UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Lusus Naturae, Folklore, and DIsplay in the Nineteenth Century in the United States Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9pm5v8bq Author Verderano Reynoso, Lena Lydia Publication Date 2012 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Lusus Naturae, Folklore, and Display in the Nineteenth Century in the United States By Lena Verderano Reynoso A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Curiosities, Display, and Lore in the United States in the Nineteenth Century in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor John Lindow Professor Daniel Melia Professor Nelson Graburn Professor David Henkin Professor Sue Schweik Spring 2012 © Copyright by Lena Verderano Reynoso 2012 All Rights Reserved Abstract Lusus Naturae, Lore, and Display in the Nineteenth Century in the United States by Lena Verderano Reynoso Doctor of Philosophy in Curiosities, Display, and Lore in the United States in the Nineteenth Century University of California, Berkeley Professor John Lindow, Chair Exhibitions of lusus naturae were at the height of popularity during the nineteenth century in the United States and reveal how popular culture reflects emerging themes in folklore. This study takes an interdisciplinary approach by examining these exhibitions as a process, where an interdependent relationship based on the knowledge of familiar folk narratives is formed between the latent performer (seller), the pitchman (lecturer), the performer (display), and the audience. The presentation, marketing, and reception of these entertaining and unusual exhibitions are analogous to various forms of folklore, and therefore function in the same manner as folklore. The interaction and experience with these living motifs are defined as motif ostension. Motif ostension evoked whole stories from fragments of information given to the audience directly or indirectly, allowing the audience to employ their own unique knowledge to add context to the narrative. The interest in these displays permeated through gender, age, and social classes in early America, allowing these displays to use folklore to negotiate a plethora of newly emerging issues under the guise of entertainment and education. The use of motif ostension was an integral form of social expression during the nineteenth century; it pushed the boundaries of folklore, and showed how folklore could be at the root of one of the most popular and influential forms of entertainment in the history of the United States. 1 for Alan Dundes i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation has led me on a journey through unexpected challenges, bereavement, and great joy. I want to thank Alan Dundes for inspiring me, and reminding me to always follow my dreams. It is not often that one meets someone so passionate about his field of study, his research, and his life. The knowledge that I learned from him has permeated all aspects of my life, and I thank him tremendously for that. My journey might not have begun without taking Stuart Blackburn’s methods seminar in 2004. He introduced me to both folklore and Alan Dundes, and for this I am very grateful. I cannot thank my advisor John Lindow enough for stepping in so graciously after the passing of my advisor, Alan Dundes. I did not think that I would be able to finish writing this dissertation, but John supported me throughout my academic journey with kindness and understanding. Our countless meetings, brainstorming sessions, and discussions helped me tremendously throughout the writing process, and even though he had some extremely large shoes to fill, he managed to admirably fill them. I also want to thank my interdisciplinary committee for believing in my project from the start, and for providing me with a great deal of comments, feedback, and advice. Thank you to David Henkin (Department of History), Daniel Melia (Department of Rhetoric), Nelson Graburn (Department of Anthropology), and Sue Schweik (Department of English). I cannot go without thanking my parents, Dale and Miho Verderano, for always cheering me on whenever I felt overwhelmed, and my wonderful in-laws Rita and Bob Denman, who showed me the sincerest love and support throughout my journey. Also, the support of incredibly inspirational people, like Dr. Laurie Ross, Jean Chu, and Jacob and Moriah Van Vleet, helped keep me focused on my goal. The enthusiasm of many carny folk, sideshow performers, and impresarios I have met along the way kept me excited about my topic—among them, Johnny Fox, Charon Henning, and James Taylor. With all of my heartfelt gratitude, I want to thank my husband Matt Reynoso for his continued love and encouragement. He never once questioned my path, and he unconditionally supported me through all the hurdles along my academic journey. Words cannot describe my great admiration for him. I thank him for being my best friend and greatest champion. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT 1 DEDICATION i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ii LIST OF FIGURES v CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION 1 Outline and Method 1 Assumptions and Limitations 1 Historical Background of Venues 3 Traditional Approaches 15 The Monster and The Wonder 15 Disability and Normality 17 Freakery, The Exotic, and The Cultural “Other” 20 As Ethnographic Object 22 American Folkloristics in the Nineteenth Century 23 Historical Perspective 26 Summary 27 CHAPTER 2. FOLK MOTIFS AND EXHIBITION: DATA 28 The Use of Folklore 28 The Tale-Type 29 The Motif 30 Display as Instantiations of Folk Motifs 34 Conjoined Twins 34 Wild Hairy People 35 Giants 39 Little People 41 Remarkable Hair 43 Extremely Old Person 44 Spotted People 44 Maternal Impression 44 Wax People, Living Statues 46 iii CHAPTER 3. FOLKLORE AS EXHIBITION: MARKETING Motif Ostension 49 Impresario as Active Bearer 52 Tradition & Authenticity 53 Folklorism & Nostalgia 55 Tourism 57 Semiotics 61 Souvenirs 63 Narratology & Display 66 Pitches 68 Epic Laws 69 Literature & Folklore 70 Pseudo-Events and Heroes 73 CHAPTER 4. FOLKLORE AND EXPERIENCE: RECEPTION 75 Patrons as Active and Passive Bearers 77 Presentation & Reception 77 Scientific Presentation 79 Liminality 81 The Performer 82 The Patron 84 The Location 85 Reception: Irish Motifs 86 CHAPTER 5. CONCLUSION 90 Retrospect 90 Interpretation 91 Functions of Folklore 92 Bodies and Performance 94 Limitations and Suggestions 97 APPENDIX 101 BIBLIOGRAPHY 109 iv LIST OF FIGURES Figure Page 1. Prominent places where lusus naturae where exhibited 15 2. The use of semiotics in the marketing and reception of exhibitions 62 of nineteenth century lusus naturae 3. Frontispiece of Edward Bulwer Lytton’s The Siamese Twins: A 73 Satirical Tale of the Times with Other Poems (1831) 4. Liminality and motif ostension 82 5. Mass culture and folklore patterns of nineteenth century human 100 exhibitions in the United States v LUSUS NATURAE, FOLKLORE, AND DISPLAY IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY IN THE UNITED STATES CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION OUTLINE & METHOD This study employs a diachronic and synchronic approach, using interdisciplinary methods to better understand how and why folklore manifests into popular entertainment in the United States in the nineteenth century. The strategy for addressing a rather large subject matter will begin by forming a perimeter around a general time period between the 1840s and the 1880s, defining “exhibit” as an unusual display primarily used as a form of entertainment, although possibly didactic in nature, which features lusus naturae (living bodies, wax replicas, or automata). Traditional studies of lusus naturae in early American exhibitions often approach the subject of “freakery” by exploring the construction of these displays from only one perspective (performer, seller, or patron). This study takes an interdisciplinary approach by examining these exhibitions as a process, where an interdependent relationship based on the knowledge of familiar folk narratives is formed between the latent performer (seller), the pitchman (lecturer), the performer (display), and the audience (patron), and demonstrates that the presentation, marketing, and reception of these entertaining and unusual exhibitions are analogous to various forms of folklore, and therefore function in the same manner as folklore. The use of primary source material including, but not limited to, newspapers, broadsides, diaries, advertisements, pamphlets, and pitchcards will be used to contextualize and describe these exhibitions, while theories from varying disciplines will be drawn upon in the analysis. By recognizing the prevalent use of folklore in nineteenth century America, particularly concerning amusements and leisure, we can begin to understand why the American public found such intrigue in images of simultaneous wonder and aberrance, and how the interaction with these displays allowed the public to negotiate a plethora of newly emerging issues under the guise of entertainment and education. ASSUMPTIONS & LIMITATIONS The study of folklore as a discipline has spawned the debate of definitions, methods, and techniques. Scholars debate what American folklore is (or isn’t), what methods to apply, if and what the theories are, what discipline it is under (literature vs. anthropology vs. its own), what content should be printed, and what parts are considered valid. It is no wonder that the general public is confused about what folklore it, and why folklore has