DOCSLIB.ORG

Regulating Election Finance a Review by the Committee on Standards in Public Life the Committee on Standards in Public Life

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Regulating Election Finance a Review by the Committee on Standards in Public Life the Committee on Standards in Public Life Regulating Election Finance A Review by the Committee on Standards in Public Life The Committee on Standards in Public Life July 2021 Regulating Election Finance A Review by the Committee on Standards in Public Life Chair, Lord Evans of Weardale July 2021 Chair’s foreword Dear Prime Minister, I am pleased to present the 22nd report of the Committee on Standards in Public Life on the regulation of election finance. Digital campaigning is revolutionising the way parties and campaigners engage with voters. But it has also made it harder to track how much is being spent, on what, where and by whom. Questions have been raised, both by those with direct experience of the system and by the public, as to whether the current framework for regulating campaign finance is coherent and proportionate. In regulating election finance it is vital to have effective rules that ensure fairness without designing a system so complex and demanding that it deters those who cannot rely on the support of well-resourced party machinery. Some will think that the recommendations in this report don’t go far enough. Others will think they are too radical. We have sought to take into account the diversity of views that we heard, and make practical recommendations that will lead to tangible improvements to the current system, both for those who must understand and comply with it and for the public, who are entitled to know how money is being spent to influence their vote. We have been guided by the principles that people have told us should underpin the regulation of election finance. These include fairness, transparency and accountability. Participation is also crucial: elections should be open to all and we have sought to ensure that our recommendations would not penalise smaller political parties and campaigners who are not supported by professional compliance teams. Our report focuses on practical proposals that seek to modernise and reform aspects of the regime. We recommend tightening the requirement to identify the true source of donations and reduce the potential for foreign money to influence UK elections. We also make recommendations to increase voter access to information about how money is spent at elections and referendums in the age of digital campaigning. We look at the issue of non- party campaigning and what changes can be made to improve regulation in this area. A main area of focus is on compliance with the law. Criminal sanctions remain necessary for serious breaches, such as deliberate attempts to circumvent the system. However, where there has been a breach of the rules as the result of an inadvertent error, we believe a civil sanction is the more appropriate route. 1 This is why we have proposed a package of recommendations to enhance the civil sanctions regime. These include the decriminalisation of criminal offences that relate to essentially administrative requirements; extending the civil sanctions regime to include candidate finance laws (to end the cliff edge for candidates where the only enforcement action that can be taken is either criminal prosecution or nothing); and new time limits for Electoral Commission investigations to encourage timely enforcement action. There are also recommendations to improve provision of guidance and advice. Together, the recommendations we have made in this report will deliver significant improvements to the current framework for regulating election finance, creating a more transparent, proportionate and effective system. Lord Evans of Weardale Chair, Committee on Standards in Public Life 2 Contents Executive summary 4 List of recommendations 11 Introduction 18 Chapter 1 What principles should underpin the regulation of election finance? 21 Chapter 2 Electoral law 30 Chapter 3 The Electoral Commission 38 Chapter 4 Donations 47 Chapter 5 Regulated periods and campaign expenditure 61 Chapter 6 Digital campaigning and election finance 68 Chapter 7 Reporting timeframes 78 Chapter 8 Non-party campaigning 84 Chapter 9 Compliance part 1 - the criminal and civil regimes 99 Chapter 10 Compliance part 2 - candidates 129 Appendix 1 140 Appendix 2 146 Appendix 3 154 Appendix 4 156 Appendix 5 157 3 Executive summary Proportionate and effective regulation of the money spent to influence the outcome of elections and referendums is vital to the operation of a functioning democracy. A little over twenty years since the regime for regulating party expenditure was established, we have taken the opportunity to review whether the current system continues to live up to the principles demanded of it. While we believe that the case for consolidation and simplification of electoral law, as proposed by the Law Commission, is unarguable, we believe that additional reforms are needed and these can be made in advance of any wholesale consolidation of the law. The majority of our recommendations are designed to deliver practical reforms to address modern campaign practices, meet emerging threats around the source of donations, deliver greater transparency and enhance compliance with election finance law. Taken together, the package of recommendations in this report will modernise the current system and increase the effectiveness of electoral regulation. Chapter summaries Chapter 1 - What principles should underpin the regulation of election finance? In this chapter, we set out the principles that contributors to our review told us should matter the most when seeking to regulate the money that is spent to influence the outcome of election and referendum campaigns. We group these principles into seven categories: Fairness The outcome of an election should be based on the electorate freely choosing and voting for their preferred candidate and policies. Electoral rules should be fair and coherent. Open to all Democratic engagement should be open to all and the regulatory system should support this. Participation should not be limited to those with deep pockets. Transparency The amount of money received by political parties, campaigners and candidates, where that money comes from and what it is spent on, are legitimate matters of public interest. Journalists and academics must have access to this information to enable them to analyse and interpret the data for voters. 4 Confidence and trust The voting public must be confident that donations and campaign expenditure are being regulated fairly. Simplicity and clarity Campaign finance laws should be clear and easy to comply with. Accountability Those involved in raising and spending money in elections need to be accountable for their actions. There needs to be a proportionate response to breaches of the law. An independent regulator The majority of contributors to the review told us they believe in the principle of a strong, independent regulator of election finance, free from the influence of any particular political party or group. Chapter 2 - Electoral law This chapter discusses the complexity of electoral law. It sets out the evidence we heard about the negative impact that this complexity may have on the willingness of people to participate in the democratic process by becoming treasurers, candidates and campaigners and on the effectiveness of electoral administration and regulation. We also examine the legal framework for party (national) and candidate (local) expenditure. Some contributors to the review expressed concern that digital campaigning has helped larger parties to focus their spending on marginal constituencies, blurring the regulatory division between expenditure intended to secure the success of the party, recorded against (high) party spending limits, and that intended to secure the success of the candidate, recorded against (relatively low) candidate spending limits. The principle of candidate spending limits is undermined if national parties are able to target expenditure heavily in particular constituencies. We signpost the recommendations in our report that will increase transparency and allow for closer monitoring of whether expenditure is correctly allocated against party or candidate spending limits. We also call on the government to bring forward a bill to simplify and consolidate electoral law as proposed by the Law Commission. Chapter 3 - The Electoral Commission The focus of our review is the Electoral Commission’s role as a regulator of donations and campaign finance laws. However, contributors were keen to share their perspectives on the Electoral Commission more broadly. 5 In this chapter we set out the Electoral Commission’s governance structure and accountability framework, before moving on to discuss the evidence we heard about the Commission’s mandate, its effectiveness and its status as an independent regulator. The majority of contributors expressed confidence in the Commission as an independent, non-partisan regulator, including those who see room for improvement in how the Commission carries out its role. However, we also heard from some MPs and campaigners who believe the Commission is institutionally biased, and cited their personal experiences to support their case. We set out our strongly-held belief in the value of an independent regulator, insulated from political pressures and at arm’s length from the government. The Electoral Commission needs to command the confidence of political parties, campaigners and the public through effective delivery and assiduous impartiality. The Commission performs an important role in our democratic system and it should be respected but also open to scrutiny and challenge. Chapter 4 - Donations In
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Report of an Investigation in Respect Of
    Report of an investigation in respect of - Vote Leave Limited - Mr Darren Grimes - BeLeave - Veterans for Britain Concerning campaign funding and spending for the 2016 referendum on the UK’s membership of the EU 17 July 2018 1 Other formats For information on obtaining this publication in a large-print or Braille version, please contact the Electoral Commission. Tel: 020 7271 0500 Email: [email protected] The Electoral Commission is the independent body which oversees elections and regulates political finance in the UK. We work to promote public confidence in the democratic process and ensure its integrity. 2 Contents 1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 4 2 The decision to investigate ............................................................................. 9 3 The investigation .......................................................................................... 12 4 The investigation findings ............................................................................. 16 Joint spending by Vote Leave and BeLeave ................................................... 16 Vote Leave’s spending limit ............................................................................. 21 Other issues with Vote Leave’s spending return ............................................. 24 BeLeave’s spending ........................................................................................ 25 Mr Grimes’ spending return ............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Social Welfare Strategies
    Throughout the world, societies are reexamining, reforming, and restructuring their social welfare systems. New ways are being sought to manage and finance these systems, and new approaches are being developed that alter the relative roles of government, private business, and individ- uals. Not surprisingly, this activity has triggered spirited debate about the relative merits of the various ways of structuring social welfare systems in general and social security programs in particular. The current changes respond to a vari- ety of forces. First, many societies are ad- justing their institutions to reflect changes in social philosophies about the relative responsibilities of government and the individual. These philosophical changes are especially dramatic in China, the former socialist countries of Eastern Europe, and the former Soviet Union; but The Advantages and Disadvantages they are also occurring in what has tradi- of Different Social Welfare Strategies tionally been thought of as the capitalist West. Second, some societies are strug- by Lawrence H. Thompson* gling to adjust to the rising costs associated with aging populations, a problem particu- The following was delivered by the author to the High Level American larly acute in the OECD countries of Asia, Meeting of Experts on The Challenges of Social Reform and New Adminis- Europe, and North America. Third, some trative and Financial Management Techniques. The meeting, which took countries are adjusting their social institu- tions to reflect new development strate- place September 5-7, 1994, in Mar de1 Plata, Argentina, was sponsored gies, a change particularly important in by the International Social Security Association at the invitation of the those countries in the Americas that seek Argentine Secretariat for Social Security in collaboration with the ISSA economic growth through greater eco- Member Organizations of that country.
    [Show full text]
  • Jo Swinson: the New Liberal Democrat Leader
    Jo Swinson: the new Liberal Democrat Leader 22 July 2019 Who is Jo Swinson? Jo Swinson was born in 1980, growing up and going to school in East Dunbartonshire, which she now represents in Parliament. Her mother was a primary school teacher while her father worked in economic development. She cites her earliest political experience as signing petitions against animal testing in the Body Shop. A Liberal Democrat supporter since she was at school, Jo joined the Liberal Democrats aged 17, while studying Management at the LSE. During her time at university, she worked as a Research Assistant for the Employers’ Forum on Disability. After graduating, Swinson moved to Hull, working as Viking FM’s Marketing & PR Manager. Aged 21, she stood against John Prescott at the 2001 general election in Hull East. Relocating back to Scotland, she worked as Marketing Manager for SpaceandPeople Plc and then as Communications Officer for the UK Public Health Association prior to her election as an MP. In 2011, she married Duncan Hames, who was the Liberal Democrat MP for Chippenham from 2010 to 2015, and is now an anti-corruption campaigner. The couple have two sons. What is Jo Swinson’s political background? Swinson was successfully elected to Parliament in 2005, winning East Dunbartonshire from Labour. In the Commons, she became a Lib Dem whip and spokesperson for culture, media and sport, before being promoted to Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland in 2006. Swinson gained additional responsibility in 2007 becoming Shadow Women and Equality Minister. She returned to the backbenches later that year, before becoming Shadow Minister for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs in 2008, retaining this role until the 2010 election.
    [Show full text]
  • Assessing the Quality of Democracy
    Assessing the Quality of Democracy A Practical Guide Assessing the Quality of Democracy A Practical Guide David Beetham Edzia Carvalho Todd Landman Stuart Weir © International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance 2008 International IDEA publications are independent of specific national or political interests. Views expressed in this publication do not necessarily represent the views of International IDEA, its Board or its Council Members. Applications for permission to reproduce or translate all or any part of this publication should be made to: International IDEA SE -103 34 Stockholm Sweden Graphic design by: Santángelo Diseño Printed by: Bulls Graphics Cover illustration © Alberto Ruggieri/Illustration Works/Corbis/Scanpix ISBN: 978-91-85724-43-7 Foreword: the state of democracy Democracy is the predominant form of government in the world to- day. For the greater part of the world democracy has been a rare or re- cent phenomenon, but successive waves of democracy throughout the 20th century meant that by the new millennium more countries were governed through democratic than through non-democratic forms of rule. Various attempts to enumerate democracies in the world agree that more than 60 per cent of all countries today have in place at least some form of minimal democratic institutions and procedures. The Community of Democracies lists more than 100 countries while the United Nations International Conference on New or Restored Democracies (ICNRD) has grown in depth, breadth and importance since it was inaugurated in 1988 as a forum for global democratic de- velopment. Increasingly, governmental, intergovernmental and non- governmental organizations emphasize that democracy is an end in itself, as well as an important means to other ends, such as economic development, poverty reduction and greater protection of interna- tionally recognized human rights.
    [Show full text]
  • The Status of Cantonese in the Education Policy of Hong Kong Kwai Sang Lee and Wai Mun Leung*
    Lee and Leung Multilingual Education 2012, 2:2 http://www.multilingual-education.com/2/1/2 RESEARCH Open Access The status of Cantonese in the education policy of Hong Kong Kwai Sang Lee and Wai Mun Leung* * Correspondence: waimun@ied. Abstract edu.hk Department of Chinese, The Hong After the handover of Hong Kong to China, a first-ever policy of “bi-literacy and Kong Institute of Education, Hong tri-lingualism” was put forward by the Special Administrative Region Government. Kong Under the trilingual policy, Cantonese, the most dominant local language, equally shares the official status with Putonghua and English only in name but not in spirit, as neither the promotion nor the funding approaches on Cantonese match its legal status. This paper reviews the status of Cantonese in Hong Kong under this policy with respect to the levels of government, education and curriculum, considers the consequences of neglecting Cantonese in the school curriculum, and discusses the importance of large-scale surveys for language policymaking. Keywords: the status of Cantonese, “bi-literacy and tri-lingualism” policy, language survey, Cantonese language education Background The adjustment of the language policy is a common phenomenon in post-colonial societies. It always results in raising the status of the regional vernacular, but the lan- guage of the ex-colonist still maintains a very strong influence on certain domains. Taking Singapore as an example, English became the dominant language in the work- place and families, and the local dialects were suppressed. It led to the degrading of both English and Chinese proficiency levels according to scholars’ evaluation (Goh 2009a, b).
    [Show full text]
  • Blended Concessional Finance: Governance Matters for Impact by Kruskaia Sierra-Escalante, Arthur Karlin & Morten Lykke Lauridsen
    www.ifc.org/thoughtleadership NOTE 66 • MAR 2019 Blended Concessional Finance: Governance Matters for Impact By Kruskaia Sierra-Escalante, Arthur Karlin & Morten Lykke Lauridsen Blended concessional finance, the combination of concessional funds with other types of finance on commercial terms, has great potential to mobilize capital and accelerate high-impact private sector investments in new and challenging markets. Yet full development of these efforts requires strong governance. IFC has been working for some time to develop a robust governance system for blended concessional finance, guided by the Development Finance Institutions Enhanced Principles, a set of principles that employ special operating procedures and checks and balances when using blended concessional finance for private sector projects. While no universal approach will fit all implementers of blended concessional finance, good governance is a common challenge. These institutions need to learn from each other to ensure good governance, as the sharing of experiences is crucial to building global trust in the use of concessional funds. And to work well, governance structures need to be transparent and focus on solving potential conflicts of interest. The combination of concessional funds and other types of launch important private projects and crowd in sources of finance on commercial terms is called blended concessional commercial finance. These first demonstration projects can finance.1 It can play a central role in creating and help unlock new markets. reinforcing markets in developing countries and can help Commercial finance and development finance institution these countries reach their development goals. This type of (DFI) finance at commercial terms can address the finance has great potential for development impact through financing needs of many projects (Figure 1).
    [Show full text]
  • Nickersonanita-E.Pdf
    Submission to ERRE by Anita Nickerson In this brief I speak only for myself. My opinions are in no way a reflection of the views of Fair Vote Canada. Their views are well set out in this submission to ERRE. ​ ​ Sections In this brief you will find the following: About the Author The Case is not Black and White, But It’s Real Why PR What System I Prefer What System I Hope You Adopt Special Issues: ● Simplicity ● Competition/Collaboration in Multi-Member Ridings ● Local Representation ● Familiarity Bias about Systems ● Referendum, Media and Mandate Who am I? I am a 42 year old woman who lives in Kitchener, Ontario. I have bachelor degrees in Psychology and Social Work, and a college diploma in Drug and Alcohol Counselling. I worked as an addictions counsellor for 8 years. I have been at home with my 15 year old daughter with special needs (we homeschool) since 2006. My husband of 16 years is a Registered Practical Nurse. For the past year, I have been employed part time by Fair Vote Canada. I’ve been working with FVC first on a local and then on a national level since 2008. I support volunteers, help coordinate national actions, and have contributed to almost every other aspect of our national campaign. This cause is my full time passion. Around 2007 I was like most Canadians - I voted, but I paid very little attention to politics ​ ​ between elections. I made voting decisions based on clips of leaders I saw on TV or something I read in the paper.
    [Show full text]
  • A Canadian Model of Proportional Representation by Robert S. Ring A
    Proportional-first-past-the-post: A Canadian model of Proportional Representation by Robert S. Ring A thesis submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Department of Political Science Memorial University St. John’s, Newfoundland and Labrador May 2014 ii Abstract For more than a decade a majority of Canadians have consistently supported the idea of proportional representation when asked, yet all attempts at electoral reform thus far have failed. Even though a majority of Canadians support proportional representation, a majority also report they are satisfied with the current electoral system (even indicating support for both in the same survey). The author seeks to reconcile these potentially conflicting desires by designing a uniquely Canadian electoral system that keeps the positive and familiar features of first-past-the- post while creating a proportional election result. The author touches on the theory of representative democracy and its relationship with proportional representation before delving into the mechanics of electoral systems. He surveys some of the major electoral system proposals and options for Canada before finally presenting his made-in-Canada solution that he believes stands a better chance at gaining approval from Canadians than past proposals. iii Acknowledgements First of foremost, I would like to express my sincerest gratitude to my brilliant supervisor, Dr. Amanda Bittner, whose continuous guidance, support, and advice over the past few years has been invaluable. I am especially grateful to you for encouraging me to pursue my Master’s and write about my electoral system idea.
    [Show full text]
  • Post Layout 1
    Friday 15 International Friday, July 26, 2019 Britain new leader rejects ‘unacceptable’ Brexit deal Johnson urged EU leaders to rethink their opposition LONDON: Britain’s new Prime Minister Boris ing the EU after 46 years without an agreement will Johnson yesterday called the current Brexit deal be less painful than economists warn. The markets negotiated with the EU “unacceptable” and set were relieved by the appointment of former preparations for leaving the bloc without an agree- Deutsche Bank Sajid Javid as finance chief. The ment as a “top priority” for the government. In a pound held steady against the dollar and euro as pugnacious debut in parliament, the former London traders waited for Johnson’s first policy moves. mayor urged EU leaders to rethink their opposition Other appointments were more divisive. Brexit to renegotiating the deal. hardliner Dominic Raab became foreign secretary After installing a right-wing government follow- and Jacob Rees-Mogg - leader of a right-wing ing a radical overhaul, Johnson doubled down on faction of Conservatives who helped bring about his promise to lead Britain out of the EU by Octo- May’s demise - as the government’s parliament ber 31 at any cost. In case of a no-deal exit, he also representative. New interior minister Priti Patel threatened to withhold the £39 billion ($49 billion) has previously expressed support for the death divorce bill that Britain has previously said it owes penalty and voted against same-sex marriage. The the EU and instead spend the money for prepara- Labor opposition-backing Mirror newspaper tions for leaving with no agreement.
    [Show full text]
  • Facilities for Trade Union Officials and Members to Exercise Their Rights – a Comparative Review 02 03
    Facilities for trade union officials and members to exercise their rights – A comparative review 02 03 Table of Contents Introduction: The background of the project......................................................................................................................7 The freedom of association and the right to organize as a matrix...............................................................................9 Part I: General Part.............................................................................................................................................................17 European and international law...........................................................................................................................................17 Comparative labour law........................................................................................................................................................21 Protection against acts of anti-union discrimination......................................................................................................21 Belgium.....................................................................................................................................................................................21 Denmark..................................................................................................................................................................................22 France.......................................................................................................................................................................................23
    [Show full text]
  • Extremism in the Electoral Arena: Challenging the Myth of American Exceptionalism Gur Bligh
    BYU Law Review Volume 2008 | Issue 5 Article 2 12-1-2008 Extremism in the Electoral Arena: Challenging the Myth of American Exceptionalism Gur Bligh Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview Part of the Election Law Commons Recommended Citation Gur Bligh, Extremism in the Electoral Arena: Challenging the Myth of American Exceptionalism, 2008 BYU L. Rev. 1367 (2008). Available at: https://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/lawreview/vol2008/iss5/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Brigham Young University Law Review at BYU Law Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in BYU Law Review by an authorized editor of BYU Law Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. BLIGH.FIN 11/24/2008 5:55 PM Extremism in the Electoral Arena: Challenging the Myth of American Exceptionalism Gur Bligh Abstract: This Article explores the limitations that the American electoral system imposes upon extremist parties and candidates. Its thesis is that extremists, and particularly anti-liberal extremists, are excluded from the American electoral arena through a combination of direct and indirect mechanisms. This claim challenges the crucial premise of American constitutional theory that the free speech doctrine is a distinct area of “American exceptionalism.” That theory posits that the American strict adherence to viewpoint neutrality, the strong emphasis upon the “dissenter,” and the freedom granted to extremist speakers is exceptional among liberal democracies. The Article argues that once we focus upon the electoral arena as a distinct arena, we discover that in this domain of core political expression, dissenting extremists are marginalized and blocked and their viewpoints are not represented.
    [Show full text]
  • Doomed to Failure? UKIP and the Organisational Challenges Facing Right-Wing Populist Anti-Political Establishment Parties
    Abedi, A. and Lundberg, T.C. (2009) Doomed to failure? UKIP and the organisational challenges facing right-wing populist anti-political establishment parties. Parliamentary Affairs, 62 (1). pp. 72-87. ISSN 0031-2290 http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/41367 Deposited on: 22 October 2010 Enlighten – Research publications by members of the University of Glasgow http://eprints.gla.ac.uk Doomed to Failure? UKIP and the Organisational Challenges Facing Right-Wing Populist Anti-Political Establishment Parties This is a pre-copy editing, author-produced version of an article accepted for publication in Parliamentary Affairs following peer review. The definitive publisher-authenticated version (‘Doomed to Failure? UKIP and the Organisational Challenges Facing Right- Wing Populist Anti-Political Establishment Parties’, Parliamentary Affairs, 62(1): 72-87, January 2009) is available online at http://pa.oxfordjournals.org/content/62/1/72.abstract. Amir Abedi Thomas Carl Lundberg Department of Political Science School of Social and Political Sciences Western Washington University Adam Smith Building 516 High Street 40 Bute Gardens Bellingham, WA 98225-9082 University of Glasgow U.S.A. Glasgow G12 8RT +1-360-650-4143 Scotland [email protected] 0141-330 5144 [email protected] Abstract: Using the UK Independence Party (UKIP), we examine the effects of sudden electoral success on an Anti-Political Establishment (APE) party. The pressures of aspiring to government necessitate organisational structures resembling those of mainstream parties, while this aspiration challenges APE parties because they differ not just in terms of their policy profiles, but also in their more ‘unorthodox’ organisational make-up, inextricably linked to their electoral appeal.
    [Show full text]