Structures Readings Book

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Structures Readings Book Structures in tertiary education and training: a kaleidoscope or merely fragments? Research readings NATIONAL CENTRE FOR VOCATIONAL EDUCATION RESEARCH Edited by Francesca Beddie Laura O’Connor Penelope Curtin Structures in tertiary education and training: a kaleidoscope or merely fragments? Research readings Edited by Francesca Beddie Laura O’Connor Penelope Curtin NATIONAL VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING RESEARCH PROGRAM RESEARCH READINGS The views and opinions expressed in this document are those of the author/ project team and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Australian Government or state and territory governments. Any interpretation of data is the responsibility of the author/project team. © Commonwealth of Australia, 2013 With the exception of the Commonwealth Coat of Arms, the Department’s logo, any material protected by a trade mark and where otherwise noted all material presented in this document is provided under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia <creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au> licence. The details of the relevant licence conditions are available on the Creative Commons website (accessible using the links provided) as is the full legal code for the CC BY 3.0 AU licence <creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode>. The Creative Commons licence conditions do not apply to all logos, graphic design, artwork and photographs. Requests and enquiries concerning other reproduction and rights should be directed to the National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER). This document should be attributed as Beddie, F, O’Connor, L & Curtin, P (eds) 2013, Structures in tertiary education and training: a kaleidoscope or merely fragments? Research readings, NCVER, Adelaide. COVER IMAGE: GETTY IMAGES/THINKSTOCK ISBN 978 1 922056 50 4 TD/TNC 112.03 Published by NCVER, ABN 87 007 967 311 Level 11, 33 King William Street, Adelaide SA 5000 PO Box 8288 Station Arcade, Adelaide SA 5000, Australia P +61 8 8230 8400 F +61 8 8212 3436 E [email protected] W <www.ncver.edu.au> About the research Structures in tertiary education and training: a kaleidoscope or merely fragments? Research readings Editors: Francesca Beddie, Laura O’Connor and Penelope Curtin In June 2010 the Standing Council on Tertiary Education, Skills and Employment (SCOTESE) adopted a new set of national research priorities in tertiary education and training for the period 2011 to 2013. One of these pointed to the need to better understand structures in the system by examining the impact of policy, funding and market frameworks on the provision of education and training. Since very few researchers have investigated these issues, the National Centre for Vocational Education research (NCVER) decided to commission essays on various aspects of the topic. We hoped to throw light on the structures in the evolving tertiary education system and to take forward debate about the current wave of reform. The authors and four discussants came together with other leaders in the system in November 2012 to talk about the essays. Given the complexity of these issues, it is quite difficult to distil the discussions into a few simple messages. Nevertheless, some of the key points were: . A common understanding of the dynamics of the system is not easy to reach. We are still not all talking about the same thing when we refer to tertiary education. There is little support for a single integrated tertiary education sector. If there is a consensus it is that variety within the sector is a good thing. While the language of markets has been adopted in the reform effort, we need to be clear we are talking about a very unusual market, both in terms of its ‘product’ and its ‘customers’. In fact, there is a dispute over who is the customer of the vocational education and training (VET) system — the individual student or the employers who ultimately employ those that the system educates and trains. Even within the sectors, there is not always consensus on definitions. This is notably the case when discussing the meaning of ‘vocation’ and the shape of competency-based training. To establish the underpinnings and value of each part of the system, we need greater clarity about the purpose of public funding, as well as a clear alignment between funding regimes and policy objectives. The issue is who should pay for what. Many pillars of the system can be strengthened. How institutions are governed, and how the workforce is organised and the system regulated require further thought. The extent of institutional autonomy is a key element. While this exercise could never determine the ideal structures for tertiary education and training, it has been invaluable in teasing out the complexity of tertiary education. It also makes clear there is no simple ‘market design’ that would meet all the objectives of the various elements of Australia’s tertiary education system. Tom Karmel Managing Director, NCVER Contents Contributors 6 Overview — Francesca Beddie 10 How educational matters influence structures in the system 15 The public good — Sharon Bell 16 What makes education ‘vocational’ in an integrated tertiary sector — Steven Hodge 26 The future of the tertiary sector workforce: a kaleidoscope of possibilities? — Michele Simons 36 Discussion: How educational matters influence structures in the system — Kwong Lee Dow 48 Who controls the system? 59 Education as an industry, and as a product — John Quiggin 60 The drivers of industry involvement in VET reform — Richard Jenkins & Ian Curry 69 Innovation and industry best practice: why industry skills councils are critical — Robert Dalitz and Di Dibley 83 Discussion: Who controls the system? — Robin Shreeve 90 Governance of the system in a competitive environment 97 How do providers respond to changes in structures in a period of reform? — Kerry Brown 98 Mismatched gears — how federal arrangements hinder the integration of the tertiary education sector — John Ross 108 A precipitate proposal — a participant’s view of structural discussions in post-secondary education — Adrian Marron 119 The strategic impact of industrial relations among tertiary education providers — Damian Oliver 132 Discussion: Governance of the system in a competitive environment — Jonathan Pincus 143 Interactions with the system 155 Student choice between VET and university — Yijuan Chen and Juergen Meinecke 156 What role does price play in student behaviour? — Michael Coelli 167 Regulating for learning in the tertiary education system — Valerie Braithwaite and Sue Fergusson 179 Discussion: Interactions with the system — Jeff Borland 190 NVETR Program funding 197 NCVER 5 Contributors Editors Ms Francesca Beddie is a consultant and former General Manager, Research, at the National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER), with a strong interest in the intersection of research and public policy. She has previously been employed as a diplomat, with postings in Indonesia, Russia and Germany. From 1995 to 1998 she was a senior officer in the Australian Agency for International Development (AusAID), where she headed the agency’s policy development and public affairs areas. Francesca has also worked as a policy and media consultant and trainer, historian and editor. From 2002 to 2004, Francesca was the executive director of Adult Learning Australia. She has served on the ABC Advisory Council and on the Australian Press Council and is a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors. Ms Penelope Curtin is a freelance editor and writer who has worked on NCVER publications for the past 25 years. She has previously been an arts administrator and a bookshop proprietor. Ms Laura O’Connor manages and coordinates research projects at NCVER, where she has worked for over five years. Of the many different projects in which she has been involved, Laura is particularly interested in the impact of structural reforms on the student experience and understanding the various pathways which exist within the education system. Other contributors Professor Sharon Bell is Deputy Vice-Chancellor at Charles Darwin University, a Professorial Fellow at the LH Martin Institute and Emeritus Professor at the University of Wollongong. She was Co-convenor of Universities Australia Executive Women (previously Australian Vice-Chancellors Committee Senior Women’s Colloquium), 2005—08. Sharon holds a PhD from the University of Sydney in the discipline of anthropology. She has worked with international agencies such as the World Bank, the Sri Lankan University Grants Commission and AusAID on institutional capacity-building projects. She is currently a recipient of an Australian Research Council Grant on Women in the Scientific Research Workforce. Professor Jeff Borland teaches in the Department of Economics at the University of Melbourne and was head of the department from 2003 to 2006. He has previously held positions at the Centre for Economic Policy Research at the Australian National University, the University of Iowa and the University of Wisconsin-Madison. In 1997 he was awarded the Australian Academy of Social Sciences Medal for Excellence in Scholarship in the Social Sciences, and in 2002 was made a Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences. Jeff’s main research interests are the operation of labour markets in Australia, program and policy evaluation and design, Australian economic history, and the economics of sport. Professor Valerie Braithwaite works in the Regulatory Institutions Network at the Australian National University. A psychologist by training, her work advances
Recommended publications
  • Inquiry Into Agricultural Education and Training in Victoria
    Education and Training Committee Inquiry into agricultural education and training in Victoria ORDERED TO BE PRINTED November 2012 by Authority Victorian Government Printer Parliamentary paper No.196 Session 2010–2012 Parliament of Victoria Education and Training Committee Inquiry into agricultural education and training in Victoria This report is also available at www.parliament.vic.gov.au/etc Printed on 100% recycled paper ISBN 978-0-9871154-2-3 ISBN 978-0-9871154-3-0 Electronic ii Contents Contents .............................................................................................................................. iii List of figures ...................................................................................................................... xi List of case studies ........................................................................................................... xiii Committee membership .................................................................................................... xv Functions of the Committee ............................................................................................. xvi Terms of reference ............................................................................................................ xvi Chair’s foreword .............................................................................................................. xvii Executive summary ......................................................................................................... xix List of
    [Show full text]
  • Dates Worth Noting
    CCAREER MAILBOX Thursday 5th May 2016 DATES WORTH NOTING News from the University of Melbourne Engineering & I T Programs for School Students The University of Melbourne offers a range of exciting opportunities for secondary school students to visit Parkville campus and experience Engineering & IT. Some of these programs include – Hands on Computing Find out what computing and information systems study involves and the careers that can follow, through this interactive day long program. No particular computer skills are required except for an inquisitive and creative mind! Students will also have the opportunity to meet with academics and current students. Date: Tuesday 28 June 2016 Time: 9.00am – 3.30pm Hands on Engineering Hands on Engineering is a day-long program, for Year 10 students who are interested in mathematics and science, providing hands on experience in a variety of fun activities and workshops to learn about the different fields of engineering. Students will also have the opportunity to tour the campus and meet with academics and current students. Date: Thursday 30 June 2016 Time: 9.00am – 3.30pm To find out more about either of the above mentioned, and/or to register, visit Engineering & I T Holiday Programs VCA Schools Program – Walks of Art 2016 Aimed at Visual Art students and their teachers, this walking tour will take you around alleyways and into some of the smaller artist-run gallery spaces around Melbourne. Learn more about the contemporary visual art scene in Melbourne, and be inspired! This series of walking tours will be hosted by a VCA final year visual art student.
    [Show full text]
  • Department of Education & Training 2016-2020 Strategic
    DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION & TRAINING 2016 -2020 STRATEGIC PLAN CONTENTS SECRETARY’S MESSAGE .......................................................................................................................................... 3 STRATEGIC INTENT .................................................................................................................................................... 4 OUR VISION .............................................................................................................................................................. 4 OUR OBJECTIVES .................................................................................................................................................... 4 OUR VALUES ............................................................................................................................................................ 4 OUR OUTCOMES...................................................................................................................................................... 5 DET OUTCOMES FRAMEWORK .............................................................................................................................. 5 EDUCATION STATE TARGETS ................................................................................................................................ 5 DET OUTCOME INDICATORS .................................................................................................................................. 8 CONTEXT: CHALLENGES AND RISKS
    [Show full text]
  • Narrative Insights Into Education Eleanor Peeler [email protected]
    Windows into the past: narrative insights into education Eleanor Peeler [email protected] WINDOWS INTO THE PAST: NARRATIVE INSIGHTS INTO EDUCATION Eleanor Peeler University of Melbourne, Melbourne Abstract The intent of this paper is to stress the importance of narrative and story, and to share the experience of opening the windows of memory to look into the past and uncover fascinating and valuable histories as portrayed in a current study. The longitudinal study of an educator follows his life story and his role in education. Set in Victoria, it explores the founding of the State’s education system and highlights progressive developments. The life story reveals the history of the system and evolving philosophies that influenced the life of the subject. The study considers the philosophies and how they influenced the subject’s thinking and actions. Using windows as a metaphor, Part 1 of the paper includes discussion regarding the appropriacy of narrative as a research tool, considers the notion of memory and introduces the research subject. Part 2 gives insights into three distinct periods and the part played by three men who guided Victoria’s educational development and growth throughout the twentieth century. In relation to each is a brief discussion of their influence on the career of the research subject. Windows into the past While the story of the narratives holds interest, the process of narrative inquiry is a valuable tool for research. The intent of this paper is to stress the importance of narrative and story, and to share the experience of opening the windows of memory to look into the past and uncover fascinating and valuable histories.
    [Show full text]
  • Formula-Based Public School Funding System in Victoria: an Empirical Analysis of Equity
    Formula-Based Public School Funding System in Victoria: An Empirical Analysis of Equity This manuscript has been peer-reviewed, accepted, and endorsed by the National Council of Professors of Educational Administration (NCPEA) as a significant contribution to the scholarship and practice of school administration and K-12 education. Bandara Bandaranayake Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, Victoria, Australia This article explores the formula-based school funding system in the state of Victoria, Australia, where state funds are directly allocated to schools based on a range of equity measures. The impact of Victoria’s funding system for education in terms of alleviating inequality and disadvantage is contentious, to say the least. It is difficult to adopt the belief that equity funding can alter the unequal levels of capacity that pupils bring into the classroom as a result of their varied socio-economic backgrounds. This study highlights a number of contextual factors that challenge the equity considerations of the Victorian school funding system. Among these factors include: the ability of individual schools to raise their own funds; allocation of a significant proportion of formula funding for staff salaries without directly addressing educational disadvantages; and the unnecessary complexity of formulas and limited community access to funding information. Nevertheless, the formula-based school funding system in Victoria presents a model in which funding is tied directly to the needs of both students and schools; a uniform criteria to apply impartially to each school; an increased level of accessible information on how the funds have been deployed; a reduced level of complexity presented compared to overlapping funding models from state, district and local authorities in other jurisdictions; and an opportunity for meaningful analysis generated on the school level to explore the impact of funding and incorporate improvements in a single funding system.
    [Show full text]
  • Autonomy and Accountability in Victorian Schools
    Making the Grade: Autonomy and Accountability in Victorian Schools Inquiry into School Devolution and Accountability Final Report July 2013 © State of Victoria 2013 This final report is copyright. No part may be reproduced by any process except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), without prior written permission from the Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission. Cover images reproduced courtesy of the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development ISBN 978-1-922222-08-4 (print) ISBN 978-1-922222-09-1 (pdf) Disclaimer The views expressed herein are those of the Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission and do not purport to represent the position of the Victorian Government. The content of this final report is provided for information purposes only. Neither the Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission nor the Victorian Government accepts any liability to any person for the information (or the use of such information) which is provided in this final report or incorporated into it by reference. The information in this final report is provided on the basis that all persons having access to this final report undertake responsibility for assessing the relevance and accuracy of its content. Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission GPO Box 4379 MELBOURNE VICTORIA 3001 AUSTRALIA Telephone: (03) 9092 5800 Facsimile: (03) 9092 5845 Website: www.vcec.vic.gov.au An appropriate citation for this publication is: Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission 2013, Making the Grade: Autonomy and Accountability in Victorian Schools, Inquiry into School Devolution and Accountability, final report, July. About the Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission The Victorian Competition and Efficiency Commission (VCEC), which is supported by a secretariat, provides the Victorian Government with independent advice on business regulation reform and opportunities for improving Victoria’s competitive position.
    [Show full text]
  • Higher Education in Regional and Rural Victoria: Distribution, Provision and Access
    Melbourne Graduate School of Education HIGHER EDUCATION IN REGIONAL AND RURAL VICTORIA: DISTRIBUTION, PROVISION AND ACCESS Jenny Chesters, Hernan Cuervo and Katherine Romei AUTHORS Dr Jenny Chesters A/ Prof. Hernan Cuervo Ms Katherine Romei The University of Melbourne ISBN: 978 0 7340 5590 3 Date: May 2020 Youth Research Centre Melbourne Graduate School of Education The University of Melbourne, Vic 3010 To cite this report: Chesters, J., Cuervo, H. and Romei, K. 2020 Higher Education in Regional and Rural Victoria: Distribution, Provision and Access. Youth Research Centre, University of Melbourne, Melbourne. All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Youth Research Centre The views expressed in this report are those of the authors and are not necessarily those of the Youth Research Centre, the Melbourne Graduate School of Education, or the University of Melbourne. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This report was funded an MSGE 2019 Development Award granted to Dr Jenny Chesters. Photos: Jenny Chesters. 2 Youth Research Centre, Melbourne Graduate School of Education CONTENTS 1. Introduction 4 2. Literature review 6 3. Higher education in the regions 8 4. Availability of courses in regional Victoria 15 5. Conclusion 16 6. References 17 7. Appendices 19 Access to university 3 1. INTRODUCTION Research indicates that students living in regional, rural and Equality of opportunity is dependent upon the availability, remote areas may be disadvantaged on at least two levels: family accessibility and affordability of study options in one’s local socioeconomic status (SES) and geographic location.
    [Show full text]
  • Access to Higher Education in Victoria 181212 Final
    Access to higher education in Victoria under the national demand-driven system An analysis of 2007-2011 higher education applications, offers and enrolments drawn from the VTAC database Ellie Newnham, Malcolm Anderson and Richard James Report prepared for the Victorian Tertiary Admissions Centre by the Centre for the Study of Higher Education, the University of Melbourne Report prepared for the Victorian Tertiary Admissions Centre by the Centre for the Study of Higher Education, University of Melbourne, December 2012 Ellie Newnham, Malcolm Anderson and Richard James 1 Acknowledgements The authors are very grateful for the insightful contributions made to this study by Elaine Wenn and Paul Livingstone of VTAC and the members of an advisory group, Kwong Lee Dow (University of Melbourne), Andrew Harvey (La Trobe University) and Sue Willis (Monash University). Newnham, E. Anderson, M. and James, R. (2012) Access to higher education in Victoria under the national demand- driven system. Centre for the Study of Higher Education, The University of Melbourne. © December 2012 This work is copyright. It may be reproduced in whole or in part for study or training purposes subject to the inclusion of an acknowledgment of the source and no commercial usage or sale. Reproduction for purposes other than those indicated above, requires the prior written permission from the Victorian Tertiary Admissions Centre or the Centre for the Study of Higher Education, The University of Melbourne. Requests and inquiries concerning reproduction and rights should be addressed to Richard James, Centre for the Study of Higher Education, The University of Melbourne VIC 3010. The views expressed in this report do not necessarily reflect the views of the Victorian Tertiary Admissions Centre.
    [Show full text]
  • Victorian Future Industries International Education
    Submission: Victorian Future Industries International Education About Navitas Navitas Ltd is an Australian global education leader providing pre-university and university programs, higher and vocational education, English language courses, migrant education and settlement services, creative media education, student recruitment, professional development and corporate training services to more than 80,000 students across a network of over 120 colleges and campuses in 27 countries. Navitas listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) in 2004 and is now an S&P/ASX Top 100 Company, employing more than 5,800 staff globally. General Comments: Navitas believes an innovative, diverse, globally connected public and private education and training sector is critical to Australia’s future prosperity, intellectual capital, social cohesion, and global engagement. Navitas welcomes the support given by various levels of government to international and transnational education, and the recognition of the contribution the international education sector makes to economies and societies, both in Australia and globally. Navitas supports the development of national, state and territory, and local government strategies and actions that are aligned to ensure ‘Australian international education is valued for the benefits it delivers to individuals, communities and economies throughout the world’1. Navitas has argued in its submission to the Australian Government’s draft national strategy for international education that “…more weight should be given to the profound and irreversible changes occurring, and that will occur, in the delivery of education (both domestic and international) over the coming decade. These changes are being driven by developing and emerging economies, young and ageing populations, geo-political forces, technological advances, and resource, health and environmental issues.
    [Show full text]
  • Languages Education Policy in Victoria 5
    Languages Education Policy in Victoria Overview of languages policies and opportunities to engage bilingual youth in Victoria ECCV Intern Policy Scoping Paper The Ethnic Communities’ Council of Victoria Inc. (ECCV) is the Voice of Multicultural Victoria. As the peak advocacy body for ethnic and multicultural organisations in Victoria, we are proud to have been the key advocate for culturally diverse communities in Victoria since 1974. For over 40 years we have been the link between multicultural communities, government and the wider community. © ECCV January 2017 Ethnic Communities’ Council of Victoria Inc. Suite 101, 398 Sydney Road, Coburg VIC 3058 T: (03) 9354 9555 F: (03) 9350 2694 W: www.eccv.org.au ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks to all those who contributed their time and expertise to support this research paper, in particular, our ECCV policy volunteer and Deakin University Masters of Arts Graduate Angela Sterjova, ECCV policy officers, and all of the consultation participants that contributed to this intern policy scoping paper. ECCV support young multicultural Victorians to strengthen the policies which make Victoria Australia’s leading multicultural state. Contents FOREWORD 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 6 BACKGROUND 7 KEY POLICY REPORTS 9 The Victorian Governments Vision for Languages 9 Languages – Expanding Your World: Plan to implement The Victorian Government’s Vision for Languages Education 2013-2025 11 Education State 12 Education State Consultation Paper 13 Education State Schools Consultation Paper 13 INTERNATIONAL, NATIONAL AND INTERSTATE
    [Show full text]
  • International Education in Regional Study Destinations: Building the Evidence Base Final Report
    INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION IN REGIONAL STUDY DESTINATIONS: BUILDING THE EVIDENCE BASE FINAL REPORT Justin Brown | Jo Doyle | Leyna Clarke | Ali Radloff | Darren Matthews Developed for the Australian Government Department of Education, Skills and Employment 1 April 2020 Cover photo: Students at James Cook University, Townsville in September 2019 This project is supported by the Australian International Education: Enabling Growth and Innovation program project fund, Department of Education, Skills and Employment. For further information, please visit the website www.internationaleducation.gov.au or www.dese.gov.au. ISBN: 978-1-74286-593-5 With the exception of any material protected by a trademark, and where otherwise noted, all material presented in this document is provided under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ au/). The details of the relevant licence conditions are available on the Creative Commons website as is the full legal code for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). International education in regional study destinations: Building the evidence base Page 2 of 139 Table of Contents Preface ...................................................................................................................................... 10 Executive Summary .................................................................................................................... 11 1. Introduction ......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Education in Australia Streams in the History Of
    STREAMS IN THE HISTORY OF COMPUTER EDUCATION IN AUSTRALIA An Overview of School and University Computer Education Arthur Tatnall and Bill Davey Victoria University and RMIT University Australia E-mail: [email protected] Abstract: In world terms, Australia moved into the educational computing, both at the Higher Education and School levels, very early. This paper looks at how university subjects, and later how whole courses in computing evolved in Australia and how these had very little effect on the later use of computers in schools. We briefly examine how computers were first used in schools, and the influences that put them there and decided how they could be used. We relate an established a model of the growth of academic subjects to the emergence of the discipline area of computing, and in particular, to the Victorian Year 12 Computer Science subject. Key words: Computer science; Information systems; Computer education; Computers across the curriculum; School computing; University computing. 1. INTRODUCTION The Commonwealth of Australia is a federation of six states and two territories each having a considerable degree of independence. Constitutionally, education is the role of the individual State; the Commonwealth Government being limited to co-ordination, leadership and the funding of specific projects. While also considering Australia-wide issues, this paper will concentrate its perspective on the state of Victoria. In this paper we will provide an overview of the evolution and history of the various streams of educational computing in Australia: University-level Computer Science and Information Systems courses, Primary and Secondary School courses teaching about computing, and the use of computers in other 84 Arthur Tatnall and Bill Davey school subjects.
    [Show full text]