Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 1 of 51
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
In re: Chapter 11
BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND Case No. 20-10343 (LSS) DELAWARE BSA, LLC, Jointly Administered Debtors. Re: D.I. 5466
DECLARATION OF KRISTIAN ROGGENDORF, ESQ., IN SUPPORT OF OBJECTION TO DEBTORS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF AN ORDER, PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 363(b) AND 105(a) OF THE BANKRUPTCY CODE, (I) AUTHORIZING THE DEBTORS TO ENTER INTO AND PERFORM UNDER THE RESTRUCTURING SUPPORT AGREEMENT, AND (II) GRANTING RELATED RELIEF
I, Kristian Roggendorf, hereby state as follows:
1. I am an attorney duly admitted to practice in the states of Oregon and Colorado, and am authorized to appear before this Court pro hac vice per the Court’s order of April 9, 2021.
I make this declaration based on my own personal knowledge, I am presenting the following facts on behalf of my clients identified in Exhibit A to the Objection fled contemporaneously with this
Declaration, and I am competent to testify to the facts asserted herein.
2. I am employed at the Zalkin Law Firm, P.C. (“the Zalkin Law Firm”), 10590 W
Ocean Air Dr. #125, San Diego, CA 92130. The Zalkin Law Firm represents 144 sexual abuse claimants in the above-captioned matter.
3. I have been representing survivors of childhood sexual abuse as a lawyer since admitted to the Oregon Bar in October of 2001. In that capacity, I have been involved in dozens of cases against the Boy Scouts of America, representing primarily men who were sexually harmed as minors during their time in scouting, first with the firm of O’Donnell Clark & Crew,
LLP in Portland, Oregon from 2001 to 2013. In 2009-10, I was acting as a partner at O’Donnell
1 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 2 of 51
Clark & Crew, representing the plaintiffs in the case of Jack Doe 1 v. Corporation of the
Presiding Bishop (and Boy Scouts of America), Case No. 0710-11295 (Or. Circ. Apr 23, 2010)
(punitive damages verdict). In the course of preparation of the case for trial, I completed virtually all of the substantive pretrial briefing involving the structure of the Boy Scouts, its interrelation with the local scout Councils and its chartered troop sponsors, the nature of the relationship between the Scout entities and sponsoring organizations, the control exercised by these entities over volunteer adult scout leaders, and the BSA’s decades-long knowledge of child abuse within scouting through its use of the Ineligible Volunteer Files (“Red Flag Files” or
“Perversion Files” [BSA’s own terms]) that tracked child molesting scout leaders. That case resulted in a verdict of $19.9 million for one of our plaintiffs in a severed single-plaintiff trial.
4. Attached as Exhibit 1 to this Declaration is a true and correct copy of the
Declaration of Nathaniel E. Marshall, the Assistant Director of Registration for the Boy Scouts of
America, filed in the Oregon Jack Doe 1 case.
5. Attached as Exhibit 2 to this Declaration is a true and correct copy of the two
Declarations of Martin Walsh, filed in N.K. v. Corporation of the Presiding Bishop, et al., King
County Superior Court Case No. 09-2-41575-7 KNT (Wash. Sup. Ct. March 3, 2011), a case in which I was involved as co-counsel with the firm of the firm now known as Pfau Cochran Vertetis and Amala, PLCC, co-signatories to the Objection filed with this Declaration.
6. Attached as Exhibit 3 to this Declaration is a true and correct copy of the
Declaration of Al Westberg, the Declaration of Alan Koppes, and the Declaration of Charles
Brasfeild, filed in Dietrich v. Defendant Doe 1 (Boy Scouts of America), et al., Solano County
/ / / /
/ / / /
2 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 3 of 51 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 4 of 51
EXHIBIT 1
CaseCase 20-10343-LSS20-10343-LSS DocDoc 3949-15683 Filed Filed 07/22/21 05/14/21 Page Page 5 2of of 51 6
1 2
3
4 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE STATE OF OREGON
5 FOR THE COUNTY OF MULTNOMAH
6 JACK DOE 1, an individual proceeding under a fictitious name; JACK DOE 2, an individual 7 proceeding under a fictitious name; JACK DOE Case No. 0710-11294 3, an individual proceeding under a fictitious 8 name; JACK DOE 4, an individual proceeding DECLARATION OF NATHANIEL E. under a fictitious name; JACK DOE 5, an MARSHALL 9 individual proceeding under a fictitious name; JACK DOE 6, an individual proceeding under a 10 fictitious name;
11 Plaintiffs, 12 v.
13 CORPORATION OF THE PRESIDING BISHOP OF THE CHURCH OF JESUS 14 CHRIST OF LATTER-DAY SAINTS, a foreign corporation sole registered to do 15 business in the State of Oregon; CORPORATION OF THE PRESIDENT OF 16 THE CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST OF LATTER-DAY SAINTS AND SUCCESSORS, 17 a foreign corporation sole registered to do business in the State of Oregon; THE BOY 18 SCOUTS OF AMERICA, a congressionally chartered corporation, authorized to do business 19 in Oregon; and CASCADE PACIFIC COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA, an 20 Oregon non-profit corporation,
21 Defendants. 22
23 I, Nathaniel E. Marshall, state and declare as follows:
24 1. I am the Assistant Director for Registration for the Boy Scouts of America
25 ("BSA"), located at BSA headquarters in Irving, Texas. I have personal knowledge of the
26 matters herein and am competent to testify as a witness. Page 1 - DECLARATION OF NATHANIEL E. MARSHALL MITCHELL, LANG & SMITH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2000 ONE MAIN PLACE 101 S.W. MAIN STREET PORTLAND, OREGON 97204-3230 TELEPHONE (503) 221-1011 H:ICTS\4 7856\Pleadings\Dec of Marshall. doc FAX (503) 248-0732 CaseCase 20-10343-LSS20-10343-LSS DocDoc 3949-15683 Filed Filed 07/22/21 05/14/21 Page Page 6 3of of 51 6
1 2. Within my duties as Assistant Director for Registration, I have the responsibility
2 to oversee the set-up and maintenance of the Ineligible Volunteer Files (the "I.V. files"). In my
3 role as Assistant Director for Registration, I am also knowledgeable regarding the purpose and
4 mission of the BSA, its relationship to locally organized Boy Scout councils, and its relationship
5 to the independent community organizations, called Chartered Organizations, that have included
6 the Scouting Program in their youth groups.
7 The Ineligible Volunteer Files
8 3. BSA has maintained I. V. files since about 1919, soon after it was chartered by an
9 Act of Congress in 1916. The I.V. files contain information reported to BSA that suggests that
1O an individual does not meet the high standers set by BSA for membership.
11 4. BSA's purpose in setting up I.V. files is to collect information in an attempt to
12 prevent any individual who does not meet the high standards of BSA from being able to register
13 with any scouting organization located in the United States of America.
14 5. An I.V. file is created when BSA receives information from a local council
15 reporting inappropriate conduct by an adult or youth member. The inappropriate conduct may
16 involve, but is not limited to, gambling, drinking, financial improprieties, or pedophilia and other
17 criminal behavior. The mores and language of the particular time period influenced what
18 conduct was deemed inappropriate. Most of these files are created based on the impressions and
19 conclusions drawn by the reporters, hearsay gathered from various sources, or news reports.
20 6. Once BSA receives notice from a local council that there has been a report of
21 inappropriate behavior by a member, a file is promptly created. Essentially, all that is placed in
22 the file is a collection of information, such as newspaper articles and the council's report. BSA
23 conducts no internal investigation to verify the information forwarded from the council.
24 7. Because much of this information is unsubstantiated, from an evidence standard,
25 and because it directly bears on the character and reputation of private individuals, BSA has kept
26 this information strictly confidential. The files are only made available within BSA on a need
Page 2 - DECLARATION OF NATHANIEL E. MARSHALL MITCHELL, LANG & SMITH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2000 ONE MAIN PLACE 101 S.W. MAIN STREET PORTLAND, OREGON 97204-3230 TELEPHONE (503) 221-1011 H:ICTS\47856\Pleadings\Dec of Marshall.doc FAX (503) 248-0732 CaseCase 20-10343-LSS20-10343-LSS DocDoc 3949-15683 Filed Filed 07/22/21 05/14/21 Page Page 7 4of of 51 6
1 to-know basis. Strong restrictions of confidentiality are imposed to protect the privacy rights of
2 ·not only the alleged victims and alleged perpetrators, but also of the persons involved as
3 witnesses or reporters.
4 8. BSA's I.V. file system depends on assurances of strict confidentiality. Witnesses
5 and reporters are often related to, or closely acquainted with, the alleged perpetrators and will
6 only come forward if confidentiality is assured, fearing otherwise that they will be exposed to
7 retaliation ranging from social stigma to physical harm or injury. BSA is concerned that
8 divulging this information under any circumstances will inhibit future reports of misconduct.
9 9. Simply redacting the names of reporters will not protect their identity. In many
1O cases, a motivated person can still determine the identities of reporters, based upon the remaining
11 information in the I.V. files.
12 The Purpose of BSA and its Relationship to Councils and Chartered Organizations
13 10. The Boy Scouts of America is a congressionally chartered benevolent
14 organization. The purpose of the Boy Scouts of America is to "promote, through organization,
15 and cooperation with other agencies, the ability of boys to do things for themselves and others, to
16 train them in scoutcraft, and to teach them patriotism, courage, self-reliance, and kindred
17 virtues."
18 11. The Scouting Movement relies on the co-operation of three entirely separate legal
19 entities: The Boy Scouts of America on the national level; local councils operating within their
20 local geographic area; and the local community organizations that actually "own" and operate
21 their Boy Scout troops and supervise and control their scouting activities. Although these three
22 separate entities have in common the goal of youth character development through "scoutcraft,
23 patriotism, courage, self-reliance, and kindred virtues" as expressed in the Scouting Program,
24 none has control over the other.
25 12. The Boy Scouts of America at the national level creates an educational resource
26 program. It develops the Scouting Program and then makes it available for use by local
Page 3 - DECLARATION OF NATHANIEL E. MARSHALL MITCHELL, LANG & SMITH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2000 ONE MAIN PLACE 101 S.W. MAIN STREET PORTLAND, OREGON 97204-3230 TELEPHONE (503) 221-1011 H:ICTS\47856\Pleadings\Dec of Marshall.doc FAX (503) 248-0732 CaseCase 20-10343-LSS20-10343-LSS DocDoc 3949-15683 Filed Filed 07/22/21 05/14/21 Page Page 8 5of of 51 6
1 community organizations as part of their service to their members and their community.
2 13, The Boy Scouts of America charters local councils, which allows the local
3 council to offer the Scouting Program to community organizations located within a prescribed
4 geographical area. Spread throughout the United States are over 300 locally incorporated
5 councils with serve their community by providing guidance and program support to independent
6 "Chartered Organizations" such as schools, churches and youth organizations. Each local
7 council is incorporated as a separate not-for-profit or benevolent organization in the state in
8 which it is located, and each local council raises and disburses its own funds and has its own
9 board of directors.
10 14, The local councils perform a similar role as The Boy Scouts of America, but in
11 the confines of their smaller geographical area. Specifically, the local councils seek to promote
12 the Scouting Movement by encouraging use of the Scouting character-building program. The
13 local councils also act as a conduit for charter applications from local sponsoring organizations
14 to The Boy Scouts of America.
15 15. Given The Boy Scouts of America's congressional charter and its institutional
16 framework, neither The Boy Scouts of America nor the local councils create, administer, or run
17 the individual scouting units or troops. Instead, it is the local community sponsor, such as
18 schools, churches or civic organizations, and their local community volunteers who organize,
19 create and run all of the troop and other scouting units in the United States. The Boy Scouts of
20 America and the local councils do not administer the Scouting Program directly but rather offer
21 the program to community organizations that wish to use the Scouting Program as a vehicle to
22 reach their own goals and objectives with the youth of that particular community.
23 16. Nationwide, currently there are approximately 130,000 locally sponsored scouting
24 units including Boy Scout troops. These units are created, organized, supervised and run by
25 approximately 1.3 million community volunteers who have absolutely no employment or agency
26 relationship with The Boy Scouts of America.
Page 4 - DECLARATION OF NATHANIEL E. MARSHALL MITCHELL, LANG & SMITH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2000 ONE MAIN PLACE 101 S.W. MAIN STREET PORTLAND, OREGON 97204-3230 TELEPHONE (503) 221-1011 H:\CTS\47856\Pleadings\Dec of Marshall.doc FAX (503) 248-0732 CaseCase 20-10343-LSS20-10343-LSS DocDoc 3949-15683 Filed Filed 07/22/21 05/14/21 Page Page 9 6of of 51 6
1 17, The troops or units do not belong to The Boy Scouts of America or to the Local
2 Council but rather are owned and operated by the chartered local community organization. As a
3 result, the sponsoring organization schedules and runs its troop to accomplish its objectives and 4 goals with the youth of that particular community. The sponsoring organization's troop
5 committee selects the troop leaders. The troop leaders' names are submitted to BSA for
6 registration, at which time BSA checks the names against the names in the BSA Ineligible
7 Volunteer Files. However, BSA does not supervise or control the manner in which the troop
8 committee governs its troop. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of a sample
9 "Annual Charter Agreement," which sets out the responsibilities of both the chartered local
10 community organization and the local council. Specifically, the chartered local community
11 organization agrees to:
12 Select a unit committee of parents and members of the chartered 13 organization (minimum of three) who will screen and select unit leaders who meet the organization's standers as well as the 14 leadership standers of the BSA. (The committee chairman must sign all leadership applications before submitting them to the 15 chattered organization for approval.) Exhibit A. 16
17 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Oregon that the foregoing 18 is true and correct. 19 DATED this __ day 20
21 22
23
24
25 26
Page 5 - DECLARATION OF NATHANIEL E. MARSHALL MITCHELL, LANG & SMITH ATTORNEYS AT LAW 2000 ONE MAIN PLACE 101 S.W. MAIN STREET PORTLAND, OREGON 97204-3230 TELEPHONE (503) 221-1011 H:\CTS\47856\Pleadings\Dec of Marshall.doc FAX (503) 248-0732 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 10 of 51
EXHIBIT 2
Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 11 of 51
1 THE HONORABLE BRIAND. GAIN 2
3
4
5
6
7 SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY
~ N.K., an individual proceeding under a pseudonym, No. 09-2-41575-7 KNT 9 Plaintiff, DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN 10 SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS V. OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 11 SUMMARY JUDGMENT CORPORATION OF THE PRESIDING 12 BISHOP OF THE CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST OF LATTER-DAY SAINTS, et al., 13 Defendants. 14
15
16 I, Martin Walsh, state and declare as follows:
17 1. I am Manager of the Membership Impact Department of the Boy Scouts of
18 · America ("BSA"). I have personal knowledge of the matters herein and am competent to
19 testify as a witness.
20 2. In my role at BSA, I am knowledgeable regarding the purpose of the national
21 BSA, its relationship to councils located throughout the United States, and the independent 22 chartered organizations that incorporate Scouting into their youth program. 23 3. BSA is a congressionally chartered non-profit organization. Pursuant to its
24 federal charter, the purpose of BSA is to "promote, through organization, and cooperation
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT- I Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 12 of 51
1 with other agencies, the ability of boys to do things for themselves and others, to train them in
2 scoutcraft, and to teach them patriotism, courage, self-reliance, and kindred virtues."
3 4. The Scouting movement consists of three entirely separate legal entities: BSA
4 on the national level; local Scout councils located in communities throughout the United
5 States; and the local community organizations which actually "own" and operate the Scout
6 troops and supervise and control their scouting activities. Although these three separate
7 entities have in common the promotion of "Scoutcraft, patriotism, courage, self-reliance, and
8 kindred virtues" as expressed in the scouting program, none has control over the other.
9 5. BSA at the national level is an educational resource program. It makes its
IO Scouting program available to local community organizations to use to fulfill their mission(s)
11 to their members and to their communities.
12 6. BSA charters councils for a prescribed geographical area. There are 297
13 locally incorporated councils in the United States 'that were established by local community
14 leaders to serve their communities by providing guidance and support to the independent
15 community organizations that operate Scout troops. Each 'council is incorporated as a
16 separate not-for-profit or benevolent organization in the state in which it is located, and each
17 council raises and disburses its own funds and has its own distinct board of directors. The
18 local Scout councils seek to help the youth in their communities through promotion of the
19 Scouting program. The local Scout councils grant charter applications to local sponsoring
20 organizations to operate Scouting units.
21 7. Given BSA's charter and the institutional framework, neither BSA nor the
22 local Scout councils create, administer, or run the individual Scouting units or troops.
23 Instead, it is local community sponsors, such as schools, churches or civic organizations, and
24 their local community volunteers who organize, create and run all of the troop and other
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 2 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 13 of 51
1 scouting units in the United States. The troops or units do not belong to BSA or to the local
2 Scout councils but rather are owned and operated by the chartered local community
3 organization. As a result, the sponsoring organization can run its troop in whatever way it
4 chooses to accomplish its own objectives and goals with the youth of that particular
5 community and determines the membership and leadership of each unit.
6 8. Nationwide, there are approximately 130,_000 locally sponsored Scouting units
7 or troops. These units are created, organized, supervised and run by approximately 1.3
8 million community volunteers who have absolutely no employment or agency relationship
9 with BSA.
10 9. To sponsor a troop, a local community organization applies for a charter from
11 the local Scout council in its geographic area. Local community organizations recruit and
12 select volunteers from their own communities to serve as troop committee members and Scout
13 leaders for their troops. Id The local community organizations provide a meeting place for
14 the troop and supervise the Scout leaders and troop activities.
15 10. The Shelton, Washington ward of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day
16 Saints was the local chartered organization that sponsored, organized and operated owned the
17 troop that Plaintiff joined in 1976. The Shelton ward is a separate legal entity from BSA and
18 the Pacific Harbors Council.
19 11. To sponsor a troop, a local community organization must apply for a charter
20 from its local Scout council, appoint a troop committee, recruit and select Scoutmasters for its
21 troop, provide a meeting place for the troop, and supervise troop activities. The community
22 organization - and not BSA or the local Scout council - selects Scout leaders, and can
23 discharge those leaders without any prior approval by BSA or the local Scout council.
24
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 3 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 14 of 51
1 12. Although BSA does not select adult troop leaders, it does check the names of
2 leaders submitted to it by the local community organizations for registration against the names
3 in BSA's Ineligible Volunteer files (the "I.V. files"). A person selected by the local
4 community organization to serve as Scout leader must complete a registration application,
5 which is sent from the local community organization to the local Scout council and the
6 information forwarded to BSA. Upon receiving the registration information, BSA checks the
7 name provided in that information against the names in the I.V. files.
8 13. BSA has maintained I.V. files since about 1919, soon after it was chartered by
9 an Act of Congress in 1916. The I.V. files contain information reported to BSA upon which it
10 has been determined that an individual does not meet the BSA's membership standards. This
11 information is provided to BSA by the local Scout councils. Grounds for ineligibility have
12 followed societal mores at the time of reporting and have included, for example, gambling,
13 drinking, financial improprieties, and pedophilia and other criminal behavior. BSA does this
14 to prevent persons previously identified as ineligible from simply reapplying in another,
15 separate local Scout council. BSA will not allow registration of a person whose name appears
16 in the I. V. files. From 1919 to 1971, over 20 million adult registered volunteers have
17 participated in BSA, of which less than two hundredths of one percent (.002%) were alleged
18 sexual abusers.
19 14. I have reviewed the records from the 1970's kept by BSA. BSA has no
20 records or information regarding "Dusty Hall" "Darrell Hall" "Dusty Rhodes" or "Dusty
21 Rhoades." None of these names are listed in BSA's Ineligible Volunteer Files. No one with
22 such names has been a BSA employee.
23 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the state of Texas that the
24 foregoing is true and correct. .,-L 25 DATED this-2_ day of March, 2011 at Irving, Texas.
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 4 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 15 of 51
1 2 072 J~I MARTIN WALSH 3 4 5
6
7 8 9
10
11 12
13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR I 00 I Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 5 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 16 of 51
1 DECLARATION OF SERVICE
2 The undersigned declares as follows:
3 I am employed at Corr Cronin Michelson Baumgardner & Preece LLP, attorneys
4 of record for Defendant Boy Scouts of America herein.
5 I hereby certify that on this date I caused true and correct copies of the foregoing
6 document to be served on all attorneys of record herein in the manner indicated below:
7 Kelly Clark Charles C. Gordon Kristian Roggendorf Jeffrey I. Tilden 8 Gilion C. Dumas Gordon Tilden Thomas & Cordell LLP 9 O'Donnell, Clark & Crew LLP 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 4000 1650 NW Naito Pkwy., Ste. 302 Seattle, WA 98154 10 Portland, OR 97209 Via Hand Delivery Via e-mail: [email protected] 11 and U.S. Mail 12 Michael T. Pfau Francis S. Floyd 13 Pfau Cochran V ertetis Kosnoff, PLLC Thomas N edderman 701 Fifth Avenue, Suite 4730 Floyd, Pflueger & Ringer 14 Seattle, WA 98104 2505 Third Avenue, Suite 300 Via Hand Delivery Seattle, WA 98121 15 Via Hand Delivery 16 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington that 17 the foregoing is true and correct. 18 DATED-this 314( day of March, 2011, at Seattle, Washington. 19
20
21 Mary Beth Dahl 22
23
24
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT- 6 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900
619 00004 kk014001 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 17 of 51
1 THE HONORABLE BRIAND. GAIN 2
3
4
5
6
7 SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY
8 N.K., an individual proceeding under a pseudonym, No. 09-2-41575-7 KNT 9 Plaintiff, DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN 10 SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS V. OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 11 SUMMARY JUDGMENT CORPORATION OF THE PRESIDING 12 BISHOP OF THE CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST OF LATTER-DAY SAINTS, et al., 13 Defendants. 14
15
16 I, Martin Walsh, state and declare as follows:
17 1. I am Manager of the Membership Impact Department of the Boy Scouts of
18 America ("BSA"). I have personal knowledge of the matters herein and am competent to
19 testify as a witness.
20 2. In my role at BSA, I am knowledgeable regarding the purpose of the national
21 BSA, its relationship to councils located throughout the United States, and the independent 22 chartered organizations that incorporate Scouting into their youth program.
23 3. The Scouting movement consists of three "layers" of distinct legal entities:
24 BSA on the national level; local Scout councils located in communities throughout the United
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AME~~I@M 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT-! ~ \_'J} LI Li Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 CP001058 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 18 of 51
1 States; and the local community organizations which actually "own" and operate the Scout
2 troops and supervise and control their scouting activities.
3 4. The first "layer" is BSA, a Congressionally-chartered corporation. BSA's
4 federal charter, states that its purpose is to make its educational scouting program available
5 for use by other organizations. BSA at the national level is an educational resource program.
6 It makes its Scouting program available to local community organizations to use to fulfill
7 their mission to their members and to their communities. In 1977, it was headquartered in
8 North_Brunswick, New Jersey.
9 5. The second "layer" of the Scouting Movement is made up of the individual
10 councils (such as the Pacific Harbors Council), which are separate nonprofit or charitable
11 corporations operating within a set geographic area. BSA charters councils for a prescribed
12 geographical area. There are approximately 300 locally incorporated councils in the United
13 States that were established by local community leaders to serve their communities by
14 providing guidance and support to the independent community organizations that operate
15 Scout troops. The local Scout councils seek to help the youth in their communities through
16 promotion of the Scouting program.
17 6. The third "layer'' is composed of independent community organizations such
18 as schools, churches or civic organizations, and their local community volunteers who
19 organize, create and run all of the troop and other scouting units in the United States.
20 Attached as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of excerpted pages ( cover page, pages 1-5
21 and pages 27-55) of the Boy Scouts of America 1977 Report to Congress. The 1977 Annual
22 Report contains a list of chartered organizations using the Scouting program in 1977. These
23 organizations own scouting units, such as Scout troops and Cub Scout packs, and select the
24 leadership for their units.
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1(),.51 SUMMARY JUDGMENT- 2 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax (206) 625-0900 CP001059 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 19 of 51
1 7. To sponsor a troop, a local community organization must apply for a charter,
2 appoint a troop committee, recruit and select Scoutmasters for its troop, provide a meeting
3 place for the troop, and supervise troop activities. The community organization- and not
4 BSA or the local Scout council - selects Scout leaders, and can discharge those leaders
5 without any prior approval by BSA or the local Scout council.
6 8. Although BSA does not select adult troop leaders, it does check the names of
7 leaders submitted to it by the local community organizations for registration against the names
8 in BSA's Ineligible Volunteer files (the "I.V. files"). A person selected by the local
9 community organization to serve as Scout leader must complete a registration application,
10 which is sent from the local community organization to the local Scout council and the
11 information forwarded to BSA. Upon receiving the registration information, BSA checks the
12 name provided in that information against the names in the LV. files.
13 9. BSA has maintained I.V. files since about 1919, soon after it was chartered by
14 an Act of Congress in 1916. The I.V. files contain information reported to BSA upon which it
15 has been determined that an individual does not meet the BSA's membership standards. This
16 information is provided to BSA by the local Scout councils. Grounds for ineligibility have
17 followed societal mores at the time of reporting and have included, for example, gambling,
18 drinking, financial improprieties, and pedophilia and other criminal behavior. BSA does this
19 to prevent persons previously identified as ineligible from simply reapplying in another,
20 separate local Scout council. BSA will not allow registration of a person whose name appears 21 in the I.V. files.
22 II
23 II
24 II
25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT - 3 Tel (206) 625-8600 CP001060 Fax (206) 625-0900 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 20 of 51
1 10. BSA's 1977 Annual Report (Exhibit A) contains a cumulative count of adults 2 leaders registered in Scouting from 1910 to 1977 of 18,548,823. This number reflects the 3 cumulative count of separate individual leaders from the "Scouters" column and the "Pack
4 Leaders" column thru 1977.
5 11. I have reviewed the records from the 1970's kept by BSA. BSA has no 6 records or information regarding "Dusty Hall" "Darrell Hall" "Dusty Rhodes" or "Dusty
7 Rhoades." None of these names are listed in BSA's Ineligible Volunteer Files. No one with
8 such names has been a BSA employee. 9 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the state of Texas that the 10 foregoing is true and correct. 11 DATED this ;sK day of July, 2011 at Irving, Texas. 12
13 MARTIN WALSH 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
CORR CRONIN MICHELSON DECLARATION OF MARTIN WALSH IN SUPPORT OF BAUMGARDNER & PREECE LLP DEFENDANT BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA'S MOTION FOR 1001 Fourth Avenue, Suite 3900 Seattle, Washington 98154-1051 SUMMARY JUDGMENT- 4 Tel (206) 625-8600 Fax(206)625-0900
CP001061 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 21 of 51
EXHIBIT A
CP001062 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 22 of 51 ·· I ,.-, /~ ._ • 1 C: "' t [/ J:;.. "- r,.(. i" ._i-\ Report to the BOY SCOUTS 95th Congress. 2d Session OF AMERICA
ANNUAt REPORT TO CONGRESS/
•
CP001063 Session 2d the to Congress, Report 95th 08902 REPORT CONGRESS TO iin ANNUAL Jersey New America of Brunswick, Scouts Boy North of to his he fit He for his and and and and have if right tasks with make these obeys of side manner is to to mind thre'aten way by rules He keep even saves does courage or rules his property. and protects inks bright tries around tries clean. at these living resources. th orderly He them. troop. the He the community pay He and helps the in he danger an body he goes to and for in laugh his has thinks He way. his time BRAVE CLEAN face cheerfully THRIFTY He OBEDIENT disobey needs. natural he CHEERFUL others. of believe what He his follows unfair, He He community If works uses looks can He keeps school, others happy. than for ideals. changed are and who \ if laws clean. God. come help LAW pcout duties. afraid. Scout Scout Scout Sco~t Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 23 of 51 A laws family, rather the country. A them A things. that others unforeseen to is conserves A carefully stand him. even home and A same those others. toward of religious his SCOUT a beliefs is REVERENT his reverent He for He ln can is is keeps the seeks of other other Scout easier treats things nation. He it respects He He T.~E everyone there He part and Scout faithful treated. all. He People about willingly is together. position. to family, reward. A respects is make customs be to harmless truth. or or his to gentle. Scouts. and things along school, kill to the others. pay polite KIND age Honesty LOYAL friend or get manners HELPFUL concerned conduct. understands wants being other a FRIENDLY true does is ideas him. of to COURTEOUS tells is is TRUSTWORTHY ls he in hurt to friends, own. on reason. He of good without as with his not promises. Scout Scout people Scout understand Scout Sc.out Scout A his code leaders, depend A people. A brother knows others regardless A A those to than for others does strength without A
CP001064 3916-77 No. 3 1977 Facilities of Councils Local Appendix National Fim1nce Review Personnel Administration Program Operations 6 4 18 12 26 27 16 20 24 CONTENTS SCOUTING/USA nation. America and for Explorer, of ls cont11UJe our and Scouting Incl qualft1es United progritlll, of ski1 possible 0'902 now the interest shall Scouts Seo1,1ts, and 1S of We J1raeyo its peopl,. Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 24 of 51 1t outdoor citOens program ScoulS, New u trad1t10na1 our for 249-6000 the ideals Cub 201 Olf,ce-Boy for for Congress States. Report. great Scouting Bnmawick, 710--480-8282 the Scouting Congress lives responsible the Scout1n9 progr11m the effective Un1ted "- Norlh National Tttlei;>hone TWX Annual from the as of of Explorers. the to rev1eW make mak.e 1977 useful one in and to youth who our Cha.rter teaching shall be:en rrore Jr. we the for has Scouts, leaders movement submft Representatives appreciation America's Federal and 1917, of valuntters 0'rle111, our nat10n 20510 Sco11ts, for pos$1b1e plan, Scout1ng volunteer House sfncel"e prepare our it with Cub Thomas ce 1n the to Executive O.C. 1ts. the 1,252,251 respectfully our TRANSMITTf\L report Pr1 made Speaker: cf. for on we ,·-· the L. Scout this has ,-tr. OF advancement progritlll Honorable 3,465,887 youth. accordance express SCOUTING/USA lg I that In for support Yolu.ntarts111 the Washington, Harvey Respectfully, Enc1osure The our" depends our Ch1et' salute Speak.er Statu, We Dear With LETTER CP001065
a. a.
5 5
4, 4,
the the for for
has has
has has
the.· the.·
the the
was was
and and
Boy Boy
once once
gives gives
pack, pack,
skills, skills,
is is
helps, helps,
about about
habits habits
States States
Federal Federal
post, post,
Federal Federal
for for
It It
practice practice
national national
program program
physical physical
the the
Scoutfng Scoutfng
personal personal
a a
meet meet
program's program's
Explorers Explorers
aim aim
for for
citizenship citizenship
people people
purpose purpose
good good
program program
purpose purpose
Scout Scout
to to
the the
and and
-purpose -purpose
new new
and and
available available
a.nd a.nd
charts. charts.
and and
United United
When When
program program
support support
Scout Scout
or or
in in
concerned concerned
(Appendix (Appendix
the the
Explorer Explorer
the the
leaders' leaders'
received received
young young
-Cub -Cub
years years
made made
is is
learn learn
develop develop
of of
helpfulness. helpfulness.
as as
method method
the the
the the
Scouting's Scouting's
. .
mental mental
by by
and and
underlying underlying
to to
planning planning
to to
Sc~uts, Sc~uts,
the-
and and
each each
encourages encourages
Action.) Action.)
Scouting's Scouting's
1916, 1916,
provide provide
youth. youth. unit unit
leadership. leadership.
and and
effort effort
Even Even
development, development,
the the
and and
series series
alike. alike.
skills. skills.
America America
unchanged. unchanged.
of of
in in
to to
development development
from from
and and
It It
helps helps
our our patrol patrol
eaoh:decade eaoh:decade
and and
over over
of of troop, troop,
a a
1910 1910
'establisbed 'establisbed
of of
accepted accepted
~couts, ~couts,
emphasized emphasized
attitudes attitudes
order order
In In
unique unique
that that
traiAing, traiAing,
Scout Scout
including including
remained remained
notebooks notebooks
program program been been
Scouts Scouts
pride. pride.
Scouting Scouting
spiritual spiritual
leadership leadership
opportunities opportunities
firmly firmly
generation, generation,
achievement achievement Since Since
character character
and and
Cub Cub
adults adults
charter charter
tegislation. tegislation.
Congress· Congress·
-again -again
fitness fitness
training, training,
Congressional Congressional
-needs·of -needs·of
-evolved -evolved
-coordinated -coordinated
is is
of of
of of
to to
of of
2, 2,
are are
the the
the the
and and
and and
and and
Cub Cub
there there
bui.ld bui.ld
these these
1877 1877
14 14
· ·
youth youth
Scout Scout
where where
end end
fitness. fitness.
attracts attracts
1i8,569 1i8,569
and and
i-ri" i-ri"
Explorer Explorer
activities activities
there there
leaders-a leaders-a
the the
leadership leadership
will will
the the
1977 1977
for for
director director
units units
Scouts Scouts
Scou'ts-and Scou'ts-and
functions functions
from from
program program
of of
encompasses encompasses
c-ommunity c-ommunity
Pennsylvania Pennsylvania
provide provide
at at
packs, packs,
vo~th vo~th
(Apperidix (Apperidix
of of
that that
Scout Scout
physical physical
many many
citizenship, citizenship,
National National
parents, parents,
22,640 22,640
of of
part part
Scouting Scouting
to to
major major
of of
end end
in in
rn-1,843,033 rn-1,843,033
members, members,
as as
28,601 28,601
and and
Scout Scout
volunteer volunteer
137,335 137,335
women women
for for
national national
138. 138.
!local !local
western western
of· of·
Administration, Administration,
the the
and and
their their
Explorers. Explorers.
to to
a a
1977 1977
training training
the the
of of
movement movement
1,224,549 1,224,549
to to
Cub Cub
and and
serve serve
educ
8 8
of of
Summary.) Summary.)
membership membership
display display
join join
adult adult
youth youth
train train
mental mental
4,718, 4,718,
when when
At At
and and
ans. ans.
and and
designed designed
happens happens
the the
· ·
total total
to to
and and
came came
people, people,
men men
troops, troops,
who who
of of
total total
program program
from from
great great
56,126 56,126
at at
Scouting Scouting
.\argest.~athering. .\argest.~athering.
.a .a
Finance Finance
young young
Program Program
The The
Personnel. Personnel.
program program
21-398,305 21-398,305
Operations, Operations, posts-a posts-a
positions. positions. 1,252,251 1,252,251
Scout Scout organizati organizati
adults adults
were were
Scouting Scouting
young young 3,465,887 3,465,887
character, character,
The The Scouts Scouts
strengthen strengthen
1977 1977
activities activities
grand grand
leaders leaders
was was Jamboree Jamboree
Mem_ben;hip Mem_ben;hip
Tile Tile
for for
-wisely -wisely
-boys -boys
·scouting's ·scouting's
a a
Is Is
1, 1,
of of
of of
to to
of of
of of
for for
are are
for for the the
the the
and and
and and
and and
plus plus
total total
Last Last
by by
office office
gains, gains,
passed passed
about about
unique unique
of of
council council
Council Council
and and
youth youth
which which
financial financial
needs needs
men men
Even Even
and and
adversely adversely
there there
changing. changing.
Appendix Appendix
we we
a a
Executive Executive
Sc9uts Sc9uts
Scouting's Scouting's
States States
styles styles
director director
grand grand
troops, troops,
youth. youth.
the the
be be
local local
parts parts
chartered chartered
(Appendix (Appendix
future. future.
East East
positive positive
nationaJ nationaJ
in in a
to to
less less
Service Service
Boy,. Boy,.
Board Board
nationally nationally
1977 1977
units units
for for
years years
been been
is is
optimistic optimistic
are are
the the
Board Board
Scout Scout
United United
the the family family
changing changing
national national Far Far
other other
program. program.
In In
1910. 1910.
in in
national national
overseas, overseas,
was was
inflation, inflation,
the the
provided provided
a a
mark mark
and and young
very very
has has
in in
1910-1977.) 1910-1977.)
the the
the the
there there
Direct Direct
seemed seemed
the the
from from
several several
which which
the the
packs, packs,
grow grow
a a
since since
dir~cted dir~cted
in in
program program
there there
by by
experienced experienced
has has
Executive Executive
now now
youth youth
Scouting Scouting
boys boys
to to
changing changing
years years
Executive Executive
posts posts
for for
better better
Scouting Scouting
trend trend
past past
and and
live live
annually. annually.
that that
Scout Scout arF arF
Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 25 of 51
support support
designated designated
68 68
areas areas
councils, councils,
nation nation
60-million 60-million
the the
this this
help help
the the
we we
fact fact
ability ability
serve serve
possessipns, possessipns,
Cub Cub
For For
America America
educational educational
elected elected
our our
membership membership
volunteer volunteer
the the
its its
organizations organizations
Europe, Europe, women women
Wherever Wherever use use
3,Membership, 3,Membership,
For For
National National
to to
American American
councils councils
Explorer Explorer
offers offers
to to
membership membership
world. world.
Board Board
pressures, pressures,
Many Many
year year
the the
local local
our our
affected affected
To To
and and
I~. I~.
I I
OF OF
-~ -~
19 19 4 4 REVIEW REVIEW CP001066 27
Appendix
~
of
top
and
Local
3,006
camp,
use
a
Council
Explorer
is
and
regions
their
Local
six
and
there
troops,
long-term
membership,
units,
the
33,
in
of
Scout
councils
councils,
each
council's
Scouting
Scouts
for
(Appendix
packs, to
local
local
each Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 26 of 51
418
the
Scout
totals.
service
about
of
leadership,
prepared
the
Cub
on
also
Units,
is
national
two-deep
137,335
information
Honor
effectiveness
index
depends
organizations.
the
with
of
the
gives
providing
This
as
serve
units
Scouting
COUNCILS
which
chartered
number
well
of
measure
they
magazine.
as
their
to
as
Index
trained,
Life
and
success
areas,
order
posts
In
The districts
LOCAL Council
leaders
29
advancement,
Boys'
26
Index.)
CP001067 BOARD,
N.J.
N.Y.
Jr.
Calif.
and
Commissioner
L.1,,
Executive
Jr.
.
Jr.
Vice-President
Vice-President
Vice-President
Vice-President
Vice-President
N.Y,
Treasurer
Ill
N.Y.
Ill.
Ill.
Fla.
Reneker
Watson,
Bay,
Price
McClure
Brunswick,
..
Scout
Reid,
Schiff
J
Parish
Francisco,
L.
Houghton
S.
M.
Monson,
C.
Honorary
Honorary
Honorary
lntern.ational
Honorary
Chicago, Naples, Armonk, Oyster Honorary
North
Chicago,
Chief Vice-President
Assistant Corning, Chicago,
San
Treasurer
COUNCIL
1977
RobertW.
Harvey
John
Amory
Arch Bryan
John Thomas
Archibald
EXECUTIVE
OFFICERS
OFFICERS
31,
December
'
NATIONAL
HONORARY
Calif.
ADVISORY
Calif.
Calif.
O.C.
OFFICERS,
Mo.
Vice-President
President
Vice-President
Vice-P.resldent
Vice-President
Jenks
N.J.
Be1:t1tel
Mirage,
Wash.
Tex.
Ford
B.
AND
Nave
K.
Murchison
Sloan
Clapp
Francisco,
Angeles,
Carter
R.
Louis,
J.
Feist
D.
K.
President
Dallas,
St.
Los
Vice-President
Honorary
Honorary
Honorary
Newark,
Honorary Rancho
Honorary
Vice-President Pinehurst, N.C.
Vice-President
Seattle,
San
Washington,
1.)
Downing
John
Irving
Norton
Henry
Kenneth
Gerald Jimmy
John
NATIONAL
(Appendix
41
54
29
46
Program,
78
Council,
42
Awards,
Championship,
44
45
42
Scouting
44
Grants,
36
Fitness
Advisory
the
44
Awards,
Development,
and
Conservation Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 27 of 51
48
Using
Adults,
44
48
45
and
Physical
Competition,
43
52
46
Scholarship
Championships,
and
Awards,
Board,
Scholarships,
41
42
Council
43
143
Contest,
Skills
Scout
57
Scholarship
Awards,
35
Growth
Scout
45
38
Sailing
74
Officers,
Awards,
77
143
Ill
43
Awards,
of
Scholarship,
Cub
Organizations
74
49
Executive
Assistance
Target
-Officers,
45
Photo
Awards,
Foundation
Bases,
Representatives,
Speaking
Agriculture
Index
75
Action,
Treasurer,
144
Sex,
Explorer
Summary,
Awards,
Awards,
of Scouters,
Camping-1977,
Antelope
Railroading
National
Scout
Advancement,
Spurgeon
Hornaday
Awards,
the
by
Explorer
Officers,
Cabinets, Explorer
Youth
Public
Sea
Chartered
Hoover
Membership-Youth
of
Foundation
of
of
H.
T.
of
American
Study,
Advancement,
Council
World
Badges,
Silver
Enforcement
Scout
Edgar
.•
Long-Term
National
Membership
68-Year Congressional
Law
National
Lifesaving
Local
National Regional
Report
Young
National National
1977 Winners
Explorers National High-Adventure National
Merit Winners Specialty-Association
Winners
Kemper
Scout
Gallup
-Exploration J Cub
William
Department
Silver
William
.Professional
1
7
6 6
8
2
3
4
9
10
11
16 17 18
12 13 14 15 27
23
26
36 28
19 20 21 22
24 25
29
30 31 32 33 34 35
Appendix
CP001068 31
N.Y.
Jr.
Utah
Pa.
O.C.
Mo.
D.C. D.C.
Tex.
L.I.,
S.D.
Ga.
N.Y.
Ohio
Ohio
City,
Wilson
Tex.
N.Y.
N.J. Ill.
Ill.
Parker
N.Y.
Parmley
Pirtle Reneker
Ohio Pirrung
Citv, Wilson
Watson, Bay,
Thomson Falls,
Tex.
Washington Parsons
Schiff
Schaeffer
McMillen
Roebling
Zeigler Worth, Starr
Schiff Sullivan
York,
J.
Foss
Lake
W, E.
A.
W. J.
W.
e.
B.
l-,
T,
North
H,
G.
M.
W.
W,
Reifel
Thomas
Fort
Bainbridge,
Washington,
Salt Chicago, Houston,
Chicago, Kansas
Tyler, Philadelphia, New
Sioux Oyster Armonk, Cincinnati, Ontario, Akron, Cincinnati,
Trenton, Washington, Washington,
Earle
LaVem
Wheeler
Gilbert Ben James George Robert David E.J, Edward Harry Leon Mary
Penn Dwight Wallace Walter
John Thomas John
Colo,
Fla.
'
Y.
Base.
Jr.
Ind.
N.
Calif.
Fla.
D.C.
Ohio
Beach, Mont.
COUNCIL
Jr.
Ga.
N.Y. Pa. N.Y.
N.Y.
Ohio
Ohio
Jr.
N.Y.
Knight
Ill.
N.Y. Force
Mo.
Fla.
Hansen
Firestone
Johnston
Mass.
t<:ennedy
Kendall Hudgins
Gray
Gott Palm
G.
Lingle, Falls,
Griffin k
1
Beach,
K,
R.
Fischer
York,
Air Garrison Johnson York,
York, McCollister
R,
M.
Jordan Lewis Angeles, Hauserman Houghton
H.
H.
C.R.
L.
Firman,
James,
T.
J.
E.
H.
Y.
l-loo
W.
M.
ndiariapolis,
New Los
Palm
N.orth I Pituburgh, ENT New New
Sebring, Cleveland, Great Chicago, Pleasantville,
Coming, Purchase.
Boston, Clayton,
Gainesville, Cincinnati,
Washington, WIiioughby,
Brittain
ADVISORY
Edwin Royal
Earle Milton Leonard
John Ben Elizabeth Zenon A.F. Hobart James Norfleet Daniel Donald
Harry F. Amory
Roy John
William
Walter
Kans.
Utah
Calif,
Fla.
Tax.
N.Y.
Minn.
Tex.
NJY.
N.Y.
Fetridge
Hawaii
Calif.
11.
Miss.
City,
Jr.
Mission.
i
Ill. Ill.
Minn, N.J.
Bechtel Ga.
Oreg.
Derby Mass.
Jr.
Wash.
Campbell
Featherstone
Beach, Catting
Campbell
Christen Baker
Benson
Douglas
K.
Bass
Budd Allen
York, A.
Worth, Detwiler
York,
D. deButts
J.
Lake J.
E.
Francisco, Christen
Clapp
C.
Antonio,
M.
Paul,
H.
Feist
R.
M.
M,
G.
D.
Cromb Harrison
Taft Allen,
A. Crosby,
Eugene,
Atlanta,
New Fort
Pleasantville, Pasadena,
Chicago, Boston, San St.
Salt Minneapolis, Seattle, Newark, Chicago, Honolulu,
Delray Shawnee San New Chicago,
Picayune,
Ivan Edwin
Kenneth
Ezra
Perry
John Paul Irving Harvey
Charles L.O. Johri William Norton
William
A.H. Vaughn Wm,
James
John
Stephen
John
Jr.
Jr.
Sr.
.
Ind.
La.
Calif.
D.C.
Ill.
Calif. Minn.
N,Y.
Ind.
Alaska
Jr.
Ohio
N.Y.
N,Y.
Md.
Calif.
Kans.
N.C.
Oreg.
~etersen
Ill.
Ramsdell Tex.
Calif.
Fla.
Parker
Pardee,
Calif.
Roesch Hills,
Nelsner
City,
I. Sarnoff
Schloss Tellepsen
Shumway
Whitney
Shannon,
Reid,
l-.
Worley
Phillips
Parish
Orleans,
York,
Norris
Schapiro B.
Sternberg, M.
R.
L. Sloan York,
T.
Young
W. N.
Angeles,
L.
S.
C.
Sevedge
S. G,
W.
D,
H.
K.
B.
Perlis
Rochester,
Indianapolis,
LaJolla,
Naples,
Columbus,
Anchorage, New Washington,
Chicago, Portland, New
Piedmont,
lndianpolis, Lawrence,
Baltimore,
Orange, Los
Houston, Beverly
New Granite Minneapolis,
Charlotte,
Kimball
Malvin
Max
George
Leo
Raymond John
Thomas
Vittz•James
John Bryan
Robert
William
John Keith
William Edfred
Forrest
Howard
John Bland
Gene
J.
John Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 28 of 51
Utah
Jr.
Calif.
Calif.
Minn.
La.
Ala.
Jr.
Pa.
BOARD
Wis.
Md.
Jr.
Mo.
Mo.
Md. N.C.
Mo.
City,
Jenks
Ga.
N.Y.
Ill. Mich.
Ohio
Kiefer Minn.
Falls,
Jackson
Jensen
McDonnell Kohnle
MacAvoy Jr.
Hartl
Nev. Monson
Marshall
McClure kea,
B. LaFortune
Tex.
Idaho
Okla.
Hummel
Johnson
Menk Neidhoefer
Mathis,
R. Nave A.
Orleans,
W. L. Krebs
C.
N.
Murchison
V.
Johnston, S.
Francisco,
Lake
J.
Louis,
Francisco,
Louis,
W.
E.
Louis,
W. Paul,
J.
A.
W.
w.
C.
Jamison
F.
Monson, Jung,
D.
Fergus
Reno,
Pittsburgh,
Atlanta, Detroit,
St.
St.
New
Baltimore,
Wheaton, Dayton,
Corning, San
Montgomery,
Tulsa, Boise,
St, Chicago,
San
Dallas,
Pinehurst, St. Saft Mllwau
Albert
EXECUTIVE
Peter
E.K.
William Downing
Reuben
A.L. Edward
Gale Richard James
Robert
Joseph Louis
Archibald Wart! Thomas Sanford Allen Arch
John
Thomas Henry
James
Jr.
Calif.
Utah
Minn. Calif.
Ind.
Calif. Ala.
Minn.
N.J.
N.Y.
Ark.
A.I.
lss.
Pa,
Mo. Gay
Ohio
Nev.
Ga. Tex.
Tex.
IIJ.
M City,
Paul,
Ohio
Brady
Eastman
Mirage,
Anderson
Briggs
Asfeld
Glib.ans Coy
Froessel
Clayton
Clements,
Flanders
Tex.
Hills,
Hanks
Hills, Ford
N.Y.
Ehre
St.
H.
Barnes
H.
H.
Donnell
P.
Smith,
F. HarPer Angeles,
W. Cathcart T. A.
H.
Louis, Francisco,
W. Lake
Bishop
Brown
D.
R. Vegas,
T.
E.
William
S.
R.
Coffield
I. Chesser Drexler
D.
C.
Short
Los West Valdosta, lndianapolfs,
St.
Birmingham, Chicago, Houston,
Jackson,
Dallas,
Rockdale,
Findlay,
Jadwin Cleveland,
Utica,
Mlnneapolls, Fort
Las San Forest
Ranch.a
Providence, Pittsburgh,
Salt
L. Robert
Zane
Rodney
Joe
Robert
Rex
Silas
Charles Francis
Alec
William
H.H. CP001069Fred
Frank Donald Victor Gerald John Whitney
Charles
Thomas Marion
John
30 33
Support
on
Service
Service
Health
Association
Field
Adventure
Service/Field
and
Committee
e
Exploring
Enforcement
Fla.
Exploring
Jr.
N.J.
Administration
Jones
N.J.
N.Y. Pring!
N.Y.
Va.
Lutheran
Clement
Palmer
Law
Law
Md.
Neisner
Aviation
Medical
Outdoor Frisch
McNltt
Sea
Oak.
M,
Mo.
G.
Kans.
McDonnell
E.
C.
B.
Field
Commissioner/Unit
Urban/Rural
Island,
Fitch,
Gaynor H.
Specialty
Dinger Sims
N.
Mo.
W.
River,
Ill.
York,
Kiefer
N.
L.
Md.
H.
Commissioner
R.
CitY,
Scouters
Tellepsen
Camping/Outdoor
Tex.
W.
Brunswick,
Scouting
of,
T.
Chairman, Jewish Melvin Rochester,
Ralph New
Chairman,
Louis,
CaraerS
Kenneth
Merritt
Chairman, Chairman, Chairman, Richard
Arthur Minot, Richard
Lawrence
Chairman, Alexandria, Robert Toms Chairman,
Chairman,
Annapolis,
Wichita,
Chairman, Harold Chairman, Robert Kansas
Sanford St.
Chairman, New
Morgan
Chicago,
Chairman,
Program
Richard Baltimore,
Chairman,
Howard Houston,
Chairman,
Calif.
Sloan
K.
for
Angeles,
Projects
Baptists
Los
Vlc1rPresident,
John
the
of Leadership
Arrow
Jr.
Training
Sr.
for
Committee
the
Relationships
end
Committee
Program
S.C.
Relationships
of
Colo,
Nattress,
Scout
Scouting
V~.
McCahill
Association
Aller\
Catholic
Church
Ohio Jr.
Ill.
Island,
Leadership
Advarcement
Lineb11rry,
Order Special
Fla.
Program
Fell
Ill.
Calif.
Ill,
P.
Hummel
Wilson Education
D.
Refiglous
Brady
Hauserman
Hitchcock
L.
Wm.
Park,
Cub
Scout
Exploring
Dreibelbis
Youth
Nev.
Tex.
Pa.
8.
Sternberg, Sr.
W.
City,
H.
M.
Scouting
Calif.
Scouting
F.
H.
G.eorge
Handicapped
Chesser
for
on
Civic
Chairman, Arlington,
Shannon,
Angeles,
Chairman,
Greensboro, N.C.
Albert
Chairman, LeRoy
Chairman, ' Ben
Cleveland,
Chicago,
,Wilflam
Development
Hinsdale,
Chairman,
Chairman, Peter Reno,
L.
Reuben Thomas Chairman,
Chipite Chairman,
Wadmalaw
Chairman,
Pensacola,
James
Chairman.,
Jason Oxford,
Chairman,
Granite
Gene
Los
Rodney
Houston, Chairman,
Chairman,
Alec
E.L.
Chairman,
Orange,
of
and
Training
Relations
Indian
Eagle Court
Support
Relationships
Fla.
N.J.
Jr.
Ind.
D.C.
D.C,
N.Y.
Compensation
Employee
National Bacon
La.
National
Professional
Labor
Key, American
Neisner
111.
Kamber
Starr
Blue
Ridge,
F.
Financial
Jr.
Personnel
Norris
B.
Association
S,
Kingsbury
es
W.
Clements, s.
Tex.
P.
Jung,
Orleans,
Benefits
Honor
Scout
Chairman,
Chari Chicago, Chairman, Basking
Relationships Longboat Indianapolis,
John
Chairman, John
Chairman, Chairman, Max
Melvin Rochester,
Brantley
Chairman, Washington,
Chairman,
Victor
Washington, Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 29 of 51
Dallas,
Chairman, Chairman, Wm.
New
A.L.
1977
Operations
Administration
COMMITTEES
31,
N.C.
Nave
Murchison
J.
Tex.
D.
Henry Pinehurst,
Vice-President,
Investment
December
Vice-President,
Dallas,
John
National
and
ranee
Ind.
Utah
nsu
NATIONAL
Community
Audit
I
Schloss
McClure Fatridge
II.
I
Jr.
L.
Va.
Finance
Gay
Magazines
Properties
McClure Donnelly Coy
Hanks Ohio
Supply Johnston
City,
Museum
JII.
Kobak
111.
Business
R.
A. Conn.
D.
Nev.
Communications
Flanders
Relationships/Membership
Ark.
B.
111. Reid,
Harrison
Lake
H.
Ghairman, Archibald Indianapolis,
Chicago,
S.
Chairman,
William
William
Chairman,
Vegas, Chicago,
Archibald Scouting
Chairman, Relationships Darien, Francis Chairman, James
Marion
Chairman,
Cleveland,
Salt
Chairman, Wm.
Chicago,
Smith,
Vice-chairman,
Springfield,
Thomas
Chairman; Bryan
Chicago,
Frank Las
Chairman,
Ft
Donald
Chairman,
32
CP001070 35
98,901 78,546
58,569
22,640
56,126
398,305
617,528
457,276
137,335
1,843,033
1,224,549
3,465,887
1,252,251
4,718,138
1977
SUMMARY
31,
Ships
and
Members
Membership
Packs
December
Posts
Scouters
Leaders
Total
Youth
Troops
Adults
Leaders
Units
Leaders
Scouts
MEMBERSHIP
Scout
·
I
Cub Explorers
Scouts
Total Pack
Post
Troop
Council
Grand
Total
Explorer
Cub
Scout
Total
2.)
(Appendix
Uniform
Safety
Events
Evaluation
and
Jr.
and
N.Y.
Augustine
Health
Activities Insignia Pardee,
National
Program
Hammond
Fla.
Va.
R.
Clayton
Calif.
Nebr.
P.
M.
C.
Poets
LaJolla,
Chairman, George Norman
Hugh Chairman, C.S.
Chairman,
Omaha, Donald
Bokeelia,
Monticello,
Chairman,
Chairman, McLean, Commissioner
I
lnt1rnational
Participation Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 30 of 51
for
Jamboree
International
International
Flanders
Ark.
World
Ohio
Foundation
Donnell
and
H. Jensen
International
Fetrldge
R.
Mich.
R.
U.S.
Smith,
Ill.
Parish
Fla.
Donald
Findlay,
Ft.
Chairman,
John
Chairman,
C.
Harrison
Ranch
Reuben Chairman, Detroit,
Scouting
Vice-President Naples,
John
Chairman, Wm.
Chicago,
Support
Adventure
D.C.
Camping
Conservation Towell
Pound
High
Philmont
N.Y.
Ohle
Ramsdell
Ga.
E
Donnell
E.
Program
Oreg.
R.
Jamison
Charles
Chairman, Armonk,
William Chairman,
Washington,
E.K.
Findlay,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Atlanta,
John
Vittz-James Chafrman, Portland,
34
CP001071 81,496 37 126,860 188,964 275,304 671,649 409,662 812,586 1,085,496 1,325,878 1,643,988 3,436,294 3,749,244 1,879,471 4,096,988 4,779,219 2,110,973 2,371,520 3,144,300 6,019,301 4,499,908 7,868,931 7,376,961 6,389,551 5,658,486 5,249,350 8,630,330 6,945,160 8,399,923 9,668.869 8,977,696 58,014,193 17,843,862 13,882.639 14,710,853 56,626,408 15,538,867 16,686,517 10,165,060 11,477,483 12,289,614 13,073,629 18,995,887 26,383,479 61,484,371 65,100,376 39,129,922 31,583,809 53,308,308 1910thru11) 10,769,041 24,675,358 42,376,467 45,997,048 47,795,216 49,628,049 40,746,314 44,139,905 29,944,471 23,037,343 21,537,885 28,100,522 20,236,331 33,076,901 36,058,864 34,524;816 37,590,314 69,311,859 60,651,879 · MEMBERSHIP 97,495 Vear 115,364 During 147,961 616,746 344,290 262,043 744,517 714,011 780,170 679,367 486,120 925,358 804,962 1,006,586 1,172,969 1,073,025 1;169,413 1,265,690 1,233,786 1,268,441 1,183,095 1.435,139 1,323,819 1,260,604 1,994.496 1,698,339 1,602,777 1,506,292 1,860,553 6,723,591 7,109,781 7,852,836 7,656,661 3,204,466 3,943,914 6,180,122 3,067.836 4,740,346 4,186,801 2,100,298 2,313,787 2,744,324 2,903,886 4,424,514 7,669,629 7,064.096 8,923,641 7,188,290 7,047,154 7,420,822 7,272,000 7,016,819 3,646,162 6,669,870 6,240,467 8,456,691 8,658,823 8,882,173 8,651.513 8,120,351 2,610.279 2,177,090 7,044,789 8,404,805 8,772,171 6,547,756 TOTAL , of GRAND Yeat 127,885 182,303 418,984 462,060 478,528 756,857 363,837 534,415 513,016 245,183 783,674 785,633 696,620 587,578 819,791 973,589 904.240 878,461 878,358 847,061 833,897 End 1,027,833 1,242,009 1,129,841 1,357,993 1,553,080 1,069,837 6.287,284 5,803,885 6,318,070 1,449,412 1,522,302 1,613,783 1,866,356 1,977,463 4,166,241 3,395,884 4,751,495 4,950.885 4,530,523 2,210,768 2,795,222 2,083,397, 2,942,779 2,141,984 2,579,616 6,405,225 5.210,294 6,427,026 3,774,015 6,247,160 6,512,597 6,685,700 6,058,608 6,043,195 5,160,958 5,322,167 3,183,266 5,732,708 5,446,910 4,884,082 4.718,138 6,831,541 1hru 1,433 5,228 8,294 15,089 14,494 20,686 30,518 42,046 60,769 81,400 102,348 148,925 124,908 184,829 454,024 234,283 296,564 690,303 369,411 563,221 848,100 , 1930 1,017,924 1,427,632 1,215,048 6,681,340 5,783,731 1,968,559 1,673,996 4,000,378 2,982,729 2,298,007 2,638,272 4,341,480 9,071.240 7,877,400 7,763,562 6,977,405 6,183,086 3,668,117 3,317,069 5,027,418 5,388,392 8,777,565 4,680,066 8,461,849 6,159,469 8,124,181 9,360,SBO 9,632,309 1,433 5,228 7,542 LEADERS 8,269 8,060 12.843 19,296' 23.232 Vear 42,009 66,691 34,117 66,775 49,161 80,458 During 104,211 176,425 141,468 981,301 502,388 440,348 261,563 215,485 753,892 648.290 386,342 317,067 570,761 879,253 963,498 1,097,267 1,066,719 1,255,526 1,284,363 1,016,764 1,044.,180 1,075,863 1,273,980 1,268,367 1,214,882 1,010,886 1,191,024 1,130,163 1,261,815 1,028,073 1,026,480 1,029,100 1,006,969 1,001,134 PACK of 1,433 Yur 4,986 7,246 4,342 4,674 9;464 End 14,738 11,704 28,213 21,378 41,758 79,187 64,557 36,697 44,754 ADULTS 170,128 120,668 140.465 102,678 286,974 216,724 777,926 786,628 587,758 253,794 425,875 711,090 757,779 720,683 790,431 643.888 644,194 646,599 665,865 686,975 789,662 766,493 666,466 376,055 628,125 633,945 508,088 634,101 651,801 335,937 800,932 623.018 617,528 thru 5,102 AND 26,662 69,848 48,090 138,023 186,749 100,033 449,639 262.428 710,899 341,809 673,553 852,311 1,042,897 1,866,536 1,587,479 1,311,667 4,026,611 2,180,074 6,566,326 3,526,347 3,036,121 5,114,658 2,511.,379 4,559,169 7,404,613 6,770,824 9,083,875 8,222,531 9,934,770 1930 12,835,798 17,699,004 18,670,004 11,710,120 13,581,387 14,529,086 10,848,633 15,543,127 18,895,980 ~p.761,396 25,866,994 24,833,297 20,083,966 23,705,111 21,290,674 22,512,615 27,607,914 28,424,190 , 6,102 44,083 25,662 64,739 51,884 82,373 YOUTH Y11r 182,514 147,418 114,615 During 234,953 696,014 442,853 286.402 759,829 373,813 335,775 574,605 887.215 819,487 1,774,179 1,339,861 1,472,955 1,606,249 1,263,668 1,142,079 3,664,287 2,050,625 2,691,153 2,762,027 2,540,691 3,762,367 3,031,137 3,602,688 3,763,202 2,841,958 2,915,972 2,762,480 3,280,955 3,467,738 3,121,035 3,513,746 2,887,791 2,738,966 '2,696,124 '3,742,411 ,;l.115,002 - '2,819,752 CUBSCOVTS ,2,346,090 of 5,102 23,361 70,880 27,831 34,065 57,274 43,762 92,995 Vaar 159,637 126,229 195,389 498,850 766,635 608,716 924,258 548,032 828,344 473,503 248,959 229,387 300,782 End 412,871 191G-24. 1,996,570 1,843,033 1,931,130 1,892,797 1,982,280 1,873,898 t.868,693 2,178,315 2,476,564 2,447,607 2,486,706 1,475,326 1.814,504 1,822,062 1,034,089 1,865,120 2,438,009 :~~;~J 2,063,743 2,361,366 2,380,336 2,243,174 1,236,683 1,101,413 2,125,394 thru belonging ,655 6,275 10,920 15,750 38.288 99,180 67,246 172,303 136,758 188,627 678,399 633,083 788,039 398,145 449,662 266,458 964,982 682,444 629,676 346,747 486,981 891,474 1910 8,576,034 7,709,302 7,941,970 8,383,001 1,069.384 1,201,941 7,470,194 6,746,794 7,008,198 8,749,337 7,234,951 1,755,554 1,378,682 1,649,632 1,137,327 1,983,057 1,552,262 1,463,652 1,868,824 1,276,712 6,247,758 6,491,274 8,916,514 3,28f 5,302,067 3,444,909 6,004,027 5,766,069 5,634,647 6,070,828 4,618,399 4,390,396 2,541,972 2,827,258 2,976,751 2,399,075 2,689,483 4,178,328 4,844,061 3,986,474 3,801,587 3,130,747 3,613,441 2,195,817 2,292,737 2,085,379 -'\8, 480,000 NEMBERSHIP and Seouu , 9,165 .. year Boy 13,760 70,455 33,083 54,762 90,923 v 135,662 172,244 166,623 153,389 During 187,980 154,668 192,280 773,827 330,767 310,021 723,110 484,064 200,709 272,151 216,002 239,644 258,381 259,367 986,340 984,111 916,646 641,368 673.606 647,317 313,167 335,152 610,122 303,327 682,429 321,472 694,110 824,793 413,645 422,886 266,739 409,923 369,441 387,361 307,437 878,961 400,824 413.884 1,171,692 1,162,8.92 1,160,144 1,067,503 1,089,568 1,199,986 1,177.810 1,173,988 1,244,394 1,103,278 1,221,024 1,131,799 1,049,269 1,070,434 1,109,279 1,087,546 1,082,185 1,136,066 SCOUTERS during became 5 of who 68-YEAR Yur(4) 8,930 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 31 of 51 10,545 End 25,804 38,621 54,345 88,737 82,793 belon91n51 155,3~3 101,991 114,374 164,7 129,304 193,747 141,878 120,727 176,619 189,068 191,968 719,757 765,141 227,501 219,476 752,873 722,331 701,867 778,815 629,924 568,885 766,083 796,639 389,109 621,036 839,618 817,998 820,575 831,009 813,176 805,621 848,710 477,115 419,476 416,592 287,354 283,519 217,134 496,732 211,197 203,166 439,815 469,779 821,679 316,648 306,774 303,207 733,997 341,167 802,303 814,697 232,862 222,467 290,441 240,490 307,601 661,135 834,723 .s52;399 Scouu total 1n Cub of thnJ figure. 55,220 173,214 116,940 237,016 472,469 676.828 342,416 876,868 (480,000) 1,661,311 1,069,420 1,297,241 1,884,539 1,481,326 3,711,869 4,277,833 4,829,821 4,658,211 2,611,217 2,857,895 7,100,418 7,467,236 3,119,568 3,413,544 6,111,667 6,011,986 3,887,745 6,353,467 5,899,911 included 8,660,529 7,848,148 9,143,641 6,719,277 9,582.409 5,404,187 8,233,191 1910 th11 30,307,664 26,623,668 29,737,630 26,830,589 27,428,632 29,079,125 25,049,139 15,803,496 19,477,852 11,469,491 18,003.122 15,136,728 16,485,086 12,591,275 12,049,665 17,272,658 10,023,070 10,881,429 14,483,797 10,458,155 18,749,628 13,166,980 13,786,143 24,214,551 28,265,551 21,028,371 23,384,498 20,262,248 22,607,936 21,816,219 30,800,988 31,222,407 1n reg1sirauon 45,000 Explorers EXPLORERS included 55,220 88,330 Vear multiple During (45,000) 101,604 114.878 737,378 638,339 567,890 560,622 481,084 207,281 273,836 988,976 896,484 923,728 924,779 624,798 953,822 572,273 395,197 938,441 929,769 805,877 857,023 869,642 AND 2,788,249 3,140,282 2,206,431 1,637,148 1,032,859 1,615.888 u:iin 2,491,230 3,040,099 3,093,306 3,337,312 3,098,923 1.622.669 1,837,404 1,774.887 1.481,969 1,483,232 1,072,010 1,167,374 1,279,433 1,356,927 1,410,368 1,319,981 1,527,015 1,118,261 1,866,539 1,972,633 2,295,264 2,679.666 2,986,567 2,977,544 2,919,039 3,112,403 1,230,716 2,692,645 2,238,823 2,344,039 2.493,511 2,836,308 2,136,726 2,763,612 2,656,217 ~bc;g,~:d, . be(:ama Leaders who SCOUTS of Ye1r 3.) Scouts 101,881 143,782 190,838 281,044 738,628 754,391 711,384 332,247 360,069 376,537 392,288 646,856 End District 406,111 446,700 781,604 606,965 692,132 600,316 623,382 606,396 652,541 541,227 595,565 873,533 943,556 910,572 956,160 968,003 830,883 882,789 1,936.277 2,149,339 1,680,524 • 1,617,985 1,044,534 1,064,770 1,655,097 2,405,220 2,396,504 2,328,955 2,167,293 1,157,341 1,864,701 1,243,305 1,800,669 1,057,750 1,036.895 1,012,446 1,726,031 1.634,672 1,917,953 1,316,508 1,397,380 2,244,649 penons-excludu 2,211,648 2,140,916 2,258,683 1,254,432 1,060,215 1,622,864 2,065,164 2,016,688 Hf}:~~~ & Boy of r~~~ts!:~~:~~IS~~~~.~~ and Different Council 36 11) 8l (Appendix (4) 1975 1910-11 1917 1978 1977 1926 1924 1925 192B 1918 1919 1920 1972 1936 1956 1913(2) 1969 1912 1922 1973 1934 1971 1930 1927 1921 1968 1932 1931 1929 1914 1915 1916 1956 1935 1967 1970 1974 1924(3) 194S 1947 1946 1966 1~63 1954 1957 1933 1962 1966 1938 1964 1937 1953 1948 1951 1961 1940 1949 1959 1950 1939 1942 1958 1944 1943 1960 1952 1941 •1923
CP001072
39 39
a a
of of
be be
to to
by by
or or
be be
at at
o! o!
or or
all all
by• by•
the the
the the
Act Act
the the
for for
the the
and and Act Act
this this
and and
con• con•
o! o!
Boy Boy
may may
with with
have have
shall shall
to to
whole whole
power power
coni;l.st coni;l.st
of of
passed passed
execu
of of
Scouts Scouts
the the
reports reports
quorum quorum
filled filled
number, number,
shall shall
shall shall
thds thds
to to
for for
this this
the the
prescribe prescribe
upon upon
pursuant pursuant
,ote ,ote
a a
definitely definitely
shall shall
successors successors
number number
the the
the the
number number
be be
of of
number number
as as
Boy Boy
have have
shall shall
.corporation, .corporation,
•by •by
Tbe Tbe
affixed affixed
resolution resolution
of of
conflict conflict
of of
and and
meeting meeting
right right
roay roay
papers papers
and and
descriptive descriptive
amend amend
liens liens
board board
powers powers
called called
annual annual
associates associates
their their
amend amend The The
be be
proceedings proceedings
their their
the the
said said
committees, committees,
or or
corporation, corporation,
whole whole
corporation corporation
to to
shall shall
incorporation, incorporation,
used used
resolution resolution
said said
section section
or or
to to
powers powers
the the
and and
the the and and
Its Its
of of
of of
majority majority
constitute constitute
the the
of of
States. States.
the the
affirmative affirmative
the the
America America in in
until until
their their
special special
by by
writing writing
a a
and and
bylaws bylaws said said
of of
manner manner
shall shall board
badges, badges,
to to
members members
first first
ot ot
of of
meeting meeting
of of
board board
bylaws. bylaws.
or or
exclusive exclusive
such such
in in
distinctly distinctly
alter, alter,
when when
the the
of of
executive executive
year year
more more
year year
a a
standing standing
Interfere Interfere
The The
affairs affairs
and and
any any
the the
and and
serve serve
may, may,
886. 886.
make make
the the
by by
exercise exercise
United United
or or
which which and and
heretofore heretofore
at at
report report
the the
the the
mortgages mortgages
In In
provided provided in in
each each
Scouts Scouts
being being
to to
documents, documents,
corporation corporation
in in
a a
of of
annual annual
or or
other other
consent consent
shall shall
executive executive
the the
of of
appeal, appeal,
bylaws, bylaws,
Stat. Stat.
m~ority m~ority
exercise exercise
It It
and and
Columbia. Columbia.
meetings meetings
necessary necessary
shall shall
sole sole
executive executive
three three board board
the the
a a
members members
Boy Boy
board, board, thereof. thereof.
to to
of of
'18 '18
board board
after after
any any
business business
of of
the the
the the
emblems emblems
illcorporators, illcorporators,
the the
any any
Act Act
extent extent
now now
the the
power power
of of
presented presented
and and
books, books,
may may
and and
dl11pose dl11pose
in in
at at
of of April
have have
the the
in in
board board
executed executed
all all
said said
th1p7-
the the
be be
the the
Congress Congress
Special Special
right right
the the
year year
mentioned mentioned
of of
to to
this this
With With
presarlbi;>d presarlbi;>d
of of
members members
preceding.• preceding.•
si;>al si;>al
,vhole ,vhole
and and
be be
program, program,
have have
committee, committee,
88-504, 88-504,
have have
of of
seal, seal,
the the
to to
citizens citizens
of of
to to
less less
board board
designate designate
shall shall
in in
District District
the the
executive executive
members members
be be appQ!nt appQ!nt
of of
executive executive
to to
day day
phrases phrases
its its
the the
shall shall
of of
the the
yi;>ar. yi;>ar.
of of
quorum quorum
be be
the the
La.w La.w
every every
members members
have have
shall shall shall shall
a a
or or
the the
Vacancies Vacancies
persons persons
executive executive
of of
purposes, purposes,
b:,laws. b:,laws.
out out
prescribed prescribed
The The
The The
may may
may may
first first
In In
have have
ofl!.ce ofl!.ce
body body
cause cause
board, board,
majority majority
autl1ority autl1ority
may may
The The
board board
be be
keep keep
meeting meeting
transmit transmit
It. It.
its its
as as
the the
nothing nothing
governing governing
thirty-first thirty-first
Publlc Publlc
the the
shall shall
The The
the the
a a
of of
executive executive
vote vote
board board
ensuing ensuing
committee, committee,
once once
remaining remaining
of of
shall shall
words words
and and
authorize authorize
or or
tlon. tlon.
management management
by by
out out
composed composed
of of
and and
board, board,
and and
ha'l'e ha'l'e
without without
corporation, corporation,
shall shall
whole whole that that
the the
1964, 1964,
to to
qualified. qualified.
carrying carrying
rights. rights.
first first
the the
notice notice
number number
bylaws. bylaws.
1916. 1916.
and and
corporation corporation
the the
before before
terms terms
or or
held held
as as
annual annual
require require
In In
governing governing
the the
80, 80,
executive executive
which which
vote vote
'bylaws. 'bylaws.
for for
the the
corporation. corporation.
of of
or or
make make
shall shall
in in
board board
the the
whole whole
be be
corpora corpora
December December
the the
have have
an an
· ·
constitute constitute shall
e::ifecutlve e::ifecutlve
of of
such such
of of
members members
and and the the
said said
Congress Congress
committees committees
power power
June June
two-thirds two-thirds
the the
veste,11. veste,11.
carrying carrying
may may
authorize authorize
on on
place place
executive executive
and and
Aur. Aur.
which which
meetings meetings
in in
the the
authorized authorized
the the
the the
of of
within within
vote vote
marks, marks,
however, however,
15 15
and and
in in
shall shall
or or
by by
by by
The The
shall shall
an an
elected elected
board board
board board
or or
That That
of of
and and
America America
of of
That That
upon upon
quorum, quorum,
have have
of of
That That
That That
whlt'h whlt'h
may may
ending ending
That That
their their
which which
time. time.
bylaws bylaws
a a
5. 5.
6. 6.
use, use, of of
9. 9.
7. 7.
executive executive
board, board,
affirmative affirmative
8. 8.
officers officers
and, and,
constitute constitute
a.mended a.mended
standing standing
majority majority
time time
may may
elected elected
board board
to to
board. board.
number number
year year
a a
an an
the the
the the an an
any any
called called
prescribed prescribed
hold hold
SEO, SEO,
majority majority
the the
America America
SEO, SEO,
SEO. SEO.
Approved Approved
SEO, SEO,
SEO. SEO.
•As •As
prescribed prescribed
are are
qualifications, qualifications,
shall shall
the the
ot ot of of
a a
the the
stitute stitute
purpose, purpose,
laws; laws;
by by
paper~ paper~ property property
and and
executive executive
in in
majority majority
constitute constitute
such such
conferred conferred
to to
executive executive
to to
property property
members members such such be be
successors successors
be be
tive tive designating designating
and and Scouts Scouts
of of understood, understood,
corporation corporation
the the at at
of of
est1tblished est1tblished
P. P.
of of
to to
A. A.
be be
of of
do do
for for
Act Act
and and
anl:I anl:I
and and
pur
New New
laws laws
them them
adopt adopt
to to
States States
of of
Frank Frank
which which
States States
thin~ thin~
Beard, Beard,
Seeley, Seeley,
and and
States; States;
Boston, Boston,
of of
through through
not not
this this
Hart, Hart,
the the
Milton Milton
assets assets
L. L.
Ernest Ernest
dividends dividends
liabilities liabilities
Columbia, Columbia,
Plainfield, Plainfield,
America," America,"
and and
offices offices
Baltimore, Baltimore, of of day day
successors, successors,
and and
sue sue
teach teach
of of
boys boys
bequest; bequest;
corporation corporation
D. D.
Neill, Neill,
F. F.
or or
of of
of of
and and
of of
of of
United United
the the
United-
Columbia Columbia
to to
West, West,
Carter Carter
to to
pay pay
and and
or or
corporate corporate
of of
P. P.
United United
associates associates
and and
methods methods
• •
under under
purpoal!II purpoal!II
acts acts
have have
1ia,th 1ia,th
Tenn.; Tenn.;
make make
of of
said said
E. E.
or or
all all
the the
the the
promote, promote,
AMERICA AMERICA
of of
and and
for for
debts debts to to
the the
the the
to to
Calif.; Calif.;
Jackson, Jackson,
of of
the the of of
Scouts Scouts
fifteen fifteen
power power
to to
Charles Charles
other other
but but
OF OF
such such
Daniel Daniel
Murray, Murray,
Garrett, Garrett,
District District
of of
devise, devise,
gift, gift,
provisions provisions
ability ability
C. C.
Charles Charles
; ;
any any
character character
for for
James James
be be
Bristol, Bristol,
D. D.
all all
declare declare
District District
of of
ancZ ancZ
using using
laws laws
associates associates
"Boy "Boy
with with
the the
the the
the the
Ill. Ill.
of of
election election
for for
gift, gift,
Livingstone Livingstone
N.Y.; N.Y.;
Stati;>B; Stati;>B;
to to
and and
corporation corporation
do do
and and
the the
the the
pleasure; pleasure;
ne<"essary ne<"essary STATES STATES
be be
of of
Uonaav, Uonaav,
Robert Robert
Berkeley, Berkeley,
Scoutcraft, Scoutcraft, Jenks, Jenks,
a a
ACTION ACTION
shall shall
way way
by by
or or
to to
H. H.
the>ir the>ir
the the
Charles Charles
at at
be be
on on
effect effect
ot ot
In In
applicable; applicable;
w. w.
virtues, virtues,
W!lliam W!lliam
by by
with with
hundred hundred
jurisdiction jurisdiction
shall shall
United United
benevolent benevolent
provide provide
N.Y.; N.Y.;
for for
Schiff, Schiff,
America., America.,
Pa.; Pa.;
Chicago, Chicago,
be be
SESSION SESSION
Rrprrsentativee Rrprrsentativee
Dulaney, Dulaney,
stock stock
I I
agencies, agencies,
politic politic
without without
Colin Colin
UNITED UNITED
Into Into
succession, succession,
Scouts, Scouts,
a a
shall shall
of of
Brooklyn, Brooklyn,
them them
Pa.; Pa.; the the I I
L. L.
of of
L. L.
ot ot
the the of of
Conn.; Conn.;
nine nine
property property
destroy destroy and and
Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 32 of 51
Jordan, Jordan,
gene,ally gene,ally
as as
of of
and and
and and of of
shall shall
ldndred ldndred
THE THE
of of
acquire, acquire,
FIRST FIRST
Boy Boy
other other
.corporation .corporation
That That
Jeremiah Jeremiah
carry carry
train train
Butralo, Butralo,
and and
Scouts Scouts
"Washington "Washington
OF OF
and and
of of
House House
within within
and and
to to
inconsistent inconsistent
White, White,
Starr Starr
to to
of of
corporation corporation
defray defray
THE THE
may may
of of
this this
perpetual perpetual
corporation. corporation.
estate estate
Scouts. Scouts.
regulations regulations
Boy Boy
solely solely
Pratt, Pratt,
assets assets
within within
with with
l\Iortlmer l\Iortlmer personal personal
Norwalk, Norwalk,
Benjamin Benjamin
Hoyt, Hoyt,
thousana thousana
Philadelphia, Philadelphia,
alter alter
and and
not not
Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh,
AT AT
Jr;, Jr;,
ot ot
.certificates .certificates
of of
the the
and and
this this
D. D. C. C.
corporate corporate
of of
of of
said said
to to
Citv Citv
Boy Boy
equity equity
of of
have have
David David
said said
and and
Territories Territories
thereof, thereof,
one one
others, others,
asaembled, asaembled, of of
being being
of of
D.C.; D.C.;
CONGRESS CONGRESS
affairs affairs
by by
issue issue
the the
members. members.
be. be.
Rich, Rich,
Stamford Stamford
necessary necessary
personal personal
Senate Senate
and and
body body
ri;>al ri;>al
same same
and and
and and
Hoyt, Hoyt,
organization organization
shall shall
to to
at at
Robinson, Robinson,
self-reliance, self-reliance,
purpose purpose
Porter, Porter,
George George
use use
a a corporation corporation
be be
State State
and and
Its Its
A. A.
which which
name name
Mich.; Mich.;
CONGRESSIONAL CONGRESSIONAL
the the
cooperation cooperation
it it
Franklin Franklin
; ;
and and
Incorporate Incorporate
shall shall
regulations regulations
law law
Columbia, Columbia,
the the
D. D.
l\I. l\I.
to to
of of
purposes purposes
the the
Nicholson, Nicholson,
by by
to to
establishing establishing
held held
Congre/18 Congre/18
purposes purposes
any any
the the
Barrett Barrett
may may
said said
of of
of of
December, December,
States States
power power
and and
receive receive
and and
Pa.; Pa.;
N.Y.; N.Y.;
N.C. N.C.
real real
and and
H. H.
name name
the the
or or
in, in,
national national
G. G.
as as
created created
Sherman Sherman
the the
and and
ACT ACT
courage, courage,
common common
business business
to to
Detroit, Detroit,
no no
4.) 4.)
and and
pro:flt pro:flt
themselves themselves
Edgar Edgar
SIXTY·FOUBTH SIXTY·FOUBTH
That That
George George
That That
domicile domicile
That That
otWashington, otWashington,
in in
of of
AN AN seal, seal,
courts courts
its its
such such
rules, rules,
enacted enacted
that that
John John
2. 2.
8. 8.
4. 4.
several several
and and
for for
District District discharge discharge
Its Its
a a
N.Y.: N.Y.:
John John
and and
it it
in in
have have
by by
Begun Begun
hereby hereby
promote promote
now now
existing existing
object object
Flushing, Flushing,
A'?'erica A'?'erica
Asheville, Asheville,
hold hold
America, America,
the the
the the
the the
SEc. SEc.
Be Be
SEO. SEO.
SEO. SEO.
(Including (Including
of of
Bicknell, Bicknell,
of of
of of
McRae, McRae,
Philadelphia, Philadelphia,
to to
Mass.; Mass.;
Md.; Md.; York, York,
of of
sued sued
Presbrey, Presbrey, and and
where where
N.J.: N.J.:
poses, poses,
are are
bylaws, bylaws,
In In
conduct conduct
and and adopt adopt
successors) successors)
organization, organization,
patriotism, patriotism,
things things
are are
the the
of of
to to
shall shall
its its
pecuniary pecuniary
(Appendix (Appendix 38 38
CP001073
41 41
Tim Tim
June June
Gary Gary
Scott Scott
Teddy Teddy
Scouts Scouts
of of
Saunders, Saunders,
Southeast Southeast
59.5 59.5
67.5 67.5
57.4 57.4
54.3 54.3
69.9 69.9
50.0 50.0
62.5 62.5
Cub Cub
Outto, Outto,
Petrie, Petrie,
Membership Membership
J.R. J.R.
Lemaster, Lemaster,
Percimt Percimt
$.C. $.C.
Ferguson, Ferguson,
Region. Region.
Doug Doug
Council, Council,
Darren Darren
Mark Mark
Scouts Scouts
Tom Tom
Area Area
Central Central
Scouts Scouts
Hartsville, Hartsville,
Region. Region.
Cub Cub
Scouts Scouts
Scouts Scouts
6,465 6,465
7,331 7,331
Dee Dee
3,318 3,318
6,549 6,549
6,049 6,049
4,306 4,306
Region. Region.
Troops Troops
Camping Camping
Scouts Scouts
34,018 34,018
Region. Region.
Cub Cub
South South
Cub Cub
PTO, PTO,
Okla. Okla.
Region. Region.
Cub Cub
Pee Pee
Cub Cub
Western Western
Pa. Pa.
Central Central
Calif. Calif.
Central Central
Ohio. Ohio.
School School
June June
Council, Council,
Minn. Minn.
O"Neal. O"Neal.
East East
of of
Northeast Northeast
Heavener, Heavener,
1 1
Council, Council,
North North
Lionville, Lionville,
Tulare, Tulare,
51.9 51.9
51.2 51.2
42. 42.
39.9 39.9
44.4 44.4
42.0 42.0
43.6 43.6
SCOUT SCOUT
CAMPING-1977 CAMPING-1977
NatiOl)S NatiOl)S
Austin, Austin,
Membership Membership
Area Area
Club, Club,
Scottie Scottie
Perce.nt Perce.nt
Council, Council,
Elamentary Elamentary
PTA, PTA,
Council, Council,
Cardington, Cardington,
PTA, PTA,
Council, Council,
am;l am;l
CUB CUB
Jaycees, Jaycees,
Indian Indian
Lions Lions
Area Area
Whitney Whitney
Club, Club,
School School
County County
Area Area
Valley Valley
School School
Mt. Mt.
CHAMPIONSHIP CHAMPIONSHIP
Hartsville Hartsville
Harding Harding
Heavener Heavener
McKnight, McKnight,
Manlfo.rd. Manlfo.rd.
78,719 78,719
59,039 59,039
94,121 94,121
84,998 84,998
47,176 47,176
Rotary Rotary
LONG-TERM LONG-TERM
Scouts Scouts
113,642 113,642
Exton Exton
Camping Camping
477,695 477,695
Garden Garden Shaw Shaw
West West
Chester Chester
30, 30,
414, 414,
NATIONAL NATIONAL
Beckman. Beckman.
B1.aine B1.aine
Roger Roger
108, 108,
519, 519,
261, 261,
221, 221,
Lytle. Lytle.
Poorman. Poorman.
Twin Twin Brandt.
FITNESS FITNESS
Pack Pack
Pack Pack
OF OF
and and
Billy Billy
Pack Pack
Pack Pack
Pack Pack
6.) 6.)
Pack Pack
5.) 5.)
Dan Dan
Tim Tim
Mark Mark
Totals Totals
and and
Place. Place.
Place. Place.
Central Central
Central Central
and and
and and
Cheek, Cheek,
end end
Place. Place.
Place. Place.
Lawrimore, Lawrimore,
Place. Place.
Central Central
Place. Place.
Region Region
National National
North North
Northeast Northeast
East East
Lytle, Lytle,
First First
(Appendix (Appendix
Fourth Fourth
Priebe, Priebe,
South South
Fifth Fifth
Southeast Southeast
Western Western Morris, Morris,
Ragion. Ragion. Mark Mark
Johnson, Johnson,
Sixth Sixth
Michel Michel
Third Third
Second Second (Appendix (Appendix
PHYSICAL PHYSICAL
WINNERS WINNERS
of of
is is
in in
to to
of of
of of
of of
so so
by by
or or
the the
in
the the
the the
the the
the the
boy. boy.
may may
755) 755)
Ohio Ohio
it it
high high
4,000 4,000
work work
Scout Scout
as as
alone. alone.
avail
educa
of of
educa
Scout. Scout.
having having
States. States.
coming coming
him him
amend
printed. printed.
of of
present present
and and
tests tests
the the
mllitary mllitary
with with
is is
Republic Republic
its its
the the
it, it,
following following
tests tests
and and
President President
award award
character character
woven woven
the the
will, will,
the the
during during
be be
at at the the
Committee Committee
movement, movement,
(H.R. (H.R.
problem problem
where where
the the
commenda
establishing establishing
of of
of of
name name
the the
of of
of of
of of
of of
with with
assistance assistance
the the
to to
protection protection
the the
of of
bill bill
distinctive distinctive
officials officials
that that
modern modern
United United
seal seal
are are
the the
of of
the the
in in
the the
report report
ot ot
bill bill
maintenance maintenance
certain certain
insignia, insignia,
repute repute
to to
by by
juvenile juvenile
bill bill
doors doors
requdrlng requdrlng
It It
of of
its its
the the
rapidly rapidly
required required
life life
educating educating
this this
value value
the the
protection protection
general general
community community
a a
the the
Its Its
the the
of of
to to
from from
self-rellance, self-rellance,
the the
o.ccaslon o.ccaslon
pass pass
tor tor
good good
In In
Army Army
ordered ordered
designates designates
ot ot
features features
of of
the the
and and
reduce reduce
practical practical
the the
in in
Insignia Insignia
magnitude magnitude
purpose purpose
out out
In In
such such
to to
ceremonies ceremonies
sess;J sess;J
submitting submitting
following following
grown grown
insignia insignia
the the
the the
every every
development development
to to
and and
established established
insignia-a insignia-a
American American citizenship.
protect protect
physical physical
and and
Imitating Imitating
and and
received received
recognized recognized
promote promote
the the
2d 2d
and and
Grand Grand
referred referred
by by
on on
Cross Cross
which which
the the
force force
SESSION SESSION
has has
addition addition
la~·s la~·s
of of
and and
reported reported
leading leading
of of
to to
order order
Involved Involved
is is
by by
maintenance maintenance
to to
recommendation recommendation
meeting meeting
Congress Congress
much much
and and
the the
protection protection
for for
endurance, endurance,
and and
insure insure
In In
was was
a a
In In
healthful healthful
use use
the the
profit profit
was was
enlarge enlarge
the the
by by
of of
type type
Cong., Cong.,
and and
badges badges
inaugural inaugural
communities communities
work work
Calendar Calendar
Judiciary, Judiciary,
first-aid first-aid
tests tests
all all
practically practically
submit submit
patent patent
demonstrated demonstrated
and and
ot ot to to
Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 33 of 51
ser~lces ser~lces
Incorporated Incorporated
does does
to to
uniform uniform
the the
and and
to to
In In
of of
auxiliary auxiliary
Its Its
with with
seelting seelting
and and
proper proper
which which
methods methods
the the
without without
whom whom
movement movement
honor, honor,
study study
Importance Importance
64th 64th
the the
the the
by by
one one
which which
movement movement
the the
was was
small small
attention attention
have have
National.Red National.Red
House House
an an
to to
reunion reunion
in in
to to
passing passing
highest highest
various various
one one
on on
the the
and and
Their Their
on on
great great
various various
America America
intellectual, intellectual,
The The
Insignia. Insignia.
leal'e leal'e
with with
180, 180,
1016, 1016,
results results
seeking seeking
The The
laws laws
as as
strength strength
,and ,and
bfll bfll
the the
pass. pass.
under under
essential essential
with with
of of
badges badges
not not
3, 3,
The The
Scout Scout
the the
him him
boy boy
of of
very very
19907, 19907,
many many
beg beg
are are
these these
organized organized
and and
upon upon
No. No.
iR iR
to to
Scouts Scouts
do do
these these
is is
but but
this this
in in
755). 755).
cities. cities.
protected protected
supplement supplement
moral, moral,
the the
In In
of of
the the
reunion, reunion,
the the
Aniel'ican Aniel'ican
resourcefulness, resourcefulness,
of of
code code
only. only.
these these
Judiciary, Judiciary,
b111 b111
of of
who who
H.R. H.R.
Is Is
now now
nationwide nationwide
Boy Boy
memorable memorable
to to
administration administration
of of
Scouts Scouts
same, same,
physical physical
received received
the the
Committee Committee
Rept. Rept.
recognition recognition
based based
the the
All All
laws laws
which which
H.R. H.R.
Immediate Immediate
is is
or or
and and
the the
medals medals
as as
requires requires
emergencies. emergencies.
Likewise Likewise
the the
the the
and and
organization organization
February February
in in
Is Is
today today
the the
to to
tl:lls tl:lls
it it
meaningless meaningless
the the
of of
CONGRESS--SECOND CONGRESS--SECOND
those those
Governments. Governments.
it it
the the
or or
Boy Boy
[H. [H.
Its Its
years years placing placing
they they
period period
activities activities
secure secure
on on
recent recent
it it
movement movement
passing passing
of of
on on
In In
be be
the the
cloth. cloth.
over over
lost. lost.
from from
that that
2 2
patent patent
in in
in in
language language
of of
the the
public public
time time
attracted attracted
intended intended
until until
Gettysburg Gettysburg
known known
the the
from from
conserve conserve
1916-Referred 1916-Referred
can can
developed developed
be be
popularity popularity
lines, lines,
from from
the the
State State
The The
pass. pass.
and and
standard standard
scheme scheme
boys boys
the the
is is
and and
soon soon
badges badges
past past
it it
at at
Scout Scout
and and
initiative initiative
to to
accompany accompany
integrity integrity
entitle entitle
limited limited
a a
the the
17, 17,
do do
training training
considered considered
by by
boy boy
great great
provide provide years years
and and
will will
delinquency delinquency
a a
the the
into· into·
and and
incorporation. incorporation.
but but
of of
to to
the the
scheme scheme
as as
and and
(to (to
Judiciary Judiciary
will will
at at
better better
present present
the the
Committee Committee
Gard, Gard,
order order
Scout Scout
Boy Boy
Identical Identical
thereto, thereto,
facilities facilities
of of
proper proper
a a
tends tends
and and
any any
few few
for for
particularly particularly
up up
protect protect
the the
the the
incorporate incorporate
the the
Is Is
Washington Washington
such such
The The
Mr. Mr.
It It
The The
The The
If If
The The
to to
report report
SIXTY-FOURTH SIXTY-FOURTH
juvenile· juvenile·
be be
FEllRU.A.llY FEllRU.A.llY recommendation recommendation
system, system,
generation generation
tion tion
past past
During During
carefully carefully
powers powers
through through
tional tional
times times
inhabitants inhabitants
Federal Federal
In In public public
floods, floods,
It It Federal Federal
tion tion
badges badges
able able
Wilson Wilson
appropriate appropriate
believed, believed,
live live
standing standing
is is
on on
qualification. qualification.
along along
protected protected
and and
signia, signia,
ments ments
program program At At
stamped stamped
.aU1ended, .aU1ended, 40 40
CP001074 43
Des
end
989,
,Post
Post
N.J.,
Northeast
Region.
Region.
Cana)oharie,
_Church,
Region.
ch.airman,
Region.
Tex.,
Region.
Region.
Region.
Region.
Region.
Region.
Council,
Region.
Region.
Central
Region.
Region.
Region.
R·egion.
Region.
Western
Northeast
Succa~unna,
Dallas,
chairman,
Central
Western
Region.
Central
Area
Tompkins,
Presbyterian
Southeast
Region.
North
Central
Central
Central
Western
Region.
Western L.
Central
Region.
Western
Western
Council,
North
54, Southeast
Council,
North
Northeast
Council,
chairman,
South
South
chairman,
East
North
Northeast
Council,
Region. Western
Council,
Central
MacKenzie,
Post
Council,
Robert
Valley
Council,
Council,
Area
Council,
S.
Morris-Sussex
Council,
Council,
Levy,
Johnson
Southeast
Council,
Council,
East
Peak
Lake
Council,
Council,
Council,
Sediacek, Council,
Central
Warrior
Area
Council,
Council,
Area
Mark
Gabrial
Pacific
County
Area
Salt
Pikes
Area
Explorers.
Area
Marlon
Group,
William
Ohio
Yosemite
Council,
Black
America
Area Area
Felice
Council, Mid-Iowa
Sen
Lights
South
Sir
Oiego
of
OFFICERS Tendoy
Great
Colo.,
Adams
High-Adventure
Area
Ala.,
Calif.,
Baltimora
Orleans
Columbia
Central
Explorers.
Valley San Calif.,
Houston
Citizens
Police,
Heart
Samoset
Council,
Stanford
Explorers. Utah,
York
Idaho,
Northern
Church,
Md.,
Exploring.
New
East
View,
Enforcement
Sam
Ohio,
Oreg.,
AWARDS
Atlanta
Calif.,
Ten
Pa.,
Local
Academy,
Wis.,
City,
Moines Marino,
City,
Kans.,
La.,
Calif.,
Oak.,
Pa.,
University,
Aviation
Law
Ga.,
Medical
Tex.,
Corporation:
N.
Des
San
AWARDS
101,
Lutheran
Circle
of
York,
Lake
Jr.,
of
of
USAF
Alto,
Malad
Mountain
Portland,
Tlmoniurn,
Delaware,
21,
Encinitas,
Government
$alt
Metairie,
Clairtoll,
Post
Marshfield,
Lawrence,
Minot, Atlanta,
Palo
Christ
Houston,
Post
and
Perkins,
Chemical
Hospital(
11.) 12.) 10.)
TY-ASSOCIATION
AM.ERICAN
Thomas,
Sandow,
Eng,
Phelps,
112,
Thomas,
Rayermann,
Stambaugh,
Craft,
Association
Law
Association Buttz,
McKenney,
Association
Kwak,
Hughes,
Meyer,
D. Worrell,
L. Bonaparte,
E.
L.
tows,
s.
Dochlnger,
Brasselle,
H.
L.
Hoke
Maxey,
H.
R.
G,
1
Allied A.
M.
Post w.
L.
o.
I
s.
E.
z.
••
.Y
Lee High-Adventure oavld Robert Richard
National National Region.
N
Larry Douglas (Appendix SPECIAL Moines, National Beth Presbyterian National EXPLORATION Allen YOUNG Merk Larry
656, (Appendix Harris Ruth (Appendix Patrick Oanlel
Bradley Ann
Douglas
Andrew
Tracey
Area
Calif.
Post
Post
Callf.,
184,
Schiff
Moose
Western
Boshell,
Council,
Southeast
Post Jose,
Restaurant
37,
E.
Region,
604,
Rescue
Region.
Burbank,
Region.
San
GRANTS
Region.
and
Post
Ship
and
Council,
Birmingham
Council,
Medical
Outdoor-Adventure
Minuteman
Western
Ill.
High-Adventure
Fire
Ehring,
Western
N.J.,
Central
Thomas
Hanlon,
Hotel
Region.
A.
Iowa,
Northeast
Ala.,
AWARDS Ark.,
Fla.,
B.
Mass.
Stream
East
County
Calif.,
WHITE
Council,
Dain
Council,
Eric
Mass.,
Council.
Park,
Gulf
Place.
Hills
Council.
Homewood,
Southeast Council,
AND
Toro,
Clara
Succasunna,
Council,
Waterloo,
Fla.
Place.
SCHOLARSHIP
Pl~ce.
Wakefield,
El
Falls,
Empire
Fayetteville, Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 34 of 51
Winter Area
County
lrmingham,
First
BLACK
Region,
Region,
Santa B
Second Council,
Third Verdugo
Region,
Beach,
Region,
Council.
Lower
Sagamore Region.
Golden
Norutnbega
Region,
Orange
Region,
SCHOLARSHIP
Westark
SCOUT
Bernabeo,
Palm
Ind.
P.
Central
Calif.
Council.
Central
Florida
Central
Western Northeast
Council,
Central
Western
Bellevue,
Newton
Church,
Burnsville,
OFFICERS
Council.
North East
Dana
McCllntock,
Southeast
California,
Marion,
PHOTO
Corporation,
Area
North
of
Central
South
North
Area
Roseville,
Allyn,
Olson,
Winnebago
Council,
Award.
Samson,
State
Maxey,
J.
Craig
president,
M.
Marriott
Presbyterian
J.
L.
Church,
vice-president,
SCOUT
vice-president,
Evergreen
Harmer,
and
RAILROADING
Council,
Watchung
W.
vice-president,
vies-president,
J.
619,
Hospital,
EXPLORER
Seattle
Donald
OF
Council.
Daniel
vice-president,
OF
United
vice-president,
Jeffrey
7.)
Executive's
Wash.,
Michael
8.)
Post
9.) McMillan,
County
David
McGann,
Council.
Foster,
Viking
McKnight,
First
Region.
Place.
Place,
Chief
Presbyterian
P.
Rom,
T,
Place.
Small,
Place.
Memorial
K.
Calumet
Scout
Place.
K.
Burkhardt,
Reservation,
C.
Place.
S.
Orange
200,
First
(Appendix
WINNERS
COLOR First
Snohomish, Minn., Region.
Western
Second
Region.
Third Wash. (Appendix
Chief
Northeast
First
Region.
WINNERS
Third
NATIONAL
Second Robert
Lo\Jge,
David (Appendix
Management
64, Lori
628, Craig Post Scout Steven
Thomas Mark
Scholtz
42
CP001075 45
716
750
1,037
1,382
1,381
South South
South
South
10,115
15,381
Central
Central
Central
Councll, Council,
Northeast
1s11
Attendance
Region.
Region.
in
Lake
of
Area
South
South
big
South
Council,
Council,
Council,
Council,
of
Canoe
Salt
Florida
Central
Council, acres
Area
Gaddo
Western
the
Wisconsin's Yucca
miles
Council,
Council,
Nation·s
Council,
backpacking, Nations
Great
South
in
Tropical
million
Tex.,
from
Caddo
Mohican
Tex., 61.5%
3,500 38.5%
lore, Principals
Area
Yucca
Utah,
100.0%
Council,
Yucca
Indian
COMPETITION Superior-Ouatico
AWARDS
Indian
five
Association
Police
Council,
located
Tex.,
Paso,
N.Y.,
the
City, Ill
SEX
Tex.,
of
Topmiller
Bar
School
Tex,,
Caddo
Okla.,
in
Western
El extending
Ore-Ida
providing Okla.,
L.
Texarkana,
BY
Yucca
Lake
its
Paso,
Falls,
SKILLS
Paso,
Chiefs
Tex.,
El
centrally
Idaho,
Salt
located
of
encompassing
Tex., with
El
Texarkana,
American
Owasso,
153,347
244,958
398,305
Charles
Secondary
programs
Owasso,
Gateway
Glens
McBryde,
Base
of
Ontario.
Base
the
Base
Paso,
Koenemann,
SPURGEON
of with
of
El
Meridian,
Section,
Erceg, Texarkana,
TARGET Gateway
Eastwood,
Kevin
Thomas,
H.
Gus McBryde,
Thomas,
Koenemann,
Association
Canoe Canoe
Adventure
EXPLORERS
Koenamann,
rivers
L.
Omaha
Explorer
BASES
Gary
Province
Association
Gus First,
Motors Corporation
clin'lblng.
of
Kevin Lawyers
Adventure
High
Gus
Kenneth
second, Anthony
Thurgood,
and the
McBryde,
Gary Males Females
Total
Koenemann,
Adventure
·
National
Florida
rock
third,
Wilderness
third,
High
and
Waters.
Lakes
National
International
Mutual
General WILLIAM Young
First,
·
Kei~h
Gus
Winners.
First,
second, and
to
Kevin
Ranch
EXPLORER High
second
Kentucky-Tennessee. and
First,
and
Region;
the
in
18.} 19.}
northern
17.J
third, third,
Sommers
Wis,consin
riding,
Scout
Maine.
Minnesota
Position.
Region;
the
second,
L.
Region; Region;
Gateway
Manitowish
and and Region;
Position,
Region.
National
Aggregate
Central
Position.
Between
to
shoreline
Northern Land
famous northern horseback
Florida lake Philmont (Appendix 20.) northern (Appendix
Keys Maine Base. (Appendix Charles HIGH-ADVENTURE
(Appendix
Grand
Region; Region; NATIONAL South Central Region; Prone Region,
Central
Central Central Sitting
Western Standing
'
•
'
Louis
New
Gulf
'
Wis.,
Long
•
Central
Bonti, Louis
Council
Council
Angeles
Angeles
St
Theodore
Northeast
23,
Hospital,
'
'
St.
•
Hill,
Fla.
East
Los
Lisa
Los
' •
'
•
•
403
Ship
9774
Lake Florida
Frontier
and
•
Grant
Milwaukee,
Council
Raton
Post
Post
1016X
1016X
Council
Last
and
N.Y.,
South
Ashman,
Boca
Kolesar
Post
Post
Administration
Valley
622,
Safety
Pavelchik,
691;
Calif.,
Rye,
Shawnee
Tom
Post
•
Moran,
Department
Richard
Passaic
Don
21
Public
Post
and
Veteran's
I
of
CHAMPIONSHIPS
and
Department
Department
and
Gene 504,
Post
Valencia,
61,
Police
SCHOLARSHIPS
AWARDS Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 35 of 51
and
VanOermeer,
Post
Department
Post
Friend
Schattgen
Police
Russell
Sheriff's
Sheriff's
Department
County
Rhodes,
of
David
Department
Police
Chris
Safety
SAILING
Steve
Roland
Mike
Explorer
Council.
Louis
Mark
Eric
Order
Police
Angeles
Angeles
Okla.
Ariz.
crew, SCHOLARSHIP
crew,
St.
Public
crew,
crew,
Region.
Los
Los
Fla.
ASSISTANCE
crew,
crew,
Council.
Council.
FOUNDATION
Medical
City,
Region.
Region.
N.J.
Fraternal
Region
Calif.
Region
Calif.
Re(lion
Region Phoenix,
Area
Area
Western
Utah.
EXPLORER
Region
Region
Region.
Region.
Central
Ohio.
klahoma
Western Wayne,
Plantation,
0
Council.
Central
Beach
Central
Council.
Bridgeton;Mo.
Orleans
Central
Westcheper-Putnam
Sandy,
Torrance,
SEA
HOOVER
Council,
Lima, Region.
North
Bejarano,
Lakewood,
Northeast
13.}
Western
Western
Western
Area
14.) FOUNDATION
Long
15.)
Horn,
Southeast
16.}
New
East
North
South Reed,
N.Y.,
Council.
R.
Region.
County
L. Lake
Romania,
Wies,
Gailey, Waingold,
E.
Saez,
La.,
ENFORCEMENT
Louis
Pl~ce.
Place.
Central
Council. S.
L.Javies,
Calif.,
D.
Council,
Place.
R.
Salt
N.
Place.
Council,
Council,
Place.
Place.
EDGAR
St.
(Appendix
Emilinda
Roosevelt J.
Rebecca
George
Area
South
Car1;1e1a Region. Mel
Southeast Region.
(Appendix
Ter,:y
LAW
Barry (Appendix
Area
Area
John KEMPER
Leslie
(Appendix
Great
Fil'$t
NATIONAL Larchmont,
Beach,
Orleans, Fourth
Fitth Third
Second
Stream
Milwaukee 44
Mo.,
Sixth
CP001076 47
205,
108,
344,
736,
47,
Oreg.
Ohio
47, 352, 216,
47,
47,
Troop
14,
47,
Pa,
67,
14,
1334,
Troop
47,
Troop
197,
535,
Troop
Troop
Troop
Troop
Troop
Troop
Post
Troop
Minn.
Alto,
N.Y.
Wis. Troop
Troop Troop
Troop
Ind.
Tenn.
Troop
Pa.
Ind.
Troop
Calif.
Troop
111.
Hermiston,
Mansfield,
Ky,
Pa.
Ky. Ky.
Ky. Ky.
Ky.
Krenzer,
Swanson,
Stewart,
Md.
Kagy,
Wikle, Mont
eld,
S. Takle,
C.
Dam,
Wis.
Weisensel,
Valley,
Klein,
121, 664,
Watts,
L.
Mayberry,
W.
Haven,
Ziegler,
Sweeney,
C.
Rouse,
Smith, Haven,
Ziegler,
Taurrnan,
32,
Streible,
Marino,
J.
Roberson,
Badges
Michael
Louisville,
Apple
Beltsville,
Beaver New
Louisville, Louisville,
Louisville,
Louisville, Louisville,
Potosi, Morristown,
New
Mifflinburg,
Levittown,
Sprlngfi
Spencerport,
San Michael
Dan
Certificates
William
John E. Post
Troop Troop Jeffrey
Dean Ralph Alvie
David Jerry Paul
David
Ray Dave Scott
Jamie Jerry
Hornaday
Hornaday
T.
T,
212,
62,
Calif.
629.
600,
115,
,
33,
4,
47,
47,
18,
60,
47,
692,
48,
City,
William
Ky.
4,
Troop
32,
47,
Ill.
Troop
Troop
47,
Post
William
Calif.
Troop
Troop
.•
Ill, Troop
Troop
Troop
Troop Troop
Troop
Troop
Jr
Troop
Troop
Troop Troop
Wis.
Mo.
Troop
Tex.
Fla.
HJ.
Redwood
Arleta, Ky.
Ky.
Chicago,
Ky. Ky.
Ky.
Ives,
Reese
Louisville,
Oreg.
Clark, Sandridge, N.C.
Conn.
Hartless,
Calif.
Brown,
Spencer,
Iran
Iran
Evans,
Nebr.
Averna,
City,
L.
Heinemann., Boyd,
G,
E.
T.
110,
D.
D. 422, 47, A.
Shafer,
Shepherd,
Dearinger,
Shepherd,
Pa.
D,
J.
Arthur,
3498,
A.
Bogaert,
Humphrey,
Crowder,
Kansas
Louisville, Kinston, Louisville,
Portland, Louisville,
Louisville,
Louisville,
Hollywood,
Erie, Cypress,
Port Gering,
Ansonia,
Charleston,
Tehran,
Tehran,
Winneconne,
Brian
David
Kevin
Millard
Roger Roger
Kevin Chris Roger Wayne Richard
Ray Pack
Mark
Joseph
Jeff Jack
Jeff
Troop William Troop Troop
1
35,
748,
36,
246,
•
47,
135,
47,
47,
19,
241,
47,
47,
Troop
Colo.
47,
Trc;,op
Troop
Troop
Post
Calif.
Troop
Calif.
Troop
Troop
Ind.
Troop
Ind.
Troop
Troop
Mich.
Troop
COUNCIL
Keyes,
Ky.
Ky.
Md.
Ky,
Ky.
Ohio
Troop
Pueblo,
Large, Okla.
Keyes,
Moore,
Beach,
Beach,
M.
Knoop,
Menzie,
Knoop,
B.
M.
Johnson,
Nevitt, Kingsley,
109,
Loklts, Nutt,
AWARDS
Marcotte,
Medals
Laguna
Vandalia,
Laguna
Louisville,
Kalamazoo,
Louisville, Jeffersonville, Edward
Craig Nannen,
Jeffersonville,
Louisville, Post
Greenbelt,
Jason
Louisville,
Tom
Charles
Kirk
Dennis
Kevin AWARDS
Joe
William Steve
Mike
Timothy
Mass.
Pt
Awards Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 36 of 51
Award
Va.
Iowa
Tex.
Dak,
N.C.
Ohio
S.
Sei!I
N,J.
Seal
Hornaday
AGRICULTURE
City,
Bedford,
HORNADAY
T.
OF
Gold Huron,
New Green Dover,
Philadelphia,
Raleigh,
Marlon,
Winchester,
Beaumont,
Sioux T.
274,
377,
424,
35,
496,
47,
William
47,
29
47,
77,
CONSERVATION
47,
Troop
47,
Post
47,
Troop
Troop
Calif.
Troop
Troop
Troop
Troop
Pa,
Troop
La.
Troop
WILI..IAM
Troop
Va.
Troop Ky.
Ky.
Ky.
Ky.
Ky.
Ohio
Troop
Ky.
Oak.
Figg,
Buttz,
Bahr,
Beach,
Albrecht,
Gray,
N.
Doidge, Berger,
E.
DEPARTMENT
R.
Mo.
Gardner,
A.
21.)
Orleans,
T. Berger,
G. Fourcade,
C.
22.)
Berger,
Hofmann,
Berger,
Louisvllle,
Louisville, Massillon,
Louisville, Williamsport,
Louisville,
Louisville, Kirk Laguna
Hale,
Minot,
New
Mark Louisville,
Ed
Bill
Winchester,
Harris
Jimmy
Robert
Dennis
Tom David
Gary
John
Jim
(Appendix
(Appendix
46
CP001077 49 Committee Committee Committee Committee Jr. Committee Committee Development Jr. Jr. Jr. Gibson Recognition Committee and Committee Committee Jr. McNair N.J. Committee Pa. Md. Fischer Sewell, N.Y. Pa. N.Y. Pa. Groce, N.Y. .J. A. Ky. Henry Tipton Cola Pa. Maine Bartholomew. S. N Creighton, H. Hahn, Cianchette N.J. Elliott Ga. M. L. L. D. Finance Exploring Administration Program P. Communications Scout Planning Membership/Relationships Memberships Volunteer E. E. S. Vice-President McCullough York, Vernen, York, Hafer President President John James Couns.el 1 l? Region Region Lau.ranee Newark, New Herbert Drumore, New Arthur Pittsfield, Hagerstown, Pittsburgh, Russell Louisville, Alton Donald John New Atlanta, Merle Frank P,aterson, Boyertown, Dr. Champney Paul Philadelphia, Murray Jamestown, G. Regional Chairman, Chairman, Chairmen, Area Legal Chairman, Chairman, Chairman, Area Chairman, Chairman, Chairman, Chairman, Northeast Southeast Jr. Jr. Jr. Jr. Committee MacAvoy Pa. CABINETS Pa. R.I. N.Y. c. Scout Conn. N.Y. N.Y. Hughes Groce, Dubois Kleinert Miss. N.C. Bone Livin.gston, Bartholomew, Worley Creighton, Marano N.Y. N.J. N.J. 25.) Ga, D, E. Cartcun Levingston Riffle E. W. Cub P. Forge, R, J. N.Y. W. President Vice-President Vice-President Vice-President President Vice-President Vice-President Vice-President R. York, B. York, President Pre,ldent President President President Thomas James 5 1 3 4 2 New New~rk, Philadelphia. Robert New Utica, Valley Arthur Dr. HerbertM. Bland Greenwich, Newark, Arthur Walter Rocco G. Charlotte, Alan Atlanta, Woonsocket, Jacques Jack Jamestown, Thomas Cleveland, Corning, Stanley REGIONAL Area Regional Regional Regional Regional Chairman, Area Regional Regi6nal Regional Regional Area Area Area (Appendix I of Gulf Sam Ridge Holy Valley Colony Quivira Catholic Church, Chehaw Catholic Council, Catholic National Lutheran the Church Gulf Latter-day Old School, of Church, Okaw of Club, Roman Church, Baptist Roman Grande Church, Roman United High Church, Andrews Christ Rio Society Hospital, Yacht First School, St. Spirit Methodist Baptist Gorretti · Jesus Theresa's Shore Name 164, Wheatley 472, Shepherd of Methodist Holy Church, Region. St. Maria United Congregational Arrow Whiteside 5, Washington Holy South Good St. Sherwood 942, Phyllis Troop Troop First United Church the 53, Central Fort 96, Pack Christian Scout Pilgrim l07, 111, 102, 155, Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 37 of 51 of 64, N.Y., Region. Ind., 9718, 131, First Troop East Region. Post Post 532, Cub First 1671, Troop Post Post Mass., CONTEST Post Troop 172, Region. Troop Order Region. Troop Calif., Region. Post Ill., Western Heights, 222, Ship Wis., .• Mass., Wis., Ga., Council, Pa., Tex., Pack Wash., Northeast Region. Tex Washington, Md., Chief, Region. Western Kans., Region. Diego, Allis, Roxbury, Central Troop Fla., Northeast Council, Bicentennial County Region. Hill, Albeny, Belleville, Baraboo, Yorktown Hingham, San REPRESENTATIVES East Houston, Ephrata, Reading, Central Region. Laredo, West SPEAKING West Council, Tex., Central Council, Wichita, National Oxen Northeast Kiy, Brandon, Jr., Council, Armstrong, Ware, Bishop, East Region. Region. South Ward, Davies, Maxey, Central Garsson, Southeast Murphy, Washington Council, Young, MIiwaukee A. R. Ebright, Duke, Benito, Region. C. Lindsey, A. Region. I. Region. County Z. F. YOUTH K. PUBLIC Murray, H. Mason, Council, San Central Central Alan Lakes South Region. Lee Thomas Mountain Council, Alan Council, Flanagan, Keith Alexander Kevin 23.) Central 24.) Keith Diego Lee John Council, Jeffery Ch\Jrch, Reid Todd Richard Division A. Southeast Four Boston North Area Southeast Northeast North San Westchester-Putnam Trails Hawk Place. Place. Richard Place. Place, Division Area North Central Place. Boswell, Place. Place. Place. Place. Council, Scout Place. Place. Place. NATIONAL Cub (Appendix Council, Scout Explorer Christ, Church, Newman (Appendix Church, Chris NATIONAL South First Hoosier Scout Fourth Fifth Explorer Second Third Council, Church, Coast Houston Council, First Fourth Church, Fifth Council, Council, Sixth Second Assumption Third Capital Sixth Saints, 48 ,
CP001078 51
Committee
Committee
Committee
Committee
Committee
Committee
Sr.
Resources
Committee
Kans.
Committee
Committee
Committee
Committee
lfl.
Minn.
Committee
Hanson
Whitney
Mo.
McCord
Minn.
Mission,
Ashton
Sternberg, Tex.
Tex.
Nebr.
Exploring
City,
M. Administration
Finance
Manpower
Communications
Relationships
C.
Scout Exploring
Administration
Finance Lavery
Tex.
Personnel Relationships
C. Tex.
H. Tex.
Okla,
Barksdale
Cromb Harvey
Calvert Skutt
Thayer Paul,
Louis,
C.
Kimball
Region
S.t. John
Minneapolis, J.
St. C.C.
Granite Gene
Omaha,
A.H.
Shawnee
Bernoid •V.J.
Midland,
Paul Dallas,
D.W.
Dallas,
Tulsa, Houston,
Carl WIiiiam Dallas,
Omar
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chaim,an,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chaitman,
Chairman,
Chairman, Chairman,
Central Region
Central
North
South
Trails)
Waters)
Central)
West
I I I I I
Committe.e
Committee
Okla,
Oak.
(Old
Ill
{Many
Ill
(Great Foster
Committee
Mo.
S. Colo. Scout
Johnson
Jr.
Ark. Minn.
Ark.
P.
Mo. Asfeld
Mex. Scout
Gaynor
Mo.
Quackenbush Starr Jouflian
Tucker City,
LaFortune Minn.
Barnes
M.
Tex.
Tex.
Kroeger
N.
H.
City,
Cub C.
Scout
0. J. M.
M.
President
Vice-President Dye,
E. Falls,
Cub
Okla.
President
Vice-President
R.
Hembree
Hembree LouJs,
President Smith,
President
Smith,
Paul, President L.
Robert
Jadwln
.President President President President
1
2
3
1
2
3 Zana L. 4
St.
St. Lakewood, Frank
Clifford Rochester,
Kansas RobeJit
Sioux
Jean Dr. Mary1111,e,
Robert H.L.
Fort H.L. Tulsa, Fort Edward
Houston, Oklahoma Roy
Amarillo, Roswell,
William William
Regional Regional
Area
Area
Area
Chairman,
Chairman,
Regional
Regional
Area
Area
Area Area
Chairman,
Chairman
Committee
Large
Large
at
at
Chairman
Chairman
Committee
Resources
Jr. Chairman Committee
Chairman
Committee
Member
Member N.C. Committee
Committee
Jr.
Jr.
Chairman
Bowers
Committee Ala.
M.D.
Committee
Ill.
Church Md.
Grier,
Scout
N.C.
Kiefer
R.
Ind. Clayton
Ind.
N.C. Czapor
Committee Wis. e,
Md.
Coy
Ohio
M.
Repids, C. Mich.
Long,
Neidhoefer
Finance
P.
T.
W.
Manpower
Resources
Cub Wilson,
Scout Exploring
Committee Relationships
Ohio
Committee
Johnson A,
Stark,
nvilf
J.
Committee
Committee
R.
Mich.
Cotta
R.
Davidsmeyer
J.
L.
John
Committee
Lawrence Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 38 of 51 Scout Whiteville,
Birmingham,
Charles Dr.
Edward Pinehurst, Anderson, Region M'redith
Roanoke
Hagerstown, Willie Anderson, Jackso J.R. John
Richard Fremont, Baltimore,
Ted
Belpre, Jack
Flint,
Francis John
Cleveland, Milwaukee,
James
Chairman,
Chairman,
Relationships Chairman,
Chairman,
Exploring Manpower
Chairman,
Scout
Chairman,
Cub
Communications Executive
Executive
Central
East
Committee
Committee
Fla.
Austin
N.C.
Chairman
Godwin
Tenn.
H.
Ind.
Urban
Ga. Lawler
Sandlin R.
Chambers
Wis.
Parker
Ohio
Ohio
Rahmberg
H. Bennett
Beach,
Kuntz
Miss. R.
Va.
Laws
Bishop E.
Mich.
Mich.
L.
Schrank
Administration
Communications Mich.
J.
8. A.
Ill.
J.
S. Ohio
President P.
Vice-President
Richard President
President
Sha/hope
President
President
Gro11e,
Aymond
Committee
Arnold
President Frank
President 3
4
President
5 President
6
President President
1
Lumbertown,
Joseph 2
Tupelo, 3 Chauncey
Brunswick, Lea John 4
Ormond 5 6
Chattanooga, W.
Beverley Norfolk,
Thomas Hon. Columbus, Lansing,
Elm Dr.
Robert
Midland,
Charles Edward Edwin Peoria, Bloomington,
Donald
Akron,
Springfield, A.H.
Jackson,
Area
Area
Area
Area
Chairman,
· Chairman,
Regional
Regional
Area
Area
Area
Area
Area Area
Finance
50
CP001079 Ill.
Okla.
Tex.
Mo.
Calif.
Ind.
Ind.
Calif.
Wis.
City,
Springfield,
Calif.
Wash,
Ohio
Tex.
City,
Calif.
Ohio
Minn.
Calif.
Kans.
II.
Iowa
I
Tex.
Utah
Galveston,
Ariz.
Upland,
Mills,
Tex.
Wayne,
Tex.
Calif.
I
Okla.
Hills,
Pasadena,
M.
Waukesha,
Merced,
Oklahoma
Altos,
Kansas
City,
Spokane,
Fort
Abilene,
Indianapolis,
Mich.
M.D.,
Dallas, Cleveland,
Nebr.
111,
Lacrosse,
Los
Glencoa,
Columbus,
Diego,
Ill,
Houston,
Northen,
Tulsa,
Waterloo,
Phoenix,
M.D.,
Fretz,
Lake
Laguna
Houston,
Region
Minneapolis,
Region
North
Richard
Flint,
Jr.,
Wofford,
Region
San
R.
·.
Taylor,
Church,
Jr.,
'
Salt
Omaha,
eg1on
Parker,
Minto,
Lougheed,
Cowles
Elliott,
McCord,
Joullian
Moody
Bauar,
Shave!,
Alexander,
.•
R M.
•.
Lang,
L
Fink,
Landes,
Silverstein,
Hultman, Humburg,
C.
M.
C. B, H.
P.
Watson,
Dye,
Central
H. Waananen,
A
Dean
Central
Torrey
Garner,
Whidden,
S.
Donald
J.
O;P.
L.
Central
O.
L.
Oliver,
L.
Marv
0.
Skutt,
Honorable
Abe
Joe
estern
East
Ernest
North
Evan
Edward
Meredith
Carroll Philip
Edward
V.J.
Dr.
Cook Dr.
Gian
Robert The Roy
Mrs.
Jack
Glen
Thomas
George
Arvi South George William
William
William
William
Julius
Walter
,Judge
;•
'
1
·.
•
,
·
''W
,.
,
0
','.,
,.
1
lfil
,,
,"
./·
1
·
·
Coll)mittee
Committee
Committee
Commtttee
Committee
Resources
Committee
Committee
Committee
Utah
Scout
Calif.
Sage
Johnson
Calif.
Arnold
Calif.
Baker Calif.
Calif,
City,
Le
Oreg,
McKee
Wash.
Greene
R.
Exploring
Finance
Varsity
Communications Manpower
Relationships
Administration Activities
Ham
M.
CitY,
F.
Stimpson
D.
Alto,
Nuys,
Lake
E.
Richard Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 39 of 51
Foster
Edwin Eugene,
Donald Lee
Irving
Alva
Seattle, Michael Dr. Palo Pasadena,
Salt Athfrton,
Van
James
Region
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman, Chairman,
Chairman,
Chairman,
Conn.
AWARDS
Western
N.Y.
Ala.
N.Y.
Ky.
Ga.
Va.
Fla.
N.J.
Pa.
N.Y.
Pa.
Ky.
Mess.
N.J.
N.Y. Greenwich,
Miss.
..
Athens,
N.C.
Apopka,
Jr
Warren,
Rochester,
Haledon,
Manhassett,
Frankfort,
Yorktown,
Birmingham,
York,
Norton,
Md.
Ridge,
Committee
Lancaster,
Fretz
Jamestown,
Jr.,
ANTELOPE
Owensboro,
Utah
Jr.,
Calif.
Atiyeh
Jackson,
Brasher North
R.
Davison,
New Jr.,
Committee
Glen
Raleigh,
Calif.
Carroll,
Scout
G.
F.
Godby,
C.
Akerman,
Calif.
Speirs
LaVale,
Marlett
Calif.
City,
Oreg.
McDonald,
Bacho, Sr., !'lorn
Brice,
M.
Calif.
Region
26.)
E.
Region
Krebs
Calif.
L.
Blauser,
Hood,
K. Combs,
Scout
Cub
Fernandes,
E.
J.
Bartholomew,
Donald Carnahan,
A.
Swartz,
President
C.
Young,
Reiber,
Bradley,
Hall,
Schiller,
M.
Waananen
H.
A.
Victo.r
Lake
E.
SILVER P.
Altos,
Von
Francisco,
Burton
President
President
President
President
President
H.
Loring
E.
B.
S.
Julian
A.
5
1
3 4
2
S.
Frederick Ronald
Khlar
Joseph
Alan
LeRoy
Los
Arcadia,
D.
Albert
Burlingame, Arvl
Dr.
Merced,
Salt
Torrance,
Portland,
San
Judge
Ward
Sen.
Gary
Dr.
Ivan Fred
Robert Dr.
Gov.
52 Dr. Houston
David Warren
1977
John
Dr. Dr. Paul Northeast John
Joseph Southeast
Stanley
S.
Arthur
Chairman,
Area
Regional Area
Area
Chairman, Area
Area
(Appendix
CP001080 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 40 of 51
NATIONAL CHARTERED ORGANIZATIONS USING THE SCOUTING PROGRAM Cub Scouts Scouts Explorers Total ~ Youth Youth Youth Youth iS A. Rl:LIGIOUS BODIES Units Members Units Members Units Members Units Members ~ African Methodist Episcopal .•..•••.•..•.•.... 166 2,798 203 2,844 26 231 395 5,873 ~ African Methodist "3 Episcopal Zion •••••.•.•.•.. 57 977 81 1,019 10 69 148 2,065 Assemblies of God N ••...••••••••••••..•..••••• 21 301 31 414 5 70 57 785 ...... Baptist •...... •••...... ••...•.... 2.408 56,392 3,601 63,322 330 4,475 6,339 124,189 Buddhist ...... 22 444 23 589 4' 67 49 1,100 Christian ctiurch-Oisciples of Christ ..•.•.••... 544 18,340 882 18,223 87 1,208 1,513 37,771 Christian Methodist . 57 Episcopal ••••..•••..•••.. 49 626 731 6 83 112 1,440 Church of Christ ••.•.•••.••••••.••••..•.•.•.• 141 4,474 215 3,973 11 117 367 8,564 Church of God ••••••.•.••..•••••••.••..•..•. 169 2,790 297 3,908 15 133 481 6,831 Church of Brethren •.•••..••••.•••.••••••••.• 50 1,782 74 1,506 2 11 126 3.299 Church of Nazarene •••••.••••••••••••••••••.• 24 552 68 1,042 5 77 97 1.671 Community-Federated•Union •••••...•.••••••• 274 9,321 347 8,366 35 476 656 18,163 Eastern Orthodox (Greek, Russian, Serbian) •.• 15 654 44 1,120 3 40 62 1,814 Friends (Society of Friends) •.•••• , ...... 13 426 35 702 4 28 52 1,156 Jewish-Synagogues and Centers •••••••••.••••• 173 4,574 257 5,733 29 360 459 10,667 Latter-day Saints "Mormon" •••.•••.•••••..•• 4,302 79,199 5,146 87,336 5,135 48,447 14,583 214,982 Lutheran ••.•••••••.•.•••••••••••••••••.••••• 1,929 66,162 2,844 62,532 273 3,645 5,046 132,339 Moravian ...... , ...... 26 841 40 824 4 58 70 1,723 Presbyterian ••••••••••••••.••.••••.••••..••.• 1,752 66,374 2,892 72,363 360 5,348 5,004 144,085 Protestant Episcopal .•••.••.•.•.••.••••••.•.• 518 18,932 993 24,065 117 1,775 1,628 44.772 Reformed ...... 108 3,998 167 3,641 14 192 289 7,831 Reorganized Latter Day Saints •.. ·••.•••••••••• ~ 49 1,356 91 1,684 7 117 147 3,157 Roman Catholic Parishes 1) •••.•.•••••••••..• I 4,498 165,111 4,810 115,944 498 7,723 9,806 288,778 Salvation Army ...... 205 3,823 277 4,058 19 203 501 8,084 Unitarian Universalist •...•••••..••••••.•.•••• 22 1,032 40 .1.020 9 100 71 2,152 United Church of Christ ...... 7.80 30,081 1,163 28,167 1·12 1,890 2,055 60,138 United Methodist ...... 4,530 164,316 6,359 146,720 704 10,011 11.593 321.047 Other Churches ••••••••••••..••.••..•••••••.• 671 16,860 922 17,626 143 1,847 ~ 36,333 TOTAL •••••••••.••••••••••.•••••••••••.••• 23,516 722,536 31,959 679,472 7,967 88,801 63,442 1,490,809 PERCENT OF GRANO TOTAL ••••••••••.• 41.9 39.2 54.6 55.5 35.2 22.3 46.2 43.0
SQ Total' Youth Youth Youth Youth B. CIVIC ANO COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS Units Members Units Members Units Members Units Members
Active 20..30 International ...... 2 79 4 113 , 11 7 203 Air Force ...... 211 10,639 239 6,964 149 2;495 599 20,098 American Legion and Auxiliary •.•...... ••.... 1,059 35,879 1,639 32,131 182 2,354 2,880 70,364 American Veterans of World War ll .••..••••. , 13 507 22 460 13 161 48 1,128 Army ....••••.•..••.••..••••.•.••..••..••... 251 11,519 363 9,330 273 4,007 887 24,856 Boys' Clubs ...... 60 1,116 81 1,404 12 130 153 2,650 Chamber of Commerce-Businessmen's Assn ... . 218 7,457 224 4,141 49 1,267 491 12,865 Civitan International .••••••.••.•••.••••••••.. 90 3,125 128 2,712 22 32B 240 6,165 Coast Guard •••••...••••••••..•.••••.•.••••.. 4 109 13 370 34 557 51 1,036 Conservation Clubs or Groups •...•••••.•...•• 3 69 25 470 24 311 52 850 Disabled American Veterans •...... •.•.•..... 22 377 51 745 5 53 78 1,175 District Committee-5cout Council •.•••.••.••.• 153 3,394 151 2,859 171 2,387 475 8,640 Eagles, Fraternal Order •••••.••••••..••.•.••.. 33 1,336 39 748 7 140 79 2,224 Economic Opportunity Agencies .•...... 87 2,015 122 2,332 64 1,460 273 5,807 Elks, Benevolent and Protective Order of .••••• 278 11,325 492 10,678 100 1,463 870 23,466 Exchange National ....•••.•••••..•..•.••••••. 43 1,584 74 1,752 14 166 131 3,502 Farm Bureau•Farrn·Cooperatives ..•.••••••.•.. 4 127 6 154 1 38 11 319 Fire Departments ...••...•.••.•.•.•....••.•.. 824 27,540 1,102 21,052 537 7,767 2,463 56,359 Governmental Bodies .••.•..•.•..••.••••.•... 89 2,173 139 2,501 208 3,974 436 8,648 Grange ••.•••.••••••••••.••..•••.•...••••...• 78 2,508 103 2,030 3 22 184 4,560 Group of Citizens ...... 1,737 43,381 1,260 23.409 535 6,843 3,532 73.633 Housing Projects •••••....••.•.•....•...•..•.. 349 6,033 371 5,908 49 738 769 12,679 Indian Tribal Councils ....••.....•••.•.••.••.. 13 146 17 273 11 122 41 541 Industry ••.•...•••.•••...••.•.•.•••.•.••..•. 782 22,906 1,110 20,749 3.378 67,798 5,270 111,453 Izaak Walton League .•.•...... •••....•.. 3 75 6 140 6 229 15 444 Jaycees U.S ...... 501 18,381 477 9,676 104 1,596 1,082 29,653 Kiwanis International •..••...•.•••.....•••.•. 626 24,287 940 20,456 184 3,119 1,750 47,862 Knights of Columbus •••.•....••..•....•.•.... 335 12,015 560 12,193 53 841 948 25,049 Knights of Pythias ...... 11 352 20 416 0 • 0 31 768 Labor Organizations ..•...•..•.•••..•...•.... 43 1,548 75 1,457 19 251 137 3,256 Lions International ...... en . 1,840 64,267 2,325 46,063 248 3,786 4,413 114,116 en Masonic Bodies ...... 61 1,744 107 1,812 9 139 177 3,695 Men's Clubs ...... •...... •...... •••.... 95 2,776 112 2,295 22 304 229 5,375 Moose, Loyal Order of ...... 82 2,984 137 2,551 20 257 239 5,792 Navy, Marines ...... 100 4,301 136 3,521 114 1,935 350 9,757
CP001081 Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 41 of 51
EXHIBIT 3
Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 42 of 51
1 SEDGWICK LLP JOHN G. GHERINI (SBN 220981) 2 [email protected] SHEYANNE H. BANE (SBN 239395) 3 sheyanne. [email protected] DAVID D. MESA (SBN 257488) 4 david. [email protected] 333 Bush Street, 30th Floor 5 San Francisco, CA 94104-2834 Telephone: (415) 781-7900 6 Facsimile: (415) 781-2635
7 Attorneys for Defendants BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA and GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA 8
9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10 COUNTY OF SOLANO - SOLANO ruSTICE CENTER
11
12 Mark Dietrich, Individually, CASE NO.: FCS041141
13 Plaintiff, [Assigned For All Purposes To Judge Paul L. Beeman, Dept. 1] 14 V. DECLARATION OF AL WESTBERG IN 15 Defendant Doe 1, Scouting Organization; SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS Defendant Doe 2, Council; and Does 3 BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND 16 through 100, inclusive, GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY 17 Defendants. JUDGMENT, OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION 18 [Served concurrently with Notice ofMotion and 19 Motion for Summary Judgment, Separate Statement of Undisputed Facts, Compendium of 20 Evidence, Compendium of Out-ofState Authorities, Request for Judicial Notice and 21 [Proposed] Order]
22 DATE: December 16, 2015 23 TIME: 8:30 a.m. DEPT: 1 24
25 Complaint Filed: January 30, 2013 26 Trial Date: February 2, 2016
27
28 20445928v] 1 DECLARATION OF AL WESTBERG IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 43 of 51
1 I, Al Westberg, declare:
2 1. I am an Area Director for the Boy Scouts of America ("BSA"), a defendant in the
3 above-entitled action. As the Area ·Director, I have personal knowledge or knowledge gained as
4 a representative of BSA of the facts in this Declaration and would testify to them if called to do
5 so.
6 2. The scouting movement consists of three separate legal entities: BSA on the
7 national level; local councils located in communities throughout the United States; and the local
8 community organizations which organize, operate, and supervise Scout troops.
9 3. Boy Scouts of America at the national level is a nonprofit educational resource
10 program. BSA's Congressional charter provides that its purpose is to "promote, through
11 organization, and cooperation with other agencies, the ability of boys to do things for themselves
12 and others, to train them in Scoutcraft, and to teach them patriotism, courage, self-reliance, and
13 kindred virtues." (A true and correct copy of the BSA's Articles ofincorporation (1916) are
14 attached as Exhibit A.) BSA makes its Scouting program available to local community
15 organizations to use as part of those organizations' service to their members and to their
16 communities.
17 4. BSA charters councils for a prescribed geographical area. There are
18 approximately 2 7 5 locally incorporated councils in the United States. These local councils
19 provide guidance and support to the independent community organizations that operate scout ·
20 troops. Each council is incorporated as a separate not-for-profit entity in the state in which it is
21 located, and each council raises and disburses its own funds and has its own board of directors.
22 Golden Empire Council, Boy Scouts of America is one such council. (True and correct copies of
23 BSA's Charters and Bylaws in effect during the relevant time period (1978-1981) are attached as
24 Exhibit B.)
25 5. BSA also issues charters to independent community organizations (such as
26 churches, parent-teacher associations, and civic organizations) to sponsor and organize troops
27 and other scouting units. These "chartered organizations," in accordance with their charters,
28 20445928vl 2 DECLARATION OF AL WESTBERG IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 44 of 51
agree to use the program in accordance with the guidelines and policies set forth in the official
2 BSA publications and literature. The chartered organizations create troop committees, which in_
3 turn supervise and run the troop, including selecting their adult leaders from their communities.
4 The troop committee is comprised of volunteers who are responsible for selecting and
5 supervising the Scoutmaster and other troop adults. (True and correct copies of the Troop
6 Committee Guidebook during the relevant time period (1978-1981) are attached hereto as
7 Exhibit C.) The Scoutmaster and Assistant Scoutmaster of a Boy Scout troop are responsible for
8 the planning, organization and supervision of the troop's various activities, such as meetings,
9 camping trips and other outings or activities. The Scoutmasters, Assistant Scoutmasters and l 0 other adult volunteers of the troops are not agents or employees of the BSA or the local councils.
11 6. Neither BSA nor local councils control or have the right to control the chartered
12 organizations or the activities of local troops. Further, BSA does not control or have the right to
13 control the day-to-day activities of the local councils.
14 7. Beginning in approximately 1920, BSA began creating Ineligible Volunteer
15 ("I.V.") files to identify and document persons who did not meet the high standards set by BSA
16 for participation in Scouting programs. Grounds for ineligibility have followed societal mores at
17 the time of reporting and have included, for example, gambling, drinking, financial improprieties,
18 dishonesty, and criminal behavior, including child molestation. The LV. files are created based
19 on voluntary reports by victims, their parents and other persons.
20 8. An LV. file is created once BSA receives information that alleges inappropriate or
21 unlawful conduct by an adult volunteer, even if never proven, and even if the child involved was
22 not involved in Scouting. BSA uses the LV. files for two principal purposes: (1) to identify
23 individuals determined to be ineligible to volunteer in the event they attempt to rejoin a Scouting
24 program in another area; and (2) to provide written justification and document why an individual
25 was deemed ineligible in the event their membership revocation is challenged in litigation. 26
27
28 20445928vl 3 DECLARATION OF AL WESTBERG IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERJCA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 45 of 51
9. During all relevant time periods, all Councils were required to submit all adult
2 volunteer applications to the BSA to detem1ine whether the applicant had previously been
3 identified as an ineligible volunteer.
4 10. On information and belief, I believe Garrett Hatfield first became involved as an
5 adult volunteer in Scouting in 1976. At the time be submitted his application, he was not
6 identified as an ineligible volunteer.
7 11. There is no record of Hatfield being involved in Scouting in any way between the
8 mid-1980s and 1999. In 1999, Hatfield applied to be a scoutmaster of Troop 974 in Reno,
9 Nevada.
12. BSA revoked Hatfield's registration in May 2001 when BSA first became aware
11 of an allegation of misconduct that occurred during 2001 during his involvement with Troop 974.
12 An IV file was created at the time, and as a result, Hatfield was immediately banned from . 13 Scouting. Hatfield was not identified as an ineligible volunteer prior to May 2001, and therefore,
14 BSA did not know, or have reason to know that Hatfield posed a specific threat of sexual
15 misconduct.
16 13. At no time was Hatfield an employee or agent of BSA
17 14. During the relevant time period when plaintiff was involved in Scouting, the BSA
18 did not have a training progran1 in place that was designed to prevent against child sexual abuse.
19 Rather, BSA's Youth Protection Training Program which is specifically designed to prevent child
20 abuse was not implemented until 1987.
21 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
22 foregoing is trne and correct.
23
24 Executed this Jl.- 4 day of September, 20] 5, at Pleasant I--Ii!l, California.
25 26
27
28 20445928vl 4 DECLARATION OF AL WESTBERG IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 46 of 51
1 SEDGWICKLLP JOHN G. GHERlNI (SBN 220981) 2 [email protected] SHEYANNE H. BANE (SBN 239395) 3 sheyanne. [email protected] DAVID D. MESA (SBN 257488) 4 david. [email protected] 333 Bush Street, 30th Floor 5 San Francisco, CA 94104-2834 Telephone: ( 415) 781-7900 6 Facsimile: (415) 781-2635
7 Attorneys for Defendants BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA and GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA 8
9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10 COUNTY OF SOLANO - SOLANO JUSTICE CENTER
11
12 Mark Dietrich, Individually, CASE NO.: FCS041141
13 Plaintiff, [Assigned For All Purposes To Judge Paul L. Be.eman, Dept. 1] 14 V. DECLARATION OF ALAN KOPPES IN 15 Defendant Doe 1, Scouting Organization; SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS Defendant Doe 2, Council; and Does 3 BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND 16 through 100, inclusive, GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY 17 Defendants. JUDGMENT, OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY ADJUDICATION 18 [Served concurrently with Notice ofMotion and 19 Motion for Summary Judgment, Separate Statement of Undisputed Facts, Compendium of 20 Evidence, Compendium of Out-of-State Authorities, Request for Judicial Notice and 21 [Proposed] OrderJ 22 DATE: December 16, 2015 23 TIME: 8:30 a.m. DEPT: 1 24
25 Complaint Filed: January 30, 2013 26 Trial Date: Februarv 2. 2016
27
28 8196689lvl 1 DECLARATION OF ALAN KOPPES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 47 of 51
1 I, Alan Koppes, declare:
2 1. I am a member of the Executive Board of the Golden Empire Council ("GEC")
3 and have been a member since in or around 1988. I was also the President of GEC in or around
4 1977. As such, I have personal knowledge or knowledge gained as a representative of GEC of
5 the facts in this Declaration and would testify to them if called to do so.
6 2. During my tenure as President of GEC, as well as during my capacity as a member
7 of the Executive Board of GEC from approximately 1988 to the present, I was familiar with the
8 day-to-day operations of the GEC, including the provisions and parameters of its bylaws, as well
9 as the charter agreement between BSA and GEC. Specifically, I knew and understood that the
10 GEC was incorporated as a California not-for-profit entity, and was and still is operated as a
11 separate legal entity from the BSA. In addition, I knew and understood that the GEC operated as
12 a separate entity from any and all chartered organizations, as well as from the individual, local
13 Boy Scout troops.
14 3. During all relevant times, the GEC did not control nor have the right to control the
15 chartered organizations or the activities of local troops. Rather, the chartered organizations
16 owned and operated the individual local troops. The adult leaders and youth members of the
17 troops, together planned, organized and ran the troops. Moreover, GEC did not select the
18 leaders, such as the Scoutmasters and Assistant Scoutmasters, of the local troops. Rather, the
19 leaders were selected by the troop committees, which are comprised of adult volunteers and
20 parents of the boys in the troops, who are selected by the chartered organization.
21 4. During all relevant time periods, GEC's role was to provide guidance and support
22 to the independent chartered organizations that operated the scout troops, as well as make
23 training available to the chartered organizations using the Scouting program and provide
24 procedures for advancements of youths in the Scouting program.
25 5. During all relevant time periods, GEC operated pursuant to its bylaws, as well as
26 the charter agreement between the GEC and BSA. It acted as a legal entity separate and apart
27 from the BSA, the local chartered organizations and individual Boy Scout troops. I have no
28 8!96689lvl 2 DECLARATION OF ALAN KOPPES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 48 of 51
1 reason to believe that the GEC ever acted outside the scope of its bylaws or its charter agreement
2 with the BSA.
3 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
4 foregoing is true and correct.
5 Executed this / 6~ay of September, 2015, at Carmichael, California.
6 7 ~ U/lf=- 8 Alan Koppes, Declarant
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19 20
21
22
23
24
- 25 26
27
28 81966891vl 3 DECLARATION OF ALAN KOPPES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN E:tvfPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMJv1ARY JUDGMENT OR IN TIIE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 49 of 51
1 SEDGWICK LLP JOHN G. GHERINI (SBN 220981) 2 [email protected] SHEYANNE H. BANE (SBN 239395) 3 sheyanne. [email protected] DAVID D. MESA (SBN 257488) 4 david. [email protected] 333 Bush Street, 30th Floor 5 San Francisco, CA 94104-2834 Telephone: (415) 781-7900 6 Facsimile: (415) 781-2635
7 Attorneys for Defendants BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA and GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA 8
9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10 COUNTY OF SOLANO - SOLANO JUSTICE CENTER
11
12 Mark Dietrich, Individually, CASE NO.: FCS041141
13 Plaintiff, [Assigned For All Purposes To Judge Paul L. Beeman, Dept. 1] 14 v. DECLARATION OF CHARLES 15 Defendant Doe 1, Scouting Organization; BRASFEILD IN SUPPORT OF MOTION Defendant Doe 2, Council; and Does 3 BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF 16 through 100, inclusive, AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA 17 Defendants. FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE, SUMMARY 18 ADJUDICATION
19 [Served concurrently with Notice ofMotion and Motion for Summary Judgment, Separate 20 Statement a/Undisputed Facts, Compendium of Evidence, Compendium of Out-ofState 21 Authorities, Request for Judicial Notice and [Proposed] Order] 22
23 DATE: · December 16, 2015 TIME: 8:30 a.m. 24 DEPT: 1 25
26 Complaint Filed: January 30, 2013 Trial Date: February 2, 2016 27,
28 82022864vl 1 DECLARATION OF CHARLES BRASFEILD IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 50 of 51
1 I, Charles Brasfeild, declare:
2 1. I am the Scout Executive for the Golden Empire Council ("GEC") and have held 3 this position since May 1, 2014. My duties as Scout Executive include, among other, planning
4 ancl fundraising on behalf of the Golden Empire Council, as well as overseeing personnel
·· 5 decisions, camp operati9ns and community relations. If called to testify as a ~itness, I could and
6 would competently testify under oath to the matters set forth herein.
7 2. Boy Scouts of America ("BSA") charters local councils, such as GEC. Local 8 councils are non-profit corporations separate and apart from BSA which are responsible for
9 making training available to chartered organizations using the Scouting program and for
1o providing procedures for advancement of youths in the Scouting program. They also provide
11 advice and support to local organizations which operate programs for youth using aspects of
12 programs created by BSA, including local Scouting units, like packs and troops. Local councils
13 have geographic boundaries. Generally speaking, a local council provides advice and support to
14 local organizations which operate local units within their geographic boundaries. Based on
15 information and belief, attached hereto as Exhibit "A" is a true and correct copy of GEC' s By-
16 Laws that were in place from 1976 through the 1990s.
17 3. BSA also charters local organizations permitting them to use pmiions of scouting 18 programs, which the local organizations select, and permitting them to use BSA material and
19 insignia in youth programs which the local organizations themselves establish. Pursuant to their
20 chaiiers with BSA, local councils administer the process of issuance and renewal of the charters
21 issued to local organizations. The chartered organizations, in accordance with their charters,
22 agree to use the program in accordance with the guidelines and policies set forth in the official
23 BSA publications and literature.
24 4. Each chartered organization, which owns and operates the local units, establishes a 25 unit committee which selects the unit leaders and supervises the unit. In the case of a troop, the
26 chartered organization appoints a troop committee comprised of adult volunteers who are
27 responsible for selecting and supervising the Scoutmaster and other troop adult volunteers. The
28 82022864vl 2 DECLARATION OF CHARLES BRASFEILD IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION Case 20-10343-LSS Doc 5683 Filed 07/22/21 Page 51 of 51
1 Scoutmaster and Assistant Scoutmaster of a Boy Scout troop are responsible for the planning,
2 organization and supervision,of the troop's activities. The GEC does not have the right to control
3 the chartered organizations or the activities of local troops or troop adults. At no time are local
4 adult troop volunteers employees or agents of GEC.
5 5. The GEC is a non-profit corporation incorporated under the laws of the State of 6 California. When I became the Scout Executive, I was hired by the GEC, not BSA. Based on
7 information and belief, attached hereto as Exhibit "B" is a true and correct copy of GEC's
8 Certificate of Amendment of Articles of Incorporation, filed on or about March 11, 1977.
9 6. Based on information and belief, Golden Empire Council did not have a training
10 program in place that was designed to prevent against child sexual abuse during the late 1970s
11 early 1980s. Rather, the first time Golden Empire Council had such a training program was
12 when BSA implemented the Youth Protection Training Program in or around 1987.
13 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the
14 foregoing is true and correct.
15 Executed this 3 0 _ day of September, 2015, at Sacramento, Californi~
16
17
18
19 20
21
22
23
24 25 26 27
28 82022864vl 3 DECLARATION OF CHARLES BRASFEILD IN SUPPORT OF MOTION BY DEFENDANTS BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA AND GOLDEN EMPIRE COUNCIL, BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION