DOCSLIB.ORG

Warm-Colored Mountain Bluebirds: an Unappreciated Identification Pitfall

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Warm-Colored Mountain Bluebirds: an Unappreciated Identification Pitfall IN THE SCOPE Warm-colored Mountain Bluebirds: An unappreciated identification pitfall Tony Leukering Despite housing just three species, the genus Sialia still causes con- sternation for birders. Confusion often occurs when birders inexpe- rienced with all three species mistake male Western Bluebirds, some of which sport little rust on the back, with Mountain Bluebirds. A second challenge involves separating males and females of Western and Eastern bluebirds. However, one of the most common pitfalls that I have seen trap birders is created by the small percentage of female Mountain Bluebirds that exhibit obvious rufescent coloration on the chest. This essay is intended to be read with reference to the picture on the back cover of this issue. Bluebird molt strategy (this is relevant, I promise!) Bluebirds, like most thrush species, conduct just one molt per year after their first year (Pyle 1997). Bluebirds in their first plumage cycle obtain their typical spotted juvenal plumage by conducting their first prebasic molt (first basic plumage = juvenal plumage) in the nest; they leave the nest in this plumage. Some time after fledging, they conduct their second molt – the preformative molt – of their short lives, replacing all of their juvenal body plumage and some of their inner greater coverts. Once this molt is finished (as late as October in more-northern and/or later-season broods), these young birds are quite difficult to discern as such in the field, as correct ageing requires discerning the difference between old and new greater coverts and/ or the presence of contrasting older primary coverts or flight feath- ers. In contrast, adult bluebirds conduct a complete prebasic molt, that is, they replace every feather. All bluebird molting is done on or Back Cover Photo This female Mountain Bluebird caused the precise identification quandary about which this essay was written. Fortunately, the excel- lent photographs (one of which is produced here) provided a superb example of warm-colored females of the species, something that I have tried to capture photographically for some time in order to write this very essay. Photograph by David Waltman, 1 December 2012 Colorado Birds October 2013 Vol. 47 No. 4 297 near the breeding grounds. With the completion of the preformative (immature) and prebasic (adult) molts, bluebirds are in the freshest plumage they will wear until conducting their next molt the follow- ing summer/fall. Warm-colored female Mountain Bluebirds The typical female Mountain Bluebird plumage, and the only one illustrated in most field guides, is of nearly unrelieved grayish body plumage (blue-gray when freshest), with variably bright blue or gray- blue wings and tail. Most females sport at least a bit of orangish cast to the chest when fresh, though this may not be discernible unless viewed at close range. Variety is inherent in biology, and this brighter color is quite variable in extent and brightness, with a minority of females (probably less than 10%) having obvious rusty coloration on the chest. This color can even extend a bit down the sides into the gray flanks and, very rarely, up into the lower part of the throat plum- age (pers. obs.). Sibley (2000) is the only major ABA-area field guide to illustrate this plumage well (though the plumage is mentioned in text in Leukering [2006]). The presentation in Sibley (2000; at least the first printings) exaggerates the orange tones. Since many birders do not expect to see orange on female Moun- tain Bluebird chests, such birds can create identification quandaries. Typically, these birds are identified as either Western or Eastern blue- birds, but they have also been suggested as possible hybrid progeny of Mountain Bluebird and one of the orange-breasted species. However, a more complete examination of such birds should reveal the longer, paler-blue wings and tail and the thinner bill lacking pale tones typi- cal of Mountain Bluebird. Relevance of molt timing Bird plumage begins to wear and fade as soon as it is grown, with feathers becoming ragged and colors duller. Thus, female Mountain Bluebirds with only slightly rufescent tones to the chest will likely lose such appearance as wear and fading progress. In fact, even the brightest females’ plumage will fade, making them stand out less from the crowd. Because of this facet of plumage, we birders are much more likely to notice such birds in fall and early winter, when the plumage is still fresh. LITEraturE CITED Leukering, T. 2006. Thrushes. In NGS Complete Birds of North America 2006 298 Colorado Birds October 2013 Vol. 47 No. 4 Pyle, P. 1997. Identification Guide to North American Birds, part I. Slate Creek Press, Bolinas, CA. Sibley, D. A. 2000. The Sibley Guide to Birds. Alfred A. Knopf, New York. Tony Leukering, 1 Pindo Palm St. W, Largo, FL 33770 ([email protected]) Colorado Birds October 2013 Vol. 47 No. 4 299 Female Mountain Bluebird, city of Longmont, Boulder County, 1 December 2012. Photograph by David Waltman In the Scope: Warm-colored Mountain Bluebirds . 297 308 Colorado Birds October 2013 Vol. 47 No. 4.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Attracting Bluebirds 1.Mount Nest Boxes
    Bluebirds A gentle bird with brilliant blue plumage, the bluebird has endeared itself to people across the country. Bluebird populations, like many other birds, have declined over the last century due primarily to loss of habitat caused by development. Bluebirds nest in tree cavities, and the loss or destruction of old, decaying trees has reduced the availability of suitable nesting sites and increased competition with other cavity-nesting birds. Bluebird Natural History There are three species of bluebirds in North America: Eastern, Western, and Mountain. The various species differ mostly in territory and feather color. The males of all three species are brilliant blue on the head and back, with varying amounts of white and rust on their neck and breast. Female bluebirds are less bright, with more gray-brown coloring on the back and blue highlights on the wings and tail. Bluebirds feed on a large variety of insects, arthropods, and invertebrates, The Eastern bluebird is one of three species of bluebirds found in North including spiders, caterpillars, and grasshoppers. Bluebirds perch on posts, America. Bluebirds are cavity nesters, and can be attracted to your property wires, or branches while scanning for insects. Watch for the bluebird’s by installing nest boxes. characteristic behavior of flying down from its perch to catch prey and then returning to the original perch to eat. In winter, bluebirds are dependent upon berries to supplement their diet. Bluebirds prefer open habitats, such as meadows, parks, orchards, farm fields, and golf courses. They often spend the winter in woodlands or groves. Ranges Eastern Bluebirds are in all states east of the Rockies, from southern Canada to the Gulf of Mexico.
    [Show full text]
  • Western Bluebird, EC 1571
    EC 1571 • April 2005 $1.00 Western Bluebird Sialia mexicana by L. Schumacher and S. Sells an you imagine eating bugs and berries and living inside a tree? Why bluebirds CWestern bluebirds do just that! They are members of the thrush family, need our help meaning that they are related to robins. Populations of western bluebirds There are three species, or kinds, of have declined over the past 50 years. bluebirds in the United States: the East- The main reason for their decline is ern bluebird, the Western bluebird, and competition for nest holes from the mountain bluebird. Both Western and European starlings and English house mountain bluebirds live in Oregon. sparrows. Starlings and house spar- Bluebirds eat mostly insects. Grass- rows are exotic species, meaning they hoppers, earthworms, snails, and beetles came from somewhere else and donʼt are among their favorite foods. They sit occur naturally in North America. These on perches and drop quickly to the ground birds were brought here (introduced) to catch food or they can catch insects in and have multiplied quickly. They out- the air. Bluebirds also eat fruit and ber- compete many of our native birds for ries, especially during the winter when nesting habitat. there are fewer insects. Another reason for bluebird decline is loss of habitat due to the cutting of dead trees and suppression of fi re. Fires are important for maintaining oak wood- lands with open meadows. Without fi re, dense forests of fi r trees can take over. Raccoons and house cats may be part of the cause of bluebird decline because they prey on bluebirds.
    [Show full text]
  • Wildlife Species List Mourning Dove Zenaida Macroura
    Wildlife Species List Mourning Dove Zenaida macroura Order: Strigiformes (Nocturnal Flesh Eaters) Northeast Nevada – Units 106 Family: Tytonidae (Barn Owls) Barn Owl Tyto alba (Subalpine Coniferous, P-J, Sagebrush Family: Strigidae (Owls) Steppe, Salt Desert Scrub Habitat, Some Flammulated Owl Otus flammeolus Western Screech-Owl Otus kennicottii Limited Riparian) Great Horned Owl Bubo virginianus Northern Pygmy-Owl Glaucidium gnoma Burrowing Owl Athene cunicularia Long-eared Owl Asio otus Birds Northern Saw-whet Owl Aegolius acadicus Order: Ciconiiformes (Long-leg Waders, etc) Order: Caprimulgiformes (Night Jars) Family: Cathartidae (New World Vultures) Family: Caprimulgidae (Goatsuckers) Turkey Vulture Cathartes aura Common Nighthawk Chordeiles minor California Condor Gymnogyps californianus(L.E.) Common Poorwill Phalaenoptilus nuttallii Order: Falconiformes (Diurnal Flesh Eaters) Order: Apodiformes (Small Fast Fliers) Family: Accipitridae (Hawks, Eagles, Osprey) Family: Apodidae (Swifts) Bald Eagle Haliaetus leucocephalus White-throated Swift Aeronautes saxatalis Northern Harrier Circus cyaneus Family: Trochilidae (Hummingbirds) Sharp-shinned Hawk Accipiter striatus Black-chinned Hummingbird Archilochus alexandri Cooper’s Hawk Accipiter cooperii Broad-tailed Hummingbird Selasphorus platycercus Northern Goshawk Accipiter gentilis Red-shouldered Hawk Buteo lineatus Broad-winged Hawk Buteo platypterus Order: Piciformes (Cavity Builders) Swainson's Hawk Buteo swainsoni Family: Picidae (Woodpeckers) Red-tailed Hawk Buteo jamaicensis Lewis’
    [Show full text]
  • Bird Communities of Gambel Oak: a Descriptive Analysis
    United States Department of Agriculture Bird Communities Forest Service Rocky Mountain of Gambel Oak: A Research Station General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-48 Descriptive Analysis March 2000 Andreas Leidolf Michael L. Wolfe Rosemary L. Pendleton Abstract Leidolf, Andreas; Wolfe, Michael L.; Pendleton, Rosemary L. 2000. Bird communities of gambel oak: a descriptive analysis. Gen. Tech. Rep. RMRS-GTR-48. Fort Collins, CO: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station. 30 p. Gambel oak (Quercus gambelii Nutt.) covers 3.75 million hectares (9.3 million acres) of the western United States. This report synthesizes current knowledge on the composition, structure, and habitat relationships of gambel oak avian communities. It lists life history attributes of 183 bird species documented from gambel oak habitats of the western United States. Structural habitat attributes important to bird-habitat relationships are identified, based on 12 independent studies. This report also highlights species of special concern, provides recommendations for monitoring, and gives suggestions for management and future research. Keywords: Avian ecology, bird-habitat relationships, neotropical migrant, oakbrush, oak woodlands, scrub oak, Quercus gambelii, Western United States The Authors ______________________________________ Andreas Leidolf is a Graduate Research Assistant in the Department of Fisheries and Wildlife at Utah State University (USU). He received a B.S. degree in Forestry/Wildlife Management from Mississippi State University in 1995. He is currently completing his M.S. degree in Fisheries and Wildlife ecology at USU. Michael L. Wolfe is a Professor in the Department of Fisheries and Wildlife at USU. He received a B.S. degree in Wildlife Management at Cornell University in 1963 and his doctorate in Forestry/Wildlife Management at the University of Göttingen, Germany, in 1967.
    [Show full text]
  • Nest Site Selection in Mountain Bluebirds
    NEST SITE SELECTION IN MOUNTAIN BLUEBIRDS CHRISTOPHER J. HERLUGSON ABSTRACT.-Nest site selection was analyzed for a Mountain Bluebird (Sia- lia currucoides) population using two different types of nest box in south- central Washington. The majority of adult females successful in fledging young during the previous year either returned to the same territory and nest box or selected the same type of nest box if they changed territories. If they were unsuccessful, adult females tended to change territories and box types. Most male and female bluebirds breeding for the first time selected the same type of box as housed their natal nest even though none of these birds re- turned to its natal territory. Nest site selection and breeding area fidelity were influenced by age, sex, previous breeding experience, and natal nest type. Recently, Cink (1976) examined the degree printing on the natal type of nest site was to which nestling House Sparrows (Passer not important. domesticus) imprinted on the type of struc- I theorized that imprinting on the natal ture housing their natal nest. Although he type of nest site would be important for sec- found no evidence that early learning or im- ondary cavity-nesting species because of printing had any effect on nest site selec- the scarcity of natural cavities and that tion, females tended to choose hole-type species-specific differences could influence nests over open nests. Other studies have nest site selection. To test these theories, I shown that some species prefer a larger to examined breeding data for a Mountain a smaller nest box (Jarvinen 1978) and that Bluebird (Sialia currucoides) population floor dimensions of a box can influence using two different types of nest box and clutch size (Karlsson and Nilsson 1977).
    [Show full text]
  • Mountain Bluebird
    Mountain Bluebird By Morgan Stewart 1 Table of Contents Idaho’s State Bird 3 Identification 4 Behavior 5 Habitat 6 Nesting 7 Species 8 Media Attributions 9 Questions 10 Glossary 11 Works Referenced 12 2 Idaho’s State Bird Idaho adopted the Mountain Bluebird as their state bird in 1931. It was suggested by Idaho school children to be considered as the state bird. This bluebird gets its name because it lives in the mountains of Western North America. For most of the year, this Mountain Bluebird will remain in the northern areas of Idaho. When the seasons change to winter, the Mountain Bluebird will fly south to live in southern California and northern Mexico to enjoy the warm weather! http://barnowlbox.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Blue-Bird-Map.jpg 3 Identification Mountain Bluebirds are fairly small thrush songbirds, typically having round heads and straight, thin bills. Compared with other bluebirds they are lanky and long- winged, with a long tail. You can identify the difference between a male and female Mountain Bluebird by their coloring. A male Mountain Bluebird is blue and will have a white underside. A female Mountain Bluebird is brown and will have pale blue wings and tail. Mountain Bluebirds’ bills are entirely black. Juveniles have fewer spots than the young of other bluebirds. Featured image: Mountain bluebird. Credit: iStock/RC Keller http://www.worldsciencefestival.com/2014/11/state-bird-extinct-2080/ 4 Behavior Mountain Bluebirds behavior is unlike any other bluebird species. Mountain Bluebirds will hover low over the grass in open fields and search for food.
    [Show full text]
  • UK-First-Breeding-Register.Pdf
    INTRODUCTION TO EDITION The original author and compiler of this record, Dave Coles has devoted a great deal of his time in creating a unique reference document which I am privileged to continue working with. By its very nature the document in a living project which will continue to grow and evolve and I can only hope and wish that I have the dedication as Dave has had in ensuring the continuity of the “First Breeding Register”. Initially all my additions and edits will be indicated in italics though this will not be used in the main body of the record (when a new record is added). Simon Matthews (2011) It is over eighty years since Emilius Hopkinson collated his RECORDS OF BIRDS BRED IN CAPTIVITY, which formed the starting point for my attempt at recording first breeding records for the UK. Since the first edition of my records was published in 1986, classification has changed several times and the present edition incorporates this up-dated classification as well as first breeding recorded since then. The research needed to produce the original volume took many years to complete and covered most avicultural literature. Since that time numerous people have kept me abreast of further breedings and pointing out those that have slipped the net. This has hopefully enabled the records to be kept up-to- date. To those I would express my thanks as indeed I do to all that have cast their eyes over the new list and passed comments, especially the ever helpful Reuben Girling who continues to pass on enquiries.
    [Show full text]
  • A Hybrid Eastern Bluebird X Mountain Bluebird.--On 28 June 1967 Robert W
    684 General Notes [Auk, Vol. 85 Wisconsin,using techniques described elsewhere (Enderson and Berger,op. cit.). Total pesticideresidues in the four sampleswere 130, 717, 754, and 2435 ppm (fat basis) with a mean of 1009 ppm. The lowest value is less than half the lowest found in adult female fat from nine Peregrinesin the Mackenzie River in 1966 (Enderson and Berger, op. cit.) and the highest,greater than any reported for this species,is four times greater than the top level in the Mackenzie samples. However, our lowest sam- ple is similar to the lowest of four from Yukon River females in 1966 (Cade et al. unpublisheddata) and the highest,from a bird caring for three small young, is about 60 per cent greaterthan Cade'shighest.--J^•Es H. Em)ERSO•,Department o/ Biology, Colorado College, Colorado Springs, Colorado 80903, D^vm G. Ros•^u, ^•I) L. G. SW^RTZ,College o/ Biological Sciencesand Renewable Resources,University o! Alaska, College,Alaska 99735. A hybrid Eastern Bluebird X Mountain Bluebird.--On 28 June 1967 Robert W. Nero, W. Harvey Beck, and I collecteda hybrid between the Eastern Bluebird (Sialia sialis) and the Mountain Bluebird (S. currucoides)at a nest box in south- western Manitoba about 40 miles west of Brandon. Determination was made by Dr. Nero, and the specimenwas depositedin the Manitoba Museum of Man and Nature in Winnipeg. The hybrid, a male, has red feathers,blue feathers,and blue feathers with red tips on both throat and breast,and is midway in generalsize betweenthe Eastern and Mountain bluebird. Its measurementsare as follows: culmen 11.8, tarsus 20.5, wing (chord) 104.3, tail 66.5 min.
    [Show full text]
  • Sialia Currucoides) Susan L
    Ethology Parental Effort in Relation to Structural Plumage Coloration in the Mountain Bluebird (Sialia currucoides) Susan L. Balenger1, L. Scott Johnson1, Jessica L. Brubaker & Emilene Ostlind Department of Biological Sciences, Towson University, Towson, MD, USA Correspondence Abstract S. L. Balenger, Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, AL 36849, USA. Indicator models of sexual selection suggest that costly ornaments signal E-mail: [email protected] reliable information regarding an individual’s quality to potential mates. In species that produce altricial offspring, the amount of parental care Received: November 20, 2006 provided by both males and females can impact reproductive success. Initial acceptance: January 19, 2007 The Good Parent Hypothesis proposes that ornamentation in biparental Final acceptance: April 12, 2007 species can act as an honest signal of parental ability to potential mates. (S.A. Foster) We tested this hypothesis using the mountain bluebird (Sialia currucoides), doi: 10.1111/j.1439-0310.2007.01386.x a sexually dichromatic, socially monogamous species in which both sexes have structurally based ornamental plumage coloration. A male’s plumage color predicted neither the rate at which it provisioned nest- lings nor brood growth rate. The same was true for females. We also found no indication of assortative mating by color or body condition. Feeding rates within pairs were positively correlated, which we suggest may be due to pairs responding similarly to the perceived needs of nest- lings or to local area prey availability. In sum, our results do not support the Good Parent Hypothesis as an explanation for the evolution of orna- mental plumage color in mountain bluebirds.
    [Show full text]
  • Children's Bluebird Activity Book
    fascinating facts © puzzles © pictures © coloring © Stories Children’s Bluebird CTIVITY OOK A B MYRNA PEARMAN and PAULINE MOUSSEAU credits © 2007 Myrna Pearman and Pauline Mousseau Reproduction of this booklet is permitted for educational, non-commercial use provided appropriate acknowledgement is made. Copyright for photographs are held by individual photographers as credited on the proceeding page. Publisher Mountain Bluebird Trails, Inc. Box 794 Ronan, MT 59864 Writing: Myrna Pearman Graphic Design and Layout: Pauline Mousseau Our thanks to the following reviewers: • Bob Niebuhr • Dr. Harry Power, III • Donna Hagerman • Nicole Bailey • Erv Davis • Maddison Pearman • Brandee Massey • Kristi Dubois, (Native Species Coordinator, Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks) • Kathern Mounteer • Gene Pyles Funded by Funding for this project was generously provided by the Thomas and Stacey Siebel Foundation. To learn more about this foundation visit: www.siebelscholars.com Dedication Dedicated to the memory of Art Aylesworth, founder of Mountain Bluebird Trails, Inc., and whose dream it was to inspire the next generation of bluebirders. 2 photo credits All photos are used with permission. Photos in booklet are by Myrna Pearman, unless noted below: Front Cover: Top right, Maridith Denton Page 5: Bottom, Lorne Scott Page 7: Tom Ulrich Page 8: Jane Brockway Page 9 Top left, Don Marble and top right, Lorne Scott Page 15: Jane Brockway Page 17: Top and middle, Lorne Scott Page 20: Top, Jane Brockway Page 26: Middle, Jane Brockway Page 27: All pictures on page, Jane Brockway Page 28: Top, Scott Johnson and middle, Jane Brockway Illustrations Illustrations by Gary Ross (from Mountain Bluebird Trail Monitoring Guide, used with permission by Red Deer River Naturalists) Coloring Illustrations by Nicole Ruuska, www.nicoleruuska.com 3 what’s inside Topic Page Introduction to Bluebirds………………………….
    [Show full text]
  • Learn About Texas Birds Activity Book
    Learn about . A Learning and Activity Book Color your own guide to the birds that wing their way across the plains, hills, forests, deserts and mountains of Texas. Text Mark W. Lockwood Conservation Biologist, Natural Resource Program Editorial Direction Georg Zappler Art Director Elena T. Ivy Educational Consultants Juliann Pool Beverly Morrell © 1997 Texas Parks and Wildlife 4200 Smith School Road Austin, Texas 78744 PWD BK P4000-038 10/97 All rights reserved. No part of this work covered by the copyright hereon may be reproduced or used in any form or by any means – graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, taping, or information storage and retrieval systems – without written permission of the publisher. Another "Learn about Texas" publication from TEXAS PARKS AND WILDLIFE PRESS ISBN- 1-885696-17-5 Key to the Cover 4 8 1 2 5 9 3 6 7 14 16 10 13 20 19 15 11 12 17 18 19 21 24 23 20 22 26 28 31 25 29 27 30 ©TPWPress 1997 1 Great Kiskadee 16 Blue Jay 2 Carolina Wren 17 Pyrrhuloxia 3 Carolina Chickadee 18 Pyrrhuloxia 4 Altamira Oriole 19 Northern Cardinal 5 Black-capped Vireo 20 Ovenbird 6 Black-capped Vireo 21 Brown Thrasher 7Tufted Titmouse 22 Belted Kingfisher 8 Painted Bunting 23 Belted Kingfisher 9 Indigo Bunting 24 Scissor-tailed Flycatcher 10 Green Jay 25 Wood Thrush 11 Green Kingfisher 26 Ruddy Turnstone 12 Green Kingfisher 27 Long-billed Thrasher 13 Vermillion Flycatcher 28 Killdeer 14 Vermillion Flycatcher 29 Olive Sparrow 15 Blue Jay 30 Olive Sparrow 31 Great Horned Owl =female =male Texas Birds More kinds of birds have been found in Texas than any other state in the United States: just over 600 species.
    [Show full text]
  • Hybridization Associated with Cycles of Ecological Succession in a Passerine Bird
    vol. 190, no. 4 the american naturalist october 2017 E–Natural History Note Hybridization Associated with Cycles of Ecological Succession in a Passerine Bird Renée A. Duckworth* and Georgy A. Semenov Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona 85721 Submitted November 14, 2016; Accepted April 10, 2017; Electronically published August 16, 2017 Online enhancements: appendix figures and tables. Dryad data: http://dx.doi.org/10.5061/dryad.6dm3c. abstract: tures of hybridization are widespread (Mallet et al. 2016); Identifying the diversity of contexts that can lead to hybrid- — ization is important for understanding its prevalence and dynamics in moreover, the discovery of mosaic hybrid zones where hy- natural populations. Despite the potential of ecological succession to bridization occurs throughout a species range at habitat tran- dramatically alter species co-occurrence and abundances, it is unknown sitions (Rand and Harrison 1989; Emms and Arnold 1997; whether it directly promotes hybridization and, if so, has long-lasting Larson et al. 2013)—indicates that hybridization is not always consequences. Here, we summarize 30years ofsurvey data across 10 pop- confined to narrow zones of secondary contact. In addition to fi ulations to show that in western and mountain bluebirds, heterospeci c variation in the spatial context of hybridization, there is also pairing occurs during repeatable and transient colonization events at the early stages of species turnover. Despite mixed pairing occurring substantial temporal variation because some hybrid zones are only during early succession, genetic data showed presence of hybrids highly stable over time and others are relatively ephemeral, at both early and late successional stages.
    [Show full text]