Tithe an Oireachtais Houses of the Oireachtas
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Tithe an Oireachtais An Comhchoiste um Shláinte agus Leanaí Tuarascáil maidir le héisteachtaí i ndáil le Scéim Ghinearálta an Bhille Sláinte Poiblí (Pacáistiú Caighdeánaithe Tobac) Imleabhar 1 Aibreán 2014 ___________________________ Houses of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health and Children Report on hearings in relation to the General Scheme of the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill Volume 1 April 2014 31/HHCN/014 Foreword by the Chairman of the Joint Committee on Health and Children, Jerry Buttimer TD. The purpose of the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill 2013 is to make it mandatory for tobacco to be sold in Standardised Packaging which will greatly increase the health warnings and reduce the ability of tobacco manufacturers to promote their brand. The Minister for Health referred the Heads of Bill to the Joint Committee on Health and Children for consultation with key stakeholders before the Bill is finalised and presented to the Houses of the Oireachtas. The Joint Committee is delighted to have this opportunity to feed into this critical piece of legislation. It allowed members of the Committee to be fully informed and enable us to provide meaningful input into the legislation, make observations and suggestions before the Bill comes before the Dáil and Seanad. It has also been an opportunity for interested groups and stakeholders to contribute to the drafting of this legislation. Tobacco packaging has been described at the last billboard for the tobacco industry and this legislation will force the industry to show with greater clarity, the devastating effects of smoking on health. Committee members have seen for themselves the packets of various shapes, sizes and colours used by tobacco companies to attract young people to take up smoking. Standardised packaging with much larger health warnings will act as a deterrent. Every year 5,200 Irish people die from diseases caused by smoking. Protecting our children and young people from taking up smoking is a key policy for the Minister for Health, and one which this Committee strongly supports. There is a wealth of international evidence on the effects of tobacco packaging in general and on perceptions and reactions to standardised packaging which support the introduction of this measure. As part of the wider consultation process, the Committee held public hearings with various interest groups and stakeholders to obtain their input. We believe that our intensive scrutiny of this subject over the last number of months, culminating in the publication of this report, will assist the Minister and the Government in their further consideration and formulation of this legislation. I would like to record our appreciation to the many different interest groups who made both oral and written submissions to the Joint Committee in its preparation of this report. I would also like to acknowledge the contribution of Ms. Monica Boyle, from the Oireachtas Library & Research Service for her assistance with this body of work, the Clerk to the Committee and the staff of the Committee Secretariat in the Houses of the Oireachtas for their assistance in its compilation. The Joint Committee presents this report to the Minister for Health as its contribution to the formulation of this critically important legislation. __________________ Jerry Buttimer, T.D., Chairman, Joint Committee on Health and Children. 3rd April 2014 st 31 Dáil Members of Joint Committee on Health and Children DEPUTIES Jerry Buttimer TD CHAIRMAN (Fine Gael) Catherine Byrne TD Ciara Conway TD Regina Doherty TD Clare Daly TD (Fine Gael) VICE CHAIR (Fine Gael) (Independent) (Labour) Robert Dowds TD Peter Fitzpatrick TD Seamus Healy TD Billy Kelleher TD (Labour) (Fine Gael) (Independent - (Fianna Fáil) WUAG) Eamonn Maloney Sandra McLellan TD Sinn Féin (Labour) Mary Mitchell Dan Neville TD Caoimhghín Ó Robert Troy TD O’Connor TD (Fine Gael) Caoláin TD (Fianna Fáil) (Fine Gael) (Sinn Féin) Senators Senator Colm Burke Senator John Crown Senator John Gilroy Senator Imelda Henry (Fine Gael) (Independent) (Labour) (Fine Gael) Senator Marc Senator Jillian Van MacSharry Turnhout (Fianna Fáil) (Independent) Table of Contents of Volume 1 and Volume 2 VOLUME 1 SECTION 1: REPORT OF THE JOINT COMMITTEE SECTION 2: LIST OF THOSE WHO PRESENTED TO THE COMMITTEE SECTION 3: ORAL PRESENTATIONS SECTION 4: TRANSCRIPTS OF MEETINGS SECTION 5: TERMS OF REFERENCE VOLUME 2 APPENDIX 1: LIST OF THOSE WHO SUBMITTED TO THE COMMITTEE APPENDIX 2: SUBMISSIONS Table of Contents of Volume One Section 1 Report of the Joint Committee……………………………………… 1 Section 2 List of those who presented to the Committee……… 91 Section 3 Oral Presentations………………………………………………………… 93 Assistant Commissioner Derek Byrne, An Garda Síochána………… 95 Detective Chief Superintendent Eugene Corcoran, An Garda Síochána Detective Chief Superintendent Padraig Kennedy, An Garda Síochána Gerard Moran, Office of the Revenue Commissioners……………….. 103 Emma Clutterbuck, Office of the Revenue Commissioners Michael Gilligan, Office of the Revenue Commissioners Gavin Maguire, Health Service Executive…………………………………… 107 Laura Garvey, Health Service Executive Kathleen O’Meara, Irish Cancer Society…………………………………….. 109 Chris Macey, Irish Heart Foundation………………………………………….. 112 Sharon Cosgrove, Asthma Society of Ireland………………………….… 105 Niamh Kelly, Asthma Society of Ireland Dr. Ross Morgan, ASH Ireland……………………………………………………. 117 Norma Cronin, ASH Ireland Damien Peelo, COPD Support Ireland………………………………………… 121 Paul Gilligan, Children’s Rights Alliance…………………………………….. 124 Cliona O Neill, Tipperary Regional Youth Service……………………… 130 Danielle Gayson, Tipperary Regional Youth Service Amy Maher, Tipperary Regional Youth Service Caroline O’Sullivan, ISPCC………………………………………………………….. 133 Dr Matthew Sadlier, Irish Medical organisation (IMO)………………. 135 Dr Anthony O’Regan, Irish Thoracic Society………………………………. 137 Owen Metcalfe, Institute of Public Health in Ireland………………….. 142 Dr Helen McAvoy, Institute of Public Health in Ireland Dr. Patrick Doorley, Royal College of Physicians of Ireland………. 145 Prof Luke Clancy, TobaccoFree Research Institute Ireland……….. 148 Dr Kate Babineau, TobaccoFree Research Institute Ireland Dr. Finbarr O’Connell, St James's Hospital…………………………………. 155 Tara Buckley, Retail Grocery Dairy & Allied Trades Association (RGDATA)…………………………………………………………………………………….. 160 Sharon Higgins, Ibec…………………………………………………………………… 162 Joe Sweeney, National Federation of Retail Newsagents Ireland…………………………………………………………………………………………. 166 Vincent Jennings, Convenience Stores and Newsagent Association…………………………………………………………………………………… 169 Paul Candon, Retail Excellence Ireland……………………………………… 172 Mike Ridgway……………………………………………………………………………… 174 Steven Donaldson, PJ Carroll and Company Limited………………… 182 Ronald Ridderbeekx, PJ Carroll and Company Limited Andrew Meagher, John Player & Sons Ltd…………………………………… 186 Dr. Axel Gietz, Imperial Tobacco John Freda, JTI Ireland Limited…………………………………………………… 189 Michiel Reerink, JTI Ireland Limited John Mallon, Forest Éireann…………………………………………………………. 194 Ken Murphy, Law Society of Ireland ……………………………………………. 197 John P. Shaw, Law Society of Ireland Section 4 Transcripts of Meetings…………………………………………..…. 203 Meeting of the 23 January 2014………………………………………………… 205 Meeting of the 30 January 2014………………………………………………… 229 Meeting of the 6 February 2014………………………………………………… 264 Meeting of the 13 February 2014………………………………………………. 313 Section 5 Terms of Reference ………………………………………….………… 357 Section 1: Report of the Joint Committee on Health and Children 1 2 Report of the Joint Committee on Health and Children General Scheme of the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill 2013 i 3 Contents 1. Conclusions and Recommendations ........................................................................ 5 2. Overview ................................................................................................................. 8 2.1 Key legislative and policy initiatives to date ................................................. 9 2.2 Legislating for the standardised/plain packaging of tobacco products ....... 11 3. Smoking - key facts and figures ............................................................................. 13 4. The General Scheme of the Bill .............................................................................. 17 4.1 General points ........................................................................................... 17 4.2 The General Scheme of the Public Health (Standardised Packaging of Tobacco) Bill 2013 ............................................................................... 18 5. Current law and policy............................................................................................. 20 5.1 Tobacco control and regulation ................................................................. 20 5.1.1 Ireland ................................................................................. 20 5.1.2 Ireland’s European and international obligations ............ 20 5.1.3 Australia .............................................................................. 24 5.1.4 The United Kingdom (UK) ................................................. 28 5.1.5 New Zealand ....................................................................... 29 5.1.6 Legal challenges to tobacco control and regulation ....... 29 Ireland ............................................................................................. 30 Australia .........................................................................................