Arxiv:2102.01755V2 [Hep-Ph] 4 Mar 2021 Rect Solution with the Discovery of the Matter-Induced of Ssms with Different Metallicities
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Measuring solar neutrinos over Gigayear timescales with Paleo Detectors Natalia Tapia-Arellano1, ∗ and Shunsaku Horiuchi1, y 1Center for Neutrino Physics, Department of Physics, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, Virginia 24061, USA (Dated: March 5, 2021) Measuring the solar neutrino flux over gigayear timescales could provide a new window to inform the Solar Standard Model as well as studies of the Earth's long-term climate. We demonstrate the feasibility of measuring the time-evolution of the 8B solar neutrino flux over gigayear timescales using paleo detectors, naturally occurring minerals which record neutrino-induced recoil tracks over geological times. We explore suitable minerals and identify track lengths of 15{30 nm to be a practical window to detect the 8B solar neutrino flux. A collection of ultra-radiopure minerals of different ages, each some 0.1 kg by mass, can be used to probe the rise of the 8B solar neutrino flux over the recent gigayear of the Sun's evolution. We also show that models of the solar abundance problem can be distinguished based on the time-integrated tracks induced by the 8B solar neutrino flux. I. INTRODUCTION [15, 16]). As a result, the solar structure is now very well constrained. By now, solar neutrinos and helioseismol- The concept of \Solar Activity" is used by the scien- ogy provide a clear view of the present energy generation tific community to study the fact that the Sun is not a rate of the Sun. By contrast, photons reveal the power 4 5 static quiet object and, in contrast to what was thought generation roughly 10 {10 years ago, corresponding to in ancient times, evolves [1]. Studying and understand- the energy transport timescale within the solar interior ing solar activity not only benefits science itself, but af- [17]. Within measurement uncertainties, the neutrino fects directly our environment as living beings and has and photon observations match, revealing the stability of the solar activity on 105 year scales. broad implications: strong solar activity affects directly ∼ our communications and travel systems and of course, However, recent measurements of the solar elemental our planet's climate [2{4]. abundances (metallicity) by Asplund et al. 2009 (here- Fundamental to the study of the evolution of the Sun after AGSS) [18] have caused a new conflict within the is the Solar Standard Model (SSM), a theoretical tool to SSM. The new photospheric measurements indicate that investigate the solar interior. First attempts to build a the solar metallicity is lower than previously estimated solar model to understand and predict more accurately by Grevesse & Sauval 1998 (hereafter GS) [19]. The SSM its core central temperature and to estimate the rates is sensitive to transitions in metals (used to refer to any- of solar neutrinos started in the mid 20th century, and thing above helium), which are an important contributor culminated in the SSM by Bahcall et al. [5]. Over the to opacity. Lower metallicity is associated with a cooler decades, the SSM has been developed and stringently solar core, and in this way, affects the solar interior. So- tested with a variety of measurements, not only neutrinos lar models using the new metallicity are no longer able to but also helioseismology (for recent reviews, see, e.g., [6]). reproduce helioseismic results, causing the so-called \so- Initial measurements of the solar neutrinos resulted in lar abundance problem" [6, 20]. Extended SSMs, where less neutrinos than predicted by the SSM, known as the some of the assumptions of the SSM are relaxed, have \solar neutrino problem." Many solutions were devel- been explored as potential solutions, e.g., early accretion oped based on producing a cooler solar core, but the causing chemical inhomogeneities [21]. While the debate phenomenon of neutrino oscillations [7] proved the cor- continues, a pragmatic approach has been to use two sets arXiv:2102.01755v2 [hep-ph] 4 Mar 2021 rect solution with the discovery of the matter-induced of SSMs with different metallicities. Neutrinos are one Mikheyev-Smirnov-Wolfenstein mechanism [8{11] and di- way to observationally test the solar abundance prob- rect measurement of all neutrino flavours of solar neu- lem through their dependence on the metallicity of the trinos by the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (SNO) ex- stellar interior. A lower metallicity causes a lower core periment [12, 13]. Presently, much of the solar neutrino temperature which in turn has a strong impact on neu- flux has been experimentally verified (see, e.g., [6, 14]). trino fluxes, in particular those involving nuclei in their In addition, helioseismic observations probe important production chain, e.g., 8B, CNO neutrinos. properties of the solar interior, such as the sound speed Detecting weakly-interacting particles like solar neu- profile, depth of the convective envelope, and surface trinos requires immense volumes to instrument enough helium abundance, to percent or better precision (e.g., target numbers to have an appreciable number of neu- trino interactions. The same difficulties faced by neutrino measurements are encountered in direct searches for dark matter, where experiments seek to observe the scatter- ∗ [email protected] ing of target nuclei by an incoming dark matter particle. y [email protected] Recently, it has been proposed that rock crystals deep 2 in the Earth could act as a new method to detect dark ature, approximately T 24 (by contrast, the dominant matter [22{25]. Called \paleo detectors", the idea is that pp chain has a T 4 dependence)/ [28]. Since most of the dark matter interactions will leave permanent structure 8B flux is emitted/ from the interior 5{10% of the solar or chemical changes (tracks) caused by the recoiling nu- radius, the 8B neutrinos provide a probe of the solar in- clei within the rocks. By strategically collecting samples terior. It is sensitive to the interior metal abundance, from geologically quiet areas, the tracks can survive geo- due to the metallicity's influence on the electromagnetic logical periods and measured in the lab through small an- opacity and hence temperature gradient inside the Sun. gle X-ray scattering. And by sampling from deep under- We model the Sun using the MESA code version r12115 ground, backgrounds caused by cosmic-ray interactions [29{33], closely following the procedure outlined in Farag in the Earth atmosphere can be mitigated. An unavoid- et al. 2020 [34]. We adopt their solar models calibrated able background comes from radioactivity of the Earth, to reproduce the present day neutrino fluxes, with final 10 but this can be rejected based on their rich track sig- age t = 4:568 Gyr [35], radius R = 6:9566 10 33 × natures. Furthermore, paleo detectors have competitive cm [36], photon luminosity Lγ = 3:828 10 erg/s [36], exposures compared to terrestrial experiments. Exposure and surface metallicity Z=X. These are× obtained by us- is the product of the target mass and duration in time. ing the built-in MESA simplex module to vary iteratively In the case of paleo detectors, 1 Gyr old samples are the mixing-length parameter and the initial hydrogen, possible, so even a small mass∼ of 10 mg would be com- helium, and metal compositions, including the effects of petitive with a terrestrial experiment of 103 kg running element diffusion [32]. The helioseimic signals of these for 10 years: both have exposures " = 0:01 kg Myr. models have been confirmed to be similar to others in In this paper, we consider the detectability of solar the literature [37]. We refer the reader to Ref. [34] for neutrinos using paleo detectors. The energies of solar further details of the calculations. neutrinos are about 1 MeV, which translate to keV We compute two SSMs made to match two differ- of recoil energy. This∼ is comparable to the recoil∼ ener- ent abundance of heavy metals at the surface of the gies ER = 0:1 100 keV caused by dark matter, meaning Sun: Z=X = 0:0229 for GS [19] and Z=X = 0:0181 for solar neutrinos− should also give rise to damage tracks. AGSS [18]. We use the built-in MESA reaction network Importantly, paleo detectors not only open a new way add pp extras to model the reactions emitting neutri- to search for solar neutrinos, they allow us to probe the nos, including pp, pep, 7Be, and 8B. For the CNO chain, Sun in the past on Gyr time scales, something that is not we use the add cno extras and add hot cno and com- possible with terrestrial detectors. Recently, paleo detec- pute the neutrinos from 13N, 15O, and 17F. Our obtained tors have been considered also as detectors of supernova neutrino fluxes for the two metallicity models, compared neutrinos [26] and atmospheric neutrinos [27] over simi- to experimentally measured values, are listed in Table I. lar geological times. To investigate the study of the SSM Our predicted fluxes are similar to those in the literature with paleo detectors, we compute two SSMs that differ in [34, 37, 38]. In Figure 1, we show the time evolution of their metallicity. We focus on the 8B neutrino flux, which these neutrino fluxes, as a function of years in the past. shows strong dependence on the solar interior tempera- We show results only for the GS metallicity model, as the ture and metallicity models. The 8B neutrinos are also AGSS is very similar on these scales. among the highest in energy, making them easier to de- tect compared to other higher-flux but lower-energy solar Channel GS AGSS Measurement neutrino components. +0:003 Φpp 5.98 6.01 6:05(1−0:011) This paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we go +0:05 Φ7Be 4.95 4.71 4:82(1 ) through our computation of the history of the solar neu- −0:04 Φ8 5.09 4.62 5:00(1 ± 0:03) trino flux with different metallicities which give us the B Φ 5.12 3.92 7:0(1+0:43) time dependency of the flux.