HAPPY VALLEY MILK – Land Use Consent Application

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard 1 J Scott & T 145 Te Raumauku Road Neutral  Lack of specific Proper waste No Kristensen RD3 wastewater management management plan plan tabled and  Traffic Movement explained  Noise Levels Speed restrictions  Light Pollution at SH31 by plant Engine brakes prohibited No burden on ODC ratepayers Screen Planting of factory 2 S & J Oliver 193 State Highway 31 Oppose  Water Supply Not Specified Not Specified Otorohanga  Wastewater  Site Suitability  Traffic Movement 3 A.J Derecourt 23 Harper Avenue Support  Additional business and Not Specified Not Specified Otorohanga growth opportunities 4 C King 16 Road Oppose  Non-compliance with Decline Yes District Plan  Nuisance - Residues - River - Rural Scenery  Traffic  Factory operation - Water Supply - Noise - Shading / Sunlight loss - Employment RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 1

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard - Other consents 5 D.J Eyeington Mr R.G Eyeington Oppose  Not in keeping with Decline Yes C.D Eyeington 229 Ohaupo Road environmental Hamilton, 3206 expectations  Impacts more than minor  Mitigation does not address effects  More information required 6 Andra Neeley 377 Owaikura Road Oppose  Traffic impacts Construction of No RD3 bypass of Otorohanga Otorohanga for heavy traffic 7 Eric Tait P.O Box 79 Support  Otorohanga is a rural town Not Specified Yes Otorohanga needing rural product production  Effects are part of development  Vehicle movements could be caused by development elsewhere 8 Keith Randle Pokuru Road East Support  Potential for Otorohanga Approve Not Specified RD2 is huge Te Kuiti  Financially for local businesses and farmers  New job opportunities 9 Elizabeth Cowan 229 Barber Road Oppose  Wastewater Decline No RD5  Water Otorohanga, 3975  Contradictory information - Dryer sizes - Wastewater treatment facilities

RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 2

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard  Regional Consents  Milk volumes and tanker fleet 10 Trevor Walters 189 Kawhia Road Oppose  Air pollution Decline Yes RD3  Noise pollution Otorohanga, 3973  Land zones  Traffic Safety  Lighting Effects  Lack of Information  Waipa River  Economic and Social Effects 11 Suzie Walters 189 Kawhia Road Oppose  Rural Zone Decline Yes RD3  Air Pollution Otorohanga, 3973  Noise Pollution  Traffic  Lighting  Lack of Information 12 Kent and Joanne 187 Kawhia Road Oppose  Water availability, water Decline Yes Morrissey RD3 quality, air pollution Otorohanga, 3973  Views  Noise  Road Safety  Wastewater  Alternative Sites  Flooding and Pollution  Shading  Setting a Precedent  Economic Environment  Insufficient Information  Lifestyle and Financial RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 3

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard Outcome 13 Vicki Cornelisson 26 Honikiwi Road Oppose  Air Pollution Decline Yes RD3  Traffic Safety Otorohanga, 3973  Noise Pollution  Land Zone  Water and Wastewater 14 Peter Cornelisson 26 Honikiwi Road Oppose  Air Pollution Decline Yes RD3  Traffic Safety Otorohanga, 3973  Noise Pollution  Land Zone  Water and Wastewater 15 Michelle Blundell 30 Honikiwi Road Oppose  Site Selection Decline Yes RD3  Traffic Otorohanga, 3973  Environmental - Water table / wetlands - Town development - Wastewater - Emissions / pollutants - Noise - Rural Character  Visual 16 Phillip Blundell 30 Honikiwi Road Oppose  Environmental Decline Yes RD3  Visual Otorohanga, 3973  Traffic  Employment 17 Paul Prescott C/- Pat Prescott Ltd Support  Economic Benefit Approve No 152 Maniapoto Street Otorohanga 18 W & L Reekers 184 Grice Road Oppose  Site Selection Not Specified Not Specified RD2  River Effects Otorohanga

RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 4

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard 19 Shaun Kohinga 17 Phillips Avenue Support  Employment Approve Not Specified Otorohanga 20 Aria Concrete 431 Totoro Road Support  Employment Approve No Pumping Aria  Business Development 21 John Mildon 64 Road Support  Employment Approve No Otorohanga 22 Allan Pratt 65C Awakino Road Support  Employment Approve No Te Kuiti  Economic Development 23 Paul Wood 6 Gradara Avenue Support  Heavy vehicles must not Instruct HVM to Yes Otorohanga use the main street of keep trucks out of Otorohanga main street 24 Lance Phillips 160 Rangiatea Road Support  Employment Approve No RD2  Competition within dairy Otorohanga industry 25 Aaron Marx P.O Box 209 Oppose  Devaluation Decline Yes Otorohanga  Amenity Values  Visual 26 Lindsay Meredith 65 Whawharua Road Support  Employment Approve No RD5  Economic Growth Otorohanga 27 Ian Robert Gollan P.O Box 228 Support  Impact of water takes Written Yes Otorohanga guarantees and remedies be included in the consent 28 Shirley Dianne Meier 28 Honikiwi Road Oppose  Water Decline No RD3  Visual Otorohanga  Traffic  Noise 29 Hugh Earwaker 427 Greenhill Drive Oppose Lack of Information Decline Yes Te Awamutu, 3800  Water use and source

RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 5

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard  No iwi, neighbour or NZTA consents  Inconsistency with Countryside Living  Proximity to river  Other resource consents not held 30 Richard Harford 6 Hillcrest Avenue Support  Employment Approve No Otorohanga  Economic Benefits 31 Wayne New 3 Hillcrest Avenue Support  Employment Approve No Otorohanga  Economic Benefits 32 Amy New 91 Main North Road Support  Employment Approve No Otorohanga  Economic Benefits 33 Kylie Mouat 6 Domain Drive Support  Economic Sustainability Approve Not Specified Otorohanga  Employment Opportunities  Attraction of people to Otorohanga 34 Scott Mouat P.O Box 187 Support  Long term sustainability of Approve Not Specified Otorohanga Otorohanga 35 Kirsty Fare 364 Old Te Kuiti Road Support  Employment Opportunities Approve Not Specified  If consents approved and all aspects of environment considered there is no reason not to go ahead 36 Rex Fare 364 Old Te Kuiti Road Support  Employment Opportunities Approve Not Specified  Economic Benefits 37 Andrew Baker 640 Ouruwhero Road Oppose  Water Supply Decline Yes  Wastewater 38 Otorohanga Timber P.O Box 18 Support  Progressive development Approve No Company Otorohanga, 3940  Community Benefits 39 Ian Clark 16 Mangamahoe Road Oppose  Water Verify noise Not Specified RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 6

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard RD3  Wastewater figures carefully Otorohanga  Noise Delay consent until WRC consents obtained 40 Ian Groube Austin Road Oppose  Water Take Decline Yes RD3  Effluent Disposal Otorohanga  Traffic Safety  ODC ratepayers should not be held to ransom over ongoing costs of supplying water  Lack of information 41 Marin Walmsley 316 Mangamahoe Road Oppose  Water Not Specified Yes RD3  Wastewater Otorohanga  Traffic 42 Pat Edwards 612 Paewhenua Road Oppose  Fonterra shareholder – Decline No Otorohanga don’t need another company  Wastewater  Water 43 P.O Box 973 Oppose  Shading Decline Yes Transport Agency Mail Centre  Intersections Hamilton, 3240  Intersection Control Attn: Lana Gooderham  Sightline Protection Agreement  Old Golf Road  Tanker Depot  Cycling Route 44 Heather Hammond 82 Otoru Road Oppose  Air Pollution Decline Yes RD2  Noise Pollution

RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 7

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard Otorohanga  Zoning  Water  Flooding & Pollution  Discharge 45 Duncan Coull (Coull 740 Ouruwhero Road Oppose  Water Decline Yes Farms Ltd) RD4  Wastewater Otorohanga  Traffic Movements 46 Alan Rogers 406 Station Road Oppose  Groundwater Decline Yes RD4  Aquifer Effects Otorohanga 47 Andrew Moir (Tihiroa [email protected] Oppose  Water Use Decline Yes Rural Water) 48 Veronica Gibson 25 Ouruwhero Road Oppose  Location Not Specified Not Specified  Noise  Visuals  Wastewater  Water 49 Sharryn R Te 516 Ngahape Road Neutral  Outside Influence Not Specified Yes Atawhai Barton RD3 Te Awamutu 50 Robert Phillips 210 Rangiatea Road Support  Competition Approve No RD2  Employment Otorohanga 51 Peter Burton 41 Maniapoto Street Support  Economic Benefits Approve Not Specified Otorohanga 52 Otorohanga P.O Box 222 Oppose  Water Requirements Decline Not Specified Zoological Society Otorohanga, 3940  Wastewater Requirements  Noise  Light  Traffic and Road Safety  Flooding and Pollution

RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 8

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard 53 Otorohanga District P.O Box 152 Support Not Specified Not Specified No Development Board Otorohanga 54 Michael & Alison 1249 Honikiwi Road Support  Intersection Design Approve with Yes Sellars RD3  Traffic and Access Modifications Otorohanga  Point and Wastewater  Regional Consent 55 K.G Ferris RD5 Oppose  Water Take Decline Yes Te Awamutu  Discharge 56 John & Sue Clark 83 Kio Kio Station Road Support  Economic Benefit Not Specified No RD4 Otorohanga 57 Earl Rattray 667 River Road Neutral  Limit Ratepayer Exposure Proceed with Not Specified Chartwell Care Hamilton, 3210 58 QEII National Trust P.O Box 3341 Neutral  Impact of land use change Consider No Wellington, 6140 on open space values concerns on QEII covenant owners 59 Alastair & Shirley 161 Veale Road Support  Economic Benefits Approve No Bell RD5  Positives outweigh Otorohanga negatives 60 Tessa Walker P.O Box 59 Support Not Specified Not Specified No Otorohanga, 3940 61 Erin Milne P.O Box 182 Support Not Specified Not Specified No Otorohanga 62 Billie-Ann Gadd P.O Box 182 Support  Economic Benefits Not Specified No Otorohanga 63 Lloyd Tahuroa 14 Gradara Avenue Support Not Specified Not Specified No Rangitaawa Otorohanga 64 Wade Humphries 7 Thomson Aveune Support Not Specified Not Specified No Otorohanga 65 Bayley Campbell 4B Turongo Street Support Not Specified Not Specified No Otorohanga RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 9

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard 66 Cheryl ? ? Support Not Specified Not Specified No 67 Social Plan Inc C/- Harkness Henry Oppose  Contrary to Part II RMA Decline Yes Private Bag 3077  Loss of Rural Amenity Hamilton, 3240  Adverse visual and Attn: Jaime Lomas landscape effects  Precedent effect  Adverse traffic effects  Adverse noise effects  Negative impact on Property values  Reverse sensitivity effects  No consideration of alternative sites  Conflict with Countryside Living Policy Area  Uncertainty - Water Supply - Wastewater - Traffic - Contradictory Information  Applicant should be required to apply for all necessary consents concurrently so that all effects can be addressed 68 Nehenehenui RMC P.O Box 151 Support  Subject to ongoing good Approve subject Yes Otorohanga, 3900 faith relationship to cultural impact  Mitigation assessment - Commissioning of Cultural Impact Assessment RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 10

# Submitter Name Submitter Support / Reasons Relief Sought Wish to be Address for Service Oppose heard - Water take application - Effects on air, water, land - Effects on traditional food source - Adverse effects on sites of significance - Discovery protocols - Monitoring protocols - Treatment of sediment laden water  Preference for water use / take consents at same time as this consent 69 Sam Williams & 83 Tihiroa Road Oppose  Traffic Decline Yes Brooke Rako- RD3  Wastewater Williams Otorohanga, 3973  Water Use

RM160079 Happy Valley Milk Ltd Summary of Submissions Received 11