Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au © Australian Sports Commission 2004
This work is copyright. Apart from any uses as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part of this publication may be reproduced by any process without written permission from the Australian Sports Commission. Requests and enquiries concerning reproduction should be addressed to:
The Manager Business Development Australian Sports Commission PO Box 176 BELCONNEN ACT 2616
Email: [email protected]
The views expressed in the country reports are those of the respondents and are not necessarily those of the Australian Government nor the ASP Sports Program. The ASC acknowledges the cooperation of the governments as well as Oceania National Olympic Committees, National Olympic Commitees, National Paralympic Committees and national sporting federations of the ASP partner countries that assisted in the preparation of this study. The ASC also acknowledges Mr Robert Phillpot for his assistance with the literature review.
For general enquiries regarding the Australian Sports Commission:
Tel: (02) 6214 1111 Fax: (02) 6251 2680 Email: [email protected] Web site: www.ausport.gov.au
ISBN 1 74013 069 3
All images Australian Sports Commission unless stated otherwise
Designed by GRi.D Communications, Canberra
Produced by Australian Sports Commission Publications staff
Printed by Paragon Printers Australasia
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Contents
1 Executive summary 1
2 Literature review 9
Introduction 10
Pacific human development indicators 11
The value of sport 17
Sport and international recognition 22
Sport and the economy 22
Summary and conclusion 23
3 Country/territory reports 25
American Samoa 27
Cook Islands 29
Fiji 33
Federated States of Micronesia 37
Guam 43
Kiribati 45
Marshall Islands (Republic of the) 49
Nauru 55
Niue 59
Palau 63
Papua New Guinea 67
Samoa 71
Solomon Islands 75
Tonga (Kingdom of) 79
Tuvalu 83
Vanuatu 87
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Appendixes 93
1 Summary of the social profile of countries 94 participating in the ASP Sports Program
2 Acronyms 95
Bibliography 96
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Executive summary 1 Chapter 1 1
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 2 Executive summary of the Pacific region sporting community.of thePacific regionsporting oftheneeds The processassistedindeveloping amorecomprehensiveunderstanding todiscussindetailthefindingsofquestionnaires. consultations were anopportunity Commission.The outby oftheAustralianSports consultations carried staffmembers country. Thecompletedquestionnaires provided thebasisforin-country participating Questionnaires were alsodeveloped anddistributedtokey stakeholders ineach community development objectivesofdeveloping countries. plays ormayassess theavailable play literatureontherolethatsport inmeetingthe assistedwiththeliteraturereview.University Theaimofthereview was tocompileand The AsiaPacific SchoolofEconomicsandManagementattheAustralian National Program. ASP Sports inthemanagementof andAusAIDaspartners Foreign andTrade, Affairs of by theDepartment Commissionwas supported 2004.TheAustralianSports early consultationsinlate2003and questionnaires andin-country literaturereview, a comprising Commission conductedtheneedsassessment, The AustralianSports of recipientcountrieswithintheresourcesavailable. sothatitwouldremaineffectiveinmeetingtheneeds could addressinthecomingyears Program assessment was toidentifysomeoftheareaspriority thattheASPSports elite andcommunitylevels in14Pacific islandcountriessince1994.Akey goalofthe development assistanceatboththe whichhasbeenproviding sport Program, Sports oftheAustralia–SouthPacific (ASP) commissioned theneedsassessmentaspart istheoutcomeofthatannouncement.TheAustralianGovernment This report development intheSouthPacific region. comprehensiveassessmentofsport first-ever John Howard MP theHon. thePrimeMinisterof Australia, At thePacific inAugust2003, IslandsForum Introduction Executive summary Chapter 1 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting , announced that the Australian Government would be undertaking the wouldbeundertaking announcedthattheAustralianGovernment , Executive summary 3 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment education health security population growth.
Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au
Fiji and the smaller island states of Cook Islands, Palau, Niue, Samoa, Nauru, Tonga terms rank the highest in of development and Tuvalu the Micronesian states of Kiribati, States Marshall Islands and Federated of Micronesia rank in the middle the larger Melanesian countries of Vanuatu, Guinea New Solomon Islands and Papua rank at the low end of the index. governance employment The needs assessment was designed to provide a record of the sporting designed to provide The needs assessment was needs of Pacific countries,region countries and to enable those in partnership with the ASP Sports Program, to respond more Results of this report will facilitate changes to the effectively. ASP Sports Program. Country-specific accurately to more developed programs will be address the needs of each country. issues discusses the broad development The needs assessment identifies and facing region countries, Pacific specifically on those serviced while focusing the by ASP Sports Program. Although not direct recipients of the program, American Samoa are members of the Oceania National included in this study as they also and Guam were It is importantCommittees. Olympic to note, however, that this report imply that does not the ASP Sports Program will address all of these issues. National governments, National Olympic Committees and donors tool for should find the needs assessment a useful strategies to promote the growth of sport.developing The ASP Sports will Program outlined in to address identified priorities stakeholders continue to work with key this report. as follows: issues facing the region can be categorised development Some of the key Purpose 2 3 The research outlined in the literature review provides details of these development provides The research outlined in the literature review ASP Sports relate to each of the countries within the issues as they Program. The importance categories differs of the issues within each of these from country to country. the United Nations Development by developed Index Through the Human Development broad categories of grouped into three region were Programme the countries of the Pacific on their 1998 index ranking. based development These are: 1
the ASP Sports Program. specifically on those serviced on those specifically by region countries,region focusing while development issues facing issues development Pacific and discusses the broad the and discusses The needs assessment identifies assessment needs The Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 4 Executive summary development issuesthatemergedfromtheneedsassessment are: The principalsport development issues Principal sport aswell asareciprocalcommitmentfromthatcountry. therelevance tothecountry by successandsustainabilityoftheprogramwillbedetermined thelong-term However, tempting todeliveragenericphysical educationprogramthroughout allcountries. itmay be economicconstraints, Dueto programdeveloped forNauru. school sport a theCookIslandsmightbedifferentto and physical educationprogramdeveloped for aschoolsport andaretailoredaccordingly. ofthisdiversity understanding For example, subsequentprogramsreflectan recognise eachcountry’s differencesandensurethat to itisimportant issues thatmany ofthecountriesidentifiedaspriorityareas.That said, development somecommonthemesemerged.These relatetobroadsport However, healthindicators. and disparity) geography (dispersion population, economicclimate, development, as acountry’s level of such isareflectionoffactors asthecountriesthemselves.Thisdiversity are asdiverse Program.Eachcountry’s needs withintheASPSports sporting community ineachcountry theassessmentthenexaminedindetailindividualneedsofsporting assistance, development canbeavaluablevehicletodeliveroverseas Recognising thatsport recognitionaswellinternational aseconomicbenefits. womenandachieving rightsof includingpromotingthe of communitydevelopment, makes positivecontributionsinother areas and politics.Evidencesuggestedthatsport health education, a tooltofosternationalintegrationbecauseofitsbroadrelevance to isincreasinglyrecognisedas recognition.Sport andforgingstronginternational identity, national fosteringcommunityand contribute effectivelytoreducingantisocialbehaviour, may also sport the areasofhealthandcommunitydevelopment. Thereview foundthat in may play thesignificantanddirectrolesport The review identifiedevidence supporting languagebarriers. political and historical, religious, ethnic, educational, itsabilitytotranscendsocial, program given componentofawide-rangingdevelopment itisanimportant issues, development alonecannotsolvetheregion’s andgoodvalue.Whileitisclearthatsport efficient non-threatening, development objectivesbecauseitisproven tobeeffective, broad roleinunderpinning plays animportant The literaturereview foundthatsport Major findings sport forpeoplewithadisability sport initiatives women-in-sport development and retention volunteer recruitment, programs physical educationandschoolsport medicine science/sport sport administrationand sport includingcoacheducation, educationprograms, sport policies national sport sport facilities. sport Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting Executive summary 5 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment
Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au
National sport policies region, within the In most countries governing there are two main responsible bodies for sport national government the Olympic and the National at the national level: In most cases, each country. of these organisations differ within Committee. The roles the Ministry Committee has a larger budget than the National Olympic of Sport. sportThe absence of national plans) policies (including implementation makes it Olympic Committee and the to define the roles of the National difficult national government in the delivery of sportIn some instances, programs. this results programs,in the duplication of where both the government and the National Olympic Committee run of scarce programs leading to an inefficient allocation similar instances,resources. In other it of activity in a particular results in a void or absence program area. In this context, a national sport policy is different to a government policy document plan. A national sportand different again to a development policy establishes the priorities of a countrydevelopment and defines the roles and responsibilities of the It all stakeholders. It is a document owned by stakeholders. key results in an efficient goals. and achievable allocation of resources and sets measurable Sport education Access to sport education has emerged as an important component of sport of establishing a sport region. The cost in the Pacific development education program within the region. Consequently, the capacity of most countries is beyond sport education, in particular coach education and accreditation, to is limited those who attend courses run international federations, by or to those coaches who participate in training programs overseas. The establishment of a regional sport education program offers a cost-effective training of more coaches,solution that would facilitate the consistent administrators and sport science/sport medicine practitioners.
stakeholders. and of the responsibilities key a countryand defines the roles the development priorities of the development A national sport policy establishes Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 6 Executive summary activity levels. Suchaprogramwould: inthePacific and regionistodevelop performance oreven maintaincurrent sport if development andretention programisessential volunteerrecruitment, countries. A aredroppinginmanyactivities. Thisproblemiscompoundedasvolunteernumbers ofpeopletoassist withtheorganisationandimplementationofsporting shortage The needsassessmentshowed thatPacific regioncountriessufferfromanacute development and retention Volunteer recruitment, schools andcommunities. anddeliverableinurbanaswell asouterisland developed mustbefullytransportable ofmoredeveloped countries.Theprogramsthatare adaptationofthecurriculum an development arethereforerequiredandcannotsimplybe approaches tocurriculum thatisheavilyA curriculum dependentonexpensiveequipment willfail.Innovative there isthecostofequipmentrequiredtodelivercurriculum. programs intheregion, respective countries.Inadditiontothesignificantcostofdeveloping physical education ofthe bedeveloped incloseconsultationwiththeeducationdepartments should assistancerequiredinthisareaalsovaries.Assistancephysical education the The level ofphysical educationinschoolsvariesthroughouttheregion.Accordingly, sporadically. occur classes whilemany countrieshave timeallocatedforphysical education, result, development. Asa intheareaofcurriculum isagenerallackofexpertise there have indicatedadesiretointroducephysical educationintotheschoolcurriculum, level (Years attheprimary 1–6).Whilemany countries particularly education system, aregrowingasapriorityinthePacific region’sPhysical educationandschoolsport Physical educationandschoolsport resource assistancearecommonthemes. theneedforstrategicadvice and in thisareaisasvariedthecountriesthemselves, their respectiveNationalOlympicCommittee.Whiletheassistance requiredby countries linked groupsthatareformally with countrieshave recentlysetupwomen-in-sport Many can play inpromotingtherightsofwomen. recognition of therolethatsport in development prioritythroughouttheregion hasemergedasasport Women insport Women insport and run sporting organisations. sporting run and activities toconductsporting skillsandexpertise withtheconfidence, volunteers have asignificanttraininganddevelopment componenttohelpprovide volunteer (retention) organisationsthebenefitsandrewards ofbeingasport show themandsporting (recruitment) volunteers seek toattractmorepeopleassport Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting Executive summary 7 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment
Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Sport facilities The standard and breadth of sporting Fiji facilities in the region vary widely. now has Games,world-class for the 2003 South Pacific facilities developed whereas countries such as Nauru, lack basic facilities such Kiribati and Tuvalu as athletics tracks. Finding sportadequate land to develop facilities is also an issue in some countries. national Building such facilities requires substantial financial contributions from the as donor countries,government as well particularly in the smaller states. Because of the cost, maximum use. planning is required to ensure facilities achieve detailed Regardless of the standard or proliferation of sport facilities in the region, each country of the major sport faces other related issues. Many facilities in the Pacific region foreign governments through their overseas development been donated by have assistance programs. As a result, knowledge of facilities management remains rudimentary in most countries, with maximum use not being achieved. Sportwith a disability for people sportDisability Despite are generally under-resourced. in the region programs sportrecognition that disability community development positive programs have ramifications, be that these programs can only there is a perception run at a high cost. inclusive sportThe reality is that an program services as athletes as well able-bodied people with a disability, solution and is a cost-effective to sport-for-all programs in the region. countries now recognise the importanceMany disability sport of programs but struggle to raise the requisite funding. when funding is available, Even remains there a resources and expertise lack of applicable in working with a disability. with athletes In has been provided, where resource and training assistance countries sport disability been successful. programs have sportAn increase in assistance to disability programs in all countries in the Pacific sportregion is required. Successful disability community significant programs have of an inclusive sport-for-all implications and are an integral component development community program.
sport-for-allprogram. community component of an inclusive component of programs are an integral programs are Successful disability sportSuccessful disability Pacific SportingPacific Needs Sporting Assessment Needs © Assessment Australian Sports © Australian Commission Sports 2004 Commission http://www.ausport.gov.au 2004 Literature review 9 Chapter 2 2
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au 10 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review growth is slow and uncertain’ (United NationsDevelopment Programme 1999). growth isslow anduncertain’ andprivatesector publicsectorjobcontracts, systems failtosecurethem employment, localisation ofjobs.Thepresent generationfaceslessoptimisticprospectsasschool publicsectorgrowthandthe brought aboutthroughnewly expanded schoolsystems, ‘the previous generationmostly cametoadulthoodatatimeofwideningopportunities, that aspirations ofthenextgeneration ofPacific islandpeopleandidentifiesinparticular highlightstheurgentrequirementacrossregiontobettermeetneeds and 1999, The Program. intheASPSports participating profileofthecountries ofthesocial provides a summary Appendix 1tothisreport Development Programme1999). forestsandminerals(UnitedNations million andvastendowmentsofarableland, withapopulation of5.7 suchas Papua New Guinea, theregion, larger countriesin have littleincommonwith 200 andlandareaof26squarekilometres, of about10 withapopulation smallatollstatessuchasTuvalu, Other thantheirgeographicproximity, resourceendowmentsandenvironmental conditions. countries andtheirpopulations, Business and theaggravation ofsocialdecay causedby theevaporation ofoldcultures( allexperiencingover-population andhealthdifficulties, collection ofmostlysmallatolls, Marianas)isa KiribatiandNorthern Guam, Nauru, Islands, theMarshall Micronesia, theFederated Statesof Wallis andFutuna.Micronesia(whichcomprisesPalau, and CookIslands, Tuvalu, Niue, AmericanSamoa, Samoa, The areacomprisesTonga, New Zealandtothesouthwest andEasterIslandtothesoutheast. Hawaii tothenorth, Vanuatu constituteMelanesia.Polynesia anareaencompassing covers andFiji Islands, Solomon 1998). ItisgenerallyrecognisedthatthecountriesofPapua New Guinea, than 6millionoftheregion’s 7millionpeople(SecretariatofthePacific Community ormore accountingforover 85percentofthetotalpopulation, largest culturalgroup, below theequator)andMicronesia(lyingabove theequator).Melanesiaisby farthe Melanesia(lyingmostly TheregionisoftengroupedasPolynesia, culturally diverse. butonethatis notingthatthePacific regionisnothomogeneous, itisworth To begin, consultation phaseoftheassessment. chapter concludesby identifyingissuesthatwere consideredinthein-country The programs thataimtoassistinstrengtheninghumandevelopment indicators. development inoverseas assistance region. Itthenassessesthevalueofsport by asthey examininghumandevelopment indicators relatetothePacific countries, This chapteranalysesthekey influencingthedevelopment ofPacific socialfactors island Introduction Literature review Chapter 2 Pacific HumanDevelopment Report, Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting aur 03.Hwvr therearestillgreatdifferencesinthesizeofthese 2003).However, January issued by theUNDevelopment Programmein Islands Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 11 Sport, Activity and Physical Antisocial analyses recent progress towards sustainable analyses recent progress towards introduced the Human Development Index (HDI) introduced the Human Development , found that while it is unlikely that sport activity and physical
Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au
Pacific Human Development Report Human Development Pacific Report1990 Human Development that measures development by combining data on length of life, by that measures development access to knowledge Programme 1990). The importanceand income (United Nations Development of life expectancy at birth that a long life is valuable in itself and lies in the common belief in the fact that various indirect benefits (adequate nutrition and good health) are closely Literacy figures are only a crude reflection associated with longer life expectancy. of access to education, particularly to the good-quality education so necessary for Theproductive life in modern society. HDI therefore includes adult literacy combined with Pacific human development indicators human development Pacific The Behaviour in Youth Behaviour and direct impact on reducing a major programs have antisocial behaviour, form an they important occur that mechanism through which personal may and social development (Cameronpositively affects behaviour 2000). and MacDougall indicators human development The next section of this chapter identifies that are islands. The indicators demonstrate the need for sustained to the Pacific relevant assistance in the region. overseas development island states: Cook Islands, 14 Pacific made by development Fiji, Kiribati, Marshall Islands, States of Micronesia, Federated Nauru, Niue, Palau, Guinea, New Papua Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, and Vanuatu. Tuvalu is to basic objective of development Programme’s The United Nations Development long, for people to enjoy create an environment and creative lives. Technical healthy and the use of statistical human development considerations of the means to achieve at times obscured the fact aggregates to measure national income and its growth have that the primary is to benefit people. Human objective of development is a development choices. The most critical ones are to lead a long and process of increasing people’s life,healthy a decent standard of living. to be educated and to enjoy Additional choices, people, many highly valued by range from political, and social freedom to economic opportunities for being creative and productive, personal and enjoying self-respect and Programme 1990). guaranteed human rights (United Nations Development The There is evidence that sportThere is evidence and assist contribute to community development may in some of the worst alleviating of the erosion of traditional cultures side-effects in the A report region. Australian Institute of Criminology, the produced by in conjunction with the Australian Sports Commission, entitled
traditional cultures in cultures traditional the region. side-effects of the erosion of of the erosion side-effects in worst some of the alleviating development and assist development may to community contribute There is evidence that sport that is evidence There benefit people. objective ofdevelopment isto obscured thefactthat theprimary development have attimes means toachieve human Technical considerationsofthe 12 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review aut 3 .2 140 129 164 147 118 0.425 121 0.515 117 0.314 0.371 107 103 70 0.583 231 1 702 0.563 196 0.590 926 1 120 0.647 46 0.663 62 157 1 182 0.774 1 060 1 Creating opportunities 0.569 868 1 Source: UnitedNationsDevelopment Programme 1999, 450 0.861 3 0.822 Papua New Guinea 714 3 Solomon Islands GlobalHDIrank 070 2 101 Vanuatu 027 8 Kiribati 947 HDI 4 Islands Marshall Federated StatesofMicronesia 0.667 Tuvalu GDPpercapita Samoa Tonga Nauru 684 2 Fiji Niue Cook Islands Palau Country Table 1 ranking isalsoshown. country’s global andtheHDIforeachofcountries.Each percapita, shows GDP commodities andtogaincommandover resourcesforadecentliving standard.Table 1 whichprovide betterapproximationsoftherelativepower tobuy capita figures, measureisenhancedby usingpurchasing-power-adjusted realGDPper indicator. This the index’s measureforthisusesthelogarithmofrealGDPpercapitaincome indicatorand enrolments.Incomeisstillanimportant andtertiary secondary primary, Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting aii ua eeomn ne,1998 Pacific HumanDevelopment Index, ua p.13. Suva, , (US$) Pacific Human Development Report 1999: Pacific HumanDevelopment Report Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 13 Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Fiji island states of Cook Islands, and the smaller Palau, Niue, Nauru, Samoa, Tonga rank highest and Tuvalu of Kiribati,the Micronesian states States of Marshall Islands and Federated the middle Micronesia rank in countries of Vanuatu,the large Melanesian Guinea New Solomon Islands and Papua of the index. rank at the low end The index values shown in Table 1 range from internationally 1 range high to internationally low. values shown in Table The index country,The highest-ranking Palau, Papua and Venezuela. to Panama has an HDI similar Djibouti and Chad, has one similar to Guinea New in Africa. the poorest countries two of a very presented in the table therefore show The 1998 index values large range of countries It also shows there are three groups of conditions in the region. development 1999): Programme (United Nations Development 1 Health indicators importantIt is recognised that good health is an element for sustainable human Infant mortalitydevelopment. has declined significantly throughout most of the region. in the region,While life expectancy is generally good there is an apparent increase in mid-adult mortality, for males. The main reasons for this increase are especially ‘lifestyle’ diseases and accidental deaths,associated with the upsurge in so-called and and vector-bornethe resurgence and emergence of infectious example, diseases (for malaria). In particular some non-communicable diseases, including diabetes, have in some countries. In Fiji,reached epidemic levels 15 to occupy diabetes cases 20 per cent of all hospital beds. Hypertension and other circulatory are also diseases increasing, Besides its related illnesses, diets high in fats and sugar. primarily by caused accidents and violence (United Nations alcohol abuse is a cause of deaths from in this report Programme 1999). The studies considered Development suggest that sport a positive impact on these health issues. have programs lifestyle diseases is a particularThe trend of increasing non-communicable concern their economically productive years.because the diseases affect people in A major cost of this pattern is the loss of skills, of ill health and death experience and productivity for communities. These types of illnesses can cause premature or sudden death, often Improved families without their primaryleaving income earner. and primary nutrition assistance in the region. health care need to be a high priority for development 2 3 14 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review aut 64 9.1 8.8 17.9 11.8 9.4 programs arelikely tocontributebettereducationaloutcomes. indicates thatsport 14.1 9.1 therelevant literature depending mainlyontheadequacyoffacilities.Generallythough, 45 12.0 needsvarieswidelyacrosstheregion relationship between educationandsporting 67 77 8.9 38 education isaseriousproblem(UnitedNationsDevelopment Programme1999).The accesstobasicprimary SolomonIslandsandPapua New Guinea, inVanuatu, example, 8.1 andhighlightsthedifferencesamongcountries.For adult literacyandschoolenrolments, 51 11.8 63 significantlyintheregion.TableThe prioritiesandneedsforeducationvary 3shows 22 15.0 19 66 Education indicators 12.5 62 54 11 65 18 67 46 Creating opportunities 65 66 20 Source: UnitedNationsDevelopment Programme 1999, 68 12.4 11 Papua New Guinea 58 Solomon Islands 74 Vanuatu 66 Kiribati 69 Islands Marshall 16 72 Federated StatesofMicronesia Tuvalu Percentage of Samoa rate Infantmortality Tonga Nauru Lifeexpectancy 66 Fiji Niue Cook Islands Palau Country Table 2 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting aii ua eeomn niaos—hat,1998 Pacific —health, humandevelopment indicators ua p.106. Suva, , tbrh(er)(e 0)government (per1000) (years) at birth Pacific Human Development Report 1999: Pacific HumanDevelopment Report spending onhealth Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 15 (per cent) Pacific Human Development Report Human Development Pacific 1999: (per cent) (per cent) 15–19 years , Suva, p. 110. Pacific human development indicators development human — education, Pacific 1998 Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au for lesser-developed countries,for lesser-developed the problem is how to re-orient large semi-subsistence communities to become more commercially productive countries,in more developed the issue is how to resolve the problem of the ‘educated a real choice between that people with skills have and to ensure unemployed’ migrating overseas or remaining at home to work. 2 The situation is complicated due to the different circumstances of each of the Pacific island countries. However, in what is clear across the entire region is that employment to grow in the foreseeable future to cater forthe formal sector is unlikely the majority of island workers. in the What is needed is a focus on creating more employment Pacific Programme 1999). informal (United Nations Development sectors of the economy Sport as an industry opportunities islands is growing and employment in the Pacific in both the private and public sectors Sport becoming more prevalent. are programs and can also stimulate associated employment,events such sellers as food and beverage at a local sporting event. Employment indicatorsEmployment island countries lies in how to provide Pacific Probably the most critical issue confronting needs while livelihood that meets people’s the population with a secure and sustainable trends indicate Economic and demographic countering the increasing problem of poverty. the demand for,that the gap between of, and the availability will almost paid employment certainlyforce and the limited economic potential of grow due to the fast-growing labour Programme 1999). these countries (United Nations Development There are essentially two long-term problems: employment 1 Papua New Guinea New Papua Programme 1999, Source: United Nations Development Creating opportunities 28.2 28.6 23 Tuvalu States of MicronesiaFederated Marshall Islands 71.3KiribatiVanuatuSolomon Islands 74.4 71.4 95.0 30.3 92.2 33.5 71.7 44 74.0 34.7 67.8 57.4 49 34 24 44 22 Cook IslandsNiueFiji92.9 NauruTongaSamoa 93.2 81.3 97.0 95.0 84.8 36 99.0 95.7 83.6 79.5 45 83.3 85.7 53 34 67 70 Table 3 Table CountryPalau literacy Adult School enrolments School enrolments 91.4 83.4 67 16 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review aut 8 0 . 18 37 15 13 42 65 limited employment opportunities. have very inparticular, Thesecountries, Nauru. 21 32 forexampleSolomonIslands and 2.7 ofthepopulation, high rateofgrowthinthispart 2.1 very have a countries withweak andlimitededucationalopportunities 100 health indicators 2.5 3.3 the Table 5showstheaverage annualgrowthrateoftheyouthpopulation.Some 32 programsmightassistinreducingthisproblem. toconsiderwhethersport important 3.0 27 3.6 suggests thatantisocialbehaviour withincommunitiesislikely toincrease.Itistherefore 500 71 1.2 182 ofyoungpeoplewithfew employment prospects 100 ahighproportion Across theregion, 85 0.3 400 800 59 412 417 2.4 4 –1.0 000 11 Creating opportunities 100 61 Source: UnitedNationsDevelopment Programme1999, 2.1 800 174 000 98 2.4 46 Papua New Guinea 500 11 –1.8 Solomon Islands 100 2 Vanuatu Kiribati 100 114 500 Islands Marshall 18 500 Federated StatesofMicronesia 16 0.9 Urbanpopulation Tuvalu Population growth Samoa Tonga Population size Nauru 800 797 Fiji Niue Cook Islands Palau Country Table 4 brings. dignity anddisciplinethatwork withoutmuchchancetoexperiencethe future ofunemployment andunderemployment, (United NationsDevelopment Programme1999).Many youngpeoplethereforefacea 000 thisnumberwillhave increasedby atleast300 population. Bytheyear2010, representing20percentoftheregion’s millionyoungpeopleaged15to24years, 1.4 therewere aspirationsofthenextgenerationPacific islandpeople.In1998, and Perhaps acrosstheregionishowtobettermeetneeds thegreatestconcern (especially forurbandwellers) andcontributetowards bettereducationaloutcomes. healthacrossthecommunity programsmay potentiallyimprove primary sport cost, For arelativelylow toprovide basichealthandeducationservices. already struggling Vanuatu ofthesecountriesare Thegovernments andNauru. SolomonIslands, example, for with theweakest alsohave socialindicators thehighestpopulationgrowthrate, some countriesmitigatesanotherwisehighpopulationgrowth.Someofthe Table 4depictsrecentpopulationgrowthforcountriesintheregion.Emigrationfrom Demographic andyouthindicators Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting aii ua eeomn niaos—dmgahc 1998 Pacific —demographic, humandevelopment indicators ua p.113. Suva, , etmtd ana vrg )(%total) (annualaverage %) (estimated) Pacific Human Development Report 1999: Pacific HumanDevelopment Report Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 17 Pacific Human Development Report Human Development Pacific 1999: of population of youth population , Suva, p. 109. Pacific human development indicators development human — youth, Pacific 1998 Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au education economic benefits. the building of national identity and national pride and integration community development crime prevention health The value of sport If sport community, of a development contributes to the overall is worthwhile it to review That is,the social impact it can make. what specific benefits can be gleaned by promoting sport the health and social countries? This section reviews among developing impact of sport. recognised the economic and social Governments in industrial countries have benefits of sport (Sport England 1999). However, most research has focused on the relationship sport between in Australia, and health outcomes. Recently there has been of sportan interest in the evaluation programs, particularly on the health and social impacts of these programs. in sport involvement and recreation in of the Australian Government’s In a review Australia, Government gets a good return on its found that ‘the Commonwealth it was in sportinvestment and that there are further and recreation benefits to be gained from an enhanced role in sport of Australia Sport and recreation’ (Commonwealth 2000 Taskforce, identified a number of benefits from the Government’s 1999). The review in sport,investment which include: Creating opportunities Federated States of MicronesiaFederated Marshall IslandsKiribati 21.0VanuatuSolomon Islands Guinea New Papua Programme 1999, Source: United Nations Development 21.7 3.4 20.6 20.3 18.0 19.9 18.7 5.8 4.0 2.6 1.4 3.5 16.3 17.7 19.4 19.6 18.2 NiueFiji20.0 NauruTongaSamoaTuvalu 0.7 11.4 17.4 22.7 20.5 21.2 15.6 –6.2 3.2 –0.5 0.5 24.0 3.8 19.6 20.3 21.7 25.7 Table 5 Table CountryPalauCook Islands as a percentage Youth growth rate Annual median age National 17.3 14.4 –5.0 –0.7 25.0 29.2 18 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review well documentedinnumerousstudiesandmostofteninclude: andphysical educationdevelopment programshaveThe generalbenefitsofsport been in the literature that the greatest benefit will be derived by encouraging sedentary people theliteraturethatgreatest benefitwillbederived by encouragingsedentary in itisalsosuggested productivity andgreaternational prosperity(Boit2002).However, It hasalsobeenarguedthat ahighhealthstandardtranslatesintohigherdomestic Organization hasidentifiedthefollowing: health mustbeoneofthemostwidelyrecognisedandsignificant.TheWorld Health thepromotionandmaintenanceof andphysical education, Of allthevaluesofsport Health benefitsofsport ratherthanonany ofthebroadersocialeffects. various healthoutcomes, most oftheresearchhasfocusedonexploringlinksbetween physical activityand limited.Torecreation programsandvarioushealthsocialoutcomesisalsofairly date, populations) isinitsinfancy. and Theresearch evidence onthelinksbetween sport and recreationprograms(forthegeneralpopulationeven moresoforindigenous It isevident fromtheliteraturereview thatindicatordevelopment onoutcomesfromsport contribute tosocialintegration. forall’programspromotesocial interactionand Physical activityand‘sport older persons. Physical activityenhancesfunctionalcapacityandindependentlivingin anxietyandfeelingsofdepression. Physical activityreducesstress, Physical activityhelpstoreduceosteoporosis. population). percentof theadultworld 20 Physical activityhelpscontrolweight (affecting andprevent/reduce hypertension physical activityprobablyprovides protectionagainstbreastcancer. that diabetescases)andcoloncancer.(90 percentofworld Evidencealsosuggests type2diabetes disease, Physical activityreducestheriskofdeveloping heart globaldeaths). (33 percentof disease Regular physical activityreducestheriskofdyingfromheart a toolforcommunication(Glenwright2002). contribution tothebreakdownofbarriers a toolforsocialmobility vehicle forreconciliation generation ofnationalpride recognition achieving international economic benefits educational benefits contribution towards development personal contributiontowardsenormous communitydevelopment significant healthbenefits Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 19 Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Sport education and physical creative contribute to a child’s talents. This is of particular significance in developing countries. Sport and antisocial behaviour Research on Aboriginal communities in Australia found that sporting events, such as carnivals,However, 1995). also found (Tatz Tatz did result in changes in behaviour that and that largely limited to the length of the event the positive effects were more integrated strategies are needed to produce lasting benefits (Cameron and MacDougall 2000). The literature, therefore, indicates that sport programs need to be impact on crime rates. lasting any long term and sustainable to have to take partto take in sport This is particularly and Connelly 1996). (Blair importantthe in urbanisation is where increased island countries Pacific to a more sedentary leading proportion a rapidly increasing lifestyle for significant There is also of the population. literature to support that sport the claim contributes to psychological wellbeing. Therefore, the long-term effects of sport health far-reaching activity have and physical of abenefits for the development country benefits. besides the immediate health Impact of sport on character Extensive literature, to the early dating back 1900s,of sport documents the impact the difficulty in empirically While character. activity in improving and physical ascertaining sport the benefits of on educational and personal remains development a topic of debate among sociologists, been recognised that participation it has in desired educational outcomes (Eitle sport be positively associated with a society’s can that sportand Eitle 2002). It is believed activity serve and physical as tools for the discovery of recreation skills. However, and development there is no consensus in the literature as to whether sport can directly affect educational outcomes. Sport and children to a variety of tasks, education expose physical not the least of which are the rules as learning specific motor as well knowledge and understanding of a game’s skills required to perform a particularSuch competencies should complement task. cognitive education (Eitle and Eitle those skills acquired through more recognised 2002). Similarly, creative talents. sport education contribute to a child’s physical and This is of particular countries, significance in developing where limited resources for education result in a limited curriculum with an emphasis on passing available of a child’s itself to the stifled development examinations — a system that lends individual creativity (Eitle and Eitle 2002). It is also important and inventiveness to educate athletes about the benefits sport can bring to a community including promoting tolerance, respect for all. and fair play and language barriers. political historical, religious, ethnic, educational, to transcendsocial, any othersocial activityandisable the populationmore thanperhaps extends tobroadsectionsof Sport 20 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review In Putnam(1993) has publishedanotherexampleofthestudysocialcapital. Robert contribute tosocieties’stockofsocialcapital(Woolcock 1998). associationsandclubs andespeciallysport there issomeevidence thatsport From thisstudy forsport. social capitalthatmightbeusedasoutcomeindicators England were directedtoinvestigate of thepossibilityofdeveloping localindicators outforSport foraproject carried some interestingevidence exists.Researchers While theconceptofsocialcapitalissubjectdebateinsciences, bothwithinandamongcountries. performance in government whichexplainsvariations todothingsforeachother’)asthe‘missinglink’, networks andtheinclinationsthatarisefromthese as ‘thecollectivevalueofallsocialnetworks academicstudieshave positedsocialcapital(definedby Putnam[2000] Increasingly, The pastdecadehasseenanexplosionofinterestintheconceptsocialcapital. identity’ andthereby helpreduceantisocialbehaviour. may provide ameans ofencouraginga‘sensecommunity antisocial activities.Sport andhelpprevent themfromengaging in sense ofcommunityidentityandpurpose, givepeoplea suchassport, activities, andparticipatory socialstructures, and modern towards counterbalancingcriminalactivities.Socialcontrolsarefoundintraditional Other studieshave alsoidentifiedhowsocialcontrolswithinthecommunitycontribute illhealthandapathy’ 2001). (Cairnduff domesticviolence, abuse, substance unemployment, spirit inthefaceofever-present scourgesofpoverty, andforgeacommunity inspire, at thegrassrootslevel have thepotentialtomotivate, activities somestudieshave foundthat‘sporting (Evans andKelly 2002).Inparticular, intheeyes ofits citizens significant factorinbringingcreditandprestigetoacountry isa insmallercountries, particularly recentstudyshowed howachievement insport, A divisionsarepresent. even whenperhapsinternal among thepeopleofacountry, canfosterasenseofbelongingandnationhood Individual andteamsuccessinsport innationbuildingandassistfosteringnationalintegration(Riordan1986). purpose aunique may serve sport cultureandpolitics, health, broad relevance toeducation, (Riordan1986).Witha politicalandlanguagebarriers historical, religious, ethnic, educational, than perhapsany othersocialactivityandisabletotranscendsocial, extendstobroadsectionsofthepopulationmore Studies have identifiedhowsport onthecommunity Impact ofsport Making DemocracyWork Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting , he examines differences in regional performance between heexaminesdifferencesinregionalperformance , Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 21 , Putnam (2000) turned the United States arguing that his focus to Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Success of women athletes Success of women has significantly contributed to the of women. emancipation Even more significant was the legacy of her victoryEven more significant was and the influence it had on the Moroccan Government, in grassroots sport which recognised the benefits of investing The result has been a generation of female Moroccan for girls as boys. as well athletes reaching the pinnacle of international competition, including Nezha Bidouane the 1997 400-metre hurdles worldwho was champion and Zohra Ouaziz who won the silver medal at the 1999 world athletics championships in the 5000 metres. region. a relatively low status in a number of countries in the Pacific have Women If the experience of Morocco is an example, participation women in sport by in the community. their position and involvement help to improve associations may declining civic engagement is an indicator of fraying social relations and, social relations is an indicator of fraying declining civic engagement in turn, and political performancedeteriorating economic country. in that as useful background,With these studies that social capital in there is evidence the island countries is in decline, Pacific sport and strengthening community-level this problem. be one means of addressing associations may Impact of sport the rights of women in promoting of women athletes has contributed It has been documented how the success significantly to the emancipation of women, particularly in those societies where been discouraged from participating traditionally women have in sport. In fact, some made a concertedmulti-ethnic communities have effort to use sport to break down prejudices (Riordan 1986). At the Los Angeles 1984 Olympic Games,first became the El Moutawakel Nawal Olympic gold medal when she won the woman from an Islamic nation to win an 400-metre also the first Moroccan, hurdles. She was of either sex, to win an Olympic gold brought her widespread recognition throughout Olympic success medal. Nawal’s her country, that the King of Morocco decreed that all girls so much so born on the In 1997,date of her victory to be named in her honour. were she became the Minister the first Muslim woman ever in Morocco and was for Sport and Youth elected as an International Olympic Committee member. northern and southern Italy, concluding good government that found where social is study, In his developed. civil society is most capital and identified a significant Putnam capital. and strong social of soccer clubs the number between relationship In Bowling Alone 22 Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment Literature review Pacific Games. hosting the2003South suchasFiji that have theresourcestoorganise large events, withthebenefitsoflatterstilllimited tothosecountries events, international major federationsandorganisingcommitteesof nationalsport federations, international NationalOlympicCommittees, schools, in provides employment opportunities Sport inthePacific region. andphysical educationarenowan industry Sport opportunities. systemprovides economic benefitsinotherareassuchasemployment national sport acoordinated benefits may notbeasdefinedfordeveloping countries.Nonetheless, anestimateforindustrialcountriesandthe however, PuntaDelEste in1999).Thisis, in held MinisterialConferenceon Physicalcosts (ThirdInternational EducationandSport andphysical activitygeneratesasaving ofUS$3.2millioninnationalmedical sport on US$1millionspent level indicatethatevery attheinternational Studies undertaken andtheeconomy Sport butwe areagreatpeople’. country, small a canfindSenegalonamap.We may ‘Noweveryone have mid-fielder KhalilouFadiga, ramifications andsymbolismofSenegal’s World Cupsuccesswere well statedby the andpolitics, may between notagreewith thecorrelation sport While everyone heraldingitasthebeginningofanew eraforSenegal. thisperformance, significance of was quicktoacknowledgethe Abdoulaye Wade, thePresident ofSenegal, tournament, andthroughouttheremainderof defeating France round.Afterthis victory, inthefirst after ofCameroonatthe1990Worldperformance Cupby makingthequarter-finals achievements intheeyes ofacountry. ofsporting Senegalmatchedthe importance The successofSenegalatthe2002FIFA World Cupexemplifiestheinternational tocreateasenseofnationalidentity.countries thatstruggle relevant forthePacific island (Monnington 2002).Thisaspectmay beparticularly internationally vibrantimageandanidentityforthatcountry generate apositive, itcanalso foster asenseofbelongingandnationhoodamongthepeoplescountry, Studies showthatthesuccessofacountry’s cannotonly individualsorteamsinsport recognition andinternational Sport eia costs. medical millioninnational US$3.2 generates asaving of andphysical activity sport on US$1millionspent every level indicatethat international atthe Studies undertaken Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004http://www.ausport.gov.au NeedsAssessment ©AustralianSports Pacific Sporting Literature review Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment 23 Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au What types of organisations are best placed to deliver the programs? these organisations? What are the main capacity constraints faced by What type of aid-delivery the to provide mechanism is best suited assistance identified? for the region to monitor What are the most suitable social indicators available the main impacts of the program? What priority areas (for example, health, or economic community development be the focus for sport should development) programs? development Finally, outcomes the literature suggested the continued need to monitor and evaluate of sport objectives of the development meet the overall programs to ensure that they region. A set of relatively simple social indicators (preferably ones that are already ofestablished throughout the region) should be chosen to monitor the impact a sport program. development This review considered the current literature on the relationship between sportconsidered the current between on the relationship literature This review and is a island countries. While there Pacific with a specific focus on the development on sportplethora of research countries, in industrial little focus has been given to world, the developing role within sport’s most notably, and The islands. in the Pacific data on the possible role and primary to compile the available was aim of this review impact of sport to identify its potential role for island countries in order on Pacific this review, As a basis for development. encouraging broad-based data on available the social, economic, health and demographic indicators of each country examined. were The role of sport in outlined, international aid programs was research and the available on the importance of sport and effect presented. Finally, countries was in developing the most sport significant studies on the relationship between and social indicators summarised. were island countries continue to face some particularlyPacific difficult development problems, of which are related to capacity constraints. many It would appear that sport island countries. of the Pacific contributes to the development Yet, sport itself is not a panacea, but rather an instrument that has for development to be effective,proven and efficient. In two particular non-threatening areas — health — sportand community development a significant and direct role. Community- play can cost than more complex and sportlevel health at a much lower a role in improving plays expensive medical care. Meanwhile, sport help to at the community level associations of community,strengthen social capital and the sense as well as reinforce social norms. sportThe literature shows that the impact of correlatesto implement to the time given programs. Short-term the same resonance as longer-term ones. programs do not have impact, lasting any have To sport need to programs be and at the local level sustainable needs tomeet genuine community needs. There be a sense of community ownership, and the capacity and determination within thethe program community to continue with the long term.over be assistance programs may in which development There are various ways delivered, meet understood. To but the principles for an effective program are well the region, specific needs of individual countries in the Pacific be a need there may to targeted sport issues that such programs develop programs. Key development should address are: Summary conclusion and Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Country/territory reports 25 Chapter 3 3
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Chapter 3 Country/territory reports Country reports
This chapter contains sections on each country and territory that 26 participates in the ASP Sports Program. The information is a result of an
extensive process that included the development and completion of
questionnaires and in-country consultations with key stakeholders. The
stakeholders consulted in the preparation of the report included national
governments, National Olympic Committees, National Paralympic
Committees, national sport federations and community groups.
The reports provide insight into the current status of sport in each Pacific SportingPacific Needs Assessment
participating country and territory, as well as identifying priority areas for
development. The priority areas vary across the countries and territories
and are a useful tool in developing a strategy for an effective development
assistance program.
While not recipients of ASP funding, American Samoa and Guam have
participated in specific ASP initiatives and have therefore been included.
The reports provide insight into the current status of sport in each participating country and territory.
Pacific Sporting Needs Assessment © Australian Sports Commission 2004 http://www.ausport.gov.au Territory American Samoa 27