DOCSLIB.ORG

The Historiography of Qalʿat Simʿān: a Curiously Under-Studied Field

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Historiography of Qalʿat Simʿān: a Curiously Under-Studied Field _full_alt_author_running_head (neem stramien B2 voor dit chapter en nul 0 in hierna): 0 _full_alt_articletitle_running_head (oude _articletitle_deel, vul hierna in): Introduction _full_article_language: en indien anders: engelse articletitle: 0 28 Loosley Leeming Chapter 2 The Historiography of Qalʿat Simʿān: a Curiously Under-Studied Field Emma Loosley Leeming In his seminal article ‘The Rise and Function of the Holy religious belief was increasingly explored in order to Man in Late Antiquity’1 Peter Brown introduced the figure understand, as far as possible, what early practitioners of Symeon Stylites to a whole new generation. As the end of Judaism or Christianity would have been thinking as of the twentieth century saw a rise in the number of peo- they went on pilgrimage or entered a sacred space for the ple studying late antiquity, largely down to the re-imagin- first time. The 1990s saw the rise of the phenomenologi- ing of this period first championed by Brown, Symeon cal approach to archaeology and the sense of place and became the poster boy of the movement seeking to re- how worshippers perceived the numinous became key aca- claim the era from the negative connotations it had car- demic debates.4 Indeed the final decades of the twentieth ried since Gibbon. In fact this new research indicated that century were also a period when a number of theorists the period between the ending of the Roman Empire and sought to define how the concept of sacred space began rise of medieval kingdoms was anything but the ‘dark in the first place.5 Bearing this in mind, one would have ages’ of popular imagination. expected this interest in the person of Symeon to have de- This flurry of late antique studies brought the enigmat- veloped to encompass the place with which he was syn- ic figure of Symeon Stylites ever closer to us with his vita onymous; the hill on the northwest limestone massif of made widely available in cheap English editions for the Syria that is known today as Qalʿat Simʿān, or in English, first time. In 1985 Theodoret’s History of the Monks of Syr- the Castle of Symeon. ia2 was published as an affordable paperback giving a new On encountering the story of Symeon for the first time generation of students the chance to read Theodoret’s ac- as a student in the middle of the 1990s, I immediately count of his personal relationship with Symeon amongst wanted to know more about the places linked to this in- many other stories of ‘spiritual athletes’ resident in fifth credible personage. Theodoret’s account and the Syriac century Syria. In 1992 this was followed by a volume that vita firmly place the events of his life in a concrete earthly brought the three vitae of Symeon Stylites together in one setting. They tell us that Symeon was from the village of translated and annotated English edition for the first Telanissos and that he joined the monastery of Tell ʿĀde time.3 Here the reader could compare the testimony of on the southern flank of Jebel Sheikh Barakat, before be- Thedoret with that by the writer of the much longer Syriac ing banished for the extremity of his ascetic practices and vita and another shorter account purportedly recorded by finally settling on an outcrop to the north of the moun- one Antonius, who claimed to be a disciple of Symeon. Yet tain.6 These places are known and easily identifiable to strangely whilst the figure of Symeon himself came out of this day and allow the modern-day pilgrim to retrace the obscurity and increasingly caught the imagination of steps of Symeon’s journey and yet, when it came to trying scholars of late antiquity, inspiring a range of research to learn more about the locations pivotal to Symeon’s life, centring on why and how one man could spend thirty six there was surprisingly little written about these sites. In years of his life stood upright on a high column, this in- fact almost the sole source of information was Georges creasing fascination with the man did not appear to trans- Tchalenko’s three volume Villages antiques de la Syrie du fer into a study of place. Nord. Le Massif du Bélus à l’époque romaine.7 This is surprising because the same period that saw the rise of late antique studies also saw a growth in stud- 4 The italicized words represent some of the buzzwords of this intel- ies relating to ritual theory. The experiential element of lectual movement. Phenomenology is normally said to have entered archaeological theory with Christopher Tilley’s A Phenomenology of Landscape: Places, Paths and Monuments, Berg; Oxford, 1994. 1 Peter Brown, ‘The Rise and Function of the Holy Man in Late 5 See Jonathan Z. Smith, To Take Place: Toward Theory in Ritual, Antiquity’, The Journal of Roman Studies 61 (1971), pp. 80–101. University of Chicago Press; Chicago, 1987. 2 Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Trans. Price, R.M., A History of the Monks of 6 The Syriac Life, 25–26, p.116 in The Lives of Simeon Stylites, Cistercian Syria, Cistercian Publications; Kalamazoo, 1985. Publications; Kalamazoo, 1992. 3 Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Antonius and Anonymous, Trans. Doran, R., 7 Georges Tchalenko, Villages antiques de la Syrie du Nord. Le Massif The Lives of Simeon Stylites, Cistercian Publications; Kalamazoo, du Bélus à l’époque romaine. Bibliothèque archéologique et histo- 1992. rique 50, Paul Geuthner; Paris, 1953. © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2019 | doi:10.1163/9789004388451_003 The Historiography Of Qalʿat Simʿān: A Curiously Under-studied Field 29 This monumental three volume survey comprised one Returning home to the United Kingdom I resolved to book of textual descriptions of each village with a sum- research the site in greater depth but found that aside mary of the monuments present both in the village itself from periodic excavation updates and articles on specific and in its immediate vicinity – from the most high status aspects of the site there was little to be found. As the bib- buildings such as churches and the villas of local landown- liography in this volume demonstrates this remains a ers, down to the more humble olive presses and cisterns. problem; in researching this list there are only two publi- These texts also took pains to note any extant inscrip- cations devoted entirely to the site – and these are fasci- tions that could furnish evidence relating to dates and cles for volume four of the final excavation report dealing patrons. The two companion volumes comprised a book with metallic objects and glass respectively.10 The prob- of maps and architectural drawings, both floorplans and lem twenty years on remains the same as when I first dis- isometric projections, of key monuments and another of covered Symeon Stylites as a young student; the man has Tchalenko’s black and white photographs taken from the received copious attention from academics wishing to un- late 1930s onwards as he undertook his fieldwork in the derstand his religious and psychological motivation and region. In the entry on Qalʿat Simʿān the brief text outlin- how his life caught the imagination of his contemporaries, ing the history of the site was extremely helpful, but even but the place has attracted less attention. Intriguingly this more useful were the isometric drawings that explained is the inverse of the events of 459 when Symeon died. how the complex had evolved until it reached its finished Then an unseemly tussle took place over who should take form under the patronage of the Emperor Zeno at the custody of the body11 with Symeon’s mortal remains car- end of the fifth century. As many others had discovered ried away to be placed in a new martyrium, where they before me, whilst Tchalenko had laid the groundwork for were to bring reflected honour on the city of Antioch. the study of Qalʿat Simʿān and the surrounding area, little However, in a break with the normal practice of shrines progress appeared to have been made in the study of the centring on the physical remnants of a holy figure, it was monument since he published Villages antiques. As a doc- eventually the column rather than Symeon’s earthly re- toral student living in Aleppo in the late 1990s, I took the mains that became the locus sancta for the cult of the opportunity to visit the Limestone Massif as frequently as saint. Intriguingly here in the early twenty-first century we possible and made multiple visits to Qalʿat Simʿān. Scout- seemed to have moved full circle and the fascination with ing the bookshops attached to the National Museum of the person of Symeon has clearly relegated the site of his Aleppo, the Citadel and any other historical site in the city ascetic feats to only a secondary importance. I searched for literature about late antique Syria in gen- With the outbreak of the Syrian Civil War in 2011 the eral and was pleased to find a full-colour catalogue of the practice of archaeology in Syria was not completely halt- Dura Europos Synagogue frescoes for sale in the Citadel, ed, but obviously it had to undergo a radical change in but material on Qalʿat Simʿān proved elusive. Saouf and methods and it was severely limited. The dangers of field- Shaʿath’s works8 were helpful as guidebooks on site, but work have meant that foreign archaeologists have been largely reproduced Tchalenko’s original drawings and did prevented from entering all or most of the country.12 The not really add to academic knowledge of the site. In ad- fact that Qalʿat Simʿān is located relatively close to the dition Ḥajjār’s9 book was first published in Aleppo whilst Turkish border and the Kurdish region in the Afrin Valley, I lived in the city, but a meeting with the author demon- as well as being in the vicinity of Aleppo, the second city strated that, as an engineer and amateur historian, this of Syria, has meant that the site has been caught in the volume lacked the specialist archaeological analysis that crossfire of the fighting and been significantly damaged at I was searching for.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Syria, a Country Study
    Syria, a country study Federal Research Division Syria, a country study Table of Contents Syria, a country study...............................................................................................................................................1 Federal Research Division.............................................................................................................................2 Foreword........................................................................................................................................................5 Preface............................................................................................................................................................6 GEOGRAPHY...............................................................................................................................................7 TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATIONS....................................................................................8 NATIONAL SECURITY..............................................................................................................................9 MUSLIM EMPIRES....................................................................................................................................10 Succeeding Caliphates and Kingdoms.........................................................................................................11 Syria.............................................................................................................................................................12
    [Show full text]
  • OOT 2020: [The Search for a Middle Clue] Written and Edited by George Charlson, Nick Clanchy, Oli Clarke, Laura Cooper, Daniel D
    OOT 2020: [The Search for a Middle Clue] Written and edited by George Charlson, Nick Clanchy, Oli Clarke, Laura Cooper, Daniel Dalland, Alexander Gunasekera, Alexander Hardwick, Claire Jones, Elisabeth Le Maistre, Matthew Lloyd, Lalit Maharjan, Alexander Peplow, Barney Pite, Jacob Robertson, Siân Round, Jeremy Sontchi, and Leonie Woodland. THE ANSWER TO THE LAST TOSS-UP SHOULD HAVE BEEN: phase transitions Packet 2 Toss-ups: 1. A work by Cavalli-Sforza and Feldman argues that a type of this process can be used to explain changes in the Italian birth rate. A 2005 book by Richardson and Boyd is partly named for the cultural form of this process. A work titled Unto Others attempts to explain altruistic behaviour as a result of this process. That work is critiqued in Burying the Vehicle, which emphasizes the importance of ‘replicators’ in this process. In The Selfish Gene, Richard Dawkins argues that this process takes place at the level of the gene. For 10 points, name this biological process, the change in heritable characteristics over time. ANSWER: evolution [accept natural selection] <GDC> 2. Susan Sontag described how the form of a film by this director ‘resists being reduced to a ‘story’’. In another film by this director, a game of Russian roulette ends anticlimactically when it is revealed that the revolver is filled with soot. This director of Smiles of a Summer Night directed another film in which the protagonist is told he is ‘guilty of guilt’. That film concerns a road trip in which Isak suffers a series of nightmares about impending death on his way to pick up an honorary degree.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Katherine Barymow January 9, 2017 ARC 499: Capstone Seminar Paths for Refugee Rehabilitation in the ISIS Free Zone INTRODUCTION There is little doubt that the Syrian civil war has catalyzed what experts and onlookers now consider the greatest humanitarian crisis in the 21st century. Per the UNHCR, the UN Refugee relief agency supporting refugee camps across the globe, roughly half of Syria’s 22 million pre-war population has been displaced, most which have fled to neighboring countries of Lebanon, Jordan, Turkey and beyond to seek refuge. 13.5 million of these people, whether unable to leave their homes or awaiting permission to do so, are in dire need of international support from non-for-profit relief agencies struggling to provide basic necessities of food, water, electricity and shelter (UNHCR.org). Unfortunately for these refugees, seeking shelter in foreign nations is rarely a positive experience. Refugee camps, with tents meant to house displaced peoples for a duration not to exceed two to three years, are overrun with hygienic crises, crime and suffering due to the relatively uncontrolled growth of refugee registrations and overburdening influx of peoples into camps already saturated with struggling families. In a period where developed nations have the greatest amount of access to media covering refugee issues, including photographs, videos and testimonials, even the most charitable nations in the world feel increasingly unable to provide contributions. Perhaps more tellingly, these nations are also growing increasingly ambivalent to the complex political scenarios involved in our leaders’ decisions and political savvy to truly make a difference. These worries are not without logical grounds or merit; the situation has simply grown far too complex for a non-expert to form an educated opinion about the consequences of each nation’s complex political maneuvers.
    [Show full text]
  • Contemporary Problems of Social Work №3 2019
    Contemporary Problems of Social Work ACADEMIC JOURNAL Vol. 5. No. 3 (19) 2019 MOSCOW CONTEMPORARY PROBLEMS OF SOCIAL WORK CONTENTS Volume 5, No. 3 (19), 2019 ECONOMY ISSN 2412-5466 Sirotskiy A.A. Combination of Requirements The journal is included into the system for Information Security to Business Processes of Russian science citation index and is in Financial Credit Institutions.................. 4 available on the website: www.elibrary.ru Ziroyan M.A., Tinyakova V.I., Tusova A.E. Basic Principles and Opportunities for Adaptive DOI 10.17922/2412-5466-2019-5-3 and Imitation Modeling of Economic Processes......11 CHIEF EDITOR Frolova E.V. PEDAGOGY doctor of sociological sciences, associate professor, Russian Marilyn Maksoud, Ivanova E.Yu. State Social University, Russia Church Culture and Orthodox Music in Syria . 17 DEPUTY EDITOR Rogach O.V. SOCIOLOGY candidate of sociological sciences, Russian State Social University, Bellatrix Alicia Olvera Bernal Russia Where is Mexico’s Foreign Policy Pointing Towards? . .22 EDITORIAL BOARD Chekmarev M.A. Feber J. (PhD, University of Trnava, The Sphere of Security in the Relations Slovakia) of the Russia and Vietnam: Mirsky J. (PhD, Ben-Gurion University The Frameworks of Cooperation of the Negev, Israel) and Solutions to Problems . .30 Moore Alan Thomas (Bachelor of Hench D.Ya. Arts (Hons), M.A., leading to the NATO Bloc Policy in EU Countries.................35 Capital FM 105.3, Ireland) Nikiporets-Takigawa G.Yu. (PhD, Mohaiuddin Farzami professor, University of Cambridge, UK) US Foreign Policy About Central Asia Petrucijová J. (PhD, University of After Incident 11 September 2001 . .39 Ostrava, Czech Republic) Sarbalaev A.M.
    [Show full text]
  • Maronite Music: History, Transmission, and Performance Practice
    MUSIC Maronite Music: History, Transmission, and Performance Practice Guilnard Moufarrej University of Califomia, Merced IN MEMORY OF REVEREND LOUIS HAGE his essay discusses the music of the Maronite Church, a Christian church I based in Lebanon. It provides an overview of the chants used in religious services and examines their transmission and performance practice. The Maronites have always faced challenges to maintain their identity and pre- serve their heritage while adapting to their cultural milieu. Their religious music reflects the dichotomy between safeguarding tradition and accepting contemporary trends. Since the late nineteenth century. Maronites looking for better opportunities and political freedom have increasingly immi- grated to the New World, where they face new challenges to preserving their religious identity while assimilating to the culture of their new home- land. Therefore, this essay reaches beyond the traditional geographic boundaries of the Maronite Church in Lebanon to examine issues in the transmission of Maronite music in the diaspora. Overview of the Maronite Church The Maronite Church is a branch of the Syro-Antiochean Church and one of the earliest distinct eastern churches. The term "Maronite" derives from the monastery of Bayt Marün (House of Maron) built in the fifth century 196 MESA I ROM ES I 44 2 I 2010 in the valley of the Orontes, near Apameus, in northern Syria. Maronites believe that this monastery was built in honor of Saint Maron (d. 410), an anchorite' who lived on a mountain near Apameus; his austerity and miracles made him a celebrity.^ His followers took part in the doctrinal discussions ofthe period, which led to their persecution by other Christian sects.
    [Show full text]
  • Medieval Painting in the Lebanon
    TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgments 1 Introduction 3 Chapter I: History and Documentation of the Paintings 5 A. Political Factors 6 B. Religious Factors 8 1) The Maronites 8 2) The East Syrians (Nestorians) 10 3) Syrian Orthodox, West Syrians or Jacobite 10 4) The Greek Orthodox and Melchites 11 5) The Abyssinians 11 C. Effects of Climate and Geography 13 D. Commerce and Trade 14 E. Tripoli as a Center of Learning 15 F. Historical Documents and Sources 17 1) Inscriptions 17 2) The Language of the Inscriptions 17 (i) Greek Inscriptions 17 (ii) Syriac Inscriptions 18 (iii) Latin Inscriptions 19 3) Written Sources 19 Chapter II: Architecture 21 A. Architectural Styles 21 B. The Prothesis and the Diaconicon 21 1) Mar Saba, Edde, Batroun 21 2) Mar Charbel, Ma'ad 22 3) Mar Girgius, Raskida 23 C. Double-Naved Churches 23 1) Double-Naved Churches in the Lebanon 23 2) The Church with a Double Apse and a Single Nave 24 3) The Double Basilica Church 24 4) Double-Naved Churches Outside the Lebanon 25 3) The Purpose of Double-Naved Churches 26 D. Summary 28 E. Problems of Restoration and Authenticity (by Jean Yasmine) 28 Chapter III: Questions of Iconography 31 A. The Main Apse 32 1) The Majestas Domini 32 2) The Deesis 34 3) The Virgin Blachernitissa and the Burning Bush 36 4) The Cross 37 5) The Anastasis 39 (i) Mar Phocas, Amioun 39 (ii) Mart Shmuni 41 B. The Side Apses 42 1) The Enthroned Virgin with Child, the Nikopoios 42 2) The Galaktotrophousa 43 3) The Baptism 46 C.
    [Show full text]
  • From Ulysses to S. Simeon Stylites: Cavafy's Debt to Tennyson
    From Ulysses to S. Simeon Stylites: Cavafy’s debt to Tennyson DAVID RICKS With the single exception of Browning, no modern poet overshadowed Cavafy as Tennyson did, and we can document this relationship with unusual clarity and richness, because we possess not just the relevant poems of Cavafy but some critical comments written in parallel. It is noteworthy, however, that neither of the two poems of Cavafy most obviously and tensely indebted to Tennyson was included in his collected poems, and we shall explore the implications of this in some detail. For the young Cavafy, Tennyson was the Poet Laureate of the colonial power and of the land of his, however scratchy, education; but he was also a poet who had devoted his copious energies to two strands which would preoccupy Cavafy. The first was his recourse to the Odyssey myth, which would stimulate Cavafy to ‘Ithaca’, his best-known poem; the second was an attempt in ‘St Simeon Stylites’ to capture the spirit of (certainly medieval, and perhaps all) Christianity, against which Cavafy, late in his career, wrote a quiet but firm riposte in his ‘Simeon’. Cavafy’s rejected poem, ‘Second Odyssey’ (1894, but only published a century later) both expresses a debt to Tennyson (who had died in 1892) in the epigraph and is evidently under its thrall – yet it can help us reach a much better understanding of the celebrated ‘Ithaca’. Second Odyssey Dante, Inferno, Canto XXVI Tennyson, ‘Ulysses’ A second Odyssey, a great one, and greater than the first, perhaps. And yet, alas, without a Homer, without hexameters.
    [Show full text]
  • Susan Ashbrook Harvey: Publication List A. Books Oxford Handbook Of
    Susan Ashbrook Harvey: publication list a. Books Oxford Handbook of Early Christian Studies, co-editor with David G. Hunter (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008). Scenting Salvation: Ancient Christianity and the Olfactory Imagination (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2006). Holy Women of the Syrian Orient, co-authored with S.P. Brock (Berkeley: University of California Press 1987). Updated paperback edition with new Preface (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998). Arabic edition, Cadmus Publishing and Distribution (in conjunction with the Syrian Orthodox Archdiocese of Aleppo), Damascus, 2000. Romanian edition, Editura Sofia, Bucarest, 2005. Asceticism and Society in Crisis: John of Ephesus and the 'Lives of the Eastern Saints' (Berkeley: University of California Press 1990). Volume Editor for the Writings of the Greco-Roman World Series, Scholars Press: The Rabbula Corpus, ed. and trans. Cornelia Horn and Robert Phenix, Jr. (Scholars Press, 2008). The Acts of Mar Mari, ed. and trans. Amir Harrak (Scholars Press, 2005). b. Chapters in Books / Encyclopedia entries “Holy Impudence, Sacred Desire: the Women of Matthew 1: 1-16 in Syriac Tradition,” in If These Stones Could Speak: Texts and Contexts, ed. George Kalantzis and Thomas Martin (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press, 2009). “Incense and Olfactory Experience in Worship,” Cambridge Dictionary of Christianity, ed. Daniel Patte (Cambridge University Press, forthcoming). "Hagiography," "John of Ephesus," "Monasticism," "Rabbula of Edessa “, “Theodora”, “Women in Syriac Tradition,” for the Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage, ed. Sebastian Brock, George Kiraz and Lucas Van Rompay (Gorgias Press, forthcoming). "Housekeeping: An Ascetic Theme in Late Antiquity," "To Train His Spirit with Books": Studies in Syrian Asceticism in honor of Sidney H.
    [Show full text]
  • Pna 34/2019 79 Artiklar
    THE PSEUDO-ROMANOS KONTAKION ON SYMEON STYLITES THE ELDER Charles Kuper ([email protected]) Thesaurus linguae Latinae Abstract: ComPared to the authentic kontakia of Romanos the Melodist, whose imPortance has been illustrated by recent studies, the corresponding pseudepigraphic tra- dition has received very little scholarly attention. One reason for this lacuna is the comPlete lack of translations into any modern language. This article repre- sents a first steP in correcting this gaP by including a brief introduction and full translation of one of these texts, the hagiograPhical Kontakion on Symeon Stylites the Elder. The Poetic form of the kontakion has two effects on the Presentation of this saint’s life. Its shorter length and divisions into stroPhae distill the narrative into a brisk, manageable story, and its literary language elevates the diction to match its lofty subject. Symeon’s withdrawal from the world, his ascension of the column, his subsequent asceticism and miracles, and the circumstances of his death and burial are all treated in turn, but the anonymous hymnographer also added his or her own Personal touch. Most notable is the extended ePisode about Symeon’s mother. In her tragic visit to the column, she relays a message to her son in direct sPeech, a first in the tradition for Symeon the Elder. Her sanctity is also Put on equal footing with her son’s. This hymn contributes to our understanding of later devotion to Symeon and the evolution of Byzantine kontakia post-Romanos. Key words: Byzantine poetry, Greek
    [Show full text]
  • Saint Simeon the Stylite: a Psychiatric Examination of the Life of a Fifth Century Monk
    Jefferson Journal of Psychiatry Volume 14 Issue 2 Article 6 January 1999 Saint Simeon the Stylite: A Psychiatric Examination of the Life of a Fifth Century Monk Iracema Leroi M.D. Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia Joseph B. A. Meagher M.D., M.R.C. (Psych) FRCPC Dalhousei University, Halifax, Nova Scotia; Nova Scotia Hospital, Dartmouth, Nova Scotia Follow this and additional works at: https://jdc.jefferson.edu/jeffjpsychiatry Part of the Psychiatry Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ouy Recommended Citation Leroi, Iracema M.D. and Meagher, Joseph B. A. M.D., M.R.C. (Psych) FRCPC (1999) "Saint Simeon the Stylite: A Psychiatric Examination of the Life of a Fifth Century Monk," Jefferson Journal of Psychiatry: Vol. 14 : Iss. 2 , Article 6. DOI: https://doi.org/10.29046/JJP.014.2.003 Available at: https://jdc.jefferson.edu/jeffjpsychiatry/vol14/iss2/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Jefferson Digital Commons. The Jefferson Digital Commons is a service of Thomas Jefferson University's Center for Teaching and Learning (CTL). The Commons is a showcase for Jefferson books and journals, peer-reviewed scholarly publications, unique historical collections from the University archives, and teaching tools. The Jefferson Digital Commons allows researchers and interested readers anywhere in the world to learn about and keep up to date with Jefferson scholarship. This article has been accepted for inclusion in Jefferson Journal of Psychiatry by an authorized administrator of the Jefferson Digital Commons. For more information, please contact: [email protected]. Saint Simeon the Stylite: A Psychiatric Examination ofthe Life ofa Fifth Century Monk Iracema Leroi, M.D.
    [Show full text]
  • ASOR Cultural Heritage Initiatives (CHI): Planning for Safeguarding Heritage Sites in Syria and Iraq1
    ASOR Cultural Heritage Initiatives (CHI): Planning for Safeguarding Heritage Sites in Syria and Iraq1 NEA-PSHSS-14-001 Weekly Report 93–94 — May 11 - 24, 2016 Michael D. Danti, Allison Cuneo, Susan Penacho, Bijan Rouhani, Amr Al-Azm, Marina Gabriel, Kyra Kaercher, Jamie O’Connell with consultation from Thomas Livoti Executive Summary During the reporting period, DigitalGlobe satellite imagery revealed that Russian military forces occupied the archaeological site of Palmyra, specifically the area known as the Northern Necropolis within the UNESCO World Heritage site boundaries. Russian forces have constructed a paved military base that includes multiple structures, a helicopter landing pad, roadways (paved and unpaved), earthen berms, and fences. Areas within and around the base are being used for light and heavy vehicle parking. The Russian Ministry of Defense (MOD) has described this construction as a temporary camp for sappers to clear the site of mines laid by ISIL militants during their occupation, although the Russian MOD has not specified the length of time the base will be operational. While the ongoing mine clearing operation is necessary, the site’s militarization exposes the fragile and poorly preserved archaeological remains in the Northern Necropolis to other threats. Camp Alpha, built by United States military forces in April 2003 on the archaeological site of Babylon in Iraq and later transferred to Polish military forces in September 2003, provides a comparative case study. Assessments of the damage have been undertaken by the United States Department of State,2 the British Museum,3 archaeologists attached to Polish forces,4 and UNESCO,5 all detailing the negative impacts of militarization.
    [Show full text]
  • ASOR Syrian Heritage Initiative (SHI): Planning for Safeguarding Heritage Sites in Syria1 NEA-PSHSS-14-001
    ASOR Syrian Heritage Initiative (SHI): Planning for Safeguarding Heritage Sites in Syria1 NEA-PSHSS-14-001 Weekly Report 6 – September 15, 2014 Michael D. Danti and Kurt W. Prescott Heritage Timeline September 14, 2014 APSA posted photos showing the destruction of a Sufi Maqam and tombs in Abu Qalqal by Islamic State. SHI Incident Report 14-030 http://www.apsa2011.com/index.php/en/provinces/aleppo/m onuments.html • Heritage for Peace posted its newsletter Damage to Syria’s Heritage 14 September 2014. September 11, 2014 DGAM posted a second overview of vandalism at St. Simeon (Samaan Jabal) in the Aleppo countryside, focusing on Zarzarita, Fadra, Sett Rum, Rafadeh, Taqla, Kafr, Bazid, and Batota (16 photographs). SHI Incident Report 14-029 http://www.dgam.gov.sy/?d=314&id=1413 September 10, 2014 DGAM posted an overview of damages at St. Simeon (Samaan Jabal) in the Aleppo countryside, detailing destruction at St. Samaan Castle, St. Simeon Monastery, The Triumphal Arch, and the Public Baths. http://www.dgam.gov.sy/?d=314&id=1411 • APSA posted a video showing excavations via bulldozer at the UNESCO World Heritage Site Palmyra. SHI Incident Report SHI14-027 http://www.apsa2011.com/index.php/en/provinces/homs/pal myra/956-palmyra-excavations-by-bulldozer-in-the- archaeological-area-10-09-2014.html 1 This report is based on research conducted by the “Syria Preservation Initiative: Planning for Safeguarding Heritage Sites in Syria.” Weekly reports reflect reporting from a variety of sources and may contain unverified material. As such, they should be treated as preliminary and subject to change.
    [Show full text]