Evaluation of Contactless Versus Contact Fingerprint Data, Phase 2 (Version 1.1)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The author(s) shown below used Federal funds provided by the U.S. Department of Justice and prepared the following final report: Document Title: Evaluation of Contactless versus Contact Fingerprint Data, Phase 2 (Version 1.1) Author(s): Lars Ericson, Ph.D., Stephen Shine Document No.: 249552 Date Received: December 2015 Award Number: 2014-ZD-CX-K001 This report has not been published by the U.S. Department of Justice. To provide better customer service, NCJRS has made this federally funded grant report available electronically. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. Evaluation of Contactless versus Contact Fingerprint Data, Phase 2 (Version 1.1) May 4, 2015 DOJ Office of Justice Programs National Institute of Justice Sensor, Surveillance, and Biometric Technologies (SSBT) Center of Excellence (CoE) Prepared for Defense Biometrics & Forensics OSD AT&L, ASD(R&E) Prepared by ManTech Advanced Systems International 1000 Technology Drive, Suite 3310 Fairmont, West Virginia 26554 Telephone: (304) 368-4120 Fax: (304) 366-8096 Dr. Lars Ericson, Director Stephen Shine (Azimuth, Inc.) UNCLASSIFIED This project was supported by Award No. 2010-IJ-CX-K024 and 2014-ZD-CX-K001, awarded by the National Institute of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. The opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the Department of Justice. This document is a research report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice. This report has not been published by the Department. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. CFPv2 Evaluation Report (v1.1) 04 May 2015 NIJ SSBT CoE TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES ....................................................................................................................... iv LIST OF TABLES ...........................................................................................................................v EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .............................................................................................................1 Data ......................................................................................................................................1 Experiments .........................................................................................................................2 Conclusions ..........................................................................................................................3 1.0 INTRODUCTION .....................................................................................................................5 1.1 About the SSBT CoE .....................................................................................................5 1.2 Disclaimers and Notices ................................................................................................6 2.0 BACKGROUND .......................................................................................................................7 2.1 Data Source: WVU Fingerprint Collection, Phase 2 .....................................................7 2.2 Fingerprint Scanners ......................................................................................................7 2.3 Evaluation of Contactless vs. Contact Fingerprint Data, Phase 1 ..................................8 3.0 TEST ENVIRONMENT & APPROACH ...............................................................................11 3.1 System Test Environment ............................................................................................11 3.2 Fingerprint Data ...........................................................................................................11 3.2.1 CFPv1 Collection Data .................................................................................12 3.3 Matching Run Evaluation Methodology ......................................................................13 3.3.1 Match Rates ..................................................................................................13 3.3.2 Similarity Score ............................................................................................14 4.0 EXPERIMENT RESULTS ......................................................................................................15 4.1 Gallery Matching Runs ................................................................................................18 4.1.1 CMR2 Rolled vs. CMR2 Rolled ...................................................................18 4.1.2 FOTF vs. FOTF ............................................................................................19 4.1.3 CMR2 Rolled (CFPv1) vs. CMR2 Rolled (CFPv1) .....................................20 4.2 CMR2 Rolled Gallery Matching Runs ........................................................................21 4.2.1 SEEK Rolled vs. CMR2 Rolled ....................................................................21 4.2.2 SEEK Plain vs. CMR2 Rolled ......................................................................22 4.2.3 MorphoIDent vs. CMR2 Rolled ...................................................................23 4.2.4 TouchPrint Rolled vs. CMR2 Rolled ............................................................24 4.2.5 TouchPrint Plain vs. CMR2 Rolled ..............................................................25 4.2.6 BioSled Rolled vs. CMR2 Rolled .................................................................26 4.2.7 BioSled Plain vs. CMR2 Rolled ...................................................................27 4.2.8 ANDI OTG Grayscale vs. CMR2 Rolled .....................................................28 4.2.9 ANDI OTG Binary vs. CMR2 Rolled ..........................................................29 4.2.10 FOTF vs. CMR2 Rolled ..............................................................................30 4.2.11 innerID vs. CMR2 Rolled ...........................................................................31 4.3 FOTF Gallery Matching Runs .....................................................................................32 4.3.1 CMR2 Rolled vs. FOTF ................................................................................32 4.3.2 SEEK Plain vs. FOTF ...................................................................................33 4.3.3 ANDI OTG Grayscale vs. FOTF ..................................................................34 4.3.4 ANDI OTG Binary vs. FOTF .......................................................................35 4.3.5 innerID vs. FOTF ..........................................................................................36 4.4 innerID Verification Run .............................................................................................37 UNCLASSIFIED ii This document is a research report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice. This report has not been published by the Department. Opinions or points of view expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. CFPv2 Evaluation Report (v1.1) 04 May 2015 NIJ SSBT CoE 4.5 CFPv1 Matching Runs .................................................................................................38 4.5.1 SEEK II Rolled vs. CMR2 Rolled (cfpv1) ...................................................38 4.5.2 TouchPrint Rolled vs. CMR2 Rolled (cfpv1) ...............................................39 4.5.3 TBS vs. CMR2 Rolled (cfpv1) .....................................................................40 5.0 ANALYSIS & DISCUSSIONS ...............................................................................................41 5.1 Comparison of Fingerprint Images ..............................................................................42 5.2 Gallery vs. Gallery .......................................................................................................43 5.3 TouchPrint CFPv1 vs. CFPv2 ......................................................................................45 5.4 LFP Gallery Results .....................................................................................................46 5.4.1 Fixed System Results ....................................................................................46 5.4.2 Mobile Device Results ..................................................................................50 5.5 CFP Gallery .................................................................................................................53 5.6 innerID Comparison.....................................................................................................54 6.0 CONCLUSIONS......................................................................................................................57 6.1 Future RDT&E Directions ...........................................................................................58 APPENDIX A: WVU COLLECTION REPORT ............................................................................1 APPENDIX B: COLLECTION DEVICE SUMMARIES – CFPv2 ...............................................1 C.1 AOS ANDI On-The-Go ................................................................................................2 C.2 Cross Match Guardian