Literacy Practices Among Migrant Teachers: Educator Perspectives and Critical Observations
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Western Michigan University ScholarWorks at WMU Dissertations Graduate College 8-2015 Literacy Practices among Migrant Teachers: Educator Perspectives and Critical Observations Briana Asmus Western Michigan University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/dissertations Part of the Bilingual, Multilingual, and Multicultural Education Commons, Chicana/o Studies Commons, and the Latina/o Studies Commons Recommended Citation Asmus, Briana, "Literacy Practices among Migrant Teachers: Educator Perspectives and Critical Observations" (2015). Dissertations. 732. https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/dissertations/732 This Dissertation-Open Access is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate College at ScholarWorks at WMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks at WMU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. LITERACY PRACTICES AMONG MIGRANT TEACHERS: EDUCATOR PERSPECTIVES AND CRITICAL OBSERVATIONS by Briana M. Asmus A dissertation submitted to the Graduate College in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy English Western Michigan University August 2015 Doctoral Committee: Karen Vocke, Ph.D., Chair Estrella Torrez, Ph.D. Susan Piazza, Ed.D. Jonathan Bush, Ph.D. LITERACY PRACTICES AMONG MIGRANT TEACHERS: EDUCATOR PERSPECTIVES AND CRITICAL OBSERVATIONS Briana Asmus, Ph.D. Western Michigan University, 2015 This research builds upon scholarship that explores the unique needs of Latina/o migrant students and the teachers who serve them. Situated within the overlapping fields of migrant education, critical literacy, and Latina/o critical theory, this narrative examines the practices and perspectives of three teachers, each with more than a decade of experience teaching migrant students in a summer migrant education program (SMEP) in Michigan. The purpose of this study is to give educators, administrators, and community members who work with migrant students additional insight into the literacy acquisition process and unique challenges of working with this population. Despite the aim of SMEPs to address areas where migrant students struggle academically, migrant students continue to struggle to frequent relocation and factors such as poverty, discrimination, and access to services. Research has generally shown that migrant students also encounter cultural, linguistic and racial barriers within school systems that can hinder their academic progress (Tatto et. al, 2000; Valencia, 2002; Romanowski, 2002; Green, 2003; Cranston-Gingras, 2003; Vocke, 2007; Torrez, 2013). Literacy is one area where migrant students continue to underperform compared to their non-migrant peers. By offering detailed portraits of teachers who work with the migrant population, this study highlights classroom practices of teachers who are tasked with increasing the literacy skills of their students. The study also reveals barriers and pathways within the institution of migrant education that impact the needs of migrant students. While this study revealed pedagogical practices unique to each case study participant, it also revealed ‘common critical practices’ shared by all of the teachers that employ aspects of critical literacy, with a consideration of their student’s knowledge and background. As school systems nationwide continue to experience an influx of migrant students who are expected to perform at the same level on state assessments as their non- migrant peers, the outcomes of this study are relevant for teachers of migrant students in all settings. In addition, this study serves as a model for stakeholders in migrant education to consider how migrant farmworker students continue to be disenfranchised by existing laws, policies and educational practices. © 2015 Briana Asmus ACKNOWLEDGMENTS To Mara. Rest in peace. I thank Ken and Mary Jo Asmus for their continued patience, lightheartedness, and kindness to me during dark days. I thank Kelly Asmus and Bryan Campbell for their friendship, company and for reminding me not to take life too seriously. I am proud to call you family. I thank Chris Nagle for his continued support and trust. It’s amazing what’s possible when you have a life you love. I thank Karen Vocke, my mentor and friend. I thank Estrella, Susan and Jonathan for their time, support and sage-like advice. I am honored to have so many brilliant scholars on my committee. Thanks to Christy, Kristin and all participants of “Writing Mania.” Many thanks to Dennis Simpson, who has supported me through two degrees. Thank you to the many people who took part in this study with caring and open hearts, and to migrant farmworkers worldwide for everything you do, and for allowing me to learn from you. ¡Gracias por todo! Finally, thanks to the many talented professors at Western Michigan University who continue to inspire me. Briana Asmus ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................. ii LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................ viii LIST OF FIGURES ............................................................................................ ix CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................... 1 The First Day ................................................................................. 1 Overview of this Study ............................................................... 3 Research Questions ............................................................. 4 Migrant Education Programs: A Historical Overview ................. 5 Definitions .................................................................................... 8 Historical Perspective of the Migrant Narrative in Education ... 11 Increasing Need ......................................................................... 15 Documenting the Teacher .......................................................... 17 Changing Responsibilities of the Educator ........................ 20 Connections to Literacy Learning .............................................. 23 Language and Literacy ....................................................... 25 Insights Provided by this Study ................................................. 26 Chapter Overview ...................................................................... 27 II. LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FOUNDATIONS ............................................................................. 29 Theoretical Frame ...................................................................... 29 iii Table of Contents—Continued CHAPTER Identifying the “Gap” in Research ............................................. 31 Examining the Role of An Educator ...................................... 33 The Continuation of Deficit Thinking ...................................... 35 Moving Beyond the Multicultural Perspective ......................... 39 Classroom Studies in Critical Literacy ...................................... 40 Themes in LatCrit ...................................................................... 44 Language ............................................................................ 47 Rights and Citizenship ........................................................ 51 Towards a LatCrit Perspective for Teachers .............................. 52 Working Against an Assimilation Model .................................. 54 Responding to the Needs of a Mobile Population ..................... 55 Summary .................................................................................... 57 III. METHODOLOGY AND TEACHER PROFILES ......................... 59 Preliminary Work ....................................................................... 59 Conferences ................................................................... 59 Teacher Trainings .......................................................... 61 Data Collection Methods and Procedures .................................. 63 Data Analysis Processes and Procedures ................................... 66 Limitations of this Study ............................................................ 70 Participant Profiles ..................................................................... 71 iv Table of Contents—Continued CHAPTER Jamie’s Professional Journey ......................................... 74 Jamie’s Teaching Context ............................................ 75 Jamie’s Critical Perspectives ........................................ 77 Alex’s Professional Journey .......................................... 78 Alex’s Teaching Context ............................................... 79 Alex’s Critical Perspectives ........................................... 80 Jordan’s Professional Journey ........................................ 81 Jordan’s Teaching Context ............................................ 82 Jordan’s Critical Perspectives ........................................ 83 Closing Thoughts ....................................................................... 84 IV. FINDINGS ...................................................................................... 86 Overview of Data Analysis ........................................................ 86 Overview of Document Analysis ............................................... 86 Literacy Models ............................................................. 88 Reports ..........................................................................