Molecular Identification of Some Forensically Important Blowflies of Southern Africa and Australia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Medical and Veterinary Entomology (2003) 17, 363–369 Molecular identification of some forensically important blowflies of southern Africa and Australia M.L.HARVEY,M.W.MANSELL* ,M.H.VILLETy andI.R.DADOUR Centre for Forensic Science, University of Western Australia, Australia, *Department of Zoology and Entomology, University of Pretoria, South Africa, and yDepartment of Zoology and Entomology, Rhodes University, South Africa Abstract. One major aspect of research in forensic entomology is the investigation of molecular techniques for the accurate identification of insects. Studies to date have addressed the corpse fauna of many geographical regions, but generally neglected the southern African calliphorid species. In this study, forensically significant calliphorids from South Africa, Swaziland, Botswana and Zimbabwe and Australia were sequenced over an 1167 base pair region of the COI gene. Phylogenetic analysis was performed to examine the ability of the region to resolve species identities and taxonomic relationships between species. Analyses by neigh- bour-joining, maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood methods all showed the potential of this region to provide the necessary species-level identifications for application to post-mortem interval (PMI) estimation; however, higher level taxonomic relationships did vary according to method of analysis. Intraspecific variation was also considered in relation to determining suitable maximum levels of variation to be expected during analysis. Individuals of some species in the study represented populations from both South Africa and the east coast of Australia, yet maximum intraspecific variation over this gene region was calculated at 0.8%,with minimum interspecific variation at 3%, indicating distinct ranges of variation to be expected at intra- and interspecific levels. This region therefore appears to provide southern African forensic entomologists with a new technique for providing accurate identification for application to estimation of PMI. Key words. Calliphora, Chrysomya, Hydrotaea, Lucilia, Calliphoridae, Blowflies, Cytochrome oxidase I gene, forensic entomology, mitochondrial DNA, Australia, Botswana, South Africa, Swaziland, Zambia, Zimbabwe. Introduction have addressed this issue by using DNA sequences to iden- tify insects, most choosing to use mitochondrial DNA Forensic entomology has been an important investigative (mtDNA) as the basis for sequencing (Sperling et al., 1994; tool for many years, particularly through its use in court Malgorn & Coquoz, 1999; Wallman & Donnellan, 2001; trials in providing an estimation of post-mortem interval Wells & Sperling, 2001; Harvey et al., 2003). These studies (PMI) in homicide cases. This application of entomology to have revealed the potential for the use of mtDNA in pro- investigations demands great accuracy in PMI estimations, viding more accurate identifications for the estimation of resulting in significant research addressing this issue. PMI. The correct identification of specimens is a critical pre- The majority of literature in the field of forensic entom- requisite in the estimation of PMI using insects, but this ology has addressed the corpse fauna of the United States, may be difficult using the traditional morphology-based Europe, Britain and Australia, but generally neglected approach (Prins, 1982; Wallman, 2001). Several studies Africa. In southern Africa, forensic entomology is being increasingly incorporated into death investigations (M. Mansell, pers. obs.). To date, southern African research Correspondence: M. L. Harvey, Centre for Forensic Science, has focused largely on the succession of insects on corpses University of Western, Australia, Stirling Highway, Nedlands WA (Louw & van der Linde, 1993), and a few studies have 6907, Australia. E-mail: [email protected] considered the succession on animal carcasses that may be # 2003 The Royal Entomological Society 363 364 M. L. Harvey et al. applied to human corpse succession (Meskin, 1986; Braack & more distantly related muscid was chosen. The Calliphor- De Vos, 1987; Ellison, 1990). Despite increased interest in inae, although commonly found on corpses in Australia, are forensic entomology, DNA-based identification still only represented by Calliphora croceipalpis Jaennicke and remains a curiosity rather than an application in southern C. vicina Robineau-Desvoidy in southern Africa and were Africa. This is largely a result of the small amount of genetic not included in this analysis. The potential of the COI data collected on the forensically significant species. A encoding region for use in identification of flies for PMI robust typing method requires a large body of data to estimation based on insects is discussed. ensure that characters used to distinguish species are repre- sented among all populations of a species, and consequently to consider the intraspecific variation that may be observed Materials and methods across the distribution of a species. The usefulness of such information becomes evident as several African insects Samples associated with carcasses have now been identified from South America (Lawrence, 1986). Adult flies were used in this study as adult morphological mtDNA is recognized as being useful for evolutionary characters allowed more rapid and accurate identification to study because of its relatively higher mutation rate than species level than larval characters. Specimens were identified nuclear DNA (Hoy, 1994), and also the presence of both using keys and characters in Zumpt (1965). Origins of speci- conserved and variable segments. Evolutionary studies of mens are shown in Table 1. Flies were trapped in Botswana, forensically important Calliphoridae using phylogenetic South Africa, Swaziland, Zambia and Zimbabwe, and techniques allow visualization of relationships between Australian specimens were taken from laboratory colonies species, based on levels of similarity in sequence data. or trapped using liver-baited traps. Specimens were preserved Such relationships are useful to elucidate, as they often in 70% ethanol and refrigerated. reflect the morphological and behavioural discrepancies observed in the field and provide a greater understanding for entomologists of potential pitfalls in data. This may be DNA extraction in the discovery of species complexes, or simply in the phylogenetic confirmation of the genetic separation of two Extraction was performed using a Chelex 100 (Bio-Rad, highly similar species over which species status may be Australia) technique modified from Hunt (1997). An inci- questioned. sion was made under the left wing of each specimen, and The potential of the cytochrome oxidase I (COI) encod- flight muscles removed and macerated. In a few specimens ing region of mtDNA has been shown to be useful for flight muscles had degraded and, consequently, a single identification in many studies (e.g. Sperling et al., 1994; wing of the fly was used for extraction. The remainder of Malgorn & Coquoz, 1999). Various segments of this region the specimen was then stored in ethanol and refrigerated, as have been sequenced in different studies, ranging from 278 a voucher specimen. The muscle or wing was then frozen using base pairs to the entire COI gene. This study considered the liquid nitrogen and ground to a fine powder using micropestles use of a 1167-bp region of the COI gene for identification of in 1.5-mL Eppendorf tubes. One hundred microlitres of a 5% forensically important calliphorids in southern Africa. The solution of Chelex was added to the ground material, vortexed region encompassed the 278-bp segment used by Harvey and incubated for 15 min on a 95C heatblock. Following et al. (2003) and the 639 sites used by Wallman & Donnellan incubation, the sample was vortexed for 5 s, and centrifuged (2001) to provide successful distinction with the Australian for 3 min at maximum speed. The supernatant was removed corpse fauna. andstoredatÀ20C. Flies from Botswana, South Africa, Swaziland, Zambia and Zimbabwe were sequenced and phylogenetic analyses used to construct evolutionary relationships between them. PCR conditions and purification of PCR products Species sequenced were Chrysomya albiceps (Wiedemann), C. megacephala (Fabricius), C. putoria (Wiedemann), The primers used amplified a region of approximately C. marginalis (Wiedemann), C. inclinata Walker and Lucilia 1270 bp. Primers were C1-J-1718 (50-30 GGAGGATTTG- sericata (Meigen). Forensically significant Australian GAAATTGATTAGTTCC) and TL2-N-3014 (50-30 TCCA- species from the subfamilies Chrysomyinae and Luciliinae ATGCACTAATCTGCCATATTA) (Simon et al., 1994). were included in order to test intraspecific variation for The PCR reaction mix consisted of: 1 Â PCR buffer species also found in southern Africa. Specimens of (Biotools, South Africa), 200 mM dNTPs (Biotools), 1.5 mM C. rufifacies (Macquart), C. varipes (Macquart) and MgCl2,25pM each primer and 3 mL template DNA, and L. cuprina (Wiedemann) were also included, along with water added to a total volume of 50 mL. A Perkin Elmer the muscid Hydrotaea rostrata (Robineau-Desvoidy). GeneAmp PCR System 2400 thermocycler was used. The Hydrotaea rostrata was included primarily for its forensic programme began with a 90-s 94C denaturation period, relevance, but also as an outgroup. Although a sarcophagid followed by 36 cycles of: 94C for 22 s, 48C for 30 s and species may have formed a more suitable outgroup, there 72C for 80 s. A final extension period of 60 s at 72C was were no sequences available