Creating Partisans: the Organizational Roots of New Parties in Latin America

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Creating Partisans: the Organizational Roots of New Parties in Latin America Creating Partisans: The Organizational Roots of New Parties in Latin America by Mathias Poertner A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Ruth Berins Collier, Co-chair Professor Thad Dunning, Co-chair Professor Leonardo Arriola Professor Pradeep Chhibber Professor David Collier Professor Edward Miguel Spring 2018 Creating Partisans: The Organizational Roots of New Parties in Latin America Copyright 2018 by Mathias Poertner 1 Abstract Creating Partisans: The Organizational Roots of New Parties in Latin America by Mathias Poertner Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, Berkeley Professor Ruth Berins Collier, Co-chair Professor Thad Dunning, Co-chair The frequent emergence of new parties is a feature of democracies almost everywhere. While most of these new parties remain ephemeral, some manage to establish stable ties with voters and win substantial electoral support over repeated elections. This divergence raises the question why some new parties are able to take root in society, establish stable ties with voters, and successfully compete in elections over time, while others fail to do so. Despite a vibrant literature on both the stability of party identification and de- alignment away from traditional parties, we do not have a good understanding yet of why some new parties succeed in taking root in society, while others fail to do so. This dissertation attempts to fill this gap. It explores different paths that new parties take to build mass support, i.e. to secure electoral support and build partisan attachments in the electorate, in the context of the recent wave of party formation in Latin America. It seeks to explain how new parties come to choose different mobilization strategies and how voters in turn respond to these different party strategies. With the decline of unions, which played a central role in the historic founding of mass parties, much of the recent literature has concentrated on parties’ direct appeals to voters and explained variation in success to secure support in terms of the type of direct appeals, e.g. based on class vs. ethnic interests or identities or charismatic appeals. In this study, I consider different types of direct appeals and also explore organizationally mediated strategies, i.e. appeals that engage voters through societal organizations. I find that organizationally mediated strategies can secure electoral support very effectively and yield durable voter ties by socializing organization members into identifying with the party. Even though the mediating role that civil society organizations can play has been 2 largely overlooked with the decline of labor unions, new types of organizations— particularly indigenous organizations, peasant unions, and informal sector unions—play similarly important roles in democratic societies today. While the existing scholarship has examined the formation of these organizations and their role in politicizing ethnic or class cleavages, little attention has been paid to the various ways in which different forms of party-organization linkages might influence vote choice and the emergence of partisanship. The argument proceeds in two steps. First, I explain the adoption of different party mobilization strategies by focusing on the intra-elite dynamics during parties’ founding moments, the period before the party contests its first major election. Two features of the founding moments—one internal to the new party, the other one external to it—are key: (1) the cohesion of the coalition of party leaders and organizational allies and (2) the credibility of other attractive parties in the party system. These factors shape early-on whether a party-organization tie becomes institutionalized by adopting routinized rules and mechanisms that govern how candidates will be selected and factional disagreements will be settled. Whether party-organization ties become institutionalized, in turn, establishes whether a new party can rely on organizationally mediated strategies or is restricted to employing direct appeals only. Furthermore, I argue that the institutionalization of a linkage can provide the basis for different types of organizationally mediated strategies and resulting party structures, depending on the structure and resources of the organizational allies. In order to explain new parties’ ability to create mass support, I then focus on voters’ responses to the different party strategies, in a second step. I show that organizationally mediated appeals can help parties obtain electoral support more effectively than most types of direct appeals. Furthermore, if the underlying party- organization linkages are institutionalized, mediated appeals also yield durable voter- party ties by socializing organization members into identifying with the party itself. Drawing on social identity and self-categorization theory, I contend that societal organizations, which serve as highly relevant and immediate reference groups to their members, provide social spaces in which socialization into new parties can occur, if the organization is organically linked to a party. This argument is tested in the context of the recent wave of party formation in Latin America. My dissertation compares three major new parties, Bolivia’s MAS, Ecuador’s Alianza PAIS, and Mexico’s MORENA, with each other and with other new parties. Using a multi-method research strategy based on 24 months of fieldwork in Bolivia, Ecuador, and Mexico, this research combines insights from over 230 in-depth interviews with representatives of parties and societal organizations with analyses of original and existing surveys, census data, and election returns, archival research, ethnographic work, and a series of novel experiments conducted in the field. i To my parents ii Contents 1 Introduction: The Organizational Roots of New Parties 1 1.1 Mass Support for New Parties ............................................................... 5 Definitions ............................................................................... 6 1.2 Explaining Mass Support: Existing Research ........................................ 8 1.2.1 Explanations of Electoral Support ............................................... 8 1.2.2 Explanations of Partisan Attachments ....................................... 11 1.3 The Mediating Role of Societal Organizations .................................... 13 1.3.1 Societal Organizations .............................................................. 14 1.3.2 Contemporary Societal Organizations ....................................... 16 1.3.3 Societal Organizations in Latin America ................................... 17 1.3.4 The Role of Organizations for Participation .............................. 18 1.4 Founding Moments, Party Strategies, and Mass Support: The Argument ..................................................................................... 20 1.5 Methods & Research Design ............................................................... 24 1.6 Organization of the Study ................................................................... 28 2 Founding Moments: Founding Coalitions and Party Strategies 29 2.1 Introduction ........................................................................................ 29 2.1.1 Party Strategies ......................................................................... 29 2.1.2 Overview of the Chapter ........................................................... 31 2.2 Founding Coalitions: Proto-leaders and Organizational Allies ............. 32 2.3 Strategic Options: Instrumental vs. Institutionalized Party-Organization Ties .................. 35 2.4 Founding Moments ............................................................................. 36 2.5 Resulting Dynamics ............................................................................ 37 2.5.1 From the Perspective of Proto-leaders ....................................... 38 2.5.2 From the Perspective of Organizations ...................................... 40 2.5.3 Stability of Institutionalized Party-Organization Ties ................ 41 2.5.4 Resulting Party Mobilization Strategies .................................... 43 3 Evidence: Development of Party Strategies in Three New Parties 46 3.1 Introduction ........................................................................................ 46 3.1.1 Founding Moments ................................................................... 47 3.1.2 Institutional Consequences ........................................................ 48 3.1.3 Mobilization Strategies Available to New Parties ...................... 51 iii 3.2 MAS in Bolivia ................................................................................... 52 3.2.1 Founding Moments: Joint Participation in High-stake Protests as Moments of Solidarity .......................................................... 52 Moments of Solidarity: First Wave of Protests ....................... 54 Moments of Solidarity: Second Wave of Protests ................... 56 3.2.2 Institutional Consequences ........................................................ 57 The Pact of Unity and the National Coordination for Change . 59 Party Congress, National Board, and Candidate Selection ...... 62 Resulting Party Structure and Mobilization Strategies ............ 68 Stability of Ties.....................................................................
Recommended publications
  • 3Rd Plenary Assembly National Congress of Chile Valparaiso, Chile April 1St – 3Rd, 2004
    FIPA/PA/2004/REP/e/vf Original: Spanish Report 3rd Plenary Assembly National Congress of Chile Valparaiso, Chile st rd April 1 – 3 , 2004 Report 3rd Plenary Assembly Vaparaiso, Chile, 1- 3 April 2004 FIPA/PA/2004/REP/e/vf Original: Spanish Contents 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................2 2. Opening Ceremony................................................................................................................2 3. First Session of the Plenary Assembly ..................................................................................3 3.1 Election of the Chair of the 3rd Plenary Meeting ............................................................3 3.2 Report of the FIPA President..........................................................................................3 3.3 Establishment of the Working Groups ............................................................................3 3.4 Other Business ...............................................................................................................4 4. Final Session of the Plenary Assembly .................................................................................4 4.1 Working Group Reports..................................................................................................4 4.1.1 Group of Women Parliamentarians of the Americas ...............................................5 4.1.2 Working Group 1 – The Fight Against Terrorism.....................................................5
    [Show full text]
  • Pdf | 437.68 Kb
    1 September 2007, N°49 Board of Trustees Co-Chairs CrisisWatch: Christopher Patten summarises briefly developments during the previous month in some 70 situations of current or potential Thomas Pickering conflict, listed alphabetically by region, providing references and links to more detailed information President and CEO sources (all references mentioned are hyperlinked in the electronic version of this bulletin); Gareth Evans assesses whether the overall situation in each case has, during the previous month, significantly deteriorated, significantly improved, or on balance remained more or less unchanged; Executive Committee alerts readers to situations where, in the coming month, there is a particular risk of new or significantly Cheryl Carolus escalated conflict, or a particular conflict resolution opportunity (noting that in some instances there may Maria Livanos Cattaui* in fact be both); and Yoichi Funabashi summarises Crisis Group’s reports and briefing papers that have been published in the last month. Frank Giustra Stephen Solarz CrisisWatch is compiled by Crisis Group’s Brussels Research Unit, drawing on multiple sources including George Soros the resources of some 130 staff members across five continents, who already report on nearly 60 of the Pär Stenbäck situations listed here. Comments and suggestions can be sent to [email protected]. *Vice-Chair To search past issues of CrisisWatch visit our databases and resources page at www.crisisgroup.org. Morton Abramowitz Adnan Abu-Odeh Kenneth Adelman August 2007
    [Show full text]
  • The Onward Migration of Nigerians in Europe
    A University of Sussex PhD thesis Available online via Sussex Research Online: http://sro.sussex.ac.uk/ This thesis is protected by copyright which belongs to the author. This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Please visit Sussex Research Online for more information and further details Imagined Futures: The Onward Migration of Nigerians in Europe Jill Ahrens Thesis submitted for the degree of PhD in Geography School of Global Studies University of Sussex June 2017 ii Summary of Thesis Dynamic mobility and migration patterns, including forced migration, have always formed part of the complex social, cultural and economic relationships between Africa and Europe. Like other Africans, Nigerian migrants live in countless locations around the world and are connected to their homeland through contingent transnational networks. This thesis explores the onward migration of Nigerian migrants towards, within and beyond Europe and analyses the motivations, patterns and outcomes of their multiple movements. Six cities in Germany, the UK and Spain are the main research locations for the fieldwork that took place over 17 months. The three countries are important destinations for Nigerian migrants in Europe and also the principal destinations of intra-European onward migrants. The cities included in this study are the capital cities Berlin, London and Madrid, as well as Cologne, Manchester and Málaga.
    [Show full text]
  • Civil Liberties: 3 Aggregate Score: 60 Freedom Rating: 3.0 Overview
    Ecuador Page 1 of 7 Published on Freedom House (https://freedomhouse.org) Home > Ecuador Ecuador Country: Ecuador Year: 2018 Freedom Status: Partly Free Political Rights: 3 Civil Liberties: 3 Aggregate Score: 60 Freedom Rating: 3.0 Overview: Elections take place regularly, though there are persistent concerns about politicization of the National Electoral Council (NEC). A leftist government has ruled the country since 2007. While former president Rafael Correa imposed restrictions on the media and civil society, a new administration that came to power in 2017 has begun rolling back repressive Correa-era policies. Ratings Change: Ecuador's civil liberties rating improved from 4 to 3, and it received an upward trend arrow, due to reduced pressure on the media and civil society, as well as progress on anticorruption efforts, under newly elected president Lenín Moreno. Political Rights and Civil Liberties: POLITICAL RIGHTS: 25 / 40 (+1) A. ELECTORAL PROCESS: 7 / 12 A1. Was the current head of government or other chief national authority elected through free and fair elections? 3 / 4 https://freedomhouse.org/print/49986 9/27/2018 Ecuador Page 2 of 7 The 2008 constitution provides for a directly elected president. The president has the authority to dissolve the legislature once in his term, which triggers new elections for both the assembly and the presidency, and to veto individual line items in legislation. In April 2017, Lenín Moreno of PAIS won the presidential runoff with 51 percent of the vote, defeating Guillermo Lasso of the Creating Opportunities–Society United for More Action (CREO-SUMA) alliance, who took 49 percent.
    [Show full text]
  • Buen Vivir As an Alternative to Sustainable Development: the Case of Cotacachi, Ecuador
    Buen Vivir as an Alternative to Sustainable Development: The case of Cotacachi, Ecuador by Natasha Chassagne Total words: 97, 589 Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the PhD in Business & Law Centre for Social Impact Swinburne University of Technology May 2019 Abstract Sustainable Development (SD) as a concept was introduced in the 1970s to incorporate environmental considerations into mainstream development practice. SD has arguably failed to achieve its aims of intergenerational sustainability and human wellbeing thus far. This research identifies the Latin American concept of Buen Vivir (BV) as an alternative to the mainstream concept of SD. BV is a plural, biocentric approach to achieving Sustainable Social and Environmental Wellbeing (SSEW). Its plurality refers to a plurality of being, as well as a plurality of knowledge and vision. Yet despite political efforts to operationalise BV, there is a gap in knowledge for a coherent articulation of what BV entails and how it is implemented at the community level. As such it this research aims to find a path for practical implementation. This thesis asks the question: can BV become a practical and viable alternative to sustainable development? Drawing on the literature, this thesis finds that BV is a contested concept with a set of core common principles. It is contextual, with no universal definition. To advance understandings of BV on the ground at the community level, I conducted a short-term ethnographic study in the Cotacachi County, Ecuador. This research found that BV can become a viable alternative to Sustainable Development if certain conditions are met. The most fundamental condition is the transition to a post-extractive economy, as BV is seen as incompatible with extractivism - defined as the extraction of natural resources to satisfy a capitalist market.
    [Show full text]
  • Elections in Ecuador February 17 Presidential & Legislative Elections
    Elections in Ecuador February 17 Presidential & Legislative Elections Frequently Asked Questions The Americas International Foundation for Electoral Systems 1850 K Street, NW | Fifth Floor | Washington, D.C. 20006 | www.IFES.org February 13, 2013 Frequently Asked Questions Who will Ecuadorians elect in the 2013 elections? ...................................................................................... 1 When are elections in Ecuador? ................................................................................................................... 1 When did the electoral process begin? ........................................................................................................ 1 How is Ecuador organized politically? .......................................................................................................... 1 What are the main political parties? ............................................................................................................ 2 Who is running for president and vice president? ....................................................................................... 2 How is election administration structured in Ecuador? ............................................................................... 3 Who can vote in this election? ..................................................................................................................... 3 During what hours will polling stations be open? .......................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Common Agenda Agenda a Common Toward Toward a Common Agenda Agenda a Common Toward
    Andean-U.S. Dialogue Forum February 2011 This report has been developed by The Carter Center and the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA) as part of the Andean-U.S. Dialogue Forum. It is intended to promote more effective cooperation by identifying convergences and divergences in priorities among the countries and the peoples of Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia and the United States. Developed as a "Common Agenda", it seeks to enhance understanding of the internal dynamics in e ach country and reduce stereotypes that impede cooperation. The report highlights the transnational issues of energy, climate change, trade, and illegal drugs, Andean Countries and the United States the for Agenda a Common Toward recognizing that progress requires a collective response. The Carter Center The Carter Center was founded in 1982 by former U.S. President Jimmy Carter and his wife, Rosalynn, in partnership with Emory University, to advance peace and health worldwide. A not-for-profit, nongovernmental organization, the Center has helped to improve life for people in more TowardToward aa CommonCommon AgendaAgenda than 70 countries by resolving conflicts; advancing democracy, human rights, and economic opportunity; preventing diseases; and improving forfor thethe AndeanAndean CountriesCountries mental health care. andand thethe UnitedUnited StatesStates International IDEA International IDEA is an intergovernmental organization with 25 member countries. The Institute supports democratic institutions and processes worldwide by providing resources to strengthen capacities, developing policy proposals and supporting democratic reforms. International IDEA's main areas of expertise are electoral processes, political party systems, constitutional processes, gender and democracy. ISBN: 978-91-86565-09-1 Toward a Common Agenda for the Andean Countries and the United States Andean-U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Ecuador: Overcoming Instability?
    ECUADOR: OVERCOMING INSTABILITY? Latin America Report N°22 – 7 August 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................................... i I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1 II. A HISTORY OF INSTABILITY .................................................................................. 2 A. POLITICS ...............................................................................................................................2 B. THE ECONOMY .....................................................................................................................6 C. RELATIONS WITH PERU AND COLOMBIA .............................................................................12 III. THE CORREA ADMINISTRATION ........................................................................ 14 A. THE 2006 ELECTIONS .........................................................................................................14 B. THE NEW GOVERNMENT’S PEOPLE AND PROGRAM ...............................................................15 C. POLITICAL STRUGGLE AND THE CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY..................................................16 1. Applying shock therapy...........................................................................................17 2. The push for the Constituent Assembly...................................................................19 3. The Constituent Assembly.......................................................................................22
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of the Parallelism Between Traditional Socialism and Socialism of the 21St Century Under the Figure of Rafael Correa”
    FACULTY OF LAW School of International Studies “ANALYSIS OF THE PARALLELISM BETWEEN TRADITIONAL SOCIALISM AND SOCIALISM OF THE 21ST CENTURY UNDER THE FIGURE OF RAFAEL CORREA” GRADUATE THESIS PRIOR TO OBTAINING A BILINGUAL BACHELOR IN INTERNATIONAL STUDIES MINOR IN FOREIGN TRADE AUTHOR: GABRIELA CAMPOVERDE DIRECTOR: AB. ANA MARÍA BUSTOS CUENCA - ECUADOR 2017 i Dedication This thesis work is mainly dedicated to my son who has been my main motivation to finish with this goal, as well as my family and my boyfriend who have supported and helped me at all times throughout this journey. ii Acknowledgments I would like to thank my family, my son and above all my parents who, despite the difficulties, have supported me at all times to achieve this goal. I would also like to thank my director, Ana María Bustos, who has guided me, in a timely manner and with a great deal of patience, in the culmination of this work. And a special thanks to my boyfriend Alvaro Abad and my sisters Samantha and Emily who have helped me unconditionally and motivated me to finally reach this goal. iii Table of Contents Dedication ......................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgments ............................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents .............................................................................................................. iv List of Tables and Figures .............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Double Bind: the Politics of Racial & Class Inequalities in the Americas
    THE DOUBLE BIND: THE POLITICS OF RACIAL & CLASS INEQUALITIES IN THE AMERICAS Report of the Task Force on Racial and Social Class Inequalities in the Americas Edited by Juliet Hooker and Alvin B. Tillery, Jr. September 2016 American Political Science Association Washington, DC Full report available online at http://www.apsanet.org/inequalities Cover Design: Steven M. Eson Interior Layout: Drew Meadows Copyright ©2016 by the American Political Science Association 1527 New Hampshire Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20036 All rights reserved. ISBN 978-1-878147-41-7 (Executive Summary) ISBN 978-1-878147-42-4 (Full Report) Task Force Members Rodney E. Hero, University of California, Berkeley Juliet Hooker, University of Texas, Austin Alvin B. Tillery, Jr., Northwestern University Melina Altamirano, Duke University Keith Banting, Queen’s University Michael C. Dawson, University of Chicago Megan Ming Francis, University of Washington Paul Frymer, Princeton University Zoltan L. Hajnal, University of California, San Diego Mala Htun, University of New Mexico Vincent Hutchings, University of Michigan Michael Jones-Correa, University of Pennsylvania Jane Junn, University of Southern California Taeku Lee, University of California, Berkeley Mara Loveman, University of California, Berkeley Raúl Madrid, University of Texas at Austin Tianna S. Paschel, University of California, Berkeley Paul Pierson, University of California, Berkeley Joe Soss, University of Minnesota Debra Thompson, Northwestern University Guillermo Trejo, University of Notre Dame Jessica L. Trounstine, University of California, Merced Sophia Jordán Wallace, University of Washington Dorian Warren, Roosevelt Institute Vesla Weaver, Yale University Table of Contents Executive Summary The Double Bind: The Politics of Racial and Class Inequalities in the Americas .
    [Show full text]
  • Why Not Anti-Populist Parties?
    Why Not Anti-Populist Parties? Theory with Evidence from the Andes and Thailand Brandon Van Dyck Political parties are critical for democracy, but where do they come from? Recent analyses, building on classic works like Lipset and Rokkan and Huntington, show that episodes of extraordinary conflict and polarization spawn enduring parties.1 Such episodes—civil war, authoritarian repression, populist mobilization—furnish raw materials for party building. Polarization generates differentiated political identities. Extra-institutional conflict motivates groups to develop ground organizations. Adversity weeds out careerists, selecting for ideologues. Intragroup shared struggle and intergroup animosity and grievance cement in-group loyalties, discouraging defection. Through these mechanisms, polarization and conflict birth parties with distinct brands, territorial infrastructures, committed activists, and cohesion. Often, such episodes produce party systems. In Latin America, civil wars spawned stable two-party systems in Uruguay, Colombia, and (more recently) El Salvador, as warring sides evolved into parties after conflict ceased. In Brazil and Chile, bureaucratic authoritarianism generated stable right and left parties founded by the supporters and opponents of outgoing dictatorships.2 It is noteworthy, then, that populism typically generates just one strong party: a populist, not an anti-populist, one.3 Where successful, populists—defined as personalistic political outsiders who electorally mobilize the popular classes against the political and/or economic elite4—almost invariably polarize society and may engender sustained, even violent conflict between populist and anti-populist forces.5 Numerous populist parties have emerged from such conflicts. In the mid-twentieth century, populism produced Argentina’s Peronist party (PJ) and Peru’s American Revolutionary Popular Alliance (APRA).
    [Show full text]
  • Ecuador Official Title: Republic of Ecuador General Information
    Ecuador Official Title: Republic of Ecuador General Information: Capital Quito Population (million) 17n./0a23 Total Area 283,561 km² Currency 1 CAN$=0.77 US $ (USD) (2018 - Annual average) National Holiday 10 August (1809 Independence Day) Language(s) Spanish (official), indigenous languages Political Information: Type of State Republic Type of Government The National Assembly is unicameral and has 137 members elected for a four-year term. Members of the Assembly are elected with: 15 from national lists, 6 representing emigrants living outside Ecuador, 2 from autonomous regions, 2 from each province and metropolitan district, and one for each 200,000 inhabitants. The President is also elected for a four-year term as head of state. Bilateral Product trade Canada - Ecuador 700 600 Balance Head of State Head of Government 500 President 400 Can. President s Exports n 300 Lenín MORENO o Lenín MORENO i l Can. l i 200 Imports M 100 Total Ministers: Foreign Rel.: José VALENCIA 0 Trade Trade: Iván ONTANEDA -100 Defence: Oswaldo JARRÍN 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Finance: Richard MARTINEZ Statistics Canada Main Political Parties Country Alliance Movement (MPAIS); Patriotic Society Party (PSP); Social Christian Party Canadian Imports (PSC); Pachakutik Plurinational Movement (MUPP-NP), Creating Opportunities (CREO), Avanza, Regional Action for Equity Movement (ARE), Democratic Integration of Carchi from: Ecuador Movement (IDC), Believing in Our People Peninsular Movement (PCG), Concertación V eg . Prod . Foo d Prod . National Assembly: Alianza País: 44, Revolución Ciudadana: 30, CREO: 20, PSC / Madera de A nimal & Pro d . Guerrero: 15, SUMA: 9, others: 19. V ehicles and Eq uip . Fat s, Oils & W axes Pro d .
    [Show full text]