“More than you need to know?”

Chapter Three

The reported occurrences of mescaline

Trichocereus peruvianus P.C.Hutchison 543 Collected in the canyon of the Río Rímac, Huarochiri Prov., Peru. 1700m.

93 Sacred Cacti 3rd ed.

Lophophora williamsii echinata and Trichocereus bridgesii SSO2 94 Chapter 3: The mescaline containing

The Distribution & Occurrence of Mescaline

Readers will quickly notice that the following section is weak or potent have on occasion proved to be just the lacking the entries for the Trichocereus species. opposite!] These now form another book: San Pedro & related Often the only data included is whether the was Trichocereus species. ie Sacred Cacti Part B. cultivated or collected from the wild. In many early papers We hope that the splitting of this work into separate books we literally have to rely on the word of the workers as to the does not cause our readers too much inconvenience. We identity of what they analyzed, as vouchers for reference’s suspect they will enjoy the benefits which the expansion sake were never prepared and there is no physical means permitted and think that these offset the disadvantages. for confirmation. In the section which follows, most taxonomic synonyms Fortunately, in recent decades, far more attention is being were omitted as these are readily available in the sources given to the importance of proper herbarium vouchers being cited and are primarily only of historical importance. (More prepared for any and all plant analysis. Even in these cases, detailed and ‘properly’ worded taxonomic descriptions of the not all workers note enough variables for their observations can be found in the listed references.) to be truly meaningful. To better assist the reader in search of more information Size and approximate age, part of plant used and stage it was thought helpful to include synonyms that are in of growth, i.e. actively gowing versus fully developed horticultural use or used in the references included. (if sampling only branches of large specimens), and time Many times plants get renamed or transferred by one of harvest (time of year and time of day) should all be authority without being accepted by some or most others. considered to be critical data to include along with place In some cases, such as Stenocereus, it is not uncommon to of origin. find several different names for the same plant depending on Ideally for a voucher some comments on the local ecology which reference work one consults. While it is unlikely that and a description of habitat would also be quite valuable. they would be encountered and still referred to as a Cereus, This could include the plants growing around it, or with it, as many cereoids were originally called, it is just as likely the immediate local conditions of occurrence [moisture, they will not be listed by MOST sources as a Stenocereus. degree of sun, etc...], its apparent niche in ecosystem, and a It is hoped that the reader will find the following chapter description of the land or terrain. helpful; any feedback on how this could be made more useful Even better would be additionally including a local soil is welcomed. test and/or sample, and analyzing as many parts and ages of Proviso: material as possible, as well as repeated tests with the same It must be kept in mind that substantial differences in specimens at different times of year. the alkaloid content and in the relative ratios of alkaloids If performing repeated samplings of the same individuals; present have been noted by numerous researchers. (True stress can become a factor capable of influencing the results. also in many families.) These differences have been noted I suggest initially using pooled smaller samples of adjacent to sometimes appear seasonally, such as the higher presence individuals within a given population. There should be of N-methylated (as compared to N-demethylated) alkaloids additional small samples taken from several individuals detected, by Lundstrom, during summer in greenhouse within the same population that is pooled in order to check maintained peyote. In contrast; in the same population of uniformity. plants, winter analysis found levels of N-demethylated Most plants can recover rapidly and well from light compounds to be higher than N-methylated ones. [While he prunings. A minimum of two years time is suggested for such used cultivated plants, the mescaline content was comparable a series of samplings with a maximum of 6-8 trimmings. to most of what is collected from the wild.] Differences in regrowth versus original growth should also They can vary as well according to the age of plant (young be evaluated. plant versus adult plant) or even by age of part (such as new The factors controlling and regulating alkaloid production growth on a large adult compared to older growth). In cacti, the would be a fascinating and productive area for future actual variables effecting such reports are, usually, unknown academic research. If chemotaxonomy is to ever be and unstudied. considered a truly useful inclusion in the repertoire of Alkaloid content has been noticed to vary substantially in taxonomic tools, we must be able to better define the amount and/or actual even composition between varieties parameters of alkaloid production. considered closely related by morphology, and concentrations Determining and taking steps to maximize alkaloid content sometimes vary widely even from one individual or locality would also be of benefit for those who view these plants to the next. In others even daily fluctuations have been as sacraments. Selection for known high alkaloid strains, noted; in Phalaris and Papaver, for example, alkaloid or focusing on clones of specific exceptional individuals, concentrations were found to be highest in the early morning. for intensive large scale breeding and propagation efforts, (Quantitative comparative isolations of Phalaris was reported would be a worthwhile avenue for everyone involved with by Appleseed.) sacramental use of these plants. Very few workers seem to concern themselves with any of this and rigorous work on this subject has rarely been performed or published. [Species suggested by published analysis to be variously 95 Sacred Cacti 3rd ed.

a thirsty Opuntia ficus-indica growing in Australia

96 Chapter 3: The mescaline containing species

The reported distribution of mescaline containing species within the family Cactaceae

Nonbold face specific names indicate acceptance as a species is still not widely recognized.

Family: Cactaceae Subfamily: Cereoideae subtribe Echinocactinae Tribe Pereskieae- Aztekium ritteri Pereskia corrugata achirasense Pereskia tampicana Gymnocalycium asterium Tribe Opuntieae- Gymnocalycium baldianum Pereskiopsis scandens Gymnocalycium calochlorum subtribe Cylindropuntia Gymnocalycium carminanthum Opuntia acanthocarpa Gymnocalycium comarapense Opuntia echinocarpa Gymnocalycium denudatum Opuntia imbricata Gymnocalycium gibbosum Opuntia spinosior Gymnocalycium horridispinum subtribe Opuntia Gymnocalycium leeanum Opuntia basilaris Gymnocalycium mesopotamicum Opuntia ficus-indica Gymnocalycium monvillei Tribe Cacteae- Gymnocalycium moserianum subtribe Cactinae Gymnocalycium netrelianum Pelecyphora aselliformis Gymnocalycium nigriareolatum subtribe Cereinae Gymnocalycium oenanthemum Polaskia chende Gymnocalycium paraguayense Pterocereus gaumeri Gymnocalycium quehlianum Stenocereus beneckei Gymnocalycium ragonesii Stenocereus eruca Gymnocalycium riograndense Stenocereus stellatus Gymnocalycium stellatum Stenocereus treleasei Gymnocalycium striglianum Stetsonia coryne Gymnocalycium triacanthum Trichocereus bridgesii ***(all forms*) Gymnocalycium uebelmannianum Trichocereus bridgesii monstrosus *** Gymnocalycium valnicekianum Trichocereus cuzcoensis *** [Often 0. See its entry.] Gymnocalycium vatteri Trichocereus fulvilanus Islaya minor Trichocereus huanucoensis * Lophophora diffusa *** (but not usual case) Trichocereus macrogonus *** Lophophora fricii *** [Does not appear to be typical.] Trichocereus pachanoi *** Lophophora jourdaniana *** Trichocereus pachanoi monstrosus * Lophophora koehresii Trichocereus pallarensis *** Lophophora williamsii williamsii *** Trichocereus peruvianus *** Lophophora williamsii echinata *** Trichocereus peruvianus monstrosus * Turbinicarpus lophophoroides Trichocereus puquiensis *** Turbinicarpus pseudomacrochele var. krainzianus Trichocereus puquiensis monstrosus * Turbinicarpus schmiedickianus var. flaviflorus Trichocereus santaensis *** Turbinicarpus schmiedickianus var. schwarzii Trichocereus schoenii *** Trichocereus scopulicola *** Please note that this system of organization is presently no longer accepted by most authorities but it is still commonly encountered in horticulture and Trichocereus sp. W.Baker 5452 ** among ethnobotanists. Trichocereus cv. SS01, SS02, SS03 * However, the genus Trichocereus was resurrected by Albesiano & Trichocereus cv. TJG *** Kiesling in 2011 and all of the molecular work to-date indicates that they Trichocereus sp. Torres & Torres: N. Chile * are on solid ground. See elsewhere in this work for more details. Trichocereus cv. “Unknown C” * Trichocereus sp. aff. huanucoensis * Most of the species listed contain only trace amounts. Trichocereus strigosus Species marked * lack formally published analytical work but have Trichocereus taquimbalensis * successful human bioassays reported. Trichocereus terscheckii *** Species marked ** have unpublished analytical work confirming mescaline’s presence as well as successful human bioassays reported. Trichocereus thelegonoides Species marked *** have both published analytical work & successful Trichocereus uyupampensis *** (Erroneous ID) human bioassays reported. Trichocereus validus Trichocereus vollianus Trichocereus werdermannianus ***

97 Sacred Cacti 3rd ed. A more recent view

Species that are missing from this list were variously discarded, Subfamily (continued) merged or ignored in the revisions. Details can be found under their Tribe Notocacteae entries. Eriosyce islayensis One thing that careful readers will notice about this arrangement is Tribe Pachycereeae that some of the new combinations merge plants with quite different Polaskia chende published chemistry. If a plant reported to contain mescaline was Pachycereus gaumeri renamed as a synonym of one which did not it was omitted from Stenocereus beneckei this list. Stenocereus eruca We would suggest that these be looked at closer with an eye for Stenocereus stellatus possible subdivision into chemical races. Stenocereus treleasei Comparisons of Anderson, Hunt & others will also rapidly reveal a Tribe Trichocereeae lack of agreement on a number of points and the seemingly capricious Gymnocalycium asterium acceptance of some and rejection of others with little if any comment. Gymnocalycium baldianum Hunt’s lack of meaningful references, including in some cases the Gymnocalycium calochlorum actual describers, precludes any resolution in a number of instances. Gymnocalycium carminanthum Some of the combinations have actually caused us to wonder if Gymnocalycium denudatum Anderson and Hunt ever actually examined flowering specimens or Gymnocalycium gibbosum in some cases ANY actual specimens. Gymnocalycium leeanum In several cases, the mergers were published by people who Gymnocalycium mesopotamicum seemingly lacked first-hand examination of the material. For Gymnocalycium monvillei instance the peculiar assertion that the slender, densely branching Gymnocalycium monvillei subsp. achirasense Trichocereus uyupampensis Backeberg and the stout, solitary Gymnocalycium monvillei subsp. horridispinum columnar Trichocereus validus sensu Backeberg are synonymous. Gymnocalycium netrelianum When faced with this situation we would suggest to botanists that Gymnocalycium oenanthemum they should not be afraid to say “I don’t know” or at least search out Gymnocalycium paraguayense bona fide materials before uttering such pronouncements in print. Gymnocalycium quehlianum What is perhaps most fascinating is the movement within the Gymnocalycium ragonesii Opuntioidae towards a lumpy definition of the species accompanied Gymnocalycium pflanzii var. riograndense by a splitter’s view of the genera. Gymnocalycium stellatum Gymnocalycium striglianum Family: Cactaceae Gymnocalycium triacanthum Subfamily: Pereskioideae Gymnocalycium uebelmannianum Pereskia corrugata Gymnocalycium valnicekianum Pereskia tampicana Gymnocalycium vatteri Subfamily: Opuntioideae Echinopsis lageniformis Cylindropuntia acanthocarpa Echinopsis cuzcoensis Cylindropuntia echinocarpa Echinopsis fulvilana Cylindropuntia imbricata Echinopsis macrogona Cylindropuntia spinosior Echinopsis pachanoi Opuntia basilaris Echinopsis peruviana Opuntia ficus-indica Echinopsis peruviana subsp. puquiensis Pereskiopsis scandens Echinopsis santaensis Subfamily Cactoideae Echinopsis schoenii Tribe Browningieae Echinopsis scopulicola Stetsonia coryne Echinopsis strigosa Tribe Cacteae Echinopsis tacaquirensis subsp. taquimbalensis Aztekium ritteri Echinopsis terscheckii Lophophora diffusa Echinopsis thelegona Lophophora fricii Echinopsis uyupampensis Lophophora williamsii Echinopsis volliana Turbinicarpus lophophoroides Turbinicarpus pseudomacrochele subsp. krainzianus Turbinicarpus schmiedickianus subsp. flaviflorus Turbinicarpus schmiedickianus subsp. schwarzii Pelecyphora aselliformis

Acharagma aguirreana (Glass & R.Foster) Glass DNA work by Wallace suggests that this is Lophophora’s closest relative Reported to contain over 2% hordenine by West et al. 1974 Formerly known as Gymnocactus aguirreanus Glass & R.Foster

98 Chapter 3: The mescaline containing species

Lophophora williamsii williamsii in South Texas

99 Sacred Cacti 3rd ed.

Lophophora williamsii echinata sensu Weniger in West Texas

100