French Courts Take a Strict Line on Ebay

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

French Courts Take a Strict Line on Ebay Column Written by Jean-François Bretonniere & IP Lawyer Virginie Ulmann French courts take a strict line on eBay In June 2008, French courts rendered sellers and buyers to whom the goods were Paris went on to rule on the sale of genuine three decisions that held eBay liable delivered, the language used for the LVMH products in breach of a selective for the sale of counterfeits on its advertisements and so on. distribution network. As eBay is not an eBay also claimed that as a mere hosting authorised dealer of perfumes and online auction platform services provider, it should benefit from the cosmetics of the Christian Dior, Kenzo, provisions of the French law implementing Givenchy and Guerlain brands, the court Not a month after a French High Court the European E-commerce Directive and found eBay guilty of serious negligence and decided that eBay should be held jointly should not be held liable unless: it had actual omissions, and parasitism infringing the liable for the sale of infringing products knowledge of the unlawful character of the rights of LVMH. based on the provisions of the French content; or it was aware of facts and Intellectual Property Code on trademark circumstances that made this unlawful Damages infringement (High Court of Troyes, 4th June character apparent; and it had not acted The Euros 38 million damages granted to the 2008), the Paris Commercial Court had to promptly to remove content once it had trademark owners included: rule again on eBay's liability for similar knowledge or awareness of such unlawful • Compensation for unauthorised activity. On 30th June, it decided three character. The court denied eBay this status, exploitation of LVMH rights (calculated cases, all initiated by companies in the ruling that it acts principally as a broker and on the basis of a royalty). LVMH Group (LVMH), regarding the sale of not as a mere technical intermediary. • Compensation for disruption of the counterfeit goods and breach of a selective perfume selective distribution network. distribution network for the distribution of Unlawful marketing • Compensation for prejudice to the LVMH perfumes and cosmetics. In two of the three cases, the Paris reputation of the trademarks, as well as In its judgments, the court found against Commercial Court concluded that eBay had for moral prejudice. eBay and awarded almost Euros 40 million the obligation “to ensure that its activity damages to LVMH. The court stated that does not generate unlawful acts, notably The claims for damages were supported eBay “favoured and amplified the unlawful counterfeiting acts, which are prejudicial to” by the report of a well-known expert, which large scale marketing” of counterfeit goods the companies of the LVMH Group. In this proposed a method of calculation based on and goods belonging to a selective regard, the decision of the Paris Commercial estimated sales of counterfeits over three distribution network. Court was stricter for eBay than the earlier months on eBay websites (and in However, unlike the Troyes High Court, ruling by the High Court of Troyes, which accordance with eBay’s own statistics). the Paris Commercial Court based its concluded that eBay did not have the These estimates were then used to decisions not on trademark infringement obligation to “ensure” the absence of determine prejudice over the whole period provisions, but instead on the French civil unlawful act, but rather the duty to “act from 2001 to 2006. liability regime. This provides that any within its powers to prevent reprehensible In addition to these damages, LVMH intentional act, negligent conduct or use of its site”. secured the right to publish the decisions in imprudence whatsoever, which causes Despite steps – such as the Verified newspapers and on all eBay websites – in damage to another, requires the damaging Rights Owner (VeRO) programme – taken by both French and English – for three weeks. party to compensate its victim. eBay, the court found that for the period Each of the six infringed companies within considered, eBay had not “implemented the LVMH group also received Euros Objections and defence efficient and appropriate measures” to fight 100,000 as reimbursement for counsel fees. As advertisements for the LVMH products the sale of counterfeits on its platform. The In the decision concerning LVMH perfumes, were hosted in the US and were mostly in stance on this issue differs greatly from that the judges ordered that eBay cease and English, eBay claimed that the Paris of the US District Court for the Southern prevent the use of the Dior, Guerlain, Kenzo Commercial Court was not competent to District of New York. In its 14th July 2008 and Givenchy brands in all advertisements repair the prejudice allegedly suffered by decision relating to a case brought by Tiffany for perfumes or cosmetics, subject to a daily LVMH. The court dismissed these & Co, the court declared that eBay Inc was fine of Euros 50,000 for non-compliance. arguments. It ruled it was competent to not liable for trademark infringement, eBay has appealed the decisions of the repair the damage that occurred in France as trademark dilution, unfair competition or false Paris Commercial Court, with the hope of the eBay websites (including foreign advertising. In particular, the court ruled that obtaining as favourable an outcome as in its websites) were accessible to the French eBay cannot be held liable for trademark US case against Tiffany & Co. public. Therefore, when assessing the infringement based solely on its generalised prejudice suffered by LVMH, the court took knowledge that trademark infringement might into account all advertisements that included be occurring on its websites. Jean-François Bretonniere and Virginie LVMH trademarks on all eBay websites, Having found eBay liable for the sale of Ulmann are partners in the Paris office of regardless of the place of residence of the counterfeit goods, the Commercial Court of Baker & McKenzie 80 Intellectual Asset Management August/September 2008 www.iam-magazine.com.
Recommended publications
  • Arent Fox “Landlord Program” Eradicates Illegal Counterfeits of Clients’ Products at “Counterfeit Triangle”
    O Arent Fox “Landlord Program” Eradicates Illegal Counterfeits of Clients’ Products at “Counterfeit Triangle” June 3, 2008 New York City recently conducted the largest seizure of illegal counterfeit merchandise in its history, recovering $1 million in counterfeit merchandise and closing three Canal Street buildings described by Mayor Michael Bloomberg as “one of the most notorious shopping malls.” Shari Hyman, director of the Mayor’s Office of Special Enforcement, labeled the closed buildings as “the worst of the worst in this business.” The city’s action follows several civil actions against Canal Street landlords brought by Arent Fox on behalf of several fashion companies who faced a growing problem that had thwarted prior efforts to combat it. Seeking new strategies, these brand owners hired Arent Fox to impose liability on Canal Street landlords who knew about their tenants’ illegal activities but remained willfully blind to the problem. Arent Fox developed an innovative “landlord program” that required the landlords to take specific steps to stop counterfeiting, including hanging signs warning consumers that the tenant was not authorized to sell plaintiffs’ brands, specifically prohibiting counterfeiting in the leases, hiring a monitor to ensure tenants’ compliance, and evicting any tenant selling counterfeits. The buildings closed by New York City officials were already subject to a consent injunction Arent Fox obtained as part of this program on behalf of Louis Vuitton, Marc Jacobs, Givenchy, Kenzo, Loewe and Burberry. The city’s seizure notably did not uncover counterfeit merchandise of any of brands represented by Arent Fox (with the exception of a few Burberry perfume bottles), although it did find a significant amount of other well-known brands not covered by the injunction.
    [Show full text]
  • Kenzo Men's Collection
    WHAT’S NEW NEW LAUNCHES L’AMY AMERICA: Kenzo Men’s Collection POWER TO THE PATTERN ’Amy America introduces the launch of Kenzo Eyewear in the U.S. The men’s collection consists of nine styles designed for 25- to 50-year-olds who love bold styling and adventure. All frames are made in France and feature exclusive Kenzo patterns, an L energetic mix of colors and materials. The brand’s trademark of spontaneity and fun is perfectly captured and illuminated by this collection with its fresh attitude and respect for its innovative heritage. —Patrisha Holly Zabrycki PHILOSOPHY: “The Kenzo eyewear collection brings together Parisian influ- ences with Japanese culture and melds fun prints and textures with the resulting collection ideal for the male customer seeking a unique, contemporary, KENZO exclusive design,” says Cheryl Canning, 4171 marketing manager. MARKETING: Merchandising materials include countercards, one- and three- place displays, as well as banners. PRICE POINT: $$$$ CONTACT: For additional information, (800) 243-6350 contact L’Amy America, ; KENZO website: www.lamyamerica.com 4164 IN SIGHT Founded in 1970 as Jungle Jap, a boutique in Paris at Galerie Vivienne where the founder Kenzo Takada sold his handmade women’s collection, Kenzo debuted its first men’s ready-to-wear collection in 1983, and its kids and home collections in 1987, followed by fragrances in 1988. In July 2011, Carol Lim and Humberto Leon, founders of the Opening KENZO Ceremony fashion retail stores and private 4167 label collection were appointed creative directors of Kenzo. Using the brand’s DNA, the duo has given Kenzo their take on the revolutionary spirit with which the brand was founded.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 ANNUAL REPORT Passionate About Creativity
    2020 ANNUAL REPORT Passionate about creativity Passionate about creativity THE LVMH SPIRIT Louis Vuitton and Moët Hennessy merged in 1987, creating the LVMH Group. From the outset, Bernard Arnault gave the Group a clear vision: to become the world leader in luxury, with a philosophy summed up in its motto, “Passionate about creativity”. Today, the LVMH Group comprises 75 exceptional Maisons, each of which creates products that embody unique craftsmanship, carefully preserved heritage and resolute modernity. Through their creations, the Maisons are the ambassadors of a refined, contemporary art de vivre. LVMH nurtures a family spirit underpinned by an unwavering long-term corporate vision. The Group’s vocation is to ensure the development of each of its Maisons while respecting their identity and their autonomy, by providing all the resources they need to design, produce and distribute their creations through carefully selected channels. Our Group and Maisons put heart and soul into everything they do. Our core identity is based on the fundamental values that run through our entire Group and are shared by all of us. These values drive our Maisons’ performance and ensure their longevity, while keeping them attuned to the spirit of the times and connected to society. Since its inception, the Group has made sustainable development one of its strategic priorities. Today, this policy provides a powerful response to the issues of corporate ethical responsibility in general, as well as the role a group like LVMH should play within French society and internationally. Our philosophy: Passionate about creativity THE VALUES OF A DEEPLY COMMITTED GROUP Being creative and innovative Creativity and innovation are part of LVMH’s DNA; throughout the years, they have been the keys to our Maisons’ success and the basis of their solid reputations.
    [Show full text]
  • LVMH 2017 Annual Report
    2017 ANNUAL REPORT Passionate about creativity Passionate about creativity W H O W E A R E A creative universe of men and women passionate about their profession and driven by the desire to innovate and achieve. A globally unrivalled group of powerfully evocative brands and great names that are synonymous with the history of luxury. A natural alliance between art and craftsmanship, dominated by creativity, virtuosity and quality. A remarkable economic success story with more than 145,000 employees worldwide and global leadership in the manufacture and distribution of luxury goods. A global vision dedicated to serving the needs of every customer. The successful marriage of cultures grounded in tradition and elegance with the most advanced product presentation, industrial organization and management techniques. A singular mix of talent, daring and thoroughness in the quest for excellence. A unique enterprise that stands out in its sector. Our philosophy: passionate about creativity LVMH VALUES INNOVATION AND CREATIVITY Because our future success will come from the desire that our new products elicit while respecting the roots of our Maisons. EXCELLENCE OF PRODUCTS AND SERVICE Because we embody what is most noble and quality-endowed in the artisan world. ENTREPRENEURSHIP Because this is the key to our ability to react and our motivation to manage our businesses as startups. 2 • 3 Selecting leather at Berluti. THE LVMH GROUP 06 Chairman’s message 12 Responsible initiatives in 2017 16 Interview with the Group Managing Director 18 Governance and Organization 20 Our Maisons and business groups 22 Performance and responsibility 24 Key fi gures and strategy 26 Talent 32 Environment 38 Responsible partnerships 40 Corporate sponsorship BUSINESS GROUP INSIGHTS 46 Wines & Spirits 56 Fashion & Leather Goods 66 Perfumes & Cosmetics 76 Watches & Jewelry 86 Selective Retailing 96 LVMH STORIES PERFORMANCE MEASURES 130 Stock market performance measures 132 Financial performance measures 134 Non-fi nancial performance measures 4 • 5 LVMH 2017 .
    [Show full text]
  • PARIS Cushman & Wakefield Global Cities Retail Guide
    PARIS Cushman & Wakefield Global Cities Retail Guide Cushman & Wakefield | Paris | 2019 0 Regarded as the fashion capital of the world, Paris is the retail, administrative and economic capital of France, accounting for near 20% of the French population and 30% of national GDP. Paris is one of the top global cities for tourists, offering many cultural pursuits for visitors. One of Paris’s main growth factors is new luxury hotel openings or re-openings and visitors from new developing countries, which are fuelling the luxury sector. This is shown by certain significant openings and department stores moving up-market. Other recent movements have accentuated the shift upmarket of areas in the Right Bank around Rue Saint-Honoré (40% of openings in 2018), rue du Faubourg Saint-Honoré, and Place Vendôme after the reopening of Louis Vuitton’s flagship in 2017. The Golden Triangle is back on the luxury market with some recent and upcoming openings on the Champs-Elysées and Avenue Montaigne. The accessible-luxury market segment is reaching maturity, and the largest French proponents have expanded abroad to find new growth markets. Other retailers such as Claudie Pierlot and The Kooples have grown opportunistically by consolidating their positions in Paris. Sustained demand from international retailers also reflects the current size of leading mass-market retailers including Primark, Uniqlo, Zara brands or H&M. In the food and beverage sector, a few high-end specialised retailers have enlivened markets in Paris, since Lafayette Gourmet has reopened on boulevard Haussmann, La Grande Épicerie in rue de Passy replacing Franck & Fils department store, and more recently the new concept Eataly in Le Marais.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release
    Press Release Contact: Christopher Kang (London), +44 207 061 3525, [email protected] Stephanie Yera (New York), +1 212-556-1957, [email protected] TECH AND POLICY LEADERS TO JOIN CELEBRITIES, ECONOMISTS, GLOBAL CEOS AND OTHER INFLUENCERS AT NEW YORK TIMES LUXURY CONFERENCE Chanel’s Maureen Chiquet, Gucci’s Marco Bizzarri, Will.i.am, Nouriel Roubini, Victoria Beckham and a diverse mix of stylemakers to join NYT Fashion Director Vanessa Friedman in Versailles November 17-18 LONDON, SEPTEMBER 14, 2015 – The New York Times announces additional distinguished participants to join Vanessa Friedman and award-winning NYT journalists at the New York Times International Luxury Conference in Versailles on November 17-18, rounding out its unprecedented program. The invitation-only event will explore the dramatic ways the luxury industry is changing in its quest for the hearts and minds of consumers around the world. The following experts have just been added to the lineup: Matt Jacobson, head of market development, Facebook Nacho Figueras, professional polo player and Ralph Lauren brand ambassador Bernard Kouchner, former French Minister of Foreign and European Affairs, and founder, Doctors Without Borders Santiago Barberi Gonzalez, president and executive creative director, Nancy Gonzalez and Santiago Gonzalez Accessories Maureen Mullen, co-founder and head of research, L2 Inc. They are the latest additions to a stellar group of participants that already includes: Maureen Chiquet, global CEO, Chanel Ariel Emanuel, co-CEO of WME |
    [Show full text]
  • MEDIA PACK 2021 Fashion Language FRENCH Opinion MUSIC UNIQUE Tradictionsart
    MEDIA PACK 2021 Fashion Language FRENCH Opinion MUSIC UNIQUE tradictionsART LITERATURE VIVRE DE ART economy CULTURE Overview: Founded in 1943, France-Amérique is the only bilingual French-English publication in the United States. Every month, the France-Amérique print magazine offers a compilation of portraits, reports, essays, and interviews to inspire thought and debate, combined with an elegant design and high-quality images. The publication analyzes French life and art de vivre, and offers a unique connec- tion to the French cultural scene in the United States. Thanks to its bilingual format, France-Amérique attracts students of French and English who use the magazine to improve their written comprehension in both languages. OUR COVERSSince the New Year, France-Amérique cover is created by French artist Léa Morichon who creatively adapts an editorial theme from each edition into an artistic cover illustration. CONTENT Each month, readers will find: Insertions: School Guide: NEWS France-Amérique publishes a bi-annual School Guide, COME ON OUT highlighting the latest trends and advancements in French education in the U.S, as well IDEAS as a comprehensive listing of bilingual schools around the BUSINESS country. FASHION TV5MONDE Guide: Each print issue features LIFESTYLE the TV5MONDE Guide, highlighting the channel’s BON APPETIT entire content. CULTURE LANGUAGE UNKNOWN FRANCE JULIO LE PARC The Perrotin gallery presents Julio Le Parc, an exhibition of works by the Paris-based Argentine modernist, a pioneer of kinetic and op art FRENCH CULTURAL EVENTS IN NORTH AMERICA keenly interested in the dynamic between a work and its viewer. April 23 through June 27 at Perrotin in NYC; perrotin.com.
    [Show full text]
  • Case No COMP/M.6212 - LVMH/ BULGARI
    EN Case No COMP/M.6212 - LVMH/ BULGARI Only the English text is available and authentic. REGULATION (EC) No 139/2004 MERGER PROCEDURE Article 6(1)(b) NON-OPPOSITION Date: 29/06/2011 In electronic form on the EUR-Lex website under document number 32011M6212 Office for Publications of the European Union L-2985 Luxembourg EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 29.6.2011 In the published version of this decision, some information has been omitted pursuant to Article C(2011) 4823 final 17(2) of Council Regulation (EC) No 139/2004 concerning non-disclosure of business secrets and other confidential information. The omissions are PUBLIC VERSION shown thus […]. Where possible the information omitted has been replaced by ranges of figures or a general description. MERGER PROCEDURE ARTICLE 6(1)(b) DECISION To the notifying party: Dear Sir/Madam, Subject: Case No COMP/M.6212 - LVMH/ BULGARI Commission decision pursuant to Article 6(1)(b) of Council Regulation No 139/20041 1. On 24 May 2011, the European Commission received notification of a proposed concentration pursuant to Article 4 of the Merger Regulation by which LVMH Moët Hennessy – Louis Vuitton Group ("LVMH", France), controlled by Groupe Arnault SAS (France), acquires within the meaning of Article 3(1)(b) of the Merger Regulation control of the whole of the undertaking Bulgari S.p.A ("Bulgari", Italy) by way of purchase of shares.2 LVMH and Bulgari will be hereinafter referred to as "the parties". I. THE PARTIES 2. LVMH is active in the production and sales of luxury goods (wines and spirits; fashion and leather goods, including accessories; perfumes and cosmetics; watches and jewellery; selective retailing as well as the luxury yachts industry).
    [Show full text]
  • Surname As a Luxury Brand: Brand Value Perspective
    SURNAME AS A LUXURY BRAND: BRAND VALUE PERSPECTIVE Barbara Mróz-Gorgoń, Ph.D., Wrocław University of Economics, Faculty of Economics Sciences, Institute of Marketing, Department of Fundamentals of Marketing, Assistant professor, ul. Komandorska 118/120, 53-345 Wrocław, Poland [email protected] BIOGRAPHY Arts brand passionate doctors’ degree in economics Areas of research: non-profit arts organizations marketing, culture and art brand image creation Since 2012 assistant professor at the Department of Marketing Fundamentals of the Institute of Marketing, Wrocław University of Economics; 2006-2012 assistant lecturer, Department of International Economic Relations Scientific activity: To date 17 scholarly papers (including articles in academic journals and monograph chapters) devoted mostly to the problems of franchising development in Poland; To date Participation in 13 conferences (including presenting papers at 5 conferences, among which 6 were international) S1-145 SURNAME AS A LUXURY BRAND: BRAND VALUE PERSPECTIVE Barbara Mróz-Gorgoń, Institute of Marketing, Department of Fundamentals of Marketing, Faculty of Economics Sciences, Wrocław University of Economics, Poland Email: [email protected] ABSTRACT Purpose - This article deals with a type of luxury fashion brand whose name is at the same time the famous surname. The author’s views are based on the analysis of the examples excerpted from fashion market. Apart from the benefits in the form of a known brand “name” and no necessity to involve great expenditure on promoting the name, the use of a form of a famous artists’ surname as a brand can bring the brand managing companies some problems. In case of luxury brands, managers have to face up for instance, to the problem of market segmentation and target group selection.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release
    Press release Tiffany & Co. Stockholders approve Acquisition by LVMH Paris, February 4, 2020 LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE (“LVMH”), the world’s leading luxury products group, announced that stockholders of Tiffany & Co. (NYSE: TIF) (“Tiffany”) have voted overwhelmingly to approve the previously announced merger agreement relating to the proposed acquisition of Tiffany by LVMH at a special meeting of Tiffany stockholders that was held today. According to the agreement announced on November 25, 2019, LVMH will acquire Tiffany, the global luxury jeweler, for $135 per share in cash, in a transaction with an equity value of approximately €14.7 billion or $16.2 billion. Bernard Arnault, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of LVMH, commented: “This approval is a significant milestone as we move closer to completing our acquisition of Tiffany, an iconic company with a rich heritage and unique positioning in the global luxury jewelry market. A globally recognized symbol of love, Tiffany will be an outstanding addition to our unique portfolio of luxury brands. We look forward to welcoming Tiffany into the LVMH family and helping the brand reach new heights as an LVMH Maison.” The transaction is still expected to close in the middle of 2020, subject to the receipt of regulatory approvals and satisfaction or waiver of other customary closing conditions. LVMH LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton is represented in Wines and Spirits by a portfolio of brands that includes Moët & Chandon, Dom Pérignon, Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin, Krug, Ruinart, Mercier, Château d’Yquem, Domaine du Clos des Lambrays, Château Cheval Blanc, Colgin Cellars, Hennessy, Glenmorangie, Ardbeg, Belvedere, Woodinville, Volcán de Mi Tierra, Chandon, Cloudy Bay, Terrazas de los Andes, Cheval des Andes, Cape Mentelle, Newton, Bodega Numanthia and Ao Yun.
    [Show full text]
  • New Appointments to the LVMH Executive Committee
    Paris, November 8th, 2017 New appointments to the LVMH Executive Committee The Group announces the following appointments to its Executive Committee: Sidney Toledano becomes Chairman and CEO of the Fashion Group after 20 years at the helm of Christian Dior Couture. The CEOs of Céline, Givenchy, Loewe, Pucci, Kenzo, Marc Jacobs, Rossimoda and Nicholas Kirkwood will report into him. Sidney Toledano becomes a member of the LVMH Executive Committee. Pietro Beccari has been appointed Chairman and CEO of Christian Dior Couture after heading up Fendi since 2012. He also becomes a member of the LVMH Executive Committee. Pierre-Yves Roussel steps down as head of the Fashion Group after ten years and becomes Special Advisor to Bernard Arnault. He will shortly assume new operational responsibilities within the LVMH Executive Committee, of which he has been a member for 14 years. Bernard Arnault commented: “Sidney Toledano is the driving force behind the huge success of Christian Dior Couture across the world. Over the past 25 years, he has done an outstanding job of developing the exceptional House of Christian Dior Couture and of promoting its elegance and modernity through its highly talented team of designers. I want to offer my profound gratitude and am delighted that we will continue to work together and benefit from his expertise.” “The appointment of Pietro Beccari as head of Christian Dior Couture signals a new era,” added Bernard Arnault. “Having been an integral member of our Group for 12 years, Pietro has an excellent track record. After several years as Marketing Director of Louis Vuitton, he oversaw strong growth at Fendi by expertly harnessing the creativity of Karl Lagerfeld and Silvia Venturini Fendi and closely aligning it to the Roman influence of the House.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release
    PRESS RELEASE LVMH increases up to 10% the shareholding held in Tod’s. Through this transaction, the twenty-year friendship between the Arnault and Della Valle families is reinforced. Milan – Paris, April 22nd, 2021 On the date hereof, Diego Della Valle & C S.r.l. (a company controlled by Mr Diego Della Valle) entered into a sale and purchase agreement with Delphine S.A.S. (a fully-owned subsidiary of LVMH) for the sale of no. 2,250,000 shares of Tod’s S.p.A., representing 6.8% of Tod’s share capital. LVMH already owns 3.2%. The price per share is 33.10 Euros, equal to the volume weighted average price of Tod’s shares of the fifteen trading days preceding the signing. The transaction will be executed on 28 April 2021. Upon completion, Mr. Diego Della Valle will own, directly and indirectly, 63.64% of Tod’s outstanding shares and LVMH will own 10.00%. Bernard Arnault said: “The friendship with Diego Della Valle and his family goes back over 20 years, a relationship cemented by common human and professional values. We are very happy to reinforce further this partnership.” Diego Della Valle said: “I am delighted by this transaction which consolidates the friendship between myself, my family, Bernard and his family, that lasts longer than 20 years now. We share the values of luxury, quality and products appeal. This may represent an excellent reason to consider further opportunities to be taken in the future ahead.” 1 / 2 LVMH LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton is represented in Wines and Spirits by a portfolio of brands that includes Moët & Chandon, Dom Pérignon, Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin, Krug, Ruinart, Mercier, Château d’Yquem, Domaine du Clos des Lambrays, Château Cheval Blanc, Colgin Cellars, Hennessy, Glenmorangie, Ardbeg, Belvedere, Woodinville, Volcán de Mi Tierra, Chandon, Cloudy Bay, Terrazas de los Andes, Cheval des Andes, Cape Mentelle, Newton, Bodega Numanthia, Ao Yun, Château d'Esclans and Château du Galoupet.
    [Show full text]