DURHAM CATHEDRAL ANNUAL REVIEW AND ACCOUNTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 MARCH 2019 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Durham Cathedral is a Chris an Church of the Anglican Communion, the shrine of St Cuthbert and the seat of the Bishop of Durham. It is a focus of pilgrimage and spirituality in North East England.
Our Purpose Our purpose is to worship God, share the gospel of Jesus Christ, welcome all who come, celebrate and pass on our rich Chris an heritage and discover our place in God’s crea on.
Our Vision Following the example of Saints Cuthbert and Bede, we share our faith and heritage globally and empower people to transform the communi es in which we live and serve.
Our Place We inhabit a treasured sacred space set in the natural and human landscape of the World Heritage Site.
What We Do Six areas of life, experienced as strands in a rope which, as they interweave, touch and support each other, make Durham Cathedral what it is today. 1. Worship and Spirituality We worship God through daily prayer and praise, and celebrate the contribu ons of music and art to the spiritual life of the Cathedral.
2. Welcome and Care We welcome all who cross our threshold and express Chris an care in all aspects of our life as a community.
3. Learning, Nurture and Forma on We help people to encounter God and grow in faith and discipleship by offering opportuni es for dialogue, learning and research.
4. Outreach and Engagement We work in ac ve partnerships for the good of the Diocese and the communi es of North East England and to contribute to Durham’s flourishing and significance.
5. Buildings, Treasures and Environment We conserve, develop and interpret our buildings, environment and historic collec ons, while respec ng the Church as a place of prayer.
6. Finance and Stewardship
2 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
We steward our resources prudently, generously and ethically to sustain our ac vi es and provide extensive public benefit. Our Values In all things, we are inspired, mo vated and challenged by the Chris an faith and the values of the Gospel.
Spirituality We recognise and respond to God’s presence in our world and among us, prac cing a reflec ve approach to what we do.
Respect We recognise the image of God in all human beings, honour their dignity and treat them with courtesy.
Jus ce We deal fairly in our personal and collec ve behaviours, work to the highest ethical standards, and are honest in our speech and behaviour. We think, speak and act with integrity, are professional in our conduct, and are publicly accountable for our ac ons.
Collabora on We are a community founded on trust that prizes team working and builds partnerships that contribute to the common good.
Sustainability We are business-like in our corporate life and prudent in our stewardship of resources. We pursue the sustainability of our opera ons and environment.
Welcome We are welcoming and hospitable to all. We show Chris an love and care to our guests and those who need our help.
Aspira on We are an outward-facing Cathedral that reaches for the future with energy and courage, and reaches out to our communi es in the hope of personal and social transforma on.
Cons tu on
The Cathedral is governed by the Cons tu on and Statutes of the Cathedral Church of Christ, Blessed Mary the Virgin and St Cuthbert of Durham, which were most recently amended on 1 May 2015.
The Chapter The members during the year were:
The Very Revd. Andrew Tremle The Dean The Revd. Canon Dr David Kennedy Resigned 30 September 2018 The Revd. Canon Michael Hampel Installed 17 November 2018 The Revd. Canon Charlo e Allen Installed 22 September 2018 Canon Catherine Barnes The Revd. Canon Rosalind Brown Re red 31 August 2018 The Venerable Ian Jagger The Archdeacon of Durham, Re red 3 March 2019 The Revd. Canon Sophie Jelley The Revd. Canon Professor Simon Oliver Canon Ivor Stolliday Canon Treasurer, re red 9 April 2019
3 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Canon Andrew Thurston Canon Treasurer, installed 10 March 2019 Canon Simon Wood
Members of the Chapter are also the Governors of The Chorister School.
Senior Office Holders Canon Philip Davies Chapter Clerk, Re red 1 April 2018 Senior Office Holders (con nued)
Ms. Amanda Anderson Chapter Clerk & Chief Opera ng Officer, Appointed 19 March 2018 Mrs. Jayne Manns Director of Finance Mr. Ian Wicks Headmaster of the Chorister School Mr. Daniel Cook Organist and Master of the Choristers
The Cathedral Council The members during the year were:
Canon Paul Chandler Chairman
The Right Revd. Paul Butler The Bishop of Durham (non-vo ng) The Very Revd. Andrew Tremle The Dean (ex-officio) The Revd. Canon Dr David Kennedy (resigned 30 September 2018) Chapter Representa ve Canon Ivor Stolliday (resigned 9 April 2019) Chapter Representa ve The Revd. Canon Alec Harding College of Canons Representa ve The Revd. Canon Judith Hirst College of Canons Representa ve Dr Patrick Gray Durham University Representa ve Miss Faye Dufferwiel Cathedral Community Representa ve Mr. Richard Hilton Cathedral Community Representa ve Mr. Khaiko Makwela-Wali Cathedral Community Representa ve Dr Maria Cockerill Co-opted Members Mrs. Kate Fenwick Co-opted Members The Revd. Ruth Gee (resigned 12 July 2018) Co-opted Members Mr. Roger Kelly (deceased 12 April 2019) Co-opted Members Mrs. Jane Robinson (resigned 20 March 2019) Co-opted Members Mr. Simon S ll Co-opted Members
Mr. Philip Davies (re red 1 April 2018) Secretary Ms. Amanda Anderson (appointed 1 April 2018) Secretary
The College of Canons The members during the year were:
The Very Revd. Andrew Tremle The Dean The Revd. Canon Charlo e Allen Installed 22 September 2018 Canon Catherine Barnes The Revd. Canon Rosalind Brown Re red 31 August 2018 The Revd. Canon Michael Hampel Installed 17 November 2018 The Venerable Ian Jagger Archdeacon of Durham, Re red 3 March 2019 The Revd. Canon Sophie Jelley
4 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
The Revd. Canon Dr David Kennedy Resigned 30 September 2018 The Revd. Canon Professor Simon Oliver Canon Ivor Stolliday Resigned 9 April 2019 Canon Andrew Thurston Installed 10 March 2019 Canon Simon Wood The Revd. Canon Stuart Bain Installed as a Supernumerary Non-Residen ary Canon 29 April 2018 The Revd. Canon Sheila Bamber The Revd. Canon Dr Alan Bartle The Revd. Canon David Brooke Resigned July 2018 The Right Revd. Mark Bryant Bishop of Jarrow, re red 23 September 2018 The Revd. Canon Janet Burbury The Revd. Canon Graeme Bu ery
The College of Canons (con nued)
Canon Paul Chandler The Right Revd. Sarah Clark Bishop of Jarrow, Consecrated 27 February 2019 The Venerable Robert Cooper Archdeacon of Sunderland, Installed 3 July 2018 The Revd. Canon Caroline Dick The Revd. Canon Raymond Dick Re red 24 April 2019 The Revd. Canon Vince Fenton The Revd. Canon Adrian Gatrill The Revd. Canon David Glover The Revd. Canon Jane Grieve The Revd. Canon Alec Harding Canon Dr James Harrison The Revd. Canon Judith Hirst The Revd. Canon Marilyn Jamieson The Revd. Canon Colin Jay Installed 29 April 2018 Canon Susan Marshall Installed 10 March 2019 Canon Dr Margaret Masson The Revd. Canon Heather Murray Canon Andrew Rogers The Revd. Canon John Ruscoe The Revd. Canon Valerie Shedden The Baroness Sherlock OBE Resigned July 2018 The Revd. Canon Dr Norman Shave Installed 10 March 2019 The Venerable Richard Simpson Archdeacon of Auckland Canon Professor Michael Snape The Revd. Canon Dorothy Snowball The Revd. Canon David Tomlinson The Revd. Canon Paul Tyler Canon Margaret Vaughan The Revd. Canon Michael Whitehead Deceased 22 May 2018 The Revd. Canon Elizabeth Wilkinson Installed 23 June 2019 The Revd. Canon Keith Woodhouse The Revd. Canon Caroline Worsfold
Mr. Philip Davies Secretary, Re red 1 April 2018 Ms. Amanda Anderson Secretary, Appointed 1 April 2018
5 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Resources Commi ee The members during the year were:
Canon Ivor Stolliday Chairman, Resigned 9 April 2019 Canon Catherine Barnes Interim Chairman, Appointed 9 April 2019
The Very Revd. Andrew Tremle The Dean The Revd. Canon Charlo e Allen From 22 September 2018 Ms. Amanda Anderson Chapter Clerk & Chief Opera ng Officer, Appointed 1 April 2018 Mr. Philip Davies Chapter Clerk, Re red 1 April 2018 The Revd. Canon Michael Hampel From 17 November 2018 Mr. Ian Hunter Head of HR and OD Mrs. Jayne Manns Director of Finance Canon Andrew Thurston From 10 March 2019 Mr. Ian Wicks From 4 September 2018
Miss Faye Dufferwiel Secretary
Fabric Advisory Commi ee The members during the year were:
Mr. Humphrey Welfare Chairman Mr. Andrew Boyce Dr. Mary Brooks From 9 July 2018 Ms. Sarah Brown From 9 July 2018 Mr. David Carrington Mr. Hugh Dixon Resigned May 2019 Mr. Colin Haylock Dr Julian Luxford Mr. Mar n Roberts
Mrs. Katharine Smith Secretary, resigned 24 July 2019 Ms. Amanda Anderson Secretary, appointed 24 July 2019
Audit Commi ee The members during the year were:
Canon Paul Chandler Chairman Canon Catherine Barnes Dr Maria Cockerill The Venerable Ian Jagger Re red 3 March 2019 Mr. Simon S ll
Mr. Philip Davies Secretary, Re red 1 April 2018 Mrs. Katharine Smith Secretary, Appointed 1 April 2018
Investment Commi ee The members during the year were:
Mr. Simon S ll Chairman The Very Revd. Andrew Tremle The Dean
6 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Mr. Andrew Martell Re red 30 April 2018 The Hon James Ramsbotham Canon Ivor Stolliday Resigned 9 April 2019 Mr. Harry Swan Canon Andrew Thurston From 10 March 2019 Mr. Luke Busbridge Mr. John Newlands
Mr. Philip Davies Secretary, Re red 1 April 2018 Mrs. Jayne Manns Secretary, Appointed 1 April 2018
Title: The Cathedral Church of Christ Blessed Mary the Virgin and St Cuthbert of Durham.
Address The Cathedral Office Investment Cazenove Capital Management The College managers Limited Durham 12 Moorgate DH1 3EH London EC2R 6DA
Auditors UNW LLP Rathbone Investment Citygate Management Limited St James’ Boulevard 1 Curzon Street Newcastle upon Tyne London NE1 4JE W1J 5FB
Bankers Barclays Bank plc Solicitors Swinburne Maddison LLP Barclays House Venture House 5 St Ann’s Street Aykley Heads Business Centre Quayside Durham Newcastle upon Tyne DH1 5TS NE1 3DX
Insurers Ecclesias cal Insurance Cathedral Mr. Chris Co on RIBA AABC Office plc Architect Purcell Beaufort House 29 Marygate Brunswick Road York Gloucester YO30 7WH GL1 1JZ
7 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Index Page(s)
The Chapter’s annual report 9 – 16
- Financial review 16 – 19
- Statement of the Chapter’s responsibili es 19 - 20
Report of the Auditors 21 – 23
Consolidated statement of financial ac vi es 24-25
Consolidated balance sheet 26-27
Charity balance sheet 28-29
Consolidated statement of cashflows 30
Notes to the accounts 31-60
Defini ons
DCT Durham Cathedral Trading Limited
DCOT Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited
FY18 Financial year ended 31 March 2018 FY19 Financial year ended 31 March 2019
PYA Prior year actual
8 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
THE CHAPTER’S ANNUAL REPORT
The Chapter presents its report and the Cathedral’s audited financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2019.
Strategic Plan 2018-2020 Durham Cathedral’s Strategic Goals for the period 2018-2020 are as follows:
1. ENRICH: To draw more people into enriching and imagina ve encounters with the Cathedral and the Chris an faith.
• We will con nue to develop the Cathedral’s offer to visitors and promote it widely. • We will con nue to develop both tradi onal and innova ve forms of worship to engage with a broader worshipping cons tuency. • We will extend our parish, ecumenical and community engagement through welcome, worship, educa on and outreach, suppor ng the Bishop’s mission. • We will develop a pilgrimage that is diocesan, na onal and interna onal leading to Pilgrimage 2020.
2. CONSERVE: To care for, develop, and improve access to our buildings, collec ons and environment.
• We will con nue to improve the management, stewardship, accessibility and promo on of the Cathedral’s collec ons. • We will develop capacity, either in-house or through partnerships, to manage and conserve our buildings, collec ons and environment. • We will implement 15-year repair and maintenance plans for the Cathedral and Precinct (including Riverbanks) and develop appropriate opportuni es to improve public access.
3. PROMOTE: Through our work, and in partnership with others, to promote excellence in the North East and be a force for good in our region.
• We will con nue to enhance the Cathedral’s economic contribu on regionally and na onally through taking ini a ves to increase visitor numbers and dwell- me in North East England. • We will ac vely promote and facilitate dialogue and public debate across the region, enhancing the role of the Cathedral as the seat of the Bishop’s teaching ministry. • We will aim to achieve na onally recognised standards of excellence across the Cathedral and celebrate these achievements. • We will build on the excellent standards of The Chorister School by growing pupil numbers, careful resource management and the development of the Chorister Endowment Fund.
4. TRANSFORM: To put the development of people at the heart of everything we do so as to transform our communi es.
• Through organiza onal development and workforce planning we will be er harness the skills and talents of the Cathedral’s staff and volunteers, in support of the Cathedral’s vision and mission. • We will support lifelong learning and encourage inter-genera onal engagement within our community. • We will improve our internal communica ons and the flow of informa on across the Cathedral.
5. SUSTAIN: To achieve greater financial sustainability
9 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
• We will produce and implement 3-year business plans for Durham Cathedral, Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited and Durham Cathedral Trading Limited. • We will con nue to grow voluntary, cketed and commercial income, including fundraising for Founda on 2020. • We will monitor financial performance and control costs by establishing a rigorous and mely financial repor ng regime. • We will improve cash management so as to achieve a steady state cash flow and remove the need for loan finance.
Role and Organisa on Durham Cathedral, or to give it its full tle, ‘The Cathedral Church of Christ, Blessed Mary the Virgin and St Cuthbert of Durham’, is a Chris an Church of the Anglican Communion, the shrine of St Cuthbert, the seat of the Bishop of Durham and a focus of pilgrimage and spirituality in North East England. The Cathedral’s governing Cons tu on and Statutes were most recently amended on 1 May 2015, in accordance with the Cathedrals Measure 1999.
Three bodies together form the body corporate of the Cathedral – the Chapter, the Cathedral Council and the College of Canons.
The Chapter is the governing body of the Cathedral, providing strategic direc on and oversight. Sec on 4 (8) of the Cathedrals Measure states that the main func on of the Chapter is “to direct and oversee the administra on of the affairs of the cathedral”. The Chapter is formed of both clergy and lay people. The Dean and all Residen ary Canons are members. In addi on, up to four lay persons, who are communicants, may be appointed by the Bishop in consulta on with the Dean and other members of the Chapter. The Chapter is chaired by the Dean.
All new Chapter members must undertake an Associa on of English Cathedrals programme of induc on, which covers Cathedral legisla on, governance, Cathedral finances and property management.
The Cathedral Council meets three mes a year to further and support the work of the Cathedral and advise the Chapter. Its membership (see page 4 of this document) is again specified in the Cons tu on and Statutes. The Council is chaired by Canon Paul Chandler, who is appointed by the Bishop. The Bishop can a end and speak at the Council although he is not a member.
The College of Canons consists of the Dean and Residen ary Canons, suffragan bishops, archdeacons and honorary and lay canons. The College meets at least once a year to consider cathedral affairs. It also has the task of elec ng a new bishop in accordance with the Appointment of Bishops Act 1533.
10 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Governance In addi on to the Chapter, the governance commi ees of Durham Cathedral are shown in purple in the below diagram:
The membership of these commi ees is listed on pages 3 to 6 of this document. An internal governance review is currently underway to examine the sufficiency, efficiency and effec veness of Durham Cathedral’s governance structure.
Public benefit Although it is not a repor ng requirement of the Church Commissioners, nevertheless Chapter confirm that they have complied with sec on 4 of the Chari es Act 2006 to have regard to the public benefit guidance published by the Charity Commission in determining the ac vi es of the Cathedral. The Cathedral not only serves the community daily in its religious and charitable work, but is an ac ve resource of na onal importance in the promo on of religion, music, educa on, history and architecture.
The Chapter Clerk’s Office The past year has con nued to be a me of change and transi on in the Chapter Clerk’s Office. Amanda Anderson has completed her first year in post as the Chapter Clerk and Chief Opera ng Officer. Katharine Smith, the Chapter Steward and Governance Manager le Durham Cathedral in July 2019. The office’s agenda has been dominated by the annual budget process, changes to data protec on regula on, an internal governance review, the produc on of departmental risk registers and an ins tu onal risk register, and the introduc on of a business planning process. The office also con nues to provide comprehensive secretariat support to the Cathedral’s main commi ees, and plays a key role in ensuring the effec ve day-to- day running of the Cathedral Office.
11 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Liturgy and Worship In the past twelve months, we have staged over 1,200 statutory services and approximately 75 special services, engaging widely with external bodies and agencies, not least the Diocese of Durham, University of Durham, Lieutenancy Office, and many schools, chari es and other organisa ons, to enrich the life of the region and to help give expression in worship to people’s need to celebrate or commemorate who they are and what their rela onship is with God and neighbor.
Highlights which sought to promote excellence and exemplify the Cathedral as a force for good have been the Remembrance weekend of November 2018 during commemora ons for the 100th anniversary of the First World War when well over 10,000 people spent me with us during this poignant weekend, a special service marking Commonwealth Day in which large numbers of children took part under the aegis of the Lord Lieutenant, and a different focus to the annual ligh ng of the Christmas tree and Blessing of the Crib when a refugee child from Sudan lit the tree through the involvement of City of Sanctuary. Advent and Christmas were celebrated, Cuthbert and Bede were honored, and Holy Week and Easter marked reflec vely and joyously-and alongside thousands of worshippers, pilgrims and visitors.
We have experimented with the passage of the liturgy at the principal Sunday celebra on of the Eucharist in an a empt to improve the flow of the liturgy, engage more effec vely with worshippers (par cularly visitors), and encourage a greater sense of the people of God “gathering” round the alter of God.
Music The past year has been very busy for the music department. We have con nued to develop strategies to aid recruitment, and a significant influx of boys in September 2018 is already star ng to bear fruit. Chorister Experience events are now a rac ng around 30 children each me, and averaging around 90 children per academic year. In September 2018 we welcomed five new Choral Scholars, and a new Junior Organ Scholar, all of whom have made a posi ve impact on our ac vi es, both within the Cathedral and externally. A par cular highlight of the Autumn term saw Choral Evensong broadcast live on BBC Radio 3, and this was extremely well received. Performance of Handel’s Messiah and The St John Passion by J.S. Bach in collabora on with the Avision Ensemble have served to embellish our liturgical life, as well as developing the breadth and range of the choir’s abili es, especially as soloists. Much a en on has been given to the organ recently, and plans are progressing with a view to a major restora on project over the coming years. As a result of two generous dona ons, we have been able to purchase a new Boston Grand Piano, which has drama cally improved our facili es. The end of the choir term in July saw us bid farewell to Francesca Massey, who has been appointed to Rochester Cathedral as Director of Music, and Phil Durrant, who has accepted a full scholarship to study music in London. Both of these opportuni es are very well deserved.
Volunteering Our remarkable volunteer community con nues to grow and diversify with increasing demand for volunteers across the organisa on with new roles being developed alongside the established roles. Mirroring an overall dip in the number of volunteers being recruited regionally and some s ff compe ons from other large organisa ons and events, we have seen a need arise for more Welcome Stewards and Open Treasure volunteers in par cular. However, even without specialist recruitment, we s ll receive an average of seven applica ons a month, so maintain a steady inflow.
We es mate that the annual contribu on in me is easily 150,000 volunteer hours per annum (roughly the full- me equivalent of 83 addi onal people per week). In addi on to adding value and supplemen ng exis ng work, direct income is around £90,000 per annum from tours, talks and tower trips.
An area of significant need iden fied for 2019 was the increasing impact of mental health. Over the past year we have therefore concentrated a lot of volunteer training and support around this area. To that end, we have offered sessions in Mental Health Awareness, Stress and Resilience, Au sm Awareness, Demen a Friends, Effec ve Listening, Mental Health First Aid and are in discussions about Suicide Awareness sessions.
12 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Visitor Services The Visitor Services Desk Team has expanded to six members to help assist with the delivery of the Encouraged Dona ons scheme which was trialed August to September 2018. Dona ons have seen an increase of over 400% which is making a major contribu on to reducing the cathedral deficit. The team have done an amazing job in conjunc on with the volunteer teams in delivering welcome, promo ng what the Cathedral has to offer, Open Treasure, guided tours and North West Tower Tours on top of the incredible growth in dona ons.
Cathedral Shop The Cathedral Shop has con nued to put in a credible performance in spite of the retail difficul es on the high street. Each year we refresh and refine the product offer. We seek to create a unique and interes ng offer which best reflects the many aspects of the Cathedral, from architecture to stained glass windows, history to spirituality. This year we have added the Rose Window range to the bespoke offer, featured the Dean’s cat Badger in the Julia Gash Durham themed product range and also created his own range of ceramic thimbles, candlesnuffers and paperweights.
Undercro Restaurant Without doubt the outstanding success of 2018 was hos ng the NEECC Annual Dinner in the Cathedral. Not only was it an exemplary piece of cross departmental working, the logis cs were not minor, but also a fantas c fundraising success for Founda on 2020. 630 senior business leaders a ended the dinner with food provided by the Baxter Storey team in the majes c se ng of the Cathedral. The standard of cuisine was excellent as was the prepara on and delivery and service.
The Undercro Restaurant also showed its versa lity in the mouthwatering array of puddings presented in the Pudding Club (now “Divine Desserts at Durham Cathedral”) with a total of 64 members of the public a ending. The day to day restaurant opera on con nues to make a significant contribu on to Cathedral turnover. The food offer is constantly reviewed with a focus on sourcing ingredients locally where possible.
Development Founda on 2020 has con nued to be the main focus of our fundraising ac vity in the last twelve months. The campaign to build an endowment of £10 million to support the annual programme of repair and conserva on of the Cathedral and precinct has received fantas c support from individuals and organisa ons alike.
We have con nued to welcome new supporters as Founda on 2020 Patrons and 2020 Club members, and to give these donors special access to the Cathedral’s works programme so that they can see for themselves the difference their generosity is making. In March 2019, the campaign benefi ed from two generous pledges totaling £300,000. Thanks to match funding from the Na onal Lo ery Heritage Fund (NLHF, formerly Heritage Lo ery fund), these gi s have been doubled to £600,000.
Founda on 2020 has also been the focus of a number of special fundraising events including further Giving Days to coincide with the founda on of the Cathedral and Cuthbertside, and a fes ve prize draw at the Christmas Market. The NEECC Dinner in the Nave (see above) raised a total of £31,000, thanks to the support of the event sponsors, including Gateshead College and Newcastle Interna onal Airport, and match funding through Barclays corporate volunteers: that total was then matched by NLHF to bring in £62,000.
Our Adopt a Book programme has now been running for three years and in that me has raised over £25,000 for the conserva on of the Cathedral’s historic library collec on restoring over 100 books back to their former glory. As ever, we would like to thank the Friends of Durham Cathedral for their generous support and to all those who help us to care for and enrich this wonderful place.
13 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Property During the year the department has: - Completed the Belfry repair works in prepara on for reopening to the public in June 2019; - Completed enabling work for Lobbies, obtained permissions and discharged all condi ons, with the works now on site; - Completed refurbishment work to College proper es (Nos. 6A, 7. 16 and 16A The College); - Reviewed Fire Risk Assessments (FRA’s) for the en re Cathedral site and renewed fire warden training, and now ge ng on with ac ons arising from assessments; - Completed improvements in Health and Safety awareness, repor ng procedures and departmental documenta on, which makes it easier for us to contribute to the ongoing safety of everyone on our site; - Completed the work force changes recommended by QIR 2013: i) Ongoing upskilling (promo ng a mason into SPAB Fellowship training, recrui ng a second Cathedral Workshop Fellowship (CWF) trained mason); ii) Improving management in the Works Yard; iii) Restructuring the Works Yard to increase maintenance. - Progressed and completed a first land sale for “Link 66” at Great Burdon, realizing a significant sum for the con nued upkeep of Durham Cathedral; - Overseen a Strategic Review of the Property Investment Por olio by Savills, which allows us to improve weak areas and work towards be er future performance; - Facilitated talks, tours, Works Yard Open Day and Dinner in the Nave stone auc on to assist the promo on of Founda on 2020.
Finance 2018/19 has seen a significant turnover of staff in the Finance team, with the remaining original long-serving members leaving by early January 2019. A full restructure of the team was undertaken in order to build a new Finance team and this process is now well underway. Despite this, the team have worked closely with colleagues from other Departments and has contributed where possible to a number of projects during the year, all of which are aimed at reducing the deficit in the Cathedrals finances, improving the flow of management informa on and assis ng others to meet the Cathedrals mission.
Human Resource and Organisa onal Development During the year, the department has: - Assisted the Friends in the recruitment and appointment of a Friends Office Manager; implemented the External Secondment agreement and arrangement; and lead of the sickness absence management of the substan ve post holder; - Assisted with recruitment and appointments to key roles-Canon Chancellor, Canon Precentor & Vice Dean, Member of Chapter (Finance) & Lay Canon, Canon Pastor, Head of Collec ons, Security Manager and HR Manager; - Carried out staff restructuring in Finance, property, Educa on, Marke ng & Events, and Visitor Services departments; - Achieved the Be er Health at Work Con nuing Excellence recogni on in November 2018 (the award ceremony was held in March 2019). The Service Agreement with “Competent Person” (NCSG Limited) was put in place and we have established and embedded the H & S Commi ee and sub-Commi ees. - Addressed iden fied priority training needs that include Safeguarding, Staff Reps (ACAS), H & S Staff Reps (NCSG), and First Aid; - Assisted in implemen ng Terms of Reference for the Resources Commi ee (including Delegated Decisions), GDPR, (including Employee and Recruitment Privacy No ces), personnel file and data management, Safeguarding, (including Terms of Reference, Service Contract for CSO, Ac on Plan and DBS), and a review of Chorister School employment contractual arrangements (as commissioned by the Resources Commi ee).
14 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Library and Collec ons Open Treasure is now fully opera onal. In the summer of 2019 we achieved the milestone of 100,000 visitors to Open Treasure. Our varied programme of temporary exhibi ons included two highligh ng the stores and possessions of Durham people: Miners: Pitmen, Pride and Prayer and Armis ce. Feas ng and Fas ng illuminated the fascina ng history of the Cathedral’s Great Kitchen-with recipes!
We con nue to host library events: the most significant this year was the visit of the Associa on Interna onale de Bibliophile: an interna onal group of 120 book collectors, librarians and scholars. We have shared the Refectory Library and its treasures with tour groups, reading groups and special interest groups including the Art Fund and the Morley Medieval Society. Three of our popular public “show and tell” events were held, displaying books on the themes of “Inventors and Innovators”, “Art” and “Languages” conferences and “show and tells”.
We are con nuing to work closely with our colleagues at Durham University. Library volunteers have transcribed 43 volumes of Hensley Henson’s diaries for the project Church, State and Na on: The Journals of Herbert Hensley Henson, 1900-1939. The Durham Priory Library project has made significant progress in digitally reuni ng the surviving manuscripts of the Durham monas c community online (175 volumes to date). The Residen al Research Library is bringing new scholars to the Barker Reading Room: the programme offers fellowships to researchers wishing to study the excep onal collec ons held by Durham University and the Cathedral.
The poten al of our archives was demonstrated by the recent discovery of a lost volume by diarist Alice Thornton. We look forward to working with Dr Cordelia Bea e to share the insights this volume will provide into 17th Century faith and family life.
Educa on 2018 saw the Educa on team engage with 16,558 par cipants in various areas including delivery in the Cathedral, Woodlands and Riverbanks, Outreach and in Open Treasure. The team were nominated for a Best of Wearside award for their new preschool Forest School sessions for parents and carers of under 5’s. We started to work with other organisa ons na onally as a centre of excellence in heritage educa on including becoming a Sandford Award Cascade Partner. We completed bespoke sessions with various County Durham Area Ac on Partnerships including “Mining in the Trimdons” with par cipants from Deaf Hill Primary School, St. Williams RC Primary School, Bluebell Meadows Primary School and Trimdon Community College. The schools researched their local mining history and its links to the Cathedral. They gathered visual informa on and even tried their hand at tradi onal pas mes popular in the mining communi es of County Durham. The ar s c outcome was then displayed in the Community Gallery within Open Treasure, which included rag rug inspired wall hangings. A er their exhibi on here they have returned to each school to be displayed for their whole school communi es to enjoy. Delivery was updated and new sessions were introduced throughout the academic year. This included, amongst other sessions, a new GCSE Religious Educa on session, a new Key Stage 2 tour about Bede and his life and new onsite tours and outreach sessions on the Vikings and the Anglo Saxons.
The Chorister School The Chorister School has enjoyed many highlights during this year. We said a fond farewell to Canon David Kennedy a er 17 years in his role as Custos and have welcomed the return to Durham of Canon Michael Hampel as Vice Dean and Custos. We have been able to refurbish the IT room facili es with a bequest from the late Dr Brian Crosby, the room being renamed in his honour. The school now has a termly Eucharist in the Cathedral; we held our first at Cuthbert- de and another on the Eve of Bede. Eight children from Year 7 were confirmed at the dawn Eucharist on Easter Day.
Recruitment of choristers has con nued strongly with a large con ngent of boys joining the choir in September 2018 as a mixture of day and boarding proba oner choristers. It has been very gra fying to see the difference that the introduc on of
15 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
day choristers has brought to the choir although many s ll choose to board. The next step is the provision of more bursaries to enable the net to be cast yet wider in the North East to make it possible for any musical child to join the choir.
The school has two new Directors of Music. Mr. Simon Lee is Director of Choral and Academic Music and Mrs. Clare Crinson, Director of Pre-Prep and Instrumental Music. Their complimentary skills have already made quite an impact on an already impressive department. Sport features strongly in the school curriculum and two new Directors of Girls and Boys games have brought energy and innova on. We have an impressive programme of matches against a wide range of schools and it is very good to see that we “punch above our weight”. Our girls are now playing cricket and have also begun to play rugby.
Financial review These accounts have been prepared in accordance with the 2015 Accoun ng and Repor ng Regula ons for English Anglican Cathedrals (“the Regula ons”) specified by the Church Commissioners under sec on 27 of the Cathedrals Measure 1999. The accounts comply with the Regula ons other than in the treatment of two items capitalised as Inventory acquired par ally with the aid of grants from public bodies. The accoun ng treatment for these items is disclosed in Note 1 under “Inventory” and the costs are disclosed in Note 7b.
The accounts have been prepared in thousands of pounds and this may result in rounding differences of £1k.
Income Income from dona ons and legacies totalled £7.19m compared to £1.83m in FY18.This substan al increase was due to the recogni on in the year of a large legacy due to be received a er the balance sheet date. Income from dona ons increased by 32%, a er the introduc on of a voluntary dona on scheme in August 2018, where visitors to the Cathedral are encouraged to donate £3.
Grants in support of mission fell slightly from £1.16m in FY18 to £1.03m in FY19. Included within this income is £293k for the comple on of capital works on the Central Tower which re-opened to the public in June 2019, and a further £313k of revenue grants for the replacement of wooden lobbies in the Cathedral with glass ones, which is a capital project that will con nue into FY20.
Income from the Cathedral’s trading subsidiary, Durham Cathedral Trading Limited (DCT), is shown under the heading “Trading and chargeable events” and totalled £587k, down 4% compared with the prior year, the majority of this fall being due to the fall in visitor numbers to the Cathedral and the difficult retail condi ons generally. The gi shop (which is operated by DCT), con nues to trade well in a compe ve market and net profits are transferred to the Cathedral under the corporate gi aid rules.
Income from the property por olio and stock market investments remained comparable to FY18. Commentary on returns from the investment and property por olios are given on pages 13 and 14.
Total income is £12.87m, 59% higher than the prior year, helping to ease the strain slightly on the Cathedral’s cashflow. Of this increase in overall income, unrestricted income showed a 1.6% decrease, whilst restricted income showed a 279% increase, being due to the inclusion of the non-recurring Surtees legacy.
Expenditure Expenditure on raising funds increased by 6% to £4.08m and accounts for 47.5% of total expenditure. Within this category, shop, restaurant and other trading costs total £1.24m (£481k (28%) higher than FY18).
Educa on and outreach costs decreased slightly by 9% to £1.19m.
Cathedral and precincts upkeep costs showed a decrease of £1.36m, accoun ng for 27% of total expenditure compared to 36% in FY18. Major repairs and restora on also included further costs on the Central Tower project which was completed a er the year-end and opened to the general public in June 2019. The cost of fabric repairs remains one of the key financial challenges faced by the Cathedral and fundraising is con nuous; both now and in the medium to long term.
16 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Total expenditure is £8.58m and is 13.7% lower than the prior year, most of this being accounted for by the “one-off” write down of the Open Treasure stonework in FY18 which had previously been capitalised.
Net gains on investments are £5.8m (FY18: £3.12m), reflec ng the unrealised gain on revalua on of land and property held as investments.
Cashflow The Cathedral con nues to face significant cashflow pressures. The consolidated cashflow statement shows a net cash ou low of £1.37m, compared to a net cash inflow of £47k for FY18.
The Cathedral does not have a steady state cashflow due to the material variance in many of its income and cost lines each year. Cash management is therefore cri cal and is ac vely managed to ensure that resources are op mised and funding charges are minimised.
Financial strategy The net FY19 deficit for unrestricted funds is £950k (FY18: £1.33m). FY19 was another challenging financial year, with property repairs and maintenance spend, a fall in visitor numbers, and a reduc on in some non-recurring income streams combining to generate a significant deficit and increase pressure on the cashflow of the Cathedral.
This level of unrestricted deficit is clearly unsustainable and steps con nue to be taken by Chapter to immediately reduce and, within the medium term, eliminate the deficit.
A strategic plan has been produced as outlined in earlier paragraphs and sets out key ac ons for the next three years. It includes growing the Cathedral’s endowment through property transac ons and matched fundraising on both na onal and interna onal levels.
It is through a combina on of fundraising, realised proceeds from property deals (invested in a new expendable endowment), growing pupil numbers at the Chorister School and increasing voluntary dona ons to the Cathedral that the Chapter an cipates that the unrestricted fund will generate an annual surplus within five to 10 years.
More immediate measures include iden fying new income streams, stringent budget management and overhead savings wherever possible.
Principal funding The Cathedral aims to be self-funded for day to day opera ons, but relies heavily on grants, legacies and other external funding for project spend – for both property and other non-recurring costs.
Adequate facili es to meet the strategic plan are in place, with an overdra facility arranged to cover cashflow requirements in light of the nega ve unrestricted reserves.
Reserves policy Reserves are needed both to maintain the level of the Cathedral’s current ac vi es and to enable the comple on of long-term projects.
The Cathedral has had to u lise through necessity all of its unrestricted reserves over the last decade, despite improving efficiencies, as it has been running with an annual deficit. As noted above, there are plans to eliminate the deficit, with an aspira on to build unrestricted reserves to cover at least six months of normal opera ng costs.
Where specific future funding needs are iden fied, Chapter has the discre on to set aside free funds for designated purposes, those funds being declared as Designated Funds. Details of Designated Funds are given in Note 16 to the Accounts.
Investments The investment objec ve is to ensure the crea on of sufficient income and capital growth to enable Durham Cathedral to carry out its purposes consistently each year with due and proper considera on to the future needs and maintenance and, if possible, the enhancement of the invested funds. The investments held by Durham Cathedral were managed during FY19 by two investment managers: Cazenove Capital Management (now part of Schroder & Co Limited) and Rathbone Investment
17 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Management Limited. A medium to low risk profile is taken on investments and performance is measured against composite benchmark indices for each fund manager.
UK equi es con nue to be the main investment class, accoun ng for 45.41% of the total por olio (FY 18 – 48.45%). Investment levels are within ranges specified by the Cathedral’s Investment Commi ee.
Gross investment income for FY19 was £646k (FY18: £571k), represen ng a yield of 3.57% (FY18: 3.47%) based on the average investment por olio market value over the year. The total return earned is consistent with the benchmark return set for both fund managers.
Investment property Durham Cathedral owns property to house clergy, staff, the Chorister School, and Cathedral offices. Other property is held for investment purposes and is rented out on a commercial basis. The property por olio includes commercial buildings, farms, houses and sundry property including garages and allotments.
The return on the property por olio is as follows:
FY19 FY18 £'000 £'000
Gross rental income 841 919 less non-recurring income (34) (67)
Adjusted income 807 852
Repairs & maintenance costs (146) (93)
Net income 661 759
Weighted average capital value of investment proper es - Note 1 23,561 23,968 Return on capital value 2.89% 3.40%
Note 1 - a weighted average has been used for the capital value, taking account of property sales during each year
Professional fees rela ng to managing the property por olio have been excluded for both years in order to ensure comparability as FY19 was the first full year they were incurred in rela on to the day-to-day management of the property por olio.
The return of 2.89% in FY19 is below the target of 3.5% required from fund managers for managed funds. The return dropped due to the con nued high level of repairs and maintenance spend, which for some proper es was required to compensate for under investment in prior years.
18 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Plans for future periods Future financial strategic work includes the introduc on of a regular business planning cycle and a complete commercial review. Other strategic work includes a full governance review.
The main “live” capital projects include comple ng the central tower project, the cloister roof and replacing the lobbies within the main body of the Cathedral.
Investment powers Under the Cathedrals Measure 1999, the Chapter may invest the Cathedral’s funds in the following categories:
• Land;
• The improvement or development of property belonging to the Cathedral, except that endowment funds may not be used to improve or develop the Cathedral itself or its ancillary buildings;
• Funds administered by the Central Board of Finance of the Church of England by CCLA Investment Management Limited; and
• Investments in which trustees may invest under the general power of investment under the Trustee Act 2000.
Statement of the Chapter’s responsibili es The Chapter is responsible under requirements laid down by the Church Commissioners under the powers given to it by Sec on 27 of the Cathedrals Measures 1999 for:
a. Keeping proper accoun ng records from which the financial posi on of the Cathedral can be ascertained with reasonable accuracy at any me;
b. Preparing and publishing an annual report and audited accounts which give a true and fair view of the financial ac vi es for each financial year of the assets, liabili es and funds at the end of each financial year of the Cathedral and its subsidiaries;
c. Sta ng that they have complied in all material respects with the regula ons on the subject prepared by The Cathedrals Administra on and Finance Associa on or describing which regula ons have not been complied with and giving reasons for non-compliance;
d. Selec ng suitable accoun ng policies and then applying them consistently;
e. Making judgements and es mates that are reasonable and prudent;
f. preparing the financial statements on the going concern basis unless it is inappropriate to presume that the charity will con nue to operate;
g. Safeguarding the assets of the Cathedral and hence taking reasonable steps for the preven on and detec on of fraud and other irregulari es; and
h. The maintenance and integrity of the corporate and financial informa on included on Durham Cathedral’s website. Legisla on in the United Kingdom governing the prepara on and dissemina on of financial statements may differ from legisla on in other jurisdic ons.
The major risks to which Durham Cathedral is exposed are assessed on an annual basis based mainly on a specific risk register which covers most aspects of the organisa on. The Chapter considers that systems are in place, which mi gate those risks. Monitoring of risk is undertaken throughout the course of the year by the Chapter, the senior management team and the Audit Commi ee.
19 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
In so far as the Chapter is aware:
• there is no relevant audit informa on of which the auditor of Durham Cathedral and its subsidiaries is unaware; and
• the Chapter members have taken all steps that they ought to have taken to make themselves aware of any relevant audit informa on and to establish that the auditor is aware of that informa on.
Auditors UNW LLP will be proposed for re-appointment as auditors for the coming financial year.
On behalf of the Chapter
………………………………………………………….. Treasurer
………………………………………………………….. Dean
Date: 17 September 2019
20 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Independent Auditors’ report to the Chapter of Durham Cathedral Opinion
We have audited the financial statements of Durham Cathedral (the “parent charity”) and its subsidiaries (the “group”) for the year ended 31 March 2019 which comprise the consolidated statement of financial ac vi es, the consolidated balance sheet, the charity balance sheet, the consolidated statement of cash flows and the related notes, including a summary of significant accoun ng policies. The financial repor ng framework that has been applied in their prepara on is applicable law and United Kingdom Accoun ng Standards, including FRS 102 'The Financial Repor ng Standard applicable in the UK and Republic of Ireland' (United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accoun ng Prac ce).
In our opinion the financial statements:
• give a true and fair view of the state of the group’s and the charity's affairs as at 31 March 2019 and of the group’s incoming resources and applica on of resources, including its income and expenditure for the year then ended;
• have been properly prepared in accordance with United Kingdom Generally Accepted Accoun ng Prac ce; and
• have been prepared in accordance with the requirements specified by the Church Commissioners under the power given to them by the Cathedrals Measure 1999.
Basis of opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with Interna onal Standards on Audi ng (UK) (ISAs (UK)) and applicable law. Our responsibili es under those standards are further described in the ‘Auditor's responsibili es for the audit of the financial statements’ sec on of our report. We are independent of the group in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit of the financial statements in the United Kingdom, including the Financial Repor ng Council's Ethical Standard, and we have fulfilled our other ethical responsibili es in accordance with these requirements. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Conclusions rela ng to going concern
We have nothing to report in respect of the following ma ers in rela on to which the ISAs (UK) require us to report to you where:
• the Chapter's use of the going concern basis of accoun ng in the prepara on of the financial statements is not appropriate; or
• Chapter have not disclosed in the financial statements any iden fied material uncertain es that may cast significant doubt about the group or the charity’s ability to con nue to adopt the going concern basis of accoun ng for a period of at least twelve months from the date when the financial statements are authorised for issue.
Respec ve responsibili es of the Chapter and auditor
The Chapter are responsible for the other informa on. The other informa on comprises the informa on included in the annual report, other than the financial statements and our auditor's report thereon. Our opinion on the financial statements does not cover the other informa on and, except to the extent otherwise explicitly stated in our report, we do not express any form of assurance conclusion thereon.
In connec on with our audit of the financial statements, our responsibility is to read the other informa on and, in doing so, consider whether the other informa on is materially inconsistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the audit or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If we iden fy such material inconsistencies or apparent material misstatements, we are required to determine whether there is a material misstatement in the financial statements or a
21 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
material misstatement of the other informa on. If, based on the work we have performed, we conclude that there is a material misstatement of this other informa on, we are required to report that fact.
We have nothing to report in this regard.
Opinion on other ma ers prescribed by the Cathedrals Measure 1999
In our opinion, based on the work undertaken in the course of the audit:
• the informa on given in the Chapter's annual report, which includes the group strategic report for the financial year, for which the financial statements are prepared is consistent with the financial statements; and
• the Chapter’s report, which includes the group strategic report, has been prepared in accordance with applicable legal requirements.
Ma ers on which we are required to report by excep on
In the light of our knowledge and understanding of the group and the charity and its environment obtained in the course of the audit, we have not iden fied material misstatements in the Chapter’s report.
We have nothing to report in respect of the following ma ers in rela on to which Companies Act 2006 requires us to report to you if, in our opinion:
• the parent charitable company has not kept adequate and sufficient accoun ng records, or returns adequate for our audit have not been received from branches not visited by us; or
• the financial statements are not in agreement with the accoun ng records and returns; or
• certain disclosures of Chapter’s remunera on specified by law not made; or
• we have not received all the informa on and explana ons we require for our audit.
Responsibili es of the Chapter
As explained more fully in the statement of the Chapter’s' responsibili es on page 14, the Chapter is responsible for the prepara on of the financial statements and for being sa sfied that they give a true and fair view, and for such internal control as the Chapter determines is necessary to enable the prepara on of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, the Chapter is responsible for assessing the charity's ability to con nue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, ma ers related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accoun ng unless the Chapter either intend to liquidate the charity or to cease opera ons, or have no realis c alterna ve but to do so.
Auditor's responsibili es for the audit of the financial statements
Our objec ves are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditor's report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs (UK) will always detect a material misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial statements.
A further descrip on of our responsibili es for the audit of the financial statements is located on the Financial Repor ng Council's website at: www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibili es. The descrip on forms part of our auditor's report.
22 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Who are we repor ng to
This report is made solely to the Chapter, as a body, in accordance with Sec ons 27 of the Cathedrals Measure 1999. Our audit work has been undertaken so that we might state to the Chapter those ma ers we are required to state to them in an Auditor's report and for no other purpose. To the fullest extent permi ed by law, we do not accept or assume responsibility to anyone other than the Chapter, as a body, for our audit work, for this report, or for the opinions we have formed.
Anne Hallowell BSc FCA DChA (Senior Statutory Auditor) for and on behalf of UNW LLP, Statutory Auditor Chartered Accountants Newcastle upon Tyne 17 September 2019
23 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Consolidated Statement of Financial Ac vi es for the year ended 31 March 2019
Note Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total Total 2018 funds funds funds 2019
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Income and endowments from: 4
Dona ons and legacies 1,126 5,872 193 7,191 1,831
Grants in support of mission 247 682 101 1,030 1,158
Charges and fees in the course of 2,038 31 - 2,069 2,357 mission
Trading and chargeable events 1,047 - - 1,047 1,211
Investments 1,467 24 - 1,491 1,492
Other income 44 - - 44 27
Total income 5,969 6,609 294 12,872 8,076
Expenditure on: 5
Raising funds (3,441) (635) - (4,076) (3,839)
Ministry (956) (9) - (965) (1,091)
Educa on and outreach (1,149) (39) - (1,188) (1,305)
Cathedral and precincts upkeep (1,722) (628) - (2,350) (3,708)
Total expenditure (7,268) (1,311) - (8,579) (9,943)
Net (outgoing)/incoming resources before investment gains/(losses) (1,299) 5,298 294 4,293 (1,867)
Net gains on investments - (63) 5,868 5,805 3,121
Net (expenditure)/income (1,299) 5,235 6,162 10,098 1,254
Transfer between funds 349 (349) - - -
Net movement in funds (950) 4,886 6,162 10,098 1,254
Funds brought forward 16 (2,782) 17,260 51,331 65,809 64,555
Funds carried forward 16 (3,732) 22,146 57,493 75,907 65,809
24 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
The consolidated SOFA for the year ended 31 March 2018 (by fund type) is included as Note 18.
The notes on pages 27 to 48 and the Special Trust accounts on page 49 form part of these Financial Statements.
25 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Consolidated Balance Sheet as at 31 March 2019
Note Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total Total funds funds funds funds funds 2019 2018
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Fixed assets
Investment assets Property 6a - 7,226 19,732 26,958 25,652
Listed Investments 6b - - 20,381 20,381 15,803
- 7,226 40,113 47,339 41,455
Non-investment assets Property 7a - 6,888 14,429 21,317 21,928
Inventory 7b 116 - - 116 116
Tangible fixed assets 7c 1,550 70 - 1,620 1,644
1,666 6,958 14,429 23,053 23,688
Total fixed assets 1,666 14,184 54,542 70,392 65,143
Current assets Stocks 9 100 - - 100 115
Debtors 10 577 5,709 - 6,286 471
Short term deposits 373 117 262 752 645
Cash at bank and in hand (5,195) 2,537 2,889 231 1,602
(4,145) 8,363 3,151 7,369 2,833
Liabili es due within one year Creditors 11 (1,041) (1) (200) (1,242) (1,342)
Net current (liabili es)/assets (5,186) 8,362 2,951 6,127 1,491
Total assets less current liabili es (3,520) 22,546 57,493 76,519 66,634
Liabili es due a er more than one year
Creditors 12 (212) (400) - (612) (825)
26 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Net assets (3,732) 22,146 57,493 75,907 65,809
Funds Unrestricted (3,732) - - (3,732) (2,782)
Restricted - 22,146 - 16,438 17,260
Endowment - - 57,493 63,201 51,331
Total funds 16.1 (3,732) 22,146 57,493 75,907 65,809
The financial statements were approved by the Chapter on 17 September 2019 and signed on their behalf by:
…………………………………………………………. …………………………………………………………….
Dean Treasurer
The notes on pages 27 to 48 and the Special Trust accounts on page 49 form part of these Financial Statements.
27 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Durham Cathedral Balance Sheet as at 31 March 2019
Note Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total Total funds funds funds funds funds 2019 2018
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Fixed assets
Investment assets Property 6a - 7,226 19,732 26,958 25,652
Listed Investments 6b - - 20,381 20,381 15,803
Investment in subsidiary 6c - 3,000 - 3,000 3,000
- 10,226 40,113 50,339 44,455
Non-investment assets Property 7a - - 14,429 14,429 14,429
Inventory 7b 116 - - 116 116
Tangible fixed assets 7c 331 45 - 376 380
447 45 14,429 14,921 14,925
Total fixed assets 447 10,271 54,542 65,260 59,380
Debtors due a er more than one year 10 - - - - 1,767
Current assets Stocks 9 5 - - 5 12
Debtors 10 1,452 5,709 - 7,161 1,308
Short term deposits 373 117 262 752 645
Cash at bank and in hand (5,255) 2,537 2,889 171 1,540
(3,425) 8,363 3,151 8,089 3,505
Liabili es due within one year Creditors 11 (933) (1) (200) (1,134) (1,240)
Net current (liabili es)/assets (4,358) 8,362 2,951 6,955 2,265
Total assets less current liabili es (3,911) 18,633 57,493 72,215 63,412
28 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Liabili es due a er more than one year
Creditors 12 (212) (400) - (612) (825)
Net assets (4,123) 18,233 57,493 71,603 62,587
Funds Unrestricted (4,123) - - (4,123) (2,915)
Restricted - 18,233 - 12,525 14,171
Endowment - - 57,493 63,201 51,331
Total funds 16.2 (4,123) 18,233 57,493 71,603 62,587
The financial statements were approved by the Chapter on 17 September 2019 and signed on their behalf by:
…………………………………………………………. ……………………………………………………………. Dean Treasurer The notes on pages 27 to 48 and the Special Trust accounts on page 49 form part of these Financial Statements.
29 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Consolidated statement of cashflows for the year ended 31 March 2019
Note 2019 2018
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Net cash ou low from opera ng ac vi es 17.1 (2,167) (736)
Returns on investments
Rents received net of costs 661 724
Interest and dividends received net of costs 646 550 ______
1,307 1,274
Capital expenditure & financial investment
Purchase of investments (6,693) (1,102)
Sales and transfers of investments 2,336 745
Sales of investment property & freehold land 4,278 -
Addi ons to tangible fixed assets (125) (41)
(204) (398)
______Cash (ou low)/inflow before management of liquid resources and financing (1,064) 140
Management of liquid resources
Net (increase)/decrease in short term deposits (107) 107
Financing
Repayment of loan (200) (200) ______
(Decrease)/increase in cash 17.3 (1,371) 47
The notes on pages 27 to 48 and the Special Trust accounts on page 49 form part of these Financial Statements.
30 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Notes to the accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
1. Accoun ng policies
The accoun ng policies which affect items that are material in determining the financial posi on of the Cathedral and its subsidiary en es are set out below. These policies form part of the notes to the financial statements.
Basis of accoun ng
The financial statements have been prepared under the historical cost conven on except for the valua on of investments and certain investment and non-investment proper es that are carried at fair value. They have been drawn up in accordance with the 2015 Accounts and Repor ng Regula ons for English Anglican Cathedral Accounts (“the Regula ons”) and Financial Repor ng Standard (FRS) 102: The Financial Repor ng Standard applicable in the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland, effec ve for accoun ng periods commencing on 1 January 2015. The accounts are presented in £ sterling, which is considered to be the func onal currency, and are rounded to the nearest £’000.
The Cathedral is classed as a public benefit en ty.
Basis of consolida on
The group financial statements consolidate the accounts of Durham Cathedral and its wholly owned subsidiary undertakings Durham Cathedral Trading Limited and Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited, all with financial year ends of 31 March. Transac ons between group en es are eliminated on consolida on. No Statement of Financial Ac vi es (“SOFA”) is presented for Durham Cathedral alone as permi ed by the Regula ons. The finances of the Chorister School Durham, are included in the Cathedral’s accounts since the School is a department of the Cathedral.
Going Concern
The Chapter has a stated intent to increase free reserves and has set in place a system of prudent budgets, forecasts and rigorous monitoring to this end. In addi on, as part of improving the Cathedrals financial sustainability and addressing the unrestricted fund deficit, ac ons are being taken to grow a new endowment fund as well as iden fying new income streams. Having taken these factors into account, and having considered the budgets and cash flow projec ons, the Chapter is confident that the Cathedral will con nue to be able to meet its liabili es as they fall due for the foreseeable future and have sufficient levels of liquid reserves, including bank borrowing, to cover short term fluctua ons in income. The Chapter therefore considers that it is appropriate to prepare the accounts on a going concern basis.
Incoming resources
All incoming resources are included in the SOFA when the Cathedral is legally en tled to the income and the amount can be quan fied with reasonable accuracy.
Proceeds from the sale of property under the terms of the Endowment are credited to permanent Endowment capital, other than proper es that have been transferred from Endowment as explained in Note 16. Any charges incurred in the purchase of property for the Endowment are capitalised where appropriate.
Resources expended
All expenditure is accounted for on an accruals basis and has been classified under headings that aggregate all costs rela ng to the category. Expenditure on repairs, restora on and maintenance of the Cathedral is charged as incurred, with the cost of major repairs and restora on being charged against the Fabric Fund, a restricted fund as disclosed in Note
31 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
16. Expenditure on Investment Property is charged against revenue unless the work results directly in a substan al increase in the value of the property and also an increase in rental income when it is capitalised. Irrecoverable VAT has been added to the item of expenditure giving rise to it.
Alloca on of support costs
The Regula ons require alloca on of the support costs to those ac vi es which they directly support. Support costs have been allocated to departments on the basis of headcount.
Cathedral and Inventory
The Cathedral and Ancillary Buildings
No value is a ributed on the balance sheet to the Cathedral or its ancillary buildings on the basis that this is not permi ed under the Regula ons.
Inventory
Inventory assets relate to heritage assets acquired since 2002. Such assets are recorded in the balance sheet at cost.
Heritage Assets
The Chapter considers that obtaining valua ons for all of the books, manuscripts and artefacts and other heritage assets in its care would involve dispropor onate cost compared with the benefit derived by users of the accounts. Consequently no values are a ributed to heritage assets in the balance sheet. Disclosure regarding heritage assets is given in Note 8.
The Chapter has a policy of retaining its heritage assets for the long term and cannot dispose of such assets held within Endowment Funds without the agreement of the Cathedral Fabric Commission for England (CFCE) and/or the Church Commissioners. Heritage items are generally acquired by dona on.
Tangible fixed assets and deprecia on
The Regula ons recommend that a professional valua on of proper es is carried out at least every five years with material movements between valua ons being included in the accounts. The Regula ons state that the valua on may be carried out by either an independent professional advisor or an appropriately qualified member of the Cathedral’s staff. Details of the basis of valua on adopted as at 31 March 2019 are given in Notes 6a and 7a.
Non-investment proper es, which are occupied by clergy and lay employees of the Cathedral, the offices, library and stone yard are included at open market value at the last valua on date. The Chorister School buildings are included on the basis of depreciated replacement cost.
The Chapter considers that the proper es (non-investment) need not be depreciated due to the policy of maintaining these assets to such a high standard that they retain a high residual value. Investment proper es are not depreciated in accordance with FRS 102.
Equipment, plant and facili es are wri en off to the Revenue Account in the period in which the expenditure is incurred, except that capital expenditure on any item over £500 is capitalised at cost and depreciated over its useful economic life.
Deprecia on rates
Capitalised tangible fixed assets are wri en off at the following rates:
Land and buildings 2% to 6.67% pa straight line
32 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Plant and equipment 5% to 33% pa straight line Fixtures and fi ngs 2% to 20% pa straight line Motor vehicles 25% pa straight line IT costs 20% to 33% pa straight line
Financial Instruments
Quoted and unquoted investments are included at fair value. Realised and unrealised gains and losses on investments are shown in the SOFA.
Debtors are measured at transac onal prices less provision for any impairment. Creditors are measured at transac on prices less any amounts se led.
Cash at bank and in hand includes cash equivalents such as cash held on the CCLA CBF Deposit Fund repayable on demand.
Stock
Stock is valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value.
Capital grants
Grants given towards the capital cost of assets are credited as income to a restricted fund and the deprecia on of the asset acquired is charged against the fund over the useful economic life of the associated asset.
Fund accoun ng
Endowment funds are funds which are held for the permanent benefit of the Cathedral. There is no power to convert capital into income. Historically, all freehold proper es were classed as Endowment, but transfers were made to restricted funds during the years ended 31 March 2012 and 31 March 2016. Please refer to Note 16 for details of this fund.
Restricted funds are funds that can only be used for par cular restricted purposes within the objects of the Cathedral. Restric ons arise when specified by the funder or when funds are raised for a specific purpose.
Unrestricted funds are funds which can be used in accordance with the charitable objects at the discre on of the Chapter.
Designated funds are funds set aside by the Chapter out of the unrestricted general fund for specific purposes or projects.
Pensions
The Chapter operates a stakeholder pension scheme that is open to all staff with three months or more service. Under new pension legisla on, all eligible staff are auto-enrolled in the stakeholder pension scheme a er three months service. Contribu ons are paid to approved funds and are charged as expenditure in the year in which they accrue.
33 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
The Chapter par cipates in a Teachers’ Pension Scheme, which is a defined benefit scheme for teaching staff only. This is a mul -employer defined benefits pension scheme and it is not possible or appropriate to iden fy the assets and liabili es of the scheme which are a ributable to the school. The charge to the statement of financial ac vi es is the amount payable in the period.
2. Key areas of judgement
The key areas of judgements in the audited accounts are regarding accoun ng for grant income, Open Treasure construc on spend and provisions for stocks and debtors.
Project specific grant income is accrued when condi ons for capital and revenue grants have been fulfilled. Such grants are claimed in arrears. Other capital grants are accounted for on receipt of the grant, with the grant condi ons having been fulfilled in advance. Open Treasure construc on spend is capitalised if it is connected with crea ng a capital asset i.e. the Open Treasure exhibi on spaces. Open Treasure spend that does not meet this criteria is expensed through the DCOT profit and loss account (and the consolidated group SOFA).
Stock provisions are calculated annually for specific stock lines based on stock holdings and slow moving stock lines. Bad debt provisions are principally in rela on to Chorister School overdue fees and provisions are made on a prudent basis where fees are unlikely to be recovered in full.
34 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
3. Employees
The average number of employees (both by full me equivalent and headcount) during the year was as follows:
Full me equivalent 2019 2018 Number Number
Dean and Chapter 75 77 Durham Cathedral Trading Limited 7 7 Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited 11 16 Chorister School 38 39
Total 131 139
Headcount 2019 2018 Number Number
Dean and Chapter 86 95 Durham Cathedral Trading Limited 13 13 Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited 16 19 Chorister School 44 42
Total 159 169
The total cost of all paid staff of the Cathedral was: 2019 2018 £'000 £'000
Salaries and s pends 3,666 3,608 Employer's Na onal Insurance costs 295 303 Employer's pension costs - teachers' pensions 129 133 Employer's pension costs - stakeholder pensions 100 110
Total 4,190 4,154
There was one employee who received remunera on between £60,000 and £70,000 in FY19 (FY18: None).
35 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Members of Chapter received the following remunera on for the year ended 31 March 2019:
Salary or Employer's Pension Total s pend NIC contribu ons contribu ons £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
The Very Revd Andrew Tremle 36 4 12 52 The Venerable Ian Jagger 3 - - 3 The Revd Canon Charlo e Allen 10 1 3 14 The Revd Canon Rosalind Brown 21 2 6 29 The Revd Canon Michael Hampel 5 - - 5 The Revd Canon David Kennedy 25 2 10 37 The Revd Canon Professor Simon Oliver 21 2 3 26 The Revd Canon Sophie Jelley 3 - - 3
Total 124 11 34 169
Compara ve figures for the year ended 31 March 2018 are as follows:
Salary or Employer's Pension Total s pend NIC contribu ons contribu ons £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
The Very Revd Andrew Tremle 35 4 12 51 The Venerable Ian Jagger 3 - - 3 The Revd Canon Rosalind Brown 33 3 9 45 The Revd Canon David Kennedy 33 3 9 45 The Revd Canon Professor Simon Oliver 21 2 3 26 The Revd Canon Sophie Jelley 3 - - 3
Total 128 12 33 173
36 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
The Dean and the two Residen ary Canons received s pends in accordance with the scales laid down by the Church Commissioners, the Archbishops’ Council and the Church of England Pensions Board. Canons Jelley and Jagger were remunerated by the Diocese of Durham and as such their s pends were included in the Diocese accounts.
Canon Professor Oliver is an employee of Durham University. The remunera on shown above represents the propor on recharged to the Cathedral. None of the lay members of Chapter received remunera on in either year, other than reimbursement of travel and subsistence costs, as disclosed below.
Four members (FY18: four) of the Chapter were reimbursed a total of £5,337 (FY18: £3,427) in respect of travel and subsistence whilst carrying out the business of the Chapter.
4. Income Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total Total funds funds funds 2019 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Dona ons and legacies Congrega onal collec ons and giving 216 - - 216 208 Dona ons 318 55 108 481 316 Income from appeals and fundraising 4 - - 4 20 Tax recoverable under gi aid on 45 - - 45 50 voluntary dona ons Income from Friends and local trusts 12 16 40 68 157 Income from AllChurches Trust - 27 - 27 - Legacies 531 5,774 45 6,350 1,080
1,126 5,872 193 7,191 1,831
Grants in support of mission Church Commissioners 170 - - 170 131 Heritage Lo ery Grants 25 89 76 190 331 World War 1 Centenary grants - - - - 318 Other revenue grants 52 593 25 670 378
247 682 101 1,030 1,158
Charges and fees in the course of mission Facility and other fees 216 - - 216 322 Income of the Chorister School 1,822 31 - 1,853 2,035
37 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
2,038 31 - 2,069 2,357
Trading and chargeable events Charges to visitors 155 - - 155 138 Income from shop, restaurant and other trading ac vi es 892 - - 892 1,073
1,047 - - 1,047 1,211
Investments Investment property 841 - - 841 919 Investments 622 24 - 646 571 Interest receivable on short term deposits 4 - - 4 2
1,467 24 - 1,491 1,492
Other sundry income 44 - - 44 27
Total income 5,969 6,609 294 12,872 8,076
Please refer to Note 18 for the FY18 SOFA analysed by fund type.
5. Expenditure Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total Total funds funds funds 2019 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Raising funds Shop, restaurant and other trading 986 616 - 1,602 1,689 costs Chorister School teaching costs 1,385 13 - 1,398 1,370 Marke ng and development 490 6 - 496 391
38 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Investment property 391 - - 391 195 Allocated support costs 189 - - 189 194
3,441 635 - 4,076 3,839
Ministry Clergy s pends and working expenses 153 - - 153 155 Clergy housing costs 17 - - 17 23 Services, music and congrega onal 570 9 - 579 691 costs Allocated support costs 216 - - 216 222
956 9 - 965 1,091
Educa on and outreach Chorister School costs 828 6 - 834 891 Educa onal ac vi es 116 10 - 126 144 Archives and library 111 13 - 124 138 Charitable and other giving - 10 - 10 35 Allocated support costs 94 - - 94 97
1,149 39 - 1,188 1,305
Cathedral and precincts upkeep Major repairs and restora on 148 628 - 776 2,004 Maintenance and interior upkeep 672 - - 672 770 U li es 119 - - 119 121 Cathedral insurance 156 - - 156 153 Precincts, security and gardens upkeep 196 - - 196 215 Allocated support costs 431 - - 431 445
1,722 628 - 2,350 3,708
Total expenditure 7,268 1,311 - 8,579 9,943
39 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Please refer to Note 18 for the FY18 SOFA analysed by fund type.
6. Investment assets Consolidated and Charity
6a. Investment property at valua on Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total Total funds funds funds 2019 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
At 1 April 2018 - 7,289 18,363 25,652 22,283 Disposals - - (4,278) (4,278) - Net increase on revalua ons - (63) 5,647 5,584 3,369
At 31 March 2019 - 7,226 19,732 26,958 25,652
Basis of property valua on
All investment proper es are freehold. The Regula ons recommend that an independent formal professional valua on is carried out at least every five years with material movements between valua ons being included in the accounts.
A professional valuer undertook desktop valua ons based of the property por olio based on reports provided by the Cathedral’s management agents. Valua ons reflect the opinion of fair value in FRS 102: The price that would be received to sell an asset, or paid to transfer a liability, in an orderly transac on between market par cipants. These valua ons excluded Durham School as well as the residen al and opera onal proper es of the Cathedral Precinct. The la er were last valued at open market value as at 31 March 2013 by JK Property Consultants LLP.
6b. Listed Investments
Consolidated and Charity Unrestricted Restricted Endowmen Total 2019 Total funds funds t funds 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Investments at market value 1 April - - 15,803 15,803 15,771 2018 Addi ons - - 6,694 6,694 1,102 Proceeds from disposals - - (2,749) (2,749) (745) Net increase/(decrease) on revalua on - - 633 633 (325)
40 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Investments at market value 31 March 2019 - - 20,381 20,381 15,803
Analysed as follows: £'000 £'000
UK equi es 9,255 7,656 Overseas equi es 4,204 3,181 UK fixed interest 2,700 2,180 Overseas fixed interest 436 433 Other investments 2,036 1,646 Cash at investment managers 1,750 707
Total investments 20,381 15,803
6c. Subsidiary Undertakings
Charity Unrestricted Restricted Endowmen Total 2019 funds funds t funds £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Investments at 1 April 2018 - 3,000 - 3,000 Addi ons - - - -
Investments at market value 31 March 2019 - 3,000 - 3,000
The subsidiary undertakings of the Cathedral comprise:
41 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
En ty Company Percentage Net assets Profit/(loss) registered shareholding as at 31 for year number March ended 31 2019 March 2019
£'000 £'000
Durham Cathedral Trading Limited 06366806 100 311 (8) Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited 08009824 100 3,925 1,323
7a. Non-investment property Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total funds funds funds £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Consolidated
At cost/valua on 1 April 2018 - 9,978 14,429 24,407 Addi ons - - - -
At cost/valua on 31 March 2019 - 9,978 14,429 24,407
Deprecia on
At 1 April 2018 - 2,479 - 2,479
Charge for the year - 611 - 611
At 31 March 2019 - 3,090 - 3,090
Net Book Value
At 31 March 2019 - 6,888 14,429 21,317
At 31 March 2018 - 7,499 14,429 21,928
42 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Total Unrestricted Restricted Endowment funds funds funds £’000 £’000 £’000 £’000
Charity
At cost/valua on 1 April 2018 - 1,493 14,429 15,922 Addi ons - - - -
At cost/valua on 31 March 2019 - 1,493 14,429 15,922
Deprecia on
At 1 April 2018 - 1,493 - 1,493 Charge for the year - - - -
At 31 March 2019 - 1,493 - 1,493
Net Book Value
At 31 March 2019 - - 14,429 14,429
At 31 March 2018 - - 14,429 14,429
The Endowment proper es are occupied as follows: 2019 2018 £'000 £'000
Clergy and staff housing 9,130 9,130 Chorister School 3,429 3,429 Cathedral ac vi es 1,870 1,870
Total 14,429 14,429
43 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
All non-investment proper es are freehold and most relate to Endowment funds. The majority of these proper es were valued at open market value as at 31 March 2013 by JK Property Consultants LLP. The Chorister School non-investment proper es were valued as at 31 March 2013 by JK Property Consultants LLP on the basis of depreciated replacement cost.
7b. Inventory Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total funds funds funds funds £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Consolidated and Charity Net book value at 1 April 2018 and 31 March 2019 116 - - 116
Inventory assets relate to works of art and heritage assets, at purchase cost.
7c. Tangible fixed assets
Consolidated Land & Plant & Fixtures, Motor Total buildings Equipment fi ngs & vehicles IT Equipment £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Cost At 1 April 2018 1,127 517 883 47 2,574 Addi ons - 22 103 - 125 Disposals - - - - -
At 31 March 2019 1,127 539 986 47 2,699
Deprecia on At 1 April 2018 175 288 424 43 930 Charge for the year 27 48 72 2 149 Disposals - - - - -
44 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
At 31 March 2019 202 336 496 45 1,079
Net book value At 31 March 2019 925 203 490 2 1,620
At 31 March 2018 952 229 459 4 1,644
Charity
Cost At 1 April 2018 237 407 364 47 1,055 Addi ons - 20 48 - 68 Disposals - - - - -
At 31 March 2019 237 427 412 47 1,123
Deprecia on At 1 April 2018 79 252 301 43 675 Charge for the year 9 43 19 1 72 Disposals - - - - -
At 31 March 2019 88 295 320 44 747
Net book value At 31 March 2019 149 132 92 3 376
At 31 March 2018 158 155 63 4 380
45 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
8. Heritage assets not recognised in the balance sheet
Cathedral, Ancillary Buildings and Inventory
The construc on of Durham Cathedral commenced in 1093 and was completed by about 1135. It is regarded as one of the finest examples of Norman architecture in the world and is situated within the Durham UNESCO World Heritage Site. The Cathedral replaced the 10th Century “White Church” built as part of a monas c founda on to house the shrine of St Cuthbert of Lindisfarne.
Objects considered to be of architectural, archaeological, ar s c or historic interest are recorded in an Inventory in accordance with S13 (1) of the Care of Cathedrals Measure 1990. These objects are held primarily for use by the Cathedral in its mission or have been vested in Chapter over me and are held as part of the historical record of the Cathedral. Items disclosed in Note 7b Inventory, are separate from those held in the S13 (1) Inventory. No value is a ributed on the balance sheet to the Cathedral, ancillary buildings or items recorded in the Inventory as explained in the accoun ng policy note.
By virtue of its extensive history Durham Cathedral owns many valuable heritage assets with historic and educa onal value. The nature and scale of the collec on belonging to the Chapter of Durham Cathedral include:
• The riverbanks and woodlands that extend round the Cathedral to the River Wear;
• Mediaeval manuscripts from the sixth century onwards;
• 1,000 volumes of post-mediaeval manuscripts;
• 10,000 books printed in the 20th and 21st centuries;
• Printed volumes of music, mainly 16th-19th century;
• A collec on of artefacts associated with the shrine of St Cuthbert: the wooden coffin, pectoral cross and other items.
The Chapter considers that the Cathedral’s heritage assets are prac cally very difficult and prohibi vely expensive to value, as a result of the unique nature of many of the items. None of the aforemen oned heritage assets are therefore included on the Cathedral’s balance sheet. Despite the difficul es in valua on, the Chapter believes that there is significant value in the heritage assets rela ve to the Cathedral’s net asset value at the financial year end.
The Chapter has a statutory duty under the Cathedrals Measure 1999 to manage and maintain the Cathedral, its contents and other buildings and monuments. The Chapter has a planned programme of major restora on works to the Cathedral and other buildings which is informed by a full quinquennial review by the Cathedral Architect. Works are overseen by the Clerk of Works and the Cathedral Architect. The majority of the conserva on and repair is carried out by highly skilled cra smen employed by the Cathedral.
The collec ons in the Library are managed by a Head of Collec ons and library team. Necessary conserva on works are carried out by accredited conservators. The Library welcomes researchers with interests in the collec ons. Access to the Library's collec ons is freely available to members of the public.
There have been no material movements in the heritage assets of the Cathedral over the last five years.
46 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
9. Stocks Charity Consolidated Charity Consolidated 2019 2019 2018 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Goods for resale 5 100 12 115
10. Debtors Long Term Debtors Charity Consolidated Charity Consolidated 2019 2019 2018 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Amounts owed by group companies - - 1,767 - - - 1,767 -
Debtors-amounts due within one year Charity Consolidated Charity Consolidated 2019 2019 2018 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Trade debtors 283 292 179 173 Other debtors 120 120 67 67 Prepayments and accrued income 5,842 5,874 102 231 Amounts owed by group companies 916 - 960 -
7,161 6,286 1,308 471
11. Creditors - amounts falling due within one year
Charity Consolidated Charity Consolidated 2019 2019 2018 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
47 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Trade creditors 21 316 738 817 Other creditors 145 145 32 23 Accruals and deferred income 454 470 218 250 Taxes and social security 81 111 52 52 Loans due within one year 200 200 200 200 Amounts owed to group companies 3 - - -
1,134 1,242 1,240 1,342
12. Creditors - amounts falling due a er more than one year
Charity Consolidated Charity Consolidated 2019 2019 2018 2018 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Loan 400 400 600 600 Final term deposits 22 22 25 25 Other creditors 190 190 200 200
612 612 825 825
A £1m loan was advanced from the Durham Diocese Board of Finance during FY13 to fund expenditure on the Open Treasure project. The key terms of the loan are as follows:
• The loan is unsecured;
• Interest at the rate of interest applicable to deposits in the CBF Church of England Deposit Fund;
• Loan term is up to 10 years, expiring on 31 March 2022;
• The loan is repayable in five annual tranches of £200,000 commencing 31 March 2018.
13. Future commitments and con ngent liabili es
There are three poten al legal claims against the Chapter outstanding at the date of signing the annual accounts, two of which the future liability have yet to be determined.
48 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Capital commitments
As at 31 March 2019 the Cathedral was commi ed to spend a further £689k on the comple on of capital works in connec on with ongoing projects.
Commitments under opera ng leases
The Cathedral’s commitments under opera ng leases is as follows:
Computer & Motor 2019 2018 other IT vehicles total total equipment £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Total payable within one year 18 10 28 28 Total payable during years 2 to 4 17 15 32 60
35 25 60 88
14. Pensions
Stakeholder scheme
The Chapter introduced a new individual stakeholder pension scheme in April 2002. This is for all non-teaching staff employed by the Chapter, the School and/or the trading subsidiaries. Employer payments under the stakeholder pension scheme in FY19 totaled £100,344 (FY18: £110,234).
Teachers’ pension scheme
Introduc on The Teachers' Pension Scheme (“TPS”) is a statutory, contributory, defined benefit scheme, governed by the Teachers' Pensions Regula ons (2010) and, from 1 April 2014, by the Teachers’ Pension Scheme Regula ons 2014. Membership is automa c for full- me teachers in academies and, from 1 January 2007, automa c for teachers in part- me employment following appointment or a change of contract, although they are able to opt out. The TPS is an unfunded scheme and members contribute on a ‘pay as you go’ basis – these contribu ons along with those made by employers are credited to the Exchequer. Re rement and other pension benefits are paid by public funds provided by Parliament.
Valua on of the Teachers’ Pension Scheme Not less than every four years the Government Actuary, using normal actuarial principles, conducts a formal actuarial review of the TPS in accordance with the Public Service Pensions (Valua ons and Employer Cost Cap) Direc ons 2014 published by HM Treasury. The aim of the review is to specify the level of future contribu ons. Actuarial scheme valua ons are dependent on assump ons about the value of future costs, design of benefits and many other factors.
49 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
The latest actuarial valua on of the TPS was carried out as at 31 March 2012 and in accordance with the Public Service Pensions (Valua ons and Employer Cost Cap) Direc ons 2014. The valua on report was published by the Department for Educa on on 9 June 2014. The key elements of the valua on and subsequent consulta on are:
• employer contribu on rates set at 16.48% of pensionable pay (including a 0.08% employer administra on charge (currently 14.1%); • scheme liabili es (pensions currently in payment and the es mated cost of future benefits) for service to the effec ve date of £191,500 million, and no onal assets (es mated future contribu ons together with the no onal investments held at the valua on date) of £176,600 million giving a no onal past service deficit of £14,900 million; • an employer cost cap of 10.9% of pensionable pay will be applied to future valua ons; • the assumed real rate of return is 3.0% in excess of prices and 2% in excess of earnings. The rate of real earnings growth is assumed to be 2.75%. The assumed nominal rate of return is 5.06%.
During the year the employer contribu on rate was 14.1%. The TPS valua on for 2012 determined an employer rate of 16.4% from September 2015, which will be payable during the implementa on period un l the next valua on which was due at March 2016, whereupon the employer contribu on rate is expected to be reassessed and will be payable from 1 April 2019.
The pension charge for the year includes employer contribu ons payable to the TPS of £128,753 (FY18: £133,333). At the financial year end £11,086 (FY18: £11,297) was accrued in respect of employer contribu ons to this scheme.
15. Associated en es and related par es
Controlled by the Chapter
Durham Cathedral Trading Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary, undertakes trading ac vi es on behalf of the Chapter and transfers profits back to the Chapter through Gi Aid or cash/profit transfers. Durham Cathedral Open Treasure Limited is also a wholly owned subsidiary which became opera onal in July 2016. Profits will also be transferred back to the Chapter through Gi Aid. Transac ons undertaken by both wholly owned subsidiaries are included in the Cathedral’s consolidated financial statements.
Not controlled by the Chapter
The Friends of Durham Cathedral
Durham Cathedral Choir Associa on
Durham Cathedral Academic Charity
Whilst both The Friends of Durham Cathedral and Durham Cathedral Choir Associa on give support to Durham Cathedral, the powers of both chari es regarding distribu on of income are discre onary.
The following par es have been iden fied as being related par es, through the involvement of Member(s) of Chapter in their management. Values of transac ons between Durham Cathedral and each related party for the year ended 31 March 2019 are disclosed below.
Related party Sales to Purchases Year-end Rent Year-end from debtor or charged rent owed (creditor) or (prepaid)
50 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
1. Durham University 54 67 5 34 - 2. St Chad's College - - - 65 - 3. Lord Crewe's Charity - - - - - 4. Durham Diocese Board of Finance - 9 1 - - 5. Friends of Durham Cathedral 27 - 10 - - 6. Durham School - - - 159 13 7. Visit County Durham - 3 - - -
Total 81 79 16 258 13
Compara ve figures for the year ended 31 March 2018 are as follows:
Related party Sales to Purchases Year-end Rent Year-end from debtor or charged rent owed (creditor) or (prepaid) £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
1. Durham University 116 63 (2) 34 - 2. St Chad's College - - - 60 - 3. Lord Crewe's Charity - - - - - 4. Durham Diocese Board of Finance - - - - - 5. Friends of Durham Cathedral 59 - 5 - - 6. Durham School 3 - - 158 5 7. Visit County Durham - 2 - - -
Total 178 65 3 252 5
51 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
16. Statement of Funds Brought Incoming (Outgoing) Gains, Balance forward resources resources (losses) & carried transfers forward £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 16.1 Consolidated Endowment funds Permanent endowment 47,360 - - - 47,360 Expendable endowment 3,971 294 - 5,868 10,133
51,331 294 - 5,868 57,493
Restricted funds 1. Freehold property fund 7,500 - - (63) 7,437 2. Open Treasure restricted fund 7,871 36 (616) (349) 6,942 3. Academic fund (3) - - - (3) 4. Chapter copes fund 25 - - - 25 5. Inventory funds 106 - - - 106 6. Library department fund 300 20 (7) - 313 7. Cathedral fabric fund 520 45 - - 565 8. Liturgical and Worship fund 5 - - - 5 9.Music fund 147 10 - - 157 10.Cathedral charitable fund 12 10 (8) - 14 11.Other restricted funds 115 87 (7) - 195 12.Educa on funds 16 4 (10) - 10 13.School outreach fund 85 15 (13) - 87 14.Special trust funds 103 23 (10) - 116 15.Central Tower - Belfry project (287) 293 - - 6 16.North Quire window 19 37 (40) - 16 17.Adopt a book 2 8 (8) - 2 18. Lobbies 624 313 (589) - 348 19. Cloister Roof 100 - (3) - 97 20. Surtees legacy fund - 5,708 - - 5,708
Total Restricted funds 17,260 6.609 (1,311) (412) 22,146
52 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Unrestricted funds General fund (3,016) 5,946 (7,216) 349 (3,937) Designated funds 234 23 (52) - 205
(2,782) 5,969 (7,268) 349 (3,732)
Total consolidated funds 65,809 12,872 (8,579) 5,805 75,907
53 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
16. Statement of Funds - con nued Brought Incoming (Outgoing) Gains, Balance forward resources resources (losses) carried & forward transfers £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 16.2 En ty Endowment funds Permanent endowment 47,360 - - - 47,360 Expendable endowment 3,971 294 - 5,868 10,133
51,331 294 - 5,868 57,493
Restricted funds - as analysed above 17,260 6,609 (1,311) (412) 22,146 Deduct DCOT element of OT Restricted fund (3,089) (21) (1,152) 349 (3,913)
Total Restricted funds 14,171 6,588 (2,463) (63) 18,233
Unrestricted funds General fund (3,149) 5,227 (6,235) (171) (4,328) Designated funds 234 23 (52) - 205
(2,915) 5,250 (6,287) (171) (4,123)
Total en ty funds 62,587 12,132 (8,750) 5,634 71,603
Endowment funds
Permanent endowment funds are funds which are held for the permanent benefit of the Cathedral. There is no power to convert capital into income.
Expendable endowment funds have been created by Chapter using income from property transac ons to create a fund that will generate income. This income will contribute towards annual expenditure, in par cular in rela on to property maintenance. Capital from this fund may be used in certain circumstances, with express permission of Chapter, for example on capital work on the historic fabric. It is hoped that money will be added to the fund from future dona ons and legacies.
Restricted funds
54 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
1. Freehold property fund
This fund was created in the year ended 31 March 2012, with proper es valued at £5.6m transferred from Endowment. The fund has been created to separately iden fy proper es purchased post-1872.
2. Open Treasure Restricted fund
This was created to ensure that funds (dona ons and grants) given specifically for this project are ring-fenced. The fund will be released as the capital assets are depreciated.
3. Academic fund
This was created to promote the establishment of a theology research post.
4. Chapter Copes fund
This was created by a dona on for the replacement of Copes worn by Chapter members.
5. Inventory funds
These were originally created by grants and relate to the acquisi on of items added to the Cathedral’s inventory.
6. Library fund
Generous dona ons were received during the year ended 31 March 2012 to enable the Library to buy back books and manuscripts that were owned by Durham Cathedral (Durham Priory) before the dissolu on of the monasteries in 1540.
7. Cathedral Fabric fund
Income comprises dona ons towards the cost of cathedral repairs. Expenditure represents repairs and maintenance of the Cathedral fabric.
8. Liturgy and Worship fund
A dona on of £5,000 enabled the crea on of this fund in 2013.
9. Music fund
The Music fund is used to facilitate special musical enhancements of the Cathedral’s worship.
55 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
10. Cathedral Charitable fund
This fund arises from alloca ons from offertory accounts and is dispersed annually to worthy causes.
11. Other Restricted funds
This comprises sundry funds ranging from £1,000 to £11,000 that have been created by dona ons for specific purposes.
12. Educa on Centre fund
This includes two restricted funds which are to be used solely by the Educa onal department.
13. School outreach fund
This fund is for Choral outreach: to inspire as many children as possible in the joy of singing, supported by both Choristers and the Cathedral.
14. Special Trust funds
These funds are analysed on page 45 of the Financial Statements.
15. Central Tower – Belfry project
This fund was created for dona ons to the Belfry renova ons that are taking place between 2015 and 2019.
16. North Quire window
This fund was created for a new stained glass window that was created through the generosity of donors.
17. Adopt a Book
This fund supports the conserva on and repair of the Cathedrals collec on of early printed books. Dona ons are generated through the Adopt a Book programme, which offers donors the opportunity to select a book from a list of eligible tles for restora on work.
18. Lobbies
Income in the fund comprises grants and dona ons given towards a project to replace the 1970’s lobbies at the Cathedral’s north and south doors with new glazed lobbies. The project will improve visitor access, flow and orienta on for all those who visit.
19. Cloister Roof
56 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
This fund has been created for grants and dona ons in support of a planned project to repair the cloister roof. The repairs were first iden fied in the 2013 Quinquennial Report (QIR) and have subsequently become “high priority” status due to further deteriora on of the roof beams.
Unrestricted funds
Designated Funds are set aside by the Chapter out of the unrestricted general fund for specific purposes or projects. Movements for the year ended 31 March 2019 are as follows:
Consolidated and Charity Balance Incoming Outgoing Fund Balance brought resources resources transfers carried forward forward £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Property designated fund 99 - - - 99 Altar frontals 13 - - - 13 Riverbanks project 8 - - - 8 School premises fund 114 23 (52) - 85
Total 234 73 (52) - 205
Transfers Transfers from restricted to unrestricted funds represent balances held within the Open Treasure fund that have now been u lised within the project, thus releasing the restric on. The remaining restricted balances represent the assets of the project that are being depreciated through the fund, as noted above.
17. Cashflow notes
17.1 Reconcilia on of net incoming resources before recognised gains to net cash (ou low) from opera ng ac vi es 2019 2018 £'000 £'000
Net incoming resources 10,098 1,254
Less: income from property - net of costs (661) (724) Less: investment income - net of costs (646) (550) Less: unrealised gain on investments (5,805) (3,043)
57 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
Add: deprecia on 760 738 Add: write off of Open Treasure stonework - 1,426 Decrease/(increase) in stocks 15 (10) (Increase) in debtors (5,815) (35) (Decrease)/Increase in creditors (113) 208
Net cash ou low from opera ng ac vi es (2,167) (736)
58 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
17.2 Reconcilia on of cash and cash equivalents 2019 2018
£'000 £'000
Cash at bank and in hand 231 1,602
Short term deposits 752 645
983 2,247
Loans (600) (800)
Cash and cash equivalents 383 1,447
17.3 Analysis of changes in net funds/(debt) As at 1 Cashflow As at 31 April March 2018 2019 £'000 £'000 £'000
Cash at bank and in hand 1,602 (1,371) 231 Debt due within one year (200) - (200) Debt due a er more than one year (600) 200 (400) Short term deposits held as current assets 645 107 752
Net funds 1,447 (1,064) 383
59 Durham Cathedral, Accounts for the year ended 31 March 2019
18. Prior year SOFA analysed by fund type
Unrestricted Restricted Endowment Total funds funds funds 2018
£'000 £'000 £'000 £'000
Income and endowments from: Dona ons and legacies 591 985 255 1,831 Grants in support of mission 478 680 - 1,158 Charges and fees in the course of mission 2,299 48 10 2,357 Trading and chargeable events 1,202 9 - 1,211 Investments 1,469 23 - 1,492 Other income 27 - - 27
Total income 6,066 1,745 265 8,076
Expenditure on: Raising funds (3,582) (257) - (3,839) Ministry (1,067) (24) - (1,091) Educa on and outreach (1,171) (134) - (1,305) Cathedral and precincts upkeep (1,571) (2,137) - (3,708)
Total expenditure (7,391) (2,552) - (9,943)
Net (outgoing)/incoming resources before investment gains/(losses) (1,325) (807) 265 (1,867)
Net gains on investments - - 3,121 3,121
Net movement in funds (1,325) (807) 3,386 1,254
Funds brought forward (1,457) 18,067 47,945 64,555
Funds carried forward (2,782) 17,260 51,331 65,809
60