National Preventive Mechanism
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM 2015 www.ombudsman.ge NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM (NPM), 2015 1 THIS PROJECT IS FUNDED BY THE EUROPEAN UNION The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of the author and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union. 2 NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM (NPM), 2015 CONTENTS 1. REVIEW OF ACTIVITIES CARRIED OUT BY THE NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM ................................................................................................... 7 1.1. PREVENTIVE VISITS .................................................................................. 7 1.2. COMMUNICATION WITH STAKEHOLDERS ............................................. 7 1.3. WORKING METHODOLOGY AND TRAINING OF THE NMP STAFF ........ 12 2. SITUATION IN PENITENTIARY ESTABLISHMENTS ......................................... 15 2.1. GENERAL OVERVIEW ............................................................................... 15 2.2. ILL-TREATMENT IN PENITENTIARY ESTABLISHMENTS .......................... 21 2.3. ORDER AND SAFETY IN PLACES FOR THE DEPRIVATION OF LIBERTY .. 30 2.4. PRISON CONDITIONS ............................................................................... 52 2.5. PENITENTIARY HEALTHCARE .................................................................. 88 2.6. SPECIAL CATEGORIES............................................................................... 128 2.7. CONTACT WITH THE OUTSIDE WORLD .................................................. 156 2.8. REQUEST/COMPLAINT MECHANISMS IN THE PENITENTIARY SYSTEM OF GEORGIA .............................................................................. 171 3. LIBERTY DEPRIVATION ESTABLISHMENT ...................................................... 185 3.1. GENERAL OVERVIEW ............................................................................... 185 3.2. TORTURE AND INHUMANE OR DEGRADING TREATMENT ................... 185 3.3. SECURITY .................................................................................................. 186 3.4. CONDITIONS OF IMPRISONMENT .......................................................... 187 3.5. MEDICAL SERVICE .................................................................................... 190 3.6. REGIME, DISCIPLINARY LIABILITY, INCENTIVES .................................... 192 3.7. CONTACT WITH THE OUTSIDE WORLD .................................................. 194 4. SITUATION IN AGENCIES SUBORDINATED TO THE MINISTRY OF INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF GEORGIA ................................................................... 197 4.1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 197 NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM (NPM), 2015 3 4.2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ......................................................................... 198 4.3. TORTURE AND OTHER INHUMAN TREATMENT ................................. 202 4.4.. PRINCIPAL SAFEGUARDS AGAINST ILL-TREATMENTS ...................... 227 4.5. PROCEDURAL SAFEGUARDS ................................................................ 240 4.6. SITUATION AT TEMPORARY DETENTION ISOLATORS ........................ 259 5. PROTECTION OF MIGRANTS FROM ILL-TREATMENT ..................................... 268 5.1. CONDITIONS IN TEMPORARY ACCOMODATION CENTER .................... 268 5.2. DETENTION AND PLACEMENT IN THE TEMPORARY ACCOMMODATION CENTER .................................................................. 269 5.3. LEGAL SAFEGUARDS FOR DETAINEES .................................................... 270 5.4. CONDITIONS IN TEMPORARY DETENTION CENTERS ............................ 271 5.5. NUTRITION ............................................................................................... 272 5.6. CONTACT WITH THE OUTSIDE WORLD .................................................. 273 5.7. DAILY SCHEDULE AND ACTIVITIES .......................................................... 273 5.8. MONITORING OF THE JOINT OPERATION FOR THE RETURN OF MIGRANTS ............................................................................................... 274 6. HUMAN RIGHTS SITUATION OF ASYLUM SEEKERS, REFUGEES AND HUMANITARIAN STATUS HOLDERS IN GEORGIA ......................................... 277 6.1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................... 277 6.2. GENERAL INFORMATION AND STATISTICS ON ASYLUM SEEKERS, REFUGEES AND HUMANITARIAN STATUS HOLDERS ............................ 278 6.3. LEGISLATIVE REGULATIONS AND THEIR COMPLIANCE WITH THE EUROPEAN STANDARDS, PLANNED CHANGES AND EXISTING SHORTCOMINGS ..................................................................................... 281 6.4. REVIEW OF THE MONITORING RESULTS OF 2015 ................................. 285 7. REPORT ON THE MONITORING OF MENTAL HEALTH INSTITUTIONS ............. 292 7.1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 292 7.2. GENERAL OVERVIEW ........................................................................... 293 7.3. MENTAL HEALTH IN GEORGIA – REFORMS AND CHALLENGES ........ 301 4 NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM (NPM), 2015 7.4. ILL-TREATMENT .................................................................................... 313 7.5. VIOLENCE AMONG THE PATIENTS AND THEIR SAFETY ..................... 319 7.6. PHYSICAL RESTRAINTS, ISOLATION AND CHEMICAL RESTRAINTS ... 323 7.7. MATERIAL CONDITIONS – SANITARY-HYGIENIC CONDITIONS, THERAPEUTIC AND SAFE ENVIRONMENT ............................................ 337 7.8. LEGAL GUARANTEES FOR PROTECTION ............................................. 358 7.9. PSYCHIATRIC CARE ............................................................................... 371 7.10. PERSONNEL ......................................................................................... 395 7.11. SPECIFICITY OF PSYCHIATRIC UNIT FOR CHILDREN ........................ 398 7.12. SPECIFICITY OF THE FORENSIC PSYCHIATRIC UNIT OF B. NANEISHVILI NATIONAL CENTRE OF MENTAL HEALTH ...................... 401 8. THE STATE OF RIGHTS OF ELDERLY PERSONS ................................................... 405 8.1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................... 405 8.2. MONITORING METHODOLOGY .............................................................. 406 8.3. MAIN FINDINGS OF MONITORING ......................................................... 409 8.4. GENERAL OVERVIEW OF LEGAL REGULATIONS .................................... 410 8.5. ABSENCE OF MECHANISM FOR SUPERVISION OF COMPLIANCE WITH STANDARDS ................................................................................... 413 8.6. INFORMATION ABOUT SERVICE DELIVERY (STANDARD №1) ............... 416 8.7. BENEFICIARY-FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT (STANDARD №2), SAFETY AND SANITARY CONDITIONS (STANDARD №3) .................................... 421 8.8. OBSERVING CONFIDENTIALITY (STANDARD №4) ................................. 426 8.9. INDIVIDUAL APPROACH IN SERVICE DELIVERY (STANDARD №5) ........ 428 8.10. CATERING (STANDARD №6) .................................................................. 431 8.11. PROMOTING SOCIAL ACTIVITY (STANDARD №7) ................................ 434 8.12. HEALTH PROTECTION (STANDARD №8) ............................................... 439 8.13. FEEDBACK AND COMPLAINT PROCEDURES (STANDARD №9) ........... 443 8.14. PROTECTION AGAINST VIOLENCE AND DISCRIMINATION (STANDARD №10) .................................................................................... 447 8.15. REQUIREMENTS TO PERSONNEL (STANDARD №11) ........................... 453 NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM (NPM), 2015 5 9. CHILDREN’S RIGHTS MONITORING IN BOARDING HOUSES RUN BY THE GEORGIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH AND THE MUSLIM CONFESSION .... 457 9.1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................... 457 9.2. INTERNAL REGULATIONS AT THE FACILITIES ......................................... 459 9.3. HEALTHCARE ............................................................................................ 467 9.4. FEEDING.................................................................................................... 476 9.5. THE RIGHT TO EDUCATION AND PREPARING FOR INDEPENDENT LIFE ........................................................................................................... 479 9.6. REST, RECREATION AND LEISURE TIME .................................................. 485 9.7. BENEFICIARY ORIENTED ENVIRONMENT .............................................. 488 9.8. EMOTIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND PROTECTION AGAINST VIOLENCE 490 10. RIGHT OF THE CHILD IN SMALL FAMILY TYPE HOUSES ................................ 498 6 NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM (NPM), 2015 1. REVIEW OF ACTIVITIES CARRIED OUT BY THE NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM 1.1. PREVENTIVE VISITS In 2015, Special Preventive Group of the Office of the Public Defender of Georgia, in order to inspect state of human rights protection, conducted 54 visits in 15 penitentiary institutions throughout the country and met with 3 300 inmates; 7 visits in the board- ing schools unders religious denominations and met with 200 children; 10 visits in the small family-type children’s houses and met with 69 children; 7 visits in the specialized residential institutions for elderly persons and met with 150 beneficiaries; 1 visit in the temporary accommodation center of the Migration Department under the Ministry of Interior and met with 18 persons. 2 monitoring