reduction from the 49.4% previously New York & New Jersey. That commitment await Federal action on the FEIS and ROD sought in the 2018 Financial Plan.
bradshawcc.com TUNNELING SPECIALISTS 410.970.8300 ACCIONA SIGNS CONTRACT TO BUILD VANCOUVER BROADWAY SUBWAY PROJECT The Broadway Subway Project Cor- PROVIDING INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS poration, led by AC- FOR TUNNELING PROJECTS CIONA, has reached financial close to build the extension of the Millennium Line, a key link for the Vancouver subway transport system. The CAD$1.728 billion contract ($1.32 billion USD), which is being procured using a design-build-finance approach, includes the design and construction of 5.7 new km of network, part of which will be under- ground, including twin tunnels with an excavation diameter of 6.3 m as well as six new stations. Construction of the subway will involve works starting in 2020, with the new extension opening in 2025. Once in service, the journey time on the Millennium Line will take 11 minutes, saving passengers an average of 30 minutes a day while alleviating traffic congestion in the city. This will sig- MICROTUNNELING nificantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions: a sustainable solution that will TBM TUNNELING benefit the whole Vancouver community. HAND TUNNELING ACCIONA will be celebrating its 20th anniversary in Canada next year. SHAFT WORK This new contract marks ACCIONA 6th active infrastructure project in BC. ACCIONA and the Italian firm Ghella have extensive work experience
in tunneling projects. Both global companies have previously successfully collaborated to construct iconic international transport infrastructure such as Scandinavia’s longest railway tunnels for the Norwegian railway authori- BRADSHAWCONSTRUCTION CORPORATION ties (the Follo Line); the Legacy Way tunnels in Brisbane (Australia); and the Bologna Node on the Milan-Naples high-speed rail section in Italy.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 6 tunnelingonline.com BART SILICON VALLEY PHASE II PROJECT: EARLY CONTRACTOR ENGAGEMENT BEGINS
are being issued to gauge interest in the four cluding Maintenance and Operations major project-related contracts from the Yard and buildings, yard track and transit design-build contractor community, rail, civil site restoration and demobi- and to obtain specific feedback on the scope lization, and the full construction of of the contract. the street level Santa Clara Station and The four contract categories are: parking garage. • Tunnel and Track work including the An RFIF for the Systems contract will fol- bored tunnel construction, procure- low by the end of the month, with the other ment of the tunnel boring machine, long two contract RFIFs to be announced later. The stretch of the BART Silicon Valley tunnel conveyors, precast tunnel lining Early construction activities are planned extension into Downtown San Jose and Santa and tunnel interior structures, including to begin in 2022 with substantial construc- Clara is entering the procurement stage of station platforms. tion completed by 2028, followed by systems the project. For this mega project, currently • Systems including system wide equip- testing, integration, and safety certification. at an early design stage, the procurement ment/fixtures such as large emergency For more contract details and information, process begins with seeking out contractors and ventilation fans, tunnel lighting, com- download this brochure. subcontractors to initially provide feedback, munication systems, bulk power supply VTA is eager to receive industry feedback on later respond to requests for proposals, then stations, traction power, line electrical, this innovative infrastructure project, the largest ultimately finish the design and physically build radio and Train Control. in Santa Clara County history. the 6-mile extension of the system including • Stations including utilities, site prepa- To register to become a vendor with VTA, four stations. ration work, station structure and receive information about upcoming solicita- VTA released a Request for Industry Feed- platform, ventilation and egress shaft tions and more, visit https://www.vta.org/busi- back (RFIF) on Sept. 16. This RFIF is the and underground station support of ness-center. Learn more about VTA’s BART first one of four and pertains to the upcoming excavation installation. Silicon Valley Phase II Project at https://www. contract for tunnel and track work. RFIFs • Newhall Yard/Santa Clara Station, in- vta.org/projects/bart-sv/phase-ii/contracting.
Call us! (800) 533-0386
THE EXCEPTIONAL SOLUTION
POWER, PERFORMANCE and ACCURACY
Proven for over 25 years, Akkerman Center Drive and Face Access, Periphery FLEXIBLE TERMS Drive MTBM systems are an exceptional solution for the accurate installation of We are committed complex, extended, and curved* tunnels in virtually any ground condition. to positioning our equipment on your next High horsepower main drive, precision VFD slurry control, and simplified project and oer flexible operator console and guidance programming are just a few reasons why terms for purchase, our innovative designs exceed customer expectations. Pairing our MTBMs lease-to-purchase, or with increase kits and project-specific cutter heads also make our MTBM rent from our rental fleet. systems a versatile choice.
Learn more at akkerman.com (800) 533.0386 - [email protected] *Extended and curved alignments are achieved with the use of our AZ100 Total Guidance System.
tunnelingonline.com 7 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 BUSINESS MIDWEST MOLE INC. briefs CHANGES OWNERSHIP LA Metro Board Moves Forward Midwest Mole Inc., a premier specialty underground contractor providing boring, MAJOR CAPITAL PROJECTS trenchless tunneling and directional drilling services throughout the Midwest and be- The Los Angeles The Crenshaw Northern Extension will yond, has announced that CEO and second- County Metropolitan extend the Crenshaw/LAX light rail line north generation owner Dan Liotti is retiring. Transportation Author- to the D Line (Purple) subway on Wilshire Bou- Dan joined his fa- ity (Metro) Board of levard and then continue to the B Line (Red) ther’s company Midwest Directors has moved subway in Hollywood. The Crenshaw/LAX Mole after graduating several major capital projects forward this Line is currently under construction and will from Purdue University month, including the Sepulveda Transit Corri- run between the C Line (Green) and the E Line in 1985 with a degree dor Project, the Crenshaw Northern Extension (Expo) when it opens in 2021. The Measure in Civil Engineering. “I and other transit projects that will transform M spending plan approved by voters in 2016 Liotti worked full time in the mobility options in L.A. County. provides about $2.2 billion for the Crenshaw office, helping with ac- Northern Extension project, although early cost counting,” he recalls. “I learned estimating Sepulveda Transit Corridor Project estimates show that projected costs could be and helped in the shop.” As he learned The Metro Board on Aug. 31 approved a significantly more due to the expected tunnel- the business and climbed the ranks, the $48.3-million contract with HNTB Corpo- ing likely to be needed. company grew. ration, Terr y A. Hayes Associates Inc. and Under the Measure M schedule, the project Shortly after his father Len retired in AECOM Technical Services to perform the is slated to begin construction in 2041 and 2007, Dan purchased the company. As environmental studies and advanced concep- begin service in 2047. Metro, in partnership the times and technology changed, Dan tual engineering for the Sepulveda Transit with the city of West Hollywood and the city of adjusted within Midwest Mole accord- Corridor project, which will build a high-speed, Los Angeles, is advancing the planning work to ingly. In keeping with one of the company high-capacity transit line connecting the San potentially accelerate the project. values to work smarter, Liotti continued to Fernando Valley, Westside and LAX. Metro introduce newer technology. will begin environmental review in 2021. Purple Line Extension Project “Dan pushed technol- The project has also been identified as a can- The Metro Board has amended the Purple ogy – in equipment and didate for possible delivery through a Public- Line Extension Section 1 budget from $2.77 techniques,” says Jason Private Partnership (P3). Metro has received billion to $2.97 billion to cover differing site Miller, President. “The strong private industry interest via a Pre-Devel- conditions and additional third-party and safe- ability to make new opment Agreement (PDA) to build the project. ty requirements. Unused project funds from the technology work is what The agency will select up to two PDA teams Expo Line project — which was completed in Miller made us successful. That to help with project planning and design and 2016 — will be used to address these changes. and a willingness to take propose transit solutions. PDA concepts will be All three sections of the subway project chances.” refined and evaluated during the environmen- are currently under construction: Section 1 is Ownership of the family business founded tal review phase. Metro staff will return with a 63 percent complete; Section 2 is 33 percent in 1982 by Len Liotti will be transferred to PDA recommendation to the Metro Board of complete and Section 3 is 13 percent complete. an Employee Stock Ownership, in which the Directors in early 2021. When done, the Purple Line will provide fast, company’s employees own shares. “It’s 100% The project would be built in one of the frequent and reliable subway service between employee-owned,” states Miller. An ESOP most heavily traveled urban corridors in the downtown L.A. and West Los Angeles. is a kind of employee benefit plan, similar to nation, and when finished will connect existing a profit-sharing plan, providing advantages and planned Metro bus and rail lines, including I-5 North HOV and Truck Lane En- for growth and employee retention without the future East San Fernando Valley Light Rail hancement Project alteration of the management structure. Transit Project, G Line (Orange), the future The Metro Board of Directors approved The change of ownership is expected Metro D Line (Purple) Extension and the and authorized Metro’s CEO to negotiate a to be a seamless transition for clients and Metro E Line (Expo). 5-year, $50 million contract with Hill Interna- vendors, as the company continues to tional, Inc., to provide construction manage- focus on providing cost-effective and envi- The Crenshaw Northern Extension ment oversight for I-5 North HOV and truck ronmentally friendly trenchless solutions, The Metro Board also approved advanc- lane enhancements. Metro is working to make working safely, and creating a welcoming ing three possible routes for the Crenshaw capacity and safety enhancements to the I-5 work environment. Northern Extension (CNE) project as well as in Santa Clarita between the SR-14 and the To reflect these changes, Midwest Mole a $50.3-million contract for environmental Parker Road interchanges. That will include has refreshed its goals and mission statement analysis, which is expected to begin later nearly 14 miles of median improvements to and adopted new branding, which includes this year. add an HOV lane in each direction from an updated logo and visual identity. The The three routes to be studied would follow north of SR-14 to just south of the Parker employee-owned company remains commit- busy travel corridors, serve major destinations Road interchange. The project also includes ted to long-standing industry relationships and employment centers and intersect with technology improvements such as count sta- and delivering quality work in the demand- five of the busiest bus routes in the region. The tions, traffic cameras and ramp metering. The ing world of tunneling, building on their routes would follow parts of San Vicente Boule- project is being designed to ease congestion decades of experience to expand services vard, Fairfax Avenue or La Brea Avenue. and improve traffic flow. geographically as part of their plan of growth for the future.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 8 tunnelingonline.com SOUND TRANSIT COMPLETES
CONSTRUCTION OF EAST LINK BELLEVUE TUNNEL A Leader in Heavy Underground Construction
Our Innovative Sound Transit announced Aug. 19 that contractors have substan- tially completed the civil construction of the tunnel that will connect Services Solve the East Main and Bellevue Downtown stations when East Link begins operating in 2023. Complex “Ten years from planning, through excavation to substantial comple- tion, this tunnel represents Sound Transit’s commitment to a local plan Infrastructure Needs: that prioritized the best transit connection through downtown Bel- levue,” said Sound Transit board member and King County Council Chair Claudia Balducci. Excavation of the one-third of a mile-long tunnel began in 2017. Us- Tunnel Rehabilitation ing a process known as the sequential excavation method (SEM), crews employed conventional equipment including track-mounted excavators and cutting equipment to remove soil in small sections, and support excavated areas with spray-applied concrete. Crews then applied water- Stormwater and proofing, and constructed the center wall and final concrete lining. Sanitation Tunnels Atkinson Construction excavated and constructed the finished tun- nel. By adapting to different ground conditions, they were able to com- plete excavation five months earlier than expected, which helped keep the project on schedule despite delays due to COVID-19. Stacy and Soft Ground, Hard Witbeck/Atkinson, the stations contractor for the segment of East Link that runs from downtown Bellevue to the Spring District, is continuing Rock and Pressurized to install track inside the tunnel. When East Link light rail service begins, eastbound trains will enter Tunneling the tunnel north of the East Main station at 112th Avenue Southeast and Main Street and travel approximately one-third of a mile, under 110th Avenue Northeast and turning east near Northeast Sixth Street 55 Years of Service to emerge at the future Bellevue Downtown Station. “Working together, the city council, community and Sound Transit as Stewards of Clean developed an alignment that works not only for the Bellevue communi- ty, but also for the commuters who will come to work in Bellevue,” said Water Bellevue Mayor Lynne Robinson. “I’m excited to ride this beautiful route through the Eastside.” “East Link’s opening in 2023 will be preceded in 2021 by Northgate Link and in 2022 by the Tacoma Link Hilltop Extension. One year later, in 2024, we will extend Link to downtown Redmond, Lynnwood and Federal Way,” said Sound Transit CEO Peter Rogoff. “These historic investments will finally give us the true mass transit network the Puget Sound region has sought for more than a half century. They will more than double our current reach and simultaneously help fuel our region’s economic recovery.” East Link will extend light rail 14 miles from downtown Seattle to downtown Bellevue and the Overlake area of Redmond via I-90, with Jay Dee Contractors, Inc. 10 stations. Following the 2023 opening of the project, in 2024 Link www.jaydee.us light rail will extend another 3.4 miles east to new stations in Southeast Redmond and downtown Redmond.
tunnelingonline.com 9 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 UTILIZATION OF UNDERGROUND SPACE PROMOTES URBAN DEVELOPMENT By Nasri Munfah, PE
Researching for this article, I encoun- City’s population was mostly in lower Manhat- tered an image from my personal nearby tan within walking distance to the light industry neighborhood in New York taken in 1917 located in the area; at the time, the city was showing the construction of the Flushing amongst the highest density cities in the world RSubway Line in Queens; the area was rural and because of the confinement of its residents to a egacities b opulation rowth and essentially farmland at the time; presently it is a small area in Manhattan. vibrant residential, commercial, industrial and The massive construction of New York City Figure 2 Megacities – Source – recreational neighborhood; see Figure 1. subway lines between 1913 and 1940, during “Megacities and our Global Urban Although this line was not underground, which 180 route miles including 12 bridge and Future” 2005 – Earth Sciences for the expansion of the New York subway around subaqueous tunnel crossings overcoming the Society Foundation, The Netherland the turn of the 20th century was instrumental river barriers, integrated Queens, Brooklyn and in the urban development of New York City the Bronx with Manhattan. This opened new by long boulevards and tree lined streets with as we know it today. Based on an article by lands for the development of affordable, low- single or two-family homes and apartment Thomas Jablonski in 2006 entitled “New York density housing for middle-class and working- houses. Open parks, institutional facilities, and City’s Subway Century - Rail Transit’s Role in class families while allowing them to fast and recreational areas were soon to follow. These Growth and Development”, at the end of the convenient access to their workplaces. Soon the transformations also brought to the new neigh- 19th century and early 20th century, New York rural areas in the outer boroughs was replaced borhoods local commercial and light industries
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 10 tunnelingonline.com Fig. 1 - The extension of the Flushing Line along Queens Boulevard, in 1917, completely changed the rural landscape of Queens
forming mini-societal areas within the larger metropolitan. In 2018 thirty-three megacities, each with a population of over 10 mil- By 1940, when the initial NYC subway system was mostly completed, lion people, and collectively housing more than 500 million people exist- the population of the city was about 7.5 million, similar to the population ed in the world; it is estimated that by 2030, 60% of the world population now of 8.3 million residents providing connectivity to the metropolitan will be residing in urban areas and the number of cities with population and prosperity to the City with over 5.5 million riders per day in 2019. over 5 million inhabitants will be over 100; this trend of urban growth is Although during the present COVID-19 pandemic, the subway ridership expected to continue throughout the 21 century. dropped to as low as 10% of its former daily passenger use, the system The large megacities will grow even larger and the number of megaci- continued to provide lifeline for essential workers who shouldered the ties will increase creating more megacities and super megacities. Figure safety and wellbeing of New Yorkers during this period. It is anticipated 2 shows mega cities in 2015 and their expected growth by 2025. This that NYC subway ridership will return to its pre-pandemic level within shift in population centers necessitates the development of infrastructure one or two years. The subway will continue to be New York’s lifeline, in cities to support the population surge including provisions of efficient sustaining its economic and physical vitality; no one can imagine New transportation systems; reliable utilities such as power, water, sewer, and York City without its subway system. communication systems; and supporting infrastructures. Unfortunately, We see similar examples throughout the world of the role of the population growth is outpacing the development of infrastructures to subway systems in urban development and connectivity of neighborhoods support such growth and the limited available surface spaces suggest that and localities. Examples include Washington Metro, Toronto subway the logical location of these systems is underground; yet most cities lack system, London underground, Seoul Metro, Hong Kong Subway, Beijing general policies about the utilization of the underground space as part of Metro and recently the Paris Metro expansion, all resulted in successful its urban planning. urban development and economic growth. However, not all stories are success stories; for example, in an article Sustainability and Resiliency of Underground Space written by Professors John Landis and Robert Cervero in 1999 entitled Environmental decline, climate change and the increased awareness of “BART and Urban Development”, The Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) the need of sustainable development invite the use of underground space. did not spur the intended developments. They conclude that BART achieved one major success and many missed opportunities. BART was instrumental in the development of the commercial hub of San Francisco Fig. 3 - Montreal “Underground City.” maintaining its preeminence as the business and financial center, but it failed to trigger similar achievements in the East Bay and reinvestment in developments in downtown Oakland, Berkley or Richmond. They concluded that the benefit of rail transit in urban development is not automatic, but it can be a catalyst for urban development through the collaboration of transit agencies, local governments, and private develop- ers to overcome obstacles of policies, design, and financing. This article will examine the benefits of the use of the underground space and its potentials in urban planning.
The Needs of Underground Space In the last few decades, underground space became increasingly important for the development of societies. Population growth, growth of metropolises, migration to cities, environmental awareness, and increased needs for transportation, water, utilities, storage, security, and sheltering encouraged the use and the development of underground space.
tunnelingonline.com 11 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 various levels connecting to transit system, underground parking, com- mercial levels, services, and connections to office buildings, with other adjoining developments. For example, Montreal’s Underground City (La Ville Souterraine) consisting of a network of 29 km (18 miles) of tunnels and underground space spread over an area of 12 square kilometres (3,000 acres) provides efficient use of the underground space. See Figure 3. Another example of efficient use of the underground space is the implementation of utility corridors, also known as utilidors in which vari- ous utility services are organized in a planned underground space rather than placed arbitrarily as various utility owners see fit often impacting other utilities and impacting surface traffic, businesses and the public when repairs or replacement are needed. Figure 4 shows an example of utilidor from Amsterdam In the last few decades, many major cities in the world started placing Fig. 4 - Utilidor in Amsterdam carries multiple utility many of its facilities and urban services underground and developing lines SOURCE: Courtesy H. Admiraal. real underground cities – but often not within an overall urban planning strategy. A report prepared by ITA/ITACUS/ISOCARP entitled “Think Increasing the demand for better living conditions in urban areas can be Deep: Planning, development and use of underground space in cities” achieved by placing infrastructure facilities, utility distribution, transpor- addressed the needs and the challenges of integrating underground space tation systems, and other supporting structures underground. The use of planning with urban planning dealing with the third dimension of space the underground space provides significant direct and indirect benefits. planning. For example, to meet the growth of population in London, In general, the underground placement of the lesser facilities such as several underground infrastructure projects were planned and are under parking, transportation, utilities, storage, etc. provides the opportunity construction including Crossrail, Thames Tideway Tunnel, Northern to develop the land for better and nobler purposes such as residential, Line Extension, and London Power Tunnels; yet there is no holistic commercial, institutional, and recreational facilities including parks and planning for the underground space. While only six of the 32 London green spaces. The multiuse of the land enhances the quality of life and boroughs consider underground structures in their plans, all are related provides environmental and economic benefits to the users and to the to residential basement design standards and none deal with the overall society at large. planning of underground space in a holistic manner. The use of the underground space is sustainable. It provides isolation The urban planning system in New York City has evolved since 1811 from the elements reducing power consumption and carbon footprint. with the establishment of the grid pattern of a 7-mile stretch of Manhat- Thermal isolation is naturally provided by the ground with a uniform tan consisting of 11 major avenues and 155 cross streets creating blocks and moderate temperature level throughout the year; it reduces the needs of approximately 250 ft by 900 ft. In 1916, New York implemented the for climate control and its associated costs and environmental impacts. first zoning resolution and by 1936 it established the City Planning The use of underground space provides additional environmental Commission. Although city planning agencies in both London and New benefits in term of visual effects, air quality by removing vehicles from York share similar objectives for improving the quality of their urban en- streets, less congestion, and a reduction of noise and vibration result- vironments addressing issues such as housing, neighborhoods, parks and ing in a better quality of life at the surface. The use of the underground public spaces, transportation, energy, water supply, waste management, facilities improves the local and global ecological cycle. air quality, climate change, resiliency, etc., neither have any underground The use of underground space provides resilient facilities. Natural spatial planning or design strategies. They are not alone in this regard, disasters such as earthquakes, hurricanes, tornadoes, thunderstorms very few cities throughout the world have such underground spatial use and flood have lesser impact on underground facilities because they are policies or standards. protected from the elements. The impacts of seismic event are far less By contrast, in Tianjin, China, for example (as well as other Chinese on underground structures than above ground structures; structural cities), in which the urban development is accelerating rapidly, and oscillation and amplification effects for underground structures are far less than surface (or above surface) structures. Underground facilities are more cost effective considering life-cycle cost and triple bottom line Fig. 6 – Tianjin underground surface planning allocate since design life of all underground facilities exceed 100 years; many different levels for different facility types existing operating tunnels are much older such as the Thames Tunnel in London constructed in 1843 and the London Underground which was first opened in 1863.
Underground Space as the Third Dimension in Urban Planning Underground space provides opportunities for better urban develop- ment. The use of subsurface space allows for a holistic urban planning benefiting from the three-dimensional space with suitable integration of the spaces above and below the surface creating opportunities for more efficient use of the urban land. It also provides the opportunity of creat- ing a more desirable, less dense surface environment by creating more open spaces and outdoor recreational facilities and parks. For example, building an underground sport arena or a shopping center while devel- oping the area above it for outdoor recreational facilities or providing green spaces allow multiple uses of the land. Often these developments are extended several levels below the surface with various functions at
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 12 tunnelingonline.com utilization of urban underground space entered benefits, and tax incentives often affect the a rapid development stage, the city planning in route, alignment, configuration, station loca- 2004 carried out an extensive research on the tions and surface connections with potential development and utilization of underground future developments. Impact of construction space. This was documented in a plan entitled on traffic, businesses and the daily lives of “Comprehensive Utilization of Underground communities could also deter public accep- Space Planning in Tianjin Central City (2006- tance of an underground transit system. The 2020)”, which is aligned to the City Urban public in affluent areas may also be concerned Master Plan. There, underground space about security and integration fearing that planning was prepared at the macro, meso and mass transit system will bring a large number micro level corresponding to the underground of unknow and undesirable people to their space use. The master plan is based on distri- neighborhood; a case in point is the lack of bution of the underground space in multiple a subway line to Georgetown in Washington, layers, namely shallow (10m), middle (20m) and D.C., despite the fact that a subway line was deep (30m). Space allocations of the various planned since mid 1970s. On the other hand, layers are based on their utilization for parking, when a development is successful around sta- services and utilities, commercial, transporta- tion locations, real estate prices rise, displac- tion, etc. See Figure 6. Underground space ing lower income residents and gentrifying planning guidelines are used to incorporate the neighborhood. This has been seen in underground space into the urban regula- many large cities with underground transit tory planning system, and to guide the urban system such as New Yok, Washington, and Los construction as a basis for urban management. Angeles. In spite of the wide spread of New Currently, the total construction area of under- York City subway system, the 4th Regional Fig. 5 – New York underground ground space in Tianjin central city has exceed- Plan issued in 2017 identified that more than systems developed at multiple levels ed 15 million square meters (160 million square one third of all New Yorkers don’t live within without controlled underground space feet), but it is still focusing on the basic level of walking distance of a subway station. Most are planning – Courtesy of Elizabeth the shallow and middle layers. With the recent low-income neighborhoods and communities Reynolds and Paul Reynolds completion of 9 subway lines totaling 470 km of color for whom transit access is dispropor- (294 miles), the city focused on the develop- tionately important and who have no other ment of transportation urban hubs and urban means of transportation to their workplaces. Understanding the potentials of under- public centers integrating the surface planning Similarly SPUR in the Bay Area in California ground space is not enough, realizing its actual with the underground space utilization; yet the in its report “The Future of Transportation” potential and facilitating its development will construction of underground rail transit cannot issued August 2020 identified equity as an require an awareness program and a continual keep pace with its urban development. This ap- essential strategy of a successful transportation dialogue among many stakeholders, including proach is also adopted by other cities in China planning and made recommendations to “Set policy-makers, city planners, engineers, devel- including Beijing and Shanghai. prices to promote efficiency and equity”. opers, and the public. The strong policies and the strong admin- It is of critical importance that new or Underground space development should be istrative controls for implementation in China extended underground transit lines or new part of city planning following the context of an would not necessarily be possible in the United systems address these disparities by establishing existing urban plan. With the predicted popula- States. However, policies that facilitate effective policies regarding land use around stations to tion growth and the growth of megacities, long-range planning of underground space use, minimize displacement of the residents such as efficient use of underground space promotes as are found in locations such as Singapore or the implementation of mixed-use development sustainable development, improves the urban Helsinki, helped those locations move closer to and affordable housing with public amenities environment, preserves natural resources, and sustainability goals and integrating under- meeting environmental and sustainability goals; accomplishes long-term, triple-bottom-line ground space with urban planning, can be thus creating vibrant public places fostering a applicable to many cities in the United States. strong economy benefiting everyone including economic benefits. For example, policies that enforce preservation the local communities. of the surface environment while permitting Nasri Munfah is a Senior Vice President facility expansion underground would provide Final Notes and Director of Tunneling and Under- a reason for moving more infrastructure Generally, all over the world, urban planners ground Engineering Center of Excellence underground in a deliberate planned approach. tend to overlook the invaluable assets of the for AECOM. He is responsible for devel- Another example is the policies adopted in underground space, “the final frontier”. Most oping and implementing the firm’s long Japan allowing public agencies the rights to urban planers and policy makers are unaware term strategic tunneling growth plan; he develop deep underground space under private of the benefits and the opportunities the under- oversees the firm’s tunneling and under- properties avoiding lengthy legal barriers and ground space has to offer. Population growth, ground projects and provides leadership in allowing more versatile and rapid development migration to metropolises, and the growth of project pursuit and delivery, the develop- of underground projects. large cities in size and number, outpace the ment of innovative solutions, recruitment development of supporting infrastructures. The and the professional development of staff. Equity in Underground Space Planning availability of space at the surface is diminish- With over 40 years of experience in tun- The decision to place transit systems un- ing and quality of life and the livability of cities neling and underground engineering, he derground often faces many challenges among are threatened. Urban underground space was responsible for the successful deliv- various competing interests. Political views, forms a societal asset, often unappreciated by ery of multi-billion-dollar projects in DBB community interest and lifestyle, commercial policy-makers and urban planners. and Alternative Delivery Methods.
tunnelingonline.com 13 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 MARKET SPOTLIGHT: ROADHEADERS
ith roots tracing back to the first half provided that the hardness (unconfined compres- A) COMPARED TO DRILL AND BLAST: of the 20th century, roadheaders sive strength) of the material to be excavated is not • No over cut have a long history in the under- in excess of 20,000 psi UC for smaller machines • Higher production in most cases, depending ground construction industry on a and 30,000 psi for the largest machines. on material wealthW of applications including tunnels, mines The market for roadheaders naturally depends • Less vibration and other underground structures. Their small on the political situations, the availability of financ- • Less noise footprint, maneuverability and adaptability make ing, and naturally on the tunnel designers, who • Less fracture of nearby rock, construc- them the right choice on a number of jobs. frequently will determine in their plans either to tion etc. So what type of jobs are ideally suited to the use use a roadheader or another means of excavating. of a roadheader? How have they evolved to meet Over the last several years, the market for B) COMPARED TO TBM: the needs of an underground contractor? To find roadheaders in North America was relatively quiet. • higher versatility out, TBM: Tunnel Business Magazine contacted Looking forward, there are numerous tunnels • less capital investment Karl Mitterndorfer, president and CEO of An- in the design phase that will be excavated with • ability to cut different tunnel shapes and traquip Corp., based in Hagerstown, Maryland. roadheaders. tunnel profiles Founded in 1985, Antraquip has become a world- wide manufacturing leader of reliable roadheaders, What are the advantages innovative rock and concrete rotary drum cutting What Types of Projects attachments, tunnel support systems and supplier of roadheaders in of other specialized machinery for the construc- Lend Themselves to tion, mining and the tunnel industries. tunneling applications? Mitterndorfer shared his views on the status of Roadheaders vs. Other roadheaders in today’s underground construction What are the limitations? industry, the latest developments in roadheader The limitations for roadheaders is the hardness Methologies? technology, and tips for getting the most out of (UCS) of the material to be excavated. At times, Most uses of roadheaders are: your machine. the combination of hardness of the material and a. In large short sections, like stations on the size limit for the roadheader limits the opera- new subway lines, in soft to medium hard tion of a roadheader. Meaning, sometimes you ground Describe the use of would need a larger machine for the specific rock b. For excavation of starter tunnels and tail roadheaders in the excavation, but you do not have enough space to tunnels for TBM projects do that. c. For smaller utility tunnels due to size tunnel market today? Is it Normally, the heavier the machine, the limitations higher the production and the higher the abil- d. For special complex geological projects, increasing? Decreasing? ity to cut harder rock. Today, roadheaders are even if the tunnel is longer, but the use of a Why? manufactured with a cutter motor power up to TBM is not acceptable due to high risk of 400kW, an operating weight up to 150 tons and the TBM getting stuck Roadheaders are the preferred way of exca- the ability to cut material with a UCS of up to e. For excavation of stations in harder mate- vating tunnels in soft to medium hard ground, 30,000 psi. rial, if drill and blast is either forbidden or mainly for tunnels that are up to 1 ½ miles long The advantages of roadheaders are: complicated.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 14 tunnelingonline.com Roadheaders remain an important part of the modern-day tunneling industry. For the right project, there is no better way to excavate the tunnel.
How has roadheaders with air conditioned closed cabins to What advice can you protect the operator from breathing dust technology evolved? particles etc. give a contractor to help What are the latest a. Remote capabilities have been improved. get the most out of the Roadheaders can be operated remotely on advancements? distances of several hundred feet. machinery? (Operating tips, The challenge to be able to cut harder and a. Automatic guidance systems can be harder rock keeps going on and on. And still the installed. maintenance tips, etc.) limit is the usage of cutting tools (cutter picks) to First, pick the right size of roadheader. Unless make it efficient and economical. Currently, the there are other reasons (like space limitations) largest roadheaders with up to 400 kW cutting What should a contractor try not to run the roadheader in harder material power can cut material up to 30,000 psi. Is it ef- look for when purchasing a than it was designed for. Also try not to run it at ficient and economical to cut material that hard? the maximum hardness allowed. Depends on the circumstances, like abrasivity roadheader? Continued service as per operating instruc- of the material to be cut, other possible ways of Every project that considers a roadheader tions is of utmost importance. excavation, etc. is different. Therefore, when purchasing a Also, follow all other guidance in the operat- roadheader the utmost importance is that the ing manuals as closely as possible. roadheader is able to do what is expected as to Replace cutter bits when necessary. Follow Increased Flexibility production, speed of excavation, etc. the instructions in the operating manual. More and more additional tools can be installed Therefore, only use a reputable supplier And, most important, if you feel, hear or see on the roadheader, sometime even on the same with a proper track record. Also make sure anything not normal, figure out the problem machine. For example, the same roadheader can you not only ask questions, but also check out – either by yourself or with help from the manu- be equipped with a drill for forepoling and a drill the track record. facturer – and repair the issue immediately. for roof-bolting. Secondly, you want to rethink what you Problems do not disappear by themselves and plan to do with the roadheader after the only get worse over time. project is finished. Do you want to keep it in Increased Safety Standards your fleet or do you want to resell it or sell it Additional substantial improvements have been back to roadheader manufacturer? If you want made on safety. to add it to your fleet, you should consider a Concluding comments a. Installation of proximity systems, which machine that can be used in numerous set ups. Roadheaders remain an important part of will shut down the machine if an unau- Since roadheaders are working and have the modern-day tunneling industry. For the thorized person is getting to close to the been working in very difficult projects, the right project, there is no better way to excavate operating machine. This also will help availability of professional support and prompt the tunnel; however, it must be within the avoiding run-ins between the roadheader – overnight – spare part supply is a necessity. criteria as outlined earlier. In North America, and the loader or scoop tram to remove It does not help you if parts have to be flown the number of roadheaders operating at any the material. in from overseas, which will – at best - take one time depends on many factors, including, a. Dust control is very critical. Consequently, days before the parts are available at the but not limited to, the design of the projects by all larger roadheaders can be equipped jobsite. the tunnel design firms.
tunnelingonline.com 15 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 UNDERGROUND PROJECTS FORGE AHEAD Jay Dee Contractors’ essential workers keep critical infrastructure safe
hen considering the essential workers who have kept construction projects safe and forged the underpinnings of large- scale sewer, water, transit and energy Wsystems, it’s important to remember the under- ground contractors. Livonia, Michigan-based Jay Dee Contractors and its team of experts have played a key role in constructing and rehabilitating the underground pipelines that convey the sewer, water and energy systems we depend on, in turn, contributing more than 50 years of infrastructure upgrades that improve the environmental profile of the Great Lakes and beyond. Established in 1965, family-owned Jay Dee has dug deep into infrastructure projects across the U.S. and Canada. Specializing in complex projects in varied geologies, Jay Dee’s work spans water, wastewater, transportation projects and more, all On September 30, 2019, the Jay Dee Contractors team got ready to with an eye toward promoting sustainability and a cleaner environment. lower the cutterhead into the shaft to attach it to the TBM. The photo While Jay Dee has completed all types of features Jay Dee’s whole day shift team. projects, water and wastewater tunnels were instrumental in the company’s development. “We like to think of ourselves as the stewards of clean to say that when a new or different challenge “It’s been challenging for us an employer. We water,” said Michael DiPonio, president of Jay Dee emerges, our unmatched team of problem-solvers have a very highly skilled team of tunnelers, but Contractors. “We’re proud of our track record finds a way. I’m proud to report our team is when it comes to working thru a pandemic, even of complex work on tunneling and infrastructure responsible for the construction of more than 50 our most experienced people are novices. Re- projects in the Great Lakes region and beyond. miles of new or improved pipeline systems over learning how to work during COVID has been Over my lifetime I have seen a dramatic improve- the last 10 years.” difficult because some of the guidelines were devel- ment in the water quality of the Great Lakes and The pandemic has required many businesses, oped quickly and are changing over time, making I’m proud that our company has made significant including tunnel contractors, to re-examine it somewhat of a moving target,” DiPonio said. contributions to that effort. protocols to ensure compliance to health and “For us the critical component has been social “Similar to millions of other essential workers, safety guidelines. As an essential business, tunnel distancing, which is extremely difficult for an un- our team was tested for its resiliency during the construction has continued on, but with some derground contractor. So, we’ve had to re-evaluate COVID-19 outbreak. However, we’re proud modifications to work practices. everything we do from limiting people in the
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 16 tunnelingonline.com This photo shows the stationary shield being delivered to the Westerly site via Goldhofer trailer and unloaded by crane on September 5, 2020.
The Jay Dee Contractors swing shift tunnel superintendent and erector operator during ring installation at the Westerly project in Ohio.
District’s 25-year, $3 billion Project Clean Lake, and value engineering. The proposed project, a CSO control plan that is cleaning up Lake Erie, currently in the permitting phase, would relocate the Cuyahoga River and other area waterways. the existing Line 5 pipeline on the lakebed in the The $135 million project, awarded to Jay Dee Straits of Mackinac, which links Lake Michigan and its JV partner Obayashi, includes approxi- and Lake Huron. mately 9,600 lf of 25-ft ID CSO storage tunnel The Great Lakes Tunnel Project involves build- excavated in rock and supported with a bolted, ing a new tunnel deep under the lake to house the gasketed, one-pass steel fiber reinforced concrete pipeline. The project would help reduce potential segmental lining. In addition to the tunnel, there impacts to the pipeline and provide complete pro- are three deep shafts. tection to water in the Straits in the unlikely event When completed, the project will reduce over- of a pipeline failure. flows into the Cuyahoga River by more than 300 trailers at shift changes to how many people can million gallons per year, further benefitting a river A Cleaner Future go in the shaft elevator and be transported to the that has experienced substantial improvement over While the global pandemic has adversely im- tunnel heading. the past several decades. pacted many industries, the future of the tunneling “One thing we can do is help make workers feel “It is rewarding working on a project like market looks bright, especially for sewer and water safe and comfortable, so we disinfect the work ar- Westerly that is helping to make a difference in projects. Even transportation projects, which may eas completely between shifts. Additionally, we ask the environment,” said Lisa Smiley, Geotechnical be affected in the shorter term due to reduced rid- our employees to err on the side of safety and not Engineer/Project Engineer for Jay Dee working on ership revenues, help create a sustainable, energy come in if they are experiencing any signs of being the Westerly project. “Last year marked the 50th efficient travel option for ever-growing cities. sick. As a result, we have a higher absentee rate, anniversary of the Cuyahoga River fire, and it is “Despite the challenges we all face, the which means we need to have a larger crew size to amazing to see how the water quality of the river outlook looks good for tunnel companies,” be able to work safely and efficiently.” and the lake have improved. In fact, not far from said Brian Hagan, Director of Equipment and the jobsite there is a fish reservation that on the Engineering at Jay Dee. “Even at the height of Creating a Cleaner Environment river that could not have existed without projects the shutdowns, all of the projects we had under The history of Jay Dee aligns with that of the like Westerly and its predecessors.” contract remained open. They are considered environmental movement and the passage of the Not too far to the northeast, Jay Dee crews critical infrastructure, which is part of what Clean Water Act in 1972. The Act led to several are engaged with another environmental project makes our work so rewarding. People still need pollution control programs beginning in the 1970s, helping to reduce impacts on Lake Ontario. The water and wastewater services, and they need to notably the Tunnel and Reservoir Plan (TARP) Coxwell Bypass Tunnel – being built by a joint go from Point A to Point B.” in Chicago, and subsequently similar programs in venture of Jay Dee, CM McNally and Michels The critical nature of tunneling projects as well the Great Lakes region and beyond. Jay Dee got Canada – is an important part of Toronto’s over- as the engineering challenges they pose can help involved with TARP early on with pump station all Don River & Central Waterfront (DR&CW) lure and retain the next generation of tunnel- construction contracts, and worked consistently on project. This tunnel will capture, store and trans- ing professionals to the field. “Tunneling is an the program into the 2000s. port combined sewer overflows, for treatment at interesting career because of the direct influence “We are very proud of our involvement with the Ashbridges Bay Treatment Plant. The tunnel, you can make on society and the environment,” TAR P,” DiPonio said. “Before the program being built by a 7.1-m TBM, comprises 10.5 km Smiley said. “It is also a great career for an engi- started, Chicago experienced sewer overflows once of new sewer approximately 50 m deep, parallel neer because every project is unique and you are every four days on average. Now, they experience to the Don River. It represents the longest single always learning something new. And, when the four overflows per year. It has been a tremendous tunnel built by Jay Dee. project is built, you see the effect your work has success and has been emulated by other cities While different in its end use, the Great Lakes on other people.” bounded to the Great Lakes.” Tunnel Project for the energy company Enbridge Hagan concurs. “Growing up in Michigan, Currently, Jay Dee is working on two wastewa- is another example of Jay Dee’s work having a we always took pride in our Great Lakes,” he ter projects in the Great Lakes region the Westerly positive influence on the environment of the Great said. “So, it has been really special being part of a Storage Tunnel in Cleveland, Ohio, and the Lakes. As part of Great Lakes Tunnel Constructors company that has worked on so many projects that Coxwell Bypass Tunnel in Toronto. with partner Obayashi, Jay Dee is working under a have helped keep the Great Lakes clean and safe. The Westerly Storage Tunnel is the most recent preconstruction services agreement with Enbridge We are proud to position ourselves as stewards of and largest of the Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer to provide constructability review, cost estimating the Great Lakes and the environment.”
tunnelingonline.com 17 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 UPGRADED LIGHTING IN “ENGINEERING WONDER” Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel Results in Unique, New Design Innovations
ince its opening in 1964, the Chesa- the right direction to keep pace with an evolving peake Bay Bridge–Tunnel (CBBT) has industry – all while reducing energy consump- not only been regarded as a critical tion in today’s modern world.” The final installation is nearing travel route, bearing approximately 4 completion, meets all project Smillion vehicles per year, but also as a modern So Long, Fluorescent Lighting requirements and looks great. engineering wonder. The CBBT is a 17.6-mile The existing linear fluorescent tunnel lumi- (28.3 km) bridge-tunnel crossing that con- naires were replaced one-for-one with 2,835 nects Northampton County, Virginia, on the Kenall LuxTran LTLI-8 LED tunnel luminaires. eastern shore, with the communities of Virginia With these new fixtures, the CBBT will save Beach, Norfolk, Chesapeake, and Portsmouth $500,00 per year in maintenance costs and on Virginia’s western shore. It is the world’s energy consumption, as well as reduced traffic second-largest bridge-tunnel complex, allowing congestion. Michael Crist, the Deputy Director critical military and shipping traffic to move of Infrastructure for the CBBT, emphasized the unimpeded from the Thimble Shoals and important of these savings. “Prior to installing Chesapeake shipping canals to the Atlantic LED lights, we had a one-week-per-month light- Ocean. [1] [2] ing detail, requiring a tunnel lane closure, with The CBBT is a complicated (and expanding) three to four operations personnel, and three combination of approximately 12 miles (19 km) or four maintenance personnel, to replace light of trestle, four high-level bridges, four artificial bulbs. Eliminating this detail is a huge cost sav- islands, two 1-mile-long (1.6 km) underwater ings and a big safety improvement,” he said. tunnels, 2 miles (3.2 km) of causeway, and 5.5 With this installation complete, the CBBT miles (8.9 km) of approach roads. While con- now has high-quality, corrosion-resistant, struction on a new parallel tunnel to ease traffic certified fixtures that will last for decades – far is getting underway, the two existing 1-mile-long beyond the point of return on investment. (1.6 km) tunnels needed an equipment overhaul To get more details about the project, we sat due to aging infrastructure. Consequently, the down with Kenall’s Transportation Sales Man- After a successful mockup trial period, CBBT began a three-year project to restore and ager, Michael Maltezos for a detailed Q&A. and a thorough review of Kenall’s submittal improve these tunnels’ critical systems and facili- ac age and certified test re orts for the ties, including lighting. hat are the specific benefits of new luminaires, the CBBT approved them The CBBT’s Director of Maintenance, Tim the new LED tunnel for the tunnels’ Interior Zones. Holloway, described the new LED lighting sys- lighting system? tems as “a long overdue solution to highly repeti- There are several benefits, including: tive and costly tunnel re-lamp lane closures, with • LuxTran LTLI-8 LED tunnel luminaires savings on power consumption being the icing meet or exceed existing light levels and on the cake.” Furthermore, Holloway continued, uniformities, and reconfirm compliance “The product we needed simply did not exist. with the ANSI/IESNA RP-22-11 Recom- Kenall worked hand in hand with us to develop mended Practice for Tunnel Lighting[3] the product and then further refine it in the field • The tunnel visibility is improved, and to make sure all our needs were met.” disability/discomfort glare is kept to a Chase Sturgis, the CBBT’s Electrical/ minimum for public safety Mechanical (E/M) Superintendent, agreed: “Re- • The CBBT realizes substantial energy placing the existing fluorescent tunnel lighting savings fixtures with new LED fixtures manufactured by • The tunnels will be equipped with robust Kenall has been a rewarding achievement of the fixtures of the highest quality, which will CBBT’s Maintenance Division. The collabora- require little-to-no maintenance Kenall coordinated with CBBT to tive effort, from procurement to commissioning Additionally, we improved the existing further customize the luminaires so this project, ensures the CBBT is taking steps in fixtures’ shallow profile, to prevent trucks from they would be structurally stable when installed.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 18 tunnelingonline.com In order to be re-fed from the adjacent existing wire way on the ceiling deck, the LED replacement luminaires had to include cord sets Kenall designed custom heat than the existing fixtures. Obviously, this was a to match those currently plugging sinks for the LED drivers to huge concern. In fact, at the time of design, no the existing wire way. mitigate the heat. luminaire manufacturer, including Kenall, could make such a shallow-profile, high-output LED tunnel fixture that would pass a heat test in a ceiling-mounted application without substantial heatsinking ... until now. In order to be re-fed from the adjacent existing wire way on the ceiling deck, the LED replace- ment luminaires had to include cord sets to match those currently plugging the existing wire way. These cord sets had to be in a spot on the new LED fixtures that would consistently line up with the plug-in receptacle locations in the existing wire way. To achieve this, multiple levels of design coordination were undertaken to ensure that both the new fixture lengths and cord set locations would work properly within the footprint of the existing fluorescent fixture and cord set locations. Finally, the luminaires had to be mounted onto the existing mounting rail, located on one side of the existing wire way. This meant that Kenall coordinated with the CBBT they all needed to have a completely customized hitting and damaging the fixtures due to the very to manufacture fixtures that would fit mounting design to fit onto the existing wire way’s low ceiling clearances (as continually happened perfectly, both in terms of longitudinal mounting rail pattern. In short, exact locations of to the existing fluorescent fixtures.) It drastically locations of the cord sets on the the LED luminaires’ mounting rails and cord set reduces the number of frequent nightly maintenance fixtures, as well as cord set lengths feeds had to be completely coordinated with exist- details required to keep the tunnel illuminated. This and clearances between the fixtures ing conditions on the tunnel wire way, yielding a reduction provides a safer work environment for and the adjacent wire way. plug-and-play application. CBBT employees, as well as the traveling public. It also provides CBBT personnel the opportunity to How were these perform other preventative maintenance work neces- placement fixtures had to physically fit within the challenges overcome? sary to the facility. existing footprints – not a standard feature at the Because the LED replacement luminaires had time of design – but a customization Kenall was able to physically fit within the existing footprints, What challenges did you have during to accommodate. Kenall had to design a completely new tunnel this lighting replacement? The LED replacement luminaires had to provide luminaire. At the time of design, not only did Due to existing conditions within the tunnel, the the required light output in all the various tunnel Kenall not have such a customized footprint tun- project tunnel lighting had to be a 1-for-1 replace- zones, without overheating. This was no small feat, nel luminaire in its product portfolio, no lighting ment of the existing continuous linear fluorescent particularly in the threshold zones where the new manufacturer did. We designed a more compact tunnel luminaires. More specifically, all the existing LED fixtures replaced existing 500W fluorescent luminaire to fit within the existing fluorescent fluorescent tunnel luminaires were ceiling-mounted luminaires. Higher-output LED fixtures inherently fixture footprint, while maintaining the acces- near the tunnel walls and the adjacent continuous produce heat, particularly in a ceiling-mounted sibility of component parts for servicing. Our linear wire way needed to be re-used to feed the application; additionally, the replacement fixtures engineers were able to implement the same or replacement luminaires. Accordingly, all LED re- required a shallower profile (less than 3-in. total!) smaller physical design/footprint for all fixtures in
tunnelingonline.com 19 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 the project’s various tunnel zones, minimizing meet all the project requirements, while main- • Class B rated for harmonic emissions, per the types and quantities of replacement fixtures, taining our standard of quality and delivering a FCC Title 47, CFR Part 15. [10] as well as parts, to be stocked by CBBT mainte- completely customized product. • Per Holloway, the fixture housings had nance personnel. to be 316 SS or marine-grade aluminum To address the challenges of providing the Why/how were these tunnel to withstand the highly corrosive loca- required light output in the threshold zones while luminaires ultimately chosen? tion of the tunnels, which are located a maintaining an extremely shallow profile, Kenall As noted previously, these luminaires did not few miles offshore designed custom heat sinks for the LED drivers to yet exist at the time of design: Michael Crist told Now that the luminaires are installed and opera- mitigate the heat. This, combined with the new us that that industry outreach identified no exist- tional, how is the tunnel lighting being received? fixture housing’s 2.5-in. profile and linear design ing light fixtures that could meet the needs of the Because Kenall supported this project every step for air flow, allowed the fixture to operate at a CBBT. Consequently, they invited manufactur- of the way, the fixtures are performing as prom- relatively low temperature, despite its location on ers to submit a custom design; then prototype ised. The final installation is nearing completion, the ceiling deck. Kenall engaged in multiple itera- designs were tested in the tunnel. After testing, meets all project requirements and looks great, so tions of driver testing at its own test lab to replicate CBBT selected the LuxTran fixture to move to a the CBBT is very pleased. The tunnel lighting is actual conditions in the tunnels, and performed pilot program, and, ultimately, for the full lighting more uniform than before, and the 5000K/70 CRI exhaustive heat testing on the fixtures to verify replacement. The design and acceptance of the system provides excellent safety and visibility for thermal performance in simulated field conditions LuxTran LTLI-8 fixtures came as the replacement drivers in the tunnels. – not just in typical ambient lab conditions. effort evolved, and as a result of a collaborative The collaboration between Kenall and the Because the LED replacement luminaires had to effort between the CBBT and Kenall. CBBT has been very positive and proactive along be re-fed from the adjacent existing wire way on the We worked with the CBBT every step of the the way, and we are extremely grateful. Michael ceiling deck, Kenall participated in field surveys with way to create lighting solutions for the new Inte- “Tee” Wells put the entire project in motion, and the CBBT to discover type, length, and location of rior, Transition and Threshold Zones, in order of led it with passion, helping to make this a reality. all cord sets, and match them. During those surveys, priority. For the initial competitive mockup, the It was Tee who led the charge up through the we discovered that some locations had only minimal CBBT asked us to provide an LED solution for a initial design, competitive mockup and the first clearance between the fixtures and the wire way, small section of the tunnels’ Interior Zones, since round of interior installation: we owe him a debt of necessitating a 90-degree cord connector. Kenall these areas would require the largest number of gratitude, and we will all reap the benefit from his coordinated with the CBBT to manufacture fixtures luminaires – 1,608 out of 2,835. Kenall engineers efforts. Working together, we have enhanced public that would fit perfectly, both in terms of longitudinal made this their top priority, and, upon comple- safety and improved efficiency for the CBBT, locations of the cord sets on the fixtures, as well as tion of testing, submitted the sample fixtures to which has made the project a great success. cord set lengths and clearances between the fixtures the CBBT for installation and review. After a and the adjacent wire way. successful mockup trial period, and a thorough https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chesapeake_Bay_Bridge–Tunnel (ac- Finally, since the LED replacement luminaires review of Kenall’s submittal package and certified cessed September 15, 2015). 2 http://www.cbbt.com/about-us/history/ (accessed September 15, had to be mounted onto the existing mounting rail test reports for the new luminaires, the CBBT ap- 2015). located on one side of the existing wire way, Kenall proved them for the tunnels’ Interior Zones. 3 Illuminating Engineering Society of North America, “ANSI/IES RP- participated in field surveys with the CBBT to Once the Interior Zone Fixtures’ final design 22-11,” Recommended Practice for Tunnel Lighting. confirm a custom mounting bracket design to fit the was tweaked and completed, based on the results 4 Underwriters Laboratories Inc., “LUMINAIRES,” Standard for Safety. existing wire way mounting rail. During that survey, of the Interior Zone Mockup, Kenall then followed 5 https://www.nemaenclosures.com/enclosure-ratings/nema-rated- we discovered that the other side of the fixtures re- the same painstaking process to complete the more enclosures/nema-4x-enclosures.html (accessed September 15, 2015). quired conventional mounting tabs, to be anchored complicated designs for the Transition and Thresh- 6 Illuminating Engineering Society of North America, “ANSI/IES into the ceiling deck. As a result, Kenall coordinated old Zones. All lighting tests, the pilot projects, and, TM-21-19,” Projecting Long Term Lumen Maintenance of LED Light with the CBBT to further customize the luminaires: ultimately, the full replacement was conducted Sources. we needed the mounting tabs to fit perfectly in loca- by CBBT personnel led by E/M Superintendent, 7 International Electrical Commission, “IEC 60598-1:2014,” Lumi- tions where anchors had not been previously drilled Chase Sturgis. naires - Part 1: General Requirements and Tests. into the ceiling deck, so they would be structurally 8 America National Standards Institute, “ANSI C136.27-2012,” For Roadway and Area Lighting Equipment - Tunnel And Underpass stable when installed. This modification/addi- hat notable fi ture listings and Lighting Luminaires. tion allowed for a quicker replacement by CBBT certifications ere re uired for the 9 America National Standards Institute, “ANSI C136.31-2018,” personnel, minimizing the need to modify existing project? Roadway and Area Lighting Equipment – Luminaire Vibration. mounting design already present. There many criteria that had to be met, including: 10 Federal Communications Commission, “CFR Part 15,” Title 47 of • Overall tunnel lighting layout to be de- the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). How did the CBBT come to signed to ANSI/IES RP-22-11. [3] work with Kenall? • UL 1598 rated, for Outdoors/Wet Loca- Michael N. Maltezos, MIES, is the Transpor- Kenall was recommended by Lighting Virginia, tions. [4] tation Sales Manager for Kenall and may after retired CBBT E/M Superintendent Michael • Rated as NEMA 4X Enclosures for Out- be reached at 847-507-4531 or michael. “Tee” Wells consulted with them regarding door Locations. [5] [email protected]. Kenosha, Wisconsin- another lighting product installed at the former • Fixtures to be rated, depending on Tunnel based Kenall produces and supports high restaurant Virginia Originals & Chesapeake Grill, Zone, 100,000-150,000 hours to L70, per quality and durable lighting solutions for the located at One Island on the Bay. IES TM-21. [6] most demanding environments. Kenall prod- The CBBT was aware of the LuxTran brand • IP66 rated, per IEC 60598. [7] ucts are manufactured in the USA and meet but wasn’t sure it would meet the project param- • 100 PSI Water Spray rated, per ANSI the guidelines established under the Buy eters: they only knew Kenall as a company that C136.27. [8] American Act and the North American Free prioritizes luminaire quality and design over low • 3G Vibration Test rated, per ANSI Trade Agreement. For additional informa- initial cost. But we proved that we were able to C136.31. [9] tion, visit www.kenall.com.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 20 tunnelingonline.com Special Sponsored Content Section
Special Sponsored Content Section TBM: Tunnel Business Magazine presents this special sponsored content section highlighting the industry’s leading consultants, contractors, suppliers and manufacturers. On the following pages these companies share their latest in products and services, success stories and more. Be sure to check out the sponsors’ websites for additional information!
Talk about timing! In April of this year TBM published my paper entitled “The Triumph of Tunneling” which correlated the demand for tunnels to the fact that the populations of large cities around the world were increasing at an unprecedented rate and that large cities cannot exist without the infrastructure provided by tunnels; i.e. water supply, waste disposal, drainage, subways, highways, and utility corridors. Fast forward six months and no one has any idea what ur itie ill l li e fi e year fr n a a re ult f l n ter reactions to the pandemic and civil unrest. At present, the tunneling u ine i in ut petiti n i fier e the t f tunnelin (especially in the US) is escalating and the funding stream for tunnels could become precarious. For instance, the September 7th issue of ENR reported that the proposed Hudson River Rail Tunnel has been postponed because of cost increases and environmental delays and that funding for water infrastructure projects will see losses in the range of $13.9 to $16.8 billion as a result of COVID impacts. Many industries are in the process of trying to decide what the “new normal” will be and I think that the tunneling industry is no exception. [email protected] • 303-704-6955
tunnelingonline.com 21 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 Special Sponsored Content Section
The Lane Construction Corporation’s Work in the Tunneling Sector Paced for Fast Growth
Water Quality Project – Storage Tunnel, Lane teams are currently working on the excavation of a 13,000-foot long tunnel for Seattle Public Utility. The project is designed to keep more than 75 million gallons of polluted stormwater and sewage out of the Lake Washington Ship Canal, Salmon Bay, and Lake Union on average each year. The TBM bring used for the Seattle Ship Canal project is an Earth Pressure Balance, currently under assembly in Germany and will be delivered to the site in January 2021. Lane’s North East Boundary Tunnel in Washington, D.C. includes a 27,000-foot long tunnel Lane’s Dugway Storage Tunnel project underneath the Nation’s capital and is forecasted to be finished in early 2023. in Cleveland, Ohio was recently completed on time in the summer of 2020. The completed project is part of a broad plan The Lane Construction Corporation is tunneling project the company has been for the collection, storage, and treatment of one of America’s leading construction awarded for DC Water. At a total value of the Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District, companies, specializing in large, complex $580 million, it includes a 27,000-foot with the objective of reducing the level of civil infrastructure. For 130 years, it has long tunnel underneath the Nation’s environmental pollution in Lake Erie. The contributed to the development of the capital and is currently 65% complete, project included construction of a 14,800- country’s network of roads, highways, f re a ted t e fini hed in early he foot long tunnel that is 24 feet in diameter. and bridges, and now establishes a 23-foot diameter tunnel is excavated with Lane’s reputation in Tunneling has been successful position in the tunneling a Tunnel Boring Machine (TBM). Lane has built from iconic past projects such as the sector, leading the industry in key projects collaborated with the Colorado School of Lake Mead Intake, Anacostia River Tunnel, across the United States. ine t rin artifi ial intelli en e t the rtland C ined Se er er CS Lane’s North East Boundary Tunnel project and apply it to predict and minimize San Francisco Underground, and many (NEBT) in Washington, D.C., is the second ettle ent i pr e effi ien ie and others. Our bid department is currently enhance overall production. pursuing strategic projects across the Lane operates on another ongoing TBM Unites States including the Pawtucket River Lane has collaborated with the Colorado School excavation project that is 50% complete Tunnel in Rhode Island, and opportunities of Mines to bring artificial intelligence to DC in Fort Wayne, Indiana. The Three Rivers in Ohio, California, and others. Water’s North East Boundary Tunnel project and r te ti n er Redu ti n unnel The United States Tunneling sector is apply it to enhance overall production. (3RPORT) contains a 24,000-foot long, growing rapidly and Lane is well positioned 18-foot diameter tunnel that is being a n t the t p rated fir y the ner constructed by means of a Slurry TBM. and its employees, top industry consultants This unique project will be completed in and nationally renowned universities. 2023 as part of a bigger environmental Based in Cheshire, Connecticut, Lane plan for the city. is wholly owned by Webuild, a global The Seattle Ship Canal project located infrastructure group. For more information, in King County, Washington, is the latest visit www.laneconstruct.com. For more tunneling project that has been awarded details about its parent company, visit www. to Lane. Formally known as the Ship Canal webuildgroup.com.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 22 tunnelingonline.com We build large, complex infrastructure projects
We Are the Underground Innovators The U.S. Tunneling sector is growing rapidly... and Lane is accelerating its innovative approach right along with it. www.LaneConstruct.com Special Sponsored Content Section
BIG BREAKTHROUGH HNTB photos for advertorialWorld’s largest soft-ground bored tunnel replaced an aging viaduct and expanded Seattle’s waterfront
damage to it and other structures. The with an 8-foot safety shoulder and 2-foot resulting mitigation plan protected the shoulders in each direction, and 15.5 feet viaduct with a barrier wall of 5-foot-diameter of vertical clearance. The design concept drilled shafts inserted between the tunnel included ramps and mainline lanes and the viaduct, protecting it from ground transitioning from inside the tunnel to four movement. ramp and two mainline roadways outside. “Differential settlement of the viaduct rearran ed the traffi e ent was estimated to be roughly three-fourths at one portal to conserve space and of an inch,” said Rich Johnson, HNTB’s narrow the corridor, shrinking the footprint design manager. “But, during the actual of the south cut-and-cover tunnels and mining, ground movement was limited to associated roadways by 50%, saving time,
one-tenth of an inch.” money, and space. The mitigation plan also included two The tunnel is designed to withstand a In 2017, Bertha, 57.3 feet-tall, 8,000- scheduled TBM maintenance stops, the magnitude 9.0 earthquake, includes state- tons and 328-feet-long, emerged from the fir t at the red tunnel uth p rtal f the art entilati n fire dete ti n and ground beneath downtown Seattle. An “We extended the bored tunnel suppression systems; an emergency egress affectionately nicknamed pressure tunnel portal 450 feet,” Johnson said. “This system with its own ventilation system; boring machine, she left behind the world’s additional length served as a proving exits every 600 feet; a security system largest soft-ground bored tunnel, two miles ground for the TBM and provided space with closed-circuit TVs; and an intelligent long and 57.3 feet in diameter — along with for another innovation, a tunnel-in-a- transportation system with variable old notions about urban transportation. box,” a three-sided enclosure, highly message signs. Now, said Brian Russell, HNTB’s project controlled environment for operators and Opened in 2019, the tunnel provides manager for the State Route 99 tunnel, maintenance crews to become familiar n enient effi ient n rth uth pa a e “Tunneling under buildings and utilities in with, and test-drive, Bertha. Drivers can now bypass downtown entirely an urban environment can be accomplished The award-winning tunnel houses two or exit directly into Seattle’s vibrant, and HNTB photos for advertorial with limited impact,” making DOTs more southbound lanes atop two northbound newly expanded, residential, commercial
willing to consider that solution. lanes. Each roadway is 32-foot-wide and tourist-friendly waterfront. HNTB was the lead designer for the $1.4 billion tunnel project, which included the permanent structures and facilities, the tunnel liner, an interior stacked roadway structure, approach cut-and-cover tunnels and roadways, and operations buildings. An accelerated schedule meant design in 27 months and delivery in multiple construction packages. The collaboration inherent in design-build sparked opportunities for innovation, including switching out the cast-in-place concrete for precast structures, providing more working space inside the tunnel and shaving 6 months off construction. At one point, Bertha mined only 14 feet below the old viaduct’s foundations, so the team took steps to prevent potential
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 24 tunnelingonline.com
SETTING THE STANDARD HNTB has set the standard in state-of-the-art tunnel design. A standard based upon solutions that work. A standard that prioritizes safety and efficiency. A standard that reflects the technical excellence that HNTB continues to set for the most complex tunnels and underground projects in the nation.
Sanja Zlatanic Chair, National Tunnel Practice [email protected] 646.652.9440
Raymond Sandiford East Region Lead [email protected] 917.710.3395
Anthony Bauer West Region Lead [email protected] 213.500.8086
The HNTB Companies Infrastructure Solutions
Alaskan Way Viaduct hntb.com Replacement Program Special Sponsored Content Section
Robbins Projects Persevere Across North America
Conveyors On the Move TBM tunnels are not the only underground projects underway in the U.S. In Lead, South Dakota a Robbins conveyor system is being readied for the Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF), a project for Fermilab. The conveyor will be used by contractor Kiewit in a project to renovate a disused gold mine into a world-class neutrino research facility. Two caverns will be excavated by drill & blast and roadheader about 1.5 km below the surface. Rock will be transported The Robbins Company is the world’s Adaptable Machine Design by cable hoist up the 1.5 km deep Ross foremost developer and manufacturer Meanwhile in Dallas, Texas, the largest Shaft to a rock crusher at the surface of advanced, underground construction hard rock TBM ever to operate in the using much of the original but refurbished machinery. Each piece of equipment, from U.S. is well on its way into the Mill Creek mining equipment, and from there will be our TBMs to our conveyors and everything Drainage Relief Tunnel. The important transported via conveyors. The Robbins in between, is engineered for maximum tunnel was designated essential by the conveyor systems are designed for the durability and premium performance, City of Dallas in order to provide 100-year unique application, and include the ensuring the successful completion of even d pr te ti n f r ea t and uthea t longest overland conveyor Robbins has the t diffi ult under r und n tru ti n Dallas, areas affected in recent years by ever provided (550 m), which travels over projects. Our teams of dedicated experts severe storms. Launched in April 2020, a main road and city park and near a are committed to getting your equipment the 11.6 m diameter Robbins Main Beam residential area. The system includes sound delivered on time, and to providing machine and continuous conveyor system da penin du t filter und pr fed continuing support from TBM launch have excavated more than 1,000 m of the transfer points, and monitoring systems, through to breakthrough. 8 km long tunnel for the Southland/Mole among other features. JV. The adaptable machine will change Find out more about Robbins products A Remote Machine Acceptance size partway through the bore, to a more and projects worldwide on our website, In 2020, projects across the U.S. and compact 9.9 m. www.TheRobbinsCompany.com. Canada have continued to proceed and to perate and e re findin ay t adapt to changing circumstances. In April of this year, Robbins assembled a 7.95 m diameter Single Shield TBM at a facility in e i and ndu ted the pany fir t ever fully remote machine acceptance testing. The Robbins machine was then disassembled and transported, and is currently in the process of being launched on the Ashbridges Bay Treatment Outfall in Ontario, Canada along with a continuous conveyor system. The tunnel will be bored through shale interbedded with limestone, siltstone and sandstone in order to replace a 70-year-old existing outfall.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 26 tunnelingonline.com FEAR NO REPAIRING THE WORLD’S LONGEST TUNNEL Designed for water pressures up to 30 bar and featuring enhanced probe drilling, a 6.8 m diameter Single Shield TBM tackled tough ground and won. The machine repaired a leak in New York City’s Delaware Aqueduct below the Hudson ROCK River, completing the job on budget and ahead of schedule.
Delaware Aqueduct Repair Project New York, USA 6.8 m Single Shield TBM
therobbinscompany.com Special Sponsored Content Section
Your TBM Project Deserves More Than Second-Tier Service You want your assets delivered on time, damage-free, and according to your specs. You want a turnkey TBM solution. No one does it better than PSC Crane & Rigging.
route surveying, over-the-road transport, onsite drayage, storage and staging, lifting and lowering, up & go skidding, and even TBM assembly. There’s a lot to be said about unraveling the many complexities within a TBM challenge—while still delivering a turnkey solution. And as PSC continues to satisfy customers and gain momentum in the tunnel-boring space nationwide, leadership knows that success often lies in not just wanting to wrap up a project on time and on budget, but in being willing to do the extra r up fr nt t a ure afe effi ient and productive completion of the job. Some companies like to tell you what they can do. PSC would rather prove it. Find out more at www.pscind.com. It’s not every day that a company brings in Dayton, Columbus, and Cincinnati, PSC nearly a century of experience to the can easily mobilize anywhere in North PSC Crane & Rigging jobsite. And when those jobsites involve America because they’ve taken the time DAYTON | COLUMBUS | CINCINNATI moving, lifting, lowering, and aligning large to invest in specialized equipment and a (888) 778 -3632 and often complex equipment, a customer highly skilled workforce—allowing them to needs to know, without a doubt, that the effectively accommodate any heavy lifting, company they’ve hired is fully capable of hauling, and equipment installation or handling every aspect of the project. relocation requirements that come their But when that jobsite involves moving way. But when it comes to TBM moves, and placing tunnel-boring machines, the there i n t a re ualified utfit in the stakes get even higher. Simply put: there’s game today than PSC. no room for mistakes when working with There’s literally nothing about a TBM TBMs—not even an inch. move that PSC can’t handle. And because No one understands this reality as of their world-class knowledge base, they much as PSC Crane & Rigging—one of know what questions to ask up front, and the industry’s leading single-source what strategies to consider to complete suppliers in the transportation, rigging, ea h pr e t ith a i u effi ien y and setting of transformers, generators, and minimal risks. The results speak for turbines, vessels, tunnel-boring machines, themselves: PSC services the entire TBM structures, and more. industry with comprehensive, multimodal a ed in the heart f hi ith ffi e solutions that include point-of-entry pick-up,
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 28 tunnelingonline.com PSC’s recent roll-on/roll-off project in Cleveland required TBM transport solutions delivered on time, on budget, and according to spec.
DAYTON 4243 West U.S. Rt. 36, Piqua, OH 45356 COLUMBUS 9026 Heritage Dr., Plain City, OH 43064 CINCINNATI 200 Olympic Dr., Milford, OH 451250 www.pscind.com | (888) 778-3632 Special Sponsored Content Section
Reinforcing Progress - DSI Tunneling LLC.
Our future begins underground. From Our ground support systems are designed deliver. Working alongside you, we help providing the commodities on which to make tunneling safer. Thanks to our you progress towards your objectives – everyday life depends, to creating local presence around the globe, we can quickly, reliably, cost-effectively. the spaces, transport conduits and satisfy your needs for ground control When you’re tackling a seemingly communications networks that connect ui ly and effi iently n atter here insurmountable objective, facing tonnes our world, mining and tunneling are vital you are. Our customized products and of rock and earth, and need the skills to human progress. As ground support systems are just in time delivered to and knowledge to achieve it, we’re with specialists, and a proactive partner to service our customers. you. We understand the complexities underground operations everywhere, Wherever you are in the world, and considerations, the depths and we’re the people that make it all possible. whenever you need us, we’ll be on the dangers far below the ground – and we We have been a leader in the ground – and beneath it – to reinforce work with you to navigate them, taking underground support business in North your operation and drive you deeper, y u d n ard and f r ard effi iently America since 1920: celebrating 100 further, faster. and intelligently, safely and sustainably. years of excellence. Our core product line You want to advance your operations By helping you progress, we’re helping ranges from steel ribs and liner plates to effi iently i pr e afety ini i e our society progress. Which is why it lattice girders, injection chemicals, bolts downtime and maximise productivity all begins underground. Together, we and pre-support systems. Each support and performance. We have the people can help you advance into the earth – system is customized and professionally and the products for every challenge, and into the future. DSI Tunneling LLC. en ineered t y ur pe ifi appli ati n and a supply chain you can rely on to Reinforcing progress.
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 30 tunnelingonline.com Reinforcing Progress
NEW – Injection Chemicals for Tunneling Applications!
The world relies on tunnels to drive economic growth and progress. And tunneling companies rely on us to drive their progress underground. By reinforcing their tunnels, protecting their people and optimising their invest- DSI Tunneling LLC ment, we keep their tunnels moving forward, opening up new opportunities 502-473-1010 to advance communities and countries. We reinforce progress - for our customers, and for the world. dsitunneling.com Special Sponsored Content Section
TREVIICOS - taking ground engineering to a deeper level with the North East Boundary Tunnel project
a broad range of techniques such as slurry walls, 5-mile tunnel built 100-feet below ground. cut-off walls, secant piles, caissons, jet grouting, n additi n t redu in din the tunnel deep & shallow mixing, and ground improvement. will increase the capacity of the city’s sewer As of late, TREVIICOS has prided itself with Dams system once connected to the other Clean and Levees rehabilitation projects thorough the Rivers Project tunnels. Diversion facilities will United States as well as infrastructural works, al e n tru ted t apture fr the providing geotechnical and specialty foundation existing sewer system and redirect them into works for underground tunnels. the tunnel by means of near surface structures After the successful completion of the and deep shafts. foundation work for the First Street Tunnel, R V C S r f r the in lude the TREVIICOS is again utilizing its expertise in construction of the support of excavation for r und en ineerin at the rth a t undary the deep shafts by slurry wall and near surface unnel f r the n in a i e structures, in addition to ground improvement TREVIICOS is a full-service ground engineering infrastructure program in Washington DC. works, mainly by jet grouting, for the shafts and fir and the rth eri an u idiary f the he deep e a e tunnel and a r adits connecting to the tunnel. Trevi Group, a worldwide leader in geotechnical segment of D.C. Water’s Clean Rivers Project is For more information on their services, contact and foundation works headquartered in Italy. de i ned t redu e hr ni din and e er TREVIICOS at their Charlestown, Massachusetts hr u h ut rth eri a R V C S pr ide er t the na tia Ri er he pr e t head uarter at r i it their innovative specialty foundation applications and involves the construction of a 23-foot diameter, website www.treviicos.com
Herrenknecht TBMs pave the way for clean river in Washington
The “Clean Rivers Project” in Washington, D.C. will ensure that 96% less untreated sewage is discharged into the Potomac River, the Anacostia River and Rock Creek. Three tunnel boring machines from Herrenknecht created huge tunnel structures with a total length of 20 kilometers, which will act both as temporary t ra e a ell a effi ient feeder line t the Blue Plains Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plant in the south of the city, the world’s largest wastewater treatment plant.
herrenknecht.com/cleanrivers
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 32 tunnelingonline.com dams building & levees foundation thefuture elements
retention systems
ground improvement
... taking ground engineering to a deeper level treviicos.com Special Sponsored Content Section
Prime Resins is the leading manufacturer of chemical grouts for soil stabilization, ground improvement and infrastructure repair.
2 centipoise. It provides superior permeation Common applications for SoiLok are and the ability to permeate in sand or silty sand geotechnical grouting, soil stabilization and containing over 20 percent of material passing ground improvement for tunneling operations, thr u h a ie e herea ultrafine underpinning foundations, hazardous waste cement and sodium silicate grouts are limited containment and water barriers. to below 20 percent. The concentration of the Equipment and operating costs are much less SoiLok is one of Prime Resins premier SoiLok can be adjusted to meet the required than a traditional sodium silicate operation. soil stabilization products. SoiLok is a water en ineer tren th pe ifi ati n dditi e are Prime Resins provides technical support, based chemical grout that provides a cost- available to increase or decrease gel times and to equipment, and material for any project. effective option for soil stabilization and ground enhance cured strength. No other chemical grout Equipment needs can be tailored to suit any improvement. SoiLok is an excellent alternative system offers the versatility and scope of use. project size or scope. So, for your next soil aterial t traditi nal r ut u h a ultrafine Department of Energy approved, SoiLok stabilization project, contact us to discuss SoiLok cement, sodium silicate and acrylates due to the has been successfully injected in various soil as a proven and important option to consider. overall operating cost savings and diversity. types nationwide. On site testing has proven Chemical grouting is often performed to bind that SoiLok permeates non-cohesive soils more Rick Broadrick and increase strength to a soil formation or to effe ti ely than diu ili ate and ultrafine 470-609-4489 pre ent r und ater infiltrati n nli e diu cement. SoiLok is a permanent chemical grout [email protected] silicate, SoiLok’s blended viscosity is less than solution, not temporary. www.primeresins.com
THE SOLUTION FOR COHESIONLESS SOILS
SOILOK ADVANTAGES: • Low mobilization costs for use • Scalable equipment options from portable pumps to trailers • Economical grout costs • Available in multiple concentrations to achieve optimum soil strengths, unlike sodium silicate
[email protected] 800-321-7212 TM primeresins.com/soilok
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 34 tunnelingonline.com Special Sponsored Content Section
A STRONG & RELIABLE PARTNER….LET’S BUILD TOGETHER.
highly depends on how predictable and durable the forms are and how many workers- hours the crew needs to put in for assembling, operating, stripping and getting the forms ready again for the next pour. This recipe holds true as much for small 1-cubic yard forms as it does for large-scale 1000-cubic yard forms. Each EVEREST form is tailored to your exact project needs. The EVEREST engineers and designers will work with your personnel in an iterative process to optimize TUNNELS - For decades, EVEREST has aided ACCESS & MINING SHAFT - Shafts are an the f r in luti n and t ffer y ur field contractors in solving the complex problems of essential part of the support and supply system crew an equipment that is safe, ergonomic, concreting subway, highway and railroad tunnels in f r the r under r und Vent haft ill highly dependable and fast to operate. a wide variety of locations and working conditions. guide an adequate supply of fresh air while The equipment supplied has been as varied as access and equipment shafts provide an BRIDGE PIER FORMS - EVEREST custom pier the application. This area of tunnel concreting can adequate supply of men and material. forms are designed with large panels and a involve rather massive formwork and unusual tunnel minimum amount of components to help you shapes and diameters. These massive jobs call for C.I.P. - Building concrete structures requires focus on pouring concrete instead of spending th de i n e i ility and e uip ent er atility f r r and anp er r e t pr fita ility valuable resources in preparation for it.
tunnelingonline.com 35 TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 Special Sponsored Content Section
Value Engineering Helps Ohio DOT Save Millions in Future Operating Costs on Lytle Tunnel Project
a li htin anufa turer and enall fit the bill well. As a result, their luminaires can be found in tunnel projects coast to coast, from the SR-99 tunnel project in Seattle, Washington to the newly repaired and renamed Hugh L. Carey tunnel in New York City. The controls-compatible LuxTran LTSI luminaires are now fully operational and reactive to outside light levels, which is critical for driver safety. Schultz added, “Light levels in tunnels are important Project Summary: The Lytle (Interstate steel lighting support system, met these and uniformity is critical because people 71) tunnel in Cincinnati underwent a specs. The selection of value-engineered are driving through them at 55 mph. It’s $32.3 million renovation that included LuxTran LTSI luminaires reduced the total a combination of dimming at certain upgrading the incumbent high-pressure nu er f fi ture re uired fr t hours for energy savings and reducing or sodium lighting to LED. 1,317, reducing the initial investment for increasing light levels based on time of Challenge: Identifying and, ultimately, the Ohio Department of Transportation day value-engineering the right LED lighting a in fe er fi ture ill al 1The Electrical Distributor, February solution to meet numerous requirements, save millions of dollars in operating costs 2017 www.tEDmag.com in ludin ener y effi ien y relia ility over the next decade. According to an vibration resistance, ingress of water and article published in February 2017 in LuxTran LTSI Features durability under the harshest conditions The Electrical Distributor, Marvin Schultz • Lumen packages: 18,661 to 90,295 – then coordinating delivery to prevent of Becker Lighting said, “They [Kenall] • Minimum 70 CRI construction delays. helped us out with the design. It was a • 80,000-125,000 hr LED Lifetime r up eff rt t find the ri ht luti n t (L70) Historic Lytle Tunnel Shines after LED takes a lot of time to get any government • Suitable for interior and exterior Lighting Upgrade organization to accept changes to original supplemental lighting The Lytle Tunnel (Interstate 71) is a plans but we succeeded. Kenall enabled • Type II, III, IV, IV-Narrow and 3-tube, 6-lane tunnel that runs under the us to replace the LED modules and drivers V-Square distributions available Lytle Park Historic District in Cincinnati, ea ily t aintain the fi ture Supp rt i • eet S ertifi ati n Ohio. It is the only vehicular tunnel in hat pe ifier alue hen r in ith • ertified per C the state of Ohio, and is just completing a two-year, $32.3million dollar upgrade to its tiles, lighting and ventilation system. The contractor selected Kenall luminaires because they fully complied with the Mott MacDonald lighting design pe ifi ati n he pe re uired products made by an experienced tunnel lighting manufacturer, with a proven history of tunnel lighting installations and demonstration of galvanic corrosion management. Kenall’s stainless steel LTSI luminaires, combined with a stainless
TBM: TUNNEL BUSINESS MAGAZINE October 2020 36 tunnelingonline.com Choose from 160 presentations to attend and visit with more than 200 exhibiting companies.
MINIMIZE Maximize DISRUPTION Production Technical Papers | Industry Exhibits | Networking Events | Special Awards | Innovations | Entertainment 2021 conference PREVIEW Attend the NASTT 2021 No-Dig Show for trenchless solutions to YOUR aging infrastructure.
For more information visit nodigshow.com
Due to the pandemic and your safety being our top priority, things may look different at the NASTT 2021 No-Dig Show. Learn more about the procedures and precautions we are taking at https://www.nodigshow.com/covid-19-precautions-procedures/. PLAN YOUR EXPERIENCE!
Sunday Monday Tuesday MARCH 28, 2021 MARCH 29, 2021 MARCH 30, 2021 EVENTS EVENTS EVENTS
7:00 AM – 5:00 PM - West E/F Lobby 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM - West E/F Lobby 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM - West E/F Lobby Attendee & Exhibitor Attendee & Exhibitor Registration Attendee & Exhibitor Registration Registration Networking Events 12:00 PM – 12:30 PM 12:00 PM – 3:30 PM - West Hall E ipe ursting enter of 7:30 AM – 9:15 AM - West Hall F2 Exhibit Hall Open Excellence Meeting ick ff reakfast (Full Conference Attendees Only) 1:00 PM – 2:00 PM 6:00 PM – 7:00 PM - West Hall F2 Annual General Meeting Pre-Gala Awards Dinner Reception 1:00 PM – 6:30 PM NASTT’s Regional Chapter Meetings Networking Events 4:00 PM – 7:30 PM Full conference attendees are invited to 7:00 PM – 10:00 PM - West Hall F2 Student Orientation Meeting rise and shine at the NASTT No-Dig Show Gala Awards Dinner* ic rea ast e orning i ro ide a 7:00 PM – 9:00 PM - W230 D un i o net or ing good ood and uc oung rofessionals antici ated a ards as e as un orgettab e Sunday Social entertain ent is year s entertain ent i be ro ided by eni o as ra ing ro is e eri- ences on t e batt efie d eni ins ires eo e to ac ie e greatness by stressing t e i ortance o outstanding eaders i at e ery e e e en i You are cordially invited to attend the No-Dig 2021 t e on y erson you are eading is yourse trenc ess industry s re iere a ards din- FORUMS ner oin eaders and co eagues ro across 11:40 AM – 11:45 AM - West E/F Lobby the industry while we honor those who have MONDAY, MARCH 29 Exhibit Hall Ribbon Cutting acco is ed outstanding ac ie e ents in t eir res ecti e fie ds i resent Ceremony and recogni e its a o a e C ass o Service & Lateral Rehabilitation Forum 11:45 AM – 3:45 PM - West Hall E as well as the Chair Award for Distinguished MA-T3-01 and MA-T3-02 er ice t e a ston oung renc ess Exhibit Hall Open oderator o n att e s renc ess ec no ogy Center c ie e ent and t e bbott nno ati e roducts er ices e abi itation e is oru i ro ide a discussion ser ice atera Networking Events nsta ation re abi itation dri en by audience artici ation 5:30 PM – 7:00 PM - West Hall F2 NASTT’s 20th Annual Educational *NASTT’s 2021 No-Dig Show Gala Awards inner is a tic eted e ent TUESDAY, MARCH 30 Fund Auction & Reception