Working Papers
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Working Papers Global Migration: Consequences and Responses Paper 2018/11, May 2018 Turkey – Country Report Legal & Policy Framework of Migration Governance Elif Çetin, Neva Övünç Öztürk, N. Ela Gökalp Aras, Zeynep Şahin Mencütek Swedish Research Institute in Istanbul (SRII) HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY © Elif ÇETİN, Neva Övünç ÖZTÜRK, N. Ela GÖKALP ARAS, Zeynep ŞAHİN MENCÜTEK This research was conducted under the Horizon 2020 project ‘RESPOND Multilevel Governance of Migration and Beyond’ (770564). This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Commission. The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of the RESPOND Project consortium/ authors and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union. The European Union is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein. Any enquiries regarding this publication should be sent to us at: [email protected] This document is available for download at http://www.crs.uu.se/respond/ 622 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY Contents List of figures 625 List of tables 626 Acknowledgements 627 List of abbreviations 627 Executive summary 629 1- Statistics and data overview 630 Explanatory note on available statistical data 630 Arrivals 630 Number of residence permits 631 Irregular migration 637 Number of applications for international protection 639 Temporary protection 642 2- The socio-economic, political and cultural context 646 A Brief description of Turkish society 647 Brief migration history 648 3- The Constitutional Organisation of the state and constitutional principles on immigration and asylum 650 Organizational structure and fundamental characteristics of the Turkish State 650 Organization of the State 651 General organization 701 Organizational structure of the administration 702 Fundamental characteristics of the State 652 Constitutional principles related to immigration and asylum 652 Organizational structure of the administration of immigration and asylum 653 Role of judiciary in the interpretation and definition of applicable legislation 655 4- The relevant legislative and institutional framework in the field of international protection657 Legal Framework 657 Primary Law 657 Secondary Law 659 Institutional Framework 662 5- The Legal Status of Foreigners 666 Beneficiaries of international protection 666 Geography of Migrants: Satellite Cities 667 The situation of ‘international protection’ applicants: arriving from Syria (temporary protection) 668 623 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY Accelerated Procedure 669 Irregular migrants 670 Regular migrants 725 Unaccompanied foreign minors 727 6- Reforms Driven from Mass Migration 677 7- Conclusion 734 Appendices 737 Annex I: Overview of the legal framework on migration, asylum, reception conditions 737 Annex II: List of authorities involved in the migration governance 691 Annex III: Flow chart of the international protection procedure 745 Annex IV: Flow chart of asylum procedure 746 Annex V: List of European Court of Human Rights and European Commission of Human Rights Decisions 747 Annex VI: Glossary 698 8- References and sources 700 624 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY List of figures Figure 1: Arrivals of non-EU citizens in 2017 681 Figure 2: Entrance to Turkey by years (2005-2017) 681 Figure 3: Number of residence permits granted (2005-2016) 682 Figure 4: Residence permits granted in 2017 (Top ten nationalities) 683 Figure 5: Types of residence permits issued in 2017 683 Figure 6: Short-term residence permits issued in 2017 (Top ten nationalities) 684 Figure 7: Family related residence permits issued in 2017 (Top ten nationalities) 684 Figure 8: Work related residence permits issued in 2017 (Top ten nationalities) 685 Figure 9: Student residence permits issued in 2017 (Top ten nationalities) 686 Figure 10: Distribution of foreigners with residence permit (as of 05.04.2018) 687 Figure 11: Numbers of irregular migrants apprehended (2005-01.03.2018) 688 Figure 12: Distribution of nationalities of irregular migrants who were caught at the Turkish border (2014- 19.12.2017) 689 Figure 13: Distribution of the apprehended irregular migrants across different provinces in Turkey in 2017 689 Figure 14: International protection applications by year 690 Figure 15: Nationalities of major groups of international protection applicants in 2017 691 Figure 16: Number of Syrians under temporary protection by year 693 Figure 17: Sheltered and unsheltered Syrian refugees by temporary shelter centres 693 Figure 18: Distribution of Syrian refugees in the scope of temporary protection by top ten province 694 Figure 19: Satellite cities 719 Figure 20: Arrivals in Greece from Turkey via Land and Sea Borders 722 625 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY List of tables Table 1. Breakdown by countries of origin and gender/age of the total numbers of international protection applicants (percentages) (as of 30.11.2017) 692 Table 2. Distribution of Syrian refugees in the scope of temporary protection by temporary shelter centres (as of 5 April 2018) 695 Table 3. Distribution by age and gender of registered Syrian refugees recorded by taking biometric data 695 Table 4. Number of Syrians who left to the country in the scope of one-to-one policy 696 Table 5. List the authorities that intervene in each stage of the procedure 716 626 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY Acknowledgements This country report is the result of a team effort. As the Swedish Research Institute in Istanbul (SRII) RESPOND: Multilevel Governance of Mass Migration in Europe and Beyond Project research team, we are grateful to Prof. Ayhan KAYA and Dr. Susan ROTTMANN for their insightful feedback, critical readings and comments. The headings of sections and sub- sections of the report were determined with the helpful guidance of the Work Package 1 (Legal and Policy Framework) coordinator, Universita Degli Studi Di Firenze (University of Florence, UNIFI). List of abbreviations AFAD Disaster and Emergency Management Authority AIDA Asylum Information Database BSECA Black Sea Economic Cooperation Area CIP Circular on International Protection CL Citizenship Law Const. Constitution DGMM Directorate-General for Migration Management EC European Commission EU European Union FRONTEX European Border and Coast Guard Agency GDI Gender Development Index HDI Human Development Index ILF International Labour Force Law IOM International Organization for Migration IR Implementation Regulation LFIP Law on Foreigners and International Protection LWPF Law on Work Permits for Foreigners MFSP Ministry of Family and Social Policies MFA Ministry of Foreign Affairs MoI Ministry of Interior OECD Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development PDMM Provincial Directorate of Migration Management RA Readmission Agreement RESPOND Multilevel Governance of Migration in Europe and Beyond RSD Refugee Status Determination TGNA The Turkish Grand National Assembly 627 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY THEC Turkish Higher Education Council TOKI Toplu Konut İdaresi Başkanlığı (Directorate of Public Housing Administration) TPR Temporary Protection Regulation UNDP United Nations Development Programme UNHCR United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees WP1 Work Package 1 628 HORIZON 2020 – RESPOND (770564) – TURKEY Executive summary This country report focuses on developments that took place during the period of 2011-2017 in the field of migration in Turkey. Traditionally a country of emigration, starting from the early 1990s, it has also become an important country of immigration, asylum and transit. Most recently, the increasing pressure of the refugee challenge, particularly given the high number of arrivals from Syria, has put the country once again under international spotlights. This report provides relevant migration statistics that are available as open source data. It briefly reviews the socio-economic, political and cultural characteristic of the country as well as its brief migration history. The report also delves into a detailed analysis of the constitutional, legal and institutional framework of Turkey’s national migration management system, which has gone through significant transition in the last few years. The report points out that due to Turkey’s geographical limitation to the 1951 Geneva Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (1951 Convention), and its associated 1967 Protocol; Turkey does not grant refugee status to people fleeing from conflicts and persecution in non-European countries. But it does provide ‘conditional refugee status’ along with ‘refugee’ and ‘subsidiary’ protection. The introduction of new sets of legislation, including the Law on Foreigners and International Protection (LFIP) in 2013, and Temporary Protection Regulation (TPR) in 2014, together with the development of new state agency to deal with migration affairs, the Directorate General of Migration Management (DGMM), paved the way for a more centrally organised national migration governance system. Moreover, the legal framework created with the LFIP and the TPR also established clearly defined migration categories such as regular migrant, irregular migrant, forced migrant and it set the criteria for granting temporary protection status. The report reveals a key duality regarding European and non-European asylum seekers to be an important characteristic of Turkey’s asylum system. The first group can obtain ‘refugee’ status’; while the second group can only obtain ‘conditional refugee status’.